← Back to 元史

卷二百〇六 列傳第九十三: 叛臣

Volume 206 Biographies 93: Contrary Ministers

Chapter 206 of 元史 · History of Yuan
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 206
Next Chapter →
1
調便
Li Tan, styled Songsou, was from Weizhou and was the son of Li Quan. Some accounts hold that he was originally a Xu from Quzhou, whose father had served as judicial administrator in Yangzhou and whom Li Quan adopted as his son. In Taizu's sixteenth year, Li Quan defected from the Song and submitted the Shandong prefectures. The Grand Tutor and King Pelu, exercising imperial authority, appointed him regional commissioner for Shandong, Huainan, and Chuzhou, with his elder brother Fu as deputy marshal. In Taizong's third year, Quan attacked the Song at Yangzhou, was defeated, and died. Tan then inherited the Yidu commission and continued to rule the territory as he saw fit. Whenever the court called for troops, he found excuses and did not report. In Xianzong's seventh year the court again ordered his forces to the capital. Tan went in person and said, "Yidu is a critical Song maritime choke point; splitting the army would be unwise." The emperor agreed and ordered him to go back and take several prefectures in the Lianhai region. He marched out, seized four linked cities including Lianshui, and loudly advertised his triumphs.
2
調 西 西 宿
In the first year of Zhongtong, when Shizu ascended the throne, Tan was made Grand Commander of the Jianghuai region. Tan reported, "We have lately taken prisoners who say the Song are massing troops to attack Lianshui. Spies also report warships massed at Xupu and Sheyang Lake, poised to break out of Jiaoxi toward Yidu. I ask that the walls and ditches be repaired in preparation." The court issued ten gold tallies and five silver tallies for Tan to reward meritorious troops, granted three hundred ingots of silver, and sent a commendatory edict. All Mongol and Han forces on the frontier were placed under his command. Tan again claimed that the Song general Lü Wende had assembled seventy-five thousand Huainan troops to attack Lianshui and was planning to build forts to threaten his position. Letters from Jia Sidao and Lü Wende that he obtained were brazenly insulting. They know the court has lately been preoccupied with internal troubles and will surely turn on us in earnest. I ask that you choose commanders and reinforce the army; I will lead the crossing of the Huai myself to avenge this insult." The chief ministers replied that the court was negotiating peace and frontier commanders should hold the border, telling him: The southerners are skilled in deception; if they have not yet attacked, do not stir rashly." Tan then memorialized: "The Yidu circuit I hold is thinly peopled. For eight years since we took Haizhou my men have never doffed their armor and the transport trains have never stopped; the people are exhausted as never before. One circuit's army against an entire enemy state is a hopeless mismatch, as everyone knows. Thanks to Your Majesty's prowess we have taken Lian and Hai and routed Xia Gui and Sun Huchen's force of more than a hundred thousand. Yet how dare I assume the enemy will not return! The Song are no longer tied down in the west and can now concentrate and strike eastward. If they pin us at Lian by land and sea, send a fleet north along the coast to raid undefended Jiao and Lai, then march infantry and cavalry on Yi, Ju, Teng, and Yi, Shandong will be lost. How can we treat that lightly or fail to prepare? When I pursued the enemy to Huai'an I could have pressed on to Yang and Chu, but the chief ministers held me back, so I did not dare advance further. If the Zaoyang, Tang, Deng, Chen, and Cai armies strike Jingshan and take Shou and Si, while the Bo, Su, Xu, and Pi armies join my command to attack Yang and Chu, both Huai regions can be secured. Once the two Huai are secure, chosen troops can take Jiangnan while we hold our ground and spare the people; then every military move will succeed. That is the best plan." He also submitted a merit roll for officers such as Feng Tai, and the court ordered Yidu official silver distributed as rewards.
3
調
In the first month of the second year Tan told the Branch Secretariat that the Song had massed hundreds of thousands of troops and rations and lined up thirteen thousand ships at Xupu to raid inner districts, while Pacification Commission supply lines were failing; he feared that if land and sea routes were cut he could not report emergencies. I ask for picked cavalry sent at forced march to reinforce us, so we can strike together from within and without, press deep while the chance lasts, and take the Jianghuai. He soon reported victory at Lianshui; the court commended him again and issued seventeen gold tallies and twenty-nine silver tallies with added rewards for the troops. On the gengyin day Tan mobilized on his own to repair Yidu's walls and reported a Song attack on Lianshui. The court sent Azhu, Harabatu, Aixianbuhua, and others with full forces and told Du Yi to reinforce the mobilization as needed. Tan then asked to command troops gathered from all circuits and for weapons; the Secretariat proposed thirty thousand arrows, but the edict granted one hundred thousand.
4
In the fourth month of the third year he again submitted letters from the Song minister Jia Sidao trying to win over commanders-in-chief Zhang Yuan, Zhang Jin, and others. Tan had ruled Shandong autonomously for more than thirty years. Dozens of memorials he sent were bluffs and threats, using the Song to extort the court while he fortified and armed himself—his designs ran deep. He had earlier sent his son Yanjian to court as a hostage, but secretly maintained a private courier line from Yidu to the hostage quarters in the capital. Now Yanjian used that private route to escape home. Tan then rebelled, surrendered the three Lian-Hai cities to the Song, wiped out the Mongol garrisons, and led his fleet back to attack Yidu. On the jiawu day he entered the city, opened the treasuries to reward his followers, and raided Putai. When the people heard of the rebellion they fled into walled towns or scattered into the hills, and for several hundred li from Yidu to Linzi the countryside fell silent.
5
退
On the guimao day the emperor learned of the rebellion and issued an edict listing Tan's crimes. On the jiachen day he ordered all armies to suppress Tan. On the jiyou day, because of Tan's rebellion, Grand Councillor Wang Wentong of the Secretariat was executed. On the renzi day Tan seized Jinan. On the guiyou day Shi Shu and Azhu were ordered to march on Jinan. Tan led his men out to raid supply trains near the city; government troops intercepted him, inflicted a crushing defeat with four thousand heads taken, and Tan fell back to defend Jinan. On the gengshen day of the fifth month they built a ring wall to besiege the city; On the jiaxu day the encirclement closed. Tan could no longer break out but still held day and night, giving the city's sons and daughters to his officers as rewards to keep their loyalty; He also sent troops to live off civilian households, seized hidden stores to keep supplies going, and when that failed levied salt per household and ordered cannibalism. By then morale collapsed beyond Tan's control; men banded in tens and hundreds and lowered themselves from the walls to escape. Knowing the city would fall, Tan killed his favorite concubine with his own hand, took a boat onto Daming Lake, and threw himself into the water; the lake was shallow and he survived, was captured, bound, and brought before Prince Qubilai's tent. Chancellor Shi Tianze said, "He should be executed at once to reassure the people." He was then executed together with the Mongol officer Nangia.
6
Wang Wentong, styled Yidao, was from Yidu. In youth he studied works of strategy and loved to sway people with his rhetoric. He petitioned lords everywhere without success, then went to see Li Tan. Tan was delighted at their talk, kept him in his headquarters, had his son Yanjian study under him, and Wentong gave his daughter to Tan in marriage. Thereafter all military matters went through him; each year he reported frontier victories, inflated enemy threats to secure his position, used public goods to buy private loyalty, and the capture of the Song prefectures Lian and Hai was his doing.
7
While Shizu was still heir apparent he sought men of talent and had long heard of Wentong. When he took the throne and threw himself into reform, someone recommended Wentong and he was summoned at once. He established the Secretariat to govern all departments, made Wentong its first Grand Councillor, and charged him with overhauling administration. The era was named Zhongtong; edicts went out to establish Pacification Commissions in ten circuits with regulations so corvée could be met without harassing the people, salt revenues kept steady, and paper currency kept flowing. Soon the Branch Secretariat was ordered to issue Zhongtong treasure notes and open trade markets at Yingzhou, Lianshui, and Guanghua Army. That winter Zhongtong notes were first issued in ten denominations from ten cash to two strings, valid everywhere without expiry, and accepted for taxes.
8
使
The following second month, while Shizu was at Kaiping, he summoned Branch Secretariat chief Mamma and Wentong and had all circuit Pacification Commissioners come to court with him. Since the previous autumn Shizu had been campaigning north against the rebel prince Ariq Böke; all corvée, salt, iron, and related levies were left entirely to Wentong and his colleagues. When the army returned he did not yet know how well these measures had worked; wartime urgency had left much undone, and the time to restore discipline was now. He therefore summoned Wentong and demanded results, appointed You Xian, Zheng Ding, Zhao Liangbi, Dong Wenbing, and others as circuit Pacification Commissioners, and reissued the regulations for all circuits to follow. Soon another edict told Pacification Commissions, darughachi, civilian officials, and tax officers to enforce bans on private salt, liquor, vinegar, and yeast products.
9
使
Wentong was jealous by nature; when the Secretariat was first set up Zhang Wenqian was Left Chancellor. Wenqian prided himself on serving state and people and constantly disputed Wentong's proposals; Wentong brooded until he found a way to remove him, and Wenqian was sent off to handle Pacification affairs in Daming and other circuits. Yao Shu, Dou Mo, and Xu Heng were men Shizu trusted; Wentong had him appoint them Grand Tutor, Grand Mentor, and Grand Guardian of the Heir—honors in name meant to keep them from daily counsel at court. Mo once attended Shizu with Wang E, Yao Shu, and Xu Heng and denounced Wentong to his face: "This man's learning is unsound; he will ruin the realm and must not hold the chancellorship." Shizu asked, "If so, who can?" Mo named Xu Heng; Shizu was displeased and ended the audience. Wang E once proposed that Right Chancellor Shi Tianze supervise the dynastic history, Left Chancellor Yelü Zhu the Liao history, and Wentong the Jin history. Shizu replied, "Supervisory titles will be fixed when the histories are actually compiled."
10
In the second month of the following year Li Tan rebelled and surrendered the three Lian-Hai cities to the Song. Earlier his son Yanjian had escaped from the capital; Tan sent word to the Secretariat. When news of the rebellion arrived, many said Wentong had sent his son Rao to exchange messages with Tan. Shizu summoned Wentong and said, "You taught Tan to rebel; everyone has known it for years. I ask what your plans were—tell me everything." Wentong replied, "I have forgotten; let me write it all out and submit it." When he finished writing, Shizu had it read aloud; it included, "If this wretch's life is spared, I guarantee to take Jiangnan for Your Majesty." Shizu said, "Do you still think you can talk your way out?" Just then Tan's messenger arrived from Ming River with three letters from Wentong; when they were shown him, Wentong turned pale and broke into a sweat. The letters mentioned a "jiazi appointment"; Shizu asked, "What does the jiazi date mean?" Wentong answered, "Li Tan long planned rebellion but dared not act while I was at court. I meant to tell Your Majesty to arrest him, but you were still campaigning in the north. The jiazi day was still years away; I said that only to delay his rebellion." Shizu said, "Enough. I raised you from the ranks and gave you power; I treated you generously—what grievance made you do this?" Wentong still hedged and would not say his crime deserved death; attendants were ordered to remove him, and only then did he go out to be bound. He then summoned Dou Mo, Yao Shu, Wang E, the monk Zicong, Zhang Rou, and others, showed them the document, and asked, "What punishment does Wentong deserve?" The civil officials said, "A subject who rebels must die." Zhang Rou alone shouted, "He should be dismembered!" Shizu said, "Say it together." All said, "Death." Shizu said, "He has already submitted before me."
11
使
Wentong was then executed. His son Rao was executed with him. An edict went to the realm: "Rebellion by a minister violates eternal law; our dynastic rule is clear: double-dealing means death. Who could expect a chief counselor to nurse treachery? Grand Councillor Wang Wentong rose from humble ranks to the highest office; the trust and favor shown him were abundant, in hopes he would bring great peace. Yet he conspired with Li Tan and sent his son Rao to pass secret messages. Recent letters in his own hand prove years of treason; he deserves public dismemberment to mark his monstrous crime. On the twenty-third of this month the rebel Wang Wentong and his son Rao have been duly executed. Alas! Betraying imperial favor to plot rebellion, death still leaves guilt unpaid; a chancellor put to extreme punishment may puzzle the age. Hear this, all my people, and know my deepest mind." Yet though Wentong died a traitor, posterity largely credits him with shaping the Yuan state's institutions and scope.
12
使 禿 使禿
When rebellion broke out in Ru and Ying the realm was shaken, and the emperor repeatedly ordered the princes to march southern campaigns with northern troops. Arugh Temür saw the dynasty could not be saved, seized the moment to gather tens of thousands at Mu'er Gu'uji, and forced princes into rebellion. He sent envoys telling the emperor, "Our forefathers gave you the realm and you have lost more than half of it. Hand me the imperial seal and I will rule myself." The emperor heard this calmly and said slowly, "Heaven's mandate endures; do as you will." He then sent edicts urging repentance, but Arugh Temür would not heed them. He ordered Privy Council director Toqash Temür and others to attack him. Reaching Chinghai, he raised ten thousand Kharchin as an army. They were not trained soldiers and were suddenly sent to battle; before the lines met they stripped their uniforms and defected to Arugh Temür. Toqash Temür's force was routed and he fled alone to Shangdu.
13
In Zhizheng 21 he sent Junior Guardian and Privy Council director Lao Zhang with one hundred thousand men, including Arugh Temür's brother Qutu Temür in the army, and they crushed the rebel force. Arugh Temür then planned to flee eastward. His officer Toqan, seeing defeat was near, joined Princes Nangia and Yushu Huer Tuhua in seizing Arugh Temür and sending him to court, where the emperor ordered his execution. Lao Zhang was made Grand Tutor, Toqan director of the Liaoyang Branch Privy Council, Qutu Temür enfeoffed as Prince of Yangdi, and Princes Nangia and others were all considered for enhanced titles. Soon Lao Zhang was further enfeoffed as Prince of Hening, made Liaobei Branch Secretariat chancellor acting Privy Council director, and charged with guarding the northern frontier.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →