← Back to 資治通鑑

卷8 秦紀三

Volume 8 Qin Records 3

Chapter 8 of 資治通鑑 · Comprehensive Mirror in Aid of Governance
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 8
Next Chapter →
1
__FORCETOC__
2
From Zhaoyang Dahuanluo through Emao Dunzang—two years in all.
3
1 ----
1. In the tenth month of winter, Sishui supervisor Ping besieged the Duke of Pei at Feng. The duke marched out, routed him, and left Yong Chi to hold the city. In the eleventh month the Duke of Pei marched on Xue. The grand administrator of Sishui, Zhuang, was beaten at Xue and fled to Qi; the Duke of Pei's Left Major overtook and killed him.
4
2
2. Zhou Zhang marched out through the pass and camped at Caoyang for more than two months before Zhang Han caught up and routed him. He fell back on Mianchi; after a fortnight Zhang Han attacked and shattered his army. Zhou Wen killed himself; his troops would fight no more.
5
使使使
Wu Shu besieged Xingyang. Li You, grand administrator of Sanchuan, held the city, and Shu could not bring it down. Chu general Tian Zang and his officers took counsel: "Zhou Zhang's army is already destroyed. Qin will be here any day. We cannot take Xingyang. When Qin comes we are finished. Better leave a skeleton force at the walls and march every able man to meet them. The fake king is proud and knows nothing of command. He is no partner in counsel—we will lose everything." They forged a royal order, killed Wu Shu, and sent his head to King Chen. King Chen sent envoys with the seal of Chu grand minister and made Tian Zang supreme general.
6
使西 ----
Tian Zang left Li Gui and the other generals at Xingyang and marched west with his best men to meet Qin at Aocang. Tian Zang fell; his army was destroyed. Zhang Han pressed on, struck Li Gui and his fellows below Xingyang, broke them, and killed them all. Deng Shuo of Yangcheng held Tan with his troops; one of Zhang Han's lieutenants routed him. Wu Feng of Zhi held Xu; Zhang Han broke him there. Both hosts broke and fled to Chen. King Chen had Deng Shuo executed.
7
3 祿 ----
3. The Second Emperor berated Li Si again and again: "You sit among the Three Excellencies—how did you let rebels run wild like this!" Li Si was terrified. Rank and emolument weighed on him; he saw no way out. He bent to the emperor's mood and wrote back: "A true sovereign must practice stern oversight and blame. That is why Shenzi says: 'To hold the realm and yet not do as you please is to wear the world as shackles.' Nothing more: if you cannot oversee and blame, but instead wear yourself out for the people like Yao or Yu, the throne becomes a chain. He who will not master Shen and Han's clear methods, who will not walk the path of oversight and blame, but seeks only his own ease across the realm— who only breaks his body and drains his mind to serve the masses is a slave to the people, not a shepherd of the realm. What honor is there in that? The enlightened ruler practices oversight and blame, decides alone above, and keeps power from his ministers. Then he can stamp out the road of benevolence, silence every remonstrance, and follow his whim without a soul daring to resist. Then ministers and people will have no breath to spare for fault or plot—who would dare dream of rebellion?" The Second Emperor was delighted. Oversight and blame grew harsher still. Heavy taxers were called good officials; prolific executioners, loyal ministers. Half the highways were flogging-grounds; the markets filled with corpses day by day. Qin trembled—and dreamed of revolt.
8
4 使 使 ----
4. Li Liang of Zhao had pacified Changshan and returned to report to the king of Zhao. The king sent him out again to take Taiyuan. At Shiyi, Qin blocked the Jingxing pass; he could not advance. A Qin general forged a letter in the Second Emperor's name to win Li Liang over. Li Liang took the letter but did not trust it. He went back to Handan and asked for reinforcements. On the road he met the king of Zhao's elder sister out drinking, with a hundred-odd riders. Li Liang mistook her for the king and bowed in the dust by the roadside. She was drunk and did not know he was a general. She sent a rider to apologize. Li Liang had always held high rank. He rose, burning with shame before his men. One attendant said: "The realm rebels against Qin. The able man rises first. The king of Zhao has always ranked below you. Now his sister would not even step down from her carriage—pursue her and kill her!" Li Liang already held Qin's letter and had been weighing defection. This insult decided him. He sent men after the king's sister, killed her, and marched on Handan. Handan was taken unawares. He killed the king of Zhao and Shao Sao. Many in Zhao were Zhang Er's and Chen Yu's eyes and ears; for that the two alone escaped.
9
5 使 ----
5. Qin Jia of Chen, Zhu Jishi of Fuli, and others rose and besieged the grand administrator of Donghai at Tan. King Chen heard and sent Lord Wuping Pan as general to oversee the army at Tan. Qin Jia refused the order, declared himself Grand Marshal, and scorned serving under Lord Wuping. He told the officers: "Lord Wuping is young and knows nothing of war. Pay him no heed!" He forged a royal order and killed Lord Wuping Pan.
10
6 西 ----
6. The Second Emperor sent chief clerks Sima Xin and Dong Yi to assist Zhang Han against the rebels. Zhang Han had already broken Wu Feng. He struck Lord Fang, pillar of state of Chen, and killed him. He pressed west against Zhang He's army. King Chen came out in person to oversee the fight. Zhang He fell.
11
7
7. In the twelfth month King Chen went to Ruyin. On his return, at Xiachengfu, his charioteer Zhuang Jia killed him and surrendered. When Chen She first became king, every old friend came to cling to him. His father-in-law came too. Chen treated him as one guest among many—a long bow, no full obeisance. The father-in-law raged: "You ride rebellion to a royal title, yet scorn your elders—you will not last!" He left without farewell. Chen knelt to apologize. The old man would not turn back. Guests grew bolder at every visit, retailing Chen's old life in the fields. Someone warned him: "These guests are fools. Their loose tongues cheapen your majesty." Chen had the man beheaded. Every old friend slipped away. After that, none remained close to Chen. Chen made Zhu Fang Director of the Center and Hu Wu Director of Faults to oversee his ministers. Generals returning from conquered lands were bound and punished if their reports displeased him. He mistook harshness for loyalty. Those he disliked he punished himself, without troubling the clerks. The generals would not stand by him. That is why he fell.
12
Chen's old palace attendant, General Lü Chen, raised the Servant Army at Xinyang, retook Chen, killed Zhuang Jia, and made Chu of Chen again. They buried King Chen at Dang with the posthumous name Hidden King.
13
----
Earlier Chen had ordered Song Liu of Zhi to pacify Nanyang and enter Wu Pass. Liu had taken Nanyang. When he heard Chen was dead, Nanyang went back to Qin. Song Liu surrendered with his army. The Second Emperor had him torn apart by chariots as a warning.
14
8使 ----
8. Zhou Shi of Wei marched to take Feng and Pei and sent to win over Yong Chi. Yong Chi had never wished to serve the Duke of Pei. He surrendered Feng to Wei. The Duke of Pei attacked and could not take it.
15
9
9. Zhang Er and Chen Yu of Zhao gathered their scattered men—several tens of thousands—and struck Li Liang. Li Liang was beaten and fled to Zhang Han.
16
----
A guest told Zhang Er and Chen Yu: "You are strangers in a strange land, clinging to Zhao. You cannot stand alone. Set up a scion of Zhao, serve him with loyalty, and you may win through." They found Zhao Xie. In the first month of spring they made Xie king of Zhao and held court at Xindu.
17
10 使使 ----
10. Ning Jun of Dongyang and Qin Jia, hearing Chen's army was broken, made Jing Ju king of Chu, marched to Fangyu, and meant to strike Qin below Dingtao; they sent Gongsun Qing to Qi to join forces and advance together. The king of Qi said: "Chen was beaten in battle. We do not know if he lives. How dare Chu set up a king without asking us!" Gongsun Qing said: "Qi never asked Chu before making a king. Why should Chu ask Qi? Chu rose first. Chu ought to give orders under Heaven." Tian Dan killed Gongsun Qing.
18
11
11. Qin's Left and Right Commandants attacked Chen again and took it. General Lü fled, rallied his scattered men, met the bandit lord of Fan, Qing Bu, struck the Left and Right Commandants, broke them at Qingbo, and made Chu of Chen once more.
19
使----
Qing Bu was from Liu, of the Ying clan. Convicted, he was tattooed and sent as a convict laborer to Mount Li. Tens of thousands labored at Mount Li. Bu made common cause with every gang leader and strong man there, then led his band south to the Yangtze and became a river pirate. Wu Rui, magistrate of Poyang, held the loyalty of the river world and was called Lord of Fan. Bu went to him with several thousand men at his back. Lord of Fan gave him his daughter in marriage and set him at the head of the army against Qin.
20
12 西西 ----
12. King Jing Ju of Chu held Liu. The Duke of Pei went to join him. Zhang Liang too had gathered a hundred-odd youths and was bound for Jing Ju. On the road he met the Duke of Pei and attached himself to him instead. The Duke of Pei made Zhang Liang Stable General. Zhang Liang spoke again and again from the Grand Duke's Art of War. The duke delighted in it and often followed his counsel. When Zhang Liang spoke to anyone else, none understood. Zhang Liang said: "The Duke of Pei is Heaven's chosen!" So he followed and never left. The Duke of Pei and Zhang Liang went together to Jing Ju and asked for troops to retake Feng. Meanwhile Zhang Han's marshal, Shi the Second, was marching north to pacify Chu, sacked Xiang, and reached Dang. Ning Jun of Dongyang and the Duke of Pei marched west, fought west of Xiao, were beaten, fell back, and rallied at Liu. In the second month, he attacked Dang; in three days he took it. He gathered six thousand troops from Dang; together with his existing force, he had nine thousand men. In the third month, he attacked Xiayi and captured it. He turned back to attack Feng but could not capture it.
21
13 西 西 使使西 ----
13. Zhao Ping of Guangling was campaigning for King Chen against Guangling but had not yet captured it. Hearing that King Chen had been defeated and was fleeing, and that Zhang Han was approaching, he crossed the Yangzi, forged an order in King Chen’s name, and appointed Xiang Liang Grand Pillar of State of Chu, saying: “The lands east of the Yangzi are settled—lead your troops west at once to attack Qin!” Liang then crossed the river westward with eight thousand men. Hearing that Chen Ying had already captured Dongyang, he sent envoys to propose a joint advance west. Chen Ying had been a clerk to the magistrate of Dongyang; living in the county seat, he was known for trustworthiness and prudence and was called an elder. The young men of Dongyang killed their magistrate, gathered twenty thousand men, and wished to make Ying their king. Ying’s mother said to him: “Since I married into your family, I have never heard of any distinguished ancestor among your forebears. To rise suddenly to great fame is ill-omened; it is better to place yourself under someone else’s leadership. If things succeed, you may still be enfeoffed as a marquis; if they fail, you can escape easily—you will not be the name the world singles out.” Ying then dared not become king and told his officers: “The Xiang clan has been a military house for generations, famous in Chu; to undertake a great enterprise now, we must have the right commander. If I rely on a great house, Qin’s destruction is assured!” His troops agreed, and he submitted his forces to Liang.
22
14 西
14. After Ying Bu had defeated the Qin army, he led his troops east; hearing that Xiang Liang had crossed the Huai westward, Bu and General Pu both placed their troops under his command. Xiang Liang’s forces totaled some sixty or seventy thousand men; he encamped at Xiapi. Jing Ju and Qin Jia encamped east of Pengcheng, intending to block Liang. Liang told his officers: “King Chen was first to raise the revolt; the fighting went badly, and we do not know where he is. Now Qin Jia has betrayed King Chen and enthroned Jing Ju—this is treason!” He advanced to attack Qin Jia; Qin Jia’s army was defeated and fled. Pursuing them to Huling, Jia turned to fight. In a single day Jia was killed and his army surrendered; Jing Ju fled and was killed in Liang’s territory.
23
西 使
Liang had absorbed Qin Jia’s army, encamped at Huling, and was preparing to march west. When Zhang Han’s army reached Li, Xiang Liang sent the detached generals Zhu Jishi and Yu Fanjun to fight them. Yu Fanjun was killed; Zhu Jishi’s army was defeated and fled to Huling. Liang then marched into Xue and executed Zhu Jishi.
24
The Lord of Pei went with a little over a hundred horsemen to see Liang; Liang gave him five thousand infantry and ten commanders of the fifth rank. The Lord of Pei returned, led his troops against Feng, and captured it. Yong Chi fled to Wei.
25
使
Xiang Liang sent Xiang Yu on a separate mission to attack Xiangcheng; the city held firm and would not fall; once it fell, he buried the defenders alive and returned to report.
26
Hearing that King Chen was certainly dead, Liang summoned the detached generals to a council at Xue; the Lord of Pei went as well. Fan Zeng of Juqi, seventy years old, had long lived in retirement and delighted in clever stratagems; he went to advise Xiang Liang: “Chen Sheng’s defeat was inevitable. Of the Six States Qin destroyed, Chu was the most blameless. Ever since King Huai entered Qin and never returned, the people of Chu have pitied him to this day. Hence Lord Nan of Chu said: ‘Though Chu has but three households, it will be Chu that destroys Qin. ’ Chen Sheng was first to raise the revolt yet did not restore a descendant of Chu and made himself ruler—such power cannot endure. You have risen east of the Yangzi; the Chu commanders who have sprung up everywhere flock to you because you are a Chu general for generations and can restore a descendant of Chu.” Xiang Liang agreed and found Xin, grandson of King Huai of Chu, among the people—he had been tending sheep. in summer, the sixth month, enthroned him as King Huai of Chu, to satisfy popular expectation. Chen Ying became Grand Pillar of State, received five districts as his fief, and joined King Huai at the capital in Xuyi. Xiang Liang styled himself Lord Martial and Faithful.
27
使西 ----
Zhang Liang urged Xiang Liang: “You have already restored Chu’s royal line; among Han’s princes, Cheng, Lord of Hengyang, is the worthiest and should be made king—this will strengthen your party.” Xiang Liang sent Zhang Liang to find Han Cheng, enthroned him as King of Han, made Zhang Liang Minister over the Masses, and with the King of Han and a little over a thousand men campaigned west into Han territory, capturing several cities that Qin soon recaptured; they ranged back and forth as roving troops in Yingchuan.
28
15 使
15. After Zhang Han had defeated King Chen, he advanced to attack the King of Wei at Linji. The King of Wei sent Zhou Shi to seek aid from Qi and Chu. King Dan of Qi and the Chu general Xiang Ta both led troops with Zhou Shi to rescue Wei. Zhang Han attacked by night with gags in the soldiers’ mouths, routed the Qi and Chu armies below Linji, and killed the King of Qi and Zhou Shi. King Jiu of Wei negotiated surrender for his people’s sake; when terms were agreed, he burned himself to death. His younger brother Bao fled to Chu; King Huai gave Wei Bao several thousand men, and he campaigned again through Wei territory. Tian Rong of Qi gathered his brother Dan’s remaining troops, fled east to Dong’e, and Zhang Han pursued and besieged him. When the people of Qi heard that King Dan was dead, they enthroned Jia, younger brother of the former King Jian of Qi; Tian Jiao became chancellor and Jiao’s younger brother Jian became general, to resist the allied lords.
29
西 使
In autumn, the seventh month, there were torrential rains. Lord Martial and Faithful marched to attack Kangfu; hearing that Tian Rong was in peril, he turned and defeated Zhang Han’s army below Dong’e; Zhang Han fled west. Tian Rong led his troops east back into Qi. Lord Martial and Faithful alone pursued north; he sent Xiang Yu and the Lord of Pei on separate missions to attack Chengyang and put it to the sword. The Chu army encamped east of Puyang, fought Zhang Han again, and defeated him again. Zhang Han rallied, held Puyang, and ringed it with moats. The Lord of Pei and Xiang Yu left and attacked Dingtao.
30
使使 ----
In the eighth month, Tian Rong attacked and drove out King Jia of Qi; Jia fled to Chu and Tian Jiao fled to Zhao. Tian Jian had earlier gone to aid Zhao and therefore stayed there, not daring to return. Tian Rong enthroned Dan’s son Shi as King of Qi; Rong became chancellor, Tian Heng became general, and they pacified Qi. Zhang Han’s forces grew stronger; Xiang Liang repeatedly sent envoys urging Qi and Zhao to raise troops and join him against Zhang Han. Tian Rong said: “If Chu kills Tian Jia and Zhao kills Jiao and Jian, then I will send troops.” Chu and Zhao refused. Tian Rong was enraged and in the end refused to send troops.
31
16
16. Zhao Gao, Director of the Palace, relied on imperial favor and acted arbitrarily; he executed many people over private grudges. Fearing that ministers reporting at court would speak of this, he persuaded the Second Emperor: “The Son of Heaven is held august because men hear his voice while ministers cannot see his face. Moreover Your Majesty is still young and may not yet understand all affairs thoroughly. If you sit in court now and your rebukes or recommendations are ever improper, you will be exposed before the ministers—this is not how to display divine wisdom to the realm. Your Majesty would do better to withdraw deep into the inner palace; with me and the attendants-in-ordinary versed in law you can await business and weigh each matter as it comes. Then ministers will not dare present doubtful matters, and the realm will call you a sage ruler.” The Second Emperor adopted his plan, stopped holding court and seeing ministers, and constantly remained in the inner palace. Zhao Gao held power as attendant-in-ordinary; all affairs were decided by Zhao Gao.
32
使 使
Gao heard that Li Si was speaking of this and went to the chancellor: “Bandits east of the passes are numerous; the emperor is in distress, yet corvée is increased, Epang Palace is being built, and useless things like dogs and horses are gathered. I wish to remonstrate, but my rank is too low—this is truly your affair, my lord. Why do you not remonstrate?” Li Si said: “Indeed—I have long wished to speak. Now the emperor does not hold court but constantly dwells deep in the palace. What I would say cannot be relayed by others. I wish to see him but have no opportunity.” Zhao Gao said: “If you truly wish to remonstrate, let me secure an audience for you and inform you.” Zhao Gao waited until the Second Emperor was feasting at leisure with women before him, then sent word to the chancellor: “His Majesty has leisure; you may report.” The chancellor came to the palace gate and requested audience. This happened three times. The Second Emperor said angrily: “I often have much leisure, yet the chancellor does not come; just when I am privately feasting, the chancellor keeps coming to report! Does the chancellor despise me, or is he trying to constrain me?” Zhao Gao then said: “The chancellor shared in the plot at Shaxiu. Your Majesty is already emperor, yet the chancellor’s honors have not increased—his intent is surely to carve out territory and make himself a king. Had Your Majesty not asked me, I would not have dared to speak. The chancellor’s eldest son Li You is governor of Sanchuan; the Chu rebels Chen Sheng and the rest are all from districts neighboring the chancellor’s fief—therefore the Chu rebels travel openly, and when they pass Sanchuan’s cities the governor will not attack. I have heard their correspondence goes back and forth; I have not obtained proof, and therefore did not dare report it. Moreover the chancellor acts outside the palace, and his authority outweighs Your Majesty’s.” The Second Emperor agreed, wished to move against the chancellor, but feared the evidence was not firm; he first sent men to investigate whether the San River governor had colluded with the rebels.
33
使
When Li Si heard of this, he memorialized the throne on Zhao Gao’s faults: “Gao wields profit and punishment at will and is no different from Your Majesty. Formerly Tian Chang was chancellor to Duke Jian of Qi, stole his favor and authority, won the people below and the ministers above, and finally assassinated Duke Jian and seized Qi—this all the world knows. Now Gao harbors perverse designs and conduct that threatens rebellion; his private wealth rivals the Tian clan’s hold on Qi. He is insatiably greedy, his power ranks just below the throne, his desires know no limit, and he usurps Your Majesty’s prestige and authority—his intent is like Han□ as chancellor to Lord An of Han. If Your Majesty does not act, I fear he will surely rebel.” The Second Emperor said: “What nonsense! Gao is a former palace eunuch, yet he does not indulge himself in comfort or change his heart in danger; he has cultivated his conduct and risen to this post through loyalty and trustworthiness. I truly esteem him. Why do you suspect him? Besides, if I do not entrust affairs to Lord Zhao, whom should I employ? Lord Zhao is refined, incorruptible, and forceful; he understands men below and suits me above—you must not doubt him!” The Second Emperor had long favored and trusted Gao; fearing Li Si would kill him, he told Zhao Gao in private. Gao said: “The chancellor’s only worry is me. Once I am dead, he will do what Tian Chang did.”
34
At this time rebels grew ever more numerous, while within the passes men were pressed into service and sent east to fight rebels without cease. The right chancellor Feng Quji, the left chancellor Li Si, and General Feng Jie remonstrated: “Rebels east of the passes have risen everywhere; Qin sends troops in pursuit and kills vast numbers, yet they still do not stop. Rebels multiply because frontier service, canal transport, relay transport, and corvée labor are crushing, and taxes are heavy. We ask that work on Epang Palace be halted for now and that frontier garrisons and transport on all sides be reduced.” The Second Emperor said: “Whoever is honored with possessing the realm may indulge his will to the utmost. The ruler is august and makes the laws clear; those below dare not do wrong—thus he controls the empire. The rulers of Yu and Xia, though honored as Sons of Heaven, personally endured poverty to yield to the people—what need had they of law! Moreover, the late emperor rose from the feudal lords and united the realm; once it was settled, he drove back the four barbarians to secure the borders and built palaces to display his triumph—and you see his achievements taking shape. I have reigned barely two years, yet rebels rise everywhere and you cannot stop them—and now you wish to abandon the late emperor’s works! Above, you fail the late emperor; below, you fail me—how can you hold office!” He handed Quji, Si, and Jie over to the law officers and had them prosecuted on other charges. Quji and Jie killed themselves; only Li Si was imprisoned. The Second Emperor entrusted the case to Zhao Gao, charged Li Si and his son You with rebellion, and had their entire clans and retainers arrested. Zhao Gao tried Li Si and flogged him more than a thousand times; unable to bear the pain, he falsely confessed.
35
使 使
Li Si did not die because he trusted in his eloquence and his achievements and knew he had no heart of rebellion; he hoped to submit a memorial and win the Second Emperor’s pardon. He then memorialized from prison: “Your servant has served as chancellor governing the people for more than thirty years. When Qin’s territory was narrow and confined, it did not exceed a thousand li, and its troops numbered only several hundred thousand. I exhausted my slight talents, secretly sent plotting ministers, supplied them with gold and jade, and had them go to persuade the feudal lords; secretly repaired armor and weapons, rectified government and teaching, assigned offices to fighting men, and honored meritorious ministers; and so in the end coerced Han, weakened Wei, broke Yan and Zhao, extinguished Qi and Chu, united the Six States, captured their kings, and established Qin as Son of Heaven. I also drove off the Hu and Mo in the north and settled Northern Yue in the south, showing Qin’s strength. I further devised reforms, standardized bushels, weights, and measures, and spread written ordinances throughout the realm to establish Qin’s name. All these are my crimes; I ought to have died long ago! Your Majesty was gracious enough to use me to the full, and only thus have I survived until now. I beg Your Majesty to consider this!” When the memorial was submitted, Zhao Gao had the clerk discard it and not present it, saying: “How may a prisoner submit a memorial!”
36
使使 使 使 使 ----
Zhao Gao had more than ten retainers pose as censors, petitioners, and palace attendants and repeatedly re-examine Li Si; each time Si answered truthfully, they had him flogged again. Later, when the Second Emperor sent men to verify the case, Li Si thought it was the same as before and would not change his testimony. He confessed; the sentence was reported to the throne. The Second Emperor was pleased and said: “But for Lord Zhao, I would nearly have been betrayed by the chancellor!” When the men the Second Emperor had sent to investigate San River governor You arrived, Chu troops had already attacked and killed him. When the envoys arrived, the case was being handed to subordinate officers; Gao fabricated charges of rebellion to fit the case, imposed the full five punishments on Li Si, and sentenced him to be cut in two at the waist in the Xianyang marketplace. Li Si came out of prison and was seized together with his second son. He turned to his second son and said: “I wish I could go with you again, leading a yellow dog out the eastern gate of Shangcai to chase hares—how could that be now!” Father and son wept together, and all three clans were exterminated. The Second Emperor then made Zhao Gao chancellor; great and small affairs were all decided by him.
37
17西 使使使
17. Xiang Liang had already defeated Zhang Han at Dong’e, marched west to Dingtao, and again defeated Qin forces. Xiang Yu and the Lord of Pei again fought Qin at Yongqiu, routed them, and beheaded Li You. Xiang Liang grew increasingly contemptuous of Qin and showed arrogance. Song Yi remonstrated: “When the general grows arrogant and the soldiers slack after victory—defeat follows. Your soldiers are already growing slack while Qin’s forces grow daily—I fear this for you, my lord.” Xiang Liang would not listen. Yu then sent Song Yi on a mission to Qi; on the road he met the Qi envoy Lord Xian of Gaoling and said: “Are you going to see Lord Xinwu?” He said: “Yes.” Song Yi said: “I predict Lord Xinwu’s army will surely be defeated. Go slowly and you will escape death; go swiftly and you will meet disaster.” The Second Emperor mustered all troops to reinforce Zhang Han; he routed the Chu army at Dingtao and Xiang Liang was killed.
38
西
Rain fell continuously from the seventh month through the ninth. Xiang Yu and the Lord of Pei attacked Waihuang without success, withdrew, and attacked Chenliu. Hearing that Lord Xinwu was dead, the troops were afraid; they marched east with General Lü Chen and moved King Huai from Xuyi to Pengcheng as his capital. Lü Chen encamped east of Pengcheng, Xiang Yu west of Pengcheng, and the Lord of Pei at Dang.
39
Wei Bao took more than twenty cities of Wei, and King Huai of Chu made him king of Wei.
40
----
In the intercalary ninth month, King Huai of Chu combined the armies of Lü Chen and Xiang Yu and took command himself; he made the Lord of Pei magistrate of Dang commandery, enfeoffed him as Marquis of Wu’an, and put him in command of Dang troops; he enfeoffed Xiang Yu as Marquis of Chang’an with the title Lord of Lu; he made Lü Chen Minister of the Masses and his father Lü Qing Grand Minister.
41
18 鹿 鹿 鹿
18. Zhang Han, having defeated Xiang Liang, thought Chu’s forces were no longer a concern; he crossed the river north, attacked Zhao, and routed them. He marched to Handan, relocated all its people to Henei, and leveled its walls. Zhang Er and King Xie of Zhao fled into Julu; Wang Li besieged them. Chen Yu gathered Changshan troops in the north, raised several tens of thousands of men, and encamped north of Julu. Zhang Han’s army lay south of Julu at Jiyuan. Zhao repeatedly asked Chu for aid.
42
Lord Xian of Gaoling was in Chu; he saw the King of Chu and said: “Song Yi predicted that Lord Xinwu’s army would be defeated, and within days it was. He foresaw defeat before battle was joined—this may be called understanding warfare.” The king summoned Song Yi to discuss strategy, was greatly pleased, and made him supreme general. Xiang Yu was made second general and Fan Zeng last general, to rescue Zhao. All subordinate generals were placed under Song Yi, who was styled “Lordling Champion.”
43
西 西 西
Earlier, King Huai of Chu had agreed with his generals: “Whoever first enters and settles Guanzhong shall be king.” At that time Qin was strong and always pursued defeated foes; none of the generals thought it profitable to enter Guanzhong first. Only Xiang Yu, resenting Qin for killing Xiang Liang, was eager to march west into Guanzhong with the Lord of Pei. King Huai’s veteran generals all said: “Xiang Yu is fierce, violent, and treacherous. He once attacked Xiangcheng and buried every survivor alive; everywhere he passes he leaves nothing but ruin. Moreover Chu has repeatedly attacked and failed; King Chen and Xiang Liang both met defeat. It is better to send a worthy elder west in the name of righteousness to win over the elders of Qin. The people of Qin have long suffered under their ruler; if a worthy elder goes who does not brutalize them, the region should submit. Xiang Yu must not be sent; only the Lord of Pei, who has always been magnanimous and worthy, should go.” King Huai therefore refused Xiang Yu and sent the Lord of Pei west to seize territory, gathering the scattered troops of King Chen and Xiang Liang to attack Qin.
44
The Lord of Pei marched by way of Dang to Yangcheng and Gangli, attacked Qin fortified camps, and broke two of their armies.
45
1----
1. In winter, the tenth month, the Qi general Tian Du broke with Tian Rong and aided Chu in rescuing Zhao.
46
2----
2. The Lord of Pei defeated the commandant of Dong commandery at Chengwu.
47
3 西 使
3. Song Yi reached Anyang and halted forty-six days without advancing. Xiang Yu said: “Qin is pressing the siege of Zhao; we ought to cross the river at once; Chu strikes from without and Zhao responds from within—the Qin army is sure to be broken.” Song Yi said: “Not so. The gadfly that strikes an ox cannot be used to crush lice. If Qin attacks Zhao and wins, its troops will be weary and we can take advantage of their exhaustion; if it does not win, we march west with drums beating and will surely take Qin. Therefore it is better to let Qin and Zhao fight first. In wearing armor and wielding sharp weapons, I am not your equal; but in sitting and plotting strategy, you are not my equal.” He then ordered the army: “Any man fierce as a tiger, ruthless as a sheep, greedy as a wolf, or so overbearing he cannot be commanded—all shall be beheaded!” He then sent his son Song Xiang as envoy to Qi, personally escorted him to Wuyan, and held a grand feast with wine.” The weather turned cold and rain poured down; the troops froze and went hungry. Xiang Yu said, “We were to unite and strike Qin, yet we have lingered here without advancing. This year the people are starving and poor; the men eat half rations of beans, the army has no grain in sight, yet you hold grand banquets; you will not cross the river to draw on Zhao's supplies and join Zhao in attacking Qin, yet talk of ‘waiting until they are worn out.’ With Qin's might against a newly founded Zhao, Zhao is sure to fall. Once Zhao falls, Qin only grows stronger—what ‘exhaustion’ is there to reap! Moreover our army has just been beaten; the king cannot sit at ease, has swept the realm and entrusted everything to you—the fate of the state hangs on this one move. You show no care for the troops yet indulge yourself—you are no true servant of the state!"
48
使 使 使----
In the eleventh month, Xiang Yu attended General Song Yi at dawn and beheaded him in his tent. He proclaimed to the army, “Song Yi conspired with Qi against Chu; King Huai secretly ordered Ji to kill him!” At that time every general submitted in awe; none dared resist, and all said, “Your house first raised Chu; now you have put down treason.” They then jointly made Yu acting supreme general. He sent men after Song Yi's son; overtaking him in Qi, they killed him. He sent Huan Chu to report to King Huai. King Huai then appointed Yu supreme general.
49
4 滿----
4 In the twelfth month, the Duke of Pei marched to Li, met Marquis Wu of Gang, took over his force of more than four thousand men, and absorbed them; then joined Wei generals Huang Xin and Wu Man to attack the Qin army and routed it.
50
5
5 An, grandson of the former King Jian of Qi, came down from Jibei to follow Xiang Yu in rescuing Zhao.
51
鹿 鹿使 使 使
Zhang Han built a supply road along the river to feed Wang Li. Wang Li's troops were well supplied and pressed hard on Julu. Inside Julu food ran out and troops were few; Zhang Er repeatedly sent for Chen Yu to advance. Chen Yu judged his force too small to face Qin and did not dare move forward. After months Zhang Er flew into a rage at Chen Yu and sent Zhang Yan and Chen Ze to rebuke him: “We were sworn friends; now the king and I face death any day, yet you hold tens of thousands of men and will not save us—what happened to dying for each other! If you still trust us, why not march against the Qin army and die together—perhaps one or two in ten might survive.” Chen Yu said, “I reckon an advance still cannot save Zhao—it would only wipe out the army for nothing. The reason I do not die with you is that I mean to avenge the King of Zhao and Lord Zhang against Qin. To die together now is only to throw meat to a starving tiger—what good would it do!” Zhang Yan and Chen Ze insisted on dying together; Chen Yu sent them with five thousand men to probe the Qin army—they were wiped out to a man. By then Qi and Yan had come to Zhao's aid; Zhang Ao too gathered more than ten thousand men from Dai in the north—all encamped near Chen Yu and none dared attack Qin.
52
鹿 鹿
Xiang Yu had killed the Young Lord Champion and awed all Chu; he sent Lord Dangyang and General Bo with twenty thousand men across the river toward Julu. After minor successes they severed Zhang Han's supply line, and Wang Li's army ran short of food. Chen Yu again asked for reinforcements. Xiang Yu then brought his whole army across the river, scuttled the boats, smashed the pots, burned the camps, and allowed only three days' rations—showing the men they must fight to the death with no thought of return. On arrival he besieged Wang Li; meeting the Qin army he fought nine engagements, crushed them, and Zhang Han withdrew. Only then did the allied armies dare press the attack; they killed Su Jiao and captured Wang Li; She Jian refused to surrender and burned himself alive. At that time the Chu army led all the allied forces. More than a dozen allied camps had come to relieve Julu, yet none dared commit their troops. When Chu attacked Qin, the allied generals only watched from their walls. Every Chu soldier fought as ten; their battle cries shook heaven and earth, and every man in the allied armies trembled with fear. After defeating the Qin army, Xiang Yu summoned the allied generals. Entering his camp gate, the allied generals all crawled forward on their knees and none dared look up at him. From this Xiang Yu became supreme commander of the allied armies. All the allies placed themselves under his command.
53
鹿 ----
Then King Xie of Zhao and Zhang Er were able to leave Julu and thank the allied armies. Zhang Er met Chen Yu and rebuked him for refusing to save Zhao; when he asked where Zhang Yan and Chen Ze were, he suspected Chen Yu had killed them and questioned him again and again. Yu said angrily, “I did not expect you to demand so much of me! Do you think I clung to the seal out of greed?” He then stripped off the seal cord and thrust it at Zhang Er, who in astonishment refused to take it. Chen Yu rose and went to relieve himself. A guest urged Zhang Er: “I have heard, ‘What Heaven offers, if you do not take, you will suffer for it. ’ General Chen offers you the seal and you refuse—that offends Heaven; take it at once!” Zhang Er then fastened on the seal and took command of Chen Yu's troops. When Chen Yu returned and saw Zhang Er would not yield the seal, he rushed out and withdrew with a few hundred trusted followers to fish and hunt in the riverside marshes. King Xie of Zhao returned to Xindu.
54
6
6 In spring, the second month, the Duke of Pei marched north against Changyi, met Peng Yue, and Peng Yue joined him with his troops. Yue was from Changyi and had long fished in the Juze marshes as leader of a band of robbers. When Chen Sheng and Xiang Liang rose, more than a hundred young men from the marshes came to Peng Yue and said, “We ask you, Zhong, to lead us.” Yue declined: “I am unwilling.” The youths pressed him until he agreed, fixing a meeting at dawn the next day—latecomers would be beheaded. At dawn the next day more than ten men were late; the last did not arrive until noon. Yue then said, “I am old, and you forced me to be your leader. So many of you were late that I cannot kill you all—I will kill only the last to arrive.” He ordered the company commander to behead that man. They all laughed and said, “Surely not to that extent! We promise never to be late again.” Yue then had one man brought forward and beheaded, set up an altar and made sacrifice, and assembled the men—all were terrified and none dared look up. He then raided the countryside, gathered scattered allied troops to more than a thousand men, and helped the Duke of Pei attack Changyi.
55
西
Changyi did not fall; the Duke of Pei marched west past Gaoyang. Li Yi of Gaoyang was poor and down on his luck and served as gatekeeper of his ward. A cavalryman under the Duke of Pei happened to be from his town; Li Yi saw him and said, “Dozens of allied commanders have passed through Gaoyang—I have asked about them all, and they are petty, fussy about ritual, self-willed, and deaf to large-minded counsel. I hear the Duke of Pei is easygoing, approachable, and full of grand design—he is truly the man I wish to serve; do not let anyone reach him before me. If you see the Duke of Pei, tell him: ‘In my ward there is Master Li, over sixty and eight feet tall; everyone calls him the Mad Scholar. He himself says, “I am no mad scholar.” ’” The cavalryman said, “The Duke of Pei dislikes scholars; when guests arrive in scholar's caps he snatches off the cap and urinates in it. He talks in great oaths—you cannot win him over as a Confucian scholar.” Li Yi said, “Tell him anyway.” The cavalryman spoke to him at his ease, exactly as Li Yi had directed.
56
使 使 滿 使 使
When the Duke of Pei reached the Gaoyang post-house, he sent for Li Yi. Li Yi came and was admitted to audience. The Duke of Pei was lounging on a couch having two women wash his feet when he received Li Yi. Li Yi entered, bowed with a long salute but did not prostrate himself, and said, “Do you mean to help Qin attack the allies? Or do you mean to lead the allies to destroy Qin?” The Duke of Pei swore, “You wretched scholar! The whole realm has long groaned under Qin; the allies have risen together against it—what do you mean by helping Qin attack the allies!” Li Yi said, “You must rally men and righteous armies to destroy lawless Qin—you should not receive an elder sprawled on your couch!” The Duke of Pei stopped the washing, rose, straightened his clothes, seated Li Yi in the place of honor, and apologized. Li Yi then discoursed on the age of the Six States' alliances. The Duke of Pei was delighted, gave Li Yi a meal, and asked, “What is your plan?” Li Yi said, “You have raised a hastily gathered host and picked up scattered troops—fewer than ten thousand men; yet you mean to march straight into mighty Qin—that is what they call thrusting your hand into a tiger's maw. Chenliu is the hub of the realm, a crossroads where all roads meet, and its granaries are full. I am on good terms with its magistrate; let me have him surrender the city to you. If he refuses, you may attack, and I will act as your agent within the walls.” He sent Li Yi ahead; the Duke of Pei followed with his army and took Chenliu. He enfeoffed Li Yi as Lord of Guangye. Li Yi recommended his younger brother Shang. Shang had by then gathered four thousand youths and came to join the Duke of Pei, who made him a general commanding Chenliu troops on campaign; Li Yi often served as envoy to the allied states.
57
西 使使
In the third month the Duke of Pei attacked Kaifeng but failed to capture it. He marched west, met Qin general Yang Xiong at Baima, fought again east of Quyu, and routed him. Yang Xiong fled to Xingyang; the Second Emperor sent an envoy to execute him and expose the corpse as a warning.
58
In summer, the fourth month, the Duke of Pei marched south against Yingchuan and put it to the sword. With Zhang Liang's help, he then overran Han territory. At that time Zhao's detached general Sima Ang was about to cross the river and enter the passes. The Duke of Pei then marched north against Pingyin, cut the southern river crossings, and fought east of Luoyang. The army fared poorly and withdrew south through Huanyuan Pass. Zhang Liang brought his troops to join the Duke of Pei. The Duke of Pei left King Cheng of Han to hold Yangzhai and marched south with Liang.
59
西 使西 西 ----
In the sixth month he fought Grand Administrator Zhi of Nanyang east of Bi, routed him, and overran Nanyang commandery; The grand administrator fled to a fortified city and held Wan. The Duke of Pei marched past Wan and continued west. Zhang Liang remonstrated: “Though you wish to hurry into the passes, Qin still has many troops holding difficult ground. If you do not take Wan now, Wan will strike from behind while strong Qin blocks the way ahead—this is a deadly course.” Thereupon the Duke of Pei by night led his army back by another route, lowered banners and flags, and at dawn had Wan surrounded three deep. The grand administrator of Nanyang was about to cut his throat when his senior clerk Chen Hui said, “It is not yet too late to die.” He then went over the wall to see the Duke of Pei and said, “I have heard that by your agreement whoever enters Xianyang first shall be king. Now you have left Wan behind. Nanyang has dozens of linked cities; its officials and people all believe surrender means death, so they hold the walls and fight on. If you assault all day, your dead and wounded will surely be many. If you march away from Wan, Wan will surely follow at your heels. Ahead you break the Xianyang pact; behind you face the menace of strong Wan. For your own sake, nothing is better than accepting surrender and enfeoffing the defender; then have him keep holding the city and lead his armored troops west with you. Cities not yet taken will hear the news and vie to open their gates for you; you will march on without hindrance.” The Duke of Pei said, “Excellent!” In autumn, the seventh month, Grand Administrator Zhi of Nanyang surrendered; he was made Marquis Yin, and Chen Hui received a fief of one thousand households. He marched west, and every place he reached submitted. At Dan River, Marquis Wu of Gaoyang E and Marquis Xiang Wang Ling surrendered. He turned back to attack Huyang, met Fan Jun's detached general Mei Xuan, and together they attacked Xi and Li—both surrendered. Where they passed no one could plunder; the people of Qin were all pleased.
60
7 使 使 使 使
7 After Wang Li's army was destroyed, Zhang Han camped at Jiyuan and Xiang Yu south of the Zhang—they faced each other but did not fight. The Qin army kept falling back; the Second Emperor sent men to rebuke Zhang Han. Zhang Han was afraid and sent Chief Clerk Xin to report to court. Reaching Xianyang, he waited three days at the Sima Gate; Zhao Gao would not see him, and he began to doubt. Chief Clerk Xin was afraid, fled back to the army, and did not dare return by the old road. Zhao Gao did send men in pursuit but could not overtake him. When Xin reached the army he reported: “Zhao Gao holds power at court; below there is nothing we can do. If we fight and win, Gao will surely envy our merit; if we lose, we cannot escape death. I beg the general to weigh this carefully!” Chen Yu also wrote Zhang Han: “Bai Qi was Qin's general—south he took Yan and Ying, north he destroyed the Lord of Ma-fu, besieged cities and seized land beyond counting, yet in the end was put to death. Meng Tian was Qin's general—north he drove off the Rong and opened several thousand li in Yuzhong, yet in the end was executed at Yangzhou. Why? Their merit was too great for Qin to reward fully, so they were killed under the law. You have been Qin's general three years; your losses run into the tens of thousands, while the allies rise ever more numerous. Zhao Gao has long flattered the throne; now in crisis he fears the Second Emperor will kill him—so he means to kill you under the law to answer for failures and send another general in your place to save himself. You have long been abroad with many enemies at court—win and you are killed, lose and you are killed. Moreover Heaven is destroying Qin—fool and sage alike know it. Now you cannot remonstrate at court, without you are a general of a dying state—standing alone yet hoping to survive forever. Is it not pitiful! Why not turn your army, join the allies, agree to attack Qin together, divide its land into kingdoms, and face south as a king in your own right! Which is better than laying your neck on the block and seeing your wife and children slaughtered?"
61
使使 使 使 使
Zhang Han wavered and secretly sent scout Shi Cheng to Xiang Yu to negotiate. Before the pact was made, Xiang Yu sent General Pu day and night to lead troops across Sanhu, camp south of the Zhang, fight the Qin army, and defeat it twice. Xiang Yu then brought his whole army against the Qin force on the Wushui and crushed it. Zhang Han sent envoys to Xiang Yu to negotiate. Xiang Yu called his officers to counsel and said, “Our grain is low; I wish to accept their terms.” The officers all said, “Good.” Xiang Yu then set a meeting at Yin Xu on the Huan River. After the pact was sworn, Zhang Han met Xiang Yu in tears and spoke of Zhao Gao. Xiang Yu then made Zhang Han King of Yong, kept him with the Chu army, appointed Chief Clerk Xin supreme general, and set him to lead the Qin troops as vanguard.
62
----
Shen Yang of Xiaqiu came down into Henan and led his troops to follow Xiang Yu.
63
8鹿 鹿 鹿 鹿 西
8 At first Grand Minister Zhao Gao wished to monopolize Qin's power and feared the ministers would not obey him, so he first set a test: he brought a deer and presented it to the Second Emperor, saying, “A horse.” The Second Emperor laughed and said, “Has the chancellor made a mistake, calling a deer a horse!” He asked those beside him; some were silent, some said horse to flatter Zhao Gao, and some said deer. Gao then secretly punished by law all who had said deer. Afterward the ministers all feared Gao and none dared speak of his faults. Gao had repeatedly said, “The rebels east of the passes can do nothing”—yet when Xiang Yu captured Wang Li and Zhang Han's army was beaten again and again, he memorialized asking for more reinforcements. East of the passes nearly all Qin officials rebelled and answered the allies, and the allies all led their hosts west. In the eighth month the Duke of Pei led tens of thousands against Wuguan and put it to the sword. Gao feared the Second Emperor's wrath would reach him, pleaded illness, and stopped attending court.
64
使使 婿 使 殿 使 便
The Second Emperor dreamed a white tiger bit and killed his left outer horse; uneasy at heart, he asked the dream interpreter what it meant. Divination said, “The Jing River is the source of harm.” The Second Emperor then fasted at Wangyi Palace, prepared to sacrifice to the Jing River, and sank four white horses. He sent envoys to rebuke Gao over the rebel troubles. Gao was afraid and secretly plotted with his son-in-law, the magistrate of Xianyang Yan Le, and his younger brother Zhao Cheng, saying, “The emperor will not heed remonstrance. Now that things are desperate, he means to shift the blame onto us. We mean to replace the emperor and set up Ziying instead. Ziying is humane and frugal, and the people all praise him.” He had the Court Commandant act as inside agent, pretended there were great bandits, ordered Le to summon officers and raise troops in pursuit, and seized Le's mother and held her at Gao's house. He sent Le with more than a thousand officers and soldiers to the gate of Wangyi Palace, bound the Guard Commandant's Master of Chariots, and said, “Bandits entered here—why did you not stop them?” The Guard Commandant said, “The encircling guards are posted with great care—how could bandits dare enter the palace!” Le then beheaded the Guard Commandant, led his officers straight in, and shot down palace gentlemen and eunuchs as he went. The gentlemen and eunuchs were terrified—some fled, some fought back. Those who resisted were killed on the spot; several tens died. The Court Commandant entered with Le and shot at the emperor behind his curtain. The Second Emperor was furious and called his attendants, but they were all panicked and would not fight. One eunuch still attended at his side and did not dare leave. The Second Emperor went inside and said to him, “Why did you not tell me sooner—it has come to this!” The eunuch said, “I did not dare speak—that is why I am still alive. Had I spoken earlier, I would already have been killed—how could I be here today!” Yan Le stepped forward to the Second Emperor and said, “Your Grace is arrogant and lawless in killing; all under Heaven rebels against you. Plan for yourself!” The Second Emperor said, “May I see the chancellor?” Le said, “No!” The Second Emperor said, “I wish to have one commandery and be king.” This was refused. Again he said, “I wish to be a marquis of ten thousand households.” This too was refused. He said, “I wish to live as a commoner with my wife and children, like the other imperial sons.” Yan Le said, “I have orders from the chancellor to execute you on behalf of all under Heaven. Though you speak much, I dare not report it!” He waved his troops forward. The Second Emperor killed himself. Yan Le returned and reported to Zhao Gao. Zhao Gao then summoned all the great ministers and princes, told them how the Second Emperor had been killed, and said, “Qin was originally a feudal kingdom; the First Emperor ruled the realm, and therefore was called Emperor. Now the Six States have risen again and Qin territory grows ever smaller—to hold the empty title of Emperor will not do. It is fitting to be king as before—that is best.” He then made Ziying King of Qin. He buried the Second Emperor as a commoner south of the altar in the Yichun Garden.
65
使 使
In the ninth month Zhao Gao ordered Ziying to fast and purify himself; he was to appear at the ancestral temple and receive the jade seal. He fasted for five days. Ziying and his two sons plotted, saying, “Chancellor Gao killed the Second Emperor at Wangyi Palace, fearing the ministers would execute him; he therefore pretended to establish me out of righteousness. I hear Zhao Gao has made a pact with Chu to destroy the Qin imperial clan and divide Guanzhong into separate kingdoms. Now he makes me fast and appear at the temple—he intends to kill me there. If I claim illness and do not go, the chancellor will surely come in person; when he comes, we kill him.” Gao sent men to summon Ziying several times; Ziying did not go. Gao did indeed come in person and said, “Affairs of the ancestral temple are weighty—why does Your Majesty not go?” Ziying then stabbed and killed Gao in the fasting palace; Gao's three clans were exterminated and exposed as a warning.
66
使
He sent troops to hold Yao Pass; the Duke of Pei wished to attack. Zhang Liang said, “Qin troops are still strong—they must not be treated lightly. I beg first to send men to multiply banners on the mountains as decoys, and send Li Yiji and Lu Jia to persuade the Qin general, tempting him with gain.” The Qin general indeed wished to ally; the Duke of Pei wished to agree. Zhang Liang said, “Only the general wishes to rebel—I fear his soldiers will not follow; better to strike them while they are slack.” The Duke of Pei led his army around Yao Pass, crossed Zhi Mountain, attacked the Qin army, and routed them south of Lantian. He then reached Lantian and fought again to the north; the Qin army was routed utterly.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →