← Back to 明史

卷二百六十六 列傳第一百五十四 馬世奇 吳麟徵 周鳳翔 劉理順 汪偉 吳甘來 王章 陳良謨 陳純德 申佳胤 成德 許直 金鉉

Volume 266 Biographies 154: Ma Shiqi, Wu Linzheng, Zhou Fengxiang, Liu Lishun, Wang Wei, Wu Ganlai, Wang Zhang, Chen Liangmo, Chen Chunde, Shen Jiayin, Cheng De, Xu Zhi, Jin Xuan

Chapter 266 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 266
Next Chapter →
1
Ma Shiqi, Wu Linzheng, Zhou Fengxiang, Liu Lishun, Wang Wei, Wu Ganlai, Wang Zhang, Chen Liangmo, Chen Chunde, Shen Jiayun, Cheng De, Xu Zhi, and Jin Xuan.
2
使西
Ma Shiqi, whose courtesy name was Junchang, came from Wuxi. His grandfather Lian had passed the jinshi examination and held the post of prefect of Guilin. As a boy Shiqi was unusually quick-witted; he loved learning and was already known for his literary gifts. In the fourth year of the Chongzhen reign he took his jinshi degree, entered the Hanlin Academy as a bachelor, and was appointed a compiler. In the eleventh year of his reign the emperor sent literary officials to announce imperial messages to the various princely domains. Shiqi was assigned to the princely courts of Shandong, Huguang, and Jiangxi, and at every stop he turned away presents offered to him. When he came back to the capital he was promoted to Left Reader-in-Waiting. He went home to observe mourning for his father.
3
使
After a long absence he returned to court and was made Left Sub-Reader. The emperor often called in court officials to hear their plans for dealing with the rebels. Shiqi said, "Of the two rebel chiefs, Li Zicheng and Zhang Xianzhong, it is easy to destroy Zhang but hard to destroy Li. The people fear Zhang yet drift toward Li—not because they love Li, but because they are worn down by government armies. If we want to win the people back, we must command governors, coordinators, and garrison commanders to keep their men in strict order so troops do not prey on civilians and civilians are not crushed by the military—then the turmoil can be stilled. The emperor thought well of this advice and issued an edict calling for stricter discipline. Bandit alarms grew worse by the day; whenever the emperor summoned his ministers, none could offer a coherent strategy. Back at his house Shiqi would sigh and weep, saying, "There is nothing left to be done. In the third month of the seventeenth year the city fell. Shiqi was at breakfast when he threw down his chopsticks and stood up, demanding to know where the emperor was and where the two crown princes were. Some said the emperor had fled the city, some that he was dead, others that both princes had been seized. Shiqi said, "Alas—if I do not die, where else can I turn? His servant asked, "What about your mother?" Shiqi replied, "It is because I fear I would bring shame upon her." Just as he was about to hang himself, his two concubines Zhu and Li appeared before him in their finest attire. Shiqi said in astonishment, "Are you taking leave of me because I am about to die? They answered, "We heard that our master would die for his principles, and we two have come to die with you." Shiqi said, "So it is!" Both concubines hanged themselves at once; Shiqi sat erect, pulled the cord tight with his own hands, and strangled himself to death. Earlier Cheng De, a secretary in the Ministry of War, facing death, had written to Shiqi asking whether he would choose a passionate death or a composed one. Shiqi wrote back, "Press on, Yuansheng. When danger comes, a gentleman gives his life—if I will not do this hard thing, who will? Let us join hands in the underworld; we have sealed this pact beforehand—do not forget it, as one does not forget a vow sworn on the soil of Xirang. Shiqi wore a long beard and had a broad forehead, high brows, and large ears; he cultivated his moral reputation, was respected in the Academy, and liked to encourage younger scholars. He was a man of integrity. When his father died, Ni Changxu, the investigating censor of Suzhou, offered three thousand taels in commutated fines to help with the funeral expenses. Shiqi refused, saying, "Suzhou is in famine—keep this money; it can be used for relief. When his patron Zhou Yanru became chief minister again, Shiqi, being from the same district, kept his distance and did not return to the capital after his mourning ended. By the time he returned to court Yanru had already been put to death; most of his close associates kept away, but Shiqi saw to his funeral arrangements. Such was his sense of honor. He was posthumously appointed Vice Minister of Rites and granted the posthumous title Wenzhong. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Wensu.
4
Wu Linzheng, whose courtesy name was Shengsheng, came from Haiyan. He received his jinshi degree in the second year of the Tianqi reign. Appointed investigating magistrate of Jianchang, he seized local bullies and captured notorious bandits, and his reputation as an able administrator grew by the day. He went home to mourn his father. He was reassigned to Xinghua, where his probity and stern bearing kept subordinates from pressing private favors on him.
5
仿便 使 使
In the fifth year of Chongzhen he was made a supervising secretary in the Bureau of Personnel and urged an end to eunuch missions, saying, "In old times eunuchs were employed and brought chaos; now they are employed in the hope of good government. A ruler's relation to his ministers is like a father's to his sons; no one has ever trusted servants, turned away from his own sons, and still expected to govern the family well. He also said, "The key to securing the people lies in prefects and county magistrates. If the prefect is honest, magistrates will not dare to steal; if the prefect is humane, magistrates will not dare to abuse the people; if the prefect is vigilant, magistrates will not dare to fob off their duties in petty ways. The court should follow the Xuande emperor's example with Kuang Zhong—choose men carefully, send them out with honor, empower them with sealed edicts, and let them serve long terms with broad discretion. Then the people's suffering and the true state of local government could reach the emperor without obstruction." At the time nothing came of it. In the censorate Linzheng became widely known for his outspoken integrity. Before long he memorialized the throne asking leave to return home and bury his father. On leaving office he addressed an open letter to his colleagues in the censorate, saying, "People say remonstrance officials count for little, yet those in power often do the very opposite of what we urge. Crafty men see this and tell the emperor plainly that their rivals form factions while they alone are loyal; they defy public opinion below and seize power from the throne above. You gentlemen should cast off all petty factional zeal and not fall into their trap, lest the disasters of the Pure Stream faction be repeated in our own day. After a long stay at home he returned to the capital. He impeached Tian Weijia, Minister of Personnel, for bribery, and Tian was removed from office. He was promoted again to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Punishments, then went into mourning for his stepmother. After mourning he was recalled as chief supervising secretary in the Bureau of Personnel, at a time when graft was everywhere and the Board of Appointments had cast aside all seniority rules. Linzheng submitted a memorial saying, "Time-limited rotation is certainly a defect in personnel policy, but without it there is no orderly way to advance men of average ability. Today appointments change as fast as a stream, with no regard for seniority; the clever advance overnight while the slow are left stacked like firewood, opening the door to frantic office-seeking and doing nothing for army or state. The emperor agreed wholeheartedly.
6
西 西
In the spring of the seventeenth year he was recommended for Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. Before long the rebels were at the gates of the capital. Linzheng was ordered to hold the Xizhi Gate. The gate lay in the rebels' main line of attack; they disguised themselves as troops coming to relieve the capital and asked to be let in. The eunuchs wanted to let them in, but Linzheng refused; he packed the gate tight with earth and stone, raised volunteers to be lowered from the wall on ropes to attack the enemy, and killed or captured many. The rebel assault grew fiercer, and Linzheng rushed to court hoping to see the emperor and report what was happening. At the Meridian Gate Wei Zaode took his hand and said, "The dynasty enjoys heaven's protection; there is nothing to fear. Troops and supplies will arrive any day now—why are you in such a hurry? He led him away, and Linzheng went back to the Xizhi Gate. The next day the city fell; when he tried to go home he found his house already in rebel hands. He went into a roadside shrine and wrote a farewell letter to his family: "The ancestral realm of more than two hundred and seventy years has collapsed in a day. Though the throne bears the regret of a dragon that has risen too high and the people suffer ruin from the head down, I served in the censorate yet could save nothing—by right I should lay aside my official robes. Bury me in a scholar's cap and plain blue robe, covered with a single quilt, to show my sorrow. He untied his belt and hanged himself. His family revived him; they gathered round weeping and asked, "May we wait until Zhu the filial scholar comes so you can take leave of him? He consented. The filial scholar Zhu, whose given name was Yuan, had once helped free Liu Zongzhou from prison and was a close friend of Linzheng. The next day Zhu Yuan came. Linzheng said fervently, "When I passed the examinations I dreamed of Liu Zongzhou reciting Wen Tianxiang's 'Song of the Lonely Sea'; now the realm lies in ruins—what reason is there to live on! He shared a cup of wine in farewell with Zhu Yuan, then hanged himself; Yuan saw to his burial rites and left. He was posthumously appointed Vice Minister of War and granted the posthumous title Zhongjie. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Zhensu.
7
西西 西
When the rebels were overrunning Shanxi, Wang Yongji, grand coordinator of Jiliao, proposed withdrawing Wu Sangui's army from Ningyuan to hold the passes and sending picked troops west to block the rebels, so that once the capital was threatened reinforcements could arrive within days. The emperor ordered the proposal debated, and Linzheng strongly endorsed it. Chief ministers Chen Yan and Wei Zaode opposed it, saying, "To give up two hundred li of territory for no reason—we dare not take responsibility for that. They cited the Han precedent of abandoning Liangzhou as proof. Linzheng submitted another memorial of several hundred words; the six censorial bureaus refused to co-sign, but he spoke out alone in a separate memorial, and the court took no notice. When alarm fires reached the inner palace the emperor finally regretted ignoring Linzheng; an order went to Wang Yongji, who galloped out of the pass and marched five hundred thousand men from Ningyuan at several tens of li a day; they entered the pass on the sixteenth and reached Fengrun on the twentieth—but Beijing had already fallen. When the city fell all eight gates were opened; only the Xizhi Gate, packed shut, could not be used. Only on the seventh day of the fifth month were laborers assembled to dig it clear.
8
Liu Lishun, whose courtesy name was Fuli, came from Qi County. In the Wanli reign he passed the provincial examinations. He sat the metropolitan examination ten times before finally passing in the seventh year of Chongzhen. At the palace audience the emperor personally ranked him first; back in the palace he said joyfully, "Today I have found a seasoned scholar. He was appointed a Hanlin compiler. He threw himself even more into study and would not keep company with anyone he did not respect.
9
In the spring of his twelfth year at court, with the capital districts under threat, he memorialized the throne on six urgent reforms: stiffen the army's spirit, relieve the destitute, appoint worthy magistrates, set firm dates for campaigns, make rewards and punishments credible, and induce defectors from the rebel ranks. He rose through the posts of Nanjing Vice Director of Studies, Left Household Assistant, and Right Reader-in-Waiting, then entered the emperor's Classics Lecture and doubled as tutor to the crown prince. Yang Sichang had resumed office from mourning and joined the Grand Secretariat; Lishun spoke bluntly against him in open court, and Sichang removed him from his post as palace lecturer. With Kaifeng nearly lost, Lishun urged placing a senior commander in Hebei and drilling suicide squads for a fallback strategy, but the memorial was blocked and never carried out. Though Yang Sichang, Xue Guoguan, and Zhou Yanru dominated the government one after another, Lishun would not lean on any faction. He had risen under Wen Tiren, yet he rarely trimmed his words to please anyone.
10
Rebel armies closed on Beijing; the defenders went unpaid, and endless rain left them hungry and freezing. Lishun sought out the chief ministers in the morning hall and pleaded for an immediate grant from the treasury; they answered with vague, noncommittal noises. He went home with a deep sigh and spent his own fortune to treat the men defending the walls. Friends asked whether he would flee; he answered gravely, "Whether the dynasty lives or dies is at stake—what is there left to discuss? After the walls were breached, his wife Wan and concubine Li begged to die before him. Once they were dead, Lishun wrote boldly: "To die for humanity and righteousness is the teaching Confucius and Mencius bequeathed. Lord Wen practiced it—why should I fall short! He finished the lines and hanged himself. He was sixty-three. Four household servants died with him. Many rebels were natives of the central plain; they came to mourn and cried, "This is Liu the palace graduate from our Qi County—he was a man of great kindness at home; why did he have to die so soon? They kowtowed all around him, wailing, and left. Afterward he was posthumously appointed Grand Mentor and honored with the temple name Wen Zheng. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Wen Lie.
11
Wang Wei, whose courtesy name was Shudu, came from Xiuning but was entered on the registers at Shangyuan. He took his jinshi degree in the first year of the Chongzhen reign. In the eleventh year he was promoted to the capital from his post as magistrate of Cixi. The emperor judged that in a time of crisis, officials drawn from the literary academies were too bookish and inexperienced in administration to handle chaos; he altered precedent and recruited into the Hanlin those local magistrates and prefects whose records were truly outstanding. Wei was made a Hanlin Compiler and given leave to go home. When he came back to the capital he was appointed tutor to the crown prince.
12
使
In the sixteenth year rebels captured Chengtian and overran Jing and Xiang. Wei, seeing Nanjing as the dynasty's last anchor, submitted his "Memorial on Thorough River Defense," arguing: "The walls of Jinling stretch one hundred and twenty li; no garrison of a hundred thousand could hold them. Strategists say the city cannot be defended—but the river can. If the enemy advances from the north, Huai'an is decisive; if from upstream, Jiujiang is decisive; holding the Huai defends the Yangtze, and holding Jiujiang defends Nanjing. On the Huai front Shi Kefa already stands as a rock; Jiujiang prefecture alone needs a senior commander posted there. From Wuchang upstream to Taiping, Caishi, and Pukou downstream, ministers of the Nanjing Board of War should establish separate commands to relay reinforcements—then Nanjing's approaches will be secure. Nanjing's war ministry commands troops it cannot deploy, while the river patrol needs men it does not have; the two branches should be made to act in concert when crisis strikes. He also urged strengthening the metropolitan magistrate and vice-magistrate, giving them longer terms and real power to rally the city's gentry and commoners and share the burden now borne only by the war ministry and river command. The emperor approved the plan and created the post of governor-general at Jiujiang. He further proposed filling depleted rolls with surplus sons from military households, drilling them, and repairing warships for river defense. Where regular pay fell short, salt revenues and transport grain could be advanced on loan to feed the troops. Each proposal addressed a pressing need of the hour.
13
滿
The next year, in the third month, rebel forces drove eastward. Wei told the Grand Secretaries, "Matters are critical—dispatch senior ministers immediately to hold the capital districts. Inside Beijing, civil officials from the Grand Secretariat down and military nobles from the dukes and marquises down should each lead their sons to defend assigned sections of the wall. Ordinary townspeople should be grouped under local scholars, with every household responsible for its own defense. Capital troops should patrol in shifts until relief armies arrive. Wei Zaode laughed, "Send grand ministers to guard the suburbs? Who would go?" Wang Wei replied, "At a moment like this you still weigh rank and personal safety? Give me any serious prefecture and I will take it. Zaode mocked him for planning too far ahead. Soon afterward the Zhending irregular Xie Jiafu murdered Grand Coordinator Xu Biao and opened the city to the rebels. Wei wept, "So it has come to this! He wrote a friend: "The rebels hold Zhending, collaborators throng the capital, grain and silk from the provinces no longer reach us, and not one minister can stave off collapse—what will become of the Son of Heaven? The men who ruined us in easier days chatter about factions and ignore the throne—where will they wag their tongues now? As rebels closed on Beijing the defenders went hungry for lack of pay; Wei bought bread and cakes to feed them. When the city fell he went home and told his stepwife Geng to look after their little boy. Geng wept, "Must I alone be left behind? She handed the child to his brother, dressed in new garments sewn shut at neck and hem, slashed her throat without success, then hanged herself until she was dead. She was twenty-three. Wei said gladly, "Now my wish is fulfilled. He laid her in the main hall, set books before his son and charged him with loyalty and filial duty, then hanged himself. He was posthumously made Junior Grand Mentor with the temple name Wen Lie. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Wen Yi.
14
西 西
Wu Ganlai, whose courtesy name was Heshou, came from Xinchang in Jiangxi. His father Zhicai served as vice commissioner of the Xi'an prefectural administration. Ganlai and his elder brother Tailai qualified together in the provincial examinations. In the first year of the Chongzhen reign Ganlai took the jinshi and was appointed a Secretariat drafter. Three years later Tailai also passed the jinshi and was made an erudite at the Nanjing Court of Imperial Sacrifices.
15
西西
In the fifth year Ganlai was promoted to supervising secretary of the Penal Section. In the seventh year severe drought ravaged the northwest; in Shaanxi and Shanxi people cannibalized one another. He asked that grain be released for relief and wrote: "Commanders like Zhang Yingchang in Shanxi butchered refugees wholesale to pad their reports, while in the heartland the people feared Cao Bianjiao's soldiers more than the rebels. Your Majesty would preserve them yet cannot; your generals slaughter them without consequence. This grieves me deeply. He also wrote: "Reward and punishment are the lever by which one general commands another. Your Majesty has lavished care on the borders and grants rewards without delay. Yet when Dutch prisoners were presented, Guizhou and Sichuan quarreled over credit; Changli was heroically held yet merit still awaits review; in crisis you demand death in battle, in calm you bind men with bureaucratic rules. Frontier justice, moreover, is one standard for civil officials and another for soldiers, one for the capital and another for the field, one for common troops and another for commanders. Men given independent commands are seized or dismissed for border offenses; yet arrogant generals whose guilt is plain are merely allowed to serve on probation. Company officers cannot control their men, generals cannot control company officers, governors cannot control generals—troops will let the enemy come and go at will. Who then will destroy the rebels for Your Majesty? He went home to observe mourning. After mourning he returned as supervising secretary of the Personnel Section, was promoted to right supervising secretary of the Military Section, and took leave to go home.
16
使
In the fifteenth year he was recalled and rose to chief supervising secretary of the Revenue Section. Troubles multiplied at home and abroad; in several districts of Jing and Xiang the rebels had not even arrived, yet governors and circuit intendants routinely claimed they were escorting princes and fled. Ganlai said, "If that is allowed, officials are simply abandoning their posts and running. Who will guard the land and the people? He then memorialized: "The Son of Heaven multiplies princes of the blood so they may shield the throne—thus the ode says, 'The royal sons are the city's walls. Yet at the first beacon they fled in a morning, abandoning the people they were sworn to protect, while the same officials boasted of 'escorting' princes to mask their surrender of whole districts. The 'walls' became optional, great cities disposable, and frontier governors a luxury the court could take or leave. With merit and guilt undistinguished and reward and punishment unsettled, nothing could be worse.' The emperor read the memorial and praised it warmly. One day the emperor pressed Revenue Minister Ni Yuanlu on grain quotas; Ganlai said, "My office works hand in glove with the ministry; supplies can be verified against the rolls. What troubles me is that troops run when they hear rebels while commoners cheer when they see them—the danger is not empty granaries but empty allegiance. Light taxes at once and win the people back. The emperor nodded in assent.
17
Ganlai fell ill and repeatedly asked to retire. The emperor then appointed Compiler Chen Mingxia to head the Revenue Section; Ganlai was relieved to be replaced. Within days rebels were at the walls of Beijing. Tailai was by then a secretary in the Ministry of Rites; Ganlai told his brother to go home and care for their mother while he himself swore to die. The next day the city fell; some said the emperor would flee south; Ganlai said, "The sovereign is clear-minded and resolute; he will not lightly abandon the capital. He rushed to the Forbidden City but could not get in. Back at his desk he looked over draft memorials and said, "With rebels running riot, talk alone is worthless. He burned every draft, unwilling to fish for posthumous fame, and hanged himself. He was posthumously made vice minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices with the temple name Zhong Jie. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Zhuang Jie.
18
調
Wang Zhang, styled Hanchen, came from Wujin. He became a jinshi in the first year of the Chongzhen reign. He was appointed magistrate of Zhuji. He lost his father early, and his mother raised him with strict discipline. After he took office, the people gave him a send-off; he came home rather late one evening. His mother scolded him, knelt, and offered him a cane, saying, "Did the court give you charge of a district so you could play the wine-server? Zhang prostrated himself and would not raise his eyes. Kin and friends interceded vigorously before she relented. He won a strong reputation governing Zhuji. After only half a year his ability won him a transfer to Yin County. The people of Zhuji and Yin competed to keep him, coming to open quarrels. His reputation in Yin grew stronger still, and he repeatedly earned the highest performance ratings.
19
調
In the eleventh year of Chongzhen he was promoted to the capital through the direct-selection process. An imperial order called for exams to fill Hanlin posts, and the newly selected officials scrambled for appointment. Supervising Secretary Chen Qixin criticized the rush. The emperor flew into a rage and ordered the Ministry of Personnel to submit a review dossier to punish court ministers who had improperly favored candidates. Ministers Jiang Fengyuan and Wang Yehao, Supervising Secretary Fu Yuanchu, Censor Yu Haoshan, and five others—a total of six—were suspended from office; Supervising Secretary Sun Jin, Censor Li Youdan, and one other—a total of three—were demoted and reassigned; Supervising Secretary Liu Huihui, Censor Liu Xingxiu, and nine others—a total of eleven—were demoted two grades but kept their posts. Minister Tian Weijia and his colleagues then proposed promoting bureau staff first. Twenty-two men were nominated, Zhang among them, and he received appointment as principal clerk in the Ministry of Works. Zhang, Ren Jun, Tu Bihong, and Li Sijing wanted to submit a memorial clearing their names but feared whoever went first would be punished. Li Shichun was very old. The four men listed his name first without telling him. When he found out he was both afraid and furious, and he cursed Zhang and the others roundly. But the emperor knew Tian had acted with bias, and ordered that the candidates be allowed to sit for the exam. He also assumed whoever had been listed first must be a man of merit: Shichun was made Hanlin compiler, and Zhang and the others were all appointed censors. Zhang memorialized asking that palace drill units be abolished and arrears on Jiangnan land taxes be remitted.
20
西
The following year he was dispatched to inspect Gansu, enforcing discipline and tightening frontier defenses. Western tribes raided Zhuanglang, and the grand coordinator urgently called up troops. Zhang said, "They are poor bandits looking for food, nothing more. He rode into their camp; they bowed in ranks begging to submit, and he gave them a little food. When drought struck the region, Zhang wrote to the city god: "If a censor takes bribes or kills the innocent, let heaven strike him down—not the common people. You feast on offerings in this land—if you cannot appeal to Heaven to save the people, I shall memorialize the emperor to replace you. He burned the summons; rain came down in torrents. Frontier soldiers borrowed from officers and paid them back with enemy heads; the officers used these to claim false victories, which repeatedly stirred border fighting. Zhang issued regulations: without a major campaign, petty kill-counts could not be used to claim merit. He impeached and dismissed Grand Coordinator Liu Hao for corruption and sloth. Of the ten provincial overseers under his authority, he drove four from office. He went home to observe mourning when his mother died. When mourning ended he returned and inspected the metropolitan garrison; the rolls listed somewhat more than 111,000 troops on paper. He said with satisfaction, "With a hundred thousand men we might still manage something. But on inspection half were ghosts on the roster, the rest were padding: they were spent—broken arrows, notched blades—and at cannon fire they covered their ears; they fell before their horses could break into a run. Meanwhile the treasury could not cover pay; none had been issued for half a year. Zhang repeatedly asked for emergency funds; the throne never answered.
21
Within a month the rebels took Zhending, and panic seized the capital. Li Guozhen, the Duke of Xiangcheng, sent fifty thousand troops to camp outside the walls; Zhang and Supervising Secretary Guang Shiheng held the Fucheng Gate. There were some 154,000 crenels inside and outside the walls—one soldier for every three. On the third he took the wall; only after ten days did he return home once to bathe and change into clean clothes. His family was horrified; he gave no reply. When rebels pressed the wall Zhang fired two guns himself and they fell back a little. Before long cannon fire at every gate ceased. Shiheng grabbed Zhang to run. Zhang cried out, "It has come to this—and you still want to live? Shiheng said, "If we die here we are no different from common soldiers. Let us go to court and find the emperor; if we cannot, then we die. It is not too late. Zhang agreed, and they rode side by side. Suddenly rebels rushed up and ordered them down from their horses. Shiheng scrambled off his horse and knelt. Zhang, whip in hand, ignored them and shouted, "I am the army-inspecting censor—who dares touch me! A rebel stabbed him in the thigh and he fell. Zhang cursed, "Traitors! The relief armies are coming! When I am dead your end will come in no time. Enraged, they piled on with spears, killed Zhang, and left. At dusk his family found his body still sitting with one hand on the ground, mouth open and eyes wide, fierce as though still cursing the rebels. His wife Jiang was back in their home district; when she heard, she wailed once and died. He was posthumously made chief minister of the Court of Judicial Review with the temple name Zhong Lie. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Jie Min. His second son Zhishi served in Fujian as principal clerk in the Bureau of Military Appointments and also died in the crisis.
22
Chen Liangmo, styled Shiliang, came from Yin. A jinshi of the fourth year of Chongzhen, he was appointed investigating officer in the Court of Judicial Review. His original given name was Tiangong. The Chonglie Emperor was devoted to the Jade Emperor and ordered all officials whose names contained tian to change them; he took the name Liangmo. In six years on the job he twice earned the highest ratings. Selected for promotion he was presented at court and made a censor.
23
滿
In the twelfth year he was dispatched to inspect Sichuan. When his term ended he was kept on for another. When bandit armies poured into Sichuan, the court ordered Liangmo to protect the Prince of Shu while Grand Coordinator Shao Jiechun focused on fighting the rebels. Liangmo prepared defenses and enforced scorched-earth tactics behind the walls. When rebels attacked Chengdu he sent generals to hold strategic points in mutual support. After several battles the rebels broke and fled. Hearing of trouble in Sichuan the emperor rebuked Liangmo, but when he learned how well he had defended the province he sent silver and silk with a complimentary edict. When he returned to the capital the rebel threat had grown worse; little of what he proposed was adopted—and then Beijing fell.
24
漿 便
Liangmo once dreamed he was bowing to Wen Tianxiang below the hall. Wen raised him up: "You and I are alike in different ages—why bow? When he woke he thought it strange. When the city fell Liangmo was ill in his quarters. He nearly died of grief and after that refused even water. Some urged him not to die; he made no reply. He told his townsman Li Tianbao, "I die for the realm and in duty cannot think of my family. Only that my mother is old, my father unburied, and no heir is fixed—that must be spoken of. He wrote a poem and gave it to Tianbao. Soon he heard the emperor had died on Coal Hill and lamented, "The sovereign died without his full regalia—how dare a minister dress in formal cap and belt! I have only my under-clothes—where will I find a proper headcloth? Tianbao offered him a headcloth. Liangmo put on the cloth, dressed in plain blue, and went inside. His concubine Lady Shi followed; together they hanged themselves. Lady Shi was from the capital, eighteen years old. Liangmo was past fifty without an heir and took her in proper ritual form; she had served him only a hundred days. After his death his clan made his elder brother's son Jiushu his heir. Jiushu soon died too, and in the end Liangmo left no line. He was posthumously made chief minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud with the temple name Gong Min. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Gong Jie.
25
Chen Chunde, styled Jingsheng, came from Lingling. As a student he was known for learning and character. Once he anchored on Dongting at night; robbed, he leapt overboard, fell into the water, then sprang onto a sandbar. By dawn he sat among the reeds, dozens of yards from where his boat lay.
26
西 調
He took his jinshi degree in the thirteenth year of Chongzhen, by which time he was already sixty. The Chongzhen Emperor summoned the new graduates and asked their views on affairs of the day. Chunde's answers pleased the emperor, who at once named him censor and assigned him to inspect Shanxi. In the seventh month hard frost struck his circuit, and the people froze and starved. Chunde petitioned for relief and exposed the evils of the selective-training system, writing: "When soldiers are skimmed from local units, they lose their homes—cut off from parents, wives, and children, from fields and family graves. They desert when they yearn for home and rout at the first clash. The men left behind make do with meager pay and see no duty in being useful; those taken away resist distant postings and serve unwillingly. Companies stand empty while rations still flow—not to the commanding general but to junior officers who profit from desertion and hoard the pay. Everyone who schemes promotion through such fraud is of this breed. Their zeal goes not into keeping ranks full but into stealing rations; Fat allowances are not spent on the troops but on buying advancement. Empty companies mean no men to drill—how can training succeed? When pay is squandered the coffers run dry—how can companies ever be filled? This is the chief disease crippling the armies today. The emperor did not heed him.
27
Back at court he oversaw education in the capital districts. He was preparing to set out on circuit when the capital fell. The rebels ordered officials to appear on a set day. Others dragged Chunde along, but once home he went to his quarters, wept, and hanged himself. Qin Jiaxi of Jingshan purchased a plot outside Yongding Gate and buried him there, with a stone marker at the grave. He was posthumously promoted to Grand Master of the Stud and given the posthumous title Gongjie ("Reverent Integrity").
28
調
Shen Jiayun, styled Kongjia. He came from Yongnian. A jinshi of the fourth year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Yifeng. The county had long been infested with bandits; Jiayun enforced the baojia household-defense system so strictly that thieves could find no refuge. When weeks of rain burst the river, he anchored a boat in the flood and plugged the break from it. He seized a notorious outlaw and had him punished to the full extent of the law. His ability won him a transfer to Qixian. In the eighth year the rebel Saodiwang marched ten thousand men against the city; its earthen ramparts were crumbling. Jiayun raised a corps of volunteers, beat the rebels back, and rebuilt the walls in brick. Prince Tang Zhu Yujian was marching to the emperor's relief and was nearing Kaifeng. Terrified senior officials met and said, "If we detain him, he will not listen. If we let him pass, the local defenders will be punished. Jiayun said, "Only the Prince of Zhou can hold him." The assembly approved, and they followed his plan.
29
Marked out for exceptional service, he was raised to principal clerk in the Ministry of Personnel's appointments office and presented five proposals for securing the borders. He was promoted to vice director in the Bureau of Merit Evaluation and helped conduct the capital-wide personnel review. Grand Secretary Xue Guoguan moved to ruin Junior Guardian Wen Anzhi. Anzhi had been Jiayun's patron in the examinations; the case dragged Jiayun down, and he was demoted to lecturer at the Nanjing National University.
30
祿 紿
Years later he became a reviewing officer in the Court of Judicial Review, then vice director of the Imperial Stud, inspecting horses around the capital. When he heard Li Zicheng had taken Juyong Pass, he sighed, "The capital is lost! Our lord and father are in peril—how can I run and live? He raced into the city, called on every senior minister with plans for defense, and none would listen. He wrote his son Zihanguang: "To live rightly is righteousness; to accept what heaven ordains is fate. Righteousness must not be betrayed, and fate must not be defied. Nothing under heaven comes to ruin faster than clinging to life and fearing death. Death from sickness, from gain, from the executioner's blade, in the bedchamber, or on the battlefield is still death—but those who die in such ways do not die for their lord and father, and so they do not know how to die well. What faces us today is the affair of lord and father; to die for righteousness is also fate, and I mean to do it. When the capital fell he dressed in full official regalia to bid his mother farewell, then rode to Wanggongchang. His servants begged him to change clothes to escape the rebels. Jiayun said, "I came from nothing and have drawn the state's pay for thirteen years. The realm is in this pass—how dare I cling to life! Two servants held close and would not leave. He lied: "I am not going to die—I am only choosing a proper place." He dismounted, spotted a great well beside the irrigated plots, and threw himself in. They screamed and tried to haul him out. Jiayun called back, "Tell my mother that she has a son who died a loyal minister—grieve no more than you must. He drowned at forty-two. He was posthumously made Vice Director of the Imperial Stud and given the posthumous title Jiemin. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Duanmin.
31
輿
Cheng De, styled Yuansheng, came from Huozhou but was registered in Huairou through his uncle's household. A jinshi of the fourth year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Ziyang. Fiercely upright, he held himself to a purity few could match and hated wrongdoing as he would a sworn foe. When Wen Zhenmeng reached the capital, De rode out to meet him, treated him as his teacher, and in conversation lashed Wen Tiren—who took note and bore a grudge. The Yanzhou prefect raised the tax quota; De fought him stubbornly and once had one of his bully clerks arrested and punished. The prefect, furious, denounced him to Censor Yu Haoshan. Haoshan was Tiren's man; he charged De with corruption and cruelty and had him hauled to Beijing. The people of Ziyang marched to the palace gates to protest his innocence. Zhenmeng, now in the Grand Secretariat, also declared the case unjust. On the road De drafted a memorial detailing Tiren's crimes—but Zhenmeng had already been forced from office by him. Haoshan impeached De again, claiming the memorial was Zhenmeng's work; the emperor let it drop. De's mother, née Zhang, ambushed Tiren on Chang'an Avenue, circled his carriage shouting abuse, and pelted him with rubble. Tiren, furious, reported the incident to the throne. The emperor ordered the metropolitan censors to remove her and had De thrown into the Brocade Guard prison for torture. He was flogged sixty strokes outside the Meridian Gate and sent into frontier exile. He was convicted on a charge of embezzling more than six thousand taels. Yet fifty imperial guards were assigned to escort Tiren wherever he went.
32
祿 祿
After seven years in exile, Censor Zhan Zhaoheng's recommendation brought him back as magistrate of Rugao. He was soon promoted to principal clerk in the Armory Bureau. He asked to stay home because his mother was elderly; the court refused, and he set out for the capital. On reaching his post he memorialized: "In these years turmoil has multiplied at home and abroad. Officials are dazzled by rank and pay; integrity and shame have vanished. In seventeen years on the throne, how few men have held to their principles and died for the cause! The Song scholar Zhang Shi wrote: 'Men who die holding their principles are found among those who speak truth to power.' To speak boldly is not hard in itself; what matters is that the court nurture such men. Honor a man's house and lane while he lives, and loyal ministers and filial sons will flourish; strip the lands of traitors before they die, and rebels and parricides will fear to act. If men who die fighting the enemy win no reward, those who bow to the enemy will go unpunished; if those who die resisting rebels are not swiftly honored, those who join the rebels will feel safe and unafraid. Not long after, the city fell. Not knowing where the emperor was, he paced the hall in anguish. He rushed to the Meridian Gate and saw Minister of War Zhang Jinyan emerging from the rebel camp. De butted his head into Jinyan's chest and cursed him; moments later, hearing the emperor was dead, he broke into wailing. He seized offerings of chicken and wine, ran to the East Flowery Gate, and poured libations before the emperor's coffin under a tea-shed, beating his forehead on the ground until it bled. Rebels bared their blades at him; he did not flinch. After the rites he went home. His younger sister, over twenty and still unmarried, stood before him. De said, "When I am gone, whom will you have? She answered, "When you die, let your sister go first." He praised her, wept, and stayed while she hanged herself. He went in to bid his mother farewell, wept until grief was spent, then went out and hanged himself. Seeing both children dead, his mother hanged herself as well. Earlier, when Huairou fell, De's father Wengui was killed and the family wiped out. His wife Liu, in Beijing, was hounded to pay the fine for his supposed graft and died of grief and terror. Now the whole household perished; only the youngest son, sent earlier to a friend's house, was spared. De was posthumously made Grand Master for Splendid Happiness and given the posthumous title Zhongyi ("Loyal and Resolute"). The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Jiemin.
33
Xu Zhi, styled Ruolu, came from Rugao. He took his jinshi degree in the seventh year of the Chongzhen reign. A disciple of Wen Zhenmeng, he honed himself on probity and principle and was appointed magistrate of Yiwu. When his mother died he went home to mourn; grief left him emaciated; for the full mourning year he ate plain food only and slept beside the bier. He was then posted to Huilai County in Guangdong. His unstained reputation won him a capital summons: chief clerk in the Ministry of Personnel's appointments bureau, then vice director in the evaluations bureau.
34
When the rebels pressed the capital, he and his colleagues agreed to contribute funds to feast the soldiers and prepare a last stand. After the city fell, the rebels ordered every official to report and register. Zhi said, "They may kill my body, but they cannot break my resolve. When rumor spread that the emperor had fled south, Zhi set out to join him. Rebel cavalry choked the roads; he went out and turned back again and again, saying, "Arms blaze on every side—where can the Son of Heaven's carriage go? The state is in turmoil and I cannot rescue it; the ruler is in danger and I cannot save him—why should I go on living! When he learned the emperor was dead, his grief was so violent he nearly perished. A friend pleaded that his father was seventy; Zhi said, "If I live on, I disgrace those who bore me. He wrote six death poems, shut his door, and hanged himself. The next morning those who viewed his body said his bearing was as if he still lived. He was posthumously appointed Minister of the Imperial Stud and granted the posthumous title Zhongjie. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Zhongmin.
35
西
Zhi had a kinsman Debo in the south who, when he heard that Emperor Zhuanglie was dead, wept for days on end. When Yangzhou fell he wept again for days on end. Whenever he sat alone he broke into tears; before every meal he set a single Chongzhen coin on the table, made a small offering, and only then ate—and wept again when he had finished. He also carved into both arms: "Born a minister of the Ming, dead a ghost of the Ming. When the matter was discovered he was put to death at the West Market.
36
Jin Xuan, styled Boyu, came from Wujin but was enrolled as a resident of Daxing in Shuntian. His grandfather Rusheng had served as vice minister in the Nanjing Ministry of Revenue. His father Xianming had been prefect of Tingzhou. From youth Xuan set his heart on great things and took the sages as his standard. At eighteen he placed first in the provincial examination. The following year, in the inaugural year of Chongzhen, he passed the jinshi. He had no taste for routine office work and was made prefectural instructor at Yangzhou, where each day he led his students in the orthodox teachings of the Zhou and Cheng schools. In private as in public his speech and conduct were measured; the students held him in deep awe. He rose in turn to lecturer in the Imperial Academy and principal clerk in the Ministry of Works.
37
The emperor was then intent on tightening control, suspecting that court ministers formed factions and pursued private gain. The treasury was empty; war pressed on every side and pay could not be met; the eunuch Zhang Yixian was dispatched to oversee both the Revenue and Works ministries, set up his own office, and ordered every bureau to attend on him with the ceremony owed a chief minister. Xuan was shamed by this and memorialized twice in protest, but his pleas were ignored. He then joined colleagues in both ministries in a pact: whoever paid Zhang a private visit would be spat in the face by the rest; Zhang was furious. When his turn came to supervise the commodity levy at Hangzhou, he pleaded illness and sought leave. Zhang seized on firearms that failed inspection and impeached Xuan, who was dismissed from office. Xuan closed his doors to guests and cooked for his parents himself.
38
In the spring of the seventeenth year he was at last recalled as principal clerk in the Ministry of War and assigned to inspect the imperial city. Learning that Datong had fallen, he memorialized: "Xuanfu and Datong are the capital's northern gates. If Datong falls, Xuanfu is in peril; if Xuanfu is in peril, the dynasty is lost. I beg that the eunuch inspector Du Xun at Xuanfu be recalled at once and full authority given to Grand Coordinator Zhu Zhifeng. Du is double-hearted and has botched the defense; Zhu is loyal and sincere—he can be trusted with the crisis. No answer came. Soon Du handed Xuanfu to the rebels; they killed Zhu, and alarm fires closed on the capital. Xuan ran to his mother and said, "Mother, you should hide for now. Your son has received the state's favor and ought to die for it. His mother Zhang was already past eighty. She scolded him: "You have received the state's grace—have I not received the state's grace! The well beneath the side hall is where I die." Xuan wept and went away.
39
When the walls were breached he rushed to court; palace women poured out in confusion. Learning the emperor was already dead, he took off his ivory tally, bowed and gave it to his family, and threw himself into the Golden Water River. His servants rushed to pull him back; he bit the arm that held him, broke free, and plunged in. The water was shallow; his head sank in the mud and he died. When his mother heard, she threw herself into the well at once; his concubine Wang followed—all perished. The rebels held the inner palace for more than a month before they left. Official caps and robes floated on the Golden Water River; the palace eunuchs pointed and said, "That is Jin of the War Ministry. His younger brother Zuan identified the body; by the mesh kerchief ring he recovered Xuan's head and buried it with a wooden effigy in proper ceremony. When the rites were finished, Zuan hanged himself. Later he was posthumously made Vice Minister of the Imperial Stud and granted the posthumous title Zhongjie. The present dynasty bestowed the posthumous title Zhongjie (Loyal Purity).
40
耀西 使 西祿
From Fan Jingwen down to Jin Xuan, twenty-one men in all chose death by their own hand. The rest for the most part bowed and scraped and went to register with the rebels. The rebels, holding that senior ministers had largely ruined the realm, threw them into prison en masse. Junior officials were used or not as the case might be: those used were sent to the rebel government's board for appointment; those not used were beaten and robbed by the false generals. Roughly seven parts submitted and three were punished. Under the Prince of Fu, six degrees of guilt were fixed for those who had joined the rebels. Civil and military officials who had died for the dynasty were alike granted posthumous titles, hereditary honors, state sacrifices, and burial, and a Shrine of Loyal Martyrs was raised in the capital. Principal civil worship: Fan Jingwen and twenty others, with Grand Coordinator Wei Jingyuan of Datong, Grand Coordinator Zhu Zhifeng of Xuanfu, the commoner Tang Wenqiong, and the student Xu Yan—four in addition. Principal military worship: the Marquis of Xinle Liu Wenbing, the Earl of Huian Zhang Qingzhen, the Earl of Xiangcheng Li Guozhen, the Commandant-escort Gong Yonggu, the Left Chief Commander Liu Wenyao, the Shanxi commander-in-chief Zhou Yuji, and the Liaodong commander-in-chief Wu Xiang—seven men. Principal eunuch worship: the director Wang Chengen alone. Principal worship of women: nine martyred wives and mothers—Zhang, mother of Chengde; Zhang, mother of Jin Xuan; Geng, wife of Wang Wei; Wan, wife of Liu Lishun, and Li, his concubine; Zhu and Li, concubines of Ma Shiqi; Shi, concubine of Chen Liangmo; and Zu, wife of Wu Xiang. Ancillary civil worship: the jinshi Meng Zhangming; the director Xu Yousheng; the supervising secretaries Gu Yu and Peng Guan; the censor Yu Zhiyu; Grand Coordinator Xu Biao; and Vice Commissioner Zhu Tinghuan—seven men. Ancillary military worship: fifteen men including the Duke of Chengguo Zhu Chunchen, the Marquis of Zhenyuan Gu Zhaoji, the Marquis of Dingyuan Deng Wenming, the Marquis of Wuding Guo Peimin, the Marquis of Yangwu Xue Lian, the Marquis of Yongkang Xu Xideng, the Marquis of Xining Song Yude, the Marquis of Huaining Sun Weifan, the Earl of Zhangwu Yang Chongyou, the Earl of Xuancheng Wei Shichun, the Earl of Qingping Wu Zunzhou, the Earl of Xinjian Wang Xiantong, the Earl of Anxiang Zhang Guangcan, the Right Chief Commander Fang Lütai, and the thousand-commander of the Brocade Guard Li Guolu. Ancillary eunuch worship: six directors—Li Fengxiang, Wang Zhixin, Gao Shiming, Chu Xianzhang, Fang Zhenghua, and Zhang Guoyuan. The magistrates offered sacrifice each spring and autumn. Yet Gu Yu, Peng Guan, Yu Zhiyu, and others had died only under rebel torture, and most of the marquises and earls had likewise perished in battle. The director Zhou Zhimao, the vice director Ning Chengielie, the secretariat drafter Song Tianxian, the acting registrar Yu Tengyun, the horse-command director Yao Cheng, and the prefect Ma Xiangqian all died without submitting—yet none had been granted posthumous rewards.
41
Xu Yousheng, styled Wenfu, came from Jintan. He passed the provincial examination; in the thirteenth year of Chongzhen he was specially promoted to principal clerk in the Ministry of Revenue and rose to vice director and then director. He was charged with supervising grain funds at Datong. When the city fell he was taken and died refusing to submit. Under the Prince of Fu he was posthumously made Vice Minister of the Imperial Stud.
42
西 使使
Xu Biao, styled Zhunming, came from Jining. In the fifth year of Tianqi he passed the jinshi. Under Chongzhen he served in turn as junior commissioner on the Huai-Xu circuit. In the second month of the sixteenth year he was suddenly promoted to Vice Censor-in-chief and grand coordinator of Baoding. At his audience he urged stronger frontier defense, the selection of able magistrates, chariot tactics against the enemy, and the settlement of refugees on abandoned land. The emperor praised him warmly. When Li Zicheng seized Shanxi and danger closed in daily, Biao was made Vice Minister of War and given overall command of troops in southern Zhili, Shandong, and Hebei while remaining grand coordinator of Baoding; he shifted his headquarters to Zhending to hold the rebels back. Soon the rebels sent envoys to demand his surrender; Biao tore up the letter and killed the messenger. A rebel column raided the capital region; the Zhending prefect Qiu Maohua sent his wife and children out of the city; Biao had him arrested and jailed. His central-army officer Xie Jiafu waited until Biao went up on the walls to plan the defense, then incited the troops, killed him, and freed Maohua from prison. Within days the rebels came and the city surrendered. Under the Prince of Fu he was posthumously made Minister of War.
43
使
Zhu Tinghuan came from Shan County. He passed the jinshi in the seventh year of Chongzhen. He was appointed principal clerk in the Ministry of Works, then in turn served as prefect of Luzhou and Daming, and was made vice commissioner for military preparedness with separate charge of the Daming circuit. In the seventeenth year, as rebels closed on the capital region, Tinghuan tightened the defenses. The rebels sent in a surrender summons; he tore it to pieces in fury. On the fourth day of the third month the rebels attacked; troops and people alike fled, and the city was lost. Taken captive, he died refusing to submit. During the reign of the Prince of Fu he was posthumously appointed Right Vice Censor-in-Chief.
44
使
Zhou Zhimao, whose courtesy name was Songru, came from Huangma. He received his jinshi degree in the seventh year of the Chongzhen reign. He rose through the ranks to director in the Ministry of Works. After his mourning period he waited in the capital for an appointment. The rebels found him, forced him to kneel, and when he refused they broke both his arms and killed him.
45
Ning Chengle, whose courtesy name was Yangchun, came from Daxing. He passed the provincial examinations, served as county instructor in Wei and as a clerk in the Ministry of Revenue, then was promoted to director in the ministry in charge of the Great Granary silver vault. When the city fell he hanged himself in his yamen.
46
Song Tianxian came from Huating in Songjiang. From a student of the Imperial Academy he was appointed secretary in the Grand Secretariat. Captured by the rebels, he hanged himself.
47
祿
Yu Tengyun came from Shuntian. He held the post of assistant director in the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. When the rebels came he told his wife, "I am a minister of this dynasty and you are a lady of rank—how can we be defiled by rebels? Husband and wife donned their official robes and calmly hanged themselves.
48
Yao Cheng, whose courtesy name was Xiaowei, came from Yuyao. Starting as a Confucian licentiate in the Ministry of Rites, he was made vice commander of the Northern City Horse and Infantry Patrol. When the city fell he hanged himself.
49
Ma Xiangqian was a native of the capital. He passed the provincial examinations and served as magistrate of Puzhou. While at home in his native place the rebels entered; he led his wife and five children to hang themselves together.
50
Censor Feng Yuandeng, Bureau of War Director Zheng Fenglan, and Messenger Xie Yuxuan were all tortured to death; Director Li Fengjia was tortured at length and then compelled to hang himself. Together with Jin, Guan, and Zhiyu they were all posthumously made Vice Directors of the Court of the Imperial Stud; Feng Yuandeng and Xie Yuxuan were even granted the posthumous title Zhongjie. Zou Fengji, a magistrate promoted to the capital, was tortured to death and posthumously appointed Assistant Director of the Court of the Imperial Stud. At the time the north and south were severed from each other, and none of these cases could be confirmed. The careers of Tang Wenqiong and Xu Yan are recorded in the Account of Loyalty and Righteousness.
51
The historian comments: "The Classic says, 'When a gentleman holds office, he is ready to die for it.'" Men of loyalty and integrity who meet danger and give their lives—how could they be striking poses for a moment to win posthumous renown! Where duty divides them, they have something firm to hold to and are not thrown into disorder. Ma Shiqi and the rest all possessed steadfast integrity, cultivated their principles, and did not betray their true nature; thus they could meet death for righteousness with the same composure—it may be said they died as they had lived.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →