← Back to 明史

卷二百四十一 列傳第一百二十九 周嘉謨 張問達 汪應蛟 王紀 孫瑋 鍾羽正 陳道亨

Volume 241 Biographies 129: Zhou Jiamo, Zhang Wenda, Wang Yingjiao, Wang Ji, Sun Wei, Zhong Yuzheng, Chen Daoheng

Chapter 241 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 241
Next Chapter →
1
Zhou Jiamo and Zhang Wenda (Lu Menglong, Fu Mei)〉 Wang Yingjiao and Wang Ji (Yang Dongming)〉 Sun Wei, Zhong Yuzheng, and Chen Daoheng (son Hongxu)〉
2
Zhou Jiamo
3
Zhou Jiamo, styled Mingqing, came from Hanchuan. He received his jinshi degree in the fifth year of the Longqing reign. He was made a principal secretary in the Ministry of Revenue and later served as prefect of Shaozhou.
4
使 使
In the tenth year of the Wanli reign he was made Vice Commissioner of Sichuan with touring authority over Luzhou. He pursued the great outlaw Yang Tengxiao to the end and had him executed. When troops of Jianwu Guard burned Regional Commander Shen Sixue's headquarters, he went out alone in a carriage to reason with them and restored order. He soon pacified the Bai Cao tribes. Whether directing troops in Qiongzhou or Guan County, he showed sound strategy in each. After five years he was promoted to surveillance commissioner, then pleaded illness and went home. After a long interval he was recalled to his former post. The eunuch monopoly-tax commissioner Qiu Chengyun spread terror, and arrests came one after another. Jiamo ordered the local offices to resist him and had wicked men who aided the oppression beaten to death; Chengyun was thus curbed.
5
使 滿 西退
He was thereupon made Left Administration Commissioner. He was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and appointed grand coordinator of Yunnan. Duo Anmin, the Longchuan pacification commissioner, rebelled, fled into Burma, and seized Manwan. Jiamo campaigned against him, captured him, installed his younger brother Anjing in his place, and returned. He was promoted to Right Vice Minister of War while retaining his grand coordinator post. The Duke of Qian, Mu Changzuo, had seized more than eight thousand qing of commoners' land; Jiamo impeached and punished him, and later impeached his grandson Qiyuan for further offenses. After some time he was reassigned to supervise military affairs in the Two Guangs while serving as grand coordinator of Guangdong. When his term ended he was given the additional rank of Right Censor-in-Chief. Guangxi chieftains brought in Annamese troops to raid the interior; government forces drove them back, and Jiamo added troops and strengthened the garrisons. Great floods in Nanhai, Sanshui, Gaoyao, Sihui, Gaoming, and other districts destroyed the dikes; he set aside redemption fines to rebuild them.
6
He was transferred to Minister of Revenue at Nanjing and soon summoned to serve as Minister of Works. When Empress Dowager Xiaoding died, the inner court demanded enormous outlays for the mourning. Jiamo argued that mourning rites had fixed middle standards and that the court should not heed attendants and squander the treasury; his advice was rejected. He was soon made Minister of Personnel.
7
退 殿 殿 滿
In the seventh month of the forty-eighth year of his reign, Emperor Shenzong died. On the first day of the eighth month, a bingwu day, Emperor Guangzong ascended the throne. Consort Zheng held the Palace of Heavenly Purity and also sought to be ennobled as empress dowager. Following remonstrance officials such as Yang Lian and Zuo Guangdou, Jiamo pressed Consort Zheng's nephew Yangxing with the weight of principle and showed him what he stood to gain or lose. The consort then moved to the Palace of Imperial Tranquility, and the bid for empress dowager status was dropped. Throughout the outer court it was said that the consort had presented eight attendants and thereby brought on the emperor's illness. On the twenty-sixth day Jiamo was summoned to audience and urged restraint of desire; the emperor looked at him a long while and had the eldest imperial son tell the outer court, "Rumors are not to be trusted." The officials then withdrew. On the twenty-ninth day the emperor's illness turned critical; Jiamo, together with Grand Secretaries Fang Congzhe, Liu Yijing, Han Kuang, and others, received his deathbed charge. That same evening the emperor died. At dawn on the first day of the ninth month, a yihai day, Guangzong's testament named the eldest imperial son as successor; yet Lady Li dominated the palace and her power was swelling, and the court feared what might come. Once they had entered to mourn, they asked to see the eldest imperial son, cried "Long live the Emperor!", escorted him to Wenhua Hall to receive the court's homage, and sent him to live at Ciqing Palace. Jiamo memorialized: "Your Highness's person is entrusted with the altars of state; you should not go in and out lightly. For the major and minor encoffining and for morning and evening attendance at the lying-in-state, you must wait until we arrive before proceeding." The eldest imperial son nodded in assent. The senior ministers resolved that the eldest imperial son would ascend the throne on the sixth day of the ninth month. Lady Li continued to occupy Qianqing as before and even wished to keep the eldest imperial son living with her. Jiamo urgently drafted a memorial and led the court in demanding that she move palace; Zuo Guangdou and Yang Lian followed with their own. On the fifth day Lady Li at last moved to Yanluan Palace. Deaths in the imperial house came one after another and the state tottered; Chief Minister Fang Congzhe wavered, while Liu Yijing and Han Kuang had only just taken power. Jiamo stood in court with stern bearing, forcefully upheld the great decisions of the day, and court and country alike looked to him as their anchor. At the end of Shenzong's reign the Qi, Chu, and Zhe factions controlled government, and the Ministry of Personnel could no longer command appointments and dismissals. Once Jiamo held the power of appointment, he assigned office solely by talent. Guangzong and Xizong succeeded to the throne in turn; Jiamo brought back large numbers of men from the dismissed rolls until venerable worthies filled the court. Those long called leaders of the three factions and clique villains who had thrown government into disorder also gradually withdrew on their own, and the central court grew clean. He then urgently described how official governance had decayed and asked that grand coordinators, surveillance commissioners, and circuit intendants be held accountable. Superiors' written evaluations mostly used polished parallel prose and often missed the truth; Jiamo asked that official appraisals be grounded in six matters: integrity, talent, mind, administration, years of service, and appearance. Each item was to record what was true, without ornamental phrasing. The emperor approved and put the reform into practice.
8
退
In the first year of the Tianqi reign, Censor Jia Jichun was punished for an offense; his colleagues Zhang Shenyan and Gao Hongtu memorialized in his defense, and the emperor wished to punish them too. Jiamo and others pressed hard for their release, and in the end only Shenyan's and Hongtu's salaries were suspended. When Zhu Qinxiang and Ni Sihui were demoted, Jiamo interceded for them as well. Supervising Secretary Huo Weihua, seeking to please Wei Zhongxian, impeached Wang An and had him executed. Jiamo detested this and had Weihua posted outside the capital. Zhongxian was furious and incited Supervising Secretary Sun Jie to impeach Jiamo for taking Liu Yijing's commission to avenge Wang An, and also cited Jiamo's appointment of Yuan Yingtai, Tong Bunian, and others as offenses. Jiamo asked to retire, and Zhongxian forged an edict granting his request. Grand Secretary Ye Xianggao and others asked that Jiamo be kept until the great evaluation of officials was finished, but the court would not listen. The following year, when Guangning fell, Jiamo, stricken with grief and anger, sent an urgent memorial impeaching Minister of War Zhang Heming for advocating war and misleading the state. In the autumn of the fifth year, Zhongxian's follower Zhou Weichi again impeached Jiamo for shielding Wang An, and he was struck from the official rolls.
9
In the first year of the Chongzhen reign he was recommended and recalled as Minister of Personnel at Nanjing, with the added title of Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent. The following year he died in office, aged eighty-four. He was posthumously ennobled as Junior Guardian.
10
Zhang Wenda
11
Zhang Wenda, styled Deyun, came from Jingyang. He received his jinshi degree in the eleventh year of the Wanli reign. He served in turn as magistrate of Gaoping and Wei, where his rule won popular gratitude. He was summoned and appointed supervising secretary in the Bureau of Punishments. When war broke out in Ningxia, he asked that all land-tax arrears throughout Shaanxi be remitted, and the court agreed. When his mourning for his father ended he was recalled to his former post and rose to Left Supervising Secretary in the Bureau of Works. The emperor was then building the Two Palaces; eunuchs profited from embezzlement and revived other labor projects, and Wenda pressed hard for them to stop, but his plea was rejected. He soon set forth the harm of the mining tax, saying, "Once a eunuch commissioner receives his mandate, he dares impeach prefects at will, and even grand coordinators and surveillance commissioners. Men such as Cheng Shouxun and Chen Bao, whom Sun Chao brought with him, went so far as to beat appointed officials to death, destroy houses, and dig up graves. If they are not prosecuted, how can the empire's outrage be answered!" While conducting examinations in Shandong he memorialized on the famine, destitution, and displacement he saw along the way and urgently asked that mining taxes be abolished empire-wide; none of it received a reply. He was then assigned to inspect the factories and storehouses. By precedent merchants were ordered to supply goods for the inner palace, their names submitted collectively for approval; this was called the collective-merchant system. Wealthy merchants usually bribed favored attendants to win exemption, and the emperor invariably granted it. Wenda memorialized twice in protest and also pressed Cheng Shouxun's crimes to the limit; all were shelved without action. He was promoted to Chief Supervising Secretary in the Bureau of Rites. He impeached Li Zhi of Jinjiang for heterodox teachings that misled the people; Li was arrested and died in prison. Li Zhi's case is treated fully in the 《Biography of Geng Dingxiang》.
12
殿
In the tenth month of the thirtieth year, when a star changed, he again asked that mining taxes be abolished entirely. Solar eclipses had fallen in the fourth month several years running; Wenda held that in this month of pure yang the omen was especially grave, and he memorialized again and again calling for moral reform in language of utmost urgency, yet the emperor never listened. He was soon made Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and appointed grand coordinator of Huguang as Right Vice Censor-in-Chief. His jurisdiction suffered floods, and he repeatedly asked for tax remission and relief grain. The emperor was then building the Three Halls and procuring timber in Chu at a projected cost of more than 4.2 million taels; Wenda cut costs on every front, sparing the people crushing burdens. After some time he was summoned as Right Vice Minister of Justice, acting head of the ministry while also acting head of the Censorate.
13
In the fifth month of the forty-third year the court reviewed judgment in the Zhang Cha club-assault case. Wenda took the advice of Registrar Lu Menglong and ordered a joint interrogation by the thirteen bureaus; testimony linked Consort Zheng's palace stewards Pang Bao and Liu Cheng. Rumors spread at court and beyond, and many suspected the consort's brother Guotai was behind it. Wenda and his colleagues memorialized the court with the findings in Zhang Cha's case. When the emperor saw Pang Bao and Liu Cheng named, he held the memorial and issued no response. He soon summoned Fang Congzhe, Wu Daonan, Wenda, and others to Cining Palace and ordered both men torn apart by execution. Barely back in the palace the emperor changed his mind again: Cha was executed first, and the Nine Ministers with the three judicial offices were ordered to interrogate Bao and Cheng jointly at Wenhua Gate. Bao and Cheng gave their original names as Zheng Jin and Liu Dengyun but refused to confess. Midway through the interrogation the Eastern Palace sent word: "Zhang Cha was truly mad; he blundered into the palace gate and wounded inner attendants—a crime that cannot be pardoned. He later implicated Bao and Cheng as palace eunuchs plotting against this palace. What could they gain from it? Charge him with trumped-up hatred and fix a lighter sentence." Wenda and others, holding that the inquiry was incomplete, memorialized: "A villain forced his way into the palace—the matter touches the fate of the state. With Zhang Cha dead, the two prisoners can easily cover for one another and fabricate testimony. Wenhua Gate is a place of solemn dignity; we dare not torture there—how are we to get at the truth? The two prisoners' one-sided statements are hardly evidence at all. Though Zhang Cha is dead, his testimony remains, and co-conspirators such as Ma Sandao likewise have statements on file—who can erase them? Moreover, at an audience in Cining Palace you ordered them executed together in person. Those august words from the throne were heard throughout the realm. Unless the case is handed to the outer court for a rigorous joint interrogation, why should they confess? Without a confession, how can the law be properly applied? In two hundred years under our founders no convicted prisoner has ever been sentenced without referral to the judicial offices. Moreover, both men are palace eunuchs. The law begins with those nearest the throne; Your Majesty should hold them to an especially strict rein and impose the severest penalty. How can you let them argue at length and not cast them out together with the judgment of the empire?" Because the two prisoners implicated the Zheng family, the emperor referred them to the outer court; as debate intensified he had them quietly killed inside, alleging death from severe wounds. Ma Sandao and four others were sentenced to penal exile on comparatively light grounds. The affair was thus brought to a close. That year he stepped down from his Censorate duties. Before long he was made Minister of Revenue and put in charge of the granaries. He soon also acted head of the Ministry of Justice and was appointed Left Censor-in-Chief. When Guangzong's illness turned critical, he shared in receiving the deathbed charge.
14
詿
In the winter of the first year of Tianqi he succeeded Zhou Jiamo as Minister of Personnel. He presided over successive grand evaluations of inner and outer officials, and in every case followed prevailing opinion. By then most of the officials punished during Wanli for ill-fated memorials had long been out of office; more than half were already dead. Wenda and colleagues resolved that those who had been beaten at court, imprisoned, or exiled ranked first and should receive posthumous honors and privileges for their sons; those demoted, banished, or struck from the registers ranked second and should receive posthumous office only. Seventy-five men received this relief.
15
Meanwhile Sun Shenxing and Zou Yuanbiao reopened the "Red Pill" controversy and pressed hard against Fang Congzhe. The throne ordered the court to deliberate; more than one hundred officials took part. After collecting the consensus Wenda joined Minister of Revenue Wang Yingjiao and others in a memorial that read:
16
"Pursuant to Shenxing's memorial, the chief guilt lies with Li Kezhuo for presenting the red pill. Kezhuo had first approached Congzhe; we ministers knew nothing of it at first. When we were summoned into Qianqing Palace we waited on the red steps; Congzhe and we ministers discussed Li Kezhuo's offering of medicine together, and all were cautious and undecided. We were soon summoned inside to kneel before the emperor; the late emperor himself said, "My body is weak," spoke of his tomb, urged us to assist Your Majesty as Yao and Shun had their successors, and then asked, "Where is Kezhuo?" Kezhuo hurried in, mixed the medicine, and presented it; shortly afterward he presented it again. The emperor's person grew comfortable and he fell asleep. This entire course of administering the medicine was witnessed jointly by Congzhe and the civil and military officials. At that moment panic gripped the court; grief was raw and urgent, and the word regicide was unbearable even to speak. The ministers themselves were sure Congzhe harbored no such intent; even Shenxing's memorial had already made allowance for him. If Kezhuo was allowed to present medicine so casually, not only Congzhe could not have stopped him—neither could I nor the others; we are all at fault. When Censor Wang Anshun and others memorialized against Kezhuo, Congzhe should have imposed a heavy penalty; instead he first fined Kezhuo's salary and then allowed him to convalesce—far too lenient. If Kezhuo is not punished severely now, how can we console the late emperor or satisfy court and country? He should be handed over to the judicial offices and punished under the law. If Cui Wensheng recklessly administered cooling medicine, he too deserves death. We ask that both men be sent to the judicial offices and tried together with Kezhuo. Congzhe, as he himself requested, should be stripped of rank and bear legal responsibility—that is how a senior minister accepts blame and is only fitting; it is not for us to debate further.
17
殿 輿
When the lady attendant sought to rule from behind a curtain, the ministers on first entering to mourn found gatekeepers barring the way; they pushed through the doors and went in. After the mourning rites they escorted the emperor to Wenhua Hall for the court homage and thrice-cried ceremony, then escorted him back to Ciqing Palace. They then argued that with the new emperor's accession the lady attendant should no longer remain in Qianqing. The Nine Ministers immediately submitted a joint memorial demanding she move; censors followed; Congzhe at last drafted a formal request, and the lady attendant moved that very day. Public opinion still faulted Congzhe for failing to lead the officials resolutely in his own memorial. Had the ministers not seized on principle and pressed memorial after memorial, she might still have shared Qianqing and usurped power—what would have become of Your Majesty's accession and return to the palace!
18
When the memorial arrived the emperor said Congzhe's intentions were clear and should not be lightly criticized; he ordered only that Kezhuo be arrested and handed to the courts. Wensheng had already been posted to Nanjing and was not pursued.
19
滿
Wenda rose through the highest offices; the three great cases—the "Stick-wielding Assault," the "Red Pill," and the "Moving Palace"—all passed through his hands. He held his positions evenly, neither inflammatory nor merely compliant. Earlier, when his term expired, he had been made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent; now he begged to retire, submitting thirteen memorials. The throne made him Junior Guardian and sent him home by imperial post.
20
In the fifth year Wei Zhongxian dominated the government. Censor Zhou Weichi impeached Wenda for forcibly promoting Wang Zhicai to build a faction and subvert government; he was stripped of rank and honors. Censor Mou Zhikui again accused Wenda of corruption and asked that he be handed to the courts for investigation. He was ordered to contribute one hundred thousand taels toward military expenses. Before long Wenda died. On Grand Coordinator Zhang Weixu's plea half the sum was remitted, but Wenda's family was ruined nonetheless. Early in Chongzhen he was posthumously made Grand Guardian and one son was granted an office. Weichi and Zhikui were both listed among the Donglin faction.
21
Lu Menglong and Fu Mei
22
Lu Menglong, styled Junqi, came from Kuaiji. He received his jinshi degree in the thirty-eighth year of the Wanli reign. He entered the Ministry of Justice as a principal clerk and was later promoted to registrar.
23
殿
When Zhang Cha's case arose he cited statutes on shooting at palaces, firing pellets, and hurling stones—all capital offenses. Once the case was ready, Prison Registrar Wang Zhicai memorialized that Zhang Cha's testimony was thorough and begged an imperial order for joint interrogation; Assistant Director Wang Shichang also urged the same. Menglong was then presiding over the Guangdong examinations with his doors closed when Principal Clerk Fu Mei of Xingtai visited him and said, "The world shields the guilty yet is ready to sacrifice the heir apparent. Though I am posted to Shanxi on penal review, I mean to memorialize forcefully—will you act with me? Menglong said, "Director Zhang has been generous to me; if I suddenly memorialized, what would that do to him? We should fight it out in the inquiry instead. Then together they went to see Wenda. Registrar Hu Shixiang and others did not want another interrogation; they urged Wenda to submit a memorial asking the throne to decide, knowing that once it was held within the matter could be quietly dropped. Menglong saw through the plan and stopped him from memorializing. The others said, "To arrest Uncle Ma San, Father-in-law Li, and the rest we need an imperial order. Menglong said, "Can the Court of Judicature not seize a single commoner without an edict from the Son of Heaven? What Zhang Cha confessed must be verified in full. Wenda agreed.
24
使
The next day seven men joined the interrogation—Shixiang, Yongjia, Huizhen, Menglong, Mei, Zhicai, and Zou Shaoxian; only Zhicai and Mei sided with Menglong. As the interrogation was about to begin everyone hesitated and murmured. Menglong called three times for the torture implements; no one moved; he slammed the table and shouted until they were brought out. Cha was tall and broad-shouldered, glaring and speaking arrogantly, showing no sign of madness. Menglong called for brush and paper and ordered him to sketch the route by which he had entered. Mei asked, "How do you know the way in?" Zhang Cha replied, "I am from Jizhou. Without a guide, how could I have gotten in?" They asked, "Who was your guide?" He said, "Elder Master Pang and Younger Master Liu." He added, "They kept me for three years and gave me one gold and one silver flask apiece." Menglong asked, "What for?" He answered, "To beat the young master." At that Shixiang sprang up from his seat and said, "We must not pursue this line of questioning. The interrogation was then broken off. Menglong was bent on learning the names of the palace eunuchs involved. A few days later Wenda ordered another joint trial by the Thirteen Offices; Zhang Cha confessed the conspiracy and named Pang Bao and Liu Cheng without withholding anything. Shixiang held the brush but hesitated to commit anything to paper; Registrar Ma Defeng pressed him, while Yongjia again balked. Menglong snorted and said, "If Assistant Director Lu will not hide anything, who would dare to? The case record was finally completed. Supervising Secretary He Shijin then submitted a memorial attacking Zheng Guotai. The emperor then had Bao and Cheng put to death inside the palace and handed Cha over to public execution; fearing a secret swap, Mei asked in person to oversee the execution. At the time, aside from Menglong, Zhicai, Mei, and Defeng, scarcely anyone failed to plead the Zheng family's cause. Soon Zhicai and Defeng were both punished, and Mei was removed from office in the capital personnel review. Menglong escaped punishment thanks to Wenda's backing and advanced from registrar to vice commissioner.
25
使 使
In the fourth year of Tianqi, rebels in Guizhou were still unrested; Grand Coordinator Cai Fuyi recommended Menglong as skilled in military affairs; he was made Right Administration Vice Commissioner to supervise troops against the rebels, while An Bangyan attacked Puding. Menglong joined Regional Commander Huang Yue in meeting them with three thousand men. Advancing at dawn through thick fog, they charged straight at the enemy and routed them completely. The Miao of Sanshan rose in revolt, and Sizhou sent urgent appeals for help. Menglong sent Central Army Wu Jiaxiang by night to strike the rebel stronghold, beating Miao drums until the valleys echoed; the Miao broke and fled, and the troops burned their camps and withdrew. He was soon reassigned to supervise troops in Huguang and promoted to Guangdong Surveillance Commissioner. His superiors erected a shrine to loyal worthies and inscribed Menglong's name on it; he quickly sent men to have it chiseled away.
26
As for Fu Mei, he served as prefect of Taizhou under Chongzhen, then resigned and went home. In the winter of the fifteenth year he contributed money to help Prefect Ji Kongjia hold the city. When the city fell he died in its defense and was posthumously made Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices.
27
Wang Yingjiao.
28
Wang Yingjiao, styled Qianfu, came from Wuyuan. He passed the metropolitan examination in the second year of Wanli. He was made a clerk in the Nanjing Ministry of War and later served as a registrar in the Nanjing Ministry of Rites. When he went to the capital on official business, Vice Minister Lu Guangzu and Censor Jiang Dongzhi were locked in mutual accusations; Yingjiao sided against Lu and memorialized to impeach him, sharply criticizing the administration.
29
西使 使 使
He rose in stages to become Shanxi Surveillance Commissioner. While directing troops at Yizhou he reported the Mining Commissioner Wang Hu's corruption, but received no reply. When war broke out again in Korea, Yingjiao was posted to Tianjin. When Grand Coordinator Wan Shide of Tianjin went to command in Korea, Yingjiao was promoted to Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief to replace him; he repeatedly submitted plans on supplies and troops, fortified key passes, and the army's morale rose sharply. When Tax Commissioner Wang Chao died, the emperor prepared to send a successor. Yingjiao memorialized asking that the appointment be halted; he offended the throne and was sharply rebuked. After the Korean campaign ended, he was made grand coordinator of Baoding. In a year of drought and locusts he threw himself into relief work. He then argued at length that the people around the capital were exhausted and asked that all mining levies be abolished. When villains such as Liu Shengqiu claimed that taxing the capital region could raise 130,000 taels of silver, Yingjiao fought the proposal in three memorials but managed only to cut the levy in half. In the spring of the thirtieth year the emperor ordered mining taxes suspended, but the order was soon reversed. Yingjiao protested again, but his advice was rejected.
30
At Tianjin, Yingjiao found the fields around Gegu and Baitang lying waste; locals told him the saline soil could not be farmed. He reasoned that without water the soil stayed alkaline but would soften when irrigated, and that converting it to paddy would pay off. He recruited settlers to reclaim five thousand mu, turned two-fifths into paddy, and yields reached four or five shi per mu; the project flourished. After his transfer to Baoding he memorialized: "Tianjin's four thousand garrison troops cost sixty thousand taels in rations, all squeezed from the populace. Keeping the troops burdens the people, but easing that burden leaves the army unfed; only garrison farming can make the troops self-sufficient. Wasteland stretches everywhere, overgrown with weeds; if we dig canals and build dikes we could reclaim seven thousand qing, each yielding three hundred shi of grain. The nearby garrisons' annual quotas could be met as well; Tianjin would not be the only beneficiary." He then laid out labor, tax rates, and reclamation plans in detail and won imperial approval to carry them out.
31
西
He then asked to expand irrigation works more widely. He wrote in summary: "The rivers in my jurisdiction could irrigate vast stretches—the Yi could water Jintai, the Huo Hengshan, the Tang Zhongshan, the Fu Xiangguo; the Zhang flows from Ye, where Ximen Bao once drew on it; Yinghai sits at the rivers' lower reaches and is no less a wetland than Jiangnan. Springs on the hillsides and groundwater are found everywhere and could all be channeled into the fields. I ask that we open canals, build dikes, assign troops to the work, and follow the southern paddy-field model throughout. The six prefectures under my charge could gain tens of thousands of qing of farmland and millions of shi of grain each year; the capital region would become self-sufficient and spared drought and flood. Even if the Grand Canal were blocked, the court could shift grain payments southward and buy grain in the north instead." Minister of Works Yang Yikui strongly endorsed the plan, and the emperor approved it in principle, but the scheme was never implemented. He was summoned to be Right Vice Minister of Works but left on leave before taking up the post. He was later promoted to Left Vice Minister of War but declined to serve in order to care for his parents. After their deaths he was never recalled.
32
Yingjiao was upright and principled, treating the state as his own household. He watched revenues and expenditures closely, checked waste, and the treasury depended on him. When the emperor's nursemaid Lady Ke sought an oversize burial plot, Yingjiao refused and earned her enmity. When others said he was too old for duty, he pressed hard to retire. The throne made him Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and sent him home with relay horses. In his farewell audience he urged the emperor to pursue sage learning, quoted Song Neo-Confucians, and warned against eunuchs and palace women. He died at home some years later. Yingjiao's scholarship centered on sincerity and reverence; whether he took office or left it, accepted or refused, he measured everything by duty. At home he shunned worldly business and usually wore plain padded hemp.
33
祿
Wang Ji, styled Weili, came from Ruicheng. He passed the metropolitan examination in the seventeenth year of Wanli. He was made investigating magistrate of Chizhou. He entered the capital as a clerk in the Office of Imperial Sacrifices and rose to registrar in the Office of Ceremonial Regulations. He upheld ritual and integrity, and his reputation among contemporaries was outstanding. In the twenty-ninth year, as the emperor kept postponing investiture of the crown prince, Ji memorialized forcefully on the matter. That winter, after the investiture was completed, he was made Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments but resigned citing illness.
34
In the forty-first year he rose from Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices to Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Baoding and neighboring prefectures. After successive floods and droughts he organized relief measures with exceptional thoroughness. Tax Supervisor Zhang Ye sought to reimpose taxes already forgiven by imperial grace; Ji fought him in two memorials, but Zhang secured a palace edict and enforced the levy anyway. Ji impeached Zhang for defying imperial orders and blocking settled policy, but received no reply. After four years his jurisdiction was well governed; he was made Right Vice Minister of Revenue and put in charge of the Grand Canal while also serving as grand coordinator of Fengyang and neighboring prefectures. In a year of severe famine he mounted relief efforts as thorough as those around the capital. When Emperor Guangzong ascended the throne, Ji was summoned as Minister of Revenue to oversee the granaries.
35
祿
In the second year of Tianqi he succeeded Huang Kezuan as Minister of Justice. While the court was debating the "Red Pill" affair, Ji and Vice Minister Yang Dongming signed a joint opinion stating, "Fang Congzhe knew the imperial consort but forgot his sovereign and father. Li Kezhuo administered the drug and the emperor died, yet Fang comforted him with gracious edicts and rewarded him with silver—where is the law of the realm? Unless Li Kezhuo is punished, the empire will not be satisfied; unless Cui Wensheng is punished, Li Kezhuo will not be satisfied; unless Fang Congzhe is stripped of rank, salary, and hereditary privilege, the wrath of Heaven, earth, and the people cannot be appeased. When the opinion was published, public sentiment was deeply stirred.
36
Principal Clerk Xu Dahua was a habitual troublemaker who daily courted Wei Zhongxian, framed upright officials, and openly impeached Supervising Secretaries Zhou Chaorui and Hui Shiyang. Ji was furious and impeached Dahua for dereliction, adding: "If Dahua truly fights villains for the throne, why does he never impeach the great ministers who collude with powerful eunuchs and destroy upright men, like Song's Cai Jing, yet daily wages war on the righteous? His reference to great ministers meant Grand Secretary Shen Yi. Dahua was dismissed as a result, while Shen Yi and Wei Zhongxian bore him deep resentment. Censor Yang Weiyuan was tied to Dahua and had long sided with Shen Yi; he joined in attacking Ji, saying Ji had named no minister in his charges and demanding that he identify them. Ji then attacked Shen Yi directly, saying, "Yi and Cai Jing lived in different ages, yet their conduct is much the same. His alliance with Wei Zhongxian matches Cai Jing's intimacy with Tong Guan; his pleading to Dong Yuchen matches Cai Jing's cordial treatment of Chen Guan; his pact with sworn friends Shao Fuzhong and Sun Jie matches Cai Jing's tight bond with Wu Juhou; his removal of entrusted senior ministers Liu Yizao and Zhou Jiamo matches Cai Jing's banishment of Lü Dafang and Su Shi; his expulsion of remonstrating officials Jiang Bingqian, Xiong Deyang, and Hou Zhenyang matches Cai Jing's demotion and exile of Liu Anshi (styled Anchang) and Ren Boyu. As for bribery and collusion with palace women and eunuchs, secret manipulation of power, repeated secret edicts while the emperor remained unaware, and covert control of the court while officials knew nothing—here too Shen Yi mirrored Cai Jing's deception of ruler and realm, a pattern that recurs across the ages." Madam Ke and Wei Zhongxian were enraged and wept before the emperor in Shen Yi's defense. The emperor said Ji was tiresome in his speech and rebuked him further.
37
Earlier, when Li Weihan, Xiong Tingbi, and Wang Huazhen were committed to judicial custody, Ji had pressed for the severest punishments in each case. Yet when he and the Censor-in-Chief and the chief judge of the Court of Judicial Review submitted the final report on Tingbi and Huazhen, he hinted that both men deserved some mercy, adding that any extraordinary imperial favor was beyond what legal officials could presume to recommend. A battalion commander named Du Mao had carried a thousand taels of silver from Grand Coordinator Tao Langxian of Deng-Lai to raise troops; when the funds ran out before any soldiers were enlisted, he dared not return home and hid at a monastery in Jizhou, where border patrols seized him and his confession implicated Tong Bunian. Bunian was a native of Liaoyang who had passed the jinshi examination, served as magistrate of Nanpi and Hejian, and been promoted to vice prefect of Kuizhou; before he could take up that post, Commissioner-in-Chief Xiong Tingbi had recommended him as assistant commissioner for military supervision at Deng-Lai. The border patrol tortured him under interrogation. Mao claimed he had lodged for three months in Bunian's Hejian yamen, plotted rebellion with him, and then set out with two servants to contact Li Yongfang. Minister of Border Affairs Zhang Heming reported the case to the throne. Heming had long been at odds with Tingbi and hoped to use the Bunian case to magnify Tingbi's guilt. Everyone at court knew Bunian was innocent, but no one dared say so. Once the prison interrogation was finished and the case moved to the Ministry of Justice, Ji had doubts and consulted the bureau directors. Director Gu Dazhang said, "If Mao really made a three-thousand-li round trip with two servants, yet under torture was nearly beaten to death without ever learning their names, how can his confession be trusted? Bunian may not be a spy, but he is indeed a kinsman of Tong Yangzhen—exiling him three thousand li would be acceptable. Ji accepted this view. Border patrols soon captured another agent, Liu Yizhan; Zhongxian suspected he was kin to Liu Yizao and wanted Yizhan and Bunian executed at once, then to implicate Yizao through Yizhan. Ji refused on every point. Shen Yi then impeached Ji on two major counts: shielding Tingbi and softening the prosecutions of Bunian and the others. The emperor ordered Ji to explain himself, then stripped him of office and reduced him to commoner status. Vice Minister Yang Dongming was put in charge of the ministry and sentenced Bunian to exile two thousand li. The verdict was submitted three times and sent back three times. Supervising Secretaries Cheng Mingshu, Zhang Pengyun, and Shen Weibing, who had been Bunian's classmates, indignantly seized on other issues to impeach Dongming in concert. Bunian remained imprisoned for a long time until he died of illness, and Dongming then resigned citing ill health.
38
After Ji was dismissed, Grand Secretaries Ye Xianggao, He Zongyan, and Shi Jixie pleaded for him, but the emperor would not listen. Later, when the eunuch faction began framing upright officials, Ji had already died and so escaped persecution. In the first year of Chongzhen his rank was restored posthumously; he was granted the title Junior Guardian, one son received hereditary office, and he was given the posthumous name Zhuangyi.
39
Yang Dongming (biography)
40
西
Yang Dongming, styled Qixiu, came from Yucheng. He served as a supervising secretary. He urged fixing the succession, early exit from the palace for the heir's preparatory education, diligent attendance at morning audience, and a fair assessment of Song Yingchang's and Li Ruzong's merits and faults. He submitted the 《Map of Henan Famine Victims》 and recommended Temple Director Zhong Huamin to lead relief efforts. As head of the personnel bureau, he assisted Sun Piyang in conducting the grand evaluation of officials. Later he impeached Shen Sixiao; the two traded accusations, and he was demoted three ranks to registrar in the Shaanxi provincial administration commission. He lived in retirement for twenty-six years. When Emperor Guangzong took the throne, he was recalled as vice minister of rites. Under the Tianqi emperor he rose to vice minister of justice. After returning home, he soon died. Early in the Chongzhen reign he was posthumously made minister of justice.
41
Sun Wei, styled Chunyu, came from Weinan. He passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of the Wanli reign. He was appointed a courier, then promoted to supervising secretary in the bureau of war. He impeached the eunuch Wei Chao and Eastern Depot officer Zheng Rujin; Rujin was sent to the imperial prison. Both were trusted confidants of Feng Bao.
42
簿
Earlier, when Zhang Juzheng was vice minister of justice, he and Hong Chaoxuan of Tong'an had treated the Prince of Liao's offense too leniently, and Juzheng resented him for it. Later Lao Kan became grand coordinator of Fujian and, seeking to please Zhang Juzheng, induced Tong'an magistrate Jin Zhi to dig up evidence against Hong Chaoxuan and sent an urgent memorial impeaching him. Before the imperial order arrived, Chaoxuan was seized and imprisoned, denied food for three days until he died; burial was forbidden and his body rotted in the jail. Kan was soon recalled as left vice censor-in-chief but had not reached Beijing when Zhang Juzheng died. Chaoxuan's son Jing, a secretary in the censorate, petitioned for justice at the palace gates; Kan again wrote urgently to Feng Bao, Jing was struck from the rolls, beaten at court, and sent home. Now Sun Wei brought the case to light and also detailed Kan's greed and cruelty; Kan was dismissed. Soon Chaoxuan's widow petitioned for justice; Qiu Zheng joined the appeal; Jing again invoked the precedents of Hu Gao and Wang Zongzai and asked that he and Kan both be put to death, whereupon Kan was banished. At that time the Brocade Guard and Eastern Depot, riding on Feng Bao's lingering power, accepted civilian lawsuits indiscriminately; provincial officials investigating local troublemakers often swept up the innocent as well; local magistrates frequently added penalties beyond what the law allowed; the emperor favored the standing cangue, weighing over three hundred jin, on which prisoners died on their feet. Sun Wei protested each of these abuses at length. An edict kept the standing cangue unchanged but adopted his recommendations on the other points. When his mother fell ill he left his post without permission and was demoted to registrar of Taoyuan. After many years he rose to minister of rites.
43
使 使
In the thirtieth year of Wanli he became right vice censor-in-chief and grand coordinator of Baoding. During the Korean campaign armies were stationed at Tianjin with monthly pay of sixty thousand taels, all assessed on the local population. His predecessor Wang Yingjiao had mobilized troops to develop paddy fields on a large scale, using the harvest to cover military pay. Sun Wei continued the policy; more land was brought under cultivation and special levies were lifted; when harvests failed in successive years and drought, locusts, and floods struck in turn, he organized relief on many fronts while the emperor sometimes released funds from the inner treasury to help. Most of his proposals for famine relief were approved. Mining commissioners in the capital region were twice as numerous as elsewhere; even after the mines were exhausted they kept digging, until each year the populace was forced to pay make-up quotas. Sun Wei repeatedly memorialized against these abuses and listed six major crimes of Tianjin tax commissioner Ma Tang, but the throne took no notice.
44
使
He was promoted to vice minister of war, then summoned as right censor-in-chief to supervise the grain depots. He was promoted to minister of revenue while continuing to supervise the granary depots. With many senior posts unfilled, he was ordered to act as military affairs commissioner. Soon he was also made acting minister of war. Sun Wei said, "Your Majesty has piled three great seals on me in succession—is there truly no one else in the empire? Among senior officials I know of Lü Kun, Liu Yuanzhen, and Wang Yingjiao; among junior officials Zou Yuanbiao, Meng Yimai, Zhao Nanxing, Jiang Shichang, and Liu Jiujing; among censors and remonstrators Wang Dewan, Feng Congwu, and others—all men of integrity fit for office. If Your Majesty waits a few more years, you will no longer be able to call on them. The emperor ignored him.
45
After Left Censor-in-Chief Wen Chun left office, no successor was appointed for eight years. In the twelfth month of the fortieth year of Wanli, with the provincial evaluation deadline looming, Sun Wei was finally ordered to serve as minister of war while acting as left censor-in-chief. Sun Wei had long enjoyed public esteem and hoped to restore discipline, but factional power was entrenched and the censorate and remonstrance bureaus ran rampant. When South Jiangxi touring censor Jing Yangqiao and education censor Xiong Tingbi impeached each other, Sun Wei ruled that Tingbi should step down pending investigation. Tingbi's allies Guan Yingzhen, Wu Liangsi, and others then bombarded Sun Wei with memorials. Sun Wei repeatedly asked to retire; each time the emperor urged him to stay. Soon the Ministry of Personnel, following the routine rotation, assigned two censors to provincial posts without consulting the censorate. Feeling he had lost authority, Sun Wei pressed harder to resign, submitting more than ten memorials. In the seventh month of the following year he kowtowed at the Wenhua Gate and waited outside the city for the imperial reply. Not until the tenth month was he granted leave to go home.
46
使 滿 西
When the Tianqi reign began he was recalled as minister of personnel in Nanjing, then transferred to minister of war with a seat in military deliberations. In the third year he was summoned to Beijing as minister of justice. The prisons were overcrowded; he asked that detainees from the capital region be held in prefectural and county jails. The palace eunuch Wang Wenjin killed someone; the Directorate of Ceremonial was asked to decide his punishment while the rest of his followers were sent to the regular courts. Sun Wei argued that one case could not be split between two jurisdictions and asked that Wenjin be tried in the regular courts as well; the emperor refused. That winter he again served as minister of personnel while acting as left censor-in-chief, and repeatedly pleaded age and illness; the emperor would not release him. The following autumn his illness grew grave; he memorialized, "Heavenly disasters now appear one after another and the people can barely survive. Within, the altars of state are at risk; without, the frontier is not secure. Law and discipline erode and popular loyalty crumbles. If Your Majesty wishes peace and good government, nothing matters more than winning hearts; and to win hearts, nothing matters more than employing worthy men. Former grand secretary Liu Yizao, censor-in-chief Zou Yuanbiao, ministers Zhou Jiamo, Wang Ji, Sun Shengxing, Sheng Yihong, and Zhong Yuzheng, vice minister Cao Yuqian, academician Wen Zhenmeng, supervising secretary Hou Zhenyang, censor Jiang Bingqian, temple official Man Chaojian, and ministry official Xu Daxiang—all seasoned, upright men now languishing in retirement: a loss the throne can ill afford. If Your Majesty would promote them, they can surely display virtue, check wrongdoing, and help win the people's hearts back for you. Above all I urge few desires to safeguard your health, diligent study to advance your virtue, forbearance to keep counsel flowing, and decisive rule to hold the reins of power. Grievously ill, I can no longer serve you in person; I offer this final plea as one who admonishes even unto death." With that he died; the court posthumously made him Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. When Wei Zhongxian was in power, the Shaanxi grand coordinator Qiao Yingjia impeached Wei as an old associate of Li Sancai and Zhao Nanxing who had undeservedly received favor and posthumous honors. An edict revoked his patent of nobility and stripped his hereditary privileges. In the early Chongzhen years these honors were restored. Later he was posthumously titled Zhuangyi (Steadfast and Resolute).
47
Zhong Yuzheng
48
Zhong Yuzheng, styled Shulian, came from Yidu. He passed the jinshi examination in the eighth year of the Wanli reign. He was appointed magistrate of Hua County. Though barely past twenty, he introduced many popular measures and was called up as a supervising secretary in the bureau of rites. He argued that imperial lectures should continue and that Zhang Jing should not be pardoned; the throne did not respond.
49
He was promoted to left supervising secretary in the bureau of works and sent to inspect border affairs at Xuanfu. Halahan Mongols intimidated the Laobadu tribes into pressing for market rewards increased by more than 270,000 taels; Zhong proposed reductions. Together with administrator Wang Xiangqian he confronted them with the costs and consequences, and none dared press the demand. Xu Shouqian, vice minister of war, had earlier served in Xuanfu and was notorious for graft; Zhong impeached him and had him removed. He also impeached and dismissed deputy commander Zhang Chongshi and others, and prosecuted everyone who had embezzled military funds.
50
使 西
On returning to court he became chief supervising secretary in the bureau of personnel. He impeached vice minister of rites Han Shineng, the Jizhou-Liaodong grand coordinator Jian Da, and assistant ministers of punishments Yang Sizhi and Hong Shengyuan for dereliction; Sizhi and Shengyuan were demoted. At the biannual audience he called for a ban on gift-giving, writing: " No fault is greater for an official than greed. Yet when eunuchs are corrupt and civil officials refuse to collude—or civil officials are corrupt and eunuchs refuse to shelter them—each side still checks the other and none dares act with impunity. Today the inner court treats the outer bureaucracy as its storehouse and the outer bureaucracy treats the inner court as its refuge; gifts and payoffs flow between them and factions close ranks. As long as this continues, an honest civil service and a well-governed realm are impossible. The emperor endorsed his proposal and ordered the relevant offices to enforce the ban. He also instructed grand secretaries and ministers to conduct public business in the palace council rooms rather than receiving visitors at home. The ministry of personnel recommended Meng Yimai for assistant prefect of Yingtian and Cai Shiding for Jiangxi education commissioner, with Lu Xingzhou and Ma Youlong as alternates. The emperor disliked Yimai and Shiding for having spoken out before and appointed only the alternates. Zhong led his colleagues in protesting: " By passing over Yimai and Shiding, Your Majesty sends a message that outspoken officials are not only dismissed once but barred forever from office—stifling straight talk and silencing remonstrance. That cannot benefit the realm. The memorial angered the throne, and those involved had their salaries reduced by varying degrees.
51
In the first month of his twentieth year on the throne, he and colleagues led by Li Xiank asked that the heir apparent leave the palace for formal instruction. The emperor was furious and demoted Li Xiank. Zhong, acknowledging that he had led the petition, asked to share Xiank's punishment and was eventually stripped of office and sent home as a commoner. He closed his doors to study; when officials came to visit he usually refused to see them. He lived in retirement for nearly thirty years. When the Guangzong emperor ascended the throne he was recalled as vice minister of the court of the imperial stud. Before he had even arrived he was promoted to director of the same bureau.
52
西 使
In the second year of Tianqi the ministry of personnel was ready to name him left vice censor-in-chief; Zhong objected: " Feng Congyu has served on the censorate far longer than I. For me to leap ahead of him would invite destructive competition. What would it say about the censorate if I took precedence over a senior colleague? He accepted appointment as censor-in-chief and let Congyu take the vice post instead. On taking office he immediately attacked Fang Congzhe for his role in the red-pill affair and the posthumous-title controversy and for delaying the empress's move to the Palace of Celestial Purity, calling him indecisive and deceitful and demanding that he be stripped of rank and punished by law. He also demanded the swift removal of Shen Hong, who had court patrons and sold influence for bribes. The court's factionalists were mostly displeased. Debate raged over the cases of Xiong Tingbi and Wang Huazhen. Zhong argued: " When accountability failed after the defeats at Kaiyuan and Tieling, Liaoyang fell; when no one was held responsible for Liaoyang, Guangning was lost. How many more times can the empire afford to lose territory because no one is punished? On this basis both men were sentenced to death. When Zhu Tongmeng attacked Zou Yuanbiao and Feng Congyu on the pretext of lecturing, Zhong defended the academies as the capital's chief moral institutions and should not be shut down; he then submitted his own resignation. Soon afterward he succeeded Congyu as left vice censor-in-chief, then was made right vice minister of revenue to supervise the granaries.
53
使
The next spring he was appointed minister of works. By precedent eunuchs received winter clothing every other year. That summer, in the sixth month, more than a thousand eunuchs demanded early payment; they stormed his office, smashed his chair, beat his staff, and stormed out hurling abuse. His enemies had evidently incited the eunuchs to provoke him. Zhong reported the incident to the throne and asked to resign. The emperor ordered the chief eunuch of ceremonial to cane and demote the ringleaders and told Zhong to return to duty. Zhong pressed harder to resign, writing: " The treasury is bankrupt, yet soldiers on the nine frontiers stand to their arms day and night without a full meal; laborers on the Qingling tombs haul loads in blazing wind and sun and cannot get their wages; while eunuchs' demands are met from morning to night. How can such favoritism not enrage everyone who hears of it? I have failed in my duties and should be removed. He submitted three more resignations and went home.
54
A year later Huo Weihua, revisiting the Three Cases, accused Zhong of serving a political faction and had his honors revoked. In the early Chongzhen years his office was restored. Years later he died. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent.
55
Chen Daoheng
56
使使
Chen Daoheng, styled Mengqi, came from Xinjian. He passed the jinshi examination in the fourteenth year of the Wanli reign. He was appointed a principal secretary in the ministry of punishments and later served as a director in the Nanjing ministry of personnel. His fellow townsmen Deng Yizan and Zhong Zhenji also served in Nanjing; people called them the "Three Pure Ones of Jiangyou." During his mother's mourning his home burned down, and he rented a house to live in. One bitter winter they had no bed curtains; his wife wore hemp clothes, and he and his son gathered scrap firewood to keep warm; he refused every gift offered them. From Huguang administrator he rose to Shandong surveillance commissioner and right administration commissioner, then became left administration commissioner in Fujian; nowhere did he keep a private coin for himself. As right vice censor-in-chief he supervised Changjiang river defense. When Guangzong ascended the throne he was promoted to right vice minister of works and grand coordinator of the Grand Canal.
57
In the second year of Tianqi the sorcerer-rebel Xu Hongru rebelled. Daoheng held Jining and secured the key passes to protect the grain-transport fleet. When the rebellion was suppressed his salary was raised and he received gifts of silver and silk. Soon he was appointed minister of war at Nanjing to assist in military affairs. Yang Lian and others jointly impeached Wei Zhongxian and were rebuked for it. Enraged, Daoheng joined the nine ministers in memorializing: "The founding emperor decreed that palace eunuchs were to handle only menial service and must not command troops or take part in government. Your Majesty thinks only of Zhongxian's small services, yet hands him the full reins of power, lets him do as he pleases, and rejects every loyal remonstrance in the court. Why should palace eunuchs matter more than the empire's scholar-officials? The memorial was ignored. Daoheng then sent repeated resignations; the emperor allowed him to return home with post horses. A year later he died.
58
Daoheng was upright, principled, and incorruptible. From provincial administrator to minister he traveled without his family—only one old servant cooked for him. In the early Chongzhen years he was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the posthumous title Qingxiang.
59
His son Hongxu.
60
His son Hongxu, styled Shiye. He served as prefect of Jinzhou and was renowned as a writer.
61
The historians comment: Under the Guangzong and Xizong emperors the court faced one crisis after another, still bearing the slack legacy of the Shenzong reign; government grew lax and the six ministries barely performed their duties. Zhou Jiamo, Zhang Wenda, and their peers served the public good with tireless devotion—men who nearly matched the Odes' praise of those "unwearied in office." Wang Yingjiao managed state finances with scrupulous care; his proposals on paddy fields were sound enough to be put into practice. Sun Wei urged the promotion of worthy men and Zhong Yuzheng urged a ban on gifts—excellent measures for their troubled times.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →