← Back to 北齊書

卷四六 補列傳第三八 循吏

Volume 46 Biographies 38: Good Officials

Chapter 46 of 北齊書 · Book of Northern Qi
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 46
Next Chapter →
1
Zhang Huayuan, Song Shiliang, his younger brother Shigui, Lang Ji, Meng Ye, Cui Boqian, Su Qiong, Fang Bao, and Lu Qubing
2
Former kings divided the realm and tended the people, using penal law to forbid wickedness and ritual teaching to guard against desire. Therefore they divided offices and appointed officials to govern the realm together. The Book of Documents says: "To know men is wisdom; to place men in office and settle the people is grace." A wise ruler wins clear-minded ministers; a benighted court breeds greedy, cruel officials. Gao Huan set the realm right after chaos and held pity close, so many prefects and magistrates proved fit for their posts. Yet he still sent battle-hardened generals to govern the outer marches—men who knew nothing of governance and had never learned the arts of rule. They were blind not only to precedent but even began by learning to hand cases to clerks by template; insatiable in levies, relentless in cruelty—though the law was sometimes enforced, they never truly reformed. Alas! This was a grave loss for the court. After the Daining era, refinement vanished; offices and judgments were sold, court and country deceived one another, and in the dynasty's last years venality grew worse still. Northern Qi had good officials—Xin Shu was not alone—many of whom won rank and fame and have their own biographies. Men such as Fang Zhonggan, who at the end of Wuping still stood apart from the crowd, are all the more praiseworthy. Here Zhang Huayuan and the rest are gathered under Good Officials.
3
滿
Zhang Huayuan, style Guoman, was from Dai commandery. As a youth he was bright and keen, with real capacity. When Gao Huan opened the Rapid Cavalry Office he made Huayuan a legal-cases staff officer, then a staff member of the Grand Chancellor's office, still attending at his side. He followed Gao Huan to Xindu and was deeply favored. Whenever Gao Huan commanded the three armies he often had Huayuan proclaim his intent.
4
使 便使 使
When Emperor Wen of Zhou first held Yong province, Gao Huan still hoped to persuade him with the logic of loyalty and rebellion and sent Huayuan through the passes to argue with him. Zhou Wen secretly meant to detain him and said: "If you can bend your swift horse's legs to stay here, we shall share wealth and honor; if not, your life ends today." Huayuan said: "The Prince of Bohai was born to order the age—perhaps Heaven itself set him free. Your lordship holds only the western passes and has cut yourselves off; Huayuan was sent to carry your message. If you will not change course today and turn calamity into blessing, but mean to coerce me, there is only death." Zhou Wen admired his candor and sent him back east. Gao Huan had long sighed over Huayuan's absence; when he heard of his return, joy showed on his face.
5
Promoted in time to inspector of Yan, he won the people's attachment and banditry ceased. The provincial prison had held more than a thousand prisoners; Huayuan judged and released them all. At year's end only several dozen men of serious crime remained; Huayuan sent even them home for New Year's greetings, on promise to return to prison on schedule. Before, fierce beasts had often ravaged the province; once Huayuan took office, six piebald horses suddenly devoured them—all called it the fruit of his transforming influence. He later died in office; people great and small mourned him aloud.
6
便 殿 便
Song Shiliang, style Yuanyou, was from Guangping. At fifteen he already had daring; he enlisted for the northern campaign and won battle merit again and again. Soon he became palace attendant censor and went to Hebei to register households, uncovering many hidden and idle persons. Returning, he saw many bones beside Jiyin city and wrote the provinces and commanderies to collect and bury them all. That night sweet rain poured down. Back at court, Emperor Xiaozhuang praised him: "The households you registered doubled the original rolls; if every official worked like you, it would be as if another realm had appeared under Heaven."
7
滿
He was appointed prefect of Qinghe. Shiliang was clear and bright in talent, especially skilled in governance; within the commandery his fame rose quickly. Southeast of the commandery lay Crooked Dike, where the Cheng clan alone held the ground and bandits gathered thickly. People said: "Better cross Wu and Kuaiji than pass Cheng's Crooked Dike." Shiliang applied his eight-article system and the bandits fled to other districts. The people rhymed: "Though Crooked Dike is steep, what good are bandits?—Lord Song alone screens their tracks." Later, at Tianbao's great amnesty, the commandery had not one prisoner beforehand—the clerks only bowed to the edict. Inside the prison millet grew, and peach trees and artemisia filled the yards. Daily the yamen gate stood empty; no one came to sue. That winter sweet springs appeared within the borders. When he was replaced, the whole city saw him off. An old man, Ding Jingang, wept and came forward: "I am ninety and recall thirty-five administrations; you govern well, and your clarity goes clean through. Now we lose a worthy magistrate—how shall the people be saved?" None failed to cling to him in tears. He was made prefect of Dong commandery and died in office. Shiliang studied hard and loved writing; he composed Outline of Characters in five chapters and Song Clan Separate Records in ten scrolls. He and his younger brother Shigui both won fame for filial piety and brotherly affection.
8
Shigui, stern from youth, loved the law and rose in time to minister of justice. People of Luo province gathered to seize the Yellow River bridge; officials arrested them and implicated more than seventeen hundred Yuan clansmen and associates. Cui Xuan as minister of justice called it rebellion; for years the case would not close. When Shigui became vice minister, he judged the matter robbery. The ringleaders were executed; the rest were all released. At the time Court chief justice Su Zhenzhi was also known for balanced competence. In the ministry they said: "To decide doubtful guilt—Su Zhenzhi; to see inside from the table—Song Shigui." Men of the time called them the ministry's twin marvels. Prisoners sent from the Southern Terrace to the Court of Justice—Shigui often cleared them. Transferred to investigating censor, he meant to inquire into their abuses; commandant Bi Yiyun would not hand prisoners over, and the exchanges would not end. Shigui memorialized, denouncing Yiyun's cruel overreach to the full. Emperor Xianzong summoned both and told Shigui: "I know the Terrace has long deceived the Court; hold to principle against them—keep this heart and you need not fear missing wealth and honor." He told Yiyun: "Your recent conduct truly deserves death; because you aim to hate evil, you are pardoned once." He turned to the court: "These two are both ministers who stick in my throat." When he died, prisoners of the Court and censorate wept: "Court Minister Song is dead—where is our road to life?"
9
Shiliang's nephew Xiaowang was learned and loved literary ornament. Short and ugly in form, he loved to praise and blame others; opinion of the time detested him. He became staff officer in Duan Xiaoyan's opening office and was recommended as literary officer to the Prince of Beiping. Denied the Forest of Literature Hall, he slandered court gentlemen and compiled Separate Records in twenty scrolls; when Qi fell he retitled it Eastern Pass Customs and Traditions, broadened his material, and presented more than thirty scrolls. His words were mostly wild error; sections were redundant and confused, without real authorship.
10
西 西
Lang Ji, style Shiye, was from Zhongshan. Eight chi tall, with a fine beard, he ranged through the classics and excelled at administrative affairs. He began as a court gentleman and rose to defender of Haixi. Wu Mingche of Liang besieged Haixi; Ji encouraged soldiers and people and held firm for more than a hundred days until grain and arms were gone—they carved wood for arrows and cut paper for fletching. When the siege lifted he returned; Vice Director Yang Yin met him: "You were a civil clerk, yet showed military strategy. Carving wood and cutting paper has no precedent—how could Ban and Mo's inventiveness be surpassed?"
11
Later he held Yingchuan concurrently; cases had stagnated for years, yet within days he cleared them all, and Terrace reports approved what Ji had ruled. Statutes grew sparse, litigation quiet, and officials and people far and near rejoiced. Pure and cautious, he sought nothing for himself; he once said: "In office one need not even make a wooden pillow—how much less anything beyond that." He only had books copied. Pan Ziyi wrote: "Copying books in office is also a fashionable fault." Ji replied: "To see fault and know benevolence—that will do." He later died in office; when the coffin was to return, escorts far and near clung to the carriage rails in tears.
12
鹿 殿 便 婿 使西
Meng Ye, style Jingye, was from Anguo in Julu. His family was poor; in youth he was a provincial clerk. Honest and cautious, when colleagues who stole official silk offered him thirty bolts he refused. When Wei Prince of Pengcheng Shao took Ding province, Ye was made records-and-keeper. Chief Administrator Liu Renzhi told Ye: "I stand outside, you within; with one heart we may succeed." Soon Renzhi was summoned to the Secretariat; leaving, he told Shao: "Of those around you, only Meng Ye can be trusted—put sole trust in him. The rest cannot be trusted." Parting from Ye he took his hand: "I leave the capital and you lose support; I fear you cannot preserve yourself afterward. Only uprightness and straightness—urge yourself." Ye had only one horse; it died from thinness. Because Ye's family was poor, Shao ordered officials to eat the horse's flesh and meant to compensate him generously; Ye firmly declined. Shao jested: "You court a famous man's reputation." Ye answered: "I am minute and low, serving in attendance; since I cannot benefit you, how could I damage your clear reputation?" Later Gao Huan wrote Shao: "The records-keeper surnamed Meng is extremely attentive—why not keep him before your eyes?" Shao was Gao Huan's son-in-law." When Ren later became governor of Yanzhou, he took leave of Personnel Director Cui Xian and said, "Of the men in this province, only Meng Ye deserves selection and promotion; the rest are not to be trusted." Cui Xian asked Ye, "When you were in Dingzhou, what achievements made Liu of Western Yanzhou admire you so?" He answered, "By nature I am blunt and honest; I only know how to improve myself—I have no other talents."
13
Early in the Tianbao era, Prince of Qinghe Yue became governor of Si Province; hearing Ye's reputation, he summoned him again as legal-affairs officer. Ye was short in stature; at their audience Yue inwardly scorned his slight build and laughed without a word. Later, after examining Ye's rulings, he told him, "Your clarity in judgment exceeds what your stature would suggest." He was soon made administrator of Dong commandery, where he became known for lenience and kindness. That year one wheat stalk bore five ears, while others bore three or four on a single stalk; the whole commandery regarded it as a sign of his transforming rule. He soon died of illness.
14
鹿
Cui Boqian, styled Shixun, came from Boling. His father Wenyue had been administrator of Julu. Orphaned young and poor, Boqian was devoted to supporting his mother. Gao Huan summoned him to Jinyang and made him staff merit officer in the chancellor's office, saying, "Pure, upright, and devoted to the public—he is a true fine assistant." He was transferred to vice governor of Ying Province. Gao Cheng made him metropolitan-area marshal and told him, "You have already distinguished yourself in the Ying region and won popular praise; the supervisory office's business is heavy—so I entrust this post to you." His clansman Xian then held favor and power; though they had been colleagues and schoolmates, Boqian never called on him except for weddings or funerals.
15
鹿 祿
Later appointed administrator of Jibei, he won wide trust through kindness and replaced the whip with one of soft tanned leather, unwilling to draw blood—shame alone was the aim. A court noble traveling through the commandery asked how the prefect governed. They answered, "Our lord's gracious rule is unlike anything of old. They recited the people's song: "Prefect Cui governs well; change the whip, spread authority and virtue, and the people do not quarrel." The guest said, "If you call it gracious rule, how can there also be authority?" They said, "Officials fear his authority; common people receive his kindness." When he was summoned to Ye, the people wept and blocked the road. Because his brother Rang was in Guanzhong, he took no further inner post and was made administrator of southern Julu, personally reviewing every matter large or small. If the poor and weak had cases unsettled, they all said, "We have our White-Beard Lord—we need not worry it will go undecided." He later became silver-gleaming grand master for splendid virtue and died.
16
Su Qiong, styled Zhenzhi, came from Wuqiang. His father Bei served Wei as far as vice minister of the court of the imperial clan. As a boy Qiong followed his father to the frontier and once called on Eastern Jingzhou inspector Cao Zhi. Zhi asked playfully, "Do you want an office?" He answered, "Offices are established to seek men, not men to seek offices." Zhi marveled at the reply and appointed him senior adjutant in the office. Gao Cheng, holding the rank of fifth-order palace guard, opened a staff office and made him penal-affairs staff officer, often encouraging him. In Bing Province there had been bandits; the senior adjutant investigated, and every suspect had confessed under torture while the owners identified them—yet the stolen goods were never found. Gao Cheng put Qiong on a fresh exhaustive inquiry; he traced the case separately and found Yuan Jingrong and more than ten others, all with the loot recovered. Gao Cheng laughed and told those who had wrongly implicated the thieves, "If you had not met my fine staff officer, you would almost have been executed unjustly."
17
便 便 綿調 使
Appointed administrator of southern Qinghe, a commandery rife with thieves, he brought officials and people to order and wicked theft ceased. Wrongdoers from neighboring districts who passed through his borders were invariably seized and delivered. Wei Shuangcheng of Lingling county lost an ox and suspected Wei Zibin of his village; Zibin was sent to the commandery, and after one thorough inquiry Qiong knew he was not the thief and released him at once. Shuangcheng complained, "The prefect let the thief go—how are ordinary people to recover their oxen?" Qiong ignored him, sent private inquiries, and separately caught the real thieves. After that people often stopped penning livestock and let herds roam free, saying, "Just leave them to the prefect." A wealthy man from a neighboring commandery stored goods inside the border to escape thieves; when bandits pressed him he said, "My goods are already with Lord Su." The bandits then withdrew. In Pingyuan commandery a demonic bandit, Liu Heigou, gathered followers with ties to the eastern sea. Villages along Qiong's border that adjoined the bandits' territory suffered no infection or implicated cases. Neighboring districts thereby submitted to his virtue. He took more than a hundred former thieves in the commandery as his attendants; good and ill among the people, and even when a senior official shared a cup of wine with someone—nothing failed to reach him at once. Qiong was pure and cautious by nature and never sent private letters. The monk Daoyan, Buddhist superintendent of Jizhou, was hugely wealthy and had many income streams in the commandery, often collected through county and commandery offices. When Daoyan wished to call on him, Qiong knew his intent; at each meeting he discussed abstruse principles with solemn respect—though Daoyan came repeatedly on debt business, he never found an opening. His disciples asked why; Daoyan said, "Each time I see the prefect he carries me straight into the blue clouds—how can I speak of earthly affairs?" A commandery man, Zhao Ying, had been administrator of Leling; at eighty he retired home. In early fifth month he brought a pair of fresh melons as a gift. Ying, relying on his age, pressed hard; Qiong finally kept them and hung them on a beam in the reception hall without ever cutting them. People then vied to offer fresh fruit; at the gate, learning Ying's melons were still there, they looked at one another and left. Commoners Yi Puming and his brothers disputed fields for years without settlement, each side citing supporters until the case involved nearly a hundred people. Qiong summoned the brothers before the crowd and said, "Brothers are what the world can scarcely obtain; fields are easy to find—if you gain land but lose your brothers' hearts, what then?" Tears fell from his eyes; none among those present failed to weep. The brothers kowtowed and begged to withdraw and reconsider; separated ten years, they then returned to live together. Each spring he gathered great Confucians Wei Jilong, Tian Yuanfeng, and others to lecture at the commandery school; in spare moments from documents he had all court clerks study—people called the clerks' quarters the students' hall. He forbade improper shrines and taught weddings and funerals to be frugal yet within ritual. In silkworm month he issued silk-gauze quota samples throughout the district; military levies were set in clear order; corvée and requisitions were always prepared in advance—commandery and county heads often had not even ten blows' penalty for delay. At the time every province and commandery sent men to his border to study his methods of government. During Tianbao, great floods struck the commandery; more than a thousand households were left without food. Qiong gathered every household in the district that had grain and personally borrowed from them to feed the hungry. The province counted households for tax levy and again sought to assess his borrowed grain. His clerks told him, "Though you pity the starving, I fear the guilt will fall on you, my lord." Qiong said, "One body may bear guilt, yet a thousand households live—what is there to resent?" He memorialized the facts, had the investigation remitted entirely, and households were kept secure. Those he had fostered as sons all said, "The prefect gave you birth." For six years in the commandery the people cherished him, and not one person brought a case to the province. Four successive memorials ranked him foremost. When mourning obliged him to leave office, he accepted none of the gifts old friends offered. Soon he was reappointed rectifier and director of the Court of Justice; court gentlemen sighed that he was underused. Master of Writing Xin Shu said, "Upright and correct—his name fixes his substance; there is no worry he will not prevail."
18
宿
Earlier, when Qiong was administrator of Qinghe, Pei Xianbo was inspector of Jizhou, harsh in applying the law, while Qiong was kind in nurturing people. Fang Yanyou was administrator of Leling; passing through the province, Pei asked outside reputation; You said, "I only hear the administrator is praised and the inspector is condemned." Pei said, "One who wins popular praise is not utterly impartial." You replied, "If that is so, then Huang Ba and Gong Sui were criminals by your standard." Later an edict ordered each province to recommend the pure and capable. Because of his earlier remark Pei feared Qiong would trap him; Qiong stated his wrongful detention, and commentators respected his fairness. Bi Yiyun was censor-in-chief, fierce and violent in office; legal officials feared him and none dared disobey. Qiong's investigations aimed at fairness; very many were cleared—court and censorate cases began with Qiong. He was transferred to gentleman of the three offices. In Zhao province, Qinghe, and southern Zhong people repeatedly reported rebellion; case after case went to Qiong for investigation, and many were cleared. Master of Writing Cui Ang told Qiong, "If you wish merit and fame, you should think of other principles; you still repeatedly clear treason cases—how lightly you hold your life?" Qiong said sternly, "What I clear are wrongful grievances—I do not release real rebels." Ang was deeply ashamed. The capital had a saying: "Judgment without doubt—Su Zhenzhi." He was transferred to left vice director and acted in Xu province affairs. In Xuzhou city the Five-Tier Temple was robbed of a hundred bronze statues; the authorities investigated neighbors on night watch and everyone suspicion touched—several tens were seized; Qiong released them all at once. The monks complained he did not pursue the thieves; Qiong sent them away, saying, "Just return to the temple—the statues will come back on their own." Ten days later he had the bandits' names and the hiding places, seized them directly, verified everything, and the thieves confessed in detail—monks and laypeople alike marveled. By old regulation the Huai crossing barred merchants at will; when Huainan had a lean year, Qiong memorialized to allow buying grain north of the Huai. Later when north Huai people were hungry, he again requested open grain trade with Huainan; merchants went back and forth, each side aiding the other, and water and land routes profited Hebei. He later became director of the Court of Justice, but Qi fell; he served Zhou as administrator of Boling.
19
Fang Bao, styled Zhonggan, came from Qinghe. His grandfather Fashou has a biography in the Book of Wei. His father was Yizong. Bao was tall and broad-shouldered, with a handsome voice and bearing. He doffed the hemp and entered service as an opening-office staff officer and concurrent mobile-office gentleman, attending Murong Shaozong. Shaozong claimed a water bane was upon him, so he bathed aboard the war galley and even threw himself into the river, hoping an apotropaic counter-measure would turn fate aside. Bao said, "Fate is Heaven's to give—what mortal scheme could hurry or delay it? If you truly face disaster, I doubt any averting rite can lift it; if there is none in truth, what would you avert?" Murong Shaozong laughed. "Cannot escape the vulgar," he said; "one goes through the motions, that is all." Before long Murong Shaozong drowned; opinion at the time took it that Bao had read the omen.
20
Promoted to administrator of Leling, he ruled with grave steadiness and pitied the poor and weak. Under Bao the yamen stayed plain and quiet and the cells stood empty. The seat lay on the coast, where the water ran salty and bitter. Bao had a well sunk and sweet water rose; people far and near credited his transforming rule. Once Bao had left office and gone home, the well turned salty again. When Qi fell he went home to tend his estate. Summons came again and again; he pleaded illness and stayed away. He died at home.
21
Lu Qubing was a native of Yangping. His manner was open and lucid; his looks were singular and striking. He doffed the hemp and became an opening-office staff officer. An edict required that cultivated men serve as county magistrates, and Qubing was appointed magistrate of Raoyang in Dingzhou. Qubing understood the affairs of the age and was by nature stern and firm; none dared cheat him, yet he was utterly fair, and officials and commoners alike marveled. He was promoted to magistrate of Cheng'an. Below the capital stood Ye, Linzhang, and Cheng'an—three counties long notorious under the imperial hub. Disorder piled on hard times; law's net hung slack, and meritorious ministers and imperial kin pressed requests from every side. Qubing tracked every matter and answered on principle. Men of influence—even grooms and petty servants—feared his bearing, yet none bore him a grudge. After the court moved to Ye, among the three magistrates' ways of rule, Qubing alone was ranked first. When Emperor Wu of Northern Zhou conquered Qi, he prized their competence in office. Qubing and Gongsun Jingmao, administrator of Jiyin, were the two not replaced; an edict singled them out for praise. In the Daye era of Sui he died in office as magistrate of Jishi.
22
The full text has been collated against Zhonghua Shuju, first edition Book of Northern Qi (November 1972).
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →