← Back to 宋史

卷三百七十七 列傳第一百三十六 向子諲 陳規 季陵 盧知原 陳桷 李璆 李朴 王庠 王衣

Volume 377 Biographies 136: Xiang Zi Yin, Chen Gui, Ji Ling, Lu Zhiyuan, Chen Jue, Li Qiu, Li Pu, Wang Xiang, Wang Yi

Chapter 377 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 377
Next Chapter →
1
Xiang Ziyin
2
Xiang Ziyin, styled Bogong, was from Linjiang. He was the great-great-grandson of Minzhong and a grandnephew of Empress Qinsheng Xiansu. In the third year of the Yuanfu era, he received an appointment as acting Gentleman for Court Service through the empress's grace for the restoration of the imperial residence, and after three promotions became magistrate of Xianping County in Kaifeng Prefecture. When a powerful local bully used his influence to break the law, Ziyin completed the case and submitted it, but Prefect Sheng Zhang—hoping for a reward for empty prisons—refused to accept it. Ziyin reported the matter, and the court authorized him to decide the case himself. Zhang was furious and impeached him on other grounds, forcing his suspension.
3
使 使
At the beginning of the Xuanhe era, his office was restored and he was appointed chief clerk of the Jiang-Huai Transport Commission. Huainan suffered drought year after year, blocking grain transport. Some proposed dredging the canal to bring it level with the Yangzi and Huai, and a eunuch championed the idea; no one dared approve or reject it. The Transport Commission dispatched Ziyin to investigate. Ziyin said, "From the Yangzi to the Huai is several hundred li, and the canal stands several zhang above the Yangzi and Huai. To dredge it level is absolutely impossible. Formerly officials opened the sluices once every three days and built storage basins, so water was never lacking. In recent years the direct-transport system was implemented; with tribute missions coming and going, sluices were opened and closed without restraint, and dams and gates were mostly gone. If we restore the old system now and enforce strict regulations, there will be no trouble." The commissioner adopted his advice, transport was restored, and he was promoted one rank. Summoned for audience, he was appointed transport intendant of Huainan. Because the Ministry of Revenue reported that various circuits failed to meet tribute quotas, he was demoted one rank.
4
使
He was transferred to Direct Associate of the Longtu Hall and deputy transport commissioner of the Jiang-Huai route. Ziyin said, "Last year Liu Shun received the wax-sealed edict of the Deposed Sage Emperor ordering circuit commissioners and prefectural commanders to raise troops to rescue the throne. I immediately had it carved on boards and dispatched proclamations throughout my jurisdiction, yet among the six circuits there was not a single response; where groups were mustered and sent out, it was like child's play, merely to evade responsibility. Only on the Huaidong route did I personally lead the various offices and roughly establish discipline. Yet the various offices still hoarded money and goods and would not supply them, utterly heedless that the sovereign and father languished within a besieged city; at the time I wished I had a sharp blade to put to their necks. Now the capital has fallen and the two emperors have been driven into exile. If rewards and punishments are not enforced, I fear the Jurchens will again threaten the borders. When Your Majesty again wishes to raise troops from all under Heaven, the various circuits will cling to old habits and know no fear—what will you rely on to overcome hardship? I hope Your Majesty will clearly order the great ministers to investigate and impeach circuit commissioners who received the wax-sealed edict but shelved it and did not march to rescue the throne, and those who claimed to march but delayed—all should be clearly dismissed." An order was issued for the judicial commissioners of each circuit to investigate and report. In the ninth month Ziyin was dismissed, because he had long been favored by Li Gang, and so Huang Qianshan removed him.
5
The next year he was appointed prefect of Xiqing Prefecture, but the roads were blocked and he could not go. Earlier, when Zhang Bangchang served as Grand Councilor of State and Military Affairs, Ziyin requested retirement to avoid him; because of remonstrators he was demoted three ranks, then recalled to serve as prefect of Tanzhou. Garrison soldiers mutinied, set fires and plundered the market, and went out to Liuyang County; Ziyin sent Vice Prefect Meng Yanqing and others to pursue them to You County and pacify them.
6
西 使
When the Jurchens broke through Jiangxi and shifted troops to Hunan, Ziyin heard the alarm and led soldiers and civilians in a death-defying defense. The imperial clansman Chengzhong Lang Yu, assigned to the eastern wall, was on the wall when Ziyin made the rounds; turning to him he said, "You are of the imperial clan—you must not imitate these men in their lax ways." Yu was moved to tears. After the Jurchens besieged for eight days, they mounted the wall and set fires; Ziyin led officials and clerks to break through the South Chu Gate and flee, and the city fell. He was punished with dismissal from office for failing to hold the city when the enemy arrived. Deputy transport commissioner Jia Shou reported that Ziyin had directed troops in street fighting and also gathered routed soldiers to return and conduct affairs; the emperor also considered that Ziyin was in a different category from other defending officials who fled at the first sign of danger, and ordered his office restored.
7
使 退 使
An edict appointed him to administer the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou. Hu An'guo was then taking refuge in Hunan and wrote to Qin Hui, saying, "Ziyin is loyal and steadfast and can uphold the Three Bonds; I hope you will pity him for falling into the hands of bandits when there was no rescue, and restore and employ him again." He was recalled to serve as prefect of Guangzhou. At the time they feared bandits would cross the mountains, and so Ziyin was immediately put in charge of the defense. Again because of remonstrators he was dismissed and then retired. Soon he was recalled as prefect of Jiangzhou, then changed to transport commissioner of Jiangdong, and promoted to Compiler of the Secret Archive. Jiangdong was to supply Liu Guangshi's army; just then Liu Yu invaded, Guangshi's army was at Hefei, and reporting lack of provisions he quickly withdrew. Ziyin galloped to Hefei, fully inspected the grain and reported; Guangshi was thereby found guilty. He was promoted to Awaiting Draftsman of the Huayou Hall. He was transferred to the Two-Zhe circuit as chief transport commissioner and appointed Vice Minister of Revenue.
8
退 退 使
On entering audience he discussed old affairs of the capital, touching considerably on rare treasures. Attendant Gentleman Pan Lianggui had been friendly with Ziyin and was very angry on hearing his words. Then Ziyin memorialized on the Jin state's return embassy and the offering for Zhu Zhen, going on at length. Lianggui went straight to the front of the couch and sternly rebuked him, "Ziyin should not weary the sacred ear with useless talk for so long." Ziyin wished to withdraw; the emperor said to Lianggui, "It was I who asked him." He again instructed Ziyin to speak at length. Ziyin spoke again and would not stop; Lianggui twice ordered him to withdraw; the emperor's expression changed and he wished to punish Lianggui. Censor-in-Chief Chang Tong said, "Lianggui is not guilty; I hope Ziyin may be permitted to serve outside the capital." The emperor was angry with Tong as well; Zhang Jiucheng said, "The reason scholars esteem Ziyin is that he cares deeply for good men. Now because of Ziyin you dismiss the Censor and again dismiss the Central Secretariat censor—this is not the way to show affection for Ziyin." The emperor's mind was somewhat eased; he annotated and instructed Tong, but Tong would not stop speaking, and so all three were dismissed. Ziyin served as Direct Academician of the Huayou Hall and prefect of Pingjiang Prefecture. When Jin envoys came to discuss peace and were about to enter the border, Ziyin refused to bow to the Jin edict; he then submitted a memorial saying, "Since antiquity sovereigns have humbled themselves to make peace with barbarians, but never have I heard of anything worse than at this time—it should be refused and not accepted." This offended Qin Hui's intent, and he retired.
9
退
Ziyin was a son of a prime minister's family and was able to discipline himself and make himself seen in his time. He was affectionate toward his younger brothers, established a charity estate, and supported poor clansmen. When he first transported grain in Huainan, Zhang Bangchang's false edict arrived; the magistrate of Hong County and those below welcomed it, bowed, and proclaimed it as usual, but only Military Retainer Xu Duanyi refused to bow and fled. When the affair was settled, Ziyin reported to the court and had Duanyi's civil rank changed. In retirement for fifteen years, he called his residence "Xianglin." He died at age sixty-eight.
10
使
Chen Gui, styled Yuanze, was from Anqiu in Mizhou. He passed the Mingfa examination. At the end of the Jingkang era the Jurchens invaded; they killed Military Commissioner of the Zhenhai Army Liu Yanqing, and his followers Zhu Jin and Wang Zai went off as bandits, raiding Sui, Ying, Fu, and other prefectures. Gui was magistrate of Anlu and led rescue-the-throne troops toward Bian; reaching Cai Prefecture, the roads were blocked and he returned. Just then Zhu Jin attacked De'an Prefecture; the prefect abandoned the city and fled, and the elders asked Gui to act as defender. Gui sent archer Zhang Li to lead troops against Jin and repulsed him. Later at Fu he joined with Jin; they used catapults and siege towers to attack the east gate. Gui repeatedly defeated them in battle, and the two men feared and withdrew with their forces.
11
使 西
At the time Sang Zhong plundered between Xiang and Han; his deputy Huo Ming stationed troops at Ying. Gui requested of the court that Ming be put in charge of Ying. Zhang Jun was grand coordinator on the Shu route; Zhong led troops to spy on him and was defeated by Wang Yan. Zhong was angry and came with several hundred horsemen to reproach Ming; Ming killed him, fled to Liu Yu, and sent a letter to recruit Gui; Gui shackled the messenger and reported it. Li Heng besieged the city, built sky-bridges, filled the moat, and with drums and shouts pressed the walls. Gui led soldiers and civilians in defense; a catapult wounded his foot, but his expression did not change. The siege grew urgent and provisions were exhausted; he spent his family wealth to reward the army, and morale rose still more. Heng sent someone saying he wished to obtain a courtesan and would then withdraw the army; Gui would not agree. The generals said, "The city has been besieged seventy days; to save a whole city with one woman—would that not do?" Gui ultimately would not give her. When the moat bridge collapsed, Gui took sixty men with fire-lances out the west gate, burned the sky-bridge, and used fire-oxen to assist; in an instant all was destroyed, and Heng withdrew his camp.
12
沿使 使
He was promoted to Direct Academician of the Huayou Hall; an edict ordered him to the temporary capital; he was changed to Direct Academician of the Xianmo Hall and transferred as prefect of Chizhou and river pacification commissioner. On entering audience he first said, "Pacification commissioners should be abolished; the generals are overbearing—please use junior officers to divide their power." The emperor accepted all of it. He was transferred to Direct Academician of the Longtu Hall and changed to prefect of Luzhou; soon he was again summoned to the temporary capital, but citing illness he declined and was appointed to administer the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou. He was again recalled as prefect of De'an Prefecture; for failure to supervise officials he was reduced two ranks.
13
退 使 退
When the Jurchens returned Henan territory, he was changed to prefect of Shunchang Prefecture, repaired walls, recruited refugees, and established mutual-security groups. When Liu Qi led troops passing through the prefecture on the way to the capital garrison, Gui went out to welcome him; before they had sat long, word came that the Jurchens had entered the capital. He immediately told Qi the city had tens of thousands of hu of grain and urged a joint plan for a death-defying defense. Together they mounted the wall to plan, assigned generals to guard the four gates, clarified scouts, and recruited local guides and spies. When deployment was roughly complete, Jin scouting cavalry were already close to the city. When they arrived, the Jin Prince of Gold and Tiger arrived with heavy troops in succession; Gui personally donned armor and, with Qi, patrolled the wall directing battle, shooting with the divine arm bow; they slightly withdrew, then infantry intercepted and many drowned in the river. Gui said, "The enemy's will has been repeatedly broken; they will surely think to use stratagems to trap us. Better to send troops secretly to cut their camp so they cannot rest day or night—this can preserve our sharpness." Qi agreed; they indeed raided the center of their camp and destroyed very many of their troops. The Jurchens urgently reported to Wuzhu. Gui gave a great feast to the officers and soldiers; halfway through the wine he asked, "Wuzhu is coming with elite troops—what plan shall we adopt?" Some generals said that having already won repeatedly, they should take advantage and withdraw the whole army. Gui said, "The court has maintained troops for fifteen years precisely for emergencies; moreover we have repeatedly broken their edge and military renown has somewhat revived. I have already allotted myself to death—advance is death and retreat is death; better to advance in loyalty." Qi rebuked the generals, "The prefect is a civil official yet swears to die defending—how much more you! Moreover the Jin camp is nearly thirty li away; when Wuzhu comes to aid, if our army moves the Jurchens will pursue, the old and young will first fall into disorder, and we will surely be thrown into confusion—not only wasting prior achievement and bringing the Two Huai into disturbance, but also shaking Jiang and Zhe. Repaying the sovereign in life yet becoming one who harms the state—better to fight with one's back to the wall and seek life within death." Soon Wuzhu arrived, personally walked the wall, and rebuked the chiefs for military errors; the crowd knelt and said, "Southern troops are not as before." Wuzhu ordered breakfast in the prefectural courtyard, broke arrows in oath, combined more than a hundred thousand troops to attack the city, and personally led three thousand Iron Floating Tower troops in mobile attack. Gui and Qi walked the wall, encouraged and roused the generals; stray arrows reached their clothes yet they showed no fear, and the army fought to the death. It was then intense summer heat; Gui told Qi not to send out too many troops, but only to rotate units and change weapons, using rest to overcome fatigue—they would surely win. Each morning he held the walls and did not go out, waiting until Jin troops were exposed in the blazing sun; by the hour of wei their strength was exhausted, then city troops competed in valor, killing and capturing beyond count, and Wuzhu fled by night. Qi reported achievement; an edict praised and instructed him, and he was transferred to Direct Academician of the Privy Council. When Gui reached Shunchang, he immediately bought grain and wheat widely to fill the granaries. The Accounting Bureau moved grain to the river; Gui requested substituting gold and silk for transport, and at this time it was put to use—what made Qi's achievement was having sufficient food.
14
西
He was transferred as prefect of Luzhou and concurrently Huai'an pacification commissioner; once he arrived, illness set in. There was an order to repair the prefectural walls; Gui was on sick leave, and clerks brought documents into his bedchamber; Gui forced himself up and said, "Command matters—the staff officer shall direct them; the prefectural walls—the vice prefect shall direct them." When he finished speaking he died, age seventy. He was posthumously given Right Regular Policy Grandee. His Attack-and-Defense Strategy was transmitted in the world.
15
仿 滿 使
Earlier, when Gui defended De'an, he once submitted in detail matters of garrison-colony fields, wishing to follow the ancient garrison-colony system, combining archers, militia, and soldiers to divide land for cultivation. Fields garrisoned by soldiers all established fortresses at strategic passes; when bandits came the forts gathered to defend, when there was peace they farmed in season, and archers all divided half their time to farm colony fields. For fields operated by civilian households, paddy fields paid one dou of polished rice per mu, dry fields paid five sheng each of wheat and beans. After three full years without arrears, the land was granted as permanent property. Refugees who returned of themselves had fields returned to them. All colony-field matters were jointly handled by the Colony Field Bureau; colony-field affairs were jointly handled by prefectural and county officials, without adding new officials; he listed items and reported, and an edict praised and rewarded him and still sent his method down to the various garrisons. Since the Shaoxing era, among civil pacification commissioners with martial renown, only Gui.
16
Gui was dignified and resolute, sparing of words and laughter, yet treated people with ease. He pledged himself to loyalty and righteousness and especially loved generous giving; his household had no surplus wealth. Once seeking a maid for his daughter, he obtained a woman very refined and elegant; wondering, he questioned her—it was the daughter of a Yunmeng jinshi; her husband died in the chaos and she had nowhere to rely on, and sold herself to live. Gui immediately gave his daughter's dowry to marry her; hearers were moved to tears. Gui's merit was equal to the generals, yet his rank did not match his labor; contemporaries together regretted it. In the eighth year of Qiandao, an edict ordered the Record of Chen Gui's Defense of De'an carved and distributed throughout the realm as a model for defending generals. A temple was established at De'an, granted the title "Worthy Defender," posthumously enfeoffed as Marquis of Loyal Benefit, later additionally enfeoffed as Wise and Keen.
17
簿
Ji Ling, styled Yanzhong, was from Longquan in Chuzhou. He passed the upper-house examination in the second year of Zhenghe and after three promotions became Erudite of the Directorate of Education. Discussing whether learning was orthodox or heterodox and their similarities and differences, the chief official was angry, slandered him to the chief ministers, and he was demoted as prefect of Shucheng County. Before long he was appointed Registrar of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and transferred to Outer Section Vice Director of the Ministry of Revenue. When Gaozong took the throne, he followed to Yangzhou. In the second year of Jianyan he held Outer Section Vice Director of the Ministry of Revenue and Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. When the Jurchens invaded south, the emperor went to Hangzhou; court ritual objects were all abandoned; Ling carried the spirit tablets of the Nine Temples on his back as he went, was appointed Attendant Gentleman, and transferred to Drafting Attendant of the Central Secretariat.
18
In the sixth month of the third year there was excessive rain; an edict sought forthright speech. Ling said:
19
輿
"The Jurchens for years have raided and trampled; the people are smeared with charcoal; resentment accumulates—disasters and anomalies coming is certainly not strange. 'Only first correct the king and rectify his affairs'—can what lies with us be neglected? I observe the court hall has no ministers who usurp orders, but only the power of generals is too great; the inner palace has no private access for women, but only eunuch customs are not reformed. Now generals hold troops to protect themselves, gradually becoming overbearing; when Miao and Liu stole the initiative and rescue-the-throne armies arrived, they trampled officials—who dared reproach them? This is generals' power too great, which has offended yang. Eunuchs ran rampant; above and below shared anger; in the end they were crushed by bandits' hands—this can serve as a warning. Recently I heard Lan Gui was again summoned; his faction congratulated one another; hearers gnashed teeth—this is eunuch custom not reformed, which has offended yang. The Hong Fan: 'A favorable sign is reverence, then timely rain... counsel, then timely cold; an unfavorable sign is madness, then constant rain... haste, then constant cold.' Since antiquity when the Son of Heaven went out he necessarily carried the temple tablets, showing there was reverence. The other day in haste welcoming and escorting, it could not be as ritual required. Having reached Qiantang, the Grand Temple was placed in a Daoist abbey and offerings were deficient; the imperial spirit was left at the river bank and installation came late. The fault of irreverence—in my view the ancestral temple should bear it. In recent years bandits were routinely permitted to accept amnesty; before long they rebelled again, falling into their scheme. Loyal ministers' anger is not cleared; common people's wrongs are not avenged—the fault of lack of counsel, in my view bandits should bear it. Roadside talk says the imperial carriage will not long remain here; by my own reckoning there is absolutely no such thing—if there were, would it not be close to madness? Since military campaigns began, mutual-security groups were already formed, patrol communities were also changed, bowmen were recruited and militia also levied—the people's strength is exhausted, yet exactions continue—would that not be close to haste? All these are caused by yin being too strong."
20
The emperor praised and accepted it.
21
使 便使
At the time Liang Yangzu was appointed transport commissioner; Giving Attendant Liu Ningzhi said it was not suitable; then Attendant Gentleman Qi Chongli was made acting Giving Attendant; when the draft was read, Ling sealed and returned the recorded yellow. He also said, "Autumn defense is already urgent; I hope Your Majesty will first fix military guards and escort ministers—if the enemy's force should run wild, then you should marshal the carriage personally to inspect camps, summon troops from all routes as aid, leave chief ministers and great ministers to lead one another in death-defying defense, and not imitate the other day when officials fled barefoot in panic in the name of escorting the carriage, abandoning cities to give the enemy, making the people fall into charcoal and wealth fill gullies and ditches."
22
使
At the time Zhang Jun was grand coordinator and disposition commissioner of the Chuan-Shaanxi routes; Ling criticized him as too autocratic, offended the imperial intent, was dismissed as Awaiting Draftsman of the Huayou Hall and prefect of Taiping Prefecture; before going he was stripped of office and given a sinecure. After several months his office was restored; he was appointed prefect of Wenzhou, then changed to Drafting Attendant of the Central Secretariat—all he forcefully declined.
23
Fan Zongyin recommended his talent; he was ordered prefect of Lin'an Prefecture and again Drafting Attendant of the Central Secretariat. On entering audience he said:
24
"There are four matters that can be deeply considered, and one that can still be relied on: the great carriage has no place of permanent halt, worthy men all lack minds to order the age, military power is divided and generals are not harmonious, government power departs and the ruler grows weaker; what can be relied on for bare survival is only that hearts of the people are not yet weary.
25
使 退 西 便 便 西
The year before last they debated crossing the Yangzi—people thought it feasible, the court thought it not, so they avoided speaking of southward crossing and issued an edict to return the carriage. Last year they debated going to Shu—people thought it not feasible, the court thought it feasible, so they relaxed defense of Jiang and Huai and managed Guan and Shaanxi. Viewing today, which is gain and which is loss? At the Weiyang change the court did not know in time yet merit went to eunuchs; at the Qiantang change the court could not rescue yet merit went to generals—this makes these men have hearts that slight court scholars. Huang Qianshan liked to use his own judgment and could not employ men; Lü Yihao knew how to use ability but did not know how to appoint the worthy. Since Zhang Kai and Xu Jingheng died with resentment, all who knew restraint and valued themselves often rolled up their hearts and withdrew. Today one cannot say there are no troops—Liu Guangshi, Han Shizhong, and Zhang Jun each recruited fugitives to expand military force and each rendered small service to repay sovereign grace. Yet in victory they did not yield to one another, in defeat they did not rescue one another—when a great enemy came, each man schemed for himself. Zhou Wang in western Zhe—people can speak of it; Zhang Jun in western Shaanxi—none dare speak. In military affairs one fears losing opportunity—expediency is permissible; yet to issue edicts oneself—is there not suspicion of usurping orders? Officials are charged to handle affairs—expediency is permissible; yet to place followers—is there not suspicion of coveting power? Even to granting surnames and changing temple names—all these harm by being too autocratic; I fear west of Shaanxi they no longer know there is Your Majesty.
26
祿
Only the ancestors' virtue and grace remain in hearts not forgotten—what is hoped for in restoration is this; Your Majesty should have means to bind them. Now you wish light levies to enrich the people's wealth, yet expenditures are just lacking; light corvée to ease the people's strength, yet armies and brigades are just rising. Edicts of self-reproach repeatedly descend, words of concern for the people repeatedly heard—earnest and urgent to the utmost—yet in the end none believe. I say move the people by action not words—Your Majesty's enfeoffments should match the worthy, salaries should match merit, punishments should match guilt; in all arrangements nothing should fail reason—there has never been one under Heaven whose heart is not satisfied."
27
西
Zhu Shengfei was appointed Jiangxi commander; before going Ling said, "In former years the Jurchens rested troops and horses at Yan Mountain, the next year moved to Hebei, the year after moved to Jingdong; now they lodge in the Huai region with no further intent to leave—the danger is imminent, one can say it is urgent. If Yihao has already gone and Shengfei has not arrived, and the Jurchens go south—troops are not trained by habit, grain is not stored by habit, and no defenses are set—how can they be resisted? I hope Your Majesty will further choose worthy deputies and plan in advance to await it. Today it is not discussing safety and danger but discussing survival and extinction—plan in the morning and act in the evening, it should be like saving the drowning; how can one not cherish every moment?" An edict ordered Liu Hongdao to hurry to Chizhou to arrange river defense. He was appointed Vice Minister of Revenue.
28
Fan Zongyin had once served the false Chu, and so all who received false appointments were recorded and employed. Ling therefore submitted a memorial saying, "In former days scholars did not establish moral repute; those who discussed affairs all liked to attack; once flaws were exposed they could not again be used—even if wiped clean, attackers followed; though ruler and minister ordered, they could not make room for them. I try to speak of those whose crimes are greatest: since Chongning and Daguan, party factions aiding great villains—those who by crooked paths glutted themselves on favor and glory, who knows how many men? When Bangchang disturbed the court, those who could not die in integrity—who knows how many men? When Miao and Liu monopolized killing, those who folded hands and were controlled—who knows how many men? To charge them by righteousness certainly does not permit execution; to pardon them by feeling is also unfortunate. Those who wield brush and ink craft their crimes; once they have an evil name, who dares recommend them? I hope for a clear edict to the chief ministers: from among the guilty choose real ability, assign affairs according to measure, do not because of one fault discard them for life; still order censors to love the state and men and speak no more." An edict posted his memorial in the court hall. Attendant Censor Shen Yuqiu impeached Ling for currying favor with the chief ministers' intent; he was dismissed and appointed to administer the Dongxiao Abbey in Hangzhou.
29
殿
In the first year of Shaoxing he was restored as Compiler of the Youwen Hall. In the second year an edict ordered inner and outer officials to speak on affairs. Ling said:
30
退 輿
"Since military campaigns began, court proclamations—unless forcibly given to the people they would not sell; army provisions and fodder—unless forcibly taken from the people they would not be supplied. The old practice of harmonized purchase—those without capital to pay has long been so; the newly implemented harmonized requisition—how much can repay its price? Once military campaigns arise, every matter is charged for fulfillment; where there is insufficiency, they advance-borrow next year's levies. Though called 'harmonized,' in fact it is forcibly taken; though called 'borrow,' in fact it is seized. Officers and soldiers for food and clothing do not take what is filling and warm but take what is rich and fine; for weapons and equipment they do not take what is solid and sharp but take what is ornate and handsome. They value the branch over the root and from the first have no fighting spirit; when bandits come they falsely say they withdraw to defend, when bandits leave they loudly say they recover—in defeat they count a thousand as one, in victory they count one as a thousand. Now the imperial carriage's clothing and use costs seven or eight tenths gone, officials' and clerks' costs five or six tenths gone—yet what does not benefit the state is that the army is too redundant. Zhang Jun's one army is supplied by Chuan and Shaanxi, Liu Guangshi's one army by Huai and Zhe, Li Gang's one army by Hu and Guang—tribute goods reaching the Ministry of Revenue and Imperial Storehouse are few. Strong armies do not lie in redundant rations—now commanders' households travel with them; at word of bandits they choose elite troops to escort the old and young, and those who follow themselves only prepare to flee—this should be debated, one. Captive women plundered by the enemy—many are in the army; support is insufficient, how can they avoid misconduct—this should be debated, two. Wherever they reach prefectures and garrisons they demand reward feasts; prefects and magistrates fear trouble and exhaust the people to serve them—this should be debated, three. False names and empty vouchers—they batch-request wherever they are, wasting official goods—this should be debated, four. Some borrow credentials, some give bribes, register names on military rolls, scheme for merit rewards—this should be debated, five. I hope an edict will order the relevant offices to focus on inquiry, reform routine to build morale—then military government will be established." He was restored as Awaiting Draftsman of the Huayou Hall and commanded Guang.
31
Earlier, in Huizhou a mad man gathered several thousand, usurped a title and rebelled. When Ling entered the jurisdiction he enticed his follower Zeng Gun, ordering him to redeem guilt by merit; within ten days he captured him. In office three years he died, age fifty-five, posthumously given Grandee of the Palace. He had a collected works in ten juan.
32
西 使
Ling was good at speaking on affairs; his memorials are worth viewing; yet when attached to Fan Zongyin he then said all who received false appointments should be promoted, and censors should not again speak on it; when attacking Zhang Jun he then said that in Shu he failed by being too autocratic, and west of Shaanxi generals would not know there was Your Majesty—gentlemen all did not consider it so. The favored physician Wang Jixian was granted Defender of Rong Prefecture; Ling drafted the appointment—contemporary opinion also on this account thought less of him.
33
Lu Zhiyuan
34
使 西使
Lu Zhiyuan, styled Xingzhi, was from Deqing in Huzhou. Through his father's appointment he became magistrate of She County; because of a near minister's recommendation he went to the Hall for examination, and after accumulated promotions became deputy transport commissioner of the Zizhou route. At the time peace had long continued and military preparedness was all relaxed; Zhiyuan recruited and supplemented military registers and built walls extending more than twenty li. When Wang Fu held the state, expenditures were boundless; Zhiyuan therefore memorialized on it; Fu was angry and dismissed him. After a long time he was recalled as judicial intendant of Jingdong, changed to deputy transport commissioner of Jiangxi; passing the capital he entered audience; Huizong encouraged him saying, "You on the Shu road—your achievement was very fine." He was then granted third-rank robes.
35
使
Earlier, tribute transport was blocked by heavy rivers; clerks and soldiers all used the opportunity for corruption. Zhiyuan managed with full intent, therefore ahead of other routes reached the capital; he was promoted one rank, soon appointed Direct Associate of the Secret Archive and transport commissioner of the Jiang-Huai, Jing, and Zhe routes. He was promoted Compiler of the Secret Archive and appointed to administer Hebei. Because remonstrators impeached him, his office was stripped and he returned to the Ministry of Personnel.
36
殿使
When Gaozong took the throne he was restored to the Longtu Hall and appointed prefect of Wenzhou. At the time Ye Nong took Jian Prefecture and Yang Qing took Chu Prefecture; Zhiyuan repaired armor and troops, increased walls and dredged moats—his force and reputation were imposing. When the emperor went east, Zhiyuan by sea route transported grain and gold and silk of more than a hundred thousand to Taizhou. Summoned for audience he was praised and promoted to Compiler of the Youwen Hall and pacification commissioner within the jurisdiction. In the prefecture four years—the people painted his image and enshrined him.
37
使
When the imperial army attacked Fan Ruwei he was summoned as additional-dispatch transport commissioner of the Two-Zhe route. Dismissed, he was appointed to administer the Taiping Abbey. Grand Coordinator Meng Geng recruited him as staff officer; he was changed to Awaiting Draftsman of the Huayou Hall and prefect of Lin'an Prefecture. Remonstrator Tang Hui said Zhiyuan's governance was perverse; an edict restored him as staff officer of the grand coordinator's office. When the memorial came again he was finally given his old office as a sinecure. In the eleventh month of the eleventh year of Shaoxing he died. Younger brother Fayuan.
38
Younger brother Fayuan
39
使 殿
Fayuan, styled Lizhi. From knowing Yongqiu County through accumulated offices to Vice Director of the Imperial Storehouse, he was granted upper-house origin. Returning from an embassy to Liao, he was transferred Director of the Directorate of Agriculture and granted third-rank robes. As Minister of Personnel he compiled ranks and service records in sequence into one book—merit, fault, grades, and evaluations clear at a glance; clerks could not deceive. Implicated by Wang Fu, he was dismissed as Awaiting Draftsman of the Xianmo Hall.
40
使殿使
In the first year of Shaoxing he was appointed to administer the Dongxiao Abbey in Lin'an. Zhang Jun by special order recalled him as prefect of Kuizhou; soon he was Longtu Academician and deputy grand coordinator and disposition commissioner of the Chuan-Shaanxi routes; he was promoted Academician of the Duanming Hall and deputy grand coordinator of Chuan-Shaanxi.
41
使 西
When the Jurchens attacked the Guan region, rebel general Shi Bin took Xing Prefecture and many prefectures responded. Fayuan ordered generals to hold the walls; those who spoke of fighting were beheaded—the crowd thought him cowardly. Before long Hedong commissioner Wang Xie withdrew for lack of food; Fayuan opened the pass and received him; together with Xie they broke Bin and recovered Xing Prefecture. Just then great bandits filled the land; Qin and Long rebel troops wished to spy on Shu; Fayuan devoted himself to soothing and strictly prepared defense, sending proclamations to all routes—hearts gradually settled. Viewing mountains and rivers' strategic passes he divided territory and placed generals: from Tao and Min to Jie and Cheng, Guan Shigu commanded, stationed at Tongchuan; from Wen and Long to Wei and Mao, Liu Qi commanded, stationed at Baxi. Before and after repeated victories—the emperor relied on him heavily.
42
When Wuzhu attacked the pass he was defeated by Wu Jie. Fayuan had long been at odds with Jie; Jie therefore reported merit and sued Fayuan for not aiding troops, not supplying grain, and not registering meritorious generals and soldiers. The emperor personally issued an edict inquiry; Fayuan defended himself very forcefully; the emperor was quite unsympathetic; grieved and indignant, he died in the army.
43
使
At the start, when Fayuan was grand coordinator of Chuan-Shaanxi, the emperor calmly said to Zhiyuan, "I am just now entrusting Chuan-Shaanxi to Fayuan." It was because both brothers were seen in the world for talent, and so both were used.
44
Chen Jue, styled Jiren, was from Pingyang in Wenzhou. Through upper-house tribute he entered the Imperial College. In the second year of Zhenghe, in palace examination he ranked third; he was granted Gentleman of Letters and military staff officer of Jizhou; after accumulated promotions he became Outer Section Vice Director of the Ministry of Public Works.
45
調滿 調
In the seventh year of Xuanhe he was judicial intendant of the Fujian route. Fuzhou mobilized autumn-defense troops; provisions did not meet expectations; they killed the commander; the mutiny arose in haste; officials and people fled in panic—the whole city was shaken. Jue entered the mutinous troops, expounded fortune and disaster; the rebels' spirit was dampened; they demanded Jue memorialize that the commander died by his own hand; Jue falsely agreed, then by hidden route galloped to memorialize, awaiting punishment for the prior false report; the court considered Jue understood the change and released him. After the rebel troops were mobilized to march, he waylaid and killed more than twenty ringleaders—the region was settled. In the fifth month of the fourth year of Jianyan he was again appointed judicial commissioner of the Fujian route; soon citing illness he requested a sinecure and administered the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou.
46
滿
In the third year of Shaoxing he was summoned as Outer Section Vice Director of the Ministry of Revenue and promoted to Director. At the time those who spoke on affairs mostly picked minor matters and omitted great benefit and harm. Jue remonstrated forcefully, "Now one should focus on the root of governing the Way, repair government to repel the enemy state—not use minor matters to weary the sacred concern as in normal times." He also said, "Prefects and magistrates fill all under Heaven—not all can be the right men; I beg to select circuit commissioners, weight their power, and lengthen their tenure." He was appointed Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. He again presented attack and defense two strategies, lying in winning hearts and repairing military government.
47
西 使
In the fifth year he was appointed Direct Associate of the Longtu Hall and prefect of Quanzhou. The next year he was changed to judicial commissioner of the Two-Zhe western route. He requested establishing village and county Three Elders to thicken custom; for palaces, carriages, horses, clothing, and implements fix graded ranks—heavy prohibition of extravagance. In the eighth year he was transferred deputy transport commissioner of the Fujian route.
48
In the tenth year he was again summoned as Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. Just then the classified compilation of Huizong's imperial writings was complete; an edict ordered it stored in the Fuwén Hall; Jue considered, "The old system from Longtu to Huayou all established academicians and awaiting draftsmen, mixed ranks recorded in statutes—Longtu above Court Gentleman for Consultation, to Huayou above Gentleman for Discussion; each hall somewhat far apart—discussants doubted it was not ordered. Direct Associate of the Fuwén Hall attached to Huayou then differed slightly from other halls; if removed then court rank was too low—I wish to consult and take the middle, combine as one column, need not be far apart, perhaps then names and ranks have order, looking up to match Your Majesty's strict reverence for the ancestors' plans and instructions." He also said, "The joint sacrifice uses the grand ox—this is normal in the sacrificial canon. At the beginning of the temporary halt full rites could not be prepared—only one sheep was used; I beg to check against the sixth year of Shaoxing edict and restore use of the grand ox."
49
In the eleventh year he was appointed Acting Vice Minister of Rites and granted third-rank robes. When the Prince of Pu'an left the inner palace, he received an edict together with the Ministry of Personnel and Court of Imperial Sacrifices to discuss precedents. Jue and others considered that since the foundation of the state was not yet established, rites should be thick to bind the hope of all under Heaven; they therefore submitted the Ceremonial Precedents for a Prince Leaving the Inner Palace—some thought it too heavy. An edict said they did not investigate precedents in detail, relied solely on their own intent, harbored wickedness and clung to factions—together with Minister of Personnel Wu Biaochen, Minister of Rites Su Fu, Directors Fang Yunyi and Ding Zhongning, Court of Imperial Sacrifices staff Wang Pu and Su Ji—all were dismissed. Soon Jue was appointed to administer the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou.
50
西使 使
In the fifteenth year he was prefect of Xiangyang Prefecture and concurrently pacification commissioner of the Jingxi southwest route. After the fires of war in Xiang and Han, people and goods were wasted; Jue requested of the court that present household counts were only one twentieth of peaceful times yet levies were still many—I beg heavy renewed reduction. The next year Jin and Fang troops rebelled; Jue sent generals to pacify them and then reported. The Han River burst its banks and flooded dwellings; he personally led soldiers and civilians to defend and build dikes—relying on this there was no trouble. Citing illness he requested a sinecure; he was appointed Compiler of the Secret Archive and administrator of the Taiping Xingguo Abbey in Jiangzhou. In the twenty-fourth year he was changed to prefect of Guangzhou and concurrently grand coordinator and pacification commissioner of the Guangnan east route; before arriving he died, age sixty-four.
51
Jue was broad and generous, cultured and refined, treated people with sincerity, yet was indifferent to glory and profit. When Qin Hui held power, taking Yongjia as adopted home, scholars who clung and attached—all without exception leaped to high importance. Jue as an old associate of the imperial lectern was known to the ruler; entering and leaving he met setbacks; late from Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices he was promoted acting minor Director of the Ancestral Temple; again because discussing rites he did not bend he offended intent and was suddenly dismissed—his integrity is worth praise. He styled himself "Layman Without Phase." He had a collected works in sixteen juan. Sons Ruoji, Ruxian, and Ruoxie. Grandson Xian, by lexicographic examination advanced in rank, served as Drafting Attendant of the Central Secretariat and Direct Academician of the Hanlin Academy.
52
西 調
Li Qiu, styled Ximei, was from Bian. He passed the Zhenghe jinshi examination, was assigned professor of Chen Prefecture, entered as Erudite of the Directorate of Education, and went out as prefect of Fang Prefecture. At the time official tea was already monopolized and people were again forced to deliver the old quota; the poor had no means and several hundred were imprisoned; when Qiu arrived he released them all the same day.
53
In the third year of Xuanhe the court debated taking Yan; when Qiu heard he said, "The hundred ministers and great officers—all sing in chorus—the state's safety and danger, its crisis lies here." He submitted a forceful memorial, roughly saying, "Taizu by sacred martial prowess obtained all under Heaven; officers and soldiers were all survivors of a hundred battles—with this to take Yan and Yun should be easy in strength. Yet Zhao Pu and his kind none dared approve the decision—because they recognized the great trend of all under Heaven and moreover valued people's lives. Now inheriting the enterprise of great peace, the elders fortunately do not know war; though not obtaining Yan and Yun territory, what lacks for Han?" The memorial was submitted without attention. When Yan was pacified he was punished as supervisor of Qingxi town in Ying Prefecture.
54
殿 西
The next year amnesty restored him as Gentleman; soon he was tested as Drafting Attendant of the Central Secretariat. He proposed that descendants of Yuanyou worthy ministers, long banned and confined, should be somewhat relaxed. Eunuch Tan Zhen went out to Hebei, was dismissed for no achievement, and was about to be again promoted—Qiu refused to draft the appointment. When Shandong bandits arose prefectures and counties could not control them; reaching Hebei there was no visible grain and soldiers were turbulent. Qiu submitted ten items in sequence, offended the great ministers' intent, and was dismissed. In the fourth year of Shaoxing he was Compiler of the Jiying Hall and prefect of Ji Prefecture. Jiangxi troops were always fierce; when Qiu first took office some stirred rebellion; he quickly captured and executed the ringleaders, soothed the rest, and broadly spread grace and trust—the territory was then settled.
55
使
After accumulated promotions he was Direct Academician of the Huayou Hall and Sichuan pacification and disposition commissioner. Chengdu's old walls were mostly ruined; when Qiu arrived he first ordered repair. Soon great floods came—the people relied on this to be safe. At the Three Rivers there were weirs that could irrigate downward a million qing of Mei fields—long abandoned unrepaired, fields and wasteland were desolate. Qiu led prefectural governors together to restore them; ultimately they received the benefit—the people of Mei were grateful and painted his image and enshrined it at the weir site. Occasionally encountering famine years people migrated; he opened granaries to relieve and sustain—no less than a million households; governing Shu's administration had much worth recording. He had the Qingxi Collection in twenty juan.
56
調西 使
Li Pu, styled Xianzhi, was from Xingguo in Qian. He passed the jinshi examination in the first year of Shaosheng, was assigned judicial staff officer of Linjiang Army, transferred professor of the Western Capital Directorate of Education—Cheng Yi alone valued and approved him. He transferred to professor of Qian Prefecture. Because he had once said the Empress Dowager Longyou should not be deposed to dwell at Yaohua Palace, there was an edict to investigate. Those who envied him wished to squeeze him to death and sent men with alarming words to move him—Pu was calm without fear. Soon his office was stripped and he was forced to stop; meeting amnesty he was assigned Clerk of Households in Ting Prefecture.
57
便 便
When Huizong took the throne, Hanlin Academician Fan Chunli himself said he awaited punishment forty-six days without hearing the jade voice; he said to Pu, "Is such-and-such a matter convenient for the state? Is such-and-such a matter convenient for the people?" Pu said, "Academician, knowing yet not speaking—no father's style." Chunli wept.
58
Right Bureau Remonstrator Chen Guan recommended Pu; there was an order to summon for audience; Pu first said, "Since Xining and Yuanfeng the political body repeatedly changed—at first one or two great ministers' learning differed, afterward they alternately held round and square and mutually attacked; if not remedied now, it will reach beyond saving." He also said, "Now scholars' learning does not seek it in themselves but only listens to the Wang clan—corrupting mind and character, nothing greater than this. I hope for an edict not to be bound by the Wang clan—then outstanding talent will emerge in succession." Cai Jing hated Pu's blunt uprightness; other chief ministers three times proposed offices—all held without release; he was again made professor of Qian Prefecture. He again incited remonstrators to discuss Pu as Yuanyou learning, unfit to lead teachers—dismissed as magistrate of Sihui in Zhaoqing Prefecture.
59
There was a wicked man who said east of the county gold and treasure were produced; fixed quota purchase and monopoly were established, fields broken, tombs excavated—it stopped only after heavy bribes; when Pu arrived he requested abolition. Changed to Gentleman for Service, he knew Qingjiang County in Linjiang Army and was chief clerk of the Guangdong pacification commission staff. When Qinzong was in the Eastern Palace he heard his name; when he took the throne he was appointed Compiler; in half a year through five promotions he reached Director of the Directorate of Education—citing illness he could not go. When Gaozong took the throne he was appointed Director of the Secretariat; urgently summoned, before arriving he died, age sixty-five. Posthumously given Awaiting Draftsman of the Baowen Hall; two of his sons and grandsons were granted office.
60
使
From small office Pu's name was esteemed under Heaven. When Cai Jing was about to force him to come, he sent men by secret route with kind intent, promising membership in the forbidden secretariat—Pu forcefully refused and would not see him; Jing's anger showed on his face, yet in the end he did not harm him. Central Secretariat Vice Minister Feng Xizai wished to meet Pu by chance; Pu laughed and said, "If I cannot see Cai Jing, how can I meet Feng Xizai by chance?" Wherever he held office there was reputation. In Guangnan he stopped his commander Sun Si from paper formalities for rescue-the-throne and urged issuing regular levies to aid the border. He broke Transport Commissioner Zheng Liang's plan to bring Zhenla to take Annan, to quiet border trouble—people praised his wisdom. Pu once wrote his own tomb inscription: "Take Heaven as heart, take the Way as body, take the time as use—it can stop." This narrates his whole life. He had the Zhanggan Collection in twenty juan circulating in the world.
61
Wang Xiang, styled Zhouyan, was from Rong Prefecture. For generations they dwelt together, called "Righteous Gate Wang Clan."
62
祿 歿
Grandfather Boqi was renowned in the district and prefecture for righteous reputation. There were salt wells registered for people to boil and deliver—many to the point of ruined households; only families with salary were exempt. Boqi requested of the prefecture to equalize among official households; but an officeholder falsely sued him and he died with resentment. Father Mengyi passed the Huangyou examination, forcefully fulfilled his father's will—spoke to prefecture and county without hearing, spoke to the prefect, spoke to the Three Departments; the Three Departments reported it—returned registration to three hundred fifty-five households and remitted the annual quota of three hundred thousand jin. He once acted as prefect of Xing Prefecture, changed Sichuan tea transport, established tea shops to exempt corvée from the people—the annual levy was also fulfilled. The route prefect resented that the plan did not come from himself and hit him with other matters—reduced three ranks, dismissed and returned, then died. Mother née Xiang was the paternal aunt of Empress Qinsheng Xiansu.
63
Xiang in youth was sharp and comprehending; at seven he could compose prose, dignified as an adult. At age thirteen, dwelling in father's mourning, grief and indignation were deep; he said to younger brother Xu, "Father was squeezed out for the straight Way; mother by the coffin swore, expecting us brothers to establish ourselves, restore father's office by posthumous grant, then permit return for burial—we encourage one another. Moreover the Decree Examination was our late father's last intent—I have the will." He then closed his door, exhaustively studied classics, histories, and the hundred schools' commentaries and learning, sought teachers a thousand li, and pursued their essential meaning. In early years he sent letters to Fan Chunren, Su Zhe, and Zhang Shangying—all holding neutral, non-partisan views; Lü Tao and Su Zhe both valued him. Once he sent Classic Explanation to Su Shi, saying, "Ministers of the Two Emperors and Three Kings all set their will on the Way; because attaining it for themselves is hard, therefore guarding it is to the utmost firm. Since Confucius and Mencius made the Six Classics, this Way has fixed discussion; what scholars cultivate does not reach antiquity—then one knows later generations see the Six Classics as easy and neglect to practice them." Shi replied, "One essay of Classic Explanation—truly these words."
64
使
In the Yuanyou era Lü Tao by the Worthy and Upright Straightforward Remonstrance examination recommended him; Xiang because Song Bangjie had completed learning but had no recommender, pushed him to go first—Tao on hearing was even more respectful. Before long, when Shaosheng ministers held power, the Decree Examination was abolished; Xiang sighed, "Fate—without failing the late teaching, to practice it in conduct is enough."
65
In the renwu year of Chongning he responded to the calligraphy examination and was first choice. Locusts at the capital—Xiang submitted a memorial discussing gains and losses of current government, saying inner and outer were blocked and bandit-barbarian trouble would arise; Zhang Shunmin on seeing it sighed at his alarming words. Failing the examination he went straight home, served parents and nurtured aspiration, not responding to examinations for eight years.
66
In the gengyin year of Daguan the lodge law was implemented throughout the realm; the prefecture again had Xiang respond to the edict. Xiang said, "Formerly because mother was fifty-two I sought to serve in support and no longer wished office; now mother is sixty and I obey the edict—is this my original heart? At the time the Yuanyou faction ban was strict; Xiang himself stated, "Su Shi, Su Zhe, and Fan Chunren as confidants; Lü Tao and Wang Ji once recommended me; Huang Tingjian, Zhang Shunmin, Wang Gong, and Ren Bocong as associates—I cannot enter examination seeking office; I wish to live hidden in fields and villages." Because younger brother Xu entered court, father's office was granted by posthumous gift—only then could burial be completed; after burial mother died.
67
After mourning ended he again entered the Eight Conducts examination; the matter went down to the Imperial College; the Grand Director determined him first under Heaven; an edict honored his gate. The court knew he could not be bent and granted the title "Recluse." Soon changed to professor of Tongchuan Prefecture, granted origin and official robes—four appointments in one day all arrived; he ultimately forcefully declined and did not accept. Though dwelling in mountains and forests, in responsive verse and rhapsody all were words of loving the ruler and worrying for the state. The empress dowager remembering her aunt once wished to grant him office; Xiang yielded to younger brother, nephews, and maternal nephew, and also equally divided fields among half-brothers and elder sister of the former mother. When Xiang died, Xiaozong posthumously titled him "Worthy Integrity."
68
Xu, in the Xuanhe era through favor reached Direct Academician of the Huayou Hall. Xiang floated among them; each built great mansions—or some say his late-years hidden integrity somewhat declined.
69
西
Wang Yi, styled Zishang, was from Licheng in Jinan. Through hereditary privilege he entered office, passed the Mingfa examination, served as legal clerk of Shen and Ji prefectures, entered as Evaluator of the Grand Court of Justice, and was promoted Court Director. Lin Lingsu gained favor and wished to destroy Buddhism to satisfy his private intent. Xiangyang monk Du Debao burned his body and lit incense; the officials watched Lingsu's intent and arrested and reported him. Yi on reading said, "The law for self-injury is only beating with the staff." Lingsu sought an inner draft and seated him on harming custom and teaching, banished and exiled him; Yi's office was stopped, soon given a sinecure. He was chief clerk of the Shaanxi chief transport commission, revising officer of the One-Office Statutes Revision Bureau, vice prefect of Xiqing Prefecture, and prefect of Hao Prefecture; before going he was summoned as Outer Section Vice Director of the Ministry of Justice.
70
At the beginning of Jianyan he was Director of the Bureau of Merits and transferred Vice Director of the Grand Court of Justice. In the third year Han Shizhong captured Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan, presented captives—caged carts nearly several hundred; first delivered to the Grand Court prison, about to execute all and expose corpses in the market. Yi memorialized, "These men by law should be executed, but among them are women who were hired or plundered and followed." Gaozong started and said, "Your words are extremely right—I did not consider this." Immediately an edict: except Fu and Zhengyan's wives and children, all were released. Fan Qiong had guilt and was sent down to the Grand Court of Justice; Yi received an edict to interrogate him. Qiong did not submit; Yi charged him with forcing the retired emperor to move in the Jingkang siege, arbitrarily killing Wu Ge, and establishing Zhang Bangchang—Qiong acknowledged death guilt. Yi turned to the clerks and said, "The prisoner's words have submitted." He was then granted death and released his relatives and staff officers.
71
In the fourth year he was promoted Court Director of the Grand Court of Justice. Earlier, Bearer of the Imperial Armory Wang Qiu was superintendent of the Longde Palace and stole all the palace's precious jade and curios; when the matter was discovered the emperor was greatly angry and wished to execute him. Yi said, "Qiu certainly can be killed, yet if not suited for what he hid, all would have become the enemy's—how could they return to the state?" He was then lenient.
72
使
Earlier, when the hundred offices had faults they were sent to the court for impeachment; up to three interrogations they took confession; the impeached feared facing trial and none dared argue. Yi memorialized, "Confession and argument are two matters; if in all cases confession is taken, that is coercing by authority, not allowing self-justification—not the law's intent; I beg that after three interrogations without admission, argument be permitted." It was approved. Together revising the One-Office Statutes, they deleted forty-seven miscellaneous capital offenses; when the book was complete the emperor praised his discussion of law as detailed and clear.
73
殿
In the first year of Shaoxing he was Acting Vice Minister of Justice. In the second year he was appointed Compiler of the Jiying Hall and given a sinecure. Soon Zhao Lingzhi by edict recommended him; he was again summoned as Vice Minister of Justice but was blocked by remonstrators. In the fourth year he died at home. Yi was straightforward and easy in nature, held the law without bending—discussants considered him worthy.
74
The discussion says: Xiang Ziyin as a prime minister's son was able to restrain himself in minister's integrity; Chen Gui as a civil Confucian minister had reputation in garrison defense—they can be called those who rose above vulgar custom. Ji Ling spoke on affairs without avoidance; the two Lu brothers were both employed and seen in the world for talent; Chen Jue kept ritual and knew change; Li Qiu in government had grace—all are worth recording. Li Pu did not yield to authority and power; Wang Xiang's aspiration was high yet his late years somewhat declined; Wang Yi was clear in forgiveness and in applying punishment not harsh—though their capacity and insight were not uniform, all also did not neglect their duties!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →