← Back to 明史

卷三百二十二 列傳第二百一十 外國三 日本

Volume 322 Biographies 210: Foreign States 3 - Japan

Chapter 322 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 322
Next Chapter →
1
使
Japan was formerly known as the land of Wo. In the early Xianheng period of the Tang dynasty, the name was changed to Japan, so called because the country lies near the Eastern Sea where the sun rises. The country is surrounded by sea, with great mountains marking its northeastern frontier. It is divided into the five capital circuits, seven roads, and three islands, comprising one hundred fifteen provinces and five hundred eighty-seven districts in all. Dozens of lesser states all acknowledge its authority. The smallest domains measure a hundred li across; the largest scarcely reach five hundred. The least populous have a thousand households; most have no more than ten or twenty thousand. The royal house bears the surname Wang by hereditary succession, and ministerial offices are likewise hereditary. Before the Song dynasty Japan maintained continuous contact with China through tribute missions, as detailed in earlier histories. Under the Yuan, Kublai Khan repeatedly sent Zhao Liangbi to summon Japan to submit, but the Japanese refused. He then ordered Xin Du, Fan Wenhu, and others to lead a fleet of one hundred thousand men against them; at Mount Wulong a violent storm struck, and the entire force perished. Further summons went unanswered, and throughout the Yuan dynasty the two countries had no diplomatic contact.
2
沿
When the Ming dynasty was founded and the Hongwu Emperor took the throne, Fang Guozhen and Zhang Shicheng were defeated in turn. Dispossessed warlords often rallied Japanese islanders to raid the coastal prefectures and counties of Shandong. In the third month of Hongwu year 2, the emperor sent the emissary Yang Zai with an edict to Japan, demanding an explanation for the raids. He declared: If you wish to submit, come to court; if not, strengthen your defenses. If you persist in piracy, I shall send generals to campaign against you. Your Majesty, weigh this carefully. The Japanese king Ashikaga did not obey. He raided Shandong again, then turned to plunder coastal communities near Wenzhou, Taizhou, and Mingzhou, and finally attacked the coastal prefectures of Fujian.
3
使 使 使 使西使
In the third month of year 3 the court again sent Zhao Zhi, associate prefect of Laizhou, to rebuke Japan. He sailed to Ximu Cliff and entered Japanese territory, but border guards refused him entry. Zhao Zhi sent a letter to Ashikaga, who then received him. Zhao Zhi expounded on the majesty and virtue of China, while the edict rebuked Japan for refusing to submit. Ashikaga replied: Though our country lies east of Fusang, we have always admired China. But the Mongols are barbarians like us, yet they sought to reduce us to vassalage. Our former king refused to submit. They sent a minister named Zhao to lure us with fair words, but before he had finished speaking, a fleet of one hundred thousand men lined our shores. By Heaven's grace, thunder and towering waves destroyed the entire army at once. Now a new Son of Heaven reigns over China, and your envoy is also surnamed Zhao—are you Mongols as well? Will you likewise entice us with fair words and then strike? He then ordered his attendants to summon troops. Zhao Zhi remained unmoved and replied calmly: The Son of Heaven of Great Ming is divine, sagely, civil, and martial—nothing like the Mongols. Nor am I any successor to their envoys. If you wish to fight, then make war on us. Ashikaga's defiance collapsed. He came down from the hall to receive Zhao Zhi and treated him with exceptional courtesy. He sent the monk Zulai with a memorial submitting as a vassal, tribute horses and local products, and returned more than seventy captives taken from Mingzhou and Taizhou. The embassy reached the capital in the tenth month of year 4. The Hongwu Emperor commended this and feasted the envoys. Reflecting that the Japanese were devoted to Buddhism and might be won over through religion, he sent eight monks including Zuchan and Keqin to escort the embassy home, and granted Ashikaga the Datong Calendar along with brocades, gauzes, and silks. That same year Japanese raiders attacked Wenzhou. In year 5 they raided Haiyan and Ganpu, then struck the coastal prefectures of Fujian. In year 6 Yu Xian was appointed commander-in-chief to patrol the coast against Japanese pirates, but the Japanese nonetheless raided Laizhou and Dengzhou. When Zuchan and his companions arrived, they preached in Japan, and the people received the teaching with considerable respect. The king, however, was arrogant and discourteous, and detained them for two years before they returned to the capital in the fifth month of year 7. Japanese raiders attacked Jiaozhou.
4
使 使 使 滿 使 滿 宿
Ashikaga was then young, and rivals who supported the Southern Court contested the succession, throwing the country into civil strife. In the seventh month of that year his ministers sent the monks Xuanwenxi and others with a letter to the Secretariat, horses and local products as tribute, but no formal memorial of submission. The emperor ordered the tribute refused but still bestowed gifts on the envoys and sent them home. Soon afterward Uji, a guardian official of another island, sent monks with a memorial offering tribute. Because the mission lacked the king's authorization and did not observe the Chinese calendar, the emperor refused this tribute as well, though he still rewarded the envoys. The Ministry of Rites was ordered to send a dispatch rebuking the impropriety of unauthorized private tribute. Because of repeated raids, the Secretariat was also ordered to send a dispatch of rebuke. In the fourth month of year 9 they sent the monks Guitingyong and others with tribute and an apology. The emperor found the memorial insincere and issued an edict of admonition, but still feasted and rewarded the envoys according to protocol. In year 12 they sent tribute again. In year 13 they sent tribute again without a memorial, presenting only a letter from the shogun Ashikaga Yoshimitsu to the chief minister—and its tone was again arrogant. The court refused the tribute and sent envoys with an edict of rebuke. In year 14 they sent tribute once more. The emperor refused it again and ordered the Ministry of Rites to rebuke both the king and the shogun, making clear his intent to launch a punitive campaign. Ashikaga submitted a memorial: I have heard that the Three Sovereigns established order and the Five Emperors passed down the regalia. China has its sovereign—but are we barbarians without rulers of our own? Heaven and earth are vast; sovereignty is not the monopoly of a single ruler. The cosmos is wide, and many realms were made to govern their own domains. All-under-Heaven belongs to all the world—not to one man alone. I dwell in distant, feeble Japan, a small and narrow realm with fewer than sixty walled towns and a frontier of less than three thousand li—yet I am content with what I have. Your Majesty reigns as sovereign of China, lord of ten thousand chariots, with thousands of walled cities and a frontier of a million li—yet you are never satisfied and constantly harbor designs to destroy us. When Heaven unleashes the engines of destruction, the stars shift and constellations change. When earth unleashes the engines of destruction, dragons and serpents course over the land. When man unleashes the engines of destruction, heaven and earth are overturned. In antiquity Yao and Shun ruled with virtue, and the four seas came as guests. Tang and Wu practiced benevolence, and the eight directions offered tribute.
5
滿 使
I have heard that the celestial court has strategies for waging war—but small states too have plans for defense. In letters you have the moral writings of Confucius and Mencius; in warfare you have the strategic arts of Sunzi and Wuzi. I hear also that Your Majesty has chosen your finest generals and raised elite troops to invade my realm. Our watery marshes and mountain isles have defenses of their own. Would we kneel in the road and submit? Submission does not guarantee survival, nor does resistance guarantee death. Let us meet before Mount Helan and settle this as a contest of arms—what have I to fear? If you prevail and I am defeated, that will satisfy the celestial court. If I prevail and you are defeated, that would be the disgrace of a great power humbled by a small state. From antiquity peace has been held supreme and ending war the mark of strength, sparing the people from slaughter and relieving the common folk from suffering. I therefore send envoys to bow before your throne and ask that the celestial court give this matter your consideration. The emperor was furious when he received the memorial, but reflecting on the Mongol precedent, he ultimately refrained from sending troops.
6
使 西
In year 16 Japanese raiders attacked Jinxiang and Pingyang. In year 19 they sent tribute envoys, but the court refused them. The following year he ordered Marquis Jiangxia Zhou Dexing to survey the terrain of Fujian's four coastal commanderies. Guard posts not sited at strategic points were relocated. One man in every three households was levied for coastal defense. Sixteen walled posts were built, forty-five inspection offices added, and more than fifteen thousand garrison troops raised. He also ordered Duke Xinguo Tang He to inspect the eastern and western prefectures of Zhejiang and reorganize coastal defenses, building fifty-nine fortified posts. From households with four adult males or more, one was conscripted, yielding fifty-eight thousand seven hundred men distributed among the coastal guards. Coastal defenses were thoroughly reorganized. In the intercalary sixth month he ordered Fujian to prepare one hundred seagoing vessels and Guangdong twice that number, to join Zhejiang in a ninth-month campaign against Japanese pirates—but the plan was never executed.
7
使 使
Earlier, Hu Weiyong had plotted rebellion and sought Japanese support. He cultivated ties with Lin Xian, commander of the Ningbo Guard, then falsely accused him and banished him to Japan to negotiate with the Japanese court. He soon had Lin Xian restored to office and recalled him, while secretly sending the Japanese king a letter requesting military aid. When Lin Xian returned, the Japanese king sent the monk Ruyao with more than four hundred armed men, pretending to offer tribute. They brought enormous candles concealing gunpowder, swords, and blades. By the time they arrived, Hu Weiyong had already been overthrown and the plot failed. The emperor was still unaware of the conspiracy. Several years later the plot was exposed. Lin Xian's entire clan was executed, and the emperor's wrath toward Japan was especially fierce. He resolved to sever relations and devoted himself entirely to coastal defense. At that time, however, the Japanese prince Teng Youshou entered the Imperial University, and the emperor still treated him kindly. In the fifth month of year 24 he was specially appointed Observation Commissioner and retained at court. Later, in the Ancestral Injunctions, he listed fifteen countries that were not to be attacked, and Japan was among them. Thereafter tribute missions ceased, and coastal alarms gradually subsided.
8
使 使 使 使 使
When the Yongle Emperor took the throne, he sent envoys with an accession edict to Japan. In Yongle 1 he again sent Left Bureau Commissioner Zhao Juren, Emissary Zhang Hong, and the monk Daocheng. Before they could depart, Japanese tribute envoys had already reached Ningbo. Minister of Rites Li Zhigang memorialized: By precedent, foreign envoys entering China may not privately carry weapons to sell to the populace. The responsible offices should be ordered to inspect their vessels, and all contraband seized and sent to the capital. The emperor replied: Foreign peoples undertaking tribute missions brave great perils traveling from afar, at considerable expense. It is only natural that they bring goods to defray their expenses. They cannot all be bound by rigid prohibitions. As for their weapons, let them be purchased at fair market price, and do not obstruct those who seek to submit. In the tenth month the envoys arrived, presenting a memorial from King Ashikaga Michiyoshi along with tribute goods. The emperor received them with great honor, sent officials to escort the embassy home, and granted Michiyoshi court robes, a gold seal with tortoise knob, and brocades, gauzes, and silks.
9
使 使 使 使
The following year, in the eleventh month, they came to congratulate the investiture of the crown prince. At that time pirates from Tsushima, Tashima, and other islands were raiding coastal communities, and the emperor instructed the Japanese king to capture them. The king sent troops who exterminated the pirates, captured twenty of their leaders, and presented them at court in the eleventh month of year 3, while also renewing tributary relations. The emperor was greatly pleased. He sent Vice Minister Pan Ci of the Court of State Ceremonial and the eunuch Wang Jin to grant the king ceremonial robes bearing the nine insignia of rank, along with paper money, brocades, and silks of the highest grade. He also returned the captives they had presented, instructing Japan to deal with them under its own laws. When the envoys reached Ningbo, they placed every one of the captives in steamers and steamed them alive. The following year, in the first month, Vice Minister Yu Shiji was sent again with a sealed imperial letter of praise, and lavish gifts were granted. A mountain in Japan was enfeoffed as Mount Shou'an, Guardian of the Realm. The emperor composed an inscription in his own hand and had it erected on the peak. In the sixth month, envoys arrived to express gratitude, and ceremonial robes were granted. In the fifth and sixth years they sent tribute repeatedly and also presented the sea pirates they had captured. On their return, the envoys asked for the two books composed by Empress Renxiao, Exhortation to Goodness and Inner Admonitions. The emperor at once ordered a hundred copies of each to be provided. In the eleventh month they presented tribute once more. In the twelfth month, the heir Yoshimochi sent envoys to announce his father's death. The emperor ordered the eunuch Zhou Quan to perform the mourning rites, granted the late king the posthumous title Gongxian, and sent funeral gifts. Officials were again sent with an imperial edict investing Yoshimochi as King of Japan. At that time fresh warnings of Japanese piracy arrived from the coast, and the court again sent officials instructing Yoshimochi to hunt the raiders down.
10
使 使 使使 使
In the fourth month of the eighth year, Yoshimochi sent envoys to give thanks. Soon afterward he presented captured sea pirates, and the emperor praised the gesture. The following year, in the second month, Wang Jin was sent again with an imperial edict bearing praise and gifts, and to purchase trade goods. The king and his ministers plotted to hold Jin back and keep him from returning. Jin secretly boarded a ship and fled home by another route. After that, Japan sent no tribute for many years. That year Japanese pirates attacked Panshi. In the fifteenth year, Japanese pirates raided Songmen, Jinxiang, and Pingyang. Some officials captured several dozen Japanese pirates and brought them to the capital. Court officials asked that the captives be punished under the law. The emperor said, "It is better to win them with kindness than to overawe them with punishment. They should be sent back." He then ordered Vice Minister of Justice Lü Yuan and others to carry an imperial edict of rebuke, commanding the pirates to repent and reform. Chinese subjects who had been abducted were also to be returned. The following year, in the fourth month, the king sent envoys to present tribute alongside Lü Yuan's party, explaining: "Sea pirates swarm everywhere, so tribute missions cannot reach Your Majesty. As for those worthless petty thieves, I truly know nothing of them. I beg forgiveness for my offenses and ask that tribute missions be allowed to resume." The emperor, finding the reply conciliatory, agreed. The envoys were received with the usual ceremony, but piracy on the seas did not stop.
11
In the seventeenth year, Japanese ships entered Wangjiashan Island. Regional Commander Liu Rong led elite troops in a forced march to Wanghaigang. Several thousand raiders in twenty boats made straight for Maxiong Island and then pressed on to besiege Wanghaigang. Rong sprung his ambush and gave battle; a flanking force cut off the enemy's retreat. The raiders fled to Cherry Orchard. Rong united his forces and attacked, beheading seven hundred forty-two men and taking eight hundred fifty-seven alive. Rong was summoned to court and enfeoffed as Marquis of Guangning. After that, the Japanese pirates no longer dared threaten Liaodong. In the twentieth year, Japanese pirates raided Xiangshan.
12
使 使
In the first month of the seventh year of Xuande, the emperor noted that tributary states from every direction had come to court while Japan alone had long stayed away. He ordered the eunuch Chai Shan to go to Ryukyu and have its king convey a message to Japan, along with an imperial edict. The following summer, King Ashikaga Yoshinori sent envoys. The emperor replied with gifts of silver and colored silks. In the autumn they came again. In the tenth month of the tenth year, when Emperor Yingzong succeeded to the throne, they sent envoys to present tribute.
13
使
In the fourth year of Jingtai they sent tribute, but on reaching Linqing they looted local residents' goods. A commander went to question them and was nearly beaten to death. The local authorities asked to arrest and punish them, but the emperor, fearing he would lose the goodwill of distant peoples, refused. Earlier, at the start of Yongle, an edict had fixed tribute from Japan at once every ten years, with no more than two hundred men and two ships, and forbade the carrying of weapons. Violators were to be treated as pirates. Two vessels were then granted for tribute missions, but afterward the Japanese consistently violated the rules. At the beginning of Xuande the terms were tightened again: no more than three hundred persons and three ships. But the Japanese, greedy for profit, carried private merchandise ten times the volume of tribute goods, all of which by precedent had to be purchased at fair price. The Ministry of Rites reported: "During Xuande, tribute items such as sulfur, sappanwood, swords, fans, and lacquerware were appraised at market value and paid in paper money or cloth and silk. The sums were modest, yet the Japanese already made enormous profit. If we now pay according to the old scale, the amount would be two hundred seventeen thousand in cash, with silver at equivalent value. The price should be sharply reduced, to a little over thirty-four thousand seven hundred taels of silver." The proposal was approved. The envoy was displeased and asked that the old rate be restored. An edict added ten thousand in cash, but he still considered it insufficient and asked for more gifts. Another edict added fifteen hundred units of cloth and silk. He left still resentful.
14
使使 使使
At the beginning of Tianshun, King Ashikaga Yoshimasa, whose earlier envoys had offended the Ming court but been pardoned, wished to send a mission of apology but did not dare approach directly. He wrote to the King of Korea asking him to intercede, and Korea relayed the request. The court deliberated and ordered Korea to verify the facts and to choose sober, responsible men as envoys who would not repeat their earlier misconduct. Even so, no tribute mission came.
15
使 便 使 使 使 使 使
In the summer of the fourth year of Chenghua, envoys finally arrived with horses to express gratitude. They were received according to regulation. Three interpreters said they were originally villagers from Ningbo, kidnapped as children by pirates and sold in Japan. They asked permission to visit home by a convenient route to tend family graves, and the request was granted. They were warned not to bring the envoys to their homes or induce Chinese subjects to go to sea. In the eleventh month the envoy Kiyohiro came again with tribute and injured people in the market. Local authorities asked that he be punished. An edict referred the matter to Kiyohiro, who replied that offenders should be judged under Japanese law and asked that they be allowed to return home for trial. He also confessed his own failure to restrain his men. The emperor pardoned everyone involved. After that, the envoys grew ever bolder. In the ninth month of the thirteenth year they came with tribute and asked for Buddhist works including the Universal Chronicle of the Buddha. An edict granted them the Pearl Forest of the Dharma Garden instead. The envoy conveyed his king's wish for extra gifts beyond the usual allowance, and an order was issued granting fifty thousand strings of cash. In the eleventh month of the twentieth year they sent tribute again. In the third month of the ninth year of Hongzhi, King Ashikaga Yoshihisa sent envoys. On the return journey, when they reached Jining, his subordinates again drew swords and killed people. The local authorities asked that they be punished. An edict ruled that henceforth only fifty men might enter the capital; the rest were to remain aboard ship under strict guard. In the winter of the eighteenth year they came with tribute. Emperor Wuzong had already ascended the throne, so they were received according to precedent and a gold tally of verification was cast and granted.
16
殿西 使 使 使 使使
In the winter of the fourth year of Zhengde they came with tribute. The Ministry of Rites reported: "In the first month of next year, after the great sacrifice there will be the celebratory banquet. Korean envoys sit in the seventh rank on the east side of the extended hall. Japan has no established place. We ask that they be assigned the seventh rank on the west side." The request was approved. The Ministry of Rites also reported: "Japan's tribute missions have customarily used three ships; this time there is only one. The silver and silks granted should match the number of ships. Moreover, they have brought no memorial. Whether to grant an imperial edict is for Your Majesty to decide." An order was issued for the relevant offices to reply by official dispatch. In the spring of the fifth year, King Ashikaga Yoshizumi sent the envoy Song Suqing with tribute. Liu Jin was then wielding power behind the throne; he accepted a thousand taels of gold from Suqing and granted him flying-fish robes — an honor without precedent. Suqing was a son of the Zhu family of Yin County, born Gao. In youth he trained in song and dance. Japanese envoys took a liking to him, but Gao's uncle Cheng owed them money, so Gao was handed over to settle the debt. By then he had become chief envoy. When he reached Suzhou, Cheng came to see him. When the affair later came to light, the law called for his death. Liu Jin protected him, claiming Cheng had already surrendered, and both men were pardoned. In the seventh year, Yoshizumi's envoys came again with tribute. Zhejiang officials reported: "Bandits now fill the capital region and Shandong. We fear the envoys may be robbed on the road. We ask that tribute goods be stored in Zhejiang's official warehouses and the memorial sent on to the capital." The Ministry of Rites and the Ministry of War jointly recommended that the Nanjing garrison commander entertain and reward the envoys on the spot and send them home, paying full value for all attached goods and not discouraging distant peoples from submitting. The recommendation was approved.
17
使 西 西 使使 使
In the fifth month of the second year of Jiajing, the tribute envoy Sōsetsu reached Ningbo. Soon afterward Suqing arrived with Mizuo, and the two parties disputed which mission was authentic. Suqing bribed the maritime trade eunuch Lai En. At the banquet Suqing was seated above Sōsetsu, and though his ship arrived later it was inspected and cleared first. Sōsetsu flew into a rage and fought him, killing Mizuo, burning their ship, and chasing Suqing to the walls of Shaoxing. Suqing hid elsewhere and escaped. The violent faction returned to Ningbo, burning and looting as they went, seized Commander Yuan Jin, and took ships out to sea. Regional Commander Liu Jin pursued them to sea and was killed in action. Censor Ouyang Zhu reported the affair and added: "According to Suqing, a man named Yixing of the Tara clan on the Western Sea route had long been under Japanese control and had no right to send tribute. Because the tribute route had to pass through the Western Sea, the Zhengde tally plates were seized. We had no choice but to use the Hongzhi tally plates and sail by the Southern Sea route. When we reached Ningbo and were challenged as impostors, violence broke out. The memorial went to the Ministry of Rites, which ruled: "Suqing's account cannot be trusted; he should not be allowed to enter court. Yet the provocation began with Sōsetsu, and many of Suqing's men were killed. Though Suqing had once committed the crime of going over to the Japanese, he had already been pardoned in the previous reign and should not be prosecuted. Simply order Suqing to return home and send a dispatch to his king instructing him to verify the tally plates and punish those responsible." The emperor had already approved when Censor Xiong Lan and Submitter Zhang Chong jointly memorialized: "Suqing's crimes are too grave to pardon. We ask that Lai En, Maritime Deputy Commissioner Zhang Qin, Regional Vice Commissioner Zhu Mingyang, Circuit Vice Commissioner Xu Wan, and Regional Commander Zhang Hao also be punished. Close the borders, cut off tribute, assert the dignity of the empire, and frustrate the designs of cunning pirates. While the matter was still under deliberation, a boat carrying Nakabayashi and Mogadorō, who had escaped from Sōsetsu's faction, was blown by storm to Korea. Koreans killed thirty of them and captured two raiders alive, whom they sent as prisoners. Submitter Xia Yan then asked that the prisoners be sent to Zhejiang for joint trial with the local authorities and Suqing. Submitter Liu Shao and Censor Wang Dao were dispatched for the purpose. By the fourth year the case was closed. Suqing, Nakabayashi, and Mogadorō were all sentenced to death and imprisoned. In time, every one of them wasted away and died in prison. When the Ryukyuan envoy Zheng Sheng was about to return home, the court instructed him to tell Japan to hand over Sōsetsu, restore Yuan Jin and the coastal captives, and otherwise face closed borders, an end to tribute, and eventual military punishment.
18
使 使 使 沿
In the ninth year, the Ryukyuan envoy Cai Han traveled through Japan, where Yoshiharu attached a memorial reading: 'Our realm has been torn by internal strife, and war has obstructed the route. The Zhengde tallies never reached the eastern capital, so Suqing carried Hongzhi-era tallies instead and asked permission to proceed. We ask that new tallies and a gold seal be issued so that tribute may resume as usual.' The Board of Rites inspected the letter and found no seal. They argued that Japanese deceit could not be trusted and that Ryukyu should relay the earlier demand unchanged.' In the seventh month of the eighteenth year, Yoshiharu's tribute mission arrived at Ningbo, and the local authorities notified the court. Japan had sent no tribute for seventeen years. The emperor ordered the touring censor, together with the three provincial commissioners, to investigate. If the mission proved genuinely submissive, it would be escorted according to precedent; if not, it would be sent home, and private dealings with local people would be forbidden. The next year, in the second month, the envoys led by Shuo Ding reached Beijing and repeated their request for new Jiajing tallies, Suqing's release, and the return of the detained tribute goods. The ministry advised: 'Tallies should not be issued prematurely; the old slips must be turned in before new ones are given. Tribute may come only once every ten years, with no more than one hundred men and three ships; no other demands should be granted.' The emperor approved the recommendation. In the seventh month of the twenty-third year they presented tribute again, arriving before the scheduled interval and without the required memorial. The ministry held that the mission should not be accepted, and it was turned away. Seeking profit from illicit trade, the envoys lingered on the coast and refused to depart. Touring Censor Gao Jie asked that coastal officials be punished and illicit trade with private brokers be ruthlessly suppressed; the emperor agreed. Inland merchants still profited from the trade and often bankrolled the envoys, so the traffic was never fully extinguished.
19
使 使
In the sixth month of the twenty-sixth year, Touring Censor Yang Jiuzhe reported that Zhejiang's coastal prefectures and the adjoining Fujian ports were all menaced by Japanese raiders. Guard posts and anti-piracy officers existed, but pirates struck unpredictably, and officials in the two provinces could not coordinate, leaving defense ineffective. He asked that a senior envoy be sent, as in earlier practice, to command all coastal prefectures so that authority and enforcement would be unified.' The court agreed, and Vice Censor-in-chief Zhu Wan was made grand coordinator of Zhejiang with military authority over five Fujian prefectures as well. Soon afterward Yoshiharu sent Zhou Liang and others ahead of schedule with four ships and six hundred men, anchoring offshore until the next year's tribute season. When local officials tried to block them, they claimed they had been delayed by storms. When word reached the court in the eleventh month, the emperor ruled that the early arrival and excess men and ships violated precedent and ordered local officials to send the mission home. In the twelfth month, Japanese raiders struck Ningbo and Taizhou, killing and looting widely, and the officials of both prefectures were punished. The next year, in the sixth month, Zhou Liang again asked to present tribute, and Zhu Wan reported it to the court. The Ministry of Rites argued that although the mission broke the rules on timing, ships, and personnel, its language was deferential and the proper tribute season was near. Outright rejection would ignore the hardship of the voyage, yet excessive leniency would repeat the mistakes made with Sōsetsu and Suqing. Zhu Wan should follow the eighteenth-year precedent: send fifty envoys onward to the capital, house the rest at the Guest Lodge, reward them moderately, and order them home. Trade restrictions and coastal defense should be left to Zhu Wan's judgment.' The emperor approved. Zhu Wan protested that fifty men were too few, and the court allowed one hundred to go to the capital. The ministry ruled that only the hundred envoys sent to court would receive rewards; the others would get nothing. Zhou Liang protested that the tribute vessels were unusually large. Such ships, he said, required five hundred men to crew. Chinese merchant vessels often sheltered on islands and became pirates, he explained, so an extra ship had been added for protection, not to defy the rules. The ministry agreed to increase the rewards and added that the hundred-man limit was impractical for Japan; restrictions should be scaled to the size of the tribute fleet.' The court accepted the proposal.
20
使 便
Japan once held nearly two hundred tally slips from the Xiaojing and Wu reigns, and earlier missions had been required to surrender old slips before receiving new ones. Now Zhou Liang produced fifteen Hongzhi tallies and claimed the rest had been stolen by Suqing's son, who could not be caught. Fifteen Zhengde tallies were kept as evidence, and forty were returned. The ministry ruled that new tallies would be issued only after all old ones were surrendered; the emperor agreed. Even while the Japanese king sent tribute, raiders from the outlying islands attacked yearly, often aided by coastal collaborators. Zhu Wan enforced the bans ruthlessly, summarily executing anyone caught trading with the Japanese without waiting for imperial approval. Powerful Zhejiang and Fujian clans that had long brokered trade with the Japanese lost their profits and turned against him. Zhu Wan also sent repeated memorials exposing great-clan collusion with Japan, earning hatred throughout Fujian and Zhejiang, above all in Fujian. Touring Censor Zhou Liang, a Fujian native, attacked Zhu Wan in a memorial and asked that his title be reduced from grand coordinator to touring inspector, stripping him of real authority. His allies at court maneuvered on his behalf, and the request was granted. Zhu Wan was dismissed from office. He was framed for unauthorized executions and took his own life. For four years thereafter no grand coordinator was appointed, the sea ban collapsed, and the crisis worsened.
21
紿
Under the founding institutions, Zhejiang maintained a Maritime Trade Supervisorate at Ningbo under a eunuch director. When foreign ships arrived, the state set prices and kept trade under central control. Under Emperor Shizong, garrison eunuchs and trade offices were abolished nationwide, and coastal smugglers took over the profits. At first merchants still controlled the trade, but as the ban on overseas commerce tightened, business moved into the mansions of powerful officials, and unpaid debts mounted. When creditors pressed for payment, the powerful either threatened them or soothed them with empty promises that the debt would someday be honored. The Japanese, cheated of their goods and unable to go home, were already furious; and ringleaders such as Wang Zhi, Xu Hai, Chen Dong, and Ma Ye, driven from the mainland, made their bases on the islands. The Japanese followed their lead and were lured into raids on the mainland. Major pirates then adopted Japanese dress and banners, split into fleets, and raided inland with enormous profit, so the crisis intensified until the court decided to restore the grand coordinator. In the seventh month of the thirty-first year, Vice Censor-in-chief Wang Yu was appointed grand coordinator, but the disaster was already uncontrollable.
22
沿使 西
Early in the dynasty, coastal guard posts and warships were established under regional commanders and anti-piracy officers, and the system was tightly organized. Years of peace left the fleet rotting and the garrisons hollow. When danger arose, patrol duty fell to hired fishing boats. The men were untrained, the boats makeshift; at the first sight of enemy sails they fled, and no commander above them could impose order. Wherever the raiders turned, devastation followed. In the third month of the thirty-second year, Wang Zhi rallied the Japanese for a massive raid; hundreds of linked ships blackened the sea. Alarms sounded at once along thousands of li of coast from eastern and western Zhejiang to north and south Jiangnan. They overran Changguo Guard. In the fourth month they struck Taicang, sacked Shanghai County, looted Jiangyin, and assaulted Zhapu. In the eighth month they pillaged Jinshan Guard and hit Chongming, Changshu, and Jiading. In the first month of the thirty-third year they swept from Taicang into Suzhou, struck Songjiang, then crossed to the north bank and threatened Tongzhou and Taizhou. In the fourth month they captured Jiashan, broke Chongming, threatened Suzhou again, and entered Chongde County. In the sixth month they raided Jiaxing from Wujiang and withdrew to camp at Zhelin. They ranged freely as though the country were empty, and Wang Yu could do nothing to stop them. Soon Wang Yu was moved to Datong, Li Tianchong replaced him, and War Minister Zhang Jing was made supreme commander. The court then mobilized troops from across the empire for a coordinated campaign. The raiders made bases at Chuanshawa and Zhelin and launched raids in every direction. The next year, in the first month, they seized boats, hit Zhapu and Haining, captured Chongde, swept through Tangqi, Xinshi, Hengtang, Shuanglin, and other towns, and assaulted Deqing County. In the fifth month they united with newly arrived raiders, burst into Jiaxing, and reached Wangjiangjing, where Zhang Jing killed more than nineteen hundred of them and drove the rest back to Zhelin. Other raiding bands looted Suzhou prefecture, spread into Jiangyin and Wuxi, and ranged across Lake Tai. Roughly speaking, only three tenths were genuine Japanese; seven tenths were Chinese collaborators dressed as Wo. In battle the raiders drove captives ahead as human shields under harsh discipline, while government troops, habitually timid, broke and ran at every encounter. The emperor then sent Vice Minister of Works Zhao Wenhua to supervise the campaign. Zhao Wenhua reversed reward and punishment, and the armies fell apart. Zhang Jing and Li Tianchong were arrested and replaced by Zhou Yan and Hu Zongxian. Within a month Zhou Yan was removed and Yang Yi took his place.
23
西
By then the raiders had spread across Jiangsu and Zhejiang, leaving scarcely a district untouched. Fresh Japanese raiders kept arriving in greater numbers and with greater ferocity. They routinely burned their ships after landing and then looted inland. Starting west of Hangzhou at Beixin Pass, they looted Chun'an, burst into She County in Huizhou, pushed through Jixi and Jingde, crossed Jing County, reached Nanling, and advanced as far as Wuhu. They burned the south bank of the Yangtze, raced toward Taiping Prefecture, struck Jiangning Guard, and pressed on to Nanjing itself. Clad in red and bearing yellow banners, the raiders hit Nanjing's Great Virtue Gate and Jiogang, then withdrew through Muling Pass and descended the Lishui River to loot Liyang and Yixing. Hearing that troops were moving out from Lake Tai, they crossed into Wujin, reached Wuxi, and camped on Huishan. In a single day and night they marched more than one hundred and eighty li to Xushu. Government troops surrounded them, caught them at Yanglin Bridge, and wiped them out. In that operation fewer than seventy raiders marched thousands of li, killed or wounded nearly four thousand people, and survived more than eighty days before they were finally destroyed in the ninth month of the thirty-fourth year.
24
滿
Grand Coordinator Cao Bangfu reported the victory, and Zhao Wenhua resented him for it. Claiming the raiders were based at Taozhai, Zhao Wenhua massed troops from Zhejiang and the capital region and took the field in person with Hu Zongxian. He also arranged a joint strike with Cao Bangfu, dividing forces and encamping at Zhuan Bridge in Songjiang. The raiders threw their best troops into the assault, routed Wenhua's force, broke his morale, and grew bolder. In the tenth month raiders landed at Yueqing and swept through Huangyan, Xianju, Fenghua, Yuyao, and Shangyu, killing and capturing beyond number. They were finally destroyed at Sheng County. Though fewer than two hundred strong, they had plunged deep into three prefectures and took fifty days to suppress. One band had set out from Rizhao in Shandong, raiding through Dong'an Guard and on through Huaian, Ganyu, Shuyang, and Taoyuan before rain trapped them at Qinghe, where Xu- and Pi-area government troops wiped them out. Fewer than fifty men had ravaged a thousand li and killed more than a thousand people — that was how fierce they were. After his defeat at Zhuan Bridge, Zhao Wenhua saw how strong the pirates had become. They shifted from Zhelin to Zhoupu, their comrades at the old bases in Chuansha and Jiading Gaoqiao carried on as before, and fresh raids came almost daily. Zhao Wenhua then asked to go back to court, claiming the threat was over.
25
使 西 便 西
The next year, in the second month, Yang Yi was removed and Hu Zongxian took his place; Ruan E was appointed grand coordinator of Zhejiang. Hu Zongxian then proposed sending envoys to warn the Japanese king to rein in the island raiders, summon back Chinese smugglers who had gone over to them, and offer pardons in exchange for loyal service. After imperial approval, he dispatched the Ningbo scholars Jiang Zhou and Chen Keyuan. By then Chen Keyuan had returned. He reported reaching Japan's Gotō Islands, where he met Wang Zhi and Mao Haifeng. They claimed Japan was in civil turmoil, that both the king and his chief minister were dead, and that the islands answered to no single authority — only a broad round of proclamations could stop the raids. He added that Satsuma, though already sending raiders, did not truly wish to make war; it sought restored tribute and trade and offered to kill pirates to prove its good faith. Jiang Zhou remained to carry the message to the islands while Chen Keyuan was sent home. Hu Zongxian reported the matter, and the Ministry of War replied: "Wang Zhi and his followers were subjects of the Ming. Now that they claim to submit, they should disarm at once. Instead they say nothing about disarming and only press for open markets and tribute trade, acting almost like a vassal state. Their designs are impossible to fathom. The frontier commanders should be told to assert imperial authority and tighten coastal defenses. Wang Zhi and his men should be ordered by proclamation to wipe out the pirate nests around Zhoushan and prove their loyalty that way. If they truly pacify the coast, imperial favor will follow. The court agreed. Both halves of Zhejiang were under attack, but Cixi suffered the worst burning and slaughter, with Yuyao close behind. Western Zhejiang from Zhelin and Zhapu to Wuzhen and Zaolin had become a chain of pirate bases holding more than twenty thousand men. Hu Zongxian was ordered to act quickly. In the seventh month Hu Zongxian reported: "Since Chen Keyuan returned, the pirate leader Mao Haifeng has beaten Wo raiders once at Zhoushan and twice at Biaoli, and sent envoys to bring the islands over one by one. He asks for a substantial reward. The ministry told Hu Zongxian to use his discretion. Xu Hai, Chen Dong, and Ma Ye were then besieging Tongxiang together. Hu Zongxian turned them against one another; Xu Hai seized Chen Dong and Ma Ye and submitted, and their remaining men were destroyed at Zhapu. Soon afterward Hu Zongxian routed Xu Hai at Liangzhuang as well. Hai lost his head, and his last followers were wiped out. Pirates in Jiangnan and western Zhejiang were largely subdued, but northern raiders struck Danyang, looted Guazhou, and burned grain barges. The next spring they hit Rugao and Haimen, attacked Tongzhou, raided Yangzhou and Gaoyou, pushed into Baoying, and finally massed at Miaowan in Huaian Prefecture. A full year passed before they were defeated. Eastern Zhejiang's pirates held Zhoushan and were hit again and again by government forces.
26
使 使
When Jiang Zhou was carrying the imperial message to the islands, he was held at Bungo and had to send a monk onward to Yamaguchi and the other islands with orders to stand down. Minamoto Yoshinaga, lord of Yamaguchi, then sent a memorial returning captives — and the document bore the royal seal. Bungo's governor Minamoto Yoshishige sent the monk Tokuyō with gifts, a memorial begging forgiveness, a request for restored tally-slips and tribute relations, and Jiang Zhou's release. Zheng Shungong, whom Yang Yi had sent to scout the seas, had reached Bungo; its lord sent the monk Seiju back on the same boat to apologize, claiming the raids had all been instigated by Chinese smugglers who dragged islanders along and that Yoshishige and his men had known nothing. Hu Zongxian reported the affair, noting that Jiang Zhou had spent two years abroad and reached only Bungo and Yamaguchi. Some missions brought gifts without proper tally-slips; others bore seals without the king's name. All of this fell short of Ming protocol. Still, they had come bearing tribute and returned captives, which showed genuine fear and a wish for mercy. Their envoys should be sent home with courtesy and told to inform Yoshishige and Yoshinaga, and through them the Japanese king, that trade would resume only after the ringleaders and Chinese collaborators were captured and delivered. The emperor approved.
27
滿 滿
While Wang Zhi held the offshore islands, he and his lieutenants Wang Ao, Ye Zongman, Xie He, and Wang Qingxi each built power by allying with Japanese raiders. The court put a marquisate and ten thousand taels of gold on his head, yet never managed to take him. Inland defenses had improved by then. Raiders still roamed widely, but many were cut down, and some islands lost every man who sailed out. Resentment turned on Wang Zhi, and he grew uneasy. Hu Zongxian came from the same home region as Wang Zhi. He housed Wang's mother, wife, and children in Hangzhou and sent Jiang Zhou with a letter from the family to summon him in. Learning that his family was safe, Wang Zhi wavered. Yoshishige and his allies were pleased as well, since China had promised trade. They fitted out large ships and sent more than forty men, including Zenmyō, to accompany Wang Zhi on a tribute-and-trade mission. In the tenth month of year thirty-six they reached Cengang in Zhoushan. Local commanders took it for an attack and mobilized for defense. Wang Zhi sent Wang Yao ahead. Wang Ao went in to see Hu Zongxian and demanded: "I came in peace — why are your troops drawn up against me? Ao was Mao Haifeng, Wang Zhi's adopted son. Hu Zongxian welcomed him lavishly, placed a hand on his heart, and swore he meant no treachery. Soon Zenmyō and the others met Vice General Lu Zong at Zhoushan, and Lu Zong ordered Wang Zhi seized and handed over. Word of the order got out, and Wang Zhi's mistrust deepened. Hu Zongxian tried every argument, but Wang Zhi would not trust him. "If you mean no harm," he said, "send Ao back out and I will come ashore. Hu Zongxian sent Ao out at once. Wang Zhi also demanded a senior officer as hostage, and Hu Zongxian sent Commander Xia Zheng. Taking this as proof of good faith, Wang Zhi came ashore with Ye Zongman and Wang Qingxi. Hu Zongxian was delighted, received them with great honor, and sent them to call on the touring censor Wang Benguo in Hangzhou, who treated them like ordinary prisoners. When Wang Ao and his men learned what had happened, they were furious. They killed Xia Zheng by dismemberment, burned their ships, took to the hills, and dug in at Cengang.
28
More than a year later fresh Japanese raiders arrived in force and struck eastern Zhejiang's three prefectures again and again. The men at Cengang slipped away to Keme, built new ships, and sailed off; Hu Zongxian did not chase them. In the eleventh month the pirates sailed south to Wuyu off Quanzhou, looted Tong'an, Hui'an, and Nan'an, attacked Funing Prefecture, and overran Fu'an and Ningde. The next April they besieged Fuzhou and held it under siege for a month. Fuqing and Yongfu were battered and broken, the disaster spread into Xinghua, and raiders stampeded into Zhangzhou. The crisis had moved wholesale to Fujian, and alarms of pirate raids began pouring in from Chaozhou and Guangdong as well. By year forty, pirates in eastern Zhejiang and the north had been subdued one after another. Soon afterward Hu Zongxian was implicated in misconduct and arrested. The next November they took Xinghua Prefecture, massacred and looted the city, and settled in at Pinghai Guard. Earlier raids in Zhejiang had overrun hundreds of counties, guard posts, and walled towns, but no prefectural seat had fallen. The shock ran deep. Yu Dayou, Qi Jiguang, Liu Xian, and other generals were rushed to the scene, joined forces, and broke the enemy. Raids in other prefectures and counties were beaten back as well, and Fujian was finally pacified.
29
After that, major Guangdong outlaws such as Zeng Yiben and Huang Chaotai routinely enlisted Japanese raiders as allies. During the Longqing reign they overran Jieshi, Jiazi, and other guard posts. They soon struck Shicheng County in Huazhou and took Jinnang Post and Shendian Guard. Wuchuan, Yangjiang, Maoming, Haifeng, Xinning, and Huilai were all burned and looted. The raiders pushed into Leizhou, Lianzhou, and Qiongzhou and brought the same devastation there. In Wanli 2 they hit Ningbo, Shaoxing, Taizhou, and Wenzhou in eastern Zhejiang and also took Guangdong's Tonggushi and Shuangyu posts. In Wanli 3 they raided Dianbai. In Wanli 4 they struck Dinghai. In Wanli 8 they hit Jiushan in Zhejiang and Penghu and Dongyong in Fujian. In Wanli 10 they raided Wenzhou and Guangdong again. In Wanli 16 they struck Zhejiang once more. By then, however, frontier officials had learned from the Jiajing disasters and kept tighter coastal defenses, and raiders usually lost when they came. Guangdong raids were especially fierce because the pirate Liang Benhao was drawing them in. Governor-General Chen Rui massed his forces, killed more than sixteen hundred enemies, sank over a hundred ships, and Liang Benhao lost his head as well. The emperor offered thanks at the suburban altars and ancestral temple, proclaimed victory, and received the usual round of congratulations.
30
使 殿 退婿 祿 沿 使
Japan still had a king in name, but the highest real office was kampaku, held at the time by Oda Nobunaga of Yamashiro. Once while hunting, Nobunaga found a man asleep under a tree. The man started up and bumped into him, and Nobunaga seized and questioned him. He gave his name as Hideyoshi, a servant from Satsuma — strong, quick, and sharp-tongued. Nobunaga took a liking to him, set him to mind horses, and nicknamed him "Under-the-Tree." He rose in Nobunaga's service, planned campaigns that swallowed more than twenty provinces, and became military governor of Settsu. When a staff officer named Akechi offended Nobunaga, Nobunaga sent Hideyoshi to crush him. Soon Nobunaga was murdered by his own man Akechi Mitsuhide. Hideyoshi was campaigning against Akechi's faction when news arrived; he wheeled about with generals such as Yukinaga, marched on the capital, destroyed Akechi, and his renown soared. He soon displaced Nobunaga's three sons, seized the title of kampaku, and absorbed his armies — this was Wanli 14. He drilled his armies, unified the sixty-six provinces, and by force or fear made Ryukyu, Luzon, Siam, and the Portuguese pay tribute. He renamed the Yamashiro capital the Great Tower, greatly expanded its walls and ramparts, and built palaces whose loftiest halls rose nine stories, stocked with women and treasure. His discipline was brutal: armies moved forward, never back, and even a son-in-law who disobeyed was put to death. That was why his campaigns seemed unstoppable. He proclaimed the Bunroku era and set his sights on invading China, conquering Korea, and holding both. He questioned Wang Zhi's old associates, heard that Chinese feared Japanese like tigers, and grew still more arrogant. He doubled down on arms and shipbuilding and planned with his commanders to use Koreans as guides for an advance on Beijing and Chinese collaborators for the coasts of Zhejiang and Fujian. Afraid Ryukyu would expose his plans, he blocked its tribute missions.
31
使
Chen Jia of Tong'an was a merchant in Ryukyu. Fearing disaster for the Ming, he worked with Ryukyu's chief secretary Zheng Jiong to slip word to Beijing through the next investiture tribute mission. Chen Jia went home as well and told Grand Coordinator Zhao Canlu what he knew. Zhao Canlu forwarded the report to the Ministry of War, which in turn notified the Korean king. The Korean king insisted the guide story was slander — and had no idea Hideyoshi was plotting against him.
32
使
Hideyoshi had begun mass conscription across the domains, stockpiling three years of grain for a personal invasion of China. Then his heir died, leaving him without a brother at hand. He had earlier taken the Bungo lord's wife as a concubine and now worried she would become a liability. The daimyo resented Hideyoshi's cruelty and tyranny, saying among themselves: This war is not against China—it is against us. Each harbored his own private designs. For this reason Hideyoshi did not dare lead the expedition himself. In the fourth month of Wanli 20 he sent his generals Kiyomasa, Teruzumi, and Yoshitoshi, with the monks Genso and Soitsu, leading several hundred warships from Tsushima. They crossed the sea, took Pusan, swept forward in victory, crossed the Imjin in the fifth month, seized Kaesong, and overran the districts of Pungdok. Korean armies collapsed without a fight. Kiyomasa and the others then pressed on the royal capital. King Yi Sun abandoned the capital and fled to Pyongyang, then to Uiju, sending envoys in rapid succession to beg for aid. The Japanese entered the capital, seized the queen and princes, pursued the king to Pyongyang, and let their troops ravage the countryside. In the seventh month Vice Commander Zu Chengxun was sent to relieve Korea. He fought the Japanese outside Pyongyang, suffered a crushing defeat, and barely escaped alive. In the eighth month the court appointed Vice Minister Song Yingchang as supreme coordinator and Li Rusong as commander-in-chief to lead the punitive expedition.
33
退 退
Ningxia was still unsettled when the Korean war broke out. War Minister Shi Xing, at his wits' end, recruited anyone who claimed he could deal with Japan. Shen Weijing of Jiaxing volunteered. Shi Xing gave him the titular rank of mobile corps commander and attached him to Li Rusong's staff. The following year Li Rusong won a great victory at Pyongyang and recovered all four lost Korean provinces. Li Rusong pressed on to Pyeongjeck, was defeated, and withdrew. Talk of investiture and tribute followed, and the court patched peace together through Shen Weijing. The affair is detailed in the Korea biography. Eventually Hideyoshi died. The Japanese fleets sailed home, and Korea's ordeal ended. Yet over seven years of Hideyoshi's invasion, hundreds of thousands of soldiers perished and millions in supplies were wasted, and neither Ming nor Korea ever achieved a decisive victory. Only with Hideyoshi's death did the war end. The Japanese withdrew to their islands, and the southeast coast at last knew a measure of peace. Hideyoshi's line survived two more generations and then died out.
34
Throughout the Ming dynasty the ban on contact with Japan was severe. Neighbors would curse one another as 'Japanese,' and parents even used the word to frighten small children.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →