← Back to 新唐書

'''卷二百一十五上''' 列傳第一百四十上 突厥上

'''卷二百一十五上''' 列傳第一百四十上 突厥上

Chapter 215 of 新唐書 · New Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 215
Next Chapter →
1
25%
Chapter 215, Part 1 — Biographies 140, Part 1: The Turks (Upper)
2
The barbarian peoples have been a scourge upon China since antiquity. For earlier periods, historians have for the most part been able to record these matters. After the Tang rose to power, the frontier peoples rose and fell in turn; four powers that at times rivaled China were the Turks, Tibet, the Uyghurs, and Yunnan. In those years the court overflowed with counsel from the ministers; what was adopted and what was set aside can be plainly seen in the annals.
3
Liu Dian argued as follows:
4
使 西 姿 使 使 使使
Yan You argued keenly but left gaps; Ban Gu was exhaustive but did not go far enough. Judged at their best: Zhou had the superior strategy, Qin the middling one, and Han had no real strategy at all. Why do I say this? Beyond the outer marches, where imperial culture does not reach: when they rebel, do not exhaust the army pursuing them; when they submit, do not lower your guard. Hold the defenses, control the passes, and mass at the choke points—so they can neither raid effectively nor truly become vassals. "Bring benefit to the Central States and thereby pacify the four quarters"—that was the Zhou approach; hence Zhou is said to have had the superior strategy. The Book of Changes states: "Kings and feudal lords establish defenses to secure their realms. Building the Long Wall and repairing frontier barriers is precisely how such defenses are established. Zhao Jianzi built the Long Wall against the northern tribes; Yan and Qin likewise raised walls to separate China from the steppe and strengthened ramparts and moats—yet their states fell while those walls still stood, and many blamed the policy. Later, when Wei built the Long Wall, advocates argued that one man's labor over a single pace secured a thousand li, with three hundred thousand men conscripted—yet in less than a month and a half they gained lasting security; hence Qin is credited with the middling strategy. The Han sent imperial princesses to marry Xiongnu chiefs, and even Gaozu knew that the Princess of Lu could not halt the King of Zhao's conspiracy—yet they still believed marriage alliance would quiet Xiongnu revolt; it did not. Modu had murdered his own father with his own hand, yet they hoped he would not strive against his wife's grandfather for dominance—was this not folly? They knew full well that marriage alliance was no lasting solution; they adopted it only because the empire had just been pacified, to buy a few years' respite from disaster. Under Emperor Wu, the empire was secure and northern raids grew infrequent—the time had come to keep the barbarians at arm's length and sever ties altogether. Instead they further drained the heartland and fought year after year—hence Yan You judged this the worst policy of all. Yet even by the reigns of Zhao and Xuan, with trained soldiers and sharp scouts and the Xiongnu driven far away, the court still repeated Feng Chun's error, pouring the treasury into the northwest—two hundred and seventy million a year. Imperial daughters of fine breeding were given as brides to yurt-dwellers; and palace women of rank were dispatched to the sands of the north. It is the duty of vassals to present sons, daughters, and tribute goods. The Book of Odes says: "None dares fail to come to court; none dares fail to acknowledge our sovereignty. For the outer marches the text speaks of their coming to us, not of our going to them. The Duke's treaty with Wu is passed over in silence and left unrecorded. How then could the Son of Heaven, in all his majesty, treat the Xiongnu as sworn brothers, and an imperial princess share a household with a barbarian chieftain's widow; stepmothers marrying stepsons, conforming to their debased customs? What sets China apart from the barbarians is the distinction between father and son, man and woman. Women of grace and beauty, their virtue ruined among foreigners—the disgrace was profound. Yet neither emperor nor minister of the Han felt shame at it. Under Wei and Jin the Qiang and Di settled along the frontier, receiving support greater than ever before. Chiefs of a hundred households and leaders of a thousand clans were granted gold seals and purple ribbons and paid at the rate of kings and marquises. Horse-herding boys and sheep-riding servants, laden with furs and fleeces in pursuit of profit, thronged the highways without end. The fruits of the plow and the products of silk and hemp were dispersed tens of thousands of li beyond the frontier. The northern tribes grew more arrogant each year while the heartland contracted daily. When they were strong, the empire exhausted its manpower to fight them; when they submitted, they were sustained as generously as before. When weak they were fed; when strong they turned inward to attack—China has served the Qiang and Hu for nearly a millennium. What tragedy could be greater? Had that wealth been redirected to reward frontier garrisons, the people would have prospered; and those titles used to reward border commanders, the generals would have been capable. Wealth would stay at home and danger fall on them—without the humiliation of sending princesses, without the burden of endless convoys. They abandoned this course and did nothing—hence Han is said to have had no strategy at all. Yan You claimed antiquity lacked a superior strategy because they could not reduce the barbarians to subjection—yet they could have; they simply chose not to. He said Qin had no strategy because it drove out the Di and lost the realm. Qin did not fall because it expelled the northern tribes. He called Han's approach the inferior strategy—campaigning against the Hu until the people were exhausted. The people were already worn down, yet the court still levied men to sustain the barbarians—this was no policy whatsoever. Hence Yan You is judged argumentative but incomplete. Ban Gu wrote, "When they come in admiration of our virtue, receive them with ritual courtesy. Why is this wrong? Ritual courtesy is for engaging with cultivated men, not for receiving beasts and barbarians. When China's refinements are displayed abroad, the Rong and Jie grow bold; and once they grow bold, raiding and plunder inevitably follow. The sages did not share food, drink, or music with them; when they came to court they sat outside the gate, and interpreters conveyed provisions to them—they were not permitted to taste China's finest flavors. The Han court habitually coddled arrogant nomads, letting them enjoy the beauties of Yan and Zhao, savor imperial delicacies, and dress in brocade and gauze—feed them and their demands grew; cut them off and they turned hostile. This was feeding wolves the finest meat and then letting them hunt at will. Chinese foot soldiers excel in rugged country; nomad horsemen excel on open ground. Stand firm and do not pursue in open chase—when they come, seal the passes so they cannot advance; when they leave, close the passes so they cannot return. Meet them with long halberds and strong crossbows—not merely to win battles, but because they are like vermin and serpents. What place has ritual courtesy in receiving such foes? This is what is meant when Ban Gu is said to have been thorough but not exhaustive.
5
Du You argued:
6
使 西 綿
Qin, from the narrow confines of Guanzhong, overthrew six great powers; now the empire exhausts its wealth to feed the capital, while beyond the frontier the Tibetans raid at will and have captured hundreds of cities, and within the realm war has not ceased for thirty years. Is this because institutions differ, and ancient and modern times are not comparable? Under the Zhou system, one hundred paces made a mu, and one hundred mu supported one household. Shang Yang aided Qin, arguing that land was not fully utilized; he redefined the mu as two hundred forty paces and assigned one hundred mu to each household. He also noted that Qin had vast lands and few people, while Jin was crowded; he enticed settlers from the Three Jin to farm, granting them favorable land and tax exemptions for their descendants, while Qin natives faced enemies abroad—office was open only to farmers and soldiers. Roughly half of every hundred men farmed and half trained for war—hence Qin's armies were strong and its treasury full. Later the routes to office multiplied, and nonessential occupations proliferated. Today only about ten in every hundred farm; the rest pursue other trades. Under Qin and Han the Zheng Canal irrigated forty thousand qing and the Bai Canal four thousand five hundred qing; by the Yonghui era combined irrigation had fallen below ten thousand qing, and by early Dali to six thousand mu. At one hu less per mu, the annual shortfall amounts to four or five million hu of grain. With land productivity exhausted and manpower dispersed, strength and wealth cannot be attained. In Han times, seven hundred li north of Chang'an lay Xiongnu land, and raids never ceased even for a moment. Their entire population was no larger than a single Han commandery; Chao Cuo urged strengthening the frontier defenses, and the north remained secure. Today west of Tong Pass, east of Long Mountain, south of Fu and Fang, and north of Zhongnan—more than ten prefectures already hold hundreds of thousands of households. Tibet's power is feeble and its skills crude; their diet is raw and their crafts clumsy—far inferior to China. Restore the two canals' fertility, encourage farmers to till, fortify strategic points, garrison the frontier, and the He and Long regions could be recovered—not merely held in defense.
7
Du You's grandson Du Mu likewise wrote:
8
宿
In peacetime ministers grow complacent in luxury, soldiers drift apart, arms rust, and horses weaken—then when rebellion erupts everywhere they are rushed into battle. Such troops are defeated before they march. This is the first cause of defeat: failure to recruit and train soldiers properly. A hundred men bear arms on government rations yet claim credit for a thousand; generals and subordinates pocket the surplus and welcome strong enemies—fighters are always few, freeloaders many. Before the fortifications are finished, the treasury is empty. This is the second cause of defeat: failure to enforce accountability. After minor victories they exaggerate their achievements and rush forward petitions for reward—sometimes twice in a single day, with multiple enfeoffments in a month. Before victory celebrations end, their ranks are raised, estates expanded, gold and silk overflowing, and sons and grandsons given office. Why would they risk their lives in earnest service? This is the third cause of defeat: rewards far too generous. After losing many troops and failing catastrophically, they leap to new commands, abandon their posts, and face execution with equanimity—within a year, without repentance, they stand again at court. This is the fourth cause of defeat: punishments far too lenient. Commanders cannot exercise sole authority—one day the formation is crescent-shaped, the next fish-scale; tens of thousands wheel and feint in confusion, and in that moment nomad cavalry strike. This is the fifth cause of defeat: failure to grant commanders full authority. In the Yuanhe era hundreds of thousands of troops were mobilized against Cai; the empire was exhausted, and victory took four years—because these five faults were never corrected. In early Changqing rebel heirs submitted in droves; soon Yan and Zhao erupted in revolt. Armies were raised and generals appointed, yet the five faults grew worse and the court could not impose its will on the rebels.
9
Such were the arguments of the two Du ministers.
10
西 使
Between the Guangde and Jianzhong reigns Tibet repeatedly crossed the Min River, often with Nanzhao as vanguard wielding halberds twice a man's height, advancing as they fought. Shu troops broke their blades and swallowed arrowheads yet could not kill a single enemy. As the invaders pressed deeper and plague deaths mounted, they judged they could not hold and withdrew. The people of Shu had a saying: "The Tibetans we can endure; it is the southern tribes who destroy us. Wei Gao opened the Qingxi Road to pacify the southern tribes, routing their tribute missions through Shu and selecting their sons to study writing and reckoning in Chengdu. When they returned home, they knew every mountain pass and strategic point. Under Emperor Wenzong they sacked Chengdu on a vast scale; for eight hundred li north from Yuexi, people and livestock were wiped out. Defeated soldiers and the destitute joined in the slaughter, and officials could not stop them. From then on the southern tribes often planned to devastate Shu, while Shu people crushed by heavy taxes were willing to open the passes, hoping for deliverance. Each year garrison troops were sent who knew nothing of the mountain terrain—after a single easy day's march they were already gasping and drenched in sweat. Commanders were harsh and corrupt, substituting coarse cloth for fine and mixing sand with grain rations. Frontier soldiers grew resentful, and Ba and Shu lived in fear. Sun Qiao urged: "The court should order the three prefectures of Yandao, Shenli, and Yuexi to survey strategic points and recruit local garrisons. Soldiers registered locally are easy to mobilize; troops raised on the frontier know the terrain. Divide garrisons by terrain, farm in spring and raise silkworms in summer for provisions, and fortify in autumn and winter to await invasion. Send honest officials annually to verify troop strength, and the state need not ship supplies from afar nor will clerks profit from corruption. Such defensive measures as these could actually be implemented; they are recorded here in this chapter.
11
西
The Turks, Tibet, and the Uyghurs are treated in order of their rise and fall; followed by the Eastern Yi and the Western Regions, reflecting the scale of military engagement; and concluding with the southern tribes, recording how the Tang dynasty met its end.
12
The Turks of the Ashina clan were descended from the northern branch of the ancient Xiongnu. They lived south of the Altai Mountains, submitted to the Rouran khans, and their clans multiplied. Under Tumen they grew powerful, adopted the title khan as equivalent to chanyu, and called his consort khatun. Their lands stretched on three sides nearly to the sea and southward to the great desert. Military governors of subordinate tribes were called she; princes were tegin; chief ministers yabghu, with twenty-eight ranks in all—including qulug chuo, apo, irbir, tutun, irkin, and tagin—all hereditary offices without fixed numbers. Royal guards were called fuli. The khan established his court on Mount Dujin, raised a golden wolf-head banner at his gate, and always sat facing east.
13
使 使 祿殿 使使 使
During the chaos of the Sui's final years, Shibi Khan Tuji succeeded to power. Chinese refugees flocked to him; the Khitan, Shiwei, Tuyuhun, and Gaochang all submitted. Rebel leaders Dou Jiande, Xue Ju, Liu Wuzhou, Liang Shidu, Li Gui, and Wang Shichong all bowed to his authority. His bowmen numbered nearly a million—the northern peoples had never been so powerful. When Gaozu raised his banner at Taiyuan, he sent Liu Wenjing to negotiate an alliance. Shibi dispatched the tegin Kangshaoli with two thousand horses and five hundred warriors to join him. After the emperor pacified the capital, the Turks grew arrogant over their contribution, and their envoys came with increasing insolence. In the first year of Wude the tegin Kutlug came to court. The emperor feasted him in the Hall of Supreme Ultimate, ordered the nine court orchestras to perform, and seated him beside the throne. That year Shibi's camp collapsed on its own. The emperor asked Internal Affairs Director Xiao Yu, who replied: "When Emperor Wen of Wei visited Xu, the city gate broke without cause—and that year he died. Is this not a similar omen? In the second year Shibi personally crossed the Yellow River to Xia Prefecture, joined the rebel Liang Shidu, and sent five hundred horsemen with Liu Wuzhou through Gouzhu to threaten Taiyuan. He died of illness before the campaign could proceed. The emperor ordered mourning at Changle Gate, commanded ministers to condole with the Turkish envoys, and sent thirty thousand bolts of silk as funeral gifts. His son Shibo was too young to succeed and was made Nibu she in the eastern territories. His younger brother Irbis she was enthroned as Elui Khan.
14
使使
Elui married Sui Princess Yicheng and sent envoys to announce the alliance, yet secretly communicated with Wang Shichong. Luzhou Inspector Li Xiyu ambushed and killed his envoys, seizing more than ten thousand head of livestock. Elui received Empress Xiao of Sui and Yang Zhengdao, son of the Prince of Qi, from Dou Jiande's custody. He installed Zhengdao as King of Sui, restored Sui institutions and calendar, assigned captured Sui subjects to his court, and established a government of ten thousand followers at Dingxiang. When the Prince of Qin campaigned against Liu Wuzhou, Elui sent his brother Buli she with two thousand horsemen to Bing Prefecture for three days. They abducted many women from the city. Inspector Li Zhongwen could not restrain them and assigned the tegin Juqian to assist in garrison duty. The following year he plotted to seize Bing Prefecture for Yang Zhengdao. Divination proved inauspicious and his advisers urged caution. Elui said: "Our ancestors lost their kingdom and survived only through Sui's favor. To forget that debt now would be disastrous. If the oracle is unfavorable, do the spirits truly know nothing? I shall decide for myself. Blood rained from the sky for three days, and dogs howled in packs at night. He fell ill; the princess gave him the Five-Stone Powder, and he soon died of erupting sores. Deeming his son Aqishi she unfit, he passed him over and enthroned his younger brother Tujue as Jieli Khan.
15
祿使
Jieli had first served as Moheduo she, with his camp directly north of Wuyuan. When Xue Ju captured Pingliang and allied with the Turks, the emperor sent Yuwen Xin to bribe Jieli into breaking with Xue Ju; Sui prefect Zhang Changsun of Wuyuan had submitted five cities to the Turks; Xin also persuaded Jieli to return Wuyuan territory. Jieli agreed to both proposals and sent troops under Zhang Changsun to join the Prince of Qin's army. Crown Prince Jiancheng proposed abolishing Feng Prefecture and ceding the Yuzhong region. Elui's son Yugu she then led ten thousand tents to settle south of the desert, with Ling Prefecture as the frontier marker.
16
使 使
Jieli married Princess Yicheng and installed Shibi's son Shibo as Tuli Khan in the eastern territories. Yicheng was the daughter of Yang Xie; her brother Shanjing also lived among the Turks. Together with Wang Shichong's envoy Wang Wensu they urged Jieli: "When Qimin's brothers fought for power, they regained their throne only through Sui's aid, and their descendants ruled thereafter. Today's emperor is no descendant of Emperor Wen of Sui. You should install Yang Zhengdao to repay Sui's great kindness. Jieli agreed, and henceforth raided the borders every year. Relying on his predecessors' accumulated strength, with sharp troops and abundant horses, he grew insufferably arrogant, ranking himself above all other peoples and treating China with contempt. His letters were insolent and full of demands. The emperor was still consolidating the realm and therefore humbled himself, forgiving debts and lavishing gifts without measure—yet Jieli's demands knew no limit.
17
使使 穿
In the fourth year Jieli led ten thousand horsemen with Yuan Junzhang to raid Yanmen. Prince of Dingxiang Li Da'en drove them back. Jieli seized the envoys Duke of Hanyang Gui, Zheng Yuanshu, and Zhangsun Shunde. The emperor retaliated by imprisoning Turkish envoys in equal number. He then raided Dai Prefecture, defeated Wang Xiaoji, plundered Hedong, invaded Yuan and Yan prefectures, and fought Tang generals without suffering significant losses.
18
紿 使 殿
The following year he returned Shunde and the others and sought peace, presenting fish glue as tribute with the claim: "To strengthen friendship between our two states. Though distrustful, the emperor released the tegin Rehan and other envoys and sent them back laden with gold. Li Da'en reported: "The Turks are starving. Mayi can be seized. The emperor ordered Palace Supervisor Dugu Sheng to join the attack. Sheng arrived late; Li Da'en hesitated to advance and encamped at New City. Jieli personally led tens of thousands of horsemen with Liu Heita to surround him. Li Da'en was killed and thousands of his men perished. He advanced on Xin Prefecture but was defeated by Li Gaoqian. Heita deployed ten thousand Turkish troops to ravage Shandong and laid waste to Ding Prefecture. Frustrated, Jieli led one hundred fifty thousand horsemen through Yanmen, besieged Bing Prefecture, raided deeply along the Fen and Lu rivers, seized five thousand captives, and sent thousands of horsemen to plunder Yuan and Ling prefectures. Crown Prince Jiancheng marched out by the Binzhou route and the Prince of Qin by the Puzhou route to attack them; Li Zihe advanced toward Yunzhong to strike the khan's rear; Duan Decao marched from Xia Prefecture to ambush their retreat. Prince of Xiangyi Shenfu fought east of the Fen River, killing five hundred Turks and capturing two thousand horses; Fen Prefecture Inspector Xiao Yi presented five thousand captives. The Turks captured Dazhen Pass and raided Hong Prefecture. Yuwen Xin and Yang Shidao of Ling Prefecture repelled them and seized several thousand horses and camels. Hearing that the Prince of Qin was approaching, Jieli withdrew beyond the frontier and the Tang armies returned. The following year Jieli joined Heita and Junzhang in minor raids on Ding, Kuang, Yuan, and Shuo prefectures, trading victories with Tang garrison commanders. The emperor stationed Crown Prince Jiancheng on the northern frontier and the Prince of Qin at Bing Prefecture against Turkish raids. They remained there for a long time before being recalled. Soon they destroyed a garrison in Dai territory, attacked Wei and Bin prefectures, briefly seized Mayi but could not hold it, then sued for peace and returned Mayi.
19
In the seventh year they attacked Yuan and Shuo, entered Dai territory without success, then joined Junzhang to attack Long Prefecture and Yinyan. The Prince of Qin and Prince of Qi Yuanji garrisoned the Binzhou route against the Turks. Junzhang and the Turks raided Yuan, Shuo, Xin, and Bing prefectures, carrying off captives in waves, and were repeatedly driven back by Tang generals. In the eighth month Jieli and Tuli mobilized all their forces, advancing south from Yuan Prefecture in successive camps. Terror spread before them; the Prince of Qin and Prince of Qi met them in battle.
20
使
Floods had cut supply lines in Guanzhong. The army halted at Bin Prefecture when the khan's ten thousand horsemen suddenly appeared at Wulong Slope. Several hundred horsemen rode forward to challenge the Tang lines, and the whole army turned pale. The Prince of Qin galloped forward with a hundred horsemen and shouted: "The empire has done the Turks no wrong. Why do you penetrate so deep into our lands? I am the Prince of Qin. I have come to settle this with the khan in person. If you insist on battle, I have only a hundred horsemen—fighting would only multiply the dead to no purpose. Jieli laughed and made no reply. He galloped to Tuli and said: "You once swore alliance with me to aid each other in need. Have you forgotten our bond of sworn brotherhood? Will you not decide this now? Tuli made no reply. As the prince prepared to ford the river, Jieli saw how few troops he had and overheard his words with Tuli. Suspicious of his brother, Jieli sent an envoy: "Do not trouble yourself, Prince. I do not intend to fight—I wish only to discuss matters with you. He then withdrew. The prince sowed discord between the brothers. Tuli turned toward the Tang and refused to fight; Jieli could not compel him. They sent Tuli and the tegin Simo to sue for peace, and the emperor agreed. Tuli pledged himself to the prince as a sworn brother. The emperor received Simo and seated him on the imperial couch. Simo prostrated himself in refusal. The emperor said: "When I see you, it is as though I see Jieli himself. Simo then accepted.
21
使 使 使
Because the Turks raided annually, someone urged the emperor: "They invade because the treasury and imperial women are at Chang'an. Move the capital and their ambitions will cease. The emperor sent Yuwen Shiji south of the mountains to survey Fan and Deng as sites for relocating the capital. The ministers approved the move. The Prince of Qin alone objected: "Barbarians have troubled China since antiquity, yet Zhou and Han never moved their capitals on their account. Give me a few years, and I will capture the khan in recompense. The emperor abandoned the plan. Jieli had already made peace, and heavy rain had ruined his bows and arrows. He disbanded his army and withdrew. The emperor convened his ministers to discuss frontier defense. Master of Works Yu Yun proposed stationing a river fleet at Wuyuan and Lingwu to block Turkish crossings. Wen Yanbo said: "Wei built the long rampart against the Xiongnu. We can do the same now. The emperor ordered Sang Xianhe to trench the frontier highways, summoned shipwrights from the south, and mobilized troops to build warships. Jieli sent envoys requesting trade at Beilou Pass. The emperor could not refuse. When the emperor first united the realm he had abolished the Twelve Armies in favor of civil rule. Now, with the Turkish threat resurgent, he restored them to train soldiers and scout cavalry.
22
In the eighth year Jieli attacked Ling and Shuo prefectures and defeated Lin Mo at New City. Zhang Jin garrisoned Shiling, Li Gaoqian Dagu, and the Prince of Qin the Puzhou route. At first the emperor had treated the Turks as an equal power. Now he declared in anger: "When the realm was unsettled, I treated the Turks generously to ease our borders. Now they have broken faith. I will destroy them—no more indulgence. He ordered that all correspondence to the Turks be rewritten as imperial edicts or commands. Before Zhang Jin reached his post, the Turks had crossed Shiling, besieged Bing Prefecture, attacked Ling, and raided Lu and Qin prefectures. Li Jing marched by the Luzhou route while Ren Gui garrisoned Taihang. Zhang Jin was defeated at Dagu. Wen Yanbo was captured and Zhang Dezheng of Yan Prefecture was killed. They then attacked Guangwu but were defeated by Prince of Rencheng Daozong. His subordinate Yugu she raided Sui Prefecture, then sued for peace and withdrew. They ravaged several Bing Prefecture counties and raided garrisons in Lan, Shan, and Peng prefectures. Tang forces won minor victories but could not contain them. Soon they raided Yuan Prefecture. Yang Tun repelled them and sent troops to garrison Dagu.
23
西 使 便 退 西 殿
In the ninth year they attacked Yuan and Ling, besieged Liang Prefecture, and advanced on Jing and Yuan. Li Jing fought them at Ling Prefecture and drove them back. They raided Huizhou in the west, besieged Wucheng, and ranged between Long and Wei prefectures. Chai Shao defeated them at Qin Prefecture, killing a tegin, three senior commanders, and a thousand men. As a rule the Turks pressed deep when victorious and sued for peace when beaten, without a trace of shame. In the seventh month Jieli led a hundred thousand horsemen against Wugong, and Chang'an went on alert. They attacked Gaoling. Yuchi Jingde met them at Jingyang, captured the irkin Wumochuo, and took more than a thousand heads. Jieli sent his strategist Zhishi Sili to court to reconnoiter. He boasted: "The two khans command a million warriors—they are here! Taizong replied: "I once pledged peace with the khan face to face, and you have broken that pledge. When I first raised my banner, your father and you rode with me. I lavished gifts of silk and treasure on you beyond reckoning. Why do you dare march on the capital and boast of your power? I ought to execute you on the spot!" Sili was terrified and pleaded for his life. Xiao Yu and Feng Deyi urged the emperor to release him with courtesy; the emperor refused and had him imprisoned at the Secretariat. Then, with Gao Shilian, Fang Xuanling, Zhou Fan, and others, he rode out the Xuanwu Gate with only six horsemen to the Wei River. Across the water he spoke with the khan and rebuked him for breaking faith. The Turkish chiefs were astonished to see the emperor. They dismounted and prostrated themselves. Soon Tang armies appeared, banners and armor blazing, ranks motionless and disciplined. The Turks were utterly unnerved. The emperor and Jieli held their horses while he signaled his troops to fall back and form ranks. Fearing the emperor had underestimated the enemy, Xiao Yu grabbed his bridle to protest. The emperor said: "I have weighed this carefully. You would not understand. The Turks swept south because they thought our recent civil strife left us unable to fight. Had I shut the gates, they would have ravaged the countryside. I came out alone to show I was unafraid and massed troops to show we would fight. I never expected to break their plan so easily. They had penetrated too deep to retreat safely. Fight and we would win; make peace and it would hold. The enemy's fate turned on this single gesture. That day Jieli sued for peace, and the emperor agreed. The next day they sacrificed a white horse and sealed the alliance with Jieli on Bian Bridge. The Turks withdrew. Xiao Yu asked: "When Jieli came, many generals urged battle, but Your Majesty refused. The Turks withdrew on their own—what was your strategy? The emperor replied: "The Turks were numerous but disordered; ruler and subjects cared only for gain. The khan sat west of the river while his chiefs came to pay me homage. Had I gotten them drunk and bound them, it would have been easy. I had also ordered Zhangsun Wuji and Li Jing to move secretly toward Youzhou. With our main force on their heels and ambushes ahead, capturing them would have been as easy as turning one's hand. But I had just taken the throne, and a state needs peace above all. Battle would mean heavy losses. Defeated but not destroyed, they would reform and become our lasting enemy. Could we afford that? Now I have sheathed our swords and showered them with silk and treasure. They will grow arrogant, and arrogance is the road to ruin—as the saying goes, 'To take, one must first give abundantly.'" Xiao Yu bowed deeply. "This is beyond my understanding!" The emperor then sent Dou Lu Kuan and Zhao Chuo to escort the Turks home. Jieli offered three thousand horses and ten thousand sheep, but the emperor refused them and ordered the return of Tang captives.
24
使
In Zhenguan 1 the Xueyantuo, Uyghurs, Bayegu, and other tribes rebelled. Jieli sent Tuli against them; Tuli was defeated and fled with a small escort. Jieli imprisoned him, and Tuli turned resentful. That year heavy snow killed countless sheep and horses and brought famine. Fearing Tang armies would strike while they were weak, the Turks entered Shuo Prefecture under the pretense of a hunting expedition. Some urged punishing them for breaking the treaty and launching an attack. The emperor said: "Even a common man must keep his word—how much more a state? I have sworn alliance with them. How could I exploit their disaster and ambush them in distress? We will strike only when they give us cause."
25
滿
The following year Tuli reported that Jieli was attacking him and begged for aid. The emperor said: "I am allied with Jieli, yet I am sworn brothers with Tuli. I cannot refuse to help him. What should we do? Minister of War Du Ruhui said: "Barbarians are faithless. Though we keep our word, they break theirs. To strike them now while they are in turmoil is to kick a man when he is down." The emperor ordered Zhou Fan to fortify Taiyuan and prepare for action. Jieli also massed troops along the frontier. Some urged rebuilding the old Great Wall and drafting peasants to garrison the frontier. The emperor said: "The Turks had frost in midsummer, five suns rose together, three months of unbroken daylight, and red mists covered the steppe. They saw these omens yet did not mend their ways—they do not fear Heaven. They wander without settling; their herds die in droves—they do not know how to use the land. Their custom is to burn the dead, yet now they build tombs—defying their fathers and ancestors and deceiving the spirits. Jieli and Tuli are at odds, tearing each other apart—there is no harmony among kin. With these four failings they are doomed to fall. We should conquer them for ourselves—why bother building walls? The Turks were plain and rough by nature. Jieli took the Chinese adviser Zhao Deyan into his trust and gradually concentrated power in his own hands. He entrusted government to foreign advisers, pushed aside his own clansmen, and launched annual raids. His people could bear it no longer. The foreign advisers were reckless and greedy, shifting loyalties constantly. Orders changed without warning. Famine struck that year, and exactions grew harsh. The tribes grew ever more restive.
26
使
The following year the Xueyantuo, a subordinate tribe, proclaimed their own khan and sent envoys to court. The emperor ordered Li Jing to attack the Turks at Mayi. Jieli fled. Nine irkin submitted with their followers, and the Bayegu, Pugu, Tongluo, and Xi chiefs all came to pay homage. The emperor dispatched six commanders with more than a hundred thousand men under Li Jing's overall command: Li Shiji by the Tongmo route, Li Jing by Dingxiang, Chai Shao by Jinhe, Prince Daozong by Datong, Wei Xiaojie by Heng'an, and Xue Wanshu by Changwu. Daozong fought at Ling Prefecture and captured tens of thousands of people and livestock. Tuli and the shes Yushe and Yinnai tegin defected with their followers. Victory reports poured in day and night. The emperor told his ministers: "When the dynasty was young, the retired emperor submitted to the Turks for the people's sake—a humiliation that has gnawed at me ever since. Now Heaven favors our generals and every campaign succeeds. At last we may redeem our honor!"
27
退
In the first month of the fourth year Li Jing encamped at Eyang Ridge and attacked Jieli by night. Jieli fled to Qikou. The chieftain Kang Sumi surrendered with Empress Xiao of Sui and Yang Zhengdao. Some claimed Chinese subjects had secretly corresponded with the empress. Yang Wenguan urged an investigation. The emperor said: "The realm was not yet united; some still looked back to Sui. Now the disloyal are pacified—why pursue this? He dropped the matter. Hard pressed, Jieli fled to Tieshan with tens of thousands of men. He sent Zhishi Sili with feigned remorse to sue for submission. The emperor dispatched Tang Jian and An Xiuren with credentials to reassure him. Li Jing knew the Turks would relax while Tang Jian was negotiating. He attacked and captured the entire force. Jieli escaped on a swift horse toward Shabolu, but Zhang Baoxiang captured him. The shes Shabolu and Sunishi submitted with their followers. The Turkish state was destroyed. Tang recovered Dingxiang and Heng'an, and the frontier reached the great desert.
28
使
Jieli was brought to the capital and presented at the Imperial Ancestral Temple. The emperor mounted Shuntian Tower with full guard while the people looked on. Officials led the khan forward. The emperor said: "You are guilty of five crimes. First: when your father's state was broken, Sui restored you, yet you never lifted a finger to aid them, leaving Sui's ancestral temples without sacrifice. Second: though we were neighbors, you broke faith and raided our borders. Third: you relied on force and would not restrain your troops, earning your tribes' hatred. Fourth: you preyed on Chinese subjects and destroyed our harvests. Fifth: you promised alliance by marriage, then delayed and slipped away. I would be justified in executing you, but I have not forgotten our covenant on the Wei River, and so I will not press the matter further. He returned Jieli's family, housed them under the Imperial Stud, and provided for their upkeep.
29
西 使
The Sijie irkin submitted with forty thousand followers. Jieli's brother Yugu she fled to Gaochang but later surrendered as well. The lord of Yiwu, long a Turkish vassal, surrendered seven cities. Tang established Western Yizhou on that territory. An edict ordered: "During past epidemics Turkish dead lay unburied south of the Great Wall, bones heaped like hills. Let the authorities offer wine and meat in sacrifice and give them proper burial." Another edict declared: "During the Sui collapse countless Chinese were taken captive. Send envoys to redeem eighty thousand men and women with gold and silk and restore them to civilian life."
30
Jieli refused to live indoors and kept a yurt pitched in the courtyard. He grew despondent, singing mournfully with his family and weeping together until he was gaunt and wasted. The emperor took pity on him. Guo Prefecture, mountainous and rich in game, would have suited his love of the hunt, and the emperor offered him the post of inspector. Jieli declined, so he was made Right Guard General and given a fine estate. The emperor remarked: "When Qimin lost his kingdom, Emperor Wen of Sui spent grain and treasure and sent armies to restore him. Yet when Shibi grew strong he besieged Emperor Yang at Yanmen. Perhaps their destruction came from betraying those who had saved them. Jieli's son Dieluozhi was deeply filial. After leaving the capital, the wives received ranked rations, and Luozhi was among them. His mother arrived last and received no share. Luozhi would not touch his ration until she was served. When the emperor heard this he sighed: "Heaven bestows filial piety without regard for Chinese or barbarian! He rewarded Luozhi generously and saw that his mother received her share.
31
祿 西姿
In the eighth year Jieli died. He was posthumously enfeoffed as King of Returning Righteousness with the temple name Disordered. By edict his countrymen buried him in their custom: the body was burned and a tomb raised east of Ba. His minister Tuyuhun Xie, a retainer of Jieli's mother Boshi, had nursed Jieli from birth. Grief-stricken, he took his own life. The emperor was moved, posthumously made him a Gentleman of the Palace Guard, and ordered him buried beside Jieli's tomb. Cen Wenben was commanded to inscribe the story on their stele. Soon Sunishi also died in loyalty to his lord. Sunishi was the younger brother of Qimin Khan. Shibi had made him she Shabolu over fifty thousand tents, headquartered northwest of Ling Prefecture. Bold and swift, he ruled with kindness, and many rallied to him. When Jieli's rule collapsed, his tribe alone remained loyal. After Tuli defected, Jieli made him lesser khan. After Jieli's defeat he brought his entire following to Tang. The steppe south of the desert lay empty. He was made Grand Protector of North Ningzhou and Right Guard General, enfeoffed as King of Cherishing Virtue.
32
西使 使 宿 使
After Jieli's fall his followers fled to the Xueyantuo or westward, yet more than a hundred thousand surrendered. The court debated their disposition. Many argued: "The Turks have plagued China for generations. They surrender from weakness, not loyalty. Register them all and settle them in vacant lands in Yan and Yu, teach them farming and weaving—a million barbarians could become ordinary subjects, China would gain population, and the northern steppe would lie empty. Secretariat Director Wen Yanbo argued: "As Emperor Guangwu of Han settled surrendered Xiongnu at Wuyuan Pass, keeping their tribes intact as a buffer without changing their customs—we would fill empty lands and show we do not distrust them. Settling them deep in Yan and Yu would violate their nature—it is not the way of humane governance." Director of the Secretariat Wei Zheng objected: "The Turks have been China's enemies for generations. Now that they surrender, if we do not destroy them outright we should at least send them back north of the Yellow River. They have the hearts of wolves. They are not our kind. Weak, they submit; strong, they rebel—that is their nature. Qin and Han conquered the lands south of the desert and made them commanderies precisely to keep barbarians away from the heartland. Why would Your Majesty settle them in Henan? A hundred thousand have surrendered. In a few years their numbers could double. Placed near the capital, they would become a disease in our very vitals." Yanbo replied: "Not so. The Son of Heaven treats the four barbarians as Heaven and Earth nurture all things—with shelter and care. The Turks are broken; their remnants submit. To abandon them without compassion violates the way of Heaven and will alienate all foreign peoples. Settling them in Henan means giving life to the dying and saving the lost. Grateful for generations, why would they rebel?" Wei Zheng countered: "In Wei times barbarian tribes were settled in nearby commanderies. After Jin conquered Wu, Guo Qin and Jiang Tong urged Emperor Wu to expel them—but he did not listen. The uprisings of Liu Yuan and Shi Le ultimately overturned the heartland. If Your Majesty insists on settling Turks in Henan, you will be rearing a tiger to plague your descendants." Yanbo replied: "The sage's way embraces all—'In education there are no distinctions of kind. They come to us broken and destitute. We shelter them, settle them inland, teach them rites and law, set them to farming, and select worthy chiefs for palace guard—what is there to fear? Moreover, when Emperor Guangwu established the Southern Chanyu, none ultimately rebelled or fled." Secretariat Vice-Director Yan Shigu, Du Chuke, Li Baiyao, and others urged settling the Turks north of the Yellow River instead. Install chieftains to govern their tribes, divide their lands, and keep them from uniting under one ruler. Small states with divided power could never challenge China—this was the way of governing from afar with loose reins. The emperor sided with Wen Yanbo. He mapped out Shuofang territory from Youzhou to Ling Prefecture, established the four prefectures Shun, You, Hua, and Chang under a grand protectorate, and divided Jieli's former lands between the Dingxiang and Yunzhong protectorates. Five hundred tribal leaders were made generals and commandants, nearly a hundred received court attendance appointments, and several thousand households registered in Chang'an. Tuli Khan was appointed Grand Protector of Shun Prefecture and ordered to lead his people to their assigned lands.
33
Tuli was first made she Nibu and married Princess Huainan of Sui. When Jieli took power he assigned his brothers to govern the tribes: Xueyantuo, Mohe, Hu, and Huxue. Tuli Khan ruled the Khitan and Mohe, with his headquarters south of Youzhou. All eastern tribes fell under his authority. Tuli taxed his people harshly and lost their loyalty. The Xueyantuo, Xi, and Mohe submitted to Tang. Jieli sent troops against them and suffered another crushing defeat. His forces scattered in turmoil. Jieli imprisoned and beat Tuli, releasing him only after a long time. Tuli had once allied with Taizong. As Jieli's power waned, he suddenly pressed Tuli with troops. Tuli refused, and the two brothers came to blows. Tuli asked to come to court. The emperor told his attendants: "Ancient rulers who toiled for their people's sake enjoyed long reigns; those who used their people for personal gain perished. The Turks are in chaos because their khan failed to rule. Tuli, though a close kinsman, could not protect himself and has come to us. Weak barbarians mean a secure frontier, yet watching them collapse I cannot be complacent. If we fall short anywhere, how can we avert disaster? Tuli was received with great honor. The emperor shared his own meal with him, made him Right Guard General, enfeoffed him as Prince of Beiping Commandery, and granted seven hundred households. When Tuli became grand protector, Taizong wrote: "Your grandfather Qimin was destroyed, and Sui restored him—but he betrayed that kindness. Your father Shibi then made himself Sui's enemy. You come to me in desperation. I do not make you khan, taking warning from these past failures. I want China secure and your clan preserved. I appoint you grand protector. Do not raid one another. Serve forever as my northern bulwark. Tuli prostrated himself and accepted. On a later visit to court he died on the road in Bing Prefecture at twenty-nine. The emperor mourned him and had Cen Wenben compose his epitaph. His son Heluoge succeeded him.
34
宿
While the emperor was at Jiucheng Palace, Tuli's brother Jieshelu, a commandant on palace guard, secretly plotted rebellion with tribal allies. He planned to seize Heluoge and flee north, telling his followers: "I hear the Prince of Jin takes up arms at midnight—I can burst in and strike the imperial camp. That night a fierce wind blew and darkness fell; the prince did not emerge. Fearing discovery, Jieshelu shot into the camp, raised a clamor, and began killing. Guards repelled him. He fled, killed stable hands, and stole horses to cross the Wei River, but was captured and executed at Yaoluo. Heluoge was pardoned and exiled beyond the passes. Ministers again argued that settling Turks in China was a mistake, and the emperor agreed. He established Ashina Simo as Yimi Nishu Irli Khan, granted him the surname Li, set his headquarters north of the river, and moved all Turks back to their former lands.
35
使 使
Simo was of Jieli's clan. His father was she Zhuoliu. When Qimin fled to Sui, the tribes north of the desert made Simo khan. When Qimin returned, Simo relinquished the title. Quick-witted and eloquent, he was favored by both Shibi and Chuluo. Because he looked like a foreigner, some doubted he was true Ashina blood. He was made only Jabiy tegin and never promoted to she. In the early Wude era he came repeatedly as envoy. Gaozu praised his sincerity and enfeoffed him as Prince of Heshun Commandery. When the tribes submitted, Simo alone stayed with Jieli and was captured. Taizong deemed him loyal, made him Right Martial Guard General and Grand Protector of Hua Prefecture over Jieli's former followers settled south of the river, and transferred his title to Prince of Huaihua Commandery. When the time came to move north, he feared the Xueyantuo and dared not leave the frontier. The emperor sent Guo Siben with credentials and a letter to the Xueyantuo: "China's way of rites never seeks to destroy nations. We attacked Jieli because he was cruel—not from greed for land or people. We settled the surrendered tribes south of the river where pasture and water were good, and their herds multiplied. Now we restore Simo as khan and return them to their former lands. The Xueyantuo received their mandate first and rank above the Turks. All lands north of the desert belong to the Xueyantuo; to the south the Turks shall hold. Each shall guard its own border without raiding the other. Whoever breaks this covenant, I shall punish with arms. Simo then departed. The emperor held a farewell feast and drew Simo forward: "One rejoices to see a single plant flourish—how much more should you rejoice that I nurture your people and rest your herds as before! Your parents' graves lie north of the river. Now you return to your old domain—I feast to comfort your journey." Simo wept, raised his cup to toast the emperor's long life, and said: "We are the remnant of a broken people. Your Majesty restores us to our homeland. May our descendants serve Tang forever to repay your grace." Prince Xiaogong of Zhao and Liu Shan went to Simo's camp, built an altar on the riverbank, and invested him with drums and banners. Ashina Zhong was made Left Wise King and Ashina Nishu Right Wise King to assist him.
36
使 使
Hearing the Turks were moving north, the Xueyantuo feared their people would flee across the desert and marshaled troops to intercept them. When the envoy arrived they apologized: "The Son of Heaven has forbidden mutual invasion. We bow and accept his decree. Yet the Turks are drunken, disorderly, and treacherous. Before their fall they killed Chinese by the thousands. Your Majesty destroyed their state—we believe their tribes should all be enslaved to repay Tang. Yet you nurture them like sons, and Jieshelu still rebelled. Their untrustworthiness could not be clearer. If they rebel again, we ask leave to destroy them for Your Majesty. In the fifteenth year Simo crossed the river with more than a hundred thousand followers, forty thousand warriors, and ninety thousand horses. He established his headquarters at old Dingxiang city—south lay the great river, north the White Road. Its vast pastures were the finest on the northern steppe, which the Turks had long contested. Simo sent envoys in gratitude: "By your grace I am made tribal chief. I hope to serve as your watchdog at the northern gate for generations. If the Xueyantuo attack, I ask shelter within the Great Wall. The emperor agreed.
37
宿
After three years he could not hold his people together. Many followers turned away. Ashamed, Simo came to court and asked to remain on palace guard. He was made Right Martial Guard General. On the Liaodong campaign he was struck by an arrow. The emperor sucked the blood from his wound. Such was his care for Simo. He died in the capital on his return. Posthumously made Minister of War and Grand Protector of Xia Prefecture, he was buried at Zhaoling. His tomb was shaped like White Road Mountain, and a stele recording his service was erected at Hua Prefecture.
38
使
Right Wise King Ashina Nishu was the son of Sunishi. When he first submitted, an imperial clanswoman was given him in marriage and he was granted the name Zhong. When he followed Simo beyond the frontier he yearned for China. Whenever he saw Tang envoys he wept and begged to enter court service. His request was granted.
39
Unable to maintain his state, Simo's remnant followers gradually crossed south of the river and were settled in Sheng and Xia prefectures. When the emperor campaigned against Liaodong, some warned that Turks settled south of the river were too close to the capital and urged him not to go east. The emperor replied: "Should a ruler harbor suspicion and division? Tang and Wu transformed the people of Jie and Zhou, and all turned toward virtue. Sui lost the Way and all under Heaven rebelled—not barbarians alone. We pity the Turks' fall and settled them south of the river to sustain them. They did not flee to the Xueyantuo but came to us from afar—they cherish us deeply. I calculate that China will have no Turkish trouble for fifty years. Once Simo's people moved south, Chebi Khan seized the vacated lands.
40
便 西祿
Chebi was also Ashina, from Tuli's division. His name was Hubo. His family had held the title of lesser khan for generations. After Jieli's defeat the tribes wished to make him their leader, but the Xueyantuo had proclaimed a khan, so he submitted to them instead. Deep, resolute, and cunning, he drew many followers. The Xueyantuo, fearing his rise, moved to kill him. He fled with his tribe. Thousands of horsemen pursued but could not catch him. He fled north of the Altai Mountains to a plateau accessible from only one side. With thirty thousand warriors he proclaimed himself Yizhu Chebi Khan, ten thousand li from Chang'an. He ruled the Geluolu to the west and the Kirghiz to the north, and raided the Xueyantuo whenever he could. As the Xueyantuo declined, Chebi's power grew.
41
調祿調 祿 使 祿
In the twenty-first year he sent his son Shabolu tegin with tribute and asked to come to court in person. The emperor sent An Diaozhe and Han Hua to escort him. Chebi showed no intention of coming to court. Han Hua plotted with the Geluolu to seize him, but Chebi discovered the plan. Han Hua and Chebi's son Zhi tegin killed each other in the fight, and Diaozhe was slain. Enraged, the emperor sent Gao Kan with Uyghur and Pugu troops. The great chiefs Geluolu Nishu Que Irli Fa, Chumukun Moheduo Irkin, and others surrendered one after another. Gao Kan attacked Mount Axi, but the tribes refused to fight. Chebi fled with his favorite concubine and a few hundred horsemen. Pursued to the Altai Mountains, he was captured and brought to the capital. Gaozong rebuked him: "When Jieli fell you did not aid him—you lacked loyalty to kin. When the Xueyantuo fell you fled and hid—you lacked loyalty to your lord. Your crimes deserve death, yet my father always pardoned captured chieftains. I pardon you now. His bonds were removed. Captives were presented at the ancestral temple and at Zhaoling. He was made Left Martial Guard General and given a residence. His people were settled at Mount Yudu under the newly established Langshan Protectorate. His son Jieman tuo had wept and urged Chebi to submit to Tang, but Chebi refused. Chebi had sent another son, Anshuo, to court. Anshuo later surrendered, was made Left Garrison Guard General, and given Xinli Prefecture to govern his followers. The Turks were now all subjects of the Tang frontier. The Chanyu Grand Protectorate was established over the Langshan, Yunzhong, and Sanggan protectorates and twenty-four prefectures including Sunong. The Hanhai Grand Protectorate governed seven protectorates including Jinwei and Xinli and eight prefectures including Xian'e and Helan. Tribal chiefs were promoted to grand protectors and prefectural governors. In Linde 1 Yanran was renamed Hanhai Grand Protectorate over the Uyghurs. The former Hanhai protectorate moved to old Yunzhong city as the Yunzhong Grand Protectorate. Frontier prefectures north of the desert fell under Hanhai; those south under Yunzhong. Yunzhong was where Princess Yicheng had lived. After Jieli's fall Li Jing settled several hundred broken Turkish tents there under Ashina De. As their numbers grew, they proposed that Tang princes be made khans to rule them from afar. The emperor said: "Today's khan is the ancient Chanyu. Yunzhong Protectorate was renamed the Chanyu Supreme Protectorate, and Prince Yin Xulun was made Chanyu Protector. At the emperor's feng and shan rites at Mount Tai, more than thirty grand protectors including Geluolu Chili accompanied him. After the ceremony their names were carved on the stele. For thirty years the north knew no alarm of war-horses.
42
調 西
At the start of Tiaolu the great chiefs Wenfu and Fengzhi of the Chanyu Protectorate rebelled, enthroned Ashina Nishufu as khan, and chieftains of twenty-four prefectures rose with them. Xiao Siye, Yuan Dazhi, and Li Jingjia were sent against them. Overconfident, they made no preparations. Rain and snow struck; soldiers froze. The rebels attacked and routed them, killing or capturing more than ten thousand. Dazhi and the others gathered survivors and fought their way out. Siye was exiled to Guizhou; the others were dismissed from office. Pei Xingjian was made supreme commander of the Dingxiang route with Li Siwen, Zhou Daowu, Cheng Wuting, and Li Wenjian. With some three hundred thousand men they pursued the rebels. Cao Huaishun was ordered to garrison Jingxing and Cui Xian to garrison Jiang and Longmen. The next year Pei Xingjian routed them at Black Mountain. His men beheaded Nishufu and surrendered with the head. Wenfu and Fengzhi were captured. The remnants held out at Langshan. Before the rebellion flocks of screaming pheasants flew into the frontier passes. Officials said: "These 'Turkish sparrows' fly south when barbarians are coming. When spring came they fell dead between Ling and Xia—mostly headless. Nishufu indeed perished." The Langshan rebels raided Yun Prefecture. Dou Huaizhe and Cheng Wuting drove them out.
43
紿 使
In Yonglong Wenfu's faction welcomed Jieli's kinsman Funian at Xia Prefecture. Funian fled across the river and was made khan. Tribes rallied to him. The next year they raided Yuan and Qing prefectures. Pei Xingjian was again made supreme commander, with Cao Huaishun and Youzhou Inspector Li Wenjian as deputies. Spies reported falsely that Funian and Wenfu held Black Sand, were starving, and could be taken with a light cavalry raid. Huaishun alone believed the report and rushed light troops to Black Sand. They found no rebels, only Xueyantuo remnants, whom they accepted in surrender. On the return march at the Great Wall they met Wenfu in battle. Casualties were roughly equal on both sides. Pei Xingjian fortified at the Daizhou pass, sowed discord between Funian and Wenfu, then attacked Funian and defeated him. Funian fled and encountered Huaishun. They fought a running battle for a day before Huaishun was routed. He abandoned his army and fled to Yunzhong. Tang soldiers were overrun; the dead were beyond count, all lying faced south. Huaishun sacrificed livestock to seal an alliance with Funian and escaped. Funian marched north, leaving family and supplies at Mount Jinyá. He led light cavalry against Huaishun, but Pei Xingjian's detachments captured his baggage. With nowhere to turn, Funian fled north to Xisha. Pei Xingjian sent Chanyu garrison troops in pursuit. Funian assumed Tang armies could not march so far and took no precautions. When they arrived he panicked. He sent envoys to Xingjian, handed over Wenfu, and surrendered. Xingjian sent him to the capital and executed him at the eastern market.
44
祿
In Yongchun 1 Kutlug rebelled again.
45
祿 祿 祿 使
Kutlug was of Jieli's clan, a division chief under Sheli Yuanying of Yunzhong Protectorate, hereditary tutun. After Funian's defeat Kutlug rallied fugitives, held Mount Zongcai, and fortified Black Sand city. With five thousand men he stole Nine Surname herds, grew strong, and proclaimed himself khan, making his brother Mokchur she and Tuxibo yabghu. Ashina Yuanzhen, inspector of surrendered tribes under the Chanyu Protectorate, was imprisoned by Chief Administrator Wang Benli. When Kutlug raided, Yuanzhen offered to summon the tribes back in exchange for pardon. The offer was accepted. Upon arrival he defected to Kutlug and became his strategist. Kutlug made him Apo Taghan and entrusted him with all troops. They raided the Chanyu Protectorate's northern frontier, attacked Bing Prefecture, and killed Lan Prefecture Inspector Wang Demao. They plundered Ding Prefecture but were repelled by Prince Yuan Gui of Huo, inspector of Beiping. They attacked Ji Prefecture, besieged the Chanyu Protectorate, and killed Administrator Zhang Xingshi. They attacked Yu Prefecture, killed Prefect Li Sijian, and captured Feng Prefecture Protector Cui Zhibian. Cheng Wuting was appointed Right Martial Guard General and Pacification Commissioner of the Chanyu route to guard the frontier.
46
祿祿
Between Sisheng and Chuigong they repeatedly raided Shuo and Dai and preyed on officials and soldiers. Chunyu Chuping was made supreme commander of the Yangqu route to attack the rebels at Mount Zongcai. At Xin Prefecture he met them in fierce battle and lost five thousand men. Wei Daijia was made supreme commander of the Yanran route to suppress them. The next year they entered Changping. Heichi Changzhi drove them back. They entered Shuo Prefecture again. Changzhi defeated them at Yellow Flower Mound and pursued them forty li until they fled across the desert. Cuan Baobi was ordered to pursue. Assuming the enemy was already broken, he recruited spies to scout two thousand li beyond the frontier, found the Turks unprepared, and rushed to attack. Word leaked before he arrived. The Turks mustered and fought to the death. Baobi was routed; he escaped alone while his entire force was destroyed. Empress Wu executed Baobi and renamed Kutlug Buzulu. Soon Yuanzhen attacked the Turgesh and died in battle.
47
祿
At the start of Tianshou Kutlug died. His son was too young to succeed. Mokchur seized the khanship. After several years he attacked Ling Prefecture and killed and plundered widely. Empress Wu sent Xue Huaiyi as supreme commander of the Shuofang route with Li Zhaode and Su Weidao, leading eighteen generals including Qiming, Wang Xiaojie, Li Duozuo, Chen Lingying, and Tian Yangming with mixed Chinese and tribal forces beyond the frontier. They found no enemy and returned. Wang Xiaojie was soon made supreme commander of the Shuofang route to guard the frontier.
48
使 使
When the Khitan Li Jinzhong rebelled, Mokchur offered to attack the rebels. The empress agreed. He was made Left Guard General and Duke of Returning State. Yan Zhiwei invested him as Qianshan Khan at his camp. Mokchur attacked the Khitan. When Jinzhong died he raided the Songmo tribe, seized Sun Wanrong's wives and baggage, and shattered their chiefs. Impressed by his campaign, the court again sent Yan Zhiwei to invest Mokchur as Special Grand Master, Elteber Great Chanyu, and Khan Who Establishes Merit and Serves the State. Before the commission arrived he attacked Ling and Sheng prefectures, ravaged the countryside, and was defeated by garrison commanders. He sent envoys to apologize, asked to become the empress's adopted son, offered his daughter for marriage to an imperial prince, and demanded the six prefectures' surrendered households. Internally submitted Turks had been settled among Feng, Sheng, Ling, Xia, Shuo, and Dai—the six river-bend prefectures of surrendered peoples. Mokchur also demanded a hundred thousand bushels of seed grain, three thousand farming tools, and tens of thousands of pounds of iron. The empress refused, and Chancellor Li Jiao agreed. Mokchur was enraged, spoke insolently, and seized the envoy Tian Guidao. Remonstrance Counselor Yao Shuang and others urged compliance. Grain, tools, and thousands of surrendered tents were sent—and the Turks grew strong.
49
使 西 西 使
Prince Wu Yanxiu of Huaiyang was betrothed to Mokchur's daughter. Yan Zhiwei and Yang Luanzhuang were sent to escort her. Mokchur sneered: "I offered my daughter to the Son of Heaven's son—and you send a Wu clan prince! We have served Tang for generations. I hear only two Tang descendants survive—I ought to install one of them. He imprisoned Yanxiu and the others, proclaimed Yan Zhiwei khan, and led a hundred thousand horsemen south against the Jingnan, Pingdi, and Qingyi armies. Murong Xuankuo surrendered with five thousand men. The Turks besieged Ji and Tan. Wu Chonggui was made supreme commander of the central Celestial Army route, Shazha Zhongyi of the western route, and Zhang Renyan of the eastern route—three hundred thousand men in all. Yan Jingrong and Li Duozuo commanded a hundred fifty thousand as rear guard of the western route. Mokchur broke through Feihu in Yu Prefecture, ravaged Ding Prefecture, killed Prefect Sun Yangao, burned settlements, and emptied the countryside. The empress offered kingship to whoever beheaded Mokchur and renamed him Zhanchuo. The Turks besieged Zhao Prefecture. Chief Administrator Tang Boruo colluded with them, entered the city, killed Prefect Gao Rui, and advanced on Xiang Prefecture. Shazha Zhongyi was made front-army commander of the Hebei route, Li Duozuo rear-army commander, and Fufushun odd-army commander. Crown Prince Zhongzong, recently returned from exile, was made grand campaign marshal with Di Renjie as deputy, Song Xuanshuang as chief administrator, Huo Xianke as marshal, Ji Xu as inspector, and Fuyu Wenxuan and six others as sub-commanders. Before they marched Mokchur heard the news. He buried alive eighty or ninety thousand captives from Zhao and Ding, withdrew by the Wuhui route, plundering everything in his path. Generals dared not fight; only Di Renjie pursued but could not catch him.
50
祿 西
Confident after victory and contemptuous of China, Mokchur's armies rivaled Jieli's and his domain stretched ten thousand li. All tribal peoples obeyed him. He made Tuxibo Left Overseer and Kutlug's son Moju Right Overseer, each commanding twenty thousand men. His son Fuju became lesser khan above the two overseers, commanding forty thousand men of the ten surnames including Chumukun as Elteber Khan of the West. Annual raids gave frontier garrisons no rest. Wei Yuanzhong was made inspector-general of Bingzhou and supreme commander of the Celestial Army, with Lou Shide as deputy, to organize defenses. Yuanzhong was transferred to supreme commander of the Lingwu route.
51
使
Mokchur stole ten thousand horses from Longyou pastures. He raided again soon after. Prince of Xiang was made supreme commander with Wu Youyi, Xue Ne, and Yuanzhong—but Mokchur withdrew before they marched. The next year he raided Yan and Xia, seized a hundred thousand sheep and horses, attacked Shiling, and besieged Bing Prefecture. Xue Jichang was made Shandong defense commissioner over nine prefectures. Zhang Renyan commanded Qingyi and barrier garrisons in support. Prince of Xiang was named Pacified North grand marshal but did not take the field. The Turks entered Dai and Xin and continued to kill and plunder.
52
使使 使
In Chang'an 3 Mokchur sent Mohedagan to offer his daughter to the crown prince. Empress Wu had Princes Chongjun and Chongming appear in full regalia. Mokchur sent the great chief Yilibahan with a thousand horses in thanks for the betrothal. The empress treated the envoy generously. When Zhongzong ascended, Mokchur attacked Wusha. Shazha Zhongyi was defeated with nearly ten thousand dead. The Turks entered Yuan and Hui and seized pasture horses. The emperor broke off the marriage and offered kingship and Guard General rank for Mokchur's head. Mokchur killed the envoy Zang Siyan. Zhang Renyan was made supreme commander of the Shuofang route. The next year the three Surrender Reception cities were built beyond the river to block raiding routes. Eventually Tang Xiujing replaced him on the frontier. When Ruizong succeeded Mokchur again sought marriage. Princess Jinshan, daughter of Prince Chengqui of Song, was betrothed to him. General Sun Yan and others were captured by the Xi at Lengling and handed to Mokchur, who killed them. Guo Yuanzhen replaced Xiujing.
53
宿 使
When Xuanzong succeeded he ended marriage alliances. Mokchur sent his son Yang Wozhi tegin to palace guard and pressed for marriage. Princess Nanhe of Shu was given as his wife. The next year his son Yinen Khan led Tong'e tegin and elite cavalry against Beiting. Guo Qianzhen beheaded Tong'e below the walls and routed them. Hubo dared not return and fled with his family. He was made Left Martial Guard General and Prince of Yanshan; his wife was styled Princess Jinshan and richly rewarded. When Yang Wozhi died, third-rank clansmen and above were ordered to mourn at his house. The Turks again requested marriage by letter. The emperor did not reply.
54
西 祿 祿 婿𨁂| 西𨁂|
In the Jingyun era Mokchur destroyed Suoge in the west and subjugated the Khitan and Xi, cruelly exploiting his subjects. As he aged he grew more brutal. Tribes resented and rebelled. The ten surnames—the five Tulu on the left and five Nushibi on the right—all sought to submit. The Geluolu, Huwu, and Shunishi, with Grand Protectors Zhu Si, Mulu Fuge, and Tabishi Hubi, submitted in succession. They were settled at the Altai Mountains. Xue Ne was made grand commander at Liangzhou with Yang Zhiyi as deputy. Guo Qianzhen was made grand commander at Bing Prefecture with Wang Jun as deputy. They pacified the new submitters and restrained raids. Mokchur repeatedly attacked the Geluolu. Protectorate commanders were ordered to support them. Turkish power gradually waned. His son-in-law Gao Wenjian of Goguryeo, Ba Protector Si Tai, Murong Daonu of Tuyuhun, Huqu Irkin and Xi Irli of Yujue, and Gao Gongyi of Goguryeo—more than ten thousand tents—submitted in succession and were settled south of the river. Wenjian was made Left Guard General and Prince of Liaoxi; Si Tai Special Grand Master, Right Guard General, Ba Protector, and Duke of Loufan; Daonu Left Martial Guard General and Duke of Yunzhong; Huqu Irkin Left Martial Guard General and Duke of Yinshan; Xi Irli Left Martial Guard General and Duke of Yanmen; Gongyi Left Army Guard General and Duke of Pingcheng—all supernumerary, with gifts according to rank.
55
使
Mokchur attacked the Nine Surnames north of the desert and routed them. The Sijie and others submitted and received offices. Xue Ne was made supreme commander of the Shuofang route with Lu Yanzuo and Du Binke to guard the frontier. Grand protectors of Jinshan, Great Desert, Yin Mountains, and Dark Pool were ordered to capture Mokchur, with published rewards. Mokchur attacked the Bayegu at the Dule River and routed them. Returning carelessly through a forest, Bayegu remnants ambushed and beheaded him. The envoy Hao Lingqian sent his head to the capital.
56
祿
Kutlug's son Kül Tigin rallied the old tribes, killed the lesser khan and nearly all the royal clan, and enthroned his brother Mojilian as Bilge Khan.
57
25%| 祿 𨁂| 使
Mojilian—called "lesser she"—was benevolent by nature. Believing the throne was not his own achievement, he yielded to Kül Tigin, who refused. Mojilian succeeded—in Kaiyuan 4. Kül Tigin was made Left Wise King with sole command of the armies. When Mokchur died Kül Tigin killed his ministers. Only Ton Yugu was spared because his daughter Bopo was Mojilian's khatun. He was dismissed to his tribe. When the Turgesh Suluk proclaimed himself khan many Turks wavered. Mojilian recalled Ton Yugu, over seventy and universally revered, to counsel on state affairs. Soon Si Tai of the Ba tribe and others returned from the river bend. When surrendered households moved south, Deputy Protector Zhang Zhiyun confiscated all their weapons and they grew resentful. Border inspector Jiang Hui restored their bows when they petitioned that the ban left them unable to hunt. They attacked Zhang Zhiyun, captured him, and prepared to deliver him to the Turks. Xue Ne and Guo Zhiyun pursued. The rebels scattered and released Zhiyun. Si Tai and others fled north in two columns. Wang Jun defeated the left column.
58
使 祿使 使 滿
Having gained the surrendered Hu, Mojilian wished to raid the frontier. Ton Yugu said: "We cannot. The emperor is formidable, the realm prosperous, and our armies are newly gathered. Mojilian wished to build a capital and erect Buddhist and Daoist temples. Ton Yugu said: "We are not one hundredth of Tang's strength. Our strength is mobility—following pasture, hunting, advancing when strong and fleeing when weak. Tang's vast armies cannot touch us. If they build cities and settle in them, one defeat and they will be captured. Buddhism and Daoism teach gentleness, not martial strength." Mojilian took his advice and sent envoys to sue for peace. The emperor deemed the overture insincere and refused. An edict mobilized three hundred thousand men under Wang Jun—including Baximi, Kirghiz, Khitan, Xi, and Turkish princes—to converge on the Jiluo River in autumn of the eighth year and capture Mojilian by separate routes. Mojilian was terrified. Ton Yugu said: "Baximi at Beiting is too far from the other tribes—they will not unite. Jun and Zhang Jiazhen are at odds—they will not cooperate and may not come at all. Even if they all come, we move north three days ahead. When their supplies run out they will withdraw. Baximi is rash and greedy. They will arrive first—we can defeat them. Baximi pressed the Turkish camp but withdrew when Jun failed to appear. The Turks wanted to attack, but Ton Yugu said: "They marched a thousand li and will fight desperately—we should not meet them head-on. Better to follow and ambush them when they are near." Two hundred li from Beiting they seized Baximi's city by a detour, then routed Baximi's army. The survivors fled to Beiting and were all captured. On the return they raided Liang Prefecture. Yang Jingshu sent Lu Gongli and Yuan Cheng against them. Ton Yugu said: "If Jingshu holds his walls we should negotiate. If he sallies out we will fight and win. Cheng ordered his men: "Bare your arms, draw full bows, and aim outward." Bitter cold split their skin; men could not draw their bows. Tang forces were routed. Cheng fled and Jingshu was demoted. The Turks revived and absorbed Mokchur's remaining followers.
59
使 調 使 使
The next year he begged for peace and asked to treat the emperor as a father. The request was granted. For years he sent tribute and marriage requests. While the emperor toured Mount Tai, Zhang Yue proposed reinforcing garrisons. Pei Guangting objected: "The feng and shan rites celebrate success—fresh mobilization would contradict that. Zhang Yue replied: "Turkish peace offers cannot be trusted. Their khan is benevolent and beloved; Kül Tigin is a fierce warrior; Ton Yugu grows wiser with age—rivals to Li Jing and Li Shiji. With all three united, they could strike while we tour the east." Pei Guangting proposed summoning Turkish ministers to court as hostages. Yuan Zhen was sent to explain the emperor's intent. Mojilian feasted with his khatun, Kül Tigin, and Ton Yugu and told Yuan Zhen: "Tibetans are dogs, yet Tang gives them princesses; the Xi and Khitan are my slaves, yet they too receive princesses; yet the Turks alone are repeatedly refused. Why? Yuan Zhen replied: "The Son of Heaven is like a son to his people—can a son marry within the family?" Mojilian retorted: "Those tribes were granted surnames and received princesses. Why not us? And we do not demand the emperor's own daughter—we only ask not to be the laughingstock of the world." Yuan Zhen promised to petition. Mojilian sent Ashina Irli Fa with tribute to attend the feng and shan ceremony. Barbarian chiefs entered guard with bows. A hare bolted before the emperor's horse; he killed it with one shot. Irli Fa prostrated himself: "Your Majesty's archery surpasses all mortal men. The emperor asked: "Are you hungry?" He replied: "Seeing Your Majesty's archery, I could fast ten days and still feel sated." He was then invited to demonstrate his riding and archery. After the ceremony they were feasted and sent home—but marriage was still denied.
60
使殿西 使
Thereafter Turkish ministers came annually. Tibet proposed joint raids; Mojilian refused and forwarded the letter. The emperor rewarded him, feasted envoy Meluo Qie, opened markets at the western Surrender Reception city, and granted silk yearly. In the nineteenth year Kül Tigin died. Zhang Quyi and Lu Xiang were sent to mourn. The emperor inscribed a stele and erected a temple with battle scenes painted on the walls. Mojilian wept whenever he saw it.
61
Mojilian's marriage petitions were granted. Geli Bi came to give thanks and set the date. Soon he was poisoned by Meluo Qie. Dying, he killed Meluo Qie and exterminated his clan. The emperor mourned him, sent Li Quan to sacrifice, erected a temple, and had Li Rong compose the epitaph. The tribes enthroned his son as Yiran Khan.
62
使 祿使 使 西 西
Yiran Khan reigned eight years and died. He sent envoys to court three times. His brother succeeded as Qapaghan Kutlug Khan. Li Zhi invested him as Dengli Khan. The next year envoy Yinanru came for New Year with tribute: "We honor the Heaven-Khan as we honor Heaven—we bring the new moon's greeting and wish the Son of Heaven long life." The young khan's mother Bopo and the official Yus Dagan meddled in government and divided the tribes. Dengli's uncles commanded east and west armies as Left and Right She, holding the finest warriors. The khan and his mother killed the West She and seized his army. The Left She attacked and killed Dengli Khan.
63
祿祿使 西 使使 西
The Left She was Pan Kül Tigin. He enthroned Bilge's son, who was killed by Kutlug Yabghu. Yabghu killed two khans in succession and made himself khan. In Tianbao 1 the Uyghurs, Geluolu, and Baximi killed Yabghu and made the Baximi chief Elteber Yishi Khan. The Uyghurs and Geluolu became Left and Right Yabghu and notified Tang. The tribes made Pan Kül Tigin's son Wusu Mish Khan, with Geladuo as West She. Tang urged Wusu Mish to submit; he refused. Baximi and the other tribes attacked him and he fled. West Yabghu Abu Si and Geladuo surrendered with five thousand tents. Geladuo was enfeoffed as Prince of Cherishing Grace.
64
使祿祿 祿
In Tianbao 3 Baximi killed Wusu Mish and sent his head to the ancestral temple. His brother White-Eyebrow tegin Helong Fu became White-Eyebrow Khan. Turkish chaos followed. Wang Zhongsi struck eleven divisions of the Left Apo Taghan. Before he finished, the Uyghurs and Geluolu killed the Baximi khan and enthroned Gulipeiluo as Kutlug Bilge Que Khan. The next year they killed White-Eyebrow Khan and sent his head to court. Kutlug Bopo Khatun, Bilge Khan's widow, submitted with her people. The emperor feasted at Hua'e Tower and enfeoffed her as Lady of Guest State with an annual stipend.
65
西西 西西 西西祿
The Turkish state founded under Northern Wei in the Datong era was now destroyed. Later tribute came only from the old Nine Surnames; their lands passed entirely to the Uyghurs. Where the clan had divided westward they were called the Western Turks. The Western Turks: their ancestor was Neudou's grandson Tuwu, titled Great Yabghu. His eldest son was Tumen Il Khan; his second was Shidianmi, also called Sedi Mi. Sedi Mi's son was Datou Khan, also Boka Khan. They divided the old Wusun lands with the Eastern Turks: east to the Turks, west to the Caspian, south to Kashgar, north to the desert, seven thousand li from the capital. Seven days northwest from Yanqi lay the Southern Court; eight days north the Northern Court—mixed with Tulu, Nushibi, Geluolu, and others. Their customs were largely Turkish, their speech slightly different.
66
便 便 便西 西使
When Eastern Turk Mughan Khan died he skipped his son Daluobian and enthroned his brother Tabo Khan. Tabo had charged his son Anluo to restore Daluobian, but the people rejected Daluobian's low-born mother and enthroned Anluo. Anluo later yielded to Mughan's nephew Shetu, who became Shabolue Khan. Daluobian became Apo Khan over his own followers. Shabolue attacked, killed his mother, and Apo fled to Datou. Datou, Western Khan, gave Apo a hundred thousand men to fight the Eastern Turks. Apo was ultimately captured by Shabolue. Under Qimin Khan, Datou attacked yearly until Sui aid to Qimin drove him to flee to Tuyuhun.
67
西使
After Apo's capture the tribes enthroned Yangsu tegin's son as Nili Khan. When Datou fled Nili was defeated. His son Daman succeeded as Nijue Chuluo Khan, harsh and suspicious in rule. In Daye he followed Emperor Yang against Goguryeo, was titled Yiwasna Khan, and married an imperial clanswoman. His brother Quedu she herded at Huining and styled himself Que Khan. When Jiangdu fell Yiwasna followed Yuwen Huaji then escaped to Chang'an. Gaozu enfeoffed him Prince of Returning Righteousness. He offered a great pearl; Gaozu refused: "I value your loyalty, not gems. Que Khan submitted in Wude 1 as Tuwuguoba Que Khan and allied with Li Gui. Cao Qiong of Ganzhou enticed him. He joined Qiong against Li Gui, was defeated, fled to Dadouba Valley, and was destroyed with Tuyuhun's help.
68
西
When Yiwasna was detained in Sui the tribes enthroned Datou's grandson Shekui Khan at Sanmi Mountain north of Kucha. States west of Yumen submitted; he rivaled the Eastern Turks. Shekui's brother Tong Yehu succeeded as Tong Yehu Khan.
69
西 使使 使 西 便 西
Tong Yehu was brave and always victorious. He annexed the Tiele, conquered Persia and Kashmir, commanded hundreds of thousands of bowmen, moved his court to the Thousand Springs north of Samarkand, and dominated the west—appointing irbir and tutun to collect tribute. Shekui's envoys asked to kill Yiwasna over old enmity; the emperor refused. Ministers argued: "Spare one man, lose a kingdom—he will trouble us later. The Prince of Qin objected: "He came to us—killing him brings ill fortune." The emperor again refused. At a palace feast, when wine ran deep, they let the envoys kill Yiwasna at the Secretariat—unannounced. Shekui sent tribute of Tiaozhi giant eggs and lion skins. The emperor cultivated alliance against the Eastern Turks. Tong Yehu set a date to attack; Jieli made peace and pledged not to fight. Tong Yehu sought marriage. The emperor asked: "The Western Turks are far—can we rely on them in crisis? Feng Deyi advised: "Ally with the far to strike the near—grant marriage to frighten the northern Turks, then deal with them later." Marriage was granted. Prince Dao Li went west. Tong Yehu sent Zhenzhu Tong Irkin with five thousand horses to seal the pact. Eastern Turkish raids blocked the route. Jieli warned: "If you fetch the Tang princess through my lands I will seize her. Tong Yehu resented this and the marriage failed. Arrogant and graceless, he lost his followers. His uncle Moheduo killed him before Tang could send funerary offerings.
70
使 使 西
Moheduo became Qulisi Bi Khan and sent tribute. Having proclaimed himself great khan after ruling a lesser division, Bi Khan lost the people's loyalty. The Nushibi pushed Nishu Mohe she as khan; he refused. Tong Yehu's son Dilitegin, exiled in Kangju, was enthroned by Nishu as Yipi Boluo Siye Hu Khan. He and Bi Khan divided the realm and fought endlessly. Taizong, grieving Yiwasna's unjust death, posthumously made him Upper Pillar of State and gave him full burial rites. In Zhenguan 4 Bi Khan sought marriage. The emperor refused: "The Turks are in turmoil—how can we marry now? Each was ordered to keep his division from attacking the others. All the Western Regions rebelled. The state was drained. Tribes rallied to Siye Hu Khan; even Bi Khan's followers deserted. They attacked Bi Khan, who fled to the Altai and was killed by Nishu. Siye Hu became great khan.
71
使 使 使殿
Siye Hu immediately marched north against the Tiele and Xueyantuo and was defeated. He was suspicious, obstinate, and harsh toward his subjects. Lesser khan Yili had done the most for the state. Siye Hu listened to slander and had him executed. The tribes were dismayed. He also plotted against Nishu, who fled to Yanqi. Meibei Taghan and Nushibi leaders deposed Siye Hu. He fled to Kangju and died of grief. The tribes welcomed Nishu from Yanqi and enthroned him as Tulu Khan. Tulu's father Mohe she had served Tong Yehu Khan. In Wude he came to court and Taizong swore brotherhood with him. When he died Nishu succeeded—or he is called Gana she. Once enthroned he sent envoys to court but declined the title of khan. Taizong sent Liu Shanyin to invest him as Tulu Khan with drums, banners, and lavish gifts. Nishu sent envoys in gratitude. Another day the retired emperor feasted envoys and asked Zhangsun Wuji: "Has antiquity ever seen such universal submission? Wuji offered long life. The retired emperor passed wine to Taizong, who bowed and returned the toast.
72
使 西 西西 西
Tulu's brother Tong'e she became Shaboluo Dilishi Khan. He sent tribute thrice and sought marriage; the emperor refused. He divided the realm into ten divisions, each led by one man with one arrow—the Ten She or Ten Arrows. The right held five Tulu divisions with five great chuo, east of Suyab; the left five Nushibi divisions had five great irkin, west of Suyab. Each arrow was one tribe—the Ten Surname Tribes. Unpopular, he was attacked by his tutun. Dilishi fought back; the tutun fled. Dilishi and his brother Buli she fled to Yanqi. Axijie Que Irkin and the tutun planned to make Yugu she great khan and Dilishi lesser khan. Tutun was killed and Yugu she was defeated by his irkin. Dilishi recovered his lands. The west made Yugu she Yipi Tulu Khan. After bloody war they divided at the Yilie River—west to Tulu, east to Dilishi. The Western Turks were split in two.
73
西 使 西 使 祿 使
Tulu built the Northern Court west of Mount Zhuohe and subjugated Boma and the Kirghiz. With Tutun Houlie Fa he attacked Dilishi. Dilishi fled to Ferghana and died. His son Yiquli Yipi Khan reigned one year and died. Nushibi leaders enthroned Gana she's son Bihuo Yehu as Yipi Shaboluo Yehu Khan. Taizong invested Shaboluo Yehu Khan and established the Southern Court north of Suihe. Kucha, Shanshan, Yanqi, Samarkand, and others submitted. Tulu grew stronger and repeatedly fought Shaboluo Yehu. Both sent envoys; Taizong ordered peace. Tulu refused, killed Yehu Khan, and annexed his realm. The Nushibi rebelled and withdrew. Tulu conquered Tokhar and raided Yizhou. Guo Xiaojie ambushed him with two thousand light cavalry from Wugu and defeated him. Tulu failed to take Tianshan. Xiaojie pursued, took a Chuyue city, and accepted Chumi's submission. Arrogant Tulu detained envoy Yuan Xiaoyou and boasted: "I am attacking Kangju—am I the equal of your Son of Heaven? He attacked Kangju, sacked the Mi kingdom, and hoarded the booty. General Nishu Quluo seized it; Tulu executed him. Huluju revolted and ravaged Tulu's forces. Tulu fled toward Tokhar, lost his followers, and held Kehedun city. Axijie Que Irkin defeated Tulu, who seized Baishui Hucheng. The Nushibi rejected Tulu and asked Tang to choose a khan. Tang sent Wen Wuyin to select a Turkish prince. They enthroned Yiquli's son as Yipi Shekui Khan.
74
使使 使 西祿 殿
Shekui Khan returned envoys to Chang'an and sent the Nushibi against Baishui Hucheng. Tulu sallied forth and routed the Nushibi with heavy losses. Tulu tried to rally old followers, but they refused: "After a thousand fought, one survived—we will not follow. Knowing he was hated, Tulu fled to Tokhar. Shekui sought marriage; Taizong demanded five states as bride-price. The marriage failed. Ashina Helu rebelled and seized the khan's tribes. Ashina Helu was fifth-generation grandson of Shidianmi Khan, son of Shekui tegin Jieyue of Yebu she. Tulu had made Helu yabghu over five tribes at Duolosi River, fifteen hundred li north of Xizhou. When Tulu fled, Shekui pursued. Helu wandered and his tribes scattered. Three tribes petitioned for Helu; the khan threatened them. They defected with Helu and Tang treated them well. Helu guided the Kucha campaign and was made Kunqiu route commander, richly rewarded. Promoted to Left Martial Guard General and Yaochi Protector at Mohe city, he gathered scattered followers.
75
西宿 西 祿 祿婿 使
At Gaozong's accession Helu plotted against Xi and Ting. Gaozong sent Qiao Baoming and took Helu's son Dieyun as hostage. Dieyun was trapped and made Right Martial Guard Commandant. Sent home, Dieyun urged Helu west to Thousand Springs as Shaboluo Khan over the ten surnames. Tulu's five chuo were Chumukun, Huluju, Shesheti, Turgesh, and Shunishi. Nushibi's five irkin were Axijie, Geshu, Bassegan, Axijie Nishu, and Geshu Chuban. Huluju Que was Helu's son-in-law. Axijie Que Irkin was strongest, with hundreds of thousands of warriors. Dieyun was made Moheduo Yabghu. Helu raided Ting Prefecture, ravaged counties, and withdrew after killing thousands. Liang Jianfang and Qibi Heli were sent with eighty thousand men against Helu. Luo Hongyi argued: "Rule China with trust, control barbarians with expedient force. Helu holds one city and thinks winter excludes Tang armies—we should strike now. Delay until spring and he will escape or rally allies. Our target is Helu; Chumi and Chumukun will rejoin him if we hesitate. Winter is harsh, but prolonged delay strengthens Helu. Pardon Chuyue and Chumi; strike Helu alone—the root, not the branches. Send tribal allies with one month's rations while the main army holds Pingluo River in support. Barbarian cavalry in front and Tang behind will corner Helu. The emperor approved and had Hongyi assist Jianfang. Zhu Ye Guzhu of the Chuyue joined Helu. Jianfang defeated him, taking nine thousand heads—not quite as Hongyi had envisioned.
76
滿 祿
In Yonghui 4 the Yaochi Protectorate was abolished; Cheng Zhijie was sent against Helu. Tulu died; his son Zhenzhu Yehu offered to attack Helu but was blocked. Next year Zhijie defeated the Geluolu and Chuyue, taking a thousand heads and ten thousand horses. Zhou Zhidu took Chumukun city with thirty thousand kills. Su Dingfang routed Helu's Shunishi camp at Yingsuo River. Wang Wendu refused battle, sacked Dudu city, and Cheng Zhijie could not restrain him.
77
使祿 西 西
In Xianqing 1 Su Dingfang was made Yili supreme commander to pursue Helu. Ashina Mishe and Buzhen were sent on the Liusha route; Nendulu and others surrendered. Dingfang's elite cavalry broke Chumukun west of Yidie River. Helu brought a hundred thousand horsemen; Dingfang met him with ten thousand. The Turks surrounded the Tang line. Dingfang planted infantry with halberds outward and cavalry to the north. Helu assaulted the infantry three times without breaking them. Dingfang's cavalry routed them—thirty thousand killed, two hundred chiefs slain. The next day the five Nushibi submitted. The five Tulu submitted to Buzhen. Dingfang sent Siye and Poyan to Talas; Yaxiang followed with submitted troops. In heavy snow Dingfang insisted on marching: "Helu thinks we cannot fight in winter—surprise him. They marched day and night to Shuanghe, joined Mishe and Buzhen, and reached Jinyá Mountain. Helu was hunting when Dingfang stormed his camp. Helu fled across the Ili River. Siye reached Thousand Springs; Mishe the Ili; Chuyue and Chumi submitted. At Shuanghe Mishe broke Bushida Taghan's line. Dingfang pursued Helu to Suyab and seized his army. Helu fled toward Shunou she but was trapped at Sudu city and delivered to the Shi kingdom. Yuanshuang and Siye's troops captured them. Dingfang restored plundered property and pacified the Western Regions. Helu told Siye: "I betrayed the emperor who favored me. Heaven's punishment is just—what can I say? I hear Han law executes criminals in the capital. Let me die at Zhaoling and apologize to the former emperor. The emperor said: "The former emperor entrusted Helu with two thousand tents. Can we present this captive at Zhaoling?" Xu Jingzong said: "Victorious armies traditionally offered wine at the ancestral temple. Feudal lords presented captives to the Son of Heaven—not at a tomb. Yet Your Majesty treats the imperial tomb like the ancestral temple—proceed without hesitation." Helu was presented at Zhaoling and spared execution.
78
鹿祿 西西 祿
Helu's lands were divided into prefectures to settle the tribes. Protectorates were established for Chumukun, Turgesh, Huluju, Shesheti, Shunishi, and others under Kunling and Mengchi grand protectorates. Subject states west to Persia became prefectures under the Pacified West Protectorate. Ashina Mishe became Xingxiwang Khan over the five Tulu; Buzhen became Jiwangjue Khan over the five Nushibi, each with a hundred thousand bolts of silk. Helu was buried beside Jieli with an epitaph on stone.
79
使
Mishe was also fifth-generation grandson of Shidianmi Khan, hereditary Moheduo Yabghu. In Zhenguan Mishe was invested as Xili Tulu Khan with drums and banners. Buzhen plotted against Mishe, who fled to court with Chuyue and Chumi and became Right Gate Guard General. Buzhen made himself Tulu Yabghu, lost his followers, and came to court as Left Garrison Guard General. Mishe served in Liaodong, was enfeoffed Baron of Pyongyang, and promoted Right Martial Guard General. After Helu's defeat both became khans with power to appoint officials in their divisions. That year Mishe killed Zhenzhu Yehu at Shuanghe and two quechuo.
80
Mishe and Buzhen failed to govern; Sijie Duman rebelled with three states and broke Khotan. Su Dingfang was sent against him at Matou River. In the fifth year Dingfang took Duman's city and forced his surrender. In Longshuo 2 Mishe and Buzhen joined Su Haizheng against Kucha. Buzhen falsely accused Mishe of rebellion. Haizheng believed the accusation and executed Mishe and his chiefs under false pretense of distributing gifts. Shunishi and Bassegan rebelled; Haizheng pursued and pacified them. Buzhen died in Qianfeng.
81
西 西 調 西
In Xianheng 2 Ashina Duzhi was made Left Martial Guard General and Fuyan Protector. In Yifeng Duzhi allied with Tibet and raised Anxi. Pei Xingjian was sent against him. Xingjian proposed taking Duzhi by stratagem without mobilizing troops. He was sent to invest the Persian prince and pacify the Arabs, passing through both realms. Duzhi was captured when he came to pay respects. Xingjian detained the chiefs and returned with Li Zhebi—in Tiaolu 1. Western Turkish power waned as the two divisions scattered. Mishe's son Yuanqing and Buzhen's son Huseluo inherited their fathers' titles and domains. Yuanqing rose to General of Pacifying the State and Acting Left Guard General. Empress Wu had tribal chiefs request the Wu surname for Ruizong's clan and renamed Huseluo Jiezhong Shizhu Khan. In Changshou Yuanqing was executed by Lai Junchen for visiting the crown prince; his son Xian was exiled.
82
西 使祿 西
The next year Ashina Chizi was made khan and raided with Tibet; Wang Xiaojie defeated them at Lengquan and Daling Valley; Han Sizhong defeated Nishu Irkin and took Tibet's Nishu Meisi city. In Shengli 2 Huseluo was made Left Guard General and Pacified Western Army commander. Wuzhile was too strong; Huseluo migrated with sixty thousand followers and died in Chang'an. His son Huaidao succeeded.
83
使 西使 西 祿 祿 西祿 祿
In Chang'an Ashina Xian became Right Martial Guard General, Ten Surname Khan, and Beiting Protector. In the fourth year Huaidao became Ten Surname Khan and Mengchi Protector. Soon Xian was made Western Desert Military Commissioner. Xian killed the rebel Dudan and accepted thirty thousand tents west of Suyab. Xian was sent to coordinate with Beiting against Mokchur's raids on submitted tribes. The Turgesh sought opportunity; Xian asked for reinforcements and to come to court—Xuanzong refused. Wang Hui was sent to reassure the frontier. Suluk was to be made Duke of Shunguo—but the Turgesh besieged Bo Huan and Dashicheng, threatening the Four Garrisons. Jiahui mobilized Geluolu troops with Xian to attack. Chancellors Song and Zhang argued: "Let the Turgesh and Geluolu fight each other—it is not our fight. Whether the strong are hurt or the weak destroyed, we profit. Wang Hui goes to soothe—not to fight. The plan was halted. Unable to control Suoge, Xian returned to Chang'an and died.
84
西西 西 西 西西
After Tuhuoxian's fall Xin was made Ten Surname Khan; Princess Jiaohe was sent with an escort. Xin was killed at Julan city; Princess Jiaohe fled home. The Western Turks perished. Turgesh Wuzhile was a separate division of the Western Turks. After Helu's fall both khans served at court; the steppe had no fixed ruler. Wuzhile served Huseluo as Moheda Taghan. Huseluo was cruel; Wuzhile won loyalty, established twenty grand protectors with seven thousand men each northwest of Suyab. He seized Suyab as his capital, with secondary seats at Gongyue and the Ili, annexing Huseluo's domain.
85
鹿 使殿 使 西 西
In Shengli 2 his son Zhenu came to court and was warmly received. In Shenlong he was enfeoffed Prince of Huaide Commandery. Wuzhile died; his son Suoge inherited as Left Martial Guard General. Suoge commanded three hundred thousand warriors; Huaidao invested him with four palace women. In Jinglong Zhongzong received Turgesh envoys with full ceremony. Suoge quarreled with general Zhongjie and they fought. Suoge accused Zhongjie and asked that he be brought to court. Zhongjie bribed Zong Chuke to stay out of court and bring Tibet against Suoge. Chuke sent Feng Jiabin to mediate. Suoge intercepted Jiabin's correspondence, killed him, and sent Zhenu to raid the frontier. Niu Shijiang died fighting at Huoshaocheng and demanded Chuke's head. Guo Yuanzhen argued Suoge was justified; he was pardoned and the west was settled.
86
Zhenu, resentful of a smaller share, defected to Mokchur to attack Suoge. Mokchur kept Zhenu and captured Suoge with twenty thousand men. Mokchur asked Zhenu: "Your brothers could not cooperate—will you serve me faithfully? He killed them both.
87
祿 祿西 祿使 使 西使 使 祿西 祿 使 祿使 西祿使西
Chebi Shichuo Suluk of the Turgesh rallied remnants and made himself khan. Suluk reunited the Turgesh to two hundred thousand and again dominated the west. In Kaiyuan 5 Suluk came to court as Turgesh Protector; his gifts were declined. Wang Hui invested Suluk as Duke of Shunguo and Jinfang route commissioner. Cunning and not fully loyal, Suluk was titled Loyal and Submissive Khan. The emperor married Huaidao's daughter to him as Princess Jiaohe. When the Turgesh sold horses at Anxi, Du Xian flogged the envoy who bore Princess Jiaohe's orders. He gave no reply. Enraged, Suluk allied with Tibet, raided the Four Garrisons, and besieged Anxi. Du Xian became chancellor; Zhao Yizhen held Anxi but was defeated sallying out. Suluk plundered and opened granaries, then withdrew on hearing Du Xian was chancellor; He sent Abu Si to court; Xuanzong feasted him. Eastern Turkish envoys disputed rank: "The Turgesh are small and were Turkish subjects—they should not sit above us. Suluk's envoy replied: "This feast is for us—we will not sit below." East and west seats were arranged with the Turgesh in the west seat before the feast could proceed.
88
祿 祿
Suluk was generous in victory and married daughters of Tibet and the Turks, making three khatuns and several yabghu sons. In old age he hoarded booty and lost the loyalty of his followers; He also suffered paralysis and neglected affairs. Moheda Taghan and Dumozhi rose while Yellow and Black surnames feuded.
89
祿 祿 使西使西 祿 使祿西 西 祿 西使
Moheda Taghan and Dumozhi assassinated Suluk. Dumozhi enthroned Tuhuoxian at Suyab; Black and Yellow factions warred. Gai Jiayun was sent to pacify the Turgesh and western states. Taghan and Jiayun with Shi and Shi kings defeated Tuhuoxian at Suyab. Tuhuoxian fled but was captured with his brother Dunabo. Menglingzha and the Ferghana king took Talas, killed the Black Surname Khan, recovered Princess Jiaohe, and resettled tens of thousands with Ferghana. All the states submitted. The Chumukun, Fuyan, Queleichuo, and other divisions all sent memorials of apology: "Born in remote borderlands, after the kingdom fell into chaos and our king died, we turned on one another in slaughter. Thanks to the Son of Heaven, who sent Jiayun with troops to punish the violent and restore order, we wish to kowtow before your sacred countenance and submit our tribes to the Anxi Protectorate as perpetual outer subjects. The emperor granted their request. The following year Queleichuo was promoted to Grand General of the Right Xiaowei Guard, the Stone Prince was enfeoffed as Prince of Shunyi, and the Shi Prince was further appointed Special Advance — a public reward for their service. Jiayun captured Tuhuoxian Guchuo and presented him at the imperial temple. The emperor pardoned him, appointing him Supernumerary Grand General of the Left Jinwu Guard and Prince of Xiuyi, and made Dun'abo Supernumerary General of the Right Wuwei Guard. Ashina Huaidao's son Xin was installed as khan of the Ten Surnames to command the Turgesh tribes. Mohadagan protested angrily: "I was the one who pacified Sulu. The credit belongs to me. And now you install Xin instead — what is that supposed to mean? He then incited the various tribes to rebel. The emperor ordered Jiayun to negotiate with him. Mohadagan then submitted with his family and tribal chieftains and was appointed to command his followers. Several years later Xin was again installed as khan, with troops sent to escort him. Xin reached Julancheng, where Mohaduo killed him. Mohaduo declared himself khan. Anxi Military Governor Fumeng Lingcha executed him and installed the great banner-chieftain Tumozhi Quejiejin as yabghu of the Three Surnames.
90
祿使
In Tianbao 1 the Turgesh tribes again installed Ilidimishigudulubili of the Black Surname as khan and sent envoys and tribute on several occasions. In the twelfth year the Black Surname tribes installed Dengli Yiluomishi as khan, and the court issued an investiture edict.
91
使 祿祿
After the Zhide era the Turgesh declined. Both the Yellow and Black surnames installed rival khans and fought one another, while the court, embroiled in domestic crises, had no time to intervene. During the Qianyuan era the Black Surname khan Aduopeiluo still managed to send envoys to court. After the Dali era the Karluk grew powerful and moved to the Suyab River. Weakened, the two surnames became subject to the Karluk, while the remnant tribes of Kunsolo joined the Uyghurs. When the Karluk fell, Tilmoch occupied Karasahr and styled himself yabghu. The remaining tribes held Jinsaling, their numbers reaching two hundred thousand.
92
Commentary: In the late Sui the empire drained its interior to wage foreign campaigns. The living exhausted themselves on the roads; the dead littered the fields. Bandits rose everywhere and together overthrew the dynasty. At this time the frontier peoples pressed in while China weakened. Among them the Turks were strongest — their bowmen were said to number a million. Disgraced Chinese outcasts rallied to them, plotting invasions and guiding them across the border. Qilibi believed himself mightier than any ruler in history. When Gaozu first took the throne he made peace with the Turks and repeatedly sent troops to help suppress rebels. He therefore flattered them and lavished gifts beyond reckoning. Seeing opportunity, the Turks allied with rebels and slaughtered and plundered officials and civilians. They then invaded in force, advancing to Weiqiao Bridge until the dust of their cavalry obscured the capital. Taizong personally led his troops, rebuking the Turks openly while secretly sowing discord among them. Internal divisions began to appear among the invaders. Within three years Qilibi was bound and presented at the northern gate. Like a thunderbolt sweeping clean, their state was reduced to ruin. Since the days of the Book of Songs and Book of Documents, no ruler has punished the violent and overthrown disorder with such divine speed. Qin and Han pale by comparison. Yet the emperor repeatedly mobilized his armies without complaint, assessed the enemy with clear-eyed precision, entrusted capable generals and ensured they received credit for their victories — a style of warfare worthy of the Yellow Emperor himself. The Turks had lost virtue and resisted the righteous empire, declining just as Tang was rising. Though the rise and fall of dynasties belongs to Heaven, their fall had clear causes of their own.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →