← Back to 新唐書

卷九十六 列傳第二十一 房玄齡 杜如晦弟:楚客 叔父:淹 五世孫:元穎 六世孫:審權 七世孫:讓能

Volume 96 Biographies 21: Fang Xuanling, younger brothers Du Ruhui and Du Chuke, Uncle: Yan, Fifth Generation Descendent: Du Yuanying, Sixth Generation Descendent: Shen Quan, Seventh Generation Descendent: Rang Neng

Chapter 96 of 新唐書 · New Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 96
Next Chapter →
1
::::::
Fang Xuanling's son, Yiai; Du Ruhui's younger brother, Chuke; their paternal uncle, Yan; fifth-generation descendant, Yuanying; sixth-generation descendant, Shenquan; seventh-generation descendant, Rangneng.
2
Fang Xuanling
3
綿
Fang Xuanling, styled Qiao, came from Linzi in Qizhou. His father Yanzhi served under the Sui and rose to serve as inspector of the Directorate of Convicts. As a boy, Xuanling was exceptionally bright. He mastered the classical canon, wrote with ease, and was accomplished in both cursive and clerical calligraphy. In the Kaihuang reign, when the empire had been reunified, everyone assumed the Sui dynasty would last forever. Xuanling quietly told his father, "The throne has no true merit behind it. The emperor merely seized the Mandate because he was Zhou's nearest kin. He kills at whim, makes no lasting provision for his heirs, muddles the line between legitimate and illegitimate sons, and encourages rivalry in luxury and presumption until the court turns on itself. In the end the dynasty will devour its own. The realm may look settled now, but its collapse is only a step away. Yanzhi was startled. "Do not speak such reckless words!" At eighteen he passed the jinshi examination. He was made a captain of the Feathered Cavalry and set to collating texts in the Secretariat. Gao Xiaoji, vice director of the Ministry of Personnel, was renowned for judging men. He told Pei Ju, "I have seen countless people, but never anyone like this young man. He will be a pillar of the state. I only regret that I shall not live to see him rise like a dragon above the gorges and into the sky. He was then appointed assistant magistrate of Yicheng. When Prince Liang of Han rebelled, Xuanling was implicated and banished to Shang Commandery. Seeing chaos spread across the Central Plains, he was filled with concern for the fate of the empire. When his father fell ill, he tended him for a hundred days without changing his clothes. After his father's death, he took no food or drink for five days.
4
稿
When the future Taizong, then Duke of Dunhuang, campaigned north of the Wei, Xuanling came on foot with a staff to present himself at the camp gate. They met as though they had known each other for years, and he was appointed recorder for the Weibei campaign headquarters. Once the duke became Prince of Qin, Xuanling was made secretary of the princely household and enfeoffed as Marquis of Linzi. He never missed a campaign. While others scrambled for curios and booty, Xuanling alone recruited men of ability for the prince's staff, quietly winning over the commanders until each was ready to die for the cause. The prince once said, "When Emperor Guangwu of Han gained Deng Yu, his followers drew closer to one another than ever. Now that I have Xuanling, he is my Deng Yu. For ten years he moved in and out of the prince's headquarters. Orders and dispatches—sometimes drafted on horseback—were always terse, complete, and never required a second draft. Gaozu said, "A man of such insight deserves real trust. When he explains matters for my son, it is as if they were talking face to face though a thousand li apart."
5
The Hidden Crown Prince and the Prince of Qin were at odds. When the prince summoned Xuanling for counsel, he answered, "Every age knows national crisis; only a sage can overcome it. Your Highness's merit fills the world. That is not human scheming alone—the spirits themselves are on your side. He then brought in Du Ruhui to help shape the decisive plan. He rose in turn to director of merit evaluation in the Shandong Grand Commissionerate and to academician of the Literature Hall. The former crown prince resented the two men and wove odd accusations against them before the emperor. Both were expelled and sent home. When the crown prince was preparing a coup, the prince called the two men in disguised as Taoist adepts and plotted with them through the night. Once the crisis was resolved and the prince became heir apparent, Xuanling was promoted to right vice tutor of the crown prince. When the crown prince ascended the throne, Xuanling became director of the Secretariat. When achievements were ranked and rewards granted, he stood first with Ruhui, Zhangsun Wuji, Yuchi Jingde, and Hou Junji. He was raised to Duke of Han with a fief of 1,300 households; the others received titles and offices in descending order. The emperor looked at the assembled ministers and said, "In weighing your service and fixing your fiefs, I fear I may fall short. Do not hold back—each of you speak for yourselves. Prince Huai'an, Li Shentong, said, "When the founding army first marched, my troops were the first to arrive. Yet now Xuanling and the rest—mere men of the brush—rank first. I do not understand it." The emperor replied, "Uncle, your troops did arrive first, but you never shared the hardship of the front lines. That is why, south of Dou Jiande, your army broke and could not rally, and why, when Liu Heida rebelled, you fled at the first sign of trouble. Xuanling and the others won the war in the command tent and secured the realm. That is why Xiao He stood above the generals. As my uncle by blood, you deserve every consideration—but kinship cannot be used to outrank men who earned their place by merit. At first the generals Qiu Shili and the rest swaggered forward, sleeves rolled up, some pointing and arguing their own cases. When they saw Shentong humbled and silenced, they said, "Your Majesty will not even favor his own kin—what grounds have we to complain?"
6
He was promoted to left vice director of the Department of State Affairs, placed in charge of compiling the national history, and his fief was changed to Wei. The emperor said, "As vice director, you should help me widen my reach and find worthy men. Yet I hear you go through hundreds of petitions and lawsuits every day. When do you have time to search for talent? He therefore ordered minor business assigned to the left and right assistant directors, while major affairs remained with the vice director.
7
The emperor once asked, "Which is harder: founding a dynasty or preserving one? Xuanling answered, "In those days the world was still raw and every warlord was fighting for supremacy. Cities fell only after siege, enemies yielded only after defeat. Founding the dynasty was the harder task." Wei Zheng said, "The rise of a true king rides on decay and chaos, overthrowing a dark and brutal order. That is almost heaven handing the Mandate to the one the people will accept. Once the realm is won, a ruler settles into pride and ease. When the people long for peace, forced labor torments them. When the age is already worn thin, harsh exactions drive them to ruin. When the state falters for these reasons, preserving it becomes the harder task. The emperor said, "Xuanling followed me through the conquest, facing death a hundred times and life only once. He knows how hard founding was. Wei Zheng helped me settle the realm. He sees that wealth and rank breed arrogance, arrogance breeds slackness, and slackness breeds ruin. He knows preservation is not easy. The hardship of founding is behind us. The hardship of preservation is what I now ask all of you to take to heart."
8
使 西
When an edict granted hereditary succession to great ministers, he was made prefect of Songzhou and his fief was moved to Liang. Because the ministers declined hereditary office, the prefecture was withdrawn and he became Duke of Liang. Not long afterward he was also made junior tutor to the crown prince. On his first visit to the Eastern Palace, the crown prince wanted to bow to him. Xuanling refused, saying he dared not accept such honor, and the ceremony was dropped. After fifteen years as chief minister, with a daughter married to a prince and a son married to an imperial princess, he felt his power and favor had reached their height. He memorialized again and again to resign, but the throne would not allow it. Soon afterward he was promoted to minister of works, yet still oversaw the government as before. Xuanling pressed his refusal. The emperor sent word: "Modesty is a fine virtue. But the state has long depended on you as chief minister. To lose a good minister in a day is like losing both hands. Your strength is not yet spent—do not decline so often! When the Prince of Jin became crown prince, Xuanling was made grand tutor to the heir and put in charge of Secretariat affairs. During mourning for his mother, he was granted a burial plot in the Zhaoling park. He was recalled to office before the mourning period had ended. When the campaign against Liaodong began, he remained behind to guard the capital. An edict read, "You fill the role of Xiao He. I need no longer look back with worry. All grain, arms, transport, and the movement and disposition of the armies were entirely under his command." Xuanling wrote again and again urging the emperor not to underestimate the enemy and not to prolong war against foreign states. He firmly declined the post of grand tutor to the crown prince, and the request was granted.
9
輿殿
In his later years he was often ill. When the emperor went to Yuhua Palace, he ordered Xuanling to remain in the capital and allowed him to conduct business from his bed. When his illness grew severe, he was summoned and allowed to enter the palace in a sedan chair. The emperor wept at the sight of him; Xuanling, too, was overcome and could not speak. The emperor ordered court physicians to attend him and the imperial kitchen to send meals, with daily reports on his condition. At the slightest sign of improvement, joy showed plainly on the emperor's face. Xuanling turned to his sons and said, "Nothing under heaven remains undone except the war against Goguryeo. The emperor is set in angry resolve, and no minister dares speak against it. If I stay silent, I shall die ashamed. He then submitted a memorial that read:
10
Peoples whom antiquity never made submit, Your Majesty has made submit. Peoples whom antiquity never controlled, Your Majesty has brought under control. Of all the threats to China, none matched the Turks—yet the great and lesser khans have surrendered one after another, cut their braids, taken up swords, and now serve in the palace guard. The Xueyantuo and Tiele were settled across prefectures and counties. Gaochang and Tuyuhun were cleared by detached columns. Only Goguryeo, defying the throne dynasty after dynasty, could never be fully brought to bay. Your Majesty, charging them with regicide and treason, personally led the six armies deep into the frontier. In less than ten days Liaodong fell; hundreds of thousands were taken captive; the survivors and the rebel king held their breath in terror. Your achievement already doubles that of any earlier reign.
11
退 退 使 使
The Book of Changes says, "Only the sage knows when to advance and when to retreat, when to survive and when to perish, and never loses the right path. Advance already holds retreat within it; survival already holds ruin within it; gain already holds loss within it. That is what I urge Your Majesty to keep in mind." Laozi says, "He who knows when he has enough will not suffer shame; he who knows when to stop will not come to harm. Your Majesty's fame and feats of arms are already more than enough. The time has come to stop opening new lands and pushing the borders further. These coarse tribes along the frontier are not men to whom one owes the full measure of benevolence and ritual propriety. The ancients regarded them as one might birds and fish—creatures to be kept, not equals to be cultivated. If you must wipe out their kind to the last, you need only fear that cornered beasts will turn and fight. Better simply to spare their lives. And yet whenever Your Majesty confirms a capital sentence, you review the case again and again, take frugal meals, and suspend the music of the court—so deeply does the weight of a human life move you. Yet now innocent men are driven into the ranks and sent under the rain of steel, their bodies torn to pieces. Old fathers and orphaned sons, widowed wives and grieving mothers watch for the wagons of the dead, clutching dry bones and weeping until their hearts break. This disturbs heaven and earth, wounds the harmony of the realm, and is a sorrow that falls upon the whole empire. If Goguryeo has violated its obligations as a subject state, it may be punished; if it plunders and harms the people, it may be destroyed; if it threatens to become a scourge to future generations, it may be eradicated. Yet none of these three conditions holds today, and still we drain the strength of the Middle Kingdom to avenge an old king's shame and settle a score for Silla. Is this not saving what is petty while ruining what is great? I beg Your Majesty to issue a generous edict of amnesty, allow Goguryeo to begin anew, burn the expedition fleet, and send the conscripts home. Then, though I die, my bones will not crumble into dust unredeemed.
12
When the Emperor read the memorial, he said to Princess Gaoyang, "The man is already at death's door, and still he troubles himself over the affairs of the realm!"
13
While Xuanling directed the government, he worked from dawn till late every night, giving himself wholly to public service and allowing nothing, however small, to go neglected. He was without jealousy. When he learned of another man's excellence, he delighted in it as though it were his own. He understood the arts of administration thoroughly, yet clothed them in learning and elegance. In framing laws and issuing commands, he always sought what was generous and equitable. He did not expect others to match his own talents, nor did he require those he employed to be flawless. Even men of low rank were given room to use whatever gifts they possessed. If he was rebuked for any fault, he would always kowtow and plead guilty, stricken with fear as though he had nowhere on earth to hide.
14
便 輿
Near the end of the Zhenguan era, Xuanling was censured and sent home. Yellow Gate Vice Censor Chu Suiliang said to the Emperor, "In his service to you, Xuanling has never been wanting. To dismiss him for a single lapse is not the way a Son of Heaven should treat a chief minister. The Emperor took his meaning and at once recalled him from his house. Later he avoided public office and refused to leave his home. Some time passed, and when the Emperor came to Furong Garden to observe the ways of the people, Xuanling told his sons and kinsmen to sweep the courtyard and halls, saying, "The imperial carriage is about to arrive. A little while later the Emperor did come to his house, and taking Xuanling with him in the carriage, returned to the palace. While the Emperor was at Cuiwei Palace, he made Li Wei, Director of the Directorate of Agriculture, Minister of Revenue. When a visitor arrived from the capital, the Emperor asked, "What did Xuanling say when he heard that Wei had been appointed Minister? The man answered, "He only remarked that Wei has a handsome beard—nothing more." The Emperor at once transferred Wei to the post of Grand Mentor of the Crown Prince. When the Emperor campaigned against Liaodong, Xuanling remained to guard the capital. A man brought an urgent denunciation. Xuanling questioned him, and the man said, "It is you, my lord, whom I mean to accuse. Xuanling dispatched a courier by post to overtake the Emperor. When the Emperor had read the report, he ordered the man beheaded. An edict followed rebuking him: "Why did you not trust yourself! Such was the measure of trust the Emperor placed in him.
15
He ran his household with strict discipline, ever fearing that his sons might grow proud and wasteful and use the family's influence to lord it over others. He gathered family admonitions old and new, had them copied onto standing screens, and gave one to each son, saying, "Keep these words before you, and they will be enough to preserve your lives and honor. The Yuan family of Han served with loyalty and integrity for generation after generation—that is the example my heart holds dear, and the one you should follow. His son Yizhi succeeded to the estate and title.
16
Son: Yi'ai
17
婿
The second son, Yi'ai, was reckless and unlettered, a man of coarse manners, though he had physical courage. He married Princess Gaoyang and was appointed General of the Right Guard. The princess was the Emperor's beloved daughter, and so the honors paid to her husband exceeded those given to any other imperial son-in-law. The princess was proud and imperious. She resented that Yizhi, as the eldest son, stood to inherit the family rank. Frightened, Yizhi offered to renounce his claim, but the Emperor refused. The princess slowly fell from the Emperor's favor and brooded in bitter resentment. She entered into an illicit affair with the Buddhist monk Bianji. The Emperor flew into a rage, executed the monk, and put several dozen serving women to death. The princess nursed her grievance, and when the Emperor died she showed no proper sorrow at his passing. Under Emperor Gaozong, Yizhi was appointed prefect of Bianzhou and Yi'ai prefect of Fangzhou. The princess again lodged false charges against Yizhi. The Emperor commanded Zhangsun Wuji to investigate, and the proof of her and Yi'ai's plot to rebel came to light. Yi'ai was executed, and the princess was ordered to take her own life. Yizhi was spared because of his father's old service and was demoted to assistant magistrate of Tongling. An edict removed Fang Xuanling from the roll of spirits honored at the imperial ancestral temple.
18
Du Ruhui
19
Du Ruhui, courtesy name Keming, was a native of Duling in the capital district of Jingzhao. His grandfather Guo had been a man of note in the Northern Zhou and Sui periods. In youth Ruhui was quick and brilliant, devoted to books, and fancied himself a man of cultivated grace. Inwardly he held himself to the highest standards, and when crisis came he always acted with swift, firm decision. During the Daye era of Sui he entered the civil service examinations. Vice Minister of Personnel Gao Xiaoji marked him out and said, "You are timber fit to become a pillar of the realm—guard your virtue well. He was thereupon appointed assistant magistrate of Fuyang, but he resigned the post and departed.
20
When Gaozu secured the capital, the Prince of Qin took him on as a military staff officer in his household, then transferred him to serve as chief administrator of the Shaanzhou headquarters. At that time many of the prince's staff were being posted away to outside offices, and the Prince was deeply troubled by the loss. Fang Xuanling said, "However many have gone, none of them is worth grieving over—but Ruhui is a man born to assist a ruler. If Your Highness means to remain forever content within your fief, you have no use for him; but if you mean to win the empire, there is no one else with whom you can achieve it. The Prince started in alarm and said, "Had you not spoken, I would almost have let him slip away!" He thereupon submitted a memorial asking that Ruhui be kept on in his staff. He accompanied the Prince on campaign and was constantly present at the secret deliberations within the command tent. In those busy years he disposed of business without a moment's delay. His colleagues all recognized his genius, yet none could tell where his abilities ended. He was promoted to director in the Bureau of Merits of the Shandong Grand Area Command, enfeoffed as Baron of Pingyi County, and made a scholar of the Hall of Literary Studies as well. When the Celestial Stratagem Command was created, he served as its commandant. When the Prince became crown prince, Ruhui was made Left Assistant to the Heir Apparent, then transferred to Minister of War, raised to Duke of Cai with an income of three thousand households, and granted a separate estate of thirteen hundred households in Yizhou. Before long he was made acting chief counselor and acting minister of personnel, placed in overall command of the Eastern Palace troops, promoted to Vice Minister of the Right of the Department of State Affairs, and kept charge of official appointments.
21
Together with Xuanling he governed the court, advancing the worthy and dismissing the unfit until every man stood in his proper place. The whole age looked to them with reverence. Supervising censor Chen Shihe submitted a memorial entitled "On Selecting Scholars," arguing that one man should not hold many offices at once—a veiled attack aimed at Ruhui and the others. The Emperor said, "Xuanling and Ruhui were not promoted merely as old companions in arms, but because their abilities qualify them to govern the realm. Does Shihe mean to use this to drive a wedge between me and my ministers? Shihe was exiled to Lingnan.
22
使 使
After a time Ruhui resigned on grounds of illness. An edict allowed him to keep his regular salary at home, and physicians sent from court followed one after another to his door. When his illness turned grave, the crown prince was sent to visit him by imperial command. The Emperor himself came to his house, and as he stroked Ruhui's hand, grief closed his throat and he could not speak. Before the end came, the Emperor promoted his son Gou, an officer of the Left Thousand-Bull Guard, to the additional post of Palace Supply Attendant. He died at the age of forty-six. The Emperor mourned him with bitter grief and posthumously granted him the rank of Grand Master of the Palace with the privilege of an independent office. At his burial he was further honored as Minister of Works, with the posthumous name Cheng, "Accomplished." The Emperor himself commanded Yu Shinan to compose the inscription for his stele, instructing him to set down the sorrow felt between lord and minister.
23
On another day, while eating melon, he found it unusually sweet and set half of it aside as an offering before Ruhui's spirit. Once he gave Xuanling a belt of yellow silver, saying, "Ruhui served me at your side, yet now I see only you. Tears running down his face, he said, "Tradition holds that ghosts and spirits fear yellow silver." He chose a gold belt instead and sent Xuanling to carry it to Ruhui's home. Later he dreamed suddenly of Ruhui as though he were still alive. The next day he told Xuanling of the dream and ordered food from the imperial kitchen sent as a sacrifice. On the first anniversary of Ruhui's death, he sent the Director of Palace Women to inquire after his wife and children. The officials and retainers of Ruhui's household were not dismissed either, and the imperial kindness shown them did not fade in the least. Later, when an edict granted hereditary honors to the founding ministers, Ruhui was posthumously made prefect of Mizhou and his noble fief was transferred to the State of Lai.
24
When they served as chief ministers, the realm had only just been settled. The structure of the central government, the forms of official business, and the standards of court ritual were largely shaped and fixed by the two of them. Whenever a question was debated before the Emperor, Xuanling would always say, "No one but Ruhui can work out the strategy for this. Yet when Ruhui came, the plan adopted in the end was always Xuanling's. Ruhui's strength lay in decisive judgment, Xuanling's in devising strategy. Knowing each other through and through, they worked as one mind to counsel and support the throne. In their time, whenever men spoke of great ministers, they said simply, "Fang and Du."
25
Gou served as prefect of Cizhou. His second son, He, was violent, cunning, and scornful of the law. He married the Princess of Chengyang, rose to Groom of the Imperial Carriage, and was enfeoffed as Duke of Xiangyang. When Chengqian plotted rebellion, He said, "Yan Liren of Langye is skilled in astronomy and says Heaven's signs demand a bold stroke — Your Highness should take the throne and make the emperor Retired Emperor. Feign illness — the emperor is sure to come in person to inquire, and then you will have your chance. When the plot failed, he was executed for his role in it. At the execution, he faced death with an air of bold pride. Gou was demoted on accumulated charges and died in exile beyond the Ling mountains.
26
Younger brother: Chuke
27
Ruhui's younger brother Chuke admired bold integrity from youth. He and his uncle Yan both fell into Wang Shichong's hands as captives. Yan bore a grudge against Ruhui and slandered him until his elder brother was executed. He also imprisoned Chuke and left him near death. When Shichong was overthrown, Yan was condemned to death. Chuke pleaded with Ruhui to spare Yan, but Ruhui refused. Chuke said, "Our uncle destroyed our brother cruelly, and now our brother would abandon our uncle — the household is nearly wiped out. How can that not grieve us! Moved by this, Ruhui pleaded with Gaozu, and Yan was pardoned. When the crisis over Crown Prince Jiancheng erupted, Chuke took refuge on Mount Song. In Zhenguan 4, he was recalled to serve as Palace Attendant. Taizong said, "You lived on the mountain as though you would not serve unless made chancellor — was that truly the case? Those who withdraw far eventually return of their own accord. A man need not fret over lacking office; what matters is whether his talents fit the task. Your brother and I, though not kin, were of one mind. Serve me as he did, and aid me. Chuke kowtowed in thanks and was promoted to Captain of the Palace Guard. Whenever he was on overnight palace duty, he kept his staff in hand until dawn without letting go. The emperor learned of this and commended him, promoting him to prefect of Puzhou, where he earned a name for capable rule before being moved to Yingzhou. Later he served as chief administrator of the Prince of Wei's household, rose to Minister of Works while acting on the prince's behalf, and became known for his firm, stern manner. Sensing the emperor's cooling toward Chengqian, he flattered the prince's influential retainers and repeatedly praised the prince's intelligence and fitness to succeed. Word reached the emperor, who kept his anger hidden. When the prince was demoted, his crimes were made public. Because of Ruhui's past service, Chuke was spared death but cashiered to live at home, ending his days as magistrate of Qianhua.
28
Uncle: Yan
29
調 簿 ' '祿
Yan, styled Zhili, was gifted in argument and widely learned, and enjoyed an excellent reputation. During the Kaihuang reign, he schemed with his friend Wei Fusi, saying, "The emperor favors men in retirement — Su Wei was recruited as a recluse and won a fine appointment. So the two withdrew together to Mount Taibai and lived as recluses. Emperor Wen took offense and banished them for frontier service in the south. After they were pardoned and returned, Gao Xiaoji, as Yongzhou secretary, recommended him for appointment as Gentlemen for Reception, and he rose through successive promotions to Censor-in-Chief. When Wang Shichong declared himself emperor, Yan was made vice minister of the civil office and grew close to those who wielded power. When Luoyang fell, he could find no post and wished to enter the service of the Hidden Crown Prince. Feng Lun then held the appointment portfolio and tipped off Fang Xuanling, who feared losing so able a man, reported to the Prince of Qin, and secured Yan as military affairs officer of the Heavenly Strategies Office and a scholar of the Literary Institute. On one banquet occasion his verse was especially fine, and the prince rewarded him with a silver bell. When Yang Wengan, military commissioner of Qingzhou, rebelled, testimony implicated the crown prince. Yan, Wang Gui, and Wei Ting were blamed and exiled to Yuexi. The Prince of Qin knew they had been falsely implicated and sent them three hundred taels of gold. When Taizong ascended the throne, he recalled Yan as Censor-in-Chief, enfeoffed him as Duke of Anji, and granted him an income of four hundred households. Yan proposed that censors be assigned to inspect each office's files for tardiness and enforce deadlines. Taizong consulted Vice Premier Feng Lun, who replied, "Every office has its own sphere — censors should punish violations, not hunt through files for pretexts. That would be excessively harsh and an invasion of others' jurisdiction. Yan fell silent. The emperor said, "Why did you not press your point? He replied, "Lord Feng spoke to the state's larger principles; I accept his view. What further case could I make?" Pleased, the emperor judged him broadly seasoned in affairs and ordered Yan to revise all ceremonial regulations and ledgers of the Eastern Palace. Soon he was made acting Minister of the Civil Office and took part in governing. More than forty of those he recommended later rose to prominence. He once recommended Chi Huaidao as worthy of appointment, and the emperor asked for particulars. Yan said, "When Huaidao was chief clerk in the Ministry of Civil Appointments under the Sui, as Emperor Yang moved to Jiangdu the courtiers all rushed to flatter him — Huaidao alone stood firm in opposition. The emperor asked, "What did you say at the time?" He said, "I sided with the majority." The emperor reproved him: "Serving a ruler means remonstrating without hiding anything — if you truly thought Huaidao right, why did you not speak out boldly?" He apologized, "My rank was too low, and I feared remonstrance would go unheeded and my death would serve no purpose." The emperor said, "If you inwardly thought the ruler beyond remonstrance, why remain in office at all? To eat the Sui state's grain yet forget the Sui state's affairs — is that loyalty?" He turned to the assembled ministers: "What do you say?" Wang Gui said, "Confucius praised Bi Gan's humanity when he remonstrated and died. Yet when Xie Zhi remonstrated and was killed, Confucius said, 'When the people have many crooked ways, do not set yourself up as upright. Great salary carries heavy responsibility — that has been true since antiquity.' The emperor smiled and said, "Your failure to remonstrate under the Sui may be forgiven. Yet Shichong trusted you closely — why did you say nothing then?" Yan replied, "I did speak, but was not heeded." The emperor said, "Shichong was obstinate, rejected counsel, and covered his errors — if so, how did you survive?" Yan had no answer left. The emperor then pressed him: "Now that you serve in office, do you have any remonstrance to offer? He answered, "I intend to remonstrate without concealment even at the cost of my life." In Zhenguan 2 he fell ill, and the emperor visited him in person. He died and was posthumously made Right Vice Premier, with the posthumous name Xiang. Though Yan held two major posts and stood high at court, he never earned a name for integrity and was criticized in his own day. His son Jingtong inherited the title and rose to Chamberlain for Dependencies.
30
Fifth-generation descendant: Yuanying
31
使
Emperor Jingzong was arrogant and ungovernable. To keep the emperor's favor, Yuanying constantly sought rare treasures to present, until tribute convoys crowded the roads one after another. Artisans worked without limit, exactions grew cruel, and he even cut army rations to feed his hoarding. Pay arrived irregularly; frontier troops went cold and hungry and scraped a living from the tribal marches. The men groaned in misery, some turned informants for the tribes, and frontier defenses fell into neglect. In Dahe 3, Nanzhao struck at a moment of weakness and raided Rong, Qian, and neighboring prefectures. Garrisons broke and fled at the first report of the enemy, local defenders served as guides, and the invaders marched into Chengdu. The enemy was already at the walls before Yuanying knew anything of it; he then gathered his personal staff and clung to the inner citadel to defend it. The invaders looted freely, burned the outer city, ravaged what remained, and withdrew after several days, leaving Shu's treasures, craftsmen, and people stripped bare. At first, desperate, Yuanying planned to flee alone, but halted when relief finally came. Emperor Wenzong sent envoys to soothe Nanzhao. Nanzhao replied, "The people of Shu asked us to kill their cruel governor; we could not do it for them. We ask Your Majesty to execute him and answer to the people of Shu. For this he was demoted to prefect of Shaozhou. Critics were still not satisfied and had him banished further as prefectural secretary of Xunzhou. His subordinates Cui Huang, Qagan Yan, and Lu Bing all lost rank and were exiled to separate places. Yuanying died in exile at sixty-four. Near death he petitioned for a posthumous title and permission to be buried at home. An edict posthumously made him Prefect of Huzhou. Yuanying had been close to Li Deyu, and when Deyu took power at the start of Huichang, an amnesty restored his office. His younger brother Yuanshuo ended his career as Prefect of the Crown Prince's Household. Yuanshuo's son was Shenquan.
32
Sixth-generation descendant: Shenquan
33
西 使 使 退
Du Shenquan, whose courtesy name was Yinheng, passed the jinshi examination and entered service on the staff of the Zhexi commandery. He passed the exceptional selection examination and was appointed Right Reminder. Under Emperor Xuanzong he entered the Hanlin Academy as an academician, rising in time to Vice Minister of War and Academician Expositor. When Emperor Yizong took the throne, Shenquan was made Associate Grand Councilor of the Secretariat-Chancellery, then Chancellery Vice Minister, and finally sent out as military commissioner of the Zhenhai Army with the same councilor title. When Pang Xun rose in rebellion at Xuzhou, Shenquan joined Linghu Tao and Cui Xuan in a coordinated pincer campaign, sending grain in an unbroken stream on which the imperial forces depended. After Pang's defeat he was promoted to Acting Minister of Works, recalled to serve as Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs, and enfeoffed as Duke of Xiangyang. He later served in succession as military commissioner of Hezhong and of Zhongwu. When he died he was posthumously honored as Grand Preceptor of the Heir Apparent and given the posthumous title De. Shenquan was grave, reserved, and taciturn, with a patient and generous disposition. He served in the Hanlin Academy longer than any of his peers and never once divulged matters of the inner court. As a regional commissioner he always received petitioners in the same hall and as a rule never withdrew to his private quarters before nightfall. Whenever he sat, he kept his robes properly arranged, as if in audience before a distinguished visitor. When he took a short rest during the day, he would instruct the attendant on duty to unhook the curtain; and even when no one else was present he would rise, take down the hooks himself, and slowly draw the curtain closed before retiring. He and Du Cong both rose to the highest civil and military offices, but because Cong had entered government earlier, contemporaries nicknamed Shenquan "Little Lord Du."
34
Seventh-generation descendant: Du Rangneng
35
調
His son Du Rangneng, courtesy name Qunyi, passed the jinshi examination, served on the staff of Prince Xuanwu Wang Bo as investigating officer, and was promoted from warden of Chang'an to collator in the Hall of Worthies. After his mother's death he won renown for filial devotion. He was later recruited to the staffs of Liu Ye and Niu Wei in turn and gradually rose to Vice Director in the Ministry of War. When Xiao Zou took charge of the Revenue Bureau, he appointed Rangneng to assist in revenue audits. When Emperor Xizong took refuge in Shu, Rangneng rushed to the mobile court, rose through three promotions to Drafting Secretary of the Secretariat, and was summoned into the Hanlin Academy. War had meanwhile erupted in the east, demanding mobilization, conciliation, and the winning over of local powers, while edicts and memorials piled up without end. Rangneng's mind was quick and penetrating; in every decree sent down and every decision taken at a critical juncture, nothing escaped his calculation, and the emperor came to depend on him deeply. After the emperor returned to the capital, Rangneng was promoted again to Minister of War and enfeoffed as Viscount of Pingping.
36
輿 使
When Li Keyong's forces approached, the emperor slipped out of Fengxiang by night, and in the panic almost no one knew he had gone. Rangneng happened to be on duty at the time. He followed on foot for more than ten li, found an abandoned horse, tore off his sash to serve as a bridle, and rode after the emperor. When Zhu Mei's soldiers closed in on the imperial train, the emperor fled to Baoji with only Rangneng still at his side. Not until the following day did Kong Wei and the others catch up. Soon afterward the court moved on toward Liang. The plank roads had by then been wrecked by Shi Junshe of Shannan, and the emperor's passage through the treacherous mountain routes was grueling, yet Rangneng never once left his side. The emperor comforted him, saying, "I have lost the Way and twice forsaken the ancestral temple. In our darkest hour you never once left me—is this not what the ancients meant by loyalty to one's charge? Rangneng kowtowed and replied, "My family has for generations received the deepest favor of the state. Your Majesty did not despise me for my inadequacy and entrusted me to stand guard over you as a shepherd guards his flock. To save myself in a moment of peril would be my disgrace." When the emperor reached Baozhong, he promoted Rangneng to Vice Minister of War and Associate Grand Councilor of the Secretariat-Chancellery.
37
使
At that time Li Yun, the Succession Prince of Xiang, had set up a rival throne, and eighteen powerful provinces and major commanderies had already rallied to him. Tribute no longer reached the mobile court, leaving nothing with which to reward the troops; the palace guard often went hungry, and emperor and ministers could only wring their hands in helplessness. Rangneng proposed dispatching a chief envoy to Hezhong to win over Wang Chongrong, and Chongrong did in fact submit to the imperial command. Before long the capital was restored to order; he was promoted to Chancellery Vice Minister and his title was changed to Duke of Xiangyang. Many officials had held posts under the puppet regime, and the judicial offices all wanted them put to death. Rangneng insisted that those who had followed under duress should not be punished harshly; he argued the point forcefully and saved a great many lives. When Emperor Zhaozong took the throne, Rangneng was made Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and Duke of Jin, granted an iron certificate of pardon, and eventually promoted to Grand Commandant.
38
忿 使 西 調
Li Maozhen held Fengxiang. After the Da Shun era his military power steadily increased; trusting in his past service, he ignored the law, and the enfeebled court could not bring him to heel. When Yang Fugong fled into Shannan, Maozhen sought to annex both Liang and Han and asked leave to march against him. Before any answer came his troops were already moving; the emperor was furious at his arrogance but had no choice but to go along. After Shannan was pacified, Maozhen was ordered to take Xingyuan and Wuding, Xu Yanruo was appointed military commissioner of Fengxiang, and the prefectures of Guo and Lang were transferred to the Wuding command. Maozhen resented the arrangement, refused to take up his new command, and submitted a memorial filled with insolent and disrespectful language. He also wrote Rangneng a letter of abuse, charging that he had abetted Li Shouliang's rebellion, suppressed loyal officials, and robbed Maozhen of his due credit—language as foul as it was unrestrained. Panic spread through the capital. Every day thousands gathered beneath the palace gates, waiting for Palace Commandant Xi Gate Chongsui to emerge and beg that Fengxiang be ceded to Maozhen for the people's sake. Chongsui replied, "This is the chief minister's decision; it has nothing to do with me. Maozhen's resentment only deepened. The emperor, enraged, ordered Rangneng to devise a strategy and pressed urgently for troop mobilization; for a full month Rangneng did not leave the palace.
39
輿 西使 便
The chief minister Cui Zhaowei was at that time secretly in league with Maozhen and Wang Xingyu, and Rangneng's every word was leaked to them. Maozhen then sent several hundred tough soldiers disguised among the townspeople to intercept Zhaowei and Zheng Yanchang on their way home. Surrounding their sedan chairs, they shouted, "Fengxiang is innocent—we beg you, sir, not to launch a punitive expedition and throw the capital into alarm! Zhaowei said, "The emperor has entrusted this to Grand Commandant Du—what do we know about it?" The crowd did not know which man was the Grand Commandant and began hurling tiles and stones indiscriminately. Zhaowei and the others fled for their lives and escaped, but lost their official seals. The emperor's fury only increased; the ringleaders were arrested and put to death. Throughout the capital people scrambled to escape the chaos, fleeing into the hills and ravines. Rangneng remonstrated with the emperor, saying, "Maozhen certainly deserves punishment, but the great rebels have only just been driven off, and Fengxiang is the empire's western gate. Your Majesty has moreover only lately taken the throne; I beg you to show a little restraint and, following the Zhenyuan precedent, treat Maozhen with forbearance rather than feed his resentment. The emperor replied, "Today our edicts cannot even pass beyond the city gates; the state's institutions are crippled and weak. This is the hour of Jia Yi's lament. Am I to drag out my days and sit idle while this goes on! Devise a plan for me; I myself will commit the army to the princes. Rangneng said, "Your Majesty wishes to purge insolence and overreach, restore imperial authority, and elevate the royal house. That is a task for all the great ministers together—it should not fall on me alone." The emperor said, "You are the chief minister; your fortunes are bound to mine—what is there to shrink from?" Rangneng wept and said, "I remain in the post of chief minister only because I hope to repay Your Majesty—how could I count the cost to myself! Your Majesty's heart is the heart of Emperor Xianzong; only the times are not yet ripe. One day I may suffer the fate of Chao Cuo, and even that would scarcely still the disaster of the Seven Kingdoms—yet how could I refuse your command?"
40
使
In the second year of Jingfu the Succession Prince of Tan was appointed punitive commissioner, with Shence General Li Huai as his deputy, and they led thirty thousand men to escort Xu Yanruo to his command. Zhaowei, inwardly fearful of men with military credit, secretly told Maozhen, "The emperor dislikes war—as soon as the army marches, the Grand Commandant will be dismissed. Maozhen then marched out his entire force to give battle at Zhouzhi. The Prince of Tan was defeated, and Maozhen drove his victory as far as Sanqiao. Rangneng said, "I warned of this in advance. Let me go back and accept death to ease the crisis. The emperor wept without stopping and said, "My mind is made up with you." Rangneng was again demoted, this time to registrar of Leizhou. Maozhen kept his army encamped and demanded that Rangneng be put to death; the emperor then ordered him to commit suicide. He was fifty-three.
41
His younger brother Yanlin served as Censor-in-Chief; and Honghui was Vice Minister of Revenue; both were executed with him. The emperor mourned them deeply and later posthumously honored Rangneng as Grand Preceptor.
42
His sons were Guangyi and, second, Xiao, who never again entered government service. Xiao entered the service of Liang and rose to wealth and high standing.
43
使 使 使
The encomium reads: Emperor Taizong, possessed of the highest sage talent, overthrew the tottering Sui, swept away the bandit armies, and once the realm was at peace put Fang Xuanling and Du Ruhui at the head of his government. In the wreckage of great upheaval, when law and order lay in ruins, they raised the fallen and restored the withered until commands and punishments shone forth complete in every detail; centuries later the realm still reaped their benefit—they were truly great chief ministers. Yet when one tries to trace how they accomplished it, the trail vanishes altogether—why should that be? Liu Fang of Tang once observed, "When the emperor quelled chaos and disaster, Fang and Du did not speak of their own merit; Wang and Wei were skilled at remonstrance, yet Fang and Du yielded them the frank word; the Ying and Wei dukes were skilled at warfare, yet Fang and Du complemented them with civil culture. They held every excellence up before the ruler. Afterward, as newer men rose to power in turn, Xuanling occupied the highest place yet did not hoard authority, and from first to last conducted himself with integrity—this is how he earned a lasting reputation. Who can doubt that this is so! Though Ruhui served only briefly, judging from Xuanling's esteem for him and the emperor's intimate regard, his counsel and decisiveness were truly far above ordinary men. When ruler and minister are enlightened and in harmony, wills aligned and counsel agreed, and they strengthen one another to completion—that is a rendezvous of a millennium; the achievements of Xiao He and Cao Shen scarcely bear comparison. Even so, the chief minister stands in Heaven's place: he assists, harmonizes, and mends, hiding his work in the very fabric of government so that men benefit without knowing how—without wisdom and clarity, how could anyone attain this? As for those who parade themselves to win fame and make their deeds plain to every household—that is precisely what Fang and Du held in contempt!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →