← Back to 明史

卷二百二十 列傳第一百〇八 萬士和 王之誥 吳百朋 劉應節 王遴 畢鏘 舒化 李世達 曾同亨 辛自修 溫純 趙世卿 李汝華

Volume 220 Biographies 108: Wan Shihe, Wang Zhigao, Wu Baipeng, Liu Yingjie, Wang Lin, Bi Qiang, Shu Hua, Li Shida, Ceng Tongheng, Xin Zixiu, Wen Chun, Zhao Shiqing, Li Ruhua

Chapter 220 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 220
Next Chapter →
1
Wan Shihe and Wang Zhigao (Liu Yiru)〉 Wu Baipeng and Liu Yingjie (Xu Shi)〉 Wang Lin, Bi Qiang, Shu Hua, Li Shida, and Ceng Tongheng (His younger brother Qianheng)〉 Xin Zixiu, Wen Chun, Zhao Shiqing, and Li Ruhua
2
便 西 使 殿使 西使 使使 使 使 便 歿 歿
Wan Shihe, whose style name was Sijie, came from Yixing. His father Wan Ji served as an instructor in Tonglu and was a man of scholarship. Shihe passed the jinshi in the twentieth year of the Jiajing reign, entered the Hanlin Academy as a bachelor, and was appointed principal secretary in the Ministry of Rites. After his period of mourning for his father, he asked to remain close to his mother for her care and was moved to the Nanjing Ministry of War. Through successive promotions he became Jiangxi Assistant Commissioner and each year reduced the court's porcelain tribute by more than a thousand pieces. He was transferred to Vice Commissioner for Education in Guizhou and then promoted to Administration Vice Commissioner in Huguan. He pacified twenty-eight rebel Miao stockades and received silver and silks in reward. When work on the Three Halls began, envoys sent to gather timber arrived in an unbroken stream. Shihe organized the work with meticulous care, and the people were able to live in peace. Promoted to Jiangxi Surveillance Commissioner, he was impeached and removed for exceeding the time allowed to take up his post. He was recalled as Surveillance Commissioner in Shandong and later served a second term as Left Administration Commissioner in Guangdong. Government affairs had come to be decided entirely by the left commissioner. Shihe said, "The court sets up two commissioners like the left and right hand—neither is higher or lower." He then arranged with the right commissioner to conduct business on alternate days. Summoned to be Prefect of Yingtian, he was promoted en route to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief. As supervisor of Nanjing grain reserves, he submitted six proposals to ease burdens on the people. Early in the Longqing reign he rose to Right Vice Minister of Revenue and supervised the granaries. He was soon moved to the Ministry of Rites and promoted to Left Vice Minister. He pleaded illness and went home. When Emperor Shenzong took the throne, Shihe was recalled as Vice Minister of Rites at Nanjing and served concurrently as head of the Directorate of Education. In the first year of Wanli, Lu Shusheng resigned as Minister of Rites. Zhang Juzheng, following Shusheng's recommendation, summoned Shihe to take his place. He submitted a series of proposals urging frugality. As disasters recurred, he also asked the throne to close off avenues of favor, make room for outspoken integrity, eliminate redundant offices, and restrain private solicitations—touching many sore points of the age. Altan and his followers presented tribute horses, and border officials requested additional ranks and rewards. Shihe argued that rewards had established quotas and border officials must not be indulged beyond them; the emperor approved. Daoist priests, leaning on Feng Bao, sought official appointments; Shihe stood firm against it. When Defender of the State Zhu Xizhong died, Juzheng agreed to grant him a royal title; Shihe fought the decision hard. When Supervising Secretary Yu Maoxue was punished for speaking out, Shihe argued that straightforward ministers should not be cast out. In this way he steadily offended Juzheng. Supervising Secretary Zhu Nanyong, following the prevailing wind, impeached him, and Shihe resigned citing illness. After Juzheng's death he was recalled as Minister of Rites at Nanjing but twice pleaded age and did not go. He died at the age of seventy-one. He was posthumously honored as Junior Tutor to the Heir Apparent with the posthumous title Wengong.
3
調使 西 便 西
Wang Zhigao, whose style name was Gaoruo, came from Shishou. He passed the jinshi in the twenty-third year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed magistrate of Jishui. He rose to principal secretary in the Ministry of Revenue, became an outside secretary in the Ministry of War, and was then posted as Assistant Commissioner in Henan. He earned merit suppressing Shi Shangzhao and was promoted to Administration Commissioner. He was transferred to Vice Commissioner for Military Affairs at Datong. For merit in raiding the Barbarian Ascendant faction, his salary was raised one grade; he became Right Administration Vice Commissioner in Shanxi, was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, and served as Grand Coordinator of Liaodong. He greatly expanded military colonies: each camp reclaimed one hundred fifty qing of land with four hundred soldiers. He submitted eight practical measures, and they were implemented. He was summoned as Right Vice Minister of War. Soon afterward, as Left Vice Minister, he was appointed supreme commander of Xuanfu, Datong, and Shanxi.
4
西西
In the first year of Longqing he was promoted on the spot to Right Censor-in-Chief. When Altan attacked Shizhou, Zhigao ordered Shanxi Commander-in-Chief Shen Weiyue and Battalion Commanders Liu Bao, You Yue, and Hei Yunlong to trail the invaders south, while instructing Datong Commander Sun Wu, Shanxi Deputy Commander Tian Shiwei, and others to march out through Tianmen Pass and cut off their retreat eastward. Grand Coordinator Wang Jiluo stayed at Daizhou and would not come out; Weiyue dared not advance, and Shizhou was lost. Tens of thousands were slaughtered; wherever they passed not a soul remained, and after fourteen days of wholesale looting they withdrew. When the report reached court, Weiyue, Shiwei, and Bao were condemned to death, Jiluo was sent to border service, and Wu was demoted. Zhigao, credited with holding Nanshan on the enemy's withdrawal, was merely demoted two ranks.
5
西西 西
The following year an edict named Zhigao, as Left Vice Minister, to inspect Ji, Liaodong, Baoding, Xuanfu, Datong, and Shanxi, and Vice Minister Liu Tao to inspect Shaanxi, Yan-sui, Ningxia, and Gansu. Zhigao declined on grounds of illness and Ji Lian took his place. Later, on Supervising Secretary Zhang Lu's memorial, both appointments were revoked and neither man was dispatched. In the third year he was recalled to command the metropolitan garrisons. He rose to Right Censor-in-Chief and was made supreme commander of Shaanxi's three frontiers. For the merit of Yan-Ning troops in storming enemy strongholds, one son was granted office, and he was moved to Minister of War at Nanjing. When Emperor Shenzong succeeded, Zhigao was summoned as Minister of Punishments. Zhang Juzheng monopolized government; Zhigao was related to him by marriage yet repeatedly urged restraint upon him. In the third year of Wanli he asked leave to take his mother home and, when he overstayed, was impeached. At the same time Zhigao asked to remain in mourning, and the request was approved. Later, when Juzheng's father died and he was ordered to remain in office rather than mourn, he had remonstrators flogged below the palace gates. When Juzheng returned from the burial, Zhigao urged him to recall straightforward officials and recover popular goodwill. He died and was posthumously honored as Grand Tutor to the Heir Apparent with the title Duanxiang.
6
歿
At that time there was Liu Yiru of Yiling, styled Mengzhen, who was likewise connected to Juzheng by marriage. He passed the jinshi in the thirty-eighth year of the Jiajing reign. He rose repeatedly to Vice Minister of Punishments. While Juzheng held power, he once wrote him a letter of remonstrance. After Juzheng's death his kin were all punished and dismissed; Yiru alone was famed for lofty integrity. He was soon appointed Minister of Works at Nanjing. After only half a year he pleaded illness and went home. Earlier, when Juzheng's daughter married Yiru's son, pearls, jade, and silks filled chests and boxes; Yiru sealed them all in a separate chamber. When Juzheng died his property was confiscated; Yiru then opened what he had sealed and returned it all. Nanjing Censor Li Yiyang asked that Yiru be recalled to court as a model of modest restraint. The emperor approved the memorial. Yiru never answered the summons and died at home. In the Tianqi reign he was posthumously given the title Zhuangjie.
7
Wu Baipeng, whose style name was Weixi, came from Yiwu. He passed the jinshi in the twenty-sixth year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed magistrate of Yongfeng. He was summoned as censor and in turn inspected Huai, Yang, and Huguang. He was promoted to vice director of the Court of Judicial Review and then to Right Vice Minister of the same court.
8
In the summer of the forty-second year he was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and placed in charge of Yunyang. His title was changed to Commissioner-in-Chief of Military Affairs and Grand Coordinator of Nan, Gan, Ting, and Zhang. Together with Guangdong Commissioner-in-Chief Wu Guifang he put down the Heyuan bandit Li Yayuan and the Chengxiang bandit Ye Danlou, and jointly destroyed the pirates at Haifeng.
9
西
Earlier, Lan Songshan and Yu Dajuan of Dapu in Guangdong had stirred rebellion and raided through Tong, Yan, Xing, and Quan. Government troops defeated them and they fled to Yongchun. They joined the Xiangliao bandits Su Apu and Fan Jizu in attacking Dehua, were defeated by Regional Commander Geng Zongyuan, and pretended to seek pacification. Baipeng likewise feigned a cease-fire while turning bandit sympathizers into informants; one after another he captured them all, though three strongholds still held out. The three strongholds were Li Wenbiao of Heping at Cengang, Xie Yunzhang of Longnan at Gaosha, and Lai Qinggui at Xialü. With Japanese raids pressing hard, the court had left them unpunished for nearly ten years. When Wenbiao died, his son Zhen and Jiang Yuezhao took his place and grew still more violent. In the autumn of the forty-fourth year Baipeng rose to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and continued as Grand Coordinator. He memorialized: "The three strongholds have taken royal titles; they accept pacification and rebel again in turn. Across Heping, Longchuan, and Xingning in Guangdong and Longnan, Xinfeng, and Anyuan in Jiangxi, they had swallowed more than half the districts. Unless they are crushed quickly, the harm will be beyond telling. Of the three strongholds only Qinggui, whose reach crossed six counties in Jiangxi and Guangdong, was the most rebellious; force must begin at Xialü." The emperor accepted the ministry's recommendation. Baipeng ordered Garrison Commander Cai Rulan to capture Qinggui at Kuzhu Ridge, and the bandits were struck with fear.
10
西
Early in Longqing the Ministry of Personnel, seeing how worn Baipeng was by campaigning, transferred him to Minister of the Court of Judicial Review. Supervising Secretaries Ouyang Yijing and others asked that Baipeng stay to fight bandits; an edict made him Right Vice Minister of War and Right Vice Censor-in-Chief with his grand coordinator title unchanged. Baipeng argued that spring and summer campaigns would disrupt planting and that pacification should be tried for now; the emperor agreed. He was soon promoted to Right Vice Minister of War at Nanjing. He asked to remain home and complete his filial mourning; the request was denied. He was moved to Right Vice Minister of Punishments. After his father's death he returned home; when recalled he was placed in the Ministry of War. Early in Wanli he was ordered to inspect Xuanfu, Datong, and Shanxi. Baipeng reviewed frontier officials on eight points—supplies, defiles, troops and horses, arms, military colonies, salt regulations, tribute horses, and rebel parties—and Wang Chonggu, Wu Dui, Guo Hu, and the rest were rewarded or punished accordingly. He also presented a frontier map on which every pass, tribal settlement, troop strength, and beacon distance stood out as plainly as lines on the palm. He went home to see his mother. Recalled as Right Censor-in-Chief at Nanjing, he was soon summoned as Minister of Punishments. A year later he died.
11
使 西 西 退 西 便
Liu Yingjie, whose style name was Zihe, came from Wei county. He passed the jinshi in the twenty-sixth year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed principal secretary in the Ministry of Revenue. He served as Vice Commissioner for Military Affairs at Jingxing and took charge of the Three Passes as well. From that point the Three Passes were placed under the Jingxing circuit. In the forty-third year, as Right Administration Vice Commissioner in Shanxi, he was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and made Grand Coordinator of Liaodong. He went home for his mother's mourning. In the first year of Longqing he was recalled to serve as Grand Coordinator of Henan. When Altan attacked Shizhou and Shanxi was thrown into alarm, Yingjie was ordered to the rescue. The raiders soon withdrew. Meanwhile Grand Coordinator Geng Suiqing of Shuntian was arrested for killing civilians to claim top credit; Yingjie took his place. He argued that Yongping's west gate lay only five hundred li from the sea mouth at Tianjin and could be linked to the grain route, and asked to recruit seafaring men to take grain at Tianjin and sail with transport officials to Yongping. The ministry held that grain troops should not be sent to sea; instead one hundred thousand shi from Shandong and Henan were stored at Tianjin for Yongping to haul overland.
12
便 便 西便
In the autumn of the fourth year he rose to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and kept his coordinator post. He was soon made Right Vice Minister of War and Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, replacing Tan Lun as supreme commander of Ji, Liaodong, and Baoding. He memorialized to halt mining at Yongping, Miyun, and Bazhou. Following Censor Fu Mengchun he also discussed frontier reserves and said stores should be planned according to whether the year was plentiful or lean. In good years payments in silver could ease the troops and grain could be accumulated; in bad years grain in kind could relieve famine and silver could be saved. The following year he proposed extending the canal to Miyun and wrote: "Miyun is embraced by the Chao and Bai rivers; nature meant it for transport. Formerly the two rivers split and met only at Niulan Mountain. Barges from Tongzhou went to Niulan Mountain; above that point grain was hauled overland to Longqing granary at great cost. Now the Bai had shifted west of the city, within two hundred paces of the tidal river; dredging channels and building dams to unite the streams would deepen the water and ease transport. Changping's old quota exceeded one hundred eighty thousand shi; now only one hundred forty thousand were delivered, and Miyun received only one hundred thousand, depending entirely on hired merchants—yet the region was poor and could not rely on that forever. He heard that much grain in Tong granary had rotted. If fifty thousand shi were shipped to Miyun while the garrison's thirty-five thousand taels in commuted silver were kept for the capital army, Tong would lose no spoiled grain, the capital troops would benefit, Miyun would escape forced merchants, and three aims would be met at once." The proposal was approved.
13
滿 西 使
Supervising Secretary Chen Qu, noting many empty rolls in the Ji garrison, asked to verify troops and cut expenses. Yingjie wrote: "When the dynasty first set up Daning, the Ji passes were still treated as inner country. After Daning was withdrawn inland and the three guards wavered, every defense matched Xuanfu and Datong, yet allotted troops numbered less than thirty thousand. Calling in outside troops at every alarm exhausted them on the march, and half were feeble. Plans to cut outside troops and recruit locals followed, while vagrants flocked when hungry and scattered when fed. They proposed hunting down deserters, yet those caught were often old or young and ill-suited to the ranks. The garrison runs from Zhenbian west to Shanhai east; troops must fit the ground, and three hundred thousand are required. Today resident and outside troops together barely exceed one hundred thirty thousand. Xuanfu spans six hundred li with fifteen thousand allotted troops; Datong spans more than a thousand li with one hundred thirty-five thousand allotted troops; Ji and Chang together cover both territories yet their forces alone are not enough. If we measure by those examples, how can we defend the line? The best course is to send over two hundred thousand crack troops, recover Daning, control the outer frontier, thicken the capital's defenses, link Xuanfu and Liaodong, set a second barrier for the state, and keep enemies far from the throne—a gain for ages. If not, station three hundred thousand men in linked posts so the line answers from end to end—a gain for a century. A third course is to pick one hundred seventy thousand resident and outside troops, train them properly, and stop relying on neighboring garrisons—a makeshift for the moment. Today none of this is done: troops are moved like chessmen, funds begged like alms, drill is sand in the hand, and battle practice is talk of tigers. The line is long and soldiers few; every move exposes a weakness. For now, as a last resort, fill the old resident quota of one hundred ten thousand with new recruits and rotate capital guest troops in relief, so troops are not exhausted and the border may steady somewhat." The ministry ordered a troop audit, but the plan to refill the ranks was never adopted.
14
In the first year of Wanli he became Right Censor-in-Chief and concurrent Right Vice Minister of War with his command unchanged. He rose to Minister of Works at Nanjing, was summoned as Minister of Military Administration, and was moved to Punishments. Feng Bangning of the Brocade Guard, a nephew of eunuch Feng Bao, did not yield on the road; Yingjie had him seized, and Bao took offense. When Luo Rufang of Yunnan arrived with a tribute memorial, Yingjie met him outside the walls to discuss Chan; Supervising Secretary Zhou Liangyin attacked this, and both Yingjie and Luo were impeached and removed. He died and was posthumously honored as Junior Tutor to the Heir Apparent.
15
Earlier Wang Zongmu had urged sea transport; Yingjie and Vice Minister Xu Shi proposed opening the Jiao-Lai Canal, which Zhang Juzheng strongly backed. Xu Shi went out as Concurrent Vice Censor-in-Chief; they planned to cut through mountains and channel springs at a cost of one million taels. Memorialists argued fiercely against it. Shi was recalled and the work stopped. Shi, a native of Changshu, eventually became Minister of Works at Nanjing.
16
稿 稿 使
Wang Lin, whose style name was Jijin, came from Bazhou. He passed the jinshi in the twenty-sixth year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed investigating magistrate of Shaoxing. He entered the Ministry of War as principal secretary and rose to outside secretary. He was stern and principled and did not form friendships lightly. Colleague Yang Jisheng impeached Yan Song and his grandson for feigning merit; the ministry was ordered to review the case. Shifan drafted his own reply and handed it to Selection Director Zhou Mian. Mian exposed the draft and was punished in turn. Minister Nie Bao, afraid, pressed the office to file Shifan's version. Lin protested face to face; Bao grew angry, and the finding followed Shifan anyway. When Jisheng was condemned to death, Lin brought him food and betrothed his daughter to Jisheng's son Yingji. Father and son were enraged and found other charges to throw him into the imperial prison. When the affair was cleared he was restored. After Jisheng died he collected the body and buried him. He became Assistant Commissioner in Shandong and then Vice Commissioner for Military Affairs at Kelan. He won a stern reputation; the grand coordinator resented him and had him impeached out of office. Officials and commoners together pleaded his case, and an edict permitted his reinstatement.
17
歿 西 滿
In the forty-fifth year he rose to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and became Grand Coordinator of Yan-sui. Raiders poured into Dingbian and Guyuan and Commander Guo Jiang was killed in battle. Supreme Commander Chen Qixue and Grand Coordinator Dai Cai were removed; Lin's salary was reduced one grade. At the start of Longqing raiders crossed the border six times and each time retreated in defeat. Yet Censor Wen Ruyu kept impeaching him, and he was suspended pending review. Later Censor Yang Zhen reviewed the case and affirmed his merit, and he returned as Grand Coordinator of Xuanfu. Regional commander Ma Fang was so fierce that the raiders dared not press far inland. Lin then greatly expanded military colonies, on which frontier grain reserves came to depend. When his term expired, he was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief. He was soon recalled and appointed Right Vice Minister of War. After going home on leave to see his parents, he was recalled to assist in military administration.
18
西 歿
When Shenzong came to the throne, Zhang Juzheng took charge of the government. Lin was his fellow graduate of the same year, but the two were never on good terms. When the court debated an inspection tour of the frontier, Lin volunteered to go. He was dispatched to the four Shaanxi defense commands. He flatly refused all gifts and gratuities. Once his mission was complete, he abruptly pleaded illness and went home. Only after Juzheng's death was he recalled as Nanjing Minister of Works. He was soon transferred to the Ministry of War to assist in state affairs. The eunuch defender Qiu Deyong pressed garrison troops into illicit service; Lin memorialized against this and proposed twelve measures to stabilize the southern capital. The emperor summoned him to serve as Minister of Revenue. The court had earlier ordered remissions and retained weaving funds totaling more than 1.76 million taels of silver, with instructions to replenish the Taicang vault; Lin argued: 'Your Majesty has built up reserves over more than a decade to barely three million taels; now a single year of remissions would be offset by immediate recovery into the treasury. Ten years of accumulation would not even cover what must be drawn and replenished in two. Moreover, the annual golden-flower quota already runs to one million taels; since the sixth year another two hundred thousand have been added—over six years that comes to well over a million. The vault is not an inexhaustible spring; if annual intake never stops increasing, what will sustain it later? He went on to say that the Jing and Tong granaries held eight million shi of grain, enough for nine years, and urged commutation of 1.5 million shi for a period of three years only. The emperor approved only one year.
19
便
At that time Privy Treasurer Xu Zhenming and Censor Xu Dai proposed irrigated fields east of the capital; Lin strongly backed the plan, and it was adopted. By precedent, Ministry of Revenue silver was reserved for military and state expenses and was not to be diverted elsewhere. At the emperor's grand wedding, ninety thousand taels of frontier relief silver had been temporarily diverted for weaving costs; when the court tried again, Lin objected strenuously. Soon afterward an edict ordered four thousand taels of gold for the Cining Palace, and Lin again resisted. In each case his remonstrance was rejected. He then submitted seven proposals on fiscal management, calling for thrift, emphasis on agriculture, collection of arrears, punishment of graft, expanded reserves, and tighter regulation of tribute trade. The emperor replied: 'As for matters touching me personally, I am already aware. Let the rest be referred to the appropriate offices for deliberation and implementation. Buddhism was then flourishing; Lin urged that able-bodied monks be sent back to farming and that those who assembled crowds for ritual observances be punished for heterodox practices. Minister of Rites Shen Li endorsed Lin's proposal. The edict had been approved, but consorts and eunuchs protested that it would be impractical, and the plan was abandoned.
20
調 退
He was transferred to Minister of War. Li Chengliang, commander of Liaodong, bestowed bribes throughout the capital but would not venture near Lin's door. His repeated objections while at the Ministry of Revenue had already earned the enmity of the eunuchs. While the emperor was inspecting his tomb site, a eunuch arrived with an imperial rescript demanding horses. Lin argued that sealed memorials should go through proper channels: the Directorate of Ceremonial relayed imperial orders via the secretariat to the ministries, and none should bypass that route; citing precedent, he refused to comply. The emperor was displeased. Grand Secretary Shen Shixing once asked Lin to appoint the duty officer Luo Xiu as Assistant Director of the Embroidered Uniform Guard; Lin refused. Shen Shixing then drafted an edict rebuking Lin for unlawfully withholding the imperial rescript and showing disrespect to the throne. Censors then launched a concerted impeachment; Lin requested retirement and was replaced by Zhang Jiayin. Supervising Secretary Zhang Yangmeng said: 'Luo Xiu was originally a bondservant of the eunuch Teng Xiang and bought his way into the imperial guard. When the assistant directorship came open last year, Minister Lin stood firm and was driven out by their slander. Before long Luo was promoted ahead of his rank, and public outrage erupted. Xiu was then dismissed, and Jiayin was removed as well. Though Lin had left office, his standing only grew; the court repeatedly sent envoys to inquire after him in his old age. He died in the thirty-sixth year of Wanli. He was posthumously given the title Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. Under Tianqi he was posthumously honored with the epithet Gongsu.
21
使西使使
Bi Qiang, styled Tingming, was from Shiyi. He passed the metropolitan examination in the thirty-second year of Jiajing. He was appointed a secretary in the Ministry of Justice. After serving as a director, he was promoted Vice Commissioner of Education for Zhejiang, transferred to Right Vice Commissioner in Guangxi, raised to Surveillance Commissioner, and then moved to Left Provincial Administrator of Huguang. He was summoned as Minister of the Imperial Stud, but before taking up the post was reassigned Governor of Yingtian. When Hai Rui governed Jiangnan he issued orders to the capital prefecture as though it were subordinate to him; Bi Qiang refused to comply. Hai Rui observed Bi's administration and came to respect him. He was promoted to Right Vice Minister of Revenue at Nanjing, with charge of granary affairs.
22
In the second year of Wanli he entered the capital as Right Vice Minister of Justice. He was transferred to the Ministry of Revenue as Supervisor of the Granaries. Promoted to Nanjing Minister of Revenue, he retired citing illness. Recalled as Nanjing Minister of Works, he was promptly transferred to the Ministry of Personnel and then summoned to the capital as Minister of Revenue. When sandstorms prompted the emperor to call for comments on current policy, Bi submitted nine recommendations. He wrote, in part: 'Embroidered Uniform Guard agents number more than 17,400, and the inner palace workshops employ just as many. These are the worst of idle mouths on the state payroll; spurious and excessive posts should be eliminated. Land surveys at the county level breed corruption; Yunnan minting fails to pay fair wages; posts abolished are reinstated, and land reclamation projects are halted just as they begin. He urged that local customs be respected and that policy not be changed recklessly. Robes and brocades already accumulate surplus year after year—why keep weaving more? The cost of sky lanterns runs to tens of thousands of taels—a particularly wasteful extravagance. Indiscriminate spending must be curtailed and frivolous luxuries abolished. His other proposals were likewise sharp and to the point. Favorites at court intervened to block them, and most were never implemented. Bi then cited his age and requested retirement. He was granted relay horses for the journey home. Bi was known for integrity and commanded wide respect. When he turned eighty, the throne sent envoys to inquire after him and conferred on him the title Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. The court sent further inquiries twice thereafter. When his grandson Ru Man came to court with a memorial of thanks, the emperor enrolled him as a student of the Imperial Academy. He died at the age of ninety-three. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the epithet Gongjie. Shu Hua, styled Rude, was from Linchuan. He received his jinshi degree in the thirty-eighth year of Jiajing. He was appointed magistrate-investigator of Hengzhou. Transferred to Fengyang, he was promoted supervising secretary in the Revenue Section.
23
使
Early in Longqing he rose through three promotions to supervising secretary in the Justice Section. The emperor entrusted power to eunuchs, and edicts often issued from behind the scenes. Shu argued: 'The law belongs to the realm as a whole; crimes great and small ought to be handed entirely to the judicial bureaus. If their rulings are wrong, we ministers may impeach them. If the throne instead issues edicts directly, judgments may reflect mere caprice, and both the judicial offices and we censors become figureheads. An edict endorsed his view. At the winter solstice sacrifice to Heaven he heard the emperor cough, interpreted it as a sign that yin was overpowering yang, and urged him to heed Heaven and nurture his vital yang—the memorial was blunt and urgent. An edict blamed recurring disasters on negligence in the ministries and ordered the secret police to conduct covert surveillance. Shu and his colleagues responded: 'The secret police patrol the capital only to hunt traitors and suppress bandits. Governing the bureaucracy is the emperor's prerogative, and policing official misconduct falls to the censorate—what business is that of the secret police? Ordering them to gather intelligence will open the door to manufactured charges and entrapment, harm the innocent, and leave everyone walking on eggshells—how is that governance? Besides, the secret police cannot investigate honestly themselves; they must rely on their runner-agents. Your Majesty trusts such men rather than your senior ministers? Censor Liu Sixian and others also spoke forcefully against the plan. The emperor rejected them all. In the end the matter was quietly dropped. A guard was seen carrying a corpse out through the North Peace Gate; Capital Garrison Commander Sun Chengfang, suspecting foul play, had him arrested and interrogated, and testimony implicated the eunuch Li Yangchun. Fearing arrest, Li Yangchun appealed directly to the emperor. He claimed the guard had been carrying a living man who died only after leaving the gate, that Sun Chengfang had manufactured the case, and that the runner guard had been wrongly punished. The emperor believed him, had Sun Chengfang beaten sixty strokes with the rod, and stripped him of office. Shu Hua asked that Yangchun's account be referred to the regular courts for review, but the emperor refused.
24
西
At the summer judicial review in his fourth year in office he secured the release of long-held prisoners Zheng Luchun and Li Fang; at the autumn court review he won pardon for Li Yi as well. Gao Gong was then dominant at court, and Lu Kai and Yang Shun had been condemned to death for framing and killing Shen Lian. Gao Gong wanted to spare Lu Kai, arguing that Yang Shun had been the ringleader and that Kai should go unpunished once Shun was executed. Shu Hua produced the case file and showed it to Gao Gong, saying, "Shen Lian's name does not appear in the original records at all. If a name does appear, Lu Kai's is the first. Lu Kai is plainly the principal offender. Gao Gong then proposed pardoning the immortal masters Wang Jin and others. Shu Hua objected: "The late emperor's dying wish was to spare them—but if you mean to pardon them now, what language can justify it? Having crossed Gao Gong, he was transferred out to serve as vice commissioner in Shaanxi. He submitted another memorial requesting retirement and went home.
25
Early in the Wanli reign he rose through several posts to Vice Minister of the Imperial Stud. Illness soon forced him to retire once more. He was recalled from the Nanjing Court of Revision and appointed Left Vice Minister of Justice. After the Burmese rebels in Yunnan were subdued, the emperor took the captives in state at the Meridian Gate tower. When Shu Hua read the memorial aloud, his voice rang clear and his deportment was dignified; the emperor's eyes never left him. Soon afterward the Ministry of Justice fell vacant, and the emperor personally appointed Shu Hua minister. Shu Hua said, "Your Majesty's mercy is rooted in your nature. Yet Prefect Qian Ruogeng and Prefect Fang Fuqian were sent to die on the frontier after sentences far harsher than the law allowed. I beg Your Majesty to instruct every official, high and low, to abide by the code and cease imposing punishments beyond the law. The founding emperor himself revised the Great Ming Code and had it posted in both wings of the palace. Today open cases are often ordered retried under heavier penalties, and settled ones are suddenly escalated to execution by imperial edict—as though the code itself were no longer adequate. Last winter's untimely snow and rain and the portents that have followed surely stem from this. The emperor replied with a warm and approving edict. While the Collected Statutes were being revised, he gathered 382 criminal precedents dating from the thirty-fourth year of Jiajing onward and presented them to the throne. An edict ordered their publication throughout the empire.
26
使
In the fourteenth year he answered an imperial call for candid advice with a series of memorials. He urged the emperor to honor his own edicts, clear the prisons, expedite trials, tighten forensic standards, and stop wrongful convictions—so that harmonizing Heaven and securing the people would again rest on the throne's own conscience. The emperor praised the advice and took it to heart. Fearing deception among his officials, the emperor would dispatch arresting officers at the slightest accusation, sweeping up witnesses and witnesses' witnesses until the paperwork piled high. Shu Hua argued: "The art of rule lies in holding to essentials; the throne should not usurp the duties of the regular offices. Otherwise blame falls upward while subordinates seize the chance to conceal their own misconduct. When a minor retainer of the Prince of Lu was beaten by a Capital Garrison clerk, the emperor flew into a rage, had the clerk thrown into the imperial prison—where he died under torture—and punished seven guards who had helped make the arrest. Shu Hua protested vigorously. An edict finally punished only the ringleader and pardoned the rest. The following year, during the supplemental round of the capital personnel review, Nanjing censors and remonstrators raised complaints against him. He responded with three successive memorials asking to retire. The emperor refused. When the annual prison review came due, he returned to duty. A palace eunuch conveyed the emperor's wish to pardon more than thirty men facing capital sentences; Shu Hua insisted it could not be done. An edict ultimately sided with him. Soon afterward, pleading grave illness, he was at last permitted to go home. When he died he was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the epithet Zhuangxi. Li Shida, styled Zicheng, was from Jingyang. He received his jinshi degree in the thirty-fifth year of Jiajing. He was appointed a principal secretary in the Ministry of Revenue. Transferred to the Ministry of Personnel, he served as director in the Performance Evaluation and Selection bureaus and, together with Lu Guangzu, became one of the minister's most trusted men. Early in the Longqing reign he withdrew to mourn his great-grandfather. Recalled to serve as Right Vice Commissioner for Transmission, he later held the post of Minister of the Imperial Stud at Nanjing.
27
In the second year of Wanli he was appointed Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and made grand coordinator of Shandong. He was soon promoted to Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief with charge of the waterways. Before he could assume that post, he was reassigned to govern Zhejiang instead. He soon retired on grounds of illness, but was recalled to supervise the grain transport and serve as grand coordinator of Fengyang. When the Yellow River shifted south and Huai'an came under threat, Shida proposed building stone embankments to shield the city. At Baoying, where Fan'guang Lake's storms caused annual flooding, he asked permission to cut a diversion channel to bleed off the floodwaters. Both proposals were approved. His next appointment was Right Vice Minister of War at the southern capital. Recalled to court, he was moved first to the Ministry of Revenue and then to Personnel, rising to Left Vice Minister. Promoted to Minister of Personnel at Nanjing, he was immediately shifted to the Ministry of War to assist in state affairs.
28
宿
He was soon summoned to serve as Minister of Justice. When the eunuch Zhang De beat a man to death, Shida demanded that he be handed over for trial; Tang Yaoqin of the Punishments Section backed him, and Zhang De was turned over to the regular courts. Magistrate Wang Jie of Daxing was demoted for beating court musicians; the emperor secretly sent two runner guards to monitor the trial, but on judgment day Sun Chengrong, director of touring inspection, turned them away. When the runners reported back, the emperor angrily summoned Shida for an explanation. Shida replied that covert surveillance was no way to run a court. Sun Chengrong, however, was stripped of his salary. When the Eastern Depot eunuch Zhang Jin was found guilty and impeached by a chorus of censors, the emperor bent the rules to protect him. Shida pressed his case in memorial after memorial until the emperor finally banished Zhang Jin from court. When the emperor's son-in-law Hou Gongchen's servant killed a commoner and stood trial, Shida asked that Gongchen be punished as well. The emperor stripped him of his post and ordered him to study ritual at the Imperial Academy. The convict Jiao Wencan did not deserve death under the code, but the emperor in anger had him thrown into prison. At the autumn court review the emperor ordered Revenue Minister Song Li to draft the sentence. Shida persuaded Song Li to reduce the charge against Jiao Wencan. Called before the emperor for defying his wishes, he answered every question by citing the law. The emperor would not yield. The emperor was then given to sudden rages in private, and attendants were often executed on trivial grounds; Shida seized on recent portents to submit a veiled remonstrance. During famine in Zhejiang, some officials proposed letting convicts buy their freedom with grain. Shida objected: "The law must not be set aside; it is better to grant pardon than to accept ransom. A pardon keeps mercy in the emperor's hands and leaves the law intact. Ransom puts power in the hands of the wealthy and teaches everyone to treat punishment as a price. Men of judgment applauded the argument. He was transferred to Left Censor-in-Chief. Capital Garrison Commander He Jia had tortured three men to death, and Censor Liu Siyu shielded him from prosecution. Shida impeached them both, and the emperor demoted Liu Siyu. He went on to impeach and dismiss several other censors, including Han Jie. Deeply resentful of the censorate, the emperor issued an edict rebuking remonstrators for pursuing private vendettas. Shida replied: "Men who serve loyally and speak plainly may sound harsh, but their hearts are clean. Even when motives are unclear, their words must still be heard and tolerated. Punishment should fall only on those who keep silent and flatter. Then honest counsel will flow daily and corrupt counsel will fade. The throne acknowledged the memorial. In the twenty-first year he and Personnel Minister Sun Luang presided over the capital evaluation and cleared out nearly every protégé of the ruling faction. When Performance Evaluation Director Zhao Nanxing was impeached and demoted, Shida fought hard for him—but Nanxing and his allies were dismissed instead; Shida then asked to retire and was refused. That autumn, when Vice Minister Zhao Yongxian was accused over a broken marriage engagement, Shida testified to his innocence. Directors Yang Yingsu and Zheng Cai then memorialized against him; Shida responded with a string of retirement petitions. He went home and died seven years later. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the epithet Minsu.
29
使 簿 調
Zeng Tongheng, styled Yuye, was from Jishui. His father Cunren had served as administration commissioner of Yunnan. In 1559, Tongheng became a jinshi graduate. He received a post as principal secretary in the Ministry of Justice. After a move to the Ministry of Rites, he was promoted to principal secretary in the Ministry of Personnel's office for literary selection. Established practice had allowed clerks to fill posts below the rank of assistant commissioner, but Tongheng took personal charge of every such appointment. His reputation matched that of Lu Guangzu and Li Shida. In the early Longqing reign, as director of literary selection, he brought back into service nearly every worthy official who had been passed over. Promoted to vice minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, he begged permission to resign at once. When the Wanli reign began, he was summoned back as vice minister of the Court of Revision. He went on to serve as prefect of Shuntian and then as right vice censor-in-chief and governor of Guizhou. When the censor Liu Tai fell afoul of Zhang Juzheng, the supervising secretary Chen Sanmo tried to purge Tongheng too—Tai's brother-in-law—claiming in a memorial that Tongheng was too frail to hold his post. He was ordered transferred to Nanjing but instead cited illness and went home. In Wanli 9, during the capital review of surplus officials, the supervising secretaries Qin Yao and the censor Qian Dai once more did Zhang Juzheng's bidding and put Tongheng on the list. He was forced into retirement.
30
使
Once Zhang Juzheng died, he was recalled as minister of imperial sacrifices at Nanjing. Summoned to head the Court of Revision, he was then made right vice minister of works. Overseeing construction of the imperial tomb, he cut wasteful spending by over three hundred thousand taels. He rose from left vice minister to full minister. Arms shipped in from the provinces usually fell short of standard; he proposed paying only half price for substandard goods and cutting textile production in half. The emperor approved both proposals. When the princess consort of the Prince of Ru'an asked for bridge toll revenue, Tongheng turned her down. The emperor sided with the princess consort in the end. Palace workshops had swelled to 15,800 artisans at the start of Longqing; though 2,500 were soon dismissed, eunuchs kept inflating the rolls without restraint. Tongheng submitted a memorial calling for a full audit. Even after the emperor had given his assent, palace eunuchs blocked the order. The supervising secretary Yang Qixiu protested in a memorial, but the court would not listen. When Tongheng's brother Qianheng proposed trimming redundant posts to save funds, capital garrison officers—fearing cuts to their pay—raised such a clamor that they waited outside court and mobbed Tongheng on his way out. Tongheng asked again to resign, but permission was denied. Upon completion of the Nine Gates project, he was made junior guardian of the heir apparent. He pressed hard for release, and the emperor granted him leave to return home with official transport. Recalled as minister of personnel at Nanjing, he refused the appointment. Eventually he was summoned back to the same post; only after many refusals did he accept. Wherever tax agents went they abused the people, and Tongheng remonstrated forcefully against it. In Wanli 33, during the grand evaluation of capital officials, he and Xu Bidaa, director of evaluations, stood their ground without yielding. That year the northern evaluation ran counter to the chief ministers' wishes, and an edict from the inner court kept supervising secretaries such as Qian Menggao on the rolls; while the southern evaluation and Tongheng's explanatory memorial likewise languished without response for a long time. Tongheng happened to be in the capital to receive his credentials and took the occasion to plead illness. The emperor made him senior guardian of the heir apparent and let him retire.
31
宿 使
Early in his Ministry of Personnel career, despite Yan Song being a fellow townsman and Minister Wu Peng having been his father's jinshi cohort, Tongheng never paid them private calls. He would sometimes sleep at his office and not go home for an entire month. He was close friends with the scholars Luo Rufang and Geng Dingxiang. When Minister Yang Bo lashed out at self-styled Confucians, Tongheng replied, "Many among them cultivate virtue quietly—they cannot be condemned wholesale. Even if some wear virtue as a mask, are they not still preferable to men who scramble for promotion without a shred of shame? He died at seventy-five. Posthumously he was made junior guardian and given the posthumous name Gongduan, "Respectful and Upright."
32
調 祿 祿
His younger brother Qianheng, styled Yujian. He was a student of Luo Hongxian. A jinshi of Wanli 5, he became magistrate of Hefei and was then moved to Xiuning. He rose to censor. After the supervising secretary Feng Jing impeached Li Chengliang and was punished, Qianheng—seeing that Minister Zhang Xueyan was shielding Chengliang—impeached them both. Enraged, the emperor demoted him to assistant magistrate of Haizhou. He worked his way back up to investigating magistrate of Daming and eventually became vice minister of the court of imperial entertainments. In the winter of Wanli 18, he was commissioned as censor to inspect border affairs at Datong. His impeachments forced out the regional commander and more than a dozen subordinates. Datong's local troops drew 12,000 shi in annual pay, but the soldiers collected it themselves, and civilians were crushed by the exactions. Qianheng proposed keeping only 200 men and disbanding the rest. His repeated memorials on frontier defense consistently struck at the heart of the matter. When officers hounded Tongheng, Grand Secretary Wang Jiaping sent this warning: "Armies may mutiny—will ministers? For you to humiliate a senior minister inside the forbidden precinct is a capital offense. The crowd then broke up. Minister Shi Xing argued that the assault on a senior official had shamed the realm, and supervising secretary Zhong Yuzheng said the same. The court took no action. Wang Jiaping pressed the case in a secret memorial, and the court finally docked Duke Xu Wenbi of the Rear Palace Office half a year's stipend while prosecuting the ringleaders. Qianheng was soon promoted to vice director of the Court of Revision and then to vice minister. When Zhao Nanxing, director of evaluations, was ousted in a personnel review, Qianheng defended him—crossing the chief ministers—and followed up with a letter rebutting them. Three times the court nominated him for a provincial governorship, and each time the appointment went nowhere. He resigned on grounds of illness and died soon after. Scrupulous in word and deed, Qianheng and his brother were alike celebrated for moral stature.
33
Xin Zixiu, styled Ziji, was from Xiangcheng. He became a jinshi in 1556. He was made magistrate of Haining. Promoted to supervising secretary in the personnel department, he wrote: "When the Ministry of Personnel fills posts, finding the right talent matters—but matching men to place matters even more. In the last grand evaluation, half the capital prefectures' junior officials were removed—surely the capital is not uniquely full of incompetents? The posts are grinding and the work is thankless. Assign officials according to whether the locality is taxing or easy, and grade evaluations according to whether the duties are heavy or light. The Ministry of Personnel endorsed his proposal and asked provincial governors and censors to impeach according to his scheme. While inspecting the capital garrisons, he impeached Marquis Gu Huan of Zhenyuan, who ran garrison affairs, and censor-in-chief Li Sui, who assisted him, asking that Huan be admonished and Sui removed. The emperor agreed. He rose to chief supervising secretary in the rites department. When Earl Liu Shiyan of Chengyi broke the law, Zixiu exposed his misconduct in full. The emperor revoked his title and put him under house arrest. In Longqing 1, when supervising secretary Hu Yingjia was punished for remonstrating, Zixiu defended him in a memorial. Soon afterward he argued that posthumous honors should be revoked from ministers Gu Kexue and Xu Kecheng and vice ministers Zhu Longxi and Guo Wenying; Kecheng had been a Daoist priest, Wenying a craftsman, and Kexue and Longxi had both curried favor by supplying elixirs. Promoted to vice minister of the imperial stud, he then resigned on grounds of illness.
34
祿
In Wanli 6 he was recalled as vice prefect of Yingtian and later promoted to minister of imperial entertainments. As right censor-in-chief he governed the six prefectures of Baoding. He secured a cut of 60,000 taels in combined corvée and lijia levies and had dikes built in Xiong and Renqiu counties to hold back flooding on the Hutuo River. Every autumn defense season, governors moved to Yizhou and taxed their jurisdictions for supplies—and kept taxing even after the season ended; Zixiu got the practice stopped. He served as minister of the Court of Revision, then as left and right vice minister of war, and was finally promoted to right censor-in-chief at Nanjing. The censor Shen Ruliang, inspecting the lower Yangzi, seized every fine in his circuit under the pretense of accepting gifts; Zixiu impeached him. Eager to crack down on corruption, the emperor ordered Shen Ruliang arrested—and summoned Zixiu to become left censor-in-chief.
35
使
In Wanli 15, during the capital officials' grand evaluation, the cabinet wanted to shield allies and purge dissenters. Minister of Personnel Yang Wei read the cabinet's wishes all too faithfully, so Zixiu filed an advance memorial urging that evaluations not be driven by favoritism or used to isolate opponents. The emperor approved, but the cabinet was displeased. More than a dozen grasping officials favored by the cabinet were targets Zixiu wanted removed. Supervising secretary Chen Yujiao, sensing he would not escape, charged that the censor-in-chief would ruin careers over a single misstep and gut the government at a stroke. In the end, every official Zixiu had meant to dismiss was spared. Soon censors including Zhang Minggang, in a supplementary review, opened their list with Minister of Works He Qiming. Qiming owed his standing to the eunuch Zhang Cheng through construction work and had long disliked Zixiu; he now accused Zixiu of orchestrating the charges out of private spite. Chen Yujiao and supervising secretary Wu Zhijia lent their support. Censors Gao Weisong, Zhao Qing, Zhang Minggang, and Zuo Zhiyi, taking offense, impeached Qiming for glossing over his faults with specious arguments. The emperor had already been swayed by Zhang Cheng and grew quite suspicious of Zixiu. Reading the memorial only deepened his displeasure. He said, "Every time the court appoints a man, the remonstrating officials swarm to tear him down. Qiming is leaving—name someone among you who is fit for the post. Gao Weisong and the others submitted full memorials accepting blame and nominated no one else. In anger the emperor sent them all out of the capital. Supervising secretary Zhang Yangmeng interceded on their behalf and also had his salary withheld. Wang Dexin, a clerk in the Ministry of Justice, submitted another memorial disputing the matter in language that encroached on the emperor's favorites. The emperor had him thrown into the imperial prison and tortured brutally to uncover the mastermind. He confessed to nothing, so the emperor struck him from the rolls. Zixiu himself no longer felt secure and urgently pleaded illness to resign and return home.
36
祿
Zixiu's rise had never been the cabinet's wish, and they would not tolerate him. After some time he was recalled as minister of justice in Nanjing. He was again summoned to serve as minister of works. Before he could take up the post, he died. He was posthumously made grand guardian of the heir apparent and given the posthumous name Su Min. Dexin was a native of Anfu; he later rose to vice director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments.
37
便
Wen Chun, styled Jingwen, was a native of Sanyuan. He passed the jinshi examination in Jiajing 44. From his post as magistrate of Shouguang he was summoned to serve as a supervising secretary in the Household section. In Longqing 3, though Emperor Muzong had completed the end of mourning, he still would not receive the chief ministers. Chun urged that ancestral precedent be followed—officials summoned for consultation, memorials decided in person—and the court acknowledged his request. He was repeatedly promoted until he became chief supervising secretary of the Military section. Wokou took Guangdong's Guanghai Guard, slaughtered and plundered on a great scale, and withdrew. Regional commander Liu Tao reported that he had fought the raiders off; Chun impeached him for deception. Liu Tao was then being summoned to command the capital garrison, so the matter was set aside without inquiry. The Duke of Qian, Mu Chaobi, had been found guilty, yet an edict permitted his son to inherit the title. Chun argued that the case was still unresolved and the succession should not be rushed. The eunuch Chen Hong petitioned to have his parents ennobled; Chun held firm that it could not be allowed. When the remonstrating officials Li Yi and Shi Xing were punished, he memorialized to save them. At first Zhao Zhenji reformed the garrison system so that each of the three camps would answer to one great general. The Marquis of Gongshun, Wu Jijue, was placed in charge of the Five Armies, while commanders-in-chief Yuan Zheng and Jiao Ze took the Divine Pivot and Divine Engine corps. Jijue was ashamed to serve as an equal and firmly declined. For his sake the emperor dismissed the two men and replaced them entirely with meritorious nobles. Chun urged a broad search for military talent without limiting appointments to hereditary titles; the court did not accept it. Later three civil officials were again ordered to share command with them, and the six were known at the time as "the six grand coordinators." Chun argued that authority was split too many ways and spoke at length on the harm this caused, and the old system was restored. Altan Khan requested tribute trade, and Gao Gong settled policy to permit it. Chun held that this would slacken frontier defenses and was not to China's advantage. He was sent out as administration vice commissioner of Huguang and pleaded illness to return home.
38
At the start of the Wanli reign, on recommendation he was recalled as administration commissioner of Henan. In Wanli 12 he moved from president of the Court of Judicial Review to vice minister of war and right vice censor-in-chief, with charge as grand coordinator of Zhejiang. He entered the capital as left vice minister of revenue, was advanced to right vice censor-in-chief, and supervised the granaries. He left office to mourn his mother. He was promoted to minister of personnel in Nanjing. He was summoned and appointed minister of works. His father was old; he asked leave to care for him and returned home. When mourning ended, he was summoned to serve as left censor-in-chief.
39
使 退 西使使
Mining-tax envoys fanned out in all directions, and local officials arrested people in droves; Chun spoke at length on the harm and asked that all be released—there was no response. Before long the eunuchs grew more overbearing still; wherever they went they plundered and violated women. Scoundrels from every quarter swarmed forward with schemes for profit: some petitioned to open the treasure mines beyond Yunnan's frontier passes; others spoke of Mount Jiyi in Luzon overseas, said always to produce gold and silver and to yield one hundred thousand taels of gold and three hundred thousand taels of silver each year; others spoke of the rich salt profits of Huai and Yang, saying that by their plan five hundred thousand taels of silver could be obtained each year. The emperor gladly accepted them all, and alarm spread near and far. Chun said, "The Burmese are watching for an opening; once the treasure mines are opened, war will surely follow. Yu Yuanjun is nothing but a salt smuggler who cannot even pay off several thousand in illicit gains—yet he wants five hundred thousand taels; where does he expect to get them? Mount Jiyi lies overseas; there cannot be gold and silver spread across the land for anyone to take at will; this is nothing but a pretext to smuggle contraband out under imperial orders and trade with foreigners—the profit goes to petty men, the harm falls on the state. I beg that all these villains be arrested and handed to us for punishment, and that the tax supervisors harming the people be swiftly withdrawn. Again there was no response. At that time court and country alike clamored to abolish mining taxes, and the emperor ignored them all. Chun and the others, anxious and at their wits' end, then proposed that the chief ministers kneel weeping at the palace gate to petition. The emperor was furious and asked who had proposed it; they answered, "Left Censor-in-Chief, your subject Chun. The emperor's rage softened; he sent someone to comfort them, saying, "The memorial will soon be issued. They then withdrew. In the end it was never carried out. Li Feng of Guangdong, Liang Yong of Shaanxi, and Yang Rong of Yunnan all stirred popular rebellion through mining taxes; Chun again spoke boldly: "Tax envoys who usurp Your Majesty's authority number in the tens; attendants who rely on the tax envoys' power number in the hundreds; local scoundrels who attach themselves as the attendants' claws and teeth number in the tens of thousands. All living souls within the realm are already afflicted by flood and drought, by procurement, transport operations, and relay duties—they have lost the will to live in uproar; how can they again withstand these millions of wolves and tigers! I pray that mining taxes be abolished this very day and that Feng and the others be arrested and brought to justice. Again there was no response.
40
使 西
Earlier, censor Gu Longzhen, on inspection tour in Guangdong, quarreled with administration commissioner Wang Pan, rose and beat him, and Pan immediately abandoned his post and left. Chun impeached him and had Longzhen dismissed. Censor Yu Yongqing, inspecting Shaanxi and corrupt, feared Chun would impeach him; he incited his colleagues to save Longzhen, openly siding against Chun to intimidate him, and also joined with chief supervising secretary Yao Wenwei to undermine Chun. Chun, unable to contain his anger, memorialized exposing Yongqing's manipulations in full and also implicating Wenwei; his language somewhat encroached on chief grand secretary Shen Yiguan. Yiguan and others memorialized in defense. The emperor issued the memorials from Yongqing and Wenwei, but kept Chun's impeachment memorial withheld. Chun grew angrier still; he submitted three memorials debating the matter and forcefully pleaded to be dismissed, and only then was Yongqing demoted. Chun thus came into open conflict with Yiguan. Supervising secretaries Chen Zheze and Zhong Zhaodou, both Yiguan's men, impeached Chun in succession. Censor Tang Zhaojing, taking offense, memorialized denouncing them as reckless. Chun sought to leave; he submitted twenty memorials and shut his doors for nine months. The emperor had long held Chun in esteem and ordered him to remain. Chun had no choice but to force himself to rise and resume his duties. When the "demonic book" affair arose, he vigorously defended Shen Li and Guo Zhengyu against false charges. When a clansman of Chu killed the grand coordinator, Chun again argued that there was no sign of rebellion. Yiguan's resentment grew deeper still. In Wanli 32 the grand evaluation of capital officials was held. Chun and vice minister of personnel Yang Shiqiao presided; those Yiguan wished to protect—Zhong Zhaodou and Qian Menggao among others—were all listed for censure. Long after the memorial entered, an edict suddenly descended with sharp rebuke, retaining all the censured remonstrating officials, while the evaluation memorial still was not issued. Chun pleaded to leave with greater force. Menggao and Zhaodou, having been retained, then submitted successive memorials attacking Chun over the Chu affair. They said Chun had bent the law to protect a rebel and further slandered him with taking bribes. Court officials were greatly alarmed and competed to impeach Menggao and the others. Menggao and the others also submitted further memorials impeaching Chun, seeking to prevail. All were kept withheld. Before long, supervising secretaries in Nanjing including Chen Jiaxun argued forcefully that the two had secret backing, formed factions to do evil, and should be swiftly expelled, while Chun should be allowed to return home to preserve the dignity owed a grand minister. The emperor finally endorsed the earlier memorials of Menggao and the others, granted Chun retirement, and Menggao and Zhaodou were also dismissed and sent home.
41
Chun served the public with integrity. Five times he presided over evaluations north and south, and his clearings and dismissals were all apt. He disciplined the hundred officials and restored discipline, and was acclaimed at the time as a great minister. When he died, he was posthumously granted the title of Junior Guardian. At the opening of the Tianqi reign, he was posthumously ennobled with the epithet Gongyi, "Respectful and Resolute."
42
耀 使
Zhao Shiqing, styled Xiangxian, was from Licheng. He passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of the Longqing reign. He was appointed a principal clerk in the Nanjing Ministry of War. When Zhang Juzheng dominated the government, policy favored strictness. Prefectural and county schools were limited to selecting no more than fifteen scholars; Officials below the rank of provincial administration and surveillance commissioners were barred from using relay horses even on official business; The death penalty was subject to a fixed annual quota; Tax collection was held to a nine-tenths rate, and local officials who failed to meet it were penalized; He also repeatedly meted out heavy punishment to memorialists. Shiqing submitted a memorial outlining five essentials for setting the age right. He asked that scholar quotas be expanded, relay-horse restrictions relaxed, capital sentences reduced, and tax collection slowed; he ended with a lengthy argument that the avenue of speech must be reopened, declaring: "Recently, censorate and remonstrance officials have fallen into the habit of oleaginous flattery, currying favor to win the throne's regard. When matters touched army and state, they bit their tongues and held their peace. They merely seized on trifling matters as a token fulfillment of their duty to remonstrate. After several years of this, they could still occupy high vice-ministerial posts and parade their standing before the scholarly world. Yet were these men wholly without principle, willing to betray Your Majesty? No—they had been chastened and did not dare speak out. In years past, Fu Yingzhen, Ai Mu, Shen Sixiao, and Zou Yuanbiao had all been banished to distant posts for their memorials, and to this day they remain among the ranks of exiled garrison troops. That is why talented men at court looked to their own safety and would rather remain silent as cicadas in winter. Your Majesty should issue a special gracious decree recalling these men, so that all under heaven clearly knows the Son of Heaven bears no ill will toward candid speech—then scholars everywhere will be drawn to serve in earnest loyalty to Your Majesty." Zhang Juzheng wished to punish him severely. Minister of Personnel Wang Guoguang said: "Punishing him would only enhance his reputation—let me bear the blame on your behalf." He was thereupon transferred out to serve as Right Administrator of the Chu princely establishment. The following year, in the capital evaluation of officials, he was again found remiss in duty and dismissed to return home.
43
西使 使西 使 竿
After Zhang Juzheng's death, he was reinstated as a director in the Ministry of Revenue and sent out as vice commissioner in Shaanxi. He rose through successive promotions to Right Vice Minister of Revenue, with responsibility for overseeing the capital granary depot. Shiqing was a skilled financial planner. In every policy he proposed, he carefully balanced revenues and expenditures, and both military and civil affairs depended on his judgment. When Revenue Minister Chen fell ill and Vice Minister Zhang Yangmeng shirked his duties, the emperor's wrath fell on them both—they were dismissed, and Shiqing was promoted to minister. At the time, mining-tax commissioners were spreading harm in every direction; the Jiangxi tax supervisor Pan Xiang went so far as to arrest and imprison members of the imperial clan on his own authority. Customs revenues had once brought in more than four hundred thousand taels annually; once the tax commissioners got their hands on them, commerce dried up, and within a few years revenue fell by a third; miscellaneous levies across the empire followed the same pattern. Annual revenues dwindled ever further; the state treasury could not make ends meet; frontier stores were exhausted—while the palace's internal expenditures grew daily more extravagant. The palace treasury received an additional two hundred thousand taels of patterned silver each year, and daily grew ever more flush. Shiqing asked that the original quota of one million taels of patterned silver be restored and the continued increases abolished; the request was denied. He pleaded for one million taels from the inner treasury plus five hundred thousand taels of horse funds from the Court of the Imperial Stud to replenish frontier stores—again defying the emperor's intent, he was sharply rebuked. Shiqing again urged that Pan Xiang be punished according to law, and joined the Nine Ministers in repeatedly cataloguing the damage wrought by the tax commissioners—all to no avail. Shiqing warned again that the people's substance was utterly drained, neighborhoods lay desolate, rebellion loomed on the horizon, and armed uprising was not far away—if the mining taxes were not abolished now, it might soon be too late. The emperor paid no heed.
44
In the thirty-second year of Wanli, Liu Cheng, the tax commissioner for Suzhou and Songjiang, requested a temporary suspension of the rice tax owing to flood damage. The emperor held that since the annual quota was sixty thousand taels and the rice tax accounted for half, a full suspension was unwarranted; he ordered that forty thousand taels remain as the quota. Shiqing memorialized: "Not long ago the rice tax was exempted, only to be levied again shortly afterward—we have already forfeited the empire's trust. Now Cheng asks to halve the tax quota, yet Your Majesty will not fully consent—does Your Majesty's compassionate impulse truly survive only in Liu Cheng's fur cap and purse, while Your Majesty himself remains utterly unmoved?" The emperor made no reply.
45
That summer, lightning set fire to the Bright Tower of the ancestral tombs; strange insects gnawed at the trees; torrential rains wrecked the bridges along the spirit way. The emperor issued an edict soliciting proposals for concrete reforms. Shiqing submitted a memorial stating:
46
鹿
Of all the reforms needed today, what could be more urgent than abolishing the mining taxes! Enlightened rulers of antiquity did not prize exotic luxuries—yet now the throne amasses ill-gotten wealth and harvests the people's resentment. Where is the frugality in that? For the sake of Your Majesty's moral standing, this is the first reason the mining taxes must be abolished. Excessive extraction invites reproach; careless hoarding inevitably teaches thieves. The Lutai Granary and Jubridge sufficed to bring down rulers by the swords of their own troops. For the sake of the altars of state, this is the second reason they must go. In antiquity, when the realm was at peace the state attended to mulberry planting and flood control; when crisis came, it debated strategies of defense. What kingdom drills mines across the four seas, monopolizes every marketplace, sends armed men against innocent civilians, tears down houses and scales walls, spreads havoc even to barnyard fowl, and carries on thus for more than a decade without end! For the dignity of the state, this is the third reason they must be abolished. The tax commissioners plundered like predators afield; backed by imperial authority, they roared like winged tigers. They desecrated graves, bringing calamity even upon the dead; they violated women, leaving honorable families to choke on bitter rage. The people seethed with resentment; outcries were heard again and again—if this continues unchecked, where will it end! For the sake of the people's suffering, this is the fourth reason they must be abolished. The state's revenues belong either to the people or to the government—yet now they have all been scraped into the coffers of corrupt agents. Arrearage collection yielded fewer arrears; customs audits produced shrinking customs revenue; treasury searches left treasuries bare; salt levies grew ever thinner; fine collection dried up the fines themselves. The outer treasuries stood utterly empty; the Ministry of Revenue was swept clean. For the sake of the national revenue, this is the fifth reason they must be abolished. An emperor's word should be as dependable as the seasons. Three years ago Your Majesty declared, "My heart is compassionate; there will come a time to end this"—yet another year has passed; how much longer must we wait? When an emperor's words are idle jest, his decrees are discarded like trash. For the sake of imperial credibility, this is the sixth reason they must be abolished.
47
Consider, Your Majesty: from food and clothing and palace maintenance to construction projects and military campaigns—what does the throne not take from the people, and what do the people not supply to the throne? Alas for these innocent common folk, who have never wronged the state—the people strain willingly to satisfy the palace's every desire, yet Your Majesty will not grant them the least satisfaction in return; the people toil eagerly to bear the palace's burdens, yet Your Majesty offers them no comfort for their labors; the people exhaust themselves in hardship on the throne's behalf, yet Your Majesty shows them no compassion for their suffering. Turned inward upon the heart, there must be discomfort. Your Majesty must not suppose that these humble commoners can be driven at will, that their lives and deaths are entirely in your hands, and that they are beneath notice. The hearts of the people are the heart of Heaven—and Heaven's reproaches now come thick and fast: thunder and fire, strange insects, torrents of rain one upon another. Omens are not sent without cause; retribution cannot be far off. To win back Heaven's favor today, Your Majesty must comfort the people's hearts—and to comfort the people's hearts, you must abolish the mining taxes. The decision requires no further deliberation.
48
使 使 西 使 使 仿
The emperor responded with gracious words but took no action. Not until the third month of the thirty-fourth year did he issue a decree abolishing the mining commissioners; taxes were also somewhat reduced. Yet in Liaodong, Yunnan, and Sichuan the tax commissioners remained in place, and officials and commoners suffered all the more. Yunnan then broke into rebellion, and Yang Rong was killed. Meanwhile the northwest suffered repeated reports of flood and drought; Shiqing repeatedly pleaded for rent reductions and famine relief—but state finances grew ever tighter. A month later he again memorialized asking that one million taels from the inner treasury be contributed toward military expenses; the request was denied. Shiqing then submitted memorial after memorial requesting retirement—fifteen in all—yet each was denied. Earlier, when the Prince of Fu's wedding was being arranged, the ministry contributed two hundred seventy thousand taels—but the emperor still considered it insufficient and repeatedly sent eunuchs to demand more. The eunuchs uttered insults and even impeached Shiqing for defying orders. Shiqing regarded this as a national disgrace and memorialized the court; the emperor ignored it. By the thirty-sixth year, when the seventh princess was given in marriage, the palace demanded several hundred thousand taels. Shiqing cited precedent and argued forcefully; an edict cut the sum by one-third. Shiqing pressed further: "Your Majesty's own grand wedding cost only seventy thousand taels, and the eldest princess's dowry totaled only one hundred twenty thousand—I beg Your Majesty to cut the sum again, following the eldest princess's precedent." The emperor, having no choice, acceded. When the Prince of Fu newly established his household outside the palace, he opened a Chongwen tax shop to compete with commoners for profit—Shiqing remonstrated against this as well.
49
使
Shiqing had long cultivated personal integrity and fulfilled his duties conscientiously in office. The emperor held him in high esteem. When the Ministry of Personnel lacked a minister, the emperor often had him serve in that capacity as well; in personnel recommendations he showed no partiality. Only in the affair where Chu clansmen and the prince traded accusations did Shiqing insist forcefully that the prince was genuine, aligning with Shen Yiguan's position. When Li Tingji served as grand secretary, Shiqing vigorously supported his appointment. Court officials then suspected Shiqing of factional allegiance. Thereupon supervising secretaries Du Shiquan, Deng Quxiao, He Shijin, and Hu Xin, along with censors Su Weilin and Ma Mengzhen, impeached him in succession; Shiqing then shut his doors and petitioned for retirement. He submitted more than ten further memorials—all without response. In the autumn of the thirty-eighth year, Shiqing formally submitted his memorial and left the capital to await the emperor's reply. The following October, he departed directly in a humble ox cart. The court officials reported the matter, but the Emperor did not punish him. He lived in retirement for seven years and then died; he was posthumously granted the title Junior Tutor of the Crown Prince.
50
西
Li Ruhua, whose style name was Maofu, came from Suizhou. He passed the jinshi examination in the eighth year of Wanli. He was appointed investigating magistrate of Yanzhou. When summoned to the capital he was appointed a supervising secretary in the Ministry of Works, and once impeached Zheng Luo, Minister of Military Administration, for neglect of duty. When he was sent to inspect border affairs in Gansu, Zheng Luo was then directing western frontier policy and advocating appeasement of the frontier tribes. Li Ruhua memorialized that Zheng Luo's fear of the enemy would invite lasting harm, impeached various commanders and officials for embezzling military funds, and also petitioned for the full reclamation of unused farmland in Gansu. After returning to court he rose to Chief Supervising Secretary of the Secretariat section, where he frequently impeached and exposed officials.
51
使 西
He was soon transferred to Vice Minister of Ceremonies, promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, and appointed Grand Coordinator of Nan and Gan. Tax commissioners were dispatched throughout the empire, and there was a proposal to collect customs duties at checkpoints and ferry stations and turn them over to the inner palace treasury. Li Ruhua argued forcefully that tax revenues were meant to provision the army and pressed to stop the scheme. Soon an edict ordered that tax administration throughout the empire be placed under local civil officials, with half the revenue remitted to the tax commissioners for the inner palace and half to the Ministry of Revenue. Only in Jiangxi did the tax commissioner Pan Xiang pressure local officials to remit all revenues through him alone. Li Ruhua argued strenuously that Pan Xiang was defying the edict, but the Emperor ultimately adopted Pan's arrangement and extended it throughout the empire.
52
使 使 使
Li Ruhua served fourteen years in Ganzhou, winning great renown through his authority and benevolence; he was promoted to Right Vice Minister of War and then summoned to serve as Left Vice Minister of Revenue. When Minister Zhao Shiqing left office, Li Ruhua took charge of the ministry. Imperial edicts repeatedly pressed for the allocation of forty thousand qing of estate land to the Prince of Fu, but the quota could not be met. Li Ruhua joined other court officials in repeated adamant protests, securing only a reduction of one quarter. After the prince had departed for his fief, an edict allowed him to dispatch his own agents to collect rents, throwing post stations everywhere into uproar. The eunuch Yan Shi went to Ruzhou and beat two men to death. Li Ruhua petitioned that princely rent collection be placed under civil officials as ancestral law prescribed and that all rent-collecting agents be withdrawn, but his proposal was rejected. When the capital region and Shandong suffered severe famine, at Li Ruhua's urging the government released grain from state granaries for sale at fair prices and disbursed silver for relief. Li Ruhua further memorialized implementing several famine-relief measures, on which both regions depended. Earlier, when Shandong had suffered famine, annual land taxes totaling seven hundred thousand taels had been remitted. That year full remissions amounted to more than 1.7 million taels in addition. With frontier military pay falling short, Li Ruhua requested that tax revenues not yet transferred to the inner palace treasury be held for one year to make up the shortfall; senior ministers also spoke in support. He submitted the memorial three times without receiving a reply. He was shortly thereafter promoted to Minister of Revenue.
53
西 宿 西
In the forty-sixth year of Wanli, when Zheng Jizhi left office, Li Ruhua also took charge of the Ministry of Personnel. When the capital region and Shaanxi again suffered severe famine, Li Ruhua petitioned for relief but received no response. With war breaking out in Liaodong, military pay was suddenly increased by three million taels. Li Ruhua repeatedly petitioned for disbursements from the inner palace treasury without success; he then drew advances from the Nanjing ministry treasury, swept up surplus reserves from treasuries across the empire, collected long-standing arrears, cut workers' rations, and opened offices selling official titles and privileges. When Liaodong Grand Coordinator Zhou Yongchun requested more troops and higher taxes, Li Ruhua proposed adding three li five hao of silver per mu to land taxes empire-wide except Guizhou, raising two million taels in military pay. The following year the same proposal for more troops and higher taxes was debated again. In April of the year after that, the Ministry of War sought funds to recruit troops and purchase horses and the Ministry of Works to manufacture weapons, and tax increases were debated once more. A further two li per mu was added, yielding 1.2 million taels. Three tax increases in succession totaled a little more than 5.2 million taels, which then became the permanent annual levy. At that time the inner palace treasury overflowed with accumulated wealth, yet when court officials petitioned for disbursements, the Emperor almost never agreed. The Minister of Revenue could do nothing else and resorted to every stopgap measure, squeezing harsh levies from the people. Meanwhile the chief minister's conscription drives reached deep into the frontier, provoking She Chongming and An Bangyan to rebel in succession and keeping armies in the field year after year. Revenues from the tax increases in Sichuan, Yunnan, Guangxi, Huguang, and Guangdong were diverted to feed these campaigns, yet Liaodong military pay remained insufficient and the empire could no longer bear the burden.
54
Li Ruhua was seasoned, diligent, and capable, and stood above factional flattery at court. During his long tenure at the Ministry of Revenue he devoted himself fully to fiscal surplus and deficit, the strength of frontier granaries, and major policies governing the salt monopoly, grain transport, and garrison agriculture. When harvests failed year after year he consistently favored relief and leniency, but he could not hold firm against the tax-increase proposals, and gradually the realm was drained dry and beset by turmoil within and without. In the first year of the Tianqi reign he fell ill and petitioned to retire; he was granted the title Senior Tutor of the Crown Prince and allowed to resign. He died and was given the posthumous name Gongmin, "Respectful and Diligent." His nephew Li Mengchen has a separate biography.
55
Appraisal: The ancients called civil administration the foundation of government; the responsibilities borne by the Seven Ministers were indeed weighty. Wan Shihe and his colleagues served with conscientious diligence, unlike those who clung to office through sycophantic compliance; Liu Yingjie, Wang Lin, Shu Hua, and Li Shida were especially outstanding among them. Li Ruhua managed the national finances at a time when war had broken out and military funds ran short; his petitions for treasury disbursements went unanswered, and unable to stake his career on the issue, he turned to expedients that left him condemned alongside the harsh tax collectors. That matters had come to such a pass—how lamentable!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →