← Back to 清史稿

卷525 列傳三百十二 藩部八 西藏

Volume 525 Biographies 312: Frontier Dependencies 8: Tibet

Chapter 525 of 清史稿 · Draft History of Qing
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 525
Next Chapter →
1
西 西
Tibet lay within the Yong Province region described in the Yu Gong. In Han times it was the territory of the Bailang, Ledu, and other Qiang peoples beyond the frontier of Shenli Commandery in Yizhou. Under the Wei and Sui dynasties it was the territory of Fuguo, Nüguo, and the Zuofeng, Xiwèi, Geyan, Chunsang, Misang, Beili, Motu, Na'e, and other Qiang domains. In Tang times it was Tubo, where reverence for Buddhism first took hold. It then destroyed Tuyuhun, brought the Yangtong and Dangxiang Qiang fully to heel, bordered the Arabs in the west, and sprawled across more than ten thousand li. By the late Tang it had weakened and its parts had scattered. Throughout the Song, tribute missions never ceased.
2
Under Kublai Khan three Pacification Commissions were set up for Ü-Tsang, Nari, Sokhu, and Lusun, together with a metropolitan commandery; wanhu and other officials charged with the populace were still appointed to pacify and gather the people. The Tibetan monk Phagspa was appointed Great Precious Dharma King and Imperial Preceptor, and successors held the title for several generations. Very many disciples bore the titles Sikong and State Duke and wore gold and jade seals.
3
沿 使 西西
In the Hongwu reign of the Ming, the regent Imperial Preceptor Namgyal Trashi was made Blazing Buddha Treasure State Preceptor and granted a jade seal. The Ü-Tsang commandery and Pacification, Pacification-and-Suppression, and wanhu offices were established, largely along Yuan lines, with Yuan state dukes such as Namka Tenzin Pelgyi Trashi and others placed at their head. Soon Ü-Tsang was converted to a mobile regional commandery, with Banzhu'er Trashi as Ü-Tsang regional commander; all subordinates were ordered to inherit their offices. Not long after, Ü-Tsang Amboluo Guard was likewise converted to a mobile regional commandery. In the Yongle reign the Ü-Tsang Ni'ersongzhai mobile regional commandery was added, along with the Bili and Shangqiongbu guards; Tibetan monks were again enfeoffed as Great Precious Dharma King, Mahayana Dharma King, Great Compassion Dharma King, Propagation-of-Teaching King, Propagation-and-Transformation King, Assistant-of-Teaching King, Praise-of-Goodness King, and Protector-of-Teaching King—eight kings in all—who sent tribute yearly or in alternate years. Between the Xuande and Chenghua reigns ennoblements were repeatedly augmented. In that land there was a monk called the Dalai Lama, who lived at the Potala Temple in Lhasa and was known as Front Tibet; there was the Panchen Lama, who lived at the Tashilhunpo Temple in Shigatse and was known as Rear Tibet; Tibetan custom revered them above all the other Tibetan kings. Tibetan lamas had all formerly belonged to the Red Hat sect; Tsongkhapa first founded the Yellow Hat sect and attained enlightenment at Ganden Monastery in Tibet. The Red Hat sect then followed Indian custom, married and bore sons, passed the Dharma Kingship by hereditary succession, specialized in esoteric spells, and in the end even swallowed swords and spat fire to dazzle the crowd, wholly abandoning the aims of precepts, concentration, and wisdom. The Yellow Hat sect forbade nearness to women; it left two great disciples who in each generation were reborn as Khutuktu and propagated Mahayana teaching. Khutuktu means, in Chinese, "incarnation." The Dalai and Panchen are the so-called two great disciples; Dalai means "supreme" and Panchen means "glorious splendor." Their custom held that in death one did not lose one's true nature and knew where one was bound; disciples would welcome and install the rebirth, ever turning in samsara yet with one's nature undimmed—so Dalai and Panchen across generations served each other as teacher. Their teaching stressed seeing one's nature and saving beings, and rejected the śrāvaka Hinayana and the petty Hinayana of illusion. By the mid-Ming they had long stood far above the Red Hat sect.
4
西 西
The first Dalai was Rol Chögyal, a descendant of the Tibetan emperor and for generations a Tibetan king. At twenty he came to Front Tibet and was made Tsongkhapa's chief disciple. He lived to eighty-four. The second was Gendün Gyatso, reborn in Draklar in Rear Tibet; he held the teaching seats at the Potala, Sera, and Tashilhunpo. He lived to sixty-seven. The third was Sönam Gyatso, the most renowned of the Dalai. He established the depa to handle military affairs, punishments, and taxes. Disciples were called Khutuktu and separately governed religious instruction. At that time the Yellow Hat teaching had not yet spread among the Mongols. Altan Khan, a Yuan descendant, annexed the tribes, raided China, campaigned in Ü-Tsang, and took the Amdo, Kham, and other tribes. Weary of war in old age, he heeded his nephew, the Ököd Jüin Sechen of the Ordos, went to welcome the Dalai, and urged him to return east. From Ganzhou he wrote Zhang Juzheng seeking to open tribute and gifts. In the Wanli reign tribute from Sönam Gyatso was accepted and enfeoffment and gifts were granted. Answering Altan's invitation, the Dalai came to Qinghai and spoke of a three-life bond of good karma. The taiji said: "From now on may the blood-and-fire Jiang be changed into the milk-overflowing quiet sea." Altan promised to build temples, one at Guihuacheng and one at Xining; and so the Yellow Hat spread through all the Mongol tribes. In Tibet the Red Hat Great Precious and Mahayana Dharma Kings all bowed as disciples and turned to the Yellow Hat. The teaching spread through the tribes; for tens of thousands of li east and west they boiled tea and worshipped as before a god; Tibetan kings held only empty titles and could no longer command. He lived to forty-seven. The fourth was Yonten Gyatso; he lived to twenty-eight. The fifth was Ngawang Lobzang Gyatso.
5
西
Formerly Tibetans commonly called their country Ü-Tsang, also Tangut. Apart from the Dalai and Panchen there was a khan, held by a Mongol chief. At that time Tsangpa Khan of Tibet and the depa employed by the Dalai were at odds. The Khoshud Khan of the Eleuths was named Güshi Khan, nineteenth in descent from Khasar, younger brother of Genghis Khan. Later he annexed the four Tangut divisions and changed his title to Güshe Khan. Because Qinghai was broad, he ordered his descendants to pasture there, while Kham and Amdo paid him tribute. Ü was ruled by the depa who served the Dalai; Tsang was ruled by Tsangpa Khan. The depa Sangye and Tsangpa Khan could not get along; he said Tsangpa oppressed the tribes and destroyed the Yellow Hat, and begged Güshe Khan to destroy him. Güshe Khan then gave Tsang to the Panchen, left his eldest son Gushri Khan to rule the people, and his second son Dalai Batuur Taiji to assist—all in the Chongde reign.
6
使 使使 使 使 殿 使 西 西
Earlier, in the Tiancong reign, when the great army took the Ming eastern provinces, a bright star appeared as an auspicious sign. Güshe Khan said: "This star is the star of the mighty khan's power. From this one may see he is no ordinary man." Thereupon Mongols far and near together honored Emperor Taizong as Qormusta Erdemtü Böged Qaγan. Thereafter he memorialized requesting funds to send envoys to invite the Dalai. In the fourth year envoys were sent with letters to the Ü-Tsang khan and the Dalai, saying, "The classics made since antiquity—we do not wish them to perish and go untransmitted; therefore envoys are sent to earnestly request them." Later, because of contrary words from the Khalkha, it did not come to pass. Güshe Khan again wrote to the Dalai, Panchen, and Tsangpa Khan, agreeing jointly to send tribute missions. The Dalai, Panchen, Tsangpa Khan, and Güshe Khan sent Irgusang Khutuktu and others with local products and a vermilion letter, first addressing Taizong as Mañjuśrī Great Emperor. Mañjuśrī means, in Chinese, "wonderful auspiciousness." When the envoys reached Shengjing, Taizong personally led princes and ministers to welcome them at the Huaiyuan Gate. He rose from his throne, went to the threshold to receive them, stood to receive the letter, met them hand in hand, ascended the couch, set a seat to the right, ordered them to sit, bestowed tea, and gave a great banquet in the Chongzheng Hall. Every five days there was a banquet, and princes and beile were ordered to entertain them in turn. They remained eight months before returning. In the eighth year a return gift was sent to the Dalai, saying: "The broad, mild, benevolent, and sage emperor of the Great Qing sends this letter to the Vajra Adept Dalai Lama. Now, hearing that the Lama has the will to save all beings and to raise and support the Buddhist Law, envoys have been sent with letters; Our heart is greatly pleased; We respectfully inquire after your peace. Whatever you wish to say, let Tsakhan Gerong and others transmit it by mouth." Letters were also sent to the Panchen and the Red Hat Lama Jidong Hutugtu and others, in the same manner. This was the beginning of friendly relations with Tibet. Thereupon the Propagation King and the monks of Honghua and Xianqing temples in Hezhou, the six Tianshan tribes, the Ü-Tsang Dongbo, Lizhou, Changxihe, Yutong, Ningyuan, Nixi, Manyi, Shencun, Ningrong, and other chieftains, and the Zhuanglang Tibetan monks successively sent tribute, presented Ming imperial seals and patents, and requested incorporation.
7
使 使 殿西 殿西
The next year the Shizu Emperor fixed the capital at Yanjing and united the realm. Güshe Khan again memorialized: "The Dalai's merit is boundless; he should be invited to the capital to chant sutras and mantras for blessings." Envoys were then sent to welcome him. In the fourth year of Shunzhi the Dalai and Panchen each sent envoys presenting gold Buddhas and prayer beads, with memorials praising merit. In the fifth year lamas including Xilabugelong were sent with letters to inquire after the Dalai and again to urge his coming. The Dalai replied in a letter, promising to come to court in a chen year. In the ninth year, tenth month, the Dalai reached Daiga; Prince Suksaha and others were ordered to go welcome him. In the twelfth month the Dalai arrived, was received at the Southern Park, entertained in the Hall of Supreme Harmony, and lodged at the Xihuang Temple. The Dalai soon said the soil and water did not suit him and asked to return; gold, silver, silks, pearls, jade, saddles, and horses were given to comfort and detain him. In the second month of the tenth year he returned; again an imperial banquet was given at the hall; Prince Suksaha with Beile Gu'ermahong and Wudahai led Eight Banner troops to escort him to Daiga; Minister of Rites Jioro Langqiu and Vice Minister of the Court of Colonial Affairs Daxili carried the gold patent and seal to Daiga and enfeoffed the Dalai as Dalai Lama, Great Benevolent Buddha of the West, Who Leads All the World in the Buddhist Teaching, Widely Pervading the Vajra. When the Dalai returned he promoted the Yellow Hat, rebuilt the Potala and sixty-two monasteries of Front Tibet, and newly built temples in Kham, Amdo, and elsewhere, totaling three thousand and seventy, it is said.
8
使
At that time Güshe Khan had already died and the Dalai was also old; great power fell to the depa Sangye. Sangye falsely sent a man from Nei'an Island posing as the Propagation King's tribute envoy; in fact the Propagation King had long been broken and reduced to a lama, yet repeated tribute still bore the king's name and requested replacement of patents and seals. When the truth was found out, they were rebuked. When Wu Sangui held Yunnan, each year he sent men to Tibet to boil tea.
9
使 西
In the thirteenth year of Kangxi, Sangui rebelled; an edict ordered Qinghai Mongol troops to enter Sichuan by Songpan. Sangye had the Dalai write to dissuade them, and also begged surrender on Sangui's behalf. When the great army besieged Wu Shifan in Yunnan, Shifan ceded Zhongdian and Weixi to Tibet to beg aid; the letter was captured by Prince Zhangtai's army. The court only garrisoned Zhongdian and did not press the matter deeply. In the twenty-first year of Kangxi he passed into nirvana at the Potala Temple, aged sixty-two.
10
西
When the Fifth Dalai died, the depa Sangye quarreled with Lhazang Khan over choosing a new Dalai. Sangye, having installed Lobzang Rinchen Tsanggye as the Sixth Dalai according to his own wish, concealed the death and falsely said the Dalai had entered meditation, dwelling in a high pavilion and seeing no one; all affairs were carried out in the Dalai's name—hence he grew still more overbearing. He sided with the Dzungars to destroy the Khalkha Mongols, incited the Dzungars to fight China, and outwardly allied with Tsewang Arabtan while inwardly sowing discord with Lhazang Khan—thus inviting the calamity of Dzungar troops invading Tibet. Several decades of turmoil in the northwest were all the work of the depa alone.
11
使 使西 西 西 使 使 使 使
Galdan was also one of the Four Eleuths; he had once entered Tibet as a lama and was on close terms with the depa. On his return he usurped his khan and claimed the Dalai had enfeoffed him as Dzungar Bökhü Güyük Khan. Because the Khalkha were cut off from Tibet by the Eleuths, they had for decades honored the rebirth of Jetsundampa Khutuktu, Tsongkhapa's third disciple, as Great Khutuktu, ranking just below the Panchen. When the Khalkha Tsetsen Khan and Tüsheet Khan went to war, the Sage Emperor sent envoys asking the Dalai to mediate. Sangye memorialized sending Galdan's Xiletü west. In Mongol, a lama who takes the teaching seat is called "Xiletü"—the Dalai's chief disciple. Jetsundampa Khutuktu also came to the alliance altar by imperial order and met Galdan's Xiletü on equal terms. Galdan sent a younger clansman to probe for weakness; he reproached the Khalkha for slighting the Dalai and was killed by Tüsheet Khan. Galdan then invaded their tribes under the pretext of revenge. The Khalkha gathered to decide whether Russia or China would serve them better; Jetsundampa said: "Russia holds a different faith and will surely treat us as aliens; we should submit to China, where the Yellow Hat flourishes." With that they settled on fleeing east. The Sage Emperor repeatedly ordered Sangye to send envoys to stop the fighting. Sangye sent Jelong Khutuktu, who secretly urged them on instead. In the twenty-ninth year they invaded south of the desert; our army defeated them at Ulan Butung. Galdan had Jelong sue for peace on his behalf, invoked the Buddha's majesty, swore an oath, and fled. Ashamed within, Sangye then, in the Dalai's name, had Qinghai Mongols and Eleuth taiji jointly offer a honorific title; the Sage Emperor refused, decreeing: "The Dalai and I look to nurturing all beings, yet the khutuktu and others sent deliberately disobeyed intent, so that Khalkha and Eleuth both suffered harm. If you can make them reconcile, I would then add a title for the Dalai; those charged with affairs failed my heart and the Dalai's intent, so that the Khalkha were broken and the Eleuths defeated—I am truly pained; how could I accept any honorific? Send back the tribute brought by the envoys!" Again and again lamas from the capital were sent into Tibet to investigate. In the thirty-fourth year the Dalai sent tribute, saying he was old and state affairs were decided by the depa, begging enfeoffment. An edict enfeoffed the depa Sangye as King of Ü-Tsang.
12
使 使 使使 使 西
In the thirty-fifth year the Sage Emperor personally campaigned against Galdan and reached the Kerulen River. Galdan was defeated and fled; he comforted his followers, saying: "This campaign was not my wish; the Dalai's envoy said a southern expedition would be greatly auspicious, and so I went deep in." The Emperor said that if the Dalai lived there could be no such thing, and sent a letter to the depa Sangye, saying: "I have questioned surrendered tribesmen, who all say the Dalai long ago left the robe; you have concealed this and not reported it. Moreover, while the Dalai lived, there was peace beyond the passes for more than sixty years; you repeatedly incited Galdan to raise arms and delight in calamity—where is the Way of the Law? The Dalai and Panchen separately preside over religious instruction; they have always held the world in turn. If the Dalai truly tires of the world, he should tell the dharma protectors and let the Panchen preside over Tsongkhapa's teaching. You make the multitude honor you and not the Panchen, and you block the Panchen from coming to the capital; I wished to reconcile the Dzungars, yet you sent the unworthy Jelong. At Ulan Butung you chose an auspicious day for the enemy army to chant sutras, watched the battle from the mountain under a canopy, presented khata if they won, and if they lost negotiated peace in their stead, misleading our pursuing army. The reason you shielded Galdan—now, at the rites announcing the destruction of the Dzungars, I send Galdan's sword and one Buddha image and one talisman of his wife Anu; let them be shown to the Dalai, let the Panchen come to the capital, and hand Jelong over to me. If not, I shall order armies of Yunnan, Sichuan, and Shaanxi to appear beneath your walls. Gather the Four Eleuths and wait; do not regret it!"
13
使 使使
Sangye in fear secretly memorialized the next year, saying: "For the misfortune of all beings, the Fifth Dalai entered nirvana in a renxu year; he has been reborn in a tranquil body and is now fifteen. Formerly, fearing unrest among the Tangut people, the death was not announced. Now on the twenty-fifth day of the tenth month of a chou year he should emerge from meditation and take the seat; I beg the Great Emperor not to disclose this. As for the Panchen, because he has not yet had smallpox, he dare not come to the capital. Jelong—I will do my utmost to bring him to the capital. I beg that his life, precepts, and body be spared, and that the Dalai's corpse be sealed in salt and enfeoffed as an image." The Sage Emperor agreed to keep it secret and to proclaim it within and without in the tenth month. When the depa's envoys returned, they met on the road troops of Tsewang Arabtan who were going to capture Galdan; they again proclaimed: "The Dalai has tired of the world; let your tribal soldiers not act rashly." Tsewang Arabtan wept and returned. The Sage Emperor, because the depa had always been double-dealing, recalled his envoys, assembled the Mongols, and displayed the sealed image—the head had already fallen off, and the depa's envoys fell to the ground in shock.
14
Sangye feared Tsewang Arabtan would take all the old Dzungar lands and leave Galdan nowhere to return; he memorialized to guard against his rampancy, while Tsewang Arabtan also memorialized that the depa was treacherous and that the newly installed Dalai was false, wishing to invade Tibet on that pretext. The Sage Emperor held both men unpredictable and granted neither request. In the forty-fourth year Sangye, because Lhazang Khan would in the end harm him, plotted to poison him; failing, he wished to drive him out by force. Lhazang Khan gathered the multitude to punish and kill Sangye; an edict enfeoffed him as Assistant-of-the-Law, Respectful-and-Obedient Lhazang Khan; he memorialized to depose the Dalai installed by Sangye, and an edict ordered him sent to the capital. Reaching Qinghai, he died on the road; according to their custom, those who acted perversely had their corpses cast away. He died aged twenty-five. This was the forty-sixth year of Kangxi. Commentators say that when Bodhidharma brought the Law to China there was a prophecy of one flower and five leaves; by the Sixth Patriarch the robe and bowl were contested, so the Sixth Patriarch no longer transmitted robe and bowl—a pattern much like that from Tsongkhapa to the Sixth Dalai. When heaven's number is exhausted, the Buddhist Law cannot be violated; how much less when the depa fraudulently produced one to exalt himself and monopolize power, in the end brewing the successive calamities of Lhazang Khan and the Dzungars.
15
使 西 西 婿
The Seventh, Lobzang Gyatso, was reborn in Litang in the forty-seventh year of Kangxi. He was born with unusual marks; on his right arm was a wheel pattern like the dharma wheel. At seven he debated scripture with many lamas and none could best him—he seemed to have innate wisdom. Earlier, after Lhazang Khan had memorialized to depose Lobzang Rinchen Tsanggye and installed the Khutuktu Ngawang Yeshe Gyatso of Bokda Mountain as Dalai, hearing the name he envied him and was about to kill him by force; his father Sonam Darjay carried him on his back and fled, and so he escaped. Qinghai artillery taiji disputed, unable to tell true from false; an edict ordered officials to lead Qinghai envoys to inspect. Lhazang Khan memorialized: "When the false Dalai was earlier sent away, I was ordered to seek the true Dalai; the Khutuktu of Bokda Mountain was found and, on the Panchen's word, took the seat." The court debated that the Khutuktu was still young and enfeoffment should wait several more years; because Lhazang Khan and the Qinghai taiji were at odds, Vice Minister He Shou was sent to assist in Tibetan affairs. This was the beginning of appointing officials to manage Tibetan affairs, yet the post was not yet permanent. In the forty-ninth year the Panchen, Lhazang Khan, and He Shou, who jointly managed Tibetan affairs, memorialized: "Ngawang Yeshe Gyatso is well versed in the classics; the Qinghai taiji believe in him; we beg patents and seals." An edict granted their request. Yet Qinghai in fact did not believe, and what was memorialized from Tibet and from Qinghai contradicted each other. In the fifty-third year Qinghai taiji and others sent troops to take Dedege, welcomed Lobzang Gyatso to Qinghai to take the seat, and begged patents and seals. The Sage Emperor feared they would provoke trouble and ordered him moved to the capital; this did not come to pass. Again he was ordered sent to Hongshan Temple, and later it was requested he be sent to Xining's Tsongkhapa Temple. Qinghai Beile Chahan Danjin again dissuaded it and even threatened dissenters with force. An edict sent great troops to escort him, and he dwelt at Tsongkhapa Temple. The Sage Emperor, because Lhazang Khan was nearly sixty, with one son garrisoned in Qinghai and one son married into Tsewang Arabtan's family, feared that on the pretext of loving his son-in-law he would be detained and not return, and his position was rather isolated and perilous. Moreover, since he had killed the depa, the people there could hardly avoid growing suspicious. The Eleuths are by nature suspicious and also very careless; if something unforeseen happened, separated by ten thousand li, rescue could not arrive in time. He was instructed to plan defenses deeply.
16
In the fifty-sixth year Tsewang Arabtan sent Taiji Tsering Donduk and others with six thousand men on foot around the Gobi, crossing the great snowy mountains south of Khotan, braving danger and miasma, marching by day and hiding by night, to Alik, claiming to escort Lhazang Khan's eldest son Galdan Tsering and his wife home. Lhazang Khan was unprepared; only when the bandits reached Dam did he realize; with his second son Sorkhang he resisted; after two months of fighting he could not prevail, fled to hold the Potala, and only then sent a memorial begging aid. The bandits induced the kashun Shakdurjab to surrender the minor prayer hall; Tangut taiji including Namjal opened the north gate of the Potala, killed Lhazang Khan, seized his youngest son Sebten and zaisang and others, searched the treasures of the temples and sent them to Ili, and confined Ngawang Yeshe Gyatso at Zakburi Temple. Sorkhang fled with thirty men and was captured; his wife came by a secret path; an edict gave her generous care.
17
西西歿 西 西
Xi'an General Erentai led Xining, Songpan, Dajianlu, and Galdan troops, together with Qinghai taiji and subordinate chieftains, to the rescue; reaching the Kelai River they met an ambush and were defeated and killed. The bandits again induced the Litang garrison lama to return to Tibet; then Batang, Chakdilo, Zhaya, and Barkam were all swayed. Soon an edict ordered Commander Fala to move Dajianlu troops to garrison Litang and protect the Khutuktu; Sonam Darjay was again ordered to instruct the garrison lama; those who resisted and would not submit were to be executed; proclamations were sent to Batang, Chakdilo, and Zhaya to register their lands and people; then they advanced and garrisoned Batang. Tsering Donduk feared and returned what had been plundered. When troops returned from Barkam they said Tangut had miasma and swelling sickness and was hard to stay in long; Qinghai Mongols all feared entering Tibet and urged the Dalai to memorialize that he could meditate wherever suitable and that a great army would disturb the multitude. Princes and ministers, mindful of the earlier defeat, also all said Tibet was perilous and remote and would not decide to advance. The Sage Emperor said Tibet screens Qinghai, Sichuan, and Yunnan; if the Dzungars seized it, the borders would know no peace. Moreover, if the bandits could come braving snow and scaling precipices, how much more our army. When Tsering Donduk heard our army had come, he would surely flee at the sight of the wind. After the religious law was settled, some might temporarily remain to guard, or long garrison the place. The Tangut multitude would all be our soldiers; if the Dzungars came again, awaiting them at ease, how hard would it be to destroy them. The great army to pacify Tibet must advance. An edict enfeoffed Lobzang Gyatso as the Sixth Dalai Lama, Who Propagates the Law and Awakens the Multitude. The Fourteenth Imperial Son Yinti was made Pacification General in the Distance, garrisoning Mulu Usu in Qinghai to manage provisions, with General Yanxin on the pacification route from Qinghai and General Galdan on theDingxi route from Sichuan—two routes striking Tibet. Tibetans also knew the Qinghai Dalai was true and the one long installed in Tibet false; jointly they begged the court to install him on the dharma seat; an edict granted gold patent and seal. Thereupon Mongol khans, princes, beile, and taiji each led their troops, hundreds or thousands, following the great army to escort the Dalai into Tibet.
18
退
Tsering Donduk himself blocked the Qinghai army on the middle route and separately sent his zaisang with thirty-six hundred men to block the southern route. General Galdan won over the Litang and Batang tribes, advanced to Chakdilo, and seized the peril at Lholung Dzong and the Jiayu Bridge. Soon he received the great general's order to advance together on the appointed day. Galdan feared that if the date were long provisions would fail; he used Vice Commander Yue Zhongqi's plan of Tibetans attacking Tibetans, recruited chieftains as vanguard, gathered skin boats to cross the river, struck straight for Lhasa, and won over seven thousand Tibetan troops. He proclaimed to great and small depa and lamas, sealed the Dalai's storehouses, divided troops to block passes, and cut the bandits' supply road. Qinghai also thrice defeated bandits who raided camps on the road, beheading and capturing more than a thousand. The Eleuths, pressed coming and going, were utterly routed, dared not return to Tibet, fled north by Kebiya, and of those who struggled back to Ili through hardship, cold, and hunger fewer than half survived.
19
On the fifteenth day of the ninth month in the fifty-ninth year of Kangxi (1720), the Dalai Lama was enthroned at the Potala. The impostor Awang Yeshe Gyatso was freed from detention only to be escorted to Beijing and stripped of his title, while every Oirat lama who had backed the rebellion was executed. A garrison of four thousand men drawn from Mongol, Sichuan, and Yunnan forces remained in Tibet. Duke Cewang Norbu took overall command of the occupation, assisted by imperial son-in-law Abao and Commander Wuge. Arigiba, depa of Khangbu and among the first Tibetan leaders to submit, had marched with the Qing army to retake Tibet; Kangchenas of Ali had cut off the Dzungars' retreat—both were enfeoffed as beile princes; Lobsang Nay came over to the Qing side and received the title Fuguo Gong to administer Ü-Tsang; Polhané became a first-rank Jasak taiji to govern Tsang. Both were named gablon ministers. In turn the Yase districts of Litang and the tribal areas of Sang'a, Banlin, Kashi, and the like under Batang all submitted; The Golog strongholds of Jiyi Ka, Nawu, and Yaliu were brought under control, some by arms and some by negotiation.
20
西 西
In the seventh month of the fifth year of Yongzheng (1727), Arigiba, Lobsang Nay, and Tsering—citing kinship with the Dalai Lama—moved against Beile Kangchenas, mustered troops to kill him, and plotted to defect to the Dzungars. The court dispatched Minister of Personnel Chalang'a at the head of over fifteen thousand soldiers from Sichuan, Shaanxi, and Yunnan to suppress the rebels. Polhané did not wait for the relief column. With nine thousand troops from Tsang and Ali he advanced from Panyu Pass toward Kaba, sent a thousand-man vanguard to storm the Khamka barrier, and clashed with Lobsang Nay's army. That night every Tibetan outpost declared for Polhané, and he marched directly on Lhasa. Resident ministers Mara and Sengge hurried to the Potala to guard the Dalai Lama while monks from the major monasteries captured Arigiba and his confederates and delivered them to Mara. Chalang'a's column arrived in time to execute the ringleaders and their kin. Polhané was promoted to beile and given supreme authority over Tibet. The emperor granted thirty thousand taels of silver to reward the army. Two resident ministers—one senior, one junior—were installed with two thousand Sichuan and Shaanxi troops split between Ü and Tsang. Thus began the system of Qing ambans in Tibet, replaced on a three-year rotation. Batang and Litang were annexed to Sichuan and placed under an xuanfusi commissioner; Zhongdian and Weixi were attached to Yunnan and governed through two newly created subprefectures.
21
西 西
In the same year Tsewang Arabtan died and was succeeded by his son Galdan Tseren, who asked leave to travel to Tibet for the tea pilgrimage and promised to send back the two sons of the captive Lhazang Khan. The court tightened defenses and relocated the Dalai Lama to the Huiyuan Temple at Litang. In the eighth year (1730) the Dalai Lama was transferred to Taining under a guard of one thousand men. Each summer Tibetan detachments manned the northern passes near Tengger Lake to watch for Dzungar incursions, withdrawing when winter snows closed the routes. Three corridors linked Tibet to Dzungar territory. The western route from Yarkand to Ali crossed formidable ranges and was long and easily guarded; the eastern Karak River corridor was blocked as well, this time by Qinghai Mongols; but the central passage along Tengger Lake lay nearest to central Tibet and therefore demanded the strongest watch. Polhané's son Tsering Tashi Tobden was appointed Jasak first-rank taiji to command the Ali garrisons and guard the Tangut frontier. In memory of Kangchenas, who had died childless after his brother fell fighting in Ali, the court enfeoffed Kangchenas's nephew Kalsang Panam Lekyi Tobgyal as Fuguo Gong and later named him gablon. The Dalai Lama's father Sonam Darjay received the same rank of Fuguo Gong. Polhané was further promoted from beile to beile prince (a higher beile rank). In the tenth year the Ladakh ruler Delek Namgyal wrote: "I govern my realm and uphold the Dharma; whenever I learn of Dzungar designs I inform the court." The emperor answered with a commendatory rescript. After the Dzungars made peace, Prince Guo and the Changkya Khutukhtu escorted the Dalai Lama from Taining to Lhasa while the Tibetan garrison was cut to one quarter of its former strength. The Changkya Khutukhtu asked that Batang and Litang be restored to Ü-Tsang as the Dalai Lama's natal region, where chieftains had raised the grandest monasteries for his early training. The court granted the Dalai Lama five thousand taels yearly from their trade revenues but kept the districts under Qing administration.
22
使 便
The Dzungar leader Tsewang Dorji Namgyal again sent pilgrims to Tibet. They entered monasteries claiming smallpox precautions, posted their own guards at the gates, and barred Qing escorts. The emperor warned that the Dzungars were treacherous: defenses must stay tight even if they seemed to have gone home. Tsering Namgyal, chafing under Qing oversight, meanwhile reported that Tibet was peaceful and asked that the garrison be withdrawn. Ministers argued that refusal would look suspicious; better to appear trusting. The emperor agreed and ordered the troops out. The Dalai Lama was told to bar Dzungar entry; despite repeated pleas he refused. He then fabricated word that Dzungars were striking Tangut toward Shuang'entukur, deployed troops to Karak Usu, and relocated Dam tribesmen. Within weeks he announced Dzungars at Ahayak and marched out with an army. Resident commander Suobai dispatched Wangdui to Karak Usu to stand guard. Wangdui found no enemy at all. The court ordered the Karak Usu detachment disbanded and the Dam people sent back to their pastures, warning against spreading panic. Prince Polhané's son-in-law Bandi Da now saw Tsering Namgyal's treasonous designs and refused to side with him. Tsering Namgyal retaliated by imprisoning Bandi Da's household. Deputy resident minister Jishan denounced Tsering Namgyal's arrogance and asked that his elder brother be summoned to help govern Tibet. Qianlong refused, telling Jishan to win him over discreetly and show no open suspicion. Soon afterward Tsering Namgyal accused his brother Tsering Tashi Tobden of sending Ali troops to raid Tibet—a frame-up. The emperor wrote to Fu Qing: "Tsering Namgyal is young, hot-tempered, and prone to make trouble. If he truly has no ulterior motive and only his brother marches on Lhasa, treat it as a family feud. If the brother is inventing charges, deal with the accuser as the situation requires."
23
In the fifteenth year of Qianlong (1750) Tsering Namgyal murdered his brother Tsering Tashi Tobden in Ali, claimed sudden illness, asked to retrieve the corpse, and offered to adopt the orphan. Both nephews—Puncog Wangbo and Tsering Wanggyal—were then living in Tsang. He sent soldiers to kill Puncog Wangbo while announcing that the youth had escaped. The younger nephew Tsering Wanggyal survived because he had taken monastic vows under the Panchen Lama. Fu Qing and Labdon warned that Tsering Namgyal had marched out of Lhasa with an armed following. By then he had already killed his brother, was corresponding with the Dzungars for reinforcements, smuggled artillery into Tsang, framed gablon Bandi Da and other officials for fleeing to Dam three hundred li away, and camped two thousand men there refusing to return. The throne ordered Deputy Commander Bandi from Qinghai to punish the rebel and told Sichuan Governor Tsering and General Yue Zhongqi to march to his support. Rebel strength blocked the mail routes; no word reached Beijing for ten days. Fu Qing and Labdon concluded that delay would let him seize the Tangut region. They invited Tsering Namgyal upstairs. The moment he stepped up they confronted him: "You defy the Son of Heaven and dishonor your father's house! Faithless to emperor and father alike—your life is forfeit!" Fu Qing seized his arm while Labdon stabbed him with a dagger, then announced amnesty for anyone forced to follow him. A follower named Robzang Tashi raised the alarm; a thousand rebels surrounded the building and set it ablaze. The Dalai Lama sent monks to rescue them, but the flames kept them out. Fu Qing and Labdon perished in the fire. Qianlong mourned the martyred ministers, posthumously made them first-class barons, and erected the Shrine of the Two Loyal Martyrs in their honor. Bandi Da rallied troops around the Dalai Lama to resist the uprising. The court named him acting gablon with the rank Fuguo Gong, splitting civil power while leaving supreme authority with the Dalai Lama. Tibetan government was reorganized into four gablons, five daipens, three depas, and three khenpos, all under the ambans and the Dalai Lama. Fifteen hundred additional Qing troops were stationed in Tibet. The Dam tribes were brought under direct amban rule on the model of interior banner administration, complete with assistant commandant and vanguard captain posts. Strong checkpoints were planted on every Dzungar route into Tibet. When Yili fell in the twenty-second year (1757), the Dzungar threat to Tibet ended for good. In that same year the Dalai Lama died at the Potala at the age of fifty.
24
The eighth Dalai Lama, Lobzang Jampel Gyatso Pelsangpo, was born in 1758 at Togché Rela Gang in Tsang. In 1762 he was enthroned at the Potala. In 1765 the Panchen Lama Bandi Yeshe gave him the novice vows. In 1768 he traveled to Ü-Tsang for the great assembly and preached in turn at Sera, Drepung, and Ganden. In 1777 the Panchen Lama conferred full monastic ordination. In 1781 the court issued an imperial patent, golden register, and golden seal, and enfeoffed the Dalai Lama's brother Sonam Tashi as Fuguo Gong. In 1783 he received a jade register and seal for state ceremonies, while routine correspondence continued to bear his earlier seal.
25
歿
In 1788 the Gurkhas attacked the Tibetan frontier. After the sixth Panchen Lama's death the relics sent from Beijing brought gifts worth hundreds of thousands of taels—imperial donations plus offerings from nobles across China and the borderlands—including jeweled crowns, crystal begging bowls, and gold-thread vestments beyond number. His elder brother, the Chöje Khutukhtu, hoarded the entire fortune, sharing nothing with the monasteries or with Tibetan troops and clergy. The younger Shamar Lama, denied a share, goaded Nepal's Gurkhas to invade on the pretext of higher trade levies and adulterated salt. Tibetan officials secretly bought off the Gurkhas. Court envoy Bazhong, Chengdu general Ehui, and commander Cheng De—far from fighting—helped khenpos promise fifteen thousand taels in annual tribute, and the invaders withdrew content. Bazhong's memorial portrayed the payoff as a Gurkha surrender and suggested enfeoffing their ruler after a tribute mission to Beijing. In the seventh month of 1789 Gurkha envoys came to Lhasa with tribute and reminded the ambans of the secret stipend. General Ehui, fearing discovery of the bribe, withheld the report from Beijing. The next year Tibet failed to pay the promised gold.
26
In the seventh month of 1791 the Gurkhas invaded again, seized Nyalam, and captured Gablon Tendün Pandita. By the eighth month they held Jilong as well. Amban Baotai evacuated the Panchen Lama to Ü-Tsang. The Gurkhas pushed to Saka Gorge and Tashilhunpo; the Chöje Khutukhtu fled. In the ninth month Captain Xu Nanteng held the government fort while the Gurkhas looted Tashilhunpo and retreated. Bazhong, who was with the emperor at Rehe, drowned himself on hearing the news. Ehui and Cheng De were ordered to relieve Tibet but dawdled on the march.
27
西 滿 調 使
In the tenth month Baotai asked to evacuate both the Dalai and Panchen Lamas to Taining. Qianlong rebuked the ambans but praised the Dalai Lama for refusing to flee. Qianlong named Fu Kang'an commander-in-chief and Hailancha second-in-command, sending Solon, Daur, garrison, and native troops to expel the Gurkhas. Military supply east of Tibet was overseen by Sichuan Governor Sun Shiyi. West of Tibet fell to Resident Minister Helin. The sector beyond the Jilong border was assigned to former Governor Huiling. In the first month of 1792 (Qianlong 57), E'hui's column retook Nyalam. That February the Pakri garrison commander marched Tibetan auxiliaries back into Sikkim and the Zongmu region. The same month the turncoat depa Boerdong came back to Tibet from the Gurkha capital Yangbu. Beijing learned Tibet had secretly promised yearly payments to Nepal. Ambans Baotai and Yaman Tai were demoted, fined, and put in the cangue for hiding the deal. March 1792: Fuk'anggan became commander-in-chief, and the Zhongba Khutukhtu was arrested and sent to Beijing. In April another three thousand Sichuan soldiers were rushed to Tibet. In the leap fourth month Fuk'anggan marched from Tingri toward Zongk'a. May brought the capture of Tsam and the recovery of Jilong. On the fifteenth they seized Reso Bridge and crossed into Nepal. Eight days later they stormed the fort at Xiebulu. In June Fuk'anggan and Hailancha cleared Dongjue, Yar Sala, Boerdong La, and neighboring strongpoints while Cheng De's detachment took Zham's iron-chain bridge. That June Gurkha king Ratna Bahadur sent senior envoys to sue for peace, handing back Dainzin Pandita and earlier prisoners. In July Fuk'anggan captured Galla and Duibumu, forced the river crossings, and pushed over seven hundred li toward the Gurkha capital at Yangbu. Brigade commandant Feiying'a and several officers were killed in action. Cheng De meanwhile stormed the Gurkha hill forts on Mount Lidi. Ratna Bahadur surrendered the old Sino-Gurkha agreement, restored Tashilhunpo's looted property, and sent back the Shamar Lama's body. In August Nepal dispatched a tributary mission. Fuk'anggan reported repeated Gurkha pleas for mercy; Qianlong ordered the surrender accepted. With monsoon snows about to seal the passes, the court agreed to stop short of Yangbu. Fuk'anggan then marched the main force home in triumph and returned to Tibet. The pacification statutes made the ambans equal in standing to the Dalai and Panchen Lamas; gablons and lesser posts were to be chosen and installed by the ambans; Ü-Tsang Tibetan forces were placed under Qing mobile and assistant commandants for training and discipline; Tibet was authorized to open mints and cast its own silver currency; and a grain commissioner was appointed to supervise finances. Only then did Qing sovereignty in Tibet become fully institutionalized.
28
For generations the rebirths of the Dalai, Panchen, and great khutukhtus had been chosen through medium séances—rife with favoritism and a byword for abuse. When the Jebtsundamba died just as the Tushiyetu Khan's wife was pregnant, courtiers instantly declared the unborn child his reincarnation; yet at term she gave birth to a girl, a scandal that never died down. Dalai and Panchen relatives likewise maneuvered for wealthy khutukhtu seats, fueling the Zhongba brothers' feud and the Gurkha war they provoked. The Dalai's brothers Zizhong and Suibeng, as Shangzhoiteba treasurers, embezzled land, promoted heterodox Red Hat lamas, and seated them beside the Dumu and Jilong khutukhtus; They extorted silver from monks, skimmed the Shang treasury, and cut pilgrims' travel stipends in half—damaging the Dalai Lama's prestige until fewer dignitaries came and public trust collapsed. After the war Qianlong imposed the Golden Urn: disputed reincarnations were resolved by writing names on lots, sealing them in a urn at Lhasa's Jokhang, chanting for three days, then drawing before Tsongkhapa's image in the presence of the ambans, Dalai Lama, and Panchen Lama. Mongol khutukhtus reported candidates to the Lifanyuan and drew lots at Yonghe Temple under the Changkya or Lama Seal Office, with new caps on Dongköl monks entering government service.
29
西
The ninth Dalai Lama, Awang Long'an Gyamco Pelsangpo, was identified in 1805 at Düquké in Kham. Precocious at two and claiming memory of his prior life, he was confirmed by special edict without Golden Urn lots. In September 1808 he was enthroned at the Potala, and his uncle Lobsang Nyentrap Namgyel received a first-rank cap. In 1813 the Panchen Lama gave him novice vows. While the Dalai Lama was a child, gablons embezzled his estates, rotated officials arbitrarily, sheltered bandits, and looted openly. Deputy Commander Wen Bi from Chengdu and Xining Commissioner Yuning were sent to Tibet to investigate, including charges between Gablon Tsebek and Cheng Lin. Tsebek was found to have imposed inland-style regulations that angered Tibetans; Cheng Lin had skimmed the treasury. Both were stripped of office and exiled to Yili and Urumqi. Thus Tibetan government rotted from within. Externally, Gurkha minister Nain Singh killed his king and was put to death. Rebel leader Renabi Gelung fled into Tibet and clashed with the British, begging the Dalai and Panchen Lamas for funds. Bhutan's chief Chözhé Chöle asked for a royal title; Wen Bi suppressed the memorial. The Pakri garrison commander extorted his border gifts and sparked a fight. Sikkim's ruler asked for Tibetan land grants and a border settlement. Burmese men and women were secretly corresponding with Tibetan khutukhtus. By then Tibet's situation was critically unstable. In February 1815 the ninth Dalai Lama died at the Potala at age eleven.
30
宿宿
The tenth Dalai Lama, Awang Lobzang Gyamco Danzin Chökyi Gyamco Pelsangpo, was chosen by Golden Urn lot at the Jokhang on the last day of March 1816. In August 1816 he was enthroned at the Potala. The Changkya Khutukhtu was sent from Beijing to supervise the installation. Galdan Xiltu Samadi Bakshi became chief tutor; Awang Nyentrap, Rinchen Pandita Ngawang Gyalpo Yeshé Tenpai Gyamco, and others served as deputies. After three years of instruction the junior tutor received the Nomonhan title, and the Dalai's father Lobzang Nyentrap gained a first-rank cap. In 1809 the Panchen Lama conferred full monastic ordination. In 1810 Bowo's rebel tribes submitted. Qing created a fourth-rank Pakri-style post at Chümudo and lesser native head posts at six border monasteries.
31
西 調 西 貿 西
Southwest of Tibet lay Dremojong (Sikkim), Tibet's frontier buffer. Since the fifth Dalai Lama they had acknowledged the Gelukpa and been ruled from Lhasa. In 1791 the ambans reported that Sikkim and Zomolang wrote to Lhasa yet ignored Tibetan orders and had suffered a decade of Gurkha occupation. Fuk'anggan ordered them to join the counteroffensive and recover their land, but they pleaded heat exhaustion and refused to advance. After Nepal surrendered they hoped to use Qing power to restore the sixth Dalai Lama's old frontier. Fuk'anggan fixed borders and barred unrestricted access to Tibet, but still let them summer at Chomo Chupi when the lowlands grew hot. Under the seventh Dalai Lama, Tibetan estates west of Chomo Chupi seized from Sikkim were granted for their upkeep, and they collected grain taxes themselves. Chomo villagers regularly traded in Sikkim. The Sikkimese raja's Tibetan wife maintained contacts with the Gurkha court. Sikkim lay eleven post-stations from Lhasa; its summer camp beyond Pakri was only one mountain from Tibet, marked by cairns but no strategic barrier, and peace had held for years. After Tibet closed the border they petitioned for land, for Chomo Yanachö subjects, and finally for the Pakri garrison command. Ü-Tsang's Shang treasury feuded with Tsang's Shangzhoiteba treasurer. Chief tutor Galdan Xiltu Samadi Bakshi was notoriously corrupt; he insulted any Tsang official who pleaded for him. Amban Wengan told the gablons to warn him that Sikkim had no right to govern Tibetan subjects and capped royal visits at once every eight years. Beijing ministers, ignorant of local facts, approved. Wengan circulated orders for strict local investigation but never publicly proclaimed the edict, fearing the Sikkimese raja would appeal. Nevertheless the raja still petitioned annually for pilgrimage tea rites and summer residence in Tibet. Not until 1824 did Amban Songting issue the earlier edicts plainly and rebuff each new request. In 1825 the Panchen Lama relayed Sikkim's plea: since the border closed, over a thousand subjects had died of disease. Every tribe may attend the Dalai Lama's enthronement except his former dependents, who are shamed before their clansmen." Tibet then allowed brief summer residence under Pakri garrison surveillance. Wengan had believed Ü-Tsang's side alone, never verified the facts, and rushed a memorial to Beijing. Aware they were mishandling a dependent state, they still let him come once for tea rites—equating Sikkim with the Dzungars. Sikkim drifted away, accepted British protection, and after the disaster at Nathu La Tibet's frontier stood open. In 1826 the tenth Dalai Lama died at the Potala at age twenty-two.
32
The eleventh Dalai Lama, Awang Kesang Tenpai Chökyi Gyatso, was born in September 1831 at Gada. In May 1841 he was confirmed by Golden Urn lots, tonsured by the Panchen Lama, and his father Tsewang Dundup was made a duke. In October 1841 Ladakh and allied tribes seized seventeen hundred li of Tibetan land and captured the Dab, Gar, and Zaren garrisons. Ambans sent Dai Bing to counterattack, rearmed Tibetan auxiliaries with muskets, and retook Zaren. Gablons surrounded the enemy, killed forty-odd Ladakhi and Senba leaders and two hundred fighters, and accepted Padbu's surrender with restoration of Fan, Tang, Dab, and Gar. Five hundred Duigar gold miners were recruited from Ü-Tsang, garrisoned under Dai Bing and four assistant officers who trained them. In April 1842 he was escorted from Rishen Monastery in eastern Ü-Tsang to the Potala throne. In 1844 the Jilong Khutukhtu became chief tutor and Lama Lobzang Langchup of Jiangzi Qujie served as deputy.
33
歿
Amban Qishan impeached the Nomonhan tutor Galdan Xiltu Samadi Bakshi Awang Gyamco for abuse of power and corruption; every charge was investigated and reported. The Lifanyuan ruled on the disgraced Nomonhan: a minor Taozhou monk elevated through three reigns, tutor to the Dalai Lama, showered with titles from Nomonhan to imperial chan master and Darhan—he should have lived in righteous seclusion. Instead he extorted Tibetans, seized peasant land, tore down the Dalai Lama's buildings, and used imperial umbrellas never bestowed on him. He seized Shang treasury assets and hid fugitives. He stamped documents away from government offices, charged tribute to the court from others' funds, looted treasuries, and ruled by whim. He neglected the Dalai Lama's household until no attendants remained; the boy was wounded in the neck and bled profusely—the tutor first failed to prevent it, then ignored it. Only Senbing stood by during the injury—and Senbing was the Nomonhan's man. The last two Dalai Lamas had each died young before taking the seal—the circumstances, the court implied, were not to be asked about openly. He would even extort fortunes in the thousands from a single released zhassak lama—a scandal beyond belief." The throne stripped Lidé of every rank and title, ordered all disciples under his monastic registry expelled, sealed his temple, and banished him to Heilongjiang. His assets were seized, sold off, and the proceeds applied to restoring monasteries across Tibet. He was soon freed but remanded to harsh local control. He later offered silver to return to central Tibet and, citing the Nepal war, petitioned again for reinstatement in Ü-Tsang. Each petition met a firm refusal. He died in the Torghut lands early in the Tongzhi era; burial there was allowed, but no successor incarnation. Twenty-three disciples were left to graze their herds in that banner. In early Guangxu the Torghut prince again paid a vast sum to secure a reincarnation; only then was the boy already found as hubilgan grudgingly permitted to take vows.
34
Qishan soon submitted twenty-eight revised articles and abolished the rules for auditing the Shang treasury and drilling Tibetan troops. By custom every disbursement of alms silver from the Shang had been reported each quarter. Once Qishan's reforms took effect, the Qing lost its grip on Tibet's finances. The ambans' salaries and troop pay had long been funded from interest on capital Fukang'an had assigned to the Shang from the Nepal campaign surplus. Qishan's new rules ended that interest fund and shifted every expense to the Shang. Tibetans later grew reluctant to pay Qing costs in Tibet, forgetting that the original endowment had been state capital lent for interest—not a levy on the Shang. In short, Qianlong's settlement had been undone entirely.
35
使
In the twelfth month of that year an imperial letter opened to the Eleventh Dalai Lama: "To the Dalai Lama: We soothe the empire and shower grace on all peoples, seeking one moral order for every land and virtue reaching the farthest corners of the earth. We depend as well on the wide preaching of the Dharma, the weaving of good karma, and the guidance of all beings toward enlightenment. Whoever masters the Greater Vehicle, upholds the orthodox teaching, and awakens the benighted tribes deserves the richest rewards and the highest honors. Your nature is deep and still, your learning in the sutras assured; omens marked your childhood, and in manhood your discipline has only hardened— since your enthronement the number of your devotees has multiplied. We commend you and, following precedent, invest you as Dalai Lama, All-Knowing Vajradhara, Great Compassionate Self-Existent Buddha, Holder of the Doctrine of All Schools, granting a new golden patent. Uphold the Yellow Hat order and preside over Ü-Tsang; let the people's welfare be your foundation and Heaven's favor your shield for the realm. Manage all Tibetan affairs through the Gablons as of old, settle matters by consultation, and report through the ambans, that Tibet may know peace, the people receive blessing, and your teaching fulfill Our care for the frontier. With this patent go gold, silver, silks, and porcelain—receive them in reverence, to the glory of the dynasty's measureless fortune. Reverently obey!"
36
使西
In the twelfth month of year twenty-six Qishan reported that the Parang—the British—sought demarcation and trade; the court told Qiying to refuse, citing standing treaties. In the seventh month of year twenty-seven Qiying reported British and German envoys asking that Tibet's old borders be surveyed and officers sent; the court took note. Amban Binliang was told to inquire in secret: if no harm appeared, approve as before; if deceit was found, rebuke them on principle. Haishan too was ordered to investigate, but the affair soon died away. In year twenty-eight Duke Tsewang Dondrup received a jeweled cap finial and the double-eyed peacock plume.
37
西歿 滿
The Twelfth Dalai Lama, Awang Lobzang Tenpai Gyatso, was discovered at Woka Dazhuo. In the first month of year eight his name was drawn from the Golden Urn. In the seventh month of year nine he was enthroned at the Potala. His father Penchok Tsewang was made a duke. Earlier, in the fourth month of year three, Nepalese and Chamdo traders fought over debts with deaths on both sides; Amban Muteng'e settled it under frontier custom with fines on each side. Nepal then overtaxed grain and obstructed trade until relations broke down; Tibetan troops lost repeatedly and Dzongkha, Jilong, Nyalam, and other posts fell. Amban Hetehe rushed to Tsang to direct defense while Chengdu General Le Bin marched Han and native troops in support. Hearing imperial columns approach, the Gorkha sent their Kazi to Lhasa to sue for peace; the court agreed to stand down. Tibet and Nepal signed ten articles: Tibet paid Nepal two thousand taels yearly in tax; Nepal returned seized districts to the Shang. The Regent Hutuktu Liedzhen, who ran the Shang, cut alms to Sera, Drepung, and Ganden; defeated in the ensuing clash and condemned by clergy and laity alike, he stole the seal and fled to Beijing. The throne stripped his title and barred any future incarnation. Nomonhan Wangchuk Gyalpo was appointed to help govern the Shang. Wangchuk Gyalpo had begun as a layman and served as Gablon—the post Tibetans call "Shaza Galon." After a feud with Liedzhen he resigned, took vows, and was now brought back to office. He began rebuilding Lhasa's city wall from west to east; the work stopped unfinished at his death. Earlier every Qing soldier from battalion commander down had been housed in the Tashilhunpo barracks. Amban Manqing, citing repeated unrest, moved the garrison into Lhasa proper, where troops thereafter rented lodgings. The Tashilhunpo camp was left empty. In year three Ganden Tripa Lobzang Chokyi Wangchuk gave the Dalai his novice vows.
38
滿調西
Nyarong rebels had long blockaded Litang and the post road; their chief Gonpo Namgyel sent Qimei Gongbo's host to Sanba on the Batang-Litang frontier, where they robbed a grain convoy and seized official dispatches from Lhasa. Distress reports also arrived from Geji. Late in the Daoguang era Sichuan governor Qishan had marched against Gonpo Namgyel without destroying him. The court later ceded disputed Nyarong lands to local chiefs, enfeoffed Gonpo Namgyel, and withdrew the army. Emboldened, he swallowed neighboring chiefdoms, cut Sichuan-Tibet trade, and throttled grain convoys until Han and tribes alike were exhausted. Amban Manqing levied Tibetan auxiliaries and loans and called the Thirty-Nine Tribes to guard Nyarong's northwest, while Governor Luo Bingzhang coordinated Dartsedo, Batang, and Litang officials with Mingzheng and the Jinchuan chiefs to strike the southeast. Tibetan troops sent to Batang looted the town on arrival and were ordered home. By year four the rebellion was over. The court granted upper, middle, and lower Nyarong to the Dalai for temples and worship. His elder brother Yeshe Lobzang Wangchuk inherited the ducal title. In year seven he traveled to Ü-Tsang on an alms round. In year eight he funded restoration of the Zhaling Kusho golden stupa. In year ten he preached and distributed tea at Drepung and Sera. In year twelve he again toured Ü-Tsang for alms. In the second month of that year he assumed civil and religious rule by imperial order. In year thirteen and Guangxu year one he again made alms tours in Ü-Tsang. He died at the Potala in the third month of Guangxu 1, aged twenty.
39
The Thirteenth Dalai, Thubten Gyatso, was born in the fifth month at Langlai's home in Dab Gyaco; once the child was identified, the Panchen and leading monks and laity petitioned Amban Songti to memorialize the throne. The court waived the Golden Urn and confirmed him as the Dalai's hubilgan. In the first month of year four the Panchen tonsured him at Gongtang Dewa and bestowed his dharma name. In the sixth month he was enthroned at the Potala and shed the hubilgan title. His father Gonggar Rinchen was made duke with jeweled finial and peacock plume. In the first month of year eight the chief tutor, the Jilong Khutukhtu, gave him full ordination and instruction.
40
During an alms tour in year ten, crowds of lamas clashed with Newar traders and sacked all eighty-three Nepalese shops in Lhasa. Nepal demanded over three hundred thousand taels in damages and massed troops to enforce payment. Amban Seleng'e sent Han and Tibetan envoys to reason with them; Nepal finally reduced the claim to a little over 180,000 taels. After the Shang and seized goods covered most of the sum, nearly 67,000 taels remained; Sichuan was ordered to pay the balance. In year eleven he toured Ü-Tsang for alms. In year fourteen Gonggar Rinchen died and his brother Dundup Dorje received the dukedom. That year he preached at Drepung and Sera. In year fifteen he again toured Ü-Tsang for alms.
41
The year of his birth, Sikkim and Bhutan, pressed by British India on their borders, began eyeing Tibet and repeatedly asked Beijing to fortify the frontier. Beijing dismissed the alarm, noting only that British agents were leasing Bhutanese land to build roads toward Tibet for trade. Yet Bhutan borders Sikkim, and Sikkim had already accepted British road works—collusion was easy to fear. Songti was told to counsel both sides to keep their borders and turn the British back. Sikkim, believing Beijing blind to frontier realities and suspecting Qing intrigue, drifted toward Britain, leasing Yatung until the Raj treated the state as a protectorate. Tibetans felt the British closing in, accused Sikkim of secret treaties with England, and often debated invasion—driving Sikkim still nearer to Britain.
42
使 退 退
When Wen Shuo was punished Tibetans judged the Qing in the wrong and took revenge into their own hands. Sheng Tai's orders to halt them met universal rage. Tibetans swore before the multitude: "Every Tibetan, man or woman, shall not share this earth and sky with the English. Whoever breaks this oath, let the people execute him!" They then massed at Phari to crush the Indian army. Sheng Tai unearthed a Qianlong-era record: in 1789, when Nepal threatened Sikkim, the Dalai had granted the Rinak district to Sikkim; now that Sikkim dealt secretly with Britain, that land ought to revert to Tibet. Sheng Tai's repeated orders went unheeded; Indian forces stormed the Rela pass and killed or wounded hundreds of Tibetans. The pursuit carried into the Chumbi valley until the Government of India forbade further advance. The ambans were ordered to the frontier to parley with British officers. London instructed Minister Liu Ruifen in Britain to negotiate a settlement. Tibetans vowed that if Britain held Sikkimese soil they would rather die than yield. In the eighth month of year fourteen a large Indian column overran Sikkim and struck Tibetans at Yatung. The Tibetans broke, abandoning Chumbi, Yatung, and Lungtar; over ten thousand men scattered in rout. The pursuit cornered several Gablons at Rinchingong, where they met Xiao Zhanxian, the ceasefire officer the ambans had sent forward. Zhanxian unfurled a Chinese placard to halt the column; the Indians held their fire and agreed to parley. Zhanxian secured a pledge to end the pursuit, though the British officer still meant to strike Rinchingong villages. He declared the ground Qing territory, said Tibet had disobeyed the throne by fighting, promised Beijing would punish the offenders, and begged the British not to advance. The British officer agreed, insisted negotiations conclude quickly, and pulled his men back. Defeated and dispossessed, Tibetans still burned for revenge; Sheng Tai forbade it again and again, to no avail. Tibetans called Han officials the "foreign party" and several times nearly rioted, but fear of their officers held them back. British officers cited the cold and pressed for talks; Sheng Tai hurried to the frontier. Tibetans, accusing peace-minded Gablons of betraying the Geluk faith, debated drowning them in the Tsangpo and demanded the amban recover all Sikkim and Bhutan—or they would fight to the last man. Tibetan forces again massed on four roads. Sheng Tai reached Tibet and forcibly blocked them, exhorted monks and laymen alike to keep the peace, then raced to the border to negotiate.
43
退退
Bitter cold killed men and horses in droves. At Phari he found ten thousand Tibetans still holding Rinchingong beyond the pass. Sheng Tai ordered them to pull back; Tibetan officers replied that until he met the British they dared not retreat far, and fell back only a few dozen li. The Sikkim raja sent his brother to pay respects, explaining that Indian troops had barred his own visit. Sheng Tai conferred with the British officer Paul at Nathang. " Sikkim and India have had a treaty for twenty-seven years; Sikkim belongs under Indian protection. Tibet has fought India and lost again and again—what would stop our army from overrunning the whole of Tibet? Only out of regard for friendly relations between states. We have therefore held our troops in check." He also demanded Tibetan indemnities for the war. " Sikkim is Tibetan territory. India and Sikkim may have made treaties before, but the Qing never received notice from the Indian government. Tibetans never raided Indian soil; Tibet owes no indemnity by any name." Meanwhile the British were opening roads in Bhutan and the Tsangpo gorges, and Tibetans were terrified anew. Paul drove a hard bargain; Sheng Tai beat down the terms until Tibetans slowly accepted the limits imposed.
44
退 退 西 西 西
Sheng Tai repeatedly demanded a British withdrawal; London refused. Even so the armed monks of the Three Great Monasteries and the ten thousand men at Rinchingong all pulled back. A dozen Gablons, leading lamas, and scores of Tibetan officers followed Sheng Tai to the frontier and camped at Rinchingong, refusing to face the British. With Sikkim unsettled, snow sealing the passes, and no grain route open, Sheng Tai too retired to Rinchingong. The Zongli Yamen sent the Englishman Hart to Tibet as interpreter. The raja's mother petitioned with her kin, recalling that the original British treaty had barred them from crossing the Teesta. Sikkim had leased land to Britain for twelve thousand rupees a year. Britain, trusting its power, had not paid for years. The India-Tibet war had again ruined them. Mother, son, and kin did not wish to submit to Britain and begged that Sikkim not be cut out of the empire's map. Britain had seized all Sikkim, imprisoned the raja at Gangtok, garrisoned the country heavily, and settled Indian and Nepali colonists on new farms. Beijing judged Sikkim beyond saving and, fearing it would block a Tibetan settlement, told Sheng Tai to refuse. Bhutan was several times larger than Sikkim; Europeans called it Bhutan; in the Guangxu era it still paid tribute. When Sheng Tai arrived, the Bhutanese raja sent seventeen hundred men as an escort. Sheng Tai feared this would give Britain a pretext and declined the escort. The raja also asked for seals and titles; Sheng Tai promised to memorialize Beijing. The historic Tibet-Sikkim border ran along Mount Yana and Mount Zhimu. Later traders opened the Chumbi shortcut that Europeans called the Rela-Bale ridge. Sheng Tai proposed fixing the Tibet-Sikkim line at Chumbi to match earlier practice and recording the India-Sikkim boundary at the Teesta in the treaty. The 1861 India-Sikkim treaty could not be verified in the archives and was set aside. Thutob Namgyal, the Sikkim raja whom India styled king, lay imprisoned at Gangtok while his mother and heir remained at Chumbi in what the British called Tibet. The Indian camp forged the raja's order to bring his two sons to Gangtok; his mother refused, brought her grandsons to Sheng Tai's camp, and wept for justice; begging the throne to intervene—yet Sheng Tai could do nothing for them. The British again tried to replace the raja; Sheng Tai quietly blocked it. Hart was snowbound and long delayed.
45
西 退 退 使 西貿 退 退 使
In the second month of year fifteen the last Tibetan units went home; Sheng Tai asked the Yamen to cable London demanding an immediate Indian withdrawal. Hart reached the frontier in the third month; Tibetans were gone. Tibetans insisted the old border still stood: after the Dalai granted Rinak to Sikkim, the Gyapardang pastures on Lungtu Hill remained Tibetan grazing—the true historic line. Chumbi had never borne a border cairn; Tibetans had only halted the British there the year before. They loathed opening trade but dared not defy Beijing. They would not allow foreigners beyond Chumbi. Hart negotiated at camp; the British refused to move the Chumbi line but allowed Sikkim's old courtesies toward the Shang and the ambans to continue. Tibetans, however, would have no such rights inside Sikkim—accept that, they said, and talks could begin. Sheng Tai agreed. After the Indian withdrawal the British still delayed signing any treaty. " Tibetans ask: why make peace with hostile Britain when Russia bears no grudge? When Russians last came to Tibet we received them with gifts and they left. Now Britain covets our land; a lucky victory has made them insufferably arrogant. Last year Russians asked to travel from Khotan into Tibet. Further British delay will turn Tibetan minds toward Moscow again. This year Mongol pilgrims cross the steppe in endless streams—and many who follow them look Russian. Secret Tibetan dealings would be hard to police. With the frontier unsettled, Russia may court Tibet while Britain and Russia eye each other—planting long troubles ahead. I beg you to instruct the British minister to cable the viceroy to conclude the Tibetan treaty at once." In the tenth month he reported: "The British now say that after withdrawal they need only follow old rules—no trade office, no new treaty. Trade was their demand from the first meeting. They kept pressing access to Tibet; I answered that Tibetan suspicions made Lhasa impossible and offered Gyantse instead. After repeated argument I conceded Phari. They pressed further; I refused again, and Paul grew angry. Trade was then their price for peace. I finally compelled Tibetans to accept trade and secured their written pledge of compliance. Now the British drop the trade question—for a reason of their own. They had assumed Tibetans would never honor a trade clause and used the demand as leverage. Now that Tibet has pledged compliance, they fear other powers will cite the clause after ratification and shut Tibet to exclusive British advantage—so they halt. Tibetans welcome the British retreat from trade talks; if neither side provokes, quiet may hold for a time. Russia too would gain no foothold—for now we may avoid fresh entanglements. But vigilance must tighten; laxity cannot recur. Both armies are home and old grievances cooled—a treaty should now seal mutual good faith. The British stall because a treaty would bind their ambitions. Summer has passed in empty delay; further postponement is impossible. Please press the British minister and cable the viceroy to conclude at once." The Sikkim raja wished to abandon his realm and live in Chumbi; Sheng Tai forbade it.
46
In the second month of year sixteen Sheng Tai, as plenipotentiary, and the viceroy signed eight articles: delimit Tibet and Sikkim from Mount Gipmochi on the Bhutan frontier to the Nepalese border; recognize British protection over Sikkim; trade, diplomacy, and grazing rights between Tibet and India to be negotiated separately; signed at Calcutta; ratifications exchanged in London by Minister Xue Fucheng. In the fifth month the Bhutanese raja received an imperial seal. In the third month of year seventeen Sheng Tai proposed moving the Nathu La checkpoint. In the eighth month he reported Tibetans resisting new customs posts and asked to keep the market at Yatung alone. The throne noted it for the relevant offices.
47
貿西
In the tenth month of year nineteen Sichuan deputy commander He Changrong, customs officer Hart, and British political officer Paul at Darjeeling signed nine trade and frontier articles: Yatung opened as a mart for British merchants under a Jingxi subprefect, with Indian agents stationed to oversee commerce; British traders might travel freely from the frontier to Yatung; inside Tibet, suits between British subjects and Chinese or Tibetans were to be heard jointly by Qing frontier officers and British agents; Dispatches for the Tibetan ambans were relayed from India: a Darjeeling officer handed them to Qing frontier commissioners for the post road. Tibetan herdsmen in Sikkim were to follow British rules, with the original treaty reported and enforced in full. After the pact, Tibetans resented British trade monopoly and grazing curbs alike and blocked the opening of Yatung.
48
退 鹿
In the first month of year twenty-one chief regent Purgyel Shabdrung gave the Dalai Lama full monastic ordination. That year Demu Hutuktu, the former regent who had run Shang-Shung affairs, stepped down on grounds of illness. In the eleventh month he assumed civil and religious authority by imperial order. In year twenty-four Nyarong clashed with Sichuan's Mingzheng tusi. Governor Lu Chuanlin sought troops to seize the region; General Gong Shou and amban Wen Hai weighed in, while the Dalai secretly sent Lobzang Trinle and other lamas to petition Beijing. The throne yielded to Tibetan opinion and returned the Three Nyarongs to the Dalai Lama rather than placing them under Sichuan. That year he went in person to Sera, Drepung, and Ganden to fund tea services and preach. In year twenty-five he toured front Tibet to collect alms. In year twenty-six he had his former Shang-Shung chief, Demu Hutuktu Awang Lobzang Choinjor, murdered, together with Loche and others of his house. He seized the estates of Demu's Tsemoling Monastery and asked amban Yu Gang to memorialize the permanent abolition of the Demu Hutuktu line. That year he traveled south to the Tsangpo region, Gyantse, and elsewhere for tea offerings and teaching.
49
使調 西
In year twenty-nine a border dispute brought British troops into Tibet. At first the Dalai Lama mistook Russia for a fellow Buddhist power and courted Moscow while snubbing Britain. Two treaties with Britain had been signed, yet neither was honored. A Russian agent entered Tibet disguised as a Mongol lama, advised the Dalai, and bought arms to fight Britain; London knew but could not stop him. Once Russia was pinned down in the east by Japan, Britain seized the moment to march. Yu Gang was ordered to mediate. Trusting the Russian advisor, the Dalai refused peace and meant to fight. He halted Yu Gang, denied ulag transport, and mobilized troops from every district. Nyarong men were Tibet's toughest fighters—and the least disciplined. They had barely reached Lhasa when they besieged the amban's yamen and killed dozens. Tibetan officers restored order and marched them to the front, but they mutinied before battle and scattered along mountain paths. Tibetan forces kept losing ground as the British advance tightened day by day. Yu Gang was relieved, then stripped of rank. Amban You Tai arrived while the British held Phari. Both sides agreed to parley at Guru under the year-sixteen treaty—supposedly to end the fighting. You Tai first urged the Dalai to block the British himself. The Dalai wavered and had no strategy beyond ordering Arrow-Point Temple rites to curse the enemy dead. Then You Tai claimed Shang-Shung would not furnish ulag and he could not travel, sending only Li Fulin, who shrank from going forward. When the British reached Gyantse they still awaited You Tai, who would not come; Tibetans turned against him. The British column swept in. Terrified, the Dalai entrusted his seal to a Ganden Gablon and fled north to Qinghai the day before. You Tai asked that the Dalai Lama title be revoked for habitual arrogance and flight when the crisis came.
50
西 西西西
Francis Younghusband, triumphant, imposed ten articles on Ganden Gablons led by Lobzang Gyalpo at Lhasa: (1) Tibet must honor the 1890 Sino-British treaty and accept its Sikkim boundary clause; (2) Gyantse, Gartok, and Yatung were to open as treaty ports; (3) and (4) omitted; (5) routes from India to Gyantse and Gartok must remain open; (6) and (7) omitted; (8) forts and stockades from the frontier to Gyantse and Lhasa were to be dismantled; (9) five acts required British consent: no land leases to foreign powers; no foreign interference; no foreign agents in Tibet; no foreign mining or telegraph rights; no pledging of Tibetan revenue or currency abroad. You Tai told Younghusband he lacked authority, was beholden to Shang-Shung, and could not supply transport; Younghusband smiled and agreed. Britain promptly cited this as proof that China exercised no sovereignty in Tibet.
51
退 西
Earlier he had wired the Foreign Ministry that one more crushing Tibetan defeat might yet turn affairs. British troops entered Lhasa to cow the Tibetan populace. After the British imposed a treaty on Tibet they tricked You Tai into signing; Beijing rebuked him harshly. British troops would hold Chumbi until Tibet paid 2,500,000 rupees in indemnity, then withdraw. Finding the Lhasa pact too damaging, the court sent Tang Shaoyi, Tianjin customs intendant and vice banner commander, to Tibet with full negotiating powers. Opinion held that the crisis required securing Sichuan's tusis and recovering the Three Nyarongs; Xi Liang and others were ordered to prepare. Xi Liang moved to abolish tusi rule; lamas of Taining Monastery took up arms. Assistant amban Feng Quan was rushed to suppress the revolt and was killed at Batang. Xi Liang sent Jianchang intendant Zhao Erfeng and provincial commander Ma Weiqi. In the sixth month of year thirty-one Ma Weiqi retook Batang; Zhao Erfeng followed, handled pacification, hunted fugitives, and cleared the region. In the eleventh month troops were sent against Sangpi Ridge Monastery in Xiangcheng, a Litang dependency whose monks had murdered officials. The next intercalary fifth month it fell; its leaders were seized, along with Daoba and Gongga Ridge. Zhao Erfeng was appointed frontier commissioner. In the eighth month he reached Litang, abolished the Litang tusi, and garrisoned five battalions across the converted districts. In the twelfth month Xiengong Monastery west of Yanjing rebelled and was subdued.
52
西 退 宿
In the first month of year thirty-three he launched schools, farming, irrigation, bridges, mining, and medicine, created counties such as Lihua, Dingxiang, and Ba'an, memorialized sweeping reforms, and received one million taels from the ministry. In the seventh month of year thirty-four he and Governor Zhao Ertong created Kang'an circuit, renamed Dartsedo Kangding prefecture, and set up Hekou, Lihua, Daocheng, Gongga Ridge, Ba'an, Sanba, Dingxiang, Yanjing, and three new western battalions. That autumn a Derge succession feud drew him west. He reached Derge in the twelfth month; rebels held Weiquka until Zhao's assault forced their surrender the following sixth month. With Derge quiet the tusi offered his lands for direct rule and Zhao set taxes with the people. In the ninth month Chunke, Gaori, and Langjiling under Lingcu were converted, and he crossed the Jinsha to tour Chunke. In the tenth month Pomi's thirty-nine tribes submitted and Baxoi sought direct rule. Zhao pacified them, cleared bandits at Leiwuqi, Shuobanduo, Lhorong, and Banbar, and seized Jiangka, Gonjo, Sangngag Choling, and Zayul.
53
使 使 使稿 西使 使 西
Tang Shaoyi reached India in the first month of 1905 and met British envoy Felicia repeatedly. The British envoy would not annul the Lhasa treaty but would discuss amendments. Tang rewrote seven or eight clauses; Felicia called that abolition in disguise and refused. Felicia was plenipotentiary in name only—Curzon ruled India's line. Tang said so to his face and won talks. Article nine's suzerainty dispute stalled the talks; Tang pleaded Liaodong duties to return to Beijing and left Zhang Yintang in India. Britain held its original line and the talks failed. A new British cabinet softened its stance; Minister Satow in Beijing received revised instructions and opened talks with the Zongli Yamen. Beijing noted Tibet's long border quarrels with India, its two prior treaties with Britain, and London's new willingness to compromise, and ordered Satow to keep negotiating. To close the affair and save sovereignty, Tang Shaoyi and Satow signed six supplementary articles: (1) the July 1904 Anglo-Tibetan treaty and its English and Chinese texts were appended, ratifications included, and both sides pledged strict observance; (1 continued) either party might at any time adopt measures needed to enforce every clause of the appended treaty. (2) Britain would not annex Tibet or meddle in its government; China would bar any other power from doing so. (3) privileges listed in article nine, section four of the 1904 treaty were reserved to China alone. (3 continued) Britain might, by agreement with China, run telegraph lines from the treaty ports to India. (4) the 1890 and 1893 Sino-British frontier treaties remained in force where not inconsistent. (5) and (6) omitted. To offset the harsher Lhasa terms, the indemnity was cut to just over 1.2 million taels. Beijing pledged to pay on Tibet's behalf; Britain assented; the pact was signed in the capital. You Tai was soon impeached; Zhang Yintang was sent to investigate. You Tai and his staff were convicted, degraded, and banished in varying degrees.
54
使 退 便便 西
Zhang Yintang entered Tibet in year thirty-two to open the treaty ports. British troops still held Chumbi until the three marts opened and indemnity cleared, so port work was urgent. In year thirty-four Zhang Yintang, as plenipotentiary, and Britain's Walsh drafted fifteen articles of Tibet-India trade regulations under the 1906 revision clause. Key provisions included: (2) demarcation of the Gyantse trade zone. (4) disputes between British subjects and Chinese or Tibetans were to be heard jointly by trade agents and local officials. (6) after withdrawal China would buy frontier rest houses and, once its telegraph reached Gyantse, purchase British lines at a set price. (8) British trade agents might use relay runners for border correspondence at open and future ports. British officials and traders could hire Chinese and Tibetans without restriction. (9) British goods must keep to designated India-Tibet trade routes. (10) British subjects might trade freely in goods or silver, buy or sell without hindrance. Besides Chinese and British seals, Tibetan Gablon Wangchuk Gyalpo also signed. The tripartite seal set a new precedent and shifted Tibet's political landscape again. Anglo-Tibetan business multiplied, and after the Lhasa treaty Qing control over Tibet grew harder still. By late Xuantong the court was pacifying eastern Tibet while the Dalai fled a second time.
55
西西 調 西殿 西西 西 使 便 便 西
Since his 1904 defeat the Dalai had lived at Urga, leaning toward Russia and at odds with the Jebtsundamba. Urga amban De Lin wired for help; Yanzhi at Xining was ordered to escort the Dalai there after winter. The Dalai then wished to stay at an Inner Mongol prince's banner, but Beijing judged the banner too small to feed his entourage. The next year he lodged at Kumbum with Arjia Hutuktu and the two could not abide each other. Governor Sheng Yun of Shaanxi-Gansu memorialized: "The Dalai Lama is miserly and restless in exile—should he be allowed to return to Tibet? The throne replied: "Return to Tibet only after Tibetan affairs are fully settled." Arjia Hutuktu was called to Beijing to reconcile them. He then traveled from Xining to Wutai Shan, came to Beijing, and was received at Renshou Hall with honors matching the Shunzhi precedent. In the tenth month of 1908 he led disciples to offer birthday blessings; the court added a title to mark exceptional favor. The Empress Dowager decreed: "The Dalai Lama, already enfeoffed under the old style as Great Compassionate Self-Master Buddha of the Western Heaven, is now further enfeoffed Sincere and Obedient Praise-Transforming Great Compassionate Self-Master Buddha of the Western Heaven, with an annual stipend of ten thousand taels of silver paid quarterly from the Sichuan treasury. Once enfeoffed, he was ordered home to Tibet with escorts appointed along the route. In Tibet he was to obey imperial law, uphold Qing good faith, guide Tibetans in virtue, and keep the peace. All business was to go through the ambans as before, so the border might stay quiet, clergy and laity united, and the court's aim of upholding the Yellow Faith and pacifying the frontier fulfilled. A national mourning then delayed the investiture ceremony. Citing ill health, the Dalai was told to depart first and receive his title at Kumbum. With court banquets suspended for mourning, no farewell feast was held; a minister escorted him out with the honors accorded on his arrival. At Xining he demanded Arjia's removal and treated it as a condition for going home. He hired a dozen drillmasters passed off as Mongols but actually Russians, and shipped large stores of arms into Tibet.
56
西 調 退
Zhang Yintang had argued that Tibet's strategic position between Britain and Russia required early reform if it was to endure. He urged Han commanders, Beiyang troops in Tibet at key posts, and stronger military backing. Amban Lian Yu likewise reported on Tibet and asked for troops. At the same time Tibetan forces on the Sichuan frontier attacked Sanya. Sanya lay in Batang, adjoining the Dege and Duona tusi and long under Sichuan. Lhasa's three great monasteries sent officials and troops to seize Upper Sanya, rallied the Zhaya and Jiangka tusi, forced the cliff communities to submit, and stirred unrest until the Dartsedo region was alarmed. Meanwhile the Chantui Tibetan official backed the Dege tusi's younger brother, expelled the elder, and raised rebellion. Dartsedo officials sent Mashu native commander Jiang Wenquan to investigate; his party was surrounded. The Sichuan governor reported in; Beijing judged that Tibetan officials had invaded Sichuan soil at Sanya and Dege, and further leniency would embolden them and break the tusi system. The governor was ordered to act with Zhao Erfeng as circumstances required. Zhao Erfeng wired urging force and tied the unrest to the Dalai, asking that the Dalai order the Tibetans back. Beijing told the Dalai reception staff and Zhang Yintang to question him; his answers were evasive. Even if the Dalai would restrain his people, a letter from exile would arrive too late while Sanya was under attack, so Zhao Erfeng was ordered to advance.
57
調 退 調 調 退
In the winter of 1908 Tibetan forces massed near Yanjing and challenged the Sichuan army. Though beaten by Sichuan troops, they held their ground and vowed to stop Zhao Erfeng from entering Tibet. Beijing saw brazen defiance backed by foreign powers; without a firm policy Tibet's hedging between neighbors would endanger the frontier. Officials revived Lian Yu's twenty-four reform articles of 1907–1908—nine bureaus for finance, training, communications, salt and tea, schools, police, agriculture, industry, and foreign affairs—and chose items to trial. Reforms needed troops, yet too large a garrison might unsettle Tibet; three thousand men were proposed. One thousand elite Sichuan soldiers, well paid and armed, would enter Tibet under a strong commander answering to the ambans. Two thousand more would be raised in Tibet with Sichuan NCOs to train and lead them for the long term. Lian Yu and Governor Zhao Erxun approved; in the sixth month of 1909 Prefect Zhong Ying led Sichuan troops to Chamdo via Dege, skirting Jiangka. Tibetans mustered at Enda and Riwoqê to block the road. In the eleventh month Zhong Ying reached Riwoqê; the Tibetans withdrew, and his column slipped through the Thirty-Nine Tribes by a back trail. In the twelfth month they reached Lhari and Jiangda. Tibetan troops ahead burned supplies, raided, and killed Han garrisons on the passes. Zhong Ying attacked and routed them.
58
西沿 西
After his 1908 audience from Xining the Dalai lingered and detoured through Dege; he did not reach Lhasa until that winter. In the first month of 1910, hearing Sichuan troops were near, he fled west by night to India while Zhong Ying fought into Tibet. On Lian Yu's report the court listed the Dalai's crimes, stripped his title, and ordered Lian Yu and Zhao Erfeng to secure the frontier and calm soldiers and civilians; it also ordered a search for a new reincarnation and left Galdan Tripa Lobzang Tenpa in charge of shang affairs; gablons and lesser officials stayed at their posts and Tibet remained quiet. That third month Lian Yu asked for resident commissioners at Qüxü, Hala Usu, Jiangda, Sog, and among the Thirty-Nine Tribes. In the second month of 1911 he abolished the assistant amban post and named Luo Changlin and Qian Xibao left and right counsellors. When Bomi rose, Lian Yu sent Zhong Ying without success; Luo Changlin then joined Zhao Erfeng and suppressed it. That autumn Sichuan troops mutinied, expelled Lian Yu, and made Zhong Ying commander; the Dalai used the turmoil to return to Lhasa. Sheltered by Britain on his flight, he changed course, expelled Zhong Ying, asserted independence, and Sino-British relations grew more entangled.
59
西 西
The first Panchen, Khedrup Je Gelek, was Tsongkhapa's second disciple. Through the fifth incarnation, Lobzang Yeshe, the line still bore the title Panchen Hutuktu. In 1695 Kangxi ordered Zhong Shenbao and others to summon him to Beijing; Ü depa Sangye Gyatso pleaded smallpox. In 1713 the court praised his learning and diligence, enfeoffed him Panchen Erdeni, and granted a golden seal and patent. The sixth, Lobzang Palden Yeshe, was allowed in 1778 to offer blessings for Qianlong's seventieth birthday. Escort and banquet honors matched the Shunzhi precedent for a Dalai audience. In the eighth month of 1780 he celebrated at Rehe, then lived at Beijing's Western Yellow Temple. That year he received a jade seal and patent and died of smallpox. Lifan Yuan Minister Boqing'e was named amban to escort the golden reliquary shrine back to Tibet.
60
The seventh, Lobzang Palden Tenpe Nyima, was moved to Taining in 1788 during the Gurkha war and told to return to Tsang when peace came. , and a golden patent was granted. In 1816, for funding the Sumpa campaign, he received the added title "Pacification and Transformation of the Frontier. In 1851 he received a seventieth-birthday gift like that of his sixtieth. He died the following year at seventy-three.
61
使 西
The eighth, Lobzang Palden Chökyi Drakpa Tenpe Wangchuk, lived to twenty-nine. The ninth, Lobzang Tubten Chökyi Gyaltsen Kelsang Chökyi Nyima, was enthroned at Tashilhunpo in the first month of 1892; his maternal grandfather Tsewang Norbu was made Fuguo Gong. In 1905, when the British entered Tibet, the Panchen was ordered to stay in Tsang and oversee affairs. In the eleventh month he toured India with a British prince; Amban You Tai objected in vain. Returning from India in the twelfth month, he was pardoned for leaving without permission and told to resume his duties. Zhang Yintang reported the Panchen, urged on by Britain, feuded with the Dalai while a Dalai proxy still held real power. He wired the Foreign Ministry to favor the Panchen, restrain the Dalai, and delay his return to Tibet. When the Dalai was to leave Xining, the Panchen promised a personal welcome but never went. Once the Dalai reached Lhasa, the Panchen immediately asked for an audience. Beijing asked Lian Yu whether bringing the Panchen to the capital would suit conditions in Tibet. After the Dalai asserted independence, the Panchen could no longer remain secure in Tibet.
62
西
The Dalai's jurisdiction held more than 3,550 monasteries, over 302,500 lamas, and 121,438 lay households. The Panchen's jurisdiction held 327 monasteries, over 13,700 lamas, and 6,752 lay households. Tibet had five noble titles: three Fuguo Gong—one demoted from beile, one from zhenguo gong, and one hereditary; one first-rank jasak taiji; and one first-rank taiji. Titles granted by grace to the Dalai's and Panchen's kin were not included. All Ü-Tsang officials were chosen jointly by the ambans with the Dalai and Panchen. In front Tibet four third-rank gablons, called the "Four Ministers," ran affairs from the Kashag. Below them were two dzimpa and two shangzo, all fourth rank. Two yercangba, two langzö, two xie'erbang, and two shödepa held fifth rank. Two dabpön, two grand translators, and three chöné held sixth rank. Dzimpa and shangzo managed the shang treasury. Lamas called the treasury office shang. Yercangba handled grain, langzö the streets, xie'erbang justice, shödepa Potala subjects, dabpön the horse farms, and the translators and chöné staffed the Kashag. Military officers were dépön—six fourth-rank posts. Rubpön numbered twelve, fifth rank. Gapön numbered twenty-four, sixth rank. Dingpön numbered 120, seventh rank. The Döndrup Körlo clan usually held these posts.
63
殿
Local administrators were called yingguan. Front Tibet had ten major ying—Nedong, Qonggyê, Gonggar, Lunze, Sangang Chözong, Gongbu Zêgang, Gyantse, Xigaze, Xiegaze, and Naktsang—with fifth-rank yingguan. Rear Tibet had three major ying—Lhatse, Lianying, and Jinlong—with fifth-rank yingguan. Front Tibet had forty-three middle ying, including Lhorong, Jomdo, Dazi, Sangye, Balang, Rinben, Rinzê, Langling, Zongka, Saga, Zuogang, Da'er, Jiangda, Gulang, Woka, Lengzhuk, Qüxü, Tuzong, Sengzong, Zaren, Ruzha, Suozhuangzi, Duo, Jiedeng, Zhigu, Sog, Lhari, Lang, Wolong, Mainpu, Ka'erze, Wenzha Ka, Xialu, Cedui, Da'erma, Nyêmo, Lagaze, Ling, Nab, Linggar, Tsolang, Yangbajing, and Ma'erjiang. Rear Tibet had fourteen middle ying—Angren, Rinzê, Jiezê, Paikozhong, Wengong, Gandian Rebujie, Zhabujia, Lhipu, Deqing Rebujie, Yang, Rongco, Tsongdui, Xie, and Ganba—with sixth-rank yingguan. Front Tibet had twenty-five minor ying—Ya'erdüi, Jindong, Lasui, Sala, Langdang, Pozhang, Zhaxi, Se, Düichong, Wangdian, Jiacuo, Lhakang, Qiongkör, Tsaili, Qulong, Zhacheng, Zhebuling, Zhaxi, Luomei, Jia'erbu, Langru, Liwu, Jiang, Yedang, and Gongbutang; rear Tibet had fifteen minor ying—Pengcuoling, Lunzhu, La'ertang, Da'erjie, Jiachong, Zhezong, Ca'er, Wuyu, Ludong, Kelang, Zhexizi, Bodo, Damuniuchang, Dongga'er, and Zhaxi; their yingguan were all seventh rank. Front Tibet had fourteen frontier garrisons: Jiangka, Duiga'erben, Galawusu, Cuola, Pakeli, Dingjie, Nyalam, Jilong, Guanjue, Buren, Bowo, Gongbu Shuoka, Rongxia'er, and Dabaka'er—all with fifth-rank garrison officers. Each garrison had one or two officers, appointed from among lamas and laymen.
64
西西西西 西西 西西西 西西 西西西西 西 西西西西 西西 西 西 西西 西
Nomadic lamas began in the east at Zhaya Dakhutuktu, adjoining Sichuan's Dajianlu chieftains; westward lay Chakdilo Bakbala Khutuktu, then Shibanduo Lama, then Leiwuqi Khutuktu; north of Shibanduo and Leiwuqi all adjoined chieftains under the Tibetan high commissioner. South of Shibanduo were the Eight-Place Lamas, and farther south the Gongbu Xika Lama. West of Leiwuqi was the Mozhugong Lama, and farther west the Galdan Lama. Northwest of Leiwuqi was the Zandian Lama, interposed among chieftains under the Tibetan high commissioner; west of it was the Liezheng Lama. West of Galdan was the Sala Lama, bordering the Potala on the west. South of Galdan was the Qionke'erjie Lama; westward lay the Zhangzhaka Lama, then the Songreling Lama, then the Narequdi Lama, then southwest the Nedong Lama, bordering the Potala on the north. West of Nedong was the Qiongjie Lama. Northwest of the Potala was the Bulepeng Lama, then farther northwest the Yangbajing Lama; west of it was the Langling Lama, bordering Tashilhunpo on the west. South of Langling was the Renben Lama; southwest was the Jiangzi Lama, then farther southwest the Gangjian Lama. West of Gangjian was the Xiega'er Lama. West of Xiega'er was the Nyalam Lama. West of Langling was the Saga Lama, and farther west the Zaren Lama. Directly under the resident high commissioner were the Eight Banners of Eleuth Dörbet at Dam: four banners at Xitang, two at Tangning, one at Foshan—all north against the Bugan Mountains and south bordering Front Tibet; one banner at Gela, northeast on the Kelai River and west bordering Rear Tibet. Each banner had one assistant commandant.
65
There were thirty-nine chieftain tribes: Qiongbu Galu, Qiongbu Barzha, Qiongbu Naklu, Lenahu'er, Seliqiongzha Ni'erzha'er, Seliqiongzha Canmabuma, Seliqiongzha Malu, Muzhu Te Yangba, Bumitele Dak, Muzhu Te Niyamuzha, Muzhu Te Lisongmaba, Muzhu Te Duomaba, Leyuanhu'er, Yironghu'er Yitama, Zhachuhe'er Suntima'er, Ba'erdashan Muduchuan Musang, Malabuxi Manong, Wozhute Zhiduo, Wozhute Wala, Pengchukehu'er, Pengchuke Pengtama'er, Pengchuke Lazhai, Pensuonakeshu Dageluke, Qintiyagangnakeshu Bilu, Penshaniyagunakeshu Se'erzha, Ba'erdamunak Xibenpen, Nageshalakeshu Lakeshi, Luokenakeshu Gongba, Sanzha, Sannalaba, Pulu, Shang'azhake, Xia'azhake, Bailiezhama'er, Shangganggalu, Xiaganggalu, Shangduo'ershu, Xiaduo'ershu. All paid horse tribute in kind and were overseen by the Barbarian-Affairs zhangjing.
66
西
The greatest mountains included Gangdise—that is, Kunlun—held to be the ancestor of mountains and waters of the eastern hemisphere; Senge Mountain; Langqian Mountain; Majiabu Mountain; Damuchuke Mountain; Langbu Mountain; Basatonglamu Mountain; Nuomohun Wubashi Mountain—these three mountains are the Three Mounds. Among great rivers, the Emu River, whose lower course is the Lancang; the Kelai River, or Black Water, whose lower course is the Lu River; the Bocangbu River; the Yarlung Tsangpo, also called the Great Jinsha River; the Pengchu River; the Gangga River. Among great lakes: Mapabendalai Pool, Langga Pool, Yamuluke Pool, Tenggeri Pool, Ya'erjia Pool. From Duilang east of Jingxi to Samada, local products included the five metals and coal mines throughout. The most noted gold mines were Erzang and Gadake. The most noted salt sources were Leya and Yagan—thirteen in all.
67
西西西西西西
Its boundaries ran west to India's Ladakh; southwest to Luomintang, Zuomulang, and Gurkha; south to Sikkim, Bhutan, and the Nu River of Luyu Ruba; east to Sichuan Batang's Nandun Jingning Mountain; southeast to Yunnan Weixi; northeast to Xining's Banmu, Bayan, and other chieftains; north to Mulu Usu, adjoining Xining's Yushu chieftains; and northwest to Ga'er Zanggucuo and Altannor, adjoining Xinjiang's Khotan and Yarkand.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →