← Back to 宋史

卷四百十四 列傳第一百七十三 史弥远 鄭清之 史嵩之 董槐 葉夢鼎 馬廷鸞

Volume 414 Biographies 173: Shi Miyuan, Zheng Qingzhi, Shi Songzhi, Dong Huai, Ye Mengding, Ma Tingluan

Chapter 414 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 414
Next Chapter →
1
Shi Miyuan, Zheng Qingzhi, Shi Songzhi, Dong Huai, Ye Mengding, and Ma Tingluan
2
Shi Miyuan
3
調沿 簿 西
Shi Miyuan, whose style was Tongshu, was the son of Shi Hao. In the sixth year of the Chunxi era (1179), he received appointment as Gentleman for Attendance. Two years later he was promoted to Gentleman for Propagating Righteousness, placed first in the civil-service examination, posted to the grain-supply office of Jiankang Prefecture, and then transferred to the Coastal Pacification Commission as a staff officer. In the fourteenth year of Chunxi he passed the jinshi civil examination. In the first year of Shaoxi (1190) he was appointed Directing Clerk of the Court of Judicial Review. The following year he was made Director of the Altar of the God of the Soil. In the third year he became Registrar of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices; because his parents were elderly he asked for a temple appointment and was assigned to administer Chongyou Abbey. He then went into mourning upon his father's death. In the second year of Qingyuan (1196) he returned to the post of Directing Clerk at the Court of Judicial Review, and shortly thereafter became professor at the Greater and Lesser Schools for imperial clansmen. At a rotating audience with the throne he asked that men of integrity be publicly honored and that greater rewards be given for recommending them; that canals be dredged, dikes reinforced, granaries stocked, tax and labor levies made equitable, farming and silk production promoted, luxury trades curbed, and every measure taken to guard against flood and drought; and that city walls be restored, arms readied, commanders chosen, soldiers trained, grain hoarded, beacon lines kept in order, and the frontier made secure against invasion. Chief Councillor Jing Yong sent his attendants away and said, "Your future career will far outshine mine; I ask you to look after my children." In the fourth year of Qingyuan he was made a compiler at the Bureau of Military Affairs, promoted to Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, soon given a concurrent post in the Ministry of Works, and then moved to the Ministry of Justice. In the sixth year he was transferred to Vice Director of the Imperial Clan Court. He requested a provincial post and was appointed prefect of Chizhou. In the fourth year of Jiatai (1204) he was appointed intendant of the Ever-Normal Granaries in western Zhe. In the first year of Kaixi (1205) he became a secretary in the Ministry of Rites, with concurrent duties on the National History and Veritable Records, then rose to Vice Director of the Palace Library and Recorder of the Emperor's Actions. In the second year of Kaixi he also served as lecturer at the Hall of Cultivating Goodness.
4
沿調 使
Han Tuozhou had urged war on the northern frontier to shore up his power; when the border armies were routed, the court ordered officials to speak freely. Miyuan memorialized: "Counselors today say that whoever strikes first controls the enemy and whoever delays is controlled. That may hold for generals in a single battle fought for immediate victory. But when the fate of the dynasty, the ancestral shrines, and the realm itself is at stake, how can we stake the lives of millions on one gamble? The capital is the heart of the empire, yet so many troops have marched out that few remain to guard it. If thieves or rebels should strike, who will defend the city? The armies posted along the Yangzi, each guarding its sector, exist to protect the mobile capital and must be kept at full strength. They should not be redeployed lightly; then court and frontier alike will be secure, with no opening for the enemy to probe. The envoys sent to the borders should be told only to inspect the frontier, rally deserters and stragglers, warn the troops, and hold the line. They must not heed reckless talk that would undo our strategy, nor chase small gains that would give the enemy cause to attack. Ease the burden on the people, strengthen the state, and wait months and years until we are ready for a major campaign. That will be the dynasty's lasting blessing."
5
While he was finishing the memorial, someone warned him, "Tuozhou will use your words to court public favor. Your mother is elderly—will you not bring grief upon her?" Miyuan replied, "These are desperate times. If what I say helps the realm and the people, I will accept punishment gladly." He was enfeoffed as Baron of Yin County and appointed acting Vice Minister of Justice. In the third year of Kaixi he moved to the Ministry of Rites, with concurrent posts on the National History and Veritable Records, while retaining his Ministry of Justice duties.
6
使 殿
After war broke out, defeat followed defeat. Repeated embassies sought peace, but the Jin court refused. The capital was shaken and the inner palace lived in fear, as if ruin might come any day, yet everyone was afraid of Tuozhou and kept silent. Miyuan urgently described the peril facing the dynasty. Prince Xun heard him and at once memorialized the throne; Tuozhou was removed from office and Chen Ziqiang was appointed Right Chief Councillor. Soon the censorate and remonstrance officials flooded the court with protests, and Tuozhou was executed. Miyuan was summoned to the Yenhe Hall. The emperor wanted to make him Signing Secretary of the Bureau of Military Affairs, but he firmly declined and was promoted instead to Minister of Rites with duties on the National History and Veritable Records.
7
使沿 使
Xun was made crown prince, with Miyuan as his grand tutor. Envoys went to the Jin to negotiate peace; the Jin returned the passes of Dasan and Geya and Hao Prefecture. Miyuan memorialized: "The frontiers along the two Huai, the Xiang, and the Han are still devastated and our armies are not yet replenished. We must urge our commanders to honor the trust we place in them; inspect the troops and correct errors in the muster rolls. Repair fortifications, restore arms, and stock provisions. Even after peace envoys have come and gone, we should live as though war were still unsettled: choose able governors and generals to strengthen our defenses, and promote the wise and brave for whatever crisis may come." He was appointed Vice Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs and Grand Mentor to the Crown Prince, and promoted to Earl.
8
使 便 使使 歿
In the first year of Jiading (1208) he became Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs, was made Marquis of Fenghua and Concurrent Administrator of Affairs, then Right Chief Councillor, Commissioner of Military Affairs, and Junior Tutor to the Crown Prince, and was raised to Duke of a founding meritocrat. When his mother died he went home to arrange the funeral. The crown prince asked that he be given a house in the capital so he could observe mourning there while remaining available for counsel. In the second year envoys urged him to return in haste; he set out and was recalled from mourning to Right Chief Councillor, Commissioner of Military Affairs, and Junior Preceptor to the Crown Prince. In the fourth year the stigma of being recalled from mourning was cleared from his record. He vindicated Zhao Ruyu, sought posthumous honors and a title for him, and corrected the slander written into the histories. Zhu Xi, Peng Guinian, Yang Wanli, and Lü Zuqian of the banned "False Learning" faction, though dead, were posthumously honored or had their names restored; their descendants were given office, and worthy elders in exile were recalled. In the fourteenth year of Jiading he was granted ritual vessels for his ancestral temple.
9
使 使 使 使使 使
When Ningzong died, Miyuan installed Lizong on the throne. He was made Grand Preceptor while keeping his posts as Right Chief Councillor and Commissioner of Military Affairs, and was raised to Duke of Wei. He declined six times, then asked to leave government, return to his estate, and quickly left the capital; the emperor agreed. In the second year of Baoqing (1226) he was appointed Junior Preceptor and given a jade belt. He urged the emperor to serve the empress dowager wholeheartedly, study hard and cultivate virtue to repay Heaven's favor, and live up to the loyalty of the realm. In the first year of Shaoding (1228), when the empress dowager received an honorific title, he was appointed Grand Tutor but declined eight times. That summer he fell ill and repeatedly asked to retire, but was refused. After a disaster in the capital he submitted five memorials asking to be removed from office, and his rank was reduced to Duke of Fenghua. In the spring of the fifth year his original rank was restored. In the sixth year, when he was to be made Grand Preceptor, he declined three times and asked that the appointment be withheld, but the emperor refused. He was then appointed Grand Preceptor, remaining Right Chief Councillor and Commissioner of Military Affairs as Duke of Lu, and declined three more times. In the fifth year of Shaoding he asked to retire and was appointed Grand Tutor. Soon afterward he was made Grand Preceptor, Left Chief Councillor, and Commissioner of Military Affairs. He asked again to leave government. He kept the title of Grand Preceptor but was given the nominal posts of Military Commissioner of Baoning and Zhaoxin and Director of Liquan Abbey, and was raised to Prince of Kuaiji. He died. When his deathbed memorial arrived, the emperor was stricken with grief and suspended court for three days. Miyuan was posthumously made Director of the Secretariat, enfeoffed as Prince of Wei, and given the posthumous title Loyal and Offering. The Ministry of Revenue paid out thousands in silver and silk as funeral gifts; the inner treasury added five thousand bolts and taels, and envoys were sent to perform the rites. When the funeral procession returned, ritual officials offered sacrifices outside the city gate; he was granted a funeral banner, jade ornaments, and the dark red and black mourning robes.
10
使 滿
Earlier, after Li Quan was killed, Huai'an was recovered and Xuyi captured, and merit rewards were handed out; every general expected exceptional promotion. When someone raised this with Miyuan, he said, "Commanding generals is like training a hawk: when it is hungry it stays with you; when it is full it flies off. When Cao Bin conquered the south, Emperor Taizu of Song still refused to make him a commissioner or chief councillor. The frontier garrisons are still in place and alarms still sound. If every general got everything he wanted and grew smug, who would die for the realm when crisis struck?" Zhao Shanxiang of the imperial clan had opened a command headquarters and had directed much of the campaign; he constantly hoped for a seat in the chief council. Miyuan said, "The imperial clan is always a delicate matter for the state. Gaozong decreed that clansmen might hold clan offices but not serve as chief councillors. At the end of Shaoxi and the start of Qingyuan, Zhao Ruyu and Ye Yanyue were given council posts only because they had helped settle the succession—an exceptional case. As I am related to Shanxiang by marriage, how could I possibly agree?" Miyuan trusted his close friend Zhou Zhu, his brother Miyuan Mao, and his nephew Xia Zhouzhuan with his deepest secrets. Everyone expected them to rise high, yet Zhu died a commoner, Mao entered office only through the chief councillor's privilege, and Zhouzhuan through a minor court favor—and none rose above Instructor in Military Affairs.
11
After executing Han Tuozhou, Miyuan had served as Ningzong's chief councillor for seventeen years. When Ningzong died he deposed the Prince of Ji, though that had not been Ningzong's wish. He installed Lizong and ruled alone for nine more years, hoarding power and filling office with sycophants. Lizong was grateful that Miyuan had put him on the throne and ignored the welfare of the realm; even when censors denounced Miyuan's crimes, the emperor would not listen. After Miyuan's death his descendants were still richly favored, and a stele was later erected bearing the title "Loyal servant who upheld the dynasty and founding meritocrat of the succession." The Prince of Ji had died under suspicious circumstances, and thoughtful men protested, yet Miyuan used Li Zhixiao, Liang Chengda, and others as his enforcers, banishing and persecuting the leading scholars of the day without mercy.
12
Zheng Qingzhi
13
調 調
Zheng Qingzhi, whose style was Deyuan, was a native of Yin in Qingyuan Prefecture. He had originally been named Xie, with the style Wenshu. As a youth he studied under Lou Fang and showed literary talent; Lou Yue often praised him highly. In the second year of Jiatai (1202) he entered the Imperial University. In the tenth year of Jiatai he passed the jinshi examination and was appointed professor in Xia Prefecture. The commander Zhao Fang was stern and slow to praise anyone. When Qingzhi came to report on affairs, Fang gave a banquet and had his sons Fan and Kui come out to bow. Fang raised Qingzhi so he need not bow in return and said, "One day I hope to leave my two sons in your care." In Hubei, tea merchants had banded together and grown violent. Qingzhi told the intendant He Bing, "These men are tough and capable; they should be enrolled as troops for emergencies." Bing quickly issued a recruitment order, and volunteers flocked in. They were called the "Tea Merchant Army" and proved valuable in later campaigns. He was transferred to preparatory duty at the Hu-Guang General Office and made librarian of the Directorate of Education. In the sixteenth year of Jiatai he was promoted to Recorder of the Imperial College. Chief Councillor Shi Miyuan and Qingzhi plotted to depose the Prince of Ji; see the biography of Prince Huo. Soon he was made professor at the establishment of Prince Weihuixian, then Instructor of the Imperial Clan School, then Doctor of the Imperial University, retaining his teaching posts throughout. When Ningzong died, the chief councillor settled the succession, and Qingzhi drafted all the edicts.
14
殿
When Lizong ascended the throne, Qingzhi was made professor at the schools for imperial clansmen, then Doctor of the Imperial Clan School, Vice Director of the Imperial Clan Court with acting duty in the Ministry of Works, and lecturer at the Chongzheng Hall. The emperor asked about public criticism over silk shoes supplied through the Inner Storehouse. Qingzhi said, "Within the palace there is already a taste for what is fresh and new in dress." The emperor said, "By precedent only a few pairs are sent each month. I do not replace them until they are worn out—how could that invite slander?" Qingzhi replied, "Xiaozong followed Gaozong, so his frugality was easy to show. Your Majesty follows Ningzong, so frugality is harder to make visible. Ningzong lived like a poor scholar, washing his collars again and again and patching his leather shoes. If you wish your frugality to be widely known, you must go beyond what Ningzong did." The emperor approved and accepted his advice.
15
殿 使
In the first year of Baoqing (1225) he was given concurrent duty in the Ministry of War and on the National History and Veritable Records, was promoted to Recorder of the Emperor's Actions, and kept his posts as historiographer, lecturer, and compiler at the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the second year he became Acting Vice Minister of Works, then Acting and finally full Supervising Secretary, and was promoted to Associate Compiler of the National History and Veritable Records. In the first year of Shaoding (1228) he was made Hanlin academician, in charge of drafting proclamations and concurrent lecturer; he was then promoted to compiler of the National History and Veritable Records, Duanming Hall academician, and deputy signatory at the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the third year he was appointed vice grand councillor and deputy signatory at the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the fourth year he was given concurrent duty as associate controller of the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the sixth year Miyuan died, and Qingzhi was appointed right grand councillor and commissioner of military affairs.
16
𡌴 使 殿使 使
In the first year of Duanping (1234), with the emperor now personally directing affairs and ruling with firm independent authority, Qingzhi likewise took the empire's welfare as his own charge. He recalled Zhen Dexiu, Wei Liaoweng, Cui Yuzhi, Li Hui, Xu Qiao, Zhao Rutan, You Yu, You Si, Hong Zikui, Wang Sui, Li Zongmian, Du Fan, Xu Qingsou, Yuan Fu, and Li Shao—a group known at the time as the "Little Yuanyou." The leading figures among them successively entered the highest councils; only Cui Yuzhi consistently declined and never came to court. Recluses such as Liu Zai and Zhao Fan were likewise singled out for special honors. At this time Jin had already fallen, yet the Song forces entering Luoyang suffered a disastrous rout. In the second year he memorialized asking to be relieved of office. The request was denied, and he was appointed special advancement, left grand councillor, and commissioner of military affairs. In the eighth month of the third year, as torrential rains and violent winds struck, he submitted four memorials asking to leave office. In the ninth month, when thunder accompanied the great sacrificial rites, he pressed his resignation request with still greater urgency. He was then made grand academician of the Guanwen Hall, commissioner of the Liquan View, and concurrent lecturer; after four memorials declining the appointment, he was retained as grand academician and made superintendent of the Dongxiao Palace. When border alarms reached him, he submitted a secret memorial: "I fear that excessive sorrow and regret may cloud Your Majesty's clarity and weigh down your firm and resolute resolve." In the third year of Jiaxi (1239) he was enfeoffed as Duke of Shen. In the fourth year an imperial emissary brought the emperor's own inscription for the "Pavilion of Assisting Virtue and Clarifying Counsel," along with one hundred thousand strings of paper currency to build a residence. Thereafter he spent his days wandering among hills and streams with guests and disciples.
17
殿使殿使 殿使 使使西
In the fourth year of Chunyou (1244), though he repeatedly declined reappointment as grand academician of the Guanwen Hall, Liquan View commissioner, and concurrent lecturer, he was made junior guardian with those same posts and was advanced to Duke of Wei. He was summoned for an audience and granted an imperial residence. In the first month of the fifth year, after celebrating the emperor's birthday, he memorialized asking to retire home; the request was denied. He was appointed junior preceptor, retained his posts as Guanwen Hall grand academician, Liquan View commissioner, and concurrent lecturer, and was advanced to Duke of Yue. Before long his son Shichang died; resolved to return east, he was once again refused permission. He was made junior master and military commissioner of the Fengguo Army, kept his posts as Liquan View commissioner and concurrent lecturer, and retained his title as Duke of Yue; he was granted a jade belt and a new residence at the Fishing Lodge on West Lake. While lecturing on the Instructions of Emperor Renzong, he said: "Emperor Renzong's humaneness and magnanimity blossomed into brilliance and clarity, enabling him to strengthen institutions without the danger of lax indulgence and slack governance; Emperor Xiaozong's brilliance and clarity were rooted in humaneness and magnanimity, enabling him to nourish the spirit of the scholar-official class without the habit of forced striving and harsh severity. Humaneness and brilliance depend on each other; that is why the reigns of Renzong and Xiaozong were so flourishing." The emperor praised and commended him.
18
使 使 退使
In the sixth year he was offered the post of grand guardian but declined forcefully. By precedent an official could transfer honors to descendants; Qingzhi asked that his great-grandfather Qia be posthumously enfeoffed, and the emperor agreed—an exceptional favor. In the seventh year he was appointed grand preceptor, right grand councillor, commissioner of military affairs, and Duke of Yue. When the imperial emissary arrived at his door, Qingzhi was off enjoying the lakes and mountains, staying at a Buddhist monastery, and did not return until dawn. At daybreak he was summoned within the palace, where he kowtowed and begged to be excused; the emperor urged him to accept, saying there were matters unknown to those outside. Hardly had he withdrawn when imperial emissaries arrived one after another. When some urged a change of reign title and renewal of governance, Qingzhi said, "Changing the reign title is the emperor's inaugural act; renewing governance is a great turning point for the court. Han precedents are hardly ancient models, yet in any case neither should be done simply because the chief minister has changed."
19
使 使 調便 調便
Troubled by border affairs, the emperor ordered Zhao Kui, as commissioner of military affairs, to take command in the field and Chen Wei, as controller of the Bureau of Military Affairs, to lead forces in Hu and Guang. Both were hesitating to accept when Qingzhi returned as chief minister, strongly backed them, and cleared every appointment without obstruction—whereupon Kui and Wei set out. Thereupon battles were fought at Sishui, Wokou, and Muku, and in every case victory was reported. In the ninth year he was offered grandee and left grand councillor with the military commission; he declined the grandeeship and remained grand preceptor. He often observed that the empire's finances were strained by maintaining troops and that military costs were further burdened by pay certificates; he sought ways to reform the system. When troops were mobilized for frontier garrison duty, he ordered Bureau of Military Affairs staff to calculate distances so routes could be eased and dispatches sequenced according to urgency. He also proposed shifting yearly mobilized garrison troops to guard the Huai front, consolidating units and dividing command to regulate rations and stipends. First he moved the Cesheng Army from Zhenjiang to garrison Sishui—a change that benefited both the state and the people.
20
沿
Where salt deficits occurred on the various circuits, officials in charge often ruined their families trying to make repayment. Qingzhi investigated those who had truly violated regulations and pursued recovery, while fully remitting debts owed through error—sparing a great many families ruin. The tax on boats along the Yangzi had long been heavy; Qingzhi abolished it in stages. At Yanqi in Chi Prefecture, for example, revenues under the designation Great Dharma Field had been divided among various offices. Qingzhi memorialized to abolish the exactions that used this as a pretext to fish for profit—amounting to several times the state's proper revenue—and had the affected offices compensated from the court. When the reply arrived, Qingzhi was drinking with guests; he raised his cup and said, "This wine tastes especially fine today!" He submitted four memorials thanking the throne and asking to retire from office.
21
退 使使
In the tenth year he presented the "Ten Tortoises Primordial Auspicious Admonitions": maintaining reverence; honoring learning; esteeming frugality; exerting effort; being able to settle affairs; discerning goodness; being careful in minute matters; examining words; cherishing time; and seeking what is solid and real. In his memorial he wrote: "It is easy to revere Heaven's anger but hard to revere Heaven's favor. Heaven's anger should cause concern, yet men treat it lightly; Heaven's favor should bring joy, yet men treat it with difficulty—why? Because worry gives rise to fear, and fear can turn Heaven's anger into favor; but pleasure gives rise to complacency, and complacency can turn Heaven's favor back into anger." The emperor was greatly pleased, ordered the historiographers to record it, and issued an edict of commendation. In the eleventh year he submitted ten memorials asking to leave office; all were denied. He was offered the post of grandee but declined forcefully. When rites were held at the Bright Hall, an order directed the Gate of Reception to provide two attendants to support him; he was again granted a jade belt and ordered to wear it at court. On dingyou in the eleventh month, after leaving court he fell gravely ill with a cold; even in his critical state he still worried that snow had not yet fallen. Soon heavy snow fell; he roused himself and said, "The officials will offer congratulations on the snow; the emperor must be greatly pleased." He had snow scooped up and brought to his bedside so he could look at it. He repeatedly memorialized asking to leave office, but when his petitions went unanswered he was finally appointed grand preceptor, military commissioner of the Baoning Army, and commissioner of the Liquan View, advanced to Duke of Qi, and granted retirement. When he died and his final memorial reached the throne, the emperor was deeply shaken and grieved, suspended court for three days, posthumously granted him Minister of the Masters of Writing, enfeoffed him posthumously as Prince of Wei Commandery, and gave him the posthumous title Loyal and Settled.
22
使 使 退使
Qingzhi did not like to stand apart in opposition. Tang Jin had once criticized him in debate; when Qingzhi returned as chief minister, Jin asked to leave. Qingzhi said, "If you insist on being the gentleman, who is left to play the villain?" He pressed him forcefully to stay. Xu Qingsou had once memorialized against Qingzhi; Qingzhi then brought him into the government to serve alongside him. Zhao Kui had inspected the armies for more than a year and asked to be relieved; the emperor did not know how to reward him. Qingzhi said, "Only making him chief minister would adequately reward his service—is Your Majesty holding back because of me? I will certainly not withdraw hastily because Kui is coming; I am willing to serve on the left and let Kui serve on the right." The emperor finally agreed, but Kui never did come to court.
23
稿
When Qingzhi drafted imperial responses and memorials, he usually kept no drafts; his Collected Works of Anwan ran to sixty juan. From the time Qingzhi joined Miyuan in deposing Prince Ji and installing Lizong, he had gradually risen to chief minister; yet the recall of upright men during the Duanping period was largely Qingzhi's work. When he became chief minister a second time, he was already advanced in years; government fell to his wife and children, and idle or dismissed men sometimes used connections to buy their way back into office—conduct the age held in little esteem.
24
Shi Songzhi
25
調 西 西 西使 使便
Shi Songzhi, whose style was Ziyou, was a native of Yin in Qingyuan Prefecture. In the thirteenth year of Jiading (1220) he passed the jinshi examination and was appointed registrar of the revenue section in Guanghua Army. In the sixteenth year he was assigned as preparatory commissioner on the Jingxi-Hubei Circuit Pacification Commission. In the seventeenth year he was promoted to administrative clerk. In the third year of Baoqing (1227) he was put in charge of confidential documents and appointed vice prefect of Xiangyang Prefecture. In the first year of Shaoding (1228), for managing garrison fields he accumulated six hundred eighty thousand units of grain at Xiangyang; his rank was raised and he was made acting prefect of Zaoyang Army. In the second year he was transferred to assistant director of the Armory and concurrently acting prefect of Zaoyang Army; soon after he also served as advisory official on the Pacification Commission. In the third year, when the garrison fields at Zaoyang were completed, he was promoted two ranks. By grace of the Bright Hall rites, he was enfeoffed as Baron of Yin County and granted a fief for sustenance. He was appointed direct access to the Secretariat, transport commissioner of Jingxi, concurrently intendant of the Ever-Normal Granaries and advisory official on the Pacification Commission. In the fourth year he was transferred to vice minister of justice and concurrently deputy pacification commissioner of Jingxi and Hubei. In the fifth year he was additionally made minister of justice and acting vice minister of punishments, promoted to pacification commissioner and concurrently prefect of Xiangyang, and granted discretionary command. In the sixth year he was transferred to vice minister of punishments while retaining his former duties.
26
調 調西
"Your subject has thoroughly weighed fundamentals and broadly considered benefits and harms, willingly accepting the charge of sluggishness in order to devise a plan of complete safety." "Jing and Xiang have suffered year after year from floods and locust plagues, famine, and mass displacement; though relief efforts have been pushed to the limit, the people can barely survive. Levies and mobilizations are already crushing—how can they bear more?" "The situation will inevitably reach the point where household heads abandon their occupations and flee, conscripts desert midway, displaced people gather into bandit bands, and famine-weakened troops collapse before battle even begins." "At such a moment, I truly fear adding anew to Your Majesty's sleepless cares." "Soldiers and people are Your Majesty's soldiers and people; at a single written order for mobilization, they go east or west as commanded." "Yet the matter touches fundamentals; I ask that success be weighed together with failure, the beginning together with the end—considering carefully and examining closely, and planning deeply and thoroughly with the chief ministers."
27
"Peace and alliance on the one hand and advance and seizure on the other absolutely cannot stand together." "Your subject received appointment to guard the frontier just as affairs converged at a critical juncture and opinions were clamorous." "Echoing others in agreement to the point of misleading the state—such a crime deserves execution;" "the folly of holding firm without shifting, in defiance of repeated admonitions—that crime also deserves execution." "Violating the imperial will affects only one person; misleading the state affects the whole empire."
28
Chief Councillor Zheng Qingzhi also wrote advising against creating divisions; Songzhi pressed forcefully to resign.
29
使 西使 西使沿使 便西使 西使沿使
The envoys to the imperial tombs had not yet returned when armies advanced on several routes together; he again memorialized asking to be dismissed, was offered acting minister of war, and declined to accept. He requested a sinecure, was promoted to direct academician of the Baozhang Pavilion, made superintendent of the Taiping Palace, and returned to his fields to care for his parents. Soon after he was made direct academician of the Huawen Pavilion, prefect of Longxing Prefecture, and concurrently Jiangxi pacification commissioner. After the army's rout, the emperor began to regret not having heeded Songzhi's advice; he summoned him for an audience, but Songzhi declined forcefully and was appointed acting minister of punishments. At his presentation he memorialized on winning people's hearts, rousing the spirit of the scholar-official class, verifying and solidifying financial administration, and other matters. He also wrote: "In affairs today, self-governance must come first; one cannot rely solely on peace negotiations." He requested a sinecure and was appointed with his former rank as prefect of Pingjiang Prefecture; when his mother fell ill he begged leave to attend her with medicine and returned without awaiting approval. He was promoted to academician of the Baozhang Pavilion, pacification commissioner of Huai West, concurrently deputy pacification commissioner along the river, and prefect of E Prefecture. After he was summoned within the palace, he was granted discretionary command and additionally served as general intendant of Hu and Guang and Huai West pacification commissioner. In the first year of Jiaxi (1237) he was promoted to academician of the Huawen Pavilion and Jingxi-Jinghu pacification commissioner, remaining deputy pacification commissioner along the river and concurrently controlling Guang, Huang, Qi, and Shu. He asked to be relieved of the concurrent general intendancy, and the request was granted.
30
殿 西西西 西西
When the siege of Luzhou was lifted, an edict commended him. On account of the Bright Hall favor, he was promoted to baron and granted additional income lands. He submitted memorials setting forth three matters each for the Yangtze and Huai regions, presented ten difficulties, and argued that Chingling could not be held without Meng Kung, begging that Meng be encouraged to remain. When Hanyang came under attack, Songzhi led troops out from Chingling, memorialized for the execution of Chang K'o-ta, and banished Lu P'u and Li Shih-ta for having abandoned their posts. In the second year, when the siege of Huang Prefecture was lifted, an edict commended him; he was appointed academician of the Tuanming Hall with his duties unchanged and favors equal to those of chief ministers, was promoted to marquis of Fenghua Commandery, and granted additional income lands. Summoned to audience, he was appointed vice grand councillor and placed in charge of the armies of the East and West, Chinghu, and Kiangsi circuits, with his headquarters at O Prefecture; he additionally supervised the Huainan West Route armies and the forces of Kuang, Ch'i, Huang, K'uei, and Shih, and was granted additional income lands. He fortified Huang Prefecture. In the eleventh month, Kuang Prefecture was recovered. In the twelfth month, Ch'u Prefecture was recovered. In the third year, he was granted the rank of Hsüan-feng Grandee and appointed right chief councillor concurrently director of the privy council and grand supervisor of the armies of the Two Huai, Szechuan, Chingxi, and Hupai; he was promoted to duke and granted additional income lands, additionally supervised the armies of Kiangsi and Hunan, and his title was revised to grand supervisor of the Yangtze, Huai, Ching, Hu, and Szechuan armies. He recommended thirty-two scholars; afterward Tung Huai and Wu Ch'ien were both acclaimed as worthy chief ministers.
31
使 西 祿 使 使
Hsin-yang was recovered, and grain from the supervisory headquarters was used to relieve famine among the Huai people. In the sixth month, Hsiang-yang was recovered; Songzhi said, "Though Hsiang-yang has been recovered, it will not be easy to defend." From then on the frontier frequently reported victories, and edicts commended him. In the fourth year, he requested a sinecure but was urgently summoned to report on affairs; he was promoted three ranks and remained right chief councillor concurrently director of the privy council; imperial favor was unusually great, and gifts were bestowed day after day. During a prolonged drought, he asked to be relieved of state affairs. After an earthquake, he repeatedly submitted memorials asking to be dismissed, but all were refused. In the first year of Ch'un-yu (1241), he presented the Admonition of the Jade Axe. When Annam sent tribute without acknowledging the dynastic calendar, Songzhi proposed following Fan Chung-yen's precedent in rejecting Western Hsia correspondence, and had the tribute returned on the ground that the court should not be apprised of it. In the second year, he presented the annals of the Kao, Hsiao, Kuang, and Ning emperors, the Essentials of Emperor Hsiao-tsung's Military Governance, the Veritable Records and Daily Calendar of Emperor Ning-tsung, the Institutional Compendium, and the Imperial Genealogy; he was promoted to grandee of the golden seal and purple girdle and granted additional income lands. That winter, he was enfeoffed as duke of Yung Kingdom and granted additional income lands. In the fourth year, when his father died, he was recalled from mourning to serve again as right chief councillor concurrently director of the privy council. The emperor repeatedly sent handwritten edicts and dispatched palace envoys to hurry him back to office. Thereupon one hundred forty-four Imperial Academy students, including Huang K'ai-po, Chin Chiu-wan, and Sun I-feng; sixty-seven Military Academy students, including Weng Jih-shan; ninety-four Capital Academy students, including Liu Shih-chü, Wang Yüan-yeh, and Huang Tao; thirty-four Princes' Academy students, including Yü Huan; and Lu Yüeh, professor of the Chien-ch'ang Prefecture school—all submitted memorials arguing that Songzhi should not be recalled from mourning, but received no response. After Hsu Yüan-chieh of the directorate of palace buildings answered at audience and Liu Chên submitted a sealed memorial, the emperor's mind was somewhat changed.
32
Earlier, Songzhi's nephew Ching Ch'ing had once remonstrated with him in a letter, saying:
33
便
"Uncle, holding the great governance of the empire, must accomplish the empire's great affairs;" "bearing the empire's great charge, must be able to achieve its great merit." Of late what you undertake gradually fails to reach completion; in your method of employing men, some are promoted without awaiting recommendation and scrutiny, some censured one day and reinstated the next, and some scarcely in mourning before being suddenly recalled. Granting that extraordinary talents receive extraordinary appointments—rich favor and special rewards to gather men of ability—do you know whether such men truly won their posts by scheming within the tent and offering the six wondrous stratagems? Or did they win them by offering bribes as staff retainers? Did they truly win them by charging on horseback and displaying the valor of a single battle? Or did they win them by aping frowns like menials and servants? One hears only that bribes are openly exchanged, policy issues from many hands, favorites and private intimates run rampant in every disgraceful way, and the ancestral regulations are being ruined today.
34
退 西
Since the supervisory headquarters was opened, the strength of the people in the southeast has been exhausted by supply and demand; prefectures and counties are hard pressed and depleted in meeting requisitions; gold, silks, fodder, and grain crowd the roads—"first the supervisory headquarters, second the supervisory headquarters"—and no one knows what business is being done or what achievement is being accomplished! Recently I hear that Szechuan is not being held; many attribute it to the error of withdrawing troops at O. Why? Garrisons were distributed in camps to guard the frontier and repel invaders, head and tail aiding each other like the serpent of Ch'ang-shan. At Wei-yang there was Chao K'uei, at Lu-chiang Tu Po-hu, and at Chin-ling Pieh Chih-chieh. The holder of the supervisory headquarters ought to occupy the strategic ground at O-chu: from there he could aid Szechuan to the west, the Huai to the east, and secure Ching and Hu to the north. Instead of planning thus, you have wholly stripped away the outer defenses and penetrated deep into the inner chambers—Uncle, your plan to secure yourself may be safe enough, but what of the living masses under heaven!
35
Hence starving people and rebel generals, seizing the opportunity to strike, have raided Yüan and Hsiang and shaken Ting and Li. If the position at Chingling stands alone, then the position at Wuch'ang will not be easy to hold; if the routes of Ching and Hu are slightly alarmed, how can the prefectures of Kiang and Che sleep in peace? Moreover, killing those who surrendered and breaking faith means the plan of the other day to withdraw frontiers cannot be used again; the inner lands losing protection means the strategy of the other day to clear the countryside cannot be applied again. Once this gap is opened, the living masses of the southeast will be no more than meat upon the chopping block. Then how can the territory of the Sung house since the southern crossing preserve its integrity without breach? Why not plan for this early—above to ease the emperor's anxiety from dawn to dusk, below to comfort your parents' hope from morning to evening? Otherwise, troops will grow weary and funds exhausted, achievements will not be completed, the ruler will worry and the minister be shamed, and public opinion will not tolerate it. Should men who fear not the powerful bind you by the law of the Spring and Autumn Annals and proclaim the fault of campaigning without effect—at such a time, could you even enjoy the leisurely nurture of bean and water? When the national history records it in days to come, you will not rank among the founding merit ministers like Chao P'u, but will be placed after the state-misleading traitors like Ts'ai Ching—leaving a stench for ten thousand years; with what face can you meet our ancestors beneath the ground? Men say disaster rises within the curtained wall and danger is like morning dew—this is what I, in deepest grief, speak to Uncle with utmost earnestness.
36
For the plan of today, nothing is better than wholly removing the petty men in the staff, summoning all the gentlemen in retirement, together changing course and joining strength in the king's affairs—then perhaps what was lost at the eastern corner may be recovered at the mulberry sunset. If you see loss yet know not how to rescue, see wrong yet know not how to reform, put fragrant orchid and foul weed in the same vessel and slow nags with swift steeds in the same manger—the great trend of the empire will day by day hasten toward peril and ruin. Uncle and Ching Ch'ing are as close as father and son; Uncle, do not dismiss this because I am young—then our clan will be greatly fortunate! The living masses under heaven will be greatly fortunate! Our ancestral altars and state will be greatly fortunate!
37
殿 使
Before long, Ching Ch'ing died suddenly; rumor had it that Songzhi had caused his death by poison. Songzhi was not tolerated by public opinion and lived in retirement for thirteen years. In the spring of the fourth year of Pao-yu (1256), he was appointed grand academician of the Kuan-wen Hall and granted additional income lands. On the kuei-ssu day of the eighth month he died; his final memorial was submitted; the emperor suspended court; he was posthumously granted junior preceptor and military commissioner of An-te Army, promoted to duke of Lu Kingdom, given the posthumous title Chung-chien, and the posthumous title was changed to Chuang-su because of a family taboo. At the beginning of Te-yu, on the memorial of Right Remonstrator Hsu Chih-fang, his posthumous title was revoked.
38
使 調簿
Tung Huai, whose style was Ting-chih, was a native of Ting-yuan in Hao Prefecture. In youth he delighted in speaking of warfare and secretly read the books of Sun Wu and Ts'ao Ts'ao, saying, "If I were given employment, I would sweep the central lands clean and restore them to the Son of Heaven." Huai had a very imposing appearance—broad forehead, full cheeks, and a handsome beard; when discussing affairs he was impassioned and compared himself to Chu-ko Liang and Chou Yü. His father Yung, encountering Huai in severity and hearing him compare himself thus, angrily laughed and said, "You do not study hard, yet delight in grand talk—this is a mad youth; I want no part of it." Huai felt ashamed at heart and thereupon humbled himself all the more, studying under Yeh Shih-yung of Yung-chia. Hearing that Fu Kuang was a disciple of Chu Hsi, he again went to study under Kuang, who sighed at his excellence in learning. In the sixth year of Chia-ting (1213), he passed the chin-shih examination and was assigned as recorder of Ching-an. He entered mourning for his father and left office.
39
西
In the fourteenth year, he was recalled to serve as judicial assistant of Kuang-te Army; a commoner falsely accused the wealthy man Li Chüeh of privately casting weapons and joining heroes to respond to Li Ch'üan; the prefecture arrested and imprisoned him; Huai perceived the injustice and reported it to the prefect, who said, "To plead for rebels is to bring extinction upon one's clan." Huai said, "The official clearly knows the case is unjust, yet forces the accused toward death to fit the law—does the law truly mean that all defendants, whether wronged or not, may be killed?" The prefect would not listen. Before long the prefect left office in grief; Huai acted as acting vice prefect and sighed, "Chüeh is truly wronged; if I do not release him now, he will have no way to live." Thereupon he reversed the charges, made clear that Chüeh had not rebelled, submitted a memorial, and in the end secured Chüeh's release from prison. In the second year of Shao-ting (1229), he was transferred to be investigating censor of Chên-chiang. The next spring he entered the capital as supervisor of documents in the archives of the ministry of punishments. In autumn he concurrently held acting charge of the archives of the ministries of rites and war, was transferred to registrar of the state farms, and was specially assigned as acting vice prefect of Chên-chiang Prefecture. Upon reaching the prefecture, Li Ch'üan rebelled, crossed the Huai and approached the Great River; the superior prefecture urgently dispatched the prefectural troops. Huai that same day led troops across the river westward; Ch'üan fled, and he then returned. In the fifth year, he entered mourning for his mother. In the third year of Tuan-p'ing (1236), he was assigned as vice prefect of Ch'i Prefecture and declined.
40
簿 使
In the first year of Chia-hsi (1237), he was summoned to the imperial secretariat, transferred to registrar of the imperial clan court, and sent out as prefect of Ch'ang Prefecture. Three days later he was made judicial intendant of Hupei. Ch'ang-te Army mutinied; at night they set fires and clamored; the prefect and commandant bolted their gates and would not come out. Huai rode with a few followers to the place of fire and inquired into the cause of the disorder. The mutineers said, "General Ma Yen-chih seized our annual stipend; we intend to hold him accountable for repayment—we are not making rebellion." Huai, seated on his horse, summoned Yen-chih and beheaded him before the horse; the mutineers returned to the ranks; the next day he arrested seven ringleaders and executed them in the market, and compensated Yen-chih's family. He was assigned to serve as inspector of Kuei, Hsia, and Yüeh. In the second year, he concurrently held acting charge as prefect of Ch'ang-te Prefecture; soon after he additionally served as vice director of the armory, while still holding judicial intendancy as before.
41
In the third year, as direct attendant of the Pao-mo Pavilion he was made prefect of Chiang Prefecture concurrently staff officer of the grand supervisory headquarters. In autumn, more than one hundred thousand refugees who had crossed the river to return home came; those in discussion all said, "With warfare underway, prefectures and commanderies urgently need stored grain and have no leisure to feed the people." Huai said, "The people are my people; to release my grain and relieve them—why may this not be done?" Those who arrived were as though returning home. At that time the Sung and the Chin were neighboring states; between Hsiang, Han, Yang, and Ch'u, local heroes all joined one another to protect their clans, and ruffians often went off to become bandit gangs. Chai Ch'üan of Fu-kuang lodged at Huang-p'i with a following of more than three thousand and gradually went out on plundering raids.
42
使
Huai had a guest persuade Ch'üan to submit; he moved him to Yang-wu Isle, had him farm mixed fields in the Ch'i-ch'un region, again feasted and rewarded him, and employed him as a deputy general. Thereupon Ts'ao Ts'ung, Liu Ch'ing-chih, and their kind all came to submit of their own accord.
43
沿使西
In the fourth year, he was promoted to direct attendant of the Hua-wen Pavilion, made prefect of T'an Prefecture, and put in charge of the affairs of the Hunan Pacification Commission. Just as the three frontiers urgently needed defense, the supervisory headquarters requisitioned day and night and the people were growing distressed; Huai devised plans to meet the demands, so that the people were not harmed and military supplies were not exhausted. In the second year of Ch'un-yu, he was transferred to Left Department bureau officer, promoted to associate in the Chih Lung-t'u Pavilion, vice commissioner of the Yangtze River frontier command, concurrently prefect of Chiang Prefecture, and supervisor of the Kiangsi Pacification Commission. When he examined the taxes, he found official exactions were severe; he issued an instruction, saying, "Having come to govern this prefecture, yet officials still steal without repenting—I shall execute them!" The officials then trembled with fear and wished to reform themselves. Huai therefore removed harms afflicting the people; whenever a levy was fit to relax, he relaxed it to benefit the people, fearing only that he might not relax enough. He devoted great attention to tallying military stores, always as though the enemy were about to arrive. The deputy general Lu Yüan was fierce and crafty and refused to obey orders; he was beheaded as a warning to the army, after which discipline was restored throughout the ranks.
44
殿沿使使 退 西使 西 西 貿 使
In the third year, he was promoted to compiler in the Secret Archive. In the fourth year, he was summoned to court to report on affairs, appointed acting Vice Minister of Revenue, granted purple robes, and promoted to compiler in the Chi-ying Hall, commissioner of the Yangtze River frontier command, Eastern Kiang pacification commissioner, concurrently prefect of Chien-k'ang, and provisional custodian of the mobile palace. Military administration had grown lax; he instituted three grades of reward for archery and, in spring and autumn, drilled the soldiers in formations, advances and retreats, and thrusting and stabbing; after more than a year they had all become elite troops. In the sixth year, he was summoned to the capital and declined the appointment. He was appointed prefect of Ching-chiang and concurrent Kwangsi Military Commissioner and Pacification Commissioner, but again declined. He was given the concurrent posts of acting Kwangsi transport intendant and judicial intendant. The chief councilor wrote to Huai, saying, "The state is currently at war; a subject must not shrink from urgent difficulties—please do not stubbornly decline, sir." That same day Huai set out on the road; upon reaching Yung Prefecture, he submitted seven strategies for frontier defense. Yung Prefecture bordered various tribal peoples to the west and, to the south, Chiao-chih and groups such as Fu-nu, Yüeh-wu, and Liu-lin, who repeatedly raided the frontier. Huai made non-aggression pacts with them and treated them with sincerity, and they all submitted and remained quiet. He also concluded a five-point agreement with Chiao-chih: no frontier violations, return of invaded territory, return of captives taken in raids, observance of the Sung calendar, and open trade. Envoys were then dispatched bearing tribute goods and elephants, and the entire south was pacified.
45
使 使 殿 使使 退
In the seventh year, he was promoted to gentlemen-at-attendance in the Pao-chang Pavilion. In the eighth year, he was transferred to Vice Minister of Works while retaining his previous duties, concurrently serving as transport commissioner. In the ninth year, he was summoned to court and enfeoffed as Baron of Ting-yuan County. He was appointed Vice Minister of War, concurrently acting supervising censor and court reader, then promoted supervising censor; he submitted a memorial asking that favors granted to imperial consort clans be curtailed so as to reassure scholars and officials throughout the realm. When officials had business that in some measure violated the law, they feared Huai and dared not submit it. As concurrent court reader he was promoted to academician in the Pao-chang Pavilion and appointed prefect of Fu-chou and Fukien pacification commissioner, but declined. His son was promoted in rank of enfeoffment. That winter he was appointed academician of the Tuan-ming Hall and co-signatory of the Bureau of Military Affairs, and elevated in enfeoffment to marquis. In the twelfth year, he became co-director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the first year of Pao-yu, he served as acting associate grand councilor. In the second year, he was promoted to associate grand councilor. The Szechwan frontier commissioner Yü Hui was stripped of office for defeat in battle; the throne ordered the Ching-Hsiang frontier commissioner Li Tseng-po to go inspect the armies, but Tseng-po declined. Huai said, "Matters being thus, how can one still sit back and watch indifferently?" He submitted a memorial asking to go in person and concentrate heavy troops at K'uei Gate to strengthen the mutual support between Ching and Shu. The edict replied, "A trusted minister is one who jointly governs the realm with Us; he ought to remain at court, not be sent to the four quarters." He submitted another memorial, saying, "Affairs under Heaven either advance or retreat—there is no standing still—and no subject dares entertain divergent intent. If Your Majesty deems me fit for trust, please grant me some latitude to prove myself; if I am inadequate for military affairs, I beg to be relieved of rank and office." His request was denied, and he was promoted in enfeoffment to Duke of Hao-liang Commandery.
46
The emperor relied on Huai more and more; Huai spoke frankly on affairs, intending to correct what was wrong in the ruler's mind rather than offer pleasing flattery. When the emperor asked about purchasing civilian grain to stock the frontier, he replied, "The people of Wu are greatly distressed; officials urgently requisition grain without regard for their plight. The people are the foundation of the state; I wish Your Majesty would first attend to that root." When the emperor asked about repairing the Grand Unity Shrine, he replied, "Earthworks rise layer upon layer and the people are exhausted by conscript labor—this is not the way to serve Heaven." When the emperor asked about frontier affairs, he replied, "With enemy states abroad, one's first plan must be self-strengthening. Those who strengthen themselves are feared by others; they need not fear others." He added, "With enemy states before us, talented men ought to be selected and put to use. When scholar-officials had faults and were impeached by law-enforcement officers, they were barred from employment for life—the court deeply regretted this waste of talent. If they were not treacherous and wicked, I wish that all would be cleared and rehabilitated, and their other merits not discarded. As for exiled and demoted officials who had long languished in distant regions and were gradually moved inland—now that they have returned alive, it would suffice merely not to employ them." Whenever Huai memorialized, the emperor always praised him.
47
使 滿
In the third year, he was appointed Right Grand Councilor and concurrently director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. Huai, considering himself elevated by the sovereign, did whatever could benefit the state; yet he attended first to the larger pattern, appointing first old associates in remote posts, and generally rotating those in office after a full year. Those greedy for advancement were displeased at first. Huai also told the emperor, "In my administration there are three things that harm governance." The emperor asked, "What are the three things that harm governance?" He replied, "Imperial consort clans do not observe the law—that is the first; senior law-enforcement officials who remain long in their posts and arrogated authority and favor—that is the second; the Palace Command does not restrain its soldiers—that is the third. Generals fail to restrain their subordinates, so soldiers run riot; when soldiers run riot, mutiny may arise at any time; when law-enforcement officials arrogating authority and favor blur the distinction between the worthy and unworthy, the wicked run rampant while the worthy hide and do not emerge; when kinsmen do not observe the law, statutes lose weight; when statutes lose weight, the court is held in contempt. If these three are not removed, governance will collapse; I beg Your Majesty to eliminate them from above." Thereupon those who envied him grew all the more numerous.
48
殿
As the emperor grew older, he wielded power alone; no minister pleased him, and he gradually came to delight in consorting with flatterers. Ting Ta-chüan was skilled at flattery; the emperor promoted him by leaps and bounds, and he secretly wielded authority while the emperor remained unaware. Ta-chüan was already an attending censor and sent an agent to seek a private connection with Huai. Huai said, "I have heard that ministers must have no private associations; I serve only the ruler and dare not make private pacts—please convey my thanks to Master Ting." Ta-chüan concluded that Huai did not favor him and deeply resented him; day and night he sought out Huai's faults. When Huai entered audience, he spoke at length that Ta-chüan was a wicked flatterer and must not be approached. The emperor said, "Ta-chüan has never spoken ill of you—do not suspect him." Huai said, "What grudge do I have with Ta-chüan? Yet Your Majesty raised me to this position; if I know Ta-chüan is wicked and keep silent, I would be failing Your Majesty. Moreover, Your Majesty deems Ta-chüan loyal while I deem him treacherous—we cannot both continue to serve Your Majesty." When the audience ended he immediately submitted a memorial requesting retirement; there was no reply. In the fourth year, he was dismissed as grand councilor by imperial rescript and appointed Grand Academician of the Kuan-wen Hall to direct the Tung-hsiao Palace. At that time Ta-chüan also impeached Huai; before the memorial was issued, he himself dispatched provincial troops to force Huai to depart. Thereupon Imperial College students including Ch'en I-chung submitted memorials in protest; the account appears in the biography of Ta-chüan.
49
使 使使
In the fifth year and in the first year of Ching-ting, he received increased fief income on both occasions through the Bright Hall sacrifice grace. In the second year, he was specially appointed judge of Fu-chou and Great Pacification Commissioner of the Fukien Circuit, but firmly declined. He was promoted in enfeoffment to Duke of Chi State, and again promoted to Duke of Hsü State. On the twenty-eighth day of the fifth month in the third year, at dusk, heaven sent down torrential rain, fierce wind, thunder, and lightning; Huai rose, dressed in cap and robes, and sat upright; he ordered the women out, lectured his students on the K'ui and Ch'ien hexagrams, and asked what hour of the night it was. The students answered that it was midnight, and thereupon he died. When his final memorial was submitted, he was posthumously enfeoffed as Junior Preceptor of the Heir Apparent and given the posthumous title Wen-ch'ing. The emperor sent an envoy to present sixty catties of gold and a thousand bolts of silk as funeral gifts.
50
Ye Mengding
51
Ye Mengding, whose style was Chen-chih, was a native of Ning-hai in T'ai Prefecture. Originally he was the son of Ch'en T'ai-p'in; at age seven he was given to his mother's clan. In youth he studied under Cheng Lin, associate in the Chih Lung-t'u Pavilion, and Chao Feng-lung, Vice Director of the Imperial Clan Court; through the Superior Imperial College examination he entered with highest distinction, and with two highest grades received initial appointment as military judicial officer of Hsin Prefecture, acted as instructor, and lectured on famine administration. He was transferred to recorder of the Imperial College.
52
In the second year of Ch'un-yu, when thunder changed its pattern, he submitted a sealed memorial urging the summoning of talent and warning against intimacy with the unworthy. The next year, in audience rotation, he spoke on six matters: the gentleman, forthright speech, military institutions, paper currency, appointment of officials, and division of frontier commands. In the same rotation as T'ang Chin he was summoned to examination for a palace post and appointed corrector in the Secretariat. In the fourth year, he was promoted to proofreader, concurrently instructor in the Chuang-wen Hall. In the fifth year, he was transferred to secretariat drafter; in audience rotation he spoke on establishing the heir, seeking wise assistants, assigning frontier commanders, and rewarding the upright and forthright. When thunder changed its pattern he submitted a memorial citing T'ang K'ang-ch'eng's doctrine of the "five things to be feared," and was transferred to assistant compiler. In the sixth year, he was appointed Vice Director of the Armory, concurrently bureau officer in the Ministry of War; in audience rotation he spoke on three matters: state finance, frontier affairs, and the integrity of the state. He also said, "Abroad there is a great enemy watching the frontier; within there is a great villain watching for an opening; strange and wicked persons beguile within the palace precincts, and corrupt minions lean on the state as on a city god; powerful frontier lords and fierce generals sprout shoots easily shaken; grass-thieves and hidden evildoers may trigger sudden change at one's very side."
53
𥮉 西
Acting as prefect of Yüan Prefecture, the transport commission arranged to purchase thirty thousand hu of rice; Meng-ting said, "Yüan has many mountains and little farmland; the court exempted coordinated purchase there for a hundred years already; if it is opened now, the people's descendants will suffer endless harm, and endless resentment will follow." A commoner named T'ang K'ai offered land to the school official; his wife and children were scattered in separation—Meng-ting returned the land to him. He destroyed the licentious shrine at Ch'i-ch'i Village in Wan-tsai and blocked up its demon well. He was summoned to the mobile court. He observed mourning for his birth mother. In the eleventh year, when mourning ended, he was appointed Outer Department vice director of the Ministry of Rites. In audience rotation he said, "Your Majesty is deluded by slander from those at your side and routinely treats those who speak as seekers of fame; slander has cut deep, and obstinacy cannot be dissolved. In recent years, when speech in some measure touched what the ruler finds difficult, if not openly dismissed then secretly demoted; if not soon sent out then traps were set; those who left were repeatedly summoned but not returned, and those who came were expelled at the first outcry." Concurrently compiler of the Imperial Genealogy, he was appointed associate in the Chih Secret Archive, Kiangsi intendant of Ever-Normal Granaries, concurrently prefect of Chi Prefecture. He kept fierce generals under control, established community and charity granaries, cleared Li I-shan's false conviction for bribery, and was summoned to serve as vice director of the Imperial Academy.
54
西 殿殿 西 殿
In the first year of Pao-yu, in audience with the emperor he argued that Kiangsi's charity granaries should be opened at once and must not wait for a provincial report. After examination in the Hall of Assembled Excellence, he was appointed lecturer at the Hall of Venerated Governance and began lecturing on the Book of Documents. Concurrently compiler of the National History and examiner of the Veritable Records, he was transferred to chancellor of the Imperial Academy. In the second year, while also serving as acting vice minister of Rites, he remonstrated against the emperor's planned visit to the Western T'ai-i Palace. In the third year he remained acting vice minister of Rites and chancellor, was promoted to co-compiler of the National History and co-compiler of the Veritable Records Academy, and soon added the post of court lecturer. He entered mourning for his mother. In the fifth year, as a compiler at the Hall of Assembled Excellence, he was assigned to govern Kan Prefecture. Ting Ta-ch'üan dominated the government and tried to bring Meng-ting into court service, but Meng-ting ultimately declined. In the sixth year he was transferred to Chien-ning Prefecture, and then to Lung-hsing Prefecture. In the first year of K'ai-ch'ing he again governed Chien-ning Prefecture, built bridges and post stations, constructed the Ta-an Pass, and resolved doubtful criminal cases.
55
殿 西
In the first year of Ching-ting he was summoned to serve as tutor to the crown prince and submitted a memorial on aligning the throne with Heaven. He was transferred to vice minister of Personnel and granted the food fief of Ning-hai County. In the second year he served concurrently as acting minister of War and acting minister of Personnel. In the third year he was transferred to minister of War, while also serving as compiler of the National History and compiler of the Veritable Records. He was transferred to minister of Personnel, declined the appointment five times and asked for a sinecure post, but the request was denied. He was appointed academician of the Tuan-ming Hall and co-signatory of the Bureau of Military Affairs, but repeatedly declined and was not allowed to withdraw. As co-director of the compilation of the Essential Military Compendium and guest of the crown prince, he was advanced to marquis of Ning-hai. In the fourth year, as signatory of the Bureau of Military Affairs he was made marquis of Lin-hai Commandery, and by Bright Hall grace was further enfeoffed as duke of Lin-hai Commandery. Chancellor Chia Ssu-tao wanted to issue kuan-tzu notes and abolish both the seventeenth and eighteenth series of hui-tzu notes; Meng-ting argued that this would harm the people, so only the seventeenth series was abolished. When the public-field law was put into effect, Meng-ting again held that it would burden the people, so the policy was carried out only in western Che-chiang and no farther. In the fifth year he declined three times without success and was promoted to vice director of the Bureau of Military Affairs and acting grand councilor. When a comet appeared, Meng-ting said it was a time for ruler and subjects alike to reform government in fear; he asked to be relieved of state duties, but again was refused. He submitted a memorial calling for the abolition of the land survey in western Che-chiang.
56
殿沿使
When Emperor Li-tsung died, the court debated the crown prince's accession and the empress dowager's regency from behind the curtain; Meng-ting said, "An empress dowager holding court behind a curtain—is that really something to welcome?" He was promoted to grand councilor and granted an increase in his food fief. Meng-ting forcefully declined the post; Ssu-tao earnestly pressed him to stay, but could not prevail. The emperor repeatedly urged him to remain, and an edict ordered the Gate of the Inner Court to seal and return his memorials of resignation. Ssu-tao memorialized, "If the grand councilor leaves, Chiang Wan-li and Wang Yao will surely not come." At Emperor Li-tsung's re-burial Meng-ting served as acting junior tutor; when the rites were finished he pleaded illness and returned home. Though repeatedly summoned by edict, he forcefully declined and was appointed academician of the Tzu-cheng Hall, prefect of Ch'ing-yüan, and coastal pacification commissioner. He suppressed sea bandits, limiting punishment to the ringleaders, and refused every surplus fee offered to him. He built relief granaries to guard against famine and constructed post stations for traveling guests.
57
使 使
In the third year of Hsien-ch'un he was again summoned as grand councilor and granted an increase in his food fief; he declined six times, but was not allowed to refuse. An edict sent Assistant Compiler Lu Yüeh and the prefect of T'ai-chou, Hsiang Kung-ts'ai, to hurry him to court; he was appointed specially advanced, right chancellor, and director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. He declined repeatedly without success and then shared duties with Ssu-tao. Wang Chia, transport commissioner of Li-chou, had once lost office for something he said, not for any crime; the Szechwan pacification commission had already appointed him as deliberating officer, and after his death his son petitioned for posthumous favors. Meng-ting now cleared Wang of wrongdoing; Ssu-tao, believing the favor had not come from himself, dismissed several provincial and ministry clerks and posted their names at court. Meng-ting said in anger, "I will never behave like Ch'en Tzu-ch'iang." He immediately asked to resign. Ssu-tao's mother rebuked him, saying, "Chancellor Yeh was content at home and never sought advancement; you forced the chancellor's seal on him, and now matters have come to this pass. If you do not do as I say, I will stop eating." Ssu-tao replied, "In office one cannot always avoid acting this way." At the same time students of the National University also submitted memorials accusing Ssu-tao of monopolizing power and clinging to office. He then repented and asked the capital intendant Hung Tao to mediate, while Meng-ting repeatedly submitted memorials asking to retire. After winter thunder appeared, he took the blame upon himself and pressed his resignation all the more forcefully.
58
殿 殿使 使 使
In the fourth year, at the examination for Yang Fei, the chancellor was not to perform the bowing rite, yet clerks called for bows; Meng-ting waved his tablet at them and hurried out. The next day he asked to return to his fields, but an edict urged him to stay. When an edict exempted prefectural governors from ascending the hall to report, Meng-ting said, "The founders of the dynasty carefully valued the trust placed in frontier governors. Before taking office they were always required to report in person, so that the court could observe their character and instruct them face to face to govern with integrity and care for the people. On reaching their posts they would receive officials and commoners and fully convey the emperor's intent, so that they would not fail the purpose for which they had been dispatched. Now men travel thousands of li and yet cannot see the emperor's face though he is within reach—this is far from the original intent of the institution." He also asked that forthright speech be welcomed. He was promoted to junior guardian. In the fifth year, citing the precedent of Tu Yen, who retired and fled alone by cart at night, he repeatedly declined. He was then appointed academician of the Kuan-wen Hall, judicial prefect of Fu-chou, and Fukien pacification grand commissioner, and was enfeoffed as duke of Hsin, but he refused to accept. He was appointed commissioner of the Li-ch'üan Abbey and again refused. In the seventh year he again served as commissioner of Li-ch'üan.
59
使 使 殿使祿
In the ninth year he was appointed junior tutor, right chancellor, and director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. Citing illness, he forcefully declined, but chancellors, clerks, bureau officers, and staff came in succession to hurry him on his way. Supporting himself while ill, he reached Shêng County, asked to resign without success, and begged to return to the mountains and forests. In a memorial he wrote, "I pray that Your Majesty will sharpen your resolve and restrain your desires; those who govern the state should win back hearts, strengthen the foundation of the realm, encourage generals, discipline prefectures and counties, and vigorously restore care for the people." He then took a small boat and went straight home. When envoys warned him of fortune and calamity, Meng-ting told them, "Honor and shame are the greater matter; life and death the lesser. There is absolutely no turning back." Ssu-tao was furious. Censorial officials memorialized to grant his request to retire to his fields, and an edict retained him as junior guardian, grand academician of the Kuan-wen Hall, and commissioner of the Li-ch'üan Abbey, without temple stipend.
60
沿使使 使
When Duke Ying first ascended the throne and consulted elder statesmen, Meng-ting submitted a sealed memorial saying, "Promote the way of teaching, train officials in integrity, strengthen ministerial loyalty, relieve the people's distress, value the selection of scholars, encourage honest officials, punish corrupt ones, and fill the military registers. He was appointed judicial prefect of Ch'ing-yüan and coastal pacification grand commissioner, but forcefully declined and continued as commissioner of the Li-ch'üan Abbey with the added post of court reader, which he also refused to accept. In the second year, when Prince I acceded at Min, Meng-ting was summoned as junior preceptor and commissioner of the T'ai-i Palace. He set out by sea, but the route was blocked and he could not proceed; facing south he wept aloud and turned back. Two years later he died. His son Ying-chi served as assistant director of the Imperial Treasury, prefect of Chien-te, vice director of the Armory, and commander of garrison troops and horses; Ying-yu served as gentleman for court audience and director of the Altar of the God of the Soil.
61
Ma Tingluan
62
調
Ma Tingluan, styled Hsiang-chung, was a native of Lo-p'ing in Jao Prefecture. He was Chuo's biological son and succeeded in the place of Chuo's elder brother Kuang. Poor but diligent in study, after reaching manhood he was hired by neighbors as a children's teacher. Whenever feasts were set before him, he thought of his mother eating plain greens at home and could not swallow the food. He passed the jinshi examination in the seventh year of Ch'un-yu, was assigned as professor at Ch'ih Prefecture, and waited six years before taking up his post.
63
使
In the second year he was promoted to assistant compiler with concurrent service in the Right Bureau, and was transferred to vice director of Palace Construction. In the third year he repeatedly asked for an outside appointment, but was refused. T'ing-luan proposed three reforms to the examination system: tighten local recommendations, give greater weight to re-examination by the provincial offices, and seek out recluses in the mountains and forests. He also spoke on famine relief, arguing that rent and levies owed by disaster-stricken prefectures and counties but impossible to collect should be remitted. He was promoted to director of the Armory with concurrent service in the Left Bureau, then also made right mentor to the crown prince, promoted to left mentor, and acting vice director of the Imperial Academy; he asked to be relieved of his concurrent post in the Left Bureau. In audience rotation he said, "The blessings of peace must begin with Your Majesty's own conduct; the virtue of peace must begin in Your Majesty's own heart." Concurrently acting duty officer of the Han-lin Academy, he was promoted to vice director of the Secretariat and then to acting academician of the Academy Institute. In the fourth year he was promoted to attendance drafter, concurrently right subordinate to the crown prince, compiler of the National History Academy, and examiner of the Veritable Records Academy. In memorial to the throne he said, "The grand astrologer must carefully record anomalies and disasters. May Your Majesty harmoniously receive Heaven's warnings and extend benefits, so as to strengthen the spirit of talented men; and with an open mind receive remonstrance, so as to strengthen the backbone of public speech. Keep the foundation of the state in mind and subordinate private interest to the public good; strengthen frontier defenses and prepare against trouble before it arises." At that time Sung Ch'en was again being considered for office; T'ing-luan cited Ho T'an's argument and strongly urged that Sung Ch'en must not be employed, and the emperor agreed. He recommended twenty scholars and was promoted to secretariat drafting officer. Ch'eng K'uei was corrupt and deceitful and ought not be granted appointment as general attendant gentleman; Wang Chih-yüan belonged to Ta-ch'üan's faction and ought not be made deputy prefect of Kiang Prefecture; Chu I ought not be made prefect of Ch'ing-yüan and pacification commissioner; Lin Shuang, Chao Pi, and Chang Ch'eng-sun were unfit for prefectural posts: he returned all their appointment documents. He also served concurrently in the National History and Veritable Records Academy. In the fifth year, when a comet appeared, he submitted a memorial speaking at length on the relationship between Heaven and human affairs. He was transferred to vice minister of Rites. Emperor Li-tsung's death edict and Emperor Tu-tsung's accession edict were both drafted by T'ing-luan. Appointed concurrently as court reader, he declined but was not permitted to withdraw. He submitted a memorial setting forth the policies of Emperor Hsiao-tsung for the throne's guidance. He was promoted to academician of the Academy Institute.
64
殿 使 殿使
In the first year of Hsien-ch'un he was promoted to academician of the Tuan-ming Hall and signatory of the Bureau of Military Affairs, while also serving as co-director of the compilation of the Essential Military Compendium. He entered mourning for his mother. In the third year he served as vice director of the Bureau of Military Affairs and co-director of the compilation of the Essential Military Compendium. In memorial to the throne he spoke of nurturing the life-vessels of the state, planting deep roots, honoring magnanimity, and practicing benevolence. He also said, "If Your Majesty restores broad-minded forbearance, keeps an open heart and waits patiently, extends inner forgiveness and tolerates what is hard to bear, then no feeling will go unheeded, no principle unexamined, villains will lose heart, upright men will speak freely, and affairs under Heaven may still be set right." He was concurrently appointed acting grand councilor. In the fifth year he was promoted to grand councilor and vice director of the Bureau of Military Affairs, and then to right chancellor and director of the Bureau of Military Affairs. In the eighth year he submitted nine memorials asking to leave office. In the ninth year he retained his posts as Guanwen Hall grand academician, prefect of Shaoxing, and grand pacification commissioner of eastern Zhe. He declined by memorial and was appointed intendant of Dongxiao Palace in Lin'an, keeping his former rank.
65
退
Early in Duzong's reign the court consulted elder statesmen; on the grand strategy of defense and recovery it turned specifically to Zhao Kui. Kui pointed emphatically and said, "This old servant has spent his life in the armies and knows these matters well; I beg the court to treat them with the utmost care." Jia Sidao's face darkened and he said, "This is the man who lost the Three Capitals—a drafting official who has spoken out of turn." Whenever Tingluan saw regulations too rigid, rewards delayed, and commanders holding back, he would promote men in the border commands, bending the rules a little. Sidao grew suspicious of rivals and had a clerk in his hall branded with ink to vent his anger. When he resigned as chief councillor, the emperor was moved for a long while and said, "Chief Councillor, please stay on for my sake." Tingluan said, "I have not long to live and fear I may never see Your Majesty again. Yet state affairs are urgent and the frontier is in grave peril. Whether the realm is safe or in peril, the sovereign does not know; what helps or harms the state—the ministers do not know; victory or defeat on the battlefield—even the frontier commanders do not know. If Your Majesty and the elder ministers will only plan for the long term, I can die in peace." He kowtowed, weeping, and withdrew.
66
The historians' judgment: Shi Miyuan deposed the heir in favor of a distant prince and refused to hear honest counsel. Zheng Qingzhi's reputation suffered when he took the chief ministership a second time. With Miyuan's crimes well known, the court was unhappy that Songzhi should follow him; recalled from mourning, he was attacked from all sides—yet he was genuinely a capable general. Of Dong Huai there is little left to dispute. What befell Ye Mengding and Ma Tingluan—how bitter their fate!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →