← Back to 宋史

卷三百六十三 列傳第一百二十二 李光 許翰 許景衡 張愨 張所 陳禾 蔣猷

Volume 363 Biographies 122: Li Guang, Xu Han, Xu Jingheng, Zhang Que, Zhang Suo, Chen He, Jiang You

Chapter 363 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 363
Next Chapter →
1
Li Guang, Xu Han, Xu Jingheng, Zhang Que, Zhang Suo, Chen He, and Jiang You
2
調 使 西
Li Guang, styled Taifa, was a native of Shangyu in Yue Prefecture. Even as a child he shunned horseplay and frivolity. His father Gao exclaimed, "My boy is a crane soaring above the clouds—surely he will bring glory to our clan!" After a parent's death he mourned with the grief of a grown man and turned away every condolence gift offered him. At the funeral every observance was conducted with exact propriety. Once his mourning was over, he entered the Imperial Academy and took the jinshi degree in the fifth year of the Chongning reign. Posted as magistrate of Kaihua, he earned a reputation for good government and was called to the Court Bureau for review; the chief ministers took offense, assigned him supervisory duty with a change of rank, and made him administrator of Changshu County in Pingjiang Prefecture. Zhu Mian's father Chong bullied others by leaning on his son's influence; Guang had Chong's household servants arrested and put in the stocks for trial. Chong flew into a rage and had a ministry envoy hint that Guang should be transferred to Wujiang as magistrate, but Guang refused to bend. He was reassigned as a document clerk in the Eastern and Western Capitals Directorate of Education.
3
When Liu Anshi was living in Nanjing, Guang called on him with the deference owed a master. Anshi passed on what he had learned from Master Wen (Sima Guang): "True learning must begin from the gate of sincerity—without self-deception." Guang accepted the lesson with evident delight. He was made an Erudite of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and then moved to the Bureau of Seals. In his first memorial he denounced the way scholar-officials had made flattery the norm, even twisting Xunzi's line that rulers "listen and obey but never hear remonstrance" into an excuse to shut down frank counsel; He added that popular resentment had condensed into strange omens and disasters. Wang Fu took offense and had the ministry assign him to Yangshuo County in Gui Prefecture. Learning that Guang had been banished for speaking out, Anshi wrote to commend his courage. Li Gang, too, had been driven from court after memorializing about the floods and was staying in Yixing; he watched for Guang at a river station, stepped out, and hailed him: "Surely that is Vice Director Li from Yue Prefecture aboard?" They spent several days together, sealed their friendship, and went their separate ways. He was made Vice Director in the Bureau of Honors and then Registrar of Tallies and Seals.
4
西 使
When Guo Yaoshi turned traitor, Guang sensed that Huizong meant to abdicate; he handed in his seal of office and told Military Affairs Commissioner Cai You, "Everything your clan has done has defied the will of the people. In the crisis we face today, unless the Crown Prince takes the throne, both sovereign and realm will be lost." You blanched and dared raise no objection. After Qinzong accepted the throne, Guang was elevated to Remonstrator of the Right Bureau. When the Retired Emperor went east on his tour, schemers drove a wedge between the two courts; Guang asked that officials assemble to settle the protocol for receiving him back. He also submitted: "The southeast's revenues have been swallowed by Zhu Mian; the northwest's coffers have been squeezed dry by Li Yan; and the empire's core finances have been bled white by Cai Jing and Wang Fu. What was labeled imperial tribute in truth filled private vaults; the state lacks six months' reserves, and common households cannot scrape together ten days' provisions. I urge a return to precedent: let the Three Departments and the Bureau of Military Affairs coordinate military, civil, and fiscal planning; have the Ministry of Revenue tally annual receipts and disbursements to set national spending; appoint auditors to review accounts; and reunite every stream of revenue under one authority."
5
使
Jurchen forces had Taiyuan under siege, and every relief column failed. Guang argued: "Our ancestors won the Three Prefectures only after generations of bloodshed; if we surrender them wholesale to the enemy, what nation will be left for us to govern? I ask that the throne command senior ministers to debate fresh plans for offense and defense, and that couriers be sent by hidden routes to rouse every able man in the Hedong eastern and northern circuits so they can strike the invaders from both ends." He was promoted to Attending Censor.
6
Memorialists were still championing Wang Anshi's doctrines, and an edict to that effect was posted in the ancestral temple. Guang protested again: "Our founders laid plans on a grand scale; Anshi sought to sweep away every statute and argued that a sovereign makes law and must never be bound by it; and when he meant to purge every senior statesman, he insisted that the throne must reshape society rather than let society reshape the throne. The Cai brothers took up and spread his teachings, and for fifty years their poison seeped into every corner of the realm. Now the court once more broadcasts this message at home and abroad, inflaming public opinion—how can that serve the dynasty's good?"
7
使便 使
Cai You planned to escort the Retired Emperor's mobile palace into the capital as a way to regain power; Guang wrote: "If You is allowed into the city, the populace will erupt; should the imperial procession be disturbed, I alone will bear blame for failing to warn of it. I beg that he be removed and punished without delay." Jiejing Garden had already been refurbished as Ningde Palace, yet the Retired Empress now wanted to take up residence inside the Forbidden City. Guang submitted: "The Forbidden City belongs to the reigning sovereign alone. Even if Your Majesty wishes to care for her comfort in person and bring her inside, you ought first to inform the Retired Emperor yourself and charge the proper offices with settling the ceremonial details." The throne circulated Guang's memorial for officials of both courts to relay upward, and the Retired Empress thereafter resided in Ningde Palace.
8
As Jurchen armies closed on the capital, fifty-two officials who deserted their posts were punished unevenly for the same crime; public opinion seethed, and Guang urged that the Court of Judicial Review apply one standard to all. With Taiyuan's plight worsening, he wrote: "Authorize Zhe Yanzhi immediately to mobilize every militiaman in Jin, Jiang, Ci, Xi, Ze, Lu, Weisheng, and Fen, along with county archer levies throughout the circuit, each district commander to lead his own men. Local magnates and gentry willing to lead should receive provisional rank, be furnished arms and armor, and march together to the rescue. The Jurchens hold an imperial prince hostage and demand the Three Prefectures; they will surely drive deeper inland. I urge a major overhaul of the capital's defenses to break their strategy."
9
He added: "Zhu Mian has used the tribute bureaucracy to bully prefectures and counties; his estates and mansions rival a prince's fortune. Appoint a bureau of upright, forceful officials to arrest Zhu Mian, his father, and the tribute commissioners and local magistrates who abetted them—men such as Hu Zhiru, Lu Zongyuan, Lu Zhi, Wang Cumin, Zhao Lin, and Song Hui—investigate every claim to the bottom, confiscate their wealth, and restore property wrested from registered households."
10
Li Hui and Li Zhuo were once more recalled to serve as remonstrators. Guang protested: "When Cai Jing returned to power, Hui and Zhuo took turns as censorial officers yet were barred from speaking a word of truth; when the Jurchens encircled the capital they sided with Bai Shizhong and Li Bangyan in pushing only to flee the foe and surrender land. Shizhong and Bangyan lost office for that very policy, yet Hui and Zhuo are rewarded with recall and seats among the remonstrators again. I ask that these appointments be revoked." The court gave no answer. Guang asked to be sent out of the capital; again he received no reply.
11
使
A comet rose between the Yin and Gen asterisms; Geng Nanzhong and his allies insisted it foretold trouble among foreign tribes and was no cause for alarm. Guang wrote: "Confucius left auspicious signs out of the Spring and Autumn Annals so that rulers would tremble and reform themselves; I have never heard of blaming heaven's warnings on barbarians beyond the frontier." When his memorial went in, he was demoted to supervisor of the wine tax at Ting Prefecture.
12
便 便 便
After Gaozong ascended the throne, Guang was made Vice Director of the Palace Library and appointed prefect of Jiang Prefecture; soon afterward he was named Attending Censor, yet in each case war-blocked roads kept him from taking up the post. In the third year of Jianyan, as the court shifted from Lin'an to Jiankang, he was made prefect of Xuan Prefecture. Fan Qiong's army was due to march through; Guang took office ahead of them, and when Qiong arrived Guang opened the gates to welcome and provision his men. They stayed three days and moved on without a single riot. Because Xuan lay near the mobile court, Guang repaired the walls, stockpiled arms and grain, enrolled the people of six counties in linked mutual-security groups he called Righteous Societies. From their ranks he picked the sturdiest fighters, placed local leaders in command, and raised more than ten thousand militiamen under the name Elite Picked Army. He fortified twenty-three choke points, divided the city into ten wards with separate patrols inside and out, let residents move freely by day, manned the walls at night, and sent fighters out at the first alarm. He redirected every district's annual seedling-tax payment to the prefectural treasury. Huan had first complained that the policy was impractical, yet when siege came it was what kept the army fed and the people alive. When word reached the court, he was named Pacification Commissioner for the circuit with discretionary authority and promoted to direct appointee of the Dragon Diagram Hall.
13
殿 使
Du Chong handed Jiankang over to the Jurchens, who then took Majia Ford. Imperial Camp commanders Wang Siye and Wang Simin had long been at odds; now they massed routed soldiers outside the walls and challenged each other to battle. Guang went to both camps in person and urged them to place the realm before private vendetta; moved, they broke camp and withdrew. Every routed officer or stray soldier who reached Xuan received a generous stipend and was sent on his way. When rebel sailors at Fanchang threatened Xuan's border, he sent troops at once, took them by surprise, and drove them to flee under cover of night. He was promoted to Compiler of the Right Hall of Literary Glory. Guang wrote: "The Jurchens may have plunged deep into Jiangsu and Zhejiang, but they fight against season and terrain; I have already ordered Liu Guangshi to march a main force here for a joint offensive. I urge that Pacification Commissioner Zhou Wang be empowered at once and a date set for a coordinated land-and-water advance."
14
使 紿
Routed general Shao Qing sailed from Zhen Prefecture with hundreds of boats and raided between Dangtu and Wuhu; Guang won him over with persuasion and sent two thousand bushels of rice. Qing was delighted and told the envoy, "We are imperial soldiers, yet everywhere we go people treat us as bandits—only Lord Li trusts us." From then on his men did not take so much as a blade of grain. Later, as his fleet passed Fanchang, someone tricked him into thinking he had entered Xuan Prefecture. He raided the north bank instead and sailed away.
15
竿 退 使
The notorious bandit Qi Fang overran Ningguo County, advanced to the walls of Xuan, and assaulted from four directions at once. Guang sent bold raiders against them; the rebels panicked and turned on one another in the dark. The court sent control officers Ju Shigu and Liu Yan to race to the rescue. The rebels stormed Chaojing Gate and lashed together a pontoon bridge of bamboo and timber to cross the moat. Within moments their forces pressed the wall, set up stone-throwers, and raised siege towers opposite the battlements. Guang had bamboo matting hung like curtains so that when boulders struck they bounced back and inflicted no damage. He fashioned battering beams from banyan trunks, braced them on the parapet to smash the enemy towers, and the rebels pulled back. Liu Yan led the Red-Heart Company in a direct assault on their camp; the rebels feigned retreat, then sprang an ambush and killed him as he pursued. Shigu's main force routed the rebels, who fled the field. Earlier in the siege Qi Fang and his lieutenant had ridden abreast around the walls, directing the placement of siege engines. Guang tied a letter to an arrow and shot it to the lieutenant's feet: "Qi Fang is a doomed outlaw whom heaven will surely destroy—you are born to a general's line; why side with rebels?" The two men began to mistrust each other, the assault slowed, Guang finally had time to prepare his defenses, and relief troops arrived. He kept a dagger in his pillow case and told his household: "The city may fall; if anyone is sent for that dagger, know that I mean to die. You must take your own lives rather than fall into the rebels' hands." He was made Awaiting Draftsman of the Hall of Literary Eminence and prefect of Lin'an.
16
使退 調
In the first month of Shaoxing 1 he was offered Hong Prefecture but firmly declined, accepting instead the sinecure of intendant of the Dongxiao Palace near Lin'an. Named prefect of Wu, he had barely arrived when he was promoted to Vice Minister of Personnel. Guang submitted a long memorial on the evils of faction: "Censors and remonstrators look out for themselves and hold back, unwilling to shoulder the task of saving a dynasty on the brink. The court had been encamped at Kuaiji for three full years. Since last autumn the enemy has shown no sign of crossing south again, yet the Huai frontier lies at our doorstep and goes utterly neglected; the thousand-li Yangzi is undefended; and the court trembles daily over plans to take ship and flee overseas. Emperor Yuan of Jin began with a tiny foothold, yet still restored the altars of state, rebuilt palaces, and held Jiang and Zhe. Liu Kun and Zu Ti fought the northern invaders across Bing, Ji, Yan, Yu, Si, and Yong, and those heartland provinces were never entirely lost. When Shi Hu's main army reached Liyang, the court ordered Wang Dao to command all forces against him—not to preach flight from the barbarians, as our ministers do today. Your Majesty is encamped at Kuaiji while Jiang and Zhe remain our foundation; for a capital where we can advance to fight and retreat to hold, nothing surpasses Jiankang. Jiankang lies one hundred eighty li from Gushu; six choke points can be held—Jiangning Post, Tigeang Shajia, Caishi, Daxin, and upstream Wuhu and Fanchang—all facing Huainan across the river. Elsewhere lie reed marshes and stretches where the current runs too fierce for fleets to pass. We should pre-position troops and grain at each pass, assign officers to sectors, mobilize local militia, and coordinate the defense. I urge Your Majesty to order the senior ministers to study this plan and put it into effect."
17
便
An edict then allowed every prefect to decide for himself whether to hold or flee as the Jurchens advanced. Guang argued: "Local officials hold the lives of the people and the fate of the altars in their hands; they must stand or fall with their posts. Opening an escape route in advance only invites flight; I beg that the earlier edict be withdrawn at once." When the emperor planned to move the court to Lin'an, Guang was ordered to take command of all troops stationed there, while also serving as Vice Minister of Revenue in charge of construction. Guang ran the work frugally and finished every task without troubling the populace. He petitioned to cancel accumulated tax debts in Zhejiang and levies in nine districts, showing that mercy should begin at home. Qi Fang, now under Guang's command, was terrified and kowtowed in the courtyard. Guang took his hand and lifted him up, saying, "Once you were a rebel and I was the prefect—we were fated to stand against each other; now we are both servants of the throne; let us devote ourselves to loyalty and leave the past behind." Fang thanked him through tears. As Lecturer-in-Waiting he added: "Jurchen raids have driven the people to banditry against their will; many can still be won back by honest persuasion. Since Li Cheng fled north the rebel bands have lost cohesion; if we now elevate a few chieftains as examples, the rest will follow and surrender one after another." He was promoted to Minister of Personnel.
18
調 西使 殿使使
General Han Shiqing, a holdover from Miao Fu's mutiny, had camped at Xuancheng for years, seized the granaries, and ignored every requisition. Guang asked leave to deal with him first and was named Pacification Commissioner of Huai West. Guang traveled by a roundabout route to the prefecture; Shiqing came to pay his respects, was seized, sent to the capital, and executed. Earlier Guang had laid his plan before the emperor in person; the chief minister, not having been consulted, was furious. Before he arrived, he was named Academician of the Hall of Bright Clarity, Grand Pacification Commissioner of Jiang East, prefect of Jiankang, and Pacification Commissioner over Shouchun, Chuzhou, Haozhou, Luzhou, Hezhou, and Wuwei. When a Taiping garrison soldier named Lu De imprisoned the prefect and seized the city, Guang devised several stratagems and captured the entire rebel band.
19
滿
After Qin Hui fell, Lü Yihao and Zhu Shengfei shared power as chief ministers—men with whom Guang had long disagreed. Critics denounced him as a Qin Hui partisan; he was demoted to a temple sinecure. He was soon restored as Awaiting Draftsman of the Hall of Literary Treasures and prefect of Hu, made Direct Academician of the Hall of Manifest Counsel, transferred to Pingjiang, and appointed Minister of Rites. Guang observed: "Every dynasty founded or restored has risen from a secure base. Gaozu drew strength from Guanzhong and Guangwu from Henei; with the court in the southeast, are not the two Zhe circuits our natural foundation? Rain and snow had fallen without pause from winter into spring, leaving the people destitute; he asked that censors be sent to verify conditions and report back. Meanwhile banditry had flared in Fujian and Hunan; Fan Ruwei and Yang Yao had risen in succession, and the court's punitive campaigns had slaughtered far too many. Now drought and famine afflict every circuit; beggars choke the highways and bandits roam freely. Send capable officials to win rebels back by kindness, order circuit supervisors to prosecute corruption, and relieve the starving refugees."
20
使 殿
Some ministers wanted to extend Sichuan's jiaozi paper money to Jiang and Zhe; Guang replied, "Jiaozi only works when it is fully backed by coin. They claim a reserve will be set aside while issuing notes regardless—such men would have the court deceive Your Majesty now so that you must deceive the people later. If coin reserves truly exist, the cash notes already in circulation work well enough—why stir up this controversy? As for the copper seal the Ministry of Works cast for the Jiaozi Office, I have refused to release it." He was made Academician of the Hall of Bright Clarity and sent to guard Taizhou, then soon transferred to Wenzhou.
21
西使
Liu Guangshi and Zhang Jun sent news of victory after victory. Guang warned: "From the Jurchens' deployments, someone is clearly directing them. They now hold the southeast's strategic ground; the enemy has marched ten thousand li and needs a quick fight—our generals must be warned to stand firm and wear them down. Within a few months their supplies will run out, and victory will be ours." He was named Pacification Commissioner of Jiang West, prefect of Hong and Grand Commissioner for Military Affairs, promoted to Minister of Personnel, and a month later made Vice Grand Councilor.
22
殿 退 殿
Qin Hui had just finalized the peace treaty and planned to post the public notice; he wanted Guang's prestige to silence opposition. The emperor was reluctant to use him, but Hui argued: "Guang commands public respect; if he countersigns the notice, idle criticism will die down." Guang was brought in. Yang Wei, a fellow townsman, wrote to rebuke him for currying favor with the chief minister, falling into the Jurchens' trap, and betraying his lifelong integrity. Guang had meant only to use the truce as breathing space to rebuild the state. When Hui then proposed stripping Huainan's garrisons and disarming the generals, Guang protested fiercely that the northern tribes are treacherous by nature, peace cannot be trusted, and defenses must not be dismantled. Hui came to hate him. When Hui appointed his protégé Zheng Yinian to the Hall for Assisting Governance, Guang openly rebuked the move before the emperor and again confronted Hui in court: "Hui means to blind Your Majesty, seize state power, and ruin the country through treachery—you must see through him." Hui flew into a rage; the next day Guang asked to resign. Gaozong said, "Yesterday you scolded Qin Hui to his face—you acted like the statesmen of old. I withdrew and sighed; I had just begun to trust you with my innermost counsels—why leave now?" Guang replied, "I have quarreled openly with the chief minister—I cannot stay." After nine memorials he was made Academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance and prefect of Shaoxing, then reassigned as intendant of the Dongxiao Palace.
23
使 便 殿
In the winter of the eleventh year, Censor Moqi Xie charged him with brooding resentment; he was demoted to Vice Military Commissioner of Jianning and exiled to Teng Prefecture. Four years later he was moved to Qiong Prefecture. After eight years on Qiong Island, his second son Mengjian was convicted on Lu Shengzhi's false charge of writing an unauthorized history; Lü Yuanzhong then accused him of exchanging poems with Hu Quan that mocked the government, and he was banished farther to Changhua. He devoted himself to scholarship and history, serene in exile. Past eighty, his writing remained vigorous. Three years later an amnesty restored him to Left Grandee for Court Audience with permission to live where he pleased. He reached Jiang Prefecture and died there. When Xiaozong ascended the throne, Guang was posthumously restored as Academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance and given the posthumous title Zhuangjian (Solemn and Simple).
24
稿稿
Mengchuan, styled Wenshou, was Guang's youngest son. When Guang was exiled south, the boy was only six. Thanks to his father's final petition he rose to Vice Director of the Imperial Treasury. When Han Tuozhou asked to meet him, Mengchuan replied, "I am sixty and have already decided to retire—I will not answer such a summons." For this he was posted out as prefect of Jiang Prefecture. He retired with the titles Grandee for Court Audience and Direct Academician of the Hall of Treasured Counsel. He died at eighty. His works included Panxi Poems (20 juan), Draft Writings (30 juan), Hongci Leigao (10 juan), Zuoshi Explanations (10 juan), Reading History (10 juan), and Miscellaneous Records (10 juan). Learned and rigorous in conduct, contemporaries hailed him as worthy to carry on his father's legacy.
25
調
Xu Han, styled Songlao, was a native of Xiangyi in Gong Prefecture. He took the jinshi degree in the third year of the Yuanyou reign. In the seventh year of Xuanhe he was recalled as Supervising Secretary. He wrote the chief minister warning that the people were destitute, turning to banditry, and the empire stood on the brink of collapse. He urged an end to the Yunzhong campaign, secure the frontier, and give the people respite. When Goryeo sent tribute, the court conscripted labor to dredge the canal and the countryside erupted in protest. Drafting Secretary Sun Fu argued that Goryeo had done the state no good and that such grand projects were unwarranted; Sun was dismissed for his pains. Han protested that Sun should not have been punished; the chief minister was furious, stripped Han of office, and sent him to oversee the Taiping Abbey in Jiang Prefecture.
26
退 使西使 使 殿
At the start of the Jingkang era he was again summoned as Supervising Secretary. The Jurchens had just lifted their siege of the capital; Han presented himself at court, was granted an audience that same day, made Hanlin Academician, and soon promoted to Censor-in-Chief. He memorialized on frontier affairs and laid out a plan for victory. When Chen Bangchang was named Grand Steward, Han submitted a fierce protest. When Zhong Shidao was demoted to palace commissioner, Han protested: "Shidao is a renowned general, steady and resourceful; the Shanxi troops trust him completely—do not strip him of command." Qinzong said the general was too old; Han replied, "Qin Shihuang thought Wang Jian too aged and sent the young Li Xin instead—and his army was humiliated in Chu; Emperor Xuan of Han thought Zhao Chongguo too old, yet Zhao still won the Golden City campaign. Since the Duke of Zhou's day, victories won by veteran generals are too many to count on two hands. Judging by history, Shidao may be old, but he is still the man for the job." He added: "This Jurchen campaign is a matter of life or death for the dynasty; one crushing blow that drives them off will preserve the Central Plain and awe the frontier peoples. Otherwise, when they return, the realm may face disaster beyond remedy. He urged that Shidao be recalled to intercept and attack them." The emperor would not heed him. He was raised to Palace Attendant and made Vice Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs, but his counsel increasingly clashed with the court's; pleading illness, he withdrew and was given the Yankang Hall academician title and made prefect of Bo. Denounced for his outspokenness, he was stripped of office and sent to oversee the Hongqing Palace at the Southern Capital.
27
殿 殿 祿
In the first year of Shaoxing he was recalled as Duanming Hall academician and intendant of Wanshou Abbey, but he refused the summons. In the second month he was restored as Zizheng Hall academician. In the fifth month of the third year he died and was posthumously made Grand Mentor of the Palace.
28
Han was versed in the classics, upright and unbending; across three reigns he rose to the highest councils, yet Wang Fu, Cai You, Huang Qianshan, and men of their stripe—fragrant and foul mingled—set loose calumny against him, and his designs were never fulfilled. Li Gang had pressed hard for his return, but Han withdrew almost at once; he too was hounded from office and died in exile. His works included Explanations of the Analects and a Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals.
29
Xu Jingheng
30
殿 使
Xu Jingheng, styled Shaoyi, was a native of Li'an in Wen Prefecture. He took the jinshi degree in the ninth year of the Yuanyou reign. In the sixth year of Xuanhe he was recalled as Investigating Censor and soon promoted to Palace Attending Censor. Wang Fu and Cai You then held sway; Jingheng said, "The Department of State Affairs has gone too long without a chief minister, and the Vice Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs has likewise stood empty. Though the Three Excellencies may nominally oversee all three departments, civil affairs have their foundation at Wenchang and military affairs at the Bureau of Military Affairs—each has its proper sphere; how can these posts stand empty for long? I urge that public counsel be gathered widely and loyal worthies chosen to fill the vacancies at court." This deeply enraged Wang Fu. The court appointed Tong Guan Commissioner for Pacification of Hedong and Hebei in preparation for a northern campaign; Jingheng listed dozens of reasons why his greed and incompetence disqualified him—but no reply came.
31
After the Fang La rebellion was put down, Jiang and Zhe prefectures lay in ruins, yet the tea-and-salt quota comparison system remained unchanged. Jingheng submitted: "Tea-and-salt levies ought to rise and fall with the number of consumers. Now that the region has been recovered, household registers are half empty and the people exhausted, yet the comparative quotas are no lower than before. How can the people escape distress?" The memorial reached the throne; an edict temporarily suspended tea-and-salt comparisons in the Two Zhes and Jiangdong circuits, to resume only when banditry had fully subsided.
32
調 婿
After the court launched the Yan-Yun campaign, logistics faltered and exactions grew ever harsher. Jingheng wrote: "Fiscal exhaustion demands frugality; popular exhaustion demands compassion. Yet non-urgent spending abounds. Palace repairs, the Huashi Convoy, and the like go under countless names. The civil bureaucracy is swollen and military rolls padded beyond measure. Unmerited rewards and extraordinary favors are seized through patronage and chance, with endless requests—cut them back to fit the ancestral statutes." He also laid bare the harm of compulsory purchase, state grain levy, and the salt monopoly—and again received no answer. Meanwhile Wu Yanfu, prefect of Yang, wrote privately to a chief minister's son praising Jingheng's talents. It was forwarded through his nephew-in-law Zhou Liheng, Keeper of the Talismans—but Liheng mistakenly delivered it to Wang Fu, who seized on the incident to ruin Jingheng and had him dismissed.
33
When Qinzong ascended the throne Jingheng was summoned as Left Remonstrator, soon made Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and concurrent Tutor of the Heir Apparent, then promoted to Drafting Secretary. Attending Censor Li Guang and Remonstrator Cheng Yu, bold and upright, had offended the chief ministers and been driven out; Jingheng defended them, was stripped of office, and given a temple sinecure.
34
When Gaozong came to the throne Jingheng was recalled as Supervising Secretary and, on arrival, made Censor-in-Chief. Zong Ze served as regent of the Eastern Capital; critics aligned with Huang Qianshan and his faction piled on his faults, seeking his removal. Jingheng wrote: "Since I crossed the Huai from Zhe to reach the Mobile Court, I have heard of Ze's tenure—his renown and governance plainly surpass all others; though I have never met him, I must admire him from afar. Had loyal men like Ze stood in the capital last winter, the catastrophe might never have grown so cruel. To harp on petty faults and ignore his devotion to the realm would be wanton cruelty. Kaifeng holds the imperial tombs and altars; if Ze is removed, is there any among the court officials whose renown and governance exceed his?" The memorial reached the emperor, who was deeply moved, sealed it and sent it to Ze, who was thereby reassured.
35
西
When the Hangzhou mutineer Chen Tong rebelled, Acting Zhexi Judicial Intendant Zhao Shujin induced his surrender and asked that he be given an official post. Jingheng said, "Innocent officials were put to death, while guilty mutineers are rewarded—never was reward and punishment so perverted." He memorialized against it and the appointment was halted. He was made Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. On weighty matters of state he always sought a private audience to speak his mind fully. Huang Qianshan and Wang Boyan, seeing Jingheng as an opponent, combined to thwart him at every turn. Some urged that at the turn of the first and second months—the day when the Great Unity star shifted position—the palace should erect an altar and worship it. Gaozong asked Jingheng, who replied, "Cultivate virtue and love the people, and Heaven sends blessing of its own—why bow to the Great Unity star?"
36
使 殿
Early on Li Gang ranked capitals: Guanzhong first, Nanyang second, Jianye last. Once in office, he pressed for Nanyang. As Censor-in-Chief, Jingheng wrote: "Nanyang has no natural defenses, lies too close to bandit country, and cannot sustain canal supply—Jianye's terrain is far stronger; I urge a settled plan to move the court there." Huang Qianshan and his allies ousted Li Gang, and the Nanyang plan died. Then scouts reported Jurchen attacks on Heyang and Sishui, and Jingheng again urged a southern move to Jianye. Soon an edict ordered the court back to the capital; Jingheng was demoted to Zizheng Hall Grand Academician and sent to oversee the Dongxiao Abbey in Hangzhou. At Guazhou he was stricken with heatstroke; he died at Jingkou, aged fifty-seven, and was posthumously titled Loyal and Simple.
37
Jingheng studied under Cheng Yi; his intent was loyal and pure, and he would not trim his counsel to the fashion of the day. Early in Jianyan Li Gang favored Nanyang, Zong Ze urged a return to the capital, and Jingheng pressed for Jianye. Huang Qianshan and his faction had long resented his independence; when the court paused at Yangzhou, frightened by rumor, they reluctantly issued the edict to return north—then seized on his counsel to cross the Yangzi as a pretext to purge him, and he died in exile. After his death Gaozong mused, "Since my enthronement, of all who served loyally and spoke boldly on the affairs of state, only Xu Jingheng." He ordered a government residence in Wenzhou granted to Jingheng's family.
38
使 便 便
Zhang Que, styled Chengbo, was a native of Lesou in Hejian. He took the jinshi in the sixth year of the Yuanyou reign. He rose through promotion to Longtu Pavilion academician and Director of Aggregate Transport Commissaries. When Gaozong was Grand Marshal rallying troops from every circuit, Que drove supply wagons in an unbroken stream and proposed that the marshal's office issue salt certificates on the spot to keep commerce moving. Within ten days he raised five hundred thousand strings of cash for the war chest. Gaozong relied on him heavily and gave him discretionary authority as acting Prefect of Daming, Northern Capital regent, and Grand Commander of Horse and Foot. When Que first learned the two emperors had been carried north, he led Deputy Commander Yan Qi and others in submitting three memorials urging Gaozong to take the throne. Finally Que wrote at length that the Central Plain could not endure a single day without an emperor—and Gaozong was deeply moved.
39
使 使
With the Jianyan reign he became Minister of Revenue, then Vice Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs, commissioner for fiscal arrangements, and deputy commissioner of the Imperial Camp. He proposed: "The people of the Three Rivers— bear hatred for the foe to the bone and long to annihilate them to avenge the dynasty. Following the Tang examples of the Zelu foot soldiers and the frontier militia of the Xiongbian, I propose organizing the people in tens and fives, soldiers nested among farmers, jointly resisting the enemy—called Patrol Communities." His regulations were so thorough that no earlier militia plan could equal them. An edict ordered them compiled into a handbook and put into practice. He was promoted to Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and eventually reached Secretariat Vice Director.
40
Que excelled at finance; on revenue and grain he spoke as if reading from his palm. In council he was forthright and possessed a great minister's bearing, yet on matters of dispute he showed neither face nor temper, and never lost the goodwill of his colleagues. He died and was posthumously titled Loyal and Solemn. The emperor often recalled him, saying Que served the realm with complete loyalty and dared speak bluntly on public affairs—an upright man in the mold of antiquity.
41
使
Zhang Suo was a native of Qingzhou. He took the jinshi degree and rose to Investigating Censor. On Gaozong's enthronement Suo was sent to inspect the imperial tombs; on his return he memorialized: "Hedong and Hebei are the empire's foundation. Misguided ministers led us first to cede the Three Prefectures, then the Two Rivers; the people there resent it to the marrow, and every hand still clenches in grief. If we rally them now, they can hold the north for us; otherwise the soldiers and people of the Two Rivers will lose all hope, and Your Majesty's cause is lost." He also laid out five advantages of returning to the capital, arguing that a realm's fate depends on the strength of its armies and the quality of its generals and ministers—not on where the court sits. He also submitted a detailed account of the Two Rivers' strategic interests. The emperor meant to entrust the affair to Suo, but Suo had denounced Huang Qianshan as treacherous and unfit for office, which might sabotage the new government. Suo was therefore removed from the censorate and made a bureau secretary in the Ministry of War. Soon he was demoted to Regiment Vice Commander of Fengzhou and exiled to Jiangzhou.
42
使 使 西便
Later, when Li Gang became chief minister, he wanted to appoint Suo to oversee the Two Rivers but hesitated because Suo had once denounced Huang Qianshan. One day he spoke to Huang Qianshan at ease: "Hebei has no capable man left but Zhang Suo—and he languishes in exile for blunt words. We have no choice but to wipe the slate clean and send him as pacification commissioner to risk his life for merit and redeem his fault—would that not serve us well?" Huang Qianshan agreed; Suo was lent the title Direct Academician of the Dragon Diagram Pavilion and made Hebei Pacification Commissioner. He was granted a million strings from the inner treasury and more than a thousand blank commission notices; three thousand Western Capital troops as his escort, with authority to appoint his own staff and act entirely at his discretion. On audience Zhang Suo laid out the strategic advantages and risks point by point. The emperor bestowed fifth-rank robes and dispatched him, appointing Wang Gui of the Direct Secretariat Pavilion as planning officer on the Pacification Commission to assist him.
43
使 西 使
Zhang Yiqian, vice commissioner of Hebei transport, sided with Huang Qianshan and memorialized that the commission should not have been set up at the Northern Capital; and argued that banditry in Hebei had only worsened since the pacification office was created; it would be better to abolish it and leave the matter entirely to the military command. Li Gang said, "Zhang Suo is still in the capital recruiting officers and has not yet departed—how can Yiqian already know he is causing trouble? The court set up the pacification commission because displaced people in Hebei had nowhere to go and turned to banditry, so that their strength might be turned to the state's use—how could the commission itself have created the bandits? Bandits now roam openly through the Eastern and Western Capital circuits, raiding prefectures and counties—surely that is not the pacification commission's fault either? The realm is in grave peril and the court is trying to set things right; Yiqian is a minor official, yet he obstructs us without cause—someone must be putting him up to it." The emperor ordered Yiqian to submit a written explanation and sent the matter to the Bureau of Military Affairs, but Wang Boyan still used Yiqian's memorial to rebuke the pacification commission. Li Gang and Wang Boyan disputed the matter before the throne, and Boyan had no reply.
44
Suo was just recruiting bold men, appointing Wang Yan overall commander and Yue Fei preparation general, when Li Gang was already removed from the chief ministership. The court replaced him with Wang Gui; Suo lost his Direct Dragon Diagram Pavilion title and was exiled to Lingnan. He died in exile. His son Zongben was given office on Yue Fei's recommendation.
45
殿
Chen He, courtesy name Xiushi, was from Yin County in Ming Prefecture. He earned the jinshi degree in 1100, the third year of Yuanfu. He rose through successive appointments to Erudite of the Imperial University. Scholarship then prized glosses and rote interrogation; He was among the first to champion moral principle and to reject mere ornament. In audience he pleased the throne and was promoted to investigating censor and then palace censor.
46
使 婿
Cai Jing dispatched the ruthless Li Xiaoshou to prosecute the Zhang Sui counterfeiting case to the end, sweeping up a host of gentlemen; He memorialized for Xiaoshou's removal. He exposed and secured the dismissal of Cai Jing's son Huang as Vice Director of the Imperial Ancestral Shrine and of He Zhizhong's son-in-law Cai Zhi as Director of Palace Construction. Long peace had left the empire's defenses slack, nowhere more so than in the southeast. He urged stronger garrisons and repairs to the walls against unforeseen danger. Critics charged him with stirring trouble, and the memorial was shelved. When bandits later rose, many marveled at his foresight. He was made Left Rectifier and soon appointed Supervising Secretary.
47
使
Tong Guan's influence was swelling; he and Huang Jingchen ran the government together while Censor-in-Chief Lu Hang abetted them from within—court gentlemen watched in alarm. He said, "This strikes at the very root of the state's safety. My office is to speak out. If I stay silent on this now, once I become supervising secretary I will no longer be charged with such remonstrance." Before even accepting the new post, he led with a bold memorial impeaching Tong Guan. He also impeached Huang Jingchen: "He leans on imperial favor to play with power and struts before the court. He brags that every edict passes through his hands, predicts whom the emperor will appoint or what he will decree, and when the order appears it matches his boast to the letter. To proclaim commands and wield the great power of appointing and dismissing is the emperor's alone—why should palace eunuchs have any part in it? My worry is not Huang Jingchen alone. Open this door and imitators will crowd in; the state's ruin may prove unstoppable. Exile him at once to the far marches."
48
便
Before he finished, the emperor rose and turned away. He seized the emperor's robe and begged leave to finish. The hem tore away. The emperor said, "Rectifier, you have torn Our robe." He replied, "If Your Majesty does not value a torn robe, how could your servant value his own life in answering you? They gain wealth and power today; Your Majesty will face ruin tomorrow." His words grew fiercer. The emperor's face changed. "If you speak thus," he said, "what have I to fear?" Attendants urged a change of robe; the emperor refused: "Leave it to commemorate an honest remonstrator." Next day Tong Guan and his circle filed complaints, insisting the realm was perfectly governed and calling such speech ill-omened. Lu Hang memorialized that He was reckless; he was banished to supervise the state wine monopoly at Xinzhou. An amnesty allowed him to return home.
49
Earlier Chen Guan, back from exile in the far south, settled at Yin, befriended He, and sent his son Zhenghui to study under him. Later Zhenghui denounced Cai Jing's crimes and was marched to the capital; Guan was arrested as well. Huang Jingchen presided over the trial and summoned He to testify. He admitted the facts and refused to evade blame. Some said he had answered badly. He said, "Life and death are ordained. How can I buy off injustice with my life? I would gladly share the punishment of a worthy man." He was dismissed as a partisan of Chen Guan.
50
An amnesty restored him; he governed Guangde Army, then Hezhou. He then mourned his mother; after the mourning period he was made prefect of Xiuzhou. When Wang Fu newly rose to power, He said, "How can I serve under Wang Fu's patronage?" He pressed his refusal and was reassigned to Ruzhou. He refused all the more firmly: "I would rather starve." Wang Fu took offense. His elder brother Bingshi served as academic instructor at Shouchun; He lived with him in his official quarters. Tong Guan happened to lead troops past the prefecture. He denied him an audience and refused his gifts. Tong Guan complained to the throne. The emperor said, "He has always been this way—can you not bear him?" At length he was appointed prefect of Shuzhou but died before taking up the post. He was posthumously honored as Grandee of Palace Attendance with the posthumous title Wénjiè (Cultured and Upright).
51
He would not trim to others' convenience; in office he stood rigidly upright in character. His writings included a nine-scroll Commentary on the Changes, a twelve-scroll Commentary on the Spring and Autumn, and ten-scroll exegeses each of the Analects and Mencius.
52
殿 使
Jiang You, courtesy name Zhongyuan, was from Jintan in Run Prefecture. He passed the civil service examination. In 1114 he became Vice Censor-in-Chief and Palace Reader, earning a name for fearless speech. He once deplored how shallow court morals had grown: officials read their superiors' moods, took their cue from the chief ministers' preferences, and mocked anyone who stood alone as a fool—such habits, he said, must not be indulged; that when chief ministers reported to the throne they chorused agreement without true debate, violating the rite of frank counsel; that the Inner Palace Service escaped censorial oversight, marring the Yuanfeng bureaucratic order; that Yang Jian should not have been made a military commissioner; and that Zhao Liangsi had no business coming and going within the inner palace. The emperor accepted every point, posted his memorial inside the Inner Palace Service, and decreed that eunuchs must never again seek military commissions. He also exposed the corrupt dealings of Meng Changling, Xu Zhu, and others. He was promoted to Minister of War and detailed deliberator of the Rites Reform Bureau. In the seventh year he oversaw the metropolitan examination, then became Minister of Works and Minister of Personnel.
53
As Academician of the Hall of Lofty Principles he governed Wuzhou. The following year he sought a temple posting and retired home. Late in the Xuanhe era he was recalled as Minister of Justice and companion to the Heir Apparent at the Hall of Exemplary Worth. Early in the Jingkang crisis he attended the Retired Emperor at Huaiyin and won a special edict demoting Tong Guan. Jiang You memorialized that Tong Guan had forfeited the world's trust and begged his banishment to the far marches. The Retired Emperor agreed and at once proclaimed the edict, pressing Tong Guan to his place of exile. He then escorted the Retired Emperor to the capital, was made Minister of War again, and rose to Rectifying Grandee. Citing illness, he was granted academician rank and made overseer of the Chongfu Palace on Mount Song. He died. He was posthumously honored as Special Advancement.
54
使
The commentators say: When the realm is drowning in flame, nothing matters more than putting the right men in place. The calamities of Jingkang and Jianyan were worse than any flood or fire. The empire was not short of talent, yet national shame went unavenged—was this not because men were not truly entrusted with power to act? Li Guang was gifted and farsighted and won acclaim wherever he served; Xu Han and Xu Jingheng spoke with piercing force; Zhang Que excelled at finance; Zhang Suo knew the strategic situation in Hebei through and through: each was a leading man of his day. Had these men been heeded and not thwarted by slander, allowed to carry out their aims, results should have followed in due course. Yet some were exiled to die in obscurity, others used but never to the full; though fortune governs empires, the cultivated man cannot wholly excuse the ruler's failure to employ them rightly. Jiang You served five reigns, fled when Jianyan began, and died in retirement—little here to commend. Chen He seized the emperor's robe and spoke his fill in the manner of remonstrators of old; his deeds antedated Xuanhe, and only under Xiaozong was he finally honored with a posthumous title.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →