← Back to 宋史

卷三百九十六 列傳第一百五十五 史浩 王淮 趙雄 權邦彥 程松 陳謙 張巖

Volume 396 Biographies 155: Shi Hao, Wang Huai, Zhao Xiong, Quan Bangyan, Cheng Song, Chen Qian, Zhang Yan

Chapter 396 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 396
Next Chapter →
1
調 滿
Shi Hao, courtesy name Zhiweng, came from Yin County in Ming Prefecture. In the fourteenth year of the Shaoxing era (1144), he passed the jinshi examination and was assigned as assistant magistrate of Yuyao County in Shaoxing. He later served as professor at Wenzhou, where Prefect Zhang Jiucheng held him in high esteem. When his term ended, he was appointed director of the Imperial University and then promoted to erudite of the National University. During a rotating audience with the emperor, he said, "One of the two princes, Pu'an and Enping, should be chosen to anchor the hopes of the realm." Emperor Gaozong nodded in agreement. The following day he told his senior ministers, "Hao has real talent." He was appointed collator in the Secretariat and concurrently instructor to both princely households. In the thirtieth year (1160), the Prince of Pu'an was made imperial son and promoted to Prince of Jian; Hao was appointed acting instructor to his household. An edict ordered the Prince of Jian's household established with one lecturer and one reader; Hao remained bureau director in the Department of State Affairs and also served as lecturer. One day, lecturing on the Rites of Zhou, he said, "The steward of provisions oversees meals; at year's end accounts are settled—but the king's, the queen's, and the heir apparent's provisions are not counted. As for the director of wine, who oversees drinking, accounts are settled at year's end—except for the king's and queen's wine; the heir apparent is not included. From this one sees that while the heir's meals need not be counted, his drinking may not go unrestrained." The prince rose and thanked him, saying, "I shall heed this instruction."
2
退 殿 使
In the thirty-first year (1161), he was transferred to vice director of the Imperial Clan Court. When the Jin emperor Haiming invaded the frontier, an edict ordered the emperor to take the field in person. With both Huai regions lost, court officials competed in urging retreat, but the Prince of Jian submitted a bold memorial asking to lead the army as vanguard. Hao spoke emphatically to the prince: "A crown prince must not command troops—remember Shensheng of Jin and Tang Suzong at Lingwu." Deeply moved, the prince had Hao draft a memorial at once, asking to accompany the emperor in filial service; its language was earnest and sincere. Gaozong had been angry, but reading the memorial his mood softened at once. When he learned Hao had drafted it, he told his ministers, "That is a true servant of the prince's household." Soon afterward, Palace Censor Wu Bi asked that the prince be made commander-in-chief and sent ahead to inspect the troops. Hao again wrote to the senior ministers, saying, "The Prince of Jian was raised in the inner palace and has never worked with the generals—how could he handle such a task?" When some proposed leaving the prince behind to guard the capital, Hao again objected. The emperor also wanted the prince to meet the generals in person, so he accompanied the imperial retinue to Jiankang.
3
祿
In the thirty-second year (1162), the emperor returned to Lin'an, made the Prince of Jian crown prince, and appointed Hao diarist and right vice tutor to the crown prince. When Emperor Xiaozong took the throne, Hao rose from drafter in the Secretariat to Hanlin academician and controller of edicts. Zhang Jun, pacification commissioner for the Jiang and Huai regions, planned to recover lost territory, but Hao disagreed and favored fortifying Guazhou and Caishi instead. Zhang Jun memorialized, "If we abandon the two Huai regions and defend only the Yangzi, we would do better to fortify Sizhou." Hao was appointed vice grand councilor. An edict called for debate on a settled policy against the enemy. Hong Zun, Jin Anjie, Tang Wenruo, and others submitted opinions in turn, but the chief ministers offered none. The emperor asked Hao, who replied, "Preparing defenses first is the sound policy. If we heed shallow schemers, raise an untrained army, hand out rewards when the enemy withdraws, and hide our troops when they return—can that be called recovery?" He recommended Lu You and Yin Ji, compilers at the Bureau of Military Affairs; both were summoned for audience and granted official status. In the first year of Longxing (1163), he was appointed right vice director of the Department of State Affairs and first argued that Zhao Ding and Li Guang were innocent and that Yue Fei had long been wronged; their ranks should be restored and their descendants given stipends. The emperor approved all of this.
4
退 殿
Li Xianzhong and Shao Hongyuan memorialized asking to lead troops forward. Hao replied, "These two generals are begging to fight on their own—are the pacification headquarters' orders no longer obeyed?" Zhang Jun requested an audience and asked that an edict be issued at once for the emperor to visit Jiankang. The emperor consulted Hao, who gave three reasons against it. After retiring, he pressed Zhang Jun: "An emperor's army must be deployed with complete safety—how can we gamble on a lucky strike?" They debated again in court. Zhang Jun said, "The Central Plains have been lost for years; if we do not recover them now, local heroes will rise and take them." Hao said, "There are no such heroes in the Central Plains—if there were, why have they not risen and overthrown the Jin?" Zhang Jun said, "The people there are unarmed and cannot rise on their own; they are waiting for our army to arrive and act as allies within." Hao said, "Chen Sheng and Wu Guang overthrew Qin with hoes and thorn branches—if heroes had to wait for our army, they would not be heroes at all." Zhang Jun then submitted privately, "Hao's mind cannot be changed; I fear we will miss our chance. I beg Your Majesty to decide resolutely." The Secretariat suddenly received Hongyuan's troop deployment report and learned that orders had bypassed the Three Departments and gone straight to the generals. Hao said to Chen Kangbo, "We all serve concurrently in the right office, yet we were not told about troop deployment—what use are we as councilors? If we do not resign, what are we waiting for?" He added, "Kangbo wants to accept defectors from Jin; I fear that will one day trouble Your Majesty's descendants. Zhang Jun is set on war; after one defeat, I fear Your Majesty will never again be able to hope for the Central Plains." Censor Wang Shipeng impeached him, and Hao was sent out to serve as prefect of Shaoxing.
5
使
Earlier, as Hao was fortifying Guazhou, he reported this and sent Palace Storehouse Vice Director Shi Zhengzhi to inspect the work; Zhengzhi debated the matter with Zhang Jun. Wang Shipeng also memorialized that Shi Zhengzhi was forming factions and implicated Hao as well. Hao was given a stipendary post and was not summoned again for thirteen years. He was recalled to serve as prefect of Shaoxing and pacification commissioner of Eastern Zhe. He returned home to mourn his mother; when the mourning period ended, he was appointed prefect of Fuzhou.
6
殿使
Early in the Chunxi era, the emperor asked the chief ministers, "I have not seen Shi Hao in a long time—is there any other reason?" He was then appointed junior guardian, grand academician of the Hall for Viewing Literature, commissioner of the Liquan Abbey, and concurrently imperial reader. In the fifth year (1178), he again became right chief councilor. The emperor said, "Since Ye Heng was dismissed, this seat has been kept open for you a long time." Hao replied, "Having received the grace to serve again as councilor, I will devote myself solely to public fairness, so that factionalism may be avoided." The emperor said, "Should a chief councilor have a faction? A ruler should not label his ministers as faction members. I simply employ the worthy; if they are not worthy, I remove them."
7
殿 殿 ' ' 使使
Wang Bian, chief receptionist at the Bureau of Military Affairs, proposed that the Palace and Infantry Commands had many phantom rolls on their registers and asked to recruit three thousand men for each command to fill them. Soon afterward the Palace Command began seizing townspeople at will. The capital was thrown into turmoil, and many of those seized cut off their fingers to show they were unfit for service. The soldiers, relying on their numbers, seized civilians' property. Hao memorialized, "Release all those seized, and arrest the leading soldiers and civilians who stirred up the uproar and send them to prison." When the case was concluded and punishment was debated, officials proposed executing one soldier and one civilian by decapitation as a warning. Hao said, "When the troops plundered people and seized goods until a riot broke out, the soldiers started the trouble; military law should indeed be applied to them. But the townsman Lu Qingtong merely fought back in resistance—can he be punished the same way? Your Majesty fears the soldiers will complain, so you are equalizing their crimes to pacify them. When the people cannot obtain justice, their words are also to be feared: 'Since death is the same either way, shall we die for the state?' Is that the speech of soldiers?" The emperor angrily said, "You are comparing me to Qin Er Shi." Hao replied calmly, "From antiquity many rulers have faced popular resentment; 'The day is come—let us perish together with you'—was that only a matter of the second Qin emperor?" Soon afterward he asked to leave office and was appointed junior tutor, military commissioner of the Baoning Army, and commissioner of the Liquan Abbey, concurrently imperial reader. Later, when someone spoke of Qingtong's injustice, the emperor said, "Shi Hao once argued forcefully on this and resigned because of it—I regret that to this day."
8
覿 覿
Zhao Xiong once recommended Liu Guangzu for a trial Hanlin post. Guangzu's examination answer discussed how scholars were selected through the civil service examinations. When it was submitted, the emperor personally annotated it, writing in summary, "The flaw in employing men is that the ruler lacks the wisdom to know men and the chief councilor cannot choose them. Since the founding of our dynasty we have been excessively lenient; chief councilors who harmed the state and great generals who lost armies have never been executed. The key is that the ruler must carefully choose his councilor, the councilor must choose the right officials, rich rewards must stand before them and executions behind them—if talent still does not emerge, I do not believe it." Once the handwritten edict was issued, court and country were greatly shaken. Commentators said Zeng Di had drafted the edict to launch Guangzu as a top examination graduate. The emperor sent Di to show it to Hao. Hao memorialized, "In the age of Tang and Yu, the four villains were extremely wicked yet were only banished; the law of three appraisals amounted to no more than demotion and promotion—there was never a category of execution. Executing high ministers is the law of Qin and Han. Taizu governed with benevolence and treated his ministers with ritual propriety; successive emperors transmitted this spirit, and by Emperor Renzong virtue and transformation flourished together. The governance of our dynasty shares the spirit of the Three Dynasties—this is our ancestral house law. The sacred instruction then says we are 'excessively lenient.' For a state to rest upon leniency—how can there be such a thing as excess? I fear commentators will say Your Majesty himself wishes to pursue harsh government and shift the blame onto the ancestors—this must be carefully considered."
9
When he was about to leave the Classics Mat and request retirement, he recommended fifteen scholars from Jiang and Zhe among lower officials; an edict ordered their promotion—all were outstanding men of the day. Men such as Xue Shusi, Yang Jian, Lu Jiuyuan, Shi Zongzhao, Chen Qian, Ye Shi, Yuan Xie, Zhao Jingzhi, and Zhang Zhizhi were later all promoted; only six did not reach high distinction.
10
西
In the tenth year (1183), he requested retirement on account of age and was appointed grand guardian with permission to retire, enfeoffed as Duke of Wei. In his later years he built a residence on West Lake in Yin, erected a pavilion to house books bestowed by two reigns, and also built a hall; the emperor wrote Bright Ruler and Worthy Minister in Joyful Assembly to name the pavilion and Former Studies to name the hall. When Emperor Guangzong ascended the throne, Hao was promoted to grand preceptor. In the fifth year of Shaoxi (1194) he died at age eighty-nine and was enfeoffed as Prince of Kuaiji Commandery. When Emperor Ningzong ascended the throne, he was granted the posthumous title Cultured and Kind and bestowed an imperial inscription reading Stele for the Elder of Pure Sincerity and Deep Virtue. In the fourteenth year of Jiading (1221), he was posthumously enfeoffed as Prince of Yue, his posthumous title was changed to Loyal and Settled, and he was granted paired sacrifice in Emperor Xiaozong's temple.
11
Hao liked recommending talent. He once proposed promoting Chen Zhimao to office and to a prefecture. The emperor knew Zhimao had once slandered Hao and asked, "Are you repaying injury with virtue?" Hao said, "I know nothing of any injury; if one treats it as injury and repays it with virtue, that is calculation." Mo Ji submitted a report on Wang Shipeng's conduct that criticized Hao especially harshly; Hao recommended Ji to manage inner edicts. The emperor said, "Was not Ji among those who criticized you?" Hao said, "I dare not let private feeling harm the public good." Ji was then appointed drafter in the Secretariat and concurrently director of the Hanlin Academy; Hao treated him as before. His generosity and forbearance were generally of this kind. His sons were Midà, Mizheng, Miyuan, and Mijian. Miyuan became right chief councilor at the beginning of Jiading; he has a separate biography.
12
祿
Wang Huai, courtesy name Jihai, came from Jinhua in Wu Prefecture. From youth he was quick-witted and perceptive, studied diligently, and was skilled at literary composition. He passed the jinshi examination in the fifteenth year of Shaoxing (1145) and was appointed assistant magistrate of Linhai in Taizhou. Prefect Xiao Zhen was struck by him at first sight and declared him material for chief minister. When Zhen took command of Shu, he recruited Huai into his staff. When Zhen departed, the others wished to keep Huai behind; Huai said, "I am taking my mother a thousand li—how could I be calculating profit and salary?" All admired his capacity and judgment, and he was transferred to collator.
13
祿 退
Emperor Gaozong ordered the vice censor-in-chief to recommend men fit to serve as censors; Zhu Zhuo recommended Huai, who was appointed investigating censor and soon transferred to right remonstrator. He first argued, "Great ministers cultivate their dignity, petty officials hold their salaries, taking purse-closing as wisdom and withdrawal as elevation. I wish Your Majesty to rectify the heart to rectify the court, and rectify the court to rectify the hundred officials." Chief Councilor Tang Situi had no public esteem; Huai listed several dozen of his crimes, and Situi was then dismissed by imperial rescript. As for Vice Minister of Personnel Shen Jie, who deceived the world and stole reputation; Bureau Director Fang Shiyin, who was crafty and treacherous; and Grand General Liu Bao, who extorted and colluded with favored power-holders—all were impeached and dismissed. He also memorialized, "The policy for self-governance has three points for internal rule: rectify the mind and methods, treasure kindness and frugality, and remove obstruction and concealment. For external rule there are four: strengthen frontier defense, select generals and commanders, clarify rewards and punishments, and store up wealth and resources." The emperor deeply praised and sighed in admiration.
14
西
He was appointed vice director of the Secretariat and concurrently lecturer to the Prince of Gong's household. At that time the Prince of Gong's wife Lady Li gave birth to Ting; Huai reported to the chief councilor, saying, "The Prince of Gong's consort Lady Li has borne the emperor's eldest legitimate grandson; I beg that the proper rites be discussed." Qian Duansli was angered by this title and memorialized, "Huai has the doctrine of using seniority to determine precedence." The emperor said, "What kind of talk is this—does it not open the way to wicked intent?" Huai was sent out to serve as prefect of Jianning and then transferred to judicial commissioner of Western Zhe. On entering audience, he set forth the advantages and ills of Fujian in great detail. The emperor praised and commended him, and also ordered him to visit the Eastern Palace once; the crown prince treated him as teacher and scholar, and a special bowing ceremony was performed. Soon afterward he was recalled, appointed vice director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, and appointed drafter in the Secretariat and concurrently director of the Hanlin Academy. Long Dayuan was posthumously granted grand preceptor and still given the privileges of equal rank with the Three Excellencies; Zhang Yue was appointed grand marshal with a capital stipendary post—all edicts were sealed and returned. He was appointed Hanlin academician and controller of edicts; his instruction edicts were profound and substantial, attaining the style of royal speech. The emperor ordered selection of men of literary learning and moral conduct; Huai recommended Zheng Boxiong, Li Tao, and Cheng Shuda, and all were promoted and employed.
15
殿 歿
In the second year of Chunxi (1175), he was appointed academician of the Hall of Brilliant Governance and deputy director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. Xin Qiji pacified the tea bandits, but the reported merit was excessively generous. Huai said, "If truth and falsehood are not verified, how can merit be rewarded?" Tribal groups in Wen Prefecture disturbed the border; Wu Ting memorialized, "Ku Yanwei suffered defeat, and the Yi people of Jing Prefecture are disturbing the border." Yang Tan memorialized, "Tian Qi suffered defeat." Huai said, "These two generals died in battle; if they are punished, how can those who come after be encouraged?" The emperor once told him, "At the Bureau of Military Affairs you handle affairs with complete fairness and no one speaks against you; in appointments you can uphold the law—this is very good." He recommended the military commanders Wu Gong, Guo Tian, and Zhang Xuan. He was appointed associate director of the Bureau of Military Affairs and vice grand councilor.
16
使 西西
At that time the chief councilor's seat had long been vacant; Huai and Li Yanying jointly performed councilor duties. Huai said, "In granting office one should judge worthiness or unworthiness, not outward appearances. If truly worthy, one dare not dismiss him because of hometown ties or old friendship; if lacking talent, one dare not shield him out of private feeling." The emperor praised this. He was promoted to director of the bureau and commissioner of military affairs. The emperor spoke of reducing the quota of military officials in mountain temple stipendary posts; Huai said, "Those with battle merit used their strength in their prime—when old, to cast them aside, is that acceptable?" Zhao Xiong said, "Northerners who have submitted should be given supernumerary appointments and ought to be ordered to report to the Ministry of Personnel." The emperor said, "For now, keep the old practice." Huai said, "Your Majesty's intent is Heaven's intent." Xiong again memorialized, "There are eight hundred imperial clansmen in mountain temple stipendary posts—they should be abolished." Huai said, "Yao treated the nine clans with kinship and harmony before he brought peace to the common people; to make blood kin distant—is that acceptable?" At that time Xin Qiji pacified the bandits of Jiangxi, Wang Zuo those of Hunan, and Liu Chun those of Guangxi; Huai handled all these appropriately and judged merit fairly. The emperor deeply praised him, saying, "Chen Kangbo may have public esteem, but in handling affairs he does not match you."
17
In the eighth year (1181), he was appointed right chief councilor and concurrently commissioner of military affairs. Earlier, from summer there had been no rain until autumn; on that day sweet rain poured down. The scholar-officials congratulated one another, and the emperor also rejoiced that rain came with the appointment of a councilor. He then ordered that silk-tax money in all prefectures be remitted for one year, amounting to eight hundred thousand strings of cash.
18
When Zhao Xiong was dismissed as councilor, the Shu scholars at court all had thoughts of leaving. Huai said, "This is the seed of the factional disasters of late Tang—how can a sage age have such a thing?" All were promoted in turn by seniority, and the Shu scholars were then reassured. Wang Bian, chief receptionist at the Bureau of Military Affairs, relied on favor to commit wickedness; Huai fully set forth his crimes, saying, "When a ruler is slandered, rarely is it not because of such men." The emperor immediately dismissed him and also said, "The chief councilor is direct, sincere, and without concealment—between ruler and minister this is exactly as it should be." Zhang Ying discussed affairs with wild bluntness; the emperor was about to dismiss him. Huai said, "Your Majesty delights in hearing straight talk; scholar-officials take speech as their distinction—this custom is to be celebrated. To dismiss him would only make his name." The emperor was pleased, and Ying was kept in office.
19
椿
At that time famine relief was urgent; Huai said, "Li Chun is experienced and seasoned—I propose appointing him commander of Changsha; Zhu Xi is solid in learning and conduct—I propose appointing him commissioner of Eastern Zhe to lead the prefectures and commanderies." Later, when merit was being recommended, the emperor said, "Zhu Xi attends carefully to his duties." Huai said, "In carrying out famine relief he is putting his learning into practice; the people have received real benefit—I wish to grant him advancement in rank." The emperor said, "Grant him promotion to the Direct Huayou Pavilion." The Chengdu commander's post was vacant; the emperor further inquired, and Huai answered with Liu Zheng. The emperor said, "Is he not a man of Min?" Huai said, "To establish the worthy without regard to origin—this is Tang's holding to the mean. Must one say that Min has Zhang Zihou and Lü Huiqing, and not Zeng Gongliang, Su Song, and Cai Xiang? Must one say that Jiang and Zhe have many famous ministers, and not Ding Wei and Wang Qinruo?" The emperor praised this. He was appointed left chief councilor.
20
At Tianchang, flooding harmed more than seventy households; some said it need not be reported. Huai said, "The ancients said a ruler must not go a single day without hearing of flood, drought, bandits, and thieves. The Record says, 'When there is disaster in the four directions, one must know of it first. How can it not be reported?" In Zhenjiang, starving people forcibly borrowed beans and grain; the chief ministers requested severe punishment. Huai said, "By statute, starving people are not guilty of a capital crime." Eight jinshi degree holders requested exemption from examination favor for rank promotion; Huai said, "If eight obtain it, then a hundred will cite it as precedent." Gong Yi, as a client of the chief ministers, received office by patronage and requested an audience at the Board of Appointments; Huai held that this door must not be opened and rejected his request. He once said that undisciplined men can in urgent need exert themselves unto death; accordingly he appointed Zhou Ji to command Anfeng Army and granted Xin Qiji a stipendary post.
21
殿
He submitted memorials repeatedly requesting to leave office and was appointed grand academician of the Hall for Viewing Literature with jurisdiction over Quzhou. Huai forcefully declined and was changed to commissioner of the Dongxiao Palace. When Emperor Guangzong succeeded to the throne, an edict inquired about initial governance; Huai advised that fulfilling filial piety and advancing virtue, revering Heaven and respecting the people, employing men and establishing policy—all lie in the beginning. When his mother died, he observed mourning according to ritual. When he fell ill, he suddenly told his family, "The Book of Changes has sixty-four hexagrams—my years are likewise." In the sixteenth year of Chunxi (1189) he died. When word of his death arrived, the emperor mourned, suspended court audience, posthumously granted him junior preceptor, and gave the posthumous title Literary and Settled.
22
Earlier, when Zhu Xi was commissioner of Eastern Zhe, he impeached Tang Zhongyou, prefect of Taizhou. Huai had long been on good terms with Zhongyou and disliked Xi; he therefore promoted Chen Jia to investigating censor and had him submit a memorial saying, "Recently the Learning of the Way has used its name to cover falsehood—I beg that an edict sternly reform this." Zheng Bing was minister of personnel; together they joined forces to attack the Learning of the Way, and Xi thereby received a stipendary post. Afterward the Qingyuan prohibition against false learning began from this.
23
便殿
Zhao Xiong, courtesy name Wenshu, came from Zizhou. He ranked first in the classified provincial examination of the first year of Longxing (1163). Yu Yunwen, pacification commissioner of the four Shu regions, recruited him as staff officer; when Yunwen entered the councilorship, he recommended him to court. In the fifth year of Qiandao (1169), he was summoned to audience in the informal hall; Emperor Xiaozong was greatly struck by him and that same day issued a handwritten edict appointing him collator.
24
使 使 使 使使 滿
Fan Chengda was envoy to Jin and was about to depart; Xiong was to have an audience; Yunwen summoned him and spoke with him. After entering audience, Xiong argued forcefully for recovery. Emperor Xiaozong was greatly pleased and said, "Merit and fame I shall share with you." He was immediately appointed right diarist, and two months later appointed drafter. The Jin envoy Yelü Zijing came to congratulate the Assembly Celebration Festival; Xiong served as host. Zijing disclosed affairs and dared not conceal them; the patrol officers reported this. The emperor summoned Xiong at night; Xiong fully reported what Zijing had said, and the emperor was pleased. When the Jin envoy came to take leave, by precedent music should be used; Xiong memorialized, "The date for the suburban sacrifice has been chosen and the Son of Heaven is now fasting—music may not be used." The emperor found this difficult; he sent a palace envoy to instruct Xiong. Xiong memorialized, "The Jin envoy surely will not dare disobey; even if there is trouble, I can lead him to the guest lodge." The emperor was greatly pleased. Xiong requested reestablishment of the Recovery Bureau, worked day and night in deliberation, submitted proposals that matched the emperor's intent, and was appointed drafter in the Secretariat. From entering the academy as a selected candidate to this point, not a full year had passed.
25
使 西西
At that time the Jin were about to launch a campaign in Henan; it was proposed that all the imperial coffins from the tombs be returned to us. The emperor ordered Xiong to go as envoy to congratulate the birthday and to limit his mission to requesting transfer of the tombs and correcting the protocol for receiving letters. After Xiong had audience with the Jin ruler, he argued back and forth several times. Jin ministers repeatedly shouted for him to rise, but Xiong's words grew only stronger; he finally obtained his request before stopping. The Jin called this a "dragon fight." He once submitted a memorial discussing plans for recovery, saying in summary, "Nothing is better than taking Shaanxi through Shu; with Shaanxi in hand one can overlook the Central Plains—this is the posture of Qin controlling the six states." In the eighth year, he left office on account of mourning for his mother.
26
殿 西
In the second year of Chunxi (1175), he was recalled as vice minister of rites, appointed academician of the Hall of Brilliant Governance, and deputy director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. One day while reporting on affairs, the emperor said, "This summer the silkworms and wheat ripened well and silk and grain prices are stable—this is cause for joy." Xiong replied, "Mencius said that the kingly way begins with freedom from hunger and cold." The emperor said, "In recent times scholar-officials love lofty discourse and are ashamed to speak of farming—there is a slight whiff of Western Jin. Do they not know that the Rites of Zhou and the Changes speak of managing wealth, and that the Duke of Zhou and Confucius ever took managing wealth as their task? And not this alone—gentlemen avoid speaking of recovery, yet do they not know that if their family had a hundred mu of fields and fifty mu within were seized by others, they would still submit petitions to recover them?" Xiong said, "Your Majesty's ambition is for great achievement—how dare I not spread these words of Yao and record them in the Record of Current Policy?" In the eleventh month, he was appointed associate director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the third month of the fifth year, he was appointed vice grand councilor. In the eleventh month, he was appointed right chief councilor. Whenever he entered audience, he always said "the two emperors are in the desert"—these words never left his lips.
27
使
Zhu Xi was repeatedly summoned but would not come out; Xiong requested that he be placed in an outer commandery and was ordered to command Nankang. Xi argued forcefully on current affairs; the emperor was angry and instructed Xiong to analyze and refute him. Xiong memorialized, "Xi is a wild scholar; his words are exhausted and his reasoning weak—to punish him would only make his name. If Heaven covers and Earth nourishes, one may set him aside and not inquire further." At this time Zhou Bida also spoke forcefully on this point, and the matter was dropped. The Shaoxing commander Zhang Jin presented a surplus of four hundred thousand strings of cash; Xiong requested that an edict be sent to Shaoxing to use this money to pay half the commutation tax for corvée and cloth purchase on the people's behalf, so that what had been taken from the people would return to them—enough to show the sage ruler's virtue.
28
殿使 使
Since Xiong served alone as councilor, Shu men at court numbered only a dozen or so. When imperial favor waned, some spoke of his private favoritism toward his clique, and the emperor grew suspicious. Soon after, Chen Xian was made Sichuan commissioner and Wang Wo tea-and-horse commissioner; the appointments came directly from the center. Xiong requested to leave; an edict urged him to stay, saying, "The chief councilor handles affairs without avoiding resentment and selects talent without regard to hometown ties." This was evidently meant as a rebuke. In the time of the ancestors, Shu men were never appointed Shu commanders; Xiong requested an outside post and was appointed grand academician of the Hall for Viewing Literature and Sichuan commissioner. Wang Lin served as censor and, citing precedent that this was impermissible, submitted a memorial arguing against it. Xiong requested exemption and was changed to pacification commissioner of Luzhou. The emperor, remembering Xiong fondly, changed his appointment to prefect of Jiangling. Jiangling had no natural defenses to rely on; Xiong requested fortification of Jiangling. When the walls were completed, the people reported no disturbance.
29
宿 西
Zhang Shi was again summoned; he argued that recovery was certainly right but that the plan was wrong, and immediately submitted a memorial. Emperor Xiaozong was greatly pleased; the next day he displayed the memorial and also issued a handwritten edict saying, "Recovery should follow exactly what Shi has set forth." He was immediately appointed lecturer and said, "When you are on overnight duty, I can discuss affairs with you." Yu Yunwen and Xiong's faction were displeased and therefore obstructed and suppressed him. At Hengshan in Guangxi horses were purchased; the various tribes were moved and pleased and competed to bring good horses. The emperor knew Shi's governance and conduct and greatly favored him; all were jealous. When Shi again went out to Jingnan, Xiong obstructed him at every turn. At that time the Directorate of Astronomy reported that the minister star was in Chu territory; the emperor said, "Zhang Shi corresponds to it." People grew even more jealous of him.
30
Quan Bangyan
31
調 使
Quan Bangyan, courtesy name Chaomei, came from Hejian. He passed the upper dormitory examination in the fourth year of Chongning (1105), was assigned as professor at Cang Prefecture, entered service as erudite of the Imperial University, was changed to Instructor, and was appointed vice director of the National University. In the second year of Xuanhe (1120), he was envoy to Liao. The next year, he submitted a bold memorial requesting the emperor to visit the Imperial Academy. He served as an academic official for more than ten years, was changed to bureau director in the Department of Justice, appointed to the Secretariat Pavilion, and made prefect of Yi Prefecture; was transferred to Xiang Prefecture and again recalled as bureau director in the Department of Justice. He disagreed with Wang Fu in counsel, was demoted in rank, and served as prefect of Ji Prefecture.
32
When the Jin entered again, Gaozong opened the grand marshal's headquarters and raised troops from the two He regions to defend Bianjing; Bangyan led his command of twenty-five hundred men and with Zong Ze hurried from Chanyuan toward Weicheng, holding the Daoma River, while troops from the various routes did not advance. When enemy troops arrived in force, they shifted camp to Nanhua. When the two emperors were moved north, Bangyan and Ze submitted five memorials urging Gaozong to ascend the throne.
33
使
In the fifth month of the first year of Jianyan (1127), he was recalled and ordered to serve as prefect of Jingnan, then changed to Dongping Prefecture. At that time half of the eastern prefectures had fallen to Jin; by then the siege grew ever tighter. Bangyan vowed to defend to the death; after several months the city fell, yet he still fought without cease. The people, moved by righteousness, followed him; breaking out of encirclement they escaped and then fled to the temporary capital. The responsible officials debated the crime of losing the city and were about to punish him severely; the emperor, because his parents, wife, and children had all been lost to the enemy, demoted him only two ranks. Soon after he was appointed academician of the Hall of Precious Culture and concurrently prefect of Jiang Prefecture and commissioner of that circuit. After reaching his post, in the winter of the third year he heard of his father's death and then resigned office.
34
使
In the fourth year, he was recalled from mourning, appointed prefect of Jiankang, declined, and was not permitted. The fierce bandit Zhang Qi ravaged Hu Prefecture; Bangyan sent a deputy general to pacify him. He was changed to commissioner of transport for the Jiang-Huai and other circuits and was known for effective administration. Critics argued, "Three years is the universal mourning period for the empire; later ages have those who shorten mourning by special dispensation in order to meet the state's urgent needs. In recent years such men as Quan Bangyan and Jiang Zhongqian, even at staff posts, have been recalled from mourning—almost the custom of the Xuanhe and Zhenghe eras. I hope this evil may be reformed to clarify human relations and strengthen custom." An edict ordered that Bangyan's duties in military supplies should continue as before; all other recalled-from-mourning appointments were abolished.
35
殿
In the first year of Shaoxing (1131), he was recalled as minister of war and concurrently imperial reader. In the second year (1132), he was appointed academician of the Hall of Brilliant Governance and deputy director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. Earlier, Bangyan submitted ten proposals for national revival, saying in summary:
36
沿 宿
"One should measure by the empire, advance great enterprise, recover territory, and not be content with ease in the southeast. In commanding the generals, one should awe them with law and limit them with rank. Order the reading and lecturing officials to take the instruction codes of successive reigns and the stories of revival from the Three Dynasties, Han, and Tang and present them daily before the throne to aid the sage learning. Also watch for slander that harms the good and obstructs the worthy, flattery that seeks ease and tolerates wrong, wickedness that trades favor for intimidation, and deceit that harbors resentment and misleads superiors—hear their words, examine their deeds, and loyalty and treachery will be distinguished. To love the people, first love their strength; to be lenient to the people, first economize their expenditures. To reduce oneself and serve to assist the state should begin with the chief ministers. To divide command and entrust great affairs is generally not what subordinate officers can do—one must have worthy ministers and great generals before it can be done. The post of commissioner may be abolished; the Yangzi-bank prefectures and counties should each prepare within their borders, all under the transport commanders—from Jing, E, Jiang, and Chi above down to Caishi and Jingkou below. Entrusting the right men is the best strategy for autumn defense. Among the imperial clan there must be outstanding men of public esteem who can meet hardship, assist in secret counsel, and remain on night guard—I wish to seek such men and place them at Your Majesty's side. When human effort is exhausted, Heaven will regret disaster—it cannot be ascribed to fate alone."
37
Lü Yihao had long been on good terms with Bangyan and recommended him for employment. The supervisory attendant Cheng Yu impeached Bangyan on five crimes; three memorials received no response. While Bangyan was at the Bureau of Military Affairs, he also said, "There are three occasions one should seize; like competing for precedence in weiqi, how can one respond and release as one goes, not controlling others but being controlled by them?" Soon after he concurrently served as acting vice grand councilor. The emperor once spoke to his chief ministers about Hunan affairs; Yihao said, "Li Gang is violent and unrestrained—I fear his governance of Tan will show no good record." The emperor said, "Gang, during the Xuanhe era, discussed flood disasters and thereby gained timely reputation." Bangyan said, "Gang originally had no memorial at all—it was merely empty reputation." This was to assist Yihao in excluding Gang. In the third year, he died.
38
稿
Bangyan participated in government for nearly a year, accomplishing nothing notable—he merely filled the seat. He had no son and took his nephew Siyan as heir. He left ten juan of draft writings, titled Remnant Compilation from the Eastern Sea, kept in the family.
39
調 使 殿
Cheng Song, courtesy name Donglao, came from Qingyang in Chi Prefecture. He passed the jinshi examination and was assigned as assistant magistrate of Changxing in Huzhou. When Zhang Sen and Wu Xi were envoys to the north, Song served as attendant. During the Qingyuan era, Han Tuozhou held power and Xi was commander of the Palace Command. At that time Song was magistrate of Qiantang County and flattered Xi to attach himself to Tuozhou. Tuozhou dismissed a favorite concubine over a small matter; Song heard of this and bought her for a hundred thousand cash. When she arrived he set out lavish furnishings, lodged her in the central hall, and he and his wife served her with care. Before long Tuozhou's anger eased and he recalled the concubine; she fully reported Song's careful treatment, and Tuozhou was greatly pleased. Song was appointed staff officer of the Capital Armies Audit Office and acting vice director of the Court of the Imperial Treasury. In less than ten days he was transferred to investigating censor and promoted to right remonstrator and remonstrance officer.
40
滿 使
Lü Zutai submitted a memorial requesting execution of Tuozhou and Su Shidan; Song and Chen Dan impeached Zutai as deserving death. Zutai was sentenced to true execution and exiled to Lingnan. When Song's year in office ended without promotion, he was deeply discontented and therefore presented a concubine to Tuozhou, naming her Song's Longevity. Tuozhou was surprised at the name and asked about it; Song answered, "I wished to make this flawed and lowly surname often receive your remembrance." He was appointed associate director of the Bureau of Military Affairs; from magistrate of a county to chief minister took only four years.
41
使 使 使 西 使 使
Before long the Jin enfeoffed Xi as Prince of Shu. Xi sent Song a letter hinting that he should leave; Song did not know what to do. The Xingyuan commander Liu Jia and tea-and-horse commissioner Fan Zhongren visited Song and plotted to raise troops to execute Xi; Song feared the matter would leak and bring disaster, and immediately bowed the two men out. Reports came that Jin troops were about to arrive; the people ran in panic, trampling one another, and the whole city was in uproar. Song hurriedly fled toward Micang Mountain, went downstream from Lang Prefecture to Chongqing, and sent a letter to Xi begging travel expenses to buy a boat and addressing Xi as Prince of Shu. Xi sent an envoy with a sealed casket as a gift; Song saw it from afar and was greatly terrified, suspecting it was a sword, and fled at once. The envoy caught up; Song had no choice but to open and look—it was gold and jewels. Song then traveled day and night out of the gorges and, facing west with tears, said, "I have now preserved my head." When Xi was executed, an edict stripped Song of office, demoted him three ranks, and ordered him to reside in Yun Prefecture; he was demoted again to vice military commissioner of the Shunchang Army and assigned to Li Prefecture. He was further reduced to vice training commissioner of Guo Prefecture and assigned to Bin Prefecture. He died in Bin Prefecture.
42
Chen Qian, courtesy name Yizhi, came from Yongjia in Wen Prefecture. A jinshi of the eighth year of Qiandao (1172), he was appointed revenue clerk of Fuzhou, supervisor of archival documents in the Ministry of Justice, then transferred to recorder of the National University, reviser at the Edict Office, and compiler at the Bureau of Military Affairs. When he set forth the five matters of national revival and reached Li Gang's proposal to establish command posts, the emperor said, "What is Gang worth discussing?" Qian said, "When Your Majesty employs great ministers, careful judgment should place one above Gang—this should follow the sacred instruction. Yet now one is placed far below Gang—what is to be done?" The emperor frowned, and they then argued at length for more than several quarters of an hour.
43
西
When Emperor Xiaozong abdicated internally, Qian served as vice prefect of Jiang Prefecture, prefect of Chang Prefecture, and commissioner of Hubei ever-normal granaries. He pacified the Dong Yao of Chen Prefecture, was granted the Direct Huanzhang Pavilion, appointed bureau director in the Ministry of Revenue, and made overall supervisor of the wealth and taxes of Hu and Guang. Qian was a client of Chief Councilor Zhao Ruyu; when factional disputes arose he was dismissed and expelled. Several years later he was recalled as judicial commissioner of the Chengdu circuit, transferred to transport judge of the Western Capital circuit, and again granted the Direct Huanzhang Pavilion.
44
Han Tuozhou plotted to provoke the Jin and ordered that those who presented horses receive office; the people of seven prefectures incited one another into banditry. Qian sent a letter to Tuozhou saying, "If one now relies on bandit gangs to carry out a policy of plunder, how can defeat and ruin be treated as a game?" Soon after he repeatedly discussed the crimes of the Xiang commander Huangfu Bin and Li Yi, and also requested dismissal. The emperor issued instructions that Xue Shusi should mediate and harmonize matters. He was transferred to vice director of the Court of Agriculture and overall supervisor of Hu and Guang, and appointed staff officer of the pacification headquarters.
45
Jin troops penetrated deeply, captured Yingcheng, burned Hanchuan, and Han Yang fled from an empty city; Wuchang was shaken with fear. Qian, as Hanlin attendant of the Baomo Pavilion, served as deputy pacification commissioner; that same day he established headquarters on the north bank and ordered the local strongman Zhao Guan to attack midstream; many soldiers and horses drowned, and the remaining troops all fled back. Before long his office was stripped and he was dismissed. Later he again served as prefect of Jiang Prefecture. When Tuozhou died and peace talks were settled, Qian was again dismissed and given a stipendary post. He died at age seventy-three.
46
Qian had a reputation for brilliance and was early on regarded favorably by the good and worthy. In his later years he was dismissed in the false-learning prohibition and was the first to call Tuozhou "my prince"; scholarly opinion therefore held him in low esteem.
47
Zhang Yan, courtesy name Xiaoweng, was a native of Daliang; his family moved to Yang Prefecture, and at the end of Shaoxing he crossed the Yangzi and settled in Huzhou. By nature he was quick-witted, supple, and skilled at ingratiation. He passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of Qiandao (1169), served through offices to investigating censor, and with Zhang Fu, Chen Ziqiang, Liu Sanjie, Cheng Song, and others fawned on Chief Councilor Han Tuozhou, slandered and expelled the worthy men of the time, and enforced the prohibition against the Learning of the Way.
48
殿 殿
He advanced to palace censor, was repeatedly promoted to supervisory attendant, and appointed vice grand councilor. Because of critics he was dismissed to serve as academician of the Hall of Literary Endeavor and prefect of Pingjiang, then soon promoted to grand academician and prefect of Yang Prefecture. At that time the border conflict had just opened; an edict ordered Yan and Cheng Song to divide command of the two Huai regions. Soon after they were recalled, and Yan became vice grand councilor and concurrently associate director of state affairs. In the second year of Kaixi (1206), he was transferred to director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. The next year, he was appointed supervisor of Jiang and Huai military forces.
49
使
At that time Fang Xinru was envoy to Jin to negotiate peace; Wu Xi rebelled with Shu, negotiations were unsettled, and Xi was executed. The Jin soon resumed the earlier talks and Xinru went again. Tuozhou urged Yan to send Bi Zaiyu and Tian Lin to combine forces and suppress the enemy, and also offered rewards for capturing the false commander alive. Before long battles in Chuan and Shaanxi suffered repeated defeats, Dasanguan fell, and the enemy's disposition changed again. Yan opened the supervisory headquarters for nine months, spending more than 3.7 million strings of official cash; seeing peace talks go back and forth, he then said he did not know warfare and firmly requested to leave.
50
便 祿
When Tuozhou was executed, Censor Zhang Xie argued that Yan and Su Shidan had formed a wicked faction and harmed the state; two ranks were stripped from Yan. Emperor Ningzong said that when the military conflict opened Yan had once said it should not be done; he was permitted to do as he wished, his original rank was restored, and he was given a stipendary post. He retired with the rank of Silver Blue-Green Glory Grandee, died, and was posthumously granted special advancement.
51
The commentator says: Shi Hao was even-tempered and forgiving by nature, yet he could not counsel his ruler in plans for recovery. Wang Huai initiated the prohibition against false learning and poisoned the good and worthy. Zhao Xiong joined Yu Yunwen in plotting to use troops, yet the old history says the two obstructed Zhang Shi—why? Bangyan defended the city and fought hard; it is a pity he assisted Lü Yihao in attacking Li Gang—gentlemen think less of him for it. Cheng Song, Chen Qian, and Zhang Yan were slanderers and flatterers—not worth counting at all!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →