← Back to 史記

平原君虞卿列傳

Biographies of Lord Pingyuan and Yu Qing

Chapter 76 of 史記 ✓ Translated
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 76
Next Chapter →
1
Lord Pingyuan, whose name was Zhao Sheng, was one of the noble princes of Zhao. Among the princes, Sheng was considered the most worthy. He delighted in hospitality, and the guests who flocked to him numbered in the thousands. Lord Pingyuan served as Chancellor to Kings Huiwen and Xiaocheng of Zhao. Three times he stepped down from the chancellorship, and three times he was restored to his post. He was eventually enfeoffed at Dongwu City.
2
Lord Pingyuan’s residence featured a tower that overlooked the homes of commoners. In one of those homes lived a crippled man who walked with great difficulty whenever he went to draw water. One of Lord Pingyuan’s concubines, looking down from the tower, saw him and burst into laughter. The next day, the crippled man came to Lord Pingyuan's gate and made this request: 'I have heard that Your Lordship delights in worthy men. Worthy men travel thousands of li without hesitation to reach you, because you honor the worthy and humble the unworthy. "It is my misfortune to suffer from this debilitating ailment. Yet one of your lordship’s concubines looked down and mocked me. I wish to have the head of the one who laughed at me." Lord Pingyuan laughed and replied, 'Very well.' The crippled man departed, and Lord Pingyuan laughed, saying: 'Look at this wretched fellow! He wants to kill my beautiful concubine just because of a single laugh. Isn't this going too far!' In the end, however, he could not bring himself to kill her. After about a year, more than half of the retainers and guests in his household had gradually drifted away. Lord Pingyuan was puzzled and said: 'I, Sheng, have never dared to treat you gentlemen discourteously. Why have so many departed?' One of his retainers stepped forward and replied: 'Because Your Lordship did not kill the concubine who laughed at the cripple, they think you value beauty over worth. The worthy men have departed.' Thereupon, Lord Pingyuan had the concubine who had laughed at the cripple beheaded. He personally went to the man's door to present the head and offer his apologies. Afterward, his retainers gradually began to return to him. At that time, Qi had Lord Mengchang, Wei had Lord Xinling, and Chu had Lord Chunshen; all of them vied with one another to attract and maintain worthy men.
3
使 使 滿 使
When Qin besieged Handan, Zhao sent Lord Pingyuan to seek aid and form an alliance with Chu. He planned to take twenty of his retainers who were accomplished in both civil and military arts. Lord Pingyuan said: 'If diplomacy can secure victory, that would be excellent. "If diplomacy fails to secure victory, then we shall take a blood oath beneath their grand hall, for I am determined to return only after the alliance is sealed." "We need not search for worthy men elsewhere; those among my own retainers will be sufficient." He found nineteen men, but among the rest, none were worthy of selection, and so he could not fill the twentieth position. Among his retainers was a man named Mao Sui. He stepped forward and recommended himself to Lord Pingyuan, saying: 'I, Sui, have heard that Your Lordship will form a vertical alliance with Chu, bringing along twenty of your retainers, seeking none from outside. "Now that you are short one man, I hope your lordship will allow me to fill that vacancy and accompany you." Lord Pingyuan said: 'Sir, how many years have you been dwelling in my household?' Mao Sui replied: 'Three years now.' Lord Pingyuan said: 'Truly, when a worthy man dwells in the world, it is like an awl placed in a bag - its point immediately becomes visible. "You have been in my household for three years now, yet I have never heard any of my attendants praise you, nor have I seen any proof of your ability. This suggests you have no particular talent." "Since you lack the necessary merit, sir, you should stay behind." Mao Sui replied: 'Your servant is only today requesting to be placed in the bag. "Had I been placed in the bag sooner, the point of my awl would have pierced through completely, rather than just showing its tip!" In the end, Lord Pingyuan allowed Mao Sui to accompany him. The nineteen other men exchanged amused glances, but they did not openly reject him.
4
殿
By the time they reached Chu, Mao Sui had debated with the nineteen others, and they were all won over by his reasoning. Lord Pingyuan discussed the merits and risks of the alliance with the King of Chu; though they began their talks at sunrise, by noon they had still reached no decision. The nineteen others said to Mao Sui: 'Sir, you go up.' Mao Sui, gripping his sword, ascended the steps one by one and said to Lord Pingyuan: 'The advantages and disadvantages of this alliance can be decided in two sentences. We began speaking of the alliance at sunrise, yet by noon we have reached no decision. Why is this?' The King of Chu said to Lord Pingyuan: 'Who is this guest?' Lord Pingyuan replied: 'He is one of my retainers.' The King of Chu rebuked him: 'Why don't you get down! I am speaking with your lord. What business do you have here!' Mao Sui advanced, gripping his sword, and said: 'Your Majesty rebukes me because of Chu's great multitude. "Within these ten paces, Your Majesty cannot rely on the strength of Chu’s armies. Your life hangs by my hand alone." My lord stands before you. Why do you rebuke me? "Furthermore, I have heard that Tang ruled the world with only seventy li of land, and King Wen made the lords his subjects with but a hundred li. It was not because their soldiers were numerous, but because they understood how to wield their position and exert their authority." "Today, Chu spans five thousand li and commands a million spears; these are the resources of a true hegemon." "With the strength of Chu, no one in the world should be able to withstand you." "Yet Bai Qi, that mere upstart, led only a few tens of thousands to wage war against Chu. In his first battle, he took Yan and Ying; in his second, he burned Yiling; and in his third, he brought disgrace upon Your Majesty’s ancestors!" "This is a grievance that should last a hundred generations and a shame that even Zhao feels on your behalf, yet Your Majesty does not seem to feel the sting of it." "This alliance is for the benefit of Chu, not merely for Zhao." My lord stands before you. Why do you rebuke me?' Chu King said: Yes yes, truly if mister words, respectfully offer state altars for vertical. Mao Sui said: Vertical fix? Chu King said: Fix. Mao Sui tell Chu King left right: Take chicken dog horse blood come. Mao Sui hold copper plate kneel advance Chu King: King when shed blood fix vertical, next my jun, next Sui. Thus the alliance was settled right there in the hall. Mao Sui left hand hold plate blood right hand call nineteen people: Gong mutually shed this blood at hall waslow. "You gentlemen are merely mediocre; you are what is known as those who only achieve things by riding on the coat-tails of others."
5
使
Ping Yuan Lord already fix vertical return, return arrive Zhao, said: Sheng did not dare again match scholar. "I have judged many men—thousands at most, hundreds at least—and I believed I had never failed to recognize a man of worth. Yet today, in the case of Master Mao, I failed." "Master Mao's single visit to Chu has made Zhao as heavy as the Nine Tripods or the Great Bells." "With only his three-inch tongue, Master Mao has proven more powerful than an army of a million men." "I shall never again presume to judge the worth of men." He then made Mao Sui a guest of the highest rank.
6
使 使 使
After Lord Pingyuan returned to Zhao, the King of Chu sent Lord Chunshen with troops to the rescue, and Lord Xinling of Wei also seized command of Jin Bi’s army to go to Zhao's aid; however, neither force had yet arrived. Qin pressed the siege of Handan with such urgency that the city was on the brink of surrender, much to the distress of Lord Pingyuan. Li Tong, the son of a relay station officer in Handan, advised Lord Pingyuan, saying: 'My lord, do you not worry about Zhao's destruction?' Ping Yuan Lord said: Zhao perish then Sheng was captive, what did not worry? Li Tong said: 'The people of Handan are cooking bones and trading children for food - this can truly be called desperate. Yet Your Lordship's rear palace numbers in the hundreds, your concubines are clothed in silk and satin, and you have surplus fine grains and meats. Meanwhile the people wear incomplete coarse garments and are not sated even with bran and husks. "The people are starving and the troops are spent—some even have to sharpen wood for spears and arrows—yet your lordship's fine vessels and chimes remain as they were in times of peace." If Qin destroys Zhao, how will you obtain these things? Make Zhao obtain complete, jun what worry no had? "If you could truly order your ladies to join the ranks of the soldiers and share in their labors, and distribute all your household possessions to feast the troops, they would be deeply moved by your virtue in this time of peril." Lord Pingyuan followed this advice and gathered three thousand men who were ready to die for the cause. Li Tong then led these three thousand men in a charge against the Qin army, forcing them to retreat thirty li. Just then, the reinforcements from Chu and Wei arrived, causing the Qin troops to abandon the siege and allowing Handan to survive. Li Tong died in the fighting, and his father was enfeoffed as the Marquis of Li in his honor.
7
Yu Qing wished to use the fact that Lord Xinling had saved Handan as a reason to request a further enfeoffment for Lord Pingyuan. Gong Sun Long hear, night drive see Ping Yuan Lord: Long hear Yu Qing wish and Xin Ling Lord save Han Dan for jun request enfeoff, had? Ping Yuan Lord said: Correct. Long said: 'This is quite impossible. "Furthermore, when the King raised you to be Chancellor of Zhao, it was not because your intelligence and ability were unique in the land." "When he partitioned Dongwu City to enfeoff you, it was not because of your great merit, nor because the people had no achievements, but simply because you are his kinsman." "You accepted the Chancellor’s seal without demurring about your lack of ability, and received the fief without speaking of your lack of merit, likewise because you considered yourself a kinsman." "Now that Lord Xinling has saved Handan and you seek an enfeoffment, it would be a kinsman receiving a city while the people are left to count the actual merit of others." "This is completely unacceptable." Yu Qing moreover grasped its two points of power - affairs were complete; he grasped the right contract and made demands. "If the plan fails, he will have merely used a hollow reputation to indebt you to him." "You must not listen to him." Lord Pingyuan then followed this advice and did not listen to Yu Qing.
8
Lord Pingyuan died in the fifteenth year of the reign of King Xiaocheng of Zhao. His descendants succeeded him, but in the end, they perished along with the state of Zhao.
9
Lord Pingyuan treated Gongsun Long with great generosity. Gongsun Long was skilled in the sophistry of 'the hard and the white,' but when Zou Yan passed through Zhao and spoke of the Great Way, Lord Pingyuan dismissed Gongsun Long.
10
Yu Qing was a wandering political strategist. Wearing straw sandals and carrying an umbrella, he arrived to advise King Xiaocheng of Zhao. At first sight, he granted a hundred yi of gold and a pair of white jade discs. After his second meeting, he was made a high minister of Zhao, and thus became known as Yu Qing.
11
使 使 使使 使 使
When Qin and Zhao fought at Changping, Zhao was not victorious and lost a chief commandant. Zhao King summon Lou Chang and Yu Qing: Army battle did not win, wei again die, my person made bind armor hasten it, how? Lou Chang said: No wasnefit, did not as send heavy envoy peace. Yu Qing said: Chang speak peace, consider did not peace army certainly break. "However, the power to decide on peace lies with Qin." Moreover wang discuss Qin, wish break Zhao army, did not? King said: Qin did not spare remain strength, certainly wish break Zhao army. Yu Qing said: King listen minister, send envoy emerge heavy treasure attach Chu Wei, Chu Wei wish obtain wang heavy treasure, certainly inner our envoy. "If Zhao sends envoys to Chu and Wei, Qin will suspect that a coalition is forming against them and will surely be filled with dread." "In this way, peace might actually be achieved." The King of Zhao did not listen; instead, he followed Lord Pingyang's advice to seek peace and sent Zheng Zhu to Qin. Qin received him. Zhao King summon Yu Qing: My person made Ping Yang Lord peace at Qin, Qin already inner Zheng Zhu, qing for what like? Yu Qing answer: King did not obtain peace, army certainly break. "All those in the world who celebrate military victories are now gathering in Qin." "Zheng Zhu is a man of high status; when he enters Qin, the King of Qin and the Marquis of Ying will surely treat him with great visible honor to show the world." "When Chu and Wei see Zhao suing for peace, they will surely not come to Your Majesty's rescue." "Once Qin knows that the world will not rescue you, they will never agree to peace." The Marquis of Ying indeed honored Zheng Zhu to show those celebrating victory that Zhao was submissive, and in the end, Qin refused to make peace. After the catastrophic defeat at Changping, Qin then besieged Handan, making Zhao the laughingstock of the world.
12
使 使
After Qin lifted the siege of Handan and the King of Zhao entered their court, he sent Zhao Hao to negotiate a treaty with Qin, agreeing to cede six counties in exchange for peace. Yu Qing tell Zhao King: Qin attack wang, tired return? King and its strength still could advance, love wang did not attack? King said: Qin attack I, did not spare remain strength, certainly and tired return. Yu Qing said: Qin and its strength attack its did not could take, tired return, wang again and its strength did not could take send it, is help Qin self attack. "When Qin attacks Your Majesty again next year, there will be no one to come to your rescue." The King told Zhao Hao what Yu Qing had said. Zhao Hao said: Yu Qing truly could exhaust Qin strength arrive place? Truly know Qin strength did not could advance, this pellet ball land did not give, made Qin next year again attack wang, wang obtain did not divide its inner peace? King said: Please listen son divide, son could certainly made next year Qin did not again attack I? Zhao Hao answer: This did not minister dare take responsibility. "In former days, the relations between the three Jin states and Qin were friendly, and they treated each other well." "Now that Qin is friendly with Han and Wei but attacks Your Majesty, it must be because the way you serve Qin is not as satisfactory as how Han and Wei serve them." "Now I have managed to relieve the pressure of Qin’s attack for you, opened the passes for trade, and secured ties with Han and Wei. Yet if by next year Your Majesty alone suffers the brunt of Qin’s aggression, it will surely be because you lag behind Han and Wei in your service to Qin." "This is a responsibility I do not dare to take upon myself."
13
使
The King reported this to Yu Qing. Yu Qing answer: Hao speak did not peace, next year Qin again attack wang, wang obtain did not divide its inner peace. "Even if we make peace now, Hao cannot guarantee that Qin will not attack us again." Now though divide six cities, what wasnefit! "If they attack again next year and you again cede what they could not take by force just to get peace, this is a policy of self-destruction. It would be better to have no peace at all." Qin though good attack, coulddid not take six counties; "Even if Zhao cannot hold out, we will not have lost those six cities by our own hand." When Qin grows weary and returns home, their troops will surely be exhausted. "If I use those six cities to win over the world and then attack the exhausted Qin, I may have 'lost' them to the world, but I will be compensated at Qin’s expense." My country still profit, who and sit divide land, self weak strong Qin! "Now Hao says that the reason Qin is friendly with Han and Wei but attacks Zhao is that your service to Qin is inferior to theirs. This would mean Your Majesty must serve Qin with six cities every year, until eventually you sit by and watch all your cities vanish." The next year Qin will again seek to divide our lands - will Your Majesty give it to them? Not give, is abandon wasfore merit provoke Qin calamity; If you keep giving, eventually you will have no more land to give. "As the saying goes: 'The strong are good at attacking, while the weak are unable to defend.'" "If we now sit idly and submit to Qin, they will gain vast territories without even wearying their troops. This only serves to strengthen Qin while further weakening Zhao." "When we cede land from an ever-weakening Zhao to an increasingly powerful Qin, their predatory ambitions will surely never cease." "Moreover, Your Majesty's lands are finite, while Qin's demands are insatiable. To satisfy boundless greed with limited territory is a course that must inevitably lead to the end of Zhao."
14
使
King Zhao's plans were not yet decided when Lou Huan arrived from Qin. The king consulted with Lou Huan, asking: 'Which is better - to cede territory to Qin or not to cede it?' Lou Huan politely declined, saying: 'This is not something this minister can presume to know.' The king said: 'Nevertheless, try telling me your personal opinion.' Lou Huan replied: 'Has Your Majesty also heard about the mother of Gongfu Wenbo? When Gongfu Wenbo, who served in Lu, died of an illness, two of his women committed suicide in his private chambers. When his mother heard of this, she did not shed a single tear. Her chamberlain said: 'How can there be a mother who does not weep when her son dies?' His mother said: 'Confucius was a worthy man, exiled from Lu, yet this man did not follow him. "Now that he is dead, two women have taken their own lives for him. One who inspires such acts must have been negligent toward his elders while being overly indulgent toward his women." Therefore, judging from the mother's perspective, she is a worthy mother; "But if viewed from the perspective of a wife, she would inevitably be seen as a jealous one." "Thus the words may be the same, but when the speaker differs, the effect on the human heart changes entirely." Now I have just arrived from Qin and if I advise against ceding territory, it would not be proper strategy; if I advise in favor of ceding it, Your Majesty might think I am acting for Qin's benefit. Therefore I dare not answer. "If I may offer my counsel to Your Majesty, it would be better to simply give them the land." The king said: 'Very well.'
15
When Yu Qing heard this, he entered and saw the king, saying: 'This is deceptive talk! Your Majesty must be careful not to cede territory!' When Lou Huan heard of this, he went to see the King. The King again shared Yu Qing’s arguments with Lou Huan. Lou Huan replied: 'Not so. "Yu Qing has grasped one side of the matter, but he misses the other." When Qin and Zhao become embroiled in conflict, why is the whole world pleased? "They say: 'I shall use my strength to take advantage of their weakness.'" "Now that Zhao’s armies are trapped by Qin, all those in the world who follow the victor will surely side with Qin." "Therefore, it would be better to cede territory immediately for peace, both to sow doubt among the other states and to satisfy Qin’s current ambitions." "Otherwise, the world will take advantage of Qin’s righteous fury and Zhao’s state of exhaustion to carve us up like a melon." Zhao will soon perish - what will Qin gain from that? "Therefore, I say that Yu Qing has grasped one aspect of the situation, but he remains blind to the other." "I hope Your Majesty will decide based on this and not deliberate any further."
16
西 使 使
When Yu Qing heard this, he went to see the king, saying: 'How dangerous! The way Lou Zi acts for Qin only increases the world's suspicions. How can this soothe Qin's ambitions? Does he not speak of how this shows weakness to the world? "Furthermore, when I advised against ceding territory to Qin, it was not merely for the sake of refusing them." "Qin demands six cities from Your Majesty, but I suggest you use those six cities to entice Qi instead." "Qi is Qin’s most bitter enemy. If they are offered Your Majesty’s six cities to join forces in an attack on Qin from the west, they will agree to Your Majesty’s proposal before the words have even left your mouth." "In this way, Your Majesty may lose territory to Qi, but you will be amply compensated at Qin’s expense." "Then the deep grievances of Qi and Zhao can be avenged, and you will have shown the world that you are a man of true capability." If Your Majesty issues this proclamation, even before troops spy across the borders, I foresee Qin sending heavy bribes to Zhao and returning to make peace with Your Majesty. "If you seek peace by allying with Qin, when Han and Wei hear of it, they will surely hold Your Majesty in the highest regard." "To honor Your Majesty, they will certainly send their most precious treasures to reach you before anyone else does." "Thus, with a single stroke, Your Majesty will have secured the friendship of three states and completely transformed your relationship with Qin." The King of Zhao said, "Excellent." He then sent Yu Qing east to meet with the King of Qi and plot against Qin. But before Yu Qing could even return, an envoy from Qin had already arrived in Zhao. When Lou Huan heard of this, he fled the state. Thereupon, Zhao enfeoffed Yu Qing with a city.
17
便
After a short while, Wei requested to form a vertical alliance. King Xiaocheng of Zhao summoned Yu Qing to consult with him. Passing by Lord Pingyuan's residence, Lord Pingyuan said: 'I wish to hear your views on the alliance.' Yu Qing went in to see the King. The king said: 'Wei requests to form a vertical alliance.' Yu Qing replied: 'Wei is mistaken.' The king said: 'I certainly have not permitted it.' Yu Qing replied: 'Your Majesty is mistaken.' The king said: 'Wei requests a vertical alliance. You say Wei is wrong. I have not permitted it, yet you say I am wrong. Then is a vertical alliance finally impossible?' Yu Qing replied: 'I have heard that when small states deal with large states, if there is profit then the large state receives the blessing, if there is defeat then the small state receives the calamity. "Now Wei, as a small state, is inviting calamity upon itself by seeking this alliance, while Your Majesty, as a great state, is rejecting a blessing by refusing it. Therefore, I say that both Your Majesty and Wei are mistaken." "I humbly believe that forming the alliance is the more advantageous course." The king said: 'Excellent.' Zhao then joined with Wei in a vertical alliance.
18
Because of his friendship with Wei Qi, Yu Qing set aside the seal of a marquis of ten thousand households and the rank of high minister. He traveled in secret with Wei Qi and eventually left Zhao, only to find himself in dire straits in Liang. After Wei Qi died and Yu Qing found no other way to fulfill his ambitions, he began to write. Drawing inspiration from the *Spring and Autumn Annals* of old and observing the events of the modern world, he composed eight chapters on topics such as 'Integrity and Duty,' 'Appellations,' 'Assessment,' and 'Political Strategy.' His work critiqued the successes and failures of states, and it has been handed down to the world as the *Yu Family Spring and Autumn Annals*.
19
使
The Grand Historian says: Lord Pingyuan was a fine nobleman of graceful bearing in this troubled age, yet he did not perceive the larger picture. As the vulgar saying goes, 'Profit blinds the intellect.' Lord Pingyuan, greedy for Feng Ting's treacherous advice, caused Zhao to lose 400,000 troops at Changping, bringing Handan to the brink of destruction. Yu Qing assessed situations and gauged feelings, devising strategies for Zhao - how skillful he was! When he could not bear to abandon Wei Qi and ended up distressed in Daliang - even a common fellow would know this was impossible, how much more so a worthy man? Yet, had Yu Qing not known such poverty and sorrow, he might never have written the book that made his name known to all later generations.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →