← Back to 舊五代史

卷六十二 唐書38: 列傳14 孟方立 張文禮 董璋

Volume 62 Book of Later Tang 38: Biographies 14 - Meng Fangli, Zhang Wenli, Dong Zhang

Chapter 62 of 舊五代史 · Old History of the Five Dynasties
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 62
Next Chapter →
1
Meng Fangli, (Ouyang Xiu's history says he was from Xingzhou; the Zizhi Tongjian says from Qianzhou.)〉 In 882 he was posted as garrison commander at Tianjing Pass in Zezhou. Huang Chao was then ravaging the capital region, and commanders changed across the provinces as unpredictably as at dice. Earlier Shen Xun and then Gao Shi had held the Zhaoyi command, both neglectful of military affairs. During the rebellions of Gui Qin and Liu Guang, Fangli seized the interval when the Lu commander was changing hands, caught the city off guard, marched his garrison forces straight into Luzhou, and proclaimed himself acting military governor. He established his seat at Xingzhou and appointed Shen Hui to administer Luzhou. (Editorial note: There is missing text before and after these two sentences. It can no longer be recovered.)〉 In the sixth month Li Cunxiao captured Mingzhou and Cizhou; Fangli sent Ma Gai and Yuan Fengtao with his entire army to give battle at Liuli Dam. Cunxiao annihilated their force and took Ma Gai and Fengtao alive. Fangli had long been harsh and impatient, and his favor never reached the ranks. After weeks of siege he toured the walls at night to rally the defenders, but the men on the battlements met him with insolence. Seeing that the troops were beyond recall, Fangli drank poison and died.
2
使 使 使 使 西 使 使 使 使使 使
His cousin Qian, prefect of Mingzhou, had long enjoyed the soldiers' trust; the army then acclaimed him acting governor and appealed to Bian for help. The Liang founder was then besieging Shi Pu, and no relief force was sent. (The Zizhi Tongjian records that Quanzhong dispatched his general Wang Yuyu with several hundred elite troops by a secret path into Xingzhou to help hold the city.)〉 In 890 Qian seized Wang Yuyu and his men and offered surrender; the Martial Emperor sent An Jinjun to take over. (The original biography of Meng Fangli is incomplete. The New Book of Tang biography records that Meng Fangli was a native of Xingzhou. He began as garrison commander at Tianjing in Zezhou and was later promoted to roaming patrol commissioner. In 881 the Zhaoyi governor Gao Yun attacked Huang Chao, was defeated at Shiqiao, withdrew to Huazhou, and was killed by his subordinate Cheng Lin. Cheng Lin then held Luzhou, but the army was furious; Fangli marched against him, killed him, and took the city. He proclaimed himself acting governor, carved Xing, Ming, and Ci into a separate command with his seat at Xingzhou, and styled it the Zhaoyi army. The people of Luzhou asked that army supervisor Wu Quanxu be appointed acting military governor. Wang Duo then commanded the allied armies; with Luzhou still unsettled, he issued an informal commission naming Fangli acting Left Regular Attendant and Grand Censor to govern Xingzhou. Fangli refused the commission, imprisoned Quanxu, and wrote to Duo asking that a scholar-official be sent to govern Luzhou. Duo sent his adviser, Secretariat Drafter Zheng Changtu, to handle Zhaoyi affairs, hoping eventually to take command himself. Emperor Xizong personally appointed the former chief minister Wang Hui as military governor. The emperor was then in the west, the Yellow River region in chaos, Fangli holding his own ground, and Li Keyong eyeing Luzhou. Wang Hui concluded the court could not enforce its will and firmly declined in favor of Changtu. Changtu governed less than three months before departing. Fangli then recommended Li Yinrui as prefect, arguing that Luzhou was rugged and its people fierce, that successive governors had rebelled, and that he would break their spirit by moving the seat to Longgangzhou; local magnates resented the move and murmured in protest. When Keyong became Hedong military governor, Zhaoyi army supervisor Qi Shenhui appealed for troops to restore the Zhaoyi command; Keyong sent He Gongya, Li Jun, and An Jinjun against Luzhou, but Fangli defeated them. He then sent Li Kexiu, who defeated Fangli's forces, killed Yinrui, seized Luzhou, and recommended Kexiu as acting governor. Originally the Zhaoyi circuit comprised Luzhou, Xingzhou, Mingzhou, and Cizhou. Fangli now held the three eastern prefectures as his own Zhaoyi command while the court appointed Kexiu over Luzhou with its former garrison—thus the circuit was split in two. Kexiu, courtesy name Chongyuan, was Li Keyong's paternal cousin. An expert horseman and archer, he campaigned constantly, rose from commander of the Left Camp to acting governor, and was promoted to acting Minister of Works. Fangli leaned on Zhu Quanzhong for support, yet Xing, Ming, and Ci were attacked every year without respite until the region was nothing but a battlefield and farming ceased. In 886 Kexiu attacked Xingzhou, recovered the old seat, and pressed on Wu'an; Fangli's generals Lü Zhen and Ma Shuang met him at Jiaogang and were routed—ten thousand heads were taken, Zhen captured, and Wu'an, Linming, Handan, and Shahe fell. Keyong appointed An Jinjun prefect of Xingzhou to pacify the region. Fangli appealed to Wang Rong for troops; Rong sent thirty thousand men, and Kexiu withdrew. Two years later Fangli led his general Xi Zhongxin with thirty thousand men against Liaozhou, bribing Helian Duo to join the campaign. When Khitan raids delayed Duo's army, Zhongxin split his force in three columns and marched with drums beating; Keyong ambushed him in a pass, destroyed his vanguard, and routed the main body; Zhongxin was captured, and only twelve men made it back. In 889 Keyong sent Li Hanzhi and Li Cunxiao against Xingzhou and into Ci and Ming; Fangli met them at Liuli Dam, was crushed, and lost both generals; the captives were shackled and displayed before the walls of Xing with the cry, "Lord Meng, surrender at once! Whoever brings me his head shall govern the three prefectures." His strength was spent, his prefectures in ruins, and morale shattered; harsh by nature and sparing of kindness, he toured the walls at night while the troops answered with insolent complaints of exhaustion. Convinced he could not recover, he went back inside, drank poison, and died. His cousin Qian, beloved by the troops, was acclaimed acting governor and appealed to Quanzhong for aid. Quanzhong was besieging Shi Pu and could not come immediately; he sent Wang Yuyu with several hundred elite troops by a secret path after Luo Hongxin refused passage, and they slipped into Xingzhou. In 890 Cunxiao attacked Xingzhou again; Qian surrendered the three prefectures of Xing, Ming, and Ci and handed over Wang Yuyu and three hundred of his men; Qian was then transferred to Taiyuan while An Jinjun was appointed training commissioner over the three prefectures and Qian named prefect of Fenzhou. Ouyang Xiu's history records that in 901 the Liang sent Shi Shuzong against Jin through Tianjing Pass; Qian opened the gates, guided the Liang army toward Taiyuan, and failed to take the city; on the return march Shuzong passed through Luzhou and delivered Qian to the Liang. The Liang founder despised his treachery and had him executed.)〉
3
退
Zhang Wenli was a native of Yan. He began as a staff officer under Liu Rengong, a man fierce and treacherous, coarse in speech and habitually insolent in conversation; from youth he had nursed one conspiracy after another. When he followed Liu Shouwen to Cangzhou, he was given command of a detached force. Shouwen went up to Yan and Ji to visit his father, then seized the city and rebelled. When the rebellion collapsed he fled to Wang Rong. Seeing that Rong neglected government, he cultivated those in power to advance himself. He told Rong repeatedly that as a commander he stood with Sun Wu, Wu Qi, Han Xin, and Bai Qi—and that none surpassed him. Rong was impressed, lavished gifts on him, adopted him as a son, granted him the surname and the name Deming, and thereafter regularly put him in command. After the victory at Baixiang he often campaigned with Emperor Zhuangzong's headquarters. Illiterate and devoid of strategy, he won favor among timid soldiers by slandering their commanders—one knew nothing of advance or retreat, another nothing of tactics—and on that basis the men hailed him as a fine general.
4
使
When the Liang general Yang Shihou held Weizhou, Wenli led thirty thousand Zhao troops on a night raid into Jing and Zong and pressed into Bei commandery. Shihou marched ahead with several thousand foot and horse and laid an ambush at Tangdian. Wenli looted heavily and withdrew with his men singing victory songs in the night, armor bundled on their backs; at Tangdian Shihou's ambush closed on every side and slaughtered them almost to a man—Wenli alone escaped on horseback. Even afterward he bragged before the other generals until one reproved him: "The affair at Tangdian is hardly something to boast about." Wenli flushed with shame. After long service at Zhenzhou he saw negligent government and an isolated populace, and constantly nursed rebellious designs; when drunk he would vent vicious threats to his attendants, chilling everyone who heard him. Wang Rong alone remained unsuspecting and drew him into his inner circle; he replaced Wenli in the field army with Fu Xi and made Wenli commissioner of city defense, after which Wenli watched only for his chance. When Rong executed Li Honggui he handed power to his son Zhaozuo. Zhaozuo was harsh and ignorant of human affairs, having long cultivated an air of lofty dignity; once power was his he plotted day and night to supplant his father and exterminated to the last man every courtier who had once curried favor.
5
Earlier Li Honggui and Li Ai had held real power, placing kin and allies in every key post, so that would-be traitors could not stir—and Wenli feared them deeply. After Honggui's execution his five hundred followers, fearing punishment, gathered in tears and whispered among themselves, unsure where to flee. Wenli exploited their disaffection and secretly incited them: "The prince has ordered me to slaughter you all. I remember how for more than ten years you bore arms for me, for family and state alike; if I obey and kill you, I betray you; if I keep silent, I fail you. The soldiers wept. That night they rose in mutiny, killed Wang Rong and his son, and annihilated the clan—only Zhaozuo's wife Lady Zhu, who had connections with the Liang, was spared; she soon sent word by a secret path to the Liang: "The Wang house has fallen to mutineers, but Princess Puning is safe." Wenli acceded to the bandit leader Zhang Youshun's request, took the title of acting governor, and administered affairs from Tancheng. He reported to the throne and demanded the commissioner's insignia; he soon sent a memorial urging Zhuangzong's accession, and Zhuangzong, for the moment forbearing, granted his request.
6
使
A menial who had risen overnight, Wenli could not compose himself in gait or breath. Whenever he went abroad more than a thousand men with drawn swords followed; he killed innocents daily until travelers dared only glance sideways; he constantly feared imperial retribution and spun endless plots. He courted the Zhu clan in the south and the Khitan in the north, often seizing their envoys until Zhuangzong returned them—which only deepened Wenli's terror. In the eighth month Zhuangzong sent Yan Bao, Shi Jiantan, and the Zhao general Fu Xi with Wang Rong's former army to suppress him. As the campaign opened Wenli lay ill with an abdominal abscess; when he heard that Shi Jiantan had taken Zhaozhou he died of shock. His sons Chujin and Chuqiu concealed the death; inside and outside headquarters none knew, and each day they sent greetings to the bedchamber as if their father still lived. Chujin and his confidant Han Zhengshi decided major affairs together and plotted further treachery. Before Wenli's abscess broke, his household saw apparitions; after dark there were songs and wails; the wild river turned the color of blood and fish died in shoals upon the surface—those who read omens knew he was doomed.
7
歿使
In the third month of the nineteenth year Yan Bao was defeated by Chujin, and Zhuangzong replaced him with Li Sizhao. In the fourth month Sizhao was struck by a stray arrow and died in camp; Li Cunjin was ordered to take his place. Cunjin too fell in battle, and Fu Cunshen was appointed northern campaign commissioner to besiege Zhenzhou. Chujin's situation grew more desperate by the day. Ren Yuan, administrative aide of the Zhaoyi circuit, rode to the walls and explained the consequences; Chujin mounted the battlements in apparent sincerity and sent his officer Zhang Peng to offer surrender to headquarters. Soon afterward Fu Cunshen's army reached the walls. That night Li Zaifeng's son Chong lowered a rope to admit the imperial army; the troops scaled the walls and by dawn had taken the city. Chujin, Chuqiu, Chuqi, their mother, and their accomplices were captured, their legs broken, and sent to headquarters; the townspeople begged that they be minced for food. Wenli's corpse was exhumed and dismembered in the marketplace.
8
使 使
Dong Zhang had been one of the Liang's fiercest generals. As a boy he served the swaggering Master Li the Seventh alongside Gao Jixing and Kong Xun as a household page. Li, originally named Rang, lavished bribes on the Liang founder until the emperor favored him, adopted him as a son, granted the Zhu surname, and named him Yourang. When Zhang came of age he entered the Liang founder's service and rose through battlefield merit to company commander. Near the end of the Longde reign Li Jitao of Luzhou surrendered to the Liang. The Lu general Pei Yue was then garrisoning Zezhou, refused Jitao's orders, and held the city on his own account. The last Liang emperor sent Zhang to capture Zezhou and appointed him its prefect. That year, when Zhuangzong entered Bian, Zhang came to court; Zhuangzong had long known his reputation and received him generously. He was soon sent back to his former post and returned to court a year later when relieved. Guo Chongtao then dominated the government and treated Zhang with exceptional favor. In the summer of Tongguang 3 he was named acting governor of Binzhou; that autumn he received the full commissioner's insignia. In the ninth month a major expedition against Shu was launched, with Zhang as superintendent of the right wing of the field army. Guo Chongtao commanded the expedition and summoned Zhang to every council on military affairs. Shu fell that winter, and Zhang was made deputy military governor of Eastern Chuan with full control of circuit affairs. At the opening of the Tiancheng reign he was promoted to acting Grand Tutor. In the second year he was made a Fellow of the Secretariat.
9
使 使 使 使 使 宿使 西使 使
An Chonghui then held power and listened to slanderers who said Meng Zhixiang would never serve the throne, whereas Dong Zhang was loyal and should be specially favored to counter Zhixiang. Zhang's son Guangye, palace park commissioner, cultivated powerful allies at court and ceaselessly praised his father while denouncing Zhixiang. With imperial favor secure, Zhang grew ever more violent and overbearing. Envoys returning from Eastern Chuan had long reported Zhang's disrespect toward the court. In the summer of the fourth year, as Mingzong prepared for the suburban sacrifice, he sent palace envoy Li Renju with an edict to the two Chuan and dispatched An Chonghui with a letter demanding five hundred thousand in tribute from Zhang. Zhang protested that his territory was poor and narrow, and tribute was reduced to one hundred thousand. The next day Zhang gave a banquet at headquarters for Renju, but noon passed and he did not appear; spies found Renju in the relay station drinking with singing girls and guests. Zhang flew into a rage, led several hundred armed men into the relay station, and ordered the doors broken open. Renju fled in terror to an inner room and was dragged out only after a long delay. Zhang seated himself and made Renju stand below the steps, then pointed at him and raged: "When I was inspector of Weibo you were a mere escort officer—even then there was rank between us. Today I am a feudal lord and you bear the emperor's commission, yet you carouse in a relay station and dare not appear by noon for my feast—how can an envoy treat the throne's business with such contempt! Western Chuan executed the envoy Li Yan—do you think I cannot do the same to you!" He signaled his attendants to seize Renju, who wept and kowtowed until he barely escaped with his life. Zhang rode back to headquarters and dismissed the feast without ever summoning Renju. On his return Renju reported Zhang's misconduct at even greater length. Soon afterward Chonghui recommended Renju as training commissioner of Langzhou, then promoted him to full military governor.
10
使 綿 使 使
In the summer of the first Changxing year, after Mingzong completed the suburban sacrifice, Zhang was promoted to acting Grand Marshal. The two Chuan governors each maintained guard armies of at least five hundred men even in small prefectures; Zhang already suspected encirclement, and when he learned Renju had been appointed to Langzhou his decision to rebel was fixed. He wrote first to his son Guangye: "The court has carved out my subordinate prefectures as a separate command and posted three thousand troops—that is a death sentence. Tell the grand councilors for me: if the court sends even one more rider through Xiegu Pass, I will rebel and break with you forever!" Guangye presented the letter to Secretariat drafter Li Qianhui. When the court again sent the inner envoy Gou Xianyi with troops to Langzhou, Guangye told Qianhui: "Before Xianyi arrives my father will rebel. I do not value my own life, but I fear burdening the court with a campaign. Stop Xianyi's march and my father will remain loyal." Chonghui refused; before Xianyi arrived Zhang had already recalled Mianzhou prefect Wu Qianyu and imprisoned him at headquarters. Qianyu was Chonghui's trusted agent, and was seized first for that reason. In the fifth month Zhang issued proclamations to Li, Lang, Sui, and neighboring prefectures accusing them of spying for the court. He soon marched on Langzhou, captured Governor Li Renju and the officer Yao Hong, and executed them. Before his rebellion Zhang had sent envoys with rich gifts to Meng Zhixiang proposing a marriage alliance. He said the court suspected him and would replace him; flight meant ruin, staying meant punishment; his territory was small and his army weak—he could not stand alone—and he asked to marry his son to Zhixiang's daughter. Zhixiang too was estranged from the court and promised him support. When Zhixiang later marched to besiege Suizhou, Zhang was free to ravage Langzhou at will.
11
使使 使 西 使 西 · · 西
That autumn an edict stripped Zhang of his ranks and appointed Tianxiong governor Shi Jingtang Eastern Chuan campaign commissioner to lead troops against him. Zhang's son Guangye, palace park commissioner, and his entire clan were executed at Luoyang. When Shi Jingtang marched against him, supply lines failed and the army withdrew. Mingzong pursued conciliation, released Western Chuan memorial officer Su Yuan and Eastern Chuan officer Liu Cheng to their circuits, and issued no further orders beyond the phrase "both sides seek peace." Zhixiang's kin in the capital had been spared; he sent word to Zhang proposing a joint memorial of thanks to the throne. Zhang raged: "Western Chuan still has brothers and nephews alive, so you wish to reopen ties with the court—my sons and grandsons are already in the grave; what thanks is there to offer!" From that moment Zhang suspected Zhixiang had betrayed him, and the rift between them began. In the fourth month of the third year Zhang led more than ten thousand men in a surprise attack on Zhixiang. (From the biography of Zhao Jiliang in the Records of the Nine Kingdoms: Jiliang once told Zhixiang in private, "Zhang is brutal and savage; if he holds a single city firm, he will be hard to defeat." When news came that Zhang had taken the field, worry showed on Zhixiang's face. Jiliang said, "Zhang has left his base undefended—Heaven is handing victory to you." Zhang was indeed defeated soon after.)〉 Zhixiang and his generals marched to meet him and fought at Mizhen in Hanzhou. Zhang's army was shattered; he escaped with only a few dozen horsemen back to Eastern Chuan. (From the biography of Zhao Tingyin in the Records of the Nine Kingdoms: Dong Zhang raided Guanghan and was marching on Chengdu; Eastern Chuan's stores were full and his men were fearless; his advance struck terror into every heart. Zhixiang personally led his generals against Zhang before Jizong Bridge and was driven back. Tingyin feigned retreat; Zhang pursued; Zhixiang and Zhang Gongduo pressed forward; Zhang's army fell into disorder; Tingyin reformed his line and joined Zhixiang in a combined assault that shattered Zhang's force.)〉 Earlier the former Lingzhou prefect Wang Hui, whom Zhang had brought to Eastern Chuan, took advantage of Zhang's defeat, led troops to kill him, and sent his head to Western Chuan.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →