← Back to 明史

卷一百九十四 列傳第八十二 喬宇 孫交 林俊 金獻民 秦金 趙璜 鄒文盛 梁材 劉麟 蔣瑤 王廷相

Volume 194 Biographies 82: Qiao Yu, Sun Jiao, Lin Jun, Jin Xianmin, Qin Jin, Zhao Huang, Zou Wencheng, Liang Cai, Liu Lin, Jiang Yao, Wang Tingxiang

Chapter 194 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 194
Next Chapter →
1
Qiao Yu; Sun Jiao (courtesy name Ziyuan)〉 Lin Jun (courtesy name Zida)〉 (Zhang Fu) Jin Xianmin; Qin Jin (Sun Zhu)〉 Zhao Huang, Zou Wencheng, Liang Cai, Liu Lin, Jiang Yao, and Wang Tingxiang
2
西 調 西 祿
Qiao Yu, whose style name was Xida, came from Leping in Shanxi. His grandfather Yi had served as Left Vice Minister of Works. His father Feng had been a director in the Bureau of Operations. Both were famed for their upright conduct. Yu passed the jinshi examination in Chenghua 20 (1484) and received appointment as a principal secretary in the Ministry of Rites. Early in the Hongzhi reign, when Wang Shu headed the Ministry of Personnel, Yu was moved to the Bureau of Appointments and rose through three promotions to bureau director. He admitted no private callers at his gate. He was promoted to Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. After the Wuzong Emperor came to the throne, Yu was dispatched to offer sacrifices at the Central Peak and the Western Sea. On his return to court, he laid out in detail six hardships he had seen afflicting soldiers and civilians along the route. Soon afterward he was made Minister of the Court of Imperial Entertainments and then served in turn as Left and Right Vice Minister of Revenue. When Liu Jin fell, many senior ministers were impeached for having joined his faction, but Yu alone remained untainted. He was appointed Minister of Rites at Nanjing. After fire struck the Qianqing Palace, he led his colleagues in memorializing on ten abuses: neglect of court audiences, the long suspension of the lecture series, the failure to name an heir, the swarm of adopted sons, Tibetan monks quartered in forbidden temples, actors attending the emperor's private quarters, imperial shops, frontier troops kept on hand, drill in fighting, rampant construction, and unceasing textile manufacture. The emperor paid no heed. After some time he was moved to the Ministry of War to assist in state affairs. Because the emperor was touring deep in the northern frontier while no one was left to supervise the realm, he urged that an heir be named without delay. When the emperor prepared to take the field against the enemy in person, Yu again led his colleagues in remonstrance. None of these appeals received any reply.
3
Before long the Prince of Ning, Chen Hao, rose in rebellion and boasted that he would take Nanjing within days. Yu put the defenses on a strict footing yet talked and laughed as calmly as ever. At times he entertained guests outside the city walls, quietly surveying where the ground favored defense or attack and stationing guards accordingly. His arrangements were thorough inside and out, and the city remained calm. The commander Yang Rui was capable and resourceful, and Yu put him in charge of the defense of Anqing. The eunuch commissioner Liu Lang was in league with Hao and had secretly posted death squads in the city. Yu investigated and uncovered the plot, then questioned the men carrying out Lang's orders; Lang was too frightened to move. Yu then searched the city thoroughly, beheaded three hundred hidden strongmen, and hung their heads along the Yangzi. Chen Hao lost his inside support and, seeing that Nanjing was ready, did not dare march east. He attacked Anqing, but Yang Rui held firm and the city would not fall. Before long he was defeated.
4
調
When the emperor reached Nanjing, he ordered all officials to attend the coming New Year's audience in military dress. Yu refused to comply and led the ministers in offering New Year's congratulations in court dress. Jiang Bin demanded the keys to the city gates, and the regional military commission consulted Yu. Yu said, "Defenses exist to guard against the unexpected. Who would dare demand the keys to the forbidden gates? And who would dare hand them over? Not even an edict from the Son of Heaven could obtain them." The regional military commission reported Yu's answer, and the demand was dropped. Bin forged edicts to press demands that arrived dozens of times a day; Yu always announced them openly at court, and Bin gradually backed off. Bin wanted to slander Yu out of office. The defense eunuch Wang Wei had once been the emperor's study companion; the emperor trusted him, and he always intervened from within, so Bin's plots came to nothing. The emperor lingered at Nanjing for nine months; Yu led the ministers in three appeals to return to the capital and himself lay prostrate at the palace gate in petition. When the imperial procession turned homeward, he escorted it as far as Yangzhou. The following year he was made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. For his merit in securing the realm, he was further made Junior Guardian.
5
歿
When the Shizong Emperor came to the throne, Yu was summoned to serve as Minister of Personnel. Ever since his days in the Bureau of Appointments Yu had shown a keen eye for character, and now personnel administration was altogether purified. The emperor was eager to set the realm in order. Yu, together with Lin Jun, Peng Ze, and Sun Jiao, all commanded great prestige throughout the realm, and the emperor entrusted them accordingly. All who had been ousted by the powerful were restored to office, and the realm looked on with hope for better days. The emperor was stubborn and inclined to have his own way; Yu's views were heard less and less. Sixty-three officials of the Xing princedom who were awaiting promotion petitioned for advancement. Yu argued that these men held nominal places on the registers and were not the same as officials actually serving in office. Dismissals and penalties were applied in varying degrees, and all bore resentment against Yu. The emperor wished to ennoble the Commandant-escort Cui Yuan as marquis and the maternal relatives Jiang Lun and Shao Xi as earls, but Yu would not agree. Before long an edict advanced Marquis Zhang Heling of Shouning to duke, ennobled the empress's father Chen Wanyan as earl, and appointed Wanyan's son Shaozu Vice Director of the Imperial Stud. Yu said, "In successive reigns no empress dowager's kin was ennobled as duke during life; Zhang Luan too was honored only after death—how can a father's posthumous grant now become a son's living ennoblement? Wanyan's ennoblement as earl is even more abrupt than Luan's was, and appointing his son to the Imperial Stud violates precedent. I pray that Your Majesty will uphold the statutes so they may endure for ages to come." The emperor would not heed any of it. Shi Dao impeached Yang Tinghe; Yu said Dao was acting from private motives, and Dao was thereupon sent to the imperial prison. Cao Jia aided Dao in impeaching Yu; Yu asked to resign, and the emperor ordered the Court of State Ceremonial to urge him back to duty.
6
Whenever Yu found a matter unacceptable, he fought it without fail, and his opposition to the "Great Rites" controversy was especially fierce. The emperor wished to add an imperial title to his biological father, the Xing Sacrificial Emperor; Yu argued that calling one's biological parent "emperor" would disturb the legitimate succession and was not the way to honor the ancestral temple or keep names and ranks in order. When the ritual officials proposed styling the Sacrificial Emperor as "biological father," the emperor changed this to "biological imperial father" and also ordered a temple to him built within the inner palace; Yu and others again submitted linked memorials in remonstrance. By special edict Xi Shu was appointed Minister of Rites; Yu again joined the Nine Ministers in saying, "Your Majesty dismissed Wang Jun and employed Xi Shu; demoted Ma Mingheng, Ji Ben, and Chen Hou, and summoned Zhang Cong, Gui E, and Huo Tao. These measures violated propriety and filled men's hearts with alarm. To set aside the consensus of the realm for all time on account of the heterodox views of one or two men, to estrange kin within and set ruler and minister at odds without, to call it loyalty while in truth burdening Your Majesty's virtue. Moreover, Shu was not chosen through court recommendation but appointed by a special inner edict—something unprecedented since the founding ancestors. We beg that Jun and Shu each return to their former posts, that Mingheng and the others be pardoned, and that Cong and E not be summoned." Soon they again asked that Cong, E, and Shu be dismissed, while Lü Zan and Zou Shouyi, who had contested the "Great Rites," were released from prison. When Cong and E reached the capital, an edict appointed both Hanlin Academicians. Yu and others again said, "Favors granted by inner edict were in former reigns generally bestowed on fawning favorites and petty men. If a scholar-official should share in such favor even once, respectable opinion would no longer accept him. Moreover, the Hanlin Academician is the most exalted and pure of posts—if men like E are placed in it, who would still be willing to serve alongside them?" The emperor was angry and sharply rebuked them. Yu then asked to retire, and permission was granted. Relay horses, bearers, and stipends were provided according to established custom. The censors Xu Zhong, Liu Yu, and others asked that Yu be retained; the emperor said, "It is not that I refuse to use Yu—Yu himself asked to leave on grounds of illness." Later, when the 《Minglun Dadian》 (Comprehensive Canon of Human Relations) was completed, earlier opinions were reviewed retrospectively and his office was stripped. When Yang Yiqing died, Yu crossed the river to mourn him. The elders of the southern capital all came out to welcome him, raising their hands to their foreheads and saying, "You, sir, are the one who saved our lives."
7
歿
As a youth Yu followed his father to the capital and studied under Yang Yiqing. After passing the jinshi examination, he again associated with Li Dongyang. His poetry and prose were bold and accomplished, and he was also versed in seal and ancient scripts. By nature he loved mountains and rivers and once climbed to the summit of Mount Taihua. He met a tiger; all the servants fell down in fright, but Yu sat upright without moving, and the tiger slowly lowered its tail and walked away. At home he lived plainly, his clothing and equipage like those of a poor scholar. After his death, his two concubines, Liu and Xu, both took their own lives to follow him. When the Muzong Emperor came to the throne, Yu's offices were restored; he was posthumously made Junior Grand Mentor and given the posthumous name Zhuangjian.
8
祿 調 調 便
Sun Jiao, courtesy name Zhitong, was a native of Lu'an. He passed the jinshi examination in the seventeenth year of Chenghua. He was appointed a secretary in the Nanjing Ministry of War and came to the attention of Minister Wang Shu. At the start of the Hongzhi reign, when Wang Shu took office at the Ministry of Personnel, Jiao was recommended and appointed Vice Director in the Office of Merit Records, then served as Director in the Office of Appointments. He served at the Ministry of Personnel for fourteen years and recommended many worthy men to office. He was promoted to Vice Minister of Ceremonies and put in charge of the Bureau of the Four Barbarians. When Datong came under threat, he was ordered to take charge of the frontier defenses around Huanghua Fort. He raised walls and ditches, expanded cultivation, and checked enemy cavalry raids. In the Yongle era, each year troops from the Longqing garrisons were sent to gather firewood and charcoal. Later the practice was abolished and the troops were instead required to pay twenty thousand taels of silver each year, leaving them heavily burdened. Jiao memorialized asking that the levy be abolished. At the start of the Zhengde reign, he was promoted to Director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments. In the third year he was made Right Vice Minister of Revenue and put in charge of the granaries, then transferred to the Ministry of Personnel. Minister Zhang Cai was allied with Liu Jin, and Jiao repeatedly remonstrated with him in sharp terms. Cai was enraged and had him transferred to Nanjing. When Liu Jin fell, Jiao was summoned and appointed Minister of Revenue. At the time the state was campaigning against roving bandits and dispatch was urgently pressed; famine followed famine and regular revenues fell short, yet Jiao arranged finances appropriately. Whenever famine was reported from the provinces, he repeatedly asked to remit taxes and send relief, so the people did not become utterly ruined; yet the petty men then in power all found this inconvenient. The emperor wished to grant the Taiping Granary to his favorite Pei De; the Yunnan garrison eunuch Zhang Lun asked to open silver mines; the Nanjing weaving eunuch Wu Jing reported that funds were exhausted—and Jiao fought every proposal. In the sixth month of the eighth year, by direct imperial order he and Minister of Rites Fu Gui were both forced to retire. Many censorial officials asked that he be kept in office, but received no reply.
9
宿 紿
The Shizong Emperor had known Jiao's reputation while still heir apparent; as soon as he took the throne, he recalled Jiao to his former post. He first asked the emperor to read the Ancestral Instructions every day, take them as the standard for word and deed, and never miss the daily lecture, whether in heat or cold. The emperor praised the advice and accepted it. Some proposed moving the Xianling mausoleum to Tianshou Mountain; Jiao said, "Matters of imperial tombs are grave. The Taizu Emperor wished to move Renzu to Mount Zhong but stopped for fear of draining its spiritual potency—this is fully recorded in the Imperial Mausoleum Stele." The proposal was then dropped. After the Wuzong Emperor's extravagance, the treasury was utterly depleted. Jiao cut redundant stipends, set fixed regulations, and cleared away longstanding abuses. Yet on matters involving eunuchs, the emperor could not fully follow his advice. Once he convened the court to discuss drawing from the inner treasury for military rations and official salaries; approval had already been given, but the eunuchs Liang Jian and others blocked it. Jiao said, "When palace and government disagree and orders are issued only to be reversed, this is not fitting for a new reign." The emperor did not listen. The eunuchs supervising granaries had initially numbered only a few, but in the Zhengde reign they increased to fifty-five. On Jiao's advice more than half were dismissed, but their numbers gradually rose again afterward. The emperor had already dismissed thirty-seven of them, but Jiao wanted them all removed, including at the Linqing, Xuzhou, and Huai granaries—none to be sent at all. The emperor ordered only that no more be added from then on. An edict had forbidden eunuchs guarding the pearl pool from interfering in local administration, but An Chuan used connections to resume his old conduct. Jiao impeached An Chuan, and the emperor ordered matters handled as in the earlier edict. In the Zhengde reign, inner attendants of the Imperial Park reached ninety-nine in number and seized untold tracts of public and private land. When the emperor took the throne, he ordered that eighteen be kept, as in the Hongzhi era. Before long specially appointed eunuchs again reached sixty-two; Jiao asked that they be reduced as at first and that all seized land be fully returned. The request was approved. He also argued that eunuchs of the Imperial Stud should follow ancestral practice, not supervise the collection of fodder and beans, and that the Ministry of Revenue should be notified of horse numbers to stop their embezzlement. The emperor did not comply. Zhang Jin, a hundred-household of the Embroidered Uniform Guard, led bailiffs to draw pay from the Tong Granary and seized goods with reckless abandon; Secretary Luo Hongzai wanted to investigate him. Jin tricked him by asking to accept a beating, then memorialized that Hongzai had unlawfully flogged an imperial guard officer. The emperor was enraged; Hongzai was arrested, sent to the imperial prison, and demoted to service outside the capital. Jiao, Lin Jun, and Qiao Yu successively memorialized in his defense, but the emperor would not listen. Yan Hong of the Imperial Stud asked for outer leopard-house lands; Jiao said, "The previous emperor, because of the leopard quarters, bequeathed endless calamity. Hong and the others wish to restore them and reopen the door to hunting excursions—this is not something we ministers dare even hear proposed." An edict granted ten qing of land to the leopard quarters; the rest was ordered leased as before by Zhao Kai and other hundred-households. As ordered he submitted the acreages of each palace estate; they differed from the old register, and the emperor demanded an explanation. Jiao said, "The old register mostly reflected lands offered through petitions and gifts; the figures were often falsely inflated. The new register is smaller because, on imperial order, a thorough audit cleared and exempted much land." The emperor's anger eased somewhat, and he ordered registers from the Chenghua and Hongzhi reigns examined and reported.
10
輿
Jiao was already seventy and repeatedly memorialized asking to retire. The emperor always comforted him and kept him in office, sending physicians to treat him. When his petitions grew more insistent, permission was granted. By handwritten edict he was given the added title Junior Mentor of the Heir Apparent and granted relay horses for his journey home. He ordered his son Yuan, a Hanlin compiler, to accompany him; local offices were to inquire after him regularly and provide grain, rice, sedan bearers, and attendants, and he was again granted travel expenses. He died at eighty and was given the posthumous name Rongxi.
11
Jiao was gentle and respectful in speech and did not lord his rank and power over others. Pure, cautious, tranquil, and sincere, he was the same from beginning to end. When he was first in Nanjing, his colleagues, finding their duties light and themselves with much leisure, would together amuse themselves with talk, drink, and chess; Jiao quietly stayed in one room and read without stopping. When some remarked on this, Jiao said, "Is speaking with the sages not better than speaking with guests, or wives and concubines!" The Prince of Xingxian had always held Jiao in high regard and once ceded land east of Yangchun Terrace to enlarge his residence. Later a eunuch said that Minister Sun had encroached on land, and the Shizong Emperor said, "This was granted by the late emperor—how dare I seize it?"
12
使
Yuan passed the jinshi examination and ended his career as Vice Commissioner of Sichuan. Careful and solid, he had his father's character.
13
使 使 調
Lin Jun, courtesy name Daiyong, was a native of Putian. He passed the jinshi examination in the fourteenth year of Chenghua. He was appointed a secretary in the Ministry of Justice and promoted to vice director. By nature he was outspoken and upright and did not drift with the crowd. When cases involved the powerful, Minister Lin Cong always assigned Jun to handle them. He memorialized asking that the heterodox monk Jixiao be executed and the favored eunuch Liang Fang punished; the emperor was greatly angered and had him sent to the imperial prison for interrogation. Zhang Fu, a chief clerk of the Rear Palace, came to his defense and was imprisoned as well. The eunuch Huai'en intervened forcefully on their behalf; Jun was demoted to magistrate of Yaozhou, and Fu to prefect of Shizong. At the time the channels of remonstrance had long been blocked; the two men's reputations for integrity shook the capital, and people said of them, "The censor is in the Ministry of Justice; the gate officer came from the Rear Palace." Soon afterward, on the first day of the first month, a stellar anomaly occurred; the emperor was moved and restored Jun to office, transferring him to Nanjing. In the first year of Hongzhi he was promoted to Vice Commissioner of Yunnan on recommendation. At Xuanhua Temple in Heqing there was said to be a living buddha; each year tens of thousands of men and women gathered, competing to gild its face with gold. Jun ordered it burned, and all the gold obtained was used to pay off the people's tax arrears. He also destroyed three hundred sixty illicit shrines and used their timber to repair the Confucian schools. Daobayu, a native chieftain of Ganyai, wished to seize his nephew's post as pacification commissioner and had held the seal for years. Jun issued a proclamation admonishing him, and the seal was returned. He was promoted to surveillance commissioner. In the fifth year he was transferred to Huguang. Citing rain, snow, and other calamitous signs, he memorialized on the strengths and failings of current policy. He also said that building princely estates at De'an and Anlu and expanding the Ji princely establishment entailed vast labor and expenditures in the tens of thousands, and the people could not bear the burden. He asked to follow the precedents of the Ning, Xiang, and De establishments, economize in all respects, not use glazed tile or white-stone carved balustrades, and asked that this be established as a fixed rule. The emperor did not comply. In the ninth year he cited illness and went home without waiting for a reply.
14
使 西西 使 西 祿
After a long while he was recommended and summoned to serve as Right Administrative Commissioner of Guangdong, but he did not accept. He was recalled as Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief at Nanjing to oversee river-defense operations. On the first day of the first month of the fourteenth year, Shaanxi and Shanxi were struck by earthquakes and flooding. In a memorial he recounted the calamities of old wrought by palace women, consort kin, inner attendants, and power-holding ministers; He asked to abolish Daoist rites, reduce textile manufacture, clear illegal corvée claims, eliminate redundant posts, halt construction, economize on provisions, restrain gifts and bestowals, guard against dissipation, keep sycophants at a distance, and draw close to worthy men. He also asked that the heir be given advance instruction and graciously recommended Vice Minister Xie Duo, Vice Directors Chu Jin and Yang Lian, retired Vice Commissioner Cao Shizhong, and the recluse Liu Min as men fit to serve as tutors. The memorial was acknowledged. After that he repeatedly memorialized asking to retire and recommended Cao Shizhong as his successor. The request was denied. In Jiangxi, a Xinchang commoner named Wang Wu turned bandit; Grand Coordinator Han Bangwen could not restore order, and Jun was ordered to inspect the province. Jun entered Wang Wu's stronghold in person; Wu offered to redeem himself through service, and every member of the band was captured. An edict immediately appointed Jun to replace Bangwen, but Jun cited the precedents of Zhu Xi declining to replace Tang Zhongyou and Bao Zheng declining to replace Song Qi and refused the post with all his strength. The emperor would not allow it. He then revised local agreements and brought every branch of administration to new order. The princely establishment levied annual stipends, routinely taking twice what the people could bear; at Jun's urging the exactions were sharply cut. The Prince of Ning, Chen Hao, was greedy and brutal; Jun repeatedly curbed his excesses. The prince asked to replace the glazed roof tiles at a cost of twenty thousand. Jun argued that things should stay as they were and that the prince must not press demands like those of Duke Shu at Jing or accept gifts like the cane stool granted the King of Wu. The prince was furious and watched for a chance to catch him out, but found no fault. When Jun happened to be on an inspection tour for the imperial birthday, he memorialized impeaching the prince and was himself suspended from salary for three months. Before long he returned home to observe mourning for his mother.
15
西 西 輿 西西 使 使 歿
When the Wuzong Emperor took the throne, censors recommended him in succession, and Jiangxi officials at court jointly memorialized asking that Jun be recalled. He was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and again appointed to pacify Jiangxi, but mourning for his father prevented him from taking up the post. In the fourth year of Zhengde he was recalled to serve as grand coordinator of Sichuan. Liu Lie of Meizhou stirred up rebellion; when he was defeated and fled, lawless men everywhere looted in his name. Jun circulated wanted portraits but could not capture him. Then the Baoning bandits Lan Tingrui, Yan Benshu, Liao Hui, and others rose one after another; their power swelled until they turned to raid Bazhou. When he suddenly encountered them at Hualong, he drove alone into their camp, explained what they stood to gain or lose, and the bandits bowed all around and pledged to surrender. Endless rain kept them from keeping their deadline; they rebelled again and overran Tongjiang. Jun routed them at Longtan River, sent Prefect Zhang Min and others in pursuit to defeat them at Menzhenzi, and captured Liao Hui. Tingrui fled to Xixiang in Shaanxi, crossed the Thirty-Six Bends of Hanzhong, and made for the Daba Mountains. Government troops caught up and broke them again. He then moved his army against the Luzhou bandit Cao Fu while also sending envoys to summon and persuade him. Fu pretended to submit, but had his younger brother Guan go on raiding as before. Commander Li Yin cut off Guan's head, and the bandits shifted their base to Jiangjin. They split into seven camps and prepared to strike Chongqing. Jun sent native troops from Youyang and Bozhou to reinforce Yin and, on New Year's Day, launched a surprise attack that smashed four of their camps. The bandits hid in civilian homes; the troops burned the houses and killed everyone inside. Pressing their advantage against the main camp, Commander Wang Yang and others walked into an ambush and were killed. Yin pushed forward again until he was fifteen li from the bandits. Fu rode out with several dozen horsemen, ran into Yin's force, and fled in defeat. Government troops pressed the attack, closed in, and besieged them; captives and those burned alive numbered slightly more than two thousand. Before long, Benshu and Tingrui were seized by Peng Shilin, a native clerk of Yongshun. For his achievements, Jun was promoted to Right Censor-in-Chief. Cao Fu's follower Fang Si was a fugitive in Sinan; he again struck Nanchuan and Qijiang, probing toward Luzhou. Jun sent out more native troops and had Vice Commissioners He Shan and Li Yue and others drive them back. When news of the victory arrived, the emperor sent a sealed letter of praise. On campaign, Jun often found himself at odds with Grand Coordinator Hong Zhong. Whenever sons of favored eunuchs tried to pass off false battlefield credit, he blocked them. Censor Yu Zi ran from the bandits, while Assistant Commissioner Wu Jing fell in battle. Ashamed, Zi tried to pin the blame on Jun and memorialized impeaching him for repeatedly reporting severed heads while the bandits were never wiped out; and for digging wells and tearing down temples, driving out monks and forcing them into banditry. Jun was then sharply rebuked again and again. When Fang Si was beaten, the bandits were nearly gone; Jun refused further promotion and reward and asked to retire to his fields at his existing rank. An edict refused his resignation of rank but permitted him to retire from office. Censors repeatedly petitioned that he be kept on, but received no answer. When Jun went home, scholars and commoners wept and ran after his carriage to see him off. This was in the eleventh month of the sixth year of Zhengde.
16
When the Shizong Emperor took the throne, Jun was recalled as Minister of Works and then moved to the Ministry of Justice. On the road he repeatedly pleaded illness, but was not allowed to turn back. He therefore urged the emperor to keep Confucian ministers near, set his heart right before issuing commands, and lead the realm by plain, unadorned example. He argued that the first edicts to be withdrawn should not use reshuffling of appointments to override public opinion. After he reached the capital, the lecture hall was suspended during the summer heat; he remonstrated by citing the ancestral tradition of diligent study. Jun was already seventy; he took quarters in the court offices to signal that he did not mean to linger. He repeatedly urged the emperor to trust senior ministers, pursue the sage's learning, reject heterodox teachings, and tighten spending. Whenever major policy was at stake, he spoke without flinching, and men inside and outside the court looked to him with hope. The graft of inner attendants Ge Jing and others came to light; after censors impeached them, an edict sent the case to the Directorate of Ceremonial for inquiry. Jun argued that if inner attendants broke the law yet the judicial offices could not try them, palace and state would no longer be one body. He asked that the case be handed to the judicial offices for open trial, as a sign of fair and clear rule. When Grand Defender Liu Hui was thrown into prison, Jun held that under the law against factional collusion he deserved the same punishment as Xu Tai and should be executed to satisfy the realm. Liao Peng, Liao Kai, Qi Zuo, and Wang Huan had been condemned to death, but edicts repeatedly stayed the execution; Jun pleaded that they be put to death at once. He also impeached Gu Dayong for occupying more than ten thousand qing of commoners' farmland. None of his pleas were accepted. Li Yangfeng, a retainer in the household of inner attendant Cui Wen, demanded a bribe from master craftsman Song Yu; when Yu refused, Yangfeng goaded Wen into beating him nearly to death. The Ministry of Justice took the case but had not yet ruled when an inner edict moved it to the Brocade Guard. Jun held the prisoner back and would not hand him over, arguing fiercely and refusing to obey. The next day he memorialized again; the emperor flew into a rage and ordered him to state his case. Jun said, "Our ancestral emperors entrusted criminal trials to the judicial offices and the capture of traitors and thieves to the Brocade Guard. Even after interrogation had yielded a result, the case still had to go to the judicial offices to fix the penalty. Never before has a prisoner whose case was still undecided been snatched away and returned to the very office that had been questioning him. Wen slipped through punishment for treason in the previous reign—a crime that should not have been spared—and now again he meddles by way of an inner edict. Your subject cannot bear to watch a hundred and fifty years of court discipline torn apart by men like these." The emperor, checked by his blunt honesty, dropped the matter.
17
Called back from retirement for his aged virtue, Jun stood on principle without dodging blame; after repeated rebuffs he asked to leave office. An edict added the title Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent, granted him courier horses, and gave him stipends as prescribed.
18
Jun repeatedly contested the Grand Rites controversy and stood with Yang Tinghe. He once memorialized that honoring one's biological parents rested on feelings that could not be suppressed and rites that could not be changed; he gathered ten precedents from Yao and Shun down to Emperor Lizong of Song and submitted them. Once the Grand Rites debate was settled, some who had offended died under the beating staff. In the autumn of the fourth year, Jun wrote from his sickbed: "In antiquity the rod and whip were punishments of shame only—they were not meant to flay a man's flesh until he died, nor were they meant for the scholar-official class. In the Chenghua reign I myself saw two or three ministers beaten at court; even though they wore thick padded underclothes and heavy felt wrappings, they still collapsed and could not rise for a long time. In the Zhengde reign the usurper Liu Jin first ordered men stripped before the beating, and by the end of that reign many died under the staff. I also saw that under Chenghua and Hongzhi, only rebels, purveyors of heterodox speech, and robbers were sent to the imperial prison before interrogation under beating was ordered. For other crimes the order was simply to send the case for questioning. To beat every case during interrogation alike is likewise no established practice. Since last year the senior ministers have been driven out almost to the last man, and the halls of government stand empty. I beg Your Sagely Clarity to take thought: honor with ceremony those who have gone, and comfort and keep those who remain. Men of towering virtue and reputation—Luo Qinshun, Wang Shouren, Lü Nan, Lu Duo, and the like—should be set at Your side. I am worn out by age and illness and await the end; I have no other wish. I dare only follow the spirit of the ancients' deathbed memorials and offer this loyal servant's heart." The emperor simply referred the memorial to the appropriate offices. The next year, as his illness turned grave, he memorialized again urging earnest study and exalted filial piety, the employment of worthy men and acceptance of remonstrance, self-restraint and the cultivation of harmony; he also declined in advance any posthumous honors, and then died. He was seventy-six years old.
19
A year later, when the Minglun Compendium was completed, Jun was posthumously condemned for siding with Tinghe; his rank was stripped, and his son Da buried him with the rites due a private gentleman.
20
退
Jun served four reigns, spoke boldly in remonstrance, entered and left office according to ritual, and held one unbroken standard to the end. At the opening of Longqing his rank was restored; he was posthumously made Junior Guardian and given the posthumous name Zhensu, Upright and Solemn. Da passed the jinshi examination in the ninth year of Zhengde. He rose to the post of Bureau Director in the Ministry of Personnel at Nanjing. He was accomplished in seal and large seal script and wrote well in the ancient prose style.
21
宿
Zhang Fu was from Jishui. He passed the jinshi examination in the eighth year of Chenghua. He served in turn as prefect of Fuzhou and Suzhou, standing apart and refusing to yield to the powerful. During the Hongzhi reign, Lin Jun was prominently promoted, but Zhang Fu, though aged, received no appointment. Wang Shu petitioned on his behalf, and the court specially granted him an honorary patent of appointment.
22
綿 使使 使
Jin Xianmin, styled Shunju, was from Mianzhou. He passed the jinshi examination in the twentieth year of Chenghua. He was appointed a palace messenger. Early in Hongzhi he was chosen as a supervising censor and sent to inspect Yunnan and Shuntian; in both posts he earned a reputation for uncompromising discipline. He left the capital to serve as vice commissioner at Tianjin and later rose to surveillance commissioner of Huguang. Early in Zhengde, with Liu Jin corrupting the government, Xianmin was charged retroactively with falsifying his survey of Tianjin lands; he and Grand Coordinator Liu Yingchen and others were clapped in irons and thrown into the imperial prison, then stripped of office and reduced to commoner status. Soon afterward he was implicated again in a Huguang case, jailed once more, fined, and allowed to return home on payment of redemption. A year later he was punished again when a verdict he had passed in the case of Liu Daolong, a man of Liuyang, proved unsound; he was required to pay a fine in grain for delivery to the frontier garrisons. After Jin's execution he was recalled to serve as surveillance commissioner of Guizhou. He was raised to vice censor-in-chief and appointed grand coordinator of Yan-sui, eventually serving as minister of justice at Nanjing.
23
Yu Xian, a centurion in the Embroidered Uniform Guard and the adopted son of the eunuch Tai, had been given administrative duties by secret edict; censorial officials protested vigorously. Xianmin memorialized: "Our ancestors established fixed regulations; the Xiaozong emperor issued explicit prohibitions; and when Your Majesty took the throne you proclaimed clear edicts. Yu Xian holds no legitimate government post and is not even surnamed Tai; that a servant raised in the inner quarters should usurp rank and disorder the institutions of state is an offense of the gravest kind. Your Majesty ought to accept the censors' advice." The emperor would not heed them. Li Quan, Wang Bangqi, and other deputy chiliarchs of the Embroidered Uniform Guard had been purged for unmerited advancement; they now submitted endless petitions in their own defense, and the case was referred to the ministries for review. Xianmin argued: "Men like Quan never set foot on a battlefield yet claim first honors for merit; they belong to no proper government roster yet vault into high rank. When Your Majesty came to the throne you removed more than three hundred such men, to the relief and approval of the realm. If such abuses reopen even once, your earlier edicts will be rendered void; how will you ever set a limit to the petitions and disturbances that follow?" The emperor nevertheless appointed Quan and his fellows probationary centurions. Xianmin memorialized again: "When an edict is issued, it must be carried out and not withdrawn. Now, on the word of unworthy petitioners, more than ninety have been restored to office overnight; this favors your intimates, breaks ancestral law, and I must lament it on Your Majesty's behalf. Your explicit decree forbade using connections to obtain administrative posts, yet frantic lobbying has already become the custom; You forbade petitions citing precedent for rank, yet a torrent of such memorials has already followed. Who opened this path of harm that still blocks good government today? I ask that Quan and his fellows be dismissed again, to still public criticism and avert the signs of heaven's displeasure." Censorial officials such as Ren Luo spoke to the same effect; the emperor would not heed them.
24
When investigators seized the account books of Zhong Xun, regional commander of Ningxia, who had been bribing officials in the capital, Xianmin's name appeared among the recipients. Supervising secretaries Cai Jing, the censor Gao Shikui, and others submitted joint impeachments; Xianmin took the occasion to request leave on grounds of illness and retire. Two years later Wang Bangqi accused the former minister Peng Ze and implicated Xianmin as well; Xianmin was arrested and held in the Ministry of Justice prison. The judicial authorities charged that Xianmin, though ordered on an independent military expedition, had not reached the field yet had falsely claimed credit in his reports. He had disgraced the conduct expected of a senior minister; he should be stripped of office and confined to private life, and his hereditary privilege annulled. The emperor assented.
25
Earlier, when the Great Rites controversy erupted, Xianmin repeatedly joined the court ministers in memorial protests. At the left Shun Gate remonstrance, when officials wept and protested, he again took the lead with Xu Wenhua. The emperor took lasting offense, and Xianmin eventually paid for it. At the opening of Longqing he received posthumous honors and compensation according to precedent.
26
使 使
Qin Jin, styled Guosheng, was from Wuxi. He passed the jinshi examination in the sixth year of Hongzhi. He was appointed a secretary in the Ministry of Revenue and rose through the ranks to bureau director. Early in Zhengde he was transferred to vice education intendant of Henan, then appointed right administration commissioner. While defending Kaifeng he routed Zhao Zhen at Chenqiao. He served in turn as left and right provincial administration commissioner of Shandong. After the ravages of marauders, he and Grand Coordinator Zhao Huang worked together to restore order and relief, and the shattered province slowly began to recover. In the ninth year he was promoted to vice censor-in-chief and appointed grand coordinator of Huguang. He memorialized for the return to government control of hills, lakes, and marshes seized by the various princely establishments. He Zhang and Luo Dahong, bandits who had surrendered, rebelled again; he put down their revolt. Gong Fuquan, a Yao leader of Guiyang in Chenzhou who proclaimed himself king, was overcome when Jin captured more than eighty strongholds, took two thousand heads, and seized Fuquan and his lieutenant Liu Fuxing among others. His achievements were registered: he was given a raise of one salary grade and the hereditary privilege of a centurion in the Embroidered Uniform Guard, but he strenuously declined and was permitted to do so. He was recalled to the capital as vice minister of revenue.
27
西
When Emperor Shizong took the throne, Qin Jin was moved to the Ministry of Personnel. Censorial officials criticized him for poor judgment of character; he was shifted back to the Ministry of Revenue, promoted to left vice minister, and placed in charge of the ministry. When the imperial in-law Shao Xi petitioned for crown estate lands, Jin cited ancestral precedent and called for an investigation. The emperor excused Shao Xi but ordered the Censorate to uphold the prohibition as before. By secret edict the palace establishments were again allowed imperial estates, with runner-officials sent to oversee them. Jin memorialized: "In the flourishing Western Han, imperial parks were granted to the poor; how can we now levy on the people to swell the imperial purse? I ask that all lands taken beyond proper limits during the Zhengde reign be surveyed and restored to their rightful owners, and that every estate steward be withdrawn." The emperor commended the proposal and adopted it at once.
28
In the second year of Jiajing he was elevated to minister of rites at Nanjing and, leading his colleagues, submitted a memorial: "Since Your Majesty inherited the throne you have shown virtue, checked wrongdoing, and labored diligently for good government, without a single improper act; heaven's favor should attend you—yet disasters and warnings have come one after another. Why is this? As the Book of Songs says: 'All things have a beginning, but few are brought to a good end. Your accession edict set every branch of government aright, and the whole realm looked up in hope of lasting peace. Lately edicts have often been disregarded, the bureaucracy no longer follows them, and the people have lost their anchor—your commands no longer carry the force they had at the start. At first you drove out the mediocre and entrusted the seasoned. Now when the Grand Secretariat drafts replies you often revise them yourself; even formal petitions from your ministers receive only placid answers in return—you no longer trust your worthies as you did at the start. At first you listened openly, answering memorials submitted at dawn before nightfall. Now when matters touch imperial in-laws or eunuchs, even united protest from the nine ministers or the censorate is met with the answer, 'The emperor has already decided.' This shows that you no longer heed counsel as you once did. At first you abolished every rank obtained by irregular promotion or favor during the previous reign. Lately honors have been dispensed too freely and promotions have multiplied without restraint. This shows that you no longer guard official ranks with the care you showed at the start. At first major criminals and factional ringleaders were left to the three legal tribunals. Now they are routinely handed to the imperial prison under the Embroidered Uniform Guard. This shows that you no longer uphold the law as you did at the start. At first you ordered the Ministry of Revenue to halve the fodder allowance for the imperial stud and directed censorial officials to audit the horse rolls. But on the advice of eunuchs such as Yan Hong, that edict was quietly dropped. This shows that you no longer attend to the people's hardship as you once did. At first you expelled the so-called Dharma Kings, Buddha's Sons, state preceptors, and meditation masters. Now, within the forbidden precincts, fasting ceremonies and Daoist rites are being held. This shows that you no longer uphold the orthodox teaching as you did at first. At first your spirit was keen and your energy abundant. Lately Your Majesty's health has faltered and your presence at court has been rare. This shows that you no longer guard your vital energies as you once did. The early reign was clear because policy came from the open court and the emperor's intimates had no part in it; Now it is muddied because policy is made by those at your side while the outer court is kept in the dark. Government must never for a single day leave the court; power must never for a single day pass into private hands. When I say that policy belongs in the court, I do not mean that you must govern unaided. With worthy ministers as your arms and trusted observers as your eyes and ears, your own authority will stand firm as the nine tripods and the realm will be secure as Mount Tai. Every sage ruler who has held the realm has governed by this principle alone. Otherwise the distance between inner and outer courts breeds partial trust, and closeness to consorts and eunuchs deafens the ruler to honest counsel. You may be said to hold all power in name, but the handle of imperial authority has passed into other hands." The memorial went to the Ministry of Rites; Minister Wang Jun pressed the emperor hard to accept it; the court noted receipt.
29
Before long he was transferred to the Ministry of War. When Sun Jiao left office, Qin Jin was recalled as minister of revenue. When the emperor sought to elevate his father, the Xingxian emperor, Qin Jin joined the court ministers protesting at the palace gate and, with He Mengchun and others, laid out point by point the faults in Zhang Cong's plan. When the ceremonial patent for the empress dowager was issued, Qin Jin and Zhao Huang again failed to appear; the emperor repeatedly censured them.
30
Qin Jin was by nature open and affable. In office he held himself entirely to integrity and rectitude. At the Ministry of Revenue he worked with especial zeal for the state. When Princess Yongfu Chang requested estates at Baodi and Wuqing, Qin Jin's remonstrance greatly reduced the amount granted. The Funning and Shanhaiguan estate granted to Xu Da, Duke of Wei, had reverted to the state on his death; when Duke of Ding Guangzuo sought to recover it, Qin Jin firmly refused. Supervising secretary Huang Chong, censor Zhang Heng, and others protested one after another; when Qin Jin and his colleagues renewed the argument, the emperor at last gave his assent. Several thousand military artisans served the inner-palace directorates. When the eunuch Liang Jian asked the ministries to procure gold, jade, pearls, and precious stones, Qin Jin submitted firm remonstrances on every point. The emperor refused to listen. Schemers led by Lu Jun requested three hundred thousand salt vouchers for the Two Huai circuit, and the emperor approved. Qin Jin fought the grant vigorously until he had repeatedly fallen from the emperor's favor.
31
In the spring of the sixth year he submitted his retirement at the official review and was sent home with post-horses, bearers, and grain allowance as prescribed. Five years later, with recommendations unceasing, he was recalled to the Nanjing Ministry of Revenue, where he memorialized six measures for the people's benefit. He was soon called to be minister of works and given the additional title of Junior Mentor of the Heir Apparent. As the emperor and Zhang Fuyi and Li Shi reviewed the senior ministers, they judged Qin Jin worthy but thought him rather old. After a few months he was made Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent and transferred to the Nanjing Ministry of War. A year later he retired and went home. He died in the twenty-third year of the reign, at seventy-eight. He was posthumously honored as Junior Guardian with the posthumous name Duanmin, "Upright and Keen."
32
His son Sun Zhu, though only a licentiate, was appointed a drafting secretary in the Secretariat. When Grand Secretary Gao Gong fell from favor and fled the capital in panic, his students all kept their distance; Zhu alone followed him and saw him off a hundred li beyond the city. Wu Zhongxing submitted a memorial condemning Zhang Juzheng for clinging to office during mourning and was flogged and thrown into the imperial prison. Zhu brought in a doctor to care for Wu's medicine and food, thereby angering Zhang Juzheng, who had him transferred to serve as judicial administrator of the Lu princely establishment. Before long he was removed on the pretext of the merit review.
33
調
Zhao Huang, styled Tingshi, was a native of Anfu. As a boy he accompanied his father to his posting, fell into a river, and survived. When he was older, he found lost gold on the road and returned all of it to its owner. He received his jinshi degree in Hongzhi 3 and was appointed a secretary in the Ministry of Works. He moved to the Ministry of War and rose to vice director. He was appointed prefect of Jinan. Crafty clerks had twisted the law for years, becoming a chronic scourge. Zhao Huang chose willing locals, trained them in the code, and once he had more than twenty who knew it well, he dismissed the old clerks and put the trained men in their place. Pasturelands of the Han princely establishment had long been on the government rolls; he opened them to tenant farmers. When the Prince of De petitioned for those lands, Huang investigated and restored them to the tenants. After seven years his record of governance stood out sharply. Early in the Zhengde reign he was promoted to vice prefect of Shuntian, but before he could take up the post Liu Jin, who hated him, had him imprisoned in connection with grand coordinator Zhu Qin's case and stripped of his name from the rolls. After Liu Jin's execution he was restored to office. He was made Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Xuanfu. He was soon transferred to Shandong. He set several hundred li of river-bank land to be reclaimed by displaced peasants and exempted them from rent. When Buddhist monks from the borderlands sought to levy taxes on that land for ritual provisions, the emperor agreed, but Huang protested until the levy was dropped. After bandits ravaged Qufu, leaving Confucius's grove and temple exposed in open country, Huang petitioned to move the county seat to Konglin; the court agreed. He was promoted to Vice Minister of Works with general charge of the waterways. When border alarms arose he was reassigned to manage the defenses of the capital region. Once the crisis passed he was ordered to administer famine relief in Shuntian and neighboring prefectures, then returned to assist at the ministry.
34
When Emperor Shizong took the throne, Zhao Huang was promoted to Left Vice Minister and placed in charge of the ministry. He slashed eunuchs' funeral allowances and inflated prices at the Directorate of Imperial Use, and abolished the inner palace's annual levies on wine, vinegar, and noodle offices for iron and bricks—amounting to tens of thousands of taels each year. In Jiajing 1 he was promoted to minister. Liu Jin had built Xuansming Palace at a cost of hundreds of thousands; after his death, schemers offered it up as an imperial estate. The new emperor ordered it returned to the people, but soon a palace edict reversed that and restored the old arrangement. Zhao Huang argued that to issue an edict and overturn it within months would show the world that the throne could not be trusted. The emperor immediately agreed. Work was under way on Renshou and Qingning Palaces, and funds were running short. Zhao Huang therefore proposed selling those holdings along with buildings at Shijingshan to supply the works, sparing the burden on the people; the emperor approved. Supervising secretaries led by Xu Jingsong argued that since the edict had promised the land to the people, officials had no right to sell it themselves, and they impeached Zhao Huang. Zhao Huang answered in a memorial, and also brought forward other accusations against Xu Jingsong. Censor Zhang Penghan charged that Zhao Huang was hounding the remonstrating officials and had lost all sense of a senior minister's duty. The emperor upbraided Zhang Penghan for shielding Xu Jingsong and dismissed him in the end. His colleague Chen Jiang, who had joined the impeachment, was also censured and asked to resign. Supervising secretary Zhang Qiao protested that by one stroke Zhao Huang had driven out two remonstrating officials, gravely damaging the dignity of the court. Minister Peng Ze memorialized that Zhang Qiao was in the wrong; Zhang Qiao replied in his own defense; the emperor smoothed matters over on both sides. When an edict ordered construction of Empress Chen's father Chen Wanyan's mansion at an estimated cost of six hundred thousand taels, Zhao Huang held the line. Chen Wanyan complained to the emperor, who had two division directors thrown into the imperial prison. Zhao Huang wrote: "Those two officials had no part in this; punish me alone." The emperor refused. Memorials pleading for the imprisoned men flooded in; Chen Wanyan, unsettled, again asked that they be spared. The two officials were released, and the construction budget was sharply cut.
35
殿 西西使
In the third year, a eunuch custodian at Xianling reported that the tomb's scale was too small and asked that it be rebuilt to match the Tianshou Mountain mausoleums. Zhao Huang replied that a tomb's design should suit its terrain and could not simply be copied; the emperor accepted his view. Later the emperor proposed moving Xianling altogether; Zhao Huang objected, and the plan was dropped. When orders came to build Yude Hall and the Jingfu and Anxi palaces, Zhao Huang asked to defer discussion until Renshou Palace was finished; the emperor refused. Soon afterward, citing portents and disasters, he renewed his earlier plea; the emperor relented and also suspended work on Renshou Palace. When Jiangxi was ordered to build a palace for a Taoist "Perfected One" and Shaanxi to oversee imperial silk works, both missions were placed under palace eunuchs; Zhao Huang protested each time by memorial. During construction of the dynastic temple, the Ministry of Revenue pared back much of what the palace eunuchs requisitioned. When the emperor asked his view, Zhao Huang said surplus funds from earlier work on the Qianqing and Kunning palaces would suffice; the emperor agreed.
36
Zhao Huang served six years as minister during the emperor's early reign, when reform was pursued vigorously and palace eunuchs dared not interfere, so he was able to perform his office. But as he continued to remonstrate without letup, he made enemies among the powerful, and the emperor's favor slowly cooled. Zhao Huang had long stood equal in reputation with Qin Jin. At the merit review both submitted their retirements and left office together. The court pleaded to keep them, but the emperor refused; they were sent home with post-horses, bearers, and grain allowance as custom prescribed.
37
Zhao Huang had a gift for administration and no lack of shrewd judgment. When affairs were in chaos and others stood staring, Zhao Huang set them straight at once. After he retired, officials vied to recommend him for recall. In the eleventh year he was summoned back to his old post but died before he could take it up. He was posthumously honored as Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent with the posthumous name Zhuangjing, "Stern and Tranquil."
38
西
Zou Wensheng, styled Shiming, was a native of Gong'an. He passed the jinshi examination in Hongzhi 6. He was appointed a supervising secretary in the Office of Scrutiny for Personnel. When Liaodong grand coordinator Han Chong impeached the garrison eunuch Liao Chi, Zou Wensheng and bureau director Yang Maoren investigated and confirmed the charges; Liao was demoted to tend incense at Changling. When the Zayan Three Guards raided the frontier repeatedly, Zou Wensheng memorialized six measures for controlling them. Minister Liu Daxia strongly approved and circulated them to frontier officials. He was soon dispatched to audit grain reserves in the Two Guangs. When the native official Cen Jun of Si'en and Cen Meng of Tianzhou went to war, Zou Wensheng wrote: "Tianzhou is Guangxi's outer bulwark; Li Man is Tianzhou's pillar of defense. Vice commissioner Wu Qing accepted heavy bribes from Cen Jun and contrived Li Man's death, setting disaster in motion. Cen Ye of the Edicts Chancery—a close kinsman of Cen Jun—papered over the affair from inside the court and leaked our plans. Execute these two men first, then proceed with the punitive campaign." Cen Ye had protectors at court, and the emperor would not listen. Wu Qing was soon removed in the merit review.
39
使 調 西
Early in the Zhengde reign he rose to chief supervising secretary in the revenue office, then served as prefect of Baoding and eventually as left provincial administrator of Fujian. In the eleventh year he was appointed Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Guizhou. Apang, Ajie, and Age of the Qingping Miao declared themselves kings; grand coordinator Cao Xiang mustered native troops from Yongshun and Baojing to suppress them, but was soon impeached and removed. Apang and his followers held Mount Xianglu, and the guard posts of Xinglong, Pianqiao, Pingyue, Xintian, Longli, and others all suffered from their raids. When Zou Wensheng arrived, he mobilized troops from Sichuan and Huguang for a joint campaign and sent Guizhou forces to storm Paomu Stockade, capturing Age. The Sichuan and Huguang troops arrived and encamped at the foot of the mountain. The mountain rose sheer from the ground; only five narrow paths led upward, and the rebels had palisades posted on every one. Assault from below failed, so they built siege towers level with the cliffs and, under cover of a night rain, scaled the rock face, tore down the palisades, and burned the rebels' huts. The rebels fled to the rear slopes and held the summit. Government troops seized an opening, climbing on vines and timber, captured Apang, and pacified the remaining rebels. They then marched against Black Miao stockades at Longtou, Duli, Dulan, Dupeng, Mixi, Dazhi, Maluo, and others, killing and accepting surrender in numbers beyond count. His merit was recorded: his salary was raised one grade, and his son was granted hereditary enrollment as a hundred-household officer in the Embroidered Uniform Guard. He pressed hard to decline both honors. When Chen Cong of Mangbu and others rose in revolt, he defeated them. Feng Lun, a native officer of Chong'an in Sichuan, bore a grudge against Yang Hong of Kaili. After Hong died, Feng Lun incited various Miao groups to mutual slaughter and raided into Guizhou. Zou Wensheng dispatched vice commissioner Cai Chao to Bozhou to supervise pacification commissioner Yang Bin in restoring order. He petitioned to restore the Anning Pacification Commission, let Hong's son succeed, and record Cai Chao's merit. Minister Wang Qiong punished Cai Chao for acting on his own authority and denied him merit credit. Shortly afterward he was transferred to the Nanjing Censorate.
40
調 使 使 使 西
Liang Cai, styled Dayong, was a native of the Right Jinwu Guard in Nanjing. He passed the jinshi examination in Hongzhi 12. Appointed magistrate of Deqing, where his diligence and quick competence produced outstanding governance. Early in the Zhengde reign he was promoted to bureau director in the Ministry of Justice, then made a censor. He was sent out as prefect of Jiaxing, then transferred to Hangzhou. Land rents varied wildly by custom; Liang Cai weighed heavy and light cases and established a uniform method. He was promoted to Right Vice Commissioner of Zhejiang, then to provincial surveillance commissioner. Garrison eunuch Bi Zhen colluded with Prince Ning and planned to raise the city in his support. Liang Cai and touring inspector Zhang Jin seized Bi Zhen and stripped him of his guard. He soon left office to mourn. Early in the Jiajing reign he was recalled to serve in Yunnan. Native chiefs had feuded for years; Liang Cai summoned them and said: "Your crimes merit death. Today I spare you; redeem yourselves with cattle and sheep." A censor found the penalty too light; Liang Cai said: "This is enough; push too hard and rebellion follows." The chiefs had worn armor beneath their robes awaiting trouble, but hearing nothing further, they stood down. He served in turn as left and right provincial administrator of Guizhou and Guangdong. For tax payments by officials and commoners alike, he required them to operate the scales themselves, with no clerk intervention. At the time the two provincial administrators most renowned for integrity were Liang Cai and Yao Mo. In the sixth year he was appointed Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Jiangxi. Barely two months later he was summoned as Left Vice Minister of Justice.
41
滿 祿祿祿 祿
He was soon moved to the Ministry of Revenue and replaced Zou Wensheng as minister. From provincial service to one of the Six Ministries in less than two years. Mindful of deep imperial favor, he redoubled his diligence. He memorialized: "My review shows last year's intake at only 1.3 million taels while outlays reached 2.4 million. Extra levies still fall short, frontier costs know no limit, and famine districts win repeated remissions—how is the state budget to be managed? He identified five abuses in detail: princely establishments, military offices, redundant stipendaries, wasteful spending, and tax arrears. He asked the court to convene ministers, devise plans, and submit them item by item." Princely and military offices each proposed three measures; everything else was strictly curtailed. The emperor approved all of it. Only the proposal to halve stipends for idle military officers was rejected. Expenditures dropped sharply and the treasury was replenished. Eunuch Mai Fu asked to collect all pasture rents in full; Liang Cai refused. Vice Minister Wang Yue audited noble and consort kin estates and said limits should vary by rank. Liang Cai memorialized: "Under the Zhou, ranked stipends included land; income came from land, not regular stipends plus extra estates. Now noble stipends already exceed proper measure, yet petitions routinely seek millions—I beg a strict ban. Beyond special grants, retain only one-third for sacrificial obligations." The emperor ordered all prior grants reviewed; illegal encroachments were returned to the people, and the powerful dared not petition recklessly. Metropolitan garrison farms were overseen by censors; in the Zhengtong era this shifted to assistant commissioners, authority weakened, and farm administration decayed. Liang Cai asked to restore censor supervision. Censor Guo Honghua said land nationwide had halved since the founding and called for universal remeasurement. Fearing disorder, Liang Cai asked only that offices clarify records and measure acre by acre where registers could not be verified. The emperor approved everything. He left office to mourn his mother. When mourning ended he was recalled to his former post. Datong grand coordinator Fan Jizu requested more military funds; Liang Cai said: "Datong already receives over 770,000 taels yearly, plus tens of thousands in special disbursements—several times the old level. Month by month it grows; the Grand Canal treasury cannot supply one garrison, let alone all nine frontiers." Fan's repeated petitions were denied; sale-of-office quotas were opened instead and sent to the Revenue and War ministries. While two palaces and seven tombs were under construction using 70,000 capital troops, Guo Xun requested monthly grain and winter clothing. Liang Cai said this broke precedent; if granted, it would cost 450,000 taels that year; and winter clothing customarily came from the inner treasury, not his ministry. Guo Xun, enraged, impeached Liang Cai for obstructing state business. The emperor rebuked Liang Cai and sided with Guo Xun. Guo Xun proposed three more measures: open mines to fund construction, send surplus salt revenue to the frontier, and let transport grain crews carry cargo. Liang Cai's review let only part pass; Guo Xun grew angrier still.
42
宿 滿 便
When Liang Cai first took the Revenue ministry, the diligent emperor backed his purge of longstanding abuses. But repeated clashes with favorites frustrated him, and he asked to transfer to the south. Supervising secretary Zhou Chong impeached him; the case went to the Ministry of Personnel, where Minister Xu Zan and others asked to keep him. The emperor was displeased and ordered both men to answer charges in person. Liang Cai accepted blame and was spared; Xu Zan and others lost salary as punishment. From this Liang Cai lost imperial favor. When his six-year term as minister expired, he was ordered to retire. Earlier the Prince of Huai's estate managers had sued tenants; Liang Cai proposed abolishing managers and having officials pay rents directly to the prince, which was approved. The prince complained of hardship and the emperor reversed course. Liang Cai had already left when Vice Minister Tang Zhou and others held to the original edict. The emperor was furious and blamed Liang Cai as well. Liang Cai was sidelined as idle Right Vice Minister; Tang Zhou lost salary and a division director went to the imperial prison.
43
The next year Revenue Minister Li Tingxiang was dismissed. Remembering Liang Cai's integrity and diligence amid many recommendations, the emperor recalled him and made him Junior Mentor of the Heir Apparent. Three times he held the national accounts, scrupulous as ever, and imperial regard ran deep. That autumn he was specially ordered to supervise the capital officials' merit review. When a major case could not be settled, he was also put in charge of the Ministry of Justice. The emperor sighed: "Twelve ministers like Liang Cai, and I would have no worry for the realm." Major construction continued, employing 46,000 garrison rotation troops from outside the capital. Guo Xun seized on absences to demand silver for hired labor and grain equal to capital troops. Li Tingxiang had once granted partial payment; Liang Cai steadfastly refused. Guo Xun impeached Liang Cai; the emperor ordered payment. Guo Xun then cited troop shortages and proposed converting deserters' cloth and cotton stipends into silver to hire workers. Liang Cai said: "Over 40,000 capital rotation troops suffice; this pretext must not drain the treasury." The emperor accepted his memorial. Guo Xun grew angrier still and charged Liang Cai with overturning established rules. Apart from that, the altar rites required ambergris incense and Liang Cai failed to deliver it on time; the emperor nursed a grievance. He was then charged with grandstanding at the expense of duty and dismissed to idle status. He returned home and soon died at seventy-one. Early in the Longqing reign he was posthumously honored as Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent with the posthumous name Duansu, "Upright and Solemn."
44
During the Jiajing years, many grand ministers flattered the emperor to win favor, but Liang Cai alone would not bend—and for that was never truly tolerated. After Liang Cai left office, frontier reserves and the state treasury fell into acute distress. The Shizong Emperor sighed: "If Liang Cai were still in office, it would not have come to this."
45
西 西 使
Liu Lin, styled Yuanrui, was a native of Anren. For generations his family had served as assistant battalion commanders in the Nanjing Guangyang Guard, and they settled there. A diligent scholar and able writer, he was called, with Gu Lin and Xu Zhenqing, one of the "Three Talents of the Jiangdong." In the ninth year of the Hongzhi reign he passed the jinshi examination. When the remonstrating officials Pang Pan and others were imprisoned, Liu Lin joined his fellow graduate Lu Kun in a joint memorial to save them. He was appointed a principal clerk in the Ministry of Justice and promoted to assistant department director. Reviewing prisoners in the capital region, he reversed wrongful convictions for more than three hundred ninety persons. At the start of the Zhengde reign he was promoted to department director and sent out as prefect of Shaoxing. Liu Jin resented Liu Lin for failing to call and offer thanks; after only five months he seized on minor matters from the earlier prisoner review and had him reduced to commoner status. The gentry and people pooled money for his travel expenses, which he refused; they built a Little Liu Shrine in his honor, pairing him with the Han official Liu Chong, and he took up residence in Huzhou. With Wu Wan, Shi Kan, Sun Yiyuan, and Long Ni he was known as the "Five Recluses of Hunan." After Liu Jin was executed, Liu Lin was recalled to fill the post at Xi'an. When his father died he took mourning leave, delighted in the landscape of Wuxing, buried his father's coffin there, and settled in Huzhou. He was recalled as left assistant administrator of Shaanxi and put in charge of grain stores. When Censor-in-Chief Deng Zhang commanded the army, he proposed raising taxes to fund provisions; Liu Lin argued fiercely against it. Soon Shaanxi commoners petitioned at court, and the plan was shelved. Shortly afterward he was transferred to be surveillance commissioner of Yunnan, then retired on grounds of illness.
46
殿
At the start of the Jiajing reign he was summoned and appointed Minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud. He was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and made grand coordinator of the six prefectures of Baoding. The eunuch Geng Zhong, defending Zijing Pass, was excessively lax; Liu Lin impeached him. He asked to remit the land-tax levies on garrison farms of the three guards at Tianjin and to draw from treasury reserves to pay the monthly stipends of the three guards at Hejian, recovering overdue taxes to make up the cost—all approved. The emperor therefore instructed the Ministry of Revenue that all military stipends at home and abroad still unpaid should be fully disbursed. He again cited illness and retired. He was recalled as President of the Court of Judicial Review and appointed Minister of Works. The palace guard troops were not issued clothing and footwear; the Embroidered Uniform Guard commander Luo An cited the precedent of the Red-Helmet Guard in requesting it, but Liu Lin firmly refused. An edict ordered silver to be measured out for them to make their own, with reissue every five years as the rule. The goods of the four bureaus were all stored in the rear-hall treasury, and bureau officials embezzled much in handling receipts and disbursements; Liu Lin asked that a special clerk be appointed to oversee them. The emperor praised the plan and bestowed the name "Treasury of Thrift and Care." Later he submitted fourteen items on economizing, cutting fraudulent expenditures by the inner-palace directorates and supervisory offices; the eunuch elite deeply resented him. When work on the Xianling Mausoleum was finished, laborers all coveted official posts. Liu Lin would only recommend modest rewards, and the petty men grew still angrier. When the emperor accepted remonstrating officials' advice and halted miscellaneous labor levies at home and abroad, Liu Lin ordered a halt to weaving in Zhejiang, Suzhou, and Songjiang—including tribute robes for the court among the stoppages. The eunuch Wu Xun complained, and Liu Lin was forced to retire. Long afterward, when rain leaked through the halls and pavilions of Xianling, Liu Lin was pursued in review and stripped of rank.
47
輿
Liu Lin was pure in conduct and upright in integrity, unyielding in office. At the Ministry of Works he spared the state's wealth and guarded against waste, yet was dismissed after little more than a year. He lived at Nantan outside the city and amused himself composing poetry. The prefect built him a terrace and ordered a hall constructed, so that he finally had a place to rest and stroll. At home for more than thirty years, court ministers repeatedly recommended him. In his later years he loved living in an upper story but lacked the strength to build one; he hung a basket-chair from a beam and lay curled within it, calling it the Spirit Tower. Wen Zhengming painted a picture and sent it to him as a gift. He died at the age of eighty-seven. He was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the posthumous title Qinghui.
48
Jiang Yao, styled Cuiqing, was a native of Gui'an. In the twelfth year of the Hongzhi reign he passed the jinshi examination. He was appointed a courier. In the Zhengde era he served as censor in both capitals. He set forth seven abuses of the age, saying among them: "The inner-palace Armory Bureau has six thousand military artisans, with two eunuch supervisors; now they have increased to more than sixty, each claiming thirty artisans. Other bureaus are the same—how can the ranks not be depleted?" He also said: "Commissioned officials and the indiscriminate recruitment of guards, braves, and warriors should all be reformed. Though Liu Jin was executed, power still rested with the eunuchs." An imperial rescript rebuked him and declared that from then on no one should again submit memorials like Jiang Yao's." He was soon sent out as prefect of Jingzhou. He built the Huangtan embankment.
49
調 西
He was transferred to Yangzhou. When the Wuzong Emperor toured south to Yangzhou, Jiang Yao supplied only what was needed for the imperial retinue and made no gifts. All the favored minions were enraged. Jiang Bin wanted to seize wealthy households' residences for a Vice General of Martial Prestige's mansion; Jiang Yao refused. Jiang Bin shut Jiang Yao in an empty house to humiliate him and threatened him with the copper mace the emperor had bestowed, but Jiang Yao was not intimidated. Once when the emperor caught a huge fish while fishing, he joked that it was worth five hundred taels; Jiang Bin immediately handed it to Jiang Yao and demanded payment. Jiang Yao brought his wife's hairpins, earrings, and formal robes and presented them, saying: "The treasury has no money; all I have is this." The emperor laughed and sent him away. The prefecture had a Qionghua View; an edict ordered the qionghua flower to be presented. Jiang Yao said that since the Northern Hunt of the Song emperors Huizong and Qinzong, the flower had been extinct and there was nothing to offer. When another edict demanded exotic goods, Jiang Yao answered in detail that they were not products of Yangzhou. The emperor said: "Ramie white cloth—is that not a Yangzhou product?" Jiang Yao had no choice and presented five hundred bolts. At that time the powerful and favored, seeing Yangzhou's wealth, made demands without limit. But for Jiang Yao, the people would have been doubly burdened. When the imperial procession returned, Jiang Yao escorted it as far as Baoying. The eunuch Qiu De bound Jiang Yao with iron chains; only after several days was he released, and he escorted the procession all the way to Linqing before returning. When the people of Yangzhou saw Jiang Yao, none failed to weep with gratitude. Later, when he was transferred to be assistant administrator of Shaanxi, they vied to contribute funds and build a shrine to worship him; his fame was greatly magnified from then on.
50
西使 調 西殿 殿殿
At the start of the Jiajing reign he served successively as left and right provincial administrators of Huguang and Jiangxi, then as Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Henan. The emperor ordered Gui E and others to review which grand coordinators should stay or go, and directed Jiang Yao to return and await reassignment. Soon afterward he was promoted step by step to Minister of Works. When work on the four suburban altars was finished, he was made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. When the Western Park palaces were completed, the emperor held a banquet. Seeing Jiang Yao and Wang Shizhong seated outside, he ordered them moved inside the hall and shifted imperial kinsmen to the right side of the hall to make room for Jiang Yao, saying: "Honoring the worthy comes before honoring one's kin." Such was the esteem in which he held Jiang Yao. At the time construction was flourishing, costing millions each year. Jiang Yao's planning always pleased the emperor, and he received many gifts and grants. He left office on mourning leave. Long afterward, from Minister of Works at Nanjing he was summoned and transferred to the northern ministry. When the emperor visited Chengtian, Jiang Yao accompanied him. Capital construction usually conscripted capital troops, many of whom were concealed and kept by powerful families. Now major works came in rapid succession, and civilians were recruited yearly for corvée at a cost of more than two million taels. Jiang Yao spoke on this and asked that non-urgent projects be halted. The troops concealed by powerful families all came forth, and recruitment costs fell sharply. He retired on account of age.
51
Jiang Yao was upright, bright, and incorruptible. After returning home he lived in a humble lane. With the ministers Liu Lin, Gu Yingxiang, and others he formed a literary wine society and wandered among the Xian hills. He died at the age of eighty-nine. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the posthumous title Gongjing.
52
便退 西 使西使退 西 使 使
Wang Tingxiang, styled Ziheng, was a native of Yifeng. From youth he had a literary reputation. He passed the jinshi examination in Hongzhi 15 (1502), was chosen as a Hanlin bachelor, and received appointment as a supervising secretary in the Bureau of Military Affairs. He left office on account of mourning. Early in the Zhengde reign, when his mourning period ended, he came to the capital. Liu Jin had him demoted for a crime to the post of assistant magistrate of Bozhou; he was then transferred in grade to magistrate of Gaochun. He was summoned and made a censor, memorializing: "Great bandits rise on every side, yet commanders cannot pacify them. This is because generals hold too little authority and cannot resist the enemy; military plans are lax, and they cannot hold the strategic passes. Wherever bandits go, villagers offer oxen and wine; many even serve them willingly. Bandits hold the power of life and death, while commanders in turn do not, so the troops will not obey orders. Commanders should be granted discretionary authority, with execution mandatory for any who retreat. Henan has level, open terrain, so bandits can flee easily; Shanxi has steep, obstructive terrain, yet they are allowed to penetrate deep—in both cases the fault lies with the commanders. If troops were arrayed at the Yellow River crossings to block the west, and forces stationed to hold Jingxing and Tianjing to block the east, while the chief commander pressed in with a great army, the bandits would be trapped whether they advanced or retreated and could be captured without fighting." The emperor sharply rebuked the regional governors and fully adopted his proposal. Before long he went out on an inspection tour of Shaanxi, curtailing the eunuch garrison commander Liao Tang, and was slandered. By then he had already been reassigned to oversee capital schools; he was seized and imprisoned in the imperial prison, and demoted to assistant magistrate of Ganyu. He was repeatedly promoted to vice commissioner in Sichuan and vice commissioner in Shandong, each time overseeing schools. In Jiajing 2 (1523) his administration was cited as outstanding, and he was promoted again to Right Administrator of Shandong. As Right Vice Censor-in-Chief he became governor of Sichuan and suppressed the Mangbu bandit Shabao.
53
祿
Soon he was recalled to administer the Censorate. He served successively as Left and Right Vice Minister of War, was transferred to Minister of War at Nanjing, and assisted in state affairs. An imperial edict had initially ordered a reduction in tribute express boats. The garrison eunuch Lai Yi again requested an increase; Wang Tingxiang asked that the weight of goods be weighed to set the number of boats, and greatly reduced edicts issued after the Xuande reign that were not ancestral institutions. At the five passes of Longjiang, Dasheng, Xinjiang, Puzi, and Jianghuai, local officials used inspection to levy customs profits; at Anqing and Jiujiang they demanded bribes under the pretext of spring and autumn reviews—Wang Tingxiang memorialized to abolish all of this. Revenues from pasture lands and reed duties were routinely embezzled by the eunuchs Yang Qi and Bu Chun and by Xu Pengju, Duke of Wei. At Wang Tingxiang's request, Qi and Chun were arrested and interrogated, and Pengju's stipend was confiscated. In the third month he entered office as Left Censor-in-Chief, memorializing that the Nanjing garrison commander's authority was too great and that the Duchy of Wei should not hold the post by hereditary succession. The supervising secretary Zeng Bian spoke similarly, and Pengju was thereupon stripped of his military command.
54
滿 滿 殿
After two years he was additionally made Minister of War while retaining his previous post, put in charge of the regiment camps, and still administered the Censorate. After two terms of appraisal he was made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. A resident of the capital region stole trees from the Tianshou imperial tombs; the touring censor Yang Shaofang applied the statute on stealing sacred vessels for great sacrifices and sentenced him to decapitation. Wang Tingxiang said: "The term sacred vessels for great sacrifices refers to the inner ritual implements, curtains, and hangings used in sacrifice. The statute text for stealing tomb timber prescribes only one hundred blows with the rod and three years' penal servitude. To set aside the primary statute now would not be equitable punishment." He offended the imperial will and was fined one month's salary. When the emperor was about to visit Chengtian, Wang Tingxiang joined the chief ministers in remonstrance, but was not heeded. Returning from the entourage tour, upon completion of nine years in office he was made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. Lightning struck the Hall of Imperial Ancestors; Wang Tingxiang said: "Only when human affairs are put in order does the way of Heaven run straight; only when great ministers uphold the law do lesser officials keep themselves pure. Now the corners of integrity are not established and bribery runs rampant; in earlier reigns it was still a matter of secret gifts at night, but now it is brazen plunder in broad daylight. When great ministers are corrupt, lesser officials all follow suit; when capital officials are greedy, outside officials have nothing to fear. In my office of upholding the laws I cannot cut off this abuse; I beg first to be dismissed." This was intended as an indirect rebuke of Ministers Yan Song, Zhang Zan, and their like. The emperor merely instructed him to remain in office, and that was all.
55
Earlier, Wang Tingxiang had asked that censors returning from provincial tours be evaluated according to six criteria. The emperor ordered him to set forth what was still incomplete and compile it into the regulations of the Censorate. He then took the items memorialized by Zhang Fujing and Wang Hong, together with fifteen newly established provisions, and submitted them; all were approved and put into practice. When fire destroyed the Nine Temples, an edict was issued calling for self-examination, and the emperor charged Wang Tingxiang: "The duty of censors touring the provinces is weighty indeed. You have presided over the Censorate for many years, yet since the six criteria were established you have not dismissed a single man through evaluation; you should now earnestly examine yourself." Wang Tingxiang, in alarm, apologized.
56
輿
Wang Tingxiang held the inner Censorate longest and possessed formidable authority. When he oversaw the regiment camps and worked alongside Guo Xun, he was circumspect in that partnership and could bring about no real reform. The supervising secretaries Li Fenglai and others discussed how the powerful seized the people's profit; the memorial was sent to the Censorate, and Wang Tingxiang ordered the Five Cities censors to verify the facts, but they delayed more than forty days. The supervising secretary Zhang Yunxian thereupon impeached Wang Tingxiang for favoritism and disrespect toward the throne. The emperor was just rebuking him when Wang Tingxiang reported what the censors had verified, namely that Guo Xun alone had seized the most. The emperor ordered Xun to memorialize in his own defense, and impeachments against Xun poured forth. Xun again provoked the emperor's anger by delaying delivery of an imperial edict he had received, and was imprisoned. Wang Tingxiang was charged with factional collusion and expelled to commoner status. Three years later he died. Wang Tingxiang was broadly learned and fond of debate, famed for his mastery of the classics. On astronomy and calendrics, cartography, musical pitch, the River Diagram and Luo Writings, and the works of Zhou Dunyi, Shao Yong, the Cheng brothers, and Zhang Zai, he had criticisms to offer in each case, yet his views were rather eccentric. At the start of the Longqing reign his office was restored; he was posthumously given the rank of Junior Guardian and the posthumous title Summin.
57
The commentator says: Qiao Yu defended Nanjing with composure and calm, enforcing readiness within—he may be called a man equal to great affairs. Seeing how Yu, together with Sun Jiao and others, polished their integrity in public service and earnestly remonstrated at court, their intent was to block the gates of imperial favor and strengthen the national interest. Though they won the ruler's trust and governed, they could not match Jian Shu and Xia Yuanji; yet in their stern purity and uncompromising integrity they yielded little to their predecessors. Jiang Yao as minister found his reputation diminished by his prefectural administration; Wang Tingxiang, presiding over the inner Censorate, never displayed firm authority—perhaps this was largely the fault of the times.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →