← Back to 明史

卷二百五十一 列傳第一百三十九 李標 劉鴻訓 錢龍錫 成基命 何如寵 徐光啟 文震孟 蔣德璟 方岳貢

Volume 251 Biographies 139: Li Biao, Liu Hongxun, Qian Longxi, Cheng Jiming, He Ruchong, Xu Guangqi, Wen Zhenmeng, Jiang Dejing, Fang Yuegong

Chapter 251 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 251
Next Chapter →
1
𣚴
Li Biao (Li Guogan; Zhou Daodeng))〉 Liu Hongxun; Qian Longxi (Qian Shisheng; Qian Shijin))〉 Cheng Jiming; He Ruchong (his elder brother He Rushen; Qian Xiangkun))〉 Xu Guangqi (Zheng Yiwei; Lin Qian))〉 Wen Zhenmeng (Zhou Bingmo))〉 Jiang Dejing (Huang Jingfang))〉 Fang Yuegong (Qiu Yu; Qiu Zhi; Tao Zhizhi))〉
2
Li Biao, whose style was Ruli, came from Gaoyi. He passed the jinshi examination in the thirty-fifth year of the Wanli reign. He was made a Hanlin bachelor and then appointed reviser. During the Taichang reign he rose step by step to Junior Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent. Under Tianqi he was elevated to Right Vice Minister of Rites and put in charge of the Household of the Heir Apparent. Biao had studied under Yue Nanxing, a fellow townsman; enemies in the factions resented this and entered his name in the Record of Donglin Comrades. Fearing reprisals, Biao pleaded illness and went home.
3
𣚴
When the Chongzhen Emperor took the throne, Biao was summoned from retirement as Minister of Rites and Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion. He came to court in the third month of Chongzhen 1. Before long Li Guogan, Lai Zongdao, and Yang Jingchen had all left office in turn, and Biao became chief grand secretary. The emperor was determined to set things right and often called ministers before him to settle routine business on the spot. Li Yangchong, grand coordinator of Xuanfu, reported that banner guards swarmed back and forth like woven cloth, their movements impossible to track, and that the cost had nowhere to come from. The emperor showed the memorial to Biao and his colleagues and said, "The frontier is in crisis—we send banner guards to scout. How can you call that false? Besides, why did our forefathers set up the factory guards in the first place?" Biao answered, "The matter certainly calls for caution. What Yangchong means is that without bribes he will face slander every day, but if he bribes them the treasury cannot bear the strain. The emperor said nothing. His colleague Liu Hongxun was impeached by Censor Wu Yu for altering an imperial rescript; the emperor wanted to punish Liu by law, but Biao insisted the bribery allegation was false. Wen Tiren attacked Qian Qianyi on the pretext that Qian had drawn him into the Zhejiang metropolitan examination affair; Supervising Secretary Zhang Yunru refuted him in open court. The emperor was furious and was ready to punish Qianyi severely; he also wanted to punish Supervising Secretary Qu Shisun, Censor Fang Kezhuang, and others. Biao said, "Your Majesty's treatment of Qianyi and Yunru began with Tiren's accusation, yet now Tiren himself is uneasy and asks to resign. I beg Your Majesty to remember that Qianyi's case was already covered by an amnesty edict and for now let him return to his native place; allow Yunru a chance to reform, and impose only light penalties on Shisun and the rest. The ministers will be settled, and Tiren will be settled as well. The emperor would not agree. From then on he deeply suspected that court officials formed factions, and Biao and his colleagues could no longer put their plans into effect. That winter Han Kuang returned to court; Biao yielded the chief ministership to him, and soon joined him in settling the case of the rebels.
4
殿
In the first month of the third year Han was dismissed and Biao again became chief grand secretary, eventually rising to Junior Guardian, concurrently Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent, Minister of Revenue, and Grand Secretary of the Hall of Military Glory. Earlier, six men had served as grand secretaries alongside Biao: Zongdao and Jingchen were driven out for siding with the eunuch faction; Hongxun was banished for altering the rescript; Zhou Daodeng and Qian Longxi were hounded from office; only Biao remained, and he submitted five memorials asking to retire. In the third month his request was granted. He died at home six years later. He was posthumously enfeoffed as Junior Tutor and given the posthumous title Wenjie.
5
𣚴 𣚴 𣚴 殿 𣚴
Li Guogan, whose style was Yuanzhi, came from Gaoyang. He passed the jinshi examination in the forty-first year of the Wanli reign. From Hanlin bachelor he rose through the ranks to Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent. In the seventh month of Tianqi 6 he was abruptly promoted to Minister of Rites and entered the Grand Secretariat. Only fourteen years after leaving the scholar's robe he reached the chief ministry—Wei Zhongxian had backed him because they were from the same district. Yet Guogan often spoke on the side of right. Liu Zhixuan impeached Zhang Guoji in order to shake the empress; Guogan said, "A son should not help his father make trouble for his mother—how much less when the parents are not estranged!" Zhang Guoji was thus spared punishment. When Censor Fang Zhenru and the Gaoyang magistrate Tang Shaoyao were imprisoned, he worked hard to save them both. At the beginning of Chongzhen, under the enthronement grace he was advanced to Left Pillar of the State, Junior Tutor concurrently Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent, Minister of Personnel, and Grand Secretary of the Central Peak Hall. The National University student Hu Huanyou impeached Guogan and others and stripped them of court dress; Guogan recommended their restoration, and contemporaries praised his magnanimity. In the fifth month of the first year he obtained leave to return home and recommended Han Kuang and Sun Chengzong as his successors. After his death he was posthumously enfeoffed as Grand Tutor and given the posthumous title Wenmin. The affairs of Zongdao and Jingchen are recorded in the biography of Huang Liji.
6
Zhou Daodeng came from Wujiang. He passed the jinshi examination in the twenty-sixth year of the Wanli reign. From Hanlin bachelor he rose to Junior Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent. Under Tianqi he served as Left Vice Minister of Rites and often took part in disputes. He went home on grounds of illness. In the autumn of the fifth year, when the court recommended candidates for Minister of Rites, Wei Zhongxian struck his name from the rolls. At the beginning of Chongzhen he entered the Grand Secretariat together with Li Biao and others. Daodeng had no learning; his answers at audience were crude and shallow, and people passed the story around as a joke. Censors Tian Shizhen, Liu Shizhen, Wang Daozhi, Wu Zhiren, and Ren Zanhua, and Supervising Secretary Yan Kedi jointly impeached him; all cases were sent to joint deliberation at court. Minister of Personnel Wang Yongguang and others reported that Daodeng had factionally shielded Grand Secretary Wang Zaijin, the licentiate Zhu Tongshi, and his fellow townsman Chen Yuding in examination appointments—all with verified facts—and he was dismissed and sent home. Five years later he died.
7
西使
Liu Hongxun, whose style was Mocheng, came from Changshan. His father Yixiang, a jinshi, served as Supervising Secretary in the Nanjing Bureau of Personnel. He pursued judgment on the late Grand Secretary Zhang Juzheng's case; the ruling faction resented him and he was sent out as Assistant Surveillance Commissioner of Longyou. He ended his career as Vice Commissioner of Shaanxi.
8
沿
In the forty-first year of Wanli, Hongxun passed the examination; from Hanlin bachelor he was appointed compiler. The Shenzong and Guangzong emperors died in succession, and edicts were promulgated in Korea. He had barely crossed the border when Liaoyang fell. Korea built two ocean-going ships for him, and he returned by sea. Along the way he took aboard refugees; the ships grew heavy and were wrecked. He waded through shallows into small boats and drifted for three days and nights, barely reaching Dengzhou to report his mission complete. He mourned his mother; when the mourning period ended he was promoted to Right Middle Gentleman-for-Instruction, then transferred to Left Tutor of the Heir Apparent, and returned home for his father's mourning. In the winter of Tianqi 6 he was recalled as Junior Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent; he offended Wei Zhongxian and was reduced to commoner status.
9
使滿 便
When the Chongzhen Emperor took the throne, Hongxun was appointed Minister of Rites and Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion, with a role in state affairs; an emissary was sent to summon him. He declined three times but was not allowed to refuse. In the fourth month of Chongzhen 1 he returned to court. At that time, although Zhongxian had fallen, his faction was still strong, and newly risen critics at the censorate attacked in groups. The chief ministers had once served with Zhongxian and dared not openly set the record straight. When Hongxun arrived he took charge resolutely, denouncing Yang Weiyuan, Li Hengmao, Yang Suoxiu, Tian Jingxin, Sun Zhixi, Ruan Dayue, Xu Shaoji, Zhang Na, Li Fan, Jia Jichun, Huo Weihua, and others—to widespread satisfaction. But Censors Yuan Hongxun, Shi Li, and Gao Jie had originally risen through Weiyuan's faction and thought to join forces to drive Hongxun out so their party could rest easy. Hongxun then argued that Suoxiu, Jichun, and Weiyuan had exposed traitors within and without, were meritorious and guiltless, and that the purge had wrongly begun with these three ministers; he also slandered Hongxun's mission to Korea, claiming he returned laden with sable and ginseng. Assistant Commander of the Embroidered-Uniform Guard Zhang Daojun also impeached Hongxun; Hongxun memorialized in his own defense. Supervising Secretary Yan Jizu said, "Hongxun was demoted and stripped of rank in the previous reign. In the Korea campaign his fleet was defeated, and he barely escaped with his life. I ask that Hongxun be summoned to direct service so we may jointly devise policies for pacification and defense. As for Hongxun's habit of seizing on any pretext to ruin others and Daojun's overstepping his station to disrupt government, unless they are severely punished there will be no end to it." The Emperor agreed. Supervising Secretary Deng Ying then fully exposed Hongxun's corruption, and also charged that Hongxun had bought his censor's post with a thousand taels of gold paid to Weiyuan. The Emperor was enraged and dismissed Hongxun from office pending investigation. Before long Gao Jie memorialized, charging that Hongxun had attacked the traitors Weiyuan, Suoxiu, Jichun, and Dayue while refusing to heed Sun Zhixi's tearful loyal counsel; he had wrongly advocated burning the Compendium of Essentials so that his private ally Sun Shenxing could be promoted. The Emperor rebuked him for reckless speech and suspended his salary. Shi Li again joined Jie in attacking him. Most of the censorate did not side with the two men, and both were dismissed.
10
In the seventh month, with the Sichuan rebels pacified, Hongxun was made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and entered the Wenyuan Pavilion. The Emperor frequently summoned court ministers for audience. Hongxun answered with unusual quickness, arguing that the people's hardship stemmed from officials' dereliction of duty, and urging the Emperor to keep men in office long enough to hold them accountable. Noting that Minister Bi Ziyan was skilled at managing taxation and Wang Zaijin at managing troops, he asked the Emperor to place greater trust in them. At first the Emperor was strongly inclined toward him. Soldiers at Shanhaiguan clamored over unpaid rations; the Emperor meant to blame the Ministry of Revenue, but Hongxun asked to disburse three hundred thousand taels from the treasury as an unexpected favor, and thereby lost the Emperor's favor.
11
稿 便殿 使 使 西
By the ninth month the affair of altering an imperial edict had arisen. By established precedent, the supervisor of the capital garrison did not command the patrol and arrest troops. The Earl of Huian, Zhang Qingzhen, supervised the capital garrison, but the edict contained the phrase "also commanding the patrol battalion," and Superintendent Zheng Qixin charged this as an encroachment on his authority. He ordered an investigation into how the Secretariat had been bribed to alter the edict, and imprisoned the drafter Tian Jiabi. Supervising Secretary Li Juesi said, "The draft was prepared by the Ministry of War, sent to the chief ministers for approval, and only then ordered copied by the Secretariat. Once copying was finished, it was reviewed again before being submitted. Both the Ministry of War and the chief ministers should be questioned." In the tenth month the Emperor held audience in the side hall and questioned the Grand Secretaries; all pleaded ignorance. The Emperor was enraged and ordered court ministers to impeach and report; Minister Bi Ziyan and the others also pleaded ignorance, and the Emperor grew still angrier. Supervising Secretary Zhang Dingyan and Censor Wang Daozhi also said there was evidence that Qingzhen had paid bribes, though they did not know who had instigated it. Censor Liu Yu said, "The instigator was Hongxun." Qingzhen said, "Altering the edict was a matter for the Secretariat; I truly had no foreknowledge. Besides, what profit could there be in adding command over a few patrol soldiers, that one would pay a heavy bribe?" The Emperor rebuked him sharply. On examining the Ministry of War memorial there were words in Hongxun's hand from the West Office; Jiabi also confessed to acting on Hongxun's orders, and the matter became impossible to explain away, while Vice Minister Zhang Fengxiang denounced him with especial force. Grand Secretaries Li Biao and Qian Longxi said Hongxun ought not to have done this and asked for further investigation. The Emperor said, "The matter is already fully exposed—why investigate further?" He pressed them to draft the rescript. Biao and the others hesitated and did not submit; Minister of Rites He Ruchong argued forcefully for Hongxun, but the Emperor's mind could not in the end be changed. They then drafted the rescript: Hongxun and Qingzhen were both stripped of office pending investigation. Before long Censor Tian Shizhen impeached Hongxun for appointing Tian Yang governor of Sichuan after accepting a bribe of two thousand taels; Supervising Secretary Yan Keshou impeached Vice Censor-in-Chief Jia Yuxiang for having been promoted through bribes paid to Hongxun. Hongxun was impeached repeatedly and memorialized again and again in his own defense, saying, "In the capital there is a sinister schemer surnamed Di who tricked Qingzhen out of a thousand taels and caused me to suffer punishment without guilt." The Emperor would not listen and referred the matter to court ministers to determine punishment.
12
祿
In the first month of the following year Minister of Personnel Wang Yongguang and others said, "Hongxun and Qingzhen are guilty beyond excuse, but the law has a provision for deliberating on the punishment of the eminent—we ask for leniency. Minister of War Wang Zaijin and Bureau Director Miao Sishun lack firm evidence of corruption and cannot be condemned on suspicion alone." The Emperor refused. Hongxun was banished to garrison duty at Daizhou; Zaijin and Sishun were both struck from the rolls; Qingzhen, as a hereditary minister, had his salary suspended for three years. Juesi, Dingyan, Daozhi, Yu, and Shizhen were each promoted one rank for their forthright speech.
13
退
While Hongxun served in government he was keen to take charge of affairs. When the Emperor disapproved of something, he would withdraw and say, "After all, the sovereign is still a young and emerging ruler." When the Emperor heard this he deeply resented it and wished to have him executed. Only through the chief ministers' forceful intercession was the punishment somewhat lightened. In the fifth month of the seventh year he died in exile. Under the Prince of Fu his office was restored.
14
Qian Longxi, courtesy name Zhiwen, was a native of Huating in Songjiang. He passed the metropolitan examination in Wanli 35. From Hanlin Bachelor he was appointed Compiler and was repeatedly promoted to Junior Mentor. In Tianqi 4 he was promoted to Vice Minister of Rites and assisted in managing the Household of the Heir Apparent. The following year he was transferred to Vice Minister of Personnel at Nanjing. He offended Wei Zhongxian and was struck from the rolls.
15
𣚴 仿
When Emperor Zhuanglie ascended the throne, because Grand Secretaries Huang Liji, Shi Fenglai, Zhang Ruitu, and Li Guo'an had all been men used by Zhongxian and could not be relied on, he ordered court ministers to recommend candidates and ten names were submitted. The Emperor followed the ancient lot-drawing rite: names were stored in a golden urn; after burning incense and bowing reverently he drew them in order—Longxi came first, then Li Biao, Lai Zongdao, and Yang Jingchen. The chief ministers, citing the many troubles in the realm, asked that one or two more be added; Zhou Daodeng and Liu Hongxun were also chosen, and all were appointed Ministers of Rites and Grand Secretaries of the Eastern Pavilion. In the sixth month of the following year Longxi entered court; Liji and the other four had all been dismissed earlier, and Zongdao and Jingchen also left that same month. Biao became chief minister; Longxi and Hongxun worked together in governing, and court affairs grew somewhat clearer. Soon, with the Sichuan rebels pacified, he was made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and transferred to the Wenyuan Pavilion.
16
使 歿
The Emperor liked to investigate border affairs and frequently sent banner guards as spies. Longxi said, "The old prohibition applied only within and around the capital; if men are sent far away, I fear they will be hard to trust." Sea bandits attacked Zhongzuo Station; Regional Commander Yu Zigao abandoned the city and fled—a crime deserving execution. The Emperor wished also to punish Governor Zhu Yifeng. Longxi said, "Yifeng's post was far away; he cannot be compared with one who abandoned the city—dismissal from office is enough to answer for the fault." When Prince Rui received his fief at Hanzhong, he requested to consume Sichuan salt. Longxi said, "Hanzhong consumes Jin salt, yet Prince Rui alone would use Sichuan salt—I fear scoundrels would trade on his name to smuggle salt privately, and no one would dare investigate." By precedent, when compiling the Veritable Records, Imperial University students were dispatched to gather materials throughout the realm; Longxi said, "What the Veritable Records require is found in the Gazette and in memorials from the various offices—sending envoys is useless and only creates disturbance; this should be stopped." The native chieftain An Xiaoliang of Wusa died; his wife remarried An Bian, chieftain of Zhanyi, who wished to take Wusa as well; the ministry deliberated and was about to approve. Longxi said, "Xiaoliang had a son, Qi Jue—install Qi Jue to recover Wusa; preserving what was endangered and continuing what was broken off is in accord with principle. An Bian is licentious and disorderly and must not be indulged." The Emperor fully agreed. The following year, because grain-transport ships had violated prohibitions and passed through customs, the Emperor wished to restore the post of Grand Coordinator of Grain Transport. Longxi said, "This office was abolished long ago and would now be restored—it is fitting to gather court ministers to discuss its advantages and disadvantages." The matter was dropped in the end. At court they debated eliminating redundant offices; the Emperor said educational officials were especially redundant. Longxi said, "Educational posts were formerly filled from annual tribute students; recently, because licentiates begged favors and were selected as tribute students, many took vacancies reserved for compilation work, and annual tribute students accumulated to more than twenty-six hundred—white-haired men dying in office, truly pitiable. Moreover, in establishing these offices our forefathers were somewhat lenient because teachers who cultivate scholars require maturity." The Emperor also accepted this. Censors Zou Yuzuo, Han Yiliang, Zhang Yunru, and Liu Silai were punished, and he interceded for them all.
17
退
After Censors Gao Jie and Shi Li were dismissed, Wang Yongguang worked hard to bring them back, but Longxi largely blocked them, and the two men deeply resented him. In settling the case of the traitors, Longxi had presided over half of it, and the villainous faction hated him to the marrow. When Yuan Chonghuan killed Mao Wenlong, his report said, "Chief Minister Longxi lingered at my residence over this matter." He then submitted a follow-up memorial on handling the aftermath, saying, "The Grand Secretaries and the minister of war discussed back and forth, and I was thereby able to carry out the orders without error." At the time Wenlong held troops and acted on his own authority, with a reputation for arrogance; that Chonghuan removed him at a stroke ought not to have been treated as a crime by the throne. That winter, in the twelfth month, the Great Qing army pressed close to the capital. The Emperor was enraged that Chonghuan had not fought vigorously and had him arrested and imprisoned; by then Jie and Li had already been brought back by Yongguang. Jie then memorialized, charging that colluding with the enemy and killing a general were Longxi's crimes, and also saying that Zu Dashou's army had collapsed and fled east because Longxi had provoked it. The Emperor, considering Longxi loyal and cautious, warned against pressing the charges too far. Longxi memorialized in his defense, saying, "When Chonghuan had audience, I saw that his appearance was poor and withdrew, telling a colleague, 'This man may not be up to the task. When Chonghuan boasted that he would recover Liaodong within five years, I went to ask his strategy; Chonghuan said, 'Recovery should begin from the Eastern Jiang. If Wenlong can be used, use him; if not, remove him—easily done. When Chonghuan suddenly executed Wenlong, his memorial contained the phrase 'I lingered. I considered Wenlong's merits and faults, which everyone at court knew, and therefore set the matter aside. How then can I be convicted of conspiracy on the strength of Chonghuan's boastful words?' He also rebutted the false charge that he had provoked Dashou, and asked to be dismissed. The Emperor reassured him, and Longxi at once returned to office. Jie attacked again in a further memorial, and the Emperor was substantially swayed. Longxi memorialized in his defense once more, then pleaded illness and was sent home. Military crises were pressing on all sides, and there was no time to bring Chonghuan's case to a conclusion.
18
使 西
In the eighth month of the third year, Shi Fu memorialized again: "Longxi backed Chonghuan's killing of the general that brought disaster to the army, promoted peace negotiations with the enemy, and lent credence to the boast that Liaodong would be recovered within five years. In betraying the realm and deceiving the throne, his crimes brooked no mercy. After Longxi left the capital, he took the tens of thousands in heavy bribes Chonghuan had given him, parked them with in-laws, maneuvered craftily behind the scenes, and saw to it that justice was not done." The Emperor was enraged and ordered the judicial officials to close the case within five days. Thereupon Liu Qiao of the Embroidered Uniform Guard submitted the record of Chonghuan's case. The Emperor summoned the ministers to the Platform and condemned Chonghuan to death. He charged Longxi with secretly cultivating ties to border commanders and covering up what should have been exposed, and ordered the court to deliberate his sentence. That day the ministers assembled in the inner yamen and judged: "Although Longxi opened the way for the general's execution, both letters contain the phrase 'handle with caution'—the intent was not to authorize murder at will. Killing Wenlong was Chonghuan's overreach. As for negotiating peace, the initiative came from Chonghuan; Longxi first answered 'weigh the matter carefully,' then 'the Son of Heaven is divinely martial—peace talks are out of the question.' Yet on matters of war and state, to discuss them in private correspondence without memorializing to expose the wrongdoing—what guilt could he escape?" The Emperor then sent envoys to arrest him. Arrested and brought in during the twelfth month, he was cast into prison. He memorialized again in his defense, submitting Chonghuan's original letters and his own replies in full, but the Emperor would not look into them. Petty men who had built their reputations on treason prosecutions now met to plot, naming Chonghuan the ringleader of rebellion and Longxi and his associates accomplices. They proposed an additional treason case to offset it. Once the plot was fixed, they meant to launch it through the Ministry of War, but Minister Liang Tingdong, fearing the Emperor's sharp judgment, did not dare take responsibility and let the matter drop. They then voted for Longxi's execution and, following the precedent of Xia Yan, prepared the West Market at the Eastern Depot for his death. The Emperor judged that Longxi had no part in treason and ordered him held indefinitely.
19
調
In the first month of the fourth year, Huang Daozhou, Right Middle Attendant, memorialized that Longxi did not deserve the death penalty. Defying the throne, he was demoted and posted away—yet the Emperor's anger toward Longxi slowly abated. In the fifth month of summer a great drought struck; Minister of Justice Hu Yingtai and others pleaded for Longxi's pardon, and Supervising Secretary Liu Silai added his voice; the throne ordered a rehearing. Longxi was released from prison and banished to serve at Dinghai garrison. Through twelve years of exile he twice missed general amnesties. His son offered grain to redeem his sentence, but Zhou Yanru had again taken power and blocked it. Under the Prince of Fu he was restored to office and sent home. He died soon after, at sixty-eight.
20
殿 西
Qian Shisheng, styled Yizhi, was from Jiashan. He topped the palace examination in the forty-fourth year of Wanli and was appointed Hanlin Compiler. Early in the Tianqi reign he retired to care for his mother. Later promoted to Left Middle Assistant, he declined to serve. When Zhao Nanxing of Gaoyi and his townsman Wei Dazhong fell victim to the eunuch faction, and when his Jiangxi classmate Wan Zuan was beaten to death in pursuit of restitution, he threw himself into their defense at the cost of his fortune—and won the Donglin faction's esteem.
21
The Emperor ruled with harsh exactitude; Wen Tiren abetted him with pitiless severity, and the court was in an uproar. Shisheng wrote the "Four Admonitions" and submitted them: rule the people with magnanimity, lead subordinates with restraint, keep the heart uncluttered, and govern with even hand. His words struck deep at the maladies of the age. The Emperor acknowledged the memorial graciously on paper but was far from pleased.
22
Before long the military licentiate Li Jin proposed registering Jiangnan's wealthy households, forcing them to declare themselves and pay up, and confiscating their property by name and deed. Shisheng loathed the proposal and drafted a rescript referring Li to the Ministry of Justice for interrogation; the Emperor refused, and his colleague Wen Tiren softened the draft. Shisheng said, "This is the seed of rebellion. I must fight it with my office." He memorialized: "Since Chen Qixin's memorializing won him a place in the inner cabinet, men who seize any pretext to climb have been many of late, but none so reckless as Jin. He claims that among gentry and magnates the greatest hold millions, the middling hundreds of thousands, and households worth ten thousand taels are beyond counting. I do not know what region he has in mind. In Jiangnan alone, if one reckons wealth by land holdings, seven or eight in ten wealthy families count their fortunes in the hundreds, three or four in ten in the thousands, and only one or two in a thousand reach ten thousand. If this is true of Jiangnan, what of the other provinces? Moreover, wealthy families in the counties are the very source of livelihood for the poor. In flood or drought, magistrates call on them for grain and cash to sell at fair rates and feed the hungry; at the first alarm of raiders, they are summoned to help man the walls. The wealthy have never ceased to serve the realm. The Rites of Zhou list twelve famine policies, and protecting the wealthy comes first. To blame war and famine on the rich, strip them bare, seize their wealth and confiscate their estates—measures Qin Shihuang would not have imposed on Ba Qing, nor Han Wudi on Bu Shi—is this what we propose for an age of enlightened rule? Shaanxi, Shanxi, Huguang, and Henan have known no peace; only a few prefectures of Jiangnan remain calm. Let this proposal gain a hearing and ruffians and desperadoes will flock to make war on the wealthy—not long before the whole empire turns to brigandage without end. One might suspect these men are the agents of the bandits themselves, peddling reckless schemes to shake public confidence—is this not far more than mere careerism!" By the time the memorial arrived, Jin had already been sent to the judicial offices for interrogation. The Emperor replied, "If you mean to burnish your reputation, your last memorial was fame enough—there is no need for such zeal. The "previous memorial" meant the "Four Admonitions." Shisheng, shaken, confessed fault and asked to retire; the Emperor granted his request at once.
23
When Shisheng first joined the Grand Secretariat, Tiren had been a strong backer. Tiren promoted Xie Sheng and Tang Shiji, and Shisheng backed them both. When Wen Zhenmeng was forced out, Shisheng could not shield him, and critics held it against him. Only now did he leave office for speaking plain truth to power.
24
His brother Shijin, a jinshi under Wanli, was appointed Principal Secretary in the Ministry of Justice. Reviewing cases in the capital region, he reversed convictions for hundreds upon hundreds. Under Chongzhen he rose from Right Commissioner of Shandong to Grand Coordinator of Yunnan. He built six fortifications at Shizong and Xinhua, dredged the Jin Zhen, Baisha, and other rivers, and quelled rebellions among the native chieftains of the Cen and Nong clans, earning substantial credit. Soon Administrative Assistant Wu Kunhua accused him of bribery; Tiren drafted a harsh edict at once and told his colleague Lin Qian to keep silent, planning to use the brother to destroy the elder Shisheng. By the time the order went out, Shijin was already dead, and the affair ended there. Shisheng died seven years after the dynastic collapse.
25
Cheng Jiming, styled Jingzhi, was from Daming; later, to avoid the taboo name of the Xuanzong Emperor, he was known by his style. He took his jinshi degree in the thirty-fifth year of Wanli. Made a Hanlin probationer, he served as Lecturer in the Directorate of Education and acting Vice Director of the Imperial Academy. In Tianqi's first year he memorialized for an imperial academy visit without clearing it with the chief ministers first; the ruling cabinet took offense, sent him back to his original post in the bureau, and he retired. He was soon recalled as Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. He rose to Right Vice Minister of Rites and Companion to the Heir Apparent, then was shifted to head the Nanjing Hanlin Academy. In the sixth year Wei Zhongxian, noting that Jiming had studied under the same teacher as Yang Lian, stripped him of office and sent him home.
26
仿 殿
In Chongzhen's first year he was recalled as Left Vice Minister of Personnel. The following tenth month, with the capital under martial law, Jiming urged recall of former Grand Secretary Sun Chengzong, an end to empty quarrels, and new military strategist posts as in the Jiajing reign; the Emperor approved all. A month later he was made Minister of Rites and Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion, entering the cabinet as chief minister. Hanlin probationer Jin Sheng recommended the monk Shen Fu for command. The Emperor had Jiming inspect his troops; Jiming declared them utterly useless, and they were indeed routed at the first engagement. Yuan Chonghuan and Zu Dashou arrived to defend the capital; summoned to the Platform, Chonghuan was handed to the legal officers while Dashou shook at his side. Jiming alone kowtowed twice for caution. The Emperor said, "Caution is only foot-dragging—what good does it do?" Jiming kowtowed again. "The enemy is at the gates—this is not like other times." The Emperor would not heed him. Dashou reached his command and at once led his troops in a rout to the east; the Emperor was deeply alarmed. Jiming said, "Have Chonghuan write him a personal letter of summons—he will come back." Military affairs were desperate; Jiming's repeated proposals were all approved and implemented. During the martial-law crisis, called to audience in the Wenhua Hall, the Emperor declared that law and discipline had collapsed and must be restored by force. Jiming said, "Good government trims excess. It is like untangling silk—find the thread and pull gently; sudden wholesale changes only make the knot worse. The Emperor said, "When men grow slack, whip them to attention—what 'wholesale changes' do you mean?" Thereafter Wen Tiren steered the Emperor toward ever-harsher rule, and the empire slid into chaos.
27
In the second month of the third year, Li Fengshen of the Ministry of Works impeached Jiming for seeking to spare Yuan Chonghuan and therefore pleading for caution. Jiming offered to resign; the Emperor demoted Fengshen one rank in Jiming's defense. When Han Kuang and Li Biao left in turn, Jiming became chief Grand Secretary, serving alongside Zhou Yanru, He Ruchong, and Qian Xiangkun. Credited for the recovery of Yongping, he was made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and promoted to Grand Secretary of the Wenyuan Pavilion. By the sixth month Wen Tiren and Wu Zongda had joined the cabinet; Yanru and Tiren, the Emperor's favorites, worked together to undermine Jiming, who could no longer hold his ground. While Chonghuan's sentence was being debated, Jiming, laid up with a foot ailment, did not attend cabinet duty. Zhang Daojun of the Embroidered Uniform Guard impeached him for dereliction of duty, and Lu Chengyuan of the Ministry of Works added a memorial in turn. Jiming submitted a memorial in his defense: "Chengyuan claims I headed court nomination twice, both times because Han Kuang and his faction meant to exploit the process to save Chonghuan. At the time of those nominations Chonghuan was still in imperial favor; who could have foreseen his later downfall or schemed beforehand to rescue him? His story echoes Fengshen and Daojun, and they will not rest until I am removed; I beg leave to retire." The Emperor reassured him and kept him in office. He eventually submitted three resignations and left office.
28
調
Jiming was generous and even-tempered, always keeping sight of the larger picture. Earlier, with the four lost cities still unrestored, Minister of War Liang Tingdong resented overall commander Ma Shilong and planned to replace him to undermine Grand Secretary Sun Chengzong. Jiming worked hard to mediate, and Shilong finally retook Zunhua and Yongping. When Ministers Zhang Fengxiang, Qiao Yunsheng, and Han Jisi were sent before the courts in succession, he pleaded their cases. Vice Censor-in-Chief Yi Yingchang was committed to the imperial prison, but at Jiming's urging his case was moved to the regular courts. Censor Li Changchun and Supervising Secretary Du Qifang were charged in a private-correspondence case and faced severe penalties. Jiming fought to save them in vain, then knelt at the Huaji Gate from dawn, saying, "Our ancestors' law required three reviews even for genuine capital offenses—how can the imperial prison condemn men to death after a single hearing?" He remained kneeling from morning until evening. The Emperor relented, and they were banished instead. Fengshen had first impeached Jiming; later he himself was imprisoned after a cannon accident and sentenced to exile. The Emperor still thought that too lenient, but at Jiming's urging the proposed sentence stood. He served as chief minister for only a few months; the Emperor meant to entrust power to Yanru, and Yanru's faction forced him out. In the eighth year he died at home. He was posthumously made Junior Guardian with the title Wenmu.
29
He Ruchong, styled Kanghou, was from Tongcheng. His father Si'ao served as magistrate of Qixia County and was beloved by the people. Ruchong took his jinshi in Wanli 26, rose from Hanlin probationer to Chancellor of the Imperial Academy. Under Tianqi he served as Right Vice Minister of Rites and helped administer the Heir Apparent's household. In the first month of the fifth year, when the Left Vice Minister was nominated at court, Wei Guangwei charged that Ruchong was on friendly terms with his fellow townsman Zuo Guangdou; Ruchong was stripped of office and sent home.
30
殿
In Chongzhen's first year he was recalled as Right Vice Minister of Personnel. Before he even arrived, he was appointed Minister of Rites. Imperial clansmen were required by precedent to seek court permission for marriages and the naming of children. Poor clansmen were stalled by the ministry; from late Wanli onward petitions piled up by the thousand. Some grew old unable to marry, others died unnamed. At Ruchong's urging, more than six hundred impoverished clansmen were allowed to marry. Grand Secretary Liu Hongxun provoked the Emperor's wrath over unauthorized edicts; Ruchong argued his case forcefully, and Liu escaped execution and was banished to the border. The following winter, with the capital under martial law, enterprising townsfolk proposed raising private funds and crowds to aid the army; many at court applauded the idea. Ruchong strongly warned that such schemes were unpredictable and dangerous, and would surely spark internal unrest. The Emperor summoned him and questioned him; he gave the same answer. The Emperor showed him a slip of intercepted intelligence that bore out Ruchong's warning, and from then on Ruchong won the Emperor's confidence. In the twelfth month he was appointed, along with Zhou Yanru and Qian Xiangkun, Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion while retaining his existing posts, and entered the cabinet. When the Emperor sought to exterminate Yuan Chonghuan's entire clan, Ruchong's appeal spared more than three hundred lives. He was successively made Junior Guardian, Minister of Revenue, and Grand Secretary of the Wuying Hall.
31
In the spring of the fourth year he assisted Yanru in overseeing the metropolitan examination. Once the examination was done, he immediately sought retirement; only after nine memorials was he allowed to leave. Taking leave of the throne, he expounded the Way of earnestly upholding the Ming dynasty. After returning home he wrote again, urging the Emperor to read the Comprehensive Mirror regularly and weigh loyalty against treachery across history; his words were urgent and sincere. In the sixth year Yanru left office, and Tiren was slated to become chief minister. Yanru, resenting Tiren for forcing him out, plotted to recall Ruchong to counter him; Ruchong, afraid of Tiren, declined six times, and Tiren became chief minister.
32
退
Ruchong was deeply filial and devoted to his kin. His mother lived to ninety, and he cared for her with undiminished devotion. Gentle and uncontentious, reluctant to seek office yet quick to leave it, he was especially admired by his contemporaries. He died in the fourteenth year. Under the Prince of Fu he was posthumously made Grand Guardian with the title Wenduan.
33
使
His elder brother Rushen passed the jinshi examination in the same year as Ruchong. He served as a director in the Ministry of Revenue, overseeing grain supplies in Liaodong. Known for his integrity, the troops asked that he be kept on for another two years. He ended his career as Right Provincial Commissioner of Zhejiang.
34
使
Qian Xiangkun, styled Hongzai, was from Kuaiji. He took his jinshi degree in the twenty-ninth year of Wanli. Made a Hanlin probationer, he served as Reviser, rose to Preceptor, and became Junior Tutor. At the beginning of the Taichang reign he was made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and lectured before the throne. After lecturing he saw the eunuch Wang An consulting with the chief ministers and immediately withdrew. Wang An sent someone to fetch him, but he steadfastly refused to join them. Under Tianqi a supervising secretary criticized imperial silk production in terms that offended senior eunuchs; the Emperor ordered him beaten, and the Grand Secretaries could not intervene. Xiangkun asked Ye Xianggao to raise the matter at the lecture hall; the beating was canceled. The cangue punishment had lately been imposed with terrible severity; Xiangkun appealed to the Emperor and secured the release of many prisoners. He was promoted again to Right Vice Minister of Rites and Companion to the Heir Apparent.
35
In the seventh month of the fourth year Ye Xianggao resigned. Censor Huang Gongfu, fearing Xiangkun would dominate the government, urged that Ye Xianggao be retained and attacked Xiangkun vigorously. Xiangkun resigned in response. In the sixth year he was nominated Minister of Rites at Nanjing. A follower of Wei Zhongxian denounced him as an ally of Miao Changqi, and he was stripped of office and sent home.
36
殿
In Chongzhen's first year he was recalled as Minister of Rites and helped administer the Heir Apparent's household. The following winter, when enemy troops threatened the capital, he submitted three plans for defense. Ordered to the ramparts to hold a sector of the wall, he kept at his post through fierce cold without flagging. The Emperor took note and appointed him Grand Secretary alongside He Ruchong. The following year Wen Tiren joined the cabinet; Xiangkun, his former student, deferentially ranked below him. He was successively made Junior Guardian and promoted to the Wuying Hall. As a Hanlin scholar Xiangkun, together with Longxi, Qianyi, and Shisheng, enjoyed great public esteem and was counted among the "Four Qians." When Tiren became chief minister, Xiangkun showed no sign of currying favor.
37
退
In the fourth year Censor Shui Jiayun repeatedly impeached Minister of War Liang Tingdong, who defended himself by memorial without waiting for the throne's directive. Tingdong had been Xiangkun's protégé; Jiayun suspected Xiangkun had tipped him off and turned his attack on Xiangkun. Yanru hated Tingdong for having once exposed corruption among his clients, and extended that hatred to Xiangkun. Xiangkun submitted five sick-leave memorials and resigned; Tingdong was dismissed. Supervising Secretaries Wu Zhiyu and Fu Chaoyou argued that Xiangkun, who was slow to seek office and quick to leave it, should not be punished for a protégé's conduct; the Emperor would not listen. After ten years at home he died without ever having been ill. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian with the title Wenzhen, and one son received the hereditary privilege of Secretariat Drafter.
38
西
Xu Guangqi, styled Zixian, was from Shanghai. He placed first in the provincial exams in Wanli 25 and took his jinshi seven years later. After serving as a Hanlin probationer he rose to Supporter in the Heir Apparent's household. He studied astronomy, calendrical science, and firearms with the Westerner Matteo Ricci and mastered Ricci's learning. He went on to study military affairs, garrison agriculture, salt administration, hydraulic works, and related subjects in depth.
39
When Yang Hao lost his armies on four fronts, the capital was convulsed with alarm. He repeatedly petitioned to train troops and serve in person; the Wanli Emperor was impressed and abruptly promoted him to Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and concurrent censor of the Henan circuit. He drilled troops at Tongzhou and submitted ten reform proposals. Liaodong was in crisis, and the court could not grant what he asked. Guangqi protested by memorial, and the court finally granted him some militia arms and equipment.
40
西
Before long the Tianqi Emperor ascended the throne. Unable to carry out his plans, Guangqi asked that his post be abolished, but the Emperor refused. He soon retired on grounds of illness. After Liaoyang fell he was recalled to office. Back at court, he strongly urged casting large numbers of Western-style cannons for city defense. The Emperor approved the proposal. While adoption was under discussion, Guangqi clashed with Minister of War Cui Jingrong; Censor Qiu Zhaolin impeached him, and he retired again on grounds of illness. In Tianqi 3 he was restored to his former post and soon promoted to Right Vice Minister of Rites. In the fifth year a follower of Wei Zhongxian named Zhi Ting impeached him, and he was stripped of office and sent home.
41
西
Recalled in Chongzhen's first year, he again pressed his plan for training troops. Before long he was put in charge of the ministry as Left Vice Minister. Worried about insufficient state revenue, the Emperor ordered court officials to propose sound policies on military farming and the salt monopoly. Guangqi argued that military colonies depended on reclaiming wasteland, and salt policy on strictly prohibiting illicit trade. The Emperor praised his advice and adopted it, elevating him to Minister of Rites. Around this time a predicted solar eclipse failed to match observation, and the Emperor wanted to punish the officials of the Astronomic Bureau. Guangqi said, "The Bureau's calculations follow Guo Shoujing's methods. Even in Yuan times eclipses sometimes failed to appear when predicted; even Guo Shoujing's system had such errors—there is nothing surprising in the Bureau's mistake. I have heard that calendars inevitably drift with time; they should be revised promptly. The Emperor agreed and ordered the Westerners Long Hua Min, Deng Yuhan, and Luo Yagu to work out a new calendar, with Guangqi overseeing the project.
42
In the first month of spring in the fourth year, Guangqi submitted eight works: one juan of A Calendrical Guide to Solar Motion; two of Essential Notes on Heavenly Measurement; two of The Great Survey; two of Tables of Solar Motion; six of Tables of the Eight Lines for Circle Division; seven of Ascension along the Yellow Path; one of Tables of Ecliptic and Equatorial Distances; and one of Tables of General Ratios. That winter, on the first day of the tenth month (xinchou), a solar eclipse occurred, and he submitted four additional treatises on observation and calculation. His exposition of time difference and parallax was the most thorough and precise of all.
43
In the fifth month of the fifth year he was made Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion while retaining his ministry post, entered the inner councils, and was appointed at the same time as Zheng Yiwei. He was soon further appointed Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and promoted to the Wenyuan Pavilion. Guangqi had long been known for practical statesmanship and a desire to serve the realm. By the time he wielded real influence he was already old; with Zhou Yanru and Wen Tiren in control, he was unable to put forward any lasting reforms. He died the following tenth month. He was posthumously honored as Junior Guardian.
44
Zheng Yiwei, styled Ziqi, was a native of Shangrao. He passed the jinshi examination in Wanli 29. Made a Hanlin bachelor, he was appointed reviser and rose step by step to Junior Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent. In Taichang 1 he was Right Vice Minister of Rites. In Tianqi 1, when the late Emperor Guangzong was installed in the ancestral temple, Emperor Xianzong was to be removed to make room. Vice Director Hong Wenheng of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices argued that Emperor Ruizong ought not remain in the temple and proposed shifting his worship to Yuzhi Palace; Yiwei blocked the proposal and the matter ended—but commentators ultimately sided with Wenheng. He was soon made Left Vice Minister and put in charge of the Household of the Heir Apparent. In the fourth year his blunt conduct at the imperial lectures brought him into conflict with the eunuch faction; he submitted a memorial asking to retire. In Chongzhen 2 he was recalled and appointed Minister of Rites. Before long he was made grand secretary alongside Guangqi; he declined twice, but the Emperor would not accept. Yiwei was fastidious and morally self-disciplined; he never forgot a book once read; his essays were learned and deep—but drafting imperial rescripts was not his forte. He once said, "I am rich in ten thousand volumes but helpless before a few lines of draft—and so the younger officials look down on me. In one memorial he misread the phrase "how much more so" (hekuang) as someone's name and drafted a rescript ordering that person brought in for questioning; only when the Emperor sent it back for revision did he realize his mistake. From then on the literary Hanlin were held lightly by the Emperor; an edict followed that academy officials must first serve as local magistrates, and the Grand Secretariat no longer drew exclusively from the Hanlin. Yiwei repeatedly asked to retire, but was refused each time. He died in office the following sixth month and was posthumously honored as Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. A censor noted that Guangqi and Yiwei had died in quick succession with empty purses on the day their coffins were sealed, and asked that they be handsomely honored so as to shame the corrupt. The Emperor agreed, posthumously naming Guangqi Wendīng and Yiwei Wenkè.
45
殿 簿
Two years later Lin Qian of Tong'an was made grand secretary, but died within half a year. Reports of his integrity earned him the posthumous title Wenmu. Qian, styled Shifu, placed third in the palace examination of Wanli 44 and was appointed a compiler. During the Tianqi reign he served as Vice Director of the Imperial Academy. An academy student named Lu Wanling proposed building a shrine to Wei Zhongxian beside the Imperial Academy, drew up a subscription register, and tried to bully Qian into leading the contributions. Qian scratched out the entry, that very evening hung up his official cap at the Gathering Stars Gate and went straight home; Zhongxian forged an edict striking him from the rolls. At the start of the Chongzhen reign he was recalled as Junior Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent. In the ninth year he entered the Grand Secretariat from the post of Vice Minister of Rites and was known for diligence, sincerity, and integrity.
46
Long afterward the Emperor remembered Guangqi's erudition and retentive mind and asked his family for his surviving manuscripts. His son Ji came to court to give thanks and presented the sixty-juan Complete Treatise on Agriculture. The court ordered the work published, further posthumously honored Guangqi as Grand Guardian, and appointed his grandson a Secretariat Drafter.
47
殿
Wen Zhenmeng, styled Wenqi, was from Wuxian and was the great-grandson of the celebrated artist Wen Zhengming. His grandfather Peng had been a Doctor of the Imperial Academy; his father Yuanfa had served as Vice Prefect of Weihui—both men were noted for their character. Zhenmeng passed the provincial examination in the Spring and Autumn Annals while still young and sat the metropolitan examination ten times. At last in Tianqi 2 he came in first in the palace examination and was appointed Senior Compiler.
48
使 退 調 調
By then Wei Zhongxian was steadily amassing power, the outer court falling in line, and senior ministers were being driven out one after another. Indignant, Zhenmeng that winter submitted his Memorial on Diligent Rule and Lecturing, writing, "The realm is beset on every side; year after year territory is lost and cities fall, armies are wiped out and commanders killed—this is when every official, high and low, must brace himself as if sleeping on brushwood and tasting gall. Yet if we go on dawdling and papering things over, the empire our ancestors built will erode day by day and month by month. Unless Your Majesty boldly breaks with routine and fires the hearts of the able, there is no telling where the realm will end up. Your Majesty holds court at dawn through every season—no one can call you idle. Yet when the Court of State Ceremonial leads memorials forward and officials kneel and rise in turn, it is no more than puppets treading a stage. I ask that we restore the ancestral practice of calling the six ministries and six censorial offices in turn to report business, impeach, and petition, so that Your Majesty and the grand secretaries may decide matters face to face. Your wisdom would grow sharper by the day, and every official would find renewed purpose. If all that is required is to submit a slip, kneel long, murmur assent, and bow toward the throne, what need is there for officials bearing mandarin-duck insignia, unicorn badges, jade pendants, and gold belts? The daily classics lectures are held on schedule and learning is not neglected—yet the lecturing officials merely recite fine phrases like village schoolmasters droning through a text. In the days of our forefathers emperor and minister spoke as freely as father and son within a household. They consulted on weighty matters of war and state and on hidden troubles among the people; nothing escaped view, fraud had nowhere to hide, and even those closest to the throne could not mislead him. If the throne is remote as a god, courtesies are exchanged in silence, and the classics are recited as empty ritual, what purpose is served by scholars holding their tablets, robes falling in order, books spread open, and brushes tucked in their caps? Since Your Majesty is estranged from his ministers and day and night sees only palace eunuchs, how can you grasp the emperor's wider vision? Peril mounts like mountains and seas, yet when a grand secretary steps in, no one can break the habit of complacency; Disaster spreads like the siege of Qian, yet provincial governors sit idle and no stern punishment follows. Recent conduct has been especially alarming. Zou Yuanbiao has left office, Feng Congwu has shut his door, and even the chief grand secretary and chief minister have one after another asked to resign. The state is emptied so private factions may build their nests—almost as if filth were being poured into the stream; Abusing the Learning of the Way to purge worthy men—a prohibition worse than the "False Learning" purge of old. The late Tang and Song dynasties stand as warnings before us. When the memorial arrived, Zhongxian kept it from the Emperor and did not present it at once. Waiting until the Emperor was watching a play, he seized on the phrase "puppets taking the stage," claiming Zhenmeng had compared the Emperor to wooden dolls and saying he must die to give the realm an example; the Emperor nodded. One day, as the lecture session ended, Zhongxian relayed an order that Zhenmeng be beaten eighty strokes in court. Chief Grand Secretary Ye Xianggao was on leave, but Secondary Grand Secretary Han Kuang protested fiercely. At the same time a memorial from Hanlin bachelor Zheng Man reached the throne; an inner rescript demoted both men and transferred them to posts outside the capital. Censors petitioned one after another on their behalf, but the Emperor would not listen. Zhenmeng likewise refused his assignment and went home. That winter in the sixth year the Taicang jinshi Gu Tongyin and student Sun Wenchi were seized by the city patrol for poems lamenting Xiong Tingbi's fate. Censor Men Kexin denounced the poems as seditious talk; the case implicated Zhenmeng, and he was stripped of rank along with Compiler Chen Renxi and Bachelor Zheng Man.
49
In Chongzhen 1 he was recalled as Lecturer-in-Waiting. He was made Left Messenger and served as a daily lecturer at court. In the spring of the third year the ministers who had settled Wei Zhongxian's treason case were leaving office one after another; survivors of Zhongxian's faction such as Wang Yongguang were daily seizing chances for revenge, and Zhenmeng memorialized against them. The Emperor was still favoring Yongguang, and no answer came. Zhenmeng was soon promoted to Left Instructor, put in charge of the Classics Bureau, and continued lecturing as before. In the fifth month he memorialized again: "Petty men are conspiring to use frontier appointments to reopen the treason cases. The realm has no shortage of decent men who lack talent and blunder—but it has no petty men who truly serve the state in loyalty. Now there is Lu Chunru—shameless his whole life, who had a celebrated worthy brutally killed—and he even seeks rehabilitation through court connections. Yongguang, as senior among the six ministers, usurped authority at every turn, reversing merit and dismissal as he pleased—arrogant in all things and ruthless in support, cunning in every scheme yet cloaking himself in plain virtue, using the annual review to upend ancestral practice and the civil-service examinations to shut out men of merit. The whole court stood in dread and no one dared speak out. When every official parrots the same line, what blessing is that for the state? The Emperor ordered him to name names and submit another memorial with specifics. Zhenmeng replied, "The man who had the worthy killed was the late Director Zhou Shunchang of the Ministry of Personnel. The annual review case was the suppression of Chief Supervising Secretary Chen Liangxun of the Personnel Office; the examination case was the rejection of Secretariat Drafters Chen Shiji and Pan Yougong. Mortified, Yongguang secretly colluded with the senior eunuch Wang Yongzuo, claiming Shiji had been a protégé of Yao Ximeng—and Zhenmeng was Ximeng's uncle. The Emperor grew suspicious. Yongguang's defense received a soothing imperial reply, while Zhenmeng was rebuked for reckless accusations. Still, the petty faction's plan to reopen the treason cases was stopped in its tracks.
50
使 便
At the lecture sessions Zhenmeng was stern and upright above all others. When several senior ministers were being arrested one after another, Zhenmeng lectured on the Analects passage "If the ruler treats his ministers with propriety," admonishing the Emperor again and again by indirection; the Emperor promptly ordered Ministers Qiao Yunsheng and Vice Minister Hu Shishang released from prison. Once, as the Emperor rested his foot on his knee, Zhenmeng was lecturing on the Songs of the Five Sons and came to the line, "Those who stand above others—how can they fail to be reverent?" He glanced at the Emperor's foot; the Emperor at once hid it in his sleeve and slowly withdrew it. People of the day called him a lecturer in the true sense of the word. After offending a powerful minister, he sought to withdraw from office. Sent on duty to the Yi princely establishment, he took the opportunity to return home and never entered service again.
51
使
In the fifth year of Chongzhen, he was promoted to Right Sub-Expositor while still at home. In time he was promoted to Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent. Earlier, in the Tianqi reign, the court ordered the compilation of the Veritable Records of Emperor Guangzong. Vice Minister of Rites Zhou Bingmo recorded the peril surrounding the heir apparent under Emperor Shenzong, along with the Demonic Book and Club Assault affairs, writing truthfully without deferring to anyone. Later, after Wei Zhongxian seized power, Censor Shi Sanwei impeached Zhou Bingmo and had him removed from office. Zhongxian had his clique revise the records, reversing right and wrong. Zhenmeng singled out several of the worst errors and submitted a memorial asking that they be corrected. The Emperor personally presided at the Level Platform and summoned the court to debate the matter face to face, but in the end Wen Tiren and Wang Yingxiong blocked the proposal.
52
In the first month of the eighth year, rebels attacked the imperial tombs at Fengyang. Zhenmeng traced in detail the roots of the chaos and said: "Those who hold office cannot put the state's interests first or serve selflessly. In a court that ought to be one, they carve out rival camps, raising favorites to their knees and casting enemies into the abyss—all of it driven by private resentment and patronage. For years now, what have they done to restore discipline? Whom have they raised up for merit and ability? What means have they used to secure the interior and drive off foreign threats? What strategy have they pursued to make the state rich and the army strong? Your Majesty should summon a righteous wrath, proclaim your grief and remorse, punish those who failed in duty, hold accountable those who have misled the state, enact policies that genuinely bring order to the people, and forgive the long-standing tax debts of the common folk. First win back the people's loyalty to check rebellion; only then discuss how to reopen the springs of revenue—not simply drain the marshes dry for a single catch. Expel every petty official who clings to rank out of fear of loss; rally every counsel and every strength to quell the chaos—then perhaps the state may yet recover! The Emperor responded with a gracious edict, yet he could not put the recommendations fully into practice.
53
By established practice, the Spring and Autumn Annals were not part of the imperial lecture program. The Emperor, believing it useful for understanding order and chaos, ordered suitable lecturers chosen to expound it. Zhenmeng was a celebrated scholar of the Spring and Autumn Annals, but Tiren envied him and quietly omitted his name. Second Assistant Qian Shisheng mentioned him, whereupon Tiren feigned astonishment and said, "We nearly overlooked this man! He then forwarded Zhenmeng's name to the throne. When Zhenmeng delivered his lectures, they proved exactly what the Emperor had hoped to hear.
54
In the sixth month the Emperor planned to add Grand Secretaries and summoned several dozen ministers to a test in drafting memorial responses. Zhenmeng pleaded illness and stayed away; Tiren happened to be on sick leave. In the seventh month the Emperor specially promoted Zhenmeng to Left Vice Minister of Rites and concurrently Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion, bringing him into the cabinet. He twice memorialized a firm refusal, but the Emperor would not accept it. Upon appointment, Grand Secretaries customarily paid courtesy calls on the Director of Ceremonial eunuchs and sent formal gifts; Zhenmeng alone refused. The head of the Directorate of Ceremonial was Cao Huachun, once a follower of the eunuch Wang An, who had long admired Zhenmeng. Through intermediaries Cao repeatedly expressed his wish to meet; Zhenmeng never went. Once in office, Zhenmeng found that whenever Tiren drafted an edict he consulted him first and always accepted his revisions. Delighted, Zhenmeng told others, "Master Wen is open-minded—how can anyone call him a schemer? His colleague He Wuzao said, "That man is deeply cunning—how can you trust him so readily? A little over ten days later Tiren began scrutinizing his drafts. Whenever he found wording he disliked, he ordered changes; if Zhenmeng refused, Tiren simply struck the passage out. Furious, Zhenmeng flung the memorials down before Tiren, who ignored him.
55
使
Chief Supervising Secretary Xu Yuqing had gained renown for impeaching Wei Zhongxian. Zhenmeng and He Wuzao wanted to appoint him Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices in Nanjing. Tiren resented Yuqing's blunt integrity and prompted Minister of Personnel Xie Sheng to impeach him for conspiring with Fujian Administrative Commissioner Shen Shaofang to procure a lucrative post. Tiren drafted a reduced punishment, calculating that if the Emperor wanted something harsher he would send the draft back for revision—and that is exactly what happened. He then drafted the dismissal of Yuqing to commoner status and the summoning of Shaofang for investigation. Zhenmeng protested in vain, then said bitterly, "For a censor to be stripped to commoner rank is the highest honor in the realm—thanks to you for making it happen. Tiren at once reported the remark to the throne. The Emperor was indeed furious and rebuked He Wuzao and Zhenmeng for favoritism and obstruction. He Wuzao was dismissed; Zhenmeng was stripped of his post and sent home.
56
No sooner had Zhenmeng taken office than an edict went out recalling the palace eunuchs serving as military overseers. When Second Assistant Wang Yingxiong left office, Zhenmeng's enemies claimed he had orchestrated it. Slander then spread that Zhenmeng had taken credit for the change, and the Emperor's regard turned against him. Zhenmeng was upright, principled, and incorruptible, with the air of the great ministers of old; yet after only three months he was dismissed and his abilities were never fully employed.
57
Six months after returning home, his nephew Yao Ximu died. Zhenmeng mourned him so bitterly that he too fell ill and died. The court requested posthumous honors for him, but the Emperor refused. In the twelfth year, an edict restored his former rank. In the fifteenth year he was posthumously made Minister of Rites, granted state funeral rites, and one son received an official appointment. Under the Prince of Fu he was posthumously granted the temple name Wensu. He had two sons, Bing and Cheng. Cheng perished in the cataclysm that befell the dynasty.
58
Zhou Bingmo, styled Zhongjing, was a native of Wuxi. His father Zhou Ziyi, a presented scholar under Jiajing, rose under Wanli to Vice Minister of Personnel and was posthumously titled Wenge. Bingmo passed the jinshi examination in the thirty-second year of Wanli. By the time the Veritable Records of Emperor Guangzong were being revised, Bingmo had already died. At the outset of Chongzhen he was posthumously made Minister of Rites with the posthumous title Wenjian. Both father and son were celebrated throughout the realm for scholarship and character.
59
西使
Jiang Dejing, styled Shenbao, was a native of Jinjiang. His father Jiang Guangyan served as Vice Commissioner of Jiangxi. Dejing passed the jinshi examination in the second year of Tianqi. He entered the Hanlin as a presented scholar and was appointed Compiler.
60
滿殿
Under Chongzhen he rose from Reader-in-Waiting to Junior Tutor and submitted detailed proposals for famine relief. He was soon promoted to Right Vice Minister of Rites. When the court debated capping private landholdings, Dejing argued: "Private land must not be confiscated; the surest way to ensure food is to keep grain prices high. In Beiping, Shanxi, Shaanxi, and northern Jiangsu, people should be encouraged to reclaim wasteland, plant mulberry and jujube, and repair irrigation works. When prefects and magistrates came up for performance review, these measures should weigh most heavily in their ratings. As for the Ever-Normal and Charity Granaries, delivering grain in kind each year as regulations require would suffice. In the spring of the fourteenth year Yang Sichang died in the field; the Emperor ordered the Nine Ministers to determine what penalties applied. Dejing's finding read: "Sichang championed ruthless taxation, imposing the bandit-suppression and training surtaxes until the people were ruined and the treasury empty and men turned to banditry; he also hid defeats and invented victory reports. His case should be handled like Qiu Luan's, with his crimes formally corrected posthumously. The Emperor did not accept the recommendation.
61
In the second month of the fifteenth year, after the spring plowing ceremony, he requested the recall of former Vice Minister Chen Zizhuang, Sacrificial Official Ni Yuanlu, and others; the Emperor approved and reinstated them all. In the sixth month, when Grand Secretaries were nominated, Dejing topped the list. At his audience he argued that border commanders needed long tenures: in half a year Ji Province had seen five governors, and affairs would only grow more neglected. The Emperor said, "If they are incompetent, replace them. He replied, "Better to choose carefully from the first than to keep replacing them later. The Emperor asked, "How can these heavenly portents be abated? He answered, "There is no better way than to rescue the common people. The Liaodong levy has lately been raised by ten million, the training levy by seven million—how can the people endure it! Under ancestral practice the three defense zones had one governor, one commissioner, and one commander-in-chief; now two governors, three commissioners, and six commanders-in-chief have been added, with dozens of deputy generals—command is fragmented; how can we prevail! The Emperor nodded in agreement. Chief Assistant Zhou Yanru had recommended Dejing as deeply learned and fit for counsel, with a polished style suited to drafting imperial pronouncements. Dejing was accordingly promoted with Huang Jingfang and Wu Shen to Minister of Rites and concurrently Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion, and all three entered the inner cabinet. Yanru and Wu Shen each cultivated their own followings; Dejing attached himself to neither. Blunt and upright by nature, he did more than anyone to bring Huang Daozhou back to office and secure leniency for Liu Zongzhou. When Kaifeng was under long siege he asked leave to ride out and direct the generals in person, but the Emperor declined in a gracious edict.
62
The following year he submitted the Imperial Review Frontier Defense Register, documenting for all nine borders and sixteen garrisons the old and new figures for troops and supplies, together with garrison farming, salt monopolies, civilian transport, canal grain, and remount costs. He soon followed with the Frontier Pacification Reward Register and the Imperial Review Abridged Register. The Emperor commended the work in the highest terms. Frontier troop returns sent to the Ministry of Revenue inflated those sent to the Ministry of War by more than half, with wasted provisions the main excess; garrison farming, salt certificates, and civilian transport worth millions per garrison were left entirely to the border commanders. The Tianjin sea route shipped three million piculs of grain and beans each year to Ji and Liaodong; only the granary superintendent and the Tianjin governor managed the accounts, with no ministry oversight at all. Dejing urged the ministry officials to integrate ministry transport, Tianjin transport, frontier civilian transport, garrison farming, and salt revenues into a single plan so that regular quotas could be met and emergency surtaxes reduced. He submitted ten additional items holding the ministries accountable, yet in the end the abuses could not be fully cleared up.
63
One day at audience the Emperor raised the subject of training troops. Dejing said: "The Collected Statutes show that the Founding Emperor trained troops with rewards and punishments tied solely to bow, crossbow, blade, and spear—that is the law for training soldiers. When guard and battalion officers of chief and junior rank filled vacancies, promotion and demotion depended on spear contests. Whenever military officers were examined, they had to prove mastery of mounted archery before inheriting their posts—that is the law for training commanders. Did the dynasty wait until now to raise an army? The Emperor was struck to silence. He also said, "By ancestral law the frontiers fed their armies through garrison farming, salt revenues, and civilian transport alone—there was never any silver shipped from the capital. Capital silver shipments began in the Zhengtong era at only tens of thousands of taels; by the end of Wanli they still totaled barely three million. Today Liaodong pay, training levies, and the old quotas together exceed twenty million taels, yet the army is smaller than ever—the waste and corruption have reached this pitch." He went on: "The Martial Emperor raised seventy-two capital guards, with four hundred thousand troops on the rolls. In the eight prefectures of the capital region alone there were two hundred eighty thousand. There were another one hundred sixty thousand rotating troops from the Middle Region, Dening, Shandong, and Henan. Each spring and autumn they marched into the capital for drill, giving the dynasty the full advantage of a heavy center commanding a lighter periphery. Today those rolls are almost entirely padded with phantom names. Moreover, every campaign had relied on guard and battalion regulars; only at the end of Jiajing did the state begin hiring mercenaries, and thereafter the standing armies were left idle. Supplemental levies kept mounting until both soldiers and civilians were crushed alike. I beg Your Majesty to uphold the statutes of the two Founding Emperors and restore the old system." The Emperor assented in principle, but never put the plan into effect.
64
In the seventeenth year Jiang Chen, a principal clerk in the Ministry of Revenue, urged adoption of paper currency, arguing that minting thirty million strings a year at one tael per string would yield thirty million taels of silver annually. Vice Minister Wang Ao Yong spoke in its favor. The Emperor set up a special Inner Treasury Paper Currency Bureau, pressing production day and night and calling on merchants to sell the notes—not one answered. Dejing said, "However simple the people may be, who would trade an ounce of silver for a scrap of paper?" The Emperor would not hear of it. Then, on the bureau officials' advice, he ordered two million jin of mulberry pulp collected from the capital region, Shandong, Henan, and Zhejiang. Dejing fought the order hard; the Emperor held his memorial back, and in the end the levy was dropped. Earlier, with military stores running short, wealthy households in the capital region, Shandong, and Henan had been drafted each year, paid a set price, and ordered to buy grain and beans for delivery to Tianjin—sometimes as much as a million piculs—and the people were thrown into turmoil. At audience Dejing laid out the harm in person, and the Emperor at once ordered a rescript drafted to abolish the scheme.
65
In the second month, with rebel armies closing in, the Emperor ordered the ministers to confer and report back by the twenty-second. Censor-in-Chief Li Banghua sent a secret memorial saying the chief ministers knew the truth but dared not speak. The next day the Emperor took the memorial in hand and asked what it was about. Chen Yan answered with Junior Grand Mentor Xiang Yu's proposal to move the heir apparent south; the Emperor read it and said nothing. Dejing pressed the case from the side, but the Emperor gave no answer.
66
西西 西
Censor Guang Shiheng renewed his attack on the harm done by training levies. Dejing drafted a rescript: "Petty men bent on extraction invented the training levy, driving the people to ruin and calamity and doing the state grave harm." The Emperor was displeased and demanded, "Who are these petty extractors?" Dejing dared not name Sichang outright and answered with the former minister Li Daiwen. The Emperor said, "I am no extractor—I only wanted to train troops." Dejing said, "Your Majesty would never stoop to extraction. Yet with old pay at five million, new pay at more than nine million, and training levies adding another seven million three hundred thousand, my ministry can hardly escape blame. And where are the troops that were supposedly trained? The Ji supervisor was to train forty-five thousand men; today there are only twenty-five thousand. The Baoding supervisor was to train thirty thousand; today there are only two thousand five hundred; Baoding garrison was to train ten thousand; today there are only two hundred; The Shan and Yong armies numbered seventy-eight thousand, Ji and Miyun one hundred thousand, Changping forty thousand, and Xuan-Da, Shanxi, and the three Shaanxi frontiers each more than two hundred thousand—yet once men were skimmed off for training, no one tracked the original rolls, the skimmed troops were never trained, and seven million taels in pay were added for nothing but a burden on the people." The Emperor said, "The three levies are already merged into one—why harp on it!" Dejing said, "The Ministry may have merged them on the books, but when prefectures and counties press for payment it is still three levies." The Emperor flew into a rage and accused him of factional collusion. Dejing defended himself vigorously while the chief ministers pleaded on his behalf. Minister Ni Yuanlu, holding that paper currency and pay were the ministry's charge, took the blame on himself, and the Emperor's anger eased. The next day Dejing submitted a formal memorial accepting blame. Though the Emperor soon abolished the training levy, Dejing still left office on the second day of the third month. Censors Wang Weixiao, Compiler Fu Dingquan, and others sent memorial after memorial begging that he be kept on—the Emperor would not listen. When Dejing heard that Shanxi had fallen, he dared not leave the capital. Learning that the court was keeping him there, he resigned from audience and moved his lodging to the outer city. When the rebels arrived, he managed to escape.
67
When the Prince of Fu was enthroned at Nanjing, he was summoned into the Grand Secretariat. He confessed three faults of his own and firmly declined. The next year, when the Prince of Tang was enthroned at Fuzhou, he was summoned together with He Wusi and Huang Jingfang. The year after that he resigned and went home, citing a foot ailment. In the ninth month the princes' cause collapsed; Dejing happened to be gravely ill and died that same month.
68
退
Huang Jingfang, courtesy name Taizhi, was also a native of Jinjiang. He passed the metropolitan examination in the fifth year of Tianqi. From Hanlin bachelor he rose to Junior Tutor and served on daily lecture duty at court. In the eleventh year of Chongzhen, at the classics lecture the Emperor asked how men should be chosen for office. Jingfang said, "Recent examinations have been unfair. Magistrate-advisors Cheng Yong and Zhu Tianlin have long been known for integrity and talent, yet they were passed over for elite appointments." He also said, "Minister of Justice Zheng Sanjun, a veteran of four reigns and unmatched in probity, ought not languish in prison." After leaving court he submitted another memorial on the matter; Sanjun was soon released, and Yong and the others were all given new posts.
69
沿調
Jingfang was soon promoted to Junior Grand Mentor. On one occasion at audience he said, "The supervising eunuch Gao Qiqian was recently recalled from the frontier, and alarms at once sounded beyond the passes—I suspect something hidden behind this. My family lives on the coast; I have seen coastal officers report a naval alarm whenever transfer orders arrive, hoping to be kept in place. Draw the parallel and the motive becomes plain." The Emperor nodded. In the fourteenth year he served as Grand Mentor while also heading the Hanlin Academy. Hanlin probationary appointments had long been suspended; Jingfang submitted a detailed memorial asking that they be restored, and also asked that Compiler Liu Tongsheng and Editor Zhao Shichun be recalled—none of it received a reply.
70
In the sixth month of the fifteenth year he pleased the Emperor at audience and was made Grand Secretary together with Jiang Dejing and Wu Shen. The next year all three were made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent; he was transferred to Minister of Revenue and the Wenyuan Pavilion. Nanjing river defense had long been entrusted to both a civil and a military commissioner; the Emperor wished to abolish the civil post and give sole charge to the Earl of Chengyi, Liu Kongzhao. Vice Censor-in-Chief Hui Shiyang was long overdue and had not reported; the Emperor ordered his name struck from the rolls. Jingfang memorialized against both decisions; the Emperor was displeased, and he sent successive memorials asking to retire. Under the Prince of Tang he was summoned back to court; before long he again asked leave to go home. After the fall of the dynasty he lived at home for more than ten years before he died.
71
Fang Yuegong, courtesy name Sichang, was a native of Gucheng. He passed the metropolitan examination in the second year of Tianqi. He was appointed a principal clerk in the Ministry of Revenue and rose to director. He successively managed the granaries and supervised Yongping grain reserves, earning a reputation in both posts for integrity and diligence.
72
In the first year of Chongzhen he was sent out as prefect of Songjiang. Pirates were rife along the coast; when captured they were beaten to death on the spot. The prefecture's southeast faced the sea, and hurricane tides battered the shore to the people's ruin; he built a stone dike some twenty li long and turned the flood into lasting benefit. The prefecture shipped several hundred thousand shi of tribute grain to the capital, yet its granaries stood five li apart; he built walls to protect them and called the place Granary City. In famine relief, public labor, rebuilding schools, and examining scholars he likewise achieved results and was several times recommended for outstanding service. When Xue Guoguan fell, his client Wang Shiyan of Shanghai was arrested; having long borne a grudge, Shiyan claimed Yuegong had once given Guoguan three thousand taels of gold, and Yuegong was arrested. Gentry and commoners went to the palace gates to plead his innocence; Governor Huang Xi also reported that the charge was false, and the case was sent to the legal offices for judgment. One day at an informal evening audience the Emperor asked the chief ministers, "Which prefect has served more than ten years on accumulated salary and been repeatedly recommended for outstanding service?" Dejing answered with Yuegong. The Emperor said, "Where is he now?" Dejing answered that he had been implicated through Shiyan; the Emperor nodded. The legal offices reported that there was no solid evidence of bribery and that his office should be restored. The Emperor praised his incorruptible conduct and approved.
73
使 使
Before long Censor Fang Shiliang recommended Yuegong and Chen Hongmi, prefect of Suzhou; Yuegong was promoted to Vice Commissioner of Shandong while also serving as Right Assistant Commissioner, with general charge of Jiangnan grain reserves. The grain barges under his supervision reached Tongzhou on schedule. The Emperor was greatly pleased. Minister of Personnel Zheng Sanjun nominated five incorruptible and capable surveillance commissioners from across the realm, and Yuegong was among them. The Emperor urgently summoned him for audience, received him at the Ping Platform, and asked what should come first in governing; he answered, "If the realm is to be brought to order and peace, the first thing is choosing prefects and magistrates; to judge whether prefects and magistrates are worthy lies with the surveillance commissioners; to judge whether surveillance commissioners are worthy lies with the touring inspectors; to judge whether touring inspectors are worthy lies with the censor-in-chief. With the right chief surveillance commissioner in place, no censor would dare flout the law." The emperor was pleased, gave him a meal, and did not let him leave until late afternoon. Six days later he was abruptly promoted to Left Vice Censor-in-Chief. On one occasion when summoned to audience, the emperor happened to be questioning Minister of Personnel Li Yuzhi about a matter. Yuzhi said, "I am in the midst of impeaching and rebutting the case." Yuegong said, "Why not submit a memorial at once?" This struck the emperor as exactly right. The next day he was ordered to keep his present office while also serving as Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion—it was the eleventh month of the sixteenth year. By precedent no grand secretary had held the censor-in-chief title; Yuegong was the first.
74
簿
Yuegong was by nature a man of administrative talent. Once he became chief minister he devoted himself to auditing ledgers and called for verification of old levies antedating amnesty, aiming chiefly at exaction—and his reputation suffered greatly. In the second month of the seventeenth year he was ordered to serve as Minister of Revenue and Minister of War while also Grand Secretary of the Hall of Literary Depth, directing grain transport, military colonies, troop training, and other affairs from Jining. Before long the arrangement was not carried out.
75
When Li Zicheng took the capital, Yuegong and Qiu Yu were seized and held in Liu Zongmin's quarters. The rebels demanded silver; Yuegong had always been incorrupt and was too poor to pay, and he was tortured without mercy. They searched his residence and found nothing; a merchant from Songjiang paid a thousand taels on his behalf. On the first day of the fourth month he and Qiu were released together. On the twelfth day, after the rebels had killed Chen Yan and others, they ordered the guards to kill the two men as well; the guards offered them cords, and both hanged themselves.
76
Qiu Yu came from Yicheng. He passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of the Tianqi reign. From Hanlin bachelor he was appointed reviser. Under Chongzhen he rose repeatedly to Junior Commissioner of the Household for the Heir Apparent. When Xiangyang fell, Qiu memorialized six measures: succor for the imperial clan in distress, selection of talented officials, commendation of those who died loyal, halting urgent levies, relief for postal distress, and prohibition of corvée labor. The emperor adopted them. He rose through the Left and Right Vice Minister posts of Rites. When summoned to audience he said, "Grand Coordinator Sun Chuanting's sortie beyond the passes bears on the fate of the realm—take care not to urge him to march out lightly. Let him steady Guanzhong; he can still rally the generals and advance to suppress the enemy when the moment is right. The emperor would not follow this advice. In the first month of the seventeenth year he was ordered to keep his present office while also serving as Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion, entering the Grand Secretariat together with Fan Jingwen. When the capital fell he was tortured twice; only two thousand taels were found in the search, and afterward he was killed.
77
Qiu's son Zhizhi was young but capable and resourceful. When Li Zicheng took Yicheng, Qiu's father Minzhong cursed the rebels and died. Zhizhi was captured and employed as an aide in the military government; soon he was made vice minister of that government to guard Xiangyang. Niu Quan, magistrate of Xiangyang, was the son of the rebel minister Venus; Li relied on him less than on Zhizhi. Zhizhi sent Sun Chuanting a letter in a wax pellet, saying, "When you fight him, I will falsely report that the Left Garrison's troops have arrived in force to shake their hearts—they are sure to look back. You strike from the rear, I rise in the middle—and the rebels can be destroyed." Chuanting was greatly pleased and replied as proposed; the letter was captured by rebel scouts. Chuanting relied on the inside contact and advanced camp after camp; Zhizhi indeed raised signal fires, reporting that the Left Garrison's troops had arrived in force. Zicheng verified the deception, summoned him, showed him Chuanting's letter, and reproached him for betraying him. Zhizhi cursed loudly, "I regret I could not cut you into ten thousand pieces—how would I follow you in rebellion!" The rebels were enraged and dismembered him.
78
The commentator says: The Chongzhen Emperor reigned only seventeen years, yet chief ministers numbered more than fifty. Those who could preserve a good name were only a few—men such as Biao. Jiming could promote old chief ministers to settle crisis; Zhenmeng was distinguished by integrity; Dejing was thoroughly versed in old regulations. Judged by the standard of Lu Xi's praise of Xue Ying, they were men who uprightly embodied the state, held to right without fear, weighed the times, and from time to time offered modest benefits. As for supporting a tottering state and setting it upright, that was another matter entirely. Alas—the realm was already in peril, and talent was exhausted along with it; the causes had long been gathering.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →