← Back to 史記

廉頗藺相如列傳

Biographies of Lian Po and Lin Xiangru

Chapter 81 of 史記 · Records of the Grand Historian
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 81
Next Chapter →
1
Lian Po was a distinguished general of Zhao. In the sixteenth year of King Huiwen of Zhao, Lian Po served as Zhao's general and attacked Qi. He routed them and took Yangjin, was appointed upper minister, and his bravery became renowned among the feudal lords. Lin Xiangru was a man of Zhao who served as retainer to Miao Xian, the eunuch director of Zhao.
2
使 使 使 使 使 使 西
During King Huiwen of Zhao's reign, Zhao acquired the He family jade disc from Chu. When King Zhaoxiang of Qin heard of it, he sent a messenger to the king of Zhao offering fifteen cities in exchange for the jade disc. The king of Zhao consulted with Grand General Lian Po and the other ministers: if they gave the bi to Qin, they feared they could not obtain Qin's cities and would only be deceived; If they refused to hand it over, they feared Qin would send troops. Unable to settle on a plan, they looked for someone who could go answer Qin, but found no one suitable. The eunuch director Miao Xian said, "My retainer Lin Xiangru is fit to be sent." The king asked, "How do you know?" He replied, "I once committed an offense and secretly planned to flee to Yan. My retainer Xiangru stopped me and asked, 'How do you know the king of Yan? I told him that I had once accompanied Your Majesty to meet the king of Yan at the border, and that the king of Yan privately grasped my hand and said, 'I wish to form a friendship.' That was how I knew him, and so I wished to go. Xiangru told me, 'Zhao is strong and Yan is weak. You are favored by the king of Zhao, and therefore the king of Yan wishes to form an alliance with you. Now if you flee Zhao and go to Yan, Yan will fear Zhao and certainly will not dare keep you. It will bind you and return you to Zhao. You would do better to bare your torso and prostrate yourself on the executioner's block to plead guilty; then perhaps you may escape. I followed his plan, and the great king graciously pardoned me. I privately consider this man a brave warrior with wisdom and strategy, fit to be sent." The king summoned Lin Xiangru and asked, "The king of Qin is offering fifteen cities for my jade. Should I send it?" Xiangru said: "Qin is strong and Zhao is weak; we have no choice but to agree." The king said, "What if he takes my jade and gives me no cities?" Xiangru said: "If Qin seeks the bi with cities, but Zhao does not agree, the fault lies with Zhao. If Zhao gives the bi, but Qin does not give Zhao the cities, the fault lies with Qin. If we weigh the two courses, it is better to agree and lay the blame on Qin." The king said: "Who can be sent?" Xiangru said, "If Your Majesty has no one else, I am willing to carry the jade as your envoy. If the cities are delivered to Zhao, the jade may remain in Qin; if the cities do not enter, I ask to return the bi intact to Zhao." The king of Zhao thereupon sent Xiangru west into Qin carrying the bi.
3
使 使 使
The king of Qin received Xiangru seated at Zhangtai, and Xiangru presented the jade disc to him. The king of Qin was delighted. He passed the jade among his consorts and attendants, and they all cried, "Long live!" Seeing that the king of Qin had no intention of repaying Zhao with cities, Xiangru stepped forward and said: "There is a flaw in the bi; please let me show Your Majesty." The king handed the jade back. Xiangru took it, stepped backward until he stood against a pillar, his hair bristling with anger as if it would lift his cap, and said to the king of Qin, "Your Majesty wanted this jade and sent a letter to the king of Zhao. The king of Zhao gathered all his ministers to discuss it, and they said, 'Qin is greedy and trusts in its power. It wants the jade on empty promises; the cities will surely never be delivered. So they advised against giving the jade to Qin. But I thought: even common friends do not deceive one another, much less great states. Moreover, it would not do to offend mighty Qin's goodwill over a single bi. The king of Zhao therefore fasted and purified himself for five days, entrusted me with the jade, and bowed in his court as he sent the letter. Why is that? He did this to honor the dignity of a great state and show proper respect. Now that I have arrived, Your Majesty has received me in an outer gallery with very arrogant ritual; Once you had the jade, you passed it to your consorts as if to make sport of me. I saw that Your Majesty had no intention of compensating Zhao with cities, so I took the jade back. If Your Majesty must press me, my head will now be smashed together with the bi against this pillar!" Xiangru clutched the jade and fixed his eyes on the pillar, ready to smash it there. The king of Qin, afraid he would shatter the jade, apologized and begged him to stop. He called for officials to spread out a map and pointed to fifteen cities that would be given to Zhao. Xiangru judged that the King of Qin was only pretending to offer Zhao cities and that in truth they could not be obtained. He then said to the King of Qin: "The He Shi bi is a treasure transmitted throughout the world. The King of Zhao was afraid and had no choice but to present it. When the king of Zhao sent the jade, he fasted and purified himself for five days. Your Majesty should likewise fast for five days and arrange the full nine-guest ceremony in court; only then will I dare present the jade." The king of Qin considered the matter and realized he could not seize the jade by force. He agreed to fast for five days and lodged Xiangru at the Guangcheng guesthouse. Xiangru judged that even after fasting, the king of Qin would break the agreement and refuse to hand over the cities. He therefore had an attendant dress in coarse clothes, hide the jade, escape by a side road, and carry it back to Zhao.
4
使 使 使
After fasting for five days, the king of Qin arranged the nine-guest ceremony in court and summoned Lin Xiangru, the Zhao envoy. Xiangru came before him and said, "From Duke Mu down through more than twenty Qin rulers, not one has kept agreements firmly and openly. I feared that Your Majesty would deceive me and that I would fail Zhao, so I sent someone to carry the jade back. It has already reached Zhao by a hidden route. Besides, Qin is strong and Zhao weak. If Your Majesty sends even a single envoy to Zhao, Zhao will present the jade at once. With Qin's power, if you first cede fifteen cities to Zhao, how would Zhao dare keep the jade and offend Your Majesty? I know that deceiving Your Majesty is a crime worthy of death. I ask to submit to the boiling cauldron; I only ask Your Majesty and your ministers to consider the matter carefully." The king of Qin and his ministers exchanged glances and laughed. Some attendants wished to lead Xiangru away, but the king of Qin said: "Now if we kill Xiangru, in the end we cannot obtain the bi, and we would cut off Qin and Zhao's friendship. Better to treat him generously on this occasion and send him back to Zhao. Would the king of Zhao for one bi's sake deceive Qin?" In the end, he granted Xiangru a formal court audience, completed the ceremony, and sent him back.
5
使
When Xiangru had returned, the king of Zhao considered him a worthy envoy who had not disgraced Zhao among the feudal lords, and appointed him upper grandee. Qin never gave Zhao the cities, and Zhao never gave Qin the jade.
6
Later, Qin attacked Zhao and captured Shicheng. The following year, Qin attacked Zhao again, killing twenty thousand men.
7
使使西
The Qin king sent an envoy to inform the Zhao king, proposing a friendly summit meeting at Mianchi Pool outside the west river. The Zhao king feared Qin and wanted to decline. Lian Po and Lin Xiangru counseled, "If the king does not go, it will show Zhao as weak and cowardly." So the Zhao king went, accompanied by Xiangru. Lian Po escorted him to the border and bade farewell, saying, "Your Majesty is going. Considering the distance and the protocol of the meeting, you should return within thirty days at most. If Your Majesty does not return in thirty days, I beg you to establish the crown prince as king. This will dash Qin's hopes." The king agreed, and thus met with the Qin king at Mianchi Pool. The Qin king, drunk on wine, said: 'I hear the Zhao king loves music. Please play the zither.' The Zhao king played the zither. The Qin scribe stepped forward and recorded: 'On such-and-such date, the Qin king and Zhao king met and drank together, commanding the Zhao king to play the zither.' Lin Xiangru stepped forward and said: 'The Zhao king hears that the Qin king is skilled in Qin music. Please strike the chime stones for the Qin king to provide mutual entertainment.' The Qin king flew into a rage and refused. Thus, Xiangru stepped forward with the chime stones and knelt to request the Qin king. The Qin king refused to strike the chime stones. Xiangru said: 'Within five paces, I beg to spatter Your Majesty with the blood from my neck!' The attendants wanted to stab Xiangru, but Xiangru glared and berated them, and the attendants all retreated in fear. Thus, the Qin king, displeased, reluctantly struck the chime stones once. Xiangru turned and summoned the Zhao scribe to record: 'On such-and-such date, the Qin king struck the chime stones for the Zhao king.' Qin's ministers said: 'Please offer fifteen Zhao cities in congratulations to the Qin king.' Lin Xiangru also said: 'Please offer Qin's Xianyang in congratulations to the Zhao king.' The Qin king finished the wine, but ultimately could gain no advantage over Zhao. Zhao also massed troops in readiness for Qin, and Qin dared not make a move.
8
After the banquet ended, they returned home, and Xiangru was appointed upper minister because of his great merit, ranking above Lian Po. Lian Po said, "I am Zhao's general, with great merit from attacking cities and fighting in the field, while Lin Xiangru has only labored with words and still ranks above me. Moreover, Xiangru was originally a lowly person. I am ashamed and cannot bear to be beneath him." He declared, "When I see Xiangru, I will certainly humiliate him." Xiangru heard this and refused to meet with him. Whenever court was held, Xiangru would often claim illness, not wishing to contend in rank with Lian Po. Soon after, when Xiangru went out and spotted Lian Po from afar, he steered his carriage aside to avoid him. Thus, his retainers together admonished him: "We who left our families to serve you did so only because we admired your noble righteousness. Now you and Lian Po hold the same rank, yet he proclaims vile words, and you fearfully hide from him. Your fear is extreme! Even common people would be ashamed of this, how much more generals and ministers! We are unworthy and request to take our leave." Lin Xiangru firmly stopped them and said, "Gentlemen, in your view, how does General Lian compare to the Qin king?" They replied, "He is not as formidable." Xiangru said, "With all the Qin king's power, I berated him in his own court and humiliated his ministers. Though I am lowly, would I alone fear General Lian? But I consider this: the only reason mighty Qin dares not attack Zhao is that we two men are here. Now if two tigers fight, they cannot both survive. The reason I do this is to put the nation's crisis before private grudges." When Lian Po heard this, he bared his torso and bore thorns on his back, and went by way of a guest to Lin Xiangru's gate to apologize. He said, "I, a low and vulgar man, never knew the general's generosity went so far." In the end they were reconciled and became friends who would die for each other.
9
That year, Lian Po attacked Qi to the east and defeated one of their armies. Two years later, Lian Po again attacked the Qi city of Ji and captured it. Three years later, Lian Po attacked Wei's Fangling and Anyang and captured them. Four years later, Lin Xiangru led troops to attack Qi, reaching Pingyi before halting. The following year Zhao She defeated the Qin army at Eyu.
10
Zhao She was a tax collector in Zhao. While collecting taxes, he found that Lord Pingyuan's household refused to pay out to the state; Zhao She enforced the law against them and executed nine of Lord Pingyuan's influential retainers. Lord Pingyuan was furious and wanted to kill him. Zhao She then persuaded him: "You are a noble lord in Zhao. If you indulge your household and do not serve the public, the law will be weakened. Weakened law means a weak state, and a weak state invites attacks from other lords. When other lords attack, Zhao will perish. How then could you maintain your wealth? With your noble status, if you serve the public according to the law, high and low will be equal. Equality between high and low means a strong state, and a strong state secures Zhao. As a noble relative, would you be insignificant in the world?" Lord Pingyuan considered him worthy and recommended him to the king. The king employed him to manage state revenues; the revenues were brought into excellent order, the people grew rich, and the treasuries were filled.
11
Qin attacked Han and positioned their army at Eyu. The king summoned Lian Po and asked: 'Can we save them?' He replied, "The road is long and treacherous. It would be difficult to save them." He then summoned Yue Cheng and asked him the same question. Yue Cheng replied just as Lian Po had. Then he summoned Zhao She and asked him. Zhao She replied, "The road is long and treacherous, like two rats fighting in a hole: the braver general will win." The king then ordered Zhao She to lead troops and save them.
12
西
The troops had marched thirty li from Handan when he ordered the army, "Anyone who offers military advice will be executed." The Qin army camped west of Wuan. The Qin troops beat their drums, roared battle cries, and prepared for battle, causing all the roof tiles in Wuan to shake. When one army scout urged an immediate rescue of Wuan, Zhao She had him beheaded on the spot. He strengthened the defensive walls and remained there twenty-eight days without advancing, further reinforcing the fortifications. A Qin spy came to infiltrate, but Zhao She fed him well and sent him on his way. The spy reported back to the Qin general, who was greatly delighted and said, "They have marched thirty li from their capital yet do not advance. They are just reinforcing fortifications. Eyu is not even Zhao territory!" Once Zhao She had sent the Qin spy away, he had his troops roll up their armor and march swiftly. They arrived in two days and one night, and he ordered the best archers to camp fifty li from Eyu. Once the fortifications were complete, the Qin forces heard of it and advanced with all their troops in full armor. Soldier Xu Li requested to offer military advice. Zhao She said: 'Bring him in.' Xu Li said: 'The Qin did not expect Zhao troops to arrive here. They come with high morale and spirit. General, you must concentrate your forces densely to meet them. Otherwise, we will surely be defeated.' Zhao She said: "I accept your command." Xu Li said: 'Please have me executed for offering unsolicited advice.' Zhao She said: "Wait until after the battle; then we will settle it at Handan." Xu Li again requested to offer advice: 'Whoever occupies the north mountain summit first will win; those who arrive later will be defeated.' Zhao She agreed and immediately dispatched ten thousand men to hurry there. The Qin troops arrived later and fought to ascend the mountain but could not. Zhao She unleashed his troops to attack them and routed the Qin army. The Qin army retreated in defeat, thus lifting the siege of Eyu and withdrawing.
13
King Huiwen of Zhao gave the title Lord Ma Fu to Zhao She and made Xu Li state defender. Thus, Zhao She held the same rank as Lian Po and Lin Xiangru.
14
使 使
Four years later King Huiwen of Zhao died, and his son King Xiaocheng ascended the throne. In the seventh year, Qin and Zhao confronted each other at Changping. Zhao She was already dead, and Lin Xiangru was gravely ill. Zhao put Lian Po in command against Qin, but after Qin defeated the Zhao army several times, Lian Po fortified his camp and refused battle. Qin repeatedly issued challenges, but Lian Po refused to engage. The Zhao king believed Qin's spies. Qin's spies spread word: 'What Qin truly fears is only that Lord Ma Fu's son, Zhao Kuo, might be appointed general.' The Zhao king therefore appointed Zhao Kuo as general to replace Lian Po. Lin Xiangru said, "Your Majesty is appointing Zhao Kuo based on reputation alone. It is like gluing the pegs of a zither and trying to play it. Zhao Kuo can only recite his father's books and commentaries by rote. He does not know how to adapt to changing circumstances." The Zhao king would not listen and appointed him general anyway.
15
使 使 便
From a young age, Zhao Kuo studied military strategy and spoke of military affairs, believing no one in the world could match him. He often discussed military affairs with his father Zhao She, who could not refute him, but did not consider it good. Zhao Kuo's mother asked Zhao She for the reason. He said, "War is a matter of life and death, yet Zhao Kuo speaks of it lightly. If Zhao does not appoint Zhao Kuo as general, fine. But if they must appoint him, the one who destroys Zhao's army will certainly be Zhao Kuo himself." When Zhao Kuo was about to depart, his mother submitted a letter to the king saying, "Zhao Kuo cannot be made a general." The king asked, "Why?" She replied, "When I first served his father as general, he personally brought food and drink to feed dozens of men, befriended hundreds, and gave all the king's and royal family's rewards to army officers and gentlemen. On the day he received orders, he never asked about family matters. Now Zhao Kuo suddenly becomes general, faces east to receive court visits, and army officers do not dare look up at him. He takes the king's rewards of gold and silk, returns home to store them, and daily looks for profitable fields and houses to buy. In your opinion, how does he compare to his father? Father and son have different hearts. I beg you not to send him." The king said, "Mother, let it go. I have already decided." Zhao Kuo's mother then said, "If the king insists on sending him, and if he proves unworthy, may I not be implicated?" The king promised.
16
Once Zhao Kuo replaced Lian Po, he changed all the regulations and replaced the army officers. Qin general Bai Qi heard this and unleashed surprise troops. He pretended to be defeated and fled, cut their grain supply routes, and divided their army into two. The soldiers' morale collapsed. After forty-plus days, the army was starving. Zhao Kuo led elite troops out to fight personally, and the Qin army shot and killed Zhao Kuo. Zhao Kuo's army was defeated, and the several hundred thousand troops surrendered to Qin. Qin buried them all alive. Altogether, Zhao lost four hundred fifty thousand men. The next year, Qin troops surrounded Handan. After more than a year, the city nearly fell. Thanks to Chu and Wei lords coming to their rescue, they were able to lift the siege of Handan. The Zhao king, because of Zhao Kuo's mother's earlier warning, ultimately did not execute her.
17
使
Five years after the siege of Handan was lifted, Yan adopted Li Fu's counsel: "Zhao's fighting men were spent at Changping, and their orphaned sons are not yet grown." Yan then raised troops to attack Zhao. Zhao sent Lian Po as general. He attacked, routed the Yan army at Hao, killed Li Fu, and surrounded Yan. Yan ceded five cities and requested peace, and Zhao accepted. Zhao enfeoffed Lian Po at Weiwen as Lord Xinping and appointed him acting chancellor.
18
退 使
When Lian Po was dismissed from Changping and returned home, during his time out of power, all his old guests left him. When he was restored to command, the retainers came back as well. Lian Po said: "Guests, withdraw!" The guest said: 'Alas! Why do you only realize this now? The world associates like the marketplace. When you have power, I follow you. When you have no power, I leave. This is simply the principle of things. Why resent it?' Six years later, Zhao sent Lian Po to attack Wei's Fanyang and captured it.
19
使
Zhao Xiao Cheng Wang died, and his son King Dao Xiang ascended the throne. He sent Yue Cheng to replace Lian Po. Lian Po was furious and attacked Yue Cheng, who fled. Lian Po fled to Daliang in Wei. The next year, Zhao appointed Li Mu as general to attack Yan, capturing Wu Sui and Fang Cheng.
20
使使 使 使 使
Lian Po lived in Liang for a long time, but Wei could not find employment for him. Zhao was repeatedly troubled by Qin troops. The Zhao king longed to have Lian Po again, and Lian Po also longed to be employed by Zhao once more. The Zhao king sent an envoy to see if Lian Po was still usable. Lian Po's enemy Guo Kai gave much gold to the envoy and ordered him to slander Lian Po. The Zhao envoy, having seen Lian Po, watched as Lian Po ate a dou of rice and ten jin of meat in one meal, then donned his armor and mounted his horse, to show he was still usable. The Zhao envoy returned and reported to the king, "General Lian is old, but he still eats well. However, while sitting with me, within a short while he relieved himself three times." The Zhao king considered him too old and did not summon him.
21
使
Chu heard Lian Po was in Wei and secretly sent people to welcome him. Lian Po served for a time as a Chu general but accomplished nothing. He said, "I miss commanding men of Zhao." Lian Po finally died at Shouchun.
22
便 使
Li Mu was one of Zhao's finest generals on the northern frontier. He often resided in Dai and Yanmen, preparing against the Xiongnu. He appointed officials as needed and had all market rents enter the commander's residence to fund the soldiers' expenses. Daily he slaughtered several oxen to feast the soldiers, practiced archery and riding, was careful with beacon fires, employed many secret spies, and generously treated the warriors. He made a rule: 'When the Xiongnu enter to raid, urgently gather and protect the people. Anyone who dares capture captives will be executed.' Whenever the Xiongnu entered, the beacon fires were carefully lit, and the people gathered for protection without daring to fight. This continued for years, with no losses or defeats. However, the Xiongnu considered Li Mu cowardly, and even Zhao's border troops thought their general was cowardly. The Zhao king rebuked Li Mu, but Li Mu continued as before. The Zhao king grew angry, summoned him back, and had someone else replace him as general.
23
使
Over a year, whenever the Xiongnu came, they went out to fight. When they went out to fight, they were repeatedly defeated, with heavy losses. The border regions could no longer farm or herd. They again requested Li Mu. Li Mu shut his door and refused to come out, firmly claiming illness. The Zhao king then strongly insisted on raising him to lead troops again. Li Mu said: 'If the king insists on employing me, then I must be allowed to act as before; only then will I dare accept the command.' The king agreed.
24
滿
When Li Mu arrived, he followed the old agreement. For years the Xiongnu gained nothing. They ultimately considered him cowardly. The border soldiers received daily rewards but were not used in battle, so all wished for one fight. He then assembled 1,300 chariots, 13,000 cavalry horses, 50,000 elite soldiers valued at a hundred gold each, and 100,000 archers, drilling them all for battle. He sent livestock out in great numbers and let the people fill the fields. When a small Xiongnu force crossed the border, he pretended to flee north in defeat and left several thousand men behind for them to capture. Hearing this, the Chanyu led a large force into Zhao. Li Mu deployed numerous surprise formations, extended his left and right wings, and struck, crushing the Xiongnu and killing more than one hundred thousand cavalry. He destroyed the Chanlan, defeated the Donghu, compelled the Linhu to surrender, and sent the Chanyu fleeing. For over ten years thereafter, the Xiongnu dared not approach Zhao's border cities.
25
使
In the first year of Zhao King Dao Xiang, after Lian Po had fled to Wei, Zhao sent Li Mu to attack Yan and captured Wu Sui and Fang Cheng. Two years later, Pang Nuan defeated Yan's army and killed Ju Xin. Seven years later, Qin defeated and killed Zhao general Hu Zhe at Wu Sui, taking ten thousand heads. Zhao then appointed Li Mu as grand general. He attacked the Qin army at Yi An, routed them, and put Qin general Huan Yi to flight. Li Mu was enfeoffed as Lord Wu An. Three years later, Qin attacked Fan Wu. Li Mu struck and defeated the Qin army, confronting Han and Wei to the south.
26
使使 使 使
In the seventh year of Zhao King Qian, Qin sent Wang Jian to attack Zhao. Zhao sent Li Mu and Sima Shang to defend against him. Qin gave much gold to Zhao king's favorite minister Guo Kai to act as a reverse spy, claiming that Li Mu and Sima Shang wished to rebel. The Zhao king then sent Zhao Cong and Qi general Yan Ju to replace Li Mu. Li Mu refused the orders. Zhao sent people to secretly arrest and behead him. Sima Shang was dismissed. Three months later, Wang Jian urgently attacked Zhao, routed and killed Zhao Cong, captured King Qian of Zhao and his general Yan Ju, thus destroying Zhao.
27
退
The Grand Historian said: To know death is certain and still be brave does not mean that dying is hard; what is hard is standing firm when death is before you. When Lin Xiangru drew the jade to himself, glared at the pillar, and rebuked the king of Qin's attendants, the worst he faced was execution. Yet many men are timid and dare not act. Xiangru once summoned his courage, overawed an enemy state and won its trust; later he stepped back and yielded to Lian Po, and his name became weightier than Mount Tai. In wisdom and courage alike, he may be said to have possessed both.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →