← Back to 宋史

卷三百一十 列傳第六十九 李迪 王曾 張知白 杜衍

Volume 310 Biographies 69: Li Di, Wang Ceng, Zhang Zhibai, Du Yan

Chapter 310 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 310
Next Chapter →
1
Li Di, whose style name was Fugu, came from Zhao Commandery by ancestry; his family later relocated to Youzhou. His great-grandfather Zaiqin fled the turmoil of the Five Dynasties period and resettled the family in Pu. Di was grave and far-sighted. He once presented his writings to Liu Kai, who was struck by them and declared, "Here is a man fit to serve as chief minister."
2
使
Having topped the jinshi rolls, he was made Vice Director of the Directorate of Palace Buildings and later served as vice-prefect of Xu and Yan. He was reassigned as a compiler in the Secretariat and drafter in the Historiography Institute, and appointed Salt and Iron Commissioner of the Three Bureaus. During the eastern Fengshan pilgrimage he again served as vice-prefect of Yan, but was demoted to oversee Haizhou's maritime tax after improperly releasing candidates in a Kaifeng prefectural examination. Promoted to Right Remonstrance Official and then prefect of Yanzhou, he was charged with inspecting capital prisons, made Attendant of Daily Affairs, and sent to pacify the Jiang-Huai region. As Vice Minister of Personnel he became Vice Commissioner of Salt and Iron and was raised to Drafter of Imperial Edicts.
3
殿 西使
When Zhenzong toured Bo, Di served as the regent's administrative aide and was subsequently appointed prefect of Bozhou. Bands of deserters were raiding towns, and though troops were dispatched to hunt them down, the pursuit dragged on without success. On arriving, Di disbanded the troops already in the field, quietly traced the bandits' haunts, led picked fighters against them, seized the ringleaders, and had them beheaded as a public warning. After his tour of duty he was recalled just as Gusiluo rose in revolt. Anxious about Guanzhong, the emperor summoned him to the Changchun Hall and made him Right Remonstrance Grandee, an academician of the Hall of Assembled Worthies, and military commissioner of Yongxing. The city teemed with lawless youths, and Di had the worst of them arrested and sent under guard to the capital. He was moved to head transport in Shaanxi, then recalled to the capital as a Hanlin Academician.
4
使
Once, while home on leave, he was abruptly summoned to the Inner Eastern Gate, where the emperor showed him the annual revenue and expenditure report that Ma Yuanfang of the Three Bureaus had submitted. After years of locusts and drought the emperor asked how to ease the crisis. Di urged drawing on the inner treasury to shore up state finances so that taxes could be lightened and the people spared further hardship. The emperor said, "I plan to replace Yuanfang with Li Shiheng. When he arrives I will release several million in gold and silk to lend the Three Bureaus." Di replied, "The sovereign's wealth knows no inner or outer court. Grant the funds by edict as a mark of grace—why call it a loan?" The emperor was pleased. He went on, "On the eastern Fengshan tour Your Majesty forbade felling trees or clearing roads along the route; post stations and prefectural seats served as temporary palaces with no more than a coat of whitewash. Yet on the tours to Fen and Bo, construction costs ran nearly a hundred times higher. Surely the locusts and drought are Heaven's warning to Your Majesty." The emperor was deeply persuaded.
5
西調 使
On another day Di was summoned to the Dragon Diagram Hall to draft an edict. The emperor said slowly, "Cao Wei at Qinzhou has repeatedly asked for reinforcements. Before any could be sent he abruptly resigned his post—he is simply afraid. Who can replace him?" Di answered, "Wei knows Gusiluo means to raid and is eyeing Guanzhong, so he sought more troops as a precaution—that is not cowardice. Besides, none of the generals match his strategic gifts—who could replace him? If Your Majesty is reluctant to dispatch more troops, is it not because you are about to assume the Jade Emperor's sacred title and wish to avoid armies marching out the Yiqiu Gate? There are ample troops in the west—detach a portion for Wei." The emperor asked how many troops stood in the west. Di said, "When I served in Shaanxi I kept troop and grain tallies in a pocket notebook for ready reference, and I still carry it." The emperor bade him produce it, had attendants bring paper and brush, and Di listed how many men to leave at each post and sent the rest to the frontier. The emperor exclaimed, "Truly we have our Lian Po and Li Mu right here in the palace." Before long Gusiluo did raid the frontier. Just as Qinzhou's troops marched out, Di was summoned again. "Will Wei prevail?" the emperor asked." He will win," Di replied. Within days the report came: Wei had routed the enemy at Sandu Valley. The emperor asked, "How did you know he would win?" Di said, "Gusiluo's men had marched far. His spies spread word that on a set day they would descend on Qinzhou to feast, hoping to goad Wei into rash action. Wei held his army still and waited for them to come—meeting their fatigue with his rested troops. That is how I knew he would prevail." The emperor esteemed him still more and from then on meant to give him major responsibilities.
6
殿 使殿
When the emperor was preparing to elevate Empress Zhangxian, Di repeatedly remonstrated, arguing that a woman of such humble birth could not be empress mother of the realm. Zhangxian never forgave him. During the Tianxi reign he was made Attendant Gentleman and Participant in Deliberations on Government Affairs. After Zhou Huaizheng's execution the emperor was furious and inclined to implicate the crown prince, but none of the ministers dared speak up. Di said calmly, "How many sons does Your Majesty have? —and yet you would contemplate such a course?" The emperor came to his senses and punished only Huaizheng and his circle. When Renzong was crown prince, Di was named Grand Preceptor but declined, noting that Taizong had never appointed guardian-tutors, and accepted only the concurrent post of Guest of the Heir Apparent. An edict directed the prince to honor his Guest as he would a tutor. He was further promoted to Vice Minister of Rites. After Kou Zhun's dismissal the emperor wished to make Di chief minister, but Di firmly refused. One day at an audience in the Zifu Hall the crown prince appeared, bowed, and said, "Your Majesty has elevated my Guest to chief minister—I thank you on his behalf." The emperor turned to Di and said, "Can you still refuse?" Di was appointed Vice Minister of Personnel, Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent, Grand Councilor, Commissioner of the Jingling Palace, and Grand Academician of the Hall of Assembled Worthies.
7
便 使 殿 使
When Zhenzong fell ill, Kou Zhun proposed putting the crown prince in charge of state and military affairs. Di backed the plan, but Ding Wei objected: "If the emperor recovers tomorrow, how will the court undo this?" Di replied, "A crown prince overseeing the realm—is that not ancient precedent?" He pressed the point relentlessly. The crown prince thereafter heard routine business in the Hall of Cultivating Goodness; everything else awaited the emperor's word. After Zhun's fall, Ding Wei gradually monopolized power, even appointing officials without informing the court. Di said angrily to his colleagues, "I rose from commoner to chief minister to serve the state. I would die without regret—how could I cling to the powerful for my own safety?" From then on they were at odds. A proposal then circulated to promote both chief councils and give them Eastern Palace posts. Di opposed it. Ding Wei also sought to install Lin Te as Vice Commissioner of Military Affairs while moving Di to Vice Director of the Secretariat with concurrent Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. By precedent no chief minister had ever served as Left Vice Director. Soon the emperor held court at the Changchun Hall, laid out appointment documents, and told the chief ministers, "These appoint you to concurrent Eastern Palace offices." Di stepped forward. "Eastern Palace staff should not be expanded, and I dare not accept this commission. Chief Minister Ding Wei deceives the throne and abuses power, favoring Lin Te and Qian Weiyan while persecuting Kou Zhun. Te's son committed murder yet the case was buried. Zhun was banished though innocent. Weiyan, a relation by marriage, was allowed into government. Cao Liyong and Feng Zheng form a clique together. I ask to be dismissed together with Wei and handed to the Censorate for investigation." The emperor was furious, withheld the appointments, and demoted Di to Vice Minister of Revenue. Ding Wei gained another audience, had an oral edict read restoring Di to the Secretariat, then sent him out as prefect of Yanzhou.
8
使 使 殿 殿
When Renzong ascended the throne the empress dowager ruled from behind the screen. Zhun was banished to Leizhou; Di was accused of factional collusion and demoted to Vice Military Training Commissioner of Hengzhou. Ding Wei sent men to hound him. Someone hinted, "If Di dies in exile, what will scholars say of you?" Ding Wei replied, "Future scholars will only write that the realm lamented him—that is all." After Ding Wei's fall Di was recalled as Director of the Secretariat and prefect of Shuzhou, later served at Jiangning, Yan, and Qing, and was again made Vice Minister of War and prefect of Henan. On a visit to the capital, with the empress dowager still behind the screen, she told Di, "You once opposed my participation in government—perhaps you went too far. Today I have raised the Son of Heaven to this point—what do you think of that?" Di answered, "I owed deep gratitude to the late emperor. Today I see a bright and sagely sovereign—I did not know the empress dowager's virtue extended so far." The empress dowager was pleased as well. As Left Vice Director he was made military commissioner of Heyang, then promoted to Minister of Works. After the empress dowager's death he was summoned as Academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance with charge of the overall Department of State Affairs. Before long he was again appointed Grand Councilor and Grand Academician of the Hall of Assembled Worthies.
9
殿 殿
During the Jingyou era Fan Feng fell afoul of the court. Di was implicated through marriage ties, dismissed to Minister of Justice and prefect of Bozhou, then transferred to Xiangzhou. He was then made Grand Academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance and Hanlin Attendant Reader and kept at the capital. Di had long disliked Lü Yijian and accused him of private dealings with Prince Jing Yuan Yan, including once securing an appointment for the monk Huiqing as Awaiting-Appointment Regulator of Credentials. Yijian demanded an inquiry. The investigation showed the act had been Di's own doing while in the Secretariat; Yijian had been absent for ritual fasting. He was demoted to Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and prefect of Mizhou. He was restored as Minister of Justice and prefect of Xuzhou. Di noted that his jurisdiction bordered Yanzhou and asked to tour the counties, offering prayers at the sacred mountain for a good harvest and a royal heir on the emperor's behalf. Renzong told his ministers, "Great ministers should investigate the people's hardships. Prayer rites are not Di's proper role—do not let him go." After some time he was made Minister of Revenue and prefect of Yanzhou, and again appointed Grand Academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance.
10
使 使
When Yuan Hao attacked Yanzhou, military readiness had long lapsed, and some frontier commanders even assumed other names to evade service. Di volunteered for frontier duty. The court refused, but the emperor greatly admired his spirit. He was made Military Commissioner of the Zhangxin Army with charge of Tianxiong, then transferred to Qingzhou. After a year he returned to his original command. He requested retirement, left office as Grand Preceptor of the Heir Apparent, and returned to Puzhou. Later his son Jianzhi, serving as Attendant Censor in charge of miscellaneous affairs, brought him to the capital. The emperor repeatedly sent envoys to inquire after him and wished to summon him, but he declined on grounds of illness. He died at the age of seventy-seven. He was posthumously honored as Minister of Works and Palace Attendant, with the posthumous name Wending. The emperor inscribed his tomb stele "Stele of the Upright Legacy" and renamed the Deng Marquis township where he was buried the Township of the Upright Legacy. His sons were Jianzhi, Suzhi, Chengzhi, and Jizhi. His grandsons were Xiaoshou, Xiaoji, and Xiaocheng.
11
Son: Jianzhi
12
使 西使
Jianzhi, whose style name was Gongming, was thoroughly versed in the precedents of the dynasty. After presenting his writings and passing a palace examination, he was granted jinshi status and appointed collator in the Hall of Literature and commissioner of the Xuanhua Army. An abandoned riverbed crossed his jurisdiction, and officials levied a "Dry Crossing Fee" on travelers. He memorialized to abolish the tax. He rose to drafter in the Hall of Assembled Worthies, held posts in the Ministry of Personnel, Kaifeng, and the Salt and Iron Commission, governed several prefectures, headed transport in Jingdong and Shaanxi, and was elevated to Attendant Censor in charge of miscellaneous affairs.
13
使 西
Jianzhi had known Kou Zhun since youth and now spoke of Zhun's service in protecting the throne. Moved, Renzong immediately granted him a stele inscribed "Commemorating Loyalty." He was made Attendant Drafter of the Tianzhang Pavilion and Director-General of Transport for Hebei, with the additional title of Academician of the Dragon Diagram Hall. He argued that hereditary privilege had grown too broad. The court issued limits, and within three years a thousand fewer people entered office from the chief councils down. He governed Jingnan, Heyang, and Chan, became Academician of the Hall of Assembled Worthies, and took charge of the Western Capital Censorate.
14
退 使
When Yingzong ascended the throne, Fu Bi recommended his scholarship and character. He was restored to office and made Attendant Reader. The emperor told him, "You are a seasoned elder of broad counsel. I seek your advice to remedy my shortcomings—not merely for classical learning." The emperor wished to tighten discipline in the palace. Jianzhi urged, "Your Majesty is the elder sovereign, raised from a collateral house. The court is watching—please show forbearance." When birthday gifts were sent to Prince Ying, precedent required that he bow in thanks and withdraw at once. The emperor told the prince to keep Jianzhi for a meal, hoping for an unhurried conversation. Soon after the prince became emperor, Jianzhi requested retirement and left office as Junior Preceptor of the Heir Apparent, having served as Minister of Works. No Gate protocol existed for farewell audiences. He was granted a special audience in the Yanhe Hall, seated, and entertained at the Hall of Cultivating Goodness. An envoy explained, "With the late emperor's coffin still in mourning, I cannot compose a poem myself." He had the lecture officials compose poems instead. The honors were lavish, and he ordered Wang Gui to record the occasion. Beyond the capital gate he received guests in plain headcloth and white robes. He was again promoted to Junior Preceptor. He died in the sixth year of Xining at the age of seventy-eight.
15
祿
There was also Li Shou, style name Yizhi, a native of Liuyang in Changsha. He served during the Zhiping era, rising to Right Remonstrance Grandee, Attendant Drafter of the Tianzhang Pavilion, and Attendant Reader. He repeatedly asked to retire on account of age, but the court refused. When Shenzong ascended the throne, he was promoted to Attendant Gentleman and Academician of the Dragon Diagram Hall. He said again, "Under the late emperor I was already seventy and dared not cling to salary for comfort. Now several more years have passed and my strength is gone—may Your Majesty show pity." He was then made Vice Minister of Justice and retired with the same banquet, poems, and preface granted to Jianzhi. Their retirements were only months apart, so contemporaries called them "the Two Lis." He died at eighty and was posthumously honored as Minister of Works.
16
Nephew: Suzhi
17
使滿
Suzhi, whose style name was Gongyi, was Di's nephew. Through Di's hereditary privilege he supervised the military supply depot of Daming Prefecture. When the Yellow River overflowed, the prefecture ordered repairs to the Guanshi dike. He finished the work without troubling the people, who were so pleased they asked that he be made magistrate. The district had many bandits who preyed on the people. Suzhi ordered every household to keep a drum. At the first sign of bandits, drums sounded and neighbors responded from near and far, and banditry dwindled away. He served as transport escort commissioner on the Imperial Canal. When the Henglong breach opened, he was ordered to guard the Golden Dike and kept the river in check for a full year.
18
使 使 使使使
He served as vice-prefect of Chanzhou. Khitan envoys were about to pass through, but the walls were in ruins. Suzhi told the prefect, "This is where Jingde defeated the Khitan—we must show strength. With our defenses like this, what will they think?" He gathered workers and rebuilt a thousand sections of wall and towers. When a palace eunuch came to inspect, he found everything restored and reported his amazement to court. He was promoted to prefect of Dezhou, made intendant of Kaifeng's subordinate counties and towns, and put in charge of criminal cases in Kuizhou and Hunan. When the Nong tribes rose beyond the ranges, Suzhi defended the borders in person. After Jiang Xie's defeat he swiftly pursued the rebels to Linhe and drove them off. Di Qing and Sun Mian jointly recommended him, and he was made transport commissioner of Hubei. He suppressed Peng Shiyi's rebellion in Chenyang but was still demoted for faults and made prefect of Qizhou. He served as transport commissioner in Jiangdong, the two Zhe circuits, and Hebei, then became Vice Commissioner of the Department of State Finance and dispatch commissioner for the Jiang-Huai region.
19
Suzhi was disciplined in private life. After his mother's death he mourned at her tomb for three years without entering any town. His younger brother Chengzhi was orphaned at birth; he raised and taught him to adulthood, and both eventually served at court. The emperor praised their household for loyalty and filial piety.
20
Nephew: Chengzhi
21
調
Chengzhi, whose style name was Fengshi, was grave in character and known for loyalty and integrity. His cousin Jianzhi offered him an official post, but he declined, passed the jinshi examination, and was appointed judicial aide in Mingzhou. The prefect bent the law at will, and no one dared oppose him—only Chengzhi stood firm and argued back. The prefect snapped, "How dare a judicial aide behave like this?" Chengzhi replied, "If Your Excellency handles a matter yourself, that is one thing. Once it is referred to the courts, the law must be followed." The prefect was silenced.
22
He once drafted a proposal on corvée exemption, which Wang Anshi praised. Early in the Xining reforms he was made textual reviewer in the Regulations Office and summoned to audience. Shenzong told the chief ministers, "Chengzhi's grasp of fiscal affairs is unrivaled." He was promoted to capital official rank. Another day the emperor told him, "Since my accession I have rarely changed anyone's rank. This is a special honor."
23
西 殿使使
He rectified the Secretariat's Criminal Section, investigated ever-normal granaries, waterworks, and corvée service in Huai and Zhe, submitted twenty chapters of the Corvée Book, and was made Collator in the Hall of Assembled Worthies. He also investigated Shaanxi, where prefectures and counties were collecting surpluses beyond what the law allowed. Chengzhi asked, "Is this what the court intends?" He corrected all the figures. He became Compiler in the Hall of Assembled Worthies, Attendant Drafter of the Baowen Pavilion, Associate Commissioner of the Pasturage Office, and investigator of capital criminal cases while also serving as Chief Secretariat Receiver of the Bureau of Military Affairs. He governed Yanzhou, then returned as acting Commissioner of the Three Bureaus.
24
使
Cai Que handled the Xiangzhou case and implicated many court officials, who all submitted to his power. Chengzhi described Cai's treacherous methods to the emperor, who came to his senses and ordered the case pursued to its conclusion. He was made Academician of the Dragon Diagram Hall but earnestly declined, asking that the post go to his elder brother Suzhi: "I was raised by my brother from childhood, and he has been an attendant drafter for ten years." The emperor said, "Your brotherly devotion is an example to the realm. Suzhi should be promoted as well." Both were promoted at once.
25
西使
A merchant violated the ban on northern pearls by selling them for a princess, and the Three Bureaus long dared not decide the case. Chengzhi said, "Should the law fear an imperial princess?" He ordered the goods seized at once. When the emperor heard of it he said, "This is how officials ought to act." He was promoted to Academician of the Bureau of Military Affairs. After improper clerk appointments he was demoted to attendant drafter and made prefect of Ruzhou. Soon he headed transport in Shaanxi, was recalled as Attendant Gentleman, Vice Minister of Personnel, and Minister of Revenue, and again made Academician of the Bureau of Military Affairs and prefect of Qingzhou. He served at Yingtian, Heyang, Chen, Yan, and Yang prefectures and then died.
26
Nephew: Jizhi
27
Jizhi, whose style name was Gongda, was likewise a son of Di's younger brother. Through hereditary privilege he entered office and served as vice-commissioner of the Ansu Army. During the Kangding era the Tangut raided the frontier and the Khitan again massed troops along the border, putting the frontier on alert. Jizhi said, "The Khitan are bound to the Tangut by marriage ties and are merely showing support while feigning strength to unsettle us. They will not break the alliance—please do not overreact." Events soon proved him right.
28
使
He was transferred as vice-prefect of Henan Prefecture. The deserter Zhang Hai gathered a band in the hills and raided cities in broad daylight. Jizhi led the pursuit, rode alone to parley with Hai, and promised to seek clemency if he surrendered. Moved, Hai let down his guard. Before the memorial reached court, troops converged and captured the entire band. As prefect of Xinzhou he cracked down on lawless monks at Mount Lingjiu, banishing dozens, then impeached himself. The court praised him and took no action against him. He entered the capital to judge cases in the Ministry of Justice. He compiled passages from Tang history useful to governance into the eighty-chapter Mirror for Ruler and Minister. Wang Yaochan presented the book and praised his scholarship; Han Qi also recommended him for a post in the Hall of Literature. Summoned for examination, he was appointed to the Direct Secretariat Pavilion and served as judge of Kaifeng and prefect of Jing, Jin, and Shan.
29
Jizhi was sharp in administrative affairs and fulfilled every post competently. He retired with the rank of Grandee of Palace Administration and was later promoted to Right Grandee of Discussion. He died at the age of eighty-five. Jianzhi's son was Xiaoji; Jizhi's sons were Xiaoshou and Xiaocheng.
30
Grandson Xiaoji
31
Xiaoji, style name Boshi. He ranked at the top of the jinshi examination and was called by name before the hall steps. Emperor Renzong turned to his ministers and said, "Is this Li Di's grandson? He can carry on the family tradition—worthy of esteem." Yan Shu and Fu Bi recommended his talents for a post in the Hall of Literature and wished to meet him. Xiaoji said, "Can rank and office be sought through private visits? In the end he did not go.
32
西 祿
He served as magistrate of Ruyin and Yongqiu counties, vice-prefect of Lang and Shu, and prefect of Sui. Though his jurisdictions were demanding, he decided cases quickly without letting evidence be twisted; by mid-morning his courtroom was empty. When asked his secret, he said, "Nothing else—just cutting red tape." In Lang, the river nearly eroded the city wall away. Most officials fled, but Xiaoji led his men to divert the water into side channels and saved the city. A Shu official took bribes and framed a commoner for murder. Xiaoji investigated for three days, uncovered the truth, and punished the official. To care for his parents, he sought a post supervising Chongfu Palace and served as vice-director of the Western Capital Directorate of Education. He spent ten years in honorary posts, rose to Grandee of Splendid Happiness, and retired with his father Jianzhi at only fifty—scholar-officials praised them, comparing them to the Two Shus.
33
Xiaoji was unassuming and skilled at nurturing health; in daily life he lived lightly and at ease. His younger brother Xiaocheng entered audience. The emperor asked after Xiaoji's health and sighed, "He far surpasses ordinary men." Eleven years later he died without illness.
34
Grandson Xiaoshou
35
使 使
Previously, local ruffians mutilated their own limbs, feigned disability to bully upright citizens, and feared no one. Xiaoshou rooted them all out, sent them to neighboring prefectures, and cleaned up the problem entirely. Made Academician Expositor, he served as prefect of Xingren and Kaide. Cai Jing launched the Zhang Yan case in Suzhou and recalled Xiaoshou from Kaifeng to investigate at once. In Suzhou he ruthlessly prosecuted counterfeiting, arresting more than a thousand. In the harsh winter prisoners were tortured mercilessly; countless lost fingers and toes to frostbite, and the dead were cast outside the walls. He tortured prisoners day and night for confessions, but Cai Jing still found him too slow and recalled him. The Yan brothers were ultimately tattooed and banished on the basis of this case. He also served as prefect of Guo and Yan. While prefect of Xingren he spent his days target-shooting with an inspector; when a madman named Zhang Li was killed, Xiaoshou was stripped of office. Before long he was restored and made prefect of Suzhou.
36
使
At the start of the Zhenghe era he was appointed Vice Minister of Justice and again made Prefect of Kaifeng. Lu Shou, a clerk of the Imperial Attendant Storehouse, stole gold, was imprisoned, and escaped. Xiaoshou arrested every guard, charging deliberate negligence; even officials off duty and guards not on watch were punished for failing to pursue the fugitive immediately. Forty were sentenced to penal servitude; bribes secretly ensured heavier beatings, and six or seven died just after leaving the city. On hearing this, the emperor ordered the rest returned. Remonstrance Official Mao Zhu denounced his cruelty and sought punishment, but the emperor ignored the request. Xiaoshou still submitted a congratulatory memorial celebrating empty prisons.
37
忿 仿
Though Xiaoshou was often disgraceful, at times he showed something commendable. An examination candidate was bullied by his servant and prepared a petition to the prefectural office in fury; fellow lodgers persuaded him to relent only after a long while. In jest he took the petition and forged Xiaoshou's florid signature with a judgment: "Without examining the case—twenty strokes of the rod." The next day the servant brought it to the prefectural office, accusing his master of forging the prefect's judgment and privately inflicting punishment. Xiaoshou had him summoned at once. After hearing the full story, Xiaoshou declared, "The judgment exactly matches my intent." He gave the servant the full number of strokes and apologized to the candidate. At the time, among thousands in the capital not a single servant dared act outrageously, and people praised him for it. The next year, citing illness, he was dismissed and made Academician of the Dragon Diagram Hall with charge of Liquan Abbey. He died and was posthumously given the rank of Right Grandee of Submission.
38
Grandson Xiaocheng
39
Xiaocheng, style name Yanwen, entered court through hereditary privilege. During a suburban sacrifice amnesty that permitted ennobling one's father, Jizhi already held the rank of Grandee of Discussion. Officials blocked it on regulatory grounds, but Xiaocheng argued this thwarted the court's intent to honor the aged. The emperor granted an exception, and it became permanent law.
40
西西 使
During the Chongning era he oversaw the Hubei and Jingxi Ever-Normal Granaries and served as intendant of criminal cases on the Southwest Jing Circuit. Song Qiaonian, Cai Jing's relation by marriage and transport commissioner of the Capital Region, recaptured an escaped prisoner. Xiaocheng reported the achievement; Qiaonian was rewarded, and Xiaocheng thereby obtained the post of Outer Section Member of the Ministry of Works. In less than a month he was transferred to Vice Director of the Court of Judicial Review. He repeatedly reported empty prisons, rose to director, received several rank increases, was elevated to Vice Minister of Works and Vice Minister of Revenue, and made Prefect of Kaifeng.
41
使 祿
Chen Guan's son Zhenghui submitted a memorial from Hangzhou accusing Cai Jing of harming the state. Prefect Cai Ni arrested Zhenghui and sent him to the capital; Chen Guan was also seized and imprisoned. Xiaocheng coerced Chen Guan to testify against his son, but he refused. When the case was finalized, Zhenghui was banished to an island at sea. Cai Jing was all the more grateful and promoted him to Minister of Justice, appointing his elder brother Xiaoshou to replace him as prefect. Xiaocheng asked to rank below his elder brother but was refused. To avoid conflict of interest with a relative, he was transferred to the Ministry of Works. He died and was posthumously given the rank of Grandee of Splendid Happiness.
42
Wang Zeng, style name Xiaoxian, was a native of Yidu in Qingzhou. Orphaned young, he was raised by his uncle Zongyuan and studied under the local scholar Zhang Zhen, excelling in literary composition. During the Xianping era he ranked first in both the Ministry of Rites examination and the palace audience after passing the provincial tribute. Yang Yi read his rhapsody and sighed, "Material for a king's minister." He was appointed Vice Director of the Directorate of Palace Buildings and vice-prefect of Ji. When his term ended, he was to be examined at the Academy of Letters. Chief Councillor Kou Zhun was impressed and had him examined in the Council Chamber, appointing him Compiler in the Secretariat, Keeper of the Historiography Institute, and Section Chief of the Three Bureaus Ministry of Revenue.
43
使 使 輿 殿退使
When peace was first established with the Khitan in the Jingde era, annual envoys addressed letters calling the Song the Southern Court and the Khitan the Northern Court. Zeng said, "It is enough to use their state name." Envoys had already been dispatched, and the wording was not changed. He was promoted to Right Remonstrance Official, Drafter of Imperial Edicts, and concurrently Compiler of the Historiography Institute. As auspicious omens multiplied, Zeng once addressed the emperor, who spoke of them. Zeng said, "This reflects the nation's peace, yet I hope Your Majesty will accept the blessing without claiming credit—if disaster comes later, you will avoid public blame." After the emperor received the Heavenly mandate and undertook the grand construction of the Jade Pure Temple of Corresponding Response, none dared object. Zeng listed five harms in remonstrance. The Court of Judicial Review had formerly been overseen by a Langzhong official; the emperor wished to elevate the post and specially appointed Zeng. He also said to Zeng, "Prisons are a weighty institution—today I must demean you." Zeng bowed his head in thanks. He was also granted three hundred thousand cash and received permission to appoint his own staff—a rule thereafter written into law. He was promoted to Hanlin Academician. One evening the emperor sat late in Chengmeng Hall and held a long audience with Zeng. After Zeng withdrew, a palace attendant conveyed the emperor's words: "I had you much in mind and did not wait to don court robes—please do not think me discourteous." Such was the honor and courtesy shown him.
44
He served as director of the Office of Criminal Review. Formerly, violating regulations without explicit authorization was uniformly punished by two years of penal servitude. Zeng argued punishment should apply only when one had personally received an imperial order. When a violation occurred, Zeng classified it as negligent error rather than deliberate breach. The emperor said, "By your reasoning, there would never again be violators of regulations." Zeng said, "The realm is vast—can every man fully understand the regulations? By Your Majesty's reasoning, there would also never again be offenders through error." The emperor understood and in the end adopted Zeng's proposal. He was again promoted to Langzhong of the Ministry of Rites Guest Section. He directed the Office of Merit Evaluation, the Memorial Clearance and Silver Terrace Office, and the Office of the Three Ranks, then became Right Remonstrance Grandee and Vice Grand Councillor.
45
使 使
At the time palace abbeys were all headed by chief ministers as commissioners. Wang Qinruo was exploiting portents to flatter the emperor and secretly sought to purge rivals. Zeng was due to head the Abbey of Congregated Spirits but yielded the post to Qinruo; the emperor began to suspect Zeng of dissent. When Qinruo became chief councillor, Zeng bought Empress He's former residence while her family still occupied it and had earth piled at their gate. The He family complained to the palace. The next day the emperor told Qinruo; Zeng was removed as Vice Minister of Rites and director of the Department of State Affairs and sent out as prefect of Yingtian. During the Tianxi era rumor spread of a demon like a flying cap that seized people at night; from the capital southward the populace was terrified. Zeng ordered neighborhood gates kept open at night and had rumor-mongers arrested; in the end no demon appeared. He was transferred to Tianxiong Army, again became Vice Grand Councillor, and was promoted to Vice Minister of Personnel and Mentor to the Heir Apparent.
46
殿
When Emperor Zhenzong fell ill, the empress effectively governed from within the palace. Though the crown prince held audiences at the Hall of Cultivating Virtue, the empress decided all affairs—a source of worry throughout the court. Qian Weiyan was a relative of the empress. Zeng secretly told Weiyan, "The crown prince is young; without the palace he cannot be established. If favors are granted the crown prince, the crown prince will be secure; if the crown prince is secure, the Liu family will be secure as well." Weiyan agreed and reported it to the empress. When the emperor died, Zeng was ordered into the mourning hall to draft the final edict: "Let Empress Mingsu assist in establishing the crown prince and provisionally decide the great affairs of state and military." Ding Wei entered and struck the word "provisionally." Zeng said, "The emperor is still a child and the empress dowager already holds court—surely this is the realm's ill fortune. Retaining the word "provisionally" would still be enough to instruct posterity. Moreover, altering imperial edicts is governed by law—this is the very place that sets the standard; do you wish to throw protocol into disorder?" Ding Wei then did not dare remove it. When Emperor Renzong ascended, Zeng was made Minister of Rites. When officials debated regency protocol, Zeng urged following Eastern Han precedent: the empress dowager would sit to the emperor's right behind a screen to hear affairs. Ding Wei alone wanted the emperor to receive officials on the first and fifteenth of each month; major matters would be decided when the empress dowager summoned chief ministers, while lesser affairs would be relayed within the palace by Lei Yonggong, Inner Attendant Ban Officer, with minor matters handled at lower levels. Zeng said, "With the two palaces apart and power in eunuch hands, disaster is already foreshadowed." Ding Wei would not heed him. Before long Yonggong was executed for his crimes, and Ding Wei was punished as well. Thereafter both palaces heard affairs from behind the screen, with chief ministers reporting as Zeng had urged.
47
殿使 使 殿 西使
When Ding Wei first fell, Ren Zhongzheng said, "He received the late emperor's trust; though guilty, please weigh his merits according to law." Zeng said, "Ding Wei offended the imperial ancestors through disloyalty—what merits remain to discuss!" When Emperor Zhenzong had just died and the court was in turmoil, Zeng alone stood firm; the court leaned heavily on him. He was appointed Vice Minister of the Secretariat while retaining his current rank, Grand Councillor, Grand Academician of the Hall for Assembling Worthies, and Commissioner of the Abbey of Congregated Spirits. When Wang Qinruo died, Zeng became Grand Academician of the Hall of Glorious Literature, Supervisor of the National History, and Commissioner of the Palace of Jade Purity and Resonance with Heaven, while serving as Vice Minister of the Chancellery and Minister of Revenue. Believing the newly enthroned emperor should be close to scholar-teachers, Zeng immediately summoned Sun Shi and Feng Yuan to lecture at the Hall of Honoring Governance. In the summer of the fourth year of Tiansheng, heavy rains fueled rumors that the Bian River had breached and a great flood was coming; the people of the capital panicked and prepared to flee east. The emperor asked Zeng, who replied, "No report of a river breach has arrived—it is only rumor among the people and not worth concern." Events soon confirmed he was right. The Shaanxi transport commissioner set up a vinegar monopoly to seize its profits and sought to extend the scheme empire-wide; Zeng petitioned for its abolition.
48
退
Zeng was stern and dignified; whenever he entered audience he spoke on matters of public interest with careful, sound reasoning; he recommended and promoted many men and especially despised those who sought advancement through favor and luck. The emperor asked Zeng, "Lately when officials request audience, many are seeking promotion." Zeng replied, "If Your Majesty restrains eager rivalry and honors quiet integrity, perhaps there will be men slow to seek office and quick to retire." Cao Liyong resented that Zeng outranked him and was often displeased; the account appears in his biography. When Liyong was implicated in wrongdoing, the empress dowager was furious; Zeng pleaded on his behalf. The empress dowager said, "You once said Liyong was overbearing—why do you plead for him now?" Zeng said, "Liyong has long relied on imperial favor; I therefore sometimes rebutted him with reason. As for the grave crimes now charged against him, those were not known to me." The empress dowager's anger eased somewhat, and in the end a lighter sentence was adopted.
49
殿便殿 使使 使 使 殿
When the empress dowager first received her investiture and was about to hold court in the Hall of Great Peace, Zeng objected; for her Changning birthday celebration, only a side hall was prepared. Relatives of the empress dowager's attendants gradually gained access through petitions; Zeng frequently blocked them, and the empress dowager grew ever more displeased. When the Palace of Jade Purity and Resonance with Heaven burned, he was sent out as prefect of Qingzhou. As military commissioner of Zhangxin Army he again governed Tianxiong Army; when Khitan envoys passed through, they quieted their carriages and followers before proceeding—none dared cause a disturbance. The people rejoiced in his governance and painted his portrait, worshipping him while he still lived. He was transferred to military commissioner of Tianping Army, Grand Councillor, and administrator of Henan Prefecture. In the first year of Jingyou, he became Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs. The next year he was appointed Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and Vice Minister of the Chancellery, Grand Councillor, Grand Academician of the Hall for Assembling Worthies, and enfeoffed as Duke of Yi.
50
Zeng was upright and solid in character, with brows and eyes fine as a painting. At court his movements always followed fixed places; in daily life he spoke and laughed little, and no one dared approach him with private requests. In youth he served alongside Yang Yi among the emperor's attendants; Yi loved banter and familiarly mocked every colleague without exception. But when speaking with Zeng he would say, "I dare not treat it as jest." Throughout life he was very frugal. Once a friend's descendant named Jing came to bid farewell; Zeng kept him and served a meal. Afterward his clerk sent several scrolls of letter paper—all of it cut from the blank backs of other people's letters. During Huangyou, Emperor Renzong personally inscribed his stele in seal script with the words "Stele Honoring the Worthy," and later renamed his township Worthy Honor Township. The imperial bestowal of seal-script stele inscriptions upon grand ministers began with Zeng. After Emperor Renzong was enshrined in the ancestral temple, an edict selected generals and ministers for paired offerings; Zeng was ranked first. Zeng had no sons; his adopted son was named Zao. He also made his younger brother Zirong's son Yi his heir. Yi served as Langzhong in the Ministry of War and as collator in the Secret Archive, retired, and died.
51
Younger brother: Zirong
52
簿
Zirong, whose style name was Xizhong, At first, through Zeng's memorial, he was appointed principal clerk of the Directorate of Palace Buildings. Having passed the jinshi examination in the Xiangfu era, he rose to Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and Associate Director of the Ritual Institute. He presented his writings, was summoned for examination, and appointed to the Hall for Assembling Worthies. He once compiled the changes in ceremonial rites since the founding of the dynasty and presented the New Compilation of the Ritual Hall to the throne. His book was deposited in the Court of Imperial Sacrifices.
53
使
He served as acting Revenue and Salt and Iron Commissioner of the Three Bureaus. Ren Bu proposed casting large coins and circulating them in the capital. Three Bureaus Commissioner Cheng Lin assembled officials to discuss the proposal. Zirong said, "Half the garrisons are now outside the walls—can large coins circulate in the city alone?" The proposal was then dropped. He served as acting Co-Inspector of Criminal Cases and prefect of Heyang. He also collected events of the Five Dynasties into the sixty-chapter Records of Tang Remnants and presented it to the throne. Promoted to Direct Attendant of the Dragon Diagram Hall, he rose to Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and acting chief judge of the Court of Judicial Review. He then selected criminal cases whose severity could serve as standards, classified them, and compiled them as precedents for judgment.
54
He was appointed Attendant Drafting in the Hall of Heavenly Manifestations, Langzhong in the Ministry of Personnel, and prefect of Jingnan. The bandit Zhang Hai raided through Xiang and Deng and reached Jingmen. Zirong reviewed prefectural troops and prepared to meet and strike him; the bandits withdrew. Promoted to Right Remonstrance Grandee and prefect of Shaanzhou, he was later transferred to Hezhong Prefecture. He then managed the Office of the Three Ranks, was promoted to Supervising Secretariat Drafter, and as Vice Minister of the Ministry of Works and academician of the Hall for Assembling Worthies was appointed prefect of Yanzhou. He did not take up the post and was instead made Vice Minister of Justice and allowed to retire. When Emperor Yingzong ascended, he was promoted in the Ministry of War rank and died.
55
His original name was Hao; his style name was Zirong. When Yuan Hao rebelled, he requested to use his style name as his personal name. By nature he was frugal and stingy. When street sweeper soldiers clearing the road encroached on his lodge property by inches, he personally went to the Kaifeng prefectural office to lodge a complaint. Yet he instructed and disciplined his descendants with strict family rules. In later years he studied Buddhism and associated with the monk Huailian.
56
Zhang Zhibai
57
Zhang Zhibai, whose style name was Yonghui, was a native of Qingchi in Cangzhou. From youth he studied devotedly, passed the jinshi examination, and rose to administrative aide of the Heyang military commission. During Xianping he submitted a memorial on pressing affairs of the day; Emperor Zhenzong was impressed, summoned him for examination at the Drafting Academy, and made him acting Right Rectifier. He presented Admonition at the Phoenix Screen and was sent out as prefect of Jianzhou. After a year he was summoned for examination at the Secretariat, given concurrent appointment to the Historiography Institute, personally granted fifth-rank robes, and made administrator of the Three Bureaus Opening and Review Office.
58
使
When Jiangnan suffered drought, he and Li Fang were sent by separate routes as pacification commissioners. Upon his return he temporarily managed the affairs of the eastern capital transport commission. The star Zhoubo appeared; the Astronomy Office reported it as an auspicious sign, and officials prostrated themselves at the gate to offer congratulations. Zhibai held that a ruler should cultivate virtue in response to Heaven, while the appearance and disappearance of stars had no bearing; he therefore set forth the essentials of good governance. The emperor told the chief ministers, "Zhibai can truly be said to devote his heart to the court." During the eastern Fengshan rites he was promoted to Right Remonstrance Official of the Department of State Affairs. He further said, "During Xianping, when Hehuang was not yet pacified, I once requested that commanderies and prefectures cease submitting reports of auspicious portents. Now all under Heaven is at peace and numinous blessings arrive together. I hope The Various Portents of Mount Tai may be placed in the Palace of Jade Purity and Resonance with Heaven, with a duplicate stored in the Secret Archive."
59
西 使
When Shaanxi suffered famine, he was ordered to inspect and tour the region. Soon afterward he became prefect of Dengzhou. When migrant laborers from the west reached his jurisdiction, Zhibai opened granaries and solicited grain from the people to relieve them. He was elevated to Attendant Drafting in the Dragon Diagram Hall and director of the Office of Merit Evaluation, then promoted to Langzhong in the Ministry of Works and sent as envoy to the Khitan. Zhibai held that the court valued inner posts and slighted outer ones; citing Tang Li Jiao's proposal to transfer palace officials to frontier prefectures, he requested an outer appointment himself. When this was denied, he was ordered to inspect capital criminal cases, but he firmly pressed his request and was made prefect of Qingzhou. Returning to the capital, he requested to head the Directorate of Education. The emperor said, "Is Zhibai weary of handling difficult duties?" The chief ministers said, "Zhibai has served both at court and in the provinces and has never schemed for himself." Thereupon he was transferred to Right Remonstrance Grandee and acting Vice Censor-in-Chief, appointed Supervising Secretariat Drafter and Vice Grand Councillor.
60
滿 輿
While serving as chancellor, Zhibai was scrupulous in conferring titles and showed not the slightest private favoritism. He often warned himself against the dangers of peak success; though eminent and honored, he lived as frugally as a poor scholar. Yet he had always been frail in constitution, and worry and fear wore on him daily. While at the Secretariat he was suddenly struck with vertigo and was carried home by carriage. The emperor personally inquired after his illness, but he could no longer speak and soon died. The court canceled the Third Day of the Third Month banquet in his honor and posthumously granted him the titles of Grand Tutor and Director of the Secretariat. Ritual official Xie Jiang proposed the posthumous title "Cultured Restraint," but Censor Wang Jiayan argued, "Zhibai upheld the Way, served the public, and would not yield in office—he was truly upright. The title should be 'Cultured Uprightness.'" Wang Ceng said, "'Cultured Restraint' is already a fine posthumous title." The title was therefore left unchanged.
61
殿
When Zhibai was nine, his father died in Xingzhou and was temporarily interred in a Buddhist temple. When the Khitan invaded Hebei, many temples fell into ruin and the temporary burial could no longer be identified. After passing the examination, Zhibai went on foot to search for the spot, found the foundation of the temple hall, and suddenly recognized the place. When the grave was opened, the clothing and shroud were all intact, and all marveled at his sincere filial devotion. Once while passing through Shaanzhou he met Vice Prefect Sun He and read an ancient stele by the roadside of several thousand characters; when tested afterward, Zhibai recalled nearly every word. During the Tiansheng era, the Khitan held a grand military review and announced they would hunt in Youzhou; the court was alarmed. The emperor consulted the executive bureaus; many officials said, "Stock grain and drill troops to guard against the unforeseen." Zhibai said, "No. The Khitan made peace with us not long ago. This move is merely to test the court at the beginning of a new reign—why should we provoke conflict ourselves? If the court remains uneasy, we could take advantage of the current river breach and mobilize troops under the pretext of flood control—they would suspect nothing." Before long the Khitan indeed withdrew. Having no sons, he adopted his elder brother's son Zisi as his heir. Zisi rose to Vice Minister of the Ministry of Works and retired.
62
使
Du Yan, whose style name was Shichang, was a native of Shanyin in Yuezhou. His father Suiliang had served as Vice Director of the Ministry of Revenue's Expenditure Section. From childhood Yan dedicated himself to rigorous discipline and was especially devoted to learning. Selected in the top tier of the jinshi examination, he was appointed investigative official for Yangzhou, then transferred to Assistant Compiler in the Secretariat and appointed prefect of Pingyao County. An imperial envoy recommended him, and he was made vice prefect of Jinzhou.
63
西 西 使使使
When an edict called for worthy administrators, he was promoted to prefect of Qianzhou. When Chen Yaozi was pacification commissioner for Shaanxi, an edict provided banquets only for feudatory prefectures. When Yaozi reached Qianzhou, he deemed Yan worthy of special honor and granted him a banquet, then transferred him to acting prefect of Fengxiang Prefecture. When he completed his tour and departed, the people of both prefectures intercepted him at the border, crying, "Why take away our worthy prefect?" He was appointed inspector of criminal cases on the Hedong circuit as Doctor of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, then promoted to Vice Director in the Ministry of Rites' Ancestral Temples Section. While touring Luzhou he redressed unjust cases, and Prefect Wang Shu wrote A Record of Judging Prison Cases in commemoration. Gao Jisheng was prefect of Shizhou when someone accused him of colluding with frontier tribes to rebel. Jisheng was arrested and detained without verdict for a long time until Yan proved the charge false and punished the accuser. A garrison commander of Ninghua Army tried a capital case without establishing the facts; Yan reviewed the case and corrected the judgment. The commander refused to accept the ruling and appealed; the emperor ordered a retrial, which confirmed that the death penalty was unwarranted. He was transferred to the western capital circuit and later appointed prefect of Yangzhou. The relevant office memorialized that Yan deserved reward for his judicial work, and he was promoted in the Ministry of Justice. Empress Dowager Zhangxian sent envoys to pacify Huainan. When they returned, before speaking of anything else she asked whether Du Yan was well; the envoys answered with reports of his governance. The empress dowager sighed and said, "I have known of him for a long time."
64
使西使 使 使
He was transferred to deputy transport commissioner of Hedong and transport commissioner of Shaanxi. He was summoned as Deputy Commissioner of the Households Bureau of the Three Bureaus, then promoted to Attendant Drafting in the Hall of Heavenly Manifestations and appointed prefect of Jiangling Prefecture. Before he could depart, Hebei ran short of military funds and he was selected as metropolitan transport commissioner. Promoted to Langzhong in the Ministry of Works, he supplied the needed funds without increasing levies on the people. On his return he became Academician on Direct Staff of the Bureau of Military Affairs. He requested an appointment outside the capital and was made Right Remonstrance Grandee and prefect of Tianxiong Army.
65
殿 便殿
Yan governed with meticulous care and did not rely on harsh punishments to drive his officials, yet officials and commoners alike stood in awe of his upright austerity. Emperor Renzong specially summoned him to serve as Vice Censor-in-Chief. He memorialized, "The Secretariat and the Bureau of Military Affairs correspond to the Three Great Ministers of antiquity—the ministers who 'sit and deliberate upon the Way. Meeting the emperor only on alternate days in the front hall—how can they exhaust the affairs of the realm? They should be summoned in rotation and granted seats in the side hall so they might fully debate what should be adopted or rejected; other matters need not personally burden Your Majesty." He also addressed the Ever-Normal Granary system: "Years have plenty and want, grain has high prices and low; when the state levels prices by law, farmers will enjoy surplus profit. Now great merchants buy cheap when prices fall; in flood or drought they hoard grain and refuse to sell, hoping prices will soar so they may reap thick profits—thereby distressing our people. I ask that the distances of prefectures, the size of their populations, strict rewards and punishments, and the accountability of officials be calibrated so that grain may flow without obstruction and purchases and releases may be properly gauged. When public stores are not yet full, those who compete to buy grain for profit should be banned; once purchases are complete and grain is stored, investigate those who misappropriate stores under the pretext of military supply. Where prefectures lack seed capital, I ask that the state treasury provide assistance. Otherwise officials sent to encourage compliance may visit every household daily—and what good will that do?"
66
He concurrently administered the Ministry of Personnel's Flowing Within Selection Office. Selection regulations were voluminous; the chief judge could not review them all, and clerks often took bribes and manipulated qualifications to commit fraud. Once Yan assumed office, he ordered the clerks to assemble the selection regulations in a box and asked, "Is this everything?" They answered, "This is everything." He reviewed them himself with painstaking care until he grasped every detail from start to finish. The next day he barred clerks from the main hall; each remained at his desk to receive and dispatch documents while Yan personally decided every selection matter—whereupon the clerks could no longer profit by fraud. Within months his reputation resounded throughout the capital. He was transferred to director of the Office of Merit Evaluation and governed it with the same firm hand he had shown at Selection. He was promoted to Vice Minister of the Ministry of Works and appointed prefect of Yongxing Army. When a man reported that his wife had vanished in broad daylight, Yan devised a plan to capture the killer, quickly seized the murderer, exhumed the buried corpse, and recovered two other women's corpses the killer had buried as well; the people of the region were astonished. He was transferred to Bingzhou. When Yuan Hao rebelled, Taiyuan being a strategic pass, Yan was given the additional title of Academician of the Dragon Diagram Hall.
67
調 使 使 使使
In the second year of Baoyuan he was promoted to Vice Minister of Justice and again appointed prefect of Yongxing Army. War was then underway; the people suffered under requisition and dispatch, and officials seized the opportunity for fraud. Yan devised a plan calibrated to distances and routes, extended deadlines, and enabled the people to deliver levies in orderly sequence—cutting costs by more than half compared with other prefectures. Recalled to serve as acting prefect of Kaifeng, those in power had heard of Yan's reputation and none dared approach him with private requests. He was appointed Co-Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs, then made Deputy Commissioner of Military Affairs. Xia Song submitted stratagems for attack and defense, and the chancellor wished to launch a military campaign. Yan said, "Gambling on success is not a fully reliable plan." They debated at length; Yan requested to be relieved but was refused, and the emperor sent a personal edict earnestly urging him to remain. He was made pacification commissioner of Hedong and appointed Vice Minister of Personnel and Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs. Whenever imperial favors arrived by private edict, he usually held the regulations in abeyance and refused to implement them; when such edicts accumulated to a dozen or more, he would return them to the emperor. When Remonstrance official Ouyang Xiu entered audience, the emperor said, "Do outsiders know that Du Yan returns private edicts unopened? Those who seek favors of me and stop because they say Yan cannot be told are even more numerous than those whose edicts he returns sealed."
68
婿 殿使
While the Khitan fought Yuan Hao beyond the Yellow River, Vice Grand Councillor Fan Zhongyan was pacification commissioner for Hedong and wished to take troops with him. Yan said, "The two states are fighting each other—they will certainly not threaten us. Our troops must not be rashly deployed." Zhongyan debated before the emperor, denounced Yan, and spoke in harsh terms. Though Zhongyan had once treated Yan with the deference due a father, Yan bore him no resentment. Liu Sanguo, son-in-law of the Khitan ruler, fled to avoid punishment; chief ministers debated granting him generous hospitality to extract intelligence on Khitan secrets. Remonstrance official Ouyang Xiu also asked that Sanguo be detained; the emperor consulted Yan. Yan said, "Our realm upholds loyalty and trust. If we violate sworn treaties and harbor fugitive rebels, the moral right will not be with us. Moreover, Sanguo is close kin to the Khitan, yet he fled to us to save himself—if he schemed thus for his own survival, how could he be trusted in affairs of state? What good would accepting him do? Better to return him." Sanguo was therefore returned. He was appointed Grand Councillor, Grand Academician of the Hall for Assembling Worthies, and concurrently Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs.
69
婿 使
Yan loved to recommend worthy men and obstruct opportunists; petty men were often displeased with him. His son-in-law Su Shunchin, a young man skilled in writing whose opinions sometimes affronted powerful families, oversaw the Memorial Submission Office and, following precedent, entertained guests with music at a temple sacrifice. Wang Yirou, a collator in the Hall for Assembling Worthies whom Yan knew, was reported to have mockingly composed A Song of Arrogance. The censors all impeached the matter, hoping thereby to imperil Yan. Remonstrance official Sun Fu reported, "Ding Du sought a major appointment in audience and asked to assign subordinate officials." Ding Du, knowing Fu's report was mistaken, urgently requested a face-to-face audience to rebut it. Because Fu was then on mission to the Khitan, Yan shelved his memorial; Ding Du deeply resented this. When Yan was dismissed, Ding Du drafted the appointment edict accusing Yan of factional collusion. At the time Fan Zhongyan and Fu Bi sought to reform the governance of the realm and clashed with those in power. Once Zhongyan and Bi went out as pacification commissioners, critics seized the moment and increasingly attacked their faults. The emperor wished to remove Zhongyan and Bi from office; Yan alone supported them, though in truth Yan's daily conduct was not factional collusion. He was sent out as Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and prefect of Yanzhou. In the seventh year of Qingli, Yan having just turned seventy, he submitted a memorial requesting return of seal and sash and was granted retirement as Junior Preceptor of the Heir Apparent.
70
While Yan served as chancellor, Jia Changchao disliked him. Commentators held that a former chancellor obtaining leave with a single memorial and retiring as one of the Three Preceptors were all without precedent—likely because Changchao had suppressed him. In the first year of Huangyou he was specially promoted to Grand Preceptor of the Heir Apparent and summoned to accompany the Bright Hall sacrifice. An edict ordered Yingtian Prefecture to escort him posthaste; the Capital Pavilion Station prepared a tent with couch and staff to receive him—but he pleaded illness and firmly declined. He was promoted to Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent; his son was granted the status of a successful jinshi candidate; he was then promoted again to Grand Preceptor of the Heir Apparent. Edict-drafter Wang Zhu requested leave to return to Yingtian Prefecture; the emperor sent an edict of inquiry and comfort and enfeoffed Yan as Duke of Qi.
71
退 使
Upright and uncompromising, Yan accumulated no private wealth. After retirement he lived in the southern capital for ten years in a humble dwelling of only a few dozen bays, yet he was content. When he went out he was attended by about ten followers, dressed in black cap, black silk robe, and leather belt. Some urged him to wear the garb of a lay Buddhist; Yan said, "Old and retired from office—can I still steal the name of a lofty recluse?" He was skilled at poetry, and his regular, running, and cursive scripts all had mastery. When gravely ill, the emperor sent palace envoys with medicine and an imperial physician—but they arrived too late. He died at eighty. He was posthumously granted the titles of Grandee and Concurrent Palace Attendant, with the posthumous title "Upright Contribution." He admonished his sons to strive in loyalty and filial piety and was buried with a single pillow and mat in a small, low grave. He composed his own death memorial, which in essence read: "Do not because of long peace neglect frontier defense; do not because of wealth treat finances lightly; establish the heir designate early to settle the people's hearts." His words touched on no private matters.
72
使
The commentators say: Li Di, Wang Ceng, Zhang Zhibai, and Du Yan were all worthy chancellors. The moral stature of the four was often much alike. When Emperor Renzong first ascended, Empress Zhangxian held court and somewhat wielded her power; autocratic rule seemed imminent. Di and Ceng spoke with stern countenance and dire warning, so that eunuchs and close attendants did not dare to covet power; Emperor Renzong's virtue ripened day by day, and Empress Zhangxian preserved her good name—in them one sees what the ancients called ministers of the altars of state. Zhibai and Yan were firm, upright, and frugal; both cherished official titles and checked opportunists—bearing the true bearing of great ministers. Among the worthy chancellors of Song, none were more numerous than in the reigns of Emperors Zhenzong and Renzong—so how could the chancellors of Han and Wei, or Tang's Song Jing and Yang Wan, alone claim the glory?
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →