← Back to 清史稿

卷252 列傳三十九 甘文焜 范承谟 马雄镇 傅宏烈

Volume 252 Biographies 39: Gan Wenkun, Fan Chengmo, Ma Xiongzhen, Fu Honglie

Chapter 252 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 252
Next Chapter →
1
Biographies 39
2
==
Gan Wenkun, whose style was Bingru, belonged to the Han military company of the Plain Blue Banner. His forebears had relocated from Fengcheng to Shenyang. His father Yingkui entered China with the conquering armies and eventually became deputy commander at Shixia.
3
使
Wenkun excelled at horsemanship and archery, loved books, and was especially drawn to stories of loyalty and filial devotion from antiquity. Starting as an academy student, he became a clerk in the Board of War and rose through the ranks to Qixinlang in the Board of Rites, earning repeated commendation on diplomatic assignments. Early in the Kangxi reign he was appointed vice-president of the Court of Judicial Review and later became prefect of Shuntian. Finding the transit duties at Chongwen Gate unjust, he submitted a memorial impeaching those responsible. When the court proposed that he take charge of the post himself, Wenkun said, "To denounce the abuse and then hold the office would be to profit from it." He firmly refused. In the sixth year he became governor of Zhili and memorialized to revive the former practice of provincial inspection tours. Touring his jurisdiction in a simple carriage, he found counties under Baoding and Zhending stricken by flood and memorialized for remission of the annual land tax. Governor-General Bai Bingzhen, citing the enormous cost of relief, asked that officials and commoners be allowed to contribute silver and grain. Wenkun donated his entire official salary to the relief effort. In recognition of his service he was granted the additional title of vice-president of the Board of Works.
4
紿
In the seventh year he was appointed governor-general of Yunnan and Guizhou and took up residence at Guiyang. Wu Sangui then held Yunnan and sought border troubles to tighten his grip on the army. He fabricated a report that the Kangdong tribes had raided, lured Wenkun into moving his forces, and secretly stirred the Kaili Miao to attack from behind. Wenkun reckoned Kangdong posed little threat, but Kaili lay at his very flank and would spread if left alone. He marched first against their stronghold and beheaded the Miao chief Arong. After the victory he arranged a joint campaign with Yunnan against Kangdong. Sangui, fearing exposure of his ruse, claimed Kangdong had already fled into the distance—and from that point feared Wenkun all the more. Wenkun made inspection tours through every prefecture and department in Yunnan and Guizhou. In the tenth year his mother died; the emperor permitted him to observe mourning without leaving his post. Wenkun again sent troops against the Zhenpo Miao and killed their chief Afu. He memorialized asking leave to return home for the burial, and was granted a leave of absence for the funeral. Sangui asked that Wenkun also hold the Yunnan governorship, ordered all troops of the governor-general's command to Yunnan under his direction, and tried to buy him off, hoping to turn him to his cause.
5
使 調 使
In the twelfth year Wenkun returned to his post just as the court began debating the abolition of the feudatory princedoms. Sangui rose in rebellion, killed the Yunnan governor Zhu Guozhi, and sent his followers to threaten Guiyang. When he heard of the revolt, Wenkun sent his cousin Wenkong with a memorial to the capital and ordered Guizhou commander Li Benshen to hold the Pan River line with his troops. Benshen was already disloyal and first wrote to sound out Wenkun's intentions. Wenkun answered in his own hand, vowing to follow Zhang Xun and Nan Jiyun in holding the city to the death—but Benshen ignored him. Benshen's troops had already accepted Sangui's bribes and broke ranks, refusing to obey. Seeing Guiyang could not be held, Wenkun had his concubine Sheng lead seven women of the household to hang themselves, then set out alone with his fourth son Guocheng for Zhenyuan, hoping to rally Hubei troops at the mountain passes and block the rebels' advance north. On the first day of the twelfth month (day bingshen) he reached Zhenyuan on day guimao, but the garrison commander Jiang Yi had already accepted a rebel commission and refused him entry. Wenkun crossed the river to Jixiang Temple, where Yi sent troops to surround him. Wenkun bowed twice toward the capital, drew his sword to take his own life. Guocheng cried that he should die first, seized the blade, cut his own throat, and handed the sword back; as his body fell, blood spattered Wenkun's robes. Wenkun said, "That boy was braver than I!" He then took his own life. He was forty-two. His clerk Heshanyatu died with him.
6
使
After the rebellion was suppressed, Guizhou governor Yang Yongjian reported Wenkun's record in office and his death in service, and the court granted generous posthumous honors. His eldest son Guojun, sub-prefect of Xuanhua, was sent to bring the coffin to Beijing; Inner Minister Tong Guowei received it at Lugou Bridge. Wenkun was posthumously made Minister of War with the posthumous name Zhongguo (Loyal and Resolute). A shrine was erected at Guiyang, and the emperor inscribed its tablet with the words "Steadfast Integrity." He had seven sons; Guobi was especially renowned.
7
西
Guobi, styled Dongping, entered office by hereditary privilege as prefect of Shaanzhou, became sub-prefect of Suzhou, and rose to prefect of Pingyang in Shanxi and Ningbo in Zhejiang, earning a reputation as a model official. During the Kangxi Emperor's southern tour, when he visited Hangzhou, he personally wrote out a poem of Zhu Xi and bestowed the plaque "Ever Faithful." He told him, "Your father died loyal to the throne, and I have never forgotten. This inscription is for your mother." He rose through successive promotions to governor of Yunnan. He was dismissed after an offense. Under Yongzheng he was recalled to serve as commander of the Han company of the Plain Yellow Banner. In the third year of the Qianlong reign he was appointed deputy lieutenant-general of the Right Wing at Suiyuan. He was dismissed again. He died in the twelfth year.
8
== 使
Fan Chengmo, whose style was Jingong, belonged to the Han military company of the Bordered Yellow Banner and was the second son of Fan Wencheng. He passed the jinshi examination in the ninth year of Shunzhi, entered the Hanlin as a bachelor, and was appointed compiler in the Hongwen Academy. He rose through successive promotions to academician of the Secretariat. In the seventh year of Kangxi he was appointed governor of Zhejiang. The dynasty was still young, refugees had not yet returned to their farms, and in eastern Zhejiang the six prefectures including Ningbo and Jinhua held especially large tracts of abandoned land. Governor-General Zhao Tingchen petitioned to reduce tax quotas, and the emperor ordered Chengmo to survey the land in person. Chengmo toured every prefecture and petitioned to exempt more than 315,500 mou of wasteland and flood-damaged fields from taxation. When flood struck Hangzhou, Jiaxing, Huzhou, and Shaoxing, Chengmo drew 80,000 taels from the provincial treasury, bought grain in Huguang, and sold it at fair prices. The poorest were allowed, under the relief rule for the aged and infirm, to carry salt for their daily bread, and a great many lives were saved. He also memorialized: "Convert grain tribute payments to silver at one tael per shi. When the wheat harvest comes next year, collect the white-grain quota in arrears over three years. Where the disaster is severe, grant remission as usual." The emperor approved, and the measures were implemented. In the tenth year he asked to resign on account of illness and was recalled to the capital. Governor-General Liu Zhaoqi and commander Saibaili reported that the people of Zhejiang had submitted more than 150 petitions begging Chengmo to stay. Censors Jiang Xizhe, Ke Song, He Yuanying, and others wrote: "Chengmo has served three years, loving the people as his own children, and refuses all lobbying and gifts. He impeached corrupt officials, punished powerful wrongdoers, and rooted out surcharges, irregular fees, and unauthorized levies. The people of Zhejiang cherish him as they would food and water in famine." The emperor ordered Chengmo to remain in office. In the eleventh year Chengmo memorialized again that surcharges on white grain in Huzhou and Jiaxing varied widely, and asked that they be capped at four dou and five sheng per shi; he also asked remission of tax arrears before Kangxi 9 for the Wenzhou and Taizhou garrisons and unpaid transport grain for Shimen and Pingyang—all referred to the Board of Revenue for approval.
9
便調
In the tenth month he was promoted to governor-general of Fujian. His refusal was not accepted, and he asked to appear before the throne. In the seventh month of the twelfth year he reached Beijing and was received in audience. Chengmo had not yet recovered; the emperor sent imperial physicians and bestowed medicines. When he improved slightly, he was urged to take up his post and was given court dress and a saddle horse. The Fujian governor-general had originally been based at Zhangzhou; now, with the feudatories about to be abolished, he was ordered to move his headquarters to Fuzhou. When Wu Sangui rebelled, Chengmo saw that Geng Jingzhong harbored rebellious intent. As the court debated troop reductions, Chengmo memorialized asking that the cuts be postponed. He also reported plans to tour the coast and station himself in an outlying prefecture where he could more easily mobilize for defense. Before he could act, Jingzhong rebelled, falsely claiming pirates had appeared, and summoned Chengmo to consult with him. Governor Liu Bingzheng had joined Jingzhong and pressed Chengmo to accompany them. Chengmo knew something was wrong. His attendants urged him to wear armor, but he said, "We are badly outnumbered; armor would do no good." He went anyway. Jingzhong's men drew their blades to threaten him; Chengmo stepped forward and cursed them without stopping. Jingzhong locked him in an earthen cell in fetters and starved him for ten days, yet he would not die. Jingzhong sent Bingzheng to urge him to submit. Chengmo kicked him to the ground and ordered his men to drag him out, crying, "The rebels will soon face execution—I will break their spirits first!" Imprisoned by the rebels for more than two years, he daily wore the court cap and robes the emperor had bestowed, still dressed in the clothes he had worn when taking leave of his mother. On the first and fifteenth of each month he hung up the official calendar and bowed twice toward the north. His cell was cramped; he called it the Dark Valley. He wrote poetry and prose on the walls in charcoal from a pine torch.
10
One of his retainers, Zhang Fujian, fought his way through the gate with a blade, cut down several rebels in succession, and died when his strength gave out. A Mongol named Mani held a false commission as Gentleman Cavalier and was assigned to guard Chengmo. Moved by Chengmo's loyalty, he plotted to help him escape. When the plot was discovered, Jingzhong was about to dismember him. He cried out, "I would rather die with a loyal minister than live with rebel traitors!"
11
In the fifteenth year imperial forces took Xianxia Pass. Jingzhong was about to surrender and hoped to excuse his crimes and save his life, fearing Chengmo would expose them. On the first day of the ninth month (day jiyou), at midnight on day jiazi, Jingzhong sent his men to force Chengmo to hang himself. His secretaries Ji Yongren, Wang Longguang, and Shen Tiancheng, his cousin Chengpu, and servants down to the lowest runners—fifty-three died with him. Their stories are told at length in the biographies of loyal martyrs. An old servant, Wang Daolong, had been sent away on business. When he returned to Yanping and heard what had happened, he cut his own throat. The rebels burned Chengmo's body and left it in the open country. A Taining cavalryman named Xu Ding carried off the remains by night and hid them. In the sixteenth year his coffin was brought back to Beijing. The emperor sent an Inner Minister and guards to receive the coffin. Chengmo was posthumously made Minister of War and Junior Tutor to the Heir Apparent, with the posthumous name Zhongzhen (Loyal and Steadfast), and the emperor wrote an epitaph for his family. In the nineteenth year Jingzhong was executed. On the day Jingzhong was led to execution, Chengmo's son Shichong cut flesh from his body as an offering at his father's tomb. The people of Fujian petitioned for a shrine in his honor, and the emperor inscribed its lintel with the words "Loyal and Steadfast, Bright as the Sun." The emperor personally wrote a preface for Chengmo's collected writings from the prison walls.
12
使
Shichong, whose style was Zimu. By privilege granted for his father's martyrdom he became prefect of Liaoyang, later served as prefect of Shunde in Zhili, and earned a reputation for benevolent rule. He rose through successive promotions to provincial judicial commissioner of Fujian. On the day he took leave of the throne, the emperor turned to the assembled ministers and said, "Here is the grandson of a founding minister and the son of a loyal martyr!" In the forty-seventh year he was promoted to governor of Guangdong and given charge of the salt administration. Two years later he was appointed governor-general of Fujian and Zhejiang. In the fifty-fourth year he was recalled to serve as Left Censor-in-Chief. The following year he was appointed Minister of War. He was ordered beyond the frontier to establish forty-seven courier stations at Modai Chahan'ao'er and E'erzhai Tu'ao'er. The following year he returned to the capital. He died soon after. The people of Fujian, remembering his virtue, added him to the shrine honoring Chengmo.
13
== 西 西
Ma Xiongzhen, whose style was Xifan, belonged to the Han military company of the Bordered Red Banner and was the son of Mingpei. He entered office by hereditary privilege as a deputy director in the Board of Works and rose to Left Vice Censor and academician of the State Historiography Academy. In the eighth year of Kangxi he was appointed governor of Shanxi. Before he could take up the post he was transferred to Guangxi. Bandits were rising on every side, and Yao and Zhuang raiders plundered Wuzhou and Pingle. Within a few months he had suppressed them. He memorialized repeatedly to stabilize salt prices, build a Confucian school, fix frontier salaries for local officials, cut military grain transport costs, and abolish burdensome procurement levies—all approved and implemented.
14
西 使 西 使 西
In the twelfth year Wu Sangui rebelled. In the thirteenth year Sun Yanling rebelled in Guangxi in support of Wu Sangui, besieged Xiongzhen's headquarters, and tried to force him to submit. The governor had no troops at his command; Xiongzhen led his household in the defense. He secretly ordered garrison commander Yi Youliang to hurry to Liuzhou and summon commander Ma Xiong to the rescue, but Ma Xiong did not respond. Xiongzhen tried to hang himself but was saved by his family. He sent an urgent wax-sealed memorial begging for reinforcements. Yanling learned of this through his spies, imprisoned Xiongzhen, and confined his family in separate quarters. Sangui sent envoys to win him over, but Xiongzhen would not submit. When Fu Honglie urged Yanling to defect back to the Qing, Yanling hesitated. Xiongzhen used the opening to send his eldest son Shiji with a memorial to Beijing. Youliang guided him out, Yang Qixiang escorted him, and at Ganzhou Jiangxi governor Dong Weiguo reported the matter to the court. The emperor sent an escort to bring him to Beijing, and on his arrival Shiji was appointed a fourth-rank metropolitan official. Several months later Xiongzhen prepared another memorial on how western Guangdong could be recovered and gave it to his grandson Guozhen, who with the guest Zhu Fang broke through the wall to escape. Later he sent Tang Shoudao and Tang Zhengfa to smuggle out his second son Shiyong, who also made his way to Beijing. When Yanling discovered this, he threw Xiongzhen's family into prison. In his fury Xiongzhen cut his own throat, but the rebels seized him again and locked him in a separate room.
15
使
In the tenth month of the sixteenth year Sangui sent his grandnephew Shizong to kill Yanling and dragged Xiongzhen to the rebel camp to force his surrender. Xiongzhen cried out, "It is my duty to guard this frontier. I cannot cut you down to serve the throne—death is what I owe!" The rebels killed his young sons Shihong and Shitai to break his spirit, but he only cursed them more fiercely, and they killed him. He was forty-four. Nine attendants including Ma Yungiao, Tang Jinbao, and Zhu Zhaoyuan died with him, as did his wife Li, concubines Gu and Liu, two daughters, and Shiji's wife Dong and concubine Miao. Their stories are told at length in the biographies of exemplary women. Xiongzhen's body lay exposed for more than forty days before Youliang gathered his bones and gave them a simple burial.
16
稿 西 使
During three years of captivity, Xiongzhen wrote and composed poetry every day. After his death the guests Sun Cheng and Chen Wenhuan escaped to Cangwu and delivered to Shiji his surviving manuscripts, Jiba Lou and Huicao Bianyi. In the seventeenth year Honglie reported how Xiongzhen had died, and the court ordered deliberation on posthumous honors. Shiji was promoted to vice-president of the Court of Judicial Review. Cheng was appointed sub-prefect as a provincial graduate, and Wenhuan was made a county magistrate. Youliang, Shoudao, Zhengfa, and Qixiang were soon given ranks as colonel and garrison commander according to their merits. In the eighteenth year Shiji went to Guangxi to bring his father's coffin to Beijing. Xiongzhen was posthumously made Grand Tutor to the Heir Apparent and Minister of War, with the posthumous name Wenyi. After Sangui's rebellion was crushed, at the New Year banquet the emperor summoned Shiji and Chen Qitai's son Ruqi before the throne to receive wine in special honor. Shiji rose to governor of Zhaoyun, and Shiyong became transport commissioner; Guozhen served as intendant of the Chang-Zhen circuit in Jiangnan, supervised grain shipments into Tibet, and died on campaign.
17
==西 西
Fu Honglie, whose style was Zhongmou, came from Jinxian in Jiangxi. At the end of the Ming dynasty he took refuge in Guangxi. Under Shunzhi, on the recommendation of Governor Wang Guoguang, he became sub-prefect of Shaozhou and later prefect of Qingyang in Gansu.
18
西 使 西便
Wu Sangui had long plotted rebellion. In the seventh year of Kangxi, Honglie secretly reported him, was arrested, convicted of false accusation, and sentenced to death. In the ninth year the emperor commuted his sentence to exile at Wuzhou. When Sangui rebelled, General Sun Yanling and commander Ma Xiong joined the revolt in Guangxi. Honglie sought to raise troops to recover the province. He outwardly accepted a false commission from Sangui, traveled among the chieftaincies of Sizhou, Sicheng, Guangnan, and Fuchuan, crossed into Annam, and recruited five thousand volunteers. He then issued a proclamation against the rebels and joined Shang Kexi's army in a move on Zhaoqing. Sangui hated him bitterly and sent Ma Xiong to Liuzhou to slaughter his entire family of a hundred souls. Honglie urged Yanling to defect back to the Qing. Southern Pacification General Aisin Gioro Shushuo was stationed at Ganzhou. Honglie wrote secretly that Yanling's wife Kong Sizhen, daughter of Prince Dingnan Wu Youde, still remembered the dynasty's favor and that Yanling could be won back. He also wrote to Imperial Commissioner Malleji, urging that if imperial troops advanced quickly on Nan'an while Honglie coordinated from Shaozhou, both Guangdong and Guangxi could be recovered. Shushuo and Malleji reported his actions in turn. The emperor praised his loyalty, appointed him governor of Guangxi and General for Subduing Rebels and Destroying Bandits, and authorized him to recruit volunteers and act at his own discretion.
19
退退使
Honglie captured Wuzhou and took Zhaoping, He, Yulin, Bobai, Beiliu, Luchuan, Xingye, and other districts. He advanced to recover Xunzhou and sent Pingle prefect Liu Xiao to the capital with a strategic memorial. For his achievements he was made Junior Guardian to the Heir Apparent, and Liu Xiao was promoted to participation commissioner. At that time Ma Xiong held Liuzhou while Sangui's generals occupied Pinglo, Nanning, and Hengzhou; rebel strength was formidable. Although Honglie won repeated victories, his new army lacked artillery and horses. He asked Shang Zhixin for help but received none. After Wu Shizong killed Yanling and seized Pinglo, he attacked Honglie at Wuzhou, but Honglie drove him off. In the seventeenth year he joined General Mangyitu in besieging Pinglo. The battle went badly, and Honglie and Mangyitu exchanged accusations. An edict noted that Honglie's troops fought bravely to recover lost territory though they received no government pay. Mangyitu withdrew from Pinglo to Hexian, then citing lack of supplies retreated again to Wuzhou, leaving all the districts Honglie had recovered to the rebels. The court ordered Mangyitu to show results. Honglie advanced with his troops, but tens of thousands of rebels crossed the Zuo River and defeated him. The rebels seized Tengxian and threatened Wuzhou. In the eighteenth year Zhixin's army arrived. Honglie divided his forces by land and water and, while the rebels were besieging the city, struck them on three sides. The rebels broke and fled. He retook Tengxian, captured Pinglo, and advanced to recover Guilin.
20
西
Honglie memorialized in secret that Yanling's former troops should be properly disbanded and that Zhixin, habitually treacherous, should be checked before he turned again. After Ma Xiong died, his son Chengyin remained with Sangui, took the false title Duke of Huaining, and pretended to seek surrender. Honglie accepted this and reported it to the court. The court appointed Chengyin General of Manifest Righteousness to command his troops. Honglie planned an advance into Yunnan and Guizhou. In the second month of the nineteenth year he halted at Liuzhou. Chengyin invited him to a conference, and when Honglie arrived Chengyin turned his troops against him, overran his camp, and sent him captive to Guiyang. Shifan tried to win him with a false commission. Honglie said, "Before your grandfather rebelled I had already impeached him. I knew your family would turn traitor. How dare you try to defile me with such an offer?" Shizong tried every argument to win him over, but Honglie only cursed him more fiercely. On day xinchou in the tenth month he was put to death. In the eleventh month Southern Expedition General Mu Zhan recovered Guiyang, gathered Honglie's remains, and reported his death. Honglie was posthumously made Grand Preceptor to the Heir Apparent and Minister of War, with the posthumous name Zhongyi. In the twenty-second year, at the request of Guangxi governor Hao Yu, a Twin Loyalty shrine was built at Guilin honoring Honglie and Ma Xiongzhen.
21
==
The commentators say: When the feudatory princes were at the height of their power, the governors the court appointed were not strong enough to stand against them. Though Wenkun governed a separate territory from Sangui, his own troops had long since gone over to the rebel. Men such as Chengmo facing Jingzhong and Xiongzhen facing Yanling lived in the same cities as their enemies and had no recourse but to die for their loyalty. Honglie raised his own army and broke with Mangyitu. Isolated, he was finally undone by Chengyin. Yet their fierce loyalty inspired the army, struck fear into the rebels, and none of them died in vain. Alas—how fierce their devotion!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →