← Back to 清史稿

卷450 列傳二百三十七 李鹤年 文彬 任道镕 许振祎 吴大澂

Volume 450 Biographies 237: Li Henian, Wen Bin, Ren Daorong, Xu Zhenyi, Wu Dacheng

Chapter 450 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 450
Next Chapter →
1
== 使調使 調
Li Henian, styled Zihe, was a native of Yizhou in Fengtian. He became a jinshi in 1845, moved from a Hanlin compiler's post to the Censorate, and was later appointed a supervising secretary. After returning home for his father's mourning and completing the prescribed period, he was sent to Henan to help manage military affairs. In 1862 he was made intendant of the Chang-Zhen-Tong-Hai Circuit, served as acting Henan judicial commissioner, transferred to Zhili, and received appointment as provincial treasurer. In 1865 he was promoted to governor of Hubei and shortly afterward transferred to Henan.
2
西 沿 西 沿
When Nian rebels were driven south from Shandong, Henian reasoned that for more than a decade they had repeatedly struck the area between Guizhou, Chenzhou, Nanyang, and Ruzhou; whenever they moved on, they still had to cross through Henan. He accordingly raised two new armies of more than ten thousand men each: the Yi Army under Song Qing, and the Songwu Army under Zhang Yao, with Shan Qing's cavalry forming a supporting wing alongside the two main forces. Song Qing's forces then won a major victory over Zhang Zongyu at Suizhou, while Henian went in person to Chen, Liu, and Qi counties to direct operations. Ren and Lai then seized the moment to strike north again; since rebel movements were unpredictable, Henian insisted that river defense was the top priority. The rebels did attack Zhongmou, but found the defenses ready and failed; they then breached a dike west of the provincial seat to divert water south, troubling Changyuan as well. Henian fired off urgent orders to land and river troops along the dike to drive off the rebels and seal the breach. The rebels fled west into Macheng and Huanggang in Hubei; the court ordered Song Qing's army across the border to join the pursuit, and countless rebels were killed. Henian kept his headquarters at Xuzhou to coordinate the effort; when the rebels slipped into Yuzhou, Song Qing routed them. Shan Qing and Liu Mingchuan of the Huai Army won a crushing victory at Ganyu, where Ren Zhu was killed. Henian was awarded the first-rank official hat finial. In 1868 he was ordered to lead troops outside the province and rode at once to Cizhou. Nian forces entered the capital region and again pressed east along the river through Hua, Jun, and neighboring areas. He was censured a second time for failing to defend and block the rebels effectively. After the Henan forces reported a victory, his official hat finial was returned as a reward. When Zhang Zongyu drowned and the Nian rebellion was suppressed, Henian was recommended for reward on the basis of first-class military merit.
3
沿
In 1871 he was promoted to Governor-General of Fujian and Zhejiang. The following year he was received in audience and granted the rare privilege of riding a horse inside the Forbidden City. He was soon made acting Fuzhou general while also serving as acting governor. When the court asked about coastal defense, he answered in a memorial: "Coastal defense depends above all on four things: training troops, securing funds, manufacturing weapons, and appointing the right men. Of these four, staffing is the most urgent, and what matters most is to assign clear responsibility. The coastal governors cannot evade their duty, but without a senior commander in overall charge, opinions will split and officials will pass blame when crisis comes." The emperor endorsed his proposal.
4
調
In 1875 he was transferred to commissioner of the Yellow River eastward and also served as acting governor of Henan. In 1881 he was appointed governor of Henan while retaining the river commission. In 1884 he was recommended for dismissal after repeatedly memorializing in his own defense during the trial of the robber Hu Ti'an; under the empress dowager's birthday amnesty his nominal rank was reduced by two grades instead. In 1887, while acting as river commissioner, he memorialized: "The Yellow River split after it burst at Dizhou in Song times, forming two channels. Not until the Ming raised Huangling Ridge did the streams reunite into one. The river's habit is to deposit silt below whenever the upper reaches flood; now both routes are choked with silt, and branch streams must be cleared in advance to provide outlets." The court approved the proposal. A year later the Zhengzhou works failed again, and he was sent to serve at a military penal station. He was soon released and sent home, and was also granted third-rank nominal status. He died in 1890. In 1909 his original rank was posthumously restored.
5
Henian had a keen eye for talent; as a young man he studied alongside Wen Xiang, and the two pushed each other to excel. While serving as a remonstrating official he submitted stern memorials impeaching Sushun for arrogance and power, and urged the court to recall Zeng Guofan from retirement, declaring that Zeng alone could defeat the rebels. He elevated Song Qing and Zhang Yao to lead the Henan armies, and both later became celebrated generals. After long service in Henan he left behind many policies that benefited the people, and locals erected stone inscriptions in his praise. When he first became river commissioner, the Heigang dike burst and hung together by a thread. Henian personally oversaw the repairs for more than twenty days and nights until the perilous stretch was secured. Emperor Guangxu once asked Li Hongzao who best understood river control; Hongzao named Henian, and the emperor, recognizing that Henian had been wronged before, appointed him river commissioner again. When he died, some among the people of Henan wept openly. His third son Bao Xun was widely learned and literary and became especially well known.
6
==滿 使 使 使
Wen Bin, styled Zhifu, of the Nara clan, was a Manchu bannerman of the Plain White Banner under the Imperial Household Department. He became a jinshi in 1852 and was appointed a secretary in the Ministry of Revenue. In 1860, as an assistant department director, he accompanied the court to Rehe. The following year he was promoted to department director and appointed prefect of Yizhou in Shandong. When Nian rebels threatened the prefectural seat, he combined forces to storm their stronghold and captured the rebel leaders Sun Huaxiang and others. For this service he was recommended for appointment at the circuit intendant level. In 1865 he joined provincial treasurer Ding Baozhen in defeating rebels at Lincheng Post in Teng County, then swung around to Dongping to block a northern breakout. He was appointed intendant of the Yan-Yi-Cao-Ji Circuit and promoted to provincial judicial commissioner. After recovering Haifeng he was promoted to provincial treasurer. In 1871 he served as acting governor and was appointed grain transport commissioner. He served again as acting governor, then soon returned to his regular commission.
7
西
In 1879, while supervising the northern grain transport, he requested an audience and met with river commissioner Li Henian and governor Zhou Hengqi to discuss the Grand Canal; together they drew up a comprehensive plan to widen and deepen the waterways, relocate the transport entrance, channel in the Wei River, build dikes and sluices, and submitted illustrated proposals to the throne. In summary he argued: "At present the northern transport entrance lies at Bali Temple south of Zhangqiu, set obliquely opposite the southern entrance some twenty-odd li away. By the time the Yellow River reaches this point the channel has narrowed, but the current spreads out and splits into many branches. As a rule, when the current favors the south the northern mouth silts up; when it favors the north the southern mouth grows shallow and blocked. Grain boats therefore leave the southern entrance, enter the Yellow River, and must run twenty li northeast to Shijia Bridge, where the Yellow River currents merge, then another twenty li south to the northern entrance at Bali Temple; only when flood season brings high water can they enter the canal. The proposal is to relocate the northern transport entrance to a point six li north of Shijia Bridge. On the river's west bank a channel would be cut along the eastern dike from Acheng to Taochangbao as the gateway from the Yellow River into the canal; with dams and storage ponds in place, Yellow River water would be kept from hijacking the current and the arduous work of hauling boats would be eased. Between the Yellow and Grand Canals, ever since the Jia closure project was completed, summer and autumn rains had nowhere to go; low-lying fields had stood under water for years. Channeling that standing water into a single reservoir would store water for transport and let farmland be drained and brought back into cultivation. Once the transport entrance is fixed, the Wei River can be brought in. A new channel would be cut from a bend in the Wei River three li east of Yuancheng Market in Zhili, run through Nanle in Zhili and Chaocheng in Shandong, and enter the canal through the Xiaokou culvert south of Zhangqiu. The Wei stands more than nine zhang above the canal along a course of over 150 li; once channeled to feed transport, the water would pour down with the force of water tipped from a high jar. The Greater and Lesser Dan Rivers could likewise be brought in through the Wei to supplement transport. Constructing four sluice gates, two dams, dredging channels, and building dikes would cost an estimated 760,000 taels of silver. Compared with the old practice of borrowing Yellow River water for transport only to dredge again as soon as silt closed in again, the difference would be enormous."
8
He also joined Governor-General Wu Yuanbing of the Two Jiangs in a memorial to restore the Huai River's old course, arguing in summary: "More than forty rivers feed the Huai into Hongze Lake; below Yangzhuang, Yunti Pass marks the old route to the sea, and the river's remaining flow enters the canal to support grain transport. In drought years stored Huai water could be sent through the canal's sluices and culverts into the Huai-Yang region to irrigate farmland. Since Hongze Lake can no longer hold back water and the Zhang and Fu diversion channels no longer run freely, every major flood puts the canal's lone eastern dike in grave danger. If the dike gave way, the flood would not stop until it had turned the Lixiahe lowlands into a wasteland. Some argued that the water must somehow be confined, but rather than trying to block it upstream, it would be better to dredge the lower course deeply." He therefore submitted a detailed plan to dredge the old channel below Yangzhuang that once carried the river to the sea.
9
He died soon afterward, and the throne issued an edict of praise and posthumous reward. Governor-General Liu Kunyi of the Two Jiangs, citing the affection the people still bore for Wen Bin, requested a dedicated shrine at Qingjiangpu, and the court approved. His son Yan Yu, a provincial graduate, served as Sichuan salt and tea intendant; Yan Xi, a provincial graduate, was prefect of Jiujiang; Yan Xie, a jinshi, was magistrate of Wuchang; Yan Zhao, a provincial graduate, served as assistant department director in the Ministry of Rites.
10
== 調 退 調
Ren Daorong, styled Xiaoyuan, was a native of Yixing in Jiangsu. Selected as a tribute student, he passed examination and received appointment to an educational post. During the Xianfeng era he helped organize local militia while at home and was appointed Fengxian district director of studies. For his work raising funds he was promoted to county magistrate, assigned to Dangyang, governed with many policies that benefited the people, and was transferred to Jiangxia. In 1863 he was promoted to prefect of Shunde. When bandits rose south of the capital region, he applied the strategy of clearing the countryside and fortifying strongpoints, repaired the local fortifications, and repeatedly defeated rebels between Shahe and Pingxiang. When Nian forces pushed north, Daorong led local militia in the defense of Shahe. He met the rebels by night, led his men in a fierce charge, took a spear wound but held his ground; the rebels slowly withdrew, and he was promoted to circuit intendant. The Ming River, entering from Guangping, had long been choked with silt. Daorong joined neighboring prefectures in dredging it and also cleared the Xiangshui River north of the prefecture, restoring more than ten thousand qing of farmland. Governors-general Zeng Guofan and Li Hongzhang recommended him again and again. In 1872 he was transferred to Baoding and soon promoted to intendant of the Kai-Gui-Chen-Xu Circuit. He rooted out long-standing abuses in river works and insisted that labor and materials be verified strictly on the ground. He once worked through wind and rain to save a perilous stretch of the middle river, and only after four days and nights was the breach brought under control.
11
使 西使便 使調 便 駿
In 1875 he served as acting provincial judicial commissioner. Appointed Jiangxi judicial commissioner, he found more than four hundred prisoners still held in the provincial jail; exercising discretionary authority to hear cases, he cleared the backlog within three months. In 1878 he was transferred to provincial treasurer of Zhejiang, then to Zhili. Since the wars began, Zhili's prefectures and counties had left expense accounts unsettled, and repeated major assignments for imperial tomb visits had tangled successive handovers. Daorong sorted new cases from old ones and set firm deadlines for clearing each. He cut apportioned levies imposed on prefectures and counties, paid out integrity-support stipends to officials in full, and urged subordinate counties to store grain against famine. In 1881 he was promoted to governor of Shandong and memorialized that military discipline had slackened; he replaced commanding generals, used Green Standard pay to train new troops, and ordered prefectures and counties to pursue bandits diligently. Between Mount Tai and the Yi River the post road was rough; he sent laborers to cut and level it, greatly easing travel. He was soon censured for recommending the dismissed prefect Pan Junqun for reward and impeached for failing to detect that compiler Lin Guozhu had tipped off his own recall; stripped of office, he was demoted to circuit intendant. He lived in retirement for many years.
12
便 調
In 1895 he was recalled to serve as Yellow River commissioner. By precedent the river commissioner maintained branch offices at both Kaifeng and Jining. Since the Xianfeng era the commissioner had usually been stationed at Kaifeng, while Shandong river affairs were handled by the governor alone. At this point the court again proposed stationing the river commissioner at Jining while the Henan governor would also oversee river works. Daorong argued: "When officials do not answer to the same chain of command, orders are hard to enforce; it is better to keep the old arrangement." The court approved. River disasters were then mostly downstream, while the commissioner was responsible only for the upper reaches, so the post was relatively light. Daorong practiced strict economy and each year returned surplus funds to the provincial treasury. In 1900 the Boxers rose, and ruffians in Henan seized the moment to stir up trouble. Daorong kept his composure and drilled three battalions of river garrison troops to help defend the province. The following year he was transferred to governor of Zhejiang. After the recent humiliation of national prestige, disputes between locals and missionaries had piled up unresolved; he heard the cases and decided them evenhandedly. He raised indemnity funds and weighed what was urgent against what could wait, so the people were not crushed under the burden. In 1902 he retired on grounds of illness. More than three years later he died at home at the age of eighty-three.
13
==西 西 西
Xu Zhenyi, styled Xianping, was a native of Fengxin in Jiangxi. Early in the Xianfeng era, as a selected tribute student he joined Zeng Guofan's military staff. When Zeng's Hunan army was trapped in Jiangxi and town after town fell, Zhenyi joined Secretariat drafter Deng Fulun in raising local militia to attack rebels in Jinxian and Dongxiang, and soon recovered Ji'an. For this service he was recommended for appointment as subprefect. In 1863 he passed the jinshi examination, was appointed a Hanlin compiler, and was sent out as educational commissioner of Shaanxi and Gansu. Surrendered Muslims in Hezhou had rebelled again, and in the Xining region Muslims and Han were killing one another daily; examinations had long been suspended. Zhenyi began holding examinations in each prefecture, enrolled many sons of the surrendered population, made up eight years of missed qualifying exams, and brought several thousand students into the schools; the Muslim communities were deeply impressed. He founded the Weijing Academy at Jingyang and stocked it with books in hopes of softening local rough customs. He also petitioned for separate provincial examination centers and separate educational commissioners for Shaanxi and Gansu, and the court approved. Governor-General Zuo Zongtang declared that lasting peace on the frontier would depend on work like this. He returned home to observe mourning for his father.
14
調
In 1876 he was recalled to his former post. In 1882 he was appointed intendant of the Zhang-Wei-Huai Circuit and cut corvée and levy expenses in subordinate counties by more than two hundred thousand taels a year. By repairing inner-river dikes in advance, he spared the salt districts of the Huai and Hai regions from flooding. In 1890 he was promoted to Yellow River commissioner eastward, built the great dam at Xingze and stone dams at Hujiatun and Mitongzhai, and kept the river secure. His key reform was strict oversight: he refused to hoard financial authority, ordered the seven departments to draw funds directly from the provincial treasury, and so long-standing abuses faded while the works grew solid. In 1895 he was transferred to governor of Guangdong, banned gambling on examination surnames, and the people of Guangdong benefited greatly. In 1898 the governorships of Guangdong, Yunnan, and Hubei were abolished, and Zhenyi was transferred to service in the capital. He took leave and returned home, and died a little over a year later. He was given a place for joint sacrifice in the Zeng Guofan shrines in Jiangsu and Henan.
15
== 西 椿椿
Wu Dacheng, styled Qingqing, was a native of Wu County in Jiangsu. In the autumn of 1862 a comet appeared in the northwest, and the throne called for candid memorials. Dacheng was then a common student and had come to the capital for the metropolitan district examination. He submitted a memorial arguing: "Good government rests on promoting frugality and elevating integrity; speak nothing of finance management, and the treasury will fill of itself. If officials devote themselves only to extortion and ignore the people's hardship, the state will surely be ruined." Six years later he passed the jinshi examination and was appointed a Hanlin compiler. When Emperor Tongzhi's wedding ceremonies grew lavish beyond measure, he memorialized to cut excessive costs, and his blunt honesty shook the court. Sent out as educational commissioner of Shaanxi and Gansu, he memorialized to add Cangjie, legendary inventor of writing, to the state sacrificial canon, and the court approved. He also recommended common students He Ruilin and Yang Shuchun for their steadfast devotion to orthodox learning; Ruilin received the title of Imperial Academy director of studies and Shuchun the Hanlin awaiting-edict title, and scholarly manners changed markedly. When the court ordered repairs to the Summer Palace, Dacheng again argued that times were hard and asked that the work be halted. The memorial was submitted and left unanswered.
16
In 1877, when Shanxi and Shaanxi were stricken by severe famine, he was ordered to help manage relief. He went in person through the disaster zone to inspect conditions and saved a great many lives. Zuo Zongtang, Zeng Guoquan, Li Hongzhang, and others submitted memorial after memorial recommending him. In 1878 he was appointed intendant of the Hebei Circuit. Famine had struck year after year, and poor farmers sold land at a fraction of its worth, often for less than a tenth of the fair price. Governor Tu Zongying ordered that land sold cheaply in famine years could be redeemed at the sale price, but powerful families often blocked redemption, leaving many farmers landless. Only Dacheng enforced the governor's policy as intended.
17
西 宿
In 1880 he was granted third-rank ministerial status and accompanied Jilin general Ming'an in managing northwestern frontier defense. Touring the strategic passes, Dacheng discovered that the Hundingzi territory of Hunchun had long been occupied by Russia. He petitioned for the old boundary maps and planned to lodge a formal protest with Russian officials, but received no approval from the throne. At the time there was a man named Han Xiaozhong, a native of Dengzhou who had worked as a hired hand for the Hou family of Fuzhou. Deep in gambling debt, he fled to Jiapigou in Jilin. The area produced gold; east of Ningguta and Sanxing, it lay ringed by mountains and stretched seven or eight hundred li across. Vagrants gathered there in bands, perhaps forty or fifty thousand strong, all under Xiaozhong's control. Xiaozhong ruled strictly but fairly, and his followers accepted his authority; they had repeatedly held off imperial armies without surrendering. Dacheng rode alone into their stronghold, stayed three days, and urged Xiaozhong to surrender; Xiaozhong hesitated, troubled by the request. Dacheng said: "I do not doubt you — do you doubt me?" Xiaozhong replied: "I would not dare doubt you, sir. I have been guilty a long time; if the commander should treat my past deeds as crimes, my death would not trouble me — but how could I fail your purpose?" Dacheng pledged to take personal responsibility, and Xiaozhong came out with him; the court granted Xiaozhong a fifth-rank hat finial, his son seventh rank, and his grandson Dengju, credited with pacifying the bandits, the rank of brigade commander. In 1881 he was appointed minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud. When the Sino-French conflict broke out, he was assigned to assist in Beiyang military affairs and garrisoned Leting and Changli.
18
使使 使 便
In 1884 he was transferred to Left Vice Censor-in-Chief. Soon afterward he was sent as envoy to Korea to settle its internal disorder, with salt transport commissioner Xuchang as his deputy. On arrival he found the Japanese minister Inoue Kaoru avoiding him and refusing an audience, while holding Korean Left State Councillor Kim Hong-jip at the State Council and demanding three hundred thousand taels in military expenses. Dacheng said to Xuchang: "This is an insult to me!" He immediately led troops to the State Council, forced the doors open, and rebuked Kim Hong-jip: "In wielding power you have ruined the country's affairs. If this agreement is handled carelessly, it will breed future troubles — that is no way to restore peace to the country." Kim Hong-jip could only assent; Inoue Kaoru was intimidated as well, cut his demand to one hundred ten thousand taels, and withdrew.
19
使
In 1885 he was ordered to Jilin to join vice commander-in-chief Yike Tang'a and Russian envoys in surveying the encroached border — the Hundingzi territory of Hunchun. Following the old boundary map of 1861, he erected five steles and a bronze pillar, personally inscribing it: "Boundaries have their markers; the state has its pillars — this pillar may stand but must not be moved." The encroached territory was restored to China, and vessels on the Tumen River at last passed freely without obstruction. In 1886 he was promoted to governor of Guangdong. Portugal had encroached on the border as far as Xiangshan near Macau. The Zongli Yamen negotiated a trade treaty that placed Macau under Portuguese jurisdiction. Dacheng objected and submitted a detailed rebuttal, but received no response.
20
In 1888 the Zhengzhou breach opened again; the emperor was furious, dismissed river commissioner Li Henian, and replaced him with Dacheng. That winter the breach was closed, and Dacheng's contribution was the largest. Dacheng enjoyed great contemporary renown; when plans for a navy were raised, Prince Chun Yixuan was placed in charge. Dacheng had long been on good terms with the prince; after the river works succeeded he was formally appointed Yellow River commissioner and granted the first-rank hat finial. Dacheng then memorialized requesting elevated titles and ceremonial honors for Prince Chun. When the memorial arrived, Empress Dowager Cixi was furious and had Prince Chun's own memorial from his first year in office — written to forestall reckless speculation — published throughout the empire. Dacheng nearly faced severe punishment, but returned home for his mother's mourning, and the affair ended there.
21
退
In 1892 he was appointed governor of Hunan. When the Donghak rebellion erupted in Korea, Japan and China went to war, and court opinion overwhelmingly favored fighting. Dacheng volunteered to lead Hunan troops to the front, and the throne graciously approved. In 1895 he marched beyond the pass to join the armies planning to retake Haicheng, while Japanese forces seized Niuzhuang by a back route. Wei Guangtao went out to meet them, but the battle went badly. Li Guangji raced to the rescue and was defeated as well, escaping with only a handful of horsemen. Enraged that the Hunan army had been wiped out, Dacheng drew his sword to kill himself; Wang Tongyu, who was serving on his staff as a Hanlin compiler, was at his side and stopped him. Guangtao asked that military law be applied; Dacheng sighed and said: "I truly cannot command troops; I should request severe punishment myself." He withdrew inside the pass and received orders dismissing him from office while keeping him temporarily at his post. He returned to Hunan, and soon afterward was ordered to vacate the governorship. In 1898 a new edict dismissed him from office and barred him permanently from further appointment. He died in 1902 at the age of sixty-eight.
22
Dacheng was accomplished in seal and bronze script; after leaving office he was desperately poor and sold calligraphy, paintings, and ancient bronzes to support himself. His works include Supplement to Ancient Seal Script, Inquiry into Ancient Jade, Inquiry into Weights and Measures, Hengxuan's Record of Ancient Bronzes, and a collected volume of prose and poetry.
23
==
The commentary says: River disasters grow worse by the day, yet river officials need only celebrate each year's calm waters as a remarkable feat; for years no one has tried to coordinate the whole system to prevent lasting catastrophe—genuine reform is hard to achieve. Henian was famed for river control; Wen Bin's proposals to relocate the transport entrance and restore the Huai River also showed real insight. Daorong rooted out long-standing abuses and practiced strict economy; Zhenyi supervised works rigorously and stamped out embezzlement through diligence and integrity—all achieved useful short-term results, but these were palliatives, not a fundamental cure. Dacheng was famous for river control, yet loved to talk of military affairs, took pride in his own talent, and in the end was ruined by empty arrogance—a pity indeed!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →