← Back to 舊唐書

卷一百二十四 列傳第七十四: 薛嵩 令狐彰 田神功 侯希逸 李正己

Volume 124 Biographies 74: Xue Song, Ling Huzhuang, Tian Shengong, Hou Xiyi, Li Zhengji

Chapter 128 of 舊唐書 · Old Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 128
Next Chapter →
1
漿
Duan Xiushi, whose courtesy name was Chenggong, came from Qianyang in Long prefecture. His grandfather Da served as a middle officer of the Left Guard. His father Xingchen had been secretary of Tao prefecture; on account of Xiushi's achievements he was posthumously enfeoffed as Great Governor-General of Yangzhou. Xiushi was profoundly filial. When he was six, his mother fell ill and he refused all food and drink for seven days; he resumed eating only after she had begun to recover. As an adult he was grave, steadfast, and resolute.
2
西西 西使 歿
In Tianbao year 4, Anxi commissioner Ma Lingcha appointed him deputy general. He took part in the attack on Humi with distinction and was given the post of deputy general of the Anxi command. In year 7, Gao Xianzhi succeeded Lingcha and led an army to besiege Talas. When the Black Robe forces arrived to relieve the city, Xianzhi was routed and the troops scattered. During the night he heard chief commander Li Siye and shouted a rebuke: "The army has been beaten and you seek only to save yourself—that is not how a true man behaves." Siye was deeply ashamed. He and Xiushi then rallied the scattered soldiers and restored the force. After the army returned, Siye asked Xianzhi to appoint Xiushi as his staff judge and had him made fruit commander of the reconnaissance command. In year 12, Feng Changqing succeeded Xianzhi and marched against Greater Bolü. The army encamped at Hesalao city, gave battle, and prevailed. As Changqing pressed the pursuit, Xiushi urged him forward: "The enemy is feigning weakness to lure us on. Post guards on both flanks and search the wooded hills." They destroyed the ambush and he was transferred to strike commander of Suide prefecture. When Suzong acceded at Lingwu he called up the Anxi army, but commissioner Liang Zai was secretly plotting treason. Xiushi said to Siye, "Can it be right that the Son of Heaven is in distress while his servants sit idle, trusting idle rumors? Is that what you intend?" Siye then went to Zai and pressed him to mobilize; Zai agreed. Five thousand foot and horse were dispatched under Siye's command toward Shuo-fang, with Xiushi as his second; they won repeated victories. Xiushi's father then died, and his mourning exceeded what the rites prescribed. Once Siye held independent command he felt as if he had lost both hands without Xiushi, memorialized for his recall from mourning, appointed him companion to the Prince of Yi, and made him staff judge.
3
西 西使 祿
When An Qingxu fled to Ye, Siye joined the allied armies in besieging him, while the Anxi baggage train was deposited at Henei. He memorialized to appoint Xiushi chief administrator of Huai prefecture with military and civil authority, and additionally as acting commissioner. The allied forces fought at Chousi Hill. Siye was killed by a stray arrow in camp, and the men chose Anxi army commander Lifei Yuanli as his successor. On hearing of Siye's death, Xiushi wrote to vanguard general Bai Xiaode instructing him to send troops to escort the coffin to Henei. Xiushi led his officers to the border to receive the procession in mourning and spent his private fortune on the funeral. Yuanli admired his conduct and recommended him for probationary vice director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments while retaining him as staff judge.
4
使 祿 使 西 使
After the defeat at Mang Hill the army withdrew to Yicheng. Yuanli was murdered by his own men and many officers perished, but Xiushi alone escaped through his wits. The troops installed Bai Xiaode as commissioner and morale steadied somewhat. He was promoted to probationary director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments and served as Xiaode's staff judge. When Xiaode was reassigned to Binning, he recommended Xiushi as probationary director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and deputy for supply and army farms. As the main army marched west it looted every district along the route. Because Binning lacked grain and supply lines were strained, they asked to encamp the army at Fengtian. Public granaries were empty, county officials fled in panic, and bandits roamed in gangs; Xiaode could not suppress them. Xiushi remarked privately, "Put me in charge of discipline and this would not happen." The army marshal relayed this, and Xiushi was appointed chief inspector with provisional authority over the Fengtian camp. His discipline was ironclad, order returned to headquarters, and Daizong heard of it with prolonged admiration. When the troops returned to Binning he resumed as chief inspector and was soon appointed prefect of Jingzhou.
5
使 使 使 使
In Dali year 1, Ma Lin was recommended for the honor of Grand Master with Gold Seal and Purple Ribbon. A soldier who could draw twenty-four bows had been caught stealing; Lin wanted to spare him. Xiushi said, "When a commander plays favorites, the law loses its force—even Han Xin and Bai Qi reborn could not govern such an army." Lin accepted his reasoning and had the man executed. Whenever Lin's decisions were unsound, Xiushi argued him down until Lin admitted his mistake. While Lin fortified Jingzhou, Xiushi served as rear-area administrator; on Lin's return he was promoted to vice censor-in-chief. When Lin was ordered to transfer his headquarters to Jingzhou, his troops—who had marched from the Four Garrisons and Beiting to save the empire—found themselves uprooted again and nursed deep grievances. The executioner officer Wang Tongzhi exploited the unrest to incite mutiny. An informant reported the plot, adding that they would rise when the night watch tightened, using the alarm drum as their signal." Xiushi summoned the drummer, rebuked him ostentatiously for negligence, and ordered him to report at the end of every watch." Each time the man reported, Xiushi delayed the drum by several quarters until the fourth watch had passed and dawn broke. With the timing thrown off, Tongzhi's uprising never materialized. The next day the informant warned that the conspirators would set the fodder yard ablaze that night and use the fire brigade as cover for a mutiny." Xiushi tightened security throughout the camp. " At midnight the fire broke out. He issued an army-wide order: "Anyone who fights the fire will be executed." Tongzhi, stationed in the outer camp, asked permission to enter and fight the blaze; Xiushi refused. The next day he executed Tongzhi, killed more than ten accomplices as a warning, and proclaimed, "Anyone who delays the transfer will be punished with extinction of his clan!" The army then marched to Jingzhou. At the new headquarters the land was nearly deserted and there were no public stores of grain. The court, alarmed at the shortage, ordered Lin to draw supplies remotely from Zheng and Ying prefectures to feed the Jingyuan army, with Xiushi as rear administrator; he governed both districts admirably. Impressed by his record, Lin recommended him as field marshal and overall commander of the army.
6
使 使使 使 退
In year 8 the Tibetans invaded; at Yancang our forces were defeated. Lin was cut off by the enemy and failed to return by nightfall; routed officers and soldiers stampeded through the gates. Chief commander Jiao Lingchen and four or five other officers straggled in in disorder. Xiushi summoned them and rebuked them: "Military law demands that when the commander is lost, his subordinates pay with their lives. Have you forgotten your duty to die and seek only to save yourselves?" They were terrified and kowtowed repeatedly. Xiushi mustered every soldier in the city who had not yet fought, placed them under his best commanders, and drew up a screen of troops on the plain east of the city to feign readiness for battle, rallying the fugitives as he did so. The Tibetans sighted the formation and dared not advance. Lin did not make it back until nightfall. In year 11 Lin fell gravely ill and could not govern; he asked Xiushi to serve as acting deputy commissioner and commander of the left wing. Xiushi appointed tenth-rank commander Zhang Yufei to muster the troops, deployed the army under arms, and prepared for any emergency. When Lin died, mourning was conducted within headquarters while Li Hanhui received guests at the gate. Only kin were allowed beside the bier; anyone who clustered in factional talk was arrested. Chief inspector Shi Tinggan and staff generals Cui Zhen and Zhang Jinghua plotted a coup; Xiushi sent Tinggan to the capital and transferred Zhen and Jinghua to distant posts, restoring order without a single execution. Xiushi was soon appointed prefect of Jingzhou, chief censor, and military commissioner of the Jingyuan, Zheng, and Ying circuit of the Four Garrisons and Beiting field army. For three or four years the Tibetans did not raid the border. His austerity and simplicity won praise throughout the realm. Outside official functions he neither listened to music nor drank wine; he kept no entertainers or concubines and amassed no private fortune; after office hours he sat alone in contemplation. When Dezong acceded, Xiushi was concurrently appointed acting Minister of Rites and Prince of Zhangye.
7
使 使西
In Jianzhong year 1, chief minister Yang Yan sought to revive Yuan Zai's plan to fortify Yuanzhou and open the Lingyang canal. The emperor sent a palace envoy to report on the project and to ask Xiushi's opinion. Xiushi argued that spring was no season for corvée labor and asked that work wait until after the harvest. Yan, resenting his opposition, transferred him to Minister of Agriculture and gave Binning commissioner Li Huai'guang the added post of Jingyuan commissioner to push the western expansion. Soon afterward Liu Wenxi rebelled, and the fortification was never built.
8
輿 使
In year 4, Zhu Ci seized the capital. Yuan Xiu urged him to stage a false welcome for the emperor while secretly advancing the rebellion. Ci dispatched general Han Min with three thousand cavalry and infantry in a forced march on Fengtian. The court, caught off guard, had no defenses ready. Ci believed that Xiushi—who had once commanded Jingyuan and won the soldiers' loyalty, then been stripped of his army—must nurse a long grievance and would join the rebellion; he summoned him to counsel. Xiushi feigned compliance while secretly persuading generals Liu Haibin and He Mingli and Yao Lingyan's aide Qi Lingyue to assassinate Ci and march to receive the emperor. All three had long been in Xiushi's favor and gave their assent. When Han Min was sent to pursue the emperor, Xiushi saw the dynasty's peril as imminent and dispatched a runner to Qi Lingyue to steal Yao Lingyan's seal. When that failed, he stamped a recall order with the Minister of Agriculture seal applied upside down. Min received the order at Luoyi station; his men could not tell the seal was reversed and turned back in panic. Xiushi told Haibin and the others, "If Min reaches the emperor, our whole party is finished! I will strike Ci down with my own hands; if I fail I shall die—but I will never bow to this traitor." He arranged with Haibin to follow up if the attempt failed and told Mingli to act from outside. The next day Ci called Xiushi to council with Yuan Xiu, Yao Lingyan, Li Zhongchen, and Li Ziping in attendance. Xiushi came in armor and sat beside Ci. When the talk turned to usurpation, he sprang up, seized Yuan Xiu's wrist, snatched his court tablet, and lunged at Ci, spitting in his face and shouting, "Traitor! I wish I could cut you to pieces—did you think I would join your rebellion?" He struck Ci down. Ci threw up his arm to block the blow, which glanced off his forehead; bleeding, he crawled away. The conspirators stood frozen and dared not move; but Haibin and the others never came. Xiushi cried, "I will not rebel with you—then kill me!" The traitors rushed in and slew him. Haibin, Mingli, and Lingyue were executed in turn. At Fengtian, Dezong heard the news, lamented that he had not used Xiushi to his full capacity, and wept for a long while.
9
歿
Earlier, seeing how few and poorly trained the palace guard were, Xiushi memorialized: "I have read that the Son of Heaven commands ten thousand chariots, a feudal lord one thousand, a grandee one hundred—meaning that the greater rules the lesser and the many control the few. The principle of exalting the sovereign, subordinating ministers, and strengthening the center while weakening the periphery rests on this foundation. Yet now barbarians defy us on the frontier and disobedient ministers plot within. I see that the palace guard is neither well trained nor numerous; if disaster strikes, what shall we depend on? A tiger inspires fear among beasts because of its claws and fangs. Strip away its claws and fangs, and even dogs and cattle can stand against it. I beg Your Majesty to give this matter your attention, however slight the benefit may be." When the Jingyuan mutiny broke out, the Shence Six Armies were called up—and not one man answered. Xiushi held firm to his loyalty and died at the rebels' hands; such was his foresight and heroic devotion.
10
使 歿
In the second month of Xingyuan year 1, an edict proclaimed: "To face danger and give one's life is loyalty; to face duty with courage is valor. You alone upheld the integrity of a loyal servant and did not shrink from death; I therefore praise your merit and proclaim it in the grand rites of state. The throne has fallen short of virtue and cannot match Heaven's mandate; deep calamity has struck and rebellion has convulsed the capital. Ministers and officials cried out with nowhere to turn; under coercion and fear, right and wrong were confounded alike. The late Grand Master Duan Xiushi, acting Minister of Rites and concurrent Minister of Agriculture, Supreme Pillar of State and Prince of Zhangye—his conduct stood like a mountain, his loyalty ran deep, righteousness showed in his face, and his courage was always tempered by humanity. He had lately governed Jingyuan with a reputation for stern justice and kindness; the mutineers knew his discipline and turned to you in good faith. The traitor Zhu Ci concealed his treachery and lured you with deceit. He upheld a subject's highest duty, saw through the arch-villain, arrayed himself at the palace gate, and threw himself against drawn steel. He swore to strike down the rebel leader to avenge his sovereign, welcomed death as homecoming, and walked among tigers unafraid. Alas, Heaven had not yet lifted the curse; success slipped from his grasp; yet his heroic spirit struck terror into the rebels. Of old Wang Shu died to preserve his integrity and Zhou Yi faced down tyranny with stern words—our faithful servant stands unashamed beside these sages. His fame resounds through the realm, his righteousness crowns all ages, and he shall inspire humanity and shine forever in history. Without extraordinary reward, how can uncommon merit be displayed? We therefore rank his merit above ordinary limits, inscribe it in the statutes, and set this example for posterity. He is posthumously appointed Grand Commandant with the posthumous title Loyal and Valiant; the historiographers are to record this, and five hundred enfeoffed households plus an estate are granted. His eldest son is granted a regular third-rank office; all other sons receive regular fifth-rank offices. Court mourning is observed for three days; after the capital is recovered, he shall receive full rites of burial and sacrifice, and his household shall be publicly honored. We bear Heaven's mandate over the multitude; if a single man goes without, the fault is Ours—how much worse when trust fails and invaders come again and again, casting loyal men into the hands of traitors. Some face peril and give their lives, growing more glorious in death; others achieve success in crisis and bend expedience to the right path; when the state benefits, life and death are one; rewards for such service cannot be bound by ordinary rules. Let the relevant offices investigate such cases and report in detail; exceptional honors shall be granted, including well-field revenues. Their portraits shall hang in the Cloud Tower and their deeds be cast on bronze vessels, so that Our loyal servants who died for righteousness shall live forever." When Dezong returned to Chang'an, another edict read: "The posthumously appointed Grand Commandant Xiushi embodied steadfast valor and roused a failing age; amid sudden crisis he concealed a heroic resolve. He sought to save the dynasty, deceived the rebel forces into turning back, disrupted their plot, and brought Our cause to fruition. He charged forward and struck at the rebel leader; his heroic name stands awe-inspiring, resounding through the ages. Officials shall be sent to perform sacrifices; his household shall be honored; all funeral expenses shall be provided by the state. A state stele shall be erected at his tomb to proclaim his glory." From the Zhenyuan era onward, whenever amnesties and festival proclamations praised loyal martyrs, Xiushi was always named first.
11
簿 殿 使 使 歿 西使 使 殿
His son Bolun rose to the post of Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent. In the first month of Dahe year 2 he memorialized: "My late father, posthumous Grand Commandant Xiushi, was by prior edicts to receive a temple and stele. Construction is complete; we request the enshrinement rite on the twenty-fifth of this month." The edict replied: "Xiushi loyally defended the altars of state; his merit warrants temple sacrifice; the moral force he embodied remains awe-inspiring after a thousand years. Merit of this order requires exceptional reward: grant five hundred bolts of silk from the revenue office stores. The relevant offices shall supply sacrificial victims, provide imperial escort and attendants, and assign one Erudite of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices to supervise." Bolun was soon appointed acting Left Regular Attendant and concurrent Supervisor of the Palace. In the eleventh month of Dahe year 4 he was made Great General of the Right Gold Crow Guard, concurrent Chief Censor, and street commissioner. In the seventh month of year 8 he was appointed acting Minister of Works and commissioner of Fujian; he later entered the capital as Minister of the Stud and died. Chief minister Li Shi reported: "Bolun was Xiushi's son. From antiquity, none who gave his life for the state matched Xiushi in worth." Wenzong said with compassion, "Bolun should receive additional funeral gifts." Court was suspended for one day in honor of the loyal servant's heir. Yan Zhenqing, whose courtesy name was Qingchen, came from Linyi in Langye. His fifth-generation ancestor Zhitui had been a Yellow Gate Attendant of Northern Qi. As a youth Zhenqing studied diligently, showed literary talent, and excelled at calligraphy. During the Kaiyuan reign he passed the jinshi examination in the top class. He was renowned for filial devotion to his parents. He was four times appointed investigating censor and served as trial reviewer of garrison and supply disputes for the Hexi and Longyou armies. At Wuyuan a wrongful case had languished unresolved; Zhenqing arrived and settled it at once. The region was in drought; rain fell when the case was resolved, and the people called it "the Censor's Rain." He also served as trial reviewer for the Hedong and Shuofang armies. When Zheng Yanzuo had left his mother's coffin in a monastery wall for twenty-nine years, Zhenqing impeached him; the brothers had been ostracized for thirty years, and the whole empire took notice. He was promoted to palace censor and Eastern Capital investigation staff judge, then to attendant censor and vice director in the Ministry of War. Yang Guozhong, angered that he would not ally with him, posted him out as prefect of Pingyuan.
12
祿 祿祿 祿使 祿 祿 祿 祿
As An Lushan's treason became plain, Zhenqing used seasonal rains as a cover to repair walls, dredge moats, secretly muster men, and fill granaries, while openly hosting literati for boating, wine, and poetry on the outer pond. Some informed on him to Lushan, who also had him watched but dismissed him as a harmless scholar. Soon Lushan rebelled and all Hebei fell—only Pingyuan stood ready. Zhenqing sent staff officer Li Ping in urgent report to the throne. When Xuanzong first heard of the rebellion he sighed, "Among the twenty-four commanderies of Hebei, is there not one loyal man?" When Ping arrived the emperor rejoiced and said to his attendants, "I do not even know what Yan Zhenqing looks like, yet he has done this!" Lushan at first still sent orders for Zhenqing to post seven thousand men from Pingyuan and Boping to guard the river crossings, with Boping prefect Zhang Xianzhi as his deputy. Zhenqing recruited ten thousand warriors in ten days, put recorder Li Zejiao in charge of their training, and appointed Diao Wansui, He Lin, Xu Hao, Ma Xiangru, Gao Kanglang, and others as generals. After Lushan captured Luoyang he killed garrison commander Li Guang, chief censor Lu Yi, and staff judge Jiang Qing, and sent their heads with Duan Ziguang to intimidate Hebei. Fearing panic among his men, Zhenqing told the generals, "I knew these three men—these are not their heads." He had Ziguang cut in two at the waist and secretly preserved the three heads. Later he restored the heads with proper adornment, supplied straw limbs, gave them full burial rites, and wept before their spirit tablets; loyalty to him deepened. Lushan posted generals Li Qin'an, Gao Miao, He Qiannian, and others to hold Tumen Pass. Zhenqing's cousin Gao Qing, prefect of Changshan, and chief administrator Yuan Lüqian killed Qin'an and Miao and sent He Qiannian captive to the capital. With Tumen opened, seventeen commanderies submitted the same day and chose Zhenqing as their leader, raising more than two hundred thousand men who blocked the rebels across Yan and Zhao. He was appointed vice director of the Ministry of Revenue while retaining his post as prefect of Pingyuan.
13
西 使 使𡻳 使西 𡻳使 西 使 祿
Li Mo of Qinghe, barely twenty, came with local men to request troops and told Zhenqing, "Your righteous leadership has launched the restoration; the Hebei commanderies look to you as their bulwark. Qinghe is your western neighbor; I have lived there and know its strengths—it can serve your purpose. Its stores are three times those of Pingyuan and its troops twice as strong. Win it over and you gain a vital ally; the lesser towns will follow as the arm moves the fingers. Whatever you command, who would refuse?" Zhenqing lent him a thousand troops. As Mo was leaving, Zhenqing asked, "The troops are marching—what counsel do you offer?" Mo replied, "The court has sent Cheng Qianli with a hundred thousand men down the Taihang toward Lukou, but the rebels hold the pass and he cannot advance. First strike Wei commandery, kill Yuan Zhita, and make prefect Sima Chui commander of the southwest; send a detachment to open Lukou and free Qianli's army to attack Ye and Youling; Pingyuan and Qinghe with a hundred thousand allies march on Luoyang while detachments hold the strategic crossings. The imperial army numbers at least a hundred thousand. Hold your walls and avoid battle; within ten days the rebels will collapse and turn on each other." Zhenqing agreed, summoned Qinghe and neighboring districts, and sent Li Zejiao, Fan Dongfu, He Lin, and Xu Hao forward. With four thousand from Qinghe and a thousand from Boping, the allied force encamped at Boping, ten li southwest of Tangyi. Yuan Zhita sent Bai Sishen and Yi Shumeng with twenty thousand men to meet them; the rebels were routed and more than ten thousand were beheaded. When Suzong reached Lingwu he appointed Zhenqing Minister of Works, concurrent Chief Censor, and Hebei investigation and suppression commissioner. Lushan sent Shi Siming and Yin Ziqi in a swift offensive; Raoyang, Hejian, Jingcheng, and Dong'an fell in turn. Only Pingyuan, Boping, and Qinghe still held out, but morale collapsed beyond recovery.
14
西 輿 使 使 西使 西
In the tenth month of Zhide year 1 he abandoned his post, crossed the river, and traveled through the Jiang-Huai and Jing-Xiang regions. In the fourth month of year 2 he had audience at Fengxiang and was appointed Minister of Justice, soon also Chief Censor. Palace drafter and vice director of Personnel Cui Yi appeared drunk at court; remonstrance grandee Li Heji behaved improperly in the ranks—Zhenqing impeached them; Cui Yi was demoted to Right Vice Heir Apparent and Li Heji to secretary of Xiping commandery. The Prince of Guangping led two hundred thousand Shuofang and Han troops to recover Chang'an; on the day of his departure the officials came to pay their respects in court. The officials bowed; he returned their bows; the farewell followed the same form. Before the palace gate the prince did not mount but walked out through the Wooden Horse Gate before riding. Guan Chongsi, the prince's chief inspector, mounted before the prince did; Zhenqing memorialized to impeach him. Suzong said, "I instruct my son earnestly whenever he goes forth, so he would not breach etiquette. Chongsi is an old general with a foot ailment; for now I wish to be lenient—say no more." The emperor returned the memorial to Zhenqing. Even though the emperor had fallen on hard times in exile, he did not neglect ritual and law. When the emperor's carriage was about to return to the capital, Li Xun of the Secretariat was sent ahead to announce the temple rites. The officials drafted the prayer text, referring to the emperor as "the succeeding Son of Heaven." Yan Zhenqing said to Cui Qi, the commissioner of ritual: "The Retired Emperor is still in Shu—is this acceptable? Cui Qi immediately memorialized the throne to have the wording changed. An imperial message praised him, acknowledging that as a leading scholar he had a deep grasp of ritual propriety. At that time the Imperial Ancestral Temple had been destroyed by rebels. Yan Zhenqing memorialized: "In the Spring and Autumn period, when the new palace burned, Duke Cheng of Lu mourned for three days. Since the Imperial Ancestral Temple has been destroyed by rebels, I ask that an altar be built in the open country, that the emperor face east and mourn, and only then send out envoys. In the end his proposal was not adopted. On military and state affairs, he spoke out whenever he had something to say. Resented by the chief ministers, he was sent out to serve as prefect of Tong Prefecture, then transferred to Pu Prefecture. Framed by the censor Tang Min, he was demoted to prefect of Rao Prefecture. He was soon appointed prefect of Sheng Prefecture and military commissioner of the Zhejiang West Circuit, then recalled to serve as Minister of Justice. Li Fuguo forged an edict moving Emperor Xuanzong to the Western Palace. Yan Zhenqing was the first to lead the whole court in submitting a memorial inquiring after the retired emperor's health. Fuguo resented this and had him demoted to senior administrator of Peng Prefecture.
15
使
When Emperor Daizong came to the throne, Yan Zhenqing was appointed prefect of Li Prefecture, then promoted to Vice Minister of Revenue and named military commissioner of Jingnan. Before he could take up that post he was removed from it and appointed Left Vice Director of the Imperial Secretariat. As the imperial carriage was about to return from Shaan, Yan Zhenqing asked that the emperor visit the Five Tombs and the Nine Temples before returning to the palace. Chief Minister Yuan Zai said to Yan Zhenqing: "Your view is admirable, but what of the fact that it does not suit present circumstances? Yan Zhenqing stepped forward angrily and said: "Whether I am kept or dismissed is for you to decide—but what crime is there in speaking out? Yet how can the chief minister again tear down the institutions of the court!" Yuan Zai deeply resented him. He was soon made Acting Minister of Justice with charge of routine affairs, and in time was enfeoffed as Duke of Lu. At that time Yuan Zai was filling the government with his own men. Fearing that court officials would report his misconduct, he proposed that whenever any official wished to raise a matter, he must first inform his department head, who would inform the chief minister, and only then would the matter reach the emperor. Yan Zhenqing submitted a memorial, saying:
16
退 使 使 使
The Assistant Censor-in-Chief Li Jin and others conveyed the chief minister's words, stating that they followed his instructions: "Because officials of the various departments submit memorials in great number, I do not shrink from reviewing them, but many of the submissions are laced with slander; from now on, those who wish to discuss affairs must first inform their department heads; the department heads must inform the chief minister; the chief minister decides whether the matter is acceptable, and only then is it memorialized to the throne. Since I heard this policy announced, court and countryside have been in uproar, and many hearts have grown timid. Why is this? The heads of the various departments are high officials whose words reach the emperor directly on their own authority. Gentlemen of the departments and the censors are Your Majesty's own eyes and ears. That is why, when they are sent out across the empire, they are charged to investigate everything, great or small, and report back on their return—this is how the ruler keeps wide-open eyes and ears. If Your Majesty now shuts off your own eyes and ears and refuses to see or hear clearly, what will the realm have left to tell you? The Book of Odes says: "Buzzing blue flies settle on the thorns. Slander knows no bounds and together throws the four states into chaos. This is because slander can turn white into black and black into white. The poet hated this deeply, and so said: "Take those slanderers and throw them to the wolves and tigers. If the wolves and tigers will not eat them, throw them to the northern wastes. Bo Ming of Xia, Wuji of Chu, and Jiang Chong of Han were all slanderers—who did not hate such men? Your Majesty's hatred of slander shows that you truly understand what it means to be a ruler. Why does Your Majesty not examine matters more carefully? Those whose accusations prove false are slanderers, and should be punished; those whose accusations prove true are upright men, and should be rewarded. Your Majesty has chosen not to do this, so that everyone will say you cannot see clearly, that you are weary of listening, and that you are using this policy as an excuse to reject honest counsel. I cannot but grieve for Your Majesty.
17
便 便
I have heard that Emperor Taizong was diligent in listening and reviewing, and common affairs were thereby put in order. Therefore he set down in the Gate Office Regulations: "If someone without a gate pass has an urgent memorial, the Gate Guard Office and the palace guard are both to lead him in to memorialize, and no obstruction is permitted. This was meant to guard against obstruction and concealment. He also kept two horses saddled and ready in the palace guard, so that urgent business could be carried to him at once. This was precisely how he kept the realm in order. After the Tianbao era, as Li Linfu's power and authority grew daily, any minister who memorialized without first consulting the chief minister would still be attacked on some other pretext, yet even he did not dare openly require all offices to inform the chief minister first. Moreover, the eunuch Yuan Siyi daily carried edicts to the Secretariat; whatever Emperor Xuanzong did or did not do, he always told Linfu in advance, who would memorialize requests before they were needed. Xuanzong was astonished and delighted as though at the work of a god. By this means his power and imperial favor grew daily, until people were afraid even to meet one another's eyes in the streets. The sovereign's intent was not carried down, and the feelings of those below did not reach above—therefore the disaster at Tong Pass gradually arose. All of this was because powerful ministers misled their ruler and did not follow Emperor Taizong's methods. Decline has carried us down to today; all the concealment in the realm has gathered upon Your Sacred Person—did Your Majesty bring this upon yourself? Rather, it arose gradually over time. At the very start of the crisis, the people had not yet been worn down, and peace could still have been restored at once. But Li Fuguo wielded power, the chief ministers monopolized government, and they indulged one another in turn, none willing to speak frankly. They broadly opened the Three Commissions, could not set the restless at ease, rebels scattered, soldiers fled north to the Tangut tribes, gathered bandits together, and this remains a plague to this day. Rebel generals frightened one another in turn; because Shi Siming was fearful, he was stirred up and turned against the court again. Moreover, the defeat at Xiang Prefecture and the fall of the Eastern Capital wore the Late Emperor down until his life was shortened. Each time I think of it, grief cuts me to the bone.
18
退使
Now warfare under Heaven has not yet been stilled, wounds not yet healed—how can Your Majesty fail to daily hear frank speech to broaden your sight and hearing, yet wish suddenly to block the path of loyal remonstrance! I have privately heard that when Your Majesty was at Shaan Prefecture, those who memorialized were not limited by rank high or low, and every effort was made to broaden what was heard and seen—this was the conduct of Yao and Shun. Officials and commoners alike thought that a reign like Emperor Taizong's could be expected at any moment. I have also heard that for a gentleman it is hard to advance and easy to withdraw. From this it follows that even when the court opens a path where nothing is taboo, there is still fear that men will not speak—how much more so when there is weariness and slackness, when the chief minister announces decisions in advance, and when the Censorate is made to draw up regulations forbidding direct access! From this point on, if no one dares to memorialize, then what Your Majesty hears and sees will come from only two or three people. Men of talent under Heaven are just now clamping shut their mouths. Later, when Your Majesty sees that no one memorializes, you will surely think the court has no affairs worth discussing—how would you know they are afraid and dare not come forward? In that case Li Linfu and Yang Guozhong will rise again. Officials and commoners alike will think that disaster is again near at hand—and they will not have long to wait. A matter like today's has never existed since antiquity; even Li Linfu and Yang Guozhong did not dare to be so openly brazen. If Your Majesty does not awaken early, you will gradually become isolated, and later even if you regret it there will be no remedy! I know full well that to offend a chief minister is to risk punishment beyond measure, yet I cannot bear to fail Your Majesty. I plead with all the urgency I can muster.
19
His remonstrance was this fierce and impassioned. Eunuchs then competed to copy the memorial and circulate it outside the palace.
20
使 使
Later, while acting as officiant at the Imperial Ancestral Temple, he spoke in court about the sacrificial vessels not being properly maintained. Yuan Zai convicted him of slander and had him demoted to vice-prefect of Xia Prefecture, then prefect of Fu and Hu Prefectures. After Yuan Zai was executed, Yan Zhenqing was appointed Minister of Justice. When Emperor Daizong died, he was made commissioner of ritual. Also, because the posthumous titles of the seven sage emperors from Emperor Gaozu downward had become numerous, he submitted a proposal asking that the original posthumous titles be taken as fixed. Yuan Cuan blocked him with flattery and opposition, and the proposal was dropped. When Yang Yan became chief minister, he hated him and changed his post to Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent while leaving him commissioner of ritual as before—outwardly showing honor, but in fact removing his authority.
21
使便 使
When Lu Qi monopolized power, he envied him, changed his post to Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent, removed him as commissioner of ritual, and said to Yan Zhenqing: "For a regional appointment, which place would suit you best? Yan Zhenqing waited for Lu Qi at the Secretariat and said: "Because of my narrow temperament, I have been hated by petty men and banished more than once. Now I am worn and old; I am fortunate if the chief minister will shelter me. When your late brother, the assistant censor-in-chief, sent his head to Pingyuan, I did not dare wipe the blood from his face with my clothes, but licked it with my tongue—can you bear not to tolerate me?" Lu Qi started back and bowed, but nursed rage in his heart. When Li Xilie captured Ru Prefecture, Lu Qi memorialized, saying: "Yan Zhenqing is trusted throughout the empire; if he is sent to persuade Xilie, troops need not be mobilized. The emperor agreed. The court turned pale. When Li Mian heard of it, he thought the court would lose a senior elder and bring shame on the dynasty, and secretly memorialized asking that Yan Zhenqing be kept. He also sent men to intercept him on the road, but they did not arrive in time.
22
退 使使 使 祿 西 使
When he first met Li Xilie and was about to announce the imperial edict, more than a thousand of Xilie's adopted sons drew their blades and pressed in on Yan Zhenqing, threatening to cut him to pieces. The generals swarmed around cursing and insulting him, raising their blades at him, but Yan Zhenqing did not stir. Li Xilie quickly shielded him with his own body, waved off his men, and when they withdrew, bowed to Yan Zhenqing and escorted him to quarters. Thereupon he pressed him to draft a memorial clearing his name and asking that troops be withdrawn. Repeatedly he sent Yan Zhenqing's nephew Xian and several parties of attendant officials in succession to the capital. The emperor gave no response to any of them. In each letter to his sons he wrote only to maintain the family temple faithfully and care for the orphans. Li Xilie gave a great banquet for the rebel party, summoned Yan Zhenqing to sit, and had him watch singers and actors revile and profane the court in mockery. Yan Zhenqing said angrily: "Sir, you are a subject of the throne—how can you let these people behave like this? Yan Zhenqing brushed off his robes and stood up. Li Xilie was ashamed and shouted for the performance to stop. At that time the envoys of Zhu Tao, Wang Wujun, Tian Yue, and Li Na were seated there. They looked at Yan Zhenqing and said to Li Xilie: "We have long heard of the Grand Preceptor's fame and virtue. Sir, you wish to assume a great title—and now the Grand Preceptor has arrived. Is this not Heaven's mandate for a rightful enthronement? If you seek a chief minister, who should come before the Grand Preceptor? Yan Zhenqing sternly rebuked them, saying: "What sort of chief minister would that be! Have you gentlemen not heard of Yan Gaoqing? He was my elder brother. When An Lushan rebelled, he was the first to raise loyal troops, and when he was killed he cursed his captors without ceasing. I am nearly eighty, have risen to Grand Preceptor, and will uphold my brother's integrity until I die. Do you think I would yield to your threats and blandishments!" The rebels dared not speak again. Li Xilie then detained Yan Zhenqing, set ten armored soldiers to guard him, and dug a square pit in the courtyard labeled "Yan's pit," but Yan Zhenqing remained calm and unconcerned. Later Zhang Boyi was defeated at An Prefecture. Li Xilie had Boyi's banner of command and severed head brought to display to Yan Zhenqing in boast. Yan Zhenqing wept in grief and threw himself to the ground. Later Li Xilie's generals Zhou Zeng and others plotted to strike at Ru Prefecture, turned their troops around and killed Xilie, and proclaimed Yan Zhenqing military commissioner. When the plot was exposed, Xilie killed Zeng and his accomplices and sent Zhenqing to Longxing Temple. Expecting death, Zhenqing drafted a final memorial, wrote his own epitaph and funeral ode, and often pointed to the west wall of his room, saying, "This is where I shall lie." After Xilie seized Bianzhou and declared himself emperor, he asked Zhenqing about court ritual. Zhenqing replied, "I am an old man who once managed state ceremonies—I remember only how feudal lords paid homage to the Son of Heaven."
23
使 使
In Xingyuan year 1, as imperial forces rallied, the rebels feared a coup at Caizhou and sent generals Xin Jingzhen and An Hua to Zhenqing's quarters. They piled firewood in the courtyard, drenched it with oil, and announced: "If you will not submit, burn yourself." Zhenqing threw himself toward the flames; Jingzhen and the others pulled him back and reported to Xilie. When Dezong recovered the capital, Xilie's brother Xiqian, who had joined Zhu Ci's faction, was executed. Xilie flew into a rage on hearing the news. On the third day of the eighth month of Xingyuan year 1 he sent eunuchs with Jingzhen and others to kill Zhenqing. They announced, "There is an edict." Zhenqing bowed. The eunuch said, "You are sentenced to death." Zhenqing said, "This old servant deserves death—but when did the envoy leave Chang'an?" The eunuch replied, "From Daliang." Zhenqing shouted, "You are a traitor—what edict is there!" They strangled him. He was seventy-seven.
24
使 歿 祿 使
After the Huai and Si regions were pacified, in Zhenyuan year 1 Chen Xianqi escorted Zhenqing's coffin to the capital. Dezong mourned him with extraordinary grief. Court was suspended for five days and he was given the posthumous title Cultured and Loyal. Another edict proclaimed: "Between ruler and subject, merit is recorded in life and honors multiplied in death—how much more when talent served the state and loyalty cost one's life. We sigh at the thought and are troubled waking and sleeping. The late Guardian Grand Preceptor Yan Zhenqing, Duke of Lu and Supreme Pillar of State—gifted by nature, outstanding in public loyalty, he served four reigns with unwavering resolve. When rebels ravaged the realm he was sent to negotiate; held captive for years, he died unbowed. Such integrity is as if he still lived. We brought this calamity upon him and cannot express our shame and grief; We therefore honor him with a grand posthumous rank and extend favor to his descendants. He is posthumously appointed Minister of Education and granted five hundred bolts of silk. When his sons Yun and Shuo completed mourning, the relevant offices recommended them for promotion beyond ordinary rank." At the southern suburban sacrifice in the eleventh month of Zhenyuan year 6, the amnesty granted one of Zhenqing's sons a regular fifth-rank office, and Yun was appointed. Wenzong's edict read: "Whenever We read the dynastic histories and encounter loyal martyrs, We sigh long and wonder how to repay them. We have heard that Conglan and Hongshi are grandsons of Gao Qing and Zhenqing. The dead cannot be recalled, but honoring their descendants accords with right principle. Those with long service records shall be appointed to central offices; those not yet established among officials shall serve as assistants in the capital. Thus may the moral wind of the realm be renewed." Zhenqing's great-grandson Hongshi was appointed army staff officer of Tongzhou.
25
歿
The historiographer writes: I think of Xian Zhen baring his head and Zilu tying his cap-strings—loyal acts, yet not the fullness of the Way. Chenggong was filial at home, capable in the field, and loyal to the state—a hero of martial virtue; had Yang Yan not manipulated power and had he been made a general to use his full talent, would Zhu Ci's disaster have occurred! Qingchen was learned, upright, and preserved his integrity to the end—a paragon of civil culture; had Lu Qi not hated the upright and had he been made chief minister to enact his policies, would Li Xilie have rebelled! A state with worthy men is secure; without them it is in peril. Dezong trusted villains within and rejected the good without, nearly destroying the dynasty—as was fitting. Alas! "To take benevolence as one's burden—is it not heavy? Only at death does one rest—is it not a far-reaching aim!" Both men upheld the Way unto death, leaving lessons for their age—rare spirits who glorify the civil and martial traditions. The commentator says: All men die; to die upright is to die in accord with Heaven's order. Both men are gone, yet their example instructs ten thousand generations.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →