← Back to 清史稿

卷354 列傳一百四十一 万承风 周系英 钱樾 秦瀛 李宗瀚 韩鼎晋 朱方增

Volume 354 Biographies 141: Wan Chengfeng, Zhou Xiying, Qian Yue, Qin Ying, Li Zonghan, Han Dingjin, Zhu Fangzeng

Chapter 354 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 354
Next Chapter →
1
Biographies 141
2
Wan Chengfeng, Zhou Xiying, Qian Yue, Qin Ying, Li Zonghan, Han Dingjin, and Zhu Fangzeng
3
西 西 滿
Wan Chengfeng, whose style was Hepu, came from Yining in Jiangxi. He received his jinshi degree in the forty-sixth year of Qianlong, entered the Hanlin Academy as a bachelor, and was made a reviser. He was posted to the Upper Study, where he tutored the future Emperor Xuanzong. In the sixtieth year of Qianlong he presided over the provincial examination in Yunnan. The future Emperor Renzong, still heir apparent, honored his departure with an imperial poem. He rose through successive posts to reader-in-waiting in the Hanlin Academy. At the triennial evaluation in the third year of Jiaqing he was demoted back to reviser. The following year he was made education commissioner of Guangdong. When pirates suddenly struck Qiongzhou, Chengfeng reported the crisis; the court ordered Governor-General Ji Qing to investigate, and Regional Commander Ximiyang'a and others were brought up for discipline on charges of cowardice. He rose to expositor of the Hanlin Academy, and when his term ended he returned to the capital, resumed service in the Upper Study, and was appointed grand tutor of the heir apparent. As education commissioner of Shandong he tightened scholarly standards and championed men of integrity. He was promoted in due course to vice minister of rites and recalled to the capital.
4
調 調
In the twelfth year he was appointed education commissioner of Jiangsu. Finding that the Qingjiangpu and Hehuatang works ran too straight and had been rebuilt only to collapse again, he memorialized to restore the former course; the throne approved and ordered it carried out. He was transferred to the Ministry of War. In the fourteenth year, when the emperor celebrated his fiftieth birthday, Chengfeng asked to leave his post and return to the capital to offer congratulations; the throne rebuked him sharply and demoted him to grand secretary of the Grand Secretariat. He was reassigned as education commissioner of Anhui. Scholars in Dingyuan were at odds with clerical runners from Fengyang, and each examination season revived their quarrel while local officials shielded the runners, deepening the scholars' anger. Chengfeng memorialized the governor to punish the runners severely and bring them to justice. Promoted to vice minister of war, he returned to the capital, resumed service in the Upper Study, and became a lecturer at the Classics Colloquium. In the seventeenth year he retired citing illness, died soon after, and was enshrined in his district's temple of local worthies. When Emperor Xuanzong took the throne he remembered their years as tutor and pupil and posthumously granted him minister of rites with the posthumous title Wenge. In the twelfth year of Daoguang he was further posthumously honored as grand tutor, and his sons Fangmao and others received differentiated imperial favors.
5
祿西 滿
Zhou Xiying, whose style was Mengcai, came from Xiangtan in Hunan. He received his jinshi degree in the fifty-eighth year of Qianlong, entered the Hanlin Academy, was made a compiler, and rose to expositor. In the tenth year of Jiaqing he became education commissioner of Sichuan. In the fourteenth year he entered regular duty in the Southern Study and was promoted to director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. He was soon transferred to the Upper Study to tutor the Third Imperial Son. The emperor instructed him: "You must teach the prince more than poetry and prose — you must ground his character in sincerity and loyalty." Xiying asked to add the Comprehensive Mirror so the prince would understand how dynasties rise and fall and know the people's hardships; the emperor approved. He became director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments and education commissioner of Shanxi. When his term ended he returned to the capital and resumed service in the Upper Study. In the nineteenth year he was made vice minister of war on the right; he left office to mourn his mother, and after the mourning period was appointed vice minister of personnel.
6
西西 調
In the twenty-fourth year locals in Xiangtan clashed with migrant settlers from Jiangxi, leaving casualties; Governor Wu Bangqing, himself a Jiangxi native, memorialized in a way that favored his fellow provincials. Xiying questioned the memorial bearer and learned the full story; at an imperial audience he laid it out in person, and Bangqing was transferred to Fujian while the case was assigned to the governor-general for investigation. Xiying had long been favored for his plain integrity; Bangqing had been friendly with him and had agreed to keep him informed of local affairs, and now wrote in his own hand about the rights and wrongs of the case; Xiying's son Ruzhen also wrote the retired supervising secretary Shi Chengzao to inquire about the case; Bangqing obtained both letters and reported them to the throne in succession. The emperor was angry that Xiying had shielded his fellow townspeople; the ministry recommended dismissal, yet he was still allowed to serve as a compiler. When Ruzhen's letter came to light, he was stripped of office and sent home.
7
西調 調
Early in the Daoguang reign he was recalled as a fourth-rank capital official and rose through reader of the Hanlin Academy to grand secretary of the Grand Secretariat. In the second year he became vice minister of works and education commissioner of Jiangxi, soon transferred to Jiangsu with permission to submit secret memorials on local conditions and the merit of officials. When catastrophic floods struck the river districts he was stationed at Jiangyin; witnessing the disaster, he wrote the governor-general and governor to retain trusted officials for relief work, borrowed thirty thousand taels from the treasury to buy grain and sell it at fair price, and won the people's gratitude. In the fourth year he was made vice minister of revenue on the left and died in office.
8
西 西西
Qian Yue, whose style was Futang, came from Jiashan in Zhejiang. He received his jinshi degree in the thirty-seventh year of Qianlong, entered the Hanlin Academy, and was made a compiler. He presided over the Shaanxi provincial examination and served as education commissioner of Sichuan. He served in the Upper Study. He twice presided over the Jiangxi provincial examination, served as education commissioner of Guangxi, and rose to junior grand tutor of the heir apparent. In the fourth year of Jiaqing he returned to the capital and resumed regular palace duty. He was rapidly promoted to grand secretary of the Grand Secretariat and vice minister of rites, and made education commissioner of Jiangsu. The magistrate of Wu county, Zhen Futing, had punished student complaints too harshly; Education Commissioner Pingshu indulged his requests and expelled twenty-five licentiates. When the emperor learned of this he removed Pingshu and sent Yue in his place; on arrival Yue first restored the students' standing and punished only three ringleaders, to the joy of scholars and townspeople alike. On his way to his post he saw boats boldly marked "Inner Court Southern Residence"; he memorialized against corrupt clerks whose fraud reflected on the throne, and an edict closed the passes and severely punished those responsible.
9
宿 調滿調 調
The Shao dam on the Southern Canal had burst, smugglers infested Guazhou and Yizhen and preyed on the people, and Yue was ordered to investigate in secret and report. In his memorial he wrote: "From eastern Henan upstream to Taoyuan and Suzhou, the Yellow River runs slow and drops its silt, raising the riverbed and shallowing the dikes, so breaches are feared everywhere. He asked that after Frost's Descent workers be mobilized to dredge the channel and strengthen the dikes, beginning with the most urgent stretches. He also argued that smuggling thrived because official salt was overpriced and the people preferred contraband; moderate the price, he said, and smuggling would die out on its own." The throne approved every proposal in the memorial. He was soon transferred to the Ministry of Personnel, and when his term ended he returned to the capital, moved to the Ministry of Revenue, and concurrently managed the Bureau of Currency. He memorialized to enforce the ban on converting grain-transport quotas to cash payments, so as to curb corruption. He returned to the Ministry of Personnel; in the ninth year he was demoted to grand secretary for failing to detect clerical fraud in which Zhao Yuelian of the Bureau of Transmission had falsely appointed a transport intendant while claiming illness. Yue memorialized in his defense; though dismissal was recommended, the throne showed mercy and allowed him to serve as a compiler. In the tenth year he was made vice director of the Court of Imperial Ceremonial and education commissioner of Shandong. He rose in succession to vice director of the Court of Judicial Review and grand secretary of the Grand Secretariat. He went home to mourn his mother, and after the mourning period pleaded illness and declined further office. He died in the twentieth year.
10
使 調西 使 鴿
Qin Ying, whose style was Lingcang, came from Wuxi in Jiangsu and was a great-great-grandson of the tutor Songling. In the forty-first year of Qianlong he was summoned for examination at the Shandong traveling palace as a provincial graduate, appointed secretary of the Grand Secretariat, served on the Grand Council staff, and rose to director. In the fifty-eighth year he was posted as intendant of Wenzhou and Chuzhou in Zhejiang, where his benevolent rule won praise. In the fifth year of Jiaqing he was promoted to provincial judicial commissioner. When Ningbo, Shaoxing, and Taizhou were flooded, officials concealed the disaster; Ying pressed the governor until relief was granted. Transferred to Hunan, he found Hengzhou suffering famine that officials again concealed while grain was earmarked for Shaanxi troops; Ying again pressed the governor, and the grain was kept for fair-price sale to the people. In the seventh year he retired citing illness. After two years he was recalled as judicial commissioner of Guangdong, supervised county efforts against banditry, and captured the notorious robbers Liang Xiuping and Wu Duanxi, who were punished by law. He pacified the Li rebels in Qiongzhou and strictly banned gambling and white-pigeon lottery tickets.
11
使祿 使
In the tenth year he became provincial treasurer of Zhejiang; at court he asked for a capital post and was made director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments, then director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. In a memorial on banditry in Guangdong he wrote in summary: "Pirates first plagued Gaozhou and Lianzhou; lately they have pushed into Guangzhou itself. Major bands led by Zheng Yi, Wushi Er, Zongbing Bao, Zhu Fen, and others had grown formidable. Inland in Shunde, Xiangshan, and Xinhui, raids led by Ma Guan and Li Yingfang recurred; they colluded with pirates and fled to sea whenever pursuit intensified. Commanding generals put to sea but made excuses to delay and never pressed the fight. Regional Commander Sun Quanmou was dismissed, only for Wei Dabin to succeed him at once. In my humble view, suppression requires three measures: first, verify the true state of the forces. When the navy is neglected, treasury funds are squandered to no purpose. Foreign and salt merchants gave generously, yet officials in charge still skimmed funds while dispatched generals remained arrogant and idle; without stern laws and punishments, the money is simply wasted. Second, establish authority. Bandits scout well; unless we overawe them from the outset, they already hold us in contempt. On the day troops march, the governor and provincial commander should raise cups and feast the men; when they return victorious, open the yamen gate and reward them; those who disobey orders shall be executed without mercy. Third, guard against empty display. Not every man seized as a bandit is a real culprit; eager for merit, officials often convict the wrong men, and when cases are reversed, no one is held seriously accountable. Henceforth the aim must be to catch real bandits — neither letting the guilty go nor wronging the innocent. Methods of defense deserve urgent attention above all. Forts guard the ports, but ports are many and garrison troops few, so pirate craft slip through the gaps; patrol boats are too few to repel pirates and even end up supplying them. The baojia system exists only on paper; runners extort under its name until it becomes an oppressive burden. To make baojia and militia training work, the people must first be won to obey. In my view, strict defense must begin with clean government, and clean government must begin with winning the people's trust. First, clear the courts of litigation. Guangdong people are litigious; despite repeated imperial orders to expedite cases, many large and small suits still languish. This is largely because cases are delayed from the outset, local bullies and professional litigators take control, testimony keeps shifting, and the truth can no longer be found. Only by pressing prefectures and counties to clear each case as it arises can the habits of laziness and favoritism be rooted out. Second, curb redundant staffing. The Six Assessments prize integrity; coastal counties charged with arresting and escorting criminals must practice economy so the treasury is not drained and the people are not burdened. Once a magistrate takes office, with secretaries and attendants living off his salary in numbers, he can hardly remain honest. Minor civil and military officers seek only profit; give them the slightest authority and they bully civil officials. Too many minor appointments only multiply harassment and burdens. Third, punish corrupt runners. Runners know local conditions well and collude with officials' kin and household staff to prey on the people. Guangdong runners often collude secretly with bandits and take illicit fees; this above all must be sternly punished. Once these three measures are in place, government is clean; once government is clean the people's trust is won, and baojia and militia training can succeed — no people who cannot be rallied, no policy that cannot be enforced." When the memorial reached the throne, an edict ordered frontier officials to adopt its recommendations. He was made governor of Shuntian prefecture.
12
祿 調 調
In the twelfth year he was promoted to vice minister of justice. Because the joint recommendation in the Minxue case involving an imperial clansman was too lenient, dismissal was proposed; the throne pardoned him but demoted him to director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments. He served as vice censor-in-chief on the left and then as vice minister of the granary yards. When the throne ordered the granary yards reorganized, fearing Ying's age he was transferred to vice censor-in-chief on the left with second-rank insignia. He was soon made vice minister of war and then returned to the Ministry of Justice. Ying judged cases with fairness and care; in Zhejiang he cleared twelve Dinghai refugees wrongly accused as bandits. When pirates falsely implicated his clansmen and charges were already filed, he corrected the record and secured their release. In the ministry he tried transport laborers accused of stealing grain; accusers claimed medicine had been placed in the grain to make it overflow, but tests failed; Emperor Renzong personally tested the claim and proved it false, winning particular praise. In the fifteenth year he resigned citing illness. He died in the first year of Daoguang.
13
Ying excelled at prose and held Yao Nai in mutual esteem; their styles were much alike.
14
西
Li Zonghan, whose style was Chunhu, came from Linchuan in Jiangxi. He received his jinshi degree in the fifty-eighth year of Qianlong, entered the Hanlin Academy, and was made a compiler. At the triennial evaluation in the third year of Jiaqing he ranked second class and was made left tutor of the heir apparent. He rose to expositor of the Hanlin Academy and served as recorder of the emperor's daily lectures and activities. In the fifth year he presided over the Fujian provincial examination; he mourned his mother, and after the mourning period resumed office and became reader of the Hanlin Academy. In the ninth year he became education commissioner of Hunan and rose through director of the Court of the Imperial Stud, vice director of the Imperial Clan Court, to vice censor-in-chief on the left. In the twentieth year he mourned his birth mother; after mourning he memorialized from home to spend his life caring for his paternal grandmother, and the request was granted. In the third year of Daoguang his grandmother died. The Ministry of Rites had earlier ruled that an adopted heir should observe three years' mourning for his birth grandmother, and Zonghan had followed that ruling; but the ministry later reverted to one year. His birth father Bingli was elderly with four sons, and because Zonghan had been given in adoption he could not complete his care. In the fifth year he came to the capital, was received in audience, and questioned in detail about his family and career. Zonghan recounted the whole story of his care for his grandmother; Emperor Xuanzong sighed and restored him to his former post. In the eighth year he was made vice minister of works, presided over the Zhejiang provincial examination, and stayed on as education commissioner. In the eleventh year his birth father died; grief shattered his health, and though ill he hurried to the funeral but died at Quzhou, aged sixty-three, and was buried in mourning dress.
15
退
Zonghan was filial, cautious, and retiring; in midlife he spent ten years in retirement caring for his parents, and his calligraphy was especially prized.
16
輿 祿輿
Han Dingjin, whose style was Shuping, came from Changshou in Sichuan. He received his jinshi degree in the sixtieth year of Qianlong, entered the Hanlin Academy, and was made a reviser. In the ninth year of Jiaqing he was made a censor. He memorialized on the harm of Catholicism's spread and asked that the ban be enforced to uproot it; the throne agreed. His mother being elderly, he asked to care for her for life; in the sixteenth year, after mourning, he resumed his former post. He memorialized six chronic abuses in Sichuan: ban irregular levies to protect the people; eliminate local ruffians before trouble grows; inspect checkpoint houses to save lives; forbid kidnapping and fraud to warn the corrupt; strictly limit surcharges to nurture honest government; and audit military administration for real results. He also reported that gambling in the capital flourished, often run by carriage servants of princes and ministers who bent the law by their influence; the emperor ordered specifics and issued an edict for stern punishment. The next day three gambling rings were broken, with the carriage servants of Grand Secretary and Metropolitan Infantry Commander Lu Kang as ringleaders. Imperial kin and court favorites were all struck with fear.
17
祿 使 使
He inspected Shandong grain transport, became supervising secretary of the Ministry of Works and vice director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments, and served as education commissioner of Shaanxi and Gansu. In his memorial he wrote: "Granaries in Yulin, Suide, and neighboring counties stand empty and must be replenished; those regions depend on Mongol grain for relief. Now both the interior and the frontier suffer famine and must be relieved by separate measures of settlement and aid." He also wrote: "For postwar recovery in the Southern Mountains, fortified villages and cleared countryside should be enforced. Displaced people crowd the mountains and form the greatest nest of villains; baojia must be strictly enforced so evildoers have nowhere to hide. He asked that the army be strictly forbidden to seize refugee women and children by force. Areas near the Southern Mountains and eastern Henan have all been ravaged by war; magistrates must be carefully chosen to revive the people's morale. Northern Sichuan suffers famine and borders Shaanxi and Gansu, whence most salt smugglers and local ruffians come; he asked for preventive measures in advance." All were ordered carried out by frontier officials as he had requested. He rose through director of the Court of Imperial Ceremonial, vice commissioner of the Office of Transmission, director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, to vice censor-in-chief on the left.
18
In the twenty-fourth year he was ordered to inspect floods in the capital region and supervise relief at Huangcun. As education commissioner of Fujian he wrote: "Government in Fujian has long been corrupt; disregard seniority and appoint honest, capable men to the key posts in Tingzhou, Zhangzhou, and Quanzhou, with long tenure to fix responsibility. The garrisons of Zhangzhou and Quanzhou collude with bandits; he asked that the provincial and regional commanders be held to impose severe punishment without favor." In the sixth year of Daoguang he became vice minister of the granary yards and retired citing illness. He was recalled as vice minister of works; at the capital evaluation he retired at his original rank. He died at home and was enshrined in the local worthies' temple.
19
Zhu Fangzeng, whose style was Hongfang, came from Haiyan in Zhejiang. He received his jinshi degree in the sixth year of Jiaqing, entered the Hanlin Academy, and was made a compiler. He presided over the Yunnan provincial examination and became vice director of studies in the Imperial Academy. In the eighteenth year, during the sectarian rebellion, Fangzeng impeached Zhili Governor-General Wen Chenghui for mishandling the crisis and secured his dismissal.
20
使 使
In response to an imperial command for his views, he discussed appointments and finances, writing in summary: "Among senior ministers today, few make recommending talent their duty. Recommendations easily invite favoritism and factional ties must be guarded against, so ministers avoid the duty out of scruple. When ministers shun the charge of favoritism and forget their duty to serve the throne through good appointments, they are throwing away the meal for fear of choking — not the conduct of men who serve the state with public loyalty. As for how to appoint men, nothing surpasses judging their words and inquiring into their deeds. Your Majesty should inquire widely and consult broadly, then verify over time. At imperial audiences each candidate should speak to his strengths in person; if he truly understands his subject, test him with tasks to see whether he can deliver. If his presentation lacks coherence, the man is unfit for office, and the recommending minister's judgment and whether his motives are public or private become clear as well. Yet I reflect that officials in office, unless they are incompetent and base, who does not wish to serve effectively? Moreover, though Your Majesty has admonished again and again, old habits persist and sudden reform is hard — for several reasons: regulations are too numerous and paperwork too trivial; even capable officials exhaust themselves on documents, and matters that truly concern governance and the people's welfare cannot be thoroughly examined. This is the first. Commissioned duties come in endless succession, public and private expenses pile up, officials have no leisure for their families, and concern for the people gradually fades. This is the second. The culture of accusation has grown worse than ever. Men have petitioned at the palace gate and brought capital suits over trifling land disputes or brawls; local officials fear their leverage and indulge them with evasions. Even men eager to serve the public — can every trivial matter reach the emperor's ear? There are even anonymous placards with no name to identify. Corrupt clerks, crafty runners, wicked commoners, and vicious servants whose schemes fail or who are punished too harshly can all fabricate rumors and accuse men's private affairs. This is enough to make officials who take on real duties shiver with fear and submit in silent forbearance. The rampant spread of villainy stems mostly from this. This is the third. Now Your Majesty wishes to rectify entrenched habits of routine indulgence; in my humble view these three abuses must be removed first, so officials may act without fear and devote themselves to real governance. In governing the state, managing finances is especially important. In antiquity a thirty-year budget governed state expenditure, weighing surplus and deficit and measuring spending by revenue, so supplies never ran short. Today the Ministry of Revenue reports annual income and expenditure once a year in summary. But central and local accounts are not unified, the threads are tangled beyond easy sorting. Moreover, every allocation is counted as expenditure without calculating what was actually spent. Old and new accounts are mixed and confusion grows worse; receipts and disbursements further vary because uncertain items throw surplus and deficit out of balance. Therefore within a single year how much was spent, checked against income, and what surplus remained — the true figures cannot be known. He asked that the Ministry of Revenue be ordered to unify central and local annual income and expenditure. Calculate the total surplus, compare it reliably with the surpluses of the previous one or two years, then weigh what is urgent and what may wait, and cut or defer every regular and exceptional expenditure where economy is possible. Thus the state may follow the ancient method of planning expenditure over the full cycle, and finances will be ample."
21
殿殿 西
In the twentieth year he entered regular duty in the Hall of Imperial Study and compiled the Shiqu Baoji and the Midian Zhulin imperial catalogues. He was soon made education commissioner of Guangxi and rose to reader of the Hanlin Academy. In the fourth year of Daoguang he ranked first at the triennial evaluation and was made grand secretary of the Grand Secretariat. He presided over the Shandong provincial examination. In the seventh year he became education commissioner of Jiangsu. He died in the tenth year.
22
Fangzeng was deeply versed in court regulations and precedent; he compiled the deeds of eminent ministers from the dynastic histories into the Congzheng Guanfa Lu, which circulated widely.
23
The commentator writes: As attendant ministers, Wan Chengfeng, Zhou Xiying, and Qian Yue made outstanding proposals wherever their inspection tours took them. Qin Ying's record in office and Li Zonghan's filial devotion were honored for more than literary talent alone. Han Dingjin and Zhu Fangzeng spoke frankly and to the point in their memorials, and all of them stood out for their bearing at court.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →