← Back to 宋史

卷三百七十九 列傳第一百三十八 章誼 韓肖冑 陳公輔 張觷 胡松年 曹勛 李稙 韓公裔

Volume 379 Biographies 138: Zhang Yi, Han Xiaozhou, Chen Gongfu, Zhang Xue, Hu Songnian, Cao Xun, Li Zhi, Han Gongyi

Chapter 379 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 379
Next Chapter →
1
使
Zhang Yi, whose courtesy name was Yishou, came from Pucheng in Jianzhou. He earned his jinshi degree in 1105, took up a post as judicial aide in Huaizhou, and later served as instructor in both Zhangzhou and Taizhou before becoming vice-prefect of Hangzhou. Early in the Jianyan reign, the bandit Chen Tong attacked the Hangzhou area; with the city sealed off, the regional commissioner ordered Zhang Yi to muster archer militia from Hangzhou's seven counties to swell the appearance of strength. Wang Yuan arrived to crush the rebels; Zhang Yi accompanied him into the city. Once order was restored, Yi was put in charge of reassurance work, and the people credited him with their deliverance.
2
西 使貿 殿
After the emperor moved to Lin'an, Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan rose in mutiny. The emperor appeared atop the palace tower with all his chief ministers and officials in attendance while panic spread through the ranks. The emperor turned to his ministers and asked, "What is your judgment of what has happened today?" Shi Ximeng, a confidential clerk on the Zhexi Pacification staff, spoke up at once: "I submit that Your Majesty should ask the three armies." Zhang Yi broke ranks and rebuked him: "What do you mean by consulting the armies? Are you trying to stir up a mutiny?" Ximeng fell back and held his tongue. The emperor praised Zhang Yi for it. Once calm was restored, Ximeng was exiled to Jiyang, while Yi was raised two ranks and appointed vice director in the Revenue Ministry. He was sent on a mission through both Zhe circuits to exchange commemorative certificates for military funds, but lost his post for slow progress. Soon afterward he was recalled to the Transport Ministry and then promoted to palace supervising censor.
3
西退使
When Zhang Jun took up the Shaanxi pacification commission, Yi memorialized that since Zhao Zhe's defeat Zhang Jun's burden had grown so heavy and his discretion so absolute that a deputy should be named to share the load. When He Li was slated for a posthumous promotion, Zhang Yi argued that He had lacked both strategy in diplomacy and plans in defense—he had been chief among those who invited catastrophe on the state—and asked that the honor be set aside.
4
Shao Qing sailed from Taiping to Pingjiang, looting every place he touched. Zhang Yi urged posting a river navy at the imperial encampment, noting that ancient fleets had three tiers—large ships as the battle line, mid-sized war junks, and small dispatch boats—each useful for attack or defense." The court ordered the three Huainan pacification commissioners to carry this out. Zhang Yi also offered four proposals on war and defense, arguing that while the Jurchens had invaded the south year after year, the court had spent those same years in flight—ministers charged with statecraft had misled the throne. When the court had lately encamped at Yangzhou, it had several hundred thousand troops on hand—enough to stand and fight. Because reconnaissance failed, the enemy appeared without warning and crossed the Yangzi eastward—a failure owed to Chief Councillors Huang Qianshan and Wang Boyan. The year before, when the court shifted to Jiankang, the army was drilled and its commanders resolute; holding the Yangzi barrier, the position was defensible. No river navy was organized; the two chief ministers pulled in different directions; and before the enemy even arrived the court fled south along the coast—a failure laid at Lü Yihao's door. Who, then, is to supply this year's strategy for holding the line or giving battle? Which minister in power will actually shoulder this for Your Majesty? In my view, wherever there are rivers and seas, the state must have ships and gear for naval war and defense; where there are natural barriers, it must lean on prefectures and counties for defense; where there are armies and commanders, the throne must govern and reassure them, not let them become private guards for their generals; where there is grain revenue, it must move by canal transport, not fall into bandits' hands. Assign each of the four to able ministers, each with his own route and mandate, backed by rich rewards and harsh penalties—who would refuse to serve?"
5
The emperor solicited plans to protect the people, suppress bandits, hold back invaders, and grow revenue. Zhang Yi answered: "Remove corrupt and brutal officials, and the people can be secured; appoint upright and fair officials, and banditry will subside; invaders remain unchecked because we lack ministers who can confront the enemy and repel aggression; treasury revenue stays thin because we lack ministers who truly understand fiscal planning. On all four counts, if the throne appoints the right men rather than trusting rules alone, government can be set in order."
6
The court convened debate on Bright Hall spirit tablets. Hu Zhiru and others proposed a joint sacrifice to Heaven and Earth with both Taizu and Taizong as associates. Zhang Yi objected: "Measured against the classics it does not fit; measured against precedent it is incomplete; applied to the worship of Heaven it is neither concise nor dignified. The dynasty already pairs Taizu with Heaven at the suburban altar, as Zhou paired Hou Ji with Heaven; Taizong should therefore pair with the Lord at the Bright Hall, as Zhou paired King Wen. In Renzong's Huangyou reign, year 2, the court first performed a Bright Hall joint sacrifice to Heaven and Earth with the ancestors as associates—a one-time ritual change. By Jiayou year 7, when the ancestral rite was held again, the court had already seen the Huangyou arrangement as wrong, ended associate tablets, and removed Earth from the rite—hence the edict stripping away cumbersome joint-accompaniment forms. Under the Jiayou edict, Taizu and Earth no longer shared the altar; and the Yuanfeng edict reforming the sacrificial canon abolished miscellaneous rites entirely. We hold that future Bright Hall great feasts should worship the Supreme Lord of Heaven alone, with Taizong as associate." The proposal was never implemented.
7
使
In 1132 he was made director of the Court of Judicial Review. When the chief ministers proposed him as prefect of Pingjiang, the emperor said: "Yi is a scholar-official; we depend on his fair and measured case reports so the people are not wronged—do not post him outside the capital." He was soon made acting vice minister of Personnel and asked that the relevant offices compile the notification rules for all four selection cycles together with each bureau's specialized regulations and successive directives into one book. Then the selection office would have fixed rules to follow, corrupt clerks could not twist the text, and once the book was done the personnel bureau would have a standard to enforce."
8
He was moved to vice minister of Justice with concurrent duty reviewing the unified bureau statutes. Zhang Yi memorialized: "The recent Shaoxing statutes and formats preserve the generous spirit of the ancestors; their main articles still follow established practice. But they have been in use long enough that implementation in the prefectures and counties is beginning to expose contradictions. If officials follow doubtful passages as written, the public is confused and unconvinced; if they clarify matters case by case, the law keeps changing and is hard to uphold. I ask that circuit commissioners, prefects, and applying offices consult the ancestors' canon, each gather gaps in the new code, report them in lists, and then have officials review, delete, and fix them as settled law."
9
殿 殿
He was promoted to Huaiyou Pavilion academician and chief coordinator at the Bureau of Military Affairs. Zhang Yi memorialized: "Han had northern and southern encampments; Tang had northern and southern guards—all forces the emperor commanded in person. The palace guards and personal armies the ancestors placed inside the forbidden gates were drawn from the finest troops in the realm. Today the Divine Martial forces are lumped into five armies filled with deserters and marketplace recruits; the palace guards on whom the throne relies for protection scarcely number a thousand or two. I urge Your Majesty to take Han and Tang's northern and southern palace guards as a model, restore our method of selecting guards, draw one guard unit from each of the five armies and from each prefecture, gather ten thousand men, and split them into two guards—then the palace guard will be strengthened and the royal house greatly secured."
10
西 使 使
In the fourth year the Jin sent Li Yongshou and Wang Yi to demand return of Liu Yu's captives and northerners held in the southeast, and also to redraw the Yangzi boundary in Liu Yu's favor. Court opinion resisted these demands, and ministers wanted to send a senior official as envoy in reply. Vice Grand Councillor Xi Yi declined because his mother was elderly and recommended Zhang Yi in his place. Yi was made Dragon Diagram academician and envoy bearing the memorial before the armies, with Sun Jin, recipient of edicts, as deputy. Zhang Yi reached Yunzhong and debated with Nianhan and Wushi, conceding little. The Jurchens pressed him to return at once. Zhang Yi replied: "I have come ten thousand li on imperial commission, also to welcome the two palaces—I must wait until my request is granted." The Jurchens had Xiao Qing deliver a letter and also rebuked Zhang Yi on matters they had heard by rumor. Yi demanded their source; when they told him plainly, he returned. At Nanjing, Liu Yu detained him, but Zhang Yi contrived his escape and returned. The emperor praised and rewarded him and promoted him to minister of Justice.
11
使 使 使 使
That winter the emperor took the field in person; the imperial army won a great victory at Huaiyin, and Zhang Yi accompanied the campaign. Back in Lin'an he was made minister of Revenue. Zhang Yi said: "The ancestors set up fiscal offices: the Revenue Ministry at court, transport commissioners and deputies in each circuit. Where southeastern tribute was heaviest they added transport dispatch to oversee deliveries—each with rules for transfers and supplements on which the ministry relied so funds would not run short. For years the annual tribute from Sichuan, Guang, and Jing-Hu has failed to reach the imperial treasury—all because transport dispatch commissioners have neglected their duties. When the capital was at Bianjing, transport dispatch was based at Zhen and Si; now that the court is in the Wu region, its office should lie between northern and southern Jinghu. I ask that the court decide where to base transport dispatch and choose able men for the post." He added: "The Revenue Ministry's left and right sections correspond to circuit transport commissioners on the left and intendant commissioners on the right. If transport dispatch is restored and each circuit gets two transport deputies, one to inspect Ever-Normal Granaries for the right section, the ministry's finances will not be lost."
12
使
In the fifth year he asked for a prefectural post on grounds of illness and was made Dragon Diagram academician and prefect of Wenzhou. That year a severe drought drove rice to a thousand cash per dou. Zhang Yi used Liu Yan's method of inviting merchants, set up purchase stations at premium prices, merchants flocked in, and the price fell on its own. The circuit commissioner reported this, and the court advanced his rank one grade. In the sixth year he was transferred to Pingjiang. When the emperor was about to visit, the supply burden was heavy; Zhang Yi handled every item properly. Called to audience, he was granted belt and tablet. The emperor said: "This is not enough to repay your service—do not thank me."
13
西西
The next year, when the court moved to Jiankang, he again became minister of Revenue. Zhang Yi memorialized on garrison farming, arguing that Jingxi, Hubei, and eastern and western Huainan had the most displaced people; if the court meant to give every household oxen and seed and every person cash and grain to encourage farming, the treasury could not bear it. The three great generals each hold a circuit; if each surrendered several counties' land to distribute among their troops and the surplus were kept to cut transport costs, that would be a substantial gain."
14
殿使
In the seventh year the emperor returned to Lin'an and made Zhang Yi Duanming Hall academician, grand pacification commissioner of Jiangnan East, prefect of Jiankang, and keeper of the traveling palace. Soon afterward he was made superintendent of the Mingdao Palace in Bozhou and relieved on his return. In the eighth year he died at sixty-one; his posthumous title was Loyal and Respectful.
15
使 使 使 𩤏
Zhang Yi was generous and dignified. By precedent censors who did not act from private spite would use an enemy's testimony to settle scores for others; Zhang Yi alone kept the larger interest in view, and scholars approved him for it. In office he debated policy in memorials numbering well over a hundred, nearly all aimed at ordering the state and aiding the times. When Xi Yi first recommended Zhang Yi as envoy to the Jin, the emperor said: "Yi also has an elderly mother; I shall tell him myself." When Zhang Yi received the order he showed no reluctance and told his family not to let his mother know. Before leaving he told his mother: "I will be back in a few months, much like when I took leave from the Imperial Academy in earlier years." When he returned, his mother never learned he had been envoy to the Jin. When Zhang Yi died, his mother was ninety-two. He had eight sons: Juan, Ju, Si, Zhan, (one character), Jiong, Chi, and Yin.
16
Han Xiaozhou
17
殿
Han Xiaozhou, whose courtesy name was Sifu, came from Anyang in Xiangzhou. His great-grandfather was Han Qi and his grandfather Han Zhongyan; for two generations his family had produced chief ministers. His father was Han Zhi. Xiaozhou entered office by hereditary privilege as clerk for ceremonial affairs and served as recorder of the Kaifeng prefectural office. He appeared at court with the prefect; Huizong asked about his lineage, granted him upper-house student status, made him vice director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments, and bestowed third-rank robes.
18
使
Soon he was made acting recipient of edicts and envoy to congratulate the Liao on the emperor's birthday. When he returned, his father Han Zhi was serving as prefect of Xiangzhou and had asked for a temple post. Xiaozhou asked for an outside post to care for his father; the court made him a direct Secretariat academician and prefect of Xiangzhou, succeeding his father. At his farewell audience the emperor said: "The late emperor decreed that the Han family should hold office in Xiang generation after generation. For father and son to succeed each other is a glorious thing." During his four years in Xiang, as imperial forces advanced toward Yan, Xiaozhou judged that the Yan region would soon see upheaval and urged quiet defensive preparations. Soon Jin cavalry crossed the border, found nothing to plunder in the countryside, and withdrew.
19
In 1128 he became prefect of Jiangzhou, entered the capital as a sacrifices director in the Rites Ministry, and was promoted to the left section. He once said: "The central plains are not yet recovered; we rely on the Yangzi barrier, and Huainan is our true shield. Its fertile fields stretch a thousand li, but much has lately gone to waste; if farming is broadly restored, transport costs will fall and army rations will suffice." Thereafter an office was set up at Jiankang and garrison farming was carried out on the Jiang and Huai. He also answered an edict with five proposals: extend outposts, restrain garrison troops, guard sea routes, aid the central plains, and reform military administration. He was promoted to vice minister of Works.
20
西
Because Sichuan and Shaanxi horse routes were often blocked, Xiaozhou asked that an office be set up at Yongzhou in Guangxi to trade with frontier peoples for horses, and the court approved. When the emperor summoned attendants to discuss war and defense, Xiaozhou submitted a detailed memorial of more than a thousand words; the emperor praised his answers as concise and apt. Minister of Personnel Xi Yi sighed: "Citing antiquity to prove the present and pressing on what the times need—only a hereditary official could do that."
21
殿
In 1132 an edict asked all officials for plans to save expense, enrich the state, strengthen the army, and give the people rest. Xiaozhou said: "Revenue categories once all belonged to the Three Bureaus; now the Revenue Ministry tracks only tribute to the capital. Ask the Revenue Ministry about each circuit's categories and it cannot list them all; ask transport commissioners about each prefecture's categories and they cannot either—lose one category name and that revenue stream vanishes. I ask that each circuit's transport commissioner tally prefectural and county receipts and disbursements, abolish what can be abolished, merge what can be merged, and fix them in a settled register. Let transport commissioners oversee prefectures and the Revenue Ministry oversee circuits, and nothing will be lost. Of great expenditures, none surpasses maintaining the army. Many dead men still appear on the rolls; establish verification for each army and punish generals who file false claims—then troop numbers will be true, rations will not be wasted, and saving expense will enrich the state. This is the greatest matter. Beyond regular taxes the people are pressed by military deadlines; clerks use this to commit fraud and exact levies by every means. Bandits drive them off again; planting and sericulture miss their season; when bandits leave they return to the fields, but before they can catch their breath, tax collectors are already at their doors. Order prefectures and counties to gather the displaced, lend them seed on official account, wait three years before levying taxes, keep registers, and grade officials on this basis—strengthen the army and give the people rest. This comes first." Many of his proposals were adopted. He also asked to restore sacrifices to Heaven and Earth, sun and moon, stars, and the altars of soil and grain; the relevant offices were then ordered to fix the year's sacrificial calendar.
22
調使 使
He was made vice minister of Personnel. Regulations were scattered and clerks exploited the gaps; Xiaozhou offered heavy rewards, had each section record them, compiled articles, and implemented them in order—abuses of twisting the text began to end. Kin of men killed in battle could seize priority assignments, while regular candidates in the ministry waited without appointment, and light duties were sometimes made burdensome. Xiaozhou asked that only same-surname kin of the fallen use grace appointments, while others must wait until they had served—ending unfairness. He also tightened entry rules at the six ministries so patronage requests could not succeed.
23
殿使
In the third year he was made Duanming Hall academician and co-signer at the Bureau of Military Affairs, envoy for communication with the Jin, with Hu Songnian as deputy; Xiaozhou accepted with resolve. The Jin chief Nianhan then monopolized power, relied on military strength, and played alliance and war off against each other; every envoy regarded the mission as perilous. Xiaozhou memorialized: "Chief ministers each follow their own views, so peace and war have no settled conclusion. Peace is only a timely expedient; when the state is secure and strong and military renown rises, we swear to wipe away this hatred and shame. We may be gone half a year without returning; there will surely be further plots. Your Majesty should advance troops quickly and must not slacken because we are there." Before leaving, his mother Lady Wen told him: "Your family has received the state's grace for generations; when you receive the order, go at once—do not think of my old age." The emperor called her a worthy mother and enfeoffed her as Lady of the Glorious State.
24
使 使
Xiaozhou reached the Jin court; knowing his lineage, the Jurchens treated him with great respect, and the round trip took only half a year. Since the emperor's accession, envoys had gone six or seven years without a return mission—only now did the Jin first send envoys back with him. After returning from the north, Xiaozhou had audience with the emperor, clashed with Zhu Shengfei, and pressed to leave office, becoming prefect of Wenzhou at his former rank and superintendent of the Dongxiao Palace in Lin'an.
25
西西 綿 西使 使 西 沿使
In the fifth year the court asked former chief ministers for war and defense strategy. Xiaozhou said: "Jurchen armies fear the western troops' strength and skill in battle. The three commanders mostly lead westerners; Wu Jie has reported successive victories; military renown is rising and enemy resolve must waver. I already know the advantage of giving battle. From Jing and Xiang to the Jiang and Huai the line runs several thousand li; better to send civil and military officials to survey the ground, find defensible positions, station troops, and store grain so the positions link together. Eastern and western Huai have pacification commissioners, but generals' headquarters remain on the river; subordinate commanders posted to divide defense get only light troops—isolated and weak, they cannot be expected to hold firm. Two generals should be moved to the north bank so the barrier can be secured." He also said: "The great generals' troops are their own household guards and mutually hostile. If you wish to send them forward together, first appoint a supreme commander, assign elite troops, and form a single army—once orders are unified, which general would dare disobey? People of the capital region, Shandong, and the northern passes hate the Jurchens to the bone; settling the displaced and winning returnees must come first. Huainan and Jiangdong have much waste land; if border people are invited, given land and grain, and their taxes remitted, they will come in streams." He also memorialized: "South of the river there is much open land. River generals each hold territory; five or six tenths of their soldiers were once farmers. Choose the less elite, put them to farming, drill skills in farming intervals, divide the harvest equally, recruit refugees from the north and landless people in Jiangnan willing to move, and establish garrison colonies. When they halt they hold firm; when they march out they attack." He was made prefect of Changzhou, summoned to the traveling palace, made superintendent of the Wanshou Abbey, and soon appointed signer at the Bureau of Military Affairs.
26
使 使
Once peace was settled, Xiaozhou was again appointed envoy of gratitude in reply. The reception envoy met him at the border and said he should be called envoy of gratitude for grace. Xiaozhou debated three or four rounds and left him speechless. Once he arrived, the Jin sent men to the lodge to discuss affairs; Xiaozhou answered each question on the spot, and all listened in awe. On his return he was given a felt carriage and relay banquets—a courtesy that began with Xiaozhou.
27
殿
He was made academician of the Hall for Aid in Governance and prefect of Shaoxing. Soon he took a temple post and lived in retirement in Yue with his younger brother Yingzhou for nearly ten years. He was known for filial devotion to his mother; he would not eat until his brother arrived; favors he received he always gave first to the clan. He died at seventy-six; his posthumous title was Original and Solemn.
28
When Qi served in Xiang he built the Daytime Brocade Hall; when Zhi served there he built the Hall of Glorious Return; Xiaozhou built the Hall of Glorious Affairs—three generations guarding their home prefecture, and people counted it an honor.
29
Chen Gongfu
30
調
Chen Gongfu, whose courtesy name was Guozuo, came from Linhai in Taizhou. In 1113 he passed the upper-house examination and was assigned instructor in Pingjiang prefecture. Zhu Mian was then a court favorite; officials fawned on him, but Gongfu would have nothing to do with him. When Mian mourned a brother, students wished to attend the funeral; Gongfu refused them leave. Mian was displeased and hinted to the powerful that Gongfu should be transferred to Yuezhou. He rose in succession to acting vice prefect of Yingtian and was appointed a secretary.
31
覿
Early in the Jingkang reign the two councils were full of Xuanhe-era holdovers. Gongfu said: "Cai Jing and Wang Fu held power for more than twenty years; censors and remonstrators all advanced through them. Tang Zhong and Shi Ji were introduced by Grand Steward Li Bangyan; Xie Kejia and Sun Jue were introduced by compiler Cai You—and when Bangyan became chief minister, they attached themselves to advance again. These four hold censor and remonstrator posts; I know they certainly cannot speak of chief ministers' faults. Choose plain, honest officials who can live in poverty, hold to integrity, refuse the powerful, and speak boldly—place them in censor and remonstrator posts, and ritual, righteousness, integrity, and shame will gradually revive. When enemy states hear of it, how would they not fear and submit! Wu Min and Li Gang were then at odds. Gongfu memorialized: "Your Majesty has just taken up rule and depends on their united counsel, yet these two ministers are already at odds. I hope Your Majesty will instruct them to strive with one mind to secure the state."
32
使
Huizong had crossed the Yangzi and not returned; the people were anxious. Gongfu strongly urged the duty between father and son and said chief ministers should be sent to welcome him back. Qinzong commended him and made him remonstrator of the right section. In early summer he sacrificed at the Jingling Palace, then visited the Yangde and Youshen abbeys. Gongfu remonstrated that the emperor should not pursue banquets and excursions as in normal times, arguing: "Cai Jing and his sons harbored treachery and misled the state, yet were never punished. Now half the court's chief ministers and officials came from their faction—someone must be shielding them." An edict banished Cai Jing to vice military commissioner of Chongxin and assigned him residence at De'an. He also memorialized: "Zhu Mian's crimes are such that the people of the capital say his whole clan should be exterminated; I beg that his sons and kin not be allowed to follow the Retired Emperor into the capital."
33
Some then accused Gongfu of belonging to Li Gang's faction and of inciting scholars and commoners to prostrate themselves before the palace gates. Gongfu stated the facts himself and resigned; afterward he set forth three matters: first, that Li Gang was a scholar who did not understand warfare—sending him to aid Taiyuan was a trap set by chief ministers and would surely fail. Second, that Yu Yingqiu should not have been banished far for his words. Third, that as the ancestors' statutes were being restored, Feng Jie should not again discuss Xining and Yuanfeng policies. His words offended the chief minister; he was punished together with Yingqiu, Cheng Yu, and Li Guang and demoted to supervise taxes in Hezhou.
34
When Gaozong took the throne, Gongfu was recalled and made vice director of the left section in the Ministry of State Affairs. The next year he finally reached Yangzhou. When Li Gang first gained power, Gongfu was appointed from outside but had not arrived before Gang fell; he was sent to Nanjian and soon given a palace abbey post.
35
In 1136 he was recalled as vice director of the Ministry of Personnel. In a memorial he said:
36
使 使 使
"Today's calamity comes because chief ministers lack integrity and loyalty and cannot sustain the realm. In normal times they offer no loyal counsel—in crisis how would they die for principle? Was this not ruined by Wang Anshi's learning? Critics still say that though Anshi's administration was bad, his learning can still be taken. I hold that Anshi's learning was worse than his administration—administration harmed talent, learning harmed hearts. The Three Classics and Explication of Characters slander the sages and shatter the great Way—not in one respect alone. The Spring and Autumn Annals rectify names, fix praise and blame, and make traitors fear—Anshi had scholars stop studying them; the Records and Han Histories record success and failure, order and chaos—as a mirror for sage rulers and loyal subjects—Anshi had scholars stop reading them. When Wang Mang usurped the throne, Yang Xiong could not die for principle but served him and wrote Exalting Qin and Praising Xin. Anshi then said: "Xiong's serving accorded with Confucius's doctrine that one may do or not do as circumstances require." In the chaos of the Five Dynasties, Feng Dao served four houses and eight rulers; Anshi said: "Dao in the Five Dynasties was best—he avoided calamity to preserve himself." If chief ministers all took Anshi as their teacher, it is fitting that they have no integrity or loyalty."
37
便
He was again made remonstrator of the left section and said restoration governance lies in gaining Heaven and gaining men—through filial piety move Heaven, through sincerity gain the people. The emperor praised him for grasping the remonstrator's role, bestowed third-rank robes, and ordered the Ministry of State Affairs to copy his diagrams and submit them for review.
38
西使西
Moved by the emperor's recognition, Gongfu gave his loyal candor ever more fully: "Rectifying the heart lies in learning; governing the state lies in employing men; the court's calamity lies in factions." He also asked to increase rotating audience officials and allow auditors, credential clerks, grain officers, monopoly officers, warehouse supervisors, and tea-yard officials who had views of their own to face the throne. When an edict announced that the court would take up residence at Jiankang, Chen Gongfu submitted a memorial outlining offensive and defensive strategy. He also asked that a senior minister be posted west of the Huai to reinforce troops at key positions, linking Ezhou and Yuezhou in the west with Chu and Si in the east so that the whole line would form a mutual pincer.
39
When word of Emperor Huizong's death arrived, Chen Gongfu urged that the court observe the full three-year mourning within the palace, that the emperor appear at court in pale yellow, that ministers not yet wear bright celebratory dress, that Huizong not yet be paired in the Bright Hall rites, and that the palace examination be suspended. He also asked that the imperial lecture hall be temporarily closed, but the request was denied.
40
退 殿
He was promoted to Vice Minister of Rites. When Zhao Ding declared that appointing and removing officials was his own responsibility, his memorial took implicit aim at Chen Gongfu, who then pressed hard for a sinecure post at a Taoist temple. He was made Hanlin Academician of the Hall for Cultivating Talent and put in charge of the Taiping Temple in Jiangzhou, then shortly afterward became prefect of Chuzhou. Promoted to Hanlin Academician of the Huiyou Pavilion, he then took charge of the Taiping Temple. He died at sixty-six and was posthumously ennobled as Grandee of the Palace. Twenty volumes of his collected writings and twelve volumes of memorials circulated after his death. Chen Gongfu spoke to the point and hated wrongdoing with the passion of a sworn foe; his sole failing, in the eyes of literati opinion, was his refusal to champion Cheng Yi's school of thought.
41
Zhang Xue, styled Rouzhi, came from Fuzhou. After passing the jinshi examination he held a minor post and refused to bend with the times. While Cai Jing held power he looked for a tutor for his sons. Zhang Xue had just arrived in the capital when Cai's kinsman Yingzhi recommended him. Zhang tried several times to decline but could not; he moved into the household as tutor, though Cai Jing himself never found time to see him. Zhang was austere and imposing, with a bearing quite unlike other tutors, and the boys were already at their limit. One day he suddenly asked them, "Have you ever been taught to run?" The boys were startled. "We have always been told to read and walk slowly," they said; "we have never been taught to run." Zhang replied, "Your father has brought the realm to ruin. Rebels will come any day, and your house will be the first hit. Your only hope of staying alive is to run fast." The boys were terrified and rushed to tell Cai Jing that the tutor had lost his mind." Cai Jing started. "That is not for you to understand," he said." He went at once to speak privately with Zhang, who said with fierce urgency, "The altars of state stand on the edge of ruin." Cai Jing collected himself and asked what should be done. Zhang said, "Summon respected elder statesmen at once and keep them close to the throne, so that the emperor's mind may be opened. Gather loyal men from across the realm and deploy them throughout the court and the provinces—that must come first." Cai Jing pressed him for names, and Zhang recommended Yang Shi, who was thereupon summoned to court.
42
西 便
Zhang later served as prefect of Nanjian and was promoted to transport commissioner for Fujian Circuit. Before he could depart, Fan Ruwei captured Jianzhou and sent Ye Che at the head of a band to attack Nanjian. The regional commander Ren Shi'an had his troops camped west of the city but would not fight hard. Zhang alone led the prefectural militia into battle. He divided them into several companies and had the city slaughter livestock for meat skewers while preparing large quantities of food. Before each engagement he fed the first company; once they were full, he sent them into the line and fed the second. When he judged the men in the field near exhaustion, he sent the third company to relieve them, and did the same with the fourth, fifth, and sixth. By rotating companies in battle, his men stayed fed and never lost their strength. Ye Che was struck by an arrow and killed, and his followers fled in rout. Knowing that Ren Shi'an feared returning without credit, Zhang boxed Ye Che's head and handed it over. The prefectural troops were furious, but Zhang said, "The rebels will come again. We cannot break them without the main army's help." Ren Shi'an was delighted and galloped off to report to headquarters that he had personally beheaded Ye Che. Before long, Ye Che's two sons returned at the head of a force dressed in white mourning, crying that they would avenge their father. Ren Shi'an and the prefectural troops then attacked from both sides and routed them, and the city was saved.
43
When he again served as prefect of Chuzhou, he once wanted to build a large vessel, but his staff could not estimate the cost. Zhang had them build a small boat, measure it, and multiply by ten. When officials planned a wall for the spirit temple in the Shaoxing Garden, craftsmen quoted eighty thousand strings of cash. Zhang had them build one zhang of wall themselves, reckoned the true cost at twenty thousand, and paid the craftsmen that amount. The eunuch overseeing the project got nothing from the deal and reported that Shaoxing could not afford the work. The Empress Dowager then paid out of her own purse—three hundred twenty thousand strings of cash. Appointed directly to the Dragon Diagram Pavilion, he governed Qianzhou, wiped out the remaining bandits, was promoted to Secretariat Compiler, and died in office. He was later given a place in the temple at Shaowu.
44
Hu Songnian
45
使 便殿 殿
Hu Songnian, styled Maolao, came from Huairen in Haizhou. Orphaned and poor as a boy, he was supported by his mother's loom and cloth sales. He read with a photographic memory and was especially deep in the Book of Changes. In the second year of Zhenghe he graduated from the upper dormitory, entered official service, and was appointed instructor at Weizhou. In the eighth year he was granted audience in the Privy Hall. Emperor Huizong was impressed by his bearing and made him collator and concurrent reader at the Hall of Cultivating Virtue. Serving as evaluation officer for the palace examination, he ranked Shen Hui first. Emperor Huizong was delighted. "I have long known Shen Hui's name," he said; "now I have him at last." He was promoted to drafting officer of the Central Secretariat.
46
便
When the court was preparing action in Yan-Yun, Hu Songnian submitted memorial after memorial warning that once border war began, the consequences would be beyond words. Because he crossed the chief minister, he was sidelined as director of the Taiping Temple. During the Jianyan era he sent secret memorials on the strategic situation in the Central Plains, was summoned to the mobile court, and was sent out as prefect of Pingjiang. Before he even crossed the border of his jurisdiction, corrupt officials resigned and went to ground. He posted seventeen reforms for public benefit in the marketplace, and the people welcomed them. He was made Hanlin Academician of the Huiyou Pavilion. He memorialized on Yangtze River defense with three points: the state lacked secure frontiers; dispatched generals lacked coordinated support; and the army failed to strike the enemy where it was weakest.
47
殿
He was recalled to serve as drafting officer of the Central Secretariat. He urged that Wuchang, Jiujiang, Jianchang, Jingkou, Wujiang, Qiantang, Mingzhou, and Yuezhou each maintain three thousand naval troops as a reserve. When Tang Ke was posthumously restored as Academician of the Hall for Viewing Literature, Hu Songnian returned the draft with a protest: "In the Jingkang catastrophe, He Bi was reckless and feckless. He should rank first among the guilty. Last year, after Qin Hui returned to court and vigorously praised Tang's steadfast resistance, Tang was posthumously honored—a move that already outraged literati opinion. Now Tang Ke's son Zhuo has declared that his father, unable to carry out a plan to bring the two captive emperors home, took poison and died. The act is solemn and worthy, echoing the noblest examples of antiquity. The throne should order the proper offices to verify the facts, so that praise is not hollow and others may be moved to follow his example."
48
便
He was appointed supervising censor. When the court was choosing generals, Hu Songnian wrote, "Wealth and rank make virtue easy; poverty makes achievement hard. Everything depends on whether those above know talent when they see it. I urge Your Majesty to visit the camps in person and pick men from the ranks; there will surely be talent worth using." He also wrote, "Recovering the Central Plains must begin in Shandong, and Shandong's loyalty must begin in Deng, Lai, and Mi. Those three prefectures are not only steadfast in custom, but also enjoy the advantage of fast boats running between Tongzhou and Taizhou." He was also made concurrent lecturer.
49
使使 使 使
When Wang Lun returned from his mission to the Jin and reported that the Jurchens wanted another high minister for negotiations, Hu Songnian was appointed acting Minister of Works and deputy to Han Xiaozhou as envoy to the Great Jin. Diplomatic contact had long been broken off, and everyone was afraid, but Hu Songnian went resolutely nonetheless. At Bianjing, Liu Yu required them to be received with the rites owed a subject. Han Xiaozhou said nothing, but Hu Songnian declared, "Long live the sage sovereign." Liu Yu asked, "What does the sage emperor intend?" Hu Songnian replied, "Our sovereign will not rest until the old territory is recovered." On his return he was appointed Minister of Personnel.
50
使
After Yue Fei recovered Xiangyang and Hanzhong, the court put Hu Songnian in charge of planning the defense. Hu Songnian urged that Yue Fei be recalled and Liu Yu's intentions watched closely. "If Liu Yu shows no reaction, his designs are unknowable," he wrote; "the troops should be ordered to hold the frontier with care." He also set out four advantages of a fleet: projecting the court's power deep into enemy territory; securing the loyalty of Shandong people who wish to return; overawing the enemy so they dare not threaten Jiangsu and Zhejiang; and pinning Liu Yu down so he cannot build strength in Xiang and Han.
51
殿 使使 使
He was made Academician of the Duanming Hall and deputy commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs. His first memorial laid out eight priorities: set a blueprint for restoration; restore discipline to strengthen the throne; make generals fear disobedience and soldiers feel rewarded; reclaim the power of appointment and dismissal; weigh praise and slander carefully; reject no talent over small faults; and let no empty paperwork displace real achievement." He also recommended Zhang Diwan: "In Huainan he once lured the enemy deep into marshland until infantry and cavalry were trapped on every side with no escape. The Jurchens have never recovered their nerve. Give him an independent command, so that the frontier gradually gains more capable generals and the court is not reduced to leaning on three or four men alone."
52
Intelligence reported that Liu Yu was preparing boats at Deng, Lai, Hai, and Mi and stockpiling fodder and grain at Huaiyang and Shunchang, planning to use Jin support to raid the frontier. Some argued that with Han Shizhong, Liu Guangshi, and Yue Fei each holding a front, there was nothing to fear. Hu Songnian replied, "Those three commands are not linked. In a crisis they will not come to one another's aid. The sea route is vast, and Suzhou, Xiuzhou, Mingzhou, and Yuezhou are the critical points. He asked for ten thousand picked troops and a senior minister posted at Jiankang to direct Han Shizhong and Liu Guangshi at Caishi and Majiadu, while five thousand men held Mingzhou and Pingjiang against attack from the rivers and sea. If no one else can be spared, I am willing to ride at once to meet the crisis." The emperor ordered Hu Songnian to the Yangtze front to confer with the generals on the advance and to reconnoiter the enemy. When the emperor resolved to take the field in person and halted at Pingjiang, he made Hu Songnian acting vice grand councillor in charge of warships and put Zhang Jun in charge of arms. Hu Songnian said, "Once policy is settled, only steady execution counts. Start today and stop tomorrow, and nothing is gained but confusion."
53
Soon illness forced him to retire as director of the Dongxiao Palace at Yangxian. Even in retirement he kept advising the court on grain levies and autumn defense, and the emperor welcomed every memorial. In the sixteenth year, on his deathbed, he called his son and said, "The great cycle turns; no one escapes it." He lay back on his pillow, breathing like thunder. A moment later he was dead, yet for a time people thought he still lived. He was sixty.
54
Hu Songnian never cared to hoard wealth. Each promotion brought its customary grant of gold and silk, but with war costs soaring he never asked for a share. When others urged him to petition the throne, he said, "Not asking is enough; asking would be fishing for praise." He loved entertaining guests, and his salary never covered the cost. Some urged him to cut back for his children's sake. Hu Songnian replied, "Wealth spoils a worthy man's resolve. Besides, my stipend is what the sovereign gives to sustain an old servant." He carried his own recommendations to the chief ministers. Every man he proposed to succeed him was eminent, and no power or patronage could sway his choices.
55
While Qin Hui held power, anyone he knew or did not know could be destroyed by suspicion, so officials everywhere flattered him to survive. Hu Songnian alone scorned him and never exchanged a single letter with him to the day he died. The world honored him for it.
56
殿
Cao Xun, styled Gongxian, came from Yangdi. His father Zu, during the Xuanhe era, served as gate protocol attendant and composer for the Hall of Sagacious Contemplation, winning favor through his quick wit in divination and repartee. Cao Xun entered service by privilege as Bearer of Faithful Trust, was specially ordered to sit the palace jinshi examination, received the highest rank, and remained a military officer.
57
便
At the start of the Jingkang era he was gate protocol attendant and supervisor of Longde Palace, and was made Grandee of Martial Righteousness. Accompanying Emperor Huizong on the forced march north, more than ten days after crossing the river he asked Cao Xun, "Do you think the people of the Central Plains have rallied to Prince Kang?" The next day he took out an imperial robe and wrote inside the collar, "Take the throne at once and come to save your parents." He also gave Cao Xun letters from Consort Wei and Lady Xing and ordered him to make his way secretly to the prince. He also told Xun, "When you find Prince Kang, tell him of any plan to reclaim the Central Plains and put every part of it into action. Do not let concern for me hold you back." He added that Taizu had left a sworn oath in the Imperial Ancestral Temple never to put to death grand ministers or officials who remonstrated; violation would bring ill fortune.
58
使使 使 使使 使使殿 使 使 使
In the eleventh year, Wuzhu dispatched envoys to discuss peace. Cao Xun was appointed Regimental Commissioner of Chengzhou and served as deputy to Liu Guangyuan in responding. On reaching the Huai River, they met Wuzhu, who sent them home and said a senior official bearing imperial credentials should come instead—clearly eager to conclude peace at once. Cao Xun returned and was promoted to Defender of Zhongzhou. When Jin envoys led by Xiao Yi arrived, Cao Xun was appointed to receive them. Soon he was given the honorary post of Observer of Rongzhou and appointed deputy envoy to return thanks to the Jin court. Summoned to the inner hall, the emperor wept and charged him with the earnest request to recover the imperial family. At their audience with the Jin emperor, chief envoy He Zhu fell prostrate and could not speak. Cao Xun argued the case again and again until the Jin ruler assented and agreed to return the imperial coffin and the Empress Dowager. After Cao Xun returned, the Jin sent Gao Ju'an and others to escort the Empress Dowager to Lin'an and again appointed Xun to receive her. He was promoted to Commissioner of the Bao Xin Army and Deputy Chief Palace Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs.
59
使使
In the twenty-ninth year he was made Military Commissioner of the Zhao Xin Army and served as deputy to Wang Lun on a mission of thanks. By then Emperor Hailing of Jin had already settled on a plan to strike south across the Huai. When Cao Xun and Wang Lun returned, they reported that the neighbor was respectful and the alliance sound; people ridiculed their delusion. Under Emperor Xiaozong he was further promoted to Grand Marshal, put in charge of the Imperial City Bureau, and granted the honors of Grand Preceptor equal to the Three Excellencies. He died in the first year of the Chunxi era and was posthumously granted the title Junior Guardian.
60
Li Zhi, whose courtesy name was Yuanzhi, came from Linhuai in Sizhou. As a boy he was bright and diligent in study, and twice passed the provincial examinations. His uncle Zhonghang moved in Su Shi's circle; when Grand Astrologer Chao Wujiu met Li Zhi he said, "Here is a man fit to serve the realm." He gave Li Zhi his daughter in marriage.
61
使
Early in the Jingkang era, the future Gaozong, then Prince Kang, opened the Grand Marshal's Headquarters. Xiang Ziyin of Hunan was moving supplies to the capital region. Bandits were rising on every side, supply lines were severed, and he found no one around him fit to send. When Li Zhi was recommended, he received a provisional appointment as Bearer of Merit and was sent to supervise four hundred boats, escorting one million taels of silver in troop rewards and a million shi of grain while recruiting more than twenty thousand loyal volunteers. From the Huai he pushed through Xu toward Ji, fighting more than ten engagements, and finally broke through by stratagem. Gaozong was then encamped at Juye. When he heard that a plain-clothed man from the southeast had arrived at the head of an army, morale surged tenfold, and he was the first to receive and commend him. Li Zhi replied with detailed and nimble clarity. Gaozong was delighted, personally set food before him, and said, "To gain a man like this is like finding a treasured jade disk—not merely securing army supplies." By special order he was made Bearer of Upright Trust and retained on the marshal's staff.
62
Li Zhi submitted three memorials urging accession: "I pray that Your Majesty will soon take the throne in full right, to settle the people's hearts and answer Heaven's will." Three times the emperor sent down handwritten notes of praise and encouragement. Deeply moved by this favor, Li Zhi spoke his mind without reserve and was resented by Wang Boyan and Huang Qianshan. After Gaozong took the throne, Li Zhi served as a staff officer of the Southeast Transport Commission, and soon afterward was appointed magistrate of Xiangyin in Tanzhou with the rank Bearer of Discussion. The county had been laid waste by Yang Yao. Li Zhi cut through the brambles, restored county government, opened the granaries, and relieved the destitute, making comfort and care his chief concern.
63
滿
Grand Councilor Zhang Jun was directing troops on the Yangzi. Recognizing Li Zhi's ability, he recommended him as Senior Gentleman of the Court and vice-prefect of Ezhou. The great bandits Ma You and Kong Yanchou had not yet been subdued. Li Zhi had warships repaired, drilled his men in river fighting, and divided his forces into left and right wings. He smashed Yanchou's ambush, executed Ma You, and both bandits were brought to heel. Zhang Jun reported the victory to court, and Li Zhi was promoted to Grand Gentleman for Court Attendance and made vice-prefect of Jingnan. When his term ended, he was appointed Outer Assistant Director in the Ministry of Revenue.
64
Qin Hui was then in power. Nearly all former staff of the marshal's headquarters were pushed aside, and Zhang Jun too left the court. Li Zhi at once sought a sinecure so he could care for his parents, lived for nineteen years at Liling near Changsha, and kept his doors closed to office.
65
便
After Qin Hui died, Xiang Ziyin was Minister of Revenue and close to the throne. When talk turned to the old days of the emperor's accession, he remembered Li Zhi's name, and Li Zhi was appointed Director in the Ministry of Revenue. On Li Zhi's first audience, the emperor said, "You are an old friend of mine." The emperor meant to give him great responsibility, but because his mother was old Li Zhi repeatedly declined, asking instead for a post that would let him care for her, and was appointed prefect of Guiyang. When his mother died he returned home to bury her, grieved so deeply that he lived in a hut by her tomb, and white egrets and red grass appeared as auspicious signs. Liu Qi wrote to him, "In loyalty and filial piety alike, Yuanzhi has both."
66
When his mourning period ended, Vice Administrator Qian Duanli recommended him for appointment as prefect of Qiongzhou. At his farewell audience the emperor said with feeling, "You are old, and Qiongzhou lies far beyond the sea." He was reassigned as prefect of Huizhou instead. Huizhou's people favored illicit shrines. Li Zhi made suppressing heterodox cults and setting hearts right his first concern, and local customs changed. He was promoted to Grand Gentleman for Court Appearance with direct access to the Secret Archive, reassigned as prefect of Zhenjiang, and then made overall intendant of mining, smelting, and coinage for the Jiang-Huai, Jing, and Xiang regions.
67
西使 西 使使
A year later the Jin broke the treaty and the court prepared a major campaign. Because Li Zhi showed talent and strategy in transport, he was given direct access to the Hall of Spreading Culture and appointed planning transport commissioner for the Jingxi and Hebei circuits. Li Zhi planned with sound method, and court deliberations leaned heavily on him. In the first year of the Qiandao era he was made judicial intendant of Jiangxi. In the second year he was given direct access to the Hall of Treasured Culture, made transport commissioner of Jiangnan East circuit, concurrently prefect of Jiankang and pacification commissioner of the circuit, and put in charge of the traveling palace garrison headquarters.
68
Li Zhi submitted a memorial setting out ten strategies for river defense in detail. In summary he wrote: "Hold the barrier of Jing and Xiang to secure the state's foundation; choose where the central army should stand, to await the great offensive; recruit and select the strong to thicken the army's power; survey defensible ground to protect the people; avoid what the enemy does best and strike where he is weak; Jin deserters should be rewarded and encouraged." Every point went straight to practical matters, without empty generalities. When the memorial reached the throne, the emperor praised it and summoned him to court as Minister of the Imperial Treasury. Illness kept him from traveling, so he retired as Grand Gentleman for Palace Attendance and Academician of the Hall of Treasured Culture and returned to Hunan.
69
Hu Anguo and his sons lived below Mount Heng, and Liu Qi lived in Xiangtan. They visited one another in discussion, and whenever state affairs came up worry showed on their faces. To the end they regretted the peace settlement. He died at the age of seventy-six. He left a collected works in ten juan titled Collected Works of Linhuai, with a preface by Hu Quan of Luling. He was given the posthumous title "Loyal and Assisting."
70
He had five sons: Ruyu, magistrate of Taoyuan county; Rushi, Senior Gentleman of the Court and prefect of Huangzhou; and Rugong, prefect of Changhua.
71
Han Gongyi
72
使 使退 退
Han Gongyi, whose courtesy name was Ziyi, came from Kaifeng. He first entered service as a clerk in the Three Halls, handled memorials for Consort Wei Xian's pavilion, and soon became inner host of Prince Kang's household. When Jin troops attacked the capital, the prince went out on a mission and Gongyi went with him. After crossing the river, officers Liu Hao and Wu Zhan fought among themselves; Gongyi reasoned with them until they stopped. At Cizhou the soldiers and people killed the envoy Wang Yun and followed the prince's carriage into the prefectural yamen. Gongyi again reasoned with them until they withdrew. When the prince was about to flee south, he and Gongyi planned a secret night march by a side road. At dawn they reached Xiangzhou without the people of Cizhou knowing. From then on the prince's affection for him deepened. After the armies withdrew, Zhang Bangchang sent men together with the prince's maternal uncle Wei Yuan to present the imperial seal of transmission. Yuan then styled himself an official of the puppet regime, and others said Zhang Bangchang could not be trusted. The prince in anger was about to execute Yuan. Gongyi said, "The imperial regalia has returned of its own accord—this is Heaven's mandate." The prince then accepted the seal and put Gongyi in charge of it. Gongyi pleaded hard for Yuan and secured his release from punishment.
73
使
Empress Yuanyou ordered the prince to enter and succeed to the throne. The headquarters staff said Jin troops were still near and urged him to encamp at Pengcheng. Gongyi said, "The dynasty was founded at Suiyang; the prince too ought to receive the mandate there." The vanguard had already set out toward Pengcheng when heaven sent thunder and lightning so violent that they could not advance. The prince took this as a sign. At midnight he spoke loudly to Gongyi: "Tomorrow we go to Suiyang—that is settled." After the prince took the throne, Gongyi was repeatedly promoted until he reached Grandee of Military Merit and Defender of Guizhou.
74
使
Later he gave offense to Huang Qianshan over some matter. When the emperor was visiting Yangzhou, Gongyi asked to leave office. Qianshan took this as shirking duty and had him demoted three ranks and sent to the Ministry of Personnel. When the emperor fled to Yue, he remembered Gongyi's old service, recalled him to his former post as staff officer of the Imperial City Bureau, still bearing imperial arms, and eventually promoted him to Observer of Guangzhou and commissioner of the You Shen Abbey.
75
使
Gongyi had served the princely household for more than thirty years with generous favor. Whenever the empress dowager held wine in the Cining Palace, Gongyi was always summoned. When the Jade Register was being compiled, many events of the marshal's headquarters had been lost. Qin Hui, knowing Gongyi was an old member of that staff, memorialized that the compilers should consult him. Soon he was made Commissioner of the Bao Kang Army. Qin Hui suspected he had gone over his head to the emperor and nursed a grudge. Right Remonstrance Grandee Wang Bo, eager to please Qin Hui, impeached and removed Gongyi. He was given an outside sinecure and lived away from court, yet the emperor's regard for him never faded.
76
西 使 使
After Qin Hui died he was at once restored as commissioner of the You Shen Abbey and given a residence west of the Henning Gate. The emperor said, "The empress dowager and I wish to see you often, so we have placed you close by." He was promoted to Military Commissioner of the Hua Rong Army and soon retired. Later, when the Hua Rong Army was renamed the Yue Yang Army, Gongyi exchanged his commission accordingly and became Military Commissioner of the Yue Yang Army. After Gaozong abdicated, he once told Xiaozong of Gongyi's loyal service and ordered the prefecture where he lived to look after him well. He died in the second year of the Qiandao era at seventy-five. He was posthumously made Grand Marshal, given the posthumous title "Respectful and Glorious," and eight of his kinsmen were granted office. Gaozong bestowed gold and silk on him in great abundance.
77
Gongyi kept himself in some measure of restraint, did not build a power base, did not trade in favors, and dared to stand apart from Huang Qianshan and Qin Hui—points in his favor as well.
78
使
Commentary: Zhang Yi had the integrity of blunt remonstrance; Han Xiaozhou rested on the prestige of his forebears. Both offered many proposals and served abroad without disgrace—these are merits worth noting. Chen Gongfu understood what a remonstrance minister should be. His impeachment of the factions of Cai Jing and Wang Fu and his analysis of the breach between Wu Min and Li Gang were sound. Yet having seen the harm of Wang Anshi's doctrines, why did he not uphold the learning of Cheng Yi? Zhang Xue condemned the ruin Cai Jing brought and recommended the worth of Yang Shi; his character was upright. Moreover, he had real skill in pacifying bandits yet did not claim the credit for himself. Hu Songnian despised Qin Hui and would have nothing to do with him. To know one's fate yet remain adaptable—such men are not easily found. Cao Xun endured the hardships of war and achieved some merit, yet when the Jin invasion was already decided he still reported that the neighbor was respectful and well disposed. How slow he was to read the signs! Li Zhi and Han Gongyi showed loyal devotion early on. As old companions of the emperor, they could stand apart from Huang Qianshan and Qin Hui, keep their doors closed, and wait for the right moment—they too knew where to stand.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →