← Back to 宋史

卷一百二十二 志第七十五 禮二十五

Volume 122 Treatises 75: Rites 25

Chapter 122 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 122
Next Chapter →
1
Imperial mausoleums, posthumous titles and enshrinement, regulations for mourning dress, burial ceremonies, and the mourning codes for officials and commoners all belong to the category of funeral rites. Visits to the imperial tombs on death anniversaries were handled under Han practice much like regular auspicious sacrifices. Under the Song system, on those days slaughter was banned, plain vegetarian fare was served, music ceased and mourning cries were observed, and participants wore unadorned dress; these observances were accordingly classified with related funeral practices.
2
When Taizu established the dynasty, he named the tombs of the Exalted, Shun, Yi, and Xuan Ancestors respectively Qin, Kang, Ding, and An Mausoleums.
3
西 使使使簿使使 使
The An Mausoleum originally stood in the southeast corner of the capital; in early Qiande it was moved to Dengfeng Village in Zi Township, forty li southwest of Gong County in Henan Prefecture. Fan Zhi, Minister over the Masses, was appointed commissioner to relocate the An Mausoleum; Dou Yi served as ritual commissioner, Liu Wensou as guard-of-honor commissioner, Xue Juzheng as insignia commissioner, and the future Taizong, then prefect of Kaifeng, as commissioner for bridges, roads, and relay supplies. Fan Zhi was soon dismissed as chief minister, and on the following day Taizong was put in charge of all five commissioner posts to oversee construction of the new tomb. The underground imperial chamber was fifty-seven feet deep and thirty-nine feet high; the tomb platform rose in three square tiers, each face of the lowest tier measuring ninety feet. It was ninety-five paces from the southern spirit gate to the breast terrace, and another ninety-five paces from the breast terrace to the magpie terrace. The breast terrace stood twenty-five feet high; the magpie terrace was four feet taller still. The spirit wall stood nine feet five inches high and ran four hundred sixty paces around the compound, with spirit gates and corner towers placed at the appropriate points.
4
簿 輿輿輿輿輿輿
The responsible offices reported: "For relocating the mausoleum, the Xuan Ancestor should receive the mourning register, and each civil official in the procession should compose two dirges. The auspicious funeral procession should employ the full grand imperial guard of honor. The mourning train was to include the great carrying litter, dragon hearse, goose-down standard, soul carriage, incense carriage, inscribed mourning banner, carriage for the mourning register and posthumous seal, exorcist figure, road-purchasing carriage, white-canopied crossbows, plain trust pennants, money-mountain litter, yellow and white paper canopies, warm and summer canopies, trays of a thousand delicacies, garment litter, whisk standard, spirit-goods litter, lacquered catalpa inner coffin, barbarian coverlet, ceremonial outer coffin, plain feather fans, wrapped sacrificial offerings, storehouse vessels, five-grain litter, porcelain jars, and evil-averting carriage. Inside the burial chamber an iron canopy covered the catalpa coffin, which rested on palm-fiber bedding; iron basins and iron mountains held burning lacquer lamps. The Xuan Ancestor was arrayed in full imperial robes and crown; the Zhaoxian Empress in flowered hairpins and pheasant-embroidered robes, with jade gifts added. The twelve spirit figures, tomb and field guardians, Ancestor Bright, Ancestor Thought, Earth Axis, and the water clock left at the tomb, among other items, were all arranged according to prescribed ritual."
5
''' '' ' 殿
The offices added: "The Ceremonies and Rites commentary on 'reburial in finest mourning' explains that when a subject serves a lord, a son a father, or a wife a husband, they must wear finest mourning because they have seen the remains in the coffin and cannot go unclad; finest mourning is worn for three months and then removed. The Essentials of the Five Rites also notes that reburial omits the ancestor-offering, since that rite is performed before the bier carriage at the start of a funeral procession, whereas a reburial requires only an announcement of relocation. We therefore ask that the emperor wear finest mourning, and that imperial relatives and civil and military officials escorting the spirit carriage do the same, removing it once the burial is finished. No ancestor-offering should be held; only a single yu sacrifice should be performed at the tomb. The Xuan Ancestor's posthumous register and seal, previously kept in the ancestral temple, should be moved into the mausoleum. Reburial rites follow the same procedures as an initial burial; offering tables and mats should be new, and any damaged burial goods should be replaced. All garments and objects placed in the coffin should be renewed. The jade gifts, stabilizing scepter, sword and pendant set, tasseled crown, and jade seals for the burial chamber should all be made of min and medicinal jade, with blue brocade cords. At the An Mausoleum the jade scepter, sword and pendant, and jade seals had all been of Khotan jade. The Xiaoming and Xiaohui tombs had used min and medicinal jade instead. Workers opened the old An Mausoleum and installed the catalpa coffins of the Xuan Ancestor and the Zhaoxian and Xiaohui empresses in the draped mourning hall. When the spirit carriage departed, magistrates and their deputies at every prefecture, county, and market town along the route came out in plain dress to receive and bid farewell to the procession, all in tears. From the departure until the imperial chamber was sealed, court sessions were suspended and music was banned throughout the capital."
6
The Shun and Yi Ancestors had originally been buried in Youzhou; Zhenzong was the first to order construction of their two tombs, and they were interred in Henan County with first-rank funeral honors. The scale was reduced by one-fifth compared with the An Mausoleum and stone work by one-third; shortly afterward the upper Ding Mausoleum was renamed the Jing Mausoleum.
7
使 殿 退
On the twentieth day of the tenth month in the ninth year of Kaibao, Taizu died. His final edict read: "Count days as months: the emperor shall resume governance after three days, observe lesser mourning on the thirteenth day, and greater mourning on the twenty-seventh. Circuit commissioners, defense commissioners, training commissioners, prefects, and acting prefects must not leave their posts without authorization to come to court. All prefectures, garrisons, and local offices shall observe three days of mourning before laying aside mourning dress." The ministers formed ranks in the palace courtyard. After the chief ministers proclaimed the edict and concluded the mourning announcement, Taizong took the throne and, wailing, received the assembled officials. The ministers offered congratulations, then returned to pay condolences, wept their fill, and withdrew.
8
殿 使
The ritual officers reported: "Ministers should wear hemp mourning headcloths with slanting bands and four corners, straight-collared hemp mourning shirts, and waist mourning cords. Commissioned women should wear hemp mourning kerchiefs, skirts, and shawls. Imperial brothers, imperial sons, and civil and military officials of the second rank and above should additionally wear hemp mourning caps, slanting bands, hats, head cords, wide sleeves, skirts, trousers, and carry bamboo staffs. Scholars and commoners wore white hemp; women wore plain unpatterned mourning dress. All armies at their encampments observed three days of mourning cries." After repeated requests from the ministers that he resume governance, he first held court at the Changchun Hall. The ministers took their places in mourning dress. The emperor set aside his staff and mourning cords, wore a slanting headband and hanging cap, rolled up the curtain, and began to conduct state business. At lesser mourning he changed to a four-cornered hemp cap, straight-collared hemp shirt, waist cord, and hemp trousers; officials of the second rank and above followed suit. At greater mourning the emperor wore a plain gauze soft-foot folded cap, pale yellow robe, and dark purple leather belt with black silver fittings. Ministers and military officers of company-commander rank and above all wore their regular colors in subdued dress, with iron belts, boots, and court tablets. Imperial princes wore full mourning dress inside the palace and subdued dress when they went out. After assuming full mourning dress, the ministers attended morning and evening audiences for three days. At lesser and greater mourning, removal of mourning, and on new- and full-moon days, they all came in to attend and offer condolences. Personal effects left behind were distributed among ministers and imperial princes, and envoys were sent to present gifts to the frontier commands. On the twenty-seventh day the chief ministers were ordered to compose the mausoleum name and the mourning register text.
9
殿退 殿 輿簿
On the seventeenth day of the third month the following year, the ministers presented the posthumous title register and seal for announcement at the southern suburb; the next day it was read before the spirit seat. On the tenth day of the fourth month the encoffining hall was opened; the emperor and ministers all wore dress as at the initial mourning. The ministers attended morning and evening in the central hall, then changed to regular dress and left the palace precinct when they withdrew. On the thirteenth day the funeral procession set out. The emperor, in full mourning, performed the opening offering and wept; the ministers came in to attend; and the catalpa coffin was lifted onto the dragon hearse. After the ancestor-offering was concluded, a halt was set outside the Gate of Bright Virtue for the farewell offering. The mourning register was read; the emperor wept his fill, bowed twice in farewell, removed full mourning and returned to the palace, while officials took their leave outside the capital. On the twenty-fifth day the imperial burial chamber was sealed. On the twenty-ninth day the yu spirit tablet arrived and was installed in the Great Bright Hall. On the nineteenth day of the fifth month he was enshrined in the fifth chamber of the ancestral temple, with Empress Xiaoming née Wang elevated as his consort. When the rites were finished, the ministers offered condolences. The auspicious and mourning processions followed the An Mausoleum precedent, with only the addition of an enclosed hearse and a spirit-silk shoulder litter; the guard of honor numbered three thousand five hundred thirty-nine men. The tomb lay in Gong County, paired with the Xuan Ancestor, and was named Yongchang.
10
殿 殿 簿
On the twenty-ninth day of the third month in the third year of Zhidao, Taizong died in the Hall of Myriad Years. Zhenzong let down his hair and wailed, then took the throne at the eastern pillar of the hall according to the final edict. The Yongxi Mausoleum was planned with an imperial chamber one hundred feet deep and eighty feet square, and a tomb platform two hundred fifty feet on each side. The grand imperial guard of honor employed one jade carriage and five leather carriages among others, with nine thousand four hundred sixty-eight men in all. The responsible offices prescribed the rite of loosened hair: the emperor, empress, imperial princes, princesses, commandery princesses, wives of imperial princes, and inner-palace women all loosened the hair on the left side; the empress dowager loosened all her hair. The emperor wore a hemp slanting band, four-cornered cap, wide sleeves, skirt, trousers, and hat, carried a bamboo staff, wore waist and head mourning cords, a straight-collared hemp mourning shirt, and a white silk under-robe. Imperial princes, imperial kinsmen, and those below followed suit, adding hemp head caps and silk under-garments. The empress dowager, empress, and commissioned women inside and outside the palace wore hemp skirts, shirts, shawls, and kerchiefs, head mourning cords, and silk under-garments. Palace women went without shawls. Civil and military officials of the second rank and above wore hemp slanting bands, four-cornered caps, head caps, wide sleeves, mourning shirts, skirts, trousers, waist cords, bamboo staffs, and silk under-robes. All other officials wore hemp wrapped headcloths, mourning shirts, and waist cords. Fifth-rank officials of the two central departments, fourth-rank officials of the Censorate and Secretariat, third-rank officials of the various bureaus and above, current and former defense and training commissioners and prefects, Inner Service Bureau staff, gatekeepers, inner-palace directors, duty officers, and the like wore hemp head caps, wrapped headcloths, wide sleeves, mourning shirts, skirts, trousers, and waist cords. Soldiers and commoners wore white shirts and paper hats; women wore plain unpatterned dress without flowered hairpins; mourning cries ceased after three days. Until the tomb was finished, he did not conduct state business on new- and full-moon days.
11
輿輿 殿
In the sixth month an edict ordered the Hanlin Academy to paint two portraits of the late emperor in everyday dress and in crimson gauze robe with imperial cap, to be set before the seat in the mourning canopy and placed before the great carrying litter. On the following day Taizong's favorite objects—bows, swords, brush and inkstone, zither and chess set, and the like—wrapped in brocade, were placed in the litter and displayed within the funeral train. On the third day of the tenth month the spirit carriage departed. Bearers, lifters, drivers, soldiers, and strongmen for the mourning train's ritual objects numbered twelve thousand one hundred ninety-three men in all. Pallbearers wore wide white silk shirts, white silk skirts, and silk headcloths with belt bands. Everything else followed the Chang Mausoleum precedent. On the second day of the eleventh month the responsible offices brought the spirit tablet to the Imperial Ancestral Temple; close ministers inscribed the posthumous title; he was enshrined in the sixth chamber, with Empress Yide née Fu elevated as his consort. Fifteen hundred guards were posted at the tomb; a hall was built to house the imperial portrait, with food offerings morning and evening and seasonal sacrifices throughout the year.
12
使 退 殿 殿西殿 殿西 退 殿 退
On the twenty-first day the ministers came to attend; they found the emperor in the eastern wing. The Gatekeeper Commissioner proclaimed an oral edict: "The late emperor has suddenly left the realm; every subject must join in mourning, and military officers at court and in the provinces alike should be shown care and reassurance." The ministers bowed, performed the ritual dance, and hailed long life; then wept their fill again and withdrew. That day memorials requesting that he resume governance were submitted three times before permission was granted. On the twenty-third day the late emperor's garments and personal objects, pearl shroud, jade casket, mouth-pearl, grave-gifts, and other items for the catalpa coffin were displayed in the Yanqing Hall, and chief ministers were summoned to inspect them together. The next day the great encoffining was performed and full mourning dress assumed. On the twenty-fifth day the responsible offices set the imperial seat and hung curtains in the western gallery of the Chongzheng Hall, all in white hemp; the ministers formed ranks outside the hall gate. The emperor, in full mourning, set aside staff and cords; attendants helped him to the seat. The Communications Attendant led the ministers into the hall courtyard, where they formed ranks facing west. When the curtain was raised, the ministers bowed twice; the lead official reported that the sacred person was in good health; the assembly thrice hailed long life and withdrew. The chief ministers ascended the hall and reported affairs according to established ritual. On the first day of the third month, at lesser mourning, the emperor performed the offering and removed full mourning dress; the ministers came to attend, then went to the inner eastern gate to submit their names and offer condolences. Thereafter they attended every seven days until the forty-ninth day, when the practice ended. On the thirteenth day, at greater mourning, the emperor laid aside mourning dress and wore subdued dress.
13
使 殿 殿 西 殿
On the fourteenth day the Directorate of Astronomy reported: "For cutting the grass at the mausoleum site, the third hour of the day on the first day of the fourth month is auspicious." On the sixteenth day Lan Jizong, commissioner for inspecting the mausoleum site, reported: "According to the Directorate of Astronomy, a site called Crouching Dragon Mound six li northeast of Yong'an County is suitable for the imperial tomb." An edict ordered Lei Yungong to reinspect the site and report back. The imperial burial chamber was designed to be eighty-one feet deep and one hundred forty feet square. The tomb was named Yongding. On the eleventh day of the ninth month chief ministers were summoned to the Huiqing Hall to inspect the items for the burial chamber—everyday dress, personal objects, and favorite possessions from his lifetime. The emperor and chief ministers discussed the Heavenly Writings, which the late emperor had received in reverence for the Way as divine gifts—extraordinary auspicious signs belonging to the Primordial Sage that could not remain in the human realm and should be installed at the Yongding Mausoleum. On the twenty-third day the Heavenly Writings were escorted to the Changchun Hall; the emperor offered incense, bowed twice, and bade them farewell. On the twenty-fourth day the Heavenly Writings set out first; the emperor performed the opening offering at the catalpa coffin and read the mourning register; when the rites were finished, the auspicious and mourning processions were assembled. Officials in plain dress went outside the Shuntian Gate, formed ranks at Banqiao, and bid the procession farewell. On returning they went to the western upper Gatehouse to submit their names and offer condolences. On the thirteenth day of the tenth month the imperial burial chamber was sealed. On the eighteenth day the yu spirit tablet reached the capital. On the nineteenth day the ministers went to the Huiqing Hall to perform the nine yu sacrifices. On the twenty-third day he was enshrined in the seventh chamber of the Imperial Ancestral Temple.
14
使 使使
On the last day of the third month in the eighth year of Jiayou, Renzong died and Yingzong took the throne. Mourning dress and construction of the Yongzhao Mausoleum followed the Ding Mausoleum precedent; forty-six thousand seven hundred soldiers from all circuits were mobilized for the work. Shi Quanbin of the Xuanging Bureau supervised construction of the catalpa coffin, submitted designs for approval, and was instructed to make it solid and complete without excessive ornament. The Three Departments requested one million five hundred thousand strings from the inner treasury, two million five hundred thousand bolts of silk and hemp, and five hundred thousand taels of silver for the tomb and rewards. Envoys were sent to announce the mourning to Liao and Xia and to present leftover personal effects; other envoys were dispatched to notify all circuits. Offerings were made when governance resumed to announce the emperor's passing; close ministers announced his ascension at the altars of Heaven and Earth, soil and grain, ancestral temples, and palace shrines; the succession was announced as well. Personal effects were distributed among the two central departments, the imperial clan, and close ministers.
15
宿使宿 殿
In the fifth month Hanlin Academician Wang Gui argued: "The emperor's posthumous title should be determined by officials of the fifth rank and above from the Secretariat-Chancellery and Censorate, fourth rank and above from the Secretariat, and third rank and above from the various bureaus, who announce to Heaven at the southern suburb, deliberate, and then submit a joint memorial. Under recent practice only literary officials draft the proposal and an edict follows immediately, excluding ordinary officials from participation—this considerably violates the principle of addressing Heaven. I propose to present the late emperor's posthumous title and ask that responsible offices be ordered to examine the old regulations, perform the suburban announcement first, and only then submit ministers' recommendations." In the seventh month chief ministers and below lodged at the Secretariat, while imperial clansmen of training commissioner rank and above stayed at the Duting Post Station to request the posthumous title at the southern suburb. In the eighth month announcements were made at the Funing Hall, the altars of Heaven and Earth, the ancestral temples, and palace shrines.
16
殿
On the twenty-eighth day of the ninth month the encoffining hall was opened; the emperor attended once daily in initial mourning dress, then changed to regular dress before leaving. On the sixth day of the tenth month the funeral procession departed; the emperor performed the opening offering and the catalpa coffin was lifted onto the dragon hearse. After the ancestor-offering was concluded, he walked out the Xuande Gate with the empress dowager while ministers bid farewell at Banqiao. On the fifteenth day the catalpa coffin was installed beside the tomb. On the seventeenth day the imperial burial chamber was opened. On the second day of the eleventh month the yu spirit tablet arrived; the empress dowager made offerings at the Qionglin Garden; the emperor walked out the Gate of the Hall of Assembled Excellence to welcome it and made offerings in the mourning canopy. On the seventh day sacrifices were offered to the yu spirit tablet. On the twenty-ninth day he was enshrined in the Imperial Ancestral Temple. The spirit tablet followed Han practice without inscribing the posthumous title; after the final yu rite the final weeping sacrifice was performed.
17
殿使
The Ritual Academy reported: "According to precedent, dress changes at greater mourning set greater mourning on the twenty-ninth day of the third month, dan removal on the twenty-ninth day of the fifth month, mourning removal on the twenty-ninth day of the sixth month, and return to auspicious dress on the first day of the seventh month; an edict has already been issued. Examining ritual scholarship, Wang Su held that mourning ended in the twenty-fifth month, while Zheng Xuan held the twenty-seventh; the Comprehensive Institutions followed Zheng's view, but if one extends to the end of the twenty-seventh month, mourning would end in the twenty-eighth and auspicious dress begin in the twenty-ninth—clearly an error. In the Tiansheng era the Edict Revising the Years and Months of the Five Mourning Grades fixed mourning at twenty-seven months, which scholars and commoners alike now follow. Three-year mourning extends from the Son of Heaven to the common people and should not differ. We ask that the twenty-ninth day of the third month be set as greater mourning, a day in the fifth month chosen for the chan rite, and the first day of the sixth month for return to auspicious dress." Accordingly, on greater mourning day he did not attend the front and rear halls; Kaifeng Prefecture suspended capital sentences and banned slaughter until the fifth day of the fourth month; academicians, observation commissioners, and above, and imperial clansmen commanding armies made daily offerings; on the twenty-eighth day all ministers came to offer sacrifices; on the twenty-ninth day mourning was removed and all ministers offered condolences.
18
殿
On the eighth day of the first month in the fourth year of Zhiping, Yingzong died and Shenzong took the throne. On the eleventh day the great encoffining was performed. On the third day of the second month the body was placed in the mourning hall. On the third day of the fourth month the posthumous title was requested. On the eighteenth day the posthumous title was announced and the register read at the Funing Hall. On the twenty-fifth day of the seventh month the encoffining hall was opened. On the eighth day of the eighth month the funeral procession departed. On the twenty-seventh day he was buried at the Yonghou Mausoleum.
19
殿
The Ritual Academy approved the ritual rule that after assuming mourning dress ministers rode horses with hemp-wrapped saddles and saddlecloths. When lesser mourning attendance ended, they removed head caps, square skirts, and wide sleeves. When greater mourning attendance ended, they wore plain gauze soft-foot wrapped headcloths and subdued official dress, and rode horses with black saddles and saddlecloths. When mourning was removed they wore plain gauze wrapped headcloths, regular dress, and black belts. Two days later they changed to auspicious dress and removed fish pendants. The yu spirit tablet arrived after the tomb was sealed; five yu rites were performed on the journey and four at the Hall of Assembled Excellence. A partial amnesty was granted for the two capitals, the capital districts, and prefectures such as Zheng and Meng, following precedent.
20
殿 殿 殿
On the fifth day of the third month in the eighth year of Yuanfeng, Shenzong died. On the thirteenth day the great encoffining was performed and the emperor assumed mourning dress. On the seventeenth day lesser mourning was observed. On the first day of the fourth month mourning was removed. On the fifth day of the seventh month the posthumous title was requested at the southern suburb. On the eighth day of the ninth month the posthumous register and seal were read at the Funing Hall. On the twenty-third day the encoffining hall was opened. On the first day of the tenth month the funeral procession departed. On the twenty-first day he was buried at the Yongyu Mausoleum. On the twenty-ninth day the yu spirit tablet arrived. On the first day of the eleventh month the yu sacrifice was performed at the Hall of Assembled Excellence. From the time earth was returned to the tomb, six yu rites were performed on the journey with the Director of Imperial Sacrifices acting in proxy; three yu rites were performed in the hall. On the fourth day the final weeping sacrifice was performed. On the fifth day he was enshrined in the ancestral temple.
21
Fan Zuyu, Corrector of Texts in the Secretariat, argued: "The former kings established ritual so that mourning for a lord matched mourning for a father—three years in the severest grade—because they feared subjects would not serve their lord as they serve a father; this is how human sentiment is governed. Since Han times not only have subjects worn no mourning for their lord, but rulers themselves have not observed three-year mourning. Only in our dynasty, since the founding ancestors, has the outer court used the system of substituting months while the inner palace has actually practiced three-year mourning. Moreover, the reason previous dynasties found the month-substitution system hard to change was that the ruler himself did not wear mourning. Today ministers substitute months while the ruler actually practices three-year mourning; hence lesser mourning on the twelfth day, lesser mourning again at one year, greater mourning on the twenty-fourth day, and greater mourning again at two years. The lian and xiang rites cannot occur twice; to observe them by days and also by months is ritual without textual basis. Greater mourning at two years, chan in the middle month—chan is the name of a sacrifice, not a mourning color. Now subdued dress is worn for three days before chan is performed—this is ritual without classical warrant. Having removed mourning dress, mourning is worn again at burial—presumably because one cannot go without mourning. After enshrinement in the temple one immediately returns to full auspicious dress—only eight months have passed, yet suddenly every ornament is worn again—this is ritual without gradual transition. The month-substitution system has been inherited too long to reverse; ministers should wear court dress but, as today, not yet remove full mourning—wearing it at one year, gradually removing heavier items, wearing it again at two years, and only then releasing full mourning; for the rest, the ruler may wear whatever dress is appropriate. For chan it is unnecessary to wear special dress; only when not yet fully auspicious until the xiang rite, and then wearing every ornament, would the three-year system approximate antiquity." An edict ordered the ritual officials to deliberate in detail.
22
Minister of Rites Han Zhongyan and others argued: "Court ceremonial differs in suitability from age to age and need not follow antiquity. If the former kings' regulations cannot all be applied, then ancestral precedents should serve as the standard. The proposal would have ministers observe three-year mourning and the populace ban music likewise, and even after passing the mausoleum not remove full mourning dress, hoping to accord with ancient practice. Because the former kings' condolence ceremonies have many detailed provisions, following antiquity would require far more than the proposal states. Since they cannot all be applied now, one should follow ancestral precedents and the late emperor's established regulations." An edict approved their recommendation.
23
殿
When the spirit tablet was enshrined in the temple, that month's winter solstice brought congratulatory memorials from all officials. Cheng Yi, Lecturer at the Chongzheng Hall, argued: "Shenzong's mourning has not yet ended; the seasons are changing and grief is still keen; I fear we will lose the ritual of dwelling in mourning and fail to set an example for the realm. I ask that congratulations be changed to condolences." The request was denied.
24
便 便
In the fourth year of Shaosheng the Grand Astrologer requested relocation of more than thirteen hundred commoners' tombs within the Yongyu Mausoleum restricted zone to improve the site's geomantic resonance. The emperor said: "Will relocating tombs not cause disturbance? If there is no harm, order that they not be moved; if relocation truly is needed for geomantic reasons, provide official funds to cover burial expenses."
25
On the twelfth day of the first month in the third year of Yuanfu, Zhezong died and Huizong took the throne. An edict ordered that mausoleum regulations follow the Yuanfeng precedent. On the eleventh day of the seventh month the encoffining hall was opened. On the twentieth day the funeral procession departed. On the eighth day of the eighth month he was buried at the Yongtai Mausoleum. On the ninth day of the ninth month, with the elevation and enshrinement completed, ministers wore auspicious dress according to precedent.
26
The Court of Imperial Sacrifices reported: "Emperor Taizong succeeded Taizu; though brothers succeeded one another and the month-substitution system was used in public, he actually wore the severest mourning grade for three years to honor the bond between ruler and subject. After public removal of mourning all state affairs were conducted appropriately, as fully recorded in the national history. The present emperor succeeded Zhezong, inheriting the era of his divine father Shenzong, and has already followed the Kaibao precedent in wearing heavy full mourning for Zhezong. Now that the spirit tablet has been enshrined, all officials should wear fully auspicious dress, and the emperor's attire should follow the precedent of the second year of Taiping Xingguo."
27
' '
The Ministry of Rites reported: "During Taiping Xingguo, Chief Minister Xue Juzheng memorialized that since public removal of mourning all affairs had been proportionate, and that ordering music to cease was alone truly inappropriate. That is, after public removal of mourning, apart from not performing music, releasing full mourning and adopting auspicious dress—the principle is quite clear. The emperor should now attend in regular dress, plain gauze extended-foot wrapped headcloth, pale yellow robe, and black rhinoceros-horn belt; we ask that responsible offices be ordered to prepare them. The chief ministers asked to follow the ritual officers' recommendation, and an edict was issued to await the completion of the mourning period before adopting auspicious dress.
28
At the time the edict bypassed the Secretariat and went directly to the responsible offices. Supervising Secretary Gong Yuan argued: "Mourning regulations are a great matter of state; carrying them out without the Secretariat is to abolish the law. Subjects wearing the severest mourning grade for their lord for three years has never been changed since antiquity. Moreover, when Your Majesty previously deliberated on mourning dress, ritual officials offered equivocal views; once Your Majesty perceived their deceit, mourning dress was corrected. Now you are compelled to follow them, and I privately grieve for Your Majesty. In Kaibao times Bing and Fen had not been pacified and warfare had not ceased; the ancestors had no leisure amid hardship, and those mourning regulations were expedients for the moment, not established precedents. Yuan was demoted to prefect of Nankang Army for this offense. An edict then ordered adherence to the originally issued three-year mourning regulation, correcting the Yuanfu third-year ninth-month directive to adopt auspicious dress from lesser mourning.
29
使 殿 沿 使
On the jiazi day of the fourth month in the fifth year of Shaoxing, Huizong died in the Five States City. In the first month of the seventh year the inquiry envoys He Xian and others returned with the news; chief ministers came to audience; the emperor wailed and beat his breast and ate nothing all day. Chief Minister Zhang Jun and others urgently pleaded before he would take millet porridge. He assumed mourning dress at the Spirit Table Hall; civil and military officials attended morning and evening at the traveling palace. From hearing of the mourning until lesser mourning, officials attended morning and evening; from lesser mourning until the chan sacrifice, they attended once each morning. The Court of Imperial Sacrifices and others reported: "Under old regulations frontier prefectures and armies were not permitted to observe mourning. Because the great commanders are the state's trusted military pillars who share its fortunes, and their generals and aides all harbor loyal indignation, they should at their encampments, from deputy commanders upward, assume mourning dress, attend morning and evening daily, and company officers weep in their own camps. Wang Lun, Attendant Drafting Master at the Huixian Pavilion, and others were appointed commissioners to welcome the catalpa coffin.
30
便便
At the time Hu Yin, prefect of Shaozhou, submitted a memorial stating in summary: "Three-year mourning is the same for the Son of Heaven and the common people alike. When Emperor Xiaowen of Han practiced modest virtue he substituted days for months, and this has been practiced ever since. Sons forget their parents and subjects forget their lords for personal convenience, knowing it is wrong yet refusing to change—even by ordinary ritual this is unacceptable; how much more when the calamity is as extraordinary as today's? Respectfully considering the late Supreme Emperor and late Mingde Empress, who suffered disgrace and were driven north, never to return—this was truly caused by Nianhan; we bear a feud that cannot share heaven under one canopy. According to ritual, if the feud is not avenged mourning is not removed; one should sleep on straw and use a spear as pillow without end. The reason is that though the realm is vast and affairs innumerable, nothing surpasses the bond between father and son or the duty between lord and subject. I have seen the imperial directive of such-and-such date citing the dynasty's old regulations to substitute days for months, and I firmly believe this is wrong. Even by ordinary ritual there must be a testamentary edict from the late emperor before such a practice may be followed. Now no edict from the late emperor has been heard, yet Your Majesty has issued a directive to carry it out—substituting days for months thus comes from Your Majesty's own intent. The late emperor in dire confinement endured dress, food, and drink beyond human endurance; in illness there was surely no provision of gruel and medicine; after death, were shrouds and encoffining complete? Proper coffining and choice of burial site—who knows where they are? In the vast desert, for whom shall we gaze and keep watch? If Your Majesty reflects on this once, the anguish is crushing beyond endurance; even if unable to follow the Spring and Autumn Annals and remove mourning only after the enemy is destroyed, one should still reform Emperor Jing of Han's thin practice and fix mourning at three years. Otherwise, to remove in twenty-seven days mourning that should never be removed in a lifetime is to add thinness upon thinness; this surely cannot be what a sage would find acceptable."
31
便' 輿 使 '
He further said: "Although dwelling in mourning for three years, military affairs must still be decided by imperial judgment, so the full rites of sincere mourning cannot all be performed. For this is not a time to rest on clods in silence but a time to rest on spears with affairs pending; when the Lord of Lu mourned the Duke of Zhou and the Xu and Yi both rose, the eastern suburb did not open—he wore ink mourning and took up arms, which Confucius approved in his sworn command. Now the six armies are on alert and a northern campaign is imminent; of the myriad state affairs, which is not military business? Your Majesty's hearing and deciding cases embodies the ritual variation; after the final weeping sacrifice, attending court in ink mourning accords with what Confucius approved and may be carried out without doubt. If this accords with Your Majesty's intent, I beg that an edict be directly issued, saying: 'Respectfully considering the Supreme Emperor and Mingde Empress, who gave birth to my humble person—great grace hard to repay, wishing to repay without limit, not one part in a hundred fulfilled. The imperial carriage went on distant campaign and met great calamity; where the news of death arrived, pain pierced my whole being. Longing for that kindly face, lost never to be seen again; the feud enemy still lives—how dare I forget? Although army and state have many concerns and sincere mourning is hard to practice, wearing hemp mourning while resting on spears is no task for another to perform. Substituting days for months is what my feelings cannot accept; arising from my own person, I institute three-year mourning. Taking up arms in ink mourning dress, with expedient regulations besides, proclaim this within and without to display my utmost feeling. As for the ceremonial codes to be carried out, order responsible offices to assemble deliberations and submit them. If anyone dares obstruct it, this would make me as a son forget filial duty; obstruction should be judged as great irreverence. Let Your Majesty personally wield the brush and issue it from within, renewing the ears and eyes of the realm to transform the world—Heaven, Earth, and the spirits will surely lend aid. Your subject cannot express his great hope sufficiently."
32
殿 西
Huizong and Empress Xiansu were first buried in the Five States City; in the twelfth year the Jin returned the catalpa coffin. As it was about to arrive, the emperor in yellow robe rode the palanquin to Linping to welcome it, then boarded the boat and changed to finest mourning, as did all officials. Once it reached the traveling capital, it was installed in the Longde Separate Palace, with separate halls for emperor and empress. Ritual officials requested the An Mausoleum precedent: when the catalpa coffin entered the border it was immediately placed in an outer coffin; responsible offices prepared imperial robes and pheasant-embroidered dress to take there; upon arrival they were placed in the outer coffin without re-encoffining. Qin Hui ordered attendant officials, remonstrance officials, and ritual officials to deliberate: since the spirit carriage had returned, the tomb should be honored and tended, or called the encoffining palace. Cheng Dunhou, Vice Director of the Ministry of Rites, hoping to please Qin Hui, alone memorialized: "Retaining the old title of encoffining palace cannot display the great trust of reconciliation, yet using the proper canon of mountain burial seems like abandoning survival for later plans. I believe one should not dress up empty names but should display great trust. Thereupon Mo Jiang, Minister of Works, and other deliberators stated: "The Grand Astrologer said the year was unfavorable for great burial; we request using Empress Mingde's precedent and provisionally encoffining. This was accepted. It was welcomed in the eighth month, the procession set out in the ninth, and encoffining was sealed in the tenth, fifty paces northwest of the Zhaoci Encoffining Palace on two hundred fifty mu of land. In the thirteenth year the tomb was renamed Yongyou.
33
使 殿殿
In the fifth month of the thirty-first year of Shaoxing a Jin envoy arrived announcing Qinzong's death. An edict stated: "I shall wear the severest mourning grade for three years to express grief and longing. That day civil and military officials in regular dress and black belts, fish pendants removed, formed ranks on the open ground south of the Tianzhang Pavilion, heard the edict and concluded mourning cries, then went outside the rear hall gate to submit names and offer condolences, then to the Spirit Table Hall to burn incense and mourn. In the sixth month Acting Vice Minister of Rites Jin Anjie and others requested following precedent to substitute days for months; from the twenty-second day of the fifth month the spirit seat was established until the seventeenth day of the sixth month for greater mourning—all full mourning dress was provisionally retained awaiting return of the catalpa coffin. This was accepted. In the seventh month Chief Minister Chen Kangbo and others led officials to the southern suburb to request the posthumous title; temple name Qinzong; the distant tomb was named Yongxian. Everything else followed Huizong's ceremonial regulations.
34
殿
On the eighth day of the tenth month in the fourteenth year of Chunxi, Gaozong died; Xiaozong wailed and beat his breast and for more than two days took no food. Soon he told Chief Minister Wang Huai that he wished not to use month substitution but, like Emperor Wu of Jin and Emperor Xiaowen of Wei, actually practice three-year mourning, which would not hinder governance. Huai and others memorialized: "The Comprehensive Mirror records that although Emperor Wu of Jin had this intent, afterward it was only deep robes and lian caps within the palace. The emperor said: "At the time the ministers could not follow and support his intent; that is why Sima Guang ridiculed them. Later Emperor Wu ultimately wished to carry it out. Huai said: "As I recall, he could not carry it out either. The emperor said: "What harm is there in my making the ancient anew? Huai said: "When attending the imperial hall, the ruler in full mourning cords and ministers in auspicious dress—is that acceptable? The emperor said: "There are naturally grades and distinctions. An inner endorsement was then issued: "I shall wear full mourning cords for three years; ministers shall themselves follow the order of substituting months. As for the ritual regulations to be carried out, order responsible offices to discuss them. An edict ordered that within the period of substituting days for months officials should conduct affairs in full mourning dress.
35
On the dinghai day, the twentieth, at lesser mourning the emperor had not changed dress; Wang Huai and others begged him to comply with ritual regulations. The emperor, weeping, said: "Great grace is hard to repay; my feelings cannot bear it. On the twenty-first day the imperial carriage returned within; the emperor in full mourning cords rode the palanquin with plain insignia; soldiers and civilians who saw it often wept. An edict ordered that from now on every five days he should go before the catalpa coffin to burn incense. The emperor wished to wear full mourning in a plain canopy and summon chief ministers and ranks, but ritual officials memorialized: "Raw hemp mourning for three years is hard to practice in the outer court. The memorial was submitted; no response was issued. On the first day of the eleventh month ritual officials Yan Shilu, You Mao, and others memorialized: "We beg that when the rites are concluded dress be changed to lesser mourning dress, removing staff and cords. When the chan sacrifice rites were concluded, change to plain gauze soft-foot folded cap, pale yellow robe, and black silver belt. When enshrinement of the spirit tablet was concluded, change to black wrapped headcloth and black rhinoceros-horn belt with dark purple fittings. When passing the palace to burn incense, perform rites in full mourning cords within the palace; mourning removed in the twenty-fifth month. The emperor endorsed: "Change the pale yellow robe to a white robe. On the jihai day, the second, greater mourning. On the xinchou day, the fourth, the chan sacrifice rites were concluded. On the renyin day, the fifth, officials requested that he resume governance; permission was not granted. On the eighth day officials submitted memorials three times, citing the Announcement to Kang phrases such as "wearing cap and robe, going out the Ying Gate" as proof. On the ninth day an edict approved.
36
宿 便 殿
On the jiayin day, the eighteenth of the first month in the fifteenth year, the hundredth day, the emperor went to the palace to perform the incense-burning rite. On the dingsi day, the twenty-first, he told the chief ministers: "Yesterday I summoned Hong Mai within; he saw that I had passed the hundredth day yet still wore coarse full mourning when reporting affairs, which should gradually change; now I should dress according to the ancient meaning of ink mourning, but the headcloth should use silk gauze or gauze. I consider silk gauze and silk unsuitable; fine cloth would be acceptable. Wang Huai and others said: "Ordinarily when scholar-officials observe mourning for a parent past the hundredth day, headcloths and shirts use fine cloth; when going out to receive guests, they use gray cloth. Now Your Majesty is practicing ritual that antiquity could not carry out—sufficient to serve as a model for ten thousand generations. The emperor further said: "How about summoning night-duty officials and the like in the evening? Huai said: "Cloth headcloth and cloth jacket are regular dress. The emperor did not agree. From then on, whenever he attended the Yanhe Hall, he wore only a white cloth folded cap and cloth shirt; when going to the palace he wore full mourning cords and carried a staff.
37
On the renzi day of the third month the encoffining hall was opened; the emperor wore initial mourning dress. On the jiayin day the funeral procession departed. On the bingyin day the encoffining was sealed. On the jiaxu day he personally performed the seventh yu sacrifice. The chief ministers stated: "The yu sacrifice is an auspicious rite and should use boots and formal robe. The emperor said: "A cloth folded cap, black belt, and cloth robe will suffice."
38
殿殿 '殿'
On the bingxu day, the twentieth, the spirit tablet was enshrined in the temple. That day an edict stated: "I yesterday issued a directive wishing to wear full mourning cords for three years; because ministers repeatedly requested that I change dress to attend the hall, I conducted affairs in the inner hall in plain cloth. Although there was an edict to wait until after enshrinement and reluctantly follow the request, examining the ceremonial codes, my heart was truly uneasy; I shall carry out the full mourning period. This approximates ancient practice. You should respect my intent and make no further requests. Thereupon the chief ministers did not dare speak further. The three-year regulation was decided by the emperor's own resolve, while the ruling chief ministers all upheld month substitution. Remonstrance official Xie E and ritual official You Mao knew in their hearts it was wrong but did not dare speak fully. Only Shen Qingchen, revising official of the Edict Office, again memorialized: "I wish to uphold the intent of 'mainly hearing great affairs in the inner hall'; when enshrinement is completed, let an imperial brush edict be issued in advance, clearly showing the resolve of full mourning, cutting off future memorials from chief ministers, permitting no further requests, striving to complete sacred filial piety, to display it to all officials and model it for the realm. The emperor accepted this advice. An edict was also issued: "The encoffining palace should follow the testamentary instructions and strive for thrift; all construction expenses shall come from the inner treasury and must not encroach on the regular budgets of responsible offices. Supervisory commissioners of all circuits and prefectural offices should submit only condolence memorials; all other rites are exempted; no contributions may be made in the name of presenting offerings to the encoffining palace. The tomb was named Yongsi.
39
On the ninth day of the sixth month in the fifth year of Shaoxi, Xiaozong died. The grand empress dowager ordered that because the emperor was ill, he was permitted to assume mourning dress within while the grand empress dowager performed the rites on his behalf.
40
仿 殿
On the ninth day of the sixth month in the second year of Qingyuan, greater mourning was observed. On the sixteenth day of the eighth month the chan sacrifice was performed. At the time Guangzong could not carry out mourning; Ningzong succeeded in mourning dress and wished after greater mourning to wear mourning two months longer, saying: "I only wish the ritual system to be fully complete; I do not quibble over these two months. Supervising Censor Hu Hong stated: "Mourning by a grandson for a grandfather has already passed its term. Those deliberating wish to observe chan two months longer—by what ceremonial code? If one says the eldest grandson bears the weight, then the Supreme Emperor has also recovered and is himself practicing twenty-seven months of heavy mourning within the palace, while Your Majesty practices it again—this makes two chief mourners in one funeral. Since antiquity, when has mourning by a grandson for a grandfather ever had such a ritual? An edict ordered attendant officials, remonstrance officials, and drafting masters to assemble deliberations. Minister of Personnel Ye Xu and others stated: "When Xiaozong first died, the Supreme Emperor was unwell and practiced three-year mourning within the palace. The emperor received the abdication and should properly follow ancient square-mourning dress; the responsible offices had failed in their deliberation. Hu Hong's present memorial cites antiquity and relies on the classics, distinguishes suspicion and clarifies subtle points—it is truly fitting. We wish to follow the request, consulting precedents: on the sixth day of the sixth month, when greater mourning rites are concluded, the emperor and all officials shall wear fully auspicious dress; on the first day of the seventh month, the emperor attends the main hall and feasts at the ancestral temple. For the future chan sacrifice, order ritual officials to examine and follow accumulated dynastic ritual precedents. On the gengxu day of the fourth month, an edict stated: "Although the ministers' deliberation accords with the ritual classics, I am somewhat uneasy regarding my longing in remembrance; I reported early to the grand empress dowager and received her directive face to face: although the Supreme Emperor has not fully recovered, the palace also practices the three-year regulation—the deliberation should be followed. I personally received her kindly instruction—how dare I not comply."
41
使 ·
Initially, at Gaozong's mourning, Xiaozong wore three-year mourning. At Xiaozong's mourning, responsible offices requested, beyond month substitution, lacquered gauze pale yellow dress—following practice before Shaoxing. When Zhu Xi first arrived, he disagreed and memorialized: "Past errors cannot now be corrected; only for the future opening of the encoffining hall and funeral procession should ritual return to initial mourning dress—then the stages of change and removal may still be deliberated. I hope a clear edict will order ritual officials to examine ritual regulations and specify them in advance. Regulations should also be made for the square-mourning dress of officials, soldiers, and commoners so they do not indulge in lavish ornament. Afterward an edict ordered all officials to conduct affairs in cool shirts—based on this recommendation. When Zhu Xi submitted this proposal, some disciples had doubts but had nothing with which to refute it. Later, reading the Correct Meaning of the Book of Rites entry "He Who Succeeds the Ancestor" in the Small Record on Mourning Dress, he appended a note at the end of his original proposal, stating in summary: "According to the Five Mourning Grades Years and Months Chart, severest grade three years—when the eldest grandson mourns for the grandfather, this is called bearing the weight
42
' ' ' ' '''''' 使 西
, the intent of the law is very clear, yet the Ritual Classic has no text; only the Commentary says: 'When the father has died and one succeeds the ancestor, wear the severest grade. Yet this is not seen in the original classic; the basis is unclear. But the Small Record says: 'When the grandfather has died and one succeeds the grandmother, three years. This may serve as collateral evidence. The Zheng Records cited in the commentary under 'He Who Succeeds the Ancestor' include the question 'When a feudal lord's father has crippling illness and cannot bear state or funeral affairs,' and Zheng answers with 'The Son of Heaven and feudal lords all wear the severest grade'—only then is it seen that while the father lives, one who inherits the state from the grandfather wears mourning. When I previously submitted this memorial, there was no text to examine and no friend to consult; therefore I spoke approximately from ritual regulations. I also doubted whether when the father lives one should not bear the weight; at the time there was no clear proof, and I answered only from the general intent of ritual regulations and human sentiment—my heart was often uneasy. Returning home and examining the texts, I first found this doctrine and then could be without doubt. Thus I knew that when learning is not expounded, the harm is so great. Yet the text of the Ritual Classic truly has omissions and gaps and must await later scholars. Had there been no Zheng Xuan, this matter would never have been decided; one cannot simply say the ancient classic fixed the system and not a single character may be added or removed. Soon an edict ordered construction west of the lower palace of the Yongsi Mausoleum of an encoffining palace; the tomb was named Yongfu.
43
In the sixth year of Qingyuan, Guangzong died; the tomb was named Yongchong.
44
In the seventeenth year of Jiading, Ningzong died; the tomb was named Yongmao.
45
In the fifth year of Jingding, Lizong died; the tomb was named Yongmu.
46
In the tenth year of Xianchun, Duzong died; the tomb was named Yongshao.
47
From Xiaozong onward, although the outer court used month substitution, the inner palace in fact practiced three-year mourning.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →