← Back to 漢書

卷三十二 張耳陳餘傳

Volume 32: Zhang Er and Chen Yu

Chapter 41 of 漢書 · Book of Han
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 41
Next Chapter →
1
Zhang Er and Chen Yu.
2
Zhang Er was from Daliang. As a young man, he served among the retainers of the Wei prince Wuji. While living as a fugitive in Waihuang, he stayed at the home of a wealthy man's guest. That man's daughter was famed for her beauty, though she had treated her husband as a menial. A retainer of her father told her, "If you truly want a worthy husband, take Zhang Er." She agreed, secured a separation, and married Zhang Er. Her family funded him lavishly. With those resources he gathered talented followers from far and wide and eventually became magistrate of Waihuang.
3
Chen Yu, also from Daliang, was devoted to classical learning. While in Zhao at Kujing, he married the daughter of the wealthy Gongcheng family. Though younger, Chen Yu treated Zhang Er like a father, and the two became sworn friends willing to die for each other.
4
使
Before he rose to power, Gaozu had once traveled with Zhang Er. After Qin conquered Wei, bounties were posted: one thousand jin for Zhang Er and five hundred for Chen Yu. They changed their identities, fled to Chen, and worked as local gatekeepers. Once an official flogged Chen Yu over a minor offense. Chen Yu wanted to rise up against him, but Zhang Er held him back and made him take the beating. After the official left, Zhang Er rebuked him, saying, "What did I tell you from the start? Would you throw your life away over a petty insult from a minor clerk?" Chen Yu apologized.
5
When Chen She's uprising reached Chen, Zhang Er and Chen Yu came to pay their respects. Chen She and his aides had long heard of their reputation; when he met them, he was delighted.
6
西
A leading man of Chen urged Chen She, saying, "General, you have taken up armor and arms, led soldiers to punish brutal Qin, and restored the state of Chu — your merit entitles you to kingship." Chen She asked the two of them. They replied, "General, you have faced death without flinching and taken measures that risked everything to rid the realm of cruelty. But they warned that if he proclaimed himself king immediately, all under Heaven would see it as private ambition. They advised him not to take kingship yet, but to march west, restore heirs of the six states, and build alliances. Then he could defeat Qin, seize Xianyang, command the feudal lords, and complete an imperial enterprise. If he made only Chen his kingdom at once, they feared the movement would splinter." Chen She did not accept their advice and declared himself king.
7
使 使西
"Zhang Er and Chen Yu again advised him that Hebei was still unsecured and his priority remained entering the passes. They said they knew Zhao's local strongmen and asked to take a special force to seize Zhao territory." The King of Chen agreed. He appointed his trusted fellow townsman Wu Chen as general, made Zhang Er and Chen Yu left and right commandants, and gave them three thousand soldiers to cross the Yellow River at Baima. As they advanced through the counties, they persuaded the local elites, saying: "Qin has made violent government and cruel punishments, ruined all under heaven, pressed laborers north for the Great Wall and south for the garrisons of the Five Ranges. Outside and inside are in turmoil; the people are exhausted; households are counted head by head and levied basket by basket to supply military expenses. Wealth is depleted and strength exhausted, and harsh laws are added on top, so that fathers and sons throughout the realm cannot sustain one another. Now King Chen has raised his arm and begun the cause for all under heaven; none fail to turn and respond. Each household vents its own anger, each repays its resentment; counties kill their magistrates and assistants, commanderies kill their governors and commandants. Now he has enlarged Chu, made Chen his royal seat, and sent Wu Guang and Zhou Wen to lead a million troops west to attack Qin. At such a moment, anyone who fails to accomplish the work of winning a marquisate is no hero. To use the realm's strength against a lawless ruler, avenge one's kin, and carve out a domain was a once-in-an-age chance." The local strongmen accepted their argument. They raised forces as they went, gathering tens of thousands, and Wu Chen took the title Lord Wuxin. They captured over ten Zhao cities, while the rest held behind their walls. Then they marched northeast on Fanyang. A Fanyang native, Kuai Tong, persuaded Magistrate Xu to surrender and convinced Lord Wuxin to reward him with a marquis seal. The full exchange is recorded in Kuai Tong's biography. After news spread, more than thirty Zhao cities surrendered without fighting.
8
At Handan, Zhang Er and Chen Yu heard that Zhou Zhang had entered the passes but been repulsed at Xi. They also heard that many commanders serving Chen She were ruined by slander and executed. "Resentful that they had only deputy rank, they told Wu Chen that Chen She could not be trusted to restore the six states. They said Wu Chen now held dozens of Zhao cities in Hebei and could not stabilize them without kingship. They warned that Chen She listened to slander and that reporting back might be fatal. They urged him not to miss the moment." Wu Chen accepted and proclaimed himself King of Zhao. He appointed Chen Yu grand general and Zhang Er chancellor.
9
使 使西 使使西 西 西使
When news reached Chen, Chen She was enraged and wanted to annihilate Wu Chen's families and attack Zhao. "Chancellor Fang remonstrated that Qin still stood and such punishment would create a second Qin. He said it was better to accept the situation, congratulate Zhao, and press them to attack Qin in the west." Chen She accepted: he kept their families under palace custody and enfeoffed Zhang Er's son Ao as Lord of Chengdu. He sent an envoy to congratulate Zhao and urge immediate westward operations into the passes. Zhang Er and Chen Yu persuaded Wu Chen, saying: "Your Majesty's kingship in Zhao is not Chu's true intention; Chu only congratulates Your Majesty as a tactic. Once Chu has destroyed Qin, it will certainly bring troops against Zhao. We beg Your Majesty not to send troops west, but to campaign north through Yan and Dai and south to gather Henei, thereby broadening your own position. With Zhao holding the Great River in the south and possessing Yan and Dai in the north, even if Chu defeats Qin it will certainly not dare control Zhao." The King of Zhao agreed, kept troops from the western front, and sent commanders into Yan, Changshan, and Shangdang.
10
使 使
When Han Guang arrived, the Yan people proclaimed him King of Yan. The Zhao king then moved north with Zhang Er and Chen Yu to secure territory on Yan's frontier. During one excursion, the Zhao king was captured by Yan forces. Yan imprisoned him and demanded a partition of land. Each envoy sent to negotiate was killed by Yan to harden its demands. Zhang Er and Chen Yu were deeply troubled. A groom went to his quarters and said, "Let me go persuade Yan for you two lords and bring the Zhao king back in the same carriage with me." Everyone in the quarters laughed and said, "Ten envoys have already gone and been killed — how can you bring back the king?" He went straight to the Yan camp. A Yan general received him and asked, "Do you know what I want?" "The general said he wanted only the Zhao king." The soldier said, "Do you know what sort of men Zhang Er and Chen Yu are?" "The general replied that they were worthy men." He said, "What do you think they desire?" "The general said they wanted their king back." The Zhao soldier laughed. He said, "You do not understand what those two want. Wu Chen, Zhang Er, and Chen Yu had taken dozens of cities by force, and each had ambitions to rule. Lord and minister, he said, cannot be spoken of on the same footing! They had only backed Wu Chen first to stabilize Zhao while things were unsettled. Now that Zhao was largely secure, they too wanted to divide and rule it, but were waiting for the right time. If Yan kept the Zhao king captive, they might publicly demand him yet privately hope Yan killed him so they could split Zhao. One Zhao was already dangerous to Yan; with two capable rulers blaming Yan for regicide, Yan would be easy to destroy." Yan accepted this reasoning and released the Zhao king. The stable-hand himself drove the king back.
11
使 使使 使
After pacifying Changshan, Li Liang reported back, and the Zhao king sent him on to take Taiyuan. At Shiyi, Qin forces blocked Jingxing Pass and stopped his advance. A Qin commander, falsely claiming to act for the Second Emperor, sent Li Liang an unsealed letter saying: "Liang once served me and received manifest favor. If he can truly turn Zhao back to Qin, I will pardon Liang's crime and honor Liang." Li Liang read it with suspicion and headed to Handan to request reinforcements. Before reaching Handan, he met the Zhao king's elder sister traveling with over a hundred horsemen. Seeing the procession from a distance, he thought the king was present and knelt in formal greeting. The princess, drunk, did not recognize him and had her riders dismiss him. Li Liang, normally treated with deference, stood up humiliated before his subordinates. "One officer said the whole realm was in revolt and the able should establish themselves first. He added that even a woman now refused proper respect to Li Liang and urged him to pursue and kill her." Already wavering because of Qin's letter, Li Liang acted in anger, had the princess killed, and then attacked Handan. Handan was caught off guard, and Wu Chen was ultimately killed. Because many locals informed for Zhang Er and Chen Yu, they managed to escape. They regrouped and raised tens of thousands of troops. A retainer said to them, "You two are strangers here; though you wish to attach yourselves to Zhao, you can hardly stand on your own; He advised them to find a descendant of Zhao and support him with legitimate authority; only then could they succeed." They located Zhao Xie, enthroned him as King of Zhao, and set his court at Xindu.
12
鹿 鹿 鹿 鹿 鹿使 使 使
Li Liang advanced and attacked Chen Yu, but Chen Yu defeated him. Li Liang fled and went over to Zhang Han. Zhang Han brought his army to Handan, moved its people to Henei, and leveled the city walls. Zhang Er and King Xie of Zhao fled into Julu, where Wang Li besieged them. Chen Yu gathered Changshan troops in the north, gained tens of thousands, and camped north of Julu. Zhang Han camped south of Julu at Jiyuan, built a supply corridor to the river, and provisioned Wang Li. Wang Li had ample supplies and pressed the assault on Julu. When food in Julu was exhausted, Zhang Er repeatedly sent men to summon Chen Yu. Chen Yu measured his own troops, judged them too few to withstand Qin, and did not dare advance. After months, Zhang Er was furious and sent Zhang Yan and Chen Shi to reproach Chen Yu, saying, "We swore we would die for each other. Now the king and I face death at any moment, yet you sit with tens of thousands of troops and refuse to come to our aid — will you not come and die with us? At the very least, one or two in ten of us might still be saved." "Chen Yu replied that he was not dying with them because he still wished to avenge Zhao and Zhang against Qin. If all died together now, he said, it would be like throwing meat to a tiger, with no gain." "Zhang Yan and Chen Shi said the crisis required dying together to keep faith, not planning for a distant future." "Chen Yu answered that he saw no benefit in that." He then sent five thousand men under Zhang Yan and Chen Shi to test Qin first; all were lost.
13
鹿 使
At that time, Yan, Qi, and Chu all heard Zhao was in danger and came to aid it. Zhang Ao also gathered over ten thousand in Dai and arrived, all camping beside Chen Yu. Xiang Yu repeatedly cut Zhang Han's supply corridor, and Wang Li's forces ran short of food. Xiang Yu then led all forces across the river and broke Zhang Han's army. The feudal armies then dared attack Qin and captured Wang Li. King Xie of Zhao and Zhang Er were thus able to emerge from Julu. When they met Chen Yu, they reproached him and asked where Zhang Yan and Chen Shi were. "Chen Yu said they had demanded certain death, so he sent them with five thousand men to test Qin first, and all perished." Zhang Er did not believe him and thought Chen Yu had killed them, questioning him repeatedly. Chen Yu angrily replied, "I did not expect you to distrust me so deeply! Do you think I would cast away my generals because of mere subordinates?" He then removed his seal and sash and handed them to Zhang Er. Zhang Er did not dare accept. While Chen Yu stepped out to the privy, a retainer persuaded Zhang Er, saying: "If Heaven gives and one does not take, one instead receives its blame. Now General Chen gives you the seal and sash. Not accepting them opposes Heaven and is inauspicious. Take them quickly." Zhang Er then wore the seal and took over Chen Yu's troops. When Chen Yu returned and saw Zhang Er had not yielded, he withdrew in anger. Zhang Er then fully absorbed his forces. Chen Yu remained only with a few hundred followers, fishing and hunting in marshes by the river. From this point, a deep rift formed between them.
14
King Xie of Zhao returned to reside at Xindu. Zhang Er entered the passes with Xiang Yu. When Xiang Yu enfeoffed the lords, Zhang Er was widely praised because he had long-standing connections. Xiang Yu had also heard of Zhang Er's worth and therefore made him King of Changshan, ruling at Xindu. Xindu was renamed Xiangguo.
15
Many of Chen Yu's followers persuaded Xiang Yu, saying: "Chen Yu and Zhang Er were one body and had merit in Zhao." Because Chen Yu had not entered the passes, Xiang Yu only granted him three counties near Nanpi when he heard he was there. He moved King Xie of Zhao to rule Dai instead.
16
使
When Zhang Er took his kingdom, Chen Yu grew even angrier and said, "Zhang Er and I rendered equal service, yet he is king while I am only a marquis." When Qi's king Tian Rong rebelled against Chu, Chen Yu sent Xia Yue to persuade Tian Rong, saying: "Xiang Yu is unfair as steward of all under heaven. He made all his generals kings over good lands and moved former kings to bad lands; now the King of Zhao actually dwells in Dai! We beg Your Majesty to lend your servant troops, and I request to use Nanpi as a defensive screen." Tian Rong wanted to build his own faction and sent troops to aid Chen Yu. Chen Yu gathered all forces from his three counties and struck Zhang Er, King of Changshan. Defeated, Zhang Er fled and said, "The Han king and I have old ties, but King Xiang is strong and installed me as king, so I mean to go to Chu." "Gan Gong said that when the Han king entered the passes, the Five Planets gathered in Eastern Well. Eastern Well belonged to Qin's celestial division. He who arrived first would surely become king. So although Chu was strong, it would ultimately submit to Han." Zhang Er therefore fled to Han. Han had also turned back to pacify the Three Qins and was besieging Zhang Han at Feiqiu. Zhang Er met the Han king, who received him generously.
17
使
After defeating Zhang Er, Chen Yu recovered all Zhao territory, welcomed King Xie back from Dai, and restored him as king. King Xie, grateful to Chen Yu, made him King of Dai. Chen Yu considered King Xie too weak and the state too newly settled, so he remained behind as the king's tutor and sent Xia Yue to defend Dai as chancellor.
18
使 西
In Han year two, Han attacked Chu in the east and notified Zhao, seeking joint action. Chen Yu said, "I will join you only if Han kills Zhang Er." The Han side then found a man who looked like Zhang Er, cut off his head, and sent it to Chen Yu. Only then did Chen Yu send troops to assist Han. After Han's defeat west of Pengcheng, Chen Yu learned Zhang Er had only feigned death and therefore turned against Han. Han sent Zhang Er and Han Xin against Zhao. They defeated Zhao at Jingxing, killed Chen Yu by the Zhi River, and pursued King Xie to Xiangguo, where they put him to death.
19
In the fourth year, in summer, Zhang Er was made King of Zhao. In the fifth year, in autumn, Er died and was given the posthumous title King Jing. His son Ao succeeded as king, married Gaozu's eldest daughter Princess Lu Yuan, and she became queen.
20
婿
In the seventh year, Gaozu passed through Zhao on his way from Pingcheng. The king of Zhao personally served his meals morning and evening, humbling himself like a son-in-law. Gaozu sat with legs spread, cursing and insulting him, and treated him with great contempt. Zhao's chancellor Guan Gao and Zhao Wu, both over sixty and former retainers of Zhang Er, grew angry and said, "Our king is a weakling!" They urged Zhang Ao, saying, "Heroes are rising everywhere, and the able establish themselves first. You serve the emperor with great respect, yet he treats you without courtesy — let us kill him for you." Zhang Ao bit his finger until it bled and said, "How wrong you are to speak of this! My father lost his state, and only through the emperor did he recover it; his kindness extends to his descendants — even the smallest benefit comes from the emperor. Please never speak of this again." "Guan Gao and more than ten others then discussed the matter among themselves.
21
They said, The fault is ours. Their king was an honorable elder who would not betray gratitude. Moreover, we cannot bear this insult to our honor; the emperor has humiliated our king, so we wish to kill him — why should we involve the king and stain him? If the plan succeeds, the credit goes to the king; if it fails, we alone will bear the punishment."
22
宿 宿
In year eight, the emperor passed through Dongyuan. Guan Gao's group secretly placed men at Bairen to strike him in a latrine. "The emperor considered lodging there, then felt uneasy and asked the county name." "He was told it was Bairen." He said, "Bairen — that sounds like being forced by men!" So he did not stay and left.
23
使 使輿
In year nine, an enemy of Guan Gao learned of the plot and reported it. The emperor then arrested the King of Zhao and those implicated in the plot. Zhao Wu and more than ten others all vied to cut their own throats. Guan Gao alone cursed them in anger, saying, "Who told you gentlemen to do this? The king in truth had no plot, yet he is being arrested along with us; if you all die, who will clear the king of the charge of rebellion?" He and the king were taken in caged carts to Chang'an. "In interrogation, Guan Gao said only his own group had acted and the king knew nothing." Officials beat him with thousands of strokes and burned him with irons; his body had no uninjured part, yet he never changed his statement. Empress Lu repeatedly said Zhang Ao, because of his tie to Princess Lu Yuan, should not be treated this way. The emperor angrily replied, "If Zhang Ao held the realm, would your daughter be the only woman he took?" When the chief justice reported Guan Gao's testimony, the emperor said, "What a strong man! Whoever knows him, go and question him privately." Grandee Xie Gong said, "I have long known him; he is exactly the sort of man in Zhao who values honor and will not break a sworn promise." The emperor sent Xie Gong with tally-staff credentials to question Guan Gao before his prison litter. Guan Gao raised his head, recognized Xie Gong, and greeted him as warmly as in earlier days. In conversation, Xie Gong asked whether Zhang Ao had truly plotted rebellion. Guan Gao said, "Does not every man love his parents, wife, and children? Now my three clans are already condemned to death — how could I trade the king for my kin! In truth the king did not rebel; only we did this." He laid out the full roots and circumstances in detail, showing the king had no knowledge of it. Xie Gong reported all this fully to the emperor, and the emperor then pardoned the King of Zhao.
24
使
The emperor admired Guan Gao for holding to his pledged word. He ordered Xie Gong to release him and tell him: "Zhang Wang has already been released; the emperor greatly values you, so you are pardoned." Guan Gao said, "The reason I did not die was to clear the King of Zhao of rebellion. Now that the king is out, my duty is fulfilled. Moreover, a subject who bears the name of plotting regicide — how could he face serving the ruler again!" He then threw back his head and died by cutting his throat.
25
After Zhang Ao was released, he remained married to Princess Luyuan as before and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Xuanping. The emperor then valued the retainers of the Zhao king and appointed them as chancellors of feudal states and commandery governors. This account appears in the biography of Tian Shu. By the reigns of Emperor Hui, Empress Gao, Emperor Wen, and Emperor Jing, the descendants of King Zhang's retainers all held offices at the two-thousand-bushel rank.
26
Early in Emperor Hui's reign, Prince Daohui of Qi presented Chengyang Commandery and honored Princess Lu Yuan as empress dowager. In the first year of Empress Gao's reign, Empress Dowager Lu Yuan died. Six years later, Marquis of Xuanping Ao died again. Empress Lu made Ao's son Yan King of Lu because his mother had been empress dowager. Pitying his youth and isolation, she also enfeoffed Ao's two sons by his former wife, making Shou Marquis of Lechang and Chi Marquis of Xindu. After Empress Gao died, the ministers executed the Lü clan and deposed the King of Lu and the two marquises. When Emperor Wen came to the throne, he re-enfeoffed the former King of Lu, Yan, as Marquis of Nangong. He died, and his son Sheng succeeded. Under Emperor Wu, Sheng was removed for a crime and the fief was abolished. During the Yuanguang era, Yan's grandson Guangguo was re-enfeoffed as Marquis of Suiling. He died, and his son Chang succeeded. During the Taichu era, Chang lost the fief for an offense of disrespect. In Yuanshi 2 of Emperor Ping, when broken noble lines were revived, Ao's great-great-great-grandson Qingji was made Marquis of Xuanping with a thousand-household estate.
27
The appraisal says: Zhang Er and Chen Yu were celebrated in their age as worthy men. Even the retainers and servants in their households were outstanding talents of the empire, and wherever they settled, men from their circle rose to be ministers and chancellors. Yet when Zhang Er and Chen Yu were first in hardship, they trusted each other to die for one another without a second thought. Yet once they occupied states and struggled for power, they finally destroyed one another. How genuine their earlier admiration had been, and how twisted their later betrayal became! Friendship founded on power and profit was something the ancients were ashamed of; this is exactly what they meant.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →