← Back to 元史

卷一百九十 列傳第七十七: 儒學二

Volume 190 Biographies 77: Confucian Scholars 2

Chapter 190 of 元史 · History of Yuan
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 190
Next Chapter →
1
Biography 77: Confucian Scholars, Part Two
2
西 使 退
Hu Changru, whose style was Jizhong, came from Yongkang in Wuzhou. In the closing years of the Tang, his forebears had moved from Tiantai. After the Song court fled south, ten members of the clan entered official life through the jinshi degree, and for generations they held imperial commissions in office, one following another. His great-grandfather Chan served as judicial aide in Qinzhou—a man of bold, unconstrained spirit who cared little for money and gave freely in haste; people likened him to Zheng Zhuang. His grandfather Yan passed the jinshi examination in the jiaxu year of Jiading and governed Min County in Fuzhou. His conduct was eminent, his opinions fearless, and his prose studded with striking passages; throughout the Duanping and Jiading eras, the literati considered him beyond their reach. While serving on the Jiangxi staff, he quelled the turmoil at Ganzhou almost at a gesture and saved the lives of hundreds of thousands. His father Juren took the jinshi degree in the dingwei year of Chunyou and served as prefect of Taizhou; in both letters and governance he stood unrivaled across the realm. In Changru's generation learning reached its height. He mastered the Nine Classics and every history, then ranged through the hundred schools—Mohist, Legalist, coalitionist, and more—along with statutes, regulations, and administrative codes, organizing the whole into a coherent order. During Xianchun his father-in-law Xu Daolong served as staff adviser to the Pacification Commissioner for Jinghu and Sichuan; Changru accompanied him into Shu, placed first in the qualifying examination, and received appointment as Diligent Merit Gentleman and supervisor of the Chongqing wine monopoly. Before long he entered service under the Pacification Commissioner Zhu Sun's grandson as concurrent aide at the General Office for Military Funds and Grain in Huguang. He and Gao Peng, Li Shen, Mei Yingchun, and others were known as the Eight Scholars of the South. He was later appointed deputy prefect of Funing, but when the Song dynasty collapsed he retired to live in seclusion in the Yongkang hills.
3
殿 簿 使 西 紿 使
In the twenty-fifth year of Zhiyuan the court issued an edict calling for men of talent, and the authorities pressed him into service. He came to the capital and waited at the Hall of Gathered Talents for imperial appointment. He was soon summoned to the inner palace, appointed Compiler at the Hall of Gathered Talents, but when his views clashed with the chief minister's he was reassigned as instructor at Yangzhou. In the first year of Yuanzhen he was posted to Jianchang, where the registrar's post happened to be vacant; Changru was ordered to fill it on an acting basis. Cheng Wenhai was then at the height of power, and his household's arrogance was so fierce that even when they broke the law no one dared challenge them. They had planted trees outside their gate that blocked the official roadway, and Changru promptly ordered them torn down. In the first year of Zhida he became chief clerk of Ninghai County in Taizhou Circuit, holding the rank of Assistant Gentleman for Attending Service. In the dingwei year of Dade eastern Zhejiang suffered a devastating locust plague; the following wushen year brought another crop failure, and people died in heaps where they lay. The Pacification Commissioner Tuohuancha set famine relief in motion, collecting 1.5 million cash from the wealthy for distribution. When he reached the county he left 250,000 of the surplus with Changru to hold in storage, then continued on to neighboring prefectures. Changru saw that Tuohuancha meant to skim the funds and distributed the entire sum to the people. A month later Tuohuancha returned and demanded the money. Changru came forward bearing a completed dossier and said, "Here is your money." Tuohuancha raged, "Your nerve is as big as a mountain! Who authorized you to act with such reckless impunity!" Changru replied, "When people miss even one day's food, they die. I admit I did not report to you in time, but the official records are complete and can be checked." Furious though he was, Tuohuancha dared press the matter no further. The county had a place called Copper Cliff where ruffians lay in ambush, constantly robbing travelers on the highway—a scourge the authorities could not suppress. Changru dressed as a merchant, had a servant carry goods behind him, and secretly told ten mounted guards to follow at a distance. When Changru reached the cliff the bandits sprang out to rob him. He was still making polite excuses when his guards suddenly closed in and seized them all. He had the entire gang arrested and punished, and thereafter travelers passed safely even at night. A farmer carrying a night-soil bucket to his fields accidentally brushed a soldier's coat. The soldier beat him, smashed the bucket, and left—and no one knew who he was. The farmer came to complain. Changru pretended to be angry at a false accusation and had him shackled in the marketplace while his men watched in secret. When the soldier who had beaten him passed by, he pointed and crowed with satisfaction. They seized the soldier, brought him to his unit, flogged him, and made him pay for the broken bucket. A group of elderly women had gathered at a Buddhist chapel to chant scriptures for blessings. One woman lost her clothes, and as Changru was passing through the countryside she brought the case to him. Changru placed sprouting barley in each woman's cupped palms and told them to circle the Buddha and chant as before. He closed his eyes, clicked his teeth, and assumed the pose of summoning spirits, saying, "I have set spirits to watch. Whoever stole the clothes—after a few circuits the barley will sprout in her hands." One woman kept opening her palms to peek. Changru pointed her out, had her bound, and returned the stolen clothes. On his return from the commandery headquarters an clerk told him of an adultery case in which the suspects would not confess despite repeated questioning. Changru said, "That is easily settled." That night he hid beneath the clerk's desk. At dawn he brought out the suspects for questioning; they grew only more stubborn. Changru pretended to tell the magistrate, "I hear the court has issued an edict—should we not go welcome it?" He ordered runners to bind the suspects to the east and west pillars, cleared the county hall, and left the courtyard empty. The suspects whispered to one another, "It has come to this—even if we die we will not confess. They will have to let us go soon." No sooner had they spoken than the clerk burst out from beneath the desk. Startled, the suspects all kowtowed and confessed. In Yongjia a younger brother had pawned a pearl hairpin to his elder brother and later redeemed it, but the elder brother's wife coveted it and claimed it had been stolen. Repeated lawsuits brought no justice, so the man went to Changru, who said, "You are not one of my people." He ordered him driven away. Before long, while prosecuting a theft case, Changru had the thief accuse the elder brother of possessing the hairpin as stolen goods. The brother was arrested and protested repeatedly in vain. Changru said, "Your household really does have such a thing—how can you call this a false charge!" The brother blurted out in panic, "We do have it—it was what my younger brother pawned." He had it brought at once for inspection, summoned the younger brother, and said, "Is this not your family's property?" The younger brother said, "It is." And so it was restored to him. Most of his official conduct was of this sort, and not all of it can be recorded here. In the first year of Yanyou he was appointed Salt Commissioner of Changshan Field under the Zhejiang Salt Transport Commission with the rank of Gentleman for Attending Service, but he never took office, resigned citing illness, and never served again, ending his days in seclusion on Tiger Grove Mountain near Hangzhou.
4
耀
Changru first studied under Yu Xuegu of Qingtian, who had studied under Wang Mengsong—also of Qingtian and heir to the learning of Ye Weidao of Longquan, a disciple of Zhu Xi. With so orthodox a lineage, Changru traveled widely to pursue its meaning and came to believe that self-cultivation through reverence was paramount. Through silent preservation and quiet observation he attained a transcendent self-possession. As a man he was luminous and magnanimous, devoted to illuminating the original mind, and boldly measured himself against Mencius. Fearing only that the Way might cease to be transmitted, he taught without tiring, and scholars of the day flocked to him as the hungry and thirsty flock to food and drink. Provincial governors and prefects invited him to lecture in the schools, where he expounded the classics to audiences of several hundred seated around him. Changru declared, "Though humanity is the most spiritually keen of beings, we arise from the same source as all things and were never divided into two natures." All were stirred to excitement, and some sighed with deep emotion. His literary compositions had soul and force, like gold hammered and jade struck—one touch and their harmonious tone rang out. Seekers came from across the realm as if buying a sacred jade disk. His commemorative inscriptions blazed with splendor and lit the four quarters, yet if the patron was unworthy he would not sell a single character for any price. He repeatedly served as chief examiner in provincial competitions, prizing substance over ornament and thereby transforming the literary climate.
5
稿
In his later years he lived at Wulin, suffering for a long time from asthma and labored breathing. One day he prepared wine and food and bade his neighbors farewell, saying he would return to his native place. A disciple who sensed his meaning asked, "Master, your spirit is undiminished—why do you so suddenly speak of departing this life?" Changru replied, "Spirit and life and death were never connected in the first place." He retired to bed. At midnight his breathing suddenly stopped. His son Ju opened the door and found him seated in proper cap and robes, already departed. He was seventy-five years old. His works in circulation included Collected Earthenware Vessels, Nanchang Collection, Ninghai Miscellany, and Drafts from the Studio of Delight in Yan.
6
His cousins Zhigang and Zhichun were both celebrated for classical learning and letters. Zhigang, style Yizhong, had once been recommended in a memorial. On phonology and the theory of written graphs he claimed to have reached insights no one else had matched, but regrettably his writings did not survive. Zhichun, style Muzhong, passed the jinshi examination in the jiaxu year of Xianchun. He lived like an ancient solitary exemplar, and his prose was especially lucid and polished, a pleasure to recite. People called them the Three Hus.
7
西 使
Xiong Penglai, whose style was Yuhe, came from Yuzhang. In the jiaxu year of Xianchun he ranked fourth on the jinshi list and was appointed Attendant Gentleman and aide to the Baoqing prefectural judge, but the Song fell before he could take office. When Kublai first secured the Jiangnan region he sought out every remaining Song scholar for service, especially favoring jinshi graduates. He appointed the former chief minister Liu Mengyan Minister and summoned the jiaxu top graduate Wang Longze as Investigating Censor of the Jiangnan Branch Secretariat. Penglai had passed the jinshi in Wang Longze's year and enjoyed a reputation no less than Longze's, yet he refused to parade himself for advancement and lived in seclusion in his home district, where students under his instruction commonly numbered well over a hundred. He distilled the essentials of Zhu Xi's Elementary Learning for his students, and households across the realm passed his book from hand to hand until it was known nearly everywhere. Yuzhang was the Jiangxi provincial capital, seat of both the Branch Secretariat and the Surveillance Commission. The men who held those posts were mostly eminent court ministers, and all received him with the courtesy due a guest. Lian Xixian's son Dun, who served as Associate Administrator, treated Penglai with the deference owed a teacher and called himself his disciple for life. Liu Xuan, the Surveillance Commissioner, showed him particular honor. Penglai was harmonious without being loose, principled without being rigid. He debated the classics daily with fellow scholars, and the Confucian community looked to him as a pillar.
8
西使 調 滿調簿 滿
When the court sent Investigating Censor Wang Gou to conduct external examinations in Jiangxi, Associate Administrators Xu Yan and Li Shi'an jointly recommended Penglai as Commissioner for Promoting Confucian Studies in Minhai. The court, noting that Fujian and Luling boasted the strongest Confucian communities in the southeast, specially appointed him to teach consecutively in two prefectures. Wherever he went he researched ancient seal and clerical scripts, tuned pitch pipes, harmonized songs and odes to revive court music, fashioned instruments and fixed texts according to ancient models, and transformed the scholars around him. When his term ended he was routinely transferred to chief clerk of Jian'an County, but he declined to go. Late in life he retired as vice-prefect of Fuqing, a title Penglai regarded with complete indifference. Scholars everywhere, following the name he chose for himself, called him Master Tianyong. In his leisure hours he would play the zither and sing for his own pleasure. He wrote two Rhapsodies on the Zither, which scholars competed to copy and recite. Disciples flocked to him in ever greater numbers until neighboring houses were full and could hold no more. Penglai lectured earnestly on the meaning of the classics and grew only more tireless with age. Most of those who studied under him became celebrated figures.
9
Early in Yanyou the court revived the jinshi examinations after they had been suspended for years. The officials in charge knew none of the old procedures and feared they would fail the imperial mandate. The provincial authorities consulted Penglai, whose answers hit every mark, and on his advice regulations were submitted that the whole realm could follow. When they asked him to serve as chief examiner he refused, saying, "Nine out of ten candidates have studied under me—that will not do." Thereafter Jiangzhe and Huguang provinces all sent humble, elaborate invitations asking him to serve as chief examiner, and he went repeatedly to oblige them. At the palace examination the candidates he had selected accounted for a third of all graduates in the empire.
10
Early on Penglai had been first recommended in his home district on the Rites of Zhou, but Yuan regulations excluded the Offices of Zhou from the examination curriculum and few scholars studied the Elder Dai's Record of Rites. Penglai raised the issue repeatedly. Among the classics Penglai's learning ran deepest in the Three Rites, and scholars of ritual studies in his day all looked to him as their authority. During Zhizhi, Emperor Yingzong began reviving ancient rites, personally wearing full court dress to sacrifice at the Grand Temple and pressing forward with ritual and music reform. Hanlin Academician Yuan Mingshan openly recommended Penglai at court, but before the summons arrived Penglai died at seventy-eight.
11
Penglai's conduct was measured and steady; joy and anger never showed on his face. When receiving guests, each left feeling fully understood. His collected works ran to thirty juan, chiefly clarifying ritual and music as they bear on civilizing the world. He also investigated astronomy, geography, technical arts, material culture, and measurement with equal thoroughness.
12
His son Taigu passed the jinshi examination by provincial recommendation.
13
調
Dai Biaoyuan, whose style was Shuaichu and who also used the style Zengbo, came from Fenghua in Qingyuan. At seven he began studying classical poetry and prose, producing many striking lines. As he grew older he studied rhapsodic composition under a local teacher but soon abandoned it and refused to write in that genre. During Xianchun he entered the Imperial Academy, advanced through the three-college system to inner-college standing, placed tenth in the Ministry of Rites examination, passed the jinshi in the second class, and was appointed instructor at Jiankang Prefecture. He was later offered posts as instructor at Lin'an and acting registrar in the Ministry of Revenue, but accepted neither. In the eighth year of Dade, Biaoyuan was already past sixty. Those in power recommended him at court, and he entered service as instructor at Xinzhou, then at Wuzhou, before resigning citing illness.
14
Early on Biaoyuan lamented that late-Song writing had lost its vigor and grown servile and mannered—a corruption already deep. He resolved to revive the literary tradition himself. Wang Yinglin of Siming and Shu Yuexiang of Tiantai were then the leading literary models of their generation, and Biaoyuan studied under both. His learning was broad and free-ranging; his prose clear, deep, and refined. He turned stale writing into something marvelous, holding force in reserve before releasing it. Even when sketching incidental subjects he never showed artifice. He gave generously to others yet guarded his approval and rarely granted it lightly. During Zhiyuan and Dade, among the great literary names of the southeast for a generation, only Biaoyuan stood apart.
15
His best-known disciple was Yuan Que, whose forms of composition and argumentative style wholly followed Biaoyuan's model.
16
Late in life the Hanlin Academy and Hall of Gathered Talents considered recommending him as Compiler and Academician, but age and illness kept him from office. He died at sixty-seven. His Shanyuan Collection circulated widely.
17
During Biaoyuan's era Ren Shilin of Siming was also celebrated for his writing.
18
祿 調 沿 簿 退
Mou Yinglong, style Bocheng, came from Shu; his family later settled in Wuxing. His grandfather Zicai served the Song and was posthumously honored as Grand Master of Splendid Happiness with the posthumous title Pure and Loyal. His father Yan served as Vice Minister of Justice. As a boy Yinglong was exceptionally quick-witted, memorizing thousands of characters a day, and his writing had a rich, weighty tone. He was entitled to enter the capital bureaucracy by hereditary privilege but yielded the benefit to his younger cousins and instead passed the jinshi examination in Xianchun. Jia Sidao then dominated the government, comparing himself to Yi Yin and the Duke of Zhou. He told Ma Tingluan, "You once knew Pure and Loyal—if his grandson will see me, I shall place him at the top of the list." Yinglong refused and would not see him. In the policy examination he laid out how communication had broken down at every level of government and how dire the state's situation had become. The examiners dared not rank him at the top. Assigned sheriff of Dingcheng in Guang Prefecture, he said, "My grandfather once answered the policy questions, offended Shi Miyuan with blunt speech, and received the post of sheriff of Hongya. Today it should be the same—and I feel no shame." The Coastal Pacification Commission invited him as staff, but he declined citing illness and never served—and then the Song fell. The former chief minister Liu Mengyan, serving Kublai as Minister of Personnel, wrote to recruit him: "Come, and a Hanlin post may be yours." Yinglong did not answer. He later entered service as instructor at Liyang Prefecture and retired in old age as chief clerk of Shangyuan County. When the Song fell his father had already retired from the Vice Ministry of Justice. Father and son made a household school, debating the classics and testing one another on principle. They developed settled views on every classic, and only their Phonological Studies of the Five Classics achieved wide circulation. Yinglong excelled at narrative writing. Seekers crowded his gate with carriage tracks, and the southeast hailed him as a literary master, comparing him to the Su father and sons of Meishan. Scholars called him Master Longshan after the name he chose for himself. He died in the first year of Taiding at seventy-eight.
19
Zheng Chusun, style Jing'ou, came from Chuzhou. In the Jingding era he passed the jinshi, governed Yueqing County in Wenzhou, and rose through posts including Director of the Imperial Clan Court and Gentleman of the Ministry of Rites. In the thirtieth year of Zhiyuan someone recommended him by name. Kublai summoned him and appointed him Direct Academician of the Hall of Gathered Talents. He was soon promoted to Erudite Lecturer and then to Academician. He requested retirement and returned to his home district.
20
西 西
His younger brother Taosun, style Jingqian, also passed the jinshi and served as custodian of the Western Marchmount Shrine. Earlier Taosun had been summoned to court, answered to the emperor's satisfaction, and was appointed Compiler at the Hanlin National History Office. When the compilers reached the final year of Song Dezuo, Taosun said, "I once served the Song. That was the year it perished—I cannot bear to record it, for to write it would be unrighteous." He never wrote it, and Kublai praised him for it. He was promoted to Hanlin Attendant for Drafting and later served as Commissioner for Promoting Confucian Studies in Jiangxi.
21
The Chusun brothers were then the most celebrated for erudition, and Confucian scholars looked up to them together. Because they were scholars of the former dynasty, Longfu Palace had robes made and bestowed them personally—an honor people regarded as extraordinary. Chusun's works included Great Changes: Images, General Commentary and Records of Zhou Yi Study. Taosun left a collected works in several juan.
22
滿 使調 使 滿 使 使 使 使
Chen Fu, style Gangzhong, came from Linhai in Taizhou. As a boy he was sharp and penetrating; what he read once he could recite from memory for life. During Zhiyuan he submitted the "Rhapsody on Great Unity" as a commoner. The Jiangzhe Branch Secretariat forwarded it to court, and he was appointed head of Shangcai Academy. When his term ended he went to the capital for appointment. In the twenty-ninth year Kublai sent Liang Zeng again as Minister of Personnel to Annan and needed a southern scholar as aide. Ministers recommended Fu for erudition and moral backbone. He was appointed Compiler at the Hanlin National History Office and acting Gentleman of the Ministry of Rites as Zeng's deputy. At his farewell audience he received fifth-rank robes and a gold tally for the journey. In the first month of the thirtieth year they reached Annan. Heir Chen Ritong, observing mourning, did not go to the suburbs to meet them and sent ministers instead; the envoys were not admitted through the Yangming central gate. Zeng and Fu returned to their lodge and sent letters charging Ritong with failure to attend court, demanding that he meet the imperial edict at the suburbs and discuss the new dynasty's protocol of precedence. Three exchanges of letters proclaimed the Son of Heaven's majesty in language bold and direct—all drafted by Fu. Every gift offered him Fu refused. The full account appears in the biography of Liang Zeng. After the mission he was appointed Hanlin Attendant for Drafting, concurrently Compiler at the National History Office. The emperor wished to place him in a key post, but ministers, resenting that he was a southerner and high-spirited, blocked the move. He was made Assistant Administrator of Jiande Circuit, then of Quzhou, and everywhere he served he won a reputation for good governance. When his term ended he asked to return to his home region and was specially granted Gentleman for Upholding Integrity and Assistant Administrator of Taizhou Circuit. In the seventh year of Dade the court dispatched Pacification Commissioners to tour the circuits. Taizhou was then in drought and famine; corpses lined the roads. The Jiangzhe Branch Secretariat ordered the Eastern Zhejiang Marshal Tuohuancha'er to distribute relief grain, but he relied on power, ignored the people's suffering, bullied officials, and imposed harsh punishments. Fu said, "The man who lets our people die like fish in a drying pond is Tuohuancha'er." He went to the Pacification Commissioner and filed nineteen charges of illegal conduct harming the people. The commissioner verified the charges, convicted Tuohuancha'er, and ordered granaries opened at once. Many lives were saved, but Fu fell ill from the ordeal and died at home at sixty-four.
23
Fu's talent was extraordinary and his nature chivalrous and free. He wrote poetry and prose largely at a stroke without laborious polish, and his collected works circulated widely.
24
His son You served as Vice Director in the Jiangzhe Branch Secretariat and retired. His elder daughter Changgui married Dong Shikai of Gaocheng and was mother of Zongji, Grand Sacrificer of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices; his younger daughter Tan married Han Jiezhi of the same district and was mother of Jian, secretary in the Bureau of Military Affairs. Both were celebrated for chaste integrity, and the court marked their gates with commendation.
25
Feng Zizhen of Youzhou was a bold spirit much like Fu, whom Fu deeply revered and considered beyond his reach. Zizhen remembered virtually every book under heaven. When he wrote, wine warm and spirits high, he had attendants ready the brush and wrote at the desk as fast as paper could be supplied—however many sheets he was given, he finished in moments. Though his matter was rich and his diction splendid as brocade, he often fell short of formal standards, and for that people valued him somewhat less.
26
使西
Dong Pu, style Taichu, came from Shunde. From childhood he had a powerful memory. At manhood he studied under Yue Shunyu and Liu Daoji and turned with sudden resolve to seeking the Way. In the sixteenth year of Zhiyuan the Surveillance Commissioner recommended him, and he entered service as judicial official of Shaanxi. Before long he returned home to care for his aging parents. He was soon summoned as director of the Astronomy Office but again declined. Early in Huangqing, when Pu was past eighty, an edict granted him retirement as Hanlin Compiler. In the third year of Yanyou he died without prior illness at eighty-five.
27
In learning he pursued the Six Classics and the subtle teachings of Confucius and Mencius, and every method by which earlier Confucians had opened new paths and clarified obscurities, integrating them all. What he attained in his own mind often had the subtlety of full synthesis. He was filial to his parents and sincere with everyone he met, wise or foolish, high or low. If someone offended him, he remained calm and would not quarrel. Prince Jie of Zhongshan said, "Pu's learning has reached both profound understanding and full moral cultivation; as a man he is clear yet penetrating, harmonious yet principled—a true gentleman." Pu lived near Longgang, and scholars called him Master Longgang.
28
調
Yang Zai, style Zhonghong, came from Pucheng in Jian; his family later moved to Hangzhou, where he was raised. Orphaned young, he read widely. His writing had a bold, sweeping quality. At forty he still would not serve. Jia Guoying of the Ministry of Revenue repeatedly recommended him, and he was summoned as a commoner to compile at the Hanlin National History Office, helped compile the Veritable Records of Emperor Wuzong, and was transferred to registrar of the Office in Charge of Government Sea Ships while supervising documents. Early in Yanyou Emperor Renzong revived the examinations. Zai was the first to answer the call, passed the jinshi, served as Gentleman for Attending Affairs and associate prefect of Fuliang in Raozhou, then as Gentleman of the Forest and assessor in the Ningguo administration, and died in office.
29
When Zhao Mengfu of Wuxing was in the Hanlin Academy he read Zai's work and esteemed it highly. Zai's literary reputation quietly stirred the capital, and whatever he wrote people copied and recited. His prose took spirit as its master—broad yet nimble, direct yet disciplined—and formed a school of its own. He was especially methodical in poetry and told students, "Poetry should draw its substance from Han and Wei, but its rhythm and tone should follow the Tang as authority." Once his poetry appeared it washed away the vulgarity of late-Song verse.
30
Yang Gangzhong of Shangyuan in Jiankang, style Zhixing, cultivated moral resolve from youth. As registrar of the Jiangdong Surveillance Commission his bearing was stern and admirable. His writing was strange, dense, and difficult, always modeling the ancients and disdaining the flat language of the commonplace world. Yuan Mingshan marveled at it deeply. He rose to Hanlin Attendant for Drafting and died in that post. His Frost Moon Collection circulated widely.
31
His nephew Li Huan, style Jinzhong, from the same prefecture, passed the jinshi by provincial recommendation and rose to Associate Commissioner for Promoting Confucian Studies in Jiangzhe. He too was famed for writing in Jiangdong—his style ample and lush, widely copied by scholars. Zai and Gangzhong were contemporaries; Huan came a generation later.
32
Liu Shen, style Guiweng, came from Luling in Ji'an. Keen by nature, he lost his father young yet knew how to stand on his own. At twelve he was already writing examination fu, policy essays, and civil-service pieces with a mature air. Song loyalists at first sight charged him with carrying the literary tradition forward. After reaching manhood he was grave, pure, and refined, always holding himself to the teacher's role. His instruction was methodical and his reputation grew daily. The Jiangnan Branch Censorate repeatedly recommended him for teaching posts, academy offices, and as a hidden worthy, but the court never responded. His writing rooted in the Six Classics, ranged through the hundred schools, and fused past and present without displaying flashy brilliance. Seekers of his writing came daily to his gate from every quarter. His poetry and prose were gathered as the Guixin Collection. Guixin was the name he chose for himself. He died in the tenth year of Zhizheng at the age of eighty-three.
33
A fellow native of the commandery, Long Renfu, styled Guanfu. Liu Yueshen, whose style name was Gaozhong. Their literary attainments ranked with Liu Shen's, and collections of their work circulated widely. Renfu's prose stood out as marvelously free and elegantly flowing, and his Collected Commentary on the Book of Changes broke ground that earlier scholars had left untouched. Yueshen was recommended for the post of Associate Intendant of Confucian Schools in Liaoyang, and Renfu for the same office in Jiang-Zhe; both declined.
34
宿
Han Xing, styled Mingshan, came from Shaoxing. His family originally came from Anyang. His eighth-generation ancestor was Wang Qi, Duke of Zhongxian of Wei, who had served as Song Minister of Works and concurrent Censor-in-Chief. His great-grandfather Yingzhou, a Left Department Director, had followed the court in its flight south and settled the family in the Yue region. By nature Xing was exceptionally quick of mind. At seven he could read several lines at a glance and commit ten thousand words to memory in a day. At nine he had mastered the Elder Dai Record of Rites. He could compose expository essays the moment he took up the brush, and the tone of his writing was austere and antique. Veteran teachers marveled at him. When he came of age he mastered an encyclopedic range of literature—from the classics and histories through every school—and pursued each to its foundations. He penetrated deepest of all into the Neo-Confucian doctrine of human nature and principle. His prose was broad, powerful, and ever-shifting in form—a distinctive voice all his own. Students came from every quarter to study with him, and the shoes stacked outside his door soon overflowed the threshold. When Yanyou opened with an edict reviving the examination system, many students asked him to teach exam technique. He told them, "Today's civil examinations all follow Zhu Xi's commentaries. How can you write acceptable examination essays without understanding Zhu Xi's learning? The Four Books and Six Classics preserve knowledge that had gone unspoken for a millennium. From the Cheng brothers through Zhu Xi, nothing essential remains unrevealed. What matters is how one lives. A man of virtue cannot help but write well. Applying that to the examination hall is a secondary concern. What other method could there be? Whatever passed through his teaching required no grand theorizing, yet its moral logic always prevailed. He did not strain for literary polish, yet polish came unbidden—and his students' essays met official standards without seeming contrived. When a scholar showed even a single virtue, he praised it without end. When he weighed right against wrong, his bearing turned stern and immovable.
35
輿 祿
Xing never traveled with carriage, horses, or attendants. Wherever he went, porters set down their loads and passersby stepped aside. Laborers in the lanes, elders in the streets, even children and servants—all called him "Master Han, Master Han." The surveillance commission once recommended him as a school instructor. He declined: "My ancestors left a humble roof against wind and rain and enough land for simple meals. To read and cultivate character without shaming the ancients is enough. I have no wish for salary or office. He accepted the appointment in name but never took up the post. In old age he grew still more retiring, yet he never ceased caring for the world. When able county prefects found themselves at a loss in governance, they sought his counsel. Xing guided them with unhurried ease, always striking the vital point—and many were the better for it.
36
During the Tianli era, Zhao Shiyan brought Xing's name to the court's attention. A decade later his disciple Li Qi, serving as Surveillance Censor of the Southern Commission, vigorously commended his moral character—but Xing was already dead. He was seventy-six years old. After his death, Yue Lu Bulhua of the Southern Censorate, who had once been his student, argued that Xing deserved a posthumous honor. The court granted him the title Master Zhuangjie. His works included Record of Rites Explanations in four juan, Poetry Phonology Explanations in one juan, Documents Doubts Resolved in one juan, a Commandery Gazetteer in eight juan, and twelve juan of collected writings.
37
During Xing's lifetime, Qingyuan produced the brothers Cheng Duanli and Cheng Duanxue. Duanli, styled Jingshu, was bright and sincere from boyhood. By fifteen he had memorized the Six Classics and could expound their major themes with clarity. Since the late Song, Qingyuan had honored the learning of Lu Jiuyuan, and Zhu Xi's teachings had never taken root there. Duanli alone studied under Shi Mengqing and passed on Zhu Xi's teaching on discerning substance and putting it into practice. A great throng of students came to his door. He wrote Methods of Reading Books, which the Directorate of Education circulated among local school officials as a model for students. He served as Professor of Confucian Learning at Quzhou Circuit. He died at the age of seventy-five. Duanxue, styled Shishu, mastered the Spring and Autumn Annals, passed the jinshi examination in the xinyou year of Zhizhi, was appointed deputy magistrate of Xianju County, and was soon transferred to Assistant Instructor at the Directorate of Education. He conducted himself by strict pedagogical standards, and students held him in awe for his stern integrity. He was promoted to Doctor of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, but died before the appointment could take effect. Later, when his son Xu achieved distinction, he was posthumously granted the title Minister of Rites. His works included Original Meaning of the Spring and Autumn Annals in thirty juan, Doubts on the Three Commentaries Resolved in twenty juan, and Questions on the Spring and Autumn Annals in ten juan.
38
調 使
Wu Shidao, styled Zhengchuan, came from Lanxi in Wuzhou. From the age when he first understood learning, he possessed a prodigious memory. He excelled at literary composition, his talent flowing freely. His poetry was clear, elegant, and spirited. In young manhood, reading the posthumous works of the Song Neo-Confucian Zhen Dexiu stirred in him a resolve to pursue learning for its own sake. He honed himself day after day, month after month. He once submitted to fellow Lanxi scholar Xu Qian his understanding of maintaining reverence and extending knowledge; Qian answered with the doctrine of principle as one yet manifest in many particulars. His intellectual horizons broadened and his moral practice deepened. He devoted himself above all to explicating moral principle, making the refutation of heterodox teachings his first concern. He passed the jinshi examination in the first year of Zhizhi and was appointed deputy magistrate of Gaoyou County. Thoroughly versed in administrative law, he ran an office his clerks dared not cheat. He was next assigned as Record Keeper of Ningguo Circuit. That year brought severe drought. Three hundred thirty thousand people depended on official relief. Shidao persuaded wealthy families to contribute thirty-seven thousand six hundred shi of grain for famine relief; He also appealed to the circuit commissioner, who forwarded the matter to court. The court allocated forty thousand shi of grain and thirty-eight thousand four hundred ingots of paper currency for relief—and more than three hundred thousand lives were saved. He was appointed magistrate of Jiande County in Chizhou. Local magnates had seized seven hundred mu belonging to the prefectural school. The prefecture referred the case to Jiande for investigation, and Shidao checked the land registers and restored every plot to the school. Jiande produced little tea yet bore an especially heavy monopoly tax—a burden on the people. Shidao pressed the authorities vigorously, and the tax was reduced. Left Chancellor Lu Sicheng and Attending Censor Kong Sili jointly recommended him. He was summoned to the Directorate of Education as Assistant Instructor and soon promoted to Doctor. He taught according to Zhu Xi's principles and Xu Heng's established methods. Every student in the six halls felt he had at last found a true master. He returned home upon his mother's death, retired with the ranks of Supporter of Discussion Grand Master and Director in the Ministry of Rites, and died at home. His publications included Miscellaneous Explanations of the Changes, Poetry, and Documents; Supplementary Critique of Hu Yuan's Spring and Autumn Commentary; Collation and Annotation of the Intrigues of the Warring States; Records of Respected Natives of the District; and twenty juan of collected writings.
39
A fellow native, Wang Yuqing, styled Shushan, served as Surveillance Censor of the Jiangnan Branch Secretariat and was likewise celebrated in his day for Confucian scholarship.
40
使
Lu Wengui, styled Zifang, came from Jiangyin. Bright from childhood, he could read a passage once and recite it from memory—and never forgot what he had learned. He mastered the classics and histories, the hundred schools, and disciplines from astronomy, geography, and calendrics to medicine and mathematics. In the early Xianchun era of the Song, at eighteen he passed the provincial selection with the Spring and Autumn Annals. After the fall of the Song he retired to seclusion east of the city, and scholars called him Master East of the Wall. When the Yanyou examinations were instituted, officials pressed him to compete—and he twice passed the provincial examinations. His writing synthesized the classics with boundless versatility. Scholars throughout the southeast looked to him as their master. The court repeatedly sent envoys with gifts to summon him, but age and illness kept him from accepting. He died at the age of eighty-five.
41
沿 使 稿
Wengui was forthright, luminous, and bold—a man who carried himself with uncommon force of character. His knowledge of geography was exhaustive: he could recite from memory every change in the administrative map, every notable figure and local product—as if they lay in the palm of his hand. A day before his final illness, he told his disciples: "By my calculations, this prefecture will suffer military calamity within twenty years—worse than the Five Dynasties or the Jianyan reign. When I die, bury me in desolate ground. Raise no mound, plant no tree. Let no one know where I lie, so that my bones may escape desecration. When rebellion later swept Jiangyin and graves were despoiled across the region, people came to respect his prescience. He left Miscellaneous Drafts East of the Wall in twenty juan.
42
西 稿
A neighbor of Wengui's, Liang Yi, styled Youzhi, came from a Fuzhou family. He was deeply versed in the classics and histories and skilled in literary composition. He taught that transforming one's character came first, and students traveled from afar to study with him. After Wengui's death, Liang Yi alone west of Zhe was regarded as the standard-bearer of pure scholarship and moral example. His books included Three Mountains Drafts, Remaining Threads of Poetry, and Compilation of Surnames in Historical Biographies, as well as Poetic Commentary Side Paths, a refined exposition of Zhu Xi's learning. He died at the age of fifty-six.
43
Zhou Renrong, styled Benxin, came from Linhai in Taizhou. His father Jingsun had been a student at the Song Imperial Academy. Originally Wang Bo of Jinhua, a champion of Zhu Xi's learning, directed Shangcai Academy on Mount Tai. Jingsun, along with fellow natives Yang Jue, Chen Tianrui, Che Ruoshui, Huang Chaoran, Zhu Zhizhong, and Xue Songnian, studied under him and received instruction in Neo-Confucian doctrine. Jingsun wrote Images and Divination in the Changes, Supplementary Remnants of the Documents, and Categories and Examples of the Spring and Autumn Annals. Renrong inherited the family tradition and also studied under Yang Jue and Chen Tianrui, mastering the Changes, Rites, and Spring and Autumn Annals while excelling as a writer. On recommendation he was appointed director of Meihua Academy. Meihua lay deep in the mountains of Chuzhou, where learning was scarcely known. Renrong introduced the district drinking ceremony, and local mores began to change. He was later appointed clerk of the Jiang-Zhe Branch Secretariat, where senior officials addressed him as Master and never treated him as a mere functionary. At the opening of the Taiding era he was summoned as Doctor at the Directorate of Education, transferred to Hanlin Compiler, and raised to Attendant Drafting Scholar at the Academy of Gathered Worthies. Ordered to perform ritual sacrifices to the sacred mountains and rivers, he fell ill at Kuaiji and never returned to court. He died at the age of sixty-one. Many of his students rose to prominence—the jinshi examination's top graduate, Tai Bughua, was among them.
44
His younger brother Zijian, styled Bendao, passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of Yanyou with the Spring and Autumn Annals and retired as Supporter of Discussion Grand Master and Administrative Assistant of Huizhou Circuit. He and his elder brother were both celebrated for literary accomplishment.
45
使
A fellow native of Renrong's, Meng Mengxun, styled Changwen, came from Huangyan. He studied under Yang Jue and Chen Tianrui alongside Renrong. Mengxun expounded the classics with exacting clarity and insisted that understanding show itself in action. Students who came from every direction respected him deeply. A circuit commissioner recommended him for his moral character, and he was appointed Registrar of the local Confucian school. In the thirteenth year of Zhizheng he was rewarded for organizing defenses against bandits and saving his home commandery with the rank of Dengshi Gentleman and appointment as Administrative Assistant of Yixing in Changzhou Circuit. He died before taking office, at seventy-four. The court posthumously honored him as Master Kangjing. His works included Original Purport of Human Nature and Principle, Doubts on the Four Books Resolved, Essentials of Han and Tang Institutions, Doubts on the Seven Regulators Resolved, and Miscellaneous Records of the Brush Sea in fifty juan.
46
使 滿
Chen Lü, styled Zhongzhong, came from Putian in Xinghua. His family had long been respected for Confucian scholarship. Chen Lü was orphaned young, yet his natural gifts were remarkably sharp. His maternal grandfather, a Zhao, was a scholar of deep learning who raised and instructed him, giving Chen Lü a secure home. He cared nothing for making a living and devoted himself entirely to study, reading every book he could find. As he matured, he traveled with his books to Wenling to study under the local master Fu Guzhi, and his fame spread steadily. Recommended for office, he was appointed Confucian instructor in Minhai. The censor-in-chief Ma Zuchang happened to be on mission in southern Quanzhou; at their first meeting he was struck by Chen Lü and said, "You are fit for the Hanlin Academy—why remain stuck in this backwater?" He urged Chen Lü to go to the capital, and they encouraged each other to make the journey. Once he reached the capital, the Hanlin lecturer Yu Ji read his essays and sighed with deep emotion: "This is what people mean when they say, 'I am old and ready to step aside—I leave this literary tradition in your hands.' He immediately invited Chen Lü to stay at his home, and they spent their days debating ethics and scholarship. Yu Ji later said he had benefited enormously from their exchanges. He and Zuchang spoke warmly of each other among the capital's leading men, and all agreed that Chen Lü's erudition made him ideal for a teaching post. Grand Councillor Zhao Shiyan added his strong recommendation, and Chen Lü was appointed Associate Instructor of the Imperial Academy. After three years, when his term ended, his students begged the court to keep him—and he was reappointed. In the second year of Yuantong he was posted as Assistant Commissioner for Confucian Schools in Jiangzhe. In the fourth year of Zhiyuan he returned to the capital as a Hanlin document-drafting official. In the first year of Zhizheng he was promoted to Assistant Director of the Imperial Academy with the rank of Gentleman of Literary Eminence. Two years later he died, at the age of fifty-six.
47
In his writing Chen Lü studied every major author from pre-Qin times through the Tang and Song masters. His prose was elegant, rigorous, and polished; he aimed to match the ancients rather than chase contemporary taste. His collected works ran to fourteen juan.
48
Chen Lü was deeply devoted to the bonds of teacher and friend, and always regarded Yu Ji as the truest friend of his life. While serving in Zhejiang, Chen Lü learned that Yu Ji had been living in retirement for several years. When the provincial examinations drew near, he asked the vice administrator Bo Shilu Chong for permission to deliver a formal invitation—and then, braving the midsummer heat, traveled a thousand li to Linchuan simply to see his old mentor again. Yu Ji was deeply moved by the visit and kept him for ten days. They parted with earnest encouragement to carry on the literary tradition, both sorrowful as though they would never meet again. Whenever Yu Ji spoke with fellow scholars, he called Chen Lü the finest friend of his life. One night he dreamed that Chen Lü raised a cup toward him and said, "I miss you deeply, and I know you have not forgotten me—we simply cannot see each other anymore." Soon after, he learned that Chen Lü had died, and Yu Ji grieved profoundly.
49
Contemporaries of comparable stature included Cheng Wen and Chen Yiceng, both celebrated scholars. Cheng Wen, styled Yiwen, came from Huizhou and rose to Vice Director of the Ministry of Rites. His writing was clear, polished, and deeply learned, and Yu Ji spoke highly of it. Chen Yiceng, styled Bofu, came from Chuzhou. Though he stuttered when he spoke, his mind was exceptionally sharp—he could recite most classical commentaries from memory. His prose was expansive and richly learned, written with blazing vitality. He rose to the rank of Associate Instructor of the Imperial Academy. Contemporaries considered both men Chen Lü's equals in talent.
50
Li Xiaoguang, styled Jihe, came from Yueqing in Wenzhou. From youth he was widely read and devoted to reviving ancient literary standards. He lived in seclusion beneath the Five Peaks of Yandang Mountain, where students traveled from every direction to study with him. Tai Bughua became his disciple, and the southern censor He Ci repeatedly recommended him for appointment to the Hanlin Academy. In the seventh year of Zhizheng the court issued a call for reclusive scholars, and Li Xiaoguang was summoned as Drafting Official of the Secretariat Directorate. He traveled to the capital with Wanzhitu, Zhili Halang, and Dong Li, was received by the emperor in the Hall of Propagating Culture, and presented his Illustrated Exposition of the Classic of Filial Piety. The emperor was delighted and rewarded him with fine wine. The following year he was promoted to Gentleman of Literary Eminence and Assistant Director of the Secretariat Directorate. He died in office at the age of fifty-three.
51
Li Xiaoguang was renowned in his day for his writing, which took the ancients as its sole model and refused to follow contemporary fashion. He would use no phrasing that did not belong to pre-Qin or Han prose. His collected works ran to twenty juan.
52
調
Yuwen Gongliang, styled Zizhen, was descended from a Chengdu family. His father Tingzu moved to Wuxing, and Gongliang was regarded as a native of that place. Gongliang mastered the classics, histories, and the teachings of the hundred schools, and even in early adulthood was known for his moral character. A wealthy man in Jiaxing hired him to tutor his sons. Near midnight someone knocked at the door—it was a woman. Gongliang sharply rebuked her and sent her away. The next day he resigned on another pretext and left, never explaining what had happened. In the fourth year of Zhishun he passed the jinshi examination and was appointed Vice Administrator of Wuyuan Prefecture in Huizhou Circuit. After his mother's death he was reassigned as Vice Administrator of Yuyao Prefecture. During a summer drought, rain fell whenever Gongliang prayed for it. The harvest was saved, and the people praised him, calling the rain "the Vice-Prefect's blessing." While administering Kuaiji County, he cleared numerous wrongful imprisonments and saved many lives. When the province ordered an inspection of tidal farmland at Songjiang, Gongliang argued that the tides were unpredictable and would eventually cause disaster. He petitioned to exempt the land from taxation entirely, and the provincial authorities agreed. He was transferred to judicial officer at Gaoyou Prefecture, then soon appointed Associate Instructor of the Imperial Academy, where he debated the classics daily with his students. Many who passed through his instruction later became distinguished officials. He was transferred to Hanlin document-drafting official and Associate Director of Edicts, while also serving as compiler at the National History Institute. Illness eventually forced him to retire. He was later recalled as Assistant Director of the Imperial Academy, appointed Commissioner for Confucian Schools in Jiangzhe, then transferred to the Lingnan Surveillance Commission. Illness finally led him to request retirement.
53
稿稿稿
In daily life Gongliang kept his robes straight and sat properly even in private. He carried a notebook whose opening page read: "Record each day's deeds each evening; if a deed cannot be recorded, do not do it—Heaven, Earth, and the spirits are witness to this vow." Such was the severity of his self-discipline. His writings included the Collected Writings on Plucking the Cassia, Collected Writings on Viewing the Light, Collected Writings on Parting the Waters, Poems of the Yizhai Studio, Casual Drafts from the Jade Hall, and Drafts from a Journey through Yue—several works in all. His disciples privately gave him the posthumous title Master of Pure Integrity.
54
Bayan, also called Shisheng and styled Zongdao, belonged to the Karluq clan and was registered with the Mongol Myriarchate. His family had long lived in Puyang County, Kaizhou. From the age of three Bayan would trace figures on the ground with his finger—threes and sixes, as though casting hexagrams. At six he studied the Classic of Filial Piety and the Analects under a local scholar and could recite both from memory immediately. Orphaned early, he was supported by his elder half-brother, who bought him classical texts and commentaries. He studied day and night without rest. As he grew older he studied under Huang Tan of Jian'an, a jinshi of the Song dynasty. Huang Tan said, "This boy's intelligence far surpasses ordinary students." He therefore gave him the surname Yan and chose both his given name and style. Eventually Huang Tan declined to teach him further, saying, "I can no longer be your teacher. Zhu Xi's commentaries on the classics are complete—go home and study them on your own." From early adulthood Bayan devoted himself to the Confucian tradition. He grasped the great principles of the classics with luminous clarity, and insights that went beyond words arose constantly from within. Local scholars came to test him with hard questions; he answered each as it came and resolved every doubt. Word spread across the Central Plains, and students flocked to him in ever-growing numbers.
55
西
In the fourth year of Zhizheng he was summoned to the capital as a reclusive scholar, appointed Hanlin Attendant Drafting Official, and took part in compiling the History of Jin. When the work was complete, he resigned and returned home. He was soon recalled as Assistant Commissioner of the Jiangxi Surveillance Commission, but after a few months illness forced him to resign. After his return, more than a thousand students came from every direction to study with him. His teaching focused on explication and insisted on genuine understanding put into action. He scorned the art of examination essays and demanded that learning prove itself in real life. Anyone who had studied under him could be recognized at once as a disciple of the Bayan school. Even followers of heterodox schools often abandoned their old doctrines to study with him. In the eighteenth year bandits from Henan swept into Hebei. Bayan urged the provincial authorities to organize local militia in groups of ten and five, but rebel forces arrived in overwhelming numbers. He crossed the Zhang River and fled north, followed by several hundred thousand local families. At Ci he was captured by rebels who knew his reputation as a scholar. They brought him before their commander and offered wealth and rank if he would submit. Bayan cursed them and refused. He bared his neck to the blade and died together with his wife and children, at the age of sixty-four.
56
西
After his death someone opened his body and found several openings in his heart. "The ancients said a sage's heart has seven apertures," they exclaimed—"was this not a man of true worth?" They replaced his heart, walled over the grave, and buried him with honor. Officials reported his death to the court, which posthumously granted him the title Supporter of Discussion Grand Master and Assistant Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, with the posthumous name Wenjie, Literary Integrity. In deliberating his posthumous title, the Court of Imperial Sacrifices argued: "Measured by the standard of defending a city, Bayan had no garrison duty yet died defending the people—he may be ranked with Li Fu, who held Jiangzhou; measured by moral courage, he held no official post yet died for principle—he may stand alongside the western censor Zhang Huan. A lifetime of practical learning, tested and unbroken at the moment of crisis—this was the kind of man the ancients called a true gentleman." Contemporaries regarded this as the correct judgment. Bayan spent his life editing the Six Classics and writing extensively, but all his work was lost in the wars.
57
使 西 使
Zhan Si, styled Dezhi, was descended from families of the Arab lands. After their homeland submitted to the Yuan, his grandfather Lukun migrated east to Fengzhou. Under Emperor Taizong, Lukun was appointed supervisor of tax levies for the Zhending and Jinan circuits on account of his ability, and the family settled in Zhending. His father Wanzhi studied under Confucian masters, valued integrity over wealth, and never sought official advancement. At nine Zhan Si could memorize a thousand characters of classical text each day. By early adulthood he submitted his work to the Hanlin academician Wang Silian for correction. Thereafter he mastered an enormous range of texts and put his learning into earnest practice. Though still young, he was already highly respected in his community. When the court began selecting officials by examination at the start of the Yanyou era, friends urged him to compete. Zhan Si only smiled and refused. Soon the censor Guo Sizhen, Hanlin academician Liu Geng, and Vice Administrator Wang Shixi submitted joint memorials recommending him. In the third year of Taiding he was summoned to Shangdu as a neglected scholar of talent. Received by the emperor at Longhu Terrace, he was treated with exceptional favor. At the time Prime Minister Tarmashirin held power, and many men from the western regions sought his patronage. Zhan Si alone refused to visit him. Tarmashirin repeatedly sent envoys to summon him, but Zhan Si declined on the grounds of caring for his parents and returned home.
58
In the third year of Tianli he was summoned to the capital as a Hanlin document-drafting official and received audience in the Kuizhang Pavilion. Emperor Wenzong asked, "Have you written anything?" The next day he presented his work The Mind-Method of Emperors and Kings, which Wenzong praised warmly. He was ordered to help compile the Great Institutions for Governing the Age, but disagreements led him to request leave. The emperor sent Yu Ji to persuade him to stay, but Zhan Si insisted that his mother needed care and was dismissed with gifts. The emperor also sent word through Yu Ji: "Return home for now—you will be summoned again soon." In the fourth year of Zhishun he was appointed Doctor of the Imperial Academy, but after his mother's death he did not take up the appointment.
59
西 西 西使 使
In the third year of Houto Yuan he was appointed censor of the Shaanxi Branch Secretariat and immediately submitted a sealed memorial with ten proposals: uphold ancestral law, centralize authority, strengthen the imperial clan, honor meritorious veterans, guard official titles, open channels for remonstrance, restore the civil service examinations, disband redundant armies, unify the penal code, and loosen harsh prohibitions. At a time when corrupt ministers were overturning established law and the emperor was listening with an open mind, Zhan Si spoke truths that no other official at court dared utter. Attending Censor Zhao Chengqing read the memorial and sighed, "When a censor speaks like this, it is a blessing for the empire." A powerful relative who governed Shaanxi abused his authority. Zhan Si exposed his crimes and opened an investigation, and the man fled his post under cover of night. An edict then arrived forbidding further pursuit of the official himself, though his personal retainers were still flogged. When he toured Yunnan as investigating censor, officials guilty of misconduct surrendered their seals and fled at once, and the distant borderlands trembled at his name. Refugees from Xiang and Han had settled in the old lands of Song Shaoxi Prefecture—several thousand households who operated illegal salt wells and organized themselves, often raiding prisoners and killing patrolmen. Zhan Si arrested their leaders but released the rest. He memorialized again: "Shaoxi's land is fertile and profitable, and refugee households grow daily. If we disperse them to their home registers they may become a border threat. We should establish an office to settle and govern them." The court established the Shaoxi Pacification Commission on the spot. In the third year he became Associate Commissioner of the Western Zhejiang Surveillance Commission and immediately investigated the Salt Transport Commissioner, the Maritime Route Commander, and officials of the Branch Commission for Buddhist Affairs for corruption. After that, no official in western Zhejiang dared enrich himself illegally. He also found that temples in western Zhejiang sheltered crafty laymen registered as Dao persons, Dao commoners, or traveling youths—men who evaded family obligations and corvée labor. In Jiaxing Circuit alone he counted 2,700 such cases. He proposed forcing them back to their clans to pay regular taxes and thus ease the burden on common people. The court approved his proposal and promulgated it as law. In the fourth year he was transferred to the Eastern Zhejiang Surveillance Commission, then resigned citing illness and returned home.
60
Throughout his censorial career Zhan Si made righting wrongs and helping the afflicted his duty. He reversed many capital convictions, yet never deliberately freed the guilty to win private gratitude. Once at Xianning he joined officials of the five offices to judge a case. A woman named Song E had taken a neighbor as lover. The neighbor told her, "I am going to kill your husband." E replied, "Zhang Ziwen is about to kill him." The next day her husband was found dead. For days investigators pursued a thief. Only then did E tell her mother-in-law that Zhang Ziwen was responsible. The five offices held it was not joint murder and that amnesty had already applied, so Zhang should be released. Zhan Si said, "Zhang Ziwen acted believing E had already consented. Moreover, E waited ten days after her husband's death before speaking. She and Zhang had plotted together and, seeing they could not hide it forever, exposed the matter. How can amnesty excuse that?" The Bureau of Military Affairs judge said, "To reverse a verdict and save a life is hidden virtue. Censor, do not cling so rigidly to the letter of the law." Zhan Si replied, "That would be deliberately releasing the guilty—not reversing a wrongful conviction. And if you wish to store up hidden virtue for the living, what of the dead man?" He alone submitted his opinion to the Ministry of Justice, and in the end Song E was convicted. Most of his judgments of guilt and punishment followed this pattern.
61
使
In the fourth year of Zhizheng he was appointed Vice Commissioner of the Jiangdong Surveillance Commission. In the tenth year he was summoned as Vice Director of the Secretariat to advise on river control, but he declined both appointments citing illness. In the eleventh year he died at home at seventy-four. In the twenty-fifth year the Crown Prince, campaigning in Jining, issued an enfeoffment order posthumously granting him Grand Master for Exalted Counsel, Minister of Rites, and Chief Commandant of Light Chariots of the Upper Rank, with posthumous title Marquis of Hengshan and the posthumous epithet Literary and Filial.
62
西西
Zhan Si was deeply versed in the classics, especially the Book of Changes. He also pursued astronomy, geography, music theory, mathematics, hydraulics, and even foreign texts to their limits. His household was poor—sometimes he lacked even plain gruel—yet he found constant joy in collating and revising the classics. His writings included Doubts on the Four Books, Reflections on the Five Classics, Diagram of Odd and Even, Yin and Yang, and Message, Essential Reach of Laozi and Zhuangzi, Record of Zhenyang's Local Conditions, Continued Gazetteer of Dongyang, Revised General Discussion on River Defense, Illustrated Classic of Western Lands, Biographies of Strange Men of the Western Regions, Record of the Lamenting Emperor of Jin, Biographies of Ministers of the Zhengda Era, Essentials of Careful Hearing, and a thirty-juan collected works kept at home.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →