← Back to 後漢書

第二十二 郡國四 青州 荊州 揚州

Volume 112: Commanderies and States Part Four

Chapter 123 of 後漢書 · Book of Later Han
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 123
Next Chapter →
1
Treatise 22: “Commanderies and States,” Part Four.
2
This part of the treatise covers Jinan, Pingyuan, Le’an, Beihai, Donglai, and Qi under the Qingzhou inspectorate.
3
It then turns to Nanyang, Nan, Jiangxia, Lingling, Guiyang, Wuling, and Changsha in Jingzhou.
4
The Yangzhou section lists Jiujiang, Danyang, Lujiang, Kuaiji, Wu, and Yuzhang.
5
The kingdom of Jinan was carved from old Qi when Emperor Wen divided the realm. Its capital lay about eighteen hundred li east of Luoyang. The kingdom counted ten county seats, 78,544 households, and 453,308 people.
6
Dongpingling was a noted iron county. Tan city stood in the county. Mount Tianshan rose within its borders.
7
Zhu County.
8
Yuling County.
9
Tai County.
10
Jian contained Lai Pavilion.
11
Tugu County.
12
Liangzou County.
13
Zouping County.
14
Dongchaoyang County.
15
Licheng produced iron. Juli Gathering appears in the same entry.
16
Pingyuan Commandery dated from Emperor Gao’s founding organization. Its seat was about thirteen hundred li north of Luoyang. Nine county seats, 155,588 households, and 1,026,508 inhabitants were registered.
17
Pingyuan County.
18
湿
The Shi River rose in Gaotang.
19
Ban County.
20
Ge was organized as a marquisate. Tradition remembers the lord of Ge in Xia times, who overthrew the usurper Zhuo and restored Shaokang.
21
Zhu’a had read “Zhu Ke” in the Springs and Autumns. Yejing Pavilion lay there.
22
Leling County.
23
湿
Shiyin County.
24
De held marquisate rank.
25
Yanci had once been called Fuping. Emperor Ming gave the county its present name.
26
西
Le’an began as the Qiansheng polity that Emperor Gao organized out of Xipingchang; the name was changed in Yongyuan 7 of Emperor He. The kingdom sat about fifteen hundred twenty li east of Luoyang. Nine seats, 74,400 households, and 424,075 people fell under its administration.
27
Linji had been Di until Emperor An altered the designation.
28
Qiansheng County.
29
Gaowan County.
30
Le’an County.
31
Bochang contained the ruins of Bogu city. Beizhong Gathering is also named. The Shi River crossed the county.
32
Liaocheng was a marquisate.
33
Li had once been under Qi’s jurisdiction.
34
Yi was organized as a marquisate. Earlier it had been part of Beihai.
35
寿
Shouguang, too, had been Beihai territory. Guan Pavilion stood in the county.
36
Emperor Jing founded the kingdom of Beihai. Guangwu’s Jianwu 37 abolished the kingdoms of Zichuan, Gaomi, and Jiaodong and merged their counties into this unit. Eighteen county seats, 158,641 households, and 853,604 inhabitants were counted.
37
Ju held Ji Pavilion, on the ground of the old state of Ji.
38
Yingling County.
39
寿
Pingshou contained Zhen city. Han Pavilion marked the old state of Han, the fief where the usurper Zhuo had been invested.
40
Duchang County.
41
Anqiu had Quqiu Pavilion.
42
Chunyu county was revived in Yongyuan 9 of Emperor He. Mi Township lay in the same county.
43
Pingchang was a marquisate transferred from Langye and still held Lou Township.
44
Zhuxu was a Langye marquisate reassigned here in Yongchu 1 of Emperor An.
45
Dong’anping had once been filed under Zichuan. Warring States gazetteers knew it as Anping. Xī Pavilion, the old Qi landmark, appears in the same note.
46
Gaomi was organized as a marquisate.
47
Chang’an marquisate was revived under Emperor An.
48
Yi’an marquisate was likewise restored by Emperor An.
49
Jiaodong held marquisate rank.
50
Jimo was a marquisate. Tang Township lay within its bounds.
51
Zhuangwu county was brought back under Emperor An.
52
Xiami county was also restored by Emperor An.
53
Ting County.
54
Donglai Commandery was founded under Emperor Gao. It lay more than three thousand li east of Luoyang. Thirteen county seats, 104,297 households, and 484,433 people were registered.
55
Huang County.
56
Mouping County.
57
Jian was organized as a marquisate.
58
Qucheng was a marquisate.
59
Ye held marquisate status. Guo Township appears in the record.
60
Dangli was a marquisate.
61
Dongmou was organized as a marquisate.
62
Changyang County.
63
Luxiang County.
64
广
Changguang had once been Langye territory.
65
Qianzou was a marquisate taken from Langye. Jie Pavilion stood in the county.
66
Gelu contained Youshe Pavilion.
67
Buqi was another Langye marquisate folded in here.
68
The kingdom of Qi continued the Qin-era commandery shell. It sat about eighteen hundred li east of Luoyang. Six county seats, 64,415 households, and 491,765 subjects completed its rolls.
69
Linzi was old Qi itself and served as the inspector’s residence.
70
西
Xi’an contained Jili Pavilion. Quqiu ward preserved the name of ancient Quqiu.
71
Changguo County.
72
Linqu was known for its three pavilions and preserved the ground of old Bing.
73
广
Guang County.
74
Banyang had once been under Jinan Commandery.
75
These units made up the Qingzhou inspectorate: six commanderies and kingdoms and sixty-five county seats altogether.
76
Nanyang Commandery traced back to the Qin empire. Its seat lay about seven hundred li south of Luoyang. Thirty-seven county seats, 528,551 households, and 2,439,618 people were registered.
77
Wan had been the polity of Shen Bo in Zhou times. Nanjiu Gathering appears in the gazetteer. Guoli ford crossed the local river. Xiyang Gathering is also named. Dongwu Pavilion stood in the county.
78
Guanjun was organized as an urban district.
79
Ye contained Mount Chang, known in the text as Fangcheng. Juan city appears in the same entry.
80
Xinye held Dongxiang, which had been called Xindu. Huangyou Gathering lay in the county.
81
Zhangling had read Chongling until Guangwu gave the present name. Shangtang Township is listed there.
82
西
Xi’e County.
83
Zhi County.
84
Luyang contained Mount Lu. Niulanlei Pavilion appears in the same note.
85
Chou County.
86
Duyang County.
87
Bowang County.
88
Wuyin was organized as an urban district.
89
Biyang County.
90
Fuyang held marquisate rank. Xing Gathering stood in the county.
91
From Mount Dafu in Tongbai above Pingshi the Huai River had its source. Yiqiu Gathering is also recorded.
92
Jiyang contained Lan Township. Huangchun Gathering lay there as well.
93
Huyang was an urban district.
94
西
West of Sui rose Duan Snake Mound, tied to the legend of the serpent.
95
Yuyang was organized as a town. The county held the hamlet called Lesser Chang’an and Dongyang Gathering.
96
Nieyang County.
97
Yin County.
98
Zan County.
99
Deng contained You Gathering, a well-known local rallying point.
100
Shandu was a marquisate.
101
Li held marquisate status.
102
Rang County.
103
Chaoyang County.
104
Caiyang was organized as a marquisate.
105
Anzhong was a marquisate.
106
Zhuyang held marquisate rank. Shedu Township appears in the record.
107
Wudang contained Hecheng Gathering.
108
Shunyang marquisate had once been called Boshan. Xu Gathering lay in the same county.
109
Chengdu County.
110
Xiangxiang County.
111
Nanxiang County.
112
Danshui had once been filed under Hongnong. Zhangmi Township stood there. Sanhu Pavilion is named in the gazetteer.
113
西
Xi had been Hongnong territory and preserved Chu’s old Baiyu town. Wu Pass guarded the western approaches to the county. Feng Township city appears in the same list.
114
Nan Commandery, too, dated from Qin. It lay fifteen hundred li south of Luoyang. Seventeen seats, 162,570 households, and 747,604 inhabitants were counted.
115
Jiangling contained Jin Township.
116
西
West of Wu county stood the famed Baidi fortress.
117
Zigui was the commandery’s own ancient seat.
118
Zhonglu was organized as a marquisate.
119
Bian held Lankou Gathering.
120
Dangyang County.
121
Huarong held marquisate rank. The great Yunmeng marsh stretched south of the county.
122
Xiangyang contained Mount Atou.
123
Qi was a marquisate. Liqiu city stood in the same entry.
124
Yicheng was organized as a marquisate.
125
Ruo held marquisate status. The county was revived in Yongping 1 of Emperor Ming.
126
Linju was a marquisate. Mount Jing rose in its territory.
127
Zhijiang was organized as a marquisate. The ground had once been the polity of Luo. Danyang Gathering appears there.
128
Yidao County.
129
Yiling held the Jingmen narrows and Mount Huya beside the Yangtze.
130
Zhouling County.
131
Henshan had once been Wuling territory.
132
Jiangxia Commandery was founded under Emperor Gao. It sat fifteen hundred li south of Luoyang. Fourteen county seats, 58,434 households, and 265,464 people were registered.
133
西
Xiling County.
134
西
Xiyang County.
135
Dai was a marquisate.
136
Meng County.
137
Jingling held marquisate rank. Yun Township lay in the county. Mount Lizhang appears there, the old Neifang peak of the documents.
138
Yundu County.
139
Shaxian County.
140
Zhu County.
141
Xiazhi County.
142
Qichun was organized as a marquisate.
143
E County.
144
Pingchun held marquisate rank.
145
Nanxinshi was a marquisate.
146
Anlu County.
147
Lingling Commandery was first set up under Emperor Wu of Han. It lay thirty-three hundred li south of Luoyang. Thirteen county seats, 212,284 households, and 1,001,578 people were registered.
148
Quanling County.
149
Lingling contained Mount Yangshuo, where the Xiang River rose.
150
South of Yingdao rose the nine peaks of Jiuyi.
151
Yingpu County.
152
Lingdao County.
153
Taoyang County.
154
Duliang contained Mount Lu on its register.
155
Fuyi was a marquisate.
156
Shi’an held marquisate status.
157
Chong’an marquisate had been Zhongwu until Yongjian 3 of Emperor Shun changed the name.
158
Xiangxiang County.
159
Zhaoyang was organized as a marquisate.
160
Zhengyang was a marquisate transferred from Changsha Commandery.
161
Guiyang Commandery dated from Emperor Gao’s reign. The commandery government sat at Chen. The region lay about thirty-nine hundred li south of Luoyang. Eleven county seats, 135,029 households, and 501,403 inhabitants were counted.
162
Chen contained Mount Keling.
163
便
Bian County.
164
Leiyang was an iron-working county.
165
Yinshan County.
166
Nanping County.
167
Linwu County.
168
Guiyang County.
169
Hankuang County.
170
Zhenyang lay in the shadow of Mount Zhaling.
171
Qujiang County.
172
Hanning county was created in Yonghe 1 of Emperor Shun.
173
Wuling Commandery went back to King Zhao of Qin. It had borne the name Qianzhong until Emperor Gao’s fifth year redesignated it Wuling. It sat twenty-one hundred li south of Luoyang. Twelve seats, 46,672 households, and 250,913 people fell under its rolls.
174
Linyuan County.
175
寿
Hanshou had been Suo until Yangjia 3 of Emperor Shun altered the name; the inspector resided there.
176
Chanling County.
177
Lingyang County.
178
Chong County.
179
Yuanling was the county of storied Hutou Mountain.
180
Chenyang County.
181
Youyang County.
182
Qianling County.
183
Tancheng County.
184
Yuannan county was set up in Jianwu 26 of Guangwu’s reign.
185
Zuotang County.
186
Changsha Commandery traced to the Qin empire. It lay twenty-eight hundred li south of Luoyang. Thirteen county seats, 255,854 households, and 1,059,372 inhabitants were registered.
187
Linxiang County.
188
You County.
189
Chaling County.
190
Ancheng County.
191
Ling County.
192
Xiangnan was organized as a marquisate. Sacred Mount Heng rose to the southeast of the county.
193
Liandao County.
194
Zhaoling County.
195
Yiyang County.
196
Xiajun County.
197
Luo County.
198
Liling County.
199
Rongling County.
200
These entries close the Jingzhou inspectorate: seven commanderies and 117 county-level seats altogether.
201
Jiujiang Commandery was a Qin foundation. It lay fifteen hundred li east of Luoyang. Fourteen county seats, 89,436 households, and 432,426 people were counted.
202
Yinling County.
203
寿
Shouchun County.
204
Junqiu County.
205
Chengde County.
206
西
Xiquyang County.
207
Hefei was organized as a marquisate.
208
Liyang marquisate served as the inspector’s residence.
209
Dangtu held Maqiu Gathering, where Xu Feng raised his revolt.
210
Quanjiao County.
211
Zhongli was a marquisate.
212
Fuling County.
213
Xiacai had once been Pei Commandery territory.
214
Ping'a, too, had once been Pei Commandery territory. Mount Tu appears in the same note.
215
Yicheng had previously belonged to Pei.
216
Danyang continued Qin’s Zhang Commandery until Emperor Wu renamed it. Its seat lay twenty-one hundred sixty li east of Luoyang. In 208 CE, Jian’an 13, Sun Quan carved Xindu Commandery out of Danyang. Sixteen county seats, 136,518 households, and 630,545 subjects were registered.
217
Wanling County.
218
Liyang County.
219
Danyang County.
220
Guzhang County.
221
Yuqian County.
222
Jing County.
223
She County.
224
You County.
225
Lingyang County.
226
西
Wuhu stood west of the middle course of the Yangtze.
227
South of Moling lay Niuzhu, the famous river ford.
228
Hushu was organized as a marquisate.
229
Jurong County.
230
Jiangcheng County.
231
Chungu County.
232
Shicheng County.
233
Emperor Wen carved Lujiang Commandery out of Huainan. Guangwu’s Jianwu 13 struck off the kingdom of Liuan and merged its counties here. The commandery lay seventeen hundred li east of Luoyang. Fourteen county seats, 101,392 households, and 424,683 inhabitants were registered.
234
Shu contained Tong Township.
235
Yulou was a marquisate.
236
South of Xunyang the Jiujiang channels widened until they merged with the great river to the east.
237
Qian County.
238
Linhu held marquisate rank.
239
Longshu was organized as a marquisate.
240
Xiang’an County.
241
Wan was an iron-producing county.
242
Juchao was a marquisate.
243
Lu’an was ranked as a kingdom.
244
Liao was a marquisate.
245
Anfeng county lay beneath great Mount Dabie.
246
Yangquan was organized as a marquisate.
247
Anfeng marquisate, written with the “wind” graph, appears as a separate fief.
248
Kuaiji Commandery dated from the Qin empire. The government had first sat at Wu until the commandery was refounded and the capital shifted to Shanyin. It lay thirty-eight hundred li east of Luoyang. Fourteen county seats, 123,090 households, and 481,196 people were counted.
249
Shanyin overlooked Mount Kuaiji to the south, crowned by the grave of Yu the Great. The Zhe River crossed the county.
250
Mao County.
251
Wushang County.
252
Zhuji County.
253
Yuji County.
254
Taiwei County.
255
Shangyu County.
256
Shan County.
257
Yuyao County.
258
Gouzhang County.
259
Yin County.
260
Zhang’an had been the old administrative seat in Minyue country until Guangwu changed the name.
261
Yongning was created in Yonghe 3 of Emperor Shun from the Eastern Ou township of Zhang’an.
262
Dongbu was organized as a marquisate.
263
Emperor Shun carved the commandery of Wu out of Kuaiji. Wu lay thirty-two hundred li east of Luoyang. Thirteen county seats, 164,164 households, and 700,782 subjects were registered.
264
西
Wu was the commandery’s own ancient seat. Lake Zhen stretched to the west, later known as the Juqu marsh.
265
Haiyan County.
266
Wucheng County.
267
Yuhang County.
268
Piling was the home of Prince Jizha of Wu. The northern arm of the Yangtze lay along its northern border.
269
Dantu County.
270
Qu’a County.
271
Youquan County.
272
An County.
273
Fuchun County.
274
Yangxian was organized as a town.
275
Wuxi was a marquisate.
276
Lou County.
277
Yuzhang Commandery was founded under Emperor Gao. It sat twenty-seven hundred li south of Luoyang. Twenty-one county seats, 406,496 households, and 1,668,906 inhabitants were counted.
278
Nanchang County.
279
Jiancheng County.
280
Xingan County.
281
Yichun County.
282
Luling County.
283
The Yuzhang River rose in Gan county.
284
Yudu County.
285
Nanye contained Mount Tailing.
286
Nancheng County.
287
The Po River flowed through Poyang. Placers yielded gold in the same district.
288
Liling contained storied Mount Fuyang.
289
Yuhan County.
290
Qianyang County.
291
西
Pengze bordered great Lake Pengli on the west.
292
Chaisang County.
293
Ai County.
294
Haihun was organized as a marquisate.
295
Pingdu marquisate had once been called Anping.
296
Shiyang County.
297
The county seat of Linru was established in Yongyuan 8 of Emperor He.
298
Jianchang was set up in Yongyuan 16 from territory taken out of Haihun county.
299
These entries close the Yangzhou inspectorate: six commanderies and ninety-two county-level seats altogether.
300
Editorial collation notes follow the main treatise text.
301
使
Collators note that the gloss misattributes the journey: "the canonical text sends the infant heir and Lady Hu to Lai, not the ruler himself."
302
西西
The note ties Cui city to Du Yu’s commentary on the Cui stronghold northwest of Chaoyang.
303
Page 3472 line 7 Pingyuan commandery has nine cities; annotation: "Qian Daxin argues that nine should read ten." Further discussion of the emendation appears in the following entry.
304
Hui Dong notes that the Former Han Treatise and Li Daoyuan’s Shuijing zhu write the river name with the graph "Ta," rather than this variant for Shi. 〈The Shuowen gloss strips the water radical and keeps only the phonetic core of the compound character.〉 …leaving the phonetic component of the compound graph.
305
Page 3472, line 10: "Shiyin." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that the Former Treatise also writes it as "Luoyin"; see the discussion above. Du Yu's commentary on the Zuo Zhuan also writes it as "Xi."
306
西
Page 3472, line 14: "Du Yu says that west of the county there is Yuan City." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that, according to the Treatise on Geography, Yuan County belonged to Pingyuan. The Shuijing writes it as "Yuan," and Li Daoyuan cites Du Yu's Explanation of Places as saying that Yuan is the same as Yuan; Zhu'e County in Jinan had Yuan City.
307
西西 西西 西
Page 3472, line 16: "Emperor Gao established Xipingchang." Note: the collected commentary cites Qian Daxin as saying that the text should read "Emperor Gao established it" and should not contain the three characters "Xipingchang"; they are certainly intrusive characters. Later, after reading the Treatise on Eunuchs, where Peng Kai was made Marquis of Xipingchang and the note says that Xipingchang County belonged to Pingyuan Commandery, he realized that these three characters should belong to the preceding text on Pingyuan Commandery. Pingyuan Commandery's nine cities should therefore be ten cities. Because these three characters were mistakenly inserted into the Le'an note, the collator changed "ten" to "nine" to match the existing count. Another note: Zhang Senkai says that Qian's explanation is entirely correct, but the Former Treatise has Pingchang County under Pingyuan; this must be the same as Xipingchang, which Qian failed to cite.
308
殿
Page 3473, line 2: "Gaowan." The Palace Edition writes "wan" as "yuan." Note: the Former Treatise writes it as "Wan"; the three characters wan, yuan, and wan were interchangeable in antiquity.
309
Page 3473, line 2: "There is Bogu City." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that the Shangshu dazhuan writes it as "Pugu."
310
Page 3473, line 6: "the ancient Bogu clan." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition reads "the Zuo Zhuan Gu clan." Hui Dong says it should read "the ancient Bogu clan"; in the various copies, "Pugu" has all been mistakenly written as "Bogu," or the character "Pu" has been omitted.
311
殿
Page 3473, line 7: "south of the county there is a place named Bei." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
312
西
Page 3473, line 9: "Du Yu says that northeast of the county there is She City." Note: the collected commentary cites Hong Yixuan as saying that the Zuo Zhuan passage for the twentieth year of Duke Zhao says, "east of Liao and She," and Du's note says, "Liao and She are the western border of Qi; northeast of Liaocheng County in Pingyuan there is She City." The note flags a likely mistake in the received line.
313
Page 3473, line 11: "Emperor Jing established it." Note: Zhang Senkai's Collation Notes says that, according to the Former Treatise, this was Beihai Commandery, so the note says "Emperor Jing established it." This kingdom was established by Shizu and cannot use that wording; it should say "Emperor Jing established the commandery," followed by the wording about Jianwu, and only then is the passage intelligible.
314
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Abolished] the three kingdoms of Zichuan, Gaomi, and Jiaodong." Note: the collation supplement says that "had" is a mistake for "abolished," and none of the editions has corrected it. The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
315
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Ting]." The collected commentary cites Qian Daxin as saying that "Ju" should be "Ting." The Treatise on Prefectures and Commanderies in the Song shu notes Ting County: under the Former Han it belonged to Jiaodong, and under the Later Han it belonged to Beihai. Some identify it with Ju in Langye, but the Ju of Langye is written with the wood radical, not the hand radical. The treatise does not say it formerly belonged to Langye, and the graphic form and radical also differ; therefore we know it is not that place. The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
316
Page 3474, line 11: "old Zhao." Note: the collected commentary cites Chen Jingyun as saying that the note's "old Zhao" is unclear and is suspected to be a mistake for "old Ji settlement."
317
殿
Page 3474, line 12: "Du Yu says it was Tang State." Note: Qi Zhaonan's textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that the original Zuo Zhuan note reads: "Tang was a settlement of Lai. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry." Here it reads "Tang State," which is incorrect.
318
西
Page 3474, line 14: "The Didiao ji says that [Xi]yang Marsh lies to the west." This is supplemented on the basis of the collected commentary citing Qian Daxin. Note: Qian says that the Didiao ji cited in the note is the note on Changguang in Langye in the Former Treatise, and that the character "Xi" should precede "Yang Marsh." The gloss admits that the point still lacks a firm resolution.
319
殿
Page 3474, line 15: "3,128 li east of Luoyang." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "one" as "two."
320
Page 3475, line 1: "Xian marquisate." Zhang Senkai's Collation Notes says that, according to the Shuowen, the xian written with the heart radical is a postal station in Mi County, Henan, while the form written with the cloth radical "<cloth-xian>" The note flags a likely mistake in the received line. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "<cloth-xian>" This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "<cloth-xian> cloth comes from Donglai; the graph has the cloth radical and xian as its phonetic," so it is written "<cloth-xian>" that is correct. The county was probably named from cloth.
321
Page 3475, line 1: "Ye." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that the Former Treatise writes it as "Ye"; ye is pronounced yi and also pronounced ye.
322
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Qi]." Note: the Former Treatise writes "Buqi"; Hui Dong and Qi Zhaonan both say that writing it as "Buqi" with the wrong final character is erroneous, and the text is now emended accordingly. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
323
殿
Page 3475, line 5: "set up two steles." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "set up" as "carved."
324
沿
Page 3475, line 12: "established by Qin." Note: Zhang Senkai's Collation Notes says that Qi was an ancient state and was not established by Qin; Qin only established Qi Commandery. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This should explain the course of its historical changes in detail; merely saying "established by Qin" is quite careless. Perhaps the character "commandery" once followed "established" and was mistakenly omitted.
325
Page 3475, line 13: "Linzi." Note: the Former Treatise writes it as "Linzi" with the water radical.
326
Page 3475, line 14: "there are three pavilions, the old Ping settlement." Note: the collation supplement cites Qian Dazhao as saying that the character "three" is erroneous and may actually be the character "Ping."
327
Page 3476, line 7: "there is a long mountain called Fangcheng." Note: the Former Treatise reads, "there is a long wall called Fangcheng." Hui Dong's supplemental note cites the Shuijing zhu, the Jin Treatise, and Sheng Hongzhi's Record of Jingzhou to prove that "long mountain" should read "long wall."
328
Page 3476, line 12: "Nieyang." Note: the collected commentary cites Qian Daxin as saying that Princess Nieyang, Emperor An's younger sister, held it as her fief, so the character "fief" should be present.
329
殿
Page 3476, line 14: "there is Hecheng settlement." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "cheng" as "city."
330
Page 3477, line 1: "there is Zhangmi Township." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that both the Former Treatise and the Danshui note in the Shuijing write it as "Miyang Township."
331
殿
Page 3477, line 7: "Du Yu says Mount Fangcheng is south of the county; Qu Wan said Chu State used Fangcheng as a wall." Note: the textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that, following the meaning of the text, it should read: "In the Zuo Zhuan, Qu Wan said, 'Chu State used Fangcheng as a wall'; Du Yu said, 'Mount Fangcheng is south of the county.'" The note flags a likely mistake in the received line.
332
殿
Page 3477, line 11: "Wu Han broke Qin Feng's territory." Note: "territory" was originally mistakenly written as "was." The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses.
333
Page 3478, line 1: "The Bowu ji says the Zhi River emerges..." Note: the collation supplement cites Liu Congchen as saying that this quotation from the Bowu ji should probably be placed under "Luyang." The Shuowen says that the Zhi River emerges from Mount Yao in Luyang, Nanyang, and flows northeast into the Ru. The Feng River emerges from Mount Zhi-Heng in Nanyang and flows east into the Ru. The Former Treatise also says that Luyang has Mount Lu, where the Zhi River emerges, flowing northeast to Dingling and entering the Ru. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. 〈This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.〉 This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The note flags a likely mistake in the received line.
334
殿
Page 3478, line 8: "Bosheng attacked Zhen Fu." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses. Note: "was" is suspected to be an error for "territory."
335
Page 3479, line 1: "Upper longevity is one hundred twenty and thirty." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition lacks the two characters "thirty."
336
殿
Page 3479, line 3: "this chrysanthemum has short stems and large flowers." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "flower" as "blossom."
337
殿
Page 3479, line 16: "Zigui originally..." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses. Note: the textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that, following the meaning of the text, the character "gui" above "state" is intrusive; the note says Du Yu called it Kui State, so it was clearly not Gui State.
338
殿
Page 3479, line 16: "Zhonglu." Note: the Palace Edition writes lu with the house radical.
339
Page 3480, line 2: "Ruo." Note: the Former Treatise writes it as ruo.
340
殿
Page 3480, line 4: "Henshan." The Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write hen with the person radical. Note: the Former Treatise writes "hen" with the person radical; Hui Dong says the Treatise on Prefectures and Commanderies in the Song shu writes it as "hen" without that radical.
341
殿
Page 3480, line 7: "east of the lake there is a stream named Chang Valley." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write chang as the ordinary "long."
342
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses.
343
Page 3480, line 15: "its scales are like fresh carp." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition writes "fresh" as "shark." Wang Xianqian says that the Mianshui note in the Shuijing writes it as "ling."
344
Page 3480, line 15: "[shooting] cannot enter." He Zhuo collated this from a fragmentary Song copy and supplemented one character, "shoot." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
345
便使
Page 3480, line 16: "pluck its nose; the charm may be used in small ways and is named mulu." Note: the Mianshui note in the Shuijing reads, "pluck its gao; the charm may be used in small ways and is named water tiger." Wang Xianqian says, "The character yan belongs with what follows; it is the yan of yansheng, charm-working." Another note: He Zhuo, using a fragmentary Song copy, changed "wood" to "water."
346
Page 3481, line 3: "southeast of the county there is Quan City." Hui Dong's supplemental note adds the character "south" on the basis of Du's note, and it is now supplemented accordingly.
347
西
Page 3481, line 3: "east of the city there is Lu City." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition writes lu with the other form. Wang Xianqian says that the Jushui note in the Shuijing writes it as "donkey," and a proverb says, "East donkey, west mill; Maicheng breaks by itself."
348
Page 3481, line 5: "Zhou State is southeast of the county." Hui Dong's supplemental note adds the character "south" on the basis of Du's note, and it is now supplemented accordingly.
349
西 殿
Page 3481, line 7: "nine li west of the county there is..." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses. Note: "fang" is suspected originally to have been mistakenly written as "wan," which was then transmitted as the graph "wan" for ten thousand.
350
殿
Page 3481, line 8: "it emerges at Pinggao Pass." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write gao as ze.
351
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses. Note: the present Classic of Mountains and Seas reads, "within it there are many yak-oxen."
352
The note flags a likely mistake in the received line. "<cart-dog>" This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. Note: the Former Treatise writes it as "dai," and Meng Kang says it is pronounced dai. The supplemental note cites Zhou Shouchang as saying: "In the Shuowen, dai means the tube around a carriage axle. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The note flags a likely mistake in the received line."
353
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[There is] Mount Zhang." The collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that, according to the Former Treatise and the Jin Treatise, the character "establish" is intrusive. The collation supplement says that "establish" should read "there is," having been corrupted through the following character "Zhang." The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
354
西
Page 3482, line 11: "east of the county there is..." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Jiu] River." The collected commentary cites Qian Dazhao as saying that "Shen" should read "Jiu." In the fifth year of Duke Ding in the Zuo Zhuan, the text says, "crossed at Chengjiu," and Du's note says, "Jingling County has the Jiu River, which emerges from Mount Liaoqu and flows southwest into the Han." The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
355
西西
Page 3482, line 11: "Du Yu says it is northwest of the county." Note: the present Du note reads, "northwest of Jingling County there is Ganyu Embankment."
356
Page 3483, line 1: "Mount Yangshuo." Note: the collation supplement says that, according to the Former Treatise, it is written "Mount Yanghai," and the Shuowen agrees. The Shuijing zhu says that Mount Yanghai is Mount Yangshuo.
357
Page 3483, line 2: "Fuyi marquisate." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that, according to the Former Treatise, Fuyi originally belonged to Lingling, and Changsha had no such county; these four characters are intrusive text. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
358
Page 3483, line 3: "Zhengyang." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that the Former Treatise writes it as "Chengyang," with cheng pronounced zheng.
359
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Chong] River." This is emended on the basis of the collation supplement citing Liu Congchen.
360
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Wei] River." This is emended on the basis of the collation supplement citing Liu Congchen.
361
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition mistakenly write it as "bo."
362
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses.
363
Page 3483, line 13: "Emperor Gao established it; Mount Shangling is 3,900 li south of Luoyang." Note: Zhang Senkai's Collation Notes says that the three characters "Mount Shangling" belong neither to the preceding nor the following context; it is not known under which county a mountain name has been dropped and inserted here, and this awaits detailed examination.
364
Page 3484, line 7: "the Jin-period Administrator Zhao Jue." Note: the collected commentary cites Qian Daxin as saying that the Jin shu writes "Jue" as "Xin." It also cites Zhou Shouchang as saying that the Xianjiang River note cites the Traditions of Former Worthies in the same way, except that "Zhao Jue" is written as "Zhao Wei."
365
殿
Page 3484, line 14: "3,000 li from Luoyang." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "three" as "two."
366
Page 3485, line 1: "2,800 li south of Luoyang." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition writes "two" as "three."
367
Page 3485, line 3: "You." The Former Treatise writes it as "Shou." Note: You was pronounced shou by Meng Kang, and the Former Treatise therefore mistakenly wrote it as "Shou"; see the supplemental notes to the Han shu.
368
殿 殿
Page 3485, line 3: "Tuling." The Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write tu as cha. Now note: in the Former Treatise, the Palace Edition writes "Chaling," while the supplemental-note edition follows the Jian'an manuscript edition in writing "Tuling." Wang Xianqian, on the basis of the Shuowen, says that tu and cha are interchangeable.
369
Page 3485, line 3: "Ancheng." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that both the Former Treatise and the Treatise on Prefectures and Commanderies write it as "Ancheng" with cheng meaning completion. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
370
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses.
371
Page 3486, line 1: "Xunqiu." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that "xun" is in one version written as "qun."
372
西西
Page 3486, line 1: "West Quyang." Note: the Former Treatise writes "Quyang"; Hui Dong says that Xiapi had a Quyang, so "west" was added.
373
Page 3486, line 4: "1,300 li from Luoyang." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition writes "three" as "two."
374
Page 3486, line 5: "there are the two mountains Tang and Hou." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that the Fengsu tong writes it as "Mount Tangju."
375
殿 西
Page 3486, line 9: "Danyang Commandery." The textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that "yang" should read "yang" with the wood radical. Now note: the Former Treatise writes it as "Yang" with the hand radical. The supplemental note cites Song Qi as saying that it should be written "yang" with the sun radical. It also cites Wang Mingsheng as saying that the character "yang" with the hand radical is used, while the subordinate county Danyang follows another form. The southern directorate editions all write "yang" with the sun radical. The Jin Treatise sometimes writes it with the hand radical and sometimes with the sun radical, but the subordinate county writes it with the wood radical. Moreover, the note says, "Mount Danyang has many red willows and lies to the west." Thus it is very clear that the county name uses the wood radical, and the commandery also should have been named from this. All forms with the hand radical or sun radical are copying errors.
376
Page 3486, line 11: "Danyang." The collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that, according to the Jin Treatise, "yang" should be written with the wood radical. Now note: the Former Treatise writes it as "yang" with the sun radical.
377
Page 3486, line 11: "Yuqian." Note: in the Former Treatise, qian is written with the alternate graph can and pronounced qian.
378
Page 3486, line 11: "You." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that in one version it is written "Yi," as seen in the Shuowen.
379
Page 3486, line 12: "Hushu." Note: the Former Treatise writes it as "Hushu" with the alternate graph shu.
380
Page 3486, line 14: "the seat of Qinzhang Commandery." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that "Qin" should read "former."
381
Page 3486, line 14: "the [second] year of Zhongping." The collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that Shen Yue and Ouyang Min both say it was the second year of Zhongping, and that all copies omit the character "two." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
382
殿 殿
Page 3486, line 16: "now called Mount Yu." The Palace Edition reads, "now called Mount Sanwang." Note: the present Classic of Mountains and Seas, in Guo's note, also writes "Mount Sanwang." However, She County and Mount Yu both appear in the Kuaiji Commandery note, so writing "Mount Yu" is correct. He Zhuo's collated edition also writes "Mount Yu"; the Palace Edition probably changed it on the basis of the present Classic of Mountains and Seas.
383
殿
Page 3487, line 8: "Wan." The Former Treatise writes it as "Huan," and the Palace Edition writes it as "Wan" with the white radical. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
384
Page 3487, line 9: "Liu'an." Note: in the Former Treatise it is "Liu," belonging to Liu'an Kingdom, without the character "an."
385
殿
Page 3488, line 2: "the senior official first..." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses.
386
殿
Page 3488, line 5: "south of the county there is Jibei Pavilion." The textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that He Zhuo's collated edition changes "bei" to "ren." Now note: the present Du note also writes "bei"; He probably changed it on the basis of a fragmentary Song copy.
387
殿
Page 3488, line 7: "established commandery Wu." The textual investigation in the Palace Edition says it should be changed to "Wu established the commandery." Now note: the collation supplement says that "established commandery Wu" means the county was promoted to a commandery; changing it instead makes the explanation more obstructed.
388
Page 3488, line 10: "Taimo." Note: in the Former Treatise, "tai" is written as "da," and Meng Kang says, "Da is pronounced like ta."
389
Page 3488, line 12: "Dongbu marquisate." The collected commentary cites Qian Daxin as saying that, according to the Treatise on Prefectures and Commanderies in the Song shu, Houguan did not exist under the Former Han; under the Later Han it was called Donghouguan and belonged to Kuaiji. This "Dongbu marquisate" should be an error for "Donghouguan"; in Han times there is no evidence of anyone being enfeoffed as Marquis of Dongbu. Now note: Qian's explanation is correct, but these four characters are in fact intrusive text; see the discussion above.
390
殿 殿 殿
Page 3488, line 13: "Mount Ji is Goujian..." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Fasting and Purification] Terrace." In the Palace Edition, "zhe" is written as "you." In both the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition, "Jirong Terrace" is written as "Fasting and Purification Terrace." Note: the Yuejue shu writes it as "Fasting and Purification Terrace," and the Baoqing Kuaiji County Gazetteer says, "Mount Ji is fifty-three li east of the county and is also named Mount Zhaitai." Thus writing "fasting and purification" is correct, and it is now emended on the basis of the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition.
391
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading. Note: the present Classic of Mountains and Seas writes "fu," and the note says, "Fuwu is a great stone resembling jade."
392
Page 3488, line 15: "there is Mount Chong." Note: in the present Yuejue shu, "chong" is written as "zhong."
393
Page 3488, line 16: "the river emerges from Mount Yu in She County." Note: the present Classic of Mountains and Seas, in Guo's note, says: "According to the Treatise on Geography, the Zhejiang emerges among the southern Man of Yi County, Xin'an, flows east into the sea, and is the present Zhejiang at Qiantang. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry."
394
殿
Page 3489, line 3: "there is Mount Shewu." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "wu" as "huang."
395
殿
Page 3489, line 3: "the Pan River emerges there." The Jian'an manuscript edition and the Palace Edition write "Pan" as "Qian." Note: Wang Xianqian's supplemental note to the Former Book says that the Qian River is the Pan River.
396
Page 3489, line 4: "in the fourth year of Jian'an, the Sun clan divided off and established Feng'an County; in the twenty-third year they established Suichang County." Note: the collected commentary cites Qian Daxin as saying that the Treatise on Prefectures and Commanderies in the Song shu differs from this, and it is not known which is correct.
397
殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Chang] lived in seclusion here." The textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that "chang" should read "Chang." Note: the collected commentary cites Ma Yulong as saying that Longqiu Chang appears in the biography of Ren Yan. The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
398
Page 3489, line 5: "within it there is a stone grove." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition writes "grove" as "bed."
399
Page 3489, line 8: "Mount Yuju." Note: the collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that, according to the Classic of Mountains and Seas, it should read "Juyu."
400
Page 3489, line 11: "thirteen cities." Note: according to Qian Daxin's textual investigation, it should read "twelve cities"; see the collation note below under An County.
401
Page 3489 line 14, the graph An; annotation: "the collected commentary cites Qian Daxin, who observes that the Former Han, Jin, and Song treatises all omit this county, while our treatise never states when it was created, so it lacks both antecedent and successor; he suspects it is a corruption of Lou, half the graph Lou being lost to yield An, which collators could not emend; suspecting lacunae, they inserted Lou after Wuxi and altered twelve cities to thirteen."
402
殿
The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses. The note flags a likely mistake in the received line.
403
殿
Page 3489, line 16: "outside Chang Gate is Helu's tomb." Note: the Palace Edition writes "chang" as the gate-name graph, agreeing with the present Yuejue shu.
404
鹿 殿
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. The collators emend the transmitted wording to match a better-attested reading.
405
Page 3490, line 1: "again, at Stone City, Helu established Mount Mei[ren]." The collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that "Mount Mei" has no basis; according to the Yuenü lu, "Stone City: Helu established Mount Meiren," so the character "ren" was omitted. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
406
Page 3490, line 1: "Mount Yu, Mount Wuxian." Note: the "mount" in "Mount Wuxian" is suspected to be a mistake for "emerged." The present Yuejue shu reads, "Mount Yu is where Wuxian emerged." Chapter 91 of the Huanyu ji reads, "where Wuxian dwelt."
407
Page 3490, line 6: "in Emperor Shun's time it sank and became a lake." Note: the collected commentary cites Hong Liangji as saying that the Shuijing zhu writes "Emperor Shun" as "Emperor An."
408
This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Bian] Mountain has a shrine to Xiang Ji." This is emended on the basis of He Zhuo's collated edition.
409
殿 殿
Page 3490, line 11: "south of the county city..." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry. "[Old Guyan] land; the tomb in Shanghu is Jizi's tomb." The Jian'an manuscript edition writes "on wasteland" as "in waste-connected land"; this follows the Palace Edition in emending it. Note: the present Yuejue shu says, "South of Piling County city was the old land of Lord Guyan." It also says, "The tomb in Shanghu at Piling is the tomb of Jizi of Yanling; it is seventy li from the county, and Shanghu connects with Shangzhou." The apparatus compares variant readings across standard block-print witnesses.
410
Page 3490, line 17: "the tomb of Taibo, King of Wu." Note: Zhang Senkai's Collation Notes says that Taibo was not King of Wu and suspects that this text has intrusive or erroneous wording.
411
Page 3491, line 5: "Yongxiu County." Note: the Jian'an manuscript edition writes xiu with the regular form.
412
Page 3491, line 5: "both were established in the [middle] of Zhongping." The collected commentary cites Hui Dong as saying that all copies omit the character "middle." This line continues or glosses the preceding collation entry.
413
Page 3491, line 6: "Jiancheng." Note: the Former Treatise writes it as "Jiancheng" with cheng meaning completion.
414
Page 3491, line 7: "Nanye." Note: the Former Treatise writes it as "Nanye."
415
殿
Page 3491, line 12: "this place was named Shangcai." Note: Qi Zhaonan's textual investigation in the Palace Edition says that, according to the preceding text, a thirty-two-character subnote under the households and population of Yuzhang Commandery beginning "The Yuzhang ji says" should be placed below this text. Looking through this treatise, whenever it cites a book, the citation must point to something specific. Above, the Yuzhang ji says, "People of Shangcai were divided off and moved to this place," which is precisely the explanation of "this place was named Shangcai." It is not known why the "Yuzhang ji" passage was moved forward; later people then failed to correct it.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →