← Back to 史記

春申君列傳

Biography of Lord Chunshen

Chapter 78 of 史記 ✓ Translated
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 78
Next Chapter →
1
使 使 使 使
Lord Chunshen was a man of Chu, named Xie, of the Huang clan. He traveled widely in his studies, became broadly learned, and served King Qingxiang of Chu. King Qingxiang valued Xie's eloquence and sent him as envoy to Qin. King Zhao of Qin sent Bai Qi to attack Han and Wei, defeating them at Huayang and capturing Wei's general Mang Mao. Han and Wei submitted and served Qin. King Zhao of Qin was about to order Bai Qi to join forces with Han and Wei to attack Chu, but before the plan could be executed, Chu's envoy Huang Xie arrived in Qin and learned of Qin's strategy. At this time, Qin had already sent Bai Qi to attack Chu, taking the commanderies of Wu and Qianzhong, capturing Ying and Yiling, and advancing east to Jingling. King Qingxiang of Chu moved his capital east to Chen county. Huang Xie witnessed King Huai of Chu being lured by Qin into attending their court, only to be deceived, detained, and die in Qin. King Qingxiang was his son. Qin held him in contempt and feared that with a single campaign they could destroy Chu entirely. Xie then submitted a memorial advising King Zhao of Qin:
2
使
In all under heaven, none are stronger than Qin and Chu. Now I hear that Your Majesty wishes to attack Chu—this would be like two tigers fighting each other. When two tigers fight each other, the lame dog benefits from their exhaustion. Better to befriend Chu. Allow me to explain my reasoning: I have heard that when things reach their extreme, they reverse course, as winter follows summer. When power reaches its peak, danger follows—like stacking chess pieces high. Now Your Majesty's territory spans two-thirds of the world—this has not occurred since the dawn of civilization; no kingdom of ten thousand chariots has ever achieved such extent. The Former Kings Wen and Zhuang refrained for three generations from rashly engaging in battle with Qi, to avoid severing the strategy of alliances through marriage. Now Your Majesty has Sheng Qiao overseeing affairs in Han, and Sheng Qiao has brought his territory into Qin. This means Your Majesty has gained a hundred li of land without deploying troops or displaying military might. Your Majesty can truly be called capable. Your Majesty again raised troops and attacked Wei, blocking the gates of Daliang, taking Henei, capturing Yan, Suantao, Xu, Tao, and entering Xing. Wei's troops scattered like clouds but dared not come to the rescue. Your Majesty's achievements are also numerous. Your Majesty rested the troops for two years, then resumed campaigning. Again annexing Pu, Yan, Shou, and Yuan, threatening Ren and Pingqiu. Huang and Jiyang were besieged, and the House of Wei submitted. Your Majesty again cut off the north of Puyang, blocked Qin's vital routes to Qi, severed the spine connecting Chu and Zhao. The world united five times and gathered six times but dared not rescue. Your Majesty's prestige is also unmatched.
3
使 便
If Your Majesty can maintain these achievements and prestige, set aside thoughts of conquest and expand the territory of benevolence and righteousness, avoiding future disasters, then the Three Kings would not be worth four, the Five Hegemons would not be worth six. If Your Majesty relies on a multitude of common people and the strength of weapons and armor, taking advantage of having broken Wei's power, desiring to force the lords of the world to submit, I fear there will be future disasters. The Book of Songs says: 'Nothing lacks a beginning, few achieve the end.' The Book of Changes says: 'The fox fords the water, wets its tail.' This speaks of how beginnings are easy but endings are difficult. How do I know this is so? In former times, the Zhi clan saw the advantage of attacking Zhao but did not foresee the disaster at Yuxi. Wu saw the convenience of attacking Qi but did not foresee the defeat at Gantui. These two states were not without great achievements, but they were blinded by advantages in front and easily suffered disasters afterward. Wu trusted Yue and followed them to attack Qi. Having defeated Qi at Ailing, on their return Yue's King Goujian captured them at the ford of Sanchu. The Zhi clan trusted Han and Wei and followed them to attack Zhao, besieging Jinyang city. Victory was near, but Han and Wei rebelled against them, killing Zhi Boyao beneath the Zao Terrace. Now Your Majesty envies that Chu has not been destroyed, but forgets that destroying Chu strengthened Han and Wei. I advise Your Majesty to consider this and not proceed.
4
滿
The Book of Songs says: 'Great martial virtue dwells afar and does not cross.' From this we can see that Chu is an ally. Neighboring states are enemies. The Book of Songs says: 'The rabbits leap about, and the hound catches them. Others have their schemes, I fathom them.' Now Your Majesty halfway believes in Han and Wei's loyalty to Your Majesty—this is exactly like Wu trusting Yue. I have heard that enemies should not be lent aid, opportunities should not be lost. I fear Han and Wei use humble words to remove their troubles but actually wish to deceive the great kingdom. Why is this? Your Majesty has no deep favors toward Han and Wei for generations, but has accumulated resentments for generations. Fathers and sons, brothers of Han and Wei who have died at Qin's hands now reach ten generations. Their home states are ruined, their altars of soil and grain destroyed, ancestral temples demolished. Bellies ripped open, intestines severed, necks broken, jaws crushed, heads separated from bodies, corpses exposed in the wilds, skulls stiff and fallen, visible across the borders. Fathers and sons, old and young bound at the neck with hands tied, becoming groups of captives meeting on the roads. Ghosts and spirits grieve in isolation, with no blood sacrifices. The people cannot live, clans are scattered, those who have fled and become servants and concubines fill the seas within the four directions. Therefore Han and Wei not being destroyed is Qin's state concern. Now you, O king aids them in attacking Chu—is this not a mistake?
5
谿
Moreover, when you, O king attacks Chu, where will the troops emerge? Will you, O king borrow the road through enemy Han and Wei? On the day the troops emerge you, O king will worry they do not return—this is you, O king providing troops to enemy Han and Wei. If you, O king do not borrow the road through enemy Han and Wei, you must attack along the right bank of the Sui River. The right bank of the Sui River—all broad rivers and great waters, mountain forests and valleys, land where crops cannot be grown. Even if you, O king takes it, it is not gaining territory. This gives you, O king the name of destroying Chu but no reality of gaining land.
6
使
Moreover, on the day you, O king attack Chu, the four states will certainly all raise troops to respond to you, O king. Qin and the state of Chu troops will be locked in combat without separating. Wei will emerge to attack Liu, Fangyu, Zhi, Huling, Dang, Xiao, Xiang—thus exhausting the old territory of Song. Qi will attack Chu southward, taking the Si River region. These are all broad plains with four-way access, fertile lands, yet left for Qin to attack alone. Your Majesty destroys Chu to fatten Han and Wei in the central states and strengthen Qi. When Han and Wei are strong, they will be able to contend with Qin. Qi to the south has the Si River as border, east faces the sea, north relies on the Yellow River, without worries from behind. No state in the world is stronger than Qi and Wei. If Qi and Wei gain land and preserve advantages while carefully serving as subordinate officials, within a year, even if they cannot become emperor themselves, they will have more than enough to prevent Your Majesty from becoming emperor.
7
With Your Majesty's vast territory, numerous people, strong weapons and armor, in one campaign creating resentment with Chu, delaying until Han and Wei return the imperial title to Qi—this is Your Majesty losing the plan. I advise Your Majesty, nothing is better than befriending Chu. If Qin and Chu unite as one to face Han, Han will certainly fold its hands. Your Majesty can deploy the danger of Dongshan, gird with the advantage of the Qu River—Han will certainly become an inner pass marquis. In this way Your Majesty stations 100,000 troops in Zheng, the Liang clan will lose heart. Xu and Yanling will be besieged, and Shangcai and Shaoling will have no commerce. In this way Wei also becomes an inner pass marquis. Your Majesty befriends Chu, and the two marquisates of ten thousand chariots within the pass will pour their land toward Qi. Qin's right flank can be taken with folded hands. Your Majesty's territory will span the two seas, commanding the world's strategic points—this makes Yan and Zhao unable to oppose Qi and Chu, Qi and Chu unable to oppose Yan and Zhao. Then threatening Yan and Zhao, directly shaking Qi and Chu—these four states will submit without being wounded.
8
使
King Zhao said: 'Excellent.' So he halted Bai Qi and made apologies to Han and Wei. He dispatched envoys bearing gifts to Chu, forging a treaty as allied states.
9
使 使 使
Huang Xie accepted the treaty and returned to Chu. Chu sent Xie along with Crown Prince Wan as hostages to Qin. Qin held them for several years. King Qingxiang of Chu fell gravely ill, preventing the crown prince's return. The Chu crown prince was friendly with Qin's prime minister Lord Ying. Thus Huang Xie counseled Lord Ying: 'Prime Minister, do you genuinely befriend the Chu crown prince?' Lord Ying said: 'Yes.' Xie said: 'The King of Chu now fears he will not survive his illness. Qin should send the crown prince back. If the crown prince ascends the throne, he will certainly honor Qin greatly and show the prime minister infinite gratitude. This gains us an ally and secures a state of ten thousand chariots. If not returned, he becomes just another commoner in Xianyang. Chu will install a different crown prince who will certainly not serve Qin. Losing an allied state and severing relations with ten thousand chariots is poor strategy. I hope the prime minister will ponder this carefully.' Lord Ying brought this to the attention of the King of Qin. The King of Qin said: 'Send the Chu crown prince's tutor first to inquire about the King of Chu's illness, then we can decide what to do.' Huang Xie devised a plan for the Chu crown prince: 'Qin's keeping of the crown prince is meant to gain leverage. Now the crown prince lacks the power to benefit Qin. I worry about this terribly. Yang Wenjun and Zi Chun are at court. If the king should die and the crown prince is absent, these two will certainly be established as heirs. The crown prince will lose his right to serve the ancestral temples. Better to escape Qin, leaving with the envoys. I will remain and accept death on your behalf.' The Chu crown prince disguised himself as a Chu envoy's chariot driver and slipped through the pass. Huang Xie stayed at the residence, continually pleading illness. When he judged the crown prince was safely distant and Qin could not catch him, Xie went to King Zhao of Qin and said: 'The Chu crown prince has gone home. He is far away by now. I deserve to die. I beg you to execute me.' King Zhao flew into a rage and wanted to let him kill himself. Lord Ying said: 'Xie serves as a minister, staking his life to follow his lord. If the crown prince ascends the throne, he will certainly appoint Xie. Better to release him guilt-free and win Chu's friendship.' Qin therefore released Huang Xie.
10
便
Three months later Xie arrived in Chu. King Qingxiang of Chu died, Crown Prince Wan ascended the throne as King Kaolie. In the first year of King Kaolie, Huang Xie was appointed prime minister, enfeoffed as Lord Chunshen, and granted twelve counties north of the Huai River. Fifteen years later, Huang Xie spoke to the King of the state of Chu: 'The northern Huai region borders Qi, affairs there are urgent. Please make it a commandery for convenience.' He therefore annexed and presented the twelve counties north of the Huai. He requested enfeoffment in the region east of the Jiang. King Kaolie agreed. Lord Chunshen built a city on the ancient ruins of Wu, establishing it as his personal capital.
11
Lord Chunshen became prime minister of Chu. At this time, Qi had Lord Mengchang, Zhao had Lord Pingyuan, Wei had Lord Xinling—all competing to win over scholars, recruiting retainers to outdo one another, strengthening their states and wielding influence.
12
使
Lord the state of Chunshen served as the state of Chu's prime minister for four years when Qin broke Zhao's Changping army of over 400,000. In the fifth year, they laid siege to Handan. Handan sent urgent pleas to Chu. Chu dispatched Lord Chunshen with troops to relieve them. The Qin forces withdrew as well. Lord Chunshen returned home. A retainer from Guanjin named Zhu Ying told Lord the state of Chunshen: 'People all consider the state of Chu strong and Your Lordship makes it weak, but in Zhu Ying's view it is not so. At this time, Chu regained its strength.
13
使 使 使使
Lord Pingyuan of Zhao sent an envoy to Lord Chunshen. Lord Chunshen lodged him in the finest guest quarters. The Zhao envoy wished to impress the state of Chu, making a cap of green jade, decorating sword hilts and scabbards with pearls and jade, requesting to present them to Lord the state of Chunshen's retainers. Lord Chunshen maintained over three thousand retainers. His most honored guests all wore pearl-embroidered shoes to greet the Zhao envoy. The envoy was deeply embarrassed.
14
Lord the state of Chunshen served as prime minister for fourteen years when Qin established King Zhuangxiang, appointing Lü Buwei as prime minister, enfeoffing him as Lord Wenxin. They conquered Eastern Zhou.
15
西
Lord the state of Chunshen served as prime minister for twenty-two years. The feudal lords, troubled by Qin's endless attacks, united in alliance to attack Qin westward. The King of the state of Chu served as alliance leader, with Lord the state of Chunshen managing affairs. They advanced to Hangu Pass. Qin launched an attack. The allied forces all retreated in rout. King Kaolie of Chu held Lord Chunshen responsible. Lord Chunshen grew increasingly estranged as a result.
16
便
A retainer from Guanjin named Zhu Ying told Lord the state of Chunshen: 'People all consider the state of Chu strong and Your Lordship makes it weak, but in Zhu Ying's view it is not so.' In the previous king's time, being friendly with Qin for twenty years without attacking the state of Chu—why? For Qin to cross the Meng Pass and attack Chu would be difficult. Borrowing roads through the two Zhous, betraying Han and Wei to attack Chu, is unthinkable. Now the situation has changed. Wei faces imminent destruction and cannot hold onto Xu and Yanling. They will permit Wei to cede these cities to Qin. Qin troops are only 160 li from Chen. What I observe is that Qin and the state of Chu will battle daily.' Chu therefore abandoned Chen and relocated to Shouchun. Qin relocated Wei's capital to Yewang and established the Eastern Commandery. Lord Chunshen therefore took up his fief in Wu, while continuing to handle prime ministerial duties.
17
使使使
King Kaolie of the state of Chu had no sons. Lord the state of Chunshen worried about this and sought women suitable for bearing children to present to him—very many, but ultimately no sons. A Zhao native named Li Yuan brought his younger sister, intending to present her to the King of Chu. Learning she was barren, he feared her favor would not last. Li Yuan sought a position as retainer to Lord Chunshen. After some time, he requested leave to return home, deliberately arriving late. When he returned to audience, Lord the state of Chunshen asked about the situation. He replied: 'The King of Qi sent an envoy to seek my younger sister. I drank with the envoy, thus missed the deadline.' Lord the state of Chunshen said: 'Have you betrothed her?' He replied: 'Not yet.' Lord the state of Chunshen said: 'Can I see her?' 'Yes.' Thus Li Yuan presented his younger sister, who won Lord Chunshen's favor. When he learned she was with child, Li Yuan conspired with his younger sister. Li Yuan's younger sister took advantage of an intimate moment to advise Lord the state of Chunshen: 'The King of the state of Chu values and favors Your Lordship more than brothers. Now Your Lordship has been prime minister of the state of Chu for over twenty years, yet the king has no sons. After a hundred years he will establish brothers, then when the state of Chu establishes new rulers, each will value their old associates. How can Your Lordship remain favored forever? This is no idle threat. Your Lordship has held high position and wielded power for years, repeatedly offending the king's brothers. If they should ascend the throne, calamity will befall you. How then can you safeguard your prime minister's seal and your fief in Jiangdong? Now I know I carry a child, though no one else is aware. I have been favored by Your Lordship not long. If you truly use Your Lordship's influence to present me to the King of the state of Chu, the king will certainly favor me. If heaven grants me a son, then Your Lordship's son becomes king. The whole the state of Chu state can be obtained—who compares to facing uncertain crimes?' Lord the state of Chunshen greatly agreed. He sent Li Yuan's younger sister out, carefully housed her and spoke of her to the King of the state of Chu. The King of the state of Chu summoned her and favored her. She bore a son, established as crown prince, making Li Yuan's younger sister queen. The King of Chu favored Li Yuan, who came to wield considerable influence.
18
Once Li Yuan had brought in his younger sister and established her as queen with her son as crown prince, he feared Lord Chunshen would reveal the secret and grow even more insolent. Secretly, he cultivated assassins, intending to kill Lord Chunshen and silence him forever. Many in the kingdom knew of his plans.
19
Lord Chunshen had served as prime minister for twenty-five years when King Kaolie of Chu fell gravely ill. Zhu Ying told Lord the state of Chunshen: 'The world has blessings that come without expectation, and disasters that come without expectation. Your Lordship now lives in an age without prospects, serving a ruler without prospects. How can you be without a companion who shares your lack of prospects?' Lord the state of Chunshen said: 'What are blessings without expectation?' 'Your Lordship has been prime minister of the state of Chu for over twenty years. Though nominally prime minister, you are truly the king of the state of Chu. The King of Chu now lies ill and will die any day. Your Lordship aids the young ruler, seizes control of the government, and ascends the throne like Yi Yin and the Duke of Zhou. When the king comes of age, you return power to him. If not, you proclaim yourself ruler facing south and take possession of the kingdom of Chu. This is what they call unexpected fortune.' Lord Chunshen said: 'What is unexpected calamity?' 'Li Yuan cares nothing for governing the state, but he is Your Lordship's mortal enemy. Instead of raising armies, he has long been cultivating assassins. When the King of Chu dies, Li Yuan will surely enter first, seize control, and kill Your Lordship to silence the secret. This is what they call unexpected disaster.' Lord Chunshen said: 'What is a companion without prospects?' He replied: 'Appoint me as your aide-de-camp. When the King of Chu dies, Li Yuan will surely enter first. I will kill Li Yuan for you. This is what they call a companion without prospects.' Lord Chunshen said: 'I will assign you the post. Li Yuan is a weakling. I treat him kindly. How could matters reach such a pass!' Zhu Ying realized his advice would be ignored and feared the danger would extend to him, so he fled.
20
使
Seventeen days later, King Kaolie of Chu died. As predicted, Li Yuan entered first, concealing assassins within the Thorn Gate. Lord Chunshen entered the Thorn Gate. Li Yuan's assassins ambushed him from both sides, beheaded him, and flung his head outside the Thorn Gate. They then commanded officials to utterly destroy Lord Chunshen's entire household. Li Yuan's younger sister, who had conceived by Lord Chunshen before being presented to the king, bore the son who was enthroned as King You of Chu.
21
In this year, Qin Shihuang had reigned for nine years. Liao Ai also stirred up rebellion in Qin, was exposed, his three clans executed to the last member, and Lü Buwei was dismissed from office.
22
The Grand Historian says: I journeyed to Chu and surveyed Lord Chunshen's ancient city—what splendid palaces! At first, Lord Chunshen's persuasion of King Zhao of Qin, and staking his life to send the Chu crown prince home—what clarity of wisdom! Later he was controlled by Li Yuan—what utter confusion! As the proverb says: 'When you should cut, don't cut, and chaos comes back to haunt you.' Does this refer to Lord Chunshen ignoring Zhu Ying's counsel?
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →