← Back to 史記

蕭相國世家

House of Chancellor Xiao

Chapter 53 of 史記 ✓ Translated
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 53
Next Chapter →
1
Chancellor Xiao He was a native of Feng in the district of Pei. His skill with documents and administrative competence earned him the position of chief clerk in Pei.
2
Back when Gaozu was still a commoner, Xiao He often used his official position to shield him from trouble. After Gaozu became a village headman, Xiao He was always at his side to help. When Gaozu was conscripted for labor service in Xianyang, every other official gave him three cash as a parting gift, but Xiao He alone gave five.
3
The Qin imperial censor assigned to oversee the commandery always commended Xiao He after working alongside him. Xiao He went on to serve as a clerk in the Sishui commandery, where he was rated first among all his peers. The Qin censor wanted to recommend him for a summons to the capital, but Xiao He firmly declined and managed to avoid the transfer.
4
When Gaozu rose in rebellion and became the Lord of Pei, Xiao He served as his deputy and managed all administrative affairs. When the Lord of Pei entered Xianyang, all the other generals raced to the treasuries to divide the gold, silk, and valuables among themselves. Xiao He alone went first to secure the Qin chancellor's and imperial censor's collections of laws, decrees, maps, and registers. When the Lord of Pei was named King of Han, he appointed Xiao He as his chancellor. Xiang Yu and the other lords sacked and burned Xianyang before departing. It was because Xiao He had secured the complete Qin archives that the King of Han came to know precisely where every strategic pass lay, how many households and people lived in each region, which areas were strong and which were weak, and what grievances the people bore. Xiao He recommended Han Xin, and the King of Han appointed him as supreme general. The details of this are recorded in the account of the Marquis of Huaiyin.
5
使 便
When the King of Han led his troops east to subdue the Three Qin kingdoms, Xiao He stayed behind as chancellor to secure Ba and Shu, pacifying the people with proclamations and keeping the army supplied with provisions. In the second year of Han, the King of Han joined the other lords in attacking Chu. Xiao He remained to guard the lands within the passes, attend the crown prince, and govern from Yueyang. He drafted laws and regulations, established ancestral temples, altars to the gods of soil and grain, palaces, and administrative districts. Whenever he submitted a memorial and it was approved, he was permitted to proceed. When there was no time to wait for approval, he acted as he saw fit and reported the matter upon the emperor's return. He managed the affairs within the passes by tallying households and organizing grain shipments to supply the army. Each time the King of Han lost his forces and had to flee, Xiao He raised fresh troops from within the passes and promptly filled the gaps. For this reason, the emperor entrusted Xiao He with sole authority over all affairs within the passes.
6
使使 使使
In the third year of Han, while the King of Han faced Xiang Yu between Jing and Suo, the emperor repeatedly sent messengers to offer his regards to the chancellor. A man named Bao Sheng told the chancellor, 'The king endures hardship in the open field yet keeps sending messengers to inquire after you. This means he harbors suspicions about your loyalty. For your own sake, you should send every one of your sons, grandsons, and brothers who can bear arms to join the army at the front. The emperor will certainly trust you all the more for it.' Xiao He followed this advice, and the King of Han was greatly pleased.
7
In the fifth year of Han, after Xiang Yu had been slain and the realm pacified, the court debated each man's merits and awarded fiefs accordingly. The ministers quarreled over who deserved the most credit, and for more than a year no verdict was reached. Gaozu judged Xiao He's contributions the greatest and enfeoffed him as Marquis of Zan, granting him the largest fief of all. The other ministers with war records protested, 'We have donned armor and taken up arms, fighting over a hundred battles at most and several dozen at least, storming cities and seizing territory, each with his own record of distinction. Yet Xiao He has never once broken a sweat on horseback. All he did was wield a writing brush and talk. He never fought, and yet he is ranked above every one of us. How can this be?' The Emperor said, 'Do you gentlemen know anything about hunting?' They replied, 'We do.' 'And do you know what a hunting dog does?' They replied, 'We do.' The Emperor said, 'In a hunt, the ones who chase down and kill the game are the dogs, but the one who picks up the trail and directs the dogs to the quarry is the hunter. Now, you gentlemen can only run down the game. Your merit is that of the dogs. But Xiao He picked up the trail and pointed the way. His merit is that of the hunter.' 'Furthermore, each of you followed me with at most two or three of your kin. Xiao He brought his entire clan of several dozen people to follow me. That kind of merit must not be forgotten.' None of the ministers dared say another word.
8
殿
After all the marquises had received their fiefs, the question of precedence arose. They all declared, 'The Marquis of Pingyang, Cao Can, bore seventy wounds on his body, storming cities and seizing territory. His merit is the greatest; he should rank first.' The emperor had already overruled the ministers once by granting Xiao He the largest fief. On the matter of precedence, he had no ready argument to counter them, yet in his heart he wanted Xiao He to be first. E Jun, who held the rank of Marquis within the Passes, stepped forward and said, 'The ministers are all wrong. Cao Can may have the merit of campaigning in the field and seizing territory, but these are achievements of the moment. The emperor confronted Chu for five years, repeatedly losing his army and his men, and fled for his life on more than one occasion. Yet Xiao He kept dispatching troops from within the passes to fill the gaps, without any edict or summons from the emperor, and on several occasions sent tens of thousands of reinforcements to relieve the emperor's desperate shortages. When Han and Chu were locked in a standoff at Xingyang for years and the army had no grain in sight, it was Xiao He who shipped provisions from within the passes, ensuring the troops never went hungry. Though Your Majesty lost the lands east of the mountains time and again, Xiao He always kept the heartland within the passes intact, waiting for Your Majesty's return. This is a merit that will endure for ten thousand generations. Even if we had lost a hundred men like Cao Can, what real harm would it have done to Han? The survival of Han did not depend on having every last one of them. How can you place the glory of a single day above the merit of ten thousand generations! Xiao He should rank first, and Cao Can second.' Gaozu said, 'Well spoken.' He thereupon decreed Xiao He first in rank and granted him the privilege of wearing his sword and shoes into the audience hall and of walking at his own pace when entering court.
9
The emperor said, 'I have heard it said that the one who recommends a worthy man deserves the highest reward. Xiao He's merit is great, but it took E Jun's words to make it shine even more clearly.' He therefore took the fief that E Jun had held as a Marquis within the Passes and elevated him to the rank of Marquis of Anping. That same day, the emperor enfeoffed more than ten members of Xiao He's family, including his father, sons, and brothers, granting each of them a fief. He also increased Xiao He's fief by two thousand households, in memory of the time long ago when the emperor was conscripted to Xianyang and Xiao He alone had given him two extra cash beyond what the others offered.
10
使使
In the eleventh year of Han, Chen Xi rose in rebellion. Gaozu personally led the campaign and marched to Handan. Before the campaign was over, the Marquis of Huaiyin plotted rebellion within the passes. Empress Lu used a stratagem devised by Xiao He to have the marquis executed. The details are recorded in the account of the Marquis of Huaiyin. When the emperor learned of the Marquis of Huaiyin's execution, he sent a messenger to promote Chancellor He to the title of Prime Minister, increased his fief by five thousand households, and assigned five hundred soldiers under a commandant as the Prime Minister's personal guard. Everyone offered congratulations, but Shao Ping alone expressed concern. Shao Ping had been the Marquis of Dongling under the Qin dynasty. After Qin fell, he became a poor commoner and grew melons east of Chang'an. The melons were so fine that people called them 'Dongling melons' after his former title. Shao Ping said to the Prime Minister, 'This is where your troubles begin. The emperor is enduring hardship in the field while you guard the capital. You have faced no arrows or stones, yet he increases your fief and stations guards around you. The Marquis of Huaiyin just rebelled from within the capital—the emperor now suspects your loyalty. The guards posted around you are not a mark of favor; they are there to watch you. I urge you to decline the new fief and instead donate your entire personal fortune to support the army. Only then will the emperor's mind be set at ease.' The Prime Minister followed this advice, and Gaozu was overjoyed.
11
使使
In the autumn of the twelfth year of Han, Ying Bu rose in rebellion. The emperor personally led the campaign against him, and kept sending messengers back to ask what the Prime Minister was doing. Since the emperor was away at war, the Prime Minister comforted and rallied the people and poured all available resources into supporting the army, just as he had done during the campaign against Chen Xi. A retainer warned the Prime Minister, 'It will not be long before your entire clan is wiped out. You hold the office of Prime Minister and rank first in merit. What more could possibly be added? Ever since you first entered the lands within the passes, you have held the hearts of the people. For more than ten years they have all rallied to you, and you have worked tirelessly to win their goodwill. The reason the emperor keeps asking about you is that he fears you might stir up the lands within the passes. Why not buy up large tracts of land on the cheap, even taking loans at low interest, and so tarnish your own reputation? Then the emperor's mind will be put at ease.' The Prime Minister took this advice, and the emperor was greatly pleased.
12
便 西 使使
When the emperor returned from defeating Ying Bu, people along the road blocked his procession to present petitions, accusing the Prime Minister of using his power to buy up their fields and houses at low prices, spending tens of millions in all. When the emperor reached the capital, the Prime Minister came to present himself at court. The emperor laughed and said, 'So the Prime Minister has been looking after the people's interests!' He handed all the people's petitions to the Prime Minister and said, 'You can apologize to them yourself.' The Prime Minister then petitioned on behalf of the people, saying, 'The farmland around Chang'an is scarce. There is much vacant land lying unused in the Shanglin Park. I ask that the people be allowed to enter and cultivate it, leaving the stubble in the fields as fodder for the wild animals rather than collecting it.' The emperor flew into a rage, saying, 'The Prime Minister has taken bribes from the merchants, and now he dares petition for my royal park!' He had the Prime Minister handed over to the Commandant of Justice, who clapped him in fetters and chains. Several days later, the Commandant of the Palace Guard, Wang, was in attendance and ventured to ask, 'What terrible crime has the Prime Minister committed that Your Majesty treats him so harshly?' The emperor replied, 'I have heard that when Li Si served as chancellor under the First Emperor of Qin, he credited every good deed to his ruler and took every failing upon himself. Now the Prime Minister has accepted gold from petty merchants and then petitioned for my park on behalf of the people, all to ingratiate himself with them. That is why I have had him arrested and put under investigation.' The Commandant Wang said, 'If a minister discovers something that would benefit the people and petitions for it, that is precisely what a prime minister ought to do. How can Your Majesty suspect the Prime Minister of taking merchants' bribes? Moreover, Your Majesty fought Chu for years, and when Chen Xi and Ying Bu rose in rebellion, Your Majesty personally led the armies against them. During all that time, the Prime Minister guarded the lands within the passes. Had he so much as stamped his foot, everything west of the passes would have ceased to be yours. The Prime Minister did not seize his advantage then. Would he now stoop to profit from the gold of petty merchants? Besides, Qin lost the empire precisely because it refused to hear criticism. Li Si's practice of deflecting blame was hardly worth emulating. Your Majesty's suspicions of the Prime Minister are beneath you.' Gaozu was not pleased to hear this. Yet that very day, he sent an envoy bearing the imperial tally to pardon and release the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister, old and ever deferential by nature, came before the emperor barefoot to offer his apology. Gaozu said, 'Enough, Prime Minister! You petitioned for the park on behalf of the people, and I refused. That only makes me a tyrant like Jie or Zhou, while you are a worthy minister. I had you arrested deliberately, so that the people would hear of my faults.'
13
Xiao He and Cao Can had never been on good terms. When Xiao He fell gravely ill, Emperor Hui came personally to visit him at his sickbed and asked, 'When you are gone, who could take your place?' Xiao He replied, 'No one knows his ministers better than their lord.' Emperor Hui asked, 'What do you think of Cao Can?' Xiao He bowed his head to the ground and said, 'Your Majesty has found the man! I can die without regret.'
14
Whenever Xiao He bought land or a house, he always chose an out-of-the-way location, and he never bothered to repair the walls or roof of his home. He said, 'If my descendants prove worthy, they will follow the example of my frugality. If they prove unworthy, at least the property will be too mean for powerful families to bother seizing.'
15
In the second year of Emperor Hui's reign, Prime Minister Xiao He passed away. He was given the posthumous title of Marquis Wenzhong.
16
His descendants lost the title through offenses over four successive generations and the line was extinguished, yet each time the Son of Heaven sought out Xiao He's heirs and restored them to the marquisate of Zan. No other minister of merit was ever treated with such honor.
17
The Grand Historian remarks: Chancellor Xiao He served as a petty clerk under the Qin, an unremarkable man with no record of extraordinary accomplishment. Yet when the Han dynasty arose, he rode in the reflected glory of the new order, faithfully guarding the keys of state. He seized upon the people's hatred of the harsh Qin laws, followed the current of the times, and helped bring about a fresh beginning. The Marquis of Huaiyin, Ying Bu, and the others all met their end by execution, but Xiao He's merit shone ever more brightly. He stood first among all the ministers, and his fame has endured through the ages, rivaling in splendor that of Hong Yao, San Yisheng, and the other great ministers of antiquity.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →