← Back to 清史稿

卷405 列傳一百九十二 曾国籓

Volume 405 Biographies 192: Ceng Guofan

Chapter 405 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 405
Next Chapter →
1
Biographies 192
2
Zeng Guofan
3
Zeng Guofan, whose original name was Zicheng and whose courtesy name was Disheng, came from Xiangxiang in Hunan. His family had farmed for generations. His grandfather Yuping was the first in the family to turn toward village learning. His father Linshu held the rank of district-school student and was known throughout the region for his filial devotion.
4
Guofan received his jinshi degree in the eighteenth year of Daoguang (1838). In the twenty-third year of the reign (1843), serving as a reviser he presided over the Sichuan provincial examinations, was later made reader-in-waiting, and rose in succession to Grand Secretary of the Grand Secretariat and Vice Minister of Rites, with concurrent charge of the Ministry of War. Tang Jian, Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, was then lecturing in the capital, and Guofan—along with Woren, Wu Tingdong, and He Guizhen—reverently attended him and pursued the Neo-Confucian study of moral principle. He also kept company with Mei Cengliang, Shao Yichen, Liu Chuanying, and others in literary composition and evidential scholarship, while keeping a keen eye on men of talent across the empire.
5
西 使 西
Early in the Xianfeng reign, rebellion flared in Guangxi, and the throne ordered the ministers to speak frankly on the empire's strengths and failures. In his memorial he declared that the day's most urgent task was putting the right men in place—that talent could be redirected, cultivated, and tested by proper methods. The emperor praised the memorial as incisive, earnest, and lucid. Soon afterward he submitted a memorial recommending Li Tangjie, Wu Tingdong, Wang Qingyun, Yan Zhengji, and Jiang Zhongyuan. As the rebel threat intensified, he memorialized again: "Insufficient revenue and unskilled troops—these are the empire's two gravest ills. Beyond the regular annual revenue, we must not resort to new schemes of exaction—for every extra fraction taken, the people suffer proportionate harm. Of annual outlays, military pay was the heaviest burden: the Green Standard rolls listed 640,000 men, yet 60,000 to 70,000 posts were routinely left vacant to help meet military costs. Since the mid-Qianlong debate over troop increases, the treasury had been wasting more than two million taels a year on the army. Even then Grand Secretary Agui had warned that the burden could not be sustained; under Jiaqing and Daoguang two rounds of cuts were proposed, yet fewer than four-tenths were actually removed. He urged cutting another 50,000 men and restoring the old rolls. From antiquity, at a dynasty's founding few troops have meant a strong state; afterward the more soldiers there are, the weaker the army grows, and the more pay is spent, the poorer the treasury becomes. He asked the emperor to cultivate commanders of real talent: if even a dozen of the seventy-one garrisons could serve as a dependable core, the throne would have forces it could trust in any emergency." He also lamented that officials at court and in the provinces flattered, deceived, and concealed the truth, with none of the old spirit of frank counsel and mutual accountability. He therefore submitted a memorial on cultivating imperial virtue and forestalling abuses, speaking with blunt directness to the emperor himself on matters others dared not raise; the throne answered with an edict of gracious approval. He served in turn as acting Vice Minister of Punishments and of Personnel. In the second year of Xianfeng (1852), while presiding over the Jiangxi provincial examinations, he was called home midway on news of his mother's death.
6
便
In the third year (1853) the Taiping rebels seized Nanjing and made it their capital, while detachments marched north into Henan and Zhili and the empire was thrown into uproar. Guofan had already been ordered to organize local defense at Changsha. At first Guofan meant to petition for permission to observe the full three-year mourning. Guo Songsong said, "You have long aspired to set the realm to rights—if you do not seize this moment to serve, what becomes of your duty to sovereign and father? Besides, taking the field in mourning dress is an ancient precedent." With that he did not decline again. Adopting the methods left by the Ming general Qi Jiguang, he recruited plain, sturdy farmers and drilled them from dawn to dusk. He chose literati for his officers, kept each unit under five hundred men, and called the force the "Hunan Braves." He wrote openly to men near and far and treated even the humble as equals. Men of talent from the countryside, moved by his sincerity, came to see him one after another; all believed that Lord Zeng was someone with whom great affairs could be discussed. When bandits erupted throughout the region, he dispatched the Hunan Braves at the first alarm. He set up a three-tier system of justice and did not burden the regular courts. Within a fortnight he had seized and summarily executed more than two hundred ruffians and corrupt clerks. Slander spread on every side; from the governor down through the provincial bureaucracy men secretly resented him, even charging that drilling troops in midsummer was cruelty. Yet his memorials consistently won imperial praise, and he enjoyed the emperor's confidence—so none dared openly stand in his way. One day the provincial garrison troops clashed with the Hunan Braves and even stormed into Guofan's headquarters. Guofan appealed in person to the governor, who offered a perfunctory apology but took no action; that same day Guofan moved his camp outside the walls to avoid the garrison. Someone asked, "Why not report this to the throne? Guofan sighed and said, "The great crisis is not yet past—how dare we trouble our sovereign and father with private grievances?"
7
西 歿 退
He had discussed with Guo Songsong and Jiang Zhongyuan how the southeast was a country of rivers and that suppressing the rebels required a navy; he memorialized to build warships at Hengzhou. None of the craftsmen or soldiers knew naval design; through careful thought he devised short oars and long sweeps so that human power could overcome wind and current, and in the end completed 240 vessels large and small. He raised ten thousand men for combined land and river operations: Chu Ruhang, Yang Zaifu, and Peng Yulin commanded the fleet, while Taqibu and Luo Zinan led the land forces. The rebels drove up from Jiangxi and again seized Jiujiang and Anqing. Jiang Zhongyuan fell in battle at Luzhou, and Wu Wenrong, commanding at Huangzhou, was likewise defeated and killed. Hanyang fell, Wuchang was placed on alert, and the rebels again swept into Hunan on the tide of victory. Burning to strike at the rebels, Guofan led his combined army and fleet down the Yangtze. As the fleet first cleared the lake, a fierce gale wrecked several dozen ships. The land force reached Yuezhou, but the vanguard collapsed and he was forced back to Changsha. The rebels seized Xiangtan; he met them at Jinggang and was beaten again. In despair Guofan threw himself into the river, but Zhang Shoulin, a member of his staff, pulled him out and saved his life. Yet at the same moment Taqibu won a crushing victory at Xiangtan. Guofan made camp at Gaofeng Temple in Changsha and set about reorganizing his forces, while men on every side mocked him. Some urged him to raise more troops. Guofan said, "Ten thousand men on land and water are not too few, yet they break the moment they meet the enemy. At Yuezhou only Yang Zaifu's single battalion among the fleet stood and fought; at Xiangtan Taqibu on land and Yang Zaifu on the water each had only two battalions—this shows that armies value quality, not numbers. When Zhuge Liang was defeated at Qishan he even planned to cut troops and rations and searched diligently for his own faults—that was no empty lesson. Moreover, the ancients made merit, guilt, reward, and punishment explicit before they fought. In this age of chaos worthy men lie low; I rallied them with a call to righteousness, and they share my peril. You followed me at first not for profit, so it is hard to enforce discipline strictly—and that is why we have been defeated. When the generals heard this, they were all convinced.
8
沿
After the land force took Xiangtan, the governor and provincial commander reported the victory, while Guofan submitted a plea for punishment. The emperor rebuked Provincial Commander Bao Qibao, stripped him of his post, and replaced him with Taqibu. On the day Taqibu received his seal, crowds gathered and marveled that Guofan knew how to judge men and that the emperor could see clearly across the realm. The rebels took Changde from Yuezhou, then drove north, and Wuchang fell once more. Guofan marched on Yuezhou, beheaded the rebel commander Zeng Tianyang, fought a series of engagements, and captured Chenglingji. He concentrated his forces at Jinkou and planned the recapture of Wuchang. Luo Zinan struck the rebel camp at Huayuan along the east bank; Taqibu lay in ambush on Hongshan; Yang Zaifu's fleet drove deep into the enemy lines, and his men stood exposed in the open, heedless of musket fire. Seeing the government forces in overwhelming strength, the rebels in Wuchang and Hanyang fled by night, and both cities were recovered. Guofan had earlier asked to be stripped of rank after the defeat at Jinggang; when that memorial was now submitted, the throne appointed him acting Governor of Hubei, soon added Vice Minister of War, released him from the acting governorship, and ordered him to command the advance downriver.
9
西 西 使
The fleet now fought with unstoppable fury, crushing the rebels at Tianjiazhen and killing tens of thousands, reaching Jiujiang with the vanguard pressing on Hukou. Unable to reduce the rebel fort at Meijiazhou, they sailed into Poyang Lake. The rebels fortified Hukou and cut off their retreat, trapping the ships so that the outer Yangtze and inner lake were completely cut off from each other. The warships on the outer river had no small craft; the rebels came by night in skiffs, set fire to the command vessels, and Guofan leaped clear and escaped as the fleet collapsed into chaos. He memorialized asking to be punished; the throne graciously excused him, declaring that the overall campaign was unharmed. In the fifth year (1855) the rebels again seized Wuhan and raided the Jing-Xiang region. Guofan sent Hu Linyi and others back to relieve Hubei, left Taqibu to press the siege of Jiujiang, and went in person to Nanchang to steady the fleet trapped in Poyang Lake. Luo Zinan campaigned in Jiangxi, retaking Yiyang, capturing Guangxin, and breaking Yining, while Taqibu died in camp. In Jiangxi Guofan clashed with Governor Chen Qimai; Luo Zinan shuttled back and forth on urgent orders and wrote to Guofan that the key to the southeast was Wuchang, asking to lead his division to relieve Hubei, and Guofan agreed. His adviser Liu Rong objected: "You rely on Taqibu and Luo Zinan. Taqibu is dead and Luo is marching away—if trouble comes, who will you send? Guofan replied, "I have weighed this carefully. The southeast must be handled this way—we accomplish nothing if we all stay trapped here. At the farewell feast Guo Songsong said to Luo Zinan, "Lord Zeng's force is thin—what then? Luo Zinan answered, "If Heaven does not mean to destroy our dynasty, Lord Zeng will not die. In the ninth month he received formal appointment as Vice Minister of War.
10
西 調 西穿 退
In the sixth year (1856) the rebel leader Shi Dakai swept from Hubei into Jiangxi and seized eight prefectures and one department in succession; the rebels at Jiujiang held firm as ever, and Hunan was cut off from news north and south. Besieged at Nanchang, Guofan posted generals at key points; urgent dispatches flew back and forth, yet he never set aside his daily reading and recitation. He composed victory songs for the army and fleet, using them to teach tactics of attack and defense and methods of camp layout and battle formation; the men who sang them were stirred to fervor and took pride in killing rebels and facing death without fear. Given his numbers, however, he could never deliver a decisive blow to the rebels. Critics clamored to recall Luo Zinan's army, but the emperor ruled that the Wuhan campaign was near success and must not be abandoned. Luo Zinan pressed the fighting ever harder and in the end died in the field. When Peng Yulin heard the alarm in Jiangxi, he walked a thousand li in straw sandals, passed through enemy lines, and reached Nanchang to help hold the city. Hu Linyi was now Governor of Hubei; Guofan's brothers Guohua and Guobao, invoking their father's order, begged troops from Hu Linyi and led five thousand men against Ruizhou. Hunan Governor Luo Bingzhang also supplied Zeng Guoquan's troops to relieve Ji'an, and the brothers all served together in the field. Meanwhile the forces Guofan had sent to relieve Hubei, after a long campaign, retook Wuhan and drove down to Jiujiang, where Li Xubing encamped eight thousand men east of the city. Li Xubing and his younger brother Li Xuyi were both among Luo Zinan's finest pupils. Yang Zaifu anchored four hundred warships along both banks; the Jiangning garrison general Duxing'a with his cavalry and Bao Chao's infantry held Xiaochikou—in all tens of thousands of men. Guofan had always led his army through anxiety and strict discipline; he came out from Nanchang to welcome them, saw their imposing array, and redoubled his stern warnings and admonitions. Yet at that very moment the Great Camp of Jiangnan collapsed; Commander Xiang Rong fell back to Danyang and died there. He Chun was appointed Imperial Commissioner, and Zhang Guoliang took overall command of the armies attacking Jiangning.
11
西
In the second month of the seventh year of Xianfeng, Zeng Guofan learned of his father's death and returned home at once. He was granted three months' leave to mourn but insisted on observing the full mourning term; the court permitted him to relinquish his vice-ministership. Once Hu Linyi had secured Hubei, he pressed the siege of Jiujiang, broke Hukou, and after years cut off the river fleet was reunited. Yang Zaifu captured Wangjiang and Dongliu in succession, swept past Anqing, took Tongling and Nizha, and joined the Jiangnan army. From this the Hunan Army's river fleet won fame throughout the empire. Hu Linyi, pointing out that Zeng Guofan had created this army and that Yang Zaifu and Peng Yulin were both his old officers, asked that Zeng Guofan be recalled to command the forces. Just as Jiujiang was retaken, Shi Dakai fled into Zhejiang and gradually into Fujian, while a splinter force again raided Jiangxi; the court ordered Zeng Guofan to take charge of Zhejiang military affairs.
12
西 西 西歿 宿
Zeng Guofan reached Jiangxi and encamped at Jianchang, and was then ordered to relieve Fujian. Zeng Guofan thought the Fujian rebels were not the main worry, but Jingdezhen stood at a vital junction; he sent generals to aid northern Ganzhou and attack Jingdezhen. Zeng Guoquan pursued the rebels to Fuliang, and the cities of Jiangxi were retaken in succession. At this time Shi Dakai again fled into Hunan and besieged Shaoyang. The emperor feared Sichuan might also be unsettled; Hu Linyi argued that Hubei's supplies depended on Sichuan salt, and that Zeng Guofan, long at war, held no territorial post—he and Guan Wen jointly memorialized asking that Zeng Guofan be sent to relieve Sichuan. When the rebels fled into Guangxi and eased pressure upstream, Chen Yucheng again seized Luzhou and Li Xubing was killed at Sanhe; Hu Linyi, seeing bandits spreading between Luzhou and Shouzhou and ultimately threatening Hunan, changed course and urged keeping Zeng Guofan to plan the Anhui campaign together. The army was split into three columns of ten thousand men each. Zeng Guofan advanced from Susong and Shipai toward Anqing; Duolonga and Bao Chao crossed Lake Tai to seize Tongcheng; Hu Linyi marched from Yingshan toward Shucheng and Lu'an. After Duolonga and his colleagues routed the rebels at Xiaochi and retook Taihu and Qianshan, they encamped at Tongcheng. Zeng Guoquan led the armies in besieging Anqing, forming a pincer with the Tongcheng force. Before Anqing fell, rebels in southern Anhui seized Guangde and stormed Hangzhou.
13
Li Xiucheng gathered the rebel hosts at Jianping and sent columns to relieve Jiangning; the Great Camp of Jiangnan collapsed again, and Changzhou and Suzhou fell in turn—it was the intercalary third month of the tenth year of Xianfeng. When Zuo Zongtang heard the news he sighed and said, "This is the turning point between victory and defeat! The armies of Jiangnan have long been led by failing generals with exhausted troops. If they are cleared away and renewed, perhaps those who come after may have something to build on?" Someone asked, "Who can take command?" Hu Linyi said, "If the court entrusts the affairs of Jiangnan to Lord Zeng, the whole realm can be pacified." Thereupon the emperor carefully chose a commander, immediately added Zeng Guofan to the Ministry of War with ministerial rank, made him acting Governor-General of the Two Jiangs, soon confirmed him in office, and appointed him Imperial Commissioner. At this time rebel strength flared in Jiangsu and Zhejiang, and some urged lifting the siege of Anqing to meet the more urgent crisis. Zeng Guofan said, "The Anqing army is the foundation for taking Jinling; it must not be moved." He then crossed the Yangtze southward and encamped at Qimen. Pleas for help from Jiangsu and Zhejiang officials and gentry arrived by the dozen each day, and edicts to relieve Suzhou, Shanghai, Anhui, and Zhenjiang followed one after another. Within days of Zeng Guofan's arrival at Qimen, the rebels seized Ningguo and Huizhou. The southeast was worn down by war, and Britain again broke relations and sent troops. Sengge Rinchen was defeated at Tianjin; Emperor Xianfeng fled to Rehe; Zeng Guofan, hearing the alarm, asked to march north with his army, but when peace was made he desisted.
14
西 退 使 西 西
That winter he was hard pressed by rebels: one column east of Qimen seized Wuyuan; one west of Qimen seized Jingdezhen; one entered Yangzhan Pass and attacked the main camp. Military reports ceased entirely; officers and officials looked fearful and repeatedly urged moving the camp to the riverbank to join the fleet. Zeng Guofan said, "A withdrawal without cause is what strategists most dread." He refused, and sent men by secret routes to order Bao Chao and Zhang Yunlan to march to join him at once. Though in the midst of the army, his spirits remained steady, and he sometimes drank and discussed literature with his advisers. Since his days at court he had kept a daily record of words and deeds, and afterward, even amid peril and hardship, he never missed a day. Zeng Guofan at Qimen had originally drawn supplies from Jiangxi; when Jingdezhen fell, debaters all urged taking Huizhou to open a route for Zhejiang grain. He then led the main army to Xiuning; rain fell, eight camps collapsed, he drafted a final testament to send home, and swore to hold Xiuning to the death. Just then Zuo Zongtang routed the rebels at Leping, the supply route opened, and he moved his headquarters to Dongliu. Duolonga repeatedly defeated the rebels at Tongcheng; Bao Chao's division raided without a fixed base; Hu Linyi again sent generals to assist. In the eighth month of the eleventh year of Xianfeng, Zeng Guoquan at last took Anqing. When victory was reported, Emperor Xianfeng died and Hu Linyi also passed away. Emperor Tongzhi succeeded; the Empress Dowager governed from behind the curtain; Zeng Guofan was given the rank of Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and ordered to coordinate Jiangsu, Anhui, Jiangxi, and Zhejiang. Zeng Guofan was fearful and memorialized to decline; the request was denied; on major state affairs he consulted the throne before acting.
15
西
At that time the false Heavenly King Hong Xiuquan held Jinling in regal pretension; the false Loyal King Li Xiucheng and others attacked Suzhou and Shanghai; the false Attendant King Li Shixian and others seized Zhejiang and Hangzhou; the false Assistant King Yang Fuqing and others held Ningguo; the false King of Kang Wang Haiyang watched Jiangxi; the false Brave King Chen Yucheng held Luzhou; Nian chief Miao Peilin moved in and out of Ying and Shou, cooperating with Yucheng and plotting to break into Shandong and Henan—all claiming forces in the hundreds of thousands. Zeng Guofan and Zeng Guoquan planned the advance; Guoquan said, "Strike Jinling at once, and the rebels must commit their full strength to defending their nest—then Suzhou and Hangzhou may be taken." Zeng Guofan agreed. He entrusted affairs of Jiangning to Guoquan, affairs of Zhejiang to Zuo Zongtang, and affairs of Jiangsu to Li Hongzhang. Li Hongzhang had formerly been Zeng Guofan's pupil, served as a compiler on his staff, was transferred to circuit intendant rank, and was now ordered to raise eight thousand braves along the Huai, given capable generals, and styled the "Huai Army." In the first year of Tongzhi he was appointed Associate Grand Secretary and directed all armies in the advance. Thus Zeng Guoquan had an army to strike Jinling, Li Hongzhang an army to recover Suzhou and Shanghai, and Yang Zaifu and Peng Yulin an army to clear the lower reaches; north of the Yangtze, Duolonga had an army to take Luzhou and Li Xuyi an army to relieve Yingzhou; south of the Yangtze, Bao Chao had an army to attack Ningguo, Zhang Yunlan an army to defend and suppress Huizhou, and Zuo Zongtang an army to recover all Zhejiang: ten columns marched together, all operating under Zeng Guofan's authority.
16
As the rebels held Jinling, they had built strong ramparts and ditches with ample supplies and arms—not to be taken in a rush. Plague broke out on a vast scale; officers and men died in heaps until the army could scarcely hold together. Zeng Guofan, judging his own virtue insufficient, asked that a senior minister be sent to the army to share his burden; the throne issued a gracious edict of consolation, saying, "When calamity spreads from Heaven, how can the fault be yours alone? Perhaps the court's policies have many failings; we ruler and ministers should strive to avert disaster and plead for the people's lives. Moreover, looking all around at home and abroad, none surpass you in talent, strength, and breadth of mind! The times are hard; do not slacken in the least." Zeng Guofan read the edict and wept with emotion. At this time Hong Xiuquan, long besieged, summoned Li Xiucheng from Suzhou and Li Shixian from Zhejiang; they came with all their forces, claiming six hundred thousand men, and besieged the army at Yuhuatai. Zeng Guoquan resisted for sixty-four days, and they withdrew. In the fifth month of the third year of Tongzhi, the river fleet took Jiufuzhou and Jiangning was completely encircled. In the tenth month, Li Hongzhang took Suzhou. In the second month of the fourth year of Tongzhi, Zuo Zongtang took Hangzhou. Zeng Guofan, because Jiangning would not fall, asked Li Hongzhang to come for a joint campaign; before he set out, Zeng Guoquan pressed the attack ever harder and took the city. With Jiangning pacified, the emperor rewarded merit: Zeng Guofan was made Senior Preceptor of the Heir Apparent, enfeoffed as First-rank Marquis of Yiyong with brave merit, and granted the double-eyed peacock feather. Since the founding of the dynasty, this was the first enfeoffment of a civil official as marquis. Court and country celebrated, yet Zeng Guofan, his work complete, did not presume; he remained cautious and deferential as if in fear. Whenever Emperor Tongzhi chose governors and governors-general, he secretly inquired about the man; Zeng Guofan dared not nominate by name in memorials, holding that frontier commanders already wielded punitive authority and should not also share appointment and dismissal power—the drift toward external strength and internal weakness must be guarded against.
17
At first, government armies were deeply set in bad habits: victors would not yield credit, the defeated would not rescue one another. Zeng Guofan trained the Hunan Army, holding that only when ten thousand men were of one mind could rebels be subdued, and so he took loyalty and integrity as his banner to the empire. Later he also held that the Huai region's spirit was vigorous and a separate army should be raised. Hunan braves excelled on mountain paths but were not suited to plains campaigning; after ten years of war their ardor had slackened somewhat, so he wished to train Huai men as successors to the Hunan braves. By then the southeast was largely settled; he reduced the Hunan Army and expanded the Huai Army, and the Nian bandit trouble arose.
18
歿 調 宿 西
The Nian bandits began as vagabonds gathering in Shandong; later they raided between Guangde, Gushi, Yingzhou, Bozhou, Huai, and Xu; they twisted paper and lit fat to signal—hence the name "Nian." They numbered hundreds of thousands, with tens of thousands of horses, trampling thousands of li, splitting and merging without fixed pattern. There were four Nian chiefs: Zhang Zongwan, Ren Zhu, Niu Hong, and Lai Wenguang. Since the Taiping rebels and militia leaders had often enlisted Nian bands to fight government troops, they grew ever more skilled in combat; Sheng Bao and Yuan Jiasan could not hold them. Sengge Rinchen campaigned for years yet could not inflict a crushing blow. Zeng Guofan heard that Sengge Rinchen's army pursued rebels with light cavalry more than three hundred li in a day and night, and said, "By the art of war this must bring the commanding general to ruin." Before long the prince indeed fell in battle at Caozhou; the emperor was greatly alarmed and ordered Zeng Guofan to hasten to Shandong to suppress the Nian, coordinate Zhili, Shandong, and Henan, while Li Hongzhang replaced him as governor-general; court orders daily pressed him to march. Zeng Guofan memorialized: "The Chu army has been reduced almost to nothing; even with Liu Songshen's division and Liu Mingchuan's Huai braves now mobilized, the force is still insufficient. More braves should be raised at Xuzhou, on the model of the Chu army, to develop the spirit of Qi and Yan; cavalry and a Yellow River fleet should also be added—these cannot be ready overnight. Zhili should raise its own defensive troops and garrison the riverbanks; Henan's army should not be made to cover Hebei as well. Sengge Rinchen once toured five provinces; your servant cannot do that. If Xuzhou is made the base camp, then Yan, Yi, Cao, and Ji in Shandong; Gui and Chen in Henan; Huai, Xu, and Hai in Jiangsu; and Lu, Feng, Ying, and Si in Anhui—these thirteen prefectures and departments would be my responsibility, and the rest would fall to the various governors and governors-general. When garrison districts have fixed assignments, military affairs gradually find their proper place." He also memorialized: "Troops should be stationed at key points at Linhuaiguan, Zhoujiakou, Jining, and Xuzhou as four garrison towns. When one place is in crisis, three others go to its aid. Now the rebels have become roving bandits; if they roam and we roam with them, we must wear ourselves out in endless pursuit. Therefore your servant holds to his original proposal: use fixed troops to control unfixed bandits, emphasizing intercepting strikes rather than trailing pursuit." Yet after more than a year as commanding general, the Nian still raided as before. Officers and men all complained that their hardship lay not in fighting but in endless pursuit; he then built a long wall from Zhangqiu to Qingjiang, relying on the Grand Canal for defense; before it was finished the Nian broke into Xiangyang and Dengzhou, so he shifted west, repaired the Sha and Jialu rivers, dug trenches, and set guards. The territorial divisions had barely been fixed when the Nian struck the Henan defense lines and surged east again. Critics widely blamed Zeng Guofan's strategy as ponderous and impractical, yet no other method could bring the Nian to heel.
19
西
The people of Shandong and Henan, used to Sengge Rinchen fighting in the field, resented Zeng Guofan, a commander-in-chief, sitting quietly at Xuzhou, and slander filled the roads. After long years in the field, Zeng Guofan grew ever more cautious about committing troops. First came his plan for four fixed garrison towns; then his strategy of holding the Yellow River and Grand Canal line. After repeated impeachment from the censorate and his own sense that river defense was failing, while the court was recalling Guoquan, he memorialized that Li Hongzhang, as governor-general of Jiangsu, should take the field at Xuzhou and jointly handle the eastern front with the Shandong governor; Zeng Guoquan, as Hubei governor, would take the field at Xiangyang and handle the western front with the Henan governor, while Zeng Guofan himself would remain at Zhoujiakou to coordinate. Others impeached him for arrogance, and Zeng Guofan concluded that power could not be held indefinitely; he grew ever more wary of slander and fearful of public censure. He took sick leave for several months, then asked to resign his post and remain with the army as a private citizen to serve; he also asked to surrender his enfeoffment—all were denied.
20
西西 西 西 西 西 殿調
In the winter of the fifth year of Tongzhi he returned to Jiangnan, and Li Hongzhang took over command of the army. Niu Hong was dead; Zhang Zongwan fled into Shaanxi while Ren Zhu and Lai Wenguang fled into Hubei—from then on they were called the Eastern and Western Nian. In the sixth year he received formal appointment as Grand Secretary and remained at his post. The Eastern Nian fled from Henan into Dengzhou, Laizhou, and Qingzhou; Li Hongzhang and Liu Changyou proposed pooling four provinces' forces to block the Grand Canal. The bandits turned west again, crossed Jiaozhou, Laizhou, and Henan, and entered Haizhou. Government forces killed Ren Zhu in battle, and Lai Wenguang fled and died at Yangzhou. With the Eastern Nian suppressed, Zeng Guofan was granted the hereditary rank of Cloud Cavalry Captain. After the Western Nian entered Shaanxi, Liu Songshan defeated them. They crossed the frozen river into Shanxi, entered Zhili, and threatened Baoding and Tianjin. Liu Songshan circled ahead of them and routed them at Xian County. Relief armies from every quarter converged, but the bandits crossed the Grand Canal and fled into Dongchang and Wuding. Li Hongzhang shifted his army to Dezhou; with the river in full flood, he held the line to trap them. Zeng Guofan sent Huang Yisheng with the river fleet to assist, and government forces crushed the bandits at Renping. Zhang Zongwan drowned himself, and the Western Nian were suppressed. Every strategy of river defense had originated with Zeng Guofan. That year he was appointed Grand Secretary of the Hall of Military Eminence and transferred to Governor-General of Zhili.
21
西 西
In government Zeng Guofan held to the larger pattern and planned for the whole strategic picture. For the western campaigns he proposed clearing the bandits of Longyou first and only then advancing beyond the passes; for Yunnan and Guizhou he proposed making Sichuan and Hunan the foundation. In each case he laid down a plan at the outset, and years later events vindicated him. Once Westerners entered China, foreign affairs grew daily more pressing. Before Nanjing fell, Russia, the United States, Britain, and France all offered military aid; Zeng Guofan politely declined. When the court debated purchasing steam engines and establishing arsenals, he strongly supported the plan and proposed selecting schoolboys to study Western technology in Europe. Whenever treaties were drafted, the throne asked what might be conceded; Zeng Guofan held that empty disputes over ceremony could be yielded, but anything that threatened the people's livelihood must be refused. Once in Zhili he made troop training, official discipline, and river control his three priorities, carried out reforms in sequence, established bureaus for clearing lawsuits and halls for honoring worthies, and government and moral instruction flourished.
22
In the fourth month of the ninth year of Tongzhi, Tianjin residents killed the French consul Fontanier, destroyed churches, and wounded dozens of Christians. Trade Commissioner Chonghou proposed severe punishment, but the people would not accept it. Zeng Guofan was then suffering from eye trouble when an edict ordered him to Tianjin at once. He sought a balanced settlement to preserve peace, executed seventeen men, and banished prefectural and district officials. When Zeng Guofan first arrived, Tianjin residents expected him to reverse Chonghou's course and prepared troops to resist the French. Yet the empire had only just been pacified, the Hunan army disbanded, and Tianjin lay close to the capital; a clash between residents and Christians was not worth war, yet Tianjin blamed him bitterly. Old friends who held lofty views wrote daily to reproach him; provincial lodges even tore down his inscribed couplets. Yet Zeng Guofan weighed the balance of Chinese and foreign military power and the costs of peace and war, blamed only himself, and offered no defense. Ding Richang memorialized: "From antiquity, outsiders fail to grasp the hardships of those inside the affair; one voice is echoed by a hundred, enough to mislead the throne and upset great plans. In the end affairs rupture, the state bears endless loss, while outsiders share none of the calamity yet win renown for upholding pure opinion—your servant is deeply pained!"
23
調
Bearing heavy slander and growing gravely ill, Zeng Guofan summoned Li Hongzhang to handle the case; within a month the affair was settled along the original lines. When a vacancy opened in the Two Jiangs, he was transferred to Jiangnan, and Li Hongzhang was made governor-general of Zhili. When the people of Jiangnan learned he was coming, they burned incense to welcome him. With classics and histories nearly lost after the rebellion, he established an official publishing bureau; its editions were meticulously collated. He ceremonially invited renowned scholars to head academies; his staff gathered the finest men of the age, and Jiangnan culture rivaled its most flourishing era.
24
退 宿 使
Zeng Guofan was imposing in bearing, with a fine beard and moustache and sharp, angular eyes. When receiving guests he would gaze at them for a long time without speaking, awing all who met him; after they left he recorded their strengths and weaknesses, never erring in his judgment. By nature he loved learning and pursued it all his life without weariness; he had a family tradition of scholarship yet was not bound to one school. His scholarship combined Han and Song learning; he held that the ancient kings' way of governing, though woven of countless strands, was unified by ritual. Regretting that Qin Huitian's Comprehensive Study of the Five Rites lacked a section on food and wealth, he compiled supplements on the salt tax, sea transport, currency, and river dikes in six volumes; he also lamented that ancient ritual was incomplete without military rites, which ought to have their own section, as Qi Jingyuan had recorded. Commentators held that the camp regulations Zeng Guofan drew up came close to true military ritual. In his later years he sought to transform the people through quiet moral example and devoted his entire salary to supporting scholars. Veteran scholars and established Confucians all gathered under his patronage. He excelled at judging men and employing them well; those he advanced and recommended are beyond counting. At a single meeting he would assess a man's talent, and he was never wrong. He often cited his ancestors' teaching of farming and reading to instruct his household. He treated officers and staff like his own sons and brothers; though they stood in awe of him, they were glad to serve him. He dwelt long in Jiangnan, where his merit and beneficence were greatest.
25
The commentator says: Zeng Guofan's achievements rested on learning, and he was skilled in moving affairs through ritual. His heart of public sincerity was especially able to win men over. In military and civil administration he strove for what was solid and practical. Whatever he planned for the empire was eventually vindicated; the age praised him, comparing him to Zhuge Liang of Han, Pei Du of Tang, and Wang Yangming of Ming—how grand his reputation! Zeng Guofan also chose thirty-three sages and worthies of past and present, made portraits with encomia, and took them as his teachers—the great outlines of his lifelong aspirations are fully seen in this. Once his fame was secure, he eagerly made recommending talent his chief task; frontier governors and commanders throughout the realm were largely his protégés. In serving the throne through the men he chose, none betrayed the trust he had placed in them. Alas! Since the restoration, there has been only this one man.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →