← Back to 明史

卷二百二十一 列傳第一百〇九 袁洪愈 王廷瞻 郭應聘 耿定向 王樵 魏時亮 郝杰 趙參魯 張孟男 李禎 丁賓

Volume 221 Biographies 109: Yuan Hongyu, Wang Tingzhan, Guo Yingpin, Geng Dingxiang, Wang Qiao, Wei Shiliang, Hao Jie, Zhao Canlu, Zhang Mengnan, Li Zhen, Ding Bin

Chapter 221 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 221
Next Chapter →
1
Yuan Hongyu (With sons Yi E and Tan Xisi)〉 Wang Tingzhan, Guo Yingpin (Wu Wenhua)〉 Geng Dingxiang (Younger brothers Dingli and Dingli)〉 Wang Qiao (With son Kentang)〉 Wei Shiliang (Chen Zan)〉 Hao Jie (Hu Kejian)〉 Zhao Canlu, Zhang Mengnan (Wei Chengfang)〉 Li Zhen, Ding Bin
2
Yuan Hongyu
3
使
Yuan Hongyu, styled Yizhi, came from Wu County. He took top honors in the provincial exams in Jiajing 25. The next year he became a jinshi and was made a Central Secretariat draftsman. He was raised to supervising secretary in the Rites section. He charged reviser Liang Shaoru with fawning on the mighty, Selection Bureau director Bai Bi with trading offices for power, and Ministers Wan Yong and Ge Shouli with lax oversight of their staffs. The throne sharply rebuked Wan and Ge, imprisoned Bai Bi by edict, and banished Liang Shaoru from court. Shaoru was a private client of Grand Secretary Yan Song. He then submitted several proposals on frontier affairs, and the court approved them all. Song had the Minister of Personnel Wu Peng post him out as Fujian Assistant Commissioner. He served as Henan Administrative Commissioner, Shandong Vice Commissioner for Education, and Huguang Administration Commissioner, winning renown everywhere for clean conduct. After Song's downfall he was recalled as Nanjing Vice Minister of the Imperial Stud and soon promoted to Minister of Imperial Sacrifices. In Longqing 5 he retired on grounds of illness.
4
簿
In the Wanli reign he was restored to office, made Nanjing Vice Minister of Works, then Right Censor-in-Chief in charge of the southern censorate, and transferred in place to Minister of Rites. Nanjing censor Tan Xisi memorialized against eunuchs and consort kin, and asked that old rules be restored: a silk-decree register in the Grand Secretariat and iron placards at the palace gates. An edict referred the matter to the Nanjing Censorate for inquiry, with intent to punish him for calumny. Hongyu had already moved to another post and his replacement had not arrived; he therefore laid out Xisi's points in full, citing Wang Keda's Guoxian Jiayou and Xue Yingqi's Xianzhang Lu. The emperor ruled that the authorities cited were not officially promulgated statutes and demoted Xisi to a minor post. Hongyu soon asked that private solicitations be banned and urgently warned of the ruin of garrison farms, proposing that merchants tender salt in exchange and that forced grain levies in the interior be lifted. All were debated and put into effect.
5
In Wanli 15 he was transferred in place to the Ministry of Personnel. That winter he pleaded age and asked to retire. The emperor esteemed his integrity and granted him Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent on retirement. For more than forty years on the rolls his house never gained a single rafter, and he went everywhere on foot. He died at the age of seventy-four. Grand Coordinator Zhou Kongjiao donated money for his burial. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent with the posthumous name Anjie.
6
His son Yi E entered office by hereditary privilege as Court Director. He died when even thin gruel ran out. Xisi was from Chaling. He eventually became Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and Grand Coordinator of Sichuan.
7
Wang Tingzhan
8
使
Wang Tingzhan, styled Zhibiao, was a native of Huanggang. His father Ji had been an administration commissioner. Tingzhan became a jinshi in Jiajing 38 and was appointed investigating magistrate of Huai'an. He entered the Censorate and oversaw garrison-farm administration in the metropolitan area. While the future Muzong was still at the Princely Establishment of Yu, he wanted to swap manor lands; Tingzhan would not allow it. In Longqing 1 his district suffered prolonged rain. He asked that rents be remitted on manor lands from the Three Palaces down and on those moved from the Princely Establishment of Yu into the Qianqing Palace. An edict cut the rents by half. He later argued that estates for meritorious kin and consort families were excessive, and proposed that at the first grant the fields be measured, succession limited by generation, and the land revert to the state when the title expired. The court approved. When Gao Gong returned as chief minister, Tingzhan repeatedly attacked him and finally retired on grounds of illness. When Shenzong ascended the throne, Tingzhan was recalled to his former office. He served as Minister of the Imperial Stud. In Wanli 5 he was appointed Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and Grand Coordinator of Sichuan. Barbarian bands repeatedly attacked Songpan. Tingzhan ordered Vice Commissioner Yang Yigui and Regional Commander Liu Xian to campaign against them, wiped out their chiefs, and the tribes surrendered. The Fengcun and Baicao tribes, long holding twenty-eight stockades, brought in more than eight thousand men, women, and children to submit. He again ordered Commander Xian to subdue the rebel tribes of Jianchang, Kuixia, Xima, Guzai, and Tiekou; each turned over its chief culprits and submitted. His salary grade rose one step; he was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and made Grand Coordinator of Nan and Gan.
9
He entered service as Nanjing Minister of Punishments. He served as Left and Right Vice Minister of Revenue in both capitals, then went out as Right Censor-in-Chief to supervise the grain transport and grand coordinate Fengyang and neighboring prefectures. The Baoying embankment on Lake Fan impounded water for the transport canals; it had been built by the Marquis of Pingjiang, Chen Xuan. With no outlet downstream it broke into eight shallows and formed a great lagoon, drowning the salt works. The Huai again rushed in and the current grew fiercer still. Former Grand Coordinator Li Shidao and others had proposed cutting the Yue River to skirt the hazard; Tingzhan took up the project. They excavated a channel 1,776 zhang long, erected three stone sluices and two flood sluices, laid 3,036 zhang of stone dike and 5,390 zhang of subsidiary dike, at a cost of more than 200,000 taels of public money, and finished in eight months. An edict commended the work and named the canal Hongji. Tingzhan was promoted to Minister of Revenue while continuing as grand coordinator. He was soon made Nanjing Minister of Punishments. Before assuming the post he asked to go home. Long afterward he died. He was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. His elder brother Tingchen is treated in the Writers biography.
10
Guo Yingpin
11
使 西使使
Guo Yingpin, styled Junbin, was from Putian. He became a jinshi in Jiajing 29. He was appointed principal clerk in the Ministry of Revenue. He rose to bureau director, then went out as prefect of Nanning. He was made Vice Commissioner for Weimao defense, then Guangdong Administration Commissioner. Following Grand Coordinator Wu Guifang he pacified Li Yayuan and separately struck the bandit chiefs Zhang Shaonan and Huang Shiliang. He was made Guangxi Surveillance Commissioner and later Left and Right Administration Commissioner. In Longqing 4 he routed the Gutian bandits, killing or capturing more than seven thousand. Later, with Grand Coordinator Yin Zhengmao, he pacified Gutian again and received another promotion.
12
便 調 使
When Zhengmao became governor-general, Yingpin was raised to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief in his place. The Yao of Fujiang rose in revolt. Fujiang stretches from Yangshuo to Zhaoping, more than three hundred li. Yao communities lined both banks, trusting the narrows to raid and rob. In the Chenghua and Zhengde periods Han Yong and Chen Jin as censors-in-chief had suppressed them; now the Yao attacked Lipu and Yong'an and took Prefect Yang Weizhi and Commander Hu Han captive. On report, Grand Secretary Zhang Juzheng asked leave to act at discretion and wrote Yingpin: "In that feverish frontier you should not detain tens of thousands of men; smash their lairs at once and the rest will lose heart." Yingpin mustered sixty thousand native and Han soldiers and ordered Regional Commander Li Xi to campaign. Before the column moved, the Huaiyuan Yao killed Prefect Ma Xiwu and rose. Yingpin and Zhengmao decided to pacify Fujiang first; within three months it was quiet, and he then dispatched Xi against Huaiyuan. Great rains and snow came; the army accomplished nothing and withdrew. Huaiyuan, the old Zangge country, lay among Huguang, Guizhou, Jing, and Li; Yao ringed the seat while registered households lived beyond the walls. Jiajing campaigns had failed; the prefect lodged in the superior city and ruled only by loose rein. Once Gutian was retaken the Yao feared the troops and offered allegiance; Xiwu then entered the district. Plans for a walled city pressed labor too hard; the Yao revolted and Xiwu was slain. That campaign therefore ended without success. Yingpin called up forces from all routes, won over the Dong and Zhuang of Baiguo, Huangtu, Damei, and Qingqi to cut the rebels off, and Xi with the generals smashed them in turn, slew their leaders, and Huaiyuan fell. The full account is in Xi's biography. At the first planning, Xi wished to wipe out the Yangshuo Jinbaoling bandits first. Yingpin said: "March on; I have my own plan." A few days after Xi left, Yingpin with Surveillance Commissioner Wu Yijie surprised and slew the chief. After Huaiyuan and Yangshuo were settled he sent Generals Men Chongwen, Yang Zhao, and Yi Kongzhao against Luorong, Shangyou, and Bianshan. All five rebel Yao bands were pacified. The emperor was delighted and made him Vice Minister of War and Right Vice Censor-in-Chief while he remained grand coordinator.
13
西 西 歿
In Wanli 2 he was called to be Vice Minister of Revenue, then soon left on mourning. Recalled in year 8, he was moved to War with concurrent Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and still governed Guangxi. With the Ten Stockades newly pacified, he and Governor-General Liu Yaohui asked three garrisons under Binzhou, native inspecting officers, and the Sinan regional commander; the stockades then stayed quiet. He rose to Right Censor-in-Chief and Vice Minister of War, governor-general of both Guang. Earlier governors-general had taken officers' gold; Yingpin refused every gift. A year later he was called to head the Nanjing Censorate; Wu Wenhua replaced him. He was soon made Minister of War with a seat in deliberations on state affairs. Long afterward he retired on grounds of illness. In Guangxi he asked to restore the shrines of Chen Xianzhang and Wang Shouren. For Liu Tai, exiled to Xunzhou, he rented quarters and supplied grain; when Liu died he paid the funeral costs, sent the body home, and set up his portrait for worship. In Nanjing he and Hai Rui lived plainly, and gentlemen dared not be extravagant. He died seven months after going home. He was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent with the name Xiangjing.
14
使 使 西 西
Wu Wenhua, styled Zibin, was from Lianjiang. His father Shize, Fujiang defense vice commissioner, had a stern name. Wenhua became a jinshi in Jiajing 35 and was made principal clerk in the Nanjing Ministry of War. He served as Sichuan Right Administration Commissioner and helped pacify the native official Feng Jizu. After four promotions he became Henan Left Administration Commissioner. In Wanli 3 he was made Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and Grand Coordinator of Guangxi. He pacified the Yao of Nanxiang, Luping, Zhoutang, and Banzhai and the Li Fuzhuang father and son of Zhaoping. With Governor-General Ling Yunyi he campaigned against the Hechi, Buqi, and Northern Three Yao. The Three Yao were not in revolt, yet Yunyi, eager for action, killed savagely; he won a hereditary privilege and Wenhua shared the reward. Made Vice Minister of Revenue, he asked leave to nurse his parents. He was raised to Vice Minister of War with concurrent Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and still governed Guangxi. He became governor-general of the two Guang and Grand Coordinator of Guangdong. He was promoted to Right Censor-in-Chief. Meanwhile Coordinators Wu Shan and Commander Hu Liangpeng had pacified Yan Xiuzhu. The Cengang rebels Li Zhen and Jiang Yuezhao had long resisted; Wenhua bought Yuezhao's capture and settled Zhen. He soon entered as Nanjing Minister of Works and was moved to War. He retired on grounds of illness. Nanjing Works was offered again; he firmly refused, and the seat stood empty three years awaiting him. He died at seventy-eight. He was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent with the name Xianghui.
15
Geng Dingxiang
16
婿 西 退
Geng Dingxiang, styled Zailun, was from Huang'an. He became a jinshi in Jiajing 35. He was made a courier, then raised to censor. Yan Song father and son held power; Minister Wu Peng clung to them. Dingxiang listed six crimes of Peng and, since Academician Dong Fen ran the metropolitan exams and favored Peng's son Shao, asked that Fen be expelled too. Song shielded them and the case died. As touring censor in Gansu he promoted and punished without partiality. On leaving, his traveling chest was one shoulder pole. Someone offered a stone classic; he left it on the border and went on. Back at court he oversaw Nanjing education. Early in Longqing he was made Right Assistant in the Court of Judicial Review. Gao Gong in power had been mocked by Dingxiang for pettiness unworthy of a chief minister; Gong bore a grudge. When Gong ran Personnel he used the review to demote Dingxiang to magistrate of Hengzhou. After Gong fell he was moved in grade to investigating magistrate of Hengzhou. In Wanli he rose to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief. Vice Minister Lu Guangzu was impeached by Censor Zhou Zhihan; Lu was kept on, but Dingxiang praised Lu and attacked Zhou. Supervising Secretary Li Yiqian said Dingxiang was driving out critics; Dingxiang asked to quit and the emperor did not pursue it. He served as Left and Right Vice Minister of Punishments and was made Nanjing Right Censor-in-Chief. Censor Wang Fanchen impeached Yingtian Coordinator Zhou Ji, yet the memorial reached Dingxiang only after more than a month. Dingxiang was furious, clung to precedent, resigned in protest, and also denounced Fanchen's impeachment as improper. He said Coordinators Chen Younian of Jiangxi and Xu Yuantai of Sichuan were worthy men ousted by Fang Wanshan and Wang Linzhi, who should be recalled while Fanchen was punished proportionately. Fanchen was fined two months' salary. Then Supervising Secretary Xu Honggang, student Xue Fujiao, Nanjing Censor Huang Renrong, and Linzhi impeached Dingxiang in turn. Linzhi said: "The southern board is far from court; memorials travel ahead and men can plot. When Censor Sun Mingzhi attacked Wei Regional Commander Xu Bangrui and Chen Yangshan attacked Director Liu Yihuan, both learned early—one escaped by favor, the other was trapped by piled charges. Hence recent submissions sometimes lag a month; that is natural and did not start with Fanchen." He also struck at Grand Secretaries Xu Guo, Left Censor Wu Shilai, and Vice Censor Zhan Yangbi. The ministers hated outspoken men; Fujiao was sent home to repent, and Linzhi and Renrong lost salary. Dingxiang had been named Minister of Revenue over the granaries; he pressed hard to withdraw. After repeated memorials he was allowed to go. He died at seventy-three. He was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent with the name Gongjian.
17
Dingxiang at first had repute at court. Later he served four chief ministers—Xu Jie, Zhang Juzheng, Shen Shixing, and Wang Xijue—without friction. When Juzheng took mourning leave he wrote friends calling him an Yi Yin and mocking critics; opinion blamed him. His doctrine came from Wang Shouren. He once invited Li Zhi of Jinjiang to Huang'an; later they grew hostile and Zhi often slighted him. Gentlemen enamored of Chan often followed Zhi. Zhi had small talent and sharp tongue; Dingxiang could not overcome him. As Yao'an prefect Zhi one day shaved his head, put on monk's dress, and sat in the hall; superiors made him quit. At Huang'an he lectured daily, admitted women, exalted Buddhism, and scorned Confucius and Mencius. Later he went north to Tongzhou; Supervising Secretary Zhang Wenda impeached him and he died in jail.
18
使
His younger brothers were Dingli and Dingli. Dingli remained a National University student. He lectured with Dingxiang, devoted to Chan mysteries. Dingli became a jinshi in Longqing and was made principal clerk in Works. In Wanli he rose to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, commanded the Yangtze patrol, and warned of mining commissioners. He was later promoted to Right Vice Minister of War in Nanjing. Upon his death he was posthumously made a full minister.
19
使 使
Wang Qiao, courtesy name Mingyuan, came from Jintan. His father Nie served as principal clerk in the Ministry of War. He spoke out against the Wuzong emperor's southern tour and was flogged at court. He ended his career as Shandong vice commissioner. Qiao became a jinshi in Jiajing 26 and was made an emissary in the Hanlin service. He rose through the ranks to assistant director in the Ministry of Justice. He wrote Du Lu Si Jian, a work noted for its precise and rigorous legal analysis. Hu Zongxian sought Wang Zhi's surrender and wanted to grant him amnesty as a sign of sincerity. Qiao argued that this rebel was unlike ordinary capitulators; Wang Zhi was executed as a result. Appointed Shandong assistant commissioner, he soon retired claiming illness. In the early Wanli reign Zhang Juzheng, who knew Qiao well, recalled him as Zhejiang assistant commissioner and then promoted him to Director of Ceremonies. Liu Tai impeached Zhang Juzheng, who then asked to leave office. Offices urged Zhang to stay; Qiao alone pleaded to shield critics and reassure the chief minister, writing in part: "Enlightened rulers have always kept counsel open—even mistaken speech they still tolerated; Great ministers who sought to magnify their lord's virtue would promote those who criticized them. This was like Wen Yanbo of Song toward Tang Jie. Now Juzheng remains while Liu Tai is punished—is this not far from how Emperor Renzong treated Tang Jie?" Zhang was furious and had him posted to Nanjing as Director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments. Shortly afterward he offered his resignation after a portent in the heavens and was removed from office. After more than a decade at home he was recalled as Nanjing vice director of the Imperial Stud, already in his seventies. That same year he rose again to chief of the Court of Judicial Review, then became Right Vice Minister of Justice in Nanjing. When Marquis of Chengyi Liu Shiyan was found to have ordered a killing, Qiao ruled to dismiss him. He was soon promoted to Right Censor-in-Chief. Supervising Secretary Lu Dazhong attacked him as too old; the emperor told him to retire.
20
Qiao was calm, honest, and unassuming—a gentle elder in bearing. Deeply learned in the classics, he produced writings on the Changes, Documents, and Spring and Autumn. At his death he was posthumously made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent with the posthumous name Gongjian ("Respectful and Plain").
21
調
His son Kentang, courtesy name Yutai. He became a jinshi in Wanli 17, entered the Hanlin as bachelor, and was made reviser. When pirates struck Korea he laid out ten proposals and asked to drill troops at sea with censorial rank. The memorial was shelved; he retired citing illness. At the metropolitan review he was demoted and reassigned. After years at home Yang Shiqiao, vice minister of Personnel, recommended him as deputy director of Royal Carriages in Nanjing. He ended his career as Fujian administration commissioner. Kentang loved books and excelled in medicine; his Zheng Zhi Zhun Sheng was encyclopedic and precise, and widely copied.
22
The biographical subject is Wei Shiliang.
23
使 使西 便殿
Wei Shiliang, courtesy name Gongfu, came from Nanchang. He became a jinshi in Jiajing 38. He was made a secretariat secretary and then promoted to supervising secretary in the Military Section. On Longqing 1/1/7 an edict canceled court; three days later another notice canceled it again. Shiliang argued the new government should not relax so quickly and submitted a forceful memorial. He was soon sent to Korea as Left Supervising Secretary assisting Reviser Xu Guo. Custom held that the king faced north to receive the edict while the envoy faced west. Shiliang objected, and the edict was read facing south instead. Returning, he rose to supervising secretary in the Revenue Section and laid out Liaodong policy in full. He then urged careful daily conduct, an end to pleasure outings, daily review of memorials in the side hall, and summoning ministers for decisions. The court acknowledged receipt. At Xingdu, on eight thousand three hundred qing of land, eunuchs seized peasant holdings, added eight hundred qing, and set up thirty-six estates. The emperor accepted the governor-censor report, had local officials collect rents, and restored annexed fields to their owners. Eunuch Zhang Yao interceded for them, and the emperor again consented. Shiliang protested vehemently, but the emperor would not listen.
24
At audience the emperor remained silent and never spoke. After Shizhou was lost, some urged the emperor to question his ministers. Two days later, after the lecture, the emperor did ask how Shizhou had fallen. Eunuch Wang Ben interrupted from the side, accusing the ministers of deception. The emperor flushed with anger and glared at him, yet Ben kept on talking. Displeased, the emperor ended the session. Shiliang charged Ben with breach of subject's decorum and lèse-majesté, citing several unlawful deeds. The memorial went nowhere, but scholars praised his courage. At the start of the tenth month the emperor halted daily lectures. Shiliang and his colleagues argued that winter had not yet set in and lectures should not cease so soon. He soon proposed enshrining Xue Xuan, Chen Xianzhang, and Wang Shouren in the Confucian temple; the memorial went to the ministries. He also urged, as spring planting began, releasing minor detainees and suspending litigation; the emperor agreed.
25
祿 祿 使祿 簿
The next June he wrote: "The realm faces three grave ills: imperial clans cannot live on their stipends, frontier pay cannot be met, and state and people alike are exhausted. For the clans there are expedients for the present and reforms for the long term. Establish clan schools at once to teach ritual and humility; princes receiving ten thousand shi should give one-fifth yearly, two-thousand-shi houses one-tenth, one-thousand-shi houses one-twentieth, to aid poor kinsmen—then fix this as permanent law. That is the short-term remedy. When clans are packed into one city poverty only deepens; let them settle nearby and work idle fields in lieu of salary; Illegitimate offspring should be heavily demoted and cut off. That is the long-term reform. Border pay rests above all on garrison salt; Pang Shangpeng, Zou Yinglong, and Ling Ru were lately put in charge with broad powers, yet the man sent to Hedong also ran Sichuan, the Jiangbei officer also Shandong and Henan, the Jiangnan officer also Zhejiang, Hunan, Yunnan, and Guizhou—weighting the interior and neglecting the frontier, not what was first intended. And one man cannot oversee several distant circuits at once. He proposed leaving interior salt to the governors while Shangpeng and the others each took a frontier zone, with long terms, clear responsibility, and exceptional rewards for success—then revenue would grow and border granaries fill themselves. Provincial coffers are empty and the people are exhausted, yet some counsel emptying every treasury into the inner palace for day-to-day spending. If the regions revolt, what reserves will we have? Prefects and magistrates exist to sustain the people: promote farming, lighten levies, enforce village compacts, tighten baojia—paperwork, lawsuits, and tax tricks are not the measure." Much of the memorial was debated and largely adopted. That winter he wrote again: "The nation's worry is popular poverty, and only prefects can relieve it—choose them with utmost care. Promote outstanding prefects straight to capital office or a governorship, and others will strive on their own. Provincial education commissioners uphold the realm's culture—pick men of proven scholarship and character, not by rotation alone. When their teaching is eminent, call them to be Grand Master of the National University or into the Hanlin as a mark of honor." The ministries deliberated, but in the end nothing was done.
26
殿
In year three he was made vice director of the Imperial Stud. At first Xu Jie and Gao Gong were at odds; Shiliang and others in court helped force Gong out. When Gong came back he reviewed the censorate and purged dissenters; Shiliang, Chen Zan, and Zhang Hao, though already raised to capital posts, were all driven out. Shiliang was faulted for lack of discretion and dismissed. Wanli 12 brought his recall to Nanjing assistant director of Punishments, on the recommendation of Qiu Yin and Yu Maoxue. He advanced to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, took charge of capital garrison affairs, and laid out fourteen essentials of defense and order. He next proposed grading prefects and magistrates on seven counts—waterworks, relief granaries, livelihood, taxation, clearing jails, suppressing bandits, and improving custom—with annual reports to ministries and censors to set their rankings. He also urged the crown prince to leave the palace for formal study. He passed through both vice ministries of Justice and became Nanjing minister of Justice. A year later he died in post.
27
In his youth Shiliang was sociable and high-spirited. He once forced Left Censor-in-Chief Zhang Yongming from office, to the disapproval of his peers. Later he regretted that act. Setbacks in mid-career turned him inward to moral philosophy. Under Tianqi he received the posthumous name Zhuangjing ("Solemn and Tranquil").
28
西
Chen Zan, courtesy name Tingke, came from Changshu. He became a jinshi in Jiajing 35. He was made magistrate of Yongfeng, Jiangxi. Rated top in administrative merit, he was raised to supervising secretary in the Justice section. He brought down Yan Song allies Grand Master of Sacrifices Wang Cai and Preceptor Tang Rujie through impeachment. He was moved up to Left Supervising Secretary. He charged Selection Bureau director Nan Xuan and asked that officials expelled for speaking out be reinstated. The emperor flew into a rage, had him thrashed sixty blows, and removed him from office. Recalled in Longqing 1 to the Personnel section, he sought honors for Yang Zui, Yang Jue, Luo Hongxian, and Yang Jisheng and punishment for the clique that murdered Shen Lian. The throne assented, and Yang Shun and Lu Kai were both seized for trial. That winter he was made Vice Minister of Imperial Sacrifices. Gao Gong resented Zan as Xu Jie's protégé; though Zan had already gone home on sick leave, he was finally banished to Luochuan assistant magistrate for rashness and never reported. In the Wanli era he eventually reached Left Vice Minister of Justice. Zan had first been driven out by Gao Gong; under Zhang Juzheng's dominance he was likewise disliked and left unreappointed. Only after Juzheng's death was he recommended back as Assistant Magistrate of Kuaiji. He later rose to vice minister. After Record Office director Gu Xiancheng was banished for criticizing abuses of the day, Zan confronted Grand Secretary Wang Xijue: "Xiancheng's memorial was entirely just—why was he punished?" Xijue replied, "He clings to pedantic talk and heeds street rumor—how could he grasp our difficulties." Zan answered, "Perhaps pedantic counsel deserves trust, street talk deserves scrutiny, and Xiancheng's concerns deserve heed as well." Xijue said nothing. In this way Zan repeatedly crossed the men at the helm. He died in office and was posthumously enfeoffed as Right Censor-in-Chief with the posthumous name Zhuangjing. Zhang is treated in the Zou Yinglong biography.
29
退使 使 西使 使 使
Hao Jie, styled Yanfu, came from Yuzhou. His father Ming had served as censor. Jie became a jinshi in Jiajing 35, served as courier, and was raised to censor. In Longqing 1 he was grand coordinator of the capital region. That winter, after raiders struck Yongping in force, he asked that levies be waived in plundered areas and wrote, "Punishment lately hits civil officials but not military men, and commanders but not their juniors—discipline the code to restore imperial authority." Both proposals were approved. He then charged Jizhou Superintendent Liu Tao and Grand Coordinator Geng Suiqing with holding back; after the raiders withdrew they claimed credit with severed heads of the slain, and he also stripped Liaodong troops of Bangchuiya battle honors while indicting Vice Commissioner Shen Yingqian and battalion commanders Li Xin and Zhou Mian. The throne removed Shen Yingqian, jailed Li Xin and Zhou Mian, and sent Tao and Suiqing home to await inquiry. The court ordered eunuch Li You to oversee Suzhou and Hangzhou weaving; the Ministry of Works protested in memorial, but the emperor refused. Jie argued, "The enthronement edict ended weaving only a year ago, yet an envoy has been dispatched again—policy is no longer consistent. Worse, eunuchs rule unchecked while officials squeeze the populace to feed them—a serious blow to the throne's reputation." The emperor still ignored him. On an imperial visit to the Southern Park, all capital garrison troops were ordered to accompany the procession. Xu Jie, Yang Bo, and others remonstrated in vain; Jie protested again, and the emperor still refused. Vice Minister of Justice Hong Chaoxuan was removed after a supplemental impeachment; when he memorialized in self-defense, Jie and others charged him with breaking protocol and he was demoted. He had once declared Gao Gong unfit for the premiership, and Gao resented him for it. When Gao returned to power, Jie immediately sought leave to quit. Once Gao fell, Jie was reinstated in his old office. He was soon posted to Shaanxi as vice commissioner after privately criticizing Zhang Juzheng's ouster of Gao Gong. He was next promoted to Left Provincial Administration Commissioner of Shandong. After impeachment he was reduced to Liaodong Stud Farm director with concurrent coastal defense duties, and given the additional title Shandong Surveillance Commissioner.
30
退 使 稿
In year seventeen he became Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Liaodong. Because he directed the generals against the enemy, one son received an official appointment. Li Chengliang was then regional commander: widely feared, yet not above falsifying battle credit. When raiders crossed the border he sometimes held back; after they withdrew he would pick off the aged and weak, raid isolated bands, or slaughter frontier dependents for false head counts—a settled habit. Supervising and coordinating officials covered for him; Jie alone refused to join them. In spring of year nineteen Chengliang, following Battalion Commander Guo Mengzheng's scheme, sent Vice Commander Li Ning to strike Ban Sheng at Zhenyi Fort and claimed over two hundred eighty heads of old and weak captives. On the march home another band blocked them; Ning ran first and several thousand troops were lost—well over half—yet Chengliang dressed up the affair to claim honors. Jie drafted a full memorial stating the facts and demanded that Governor-General Jian Da co-submit it. Da hid Jie's draft and filed his own memorial praising the victory. Investigating censor Hu Kejian hurried a memorial against Ning, linking Chengliang in the charges and attacking Jie as well. The Ministry of War declined to consider Ning's crimes. Kejian, furious, laid bare all Chengliang's and Da's cover-ups. Previously, in winter of year eighteen Haizhou had been ravaged for thirteen days; Vice Commander Sun Shoulian never fought, and Chengliang never relieved the town. Kejian had impeached Shoulian, but Shen Shihang and Xu Guo protected him, and the court merely ordered him to await inquiry. Kejian then wrote, "When I first impeached Shoulian, Shihang tried to block me by letter; when I impeached Ning, he and Xu Guo urged me to soften the charges. Private favor over public duty will wreck frontier defense." He also denounced Shen Yiyu, Da, and Ministry of War supervising secretary Zhang Yingdeng as a deceitful clique; Da had suppressed Jie's joint memorial on merit and guilt, and he now traced years of Chengliang's inflated victories. The emperor ruled that Chengliang's earlier feats had been confirmed by investigating censors and that Kejian's charges were groundless surmise. Chengliang and the rest were left untouched, yet the emperor inwardly judged Jie trustworthy.
31
He was soon advanced to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief. After Japan overran Korea, Da sent Lieutenant Commander Zu Chengxun with three thousand troops; all perished. When news arrived Jie was impeached too, but the emperor expressly spared him. With the Korean king fleeing toward Liaodong, Jie asked that he be lodged at a safe site beyond the border and that his retinue be provided for; the court agreed. He was soon made Right Vice Minister of War and governor-general of Ji, Liaodong, and Baoding. Recalled to direct military affairs, he rose to Right Censor-in-Chief. When Japan's enfeoffment and tribute were debated, Jie declared, "Hideyoshi's crimes cry out for execution, yet if we grant him rank and titles, the outer world will say the court has no worthy men." Overruled, he was moved to Nanjing Minister of Revenue. He went home on sick leave. He was recalled as Nanjing Minister of Works. He was at once shifted to the Ministry of War to assist in state affairs. He died while serving. He was posthumously enfeoffed as Junior Mentor of the Heir Apparent.
32
祿
Hu Kejian, styled Gongzhi, came from Guangshan. He became a jinshi in Wanli 14. Leaving the Hanlin Academy, he became investigating censor for Shandong. Liaodong fell under his circuit, and he memorialized to ban purchased merit and stolen battle credit. Once he impeached Chengliang, men of influence turned against him. Kejian charged Left Censor-in-Chief Li Shida with shielding criminals, even calling him a traitor; the ruling faction declared him unfit for the censorate and banished him to Qishui assistant magistrate. Sent home over the affair, he remained in private life for thirty years. At Guangzong's accession he was recalled as Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Entertainments. In the Tianqi era he rose to Right Vice Minister of Justice. In winter of year five the factionalist Li Hengmao denounced him as decrepit and he was removed. Early in Chongzhen his rank was restored. After death he was posthumously made Minister. Kejian was born Fu but had taken the surname Hu, restoring his original name only after many years.
33
Zhao Canlu
34
涿
Zhao Canlu, styled Zongchuan, came from Yin. He became a jinshi in Longqing 5. Chosen as Hanlin Bachelor, he moved to supervising secretary in the Revenue section. In Wanli 2 Empress Dowager Cisheng built a temple at Zhuozhou to the Goddess Bixia. Ministry and censorate officials protested in memorial, but the emperor refused. Canlu condemned the rite as improper and wrote, "Bandits have ravaged north and south, ruining the people; dredging levies have driven families to sell even wives and children. Your Majesty has already drawn over fifty thousand taels from the treasury for bridges and temples. Redirected to famine relief, the blessing would be far greater." The emperor still ignored the plea. When Nanjing eunuch Zhang Jin drunkenly humiliated supervising secretary Wang Yi, Zheng Yue and Yang Jie memorialized in protest without response; Canlu added, "Jin belongs to garrison eunuch Shen Xin's faction—unless Xin is punished too, the public will not be appeased. Shen Xin was then in league with Feng Bao, and court opinion turned against the memorialists: Yue and the others lost their stipends, and Canlu was banished to the post of county recorder at Gao'an. Later transferred to magistrate's assistant at Raozhou and promoted to educational commissioner in Fujian, he soon petitioned to hurry home on urgent leave. After a death in the family and completion of mourning, he returned to his educational duties in Fujian. He rose through service to Vice Minister of Ceremonies in Nanjing. In Wanli 17 he was appointed Grand Coordinator of Fujian with the rank of Right Vice Censor-in-Chief. He tightened the coastal prohibition and put to death merchants who colluded with Japanese pirates. He was appointed Minister of the Court of Judicial Review. Recalled as Left Vice Minister of Justice, reassigned to War and then shortly to Personnel. As the proposal to enfeoff Japan and receive its tribute came up, Canlu held firm that it must not be allowed. Grand Coordinator Gu Yangqian took offense, disputed the point at court, and argued that Canlu understood Japanese affairs and should be given the task. When the memorial reached the court for discussion, Canlu restated his position and composed Three Discourses on Eastern Enfeoffment, setting out the pros and cons with thorough clarity. In the end the enfeoffment scheme came to nothing. He was made Minister of Justice at Nanjing. The Marquis of Chengyi, Liu Shiyan, had falsely read the stars and plotted to raise troops in the name of saving the throne; once impeached and brought before the courts, Canlu ruled that he deserved death. Zhao Xueshi, a director in the Nanjing Ministry of Works, was impeached by Vice Minister Zhou Sijing for profiteering, and exile was recommended. Xueshi transferred guilt to his household servants, and the judicial authorities imposed a light penalty. Censor Zhu Wubi renewed the impeachment and extended it to Canlu, charging that Xueshi was a kinsman of Grand Secretary Zhao Zhigao and that Canlu had protected him for that reason. Canlu asked to retire. Personnel Minister Sun Piyang and others argued that Canlu's record had always been upright and that he ought not be permitted to resign; the throne ordered him to remain. He was eventually raised to Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. He retired from office, died, and was posthumously honored with the title Duansu.
35
The biography turns to Zhang Mengnan.
36
調
Zhang Mengnan, styled Yuansi, came from Zhongmu. He became a jinshi in Jiajing 44. He was made magistrate's assistant at Guangping. He was later moved up to subprefect of Hanzhong. Recalled to the capital as judicial assistant of Shuntian, he rose step by step to Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Seals. While Gao Gong served in the Grand Secretariat and also headed Personnel, his wife was Mengnan's aunt by marriage, yet beyond official matters they exchanged no private words. Gong took offense at this, and for four years Mengnan received no advancement. After Gong was driven from office, friends and relatives all kept their distance, but Mengnan alone stayed at Gong's house, helped him pack, and escorted him to the city outskirts. Once Zhang Juzheng came to power, he raised Mengnan to Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Stud. Mengnan again refused to court favor, fell from Juzheng's good graces, and was passed over for further appointments. Only after Juzheng's downfall, and after a long wait, was he gradually promoted to Right Vice Minister of Works at Nanjing. He was soon recalled to the capital and, retaining his rank, took charge of the Office for Transmission.
37
In Wanli 17, after eight months without holding court, Mengnan submitted a remonstrance noting that southerners were pleading the case of the late Censor-in-Chief Li Cai while the people of Cai were protesting the injustice done to the late Magistrate Cao Shiqing; with those petitions still held back and the petitioners detained at the Horse and Chariot Office, barely fed and facing uncertain survival, the throne's moral standing was being harmed. Moved by this, the emperor began to hold court at the gate from time to time. That winter he moved to Revenue and was advanced to Left Vice Minister. He was soon made Nanjing Minister of Works and then immediately reassigned to Revenue. Nanjing's granaries were then nearly empty; when Mengnan took charge the supply would barely cover two years, yet within a year he had built up a seven-year reserve. When the Water Office repaired its granaries, he contributed two thousand taels from surplus public funds to help. When someone asked why he was working another man's field, Mengnan replied: if it is the state's business, must one mark off boundaries? Nanjing censor Chen Suowen accused Mengnan of greed and meanness, but Personnel Minister Sun Rong testified that Mengnan was loyal and scrupulous and that the censor's charges stemmed from a director's dispute; the emperor kept him in office. Mengnan asked to resign, but permission was denied. After a second petition to retire, he was at last allowed to go home. After some years he was recalled to his former post.
38
In the spring of Wanli 30 an edict announced the abolition of mining levies. Before long the order was not put into effect. Mengnan led his colleagues in protest, but received no reply. He was promoted to Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. He petitioned five times to retire, but each request was refused. As the mining-tax scourge worsened by the day, Mengnan drafted a deathbed memorial thousands of words long, denouncing the levy in detail and declaring: as a territorial official I know that every tax collected across the realm comes from what people have left after selling their children and cutting flesh from their bones. My duty is to collect taxes — I perform that duty, and the people are the ones who suffer. To gather riches by harming the people and to oppress the people so as to unsettle the realm — what use is a minister who does this? I cannot contain my grief; I speak only as one who fears for the realm, like the man of Qi who worried that the sky might fall. He had his son present the memorial, and died the following day. Nanjing Minister Zhao Canlu and others praised his upright loyalty, and he was posthumously honored as Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent.
39
使 祿西
Wei Chengfang, styled Junda, came from Dazhou. He became a jinshi in Longqing 2. Under Wanli he rose through the ranks to prefect of Wenzhou. Upright and honest, he was adept at caring for the populace. Raised to Vice Commissioner in Zhejiang, he cited illness and retired. On recommendation he returned to office, served as Shandong administrative commissioner, and later became Minister of Banquets at Nanjing. The Ministry of Personnel proposed Vice Minister of Ceremonies Zhu Jingxun for Right Commissioner for Transmission, with Chengfang as his deputy. Zhu Jingxun was the son of Grand Secretary Geng. Geng argued: Chengfang was my jinshi year-mate, and his quiet integrity is seldom matched; a minister's son should not rank ahead of him. The emperor approved. He was soon made Nanjing Minister of Imperial Sacrifices, then promoted Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and appointed Grand Coordinator of Jiangxi. He rigorously barred gifts, and his subordinates vied to tighten their own conduct. Recalled as Right Vice Minister of War at Nanjing, he was immediately appointed Minister of Revenue. The Prince of Fu sought reed lands stretching more than a thousand li from Jiangdu to Taiping and sent his own eunuchs to impose levies along the route. Chengfang protested in strong memorials, but in the end the throne would not yield. During Wanli, Nanjing ministers of Revenue famed for integrity were first Zhang Mengnan and later Chengfang. He was shortly transferred to Personnel. He died while still serving. He was posthumously honored as Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent with the title Qingmin.
40
調
Li Zhen, styled Weiqing, came from Anhua. He became a jinshi in Longqing 5. He served as magistrate of Gaoping before being called up as a censor. Early in Wanli, when Fu Yingzhen was thrown into prison for outspoken remonstrance, Zhen joined colleague Qiao Yan and supervising secretary Xu Zhenming in forcing entry to watch over him and was punished with demotion to clerk of the Changlu Salt Transport Office. He moved on to magistrate's assistant at Guide and a directorship in Rites, then rose three times to vice prefect of Shuntian. In Wanli 18, with trouble on the Tao and Yellow River frontiers, he argued forcefully that tribute trade was no policy and listed four failings of the border administration. The emperor held that tribute relations had stood for twenty years and the original arrangement should not be faulted, so the memorial was set aside. As Grand Coordinator of Huguang with the rank of Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, he argued that Magistrate Liang Daoning, a capable local administrator, had wrongly received the lowest evaluation and that officials who let bias govern ratings should be punished to spur the others. When recommending staff, one should not single out only senior men; junior officials such as Zhao Jiao and Yang Guo also deserve clear commendation. Jiao and Guo were among those raised from clerical posts early in Wanli. The throne approved each proposal. Recalled as Left Vice Censor-in-Chief, he was soon advanced to Right Vice Minister of Revenue. When Zhao Yongxian came under attack for refusing a marriage alliance, Revenue Bureau director Zheng Cai renewed the slander against him. Zhen answered Cai's memorial in a rebuttal that also touched on Cai's father, Luo. Enraged, Cai memorialized against Zhen in turn; Zhen asked to retire, but permission was refused. Censor Song Xingzu proposed moving Cai to another ministry so he would not clash with Zhen and the standing of senior ministers would be preserved; Cai was accordingly posted to Nanjing. He was shortly moved to War and raised to Left Vice Minister.
41
In Wanli 24 the Japanese enfeoffment and tribute negotiations broke down, and both Senior Grand Secretary Zhao Zhigao and Minister Shi Xing faced impeachment. The court debated war and defense, and every memorial on the subject went to the Ministry of War. Zhen and his colleagues wrote that the debate now turned on only three questions: war, defense, and enfeoffment. On enfeoffment, though Li Zongcheng has already been dispatched, Yang Fangheng remains in Japan. To break off the mission abruptly would abandon several hundred countrymen in a foreign land, while our armies and provisions are not yet ready for a distant campaign. Yang Fangheng should wait quietly — if the kampaku comes to receive the envoy, proceed with enfeoffment; if not, halt. War and defense should be our substantive work, with policy adjusted as conditions require. Korea has long upheld ritual decorum, and wherever our troops are stationed they must be strictly barred from looting. The throne approved the plan as memorialized. The memorial also held that Zhao Zhigao and Shi Xing should resign. The emperor reprimanded Li Zhen: confine yourself to strategy and defense—why did you presume to weigh senior ministers' fate? For now the matter would drop. Zhao Zhigao thereafter bore a grudge against Li Zhen. The next year Shi Xing fell from favor and Li Zhen was told to stand in as minister. Li Zhen urged major fortification, colonization, and new garrisons at Pyongyang, Seoul, and Pusan, Korea's key sites, and laid out fifteen war-and-defense measures—all adopted. He continued to send strategic plans to court.
42
西 西 西
When Sichuan came under attack, Li Zhen argued: "Sichuan borders Shaanxi; Songpan had long been unmolested because tribal peoples formed a buffer. After Altan drove his herds westward, the Longyou frontier erupted. As Longyou hardened its defenses the raiders turned aside—and the harm moved into Sichuan. Today more than half the tribes have been subordinated to the western Mongols. On the maps, secret routes from the northern frontier into Shu pass through gaps often less than three hamlets apart. Only sheer cliffs stand in the way: Zhenlu Fort holds the gate to Zhangla, and Hongqiao Pass guards the neck of Songpan. Outside the forts and passes, every ridge and cliff can be garrisoned. Hold Ayu Ridge and the enemy cannot pass Zha Ji to threaten the fort. Garrison Huang Shengchang and they will not dare bypass the beacon towers to strike the pass. Hengshan and Guai Shiya are equally vital—all need urgent defense plans; the governor-generals should draw them up and report. The memorial was approved.
43
便 調
Li Zhen was blunt, principled, and firm; his stewardship was judged sound. Some urged making him minister at once, but Zhao Zhigao, nursing old grievances, quietly blocked it. Zhang Wei and Shen Yiguan, close to Xing Bing and Yang Hao, likewise disliked Li Zhen's course and called him no soldier—only Xiao Dayheng was fit. The emperor would not listen. When Xing and Yang continued to fail, Zhao Zhigao again moved to remove Li Zhen, and Censor Kuang Shangjin charged him with mediocrity. The emperor again refused. When Gansu needed a governor, Li Zhen nominated the well-known Liu Minkuan. Supervising Secretary Yang Yingwen objected: Liu Minkuan was already under disciplinary review and should not be put forward. The emperor challenged Li Zhen, who replied: "An earlier edict reserved Liu Minkuan for the next governorship vacancy—that is why I named him. Enraged that Li Zhen would not admit error, the emperor posted him to Nanjing. At the next personnel review Nanjing remonstrators brought charges against him and he was forced to retire.
44
Years later he was recalled as Nanjing minister of Justice. A year on he pleaded illness again and left for home without waiting for permission; the emperor was furious. Grand Secretary Ye Xianggao argued: "Li Zhen is genuinely ill and should not be harshly punished. For a decade and more, perhaps one in a hundred senior ministers who asked to retire was allowed to go. Li Tingji and Zhao Shiqing were held at court for years, their pleas numbering over a hundred memorials. Today Ministers Sun Piyang and Li Hualong, whose reviews of military administration have gone unread, are likewise pressing to resign. If others follow Li Zhen's path, the prestige of the government itself will suffer. Ministers leave for a handful of reasons. Sickness, censure, or inability to perform the duties—all are grounds to let a man go. Meet their circumstances flexibly: keep them when retention is justified, release them when it is not. The emperor nevertheless stripped Li Zhen of rank and ordered him to live in disgrace. He died soon after.
45
Ding Bin, courtesy name Liyuan, came from Jiashan. He earned his jinshi degree in Longqing 5. He was made magistrate of Jurong. He was called up and made a censor. Grand Secretary Zhang Juzheng—Bin's examiner—framed Liu Tai for graft and sent Bin to Liaodong to prosecute the case. Bin refused outright, provoked Juzheng, and resigned. Wanli 19 brought restoration on recommendation, but mourning soon took him home again. He was recalled as assistant director of the Nanjing Court of Punishments. He advanced to Nanjing Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief and inspector of Yangtze river defenses. With river defenses slack, he toured the line in one boat with his officers, reinforced critical posts, and kept his jurisdiction at peace. Southern garrison officers who traveled to the capital to claim hereditary posts often languished without appointment; he proposed conducting succession reviews in Nanjing instead. When the heretical cult of Liu Tianxu was exposed, War Minister Sun Kuang sought a sweeping prosecution; the court referred the case to the judiciary. Acting as Nanjing chief judicial reviewer, he overturned the case: seven were sentenced to death, the rest freed. He was called to be Left Vice Minister of Works and soon made Nanjing minister of Works. He replaced the road from Nanjing proper to Danyang with stone paving, to travelers' acclaim. He repeatedly asked to retire on grounds of age; only when Guangzong took the throne was release granted.
46
For thirty years in Nanjing office he sought famine relief whenever drought or flood struck, often adding his own funds. Early in retirement as a censor, then again during mourning leave, three consecutive famine years led him to give generously for relief. In Tianqi 5 he again gave three thousand shi of grain to the poor and three thousand taels to pay taxes for impoverished households. The provincial authorities reported his record of charity; already a Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent, he was raised to Senior Guardian and his household was publicly honored. In his great age he received three imperial inquiries after his welfare. He died in Chongzhen 6 at the age of ninety-one. He was posthumously named Qinghui ("Pure and Kind").
47
The historians note: Nanjing ministries were posts of high dignity but little executive weight—a garden in which to cultivate standing; men of depth and reputation were sent there. Those who were stern and independent, and therefore disliked by the men in power, were kept at such a distance. Men like Yuan Hongyu lived out their careers in these honorable but idle posts, their talents unused—yet preserving themselves in the process. Ambitious climbers of the age might take the lesson to heart.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →