← Back to 清史稿

卷319 列傳一百六 于敏中 和珅子:丰绅殷德 弟:和琳 苏凌阿

Volume 319 Biographies 106: Yu Minzhong, He Shen son: Feng Shenyinde, younger brother: He Lin, Su Linga

Chapter 319 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 319
Next Chapter →
1
-{}-
Yu Minzhong; He Shen; his younger brother He Lin; and Su Linga.
2
祿滿
He Shen, styled Zhizhai, of the Niohuru clan, was a Manchu of the Plain Red Banner. In his youth he was poor and without means, and became a licentiate at the imperial college. In Qianlong 34 he inherited the third-rank Light Chariot Commandant. He was soon appointed a third-class bodyguard and selected for service in the Sticky Pole Office, the emperor's personal guard corps. In the fortieth year he was assigned to duty at the Gate of Heavenly Purity, promoted to imperial bodyguard, and also made deputy commander-in-chief. The next year he was appointed vice minister of Revenue, made a Grand Councilor, and also grand minister of the Imperial Household Department, rising rapidly in favor. He also served as commander of the Metropolitan Garrison, superintendent of the Chongwen Gate tax office, and director of imperial camp affairs. In the forty-fifth year he was ordered to accompany Vice Minister Ka Ning'a to Yunnan to investigate corruption charges against Governor-General Li Shiyao. Li Shiyao was regarded as a talented minister in whom the emperor placed great trust. When He Shen arrived, he interrogated Li's servants and obtained proof of his greed and extortion. Li was sentenced to death by slow slicing. He Shen memorialized that Yunnan's administration had grown lax, that many prefectures and counties showed treasury shortfalls, and that urgent rectification was required. The emperor wished to appoint He Shen governor-general, but thought it improper to give the post to the very man who had impeached Li, and so Fu Kang'an was appointed in his place. He was ordered back to the capital, and before he arrived was promoted to minister of Revenue and councilor of state. When he reported back, he personally presented his views on Yunnan salt administration, coinage, and frontier affairs. Most pleased the emperor, and all were approved. He was appointed imperial presence grand minister and also commander-in-chief. His son Fengshen Yinde was granted marriage to Princess Hexiao as imperial son-in-law; the wedding was deferred until the princess came of age. He was further made chief grand minister of the imperial bodyguard, chief director of the Siku Quanshu project, and concurrently minister in charge of Mongol affairs. His favor now surpassed every other official at court.
3
調
In the forty-sixth year the Salar Muslim leader Su Forty-three and others rebelled in Gansu and pressed upon Lanzhou. The imperial son-in-law Lawang Duorji, Chief Grand Minister Hailancha, and Guard Captain Esente led troops to suppress them. He Shen was appointed imperial commissioner and sent with Grand Secretary A Gui to supervise the campaign. A Gui was ill and urged He Shen to press forward at forced marches ahead of him. When He Shen arrived, Hailancha and the others had already defeated the rebels. He immediately directed the generals to advance in four columns. Hailancha drove the rebels onto a mountain ridge and wiped out their ambush force. The rebels had dug trenches and ditches several zhang deep and cut off the smaller paths, making further advance impossible. Brigadier Tu Qinbao was killed in battle. Several days later A Gui arrived. He Shen blamed the generals for disobeying his orders. A Gui said, "Such men deserve execution!" The next day, as they jointly arranged the battle plan, every command A Gui issued was obeyed at once. A Gui then said, "The generals show no insubordination whatsoever—whom do you propose to execute?" He Shen was furious. The emperor had quietly taken note of this. An edict rebuked He Shen for concealing Tu Qinbao's death and failing to report it, for delaying his arrival at the front, and for impeaching Hailancha and Esente and reversing right and wrong about who had fought first; it further stated that once A Gui reached the army the arrangements became orderly and one man was enough to finish the rebels; with He Shen present military affairs lacked unity, whereas Hailancha and the others had long served under A Gui and were easy to command. He Shen was ordered to return to the capital at once. From this He Shen nursed a grudge against A Gui and remained at odds with him for the rest of his life. He soon also served as acting minister of War and took charge of the three treasuries of the Ministry of Revenue.
4
使 調
In the forty-seventh year Censor Qian Feng impeached Shandong Governor Guo Tai and Provincial Administration Commissioner Yu Yijian for greed, indulgence, and private profit. He Shen was ordered to join Censor-in-Chief Liu Yong in the investigation, and Qian Feng went along. He Shen secretly favored Guo Tai. As soon as he arrived he inspected the treasury, had several dozen sealed silver packets drawn at random and found no shortage, then immediately returned to his lodging. Qian Feng requested that the treasury be sealed. The next day all the silver was examined, and evidence was found that market silver had been borrowed to cover shortfalls. The crimes of Guo Tai and the others were all verified. At the time the emperor was extending favor to ministers at court and abroad. He Shen was given the title Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and appointed lecturer at the imperial lectures. In the forty-eighth year he was granted double peacock feathers and made chief director of the National History Bureau, superintendent of the Wenyuan Pavilion, and director of the Manchu Classics project. When the Muslim rebels at Shi Feng Fort in Gansu were pacified, he was rewarded for carrying out the imperial will. He was again granted the hereditary Light Chariot Commandant, and together with his previous post was made a first-rank baron. He was transferred to minister of Personnel and associate grand secretary, while continuing to manage the Ministry of Revenue as before.
5
使 使 殿 調 便
In the fifty-first year Censor Cao Xibao impeached He Shen's household slave Liu Quan for arrogating prerogatives and building houses in violation of regulations. The emperor saw that Cao really wished to impeach He Shen himself but dared not say so openly, and so used the household member as his pretext. Imperial princes and ministers together with the Censorate were ordered to summon Cao Xibao and have him speak directly of He Shen's private abuses, but he ultimately could not substantiate any charge. He Shen had also beforehand had Liu Quan demolish and rebuild the house. Inspection could not verify the charge, and Cao Xibao was punished. A month later He Shen was appointed Grand Secretary of the Wenhua Hall. An edict stated that he had managed the Chongwen Gate superintendency for eight years, that a grand secretary should not also hold revenue-collection duties, and that Cao Xibao's impeachment of his household member may not have been unrelated to the matter. His superintendency was therefore removed. Ministry clerk Zhan Lu was promoted to prefect of Guangxin. The emperor saw that he was young and unfit for a regional post and rebuked He Shen for reckless recommendation. Also, Governor-General Fu Lehun of Guangdong and Guangxi had indulged his household in extortion. He Shen requested that Fu Lehun be transferred back without launching a major prosecution. Rice in the capital was dear. He Shen requested a ban on hoarding: anyone holding more than fifty shi would have to surrender the surplus to government granaries for sale at reduced price. Merchants and commoners found the measure inconvenient. Court ministers went along with the original proposal, and the emperor sharply rebuked them all. In the fifty-third year, with the Taiwan rebel Lin Shuangwen pacified, he was promoted to third-rank Loyal and Assisting Count and granted a purple bridle. In the fifty-fifth year he was granted the yellow belt and a four-panel patched robe. For the emperor's eightieth birthday, He Shen and Minister Jin Jian were ordered to manage the celebration affairs exclusively. Academician Yin Zhuangtu memorialized that the provincial treasuries were empty. The emperor was visibly moved. He Shen requested that Yin Zhuangtu be sent at once to inspect the treasuries of every province, with Vice Minister Qing Cheng supervising. At each province Qing Cheng obstructed the inspection, waiting until funds had been shifted to cover the gaps before the treasury was opened. No shortfalls were found anywhere, and Yin Zhuangtu was dismissed for false statements.
6
使便 使
In the fifty-sixth year stone classics were carved at the Piyong, and He Shen was appointed chief director. At the time there were eight directors. Minister Peng Yuanrui alone undertook the collation and was ordered to compile the Collected Emendations to the Stone Classics. When the work was finished Yuanrui received special rewards. He Shen envied this. He slandered Yuanrui's compilation as poor and further said that only the Son of Heaven may emend texts. The emperor said, "The book was imperially approved—how can it be called a private work?" He Shen then had others compose emendations against the Collected Emendations, passed them off as his own work and presented them to the throne, criticized the Collected Emendations as inconvenient for students, and requested their destruction. The emperor did not permit it. The academy officials memorialized requesting publication, but He Shen blocked it and the plan was halted. He also secretly had men grind down characters on the stone tablets, altering every reading that followed antiquity.
7
殿 調
In the fifty-seventh year, with Gorkha pacified, he received merit evaluation and was also made chancellor of the Hanlin Academy. In the sixtieth year he served as reader at the palace examination and as instructor to the newly passed jinshi. At the time the annual capital review had suspended executions; only the most serious cases required an imperial decision. While managing Mongol affairs, He Shen left a memorial on a serious Mongol case unsent. He was demoted one rank but kept in office. Also, at the military metropolitan examination he drafted the policy questions, and the emperor ordered verification against the Veritable Records. By precedent the Veritable Records do not record military examination policy questions. He Shen answered casually and not in accord with fact. An edict rebuked him for shielding faults and concealing errors, and he was dismissed from office but retained to serve. Previously he had repeatedly been nominated for merit evaluation at the capital inspection, but that year the nomination was specially suspended. In Jiaqing 2 he was transferred to manage the Ministry of Punishments. Soon afterward, because of military supply accounting, he again concurrently managed the Ministry of Revenue. In the third year, with the teaching-bandit Wang Sanhuai captured, he was promoted to duke for his supporting merit.
8
He Shen had held power for a long time. Skilled at reading the Gaozong Emperor's wishes, he wielded stolen authority and made his own fortune. Those who would not attach themselves to him he watched for an opening to rouse the emperor's anger and bring them down; those who paid bribes he would intercede for, or deliberately slow a case, waiting for the emperor's anger to subside. High officials relied on him as a secret patron and squeezed their subordinates to supply what he wanted. Salt administration and river works had always been rich sources of profit, but under his insatiable exactions they grew daily more ruined. The Sichuan-Hubei bandit turmoil arose from aggravated grievances. The generals mostly relied on He Shen, wasted funds lavishly, and for a long time achieved nothing. A Gui, as the leading minister among meritorious officials, had never gotten along with him and was obstructed by him. When on duty he would not lodge together with him in the same duty quarters. After A Gui died, He Shen grew even more unbridled. On Grand Council rescripts he alone signed his own name. His colleague Ji Huang was elderly and was repeatedly reprimanded on false charges. Wang Jie held to integrity and constantly clashed with him, yet could not restrain him either. Zhu Gui had formerly been tutor to the Jiaqing Emperor. While serving as governor-general of Guangdong and Guangxi, the Gaozong Emperor wished to summon him as grand secretary. He Shen envied his advancement, secretly took the Jiaqing Emperor's congratulatory poem and showed it to Gaozong, accusing Zhu of currying favor. Gaozong was greatly enraged, and only Dong Gao's remonstrance saved Zhu from punishment; soon afterward, on other grounds, Zhu Gui was demoted to governor of Anhui and barred from recall to the capital. Among the censors only Qian Feng, in impeaching his associate Guo Tai, obtained justice. Later, commenting that He Shen and A Gui did not lodge together when on duty, he was ordered to supervise the matter and died from overwork. Cao Xibao and Yin Zhuangtu were all punished, and none dared speak openly of his crimes. Though Gaozong checked him when matters arose, He Shen cleverly patched things over and, undisciplined, grew ever more wanton. The Jiaqing Emperor had known his treachery from his time as heir apparent. Upon ascending the throne, because Gaozong was advanced in years he did not wish to act rashly and still treated him with forbearance.
9
殿 輿 仿 殿
In the first month of the fourth year Gaozong died. Supervising Secretary Wang Niansun was the first to impeach He Shen's unlawful conduct. On the very day the mourning edict was proclaimed, the Jiaqing Emperor issued orders for his arrest and trial. Princes and ministers jointly investigated, and all charges were verified. An edict announced He Shen's crimes, stating in part: "On the third day of the ninth month of Qianlong 60 I received my late father's investiture as crown prince, though it had not yet been publicly announced. On the second, He Shen ahead of me presented a ruyi scepter, taking the posture of one who had aided my accession—first great crime. Riding a horse straight through the left gate of the Old Summer Palace, passing the Hall of Imperial Brightness, to Shoushan Kou—second great crime. Crossing the chair-bridge into the inner palace and entering the Gate of Divine Prowess in a sedan chair—third great crime. Taking palace women as a secondary wife—fourth great crime. Arbitrarily suppressing military reports from all routes, deliberately deceiving and concealing—fifth great crime. When my late father's sacred person was unwell, He Shen showed no sorrow and joked and laughed as usual—sixth great crime. My late father, straining despite illness to approve memorials, sometimes wrote imperfectly. He Shen would say it would be better to tear them up and redraft—seventh great crime. While managing Revenue accounting, he alone monopolized Ministry affairs, altered established rules, and did not allow ministry officials to participate in deliberation—eighth great crime. Last year Kuishu memorialized that bandits in the Xunhua and Guide departments were plundering Qinghai. He Shen returned the original memorial and concealed it without action—ninth great crime. After my late father passed away, I ordered that Mongol princes who had not had smallpox need not come to the capital. He Shen on his own authority ordered that both those who had and had not had smallpox need not come—tenth great crime. Grand Secretary Su Linga was hard of hearing and feeble. Because he was related by marriage to He Shen's younger brother He Lin, this was concealed and not reported; Vice Ministers Wu Sheng Lan and Li Huang, and Minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud Li Guangyun, served as tutors in his household. He protected their promotion to ministerial rank and concurrent posts as provincial examination commissioner—eleventh great crime. Personnel registered in the Grand Council he arbitrarily dismissed—twelfth great crime. Among the confiscated property, his nanmu houses were extravagantly built in violation of regulations, modeled on the Palace of Tranquil Longevity. The adornments of his gardens and residences were no different from the Penglai Isle and Jade Terrace of the Old Summer Palace—thirteenth great crime. At his tomb in Jizhou he set up a sacrificial hall and built a tunnel. Local people called it He Ling—fourteenth great crime. He possessed more than two hundred pearl bracelets, several times the number in the inner palace. Some large pearls were bigger than those on the imperial crown—fifteenth great crime. Gem-studded finials were not what he should have possessed, yet he had dozens. Whole large gems were beyond count, surpassing those in the inner palace—sixteenth great crime. Stored silver and clothing numbered more than ten million—seventeenth great crime. Gold hidden in hollow walls amounted to more than twenty-six thousand taels. A private treasury held more than six thousand taels of gold, and cellars concealed more than three million taels of silver—eighteenth great crime. Pawnshops and money shops in Tongzhou and Jizhou had capital of more than one hundred thousand, competing with the people for profit—nineteenth great crime. His household slave Liu Quan's family property reached more than two hundred thousand, and included large pearl bracelets—twentieth great crime." Ministers at court and abroad memorialized that He Shen's crimes warranted the charge of great treason. The emperor, still considering that He Shen had once served as chief minister, could not bear to have him executed in the marketplace and granted him death by suicide.
10
使 滿使
Those who impeached He Shen compared him to Cao Cao and Wang Mang. Zhili Provincial Administration Commissioner Wu Xiongguang had formerly served in the Grand Council. When he came to audience the emperor asked, "People say He Shen had rebellious intent—is this so?" Wu Xiongguang said, "All who harbor disloyal designs must win people's hearts. He Shen, however, had almost no Manchus or Han who would attach themselves to him. Even if he harbored disloyal intent, who would follow him?" The emperor said, "Then was it not perhaps too hasty to punish him?" Wu Xiongguang said, "If his crimes are not punished swiftly, ignorant men will watch and wait for opportunities, and other troubles will arise. Acting swiftly is the fullest expression of righteousness; concluding swiftly is the highest expression of benevolence." After He Shen was executed, the emperor announced to court ministers, "All who were recommended by He Shen or who sought favor at his door shall not be deeply investigated. They are urged to reform, and all are granted a fresh start." When some said He Shen's property still had concealed portions, these too were dismissed without inquiry. While He Shen was in power, he ordered that all memorialists send copies of their memorials to the Grand Council; tribute presented to the throne had first to be reported to him. He arbitrarily approved or rejected it, and whatever was not fully accepted went into his private possession. More than a thousand men of the Metropolitan Garrison patrol battalion served at He Shen's private residence. He also ordered each ministry to recommend aged and mediocre officials as censors. At this time all these abuses were abolished. Established rules in the Ministries of Personnel and Revenue that He Shen had altered were memorialized by ministers requesting step-by-step correction. Initially, during the Qianlong reign he was ordered to transfer to the Plain Yellow Banner. After his conviction he remained registered in the Plain Red Banner.
11
綿
His son Fengshen Yinde married Princess Hexiao of the first rank and was repeatedly promoted to commander-in-chief, concurrently commander of the Guard Corps, and grand minister of the Imperial Household Department. When He Shen was executed, court ministers deliberated on stripping his titles and offices. An edict stated that because of the princess, he was allowed to retain inheritance of the earldom. Soon, in the confiscation of property, eastern pearl court beads were found—items subordinates should not possess. When household members were interrogated, they said He Shen at times hung them under a lamp and spoke to himself before a mirror. The Jiaqing Emperor was enraged and stripped Fengshen Yinde of the earldom. He still inherited his former post of third-rank Light Chariot Commandant. In Jiaqing 7, with the Sichuan-Hubei-Shaanxi teaching-bandits pacified, favor was extended and he was given the rank of commoner duke and appointed minister without portfolio. Before long, the princess's household steward Kuifu accused Fengshen Yinde of practicing martial arts, plotting disloyalty, and intending to harm the princess. Court ministers jointly investigated and found it to be a false accusation. An edict stated that Fengshen Yinde and the princess had always been harmonious. His composition "Ode to the Green Fly" showed fear of slander and dread of ridicule, with no resentment or disloyalty; he was only convicted of the crime of keeping a concubine who bore a daughter during the mourning period. His ducal title was stripped, his office removed, and he was confined at home. In the eleventh year he was appointed first-class bodyguard, promoted to deputy commander-in-chief, and granted the title of earl. In the fifteenth year he fell ill, requested release from office, and was granted the title of duke. He soon died. Having no son, He Lin's son Fengshen Yimian inherited the Light Chariot Commandant.
12
More than fifteen years after He Shen's execution, the National History Bureau submitted his biography. The Jiaqing Emperor found the account sparse in detail and noted that it omitted the many rebukes Gaozong had imposed. Such an account could not serve to inform the present and transmit to posterity. Compiler Xi Yu was dismissed from office, and a special edict was issued as admonition.
13
使 西 綿
His younger brother He Lin, starting as a clerk, was repeatedly promoted to censor of the Huguang circuit. He impeached Hubei Surveillance Commissioner Li Tianpei for privately associating with grain transport boats to carry timber. Investigation revealed that Governor-General Fu Kang'an of Guangdong and Guangxi had sent letters requesting purchase. The emperor commended He Lin's upright integrity, referred the matter to the ministry for merit evaluation, and from this he came to be promoted and employed. From a supervising secretary in the Ministry of Personnel he was exceptionally promoted to academician of the Grand Secretariat, concurrently with the rank of vice minister of Rites. Soon he was appointed vice minister of War and deputy commander-in-chief of the Plain Blue Banner Han Army. When Gorkha disturbed rear Tibet, General Fu Kang'an went to suppress them. The emperor ordered He Lin to supervise courier stations, transport relays, and related matters east of front Tibet. Soon he was ordered to alternate with E Hui in managing grain supplies and was promoted to minister of Works. He memorialized on the repentance of the bandit chief Ratna Badur. An edict ordered Fu Kang'an to accept surrender and, together with He Lin, properly arrange follow-up measures. Before long he was appointed commander-in-chief of the Bordered White Banner Han Army. He was ordered together with Sun Shiyi and Hui Ling to audit and settle accounts west of Zham, while still managing Tibetan affairs. In Qianlong 58 he was granted the hereditary Cloud Cavalry Commandant. In the fifty-ninth year he was appointed governor-general of Sichuan. In the sixtieth year the Miao leader Shi Liudeng rebelled in Guizhou, disturbing Zhengda, Xiunao, and Songtao. The Hunan Miao Wu Bansheng and Shi Sanbao responded, besieging Yongshou. The emperor ordered Yunnan-Guizhou Governor-General Fu Kang'an to go suppress them. He Lin was then on his way to the capital. When he reached Yingzhou, the Songtao bandits had already broken into Xiushan territory. He Lin heard the alarm and rushed there, directing Brigadier Zhang Zhilin and Regimental Commander Ma Yu to drive them off; Later he again defeated the bandits at Yannong, advanced to attack Huangpi at Paomushan, and opened the route to Songtao. He was rewarded with double peacock feathers. At the time Fu Kang'an had already relieved the sieges of Zhengda, Xiunao, and Songtao and was attacking Shi Liudeng at Datang Post. He Lin led troops to join him and was then ordered to assist in military affairs; He captured the Xiafei fort and Wulong Rock, received the surrender of more than seventy stockades, and was enfeoffed as first-rank Baron of Promoting Courage. He again attacked and took Yanbishan and was rewarded with an imperial sable jacket. Also for the merit of receiving Wu Bansheng's surrender, he was rewarded with the yellow belt. Great victories at the stockades of Longjiao Fort, Yabao, and Tianxing earned him the title Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and a black-fox formal robe. In Jiaqing 1 he captured the passes of Jieshigang, Liaojiachong, and Lianfengni and was granted use of the purple bridle. When Fu Kang'an died, He Lin was ordered to supervise military affairs. At the time Shi Sanbao had already been captured, but Shi Liudeng still held Pinglong. He seized the Jianyunshan battery, recovered Qianzhou, and was rewarded with triple peacock feathers. In the eighth month he advanced to besiege Pinglong and died in camp. He was posthumously promoted to first-rank duke, given the posthumous name Zhongzhuang, and granted sacrificial rites and burial honors. He was ordered to share sacrifice in the Imperial Ancestral Temple, worshipped in the Shrines of Manifest Loyalty, Worthy Virtue, and others, and his family was permitted to build a private shrine. In the fourth year, after He Shen was executed, court ministers judged that He Lin had relied on influence to claim merit. The emperor also blamed him for joining the Miao suppression and hampering Fu Kang'an so the army achieved nothing. He was ordered removed from the Imperial Ancestral Temple, his private shrine destroyed, and his son Fengshen Yimian stripped of the ducal title and made to inherit the third-rank Light Chariot Commandant instead.
14
滿 西
Su Linga was a Manchu of the Plain White Banner. In Qianlong 6 he became a translation licentiate. From a secretary in the Grand Secretariat he was repeatedly promoted to intendant of the Guangrao-Jiunan circuit in Jiangxi. He was demoted. In the fiftieth year, from a department vice director in the Ministry of Personnel he was exceptionally promoted and served successively as vice minister in the Ministries of War, Works, and Revenue. He was transferred to minister of Revenue. He went out to serve as governor-general of Liangjiang. In Jiaqing 2 he was appointed Grand Secretary of the Eastern Pavilion and also acting minister of Punishments. After He Shen was executed, he retired and was assigned to guard the Yuling Mausoleum. He died.
15
The commentators say: Gaozong was resolute and stern. When ministers had faults he showed no leniency. Tradition holds that Minzhong lost the emperor's favor through his association with Gao Yun. When he fell ill and was ordered to take leave, a dhāraṇī sutra quilt was suddenly bestowed on him, and he was soon reported as not recovering. Observing the edict removing him from the temple of worthies, which even cited Yan Song as a parallel, whether the rumor is true or false cannot be known. He Shen succeeded in wielding power when Gaozong grew weary of governing. Relying on favor he was greedy and wanton, and in the end failed because of this. The Jiaqing Emperor once discussed Tang Emperor Daizong's killing of Li Fuguo, saying, "When Daizong was crown prince, he barely escaped being slandered by Fuguo. When he ascended the throne, he corrected Fuguo's crimes and executed him—a prison clerk could have handled it." This was surely directed at He Shen.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →