← Back to 新五代史

卷六十三 前蜀世家第三: 王建

Volume 63: Hereditary House of Former Shu

Chapter 63 of 新五代史 · New History of the Five Dynasties
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 63
Next Chapter →
1
Wang Jian, whose courtesy name was Guangtu, came from Wuyang in Xuzhou. He had heavy brows and a broad forehead, and his bearing was imposing. As a young man he was a rascal who made his living slaughtering oxen, stealing donkeys, and smuggling salt; neighbors called him "Bandit Wang Eight." He later enlisted in the Zhongwu Army and gradually rose to company commander.
2
鹿 西 使 使 西 使 使宿
After Huang Chao seized Chang'an, Emperor Xizong took refuge in Shu. The Zhongwu general Lu Yanhong led eight thousand men under Yang Fuguang to fight the rebels. When Chao was routed and fled, Fuguang split his army into eight companies of a thousand men apiece; Jian and Yanhong each commanded one company. After Fuguang died, Yanhong led the eight companies west to join Xizong in Shu, looting every district they passed through. At Xingyuan he drove out the military commissioner Niu Cong and declared himself acting commissioner. Xizong promptly confirmed Yanhong as military commissioner, and Yanhong appointed Jian and the other seven company heads as prefects of subordinate districts. Soon Yanhong marched east with his forces and seized Chen and Xu. Jian, Jin Hui, Han Jian, Zhang Zao, and Li Shitai each led one company west into Shu. Xizong was delighted and dubbed them the "Five Companies of the Imperial Escort," placing them under the Shidian Army eunuch Tian Lingzi, who adopted Jian and his companions as sons. When Xizong returned to Chang'an, he put Jian and Jin Hui in command of the Shence Army on palace guard duty.
3
西使西使 使
Once Xizong had reached Xingyuan, Lingzi concluded that the emperor's exile was his doing and feared punishment. The Xichuan military commissioner Chen Jingxuan was his younger uterine brother, so Lingzi sought appointment as Xichuan army supervisor, with Yang Fugong succeeding him as army supervisor. Fugong posted Jian as prefect of Bi. Jian then rallied fugitives and hill tribes until he had eight thousand men, attacked Lang Prefecture, and captured its prefect Yang Xingqian. He also attacked Li Prefecture, whose prefect Wang Gong abandoned the city and fled. Jingxuan was alarmed and asked Lingzi, who said, "Wang Eight is my boy. Send one messenger to summon him and you can keep him at your side." He then sent men to summon Jian.
4
使
When Jingxuan refused to step down, Emperor Zhaozong ordered Zhaodu to march against him with Yan Lang's forces. Zhaozong appointed Jian adjutant commander-in-chief of the punitive headquarters. After a long stalemate, Jian told Zhaodu, "You have brought tens of thousands to harry the people of the two Shu, yet the army has campaigned for ages without success—what now? The Tang house is in turmoil, and eastern prefectures have armies pressing the capital. You should return to serve the Son of Heaven, pacify the central plains, and secure the foundation—this barbarian country is no place to keep you." Zhaodu wavered. Jian had soldiers seize Zhaodu's personal clerk at the camp gate, carve him up, and eat him. Jian came in to report, "The men were starving—they needed this for food!" Zhaodu was terrified and at once left his credentials and tally with Jian and marched east. Once Zhaodu had gone, Jian seized Jianmen Pass with troops, and the two Shu were cut off from the east.
5
使 使 西使使
Shan Xingzhang held Guangdu; Jian routed him, and Xingzhang fled to Meizhou and surrendered the prefecture. Jian marched on Chengdu, and the prefectures of Zi, Jian, Rong, Mao, Jia, and Qiong each killed their prefects and submitted to him. Jian pressed Chengdu hard. Tian Lingzi climbed the wall and called to him, "I was always close to you—what grievance brings you to this!" Jian replied, "Army Supervisor, the bond between father and son—how could I forget it in my heart! Yet an army sent against one who refuses transfer—that is the Son of Heaven's command." That night Lingzi entered Jian's camp and handed over the commissioner's tally and seal. The next day Jingxuan opened the gates and welcomed Jian in. Before entering the city, Jian appointed Zhang Yan camp commander and warned his troops, "Zhang is camp commander now—do not break his orders. If you are seized and brought to me, I may still spare you; if he kills you and then reports it, I cannot hold him to account either." Once Jian entered, the soldiers looted and killed a hundred people before he stopped them. Later Jian transferred Jingxuan to Yazhou and had him killed; he reappointed Lingzi as army supervisor, then killed him too. In the tenth month of Dashun year 2, Tang appointed Jian acting Minister of Works, prefect of Chengdu, deputy military commissioner of Jiannan West with full commission authority, circuit observer and administrator, and commissioner for pacifying the eight kingdoms of Yunnan.
6
綿 綿 使
Gu Yanlang of Dongchuan died, and his younger brother Yanhui took his place. Tang sent the eunuch Zong Daobi to invest Yanhui with the Dongchuan commission. Mianzhou prefect Chang Hou seized Daobi and used him to attack Zizhou, so Jian dispatched Li Jian, Wang Zongti, and others against Hou. Since Yanlang's death Jian had wanted to annex Dongchuan but lacked a pretext. When Li Jian marched against Hou, he instructed them, "Once you defeat Hou, Yanhui will surely come out to reward the army—bring him back with you, and I need not march again." Li Jian defeated Hou at Zhongyang; Hou fled to Mianzhou, returned the Tang commission to Daobi, and released him. Yanhui, now confirmed in office, pleaded illness and refused to come out and reward the army. In Qianning year 2, Jian sent Wang Zongti against him. In the twelfth month Zongti routed Yanhui at Qiulin, killed his general Luo Zhang, and besieged Zizhou. In the fifth month of year 3, Zhaozong sent the eunuch Yuan Yijian to order Jian to stand down, and Jian withdrew to Chengdu. Qiannan military commissioner Wang Zhao surrendered his territory to Jian.
7
使西使 使
In year 4, Zongti attacked Dongchuan again while Jian sent Wang Zongkan, Zong Ruan, and others through the gorges to seize Yu and Lu. In the fifth month Jian led the Dongchuan campaign in person. Zhaozong sent remonstrance officer Li Xun and aide Wei Zhuang to announce the imperial will in both Shu and order Jian to stand down. Jian ignored the edict. Tang then demoted him to prefect of Nanzhou, made the Prince of Tan military commissioner of Fengxiang, and appointed Li Maozhen to replace him in Xichuan. Maozhen refused the appointment, so Tang restored Jian's rank and titles. In the tenth month of winter Jian captured Zizhou, and Yanhui took his own life. Yanhui's general Gu Yanyao, seeing the city doomed, told his officers, "To serve our lord is to stand with him in life and death!" He pointed to the guest-iron sword at his belt. "If anyone turns traitor in this crisis, let him bite this blade!" As the city was about to fall, Yanyao and Yanhui gathered the officers for a final feast and died with them. Jian made Wang Zongti acting commissioner of Dongchuan, and Tang confirmed him as military commissioner. Jian now held both Shu circuits.
8
使
In year 7, Liang overthrew Tang and sent envoys to Jian, but he refused to receive them. Jian then sent urgent proclamations across the realm to rally armies against Liang, but everyone saw he was not sincere and none answered.
9
鹿 使 宿
That year, in the first month, a giant was seen on Mount Qingcheng. In the sixth month a phoenix appeared in Wansui County and a yellow dragon in the Jiayang River, and prefectures everywhere reported sweet dew, white deer, white sparrows, tortoises, and dragons as omens. On the jihai day of the ninth month of autumn, Jian took the imperial throne. He enfeoffed his sons as kings, appointed Wang Zongji director of the Secretariat, Wei Zhuang left regular cavalier attendant with concurrent Secretariat-Chancellery duty, Tang Xi commissioner of palace secrets, Zheng Qian censor-in-chief, Zhang Ge and Wang Kai as Hanlin academicians, and Zhou Boya prefect of Chengdu. Shu was rich and well protected by terrain; at the end of Tang many scholars sought refuge with Jian to escape the chaos. Though Jian had risen from banditry, he was clever and cunning by nature and treated scholars well, so when he took the imperial title he staffed his court with eminent Tang ministerial families; Zhuang was a grandson of Jian Su; Ge was a son of Jun. Jian told his attendants, "When I was a Shence general on palace guard duty, I saw the emperor summon Hanlin academicians at night. They came and went freely, treated with the intimacy of close colleagues—nothing like the standing of generals and ministers." For that reason he treated Ge and the others with exceptional favor, and more than a hundred others, including Song Bi, were all trusted and employed.
10
In year 2 he promulgated the Yongchang calendar. At Guangdu the grain grew with joined ears.
11
使 退西
In the eighth month of year 3, fifty dragons were seen in the waters of Xunyang. In the tenth month a qilin appeared in Bi Prefecture. In the twelfth month he proclaimed a general amnesty and renamed the coming year Yongping year 1. The Prince of Qi, Li Maozhen, was himself besieged by Liang. With Shannan now in Shu's hands, his territory was cramped and his position isolated, so he made peace with Jian, married his son to Jian's daughter, and asked for his former Shannan lands. Jian refused in anger and appointed Wang Zongkan overall commander of the northern route, with Zong You, Zong He, and Tang Xi as commissioners on three fronts to attack Qi. At Qingni, Zongkan was defeated, fell back to Xixian, and was surrounded by Maozhen's army. Jian led the relief force in person, routed the Qi army, and marched as far as Xingyuan before returning. He added the honorific title Emperor Yingwu Ruisheng Guangxiao.
12
使穿 祿 使 使
In year 2 he added the further honorific Emperor Yingwu Ruisheng Shengong Wende Guangxiao. Earlier, when Tian Lingzi served as army supervisor, he had stolen Tang's dynastic seal, brought it to Shu, and buried it. In the second month the imperial provisioner Ouyang Rou was repairing Lingzi's old residence, unearthed the seal, and presented it. In the fifth month Liang sent palace attendant Lu Bi on a friendly mission, treating Jian as an elder brother. The mission seal read "Seal of Great Liang Entering Shu." Chief minister Zhang Ge said, "By Tang precedent, envoys to foreign states bore seals reading 'Seal of Great Tang Entering Such-and-Such State.' Liang already treats Your Majesty as an elder brother—why demean us like a barbarian power?" Jian was furious and wanted to kill the Liang envoy. Ge said, "This is only a blunder by Liang's officials—we must not break the goodwill between our states." Soon Liang's founding emperor died. Jian sent director of imperial construction Li Hong to offer condolences and had his mission seal inscribed "Seal of Great Shu Entering Liang." At Jian Prefecture trees grew with joined trunks. In the sixth month a qilin appeared in Wen Prefecture. In the twelfth month a yellow dragon appeared in the Fuyi River.
13
鹿 仿 使使 使
In the first month of year 3 a qilin appeared at Yongtai. In the fifth month a zouyu appeared at Bishan, followed by two deer. In the seventh month of autumn, Crown Prince Yuanying killed junior guardian of the heir Tang Xi. Yuanying was Jian's second son. He was first named Zongyi, then Zongtan. Jian found a bronze plaque at Shifang inscribed with more than twenty characters and took it as a prophecy, using it to name his sons; hence this son was renamed Yuanying. Yuanying had a protruding mouth and buck teeth but was skilled in many arts. He could shoot through the hole in a coin, and once tossed a painted ball onto a galloping horse and shot it without ever missing. At seventeen he was made crown prince, took charge of the Six Armies, founded the Tianwu Shenji camp, opened the Yonghe bureau, and appointed its staff. Because Yuanying was young yet bore heavy responsibility, Jian left him a written admonition: "Do everything as I have done, and you can preserve the state." He also appointed the Daoist master Guangcheng, Du Guangting, as his tutor. Tang Xi was Jian's favorite. Yuanying despised him and repeatedly mocked him at court. Fearing a breach between them, Jian removed Xi as commissioner of palace secrets and posted him as military commissioner of Xingyuan. Soon Xi was dismissed and returned to court, where Yuanying publicly denounced his faults. Jian grew still more displeased. That month, on the Qixi festival, Yuanying summoned the princes and senior ministers to a feast, but Prince Zonghan, commissioner of palace secrets Pan Qiao, and Hanlin academician Mao Wenxi did not attend. Yuanying said angrily, "The prince stayed away because Qiao and Wenxi put him up to it!" The next day Yuanying told Jian that Qiao and Wenxi had been sowing discord. Jian was furious and was about to punish them. Yuanying left, and Xi entered. When Jian questioned him, Xi said, "The crown prince is plotting rebellion. He means to summon the generals and princes, confine them with troops, and then strike!" Jian hesitated. Xi asked permission to bring camp troops in as guards. Yuanying had made no preparations, but when he heard that Xi was summoning troops he assumed he was marked for death. He joined the actor An Xixiang and the officer Yu Quanshu in leading Tianwu troops to defend himself, had Qiao and Wenxi seized and flogged, and confined them in their homes; He summoned the generals Xu Yao and Chang Qian to resist Xi. They fought at the Shenwu Gate; Xi was struck by an arrow, fell from his horse, and died. Jian sent Wang Zonghe to suppress him. Yuanying's army broke and fled, and Yuanying hid in the railing of the Leaping Dragon Pool. The next day he came out to beg for food. Shu people recognized him and reported it. Jian sent Zonghan to summon him, but before Zonghan arrived the palace guards killed him. Jian then made his youngest son, the Prince of Zheng Zongyan, crown prince. A white dragon appeared in the river at Qiong Prefecture.
14
使
In year 4, Gao Jichang of Jingnan invaded Wushan in Shu. Jian sent Prince Zongshou, who defeated him at Qutang. In the eighth month he executed Qiannan military commissioner Wang Zongxun. That winter southern tribes raided the frontier. Jian sent Prince Zongfan, who defeated them on the Dadu River. A qilin appeared in Chang Prefecture.
15
殿
In year 5 he built the Shouchang Hall in the Longxing Palace and painted Jian's portrait on its walls; he also built the Futian Pavilion and painted portraits of his meritorious officials. In the eleventh month a great fire burned his palaces. He sent Wang Zongchou and others against Qi, seized its four prefectures of Qin, Feng, Jie, and Cheng, and advanced to Dasanguan Pass. Liang's rebel general Liu Zhijun was in Qi and thereupon defected with his entire clan.
16
殿使殿
In Tongzheng year 1 he sent Wang Zongwan and others with a hundred and twenty thousand troops through Dasanguan against Qi and captured Long Prefecture. In the eighth month he built the Wensi Hall, used fifth-rank regular officials to purchase books for it, and made inner commissioner of palace secrets Mao Wenxi its grand academician. A yellow dragon appeared in the Dachang Pool. In the tenth month he proclaimed a general amnesty. He renamed the coming year Tianhan and changed the state designation to Han.
17
In Tianhan year 1 he executed Liu Zhijun. In the twelfth month he proclaimed a general amnesty, renamed the coming year Guangtian, and restored the state designation to Shu.
18
Yan, whose courtesy name was Huayuan. Jian had eleven sons: the Princes of Wei Zongren, Jian Yuanying, Zhao Zongji, Bin Zonglu, Han Zongzhi, Ju Zongte, Xin Zongjie, Lu Zongding, Xing Zongze, and Xue Zongping. The Prince of Zheng, Zongyan, was the youngest. His mother was Consort Xu the Worthy. Favored through her influence, he was made crown prince, opened the Chongxian bureau and appointed its staff, later renamed the Tiance bureau. Yan had a square face and large mouth, hands that hung past his knees, and eyes so prominent that they could be seen from behind; he was fairly learned and could write florid verse. After Yuanying died, Jian thought Prince Zonglu of Bin resembled him in looks and Prince Zongjie of Xin was the most talented of his sons, and he meant to choose between them. But Consort Xu held exclusive favor, and the aging Jian was senile. She and the eunuch Tang Wenyi coached physiognomists to declare Yan's face the most exalted and urged chief minister Zhang Ge to endorse it, and Yan became crown prince.
19
When Jian died, Yan succeeded him, posthumously titling him Emperor Shenwu Shengwen Xiaode Minghui, with temple name Gaozu and tomb Yongling. Jian's principal consort, Lady Zhou, was titled Empress Zhaosheng and died a few days after him. Yan therefore honored his mother Lady Xu as empress dowager and his younger sister the Pure Consort as grand imperial consort. The empress dowager and grand imperial consort sold offices by edict. From prefect downward, every vacancy drew several bidders, and the highest payment won; and in major cities they opened government shops to seize profits from the people.
20
殿
Yan in his youth was dissolute and entrusted government to the eunuchs Song Guangsi, Guangbao, Jing Runcheng, Wang Chengxiu, Ouyang Huang, Tian Luchou, and others; he took Han Zhao, Pan Zaiying, Gu Zaixun, Yan Xu, and others as intimate companions; he built the Xuanhua Garden with halls named Chongguang, Taiqing, Yanchang, and Huizhen, palaces named Qinghe and Yingxian, pavilions named Jiangzhen, Penglai, and Danxia, the Feiluan Pavilion, and the Ruishou Gate; he also built the Yishen Pavilion, where he drank day and night with his companions and women. Once on the Double Ninth he feasted in the Xuanhua Garden. Prince Zongshou spoke of the fate of the realm and wept as he spoke. Han Zhao and the others said, "The prince is drunk and maudlin!" The companions all mocked him with disrespectful jests, and the hall erupted in laughter. Yan took no notice.
21
使
The people of Shu were wealthy and fond of outings. In the Wangs' later years the fashion was for tiny caps that barely covered the crown and fell off at a bow, called "perilous-brain caps." Yan took this as an ill omen and banned it. Yet Yan favored large caps. When he went out in disguise, people recognized him by his large cap, so he ordered everyone in the realm to wear large caps. He also favored pointed kerchiefs wrapped like cones. The palace women wore golden lotus crowns and Daoist robes. When drunk they removed their caps, bound their hair in topknots, applied rouge, and called the look "drunken makeup," which the whole realm imitated. Once he toured Mount Qingcheng with the empress dowager and grand imperial consort. The palace women's robes were painted with clouds and mist and seemed from afar like drifting immortals. Yan composed the "Ganzhou Tune" describing their immortal aspect. As they went up and down the valleys he would sing it himself while the palace women joined in. The year after Yan's accession he renamed the era Qiande.
22
In the first month of Qiande year 1 he sacrificed to Heaven at the southern suburb, proclaimed a general amnesty, and added the honorific Emperor Shengde Mingxiao.
23
西 耀
In the winter of year 2 he toured north as far as Xixian, with banners, flags, weapons, and armor stretching more than a hundred li. On his return he went upriver from Lang Prefecture in dragon boats and painted barges that dazzled the waters. Every district along the route was levied beyond endurance. In the first month of year 3 he returned to Chengdu.
24
殿
In year 5 he built the Shangqing Palace, molded an image of Prince Zijin and honored him as the Holy Ancestor Emperor Yuchen of the Supreme Way, and molded images of Jian and Yan standing in attendance at his sides; in the main hall he also molded the Mysterious Origin Emperor and the Tang emperors, arrayed the imperial equipage, and performed court before them.
25
使 使 綿 綿 退 綿 殿 綿 輿
In year 6 he appointed Wang Chengxiu military commissioner of Tianxiong. The Tianxiong army was stationed at Qin Prefecture. Chengxiu had gained favor as a eunuch and become palace attendant. His wife Lady Yan was surpassingly beautiful, and Yan took her as a lover. At this time Tang's Emperor Zhuangzong overthrew Liang, and the people of Shu were alarmed. Zhuangzong sent Li Yan on a friendly mission to Shu. Yan accompanied him to court at Shangqing while the capital's gentry and commoners lined the road with curtains, pearls, and jade. Yan saw a realm rich in people and goods but ruled by an arrogant, dissolute Yan, and on returning he urged an attack on Shu. The next year Tang's Prince of Wei Jiji and Guo Chongtao invaded Shu. That year Yan renamed the era Xiankang. Since his accession Yan had hunted yearly at Mount Zilai. That year he also visited Yangpinghua in Peng Prefecture and Sanxue Mountain in Han Prefecture. For the sake of Wang Chengxiu's wife Lady Yan, in the tenth month he visited Qin Prefecture. His ministers urgently remonstrated, but Yan would not listen. At Zitong a great wind tore off roofs and uprooted trees. The grand astrologer said, "This is the Greedy Wolf wind—armies will be defeated and generals slain." Yan took no notice. When Yan reached Miangu and Tang troops entered Shu, he was alarmed and hurried back. Wherever Tang troops went, prefectures and counties welcomed them and submitted. Yan left Wang Zongbi to hold Miangu and sent Wang Zongxun, Zongyan, and Zongyu with troops to resist Tang. Zongxun and the others reached Sanquan and fled at the first sight of Tang forces. Yan ordered Zongbi to execute Zongxun and the others, but Zongbi instead conspired with them and submitted to Tang. Yan returned from Miangu to Chengdu. Officials and palace women welcomed him at Qili Pavilion, and he entered the city mixed with palace women arrayed as a Uighur company. The next day he held court at the Wenhua Hall and wept with his ministers face to face. Zongbi also galloped back from Miangu, mounted the Taixuan Gate, seized and killed Chengdu prefect Han Zhao and the eunuchs Song Guangsi, Jing Runcheng, and Ouyang Huang, boxed their heads, and sent them to Jiji. Yan at once submitted a memorial begging to surrender, and Zongbi moved him to the Tianqi Palace. When the Prince of Wei Jiji reached Chengdu, Yan and his court came out bound, carrying coffins, and surrendered at Qili Pavilion.
26
Zhuangzong summoned Yan to Luoyang and bestowed an edict: "Surely you shall be enfeoffed with territory; surely no man shall be wronged in peril—the three luminaries are above, and not one word shall deceive!" Yan received the edict gladly and set out east with his clan, the former chief ministers Wang Kai, Zhang Ge, Yu Chuansu, Xu Ji, Hanlin academician Li Min, and the families of his generals and aides—several thousand people in all. In the fourth month of Tongguang year 4, at Qinchuan Post Station, Zhuangzong followed the actor Jing Jin's advice and sent the eunuch Xiang Yansi to execute his entire clan. Yan's mother Lady Xu cried out at the execution, "My son surrendered a whole state and is repaid with slaughter—faith and righteousness both cast aside. I know disaster will follow without delay!" Yan's concubine Lady Liu, with hair black as clouds and great beauty, was about to be spared. She said, "State and house are lost—I will not accept disgrace!" She then went to her death.
27
西使
Zongbi, born Wei Hongfu, was adopted by Jian. When Jian attacked Gu Yanhui, Zongbi had often leaked Jian's plans to Yanhui. After Yanhui's defeat, Jian treated him as before. When Jian fell ill near death, Zongbi served as grand preceptor and director of the Secretariat with charge of the Six Armies and assisted in government. After Yan surrendered, Zongbi presented Shu's treasures to the Prince of Wei and Guo Chongtao and asked to be made Xichuan military commissioner. The prince said, "These are my family's things—why present them?" A few days later Chongtao had him killed.
28
退使 使
Zongshou was the son of a common family in Xuzhou. Jian, sharing the surname Wang, adopted him as a son. Zongshou loved learning and was skilled at the zither and go. Retiring by nature, he favored Daoist practices and served Jian as military commissioner of the Zhenjiang army. After Yan succeeded, Zongshou became junior guardian of the heir with court attendance and amused himself refining elixirs and cultivating breath. Yan was dissolute, and only Zongshou often remonstrated sharply. He later became military commissioner of the Wuxin army. When Tang invaded Shu, districts everywhere welcomed and submitted. The Prince of Wei once wrote to recruit him, but Zongshou alone refused. Hearing that Yan had already surrendered with the jade disk, he grieved greatly and followed him east. At Qiyang he bribed the guards and gained an audience. Yan wept until his robe was soaked and said, "Had I followed your counsel earlier, how could this day have come!" After Yan's death Zongshou fled to Mianchi. Hearing that Zhuangzong had been assassinated, he hid in Mount Xiong'er. In Tiancheng year 2 he emerged and went to the capital, submitting a memorial asking permission to bury Yan's clan. Emperor Ming praised his loyalty, appointed him acting military secretary of the Baoyi army, enfeoffed him as Duke Shunzheng of Yan, and permitted burial with feudal honors. Zongshou recovered the eighteen coffins of the Wang house and buried them at Sanzhao Village south of Chang'an.
29
Alas, since Qin and Han scholars have often spoken of auspicious omens, and even skilled debaters cannot dispel the delusion. When I read the Book of Shu, I find that tortoises, dragons, qilin, phoenixes, zouyu, and the other omens called the king's auspicious signs all appeared in that state without exception. How strange! Yet examine why the Wang house rose, fell, succeeded, and failed, and the answer becomes clear. If one Wang house alone seems insufficient proof, then look at whether the realm was governed or in turmoil at the time, and the answer becomes clear.
30
西 西 西西
The dragon is divine because it is unseen, and fulfills its will by rising on clouds and traversing Heaven. Now it lies exposed for all to see—that is not divine; it does not ascend to Heaven but appears in the water below—that is a failure of its proper role. And how numerous they are—this can only be called an ill omen! The phoenix is a bird that keeps far from mankind. In antiquity Shun governed the realm. When his government was accomplished and the people were pleased, he ordered Kui to compose music. When the music was harmonious, birds and beasts hearing it danced with joy. At that time the phoenix happened to arrive, and Shun's scribes recorded it as a blessing. Later ages took the phoenix's coming as a sign of righteous rule. Afterward the phoenix appeared again and again, sometimes under mediocre rulers and perverse government, sometimes amid peril, ruin, and great chaos—was that truly an auspicious omen? The qilin is a beast that keeps far from mankind. In antiquity Duke Ai of Lu went hunting, captured one, and did not recognize it. He had sought it out—it did not come forth of its own accord. That is why Confucius wrote in the "Spring and Autumn Annals" that he "obtained a qilin on a western hunt"—he was satirizing the event. "Western hunt"—not because the hunt was far away; "obtained a qilin"—he detested that everything was taken. A hunt must record the place, but Duke Ai ranged over so much territory that not every place could be named, so Confucius wrote "west" to encompass them all, meaning the duke reached everywhere in the state's west. The qilin is a beast men rarely recognize. This shows the duke exhausted mountains and drained marshes in taking all, until even beasts he did not recognize were hunted down—hence Confucius was satirizing him. After the sage had passed away, heterodox teachings arose that made the qilin the king's auspicious omen and attached to it mandate texts, prophecies, and weird marvels. The phoenix once appeared under Shun and was taken as an omen—there is still something to be said for that. But when it later appeared in chaotic ages, one can see it was no omen. As for the qilin, in well-governed ages such as those of Yao, Shun, Yu, Tang, Wen, Wu, and the Duke of Zhou, it never appeared. Its one recorded appearance came in a chaotic age—who then could call it an omen? The tortoise is a dark creature found in countless muddy streams and marshes. That the dead are prized by divination officers is simply because use has its proper occasion. Yet the Dai Clan Rites treats its presence in the palace moat as an auspicious omen hard for kings to obtain. The Dai Rites was pieced together from many schools, and its errors are many. As for the zouyu, I do not know what creature it is. The Odes says, "Alas, the zouyu!" Jia Yi held that zou meant King Wen's park; and yu meant the park officer. In Jia Yi's time the explanation was thus. Then is treating it as a beast an idea from more recent times?
31
Breaking another's delusion is hard to dispute while belief is firm. Wait until doubt arises, then press the attack—that may succeed. Qilin, phoenix, tortoise, and dragon—the king's auspicious omens—all appeared in the Five Dynasties era and moreover gathered in Shu. Even those fond of auspicious-omen theories must find this doubtful. Attack the belief through what is doubtful, and perhaps the deluded will have cause to reflect.
32
西使
(According to the Book of Former Shu, the Chart of the Course of Fate, and the Record of the Nine States, Jian entered Chengdu in Tang's Dashun year 2 as Xichuan military commissioner, established his title in the ninth month of Tianfu year 7, and changed the era name to Wucheng in the first month of the following year. This chronology is now taken as fixed. Only the Old History of the Five Dynasties, which says he entered Chengdu in Longji year 1 and established his title and changed the era in Tianyou year 5, is in error. As for Shu's fall in Later Tang's Tongguang year 3, all books agree. From Dashun year 2 to Tongguang year 3, thirty-five years in all.)]〉
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →