← Back to 晉書

卷一百二十七 載記第二十七 慕容德

Volume 12 Records 27: Murong De

Chapter 127 of 晉書 · Book of Jin
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 127
Next Chapter →
1
Murong De.
2
姿
Murong De, whose courtesy name was Xuanming, was Murong Huang’s youngest son. His mother Lady Gongsun dreamed of the sun slipping into her navel, then bore him in a daytime doze. Before he came of age he already stood eight feet two inches tall, cut an imposing figure, and bore the paired “sun-brow” and “crescent moon” lines on his forehead that physiognomists read as imperial signs. He read widely, kept a cool and careful temper, and excelled at more than one craft. When Murong Jun declared himself emperor, Murong De was made duke of Liang and rose through posts as inspector of You and general of the left guard. When Murong Chui took the throne Murong De was refashioned prince of Fanyang, then advanced to prefect of the Wei capital region and given the concurrent title of regular attendant for scattered cavalry. Soon Fu Shuang, one of Fu Jian’s generals, rebelled from Shan commandery, while another general, Fu Liu, rose at Baohan to join him. Murong De urged Murong Chui to strike Fu Jian while Qin was divided, speaking with such fire that men of judgment called him far-sighted—yet Murong Chui would not act. Murong Chui, impressed, began debating statecraft and strategy with him, and Murong De’s advice was always blunt and to the point. Murong Chui told him, “Your judgment has matured—you are no longer the raw boy they used to dismiss east of the Yangzi.” At the battle of Fangtou he joined Murong Chui as general who campaigns south and helped shatter the Eastern Jin army. When Murong Chui defected to Fu Jian, Murong De lost his post as an accomplice. After Murong Chui’s rebellion collapsed he was deported to Chang’an, where Fu Jian named him prefect of Zhangye; a few years later he was sent home in disgrace.
3
使
When Fu Jian marched his host to the great river, he named Murong De general who rouses might. After Feishui, Fu Jian was separated from Lady Zhang. Murong Chui meant to rescue her and bring her along. Murong De said gravely, “When King Zhuang of Chu annexed Chen he listened to Wu Chen and turned his back on the fatal beauty Xia Ji. Such women are ill omens—they topple kings. Camp followers and concubines have no place in a retreating army; Qin’s rout began with just this sort of indulgence. Cover your eyes and ride past—why would you drag her into our column?” Murong Chui refused to listen; Murong De spurred his horse and rode away in disgust. When they halted at Xingyang he told Murong Chui, “Goujian of Yue once swallowed humiliation on Mount Kuaiji—and in the end swallowed Wu. The sage waits for the moment; when he moves, every stroke succeeds. Heaven is already punishing Qin for its crimes—its hosts lie broken on the field. Strike now while they reel and you can win back the Murong altars.” Murong Chui would not listen. Murong De followed him north to Ye.
4
鹿 使
When Murong Chui declared himself king of Yan he made Murong De grand general of chariots and cavalry, restored his princedom of Fanyang, kept him at court to secure the capital, and gave him a voice in every policy decision. In time he was promoted to minister of education. At that time Murong Yong held Changzi with a hundred thousand men under arms, and Murong Chui planned a campaign against him. The courtiers hesitated, but Murong De came forward and argued that the three royal forebears had long accumulated moral credit still remembered in song, which was why Murong Chui's rise had drawn support as if by fate; while his martial prestige mattered, old loyalty mattered too, and the elite of Yan and Zhao were willing to serve Later Yan. Now that Murong Yong had proclaimed an illegitimate regime, incited Chinese and frontier peoples, and set petty warlords loose in endless rivalry for the realm, Murong Yong should be eliminated first to align the army's will. Even Emperor Guangwu had rushed into Su Mao's crisis without sparing his weary officials; that was hardly cruelty on his part. The circumstances were desperate, and that explained it. Military doctrine allows action when there is no alternative; Murong Chui could hardly afford to stand aside. Murong Chui smiled and told his faction that the minister of education's counsel aligned with his own. Two minds in accord can cut through bronze, he said, and his decision was made. Murong Chui accepted the advice. On his deathbed Murong Chui ordered Murong Bao to place Ye in Murong De's hands. Once Murong Bao had taken the throne, he named Murong De commissioner with credentials, supreme commander over military affairs in Ji, Yan, Qing, Xu, Jing, and Yu, specially advanced, chariot-and-cavalry general-in-chief, and governor of Ji, with the southern barbarian colonelcy, based at Ye; he dissolved the rear administration and concentrated southern affairs under Murong De's unified command.
5
退 𧨳 西
The Wei commander Tuoba Zhang assaulted Ye, and Murong De dispatched Murong Qing, Prince of Nan'an, and others on a night attack that routed him. The Wei forces pulled back to Xincheng, where Murong Qing and his colleagues asked permission to attack. Han Fan, the provincial adjutant, urged that the ancients decided victory in council before they took the field. He listed four reasons not to strike the Wei army and three reasons Later Yan should stay put. Wei's troops were deep in hostile territory and favored open battle, which was the first reason not to engage them. They had thrust close to the heartland and camped on perilous ground, which was the second reason to hold off. Their front had been beaten but their rear was consolidating, which was the third reason to avoid battle. They outnumbered Murong De's forces, which was the fourth reason not to strike. Murong De's army fought on home soil, which was the first reason not to stir. A failed sortie would shatter morale, which was the second reason to stay still. The defenses were unfinished and left Murong De exposed if the enemy came, which was the third reason to remain passive. These were classic taboos in the art of war; better to deepen ditches, heighten walls, and wait out the enemy at leisure. Their supply lines stretched a thousand li across empty country, so prolonged operations would drain their stores; repeated assaults would bleed their columns, wear would breed disorder, and careful timing could bring victory. Murong De replied that Han Fan's counsel matched the quality of Zhang Liang and Chen Ping. He therefore recalled Murong Qing and withdrew the troops. Wei dispatched Helai Lu, Prince of Liaoxi, with cavalry to cooperate with Tuoba Zhang in the siege of Ye; Murong De sent Liu Zao to Yao Xing for aid and news of his mother and brother, but no relief came and panic spread through the ranks. Murong De then hosted the soldiers himself, lavished care on them, and they repaid his kindness with a will to fight to the death. Tuoba Zhang and Helai Lu fell into mutual discord and slipped away with their commands. Ding Tong, chief clerk under Tuoba Zhang, defected with his troops and reported that Zhang's army was exhausted and vulnerable. Murong De sent a commander in pursuit who crushed Tuoba Zhang's force, and morale finally firmed.
6
Meanwhile Wei troops entered Zhongshan, Murong Bao fled toward Ji, and Murong Xiang proclaimed himself at Zhongshan. When Liu Zao came back from Yao Xing's court, Yao Xing's director of astronomy Gao Lu sent his nephew Wang Jinghui with him bearing a jade seal plus charts and cryptic prophecies declaring that virtue brought prosperity and its absence brought ruin. They proclaimed that Murong De bore Heaven's mandate, supple yet ultimately unyielding. A popular verse added that whirlwinds would scour the land, cryptic signs would spark uprising, the realm would boil while Zhongshan collapsed, and only the virtuous man would seize the Three Terraces. Murong De's officials argued that with Murong Xiang's usurpation at Zhongshan, Wei's power swelling in Ji, and Murong Bao's fate uncertain, Murong De should take the imperial dignity. Murong De refused. Soon Murong Da arrived from Longcheng claiming Murong Bao was alive, and the push for enthronement stopped. Murong Bao then appointed Murong De chancellor and governor of Ji, empowering him to govern the south.
7
使 退 輿
Murong Lin, Murong De's nephew, fled from Yitai to Ye and warned that Wei would press its victory against Ye after Zhongshan's fall; grain reserves were ample but the sprawling walls were hard to hold, and shaken morale made fighting unwise. He urged Murong De to move the army south across the river before Wei arrived, join Murong He, Prince of Luyang, seize Huatai to stockpile men and supplies, and strike when opportunity allowed—the best course. Even if Wei seized Zhongshan, it could not linger; it would raid the population and withdraw. The populace would resist forced migration and turmoil would follow; Murong De could then project power to support them, leaving Wei caught between interior and exterior foes, while he won over the displaced with mercy and credibility and gathered the refugees for a decisive blow. Murong He had already advocated a southern shift, so Murong De agreed. In the second year of Longan Murong De moved forty thousand households and twenty-seven thousand carts from Ye toward Huatai. Storms sank the flotilla as Wei closed in, spreading panic and talk of retreating to Liyang. That night the river froze solid, allowing a night crossing; by morning Wei arrived as the ice thawed, as though the gods favored Murong De. He renamed the Liyang crossing the Heavenly Bridge Ford. Upon reaching Huatai, a propitious star appeared in the Tail and Basket lunar mansions. The Zhang River produced white jade in the form of an imperial seal. Murong De then followed Later Yan's precedent, proclaimed his own inaugural reign, amnestied capital crimes and below, and set up a full bureaucracy. He named Murong Lin minister of works and chief of the secretariat, Murong Fa central-army general, Yu Ba senior vice-president of the secretariat, Ding Tong junior vice-president, and distributed other posts accordingly. Earlier a qilin sighting in Hejian had led Murong Lin to claim it as his personal portent. When his plot surfaced he was condemned to death. That summer Helai Lu of Wei brought his command over to Murong De's side.
8
使 退 輿 殿
Murong Bao then fled south from Longcheng to Liyang and dispatched Zhao Si, his central palace gate director, to call Murong Zhong to escort him. Murong Zhong, who had first urged Murong De to take the throne, took offense, jailed Zhao Si, and sent a courier to inform Murong De. Murong De told his followers they had pressed him into regency for the dynasty's sake. He added that with the heir-apparent in flight and the realm leaderless, he had bowed to their advice to hold expectations together. Now that Heaven seemed to relent and the heir might return, he would ready his equipage to welcome Murong Bao, confess his faults at court, then withdraw to private life with a scholar's headwrap—what did they think? Gentleman attendant at the yellow gate Zhang Hua replied that only a heroic figure could revive the state in an age of contention. In a shifting balance of power no timid man could save the day. If Murong De indulged petty mercy, threw away a mandate Heaven had given him, and let power slip away, he would lose his life—there was no virtue in abdicating then. Murong De answered that the ancients took power boldly yet ruled legitimately, a balance he had not mastered, which left him torn and unresolved. Yu Hu volunteered to ride north and learn Murong Bao's true situation; Murong De sent him off in tears. He led hundreds of picked men north with Zhao Si plotting to murder Murong Bao. After dispatching Zhao Si, Murong Bao had learned of Murong De's assumption of power and fled north in fear. Yu Hu found no sign of Murong Bao, seized Zhao Si, and came back. Murong De intended to employ Zhao Si for his knowledge of court precedent. Zhao Si replied that even Guan Yu, honored by Cao Cao, had not forgotten his first master's grace. Though he was a castrated menial favored by the state, even dogs and horses kept loyalty—how much more a man. He begged leave to rejoin his sovereign and prove his humble loyalty. Murong De pressed him to stay. Zhao Si angrily cited how Jin and Zheng buttressed declining Zhou and how the Prince of Liang had saved Han from the Rebellion of the Seven States. As the emperor's uncle and a minister of the highest rank, he should have rallied the lords to restore the house, yet he exploited the dynasty's peril like Sima Lun's usurpation. Zhao Si could not match Shen Baoxu's weeping at the court of Qin, yet he still envied Junbin for refusing to live under Wang Mang. Murong De flew into a rage and had him executed.
9
The Jin governor of Nanyang, Lüqiu Xian, and Ningshuo general Deng Qifang marched twenty thousand troops against him and encamped at Guancheng. Murong De sent Central Army Murong Fa and Pacification General Murong He to meet them, and the Jin army was routed. Murong De blamed Murong Fa for breaking off the pursuit of the Jin force and executed his Pacification Army major Jin Gui.
10
When Fu Deng fell to Yao Xing, his brother Fu Guang led their followers to submit to Murong De, who named him Champion General and settled them at Qihuo Fort. Mars stood over Dongjing; some claimed Former Qin would revive. Fu Guang thereupon proclaimed himself King of Qin and routed Murong De's general Murong Zhong. Murong De had only just set his capital at Huatai between Jin and Wei, holding fewer than ten towns and only a few tens of thousands of troops. After Murong Zhong's defeat, many wavering followers went over to Fu Guang. Murong De left Murong He to hold Huatai, marched in person against Fu Guang, and killed him.
11
退 輿𧨳 西
When Murong Bao came to Liyang, chief clerk Li Bian urged Murong He to admit him, but Murong He refused. Li Bian feared exposure, drew Jin troops to Guancheng, and hoped Murong De would take the field himself so Li Bian could raise revolt behind him. Murong De did not march, and Li Bian grew still more anxious. When Murong De set out on this campaign, Li Bian again pressed Murong He to revolt, and Murong He again refused. Li Bian slew Murong He in rage and handed Huatai over to Wei. With every soldier's family inside the walls Murong De prepared to strike, but Han Fan said Wei held the town and its stores, the strategic balance had flipped, morale was brittle, and battle was unwise. Han Fan urged seizing a base like Guanzhong first, building strength, then striking back as the superior course. Murong De called off the assault. Right Guard general Murong Yun executed Li Bian and led out over twenty thousand dependents, to the army's delight. Murong De asked his court how to advance against strong enemies with no rear base now that Fu Guang was dead but Huatai was lost. Zhang Hua argued Pengcheng's terrain and wealth made it a capital worth taking by force. Murong Zhong, Muyu Hu, Feng Cheng, Han Fan, and others pressed to retake Huatai, while Pan Cong called it a hub ill suited to an imperial seat. Pan Cong warned that Huatai lay open to Wei and to Yao Xing's Qin and could not be held with complacency. He added that Pengcheng was open ground where Jin would block Later Yan's advance. Pan Cong noted its nearness to the rivers, floods, and Jin's naval strength. He argued water fighting favored the southern foe, so even victory there would not secure Murong De long term. He praised Qi and Qing as Eastern Qin, populous, defensible, and rich for military power. Pan Cong said the Qi elite yearned for a worthy ruler to follow. He named Guanggu, Cao Yi's fortress, as defensible enough for a capital. He proposed envoys then an army, arguing Bi Lü Hun who had wronged Later Yan would flip or yield. If Bi Lü Hun resisted, Pan Cong expected him to collapse under pressure. Holding Guanggu would mirror Han control of Guanzhong and Henei. Murong De remained undecided. Murong De consulted the monk Lang Gong, versed in astrology. Lang Gong endorsed Pan Cong's strategy as state building. He read a comet over Xu and Wei as Qi's astrological field and an omen of renewal. He urged securing Lu, touring Langye, then besieging Linqi in autumn as Heaven's course. Murong De marched south, winning the north of Yanzhou and installing officials. His troops refrained from looting, elders were cared for, and locals brought food and drink to the road.
12
使 西
Murong De summoned Bi Lü Hun in Qi commandery; when he refused, Murong Zhong attacked with twenty thousand men. Taking Langye, Murong De drew over a hundred thousand from Xu and Yanzhou and forty thousand more north of Langye. He took Ju as garrison commander Ren An fled, leaving Pan Cong to hold the city. Murong Zhong's proclamation to Qingzhou cited fate and classical precedent. He claimed crisis revealed the destined sage ruler. He compared Later Yan to King Xuan and Emperor Guangwu reviving ruined dynasties. He described the realm's fragmentation after Yongkang. He accused Bi Lü Hun's father Bi Wei of banditry with Duan Kan until Later Yan's eastern campaign extirpated them. He said Bi Lü Hun survived Later Yan's mercy yet oppressed Qi, courted the south, and exploited the people. He framed Murong De's great army as punishing Qi and Lu for sheltering Bi Lü Hun at Yingqiu. He likened the campaign to Han Xin's swift conquest of Qi. He cited Geng Yan's rapid victory over Bu Mao. A Later Yan host could crush a corner rebel more easily still. Murong Zhong boasted one hundred twenty thousand picked cavalry and infantry under his command. No city could withstand such an assault. No enemy could stand against that force. Dou Rong's submission to Han brought lasting honor. Peng Chong's revolt ended in ignominious death. Cao Yi's arrogance ended in capture by Later Zhao. Duan Kan's breach of order brought destruction under the previous regime. Murong Zhong asked whether history did not show clear outcomes. Bi Lü Hun would be richly rewarded if he repented. Resistance would mean total annihilation. He offered founding minister rank for Bi Lü Hun's head. If men missed the chance to defect, victor and vanquished alike would be ruined. Learning of Murong De's approach, Bi Lü Hun moved over eight thousand households into Guanggu. The commanderies submitted to Murong De on Murong Zhong's summons. Bi Lü Hun fled toward Wei with his family. Murong De sent She Sheng colonel Liu Gang to run him down and execute him at Ju. Bi Lü Hun's staff officer Zhang Ying had co-written strident edicts with him. Murong De captured Zhang Ying and reproached him. Zhang Ying calmly compared himself to Kuai Tong serving Han Xin under Bi Lü Hun. Kuai Tong was spared while he faced death, which he called ill luck beside the precedent. He accepted guilt like Fangfeng yet hinted Murong De lacked sage kings' virtue. Murong De first admired the answer but still executed Zhang Ying. Murong De marched into Guanggu.
13
使 輿輿
In the fourth year he took the imperial title at the southern altar, amnestied the realm, adopted the Jianping era, placed a mobile temple south of the palace, and dispatched envoys to announce the deed. He promoted Murong Zhong to steward, Muyu Ba to minister of works, Feng Fu and Muyu Hu as left and right directors. He sent Feng Kai and Feng Cheng to tour local customs and feast the troops. He named his consort Lady Duan empress. He founded an academy with two hundred students from elite families.
14
調調
Drunk at court he asked which classical ruler his modest diligent reign resembled. Ju Zhong compared him to Shaokang and Guangwu. Murong De told his staff to award Ju Zhong a thousand bolts of silk. When Ju Zhong objected to the lavish gift Murong De called it banter for banter. Murong De said Ju Zhong's flattery earned a joking reward that need not be refused. Han Fan objected that rulers should not jest and ministers should not dissemble. He called the exchange mutual deception and a failure for both sides. Murong De delighted in the rebuke and gave Han Fan fifty bolts of silk. Frank counsel flourished and the court gained upright officials.
15
便西 祿 祿使 祿
Murong De sent Du Hong to Chang'an for news of his mother and brother, and Du Hong vowed to reach Zhangye or die trying if he failed. Du Hong asked a county stipend for his aging father to show filial duty. Zhang Hua called Du Hong venal for asking pay before departing. Murong De refused to withhold reward for a mission to fetch his kin. He read Du Hong's request as loyalty and filial piety beneath a mercenary surface. Murong De named Du Xiong magistrate of Pingyuan. Du Hong was killed by bandits at Zhangye; Murong De mourned him and richly aided his family.
16
The next year atop Yingqiu Murong De wondered at Yan Ying's tomb near the walls against ritual. He asked whether the sage Yan Ying meant to lie so close to the market and walls. Qingzhou graduate Yan Mo noted Confucius had praised his forebear Yan Ying. Yan Mo implied Yan Ying chose humility over pomp despite knowing better. Yan Mo explained that Yan Ying kept government in the family and used austerity to set the tone for his age. He lived in a mean alley—at death could he pick his burial ground? He lay close to the gate because he still hoped to echo Yan Ying's lifelong intent. He brought Yan Mo to the Han-era temple of Prince Jing of Chengyang, feasted elders at Shen Pool, climbed Sheshou, looked toward the tripod hills, then gazed at Mount Niu and sighed that no one escapes death. He was overcome with melancholy and half wished to end his days there. He quizzed Yan Mo on Qi's geography and famous stories. Yan Mo answered in fluent detail and sketched a map in the dust. Murong De was so impressed he named him a gentleman of the Masters of Writing. He opened ironworks on Mount Shang and salt monopolies at Wuchang Marsh to swell the army's coffers.
17
殿
His old clerk Zhao Rong arrived from Chang'an with word of his mother and brother's deaths; Murong De howled until he coughed blood and fell gravely ill. Metropolitan commandant Murong Da seized the moment to rebel, sent Huang Kui against the Duan Gate, and won inside help from Hou Chimei. A eunuch helped Murong De over the wall into hiding. Duan Hong and the rest heard the alarm and sealed the four gates with troops. Murong De re-entered the palace, executed Hou Chimei's faction, and Murong Da fled to Wei. Murong Fa clashed with Wei north of Ji near Biaoyu and routed them.
18
𧨳西 使 退 𧨳使 𧨳
Han Fan memorialized that Western Qin and Eastern Jin still shamed the dynasty, the old capitals lay in ruins, and loyal men should ache to strike. Yet the house of Jin still staggered, so great evils went unstruck. People muttered that a morning's peace bought no lasting safety. Murong De's policy favored mercy, light taxes, and rest for the people. That could secure Shandong but would not recover the deep south or the northwest. Rebels still held three fronts against him. Han Fan urged building food and forces for offense and defense. He described tax evasion through hidden households and urged registration reform before harsher punishments. Registering real households would help revenue and justice. Han Fan offered to carry the policy even at personal risk. Murong De agreed and sent Murong Zhen to seal the frontier against flight. He named Han Fan inspector and uncovered fifty-eight thousand concealed households. Han Fan camped in the fields and never troubled the locals.
19
使
Murong De convened the academy and presided over the examinations himself. Over wine he mourned to Lu Sui how Qi's literati had vanished into weed-covered graves. Lu Sui compared him to rulers who honored ancient worthies' graves. He said Murong De's kindness outshamed King Wu and Gaozu.
20
西 西
A charlatan named Wang Shi had declared himself emperor on Mount Tai with a full family of bogus titles. Murong Zhen took him and executed him publicly. At the block he claimed his imperial kin were 'in exile' or dead to mutiny. Only I, he said, was left alive. His wife snapped that his big mouth had doomed him. He answered, 'My empress! He asked if any dynasty lasted forever.' Even as the headsman's blade rang on his skull he insisted on his emperor title. Murong De only laughed.
21
漿 西 使 西 使
When Huan Xuan prepared his coup he purged dissenters. Several Jin officials fled north to Murong De. Han Fan urged exploiting Huan Xuan's usurpation. When the hour strikes but no worthy leader stands forward, no great restoration can be achieved. When a capable man lacks the right season, even heroic designs cannot take flight. True success needed man and heaven in accord. Seven years had passed since Jin's internal collapse. Han Fan called Huan Xuan worse than Dong Zhuo and ripe for attack. No opportunity could top the present. Murong De could crush him as easily as echo follows sound. Jin's lower Yangzi defenses were still thin. Ten thousand men could sweep to the lower Yangzi and meet surrender. Victory would yield territory to face Qin and Wei. No better moment existed to enlarge the realm. Delay would let Jin recover and close the window. Miss the moment and trouble would follow. Heaven-sent chances wasted bring regret. He begged Murong De to act. Murong De answered that he nursed a long grudge against the barbarians who ruined Luoyang. He cited Shaokang and boasted his Shandong base and trained army. He still meant to pacify the north before marching south. His southern strike remained deferred. He asked his nobles to debate Han Fan's plan. The court judged Huan Xuan too strong for the moment and dropped the idea. He staged a review west of the city with hundreds of thousands on parade. He flattered the Jin defectors as avengers like Xi Ke and Wu Zixu. He urged them to live up to those models. They swore loyalty in return. When news came of Huan Xuan's fall Murong De mobilized then canceled the campaign because of illness.
22
Murong Chao, whom he had summoned from Chang'an, now arrived. Murong De dreamed his father told him to adopt Murong Chao as heir. He told his consort the dream foretold his death. He named Murong Chao crown prince and issued a broad amnesty. He died the same month at seventy sui. They ran decoy coffers out each gate and hid his true burial in the hills. His reign lasted five years. His temple posthumous title was Emperor Xianwu.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →