← Back to 清史稿

卷269 列傳五十六 索额图 明珠

Volume 269 Biographies 56: Suo Etu, Ming Zhu

Chapter 269 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 269
Next Chapter →
1
-{}-
Songgotu, Mingzhu, Yu Guozhu, and Folun
2
滿 殿 調
Songgotu of the Heseri clan, a Manchu of the Bordered Yellow Banner, was Sony's second son. He began as a guard and rose in steady steps from third to first rank. In Kangxi 7 (1668) he became vice president of the Board of Civil Appointments. In the fifth month of Kangxi 8 (1669) he resigned his office to serve at court and was restored to first-rank guard. After Oboi's fall, Grand Secretary Banbursan was put to death as his partisan; Songgotu was made grand secretary of the Historiographic Institute and company commander. In Kangxi 9 (1670) he became grand secretary of the Hall of Preserving Harmony. In Kangxi 11 (1672), on completion of the Shunzhi Veritable Records, he received the title Grand Tutor to the Crown Prince. In Kangxi 15 (1676) Grand Secretary Xiong Cilü's draft memorial was faulty; he rewrote it on a slip and then destroyed the slip. Songgotu joined Grand Secretaries Batai and Du Lide in impeaching him, and Cilü was dismissed and sent home. At the Kangxi 18 (1679) metropolitan review, Lecturing Reader Gu Badai was rated competent on campaign service; the Hanlin entered 'diligent in government, gifted in talent,' but Songgotu altered it to 'frivolous,' and Badai was demoted. The full account appears in Gu Badai's biography.
3
Songgotu's power grew day by day. After an earthquake, Left Censor-in-Chief Wei Xiangsu reported Songgotu's abuse of power, greed, and license, and urged severe punishment. The emperor said, 'Self-reform must begin with me!' The next day he summoned Songgotu and the ministers and said, 'This earthquake has come; I must examine myself. You too must cleanse your hearts and devote yourselves to the public good. Since your appointments, many of you have grown wealthy, yet you form factions for private ends and grow ever more corrupt. If your deeds are exposed, the law stands ready—I will not spare you!' At that time Songgotu and Mingzhu shared power, each building private factions; their greed and extravagance dominated the court, which is why he spoke as he did. The emperor also wrote 'restraint and careful measure' on a placard and gave it to him.
4
In the eighth month of Kangxi 19 (1680) he resigned on grounds of illness; the emperor praised his diligence and skill in war planning and made him an interior minister. He was soon appointed a deliberative minister. Earlier, Songgotu's elder brother Gabula had been enfeoffed as a first-rank duke when favor was extended to the empress's birth family at Xiaochengren's posthumous investiture; his younger brother Xinyu inherited Sony's original rank as a first-rank baron; Fabao inherited Sony's augmented rank as a first-rank duke. In the third month of Kangxi 23 (1684), Xinyu and the others were condemned as idle and arrogant; Songgotu was blamed for poor discipline, stripped of his ministerial posts and Grand Tutor title, left only as company commander, and Fabao lost his dukedom. In Kangxi 25 (1686) he was appointed senior interior minister of the guards.
5
使耀 貿 耀
Russia had repeatedly raided the Amur frontier and held Albazin, its garrison withdrawing and returning; the emperor sent troops to besiege the post. The tsar apologized and sent Fyodor Alekseyevich and others to negotiate the boundary. In Kangxi 28 (1689) the emperor sent Songgotu and Commander-in-Chief Tong Guogang to negotiate. Songgotu memorialized that Nerchinsk and Albazin ought both to remain Chinese territory.' The emperor replied that if Nerchinsk were kept, Russia would have no base for trade, and proposed the Argun River as the boundary.' In the talks Fyodor Alekseyevich pressed for Nerchinsk and Albazin. Songgotu and his party firmly rejected the demand, upheld the emperor's terms, set the boundary at the Argun and Gorbi Rivers, erected boundary markers, and returned.
6
西
In Kangxi 29 (1690) Prince Yu Fuquan was made grand general against Galdan; Songgotu led Mukden, Jilin, and Khorchin forces to Bairin and helped defeat Galdan at Ulan Butung. He was demoted four ranks for not pursuing the enemy to the end. In Kangxi 35 (1696) he joined the emperor's personal campaign, leading the Eight Banners vanguard, four Chahar banners, and Green Standard Han troops, and supervised the firearms corps. Grand General Fiyanggū advanced along the western route to Tüla. The emperor encamped on the Kerulen while Galdan fled. Fiyanggū intercepted him at Jao Modo and routed his army. In Kangxi 36 (1697) the emperor returned to Ningxia and put Songgotu in charge of the water courier route; Galdan died about then. His service was rewarded and the four ranks previously taken were restored. In the ninth month of Kangxi 40 (1701) he retired on grounds of age; Xinyu succeeded him as senior interior minister of the guards.
7
退 滿
Songgotu served the crown prince faithfully, yet the heir gradually fell from the emperor's favor. In Kangxi 41 (1702), while the emperor inspected the rivers at Dezhou, the crown prince fell ill; Songgotu was summoned from Beijing to nurse him. After more than a month the heir recovered and they returned to Beijing. That year Xinyu lost his post for beating a servant to death. In the fifth month of Kangxi 42 (1703) the emperor had Songgotu arrested and confined by the Imperial Clan Court, saying, 'You were a grand secretary, dismissed for greed and corruption, then reappointed, yet you show no shame. Your own people denounced you; you were kept in confinement three years while I meant to be lenient. Yet you cling to your faults, form factions, act recklessly, and debate state affairs. At Dezhou you rode to the middle gate before dismounting—for that alone you deserved death. Any single deed of yours would merit execution. Remembering you were once a minister, I cannot bring myself to kill you—for now I spare your life.' He also had Songgotu's sons confined under Xinyu and Fabao, warning, 'If further trouble arises, Xinyu and Fabao's entire clans shall die!' Songgotu's partisans Ma'ertu, E'ekuli, Wendai, Shao Gan, and Tong Bao were strictly confined; Amida was spared because of his age. All their kinsmen serving in the ministries and courts were stripped of office. Jiang Huang was sent to the Ministry of Justice for execution because private letters from Songgotu were found in his home. Manchus who had had only occasional contact and Han officials who had associated with him were spared and not questioned. Soon afterward Songgotu died in confinement.
8
Years later the crown prince was deposed for madness; the emperor announced his crimes, saying, 'Songgotu helped Yinreng plot treason; I knew it and was about to execute Songgotu. Now Yinreng seeks to avenge Songgotu, leaving me watchful and uneasy.' He also executed Songgotu's sons Ge'erfen and A'erjishan. On another occasion the emperor told the court, 'Songgotu once urged that the crown prince's dress and regalia all be yellow, so that his ritual forms nearly matched my own. The heir's growing arrogance truly began here. Songgotu was truly the greatest criminal of our dynasty!'
9
滿 使
Mingzhu, styled Duanfan, of the Nara clan and the Bordered Yellow Banner, was a grandson of Yehe beile Gintaisi. His father Niyaha submitted when the Taizu destroyed Yehe and was made a company commander. From the guards Mingzhu became director of ceremonial regulation in the Imperial Procession Guard, then director in the Imperial Household Department. In Kangxi 3 (1664) he was promoted to superintendent. In Kangxi 5 (1666) he became an academician of the Hall of Literary Glory. In Kangxi 7 (1668) he inspected the Huai and Yangzhou river works and proposed restoring the Xinghua Baijuchang sluice and cutting a diversion on the Yellow River's north bank. He was soon appointed minister of justice. He became left censor-in-chief of the Censorate and lecturer at the Classics Colloquium. In Kangxi 11 (1672) he became minister of war. In Kangxi 12 (1673) the emperor reviewed the Eight Banners armored troops at the Hawk-Drying Terrace in the Southern Park. Mingzhu drew up drill regulations in advance; on the day of review the troops were perfectly ordered, and the emperor praised him and made his methods standard.
10
調 殿
Early in the Kangxi reign the south was pacified but heavily garrisoned: Wu Sangui in Yunnan, Shang Kexi in Guangdong, and Geng Jingzhong in Fujian. After more than a decade they grew arrogant and overbearing, Sangui most of all. Kexi too grew alarmed and memorialized to surrender his fief and retire to Haicheng. Jingzhong and Sangui soon made the same request. The emperor consulted his ministers; Revenue Minister Misihan, Justice Minister Moluo, and others favored abolishing the fiefs, and Mingzhu agreed. The other ministers remained silent. The emperor said, 'Sangui and the others have plotted for years; if we do not act now, we will nurse a sore into a mortal disease. Whether we abolish the fiefs or not they will rebel—better to strike first.' He then issued an edict approving the plan. Sangui rebelled, and Jingzhong and Kexi's son Zhixin joined him. Blame fell on those who had urged abolition; Songgotu called for their execution. The emperor said, 'This was my decision—what crime have the others committed?' Mingzhu was thereafter praised as having matched the emperor's mind. In Kangxi 14 (1675) he became minister of civil appointments. In Kangxi 16 (1677) he became grand secretary of the Hall of Military Glory, repeatedly headed major compilations including the Veritable Records and History of the Ming, and rose to Grand Preceptor to the Crown Prince. After the three rebellions were crushed, the emperor told the court that only Mingzhu and his allies had matched his intent on abolishing the fiefs, adding, 'Some then wanted the advocates executed; had I agreed, they would lie wronged in their graves!'
11
便
Once Mingzhu dominated the government, he neglected official integrity and bribes piled mountain-high. Folun and Yu Guozhu were his allies; he advanced them to high office. Jin Fu, supervising the southern rivers, favored dikes to confine the current, arguing the lower course need not be dredged. Yu Chenglong and others urged dredging the lower reaches, and the two sides clashed. Fu also promoted military colonies; critics said they harmed the people, and most opposed him—only Mingzhu backed his plan. Cai Yurong and Zhang Qian had both been Mingzhu's protégés; when they were prosecuted, officials proposed leniency lest their patrons be implicated, until the emperor rebuked them and the sentences stood. He and Songgotu built rival factions and undermined each other. Born to wealth and power, Songgotu was arrogant; he openly drove off those who would not join him and favored only Li Guangdi among the court. Mingzhu cultivated humility, spent freely to win newcomers, ruined opponents by intrigue, and allied with Xu Qianxue and his circle. Songgotu cultivated the crown prince; Mingzhu opposed him and secretly drove away officials who served the heir. He recommended Tang Bin as tutor to the crown prince, then used the appointment to destroy him. During a long drought the emperor had Degeli, a lecturer on the Changes recommended by Guangdi, divine; the hexagram Guai led him to declare that petty men held power and heaven withheld its bounty—an indictment of Mingzhu. The full account appears in Degeli's biography.
12
'' '' 滿 滿 滿 滿 使 使
In Kangxi 27 (1688) Censor Guo Xiu impeached them: 'Mingzhu and Guozhu betray the public for private gain; Grand Secretariat drafts all follow Mingzhu's orders, light or heavy at his whim. Guozhu carries out his will; even when drafts are wrong, no colleague dares correct them. Though the emperor sometimes rebukes them, they show no remorse or reform. When an edict praised someone, Mingzhu would say, 'That was my recommendation'; when someone was criticized, he would say, 'The emperor was displeased, but I smoothed it over'; he embellished at will, traded favors for power, bound followers to him, and extorted bribes. After daily audience he left by the central left gate while Manchu and Han ministers waited bowing; he whispered with them at length and revealed the emperor's every intention. On any ministry matter even remotely connected, they had to seek his permission first. Mingzhu built a wide faction among the Manchus—Folun, Gesite, Fularata, Xizhu, and others—and controlled every joint conference and recommendation; among Han officials Guozhu handled the money; for governorships and provincial posts they extorted bribes through intermediaries until every demand was met. By Kangxi 23, learning-intendants due for promotion routinely bargained for posts; every vacancy was sold in advance. Jin Fu was allied with Mingzhu; when opening the lower river was first proposed, Fu was eager to take charge. When the emperor wanted another appointee, they nominated the favored Yu Chenglong, though he was only a surveillance commissioner and Fu still controlled memorials—at that point they had not yet meant to obstruct. When Fu inflated the project and clashed with Chenglong, he began to obstruct it with all his power. Knowing his guilt, Mingzhu spoke gently in public and used every wile to please, while secretly he acted with ruthless malice. He most feared the censors and bound every new appointee to show him memorials before they were submitted. As left censor-in-chief, Folun saw Li Xingqian's memorials win praise and Wu Zhenfang's impeachments gain traction, and had them destroyed on trumped-up charges. Mingzhu's cunning covered his crimes; with Guozhu's schemes echoing his, he betrayed the throne and threw government into disorder. I humbly urge immediate severe punishment.'
13
西
When the memorial arrived, the emperor told the Board of Civil Appointments, 'The state sets up offices and divides duties; officials must pledge themselves to purity, uphold the law, and practice scruple in small things. Today the ministers at court, from grand secretaries down, know only faction-making, private favor, and ruining rivals. In every conference one or two lead and the rest echo, all unprincipled followers. When court deliberation is like this, what can the state rely on? Important posts were to be filled by joint recommendation to find worthy men and make appointees fear disgracing their patrons—yet the corrupt are often exposed anyway. All this comes from faction-building and bribery. I cannot bear to punish great ministers, and some rendered merit in war, so I spare them exposure. Strip Mingzhu of his grand secretaryship and assign him to the senior interior ministers of the guards.' He was soon appointed an interior minister. He later joined the campaign against Galdan, supervised western-route provisions, and had his rank restored for merit.
14
After leaving office Mingzhu retained influence, but for twenty years as interior minister he never regained real power. He died in Kangxi 47 (1708). His sons Xingde and Kuixu have separate biographies.
15
-{}- 殿-{}- -{}-
Yu Guozhu, styled Liangshi, was from Daye in Huguang. A Shunzhi 9 jinshi, he became investigating censor of Yanzhou. He became a courier in the Courier Office, then a director in the Ministry of Revenue. In Kangxi 15 (1676) he became supervising censor of the Revenue Section. During the wars he memorialized repeatedly on supplies with sharp, precise analysis. In Kangxi 20 (1681) he became vice censor-in-chief of the left. He was soon made governor of Jiangning and proposed machine weaving of wide satin. The emperor replied, 'This is not an everyday item—why waste labor and money?' Under Mingzhu's power Guozhu sought illicit profit to please him; promoted to left censor-in-chief and revenue minister, he was succeeded in Jiangsu by Tang Bin; Guozhu demanded gold for Mingzhu; when Bin refused, they destroyed him. In Kangxi 26 (1687) he became grand secretary of the Hall of Military Glory, tightened his bond with Mingzhu, and was nicknamed 'Yu Qin Hui.' While attending the tombs the emperor summoned Yu Chenglong en route; Chenglong fully exposed the corruption of Mingzhu, Guozhu, and their circle. On his return the emperor questioned Gao Shiqi, who confirmed the report. After Guo Xiu's impeachment, accusers swarmed; even Guozhu's disciple Chen Shi'an memorialized against him with telling force, and Guozhu lost his post. After leaving Beijing he built a mansion at Jiangning; Supervising Censor He Jinlan impeached him again and he was ordered home. He died at home.
16
祿滿 使
Folun of the Sumuru clan was a Manchu of the Plain White Banner. He rose from clerk to Grand Secretariat academician. After Sangui's death his grandson Shifan still held Yunnan and Guizhou; Folun was put in charge of provisions, opened the Zhenyuan supply route, and soon managed Sichuan as well. When the rebellion ended he became vice president of justice. He became left censor-in-chief, then minister of works, then served in justice and revenue. On the lower-river project Jin Fu and Surveillance Commissioner Yu Chenglong clashed; Folun joined Vice President Xiong Yixiao and others to investigate. Directed by Mingzhu, Folun ruled for Fu's plan and was impeached by Grain Transport Director Mu Tianyan. Censor Lu Zuxiu also impeached Folun for favoring Fu, saying that at the Nine Ministers' conference Ke'erkun toadied to Folun while Zhang Yushu and Xu Qianxue argued that colony lands should be returned to the people—Ke'erkun ignored them. Other ministers sometimes never saw a word of the proceedings.' The emperor was furious and ordered a severe inquiry. When Guo Xiu impeached Mingzhu and named Folun as his partisan, Folun was dismissed. Fu and others were summoned to court; Folun then urged halting the colonies and abolishing the offices created for them. The ministry recommended stripping Folun of office; the emperor let him keep company command. He was soon made superintendent of the Imperial Household Department.
17
As governor of Shandong he memorialized to equalize taxes and corvée so gentry and commoners alike bore service; the emperor praised his earnest devotion. Earlier, Wei County magistrate Zhu Dunhou had been exposed for corruption by Governor Qian Li; through Xu Qianxue's intercession he escaped punishment and was even promoted to director in Beijing. When the affair surfaced, Folun investigated; Qianxue lost his post. Folun also charged that as Wujiang magistrate Xiu had embezzled public funds, and that his father Jingchang—formerly Erbiao, a slave of the Ming censor Huang Zongchang executed as a rebel—had been given a false name so Xiu could usurp honors, which should be revoked. Qianxue had once sided with Mingzhu and later broke with him; some said Xiu's impeachment was really Qianxue's work, and Folun struck back. He was soon made governor-general of Sichuan and Shaanxi, then minister of rites in Beijing. In Kangxi 38 (1699) he became grand secretary of the Hall of Literary Depth. In Kangxi 39 (1700) Xiu came to audience and pleaded that his father had been falsely accused. The emperor questioned Folun; he admitted the charges were false, deserved dismissal, and escaped punishment through amnesty. He soon retired at his former rank. He died soon after.
18
滿
The commentator writes: In the Kangxi era only Songgotu and Mingzhu among Manchu ministers truly vied for power; for a time their influence blazed, yet neither kept a good name and both fell to greed and extravagance. Songgotu fell for siding with the crown prince, and disaster reached his descendants. Mingzhu rivaled Songgotu and did not back the crown prince; though impeached and removed from office, the Kangxi Emperor still remembered his support for abolishing the fiefs and protected him—compared with Songgotu, was he not the luckier man? Guozhu and Folun were only lesser hangers-on of the powerful.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →