← Back to 宋史

卷二百六十九 列傳第二十八 陶穀 扈蒙 王著 王祐 楊昭儉 魚崇諒 張澹 高錫

Volume 269 Biographies 28: Tao Gu, Hu Meng, Wang Zhe, Wang You, Yang Zhaojian, Yu Chongliang, Zhang Dan, Gao Xi

Chapter 269 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 269
Next Chapter →
1
鹿
Tao Gu, styled Xiushi, came from Xinping in Bin Prefecture. The family had originally borne the surname Tang but changed it to evade the imperial taboo of the Jin founder. For generations under the Northern Qi, Sui, and Tang they had ranked among the great families. His grandfather Yanqian had served as prefect of Ci, Jiang, and Li, won renown as a poet, and took the sobriquet Master of Deer Gate. His father Huan had governed Yi Prefecture, but during the chaos at the close of the Tang he was slain by Yang Chongben, the military governor of Bin. Gu was still a child then and grew up in Chongben's house with his mother, Lady Liu.
2
西
Before he was twenty he could already write essays, and he entered service as a collator in the palace library and as adjutant on the Shanzhou military staff. He once submitted a literary work to Chief Minister Li Song, who thought very highly of his prose. He Ning was serving as chief minister at the same time, and the two of them jointly recommended him for posts as associate editor in the Secretariat and collator in the Hall of Assembled Worthies. He was then made an investigating censor assigned to the western capital, and later promoted to vice director in the Ministry of Works with responsibility for drafting imperial edicts. After the Jin founder abolished the Hanlin Academy, Gu assumed responsibility for drafting both palace and court proclamations. With the volume of edicts overwhelming, much of the work was entrusted to Gu and carried out to general satisfaction, and his drafts were regarded as the best of the age. Early in the reign of Emperor Shaodi he received the crimson robe, boots, court tablet, and black silver belt. In the ninth year of the Tianfu era he was made director in the Ministry of Revenues.
3
西
Earlier, after Li Song had gone north with the Khitans, Gaozu entered the capital and gave Song's mansion to Su Fengji; Song still owned other estates in the western capital, and Fengji seized those as well. When Song came back from the north he offered the deed of the house to Fengji, but Fengji was not appeased, and Song's sons and nephews kept voicing grievances. Fengji then engineered charges that sent Song and his brothers Yu and Wei to prison; in fear Song pleaded illness and refused to leave his home. Song's kinsman Fang, who served as a secretary in the palace archives, once called on him, and Song asked Fang, "Has the court been saying anything about me lately?" Fang replied, "Nothing else that I know of—only that Drafting Attendant Tao keeps spreading harsh slanders against you in public gatherings." Song sighed and said, "When Gu was only a Shanzhou adjutant I brought him into the Hall of Assembled Worthies, and within a few years I had him drafting edicts—what debt does that Tao boy think I owe him?" After Song fell victim to the purge, Fang once called on Gu on official business, and Gu asked him, "Do you know Vice Minister Li?" Fang straightened his garments and answered, "He is my father's cousin." Gu said, "I had a hand in bringing down the Li family." Fang broke out in a cold sweat at the words.
4
Gu was brusque by temperament; at a banquet with Yanzhou commander An Shenxin he quarreled over wine, and Shenxin reported him to the throne. The court was then indulging its military commanders, and Gu was demoted to vice minister of rites.
5
西
He once memorialized, "During my recent service at the western capital I found that the capital judicial office rarely rendered immediate decisions in criminal cases. Even petty quarrels between neighbors were left to fester for months; burials in the wards could not proceed until the capital office issued its ruling, and when a servant died of illness an official inspection was still required. Clerks exploited the delays to extort bribes, and corpses sometimes lay unburied for ten days or more. I ask that clear regulations be issued to eliminate these abuses." The court approved his proposal. Soon afterward he was made a drafter in the Secretariat. He also asked that palace musicians receive proper training, that two dance attendants be abolished, and that commoners be forbidden to cut mulberry and jujube trees for fuel—all of which were approved. In the third year of the Kaiyun era he received the gold-and-purple insignia of high rank.
6
西
When the Khitan emperor withdrew northward he tried to force Gu to accompany him. Gu hid in a monastery, dressed in plain hemp cloth, and passed himself off as a wandering monk. Soldiers suspected the disguise, and as many as four times a day armed men threatened him at knifepoint. Gu was well versed in astronomy and told his companions, "The five planets are aligned in the southwest—a king will rise in the Central Plains. The Khitan ruler will never make it home alive." When Yelü Deguang died and a comet's tail pointed north, Gu said, "From now on the Khitans will tear one another apart and never again trouble China." He then made his way back to the Later Han court and was appointed supervising secretary. During the Qianyou reign the court ordered officials in regular attendance to take turns addressing the throne. Gu memorialized, "The rule of submitting memorials every five days was never part of the old system. Having every official speak in rotation is hardly the same as offering sound counsel. It only burdens Your Majesty's attention without helping governance, and I ask that the rotation be discontinued. Whenever a court official learns something worth reporting, let him be allowed to come to the palace at any time to inform the throne." The emperor agreed.
7
Emperor Shizong once told his chief ministers, "Looking at how rulers and ministers of past ages achieved peace and good government, I see that it is no easy thing. I also recall that after the Tang and Jin courts lost their moral authority, treacherous ministers and cunning generals seized power again and again. The central plains have only just been secured, while Wu, Shu, You, and Bing still stand outside our rule and our civilizing influence has not yet spread far. I should have my close advisers each draft policy essays setting out plans for governing the realm." He then ordered Chief Academician Xu Taifu and more than twenty others to write treatises titled On the Difficulties of Rulership and Ministerial Service and Strategies for Pacifying the Frontiers and submit them to the throne. Most of the essays urged cultivating civil virtue and winning over distant peoples, but Gu, Dou Yi, Yang Zhaojian, and Wang Pu argued that because our borders lay hard against the Yangzi and Huai regions, military force should be used to seize them. Ever since his victory at Gaoping, Shizong had drilled his armies and studied strategy with an eye to reunifying the empire. When he read these essays he welcomed their counsel, and his determination to conquer the south grew all the stronger.
8
In the third year of Xiande he was promoted to vice minister of war and made chief academician of the Hanlin. Shizong took a close interest in agriculture and had artisans carve wooden figures of a plowman, a weaver, and a silkworm keeper for display in the inner palace as a way to promote farming; Gu wrote laudatory inscriptions and presented them. In the sixth year of Xiande he was also made vice minister of personnel.
9
Early in the Song he was made minister of rites while retaining his post as chief Hanlin academician. While serving in the Hanlin, Gu clashed with Dou Yi, whose public standing he feared would eclipse his own; he joined Chief Minister Zhao Pu, Zhao Feng, Gao Xi, and others in a campaign to block Yi, and Yi never rose to chief minister.
10
使 使簿 輿
In the second year of Qiande he oversaw personnel selection in the Ministry of Personnel and supervised the civil service examinations. He again directed the southern suburban sacrifices, and most of the ritual regalia and procedures were established by him. Fan Zhi was then serving as grand ritual commissioner and, finding that the imperial procession's escort included armored cavalry in full trappings whose specifications were unknown, asked Gu about them. Gu replied, "In the dingchou year of Liang's Zhenming reign, Zhang Quanyi, governor of Henan, presented three hundred sets of infantry armor and two hundred sets of horse trappings. The infantry armor was lined with cloth, faced with yellow ge, painted in blue-green to resemble lamellar plates, with skirts of red brocade and green-blue ge, laced with crimson leather and fitted with gold and bronze fittings, reaching to the knee. The breastplate bore a human face with two eyes, and the back piece was joined to it with red brocade worked in the pattern of a soaring serpent. The horse trappings were essentially ordinary horse armor, with ornamental plumes added only to the chest piece and the crupper. When Zhuangzong entered Luoyang, the whole stock was burned." Fan Zhi ordered the appropriate offices to follow Gu's specifications and manufacture replacements. The great imperial carriage had also long since lost its specifications; Gu designed a new one that remained in use thereafter. When the Gate of Illustrious Virtue was completed, the court commissioned Gu to write its commemorative inscription.
11
殿
During the Qiande era he appointed Vice Director Wang Yisun of the treasury bureau and Doctor of the Changes Xi Yu to examine the sons of ranked officials. Gu asked Xi Yu to look after his son Zou, whose examination papers were incompetent yet were reported as passing, and Zou was appointed presenter of horses in the palace domestic service. The affair was soon exposed; the censorate investigated; Xi Yu was demoted to revenue clerk in Qianzhou, Wang Yisun to left supporter of the heir apparent, and Gu's salary was suspended for two months. Gu was later promoted in succession to minister of punishments and minister of revenue. He died in the third year of Kaibao at the age of sixty-eight. He was posthumously enfeoffed as right vice director of the Department of State Affairs.
12
Gu had an extraordinary memory and loved learning; he mastered the classics and histories and had read widely in the philosophical masters, Buddhist texts, and Daoist writings; he collected many fine calligraphies and famous paintings and wrote an excellent clerical hand. He was sharp-witted and learned, but ambitious and eager to advance; whenever he met a talented junior scholar he lavished praise on him; yet when he heard of a senior official with a strong reputation, he would contrive slanders to bring him down—his jealousy and hunger for fame showed in countless ways like this. When Taizu was preparing to accept the abdication, no abdication text had yet been drafted; Gu stood beside him, pulled a document from his robe, and presented it with the words, "It is already done." Taizu despised him for it. He once said of himself, "The bone structure of my skull is extraordinary—I am destined to wear the premier's cap with its cicada ornament." He clearly meant that he was destined for the highest office, and many people mocked him for it. His son Bing rose to the post of attendant of the imperial diary. In the fourth year of Tianxi, Gu's grandson Shi passed the examination for collator in the Secretariat.
13
涿 使 簿 使
Hu Meng, styled Riyong, came from Anci in You Prefecture. His great-grandfather Yang had served as vice prefect of Zhuo Prefecture. His grandfather Zhizhou had been a judicial aide on the staff of the Luolong military governor. His father Zeng had been commissioner of the imperial gardens. Meng showed literary talent early; during the Jin Tianfu era he passed the jinshi examination, and under the Later Han he served as registrar of E County. When Zhao Sizong rebelled, Guo Congyi was sent to suppress him. The county and prefectural officials all wore military dress as they hurried about their duties, but Meng appeared in full scholarly robes and moved with unhurried grace, which greatly surprised Congyi. Transport commissioner Li Gu explained, "Meng is a literary gentleman and is not accustomed to administrative work." Congyi left him alone after that. During the Zhou Guangshun era he served as secretary to Zhao Hui, military governor of Guide, and was then summoned to the posts of right reminder, duty historian in the History Office, and drafter of edicts. Meng's cousin Zai was then a Hanlin academician, and the two of them together handled palace and court edicts, earning the nickname "the two Hus."
14
Early in the Song he rose from secretariat drafter to Hanlin academician but was demoted to left supporter of the heir apparent for having solicited favors for his examination-year fellow Qiu Hua; he was later made left remonstrator and put in charge of market taxes at Daming. In the sixth year of his reign he was restored to drafting edicts and appointed compiler in the History Office. During the Kaibao era he was ordered to join Li Mu and others in compiling the History of the Five Dynasties and in revising the Comprehensive Materia Medica of Past and Present. In the fifth year he again supervised the civil service examinations.
15
殿 殿 殿
In the seventh year Meng memorialized, "In the Tang, whenever Emperor Wenzong summoned his ministers to discuss state affairs, he had the attendants of the imperial diary stand at the side of the hall with brush in hand to record what was said, which is why the Veritable Records of Emperor Wenzong are relatively full. Under Later Tang Emperor Mingzong as well, academicians of the Hall of Illustrious Brightness and direct academicians of the Bureau of Military Affairs were ordered to compile the court diary in rotation and submit it to the historiographers. Recently this practice has fallen into complete disuse; although each quarter an inner-palace diary and records from the Bureau of Military Affairs are still sent to the History Office, they note nothing beyond officials' audiences, leave-takings, and expressions of gratitude. The emperor's own words and deeds go unrecorded. Because chief ministers fear leaks, they are reluctant to circulate information; and the historiographers stand too far outside the inner circle to learn what happened. I ask that henceforth all decisions, expressions of favor, and other pronouncements from the imperial heart worthy of the historical record be entrusted to the chief ministers and vice directors of the Secretariat to copy in monthly rotation for the historiographers' use." The emperor agreed and placed Vice Director Lu Duoxun in charge of the project.
16
殿
In the first month of the ninth year the court assembled in the Hall of Qianyuan with the surrendered kings in attendance and full ceremonial music. Meng submitted his "Ode to Sagely Achievement," praising Taizu's acceptance of the abdication and unification of the realm; though the language was florid, an edict commended it. Lu Duoxun took a dislike to him, and he was sent out to serve as prefect of Jiangling.
17
When Taizong succeeded to the throne he was recalled as secretariat drafter and soon restored to the Hanlin Academy. He joined Li Fang in compiling the Veritable Records of Taizu. In the fourth year of Taiping Xingguo, after returning from the Taiyuan campaign, he was made vice minister of revenue and chief Hanlin academician. In the third year of Yongxi he fell ill and retired with the rank of minister of works. He died soon afterward at the age of seventy-two. He was posthumously enfeoffed as right vice director of the Department of State Affairs.
18
After the deaths of Zhang Zhao and Dou Yi, most revisions to court regulations and ritual protocols were made by Meng. When Taizu first accepted the Zhou abdication, he enshrined four generations of ancestors and performed the suburban sacrifice in person, matching his great-grandfather the Proclamation Ancestor with Heaven. When Taizong came to the throne, the ritual officials argued that Shun sacrificed to Ku, the Shang to Ming, and the Zhou to Hou Ji at the suburban rites—these were the ancestral spirits on whom each dynasty's kingship had been founded. Han Gaozu's father the Grand Duke and Guangwu's father the Lord of Nandun, though honored as imperial fathers, were never matched with Heaven in the suburban sacrifice. Thus when suburban sacrifices were held again in the third and sixth years of Taiping Xingguo, matching Taizu with Heaven was ritually proper. When Taizong prepared to perform the Feng sacrifice on Mount Tai, Meng ruled that "nothing honors the father more than matching him with Heaven" and proposed matching the Proclamation Ancestor with Heaven." After the Feng and Chan were abandoned in favor of suburban sacrifice in the first year of Yongxi, this arrangement was implemented, though scholars of ritual disapproved.
19
Meng was sober and steady, never gossiping about others, devoted to Buddhist texts and averse to bloodshed; the gentry praised him as a good man. He suffered from uncontrollable fits of laughter, which he could not suppress even in the emperor's presence. He was a prolific author; his twenty-juan Collected Works from Aoshan circulated widely. Zai, styled Zhongxi, has a separate biography in the History of the Five Dynasties.
20
使 殿 使
Wang Zhe, styled Chenxiang, came from Shanfu in Shan Prefecture. He was open-hearted and guileless. He showed literary talent early and passed the jinshi examination during the Later Han Qianyou era. When the Zhou founder was posted at Daming, Shizong accompanied him and, hearing of Zhe's reputation, took him onto his staff, through which Zhe gained an audience with the Zhou founder. During Guangshun, when Shizong was posted at Cao Prefecture, he appointed Zhe surveillance commissioner aide. He followed Shizong to the capital and was promoted to palace director; and when Shizong succeeded to the throne he was made vice director of the revenue section. In the third year of Xiande he was made a Hanlin academician. In the sixth year he went into mourning for a family death but was recalled to office before the mourning period ended. When Southern Tang's Li Jing sent his brother Congshan to present tribute, Emperor Gong had just succeeded to the throne; Zhe was ordered to escort the envoy to Suiyang, promoted to director in the Ministry of Revenue with responsibility for drafting edicts, and granted the gold-and-purple insignia. When Shizong's funeral procession went to Qing Mausoleum with Empress Fu in attendance, Zhe handled all the official arrangements.
21
宿殿 宿
Early in the Song he was made secretariat drafter. In the second year of Jianlong he supervised the civil service examinations. When Bozhou presented purple fungus, Yanzhou reported a white hare, and Longzhou offered a yellow parrot, Zhe submitted a eulogy that doubled as admonition. Taizu greatly approved his intent and issued an edict commending him. In the spring of the fourth year, while on night duty in the inner palace, he became drunk; his hair fell over his face, and in the night he knocked on the Gate of Nurturing Virtue demanding an audience. The emperor was furious, exposed his offense of spending the night drunk in a brothel, and demoted him to vice director in the Ministry of Revenue. Early in Qiande he was transferred to vice director in the Ministry of War. In the second year he was restored to drafting edicts. A few months later he was made compiler in the History Office with charge of its affairs. In the third year he was promoted to director in the Ministry of Revenue. In the sixth year he was restored to the Hanlin Academy, made director in the Ministry of War, and again supervised the civil service examinations. He died suddenly in the winter of the second year of Kaibao at the age of forty-two.
22
Zhe had shown exceptional talent from youth; Shizong, remembering him as an old member of his staff, treated him with special favor, often summoned him for conversation, had the princes bow to him, and always addressed him as "Academician" without using his personal name. Shizong repeatedly intended to make him chief minister but kept putting it off because of his drinking. When Shizong's illness grew critical, Taizu and Fan Zhi came to receive his final instructions; he told Zhi and the others, "Wang Zhe is an old companion from my princely days; barring some obstacle, I would have made him chief minister." After Shizong died, nothing came of it. Zhe was sociable and generous in promoting younger scholars; his contemporaries among the gentry spoke well of him. He has a separate biography in the History of the Five Dynasties.
23
Wang Hu, styled Jingshu, came from Shen in Daming Prefecture. His grandfather Yan had served as magistrate of Liyang under the Tang. His father Che passed the jinshi examination under Later Tang and rose to left remonstrator.
24
使 使
From youth Hu devoted himself to letters and possessed a bold, spirited temperament. During the Jin Tianfu era he submitted a literary work to Sang Weihan, who praised its elegance, and his reputation spread through the capital. Du Chongwei, military governor of Ye, recruited him as surveillance commissioner aide. Early in the Later Han, when Chongwei was transferred to Suiyang and grew restless, Hu urged him not to rebel against the Han court, but Chongwei would not listen. Hu was demoted to revenue clerk in Qinzhou for his association with Chongwei; he wrote a letter to hometown friends expressing his principles in lofty, vigorous language that won wide praise. Under the Zhou he served successively as magistrate of Wei County and Nanle.
25
殿
When Taizu accepted the abdication, Hu was made investigating censor, transferred from Wei County to govern Guang Prefecture, and then promoted to attending censor in the palace. In the third year of Qiande he was put in charge of drafting edicts. In the sixth year he was made compiler in the Hall of Assembled Worthies and promoted to vice director in the Ministry of Revenue.
26
使 使
When Taizu campaigned against Taiyuan, the army had already crossed the Yellow River. Supplies from the prefectures piled up in Shangdang city until the roads were choked with wagons; when the emperor heard of it he was ready to punish the transport commissioner for the delay. Zhao Pu said, "Our armies have only just arrived; if we punish the transport commissioner now, the enemy will think our supplies are inadequate and seize the chance to probe our weakness—that is no way to overawe distant foes. Send someone capable of handling difficult assignments to take charge of that prefecture—that will suffice." The emperor immediately appointed Hu prefect of Lu. When he arrived, supplies flowed without interruption and the roads were cleared; after the army withdrew he was recalled to court.
27
When Fu Yanqing was posted at Daming and governed poorly, Taizu sent Hu to replace him and watch Yanqing's conduct, telling him, "This is your native place—the occasion for returning in glory." Hu swore on the lives of his entire household that Yanqing was innocent and added, "The rulers of the Five Dynasties often destroyed innocent men through suspicion, and their dynasties therefore did not endure; I beg Your Majesty to take warning from this." Yanqing was spared, and later generations said Hu had earned hidden merit.
28
When troops were sent to the Lingnan region, he was transferred to Xiang Prefecture. After Hunan was pacified he was made prefect of Tanzhou. He was recalled and put in charge of personnel selection in the Ministry of Personnel. At that time Hou Zhi of the left office had returned from Yangzhou and resumed adjudicating selections; Hu handled appointments for the Secretariat and frequently overturned Zhi's nominations. Lu Duoxun was friendly with Zhi, and Zhi complained to him; Duoxun had long resented Hu for refusing to align with him and had Hu sent out as administrative aide on the staff of the Zhenguo army.
29
Early in Taiping Xingguo he was transferred to Hezhong Prefecture. He was recalled as vice director of the left office, made secretariat drafter, and appointed compiler in the History Office. Soon afterward he was put in charge of Kaifeng Prefecture but requested sick leave. Taizong, noting Hu's literary distinction and integrity, specially promoted him to vice minister of war. He died a little over a month later at the age of sixty-four.
30
When Hu was drafting edicts, Hanlin academician Lu Duoxun was secretly working to undermine Zhao Pu and repeatedly urged Hu to join him, but Hu refused. One day Hu cited Yuwen Rong's persecution of Zhang Yue as a warning, which only deepened Duoxun's resentment. When Pu returned to power, Duoxun indeed fell—a outcome much like the Yuwen Rong affair—and observers admired Hu's foresight.
31
Hu had three sons: Yi, Dan, and Xu. Dan has a separate biography. When Hu supervised the examinations he promoted many talented men from humble backgrounds, including Bi Shian and Chai Chengwu; later he and his son Dan both served in the drafting offices and reached the Secretariat. Yi, styled Wende, devoted himself to scholarship, passed the jinshi examination, served as prefect of Yuanzhou with distinction, and died at forty-nine.
32
His son Xu
33
Xu, styled Zhongming. He was strict in managing his household but lenient toward others and especially loyal in friendship. He entered service by yin privilege as grand sacrificer and once served as magistrate of Gou Clan County. Officials in nearby counties were notoriously corrupt and grasping, and the people sang: "Yongning needs three hoes, Gou Clan County needs but one sickle." He later served as magistrate of Yongqiu County as well.
34
殿
Zhenzong had already heard of Xu's talents while serving as heir apparent in the capital, and after his accession he promoted Xu three times until he reached the rank of palace bureau director. Once Dan became chief minister, Xu stopped taking office to avoid the appearance of nepotism. Wang Ju once recommended Xu as capable of handling demanding posts, and Zhenzong summoned Dan and said, "Brothers have often held high office together in past dynasties. The court appoints men for their ability—surely it would not hold your brother back on your account?" The emperor then ordered Xu appointed as an investigator for the capital prefecture, but Dan firmly declined the post, and Xu was instead assigned as vice director of the Southern Bureau. After serving as vice director of the Directorate of Education, he was sent out to govern Ying Prefecture, where he organized famine relief with notable success.
35
In the Dazhong Xiangfu period, after Dan's death, Xu served in both central and local posts with distinguished achievements, and from his post as bureau director in the Ministry of War he was appointed prefect of Yingtian Prefecture. He died at the age of sixty-eight.
36
Yi's son Mu and Xu's son Zhi both proved themselves fully equal to their duties.
37
His son Zhi
38
退 使
Zhi, styled Ziye. From boyhood he was careful, honest, and unpretentious, and he applied himself to scholarship under Yang Yi, who marveled at his exceptional talent. When his uncle Dan read his essays, he praised them with deep admiration. He entered service by yin privilege as a ceremonial officer in the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. He later submitted his writings for a palace examination, passed the jinshi with highest honors, was recommended as an archives collator, then served as a collator in the Hall of Assembled Worthies, and rose to assistant department director in the Ministry of Rites. While mourning his father, he and his younger brothers lived on husked millet and vegetables alone. After the mourning period he served as judicial intendant of Suzhou, where Prefect Huang Zongdan looked down on him for his youth; once during a dispute Zongdan said, "How dare a young man stand up to his senior?" Zhi replied, "When a matter ought to be contested, that is simply doing one's duty." He refused to back down. Zongdan arrested more than a hundred counterfeiters and had them imprisoned for trial; afterward he told Zhi with satisfaction, "I caught them by setting a trap." His delight was plain to see. Zhi said, "You trap men with schemes, send them to their deaths, and then rejoice—is that what benevolent government looks like?" Ashamed and abashed, Zongdan lightened their sentences. He was reassigned as vice director of the Ministry of Justice and the Southern Bureau of the Ministry of Personnel, and then appointed prefect of Cai Prefecture. Each year the people of the prefecture made offerings at the temple of Wu Yuanji, but Zhi said, "How can a rebel and traitor be worshipped by the people?" He tore the temple down and rebuilt it with images of Di Renjie and Li Su for worship, and the people of Cai still call it the "Twin Temples." From his post as bureau director he was recalled to serve as an investigator for the Kaifeng prefecture. His elder brother Yong was then a judicial officer of the Three Departments, and Zhi, unwilling to have both brothers serving together in the capital offices, declined the post and was instead appointed prefect of Shou Prefecture, then transferred to Lu Prefecture. A bandit killed his fellows, seized their goods, and fled, but was eventually caught. Zhi argued that the bandit deserved death, but the Court of Judicial Review held that the law did not require it; Zhi said, "The law pardons bandits who kill their companions only if they surrender voluntarily, so as to sow distrust among their fellows and give them a chance to reform—that is the law's purpose. But this man murdered his companions, seized their property, and was captured in flight—if he is pardoned now, how does that serve the law's intent?" His memorial went unanswered, and he was demoted to superintendent of the Lingxian Abbey in Shuzhou. He gathered methods of body cultivation and longevity from antiquity and his own day, and wrote the "Comprehensive Record of the Baoyuan Era" in one hundred juan. More than a year later, Han Qi, as director of the Court of Judicial Review, petitioned that bandits who kill their companions should not be pardoned unless they surrender voluntarily, and this was enacted as law. Zheng Xian and Ye Qingchen then declared that Zhi had committed no crime and praised his abilities; he was restored to office as prefect of Taizhou, promoted to bureau director of the treasury, and appointed transport commissioner for the Jinghu North circuit.
39
While temporarily handling affairs at Jiangling Prefecture, he heard a suit against a man who had missed the deadline for a betrothal; the man explained that poverty left him without the means to proceed, and so he had broken the engagement. Zhi asked what the expenses would come to and paid them out of his own purse. When an official arrested a man for stealing clothes, the thief kowtowed and said, "I have never done wrong before; hunger and cold drove me to this." Zhi had clothes brought to dress him and let him go. He was also made a historiographer of the History Office and co-director of the Ministry of Personnel's stream-within selection board. Promoted to gentleman awaiting appointment at the Hall of Heavenly Manifestations, he was sent out to govern Shan Prefecture, where he died.
40
Though Zhi came from a wealthy and eminent family and his brothers lived in accustomed luxury, he disciplined himself, loved what was good, and kept to a plain life like a poor scholar; he refused to hoard wealth and sometimes could barely support himself. In the early days, when Dan was a Secretariat drafter, the family was so poor that he and his brothers borrowed money at interest; when they missed the repayment date, they settled the debt with the horse Dan rode. While reading one day, Zhi came upon the old contract; he gathered the younger members of the family and said, "This is the spirit of our house—never forget it." When Fan Zhongyan was exiled to Raozhou at the height of the campaign against factional cliques, Zhi alone went with wine to bid him farewell. When some ridiculed him for it, Zhi said, "Master Fan is a man of worth; to be counted among his associates would be an honor." People admired him all the more for it.
41
Next is Yang Zhaojian.
42
Yang Zhaojian, styled Zhongbao, came from Chang'an in Jingzhao. His great-grandfather Sifu had served the Tang as vice director of the Secretariat, grand councillor, and minister of personnel. His grandfather Shou had been Tang minister of justice. His father Jing had served the Liang as left remonstrance bureau grandee.
43
殿
Zhaojian was quick and brilliant as a youth, and during the Changxing era of Later Tang he passed the jinshi examination. He began his career as a military investigator on the staff of the Chengde circuit. He served as secretary at Zhen and Wei, was appointed left reminder and duty historian, and joined Secretariat drafter Zhang Zhaoyuan and others in compiling the "Veritable Records of Emperor Mingzong." When the work was finished, he was promoted to palace attendant censor.
44
使 使 使
At the beginning of the Tianfu era he was appointed assistant director of the Ministry of Rites. The Jin founder appointed Chief Minister Feng Dao envoy for the Khitan investiture mission with Zhaojian as his deputy; Zhaojian was made assistant director of the Bureau of Appointments, then bureau director of the forestry bureau, and soon afterward was given the concurrent duty of drafting edicts. In less than a month he received three appointments in succession, to the envy of his contemporaries. He also served as birthday envoy to Gao Conghui of Jingnan and was awarded the gold-and-purple insignia of high rank. After returning from the mission he was appointed Secretariat drafter and also made a Hanlin academician.
45
使
At that time the overbearing general Zhang Yanze, stationed at Jingyuan, had brutally murdered his staff officer Zhang Shi, yet the court imposed no punishment. Zhaojian joined Bureau Director Li Tao of the Ministry of Justice and Remonstrance Bureau Grandee Zheng Shouyi in a forceful memorial detailing the crime and demanding that Zhang be punished according to law. Their memorial received no reply. An edict then ordered court officials to take turns addressing the throne, and also allowed sealed memorials to be submitted at any time. Zhaojian submitted another memorial: "The Son of Heaven rules the four seas and faces ten thousand affairs each day; remonstrating ministers should be established to repair the court's failings. Yet though remonstrators exist in name, the path of candid speech is blocked; honest counsel never reaches the emperor's ears, while sycophants win favor at his side. The Censorate exists to uphold discipline and investigate wrongdoing; the wronged ought to be vindicated, and corrupt officials ought to be punished with demotion and exile. Since Your Majesty took the throne, excessive leniency has rendered both offices little more than empty titles. The result is that military commissioners scorn the laws of the court and butcher their staff; victims who appeal for justice at the palace gates are sent back to the very provinces that wronged them. They rest secure in their arrogance and give no thought to the anguish of those whose grievances are suppressed. I beg Your Majesty to act with resolute judgment and execute Yanze to satisfy the officers and men." Powerful ministers therefore came to resent him. He happened to be on leave in Luoyang and failed to attend the Jin founder's funeral; the authorities impeached him and he was stripped of his post.
46
Before long he was restored as vice governor of Henan, then made vice director of the Secretariat, and soon returned to his post as Secretariat drafter. When the Yellow River broke its banks in several prefectures, corvée labor was mobilized on a vast scale under the local commander, and the breach was eventually closed. The young Jin emperor was delighted and ordered a stele erected to commemorate the achievement. Zhaojian remonstrated in a memorial: "Your Majesty, rather than carving stone to celebrate success, it would be better to issue an edict expressing grief and concern; rather than wielding the brush in praise, it would be better to publish a proclamation of self-reproach." His words were forceful and sincere; the young emperor sighed in admiration and ultimately abandoned the plan. Emperor Shizong of Later Zhou admired his talent and recalled him to the Hanlin Academy as an academician. After little more than a year he was made censor-in-chief and restored many long-neglected censorate practices. Soon afterward, because of errors in adjudicating cases, he was demoted together with supervising censor Zhao Li and attendant censor Zhang Jiu to traveling vice marshal of the Wusheng Army.
47
退
In the second year of Kaibao he was appointed tutor of the heir apparent, but he requested retirement because of failing eyesight. In the sixth year he retired with the rank of minister of works. When Emperor Taizong took the throne, Zhaojian was further honored with the title of minister of rites. He died in the second year of Taiping Xingguo at the age of seventy-six.
48
Zhaojian had an elegant bearing, spoke well on philosophical principles, and won a reputation for integrity under the Jin. Yet he had a sharp tongue and loved to mock and criticize; the chief ministers feared his attacks and often humored him.
49
Next is Yu Chongliang.
50
便使
Yu Chongliang, styled Zhongyi, came from a family originally of Shanyang in Chuzhou that later relocated to Shan. Chongliang had originally been named Chongyuan but changed his name to avoid the imperial taboo of the Han founder. He could write essays from childhood, and upon reaching adulthood he was recruited as a staff officer by the prefect of Xiangzhou. When the Wei military governor Yang Shihou died, Xiangzhou was made the seat of the Zhaode Army, and half of the counties of Wei Prefecture were placed under its jurisdiction. The people of Wei were unhappy with the change; staff officer Zhang Yan and his followers imprisoned Military Commissioner He Delun and surrendered to Zhuangzong, while Chongliang fled back to Shan.
51
使 使 調 使
When the Han founder took power, he had all the Khitan edicts Chongliang had received seized and burned in the court hall, then restored him to the duty of drafting edicts. He was soon appointed Hanlin academician and concurrently made Secretariat drafter. When Emperor Yin acceded, Chongliang asked to be posted near home to care for his aging mother; he was appointed vice military commissioner of the Baoyi Army with the concurrent title of prefect of Taizhou and drew the prefectural salary. When an expedition was launched against the three rebellions, Military Commissioner Bai Wenke took the field while Chongliang managed affairs behind the lines. Whatever the army needed in stores or transfers, he met every deadline, and the surrounding commands depended on him. Chongliang's entire family was trapped in Fengxiang; when the city fell after more than a year, Transport Commissioner Li Gu sheltered several dozen of his kin, and none came to harm. Chongliang took leave to go from Qi and bring them to live with him in Shan. Soon afterward Wang Renyu left his inner-court post, and the court proposed recalling Chongliang as a Hanlin academician.
52
使
After the Zhou founder took the throne, the flood of written edicts all passed through Chongliang's hand. Early in the Guangshun era he was additionally made Vice Director of the Ministry of Works and continued in his duties. When Murong Yanchao of Yanzhou was granted an enlarged fief, he was already nursing treasonous thoughts; Chongliang was dispatched to present the patent of appointment and offer reassuring words. With many men then submitting policy proposals, the court had Chongliang examine candidates at the Bureau of Military Affairs and rank them for promotion or demotion.
53
滿
With an aging mother who longed for home, Chongliang asked to leave office and return to care for her. The emperor granted him extended leave and sent his mother gifts of clothing, silk, tea, medicine, and cash; after the hundred-day leave, his home prefecture was to pay him thirty thousand cash and fifteen bushels of grain each month. He was soon made Vice Director of the Ministry of Rites and restored as a Hanlin academician. When ordered to bring his mother back to court, Chongliang memorialized again citing her age and illness and pleading to retire for good to support her; the emperor's gracious reply refused. During Emperor Shizong's Gaoping campaign, Chongliang had not yet reported for duty; Tao Gu seized the moment and said, "Yu Chongliang is dragging his feet and never showing up—he is clearly wavering." The emperor grew quite suspicious of him. Chongliang submitted another memorial citing his mother's illness, and the emperor allowed him to retire to Shanzhou and care for her there. He never returned to office for the rest of Emperor Taizu's reign.
54
祿
When Emperor Taizong acceded, he was granted the titles Golden Purple-Glow Grandee of the Palace and Vice Director of the Ministry of War in honorific retirement. He died a little over a year later.
55
滿
Zhang Dan, styled Chenwen, came from a family originally of Nanyang that later settled in Henan. Dan loved learning from childhood and showed real literary gift. In the early Kaiyun era of Later Jin he earned his jinshi degree. Chief Minister Sang Weihan took a liking to him and married him to his daughter. He entered service as a proofreader and staff member of the Zhaowen Hall, rose to secretary, served as an investigating officer on the Salt and Iron Commission, held the posts of Left Reminder and Vice Director of the Ministry of Rites, and throughout also worked as a historiographer in the History Institute. He served as magistrate of Luoyang, and when his term expired he was made Vice Director of the Ministry of Personnel and again assigned to the History Institute. Early in the reign of Zhou's Gongdi he was made Right Division Vice Director and put in charge of drafting edicts.
56
殿 殿 使
In Jianlong 2 he was further promoted to Director of the Ministry of Sacrifices. Secretary Zhang Quhua then submitted a memorial claiming literary merit and asking to compete alongside Dan, Edict Drafter Lu Duosun of the Ministry of Sacrifices, and Palace Attendant Censor Shi Song so their relative talents could be judged. Taizu had them examined in the Hall of Martial Lectures; Dan's answers missed the point of the policy questions, and he was demoted to Left Division Vice Director. Soon afterward he was assigned as co-prefect of Taizhou and deputy commissioner of the Hailing salt works. After the conquest of Shu he served as co-prefect of Zizhou and was again made Director of the Ministry of Sacrifices.
57
使 殿 使
Early in the Kaibao era he was transferred on the spot to Director of the Ministry of Granaries. In the winter of the fourth year he resumed drafting edicts at his existing rank. In the sixth year, with Li Fang demoted and Lu Duosun dispatched to Jiangnan, the inner secretariat had no academician on duty; Taizu had Dan serve temporarily as head of the Hanlin Academy. At the Changchun festival in the seventh year he acted as Director of the Palace Receptions and presented the wine; the emperor then granted him golden-purple insignia. In the sixth month he was temporarily put in charge of inspecting Three Departments affairs. In less than ten days a carbuncle on his back brought him down; he was fifty-six. Learning he had no son, Taizu was deeply moved and ordered a palace envoy to supervise his burial in Luoyang.
58
Dan had an elegant bearing and a gift for conversation; in every post he took up he put affairs in order and left things well governed. After losing a literary contest to fellow drafters and being pushed back to routine bureau work, he was deeply discontented. Only in his later years, by currying favor with Lu Duosun, did he win promotion again.
59
使
During the Chunhua era, discussing men of letters, Emperor Taizong said, "Dan had been drafting imperial edicts, yet they tested him on policy questions—not his forte. Surely Tao Gu and Gao Xi rallied behind Zhang Quhua to block Dan's path. If Gu and his friends were tested out of the blue, would none of them miss the mark?"
60
西
Gao Xi, styled Tianfu, came from Yuxiang in Hezhong. His family had long been devoted to learning; bright from childhood, he could already write essays. During the Qianyou era of Later Han he sat for the jinshi examination. When Wang Yan governed Xuzhou he recruited Xi as his chief secretary; and when Wang held the western capital he also appointed Xi investigating officer of Henan Prefecture. He lost his post when a criminal case he handled proved unfounded; after being reassigned to Jing Prefecture he was able to return home when an amnesty was proclaimed. Early in the Xiande era, when Liu Chong raided the border, the chief minister urged sending a general against him; Emperor Shizong insisted on taking the field himself, won at Gaoping, and executed the failed generals Fan Aineng and others. From then on he decided every matter himself, great or small, and no longer held the regular offices accountable. Xi walked to the public suggestion box and submitted a memorial urging the appointment of worthy men and a proper division of duties among offices; it went unanswered. Shizong once ordered Hanlin academicians and Secretariat officials to compose lyrics for variety players, have them rehearsed at the Court Entertainment Office, and perform them at his banquets and outings. Xi submitted another memorial in protest. He later served as investigating officer on the defense staff of Cai Prefecture.
61
Early in the Song he quit his post and returned to the capital, placed another memorial in the suggestion box calling for a ban on private arms, and again received no answer. In Jianlong 5 he wrote to Chief Minister Fan Zhi, who recommended him for the post of Assistant Archivist. The following spring he was promoted to investigating censor. That autumn he was made Left Reminder and edict drafter, with the additional title of Vice Director of the Ministry of Agriculture.
62
使
Early in the Qiande era he was granted the privilege of crimson robes. When the future Emperor Taizong governed the capital, Shi Xizai served on his staff; Xi's younger brother Xian took the jinshi examination and importuned Xizai, hoping to be ranked first among recommendees. Xian's writing was plainly weak, and Xizai refused; Xi nursed a deep grudge and repeatedly told the emperor that Xizai's fawning praise was shameless. The emperor reported all of this to the Prince of Zhao and added, "I will find someone else to replace him for you." The prince replied, "Xizai has been diligent in his post. I hear Gao Xi once tried to get his brother recommended and Xizai turned him down—I worry he is being set up by Xi." The emperor saw the truth at once. Though he was furious with Xi, he had no immediate grounds to move against him. When sent on a mission to Qingzhou he secretly accepted gifts from Military Commissioner Guo Chong; he also once wrote the prefect of Lizhou on behalf of a monk seeking purple robes, and someone denounced him. The censorate investigated and confirmed the charges, and he was demoted to military adjutant of Laizhou. After a general amnesty he was reassigned as vice prefect of Junzhou and later transferred to Chenzhou. He died in the eighth year of the Taiping Xingguo era.
63
His nephew Mián.
64
His nephew Mián.
65
簿
Mián, styled Zizhuang, went to court during the Xiande era with a memorial that pleased the emperor, and was raised straight to Remonstrance and Advice Grandee. Chief Minister Fan Zhi thought the promotion too steep; the emperor instead made him an Entry-Level Gentleman acting as Right Supplementation Reminder, with extra gifts. Early in the Song he rose from vice director of the ministries of food and justice to director of the ministry of food, then was sent out to govern Yizhou. He died in Yongxi 2 at the age of fifty. He was posthumously given the title Right Remonstrance and Advice Grandee, and his son Chuixiu was enrolled as magistrate of Gushi.
66
The historians comment: Since Tang times, Hanlin academicians on duty and Secretariat drafters had jointly handled imperial pronouncements—celebrating merit, proclaiming virtue, and rebuking failings. These were not posts confined to literary ornament alone. Under the Song as well, literary talent was still sought for these posts; Gu's sharp brilliance, Zhe's quick mind, Dan's administrative record, Xi's policy counsel, and Mián's steady character all had something to commend them. Yet those who had drafted the edicts facilitating the dynastic transition were viewed coldly by their emperors and never won high trust again. Treachery and jealousy of one's betters, dissipation without restraint, clinging to power for advancement, and weaving slander for personal gain—all of this deserves no respect. Hu Meng was learned, generous, and long-suffering; after Dou Yi he helped set the court's ritual code. Yet in the debate over the southern suburban sacrifice he urged replacing Emperor Taizu with Emperor Xuan as Heaven's consort—a proposal wise men rejected. Yang Zhaojian spoke boldly against arrogant power and meant to bring down overbearing generals, but his ceaseless invective earned him a foul reputation. Was he, perhaps, one of those who mistake hostility for honesty? Yu Chongliang was utterly devoted to his mother, yet was slandered for his trouble, retired for good to care for her, and never served again. When the court later honored him posthumously, it heartened every man who would do right. Wang You staked his family's lives on vouching that Fu Yanqing had no treasonous intent and warned that rulers who slaughter the innocent out of suspicion do not long keep the throne—thereby easing the future Emperor Taizong's doubts. He also blocked Lu Duosun's move against Zhao Pu and was demoted for it. The virtuous are rewarded in their heirs; little wonder that his son Dan became one of the great ministers of the Song.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →