← Back to 明史

卷二百七十六 列傳第一百六十四 朱大典 張國維 張肯堂 曾櫻 朱繼祚 余煌 王瑞栴 路振飛 何楷 熊汝霖 錢肅樂 沈宸荃

Volume 276 Biographies 164: Zhu Dadian, Zhang Guowei, Zhang Kentang, Ceng Ying, Zhu Jizuo, Yu Huang, Wang Ruizhan, Lu Zhenfei, He Kai, Xiong Rulin, Qian Sule, Shen Chenquan

Chapter 276 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 276
Next Chapter →
1
Zhu Dadian (Wang Daokun and others)〉 Zhang Guowei and Zhang Kentang (Li Xiangzhong, Wu Zhongluan, Zhu Yongyou, and others)〉 Ceng Ying and Zhu Jizuo (Tang Fen and others)〉 Yu Huang (Chen Hanhui)〉 Wang Ruizhi, Lu Zhenfei, and He Kai (Lin Lanyou)〉 Xiong Rulin and Qian Sule (Liu Zhongzao and Zheng Zunqian)〉 Shen Chenquan (Lü Xiang of the same district)〉
2
使
Zhu Dadian, whose style was Yanzhi, came from Jinhua. His family had been poor for generations. Once he began his studies, Dadian proved bold and open-handed in temperament. He received his jinshi degree in the forty-fourth year of the Wanli reign and was made magistrate of Zhangqiu. In the second year of Tianqi he was raised to supervising secretary in the Military Bureau. When the eunuchs Wang Tigan, Wei Zhongxian, and eleven others, along with the wet nurse Ke Shi, claimed credit for guarding the throne and secured hereditary posts in the Embroidered Uniform Guard, Dadian lodged a forceful memorial of protest. In the fifth year he was posted to Fujian as vice commissioner, promoted to right administration commissioner, and then went home to observe mourning.
3
調 調
In the third year of Chongzhen he was restored to office, served in Shandong, and was soon reassigned to Tianjin. In the fourth month of the fifth year, Li Jiucheng and Kong Youde laid siege to Laizhou. When Grand Coordinator Xu Congzhi of Shandong was struck dead by cannon fire, Dadian was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief in his place and ordered to base himself at Qingzhou to direct troops and supplies. In the seventh month Grand Coordinator Xie Lian of Deng and Lai was captured by the rebels again, and Supreme Commander Liu Yulie was taken into custody. The court then abolished the posts of supreme commander and Deng-Lai grand coordinator and entrusted everything to Dadian alone, who coordinated tens of thousands of regular and auxiliary troops with more than 4,800 seasoned fighters from beyond the pass in a combined suppression. Regional Commander Jin Guoqi took the field at the head of Vice Commanders Jin Guochen and Liu Bangyu, Assistant Commanders Zu Dabi, Zu Kuan, and Zhang Tao, Mobile Corps Commander Bai Yongfu, and the former regional commander Wu Sangui together with Sangui's son Sanguan, while the eunuch Gao Qiqian oversaw the army's pay and supplies; the force marched as far as Dezhou. When the rebels struck Pingdu again, Vice Commanders Mou Wenshou and He Weizhong rushed to its aid, slew the rebel leader Chen Youshi, and Weizhong lost his life in the fighting. In the eighth month Touring Censor and Army Supervisor Xie Sanbin arrived at Changyi and called for the execution of Wang Hong and Liu Guozhu; the throne ordered both men arrested and brought to trial. Minister of War Xiong Mingyu was likewise removed from office for having favored negotiation at the expense of the realm. Sanbin lodged another forceful memorial demanding that the court cease all talk of pacification.
4
使
When Guoqi's force reached Changyi, it split into three columns. Troops from beyond the pass under Guoqi led the way, Deng Qi's foot soldiers followed, and this central column advanced from Huibu. Regional Commander Chen Hongfan of Changping, together with Vice Commanders Liu Zeqing and Fang Denghua, moved up the southern route through Pingdu. Assistant Commanders Wang Zhifu and Wang Wenwei took the northern route through Haimiao. Orders went out for Mobile Corps Commander Xu Yuanheng to bring up the Laiyang troops, while Mou Wenshou was stationed to guard Xinhe. Every unit marched with three days' provisions, gathered on the east bank of the Xin River, and forded the churning waters. At Shahe, Zu Kuan met Kong Youde in open combat. Kuan led the charge and Guochen came up behind him; the rebels were routed, and the victorious columns chased them all the way to the city walls. The rebels slipped away eastward in the dead of night, and the siege was finally broken. The garrison, fearing a trap, turned their guns on the approaching force. Gao Qiqian dispatched a palace envoy to announce the relief, and the entire city broke into celebration. Not until the following day did the southern column finally arrive. Guoqi's force then pursued the rebels into Huangxian, taking thirteen thousand heads and eight hundred prisoners, while tens of thousands more fled or perished in the sea.
5
西 祿
The rebels retreated into Dengzhou, where Guochen's men threw up a tight cordon around the city. Mountains ringed the city on three sides while the fourth faced the sea; the walls ran some thirty li, with both flanks abutting the coast. Relief troops rotated in shifts so the rebels could not escape, but rebel artillery inflicted heavy casualties on the besieging force. Li Jiucheng led his men out to meet the attackers in the field. In the eleventh month Jiucheng threw himself into a desperate fight until a surrendering soldier betrayed his strategy. Government forces converged on him and cut him down in battle, after which the rebels wailed without cease. Five men headed the rebellion—Jiucheng, Youde, Youshi, Geng Zhongming, and Mao Chenglu—and two of them were now dead. The emperor praised the relief of the siege, promoted Dadian to right assistant censor-in-chief, and granted graded rewards to the commanders and officials. In that same month Guoqi died and Wu Sangui took his place. After a prolonged siege the rebels were starving, yet confident they could flee by sea from the water city, they refused to yield. Once Wang Zhifu and Zu Kuan captured the outer rampart by the water gate, panic swept through the rebel ranks.
6
退 祿 祿
In mid-second month of the sixth year Youde slipped away first, putting his family and treasure aboard ships and sailing out to sea. Zhongming left the water city to Vice Commander Wang Bingzhong and fled alone by boat, allowing government troops to occupy the main city. An assault on the water city failed to bring it down. Mobile Corps Commander Liu Liangzuo proposed mining the walls: his men concealed themselves in Yongfu Temple, dug beneath the ramparts, set off their charges, and when the wall gave way government troops poured in. The rebels fell back to Penglai Pavilion until Dadian offered terms and they at last disarmed. Over a thousand prisoners were taken, together with Bingzhong and seventy-five rebel generals, while countless others hanged themselves or drowned; the rebellion was completely crushed. Youde's party fled toward Lüshun, where Island Commander Huang Long ambushed them, capturing Chenglu, Guangfu, and Yougong alive and executing Yingyuan. Youde and Zhongming alone got away. Chenglu and his companions were then sent to the capital as prisoners. The day before the scheduled execution, Yougong broke free of his shackles and escaped. The emperor flew into a rage, had the custodial officers beheaded, and punished numerous officials in the Ministry of Punishments. He was soon recaptured and put to death. When rewards were apportioned, Dadian was made right vice minister of war, granted hereditary rank as a hundred-household commander in the Embroidered Uniform Guard, and kept his grand coordinator post.
7
退 西
In the second month of the eighth year rebels overran Fengyang and desecrated the imperial mausoleums, and Supreme Commander Yang Yipeng was taken into custody. Dadian was ordered to take charge of the grain transport and to serve concurrently as grand coordinator of Lu, Feng, Huai, and Yang, with his headquarters at Fengyang. By then much of the territory north of the Yangzi had been lost. In the first month of the following year the rebels encircled Chuzhou with camps stretching over a hundred li, until Regional Commander Zu Kuan routed them. Dadian joined Supreme Director Lu Xiangsheng in pursuit and broke them a second time. He rushed his troops back to block the rebel horde at Fengyang, and only then did they retreat. In the eleventh year the rebels crossed the Yangzi again, aiming to slip into the Chashan region. Dadian and Grand Coordinator Shi Kefa of Anqing moved to intercept them, and the rebels turned west in flight. Dadian had already been demoted for losing counties and districts yet was left in post. In the fourth month of that year he was demoted three more ranks for failing to suppress the rebels on schedule. Shortly afterward his ranks were fully restored in recognition of his relief operations and grain transport.
8
In the thirteenth year Henan rebels swept deep into Huguang. Dadian dispatched generals to the rescue with repeated success and was promoted to left vice minister. In the sixth month of the following year he was placed in supreme command of military affairs north of the Yangzi and in Henan and Huguang, remaining at Fengyang to focus on the roving rebels while Kefa took over the grain transport. Rebel chief Yuan Shizhong commanded tens of thousands and terrorized the region between Ying and Bo. Dadian led Regional Commander Liu Liangzuo and others to crush them, and graded rewards followed. Though Dadian had done real service in defense, he could not keep his hands clean and was repeatedly impeached by Supervising Secretary Fang Shiliang, Censor Zheng Kunzhen, and others until an edict removed him from office pending investigation. Before that case was settled, the Xu Du rebellion erupted in Dongyang.
9
調
Xu Du was a degree candidate with a proud temper; enraged by the magistrate's oppressive exactions, he rebelled and laid siege to Jinhua. Dadian's son Wanhua raised tough fighters to resist the rebels, and after the uprising was crushed those recruits refused to disband. On hearing this, Dadian rushed home. Magistrate Xu Tiaoyuan, checking the rebel muster rolls, found Wanhua's name and accused Dadian of letting his son collude with the enemy. Touring Censor Zuo Guangxian reported the matter to court; an edict ordered Dadian arrested, his property seized for military funds, and Supervising Secretary Han Ruyu was told to hurry the case along.
10
Soon afterward the capital fell and the Prince of Fu ascended the throne. When someone testified to his innocence and Dadian also cultivated ties with Ma Shiying and Ruan Dacheng, he was recalled as left vice minister of war. Within a month he was promoted to minister and placed in supreme command of military affairs along the upper Yangzi. When Zuo Liangyu took up arms, Dadian was ordered to oversee Huang Degong's force in opposing him. When the Prince of Fu fled to Taiping, Dadian and Ruan Dacheng boarded his vessel, pledged themselves to fight to the end. Degong fell in battle, the prince was taken prisoner, and the two men escaped to Hangzhou. After the Prince of Lu surrendered as well, Dadian went back to his native district and held its city in a last stand. The Prince of Tang, on hearing this, promptly named him Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion and commander of the eastern Zhejiang front. A year later the city fell, and he and his whole family perished.
11
西
In those days many districts east and west of Zhejiang fell in turn; among those who died in office were, at Hangzhou, Vice Prefect Wang Daokun, Magistrate Gu Xianjian of Qiantang, and Magistrate Tang Zicai of Lin'an; at Shaoxing, Ministry of War Director Gao Dai and Ye Ruyai; and at Quzhou, Touring Censor Wang Jingliang, Prefect Wu Jingzheng, Judicial Assistant Deng Yanzhong, and Magistrate Fang Zhao of Jiangshan. Among students and commoners who gave their lives for the cause, the best known were Pan Ji and Zhou Bonian of Kuaiji, Zhu Wei of Shanyin, Fu Rijiong of Zhuji, Zhao Jinglin of Yin, Zhang Junzheng of Pujiang, Zou Qinyao of Ruian, and Zou Zhiqi of Yongjia.
12
Wang Daokun, styled Zhaoping, came from Qiantang. He passed the provincial examination in the first year of Tianqi. Under Chongzhen he served as magistrate of Nanping and was later made vice prefect of Nanxiong. When rebels broke out in Guangze, local elders insisted that only Daokun could restore order. The provincial authorities petitioned for him, and an edict reassigned him as vice prefect of Shaowu with responsibility for Guangze. Combining conciliation with force, he brought the region under control. Emperor Chongzhen broke precedent in searching for talent and summoned able officials from across the empire; the provincial authorities nominated Daokun. While awaiting his new appointment the capital fell, and he made his way south in disguise. When Hangzhou fell he took his own life by hanging.
13
調 使
Gu Xianjian, styled Hanshi, came from Kunshan and was the great-grandson of Grand Secretary Gu Dingchen. He became a jinshi in the sixteenth year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Qiantang. He had barely assumed office when news of the capital's fall threw the populace into panic. Xianjian cracked down on ruffians and tightened the city's defenses. Touring Censor Peng Yufeng's greed and cruelty sparked a riot, but Xianjian's mediation settled the affair and spared the people mass reprisals. After the Southern Capital fell, Zhenjiang commander Zheng Cai marched his men back to Fujian, looting the countryside as they went. Xianjian spent his own money to entertain and reward them, and they finally moved on without entering the city. Soon afterward Ma Shiying arrived with an army. Before long the forces of the great general Fang Guo'an appeared as well. Xianjian worked with his superiors to send gifts in advance, keeping the soldiers out of the city. The surrounding countryside was badly looted, but the city itself was spared. While every supervising official and local magistrate fled, Xianjian sent his family away but stayed at his post alone. After the Prince of Lu surrendered, Xianjian refused to go and submit. He was soon captured and executed.
14
Tang Zicai came from Dazhou. He served as magistrate of Lin'an. When Hangzhou fell, Zicai fled into the hills with his nephew Jieyu. Reports that he had received orders from the Prince of Lu and was plotting rebellion led to his capture. Zicai urged Jieyu to escape, but the nephew refused, and both perished.
15
Gao Dai, styled Luzhan, came from Kuaiji. Under Chongzhen he passed the Shuntian provincial examination as a military student, and the Prince of Lu made him a director in the Bureau of Appointments. When Shaoxing fell he stopped eating and prayed for death. His son Lang, seeing that his father's mind was made up, threw himself into the sea and drowned. Dai exclaimed on hearing this: So my son could go before me after all! He said nothing more, and died himself a few days later.
16
Ye Ruyai, styled Hengsheng, was from the same district as Dai and became a Ministry of War director after passing the provincial examination. When he heard the news, he and his wife Wang withdrew to the family tombs at Tongwu and drowned themselves together.
17
西
Wang Jingliang, styled Wuhou, came from Wujiang. He received his jinshi degree in the final years of Chongzhen. He served the Prince of Fu as a secretariat drafter. When the Prince of Tang took the throne, he was made censor and grand coordinator of Jin and Qu, with oversight of education as well. Wu Jingzheng came from Anfu. A tribute student who became magistrate of Xi'an, he was abruptly promoted by the Prince of Tang to act as prefect. Deng Yanzhong came from Jiangling. He became a judicial assistant after passing the provincial examination. When Quzhou fell, Jingzheng drowned himself in a well, while Jingliang and Yanzhong hanged themselves. Zhang Pengyi, the garrison commander sent by the Prince of Lu, died as well.
18
Fang Zhao came from Xuancheng. He was acting magistrate of Jiangshan. After Jinhua was sacked, he gathered the elders and said: The army is coming, and I cannot in conscience flee. Yet I cannot let the whole city suffer on my account alone. He sealed his official seal, donned his cap and belt, bowed toward the north, and drowned himself in a well. The people buried him and raised a shrine in his memory.
19
Zhang Guowei, styled Yuyu, came from Dongyang. He became a jinshi in the second year of Tianqi. He was appointed magistrate of Panyu. In the first year of Chongzhen he was made supervising secretary in the Punishments Bureau and drove from office Vice Censor-in-Chief Yang Suoxiu and Censor Tian Jingxin, both allies of Wei Zhongxian. He then submitted five policy recommendations, opening with: Your Majesty pursues good government too eagerly and holds officials to too harsh a standard. The slow-footed tiptoe to escape blame, the clever twist and turn to win favor—who can still throw himself wholeheartedly into the state's business? The realm looks sharply governed, yet the ties between ruler and servants have grown thin; here is where your keen judgment should be tempered. Under the founding emperors, grand secretaries sometimes returned edicts unaccepted, and sometimes fought a single issue through repeated memorials. Today, at the first rebuke they bow their heads in haste; at the first order to revise a draft, they rush to comply lest they fall behind. Even when a policy is wrong they dare not press their case; here is where deference to the throne should be checked. Imperial audiences were meant to let subjects speak freely, and no one had ever been punished for what he said there. Now only the emperor's words are relayed, and no subject is seen to respond in open debate. My colleague Xiong Fenwei, only ten days after returning to court, misspoke once and was immediately banished. Could you not have imposed a lighter penalty, to show a measure of tolerance? This is where harmony between throne and officials ought to be restored. His second and third points urged lighter punishments and broader mercy. The emperor did not adopt all of his advice. He was promoted to chief supervising secretary in the Rites Bureau. After an earthquake struck the capital he delivered a sharp critique of misgovernment and was moved to vice minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices.
20
宿 宿宿
In the seventh year he was made right vice censor-in-chief and grand coordinator of Yingtian, Anqing, and nine other prefectures. That winter rebels struck Tongcheng and annihilated the government force. Though still a young man, Guowei's hair turned white overnight. In the first month of the following year he marched with Vice Commander Xu Ziqiang to relieve the city, while Pan Kedai, Chen Erming, and others held Tongcheng against the siege. The rebels then turned on Qianshan, where Magistrate Zhao Shiyan was mortally wounded. They struck Taihu as well, killing Magistrate Jin Yingyuan and Instructor Hu Yongning. Guowei's arrival broke the siege of Tongcheng; he sent Garrison Commander Zhu Shiyin to Qianshan and Company Commander Zhang Qiwei to Taihu. Shiyin fell in battle, while at Susong Ziqiang fought the rebels to a bloody standstill. Anqing mountaineers rolled boulders down on the rebels, killing many, and the survivors fled over Yingshan and Huoshan. In the ninth month the rebels re-entered Qianshan and Taihu through Susong, while another band under Saodiwang overran Susong and two neighboring counties. Guowei recruited two thousand local militiamen for garrison duty and turned military affairs over to Army Supervisor Shi Kefa. In the first month of the following year rebels besieged Jiangpu, and he sent Garrison Commanders Jiang Ruolai and Chen Yuwang to drive them back. In the twelfth month rebel detachments struck Huaining, but Kefa, Zuo Liangyu, and Ma Huang held them off. When they attacked Jiangpu again, Vice Commander Cheng Long, Ruolai, Yuwang, and others held the line. Every city in the region was saved. They besieged Wangjiang as well, but his relief force broke the siege.
21
In the third month of the tenth year Guowei led Cheng Long and others to Anqing to face the rebels at Fengjiadian, where Long's force of several thousand was wiped out. The rebels swept east, taking Hezhou, Hanshan, and Dingyuan, capturing Liuhe after Magistrate Zheng Tongyuan fled, and then advancing on Tianchang. As rebel strength grew daily, Guowei petitioned the court to carve out Anqing, Chizhou, and Taiping into a separate jurisdiction with Kefa as grand coordinator. From this time on, Anqing was placed outside the jurisdiction of the Jiangnan grand coordinator. Some officials proposed detaching Jiangpu and Liuhe as well so Guowei could focus solely on Jiangnan, but the court refused.
22
Guowei was open-handed and good-natured, and he won over the gentry. Whenever neighboring prefectures were hit by disaster, he petitioned the court for relief. He fortified Taihu and Fanchang, built the Jiuli Stone Dam at Suzhou plus the inner and outer dikes at Pingwang and the Changzhou–He embankments, repaired Songjiang's sea walls, and dredged the transport channels at Zhenjiang and Jiangyin—with solid results in every case. He was promoted to vice minister of Works and right vice censor-in-chief, with overall responsibility for river management. During a severe drought the transport channels dried up, and Guowei dredged rivers throughout the region to restore grain shipments. During the Shandong famine he saved countless poor people from starvation.
23
In the summer of the fourteenth year, with bandits rampant in Shandong, he was made vice minister of War and put in charge of troops at the Huai, Xu, Lin, and Tong garrisons to protect the grain route. Li Qingshan, a major bandit leader with tens of thousands of followers, held Liangshan Marsh and sent his men to seize eight canal locks including Hanzhuang, blocking the transport route. As Zhou Yanru traveled north to answer the imperial summons, Qingshan came to see him and claimed his band was protecting grain shipments, not rebelling. Yanru agreed to bring this up at court, and Qingshan was given an official post. But Qingshan instead hijacked grain boats, looted and burned along the route, and advanced on Linqing. Guowei rallied his forces, defeated them, and took them prisoner; the captives were sent to court and executed by dismemberment in public. When Minister of War Chen Xinjia was thrown into prison, the emperor recalled Guowei to fill the post. He established rules for rewards and punishments in combat and defense, and submitted seven reforms—tightening hereditary office, calibrating promotions, scrutinizing memorial nominations, and others—all of which the emperor approved. When Kaifeng fell and threw Hebei into turmoil, he proposed several river-defense measures, which the emperor also adopted.
24
In the fourth month of the sixteenth year our Great Qing armies entered the capital region; Guowei ordered Zhao Guangbian to hold Luoshan, but the combined forces of eight regional commanders were routed. Critics attacked Guowei, and he was dismissed and soon thrown in prison. Remembering his work on the waterways, the emperor had him freed. Summoned for audience at the Zhongzuo Gate, he was restored to his former rank with the concurrent post of right vice censor-in-chief and sent posthaste to Jiangnan and Zhejiang to oversee troop training and grain supplies. Ten days after he left the capital, the city fell to the enemy.
25
The Prince of Fu recalled him to help manage military affairs. His success against the Shandong bandits was formally recognized; he was made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent and granted hereditary rank in the Embroidered Uniform Guard. When Minister of Personnel Xu Shiqing resigned, most officials believed Guowei should succeed him. Ma Shiying was passed over, and Zhang Jie was appointed instead. Guowei requested leave to go home and care for his parents.
26
殿
When the Southern Capital fell, the Prince of Lu set up a regency at Hangzhou a month later but surrendered within days. In the intercalary sixth month Guowei went to Taizhou to pay homage to the Prince of Lu and petitioned him to assume the regency. The court moved to Shaoxing the same day, and Guowei was made Junior Tutor and Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent, Minister of War, and Grand Secretary of the Wuying Hall, with command over the Yangtze defense. Regional Commander Fang Guoan arrived from Jinhua as well. Ma Shiying, who had long been close to Guoan, hid in his camp and requested an audience. Guowei charged him with ten major crimes, and Ma Shiying dared not appear at court. He recaptured Fuyang and Yuqian, strengthened river defenses along critical points, and coordinated the camps of Guoan, Wang Zhiren, Zheng Zunqian, Xiong Rulin, Sun Jiaji, and Qian Sule for a prolonged defense. In the fifth month of Shunzhi 3 the allied armies collapsed for lack of supplies; the prince fled Taizhou by sea, and Guowei withdrew to defend Dongyang. In the sixth month, seeing resistance was hopeless, he wrote three farewell poems and drowned himself at the age of fifty-two.
27
Zhang Kentang, styled Zaining, came from Huating in Songjiang. He became a jinshi in the fifth year of Tianqi. He was appointed magistrate of Jun County. In the seventh year of Chongzhen he was promoted to censor. The following spring, after bandits overran Fengyang, he submitted a five-point plan to destroy them. After the imperial tombs were threatened, he memorialized that the chief ministers should not treat the crisis as if it were someone else's problem—Qin and Yue ignoring each other's woes—but the emperor paid no attention. As touring censor in Fujian he was repeatedly rewarded for suppressing bandits. Back at court he said: "Intendants and commissioners compete shamelessly for posts they want to keep indefinitely; and for posts they wish to avoid they claim their talents are needed elsewhere. One year in the north, the next in Fujian and Guangdong—the round trip alone can run thousands of li, deadlines slip, and delays stretch for months. Every reshuffle only brings another wave of disruption. The emperor agreed with him. In the tenth month of the twelfth year Yang Sichang was dispatched as supreme commander. Kentang submitted a memorial: "Through history rebels have been dispersed at first and destroyed once their strength solidified—appeasement alone has never worked. With the chief minister taking up his new command, the rebels will surely revert to their old trick of playing pitiful supplicants. Failed officials, hoping to cover their past defeats, will work every angle to push appeasement again. Issue a clear order that extermination is the only policy. Anyone who again advocates appeasement should face severe punishment. The emperor scolded him for narrow-minded presumption.
28
退
In the fourth month of the fourteenth year he wrote: "Rogues destroy cities and rampage freely as if no one were there—nothing like this has occurred under Supreme Commander Sichang. The immediate priority is to relieve Sichang of command. But by the time the memorial reached court, Sichang was already dead. In the twelfth month he wrote again: "We cannot say there are no officials fighting bandits—yet beyond grand coordinators we have pacification commissioners, and above governors-general we still add supreme commanders. The titles differ but the authority does not. Huguang reports its own victories while Henan reports its own defeats; Nanyang has fallen and an imperial prince is imperiled—what is the supreme commander actually commanding? Is the supreme commander supposed to sit at headquarters issuing directives, or divide rebel forces and fight them on the ground until he is exhausted? Are the governors of Shaanxi and Baoding to defend their territories in mutual support, or simply chase rebels across borders with whatever troops they can spare? Should grand coordinators obey the supreme commander's every order, or assess rebel strength on the spot and choose when to fight or hold? On all these crucial points there is no clarity—the court decides in the dark while officials serve blind. When territory is lost and armies destroyed, the court blames governors and coordinators to save itself, they blame each other to escape punishment—and frontier affairs become ungovernable. The emperor accepted his advice and ordered the relevant offices to study it. In the fifteenth year he petitioned to restore officials punished for remonstrating; Yin Run, Li Qing, and Liu Chang were returned to their posts as supervising secretaries, and Zhou Yijing as censor. Kentang was made vice director of the Court of Judicial Review, then promoted to right vice censor-in-chief and grand coordinator of Fujian.
29
便
Regional Commander Zheng Hongkui brought Prince Tang Zhu Yujian into Fujian; with Zhilong, Zheng's brother and Earl of Nan'an, and Kentang he urged the prince to take the throne, and Kentang was made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and Minister of Personnel. When Zeng Ying arrived, censor-officials wanted him to head the Ministry of Personnel, so Kentang was placed in charge of the Censorate instead. Kentang asked to recruit a naval force and reach Jiangnan by sea to raise loyal troops, while the prince would advance from Xianxia into eastern Zhejiang to coordinate with him. He was promoted to Junior Guardian, given an imperial commission and seal, and empowered to act at discretion. Zhilong, harboring his own agenda, quietly blocked the plan, and the expedition never happened.
30
西
In Shunzhi 3 the prince was defeated and killed, and Kentang fled overseas. In the sixth year he reached Zhoushan, where the Prince of Lu made him Grand Secretary of the Eastern Hall. In the eighth year Great Qing forces exploited the fog to mass at Luotou Gate. Dingxi Marquis Zhang Mingzhen took the prince to sea and left Kentang to hold the city. With six thousand soldiers and over ten thousand civilians inside, the city held for more than ten days. When the city fell, Kentang, dressed in python robe and jade belt, seated himself facing south; he had his four concubines, daughter-in-law, and granddaughter killed first, then calmly wrote a poem and hanged himself.
31
使西
Those who died with him included Minister of War Li Xiangzhong, Minister of Rites Wu Zhongluan, Vice Minister of Personnel Zhu Yongyou, Anyang General Liu Shixun, and Left Commissioner-in-Chief Zhang Mingyang. Also among the dead were Communications Commissioner Zheng Zunyian of Kuaiji, Supervising Secretary Dong Zhining of Yin County, War Bureau Director Zhu Yangshi of Jiangyin, Revenue directors Lin Ying of Fujian and Jiang Yongji of Suzhou, Rites director Dong Yuan of Kuaiji, War directors Zhu Wannian of Fujian, Gu Zhen of Changzhou, and Li Kaiguo of Linshan Guard, Works director Gu Zhongyao of Changzhou, Drafting Secretary Su Zhaoren of Suzhou, Works Bureau clerk Dai Zhongming of Yin County, Dingxi Marquis staff officer Gu Mingji of Shuntian, student Lin Shiying of Fujian, Embroidered Uniform Guard Commander Wang Chaoxiang, and eunuch Liu Chao of the Directorate of Palace Eunuchs. Twenty-one people in all.
32
調 使
Li Xiangzhong came from Zhongxiang. He became a jinshi in the thirteenth year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Changxing, then transferred to Xiushui. Under the Prince of Fu he served as a bureau director in the Imperial Procession Office and as vice commissioner for military preparedness in Suzhou and Songjiang. The Prince of Tang made him director of the Court of Imperial Seals. When the Fujian cause collapsed he fled to the coast. When the Prince of Lu assumed the regency he was summoned as right vice censor-in-chief, followed the prince to sea, was promoted to Minister of War, and went with him to Zhoushan. When the city fell the Qing commander summoned Xiangzhong, but he refused to come. Soldiers were sent to capture him, and he was brought in wearing funeral robes. The commander snapped at him: "We invited you and you stayed away; the moment we sent soldiers to fetch you, here you are—why is that Xiangzhong answered calmly: "Before, I refused office; now I accept death."
33
Wu Zhongluan, styled Luanzhi, came from Wujin. He became a jinshi in the seventh year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Changxing. After drought and flood left him short of the training-supply quota, he was demoted to registrar at Shaoxing. A year later he was transferred to judicial assistant at Guilin. When he heard of the turmoil in the capital, he wept and said, "Ma Junchang will surely die for his principles. Before long Shichang did die." When the Prince of Fu was enthroned, he was transferred to a directorship in the Ministry of Rites. Reaching Nanxiong, he learned the Southern Capital had fallen, so he turned toward Fujian and passionately laid out the national strategy. When the Prince of Lu took up arms, Zhongluan was appointed Minister of Rites and traveled back and forth on Mount Putuo. When Qing troops reached Ningbo, Zhongluan spoke boldly to those around him: "In the past Zhongda died in the eunuch purge, but I was only a scholar and could not die with him. Junchang died in the rebels' uprising, but as a minister far from the capital I could not follow him in death. Now the time has come! He then crossed the sea in haste, entered the Confucian temple of Changguo Guard, piled firewood beneath the left gallery, clasped Confucius's wooden spirit tablet to his chest, and burned himself to death. Zhongda was Li Yingsheng of Jiangyin, a disciple of Zhongluan who had offended Wei Zhongxian and perished in the eunuch faction purge.
34
Zhu Yongyou, styled Yuanqi. He became a jinshi in the seventh year of Chongzhen. He was appointed a director in the Ministry of Justice, transferred to the Ministry of Personnel, and eventually dismissed and sent home. He served the Prince of Tang and later made his way to Zhoushan. When the city fell he was captured; he asked to become a monk, but permission was denied, and he went to his death. Mingyang was the younger brother of Mingzhen. When the city fell, dozens of people from his mother Fan downward burned themselves to death.
35
When Chaoxiang heard the city had fallen, he helped Consort Chen the princess, Noble Consort Zhang, and Duchess Du of Yiyang into a well, covered it with heavy stones, and cut his own throat beside them. Kaiguo's mother and the wives of Ying and Mingji all took their own lives.
36
Ceng Ying, styled Zhonghan, came from Xiajiang. He became a jinshi in the forty-fourth year of Wanli. He was appointed a director in the Ministry of Works and rose to bureau director. In the second year of Tianqi he was promoted to prefect of Changzhou. Censors assigned to salt, transport, rivers, grain transport, education, and garrison fields all held impeachment power, and their dispatches arrived every day. Ying wrote to the Nanjing Censorate: "Elsewhere a prefect or magistrate runs himself ragged for one touring censor; in the Southern Metropolitan Region he must do so for several. Please rein all of them in and abolish such bad practices as secret investigations and extracting ransom payments. Censor-in-Chief Xiong Mingyu then enforced restraint on them.
37
Ying lived with integrity, governed with kindness and fairness, and did not fear the powerful. A garrison-field censor demanded the names of subordinate officials due for impeachment, but Ying refused to respond. The censor tried to intimidate him with harsh words; Ying replied, "My staff has been worn out; there is no one left to impeach—only the prefect is unworthy. He then marked himself down for the lowest rating, shut his doors, and awaited punishment. The governor and censor urgently urged him to stay, and he resumed his duties. The imperial weaving eunuch Li Shi tried to force the prefect to perform subordinate obeisance, but Ying refused. Shi sent an official dispatch addressing him with the familiar "you" as an insult; Ying replied in the same familiar terms and never yielded. When Gao Panlong of Wuxi and Miao Changqi and Li Yingsheng of Jiangyin were arrested, Ying gave Changqi and Yingsheng financial aid; after Panlong's death he handled the funeral arrangements, wrote a memorial essay for him, and secured the release of his son and servants from prison. Mao Shilong of Yixing had been sentenced to exile for offending Wei Zhongxian; Ying urged him to flee. When officials came to seize his family, they were spared thanks to Ying. Sun Shenxing of Wujin had offended Zhongxian and was bound for exile; Ying delayed his journey. When Zhongxian fell from power, the matter was dropped.
38
退 使
In the first year of Chongzhen he was made right administration commissioner for southern Zhangzhou. When bandits from Jiulian Mountain attacked Shanghang, Ying raised stalwart fighters and drove them off, then raided their stronghold by night and killed nearly all of them. Local gentry and commoners built a shrine in Ying's honor. He returned home to observe mourning for his mother. When his mourning period ended he was restored to office and put in charge of Xing and Quan prefectures. He was promoted to surveillance commissioner with jurisdiction over Fuzhou and Ningde. Earlier, when Western barbarians raided Xing and Quan, Ying asked Governor Zou Weilian to deploy Vice Commander-in-Chief Zheng Zhilong as the vanguard, and they duly won. When Liu Xiang raided Guangdong, Governor-General Xiong Wencan wanted Zhilong's help, but Weilian and others, knowing Xiang and Zhilong were old associates, hesitated and would not send him. Ying pledged his own household—one hundred lives—to vouch for Zhilong, and they went on to defeat and destroy Xiang; Zhilong was deeply grateful to Ying.
39
In the winter of the tenth year the emperor believed Eastern Depot reports that Ying had bribed officials to seek promotion, and ordered him shackled and brought to the capital. Censor Ye Chuchun, who had once served under Ying and knew him to be incorruptible, subtly spoke in his favor in another memorial. The throne ordered an inquiry; he fully attested to Ying's worth, but said he did not know where the bribery charge had come from. When the edict reached Fujian, Governor Shen Youlong and Censor Zhang Kentang found in the Depot dispatch the name of a schemer, Huang Sichen. Zhilong came forward and said, "Sichen is the man I sent. Grateful for Ying's kindness, I feared he would be transferred away, so I sent him from the capital to inquire. Sichen then spoke falsely and caused this whole affair. Youlong and Kentang reported this to the throne and vigorously cleared Ying's name; Zhilong also submitted a memorial asking to be punished. Because Ying was poor, local gentry and commoners pooled money for his travel expenses, and several thousand elders followed him to the capital to beat the drum of grievance and plead his case. The emperor ordered that he not be imprisoned and that he await further orders at a capital residence. Zhilong's grand marshal title was stripped, and Ying was restored to his former office to inspect the sea routes.
40
使 調 使
Soon, because bandits were rampant in Heng and Yong, Ying was made surveillance commissioner of Huguang with jurisdiction over Hunan and was given an imperial commission. By precedent, regional commissioners did not receive imperial commissions; the emperor made a special exception for him. By then bandits had ravaged more than ten prefectures and counties, while the prefect, judicial assistant, and salt controller of Yongzhou were all unfit for their posts. Ying recommended Suzhou Vice Prefect Yan Rishu and Guide Judicial Assistant Wan Yuanji as men of talent. Both had just been dismissed for unrelated offenses, but on Ying's recommendation both were reappointed. Ying then deployed Zhilong against the bandits; many surrendered, and the region was pacified. He was transferred to right administration commissioner of Shandong with jurisdiction over Deng and Lai.
41
退
In the spring of the fourteenth year he was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief and replaced Xu Renlong as governor of the region. The following year he was transferred to right vice minister of Works at Nanjing and asked for leave to return home. When Shandong first came under attack, the counties under Governor Wang Yongji in Ji, Yan, and Dong prefectures were all lost, yet he concealed the losses and did not report them. When the troops withdrew, he reported the territory as recovered. Ying, by contrast, had lost only a few counties in Qing, Deng, and Lai, and reported the facts exactly as they were. When punishments were meted out, Yongji was actually promoted to governor-general, while Ying was stripped of office and thrown into the Ministry of Justice prison. Within ten days the capital fell; the rebels freed the prisoners, and Ying fled home.
42
使
Later the Prince of Tang proclaimed himself ruler at Fuzhou. Zhilong recommended that Ying be recalled as Minister of Works and Eastern Pavilion grand secretary. Before long he was put in charge of the envoy bureau; soon he was promoted to Junior Mentor, Minister of Personnel, and Wenyuan Pavilion grand secretary. The prince stayed at Yanping and left Ying to hold Fuzhou. When Qing troops took Fuzhou, Ying fled with his family across the sea to Zhongzuo Guard. Five years later, when that place came under attack, he hanged himself.
43
Zhu Jizuo came from Putian. He became a jinshi in the forty-seventh year of Wanli. He was selected as a Hanlin bachelor and appointed compiling editor. During the Tianqi reign he helped compile the Record of Essentials from Three Reigns, but was soon dismissed. At the start of the Chongzhen reign he was restored to office. He rose to right vice minister of Rites and served as chief compiler of the Veritable Records. Supervising Secretary Ge Shu argued that Jizuo, having helped compile the Essentials, had offended the moral critics and should not supervise the national history; the court did not agree. Jizuo soon resigned on grounds of illness. He was recalled as Minister of Rites at Nanjing, but was dismissed again after public outcry. Under the Prince of Fu he was recalled to his former office, but never took up the post. After the Southern Capital fell, the Prince of Tang summoned him as Eastern Pavilion grand secretary, and he followed the prince to Tingzhou. When the prince was captured, Jizuo fled back to his hometown. When the Prince of Lu assumed the regency, Jizuo raised troops in his support and captured Xinghua. Before long Qing troops arrived and the city fell again. Jizuo, along with Administration Commissioner Tang Fen, Supervising Secretary Lin Mei, and Magistrate Du Tingjian, all died in the fighting.
44
Fen, styled Fanghou, came from Jiashan. He became a jinshi in the sixteenth year of Chongzhen. Under the Prince of Fu he served as judicial assistant on Shi Kefa's staff. The Prince of Tang made him a censor. He was soon made circuit intendant for Xing and Quan. When the city fell he sat in the hall in his scarlet official robes and was killed. Mei, styled Xiaomei, came from the same district as Zhu Jizuo. After passing the jinshi examination he was appointed magistrate of Wujiang. When Suzhou fell, he went home and entered the service of the Prince of Tang. At that point he hanged himself. Tingjian, a native of Hangzhou, served as magistrate of Putian.
45
From the first month of the second year of the Prince of Lu's regency, when he reached Changyuan, through the first month of the following year, his forces in succession captured the three prefectures of Jianning, Shaowu, and Xinghua, the department of Funing, and twenty-seven counties including Zhangpu, Haicheng, Lianjiang, and Changle, and military morale rose sharply. By then everything that had been taken was lost again. When Haicheng fell, Magistrate Hong Youwen died defending it. When Yongfu fell, Yan Zhengji, a supervising secretary from the district, and Lin Fengjing, a censor likewise from the district, both drowned themselves. When Changle fell, Wang Enji, a censor from the district, took poison and died, and his wife, Lady Li, died with him. When Jianning fell, the defending general Wang Qi fought street by street but could not hold out, and burned himself to death.
46
Yu Huang, styled Wuzhen, came from Kuaiji. In the fifth year of Tianqi he placed first in the jinshi examination. He was appointed Hanlin compiler and helped compile the Records of Three Reigns. During the Chongzhen reign he returned home to mourn his mother. When his mourning ended he was recalled as Left Assistant Director, then served successively as Left Instructor and Right Vice Director of the Heir Apparent's Household, and lectured at the imperial Classics Colloquium. Supervising Secretary Han Yuan impeached Vice Minister of Rites Wu Shiyuan, Censor Hua Qifang, and Huang for their role in compiling the Records and argued they should be dismissed, but the emperor ignored the charge. Huang submitted a memorial in his own defense, and the emperor again sent him a gracious edict of reassurance. When Minister of Revenue Cheng Guoxiang proposed borrowing the capital's house rents, Huang protested that this must not be allowed and asked leave to return home. He then went into mourning for his father. When his mourning ended he long refused to return to office. When the Prince of Lu assumed the regency at Shaoxing, Huang was summoned as Right Vice Minister of Rites and again as Minister of Revenue, but he accepted neither appointment. The following year, with military officers growing ever more overbearing, Huang was appointed Minister of War and only then accepted office. At the time officials competed shamelessly for high rank, their petitions and requests never satisfied. Huang submitted a memorial: "The realm grows more perilous by the day, court affairs more chaotic, not an inch of territory has been recovered, and there are no resources for war or defense. When officials ask for sacrificial honors, they ought to remember that the former emperor's seasonal offerings are not yet properly arranged; when they ask for burial rites, they ought to remember that the former emperor's tomb has not yet been built; when they ask for enfeoffment, they ought to remember that the former emperor's ancestral temple has not yet received its offerings; when they ask for hereditary privilege, they ought to remember that the former emperor's descendants are not yet secure; when they ask for a posthumous title, they ought to remember that the former emperor's glory has not yet been properly proclaimed. At the time this was regarded as a memorable statement. When Qing troops crossed the Yangzi, the prince fled by sea. On the second day of the sixth month Huang threw himself into the water, but boatmen pulled him out. Two days later he threw himself into deeper water and died.
47
Chen Hanhui, styled Mushu, came from Linhai. He became a jinshi in the seventh year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Jingjiang, but Censor Zuo Guangxian impeached him and had him removed. When the Northern Capital fell, he swore an oath before the people and called for armed resistance. When the Prince of Fu was enthroned, however, unauthorized local levies were forbidden, and he abandoned the effort. He was soon recalled as a principal clerk in the Bureau of Appointments and placed in charge of troops north of the Yangzi. When the campaign failed he returned home, and the Prince of Lu promoted him to Right Vice Minister of Rites. He followed the prince by sea, but they were soon separated; weeping, he entered Yunfeng Mountain, wrote ten final poems, and drowned himself.
48
調 調 調 使
Wang Ruizhan, styled Shengmu, came from Yongjia. He became a jinshi in the fifth year of Tianqi. He was appointed judicial assistant of Suzhou and also oversaw grain exchange and transport. When soldiers and civilians exchanged grain, constant friction between them provoked trouble. Ruizhan managed the exchange skillfully, saving thirty thousand taels in wasteful expenses each year, and his superiors had the regulation carved in stone. When a nobleman's younger brother broke the law, Ruizhan arrested and tried him according to statute. The man slandered him to those in power, a transfer was about to be ordered, and Ruizhan resigned and went home. In the seventh year of Chongzhen he was recalled as judicial assistant of Hejian, then promoted to principal clerk in the Ministry of Works, transferred to the Ministry of War, made assistant department director in the Bureau of Appointments, and elevated to military defense vice commissioner of Huguang, stationed at Xiangyang. In the spring of the eleventh year Zhang Xianzhong held Gucheng and petitioned for surrender, and Grand Coordinator Xiong Wencan agreed. Ruizhan thought this was a mistake and consulted Touring Inspector Lin Mingqiu and Regional Commander Zuo Liangyu about seizing Zhang when he arrived. Xiong Wencan stubbornly refused. Ruizhan said: "The rebel is trying to fool us with a trick, and we must not let ourselves be fooled. Zuo Liangyu and the generals Jia Yixuan and Zhou Shifeng all have troops nearby; if we combine forces and strike, how can we fail? Xiong Wencan grew angry and rebuked him for obstructing the surrender negotiations. Ruizhan replied: "If we appease the rebels before they have been defeated, they will have nothing to fear. Only by showing them we will certainly exterminate them will they submit in heart and dare not rebel again. This is not obstruction but completion of the same policy. Xiong Wencan would not listen. Ruizhan then submitted three plans—follow the campaign, return to farming, and disband—but Xiong Wencan ignored them as well. Ruizhan himself drafted a proclamation to Zhang Xianzhong, but Zhang, counting on Xiong Wencan's protection, ignored it. The following year Zhang Xianzhong rebelled, but Ruizhan had already gone home to mourn his father. Zhang Xianzhong left a letter on the wall declaring that the grand coordinator had driven him to rebel. It listed the names of his superiors and the dates on which they took bribes, and at the end he wrote: "Of all those who refused my gold, only Vice Commissioner Wang did. From this Ruizhan's reputation spread far and wide. When his mourning ended he had not yet been reappointed before the capital fell. Under the Prince of Fu he served as Vice Director of the Imperial Stud, memorialized at length on the abuses of local officials, and soon resigned. The Prince of Tang summoned him to Fujian to his former office, but he soon returned home again. When all of Fujian was lost and Wenzhou too could not be held, he took refuge in the mountains. When someone tried to recommend him to come out of hiding and serve again, he bowed farewell at the family shrine, then calmly went inside and hanged himself.
49
滿
Lu Zhenfei, styled Jianbai, came from Quzhou. He became a jinshi in the fifth year of Tianqi. He was appointed magistrate of Jingyang. Senior officials, currying favor with Wei Zhongxian, planned to build a shrine in Jingyang, but Zhenfei firmly refused. Zhang Wenda, a local man, offended the eunuch faction and was ordered to repay one hundred thousand taels in alleged embezzlement. Zhenfei deliberately delayed the case, and when the eunuch faction fell the matter was dropped. When bandits entered the district, he drove them back. In the fourth year of Chongzhen he was recalled and appointed censor. He memorialized impeaching Zhou Yanru as base, corrupt, treacherous, and dangerous, accusing him of forming factions with the wicked and disgracing the upright, and urging his immediate dismissal to clear the way for worthy ministers; the emperor sharply rebuked him. Before long he set forth ten great abuses of the times: pursuing petty detail while forgetting the substance of government; losing integrity and ruining official conduct; the people growing poorer while levies grow heavier; urgency in crisis but laxness in peace; seeing obvious calamities while forgetting hidden dangers; seeking to govern affairs but rarely governing men; blaming outsiders heavily while going easy on insiders; strict in small matters and lenient in great ones; ministers growing daily more negligent and the sovereign daily more suspicious; edicts issued but never carried out. When the memorial arrived, the emperor ordered it referred to the relevant offices. When Shandong troops mutinied, he impeached Grand Coordinators Yu Dacheng and Sun Yuanhua and accused Zhou Yanru of bending the law to shield the guilty, but the emperor ignored it. Later he impeached Minister of Personnel Min Hongxue for cultivating powerful patrons and planting private clients, arguing that official conduct had worsened daily since Min took charge of appointments; Min resigned. When Xie Sheng, Minister of Personnel at Nanjing, was court-nominated as Left Censor-in-Chief, Zhenfei denounced his misconduct at length, and Xie was not appointed. In the sixth year he served as touring censor in Fujian. The pirate Liu Xiang repeatedly incited the red-haired foreigners to raid the coast; Zhenfei offered a reward of one thousand taels to encourage his troops, dispatched Mobile Corps Commander Zheng Zhilong and others to defeat them decisively, and was rewarded with silver and silks by imperial edict. When his term ended he was selected for appointment as a capital official. Earlier, when Zhenfei discussed the pirate situation, he said Grand Coordinator Zou Weilian was incapable of handling it, and his words gave offense. Zou Weilian was dismissed, but scarcely had the order been issued when repeated reports of victory arrived; Zhenfei then forcefully publicized his achievements, and Zou was recalled.
50
使 祿
In the summer of the eighth year the emperor was about to select new chief ministers. Zhenfei said: "The grand ceremony of selecting ministers by divination will lose its luster if those who creep in by connections attach themselves to it. Men like Zhou Yanru and Wen Tiren before them were abandoned by public opinion; after they took office the people grew destitute and banditry rose—men who disgrace themselves cannot set the realm right. Zhou Yanru had already been dismissed by then, but Wen Tiren was chief minister and bore a grudge against him. Before long, as touring censor in Suzhou and Songjiang, Zhenfei petitioned to abolish four great abuses—cloth delivery, silver collection, white grain, and grain exchange—and the people's hardship was eased. When Qian Qianyi and Qu Shisi of Changshu were denounced by the schemer Zhang Hanru, Wen Tiren blamed Zhenfei for failing to impeach them and drafted an edict ordering him to explain himself. Zhenfei declared Qian Qianyi innocent, and his words cut at Wen Tiren. Wen Tiren, enraged, stirred the emperor's anger and had him demoted to inspecting clerk in the Henan surveillance commission. He was later recalled as Director of the Imperial Park and was promoted repeatedly to Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments.
51
西 宿 使使使宿 竿
In the autumn of the sixteenth year he was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief, placed in charge of the Grand Canal grain transport, and made grand coordinator of Huai and Yang. In the first month of the following year, rebel armies overran Shanxi. Zhenfei sent seventeen officers, including Jin Shenghuan, to defend the river in separate columns from Xu, Si, and Suqian all the way to Andong and Shuyang. He also organized local militia, rewarded them with feasts of beef and wine, and mustered several tens of thousands of tough fighters from the region between the Huai Rivers. The Princes of Fu, Zhou, Lu, and Chong, fleeing the rebels, all reached the Huai region on the same day. The senior generals Liu Zeqing, Gao Jie, and others likewise abandoned their posts along the river and retreated south. Zhenfei welcomed and hosted them all. In early the fourth month, upon hearing that Beijing had fallen, the Prince of Fu was enthroned at Nanjing. Lü Bizhou, vice commissioner of Henan, arrived as the rebels' military governor to replace Zhenfei; the jinshi Wu Su came as their defense commissioner to pacify Xu and Pei; and the rebel general Dong Xueli occupied Suqian. Zhenfei attacked, captured Bizhou and Su, and put Xueli to flight. He had Bizhou hoisted on a pole at the execution ground, ordered every soldier to shoot three arrows at him, and then had him cut apart. Su was bound and paraded through the markets, given eighty lashes, sent to court in a caged cart, and executed. In the fifth month Ma Shiying, wanting to install his protégé Tian Yang, had Zhenfei removed from office. Zhenfei was also in mourning for his mother; with no home to return to, he took refuge in Suzhou. Soon afterward his service was recognized, and he was promoted to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief while still at home.
52
When Zhenfei first took charge of the Grand Canal transport, he visited the imperial tombs at Fengyang. A geomancer declared that the high wall bore the aura of imperial destiny. The Tang Prince Yujian was then imprisoned for a crime and assigned to guard the tombs, where eunuchs mistreated him. Zhenfei memorialized the throne asking that punished members of the imperial clan be broadly pardoned, and his request was granted. In the second year of Shunzhi, the Qing army took Nanjing; Yujian declared himself ruler at Fuzhou and appointed Zhenfei Left Censor-in-Chief. He offered a fifth-rank post and two thousand taels of gold to anyone who could bring Zhenfei to him. Zhenfei answered the summons, and en route was appointed Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent, Minister of Personnel, and Grand Secretary of the Wenyuan Pavilion. When he arrived, the prince was overjoyed. He feasted with him until midnight, then had the candles put out and saw him home, gave him his own jade belt, and appointed one of his sons Secretary in the Bureau of Appointments. His service in defending the Huai region was again recognized with a hereditary commandership in the Embroidered Uniform Guard. The prince often rebuked his ministers for negligence. Zhenfei then said: "Your Majesty says that if officials do not break their habit of drift and delay, ruin will surely follow. I say that if Your Majesty does not change your own harsh impatience, restoration may not be achieved either. Your Majesty has a heart that loves the people, yet no policies that truly benefit them; you are keen to hear advice, yet you never see its effects. You give way to anger and pleasure too easily, and your orders are changed again and again. Seeing that your ministers are mediocre, you press them too hard; because you have read widely in history, you demand exhaustive perfection in everything—each thing Your Majesty prides yourself on is exactly what I most fear. His words, it is said, struck directly at the prince's weaknesses. In the third year the Qing army advanced on Xianxia Pass. Yujian fled to Tingzhou, and Zhenfei rushed after him but could not catch up. When Tingzhou fell, he took refuge on a coastal island. The next year he answered the Yongli King's summons and died on the journey.
53
殿
He Kai, styled Yuanzi, was from Zhenhai Guard in Zhangzhou. He passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of Tianqi. During Wei Zhongxian's corrupt rule, he declined to seek office and returned home. Under Chongzhen he was appointed a secretary in the Ministry of Revenue, promoted to vice director, and then transferred to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Punishments. Rebel armies took Fengyang and desecrated the imperial tombs. Kai impeached Grand Coordinator Yang Yipeng and Investigating Censor Wu Zhenyong, and also attacked chief ministers Wen Tiren and Wang Yingxiong, saying: "Zhenyong is Tiren's private man; Yipeng is Yingxiong's examination patron. Rebels had violated the imperial tombs, provoking outrage in heaven and on earth. Your Majesty suspended court lectures and withdrew from the palace hall, moving officials and commoners alike. Yet the two chief ministers alone treated the matter lightly, wanting Yipeng and Zhenyong to redeem themselves while keeping their posts. Personal connections weighed more heavily than the tombs of the imperial ancestors; their factional ties ran deep, and they cared nothing for the ridicule of the realm. His memorial offended the throne, and he was demoted one rank but allowed to remain in office. He again said: "In their defenses, Yingxiong and Tiren openly invoked their students and in-laws. The judicial officials show favoritism precisely because of this. I beg that the chief ministers be instructed not to treat state affairs as a game of personal favor and enmity. Yingxiong submitted another defense. Kai said: "My memorial has not yet received a response, yet Yingxiong quoted from it a day earlier—someone inside the palace must be leaking confidential documents. The emperor was moved and ordered Yingxiong to explain himself; Yingxiong ultimately left office as a result. Minister of Personnel Xie Sheng said that Dengzhou and Laizhou were vital posts and that Grand Coordinator Chen Yingyuan's request to resign on grounds of illness should be granted. But when Lao Yongjia was recommended to replace Yingyuan, he then argued that the grand coordinator of Deng and Lai was a superfluous post to begin with. Kai also memorialized the throne to refute him. Kai also asked that the late Censor-in-Chief Gao Panlong be granted posthumous honors, that posthumous titles be conferred on Zuo Guangdou and other loyal ministers, and that Hui Shiyang be recalled to office. Many of his memorials were accepted. He was promoted repeatedly to chief supervising secretary in the Bureau of Works.
54
In the fifth month of the eleventh year, because Mars was in retrograde motion, the emperor reduced his meals and undertook self-examination. Minister of War Yang Sichang was then advocating appeasement and repeatedly cited historical precedents in his memorials. Kai and the Nanjing censor Lin Lanyou successively argued against him. Kai said: "Sichang cites the Jianwu-era appeasement of the frontier to justify paying off the enemy, the Yuan dynasty's dealings with Tian Xing to justify pacification, and the repeated defeats of the Taiping Xingguo reign to argue that force cannot be used—nothing but forced analogies. As for his citation of Empress Ma in the second year of Yongping, it is impossible to see what he is even criticizing. The emperor was then shielding Sichang and would not heed the criticism. A month later, when Sichang left mourning early to join the Grand Secretariat, Kai impeached him again. Offending the throne, Kai was demoted two ranks to assistant director of the Nanjing Directorate of Education. He returned home to mourn his mother. When his mourning period ended, court ministers recommended him jointly; he was summoned to the capital, but the city had already fallen.
55
殿 使
The Prince of Fu promoted Kai to Right Vice Minister of Revenue to supervise the coinage system and also appointed him Right Vice Minister of Works. He repeatedly asked to resign, but was refused. In the second year of Shunzhi, when Nanjing fell, Kai fled to Hangzhou. He followed the Tang Prince into Fujian and was promoted to Minister of Revenue. The brothers Zheng Zhilong and Hong Kui were extremely overbearing. When the court performed the suburban sacrifice to Heaven, they claimed illness and stayed away; Kai said Zhilong showed no proper deference of a subject. The prince praised his moral courage and put him in charge of the Censorate. Hong Kui fanned himself in the audience hall; Kai rebuked him and made him stop, and the two brothers grew even angrier. Knowing he could not remain, Kai repeatedly asked to resign. On the road he was ambushed and one ear was cut off—the assailant was Yang Geng, a subordinate general sent by Zhilong. When Zhangzhou fell, Kai died of grief and despair.
56
Kai was deeply learned, reading without pause winter and summer, and was especially accomplished in classical studies.
57
祿
Lin Lanyou, styled Hanquan, was from Xianyou. He passed the jinshi examination in the fourth year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Lingui. He was promoted to censor at Nanjing. In a memorial he impeached Grand Secretaries Zhang Zhifa and Xue Guoguan, Minister of Personnel Tian Weijia, and others, arguing that Sichang had failed in both loyalty and filial duty. He was demoted to registrar in the Zhejiang surveillance commission and, together with Kai, Huang Daozhou, Liu Tongsheng, and Zhao Shichun, was known as the Five Remonstrators of Chang'an. He was transferred to assistant director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments. When the capital fell, he went into hiding. He was captured by the rebels and tortured severely. When the rebels were defeated, he returned south. The Tang Prince appointed him Vice Director of the Court of the Imperial Stud and later promoted him to Vice Censor-in-Chief. When the cause failed, he fled with his family to the coast and died there more than ten years later.
58
Xiong Rulin, styled Yuyin, was from Yuyao. He passed the jinshi examination in the fourth year of Chongzhen. He was appointed magistrate of Tong'an. He was promoted to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Revenue. In a memorial he set forth the failures in appointing generals, saying: "From company commander to vice general, a man should have served in successive posts with proven merit before being given command of troops. Now, before their feet have even touched a battlefield, headquarters already reports their victories. Clerks lead crack troops and pampered sons hold military seals—how can they be expected to fight with righteous fury? In choosing senior generals, the court should summon vice generals with proven records, grant them audience from time to time, and appoint the most capable. When court ministers make bad recommendations, the law making recommending officials jointly liable should be applied. The emperor accepted his advice. Later he said: "Yang Sichang has not been punished and Lu Xiangsheng has not been rewarded—this greatly undermines the spirit of loyal service. The former supervising secretary Shen Xun was the one who devised for Yang Sichang the plan to levy training funds and drove the common people of the Central Plains into rebellion. The supervising recorder chief registrar Yu Jue was the one who handled Yang Sichang's planning, garrisoned three thousand men at Xiangyang, and fled at every fallen city. Song Yihe—now removed from office and awaiting a successor—was the one Yang Sichang promoted, who survived the fall of the Xiang princely establishment, bribed Chen Xinjia heavily, and shifted the blame onto Yun commissioner Yuan Jixian. All were ministers who had harmed the state and deserved punishment. No response was issued.
59
When the capital was placed under martial law, Xiong Rulin was assigned to guard the Dongzhimen gate. On one occasion he was summoned for an audience and said: "The generals do not take responsibility for fighting. The enemy ranged north and south while our troops merely trailed behind—like lackeys escorting a noble, crossbows shouldered yet unable even to catch the enemy's dust. What does it mean to be called a general, or a supreme commander? The emperor agreed heartily. Later he said: "Officials whom the regular authorities have investigated and censured must not be recklessly recommended as frontier talents; officials whom surveillance commissioners have investigated and censured must not be hurriedly promoted to provincial governor. Only then would frontier command not become a back door for unworthy men. He also said: "Since martial law was declared, I have submitted twenty memorials in all. Of my proposals for relief and suppression, scarcely one in a hundred has been adopted. Yet what I foresaw of the enemy's movements has, alas, proved all too accurate. Lately refugees from outlying counties have poured into the capital; they all say they are fleeing our own troops, not the enemy. When Bazhou fell, the enemy had barely begun to kill and plunder; it was the government troops who arrived afterward and left no one alive. The court spends millions each year to maintain armies—is it meant to destroy our own people? The emperor took offense at a phrase about weeping in the grave and demoted him to proofreader in the Fujian provincial surveillance commission.
60
仿{}
When the Prince of Fu was enthroned, Xiong Rulin was recalled to office. He submitted a memorial saying: "Coming from Danyang, I learned that Zhejiang troops were attacked by frontier troops, who burned civilian dwellings over more than ten li. A frontier commander was heard to say: 'The Four Garrisons won noble ranks through killing and plunder—why should I hesitate to do likewise?' I had expected the Four Garrisons to march north resolutely and wipe away this shame; why do they now linger in Huai and Yang? Moreover, the pay for a single garrison runs as high as six hundred thousand taels—the court cannot possibly sustain it. Even under the old frontier-garrison system, bases should be opened north of the Yellow River; instead they are stationed deep in the interior and treated merely as an outer rampart. Shortly afterward he said: "From what I have observed of the present situation, recovery is out of reach—and even a divided peace is not yet assured. The court should be debating daily how to supply troops and defend the realm; instead it fixates on private feuds and factional rivalry. Ennobled generals of the regional commands brandish sharp tongues and sharper pens; lately they have used anonymous placards to purge veteran ministers and, invoking distant imperial clansmen, impeached the chief ministers. Inside and outside the court there is uproar, and many fear the secret police will be restored. The secret police built power and extracted profit until common folk could not live in peace. The late emperor abolished only this institution, yet even that aroused resentment among officials. The recent past is not far off—let it be a warning for what comes next. The late emperor cherished the imperial clans, yet at word of bandits they fled first—who then would die for the realm? The late emperor honored military men, yet defection, arrogance, and insubordination followed one upon another. The late emperor entrusted ennobled commanders, yet the capital army's finest troops became bandits' spoils. The late emperor relied on inner eunuchs, yet gates were opened to the enemy—a story on everyone's lips. The late emperor promoted civil officials out of turn, yet among frontier grand coordinators and governors, who defended the borders? Those hurled into high office bowed in ranks at the rebels' court. To understand why we lost the realm is to understand how we may yet hold what remains. If not now, then when? After the memorial was submitted, his salary was suspended. He was soon appointed right supervising secretary in the Bureau of Personnel.
61
使 便滿
At first, when Ma Shiying recommended Ruan Dacheng, Xiong Rulin argued forcefully against it. When Ruan Dacheng was appointed to assist the Ministry of War, Xiong Rulin said again: "Ruan is being used for his military knowledge and should be posted where he can be useful, not kept at the central court. The court would not listen. A month later, taking leave of the throne on a diplomatic mission, he said: "Court debate grows more fractious by the day, and palace and ministry read each other's moods ever more shrewdly. The vice-minister and Secretariat second-rank posts no longer go through court recommendation; fourth-rank surveillance commissioners are being promoted straight to Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent. Back channels multiply, and slander runs rampant. If one man is passed over, the whole court is branded a faction; if one official is posted elsewhere, the men in charge are denounced as deserving death. National mourning is ignored while private schemes succeed. Gold and silver fill the halls, green and purple robes choke the roads—the decadence of the Six Dynasties has returned. Have they no thought of where they will rest when this is over? No response was issued.
62
Before long Nanjing fell, and Ma Shiying fled to Hangzhou. Xiong Rulin rebuked him for abandoning his sovereign; Ma Shiying had no answer. When Hangzhou also fell, he raised troops together with Sun Jiaji. When the Prince of Lu assumed regency, Xiong Rulin was promoted to right vice censor-in-chief, placed in supreme command of river defense, and suffered repeated defeats. He went to Haining to raise ten thousand troops and was promoted to right vice minister of war. When the Prince of Tang was enthroned in Fujian and sent Liu Zhongzao to promulgate an edict, Xiong Rulin issued a proclamation firmly refusing obedience. In the third year of Shunzhi he was promoted to minister of war and followed the Prince of Lu to sea. The following year he was also made Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion while retaining his original post. In the spring of the following year, Zheng Cai, bearing a grudge against Xiong Rulin, sent men in secret to murder him and cast his young son into the sea.
63
Qian Sule, styled Xisheng, was from Yin county. He was the grandson of Ruogeng, prefect of Linjiang, and nephew of Jingzhong, prefect of Ningguo. He passed the jinshi examination in the tenth year of Chongzhen and was appointed prefect of Taicang. Great-house slaves and cunning clerks conspired in wrongdoing, while violent men formed gangs to murder people and burn the bodies. Qian Sule punished them severely, and all ceased their outrages. He also posted red and white lists naming the good and the bad; those on the white list he shackled before the hall and had beaten severely. In time, the number beaten each day steadily declined. He once served concurrently in Kunshan and Chongming, and the people of both counties erected steles in his honor. He was transferred to vice director in the Ministry of Justice, then soon entered mourning for both parents in succession.
64
In the second year of Shunzhi, the Qing army took Hangzhou, and many neighboring prefectures surrendered. In the intercalary sixth month, Ningbo's local gentry debated submitting to the Qing, but Qian Sule urged resistance and raising troops. The licentiates Hua Xia, Dong Zhining, and others intercepted the road to pay homage to Qian Sule as their leader; tens of thousands of townsfolk gathered, and he then raised his command standard and took charge. The surveillance commissioners, prefects, and magistrates of the prefecture all fled; only one vice-prefect remained to manage affairs. Qian Sule secured the warehouse registers, repaired defensive stores, and allied with regional commander Wang Zhiren to hold the city together. Hearing that the Prince of Lu was at Taizhou, he sent the presented scholar Zhang Huangyan with a memorial asking him to assume regency. When Shaoxing and Yuyao also rose in arms, the prince went to Shaoxing to assume regency. Qian Sule was summoned as right vice censor-in-chief and tasked with defending the Qiantang line. He was soon promoted to right assistant censor-in-chief. At that time Wang Zhiren and the great general Fang Guo'an were both ennobled; their troops were fed from the land tax of Ningbo, Shaoxing, and Taizhou, which could not sustain them, and they were chronically short of rations. Later he was also made right vice minister of war. In the fifth month of the following year, provisions ran out and the troops were all dispersed. When the Prince of Lu took to the sea, Qian Sule went to Zhoushan as well. The Prince of Tang summoned him, but he had barely entered Fujian when the prince died. He then hid on Haitan Mountain and lived on wild yams. The following year, when the Prince of Lu put in at Changyuan, Qian Sule was summoned as minister of war and recommended Liu Yichun, Wu Zhongluan, and others for office. The year after that, Qian Sule was appointed Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion.
65
歿
Though the Prince of Tang was dead, his general Xu Denghua still held Funing; the Prince of Lu sent Grand Secretary Liu Zhongzao to besiege him. Xu Denghua wished to surrender but hesitated, saying: "Can there be a Son of Heaven on the open sea? Can there be a grand duke aboard a ship? Qian Sule wrote in reply: "General, have you never heard that at the end of the Southern Song both emperors were aboard ship together?" Xu Denghua then surrendered. Zheng Cai seized sole power and sequentially murdered Xiong Rulin and Zheng Zunqian. Qian Sule died aboard ship of grief and anger; Jin Sheng, a great-grandson of the former chief minister Ye Xianggao, buried him on Huangbo Mountain in Fuqing.
66
Liu Zhongzao was a native of Fu'an. After passing the jinshi examination he was appointed court courier. When rebels took the capital, he was en route on his mission and was beaten and robbed. After the rebels were defeated and withdrew south, he entered the service of the Prince of Tang. He later served the Prince of Lu, captured and held Funing, and moved his headquarters to Fu'an. When the Qing army stormed the city, he donned his official cap and sash, sat in the hall, wrote a final lament, and killed himself by swallowing gold dust.
67
Zheng Zunqian came from Kuaiji. He was a degree candidate. After the Prince of Lu surrendered Hangzhou to the Qing, Zunqian rallied local forces for the Prince of Lu and fought a hard campaign across Zhejiang and Fujian. He followed the prince overseas and, like Xiong Rulin, was murdered by Zheng Cai.
68
谿 使
Shen Chenquan came from Cixi. He became a jinshi in the thirteenth year of Chongzhen. Appointed a court courier, he was sent on a mission and then returned to his home district. When the Prince of Fu took the throne, he returned to court. Promoted to censor, he submitted a memorial on five urgent reforms, each aimed at the day's gravest abuses. He went on to denounce ministers who had perverted justice and sheltered the wicked, and urged the prince to endure hardship and plan for national revenge. He soon recommended such scholar-officials as Huang Daozhou, Liu Tongsheng, Ge Shijun, Xu Kan, and Wu Weiye. He also wrote: The men entrusted with Shandong and Henan are Wang Yongji and Zhang Jinyan. Yongji failed when it mattered; the late emperor made him supreme commander, yet with an army near the capital he did nothing as the realm collapsed. Jinyan was only a ministry clerk when the late emperor suddenly put him at the head of the secretariat, yet he was among the first to submit to the rebels. The severest punishment for both men would not be excessive. Your Majesty bent the law to keep them in office, yet Yongji still hesitates and delays while Jinyan flees south in disgrace. How can they face the late emperor in death, or face Your Majesty in life? He Qian, grand coordinator of Changping, allowed the imperial tombs to fall, and his crime should be punished as well. After the capital fell, every territorial official should have armed for national revenge, yet many fled before the enemy even approached and set a cowardly example for the people. Can men such as Canal Supreme Commander Huang Xixian and Shandong Grand Coordinator Qiu Zude still be allowed to idle at home! When the memorial arrived, Qian, Zude, and others were ordered arrested, but Yongji and Jinyan went unpunished. With court affairs in chaos, Chenquan alone held firm, and the powerful mostly turned against him. The following year he left the capital under the regular rotation to become military intendant of Suzhou and Songjiang. Before he could take up the post, the Southern Capital fell, and Chenquan raised troops in his home district. When the Prince of Lu became regent, he was made right vice censor-in-chief. When the cause collapsed, Chenquan left his family and followed the prince to sea. When the prince based himself at Changyuan, Chenquan rose in succession to grand secretary. He followed the prince to Zhoushan, then sailed on to Xiamen and Jinmen. Later, when their vessel anchored off Nanzhi Mountain, a storm overtook them and Chenquan was lost at sea.
69
His fellow townsman Shen Lüxiang had served as magistrate and, during the regency, was made censor to oversee supplies at Taizhou. When the city fell he hid in the hills, was captured, and executed.
70
The commentator says: After 1644 the Ming mandate was spent; within a year the Southern Capital fell as well, and nothing more could realistically be done. Zhu Dadian, Zhang Guowei, and others clung to a private sense of duty, propping up empty titles along the coast merely to survive from day to day. With superiors in decline and subordinates out of control, and with no order left in affairs, how could they hope to secure even a partial restoration?
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →