← Back to 明史

卷二百二十五 列傳第一百十三 張瀚 王國光 梁夢龍 楊巍 李戴 趙煥 鄭繼之

Volume 225 Biographies 113: Zhang Han, Wang Guoguang, Liang Menglong, Yang Wei, Li Dai, Zhao Huan, Zheng Jizhi

Chapter 225 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 225
Next Chapter →
1
Zhang Han, Wang Guoguang, Liang Menglong, Yang Wei, Li Dai, Zhao Huan, and Zheng Jizhi
2
使使 西使
Zhang Han, courtesy name Ziwen, came from Renhe. He passed the metropolitan examination in the fourteenth year of the Jiajing reign (1535). He was appointed principal clerk in the Nanjing Ministry of Works. After serving as prefect of Luzhou, he was transferred to Daming. When Altan Khan besieged the capital, an imperial edict dispatched a bureau director from the Ministry of War to raise militia from the capital region for its defense. Han at once examined household registers, drafting one man from every thirty households while having the remaining twenty-nine households supply his rations, and in this way raised eight hundred troops. He hurried to Zhending and invited the envoy to inspect the troops, and the envoy commended his capability. He rose through successive posts to become left provincial administration commissioner of Shaanxi, then was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief with authority to administer the province. Barely half a year later he was summoned to the capital as president of the Court of Judicial Review. He was promoted to right vice minister of the Ministry of Punishments, then shortly afterward transferred to the Ministry of War and placed in charge of grain transport.
3
滿 退 輿
In the first year of the Wanli reign (1573), Minister of Personnel Yang Bo was removed, and Han was called to succeed him. When his term expired, he was granted the additional title of Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. When the court recommended candidates for Minister of Personnel, Ge Shouli, the Left Censor-in-Chief, ranked first, Zhu Heng, Minister of Works, second, and Han third. Zhang Juzheng disliked Ge Shouli's obstinacy and was tired of Zhu Heng's arrogance, and therefore singled out Han for promotion. Han's seniority and reputation were slight, and after this abrupt elevation the entire court leaned ever more toward Zhang Juzheng; in advancing and retiring high ministers, Han generally followed Juzheng's wishes. Even when he ventured his own opinion, public sentiment usually did not align with it. On this account he was impeached by the investigating censors Zheng Zhun and Wang Xiyuan. Zhang Juzheng regarded him favorably and would not allow the impeachments to stand. When Censor Liu Tai impeached Zhang Juzheng, he also criticized Han's disorderly rule in Shaanxi and his habit of assenting to whatever Juzheng wanted.
4
歿
When Zhang Juzheng's father died and a plan was made for him to remain in office instead of observing mourning, Han opposed it in his heart. A rescript from the throne directed Han to urge that Juzheng be kept in post; Juzheng also drafted his own memorial and signaled to Han's staff that they should seek an imperial response. Han feigned incomprehension, saying, "When the chief minister rushes home for a parent's funeral, an exceptional dispensation should be granted—that concerns the Ministry of Rites. What business is it of the Ministry of Personnel? Zhang Juzheng sent another intermediary to persuade him, but Han would not budge; finally a rescript censured him for having long defied the imperial order and lacking the deportment owed a minister. The officials at court were terrified and memorialized one after another to keep Zhang Juzheng in office; Han alone would not add his name. Clasping his chest, he sighed: "The three bonds of society are undone! Enraged, Zhang Juzheng prompted the supervising secretaries Wang Daocheng and the censor Xie Siqi to dredge up other charges against him and compelled him to resign and retire. After Zhang Juzheng died, the emperor came to miss Han. An edict instructed the appropriate agencies to supply him a monthly allowance, and when he turned eighty the throne sent a special message asking after his welfare. When he died he was posthumously honored as Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and given the posthumous name Gongyi ("Respectful and Benevolent").
5
調 簿 便
Wang Guoguang, courtesy name Ruguan, came from Yangcheng. He passed the metropolitan examination in the twenty-third year of the Jiajing reign (1544). He was appointed magistrate of Wujiang. Neighboring counties brought doubtful cases to him for judgment, and his interrogations invariably uncovered the facts. After transfer to Yifeng he was promoted to principal clerk in the Ministry of War. He moved to the Ministry of Personnel and rose to bureau director of civil appointments. Through successive promotions he became right vice minister of the Ministry of Revenue and was placed in charge of the granary depots. He resigned citing illness. In the fourth year of the Longqing reign (1570) he was recalled as left vice minister of the Ministry of Punishments and appointed Minister of Punishments at Nanjing. Before he assumed that office he was shifted to the Ministry of Revenue and again placed over the granary depots. When the Shenzong Emperor came to the throne, he resumed direct management of the ministry. Records had become voluminous and burdensome: from the counties and prefectures up to the ministry, charges for copying, transport, delivery, and payment afflicted both government and populace. Guoguang submitted a memorial asking that procedures be consolidated, cutting redundant paperwork by roughly a third to a half, and contemporaries hailed the reform as a welcome simplification. Since the Hongzhi reign the thirteen bureaus of the Ministry of Revenue, cramped for space, had been run by the bureau director alone; vice directors and principal clerks appeared only once, on the day they received appointment. When the director could not cope, work was handed to clerks and runners, and malfeasance only grew worse. Guoguang required them all to work in the offices, and official business was once again properly conducted. Frontier supplies were said to be exhausted, yet there was no reliable accounting of yearly outlays on the borders, garrison farming, or salt revenues. Guoguang asked that frontier officials be ordered to verify the figures and submit a durable long-term plan. The grand coordinator of Gansu, Liao Fengjie, and others each submitted detailed accounts, and waste and corruption were curbed as a result.
6
使 便 西
In the first year of Wanli he memorialized: "At the founding of the dynasty, the grain retained locally by prefectures and counties from summer tax and autumn grain payments came to roughly twelve million piculs. Policy then favored leniency; beyond yearly expenditures, the surplus in silver was reckoned at more than a million taels. Had local officials collected the full levy every year, county and prefectural granaries would have stayed full, and flood, drought, or banditry could not have brought disaster. Today, at the first sign of war or famine, capital reserves are seized and the imperial privy purse is tapped. Because local officials treated retained grain as a low priority and called vigorous collection harassment of the people, the system has decayed to its present state. He asked that grand coordinators and surveillance commissioners nationwide require full reports of receipts, disbursements, retained grain, and arrears, so his ministry could balance accounts flexibly and apply the surplus to frontier needs. Officials who failed to press collection vigorously should all be held to the new rules." The throne approved the proposal. Capital garrison troops who drew rations at Tongzhou endured long, painful waits. Guoguang proposed dispatching a bureau director to oversee the office, named the Ration Desk; troops presented their vouchers, received verification, and were issued grain within three days—a great relief to the garrison. Revenue and grain accounts were scattered across many bureaus; Guoguang asked that they be consolidated with clear lines of responsibility: the capital region under the Fujian Bureau, the southern metropolitan area under Sichuan, salt under Shandong, customs under Guizhou, the Huai, Xu, Lin, and De granaries under Yunnan, and fodder for the imperial horse stables, elephant quarters, and twenty-four remount depots under Guangxi. These arrangements became permanent regulations.
7
詿
In the third year he was singled out for censure in the capital officials' evaluation. Guoguang was impeached by supervising secretaries and censors at Nanjing. He memorialized again asking to be dismissed, but the emperor expressly kept him in office. The following year he pressed the request again, and an edict allowed him to return home with post-horses provided. Before leaving office he submitted the regulations he had compiled under the title Records of Wanli Accounts. The emperor commended his care for state finances and ordered the Ministry of Revenue to revise the work. When the book was finished, an edict commended him with imperial praise. That winter in the fifth year, Minister of Personnel Zhang Han was removed and Guoguang was recalled to succeed him. He proposed reforms on evaluating substantive governance, separating essential from redundant procedures, holding prefects and magistrates accountable, easing burdens on junior officials, and ending supplemental surcharges—all of which were approved. Shortly afterward, on the strength of his performance review, he was granted the additional title of Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. In the eighth year, when outer officials were due for evaluation, he asked that no fixed deadline be imposed. The throne agreed and also allowed officials who had erred through misunderstanding to defend themselves openly and clear their names. The following year, in the major evaluation of capital officials, he followed Zhang Juzheng's wishes and placed Wu Zhonghang and four others on the censure list.
8
Guoguang was talented and capable. When he first took charge of national finances he offered many constructive proposals. By then, hemmed in by the chief minister, his reputation fell short of what it had been at first. The supervising secretary Shang Shangzhong accused Guoguang of staffing appointments with his own favorites; Zhang Shize, a supervising secretary who had been sent out as vice commissioner of Henan and resented Guoguang, impeached him for selling offices and taking bribes. Guoguang memorialized again in his own defense; the emperor again urged him to stay, blamed Shize for acting from private spite, and demoted him to assistant magistrate of Yizhen. After Zhang Juzheng died, Censor Yang Yinqiu impeached Guoguang on six counts. The emperor was angered and removed him from office to live in idleness. Later, mindful of his service, the emperor restored his rank and allowed him to retire with honors.
9
西 宿 使 使
Liang Menglong, courtesy name Qianji, came from Zhending. He passed the metropolitan examination in the thirty-second year of the Jiajing reign (1553) and was appointed a Hanlin bachelor. He was appointed supervising secretary in the Bureau of Military Affairs and was the first to impeach Minister of Personnel Li Mo. The emperor was then showing Li Mo great favor and took no action. He was sent out to audit military grain stores in Shaanxi. He impeached the former grand coordinator of Yan-sui, Wang Lun, the bureau director in charge of grain Chen Can, and others; they were dismissed or demoted to varying degrees. He rose to chief supervising secretary of the Bureau of Personnel. The emperor was angry with Minister of Rites Wu Shan; Menglong, unwilling to impeach Shan alone and offend orthodox opinion, also impeached Minister of Personnel Wu Peng and secured both men's dismissal. He once memorialized: "Whether the chief minister is worthy bears directly on whether governance flourishes or declines. He asked that seniority rules be set aside and that officials at court be instructed to recommend publicly men of proven virtue and long-standing reputation, to brighten sagely rule." The emperor suspected the officials of secretly backing particular candidates and ordered them to explain themselves. Menglong apologized in alarm, and his salary was suspended. He was promoted to vice prefect of Shuntian Prefecture. Singled out for censure in the capital evaluation, he was sent out as vice commissioner of Henan. When the Yellow River broke through at Pei County, Minister Zhu Heng proposed cutting a new channel at Xu and Pi, and Menglong directed the work. After three promotions he became right provincial administration commissioner of Henan.
10
宿 便 便 沿
In the fourth year of the Longqing reign (1570) he was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief with authority as grand coordinator of Shandong. That autumn the river broke through at Suqian and sank eight hundred grain-transport vessels. The court debated reviving sea transport and put Menglong in charge. Menglong said: "The southern sea route runs from Huai'an to Jiaozhou, and the northern one from Tianjin to Haicang, with merchant vessels passing regularly between the two. People from the coastal islands and merchants also travel that stretch between Jiaozhou and Haicang. We therefore dispatched men to haul two thousand shi of grain from Huai'an and fifteen hundred shi of wheat from Jiaozhou by sea to Tianjin as a trial of the route, and everything went smoothly. The run from Huai'an to Tianjin takes about twenty days. Before the fifth month the winds are mild and fair, making sailing especially easy. Moreover, the ships keep to coastal waters, where a chain of islands offers shelter when winds turn bad. So long as the vessels are seaworthy and sailing follows the proper seasonal signs, there is little cause for concern. Compared with the old Yuan dynasty route of Yin Minglue, this route is safer and more convenient still. This is precisely what Qiu Jun meant by 'transport by sea along the coast.' We ask that the canal route serve as the primary channel of transport and the sea route as a backup. If the canal cannot be opened promptly, sea transport could fill the gap while the river channel receives the concentrated dredging needed for a lasting solution. Coastal defense is also vitally important: the guard posts along the coast have been slack for years without remedial action, and thoughtful observers see trouble ahead. Implementing sea transport while also tightening coastal defense would aid the state's finances and strengthen military readiness alike. The memorial was referred to the Ministry of Revenue, which noted that sea transport had long been discontinued and could not be fully restored at once; it proposed that the grain transport office allocate 120,000 shi to be shipped from the Huai region by sea to Tianjin. The Ministry of Works provided funds for the sea convoy. Imperial approval was granted. In the end sea transport was never implemented; the full account appears in the biography of Wang Zongmu. The following winter he was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief and transferred to serve as grand coordinator of Henan.
11
Early in the Shenzong reign, Zhang Juzheng was chief minister. Menglong was one of his protégés and a particular favorite; Zhang summoned him to the post of right vice minister of the Ministry of Revenue. Soon afterward he was moved to the Ministry of War and dispatched to reward meritorious officers and soldiers in Liaodong. In the fifth year (1577) he was promoted from left vice minister of the Ministry of War to right censor-in-chief with overall command of military affairs in Ji, Liaodong, and Baoding. Li Chengliang routed the Tumen tribes in a major victory at Changding Fort; the emperor announced the triumph at the ancestral temple, distributed lavish rewards, and granted an official appointment to one of Menglong's sons. Before long, supervising secretary Guang Mao argued: "These were tribes that had submitted and been settled within the defenses; Vice Commander Tao Chengyong had feigned a reward distribution to launch a surprise attack. He should be punished for slaughtering those who had surrendered. Minister of War Fang Fengshi strained to defend the action, and Menglong and the others declined the honors extended to their sons. When thirty thousand Tumen horsemen raided Dongchang Fort, Chengliang drove them off. When Ningqian was again threatened, Menglong personally led three thousand elite troops through Shanhaiguan to support Chengliang, dispatched two vice generals to intercept the invaders, and shifted Qi Jiguang to Yipianshi to block their retreat; the enemy then withdrew. He reported victories in succession at Yong'an Fort, Dingzipo, Malanyu, Yangshanmu, Hongtucheng, Kuandian, Guangning You Tun, Jin, Yi, Daning Fort, and other places; after repeated imperial commendations he was promoted on the spot to minister of war. For building the border walls at Huanghuazhen and Gubeikou he was made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and again had a son ennobled as hereditary thousand-household commander in the Embroidered Uniform Guard. Summoned to the capital to head the ministry, he memorialized on four points of military administration. Shortly afterward, for his frontier service, he was made Senior Guardian of the Heir Apparent.
12
歿
In the sixth month of the tenth year (1582), when Juzheng died, Minister of Personnel Wang Guoguang was impeached and removed, and Menglong took his place. A month later, censor Jiang Dongzhi charged that Menglong had secured the Ministry of Personnel through bribery arranged by Xu Jue and had betrothed his granddaughter to Xu Jue's younger brother as a wife for his son; censors Deng Lian and Zhao Kai joined the attack, and Menglong was ordered to retire. He lived in retirement for nineteen years before his death. During the Tianqi reign, Zhao Nanxing appealed on behalf of his frontier record, and he was posthumously made Junior Grand Guardian. Near the end of the Chongzhen reign he was posthumously given the epithet Zhenmin, "Upright and Perceptive."
13
西 使 西 西 沿
Yang Wei, courtesy name Boqian, came from Haifeng. He passed the metropolitan examination in the twenty-sixth year of the Jiajing reign (1547). He was appointed magistrate of Wujin. He was promoted to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Military Affairs. Chief inspector of the Yangtze defenses Shi Baoshan had already been transferred to president of the Court of Judicial Review. Wei argued: "The pirate threat in the southeast is severe; the coordinating officers and grand coordinators have all been condemned, yet Baoshan alone escaped censure and even secured a favorable promotion through connections. I ask that the Ministry of Personnel be penalized as well. The emperor was incensed, suspended the appointment bureau's salaries, and restored Baoshan to his former post. Having crossed the Ministry of Personnel, he was sent out as surveillance commissioner of Shanxi. Soon he was made administration commissioner with responsibility for defending Xuanfu. When raiders crossed the border, he joined vice general Ma Fang in defeating them and killing their chieftain, and received rewards of silver and silk. He was soon appointed Yanghe vice commissioner for military defense. He was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief with authority as grand coordinator of Xuanfu. For the victory in storming the enemy stronghold, he was promoted two ranks. A year later he retired to care for his mother. Two years later he was recalled to serve as grand coordinator of Shaanxi. He rebuilt garrison forces and recovered farmland that princely estates had seized. Early in the Longqing reign he was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief and transferred to grand coordinator of Shanxi. Annual courier and post-station levies in his jurisdiction amounted to 540,000 taels; Wei asked that they be cut by one quarter. He built and repaired border forts and issued orders to disperse the band of the outlaw Li Jiujing. He again asked to retire and care for his mother.
14
When Shenzong took the throne, he was appointed right vice minister of the Ministry of War. In the second year of the Wanli reign (1574) he moved to the Ministry of Personnel, rose to left vice minister, and then retired again to observe mourning for his mother. His mother died at over one hundred years of age. In the tenth year (1582) he was recalled as minister of the Nanjing Ministry of Revenue and soon summoned to head the Ministry of Works in the capital. An edict ordered a temporary palace built near Gongde Temple. Wei objected, and the project was abandoned. The following year he was transferred to the Ministry of Revenue and then appointed minister of personnel. Under Ming practice the Six Ministries each handled affairs across the empire, and the Grand Secretariat was not to intrude. Not until Yan Song's time did the secretariat begin quietly undermining ministerial authority. By Zhang Juzheng's time ministerial authority had passed entirely to the Grand Secretariat; ministers approached the secretariat deferentially, like subordinates, and the ancestral system was transformed. By then Shen Shixing was chief minister. Wei had long been known for integrity and enjoyed public esteem, but in old age he grew pliant and largely deferred to Shen Shixing. When censor Ding Cilü spoke out on examination-field abuses, Shixing, Yu Youding, Xu Guo, and their allies all turned against him. Wei arranged Ding Cilü's demotion; censors Jiang Dongzhi, Li Zhi, and others attacked him for it, and both he and Shixing asked to be dismissed. The emperor accepted the senior ministers' plea, kept Wei and his colleagues in office while admonishing their critics, and Wei returned to duty.
15
殿
When Juzheng had just fallen, censorial voices were loud at court; the emperor also suspected the senior ministers of collusion and wanted remonstrance officials to expose it and break the wall of obstruction. Fearful of attack, the chief minister's office and the Ministry of Personnel secretly relied on each other to curb the censorial faction. In the ninth-year capital evaluation, Zhang Juzheng had ordered the Ministry of Personnel to purge all opponents. In the fifteenth year, at the next grand evaluation, Censor-in-chief Xin Zixiu wanted a thorough purge; Wei held the process back at the chief minister's direction. Only thirty-three jinshi-degree holders were demoted or dismissed, and not a single one among Hanlin academicians, ministry appointees, supervising secretaries, or censors. Worthy and unworthy were indistinguishable, and public opinion turned bitter. In the summer of the seventeenth year the emperor had long absent himself from court; court and country alike suspected he was feigning illness because Zhang Jin had not been appointed. Wei led his colleagues in asking that the emperor resume court in the autumn. By the tenth month Wei and his colleagues petitioned again. The emperor was displeased and accused them of grandstanding.
16
In his early career Wei served widely at court and in the provinces and enjoyed a strong reputation. Once he held the power of appointment, his standing fell sharply. Yet he remained personally upright, and by nature he was generous and forbearing rather than harsh. The following year, nearing eighty, he repeatedly memorialized asking to retire. An edict granted him imperial post-horses and stipend servants according to precedent. Fifteen years after retiring, he died at ninety-two. He was posthumously made Junior Grand Guardian.
17
西使 西使
Li Dai, courtesy name Renfu, came from Yanjin. He passed the metropolitan examination in the second year of the Longqing reign (1568). Appointed magistrate of Xinghua, he governed with evident benefit to the people. He was promoted to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Revenue. Guangdong had raised taxes on the populace to fund military campaigns. When order was restored early in the Wanli reign, Dai memorialized to have the taxes corrected. He rose in successive steps to chief supervising secretary in the Bureau of Rites. He was sent out as right administration commissioner of Shaanxi and was promoted to provincial surveillance commissioner. Zhang Juzheng prized strict reputation and law; regional governors everywhere followed suit with harsh governance, but Dai alone held to a lenient course. From left provincial administration commissioner of Shanxi he was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief with authority as grand coordinator of Shandong. In years of famine he repeatedly petitioned for tax remissions and relief grain. He was summoned to the capital as vice minister of the Ministry of Punishments. He rose in succession to minister of the Nanjing Ministry of Revenue, was summoned to head the Ministry of Works, and then left office to mourn his stepmother.
18
西
In the twenty-sixth year of the Wanli reign, Minister of Personnel Cai Guozhen was removed from office. The court nominated seven candidates to succeed him; Dai was listed last, yet the emperor personally elevated and appointed him. At that time Zhao Zhigao and Shen Yiguan dominated the government. Though they did not dare openly curtail the ministry's prerogatives, senior offices were understaffed, and the nine ministers plus the censorate supervising secretaries holding sealed authority were all permitted to nominate their own candidates for the throne to decide. Even the section chiefs of the Ministry of Personnel were put forward by the nine ministers, so the minister could no longer choose his own staff. Prefectural and county officials throughout the realm were appointed entirely by lottery, and the ministry's power dwindled by the day. When Dai assumed his duties, he scrupulously followed the new rules and counted himself lucky merely to escape censure. The following year the capital personnel evaluation was held. The compiler Liu Gang, the Middle Secretariat drafter Ding Yuanjian, and the Nanjing review official Long Qilei had all once offended those in power through their memorials; all were marked for the evaluation, and public opinion was largely unsympathetic to Dai. Yet the succession remained unsettled, and the crown prince's capping and marriage had long been deferred; Dai repeatedly urged his colleagues in court to remonstrate forthrightly. When the damage wrought by mining levies grew acute, Dai led the nine ministers in memorializing: "Chen Zeng opened mines in Shandong, and Magistrate Wu Zongyao was arrested. Li Dao collected levies at Hukou, and Prefect Wu Baoxiu and others were arrested in turn. How many men like Zeng and Dao are there across the empire? How can local officials possibly cope? Moreover, flood and drought strike in succession, fields lie desolate and depleted, troops and supplies for the eastern campaign keep mounting—and now word comes of trouble on the western frontier as well. The people can barely survive, and evildoers are already stirring in secret—why, then, deliberately trip the trigger and hasten revolt!" No answer came.
19
西使調 調
Zhang Zhong, the Shanxi tax commissioner, memorialized to have Xia County Magistrate Han Xun transferred on the grounds that his post was remote and insignificant. Dai memorialized that palace eunuchs had no right to usurp the power of denunciation and investigation, and contested the move. Chen Feng of Huguang repeatedly memorialized to have local officials arrested; Dai and his colleagues argued forcefully once more, adding: "Feng, and Gao Huai of Liaodong, who illegally recruit crack troops and terrorize the populace, above all must be called to account." The emperor again paid no heed. Soon afterward he joined his colleagues again in stating: "From the sixth month of last summer until now there has been no rain; the roads are lined with the starving. Grand Coordinator Wang Yingjiao reported 180,000 famine victims. On top of this come repeated bandit alarms and one campaign after another; levies rise with every household quota, rents increase acre by measured acre—the tax burden is now more than twice what it was twenty years ago. The land had scarcely begun to recover when the damage of mining and commercial levies struck again. Whether or not any mine tax is owed, they forcibly squeeze the people regardless—by what principle? Wealthy households are few across the empire—how far can the villains' depredations go? Point at a man's house and threaten him with 'There is ore beneath it,' and his family is ruined on the spot; cry 'He evaded taxes,' and his coffers are drained at once. Armed with accusations that cannot be disproved and backed by men who fear nothing, how can ordinary people fail to be driven to ruin and revolt? Uprisings in Huguang have been reported again and again, and recently Wuchang has seen the worst of it. Do these people not cherish their own lives? Revolt means death, and so does submission—rather than die in silence alone, they would rather perish together with their tormentors. Once ignited, the blaze cannot be checked. Can Your Majesty treat this as a trifling matter?" Again there was no answer.
20
In the second month of the thirtieth year, the emperor fell ill and issued an edict abolishing mining levies, releasing prisoners, and recalling officials who had been punished for remonstrance. The next day, as the emperor recovered somewhat, he ordered mining levies and commercial taxes resumed as before. Dai led his colleagues in strenuous remonstrance. As for releasing the guilty and recalling the dismissed, the emperor still left implementation to the grand secretaries; Dai at once wanted to submit a memorial listing names, but Minister of Punishments Xiao Daheng held that any release of the guilty must first be reported to the throne. Just as the memorial was being prepared, Court of the Imperial Stud president Nan Qizhong impeached Dai and his colleagues for failing to comply, citing the long delay on both matters. The emperor grew angry and suspended the earlier edicts altogether. Dai accepted blame and asked to be dismissed; the emperor refused. Thereafter he twice petitioned for the recall of dismissed officials and four times led the nine ministers in begging that mining levies be halted—all to no avail. Merit-review section chief Zhao Bangqing was by nature stern and uncompromising. When supervising secretary Zhang Fengxiang impeached him, he suspected the move originated with Selection section chief Deng Guangzuo and Verification section chief Hou Zhigong, and in his defense memorial he attacked them. Censor Shen Zhenglong and supervising secretary Tian Dayi submitted memorial after memorial impeaching Bangqing. Furious, Bangqing laid bare all the private misconduct of Guangzuo and Zhigong. Guangzuo also sent up a memorial counterattacking with force; the ministry erupted in uproar, and Dai could restrain no one. Censors Zuo Zongyi and Li Pei then impeached Dai for setting a disgraceful example; Dai pleaded illness and asked to resign. The emperor ordered him to stay, demoted Bangqing three ranks, allowed Guangzuo and Zhigong to return home, and the uproar finally subsided.
21
The following winter the demonic placard affair broke out. Embroidered Uniform Guard officer Wang Zhizhen and others bore a grudge against their colleague Zhou Jiaqing and claimed the demonic placard was Jiaqing's doing; Jiaqing was sent to the imperial prison for exhaustive investigation. Jiaqing was Dai's nephew; when the joint interrogation was held, Dai withdrew to avoid the appearance of partiality. When the emperor heard of this, he took offense. At the same time Wang Shiqi's correspondence affair came to light, and the matter was referred to the ministry for deliberation. Shiqi submitted a memorial defending himself. The emperor said Shiqi ought not defend himself and rebuked Dai for failing to restrain his subordinate. Dai accepted blame, but his memorial bore the wrong seal and he was rebuked again; punishment fell on his staff. Dai submitted a memorial of apology, again using the same seal. The emperor grew angry, ordered him to retire, and stripped the salaries of all officials in the ministry below the rank of section chief.
22
Dai headed the Ministry of Personnel for six years. A gentle, elder statesman he was, yet his standing fell short of men such as Lu Guangzu. With Zhao Zhigao and Shen Yiguan wielding power, Dai did not dare dissent; he therefore remained long in office while personnel administration fell ever further into decay. Upon his death he was posthumously granted the title of Junior Guardian.
23
Zhao Huan, courtesy name Wenguang, came from Ye County. He passed the metropolitan examination in the forty-fourth year of the Jiajing reign (1565). He was appointed magistrate of Wucheng. He entered the capital as a principal clerk in the Ministry of Works and was transferred to serve as a censor. In the third year of the Wanli reign, the eunuch Zhang Hong requested that his faction be sent to monopolize timber at Zhending; Huan and supervising secretary Hou Yuzhao submitted a joint memorial in protest, but it was not accepted. When Zhang Juzheng was bereaved of his father, censorial officials submitted memorial after memorial asking that he be retained in office; Huan alone refused to sign. He was promoted to vice prefect of Shuntian Prefecture and rose in succession to left vice censor-in-chief.
24
滿
In the third month of the fourteenth year, amid dust storms the emperor solicited candid opinion from the court. Huan asked that imperial magnanimity be restored, loyal remonstrance welcomed, levity in court curbed, and policy decrees trusted; that ministers be summoned regularly to discuss governance, practical reforms implemented step by step, and every abuse within the inner palace abolished; and that grand coordinators and local officials be charged to seek out the people's hardships. The emperor praised and accepted his advice. He was soon transferred to right vice minister of the Ministry of Works. He was transferred to the Ministry of Personnel and promoted to left vice minister. He requested leave and went home. He was recalled as right censor-in-chief in Nanjing but declined on the grounds that his parents were elderly. At that time Huan's elder brother Yao, vice censor-in-chief and grand coordinator of Liaodong, also asked to return home to care for their parents. The Ministry of Personnel reported that the two men's circumstances were alike, that Yao was the eldest son and had long served on the frontier, and that he might be permitted to return. Huan alone was pressed to take up his post. He was soon summoned to serve as Minister of Punishments. When the court debated Japan's tribute mission, he forcefully argued that the policy was unsound. A man named Zhu Longguang denounced Li Rusong for colluding with Japanese pirates and had him imprisoned; he also had Rusong's associate Chen Zhongdeng shackled in the noonday sun, to be banished to a malarial region when the sentence expired. Huan argued that in the midsummer heat they would surely die, and that neither man's crime warranted death; in two memorials he contested the matter forcefully. He defied the imperial will and was rebuked. He again lost the emperor's favor over his handling of the case of Zhejiang touring censor Peng Yingcan and retired citing illness. He was again recalled as right censor-in-chief in Nanjing and at once offered appointment as Minister of Personnel; he accepted neither post. He lived in retirement at home for sixteen years. He was summoned to serve as Minister of Punishments and soon also held concurrent charge of the Ministry of War.
25
In the second month of the fortieth year Sun Buyang left office, and Huan was shifted to acting minister of the Ministry of Personnel. At that time the Shenzong Emperor had grown slack in governance, and many offices stood vacant. Ye Xianggao alone remained in the inner cabinet; he had already kept his doors shut for three months. Of the six ministers only Huan remained, and since he also held concurrent charge of the Ministry of Personnel, that ministry had no regular chief in office at all. Minister of War Li Hualong died; Wang Xiangqian was summoned but had not yet arrived, and no vice minister was appointed either. The Ministries of Revenue, Rites, and Works each had only a single vice minister left. Since Wen Chun's dismissal from the Censorate, the post of chief censor had stood vacant for eight years. By precedent there were fifty supervising secretaries and one hundred ten censors; by then there were no more than ten of each. Huan repeatedly memorialized begging that the vacancies be filled. The emperor answered none of them. That August Huan was finally appointed Minister of Personnel, and four vice ministers were also appointed across the ministries. Soon afterward the examination-and-selection orders were issued, filling seventeen supervising secretaries and fifty censorial posts, and the remonstrating voice of the court was said to flourish once more.
26
使
Yet by then factional cliques had already formed, and debate at court stood sharply divided. Huan had long enjoyed a reputation for integrity; suddenly raised from retirement, he had no prior ties among court officials, yet he had never been on good terms with the Donglin faction. Those who attacked the Donglin faction seized the opportunity to gain influence over him. His actions and appointments often failed to accord with prevailing opinion, and he was successively impeached by Censor Li Ruoxing and Supervising Secretary Sun Zhenji. Each time, the emperor issued gracious edicts urging him to remain in office. Soon afterward, Bu Lüji, a section chief in the Ministry of War, was impeached by Sun Wei, the Censor-in-Chief then acting as minister of war. Huan held that Lüji's offense was minor and proposed a three-month salary deduction. Supervising Secretary Zhao Xingbang impeached Huan for favoritism. Huan memorialized in his own defense and again asked to resign. Xianggao said: "State affairs are now grave, and capable men grow fewer by the day. Men out of office wait indefinitely for recall, while those still at court are as few as stars at dawn; yet officials high and low pursue one another with daily strife—hardly a blessing to the state. I hope that hereafter we may all lay aside settled prejudices and devote ourselves to the state's troubles—letting censorial officers speak freely in debate and letting those in charge decide in policy. Then grand ministers may act without chafing at censorial checks, and censorial officers may speak without fear of reprisal from those in power—and affairs under Heaven may yet be managed." He thereupon asked that Huan be instructed to resume his duties, and Huan finally returned to office.
27
The following spring, under the annual rotation custom, Sun Zhenji and Censors Wang Shixi and Wei Yunzhong were transferred to posts outside the capital. All three had been vigorous attackers of Tang Binyin and Xiong Tingbi; moreover Huan had not referred the transfers to the Censorate for consultation, whereupon Censor Tang Zhaojing protested on grounds of precedent and denounced Huan as well. Huan repeatedly memorialized in angry rebuttal, shut himself indoors, and refused to appear; the emperor issued an edict urging him to return to duty. Tang Zhaojing, having failed to prevail, submitted his resignation and returned home directly. His colleagues Li Banghua, Zhou Qiyuan, and Sun Juxiang, together with Bureau Director He Lang of the Ministry of Revenue, jointly impeached Huan for abuse of power and petitioned that Sun Zhenji and the others be restored to their censorial posts. The emperor penalized the protesting officials with salary deductions and demoted He Lang's rank to placate Huan. Huan pressed all the harder for dismissal. In the ninth month he kowtowed before the palace gates, left the capital, and awaited the emperor's decision. The emperor still sent word urging him to remain in office. Supervising Secretary Li Chengming again impeached Huan for ostracizing opponents and favoring allies; Huan declared himself gravely ill and steadfastly refused to return. More than a month later, he was at last permitted to return home by official relay.
28
退 滿
In the forty-sixth year of Wanli (1618), Minister of Personnel Zheng Jizhi left office. By then the factions held firm sway, and the morally upright had been driven from court entirely. Of the Qi faction, Qi Shijiao was especially overbearing in his influence. Judging Huan, as a fellow townsman, to be elderly and pliable, he worked hard to install Huan as Jizhi's successor; Huan was seventy-seven. Once in office, he followed Qi Shijiao's lead in everything and dared voice no dissent, and his long-standing reputation suffered all the more. The emperor still trusted Huan, valuing his integrity. The following July, when alarms came from Liaodong, Huan led the court officials to the Wenhua Gate and firmly petitioned the emperor to hold audience and discuss state affairs. Not until evening did a palace eunuch instruct them to withdraw, while vital military and state business remained shelved as before. Huan and the others submitted another memorial pressing the point, warning: "If one day the enemy tramples through Ji Gate and knocks at the palace gates, will Your Majesty still lie at ease in the inner palace and plead illness to refuse audience?" The emperor was shamed by this. When his performance review came due he should have received a promotion in rank, but the memorial was left unanswered. Huan soon died, and the customary posthumous honors were denied. Only when Emperor Guangzong ascended the throne were the honors granted according to custom. Early in the reign of Emperor Xizong (Tianqi), he was posthumously named Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent.
29
使 西
Zheng Jizhi, courtesy name Boxiao, was a native of Xiangyang. He passed the metropolitan examination in the forty-fourth year of the Jiajing reign (1565). He was appointed magistrate of Yugan. He was promoted to section chief in the Ministry of Revenue and rose through the ranks to bureau director. He was appointed prefect of Ningguo, then promoted to vice commissioner of Sichuan, but returned home to care for his aging parents. After his mourning period ended, he remained out of office for many years. In the nineteenth year of Wanli (1591), on the recommendation of Supervising Secretary Chen Shangxiang, he was recalled to serve in Jiangxi and promoted to Right Assistant Commissioner. He was summoned to the capital as Vice Minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud and eventually rose to Chief of the Court of Judicial Review. When the eastern expedition army was withdrawn, Minister of Personnel Li Dai proposed keeping fifteen thousand troops in garrison and having Korea supply their provisions. Jizhi said: "If we keep troops there, we ought to supply them ourselves—why drain our tributary ally?" Those who debated the matter applauded it. After nine years at the Court of Judicial Review, he was promoted to Minister of Revenue at Nanjing and then immediately transferred to Minister of Personnel.
30
退
In the forty-first year of Wanli (1613), Minister of Personnel Zhao Huan was dismissed. Though the emperor had grown negligent of routine business, he remained careful about appointments through the Ministry of Personnel and for a long time filled Huan's post with no successor. Because Zheng Jizhi enjoyed a reputation for integrity, he was summoned the following February to replace Huan. Zheng Jizhi had long languished in undemanding posts and had no factional backing. Yet by then the censorial officers held real power; the Qi, Chu, and Zhe factions were especially overbearing, and the rise and fall of senior officials depended entirely on their whim. Zheng Jizhi was a native of Chu, steeped in its factional rhetoric; he was also over eighty, senile and confused, and so deferred entirely to the factions' will. Wang Dazhi, director of the Appointment Bureau, was the man Zheng Jizhi relied on most. That autumn, under the annual rotation custom, Censors Song and Pan Zhixiang, Supervising Secretary Zhang Jian, and Nanjing Supervising Secretary Zhang Dujing were transferred to outside posts—all men who had once vigorously attacked Tang Binyin and Xiong Tingbi. By established custom, transfers of censorial officials required consultation with the Censorate and the Ministry of Personnel's personnel section; Zheng Jizhi did not permit them to be informed. When censorial posts came up for selection, Secretariat drafter Zhang Guangfang and magistrates Zhao Yunchang, Zhang Tinggong, Kuang Mingluan, and Pu Zhongyu should have been among the candidates; but because they were perceived as leaning toward Yu Li and Li Sancai, they were passed over and reassigned to ministry clerkships. Zhao Guoqi, a colleague of Wang Dazhi, raised an objection. Wang Dazhi flew into a rage and maneuvered through Zheng Jizhi to have him dismissed. Censors Sun Juxiang, Zhang Wudian, and Zhou Qiyuan thereupon protested on grounds of the annual rotation precedent and argued that Zhang Guangfang and the other four had been wronged; Li Jin, chief supervising secretary of the personnel section, also submitted a forceful memorial impeaching Wang Dazhi for abuse of office. Censor Tang Shiji, by contrast, sided with the Ministry of Personnel and denounced Sun Juxiang and his allies. Sun Juxiang and Li Jin angrily submitted joint memorials impeaching Tang Shiji. Other supervising secretaries and censors again rallied to Tang Shiji and pressed their attack on Sun Juxiang. Sun Juxiang submitted another forceful memorial attacking Wang Dazhi, who then pleaded illness and resigned. Zheng Jizhi recognized the injustice but offered no defense.
31
調 使
The following February, with Hu Laichao as director of the Appointment Bureau, Chief Supervising Secretary Zhang Guoru and Censors Ma Mengzhen and Xu Liangyan were transferred to outside posts—again without consulting the Censorate or the personnel section. Zhang Guoru had already been nominated for a capital chief ministership and by regulation should not have been sent outside; Ma Mengzhen and Xu Liangyan, meanwhile, had long antagonized the factions—hence Hu Laichao's move to suppress them. Zheng Jizhi was powerless to stop it. Sun Juxiang and his allies had already left the capital; Li Jin alone continued to protest, denouncing Zheng Jizhi and Hu Laichao in the strongest terms. Hu Laichao and his allies could not refute him; their faction resolved to overwhelm him by numbers, and the allied censors launched a collective attack on Li Jin. Li Jin fought back fiercely, submitting three memorials in succession. Hu Laichao and his allies replied with three denunciatory memorials of their own, their arguments growing increasingly thin. Hu Laichao then argued: "The annual rotation's requirement of joint consultation was meant only as a compromise by those in power—it was never meant as a binding rule. I petition that the earlier order be revised." The emperor took no action whatsoever. Li Jin, who was then away on an official mission, resigned on his own initiative. That autumn, Supervising Secretary Mei Zhihuan and Censors Li Ruoxing and Zhang Wudian were transferred outside the usual rotation—and again the responsible offices were not consulted in advance. Han Guangyu of the personnel section and Censor Xu Yangliang raised mild objections, but they stood alone and ultimately could not prevail. At the time Li Zhi of Jinyun served as Minister of Justice while also acting head of the Censorate—another figure the Zhe faction had installed. In the forty-fifth year of Wanli (1617), at the grand evaluation of capital officials, Zheng Jizhi and Li Zhi oversaw the proceedings, assisted by Bureau Director Zhao Shie, Supervising Secretary Xu Shaoji, and Censor Han Jun. Decisions on who would stay and who would go rested entirely with Xu Shaoji and his allies; Zheng Jizhi simply ratified their choices. Within a short time, virtually everyone at odds with the factions was demoted or dismissed; senior officials were brought down on petty charges, and the ranks of the worthy were emptied out.
32
Citing age and infirmity, Zheng Jizhi repeatedly petitioned to retire; each time the emperor urged him to stay and refused his request. The following spring he kowtowed before the palace gates, withdrew to await orders outside the city. On hearing of this, the emperor permitted him to return home by official relay. He died several years later, at the age of ninety-two. He was posthumously named Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent.
33
The commentator writes: Zhang Han, Wang Guoguang, and Liang Menglong were all praised for their administrative ability; Yang Wei, Zhao Huan, and Zheng Jizhi likewise enjoyed reputations for integrity—yet once they wielded control over appointments, they fell under bitter censure. At the time the chief ministers were at odds and the censorial officers wielded coercive power—a long-festering ill, difficult to reverse. Yet measured against the standard of putting public duty above private interest, these men can hardly have been without a sense of shame.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →