← Back to 漢書

卷三十七 季布欒布田叔傳

Volume 37: Ji Bu, Luan Bu and Tian Shu

Chapter 46 of 漢書 · Book of Han
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 46
Next Chapter →
1
使
Ji Bu was a native of Chu who had won renown as a knight-errant. Xiang Yu put him in command of troops, and time and again he cornered the King of Han. After Xiang Yu fell, Gaozu posted a reward of a thousand pounds of gold for Ji Bu, with death for three generations of kin for anyone who dared hide him. Ji Bu took refuge with the Zhou clan of Puyang. They told him, "The Han are hunting you relentlessly; their agents will soon be at my door. If you will trust me, I have a plan to propose; if not, I would rather slit my own throat first." Ji Bu agreed. They shaved his head, clamped him in the convict's collar, dressed him in a laborer's hemp, stowed him in a funeral cart with several dozen household servants, and drove him to Zhu Jia of Lu to be sold off as a slave. Zhu Jia recognized him at once as Ji Bu, bought him, and lodged him on a country estate. Then he traveled to Luoyang to see Xiahou Ying, the Marquis of Ru-yin, and argued, "What wrong has Ji Bu done? Ministers serve their own lords—that is simply what duty requires. Are we to execute every man who once served the house of Xiang? The Son of Heaven has only just won the realm; to hound one man out of personal spite shows a narrowness ill befitting his position. A man of Ji Bu's caliber, pressed this hard, will flee north to the Xiongnu or south to Nanyue. To drive a brave man into the arms of a rival is the sort of blunder that made Wu Zixu flog the grave of King Ping of Chu. Why not find a tactful moment and put this to the emperor yourself?" Xiahou Ying knew Zhu Jia for a famous man of chivalry and guessed Ji Bu lay hidden with him; he agreed to speak. When a suitable occasion came, he repeated Zhu Jia's argument to the throne. The emperor then granted Ji Bu a full pardon. Men of rank admired Ji Bu for bending unyielding pride into survival, and Zhu Jia's name rang through the age for it. Ji Bu was summoned to court, thanked the emperor, and was appointed a gentleman of the palace.
2
殿
Under Emperor Hui he rose to general of the palace gentlemen. The Chanyu had once sent a letter that insulted Empress Dowager Lü; enraged, she called her generals in council. Fan Kuai, the senior general, declared, "Give me a hundred thousand men and I will sweep through the heart of the Xiongnu steppe." The generals, eager to please the empress dowager, pronounced Fan Kuai right. Ji Bu said, "Fan Kuai deserves execution. Gaozu himself led over three hundred thousand men and was trapped at Pingcheng—and Fan Kuai was in that army. How dare he now boast that a mere hundred thousand could ride roughshod over the Xiongnu? He is lying to your faces! Moreover, the Qin empire crumbled in part because it exhausted itself on the northern frontier, and Chen Sheng rose in rebellion. The realm is still bleeding from those wars, and Fan Kuai flatters you to your face and would unsettle the whole empire again." A chill fell over the hall; the empress dowager adjourned court and never again brought up war on the Xiongnu.
3
使
Ji Bu was appointed governor of Hedong. Under Emperor Wen, word of his talent reached the throne; he was summoned with a view to making him grandee secretary. Others countered that he was a brawler when drunk and impossible to work with. He reached the capital, was kept a month in the official hostel, then sent away without appointment. Ji Bu stepped forward and said, "I stand under sentence of fault at Hedong; Your Majesty summoned me without cause—someone must have oversold me to you. Now that I am here, I am given no charge and dismissed—someone has blackened me behind my back. If one man's praise brings me to court and one man's slander sends me packing, thoughtful men everywhere will draw their own conclusions about Your Majesty's judgment." The emperor fell silent, then said with embarrassment, "Hedong is one of my vital provinces; I merely wished to see you in person." Ji Bu returned to his post.
4
使 使
The rhetorician Cao Qiusheng traded on influence for gold, curried favor with men such as the favorite Zhao Tan, and was close to Dou Zhang, the empress's brother. When Ji Bu heard of it, he wrote to Dou Zhang warning him, "Cao Qiusheng is no man of substance; have nothing to do with him." When Cao Qiusheng came home, he wanted a letter of introduction to Ji Bu. Dou Zhang said, "General Ji dislikes you; you had better not go." Cao pressed until Dou yielded a letter, then set out. He had his letter sent ahead; Ji Bu flew into a rage and waited for Cao Qiusheng. When Cao arrived, he bowed to Ji Bu and said, "Chu has a saying: 'A hundred pounds of gold cannot buy Ji Bu's word'—how did you earn such fame across Liang and Chu? We are both men of Chu; if I spread your name through the realm, would that not serve you well? Why do you shut me out so coldly!" Ji Bu was delighted. He brought him inside, kept him for months as an honored guest, and sent him away with rich gifts. It was Cao Qiusheng's praise that made Ji Bu's name ring louder still.
5
Ji Bu's younger brother Ji Xin overshadowed all Guanzhong in sheer force of character; in person he was courteous and restrained, yet as a knight-errant his reputation ran for a thousand miles, and fighting men vied to die for him. After killing a man he fled to Wu and hid with Yuan Ang, whom he treated as an elder while treating Guan Fu, Ji Fu, and their like as younger brothers. He served as a marshal of the center; even Commandant Zhi Du would not touch him. Young ruffians often invoked his name without permission. In those days Guanzhong knew Ji Xin for his courage and Ji Bu for keeping his word.
6
西 使 使
Ji Bu's maternal uncle Ding Gong, a general under Xiang Yu, had pressed Gaozu hard west of Pengcheng. In close combat the King of Han was desperate; turning to Ding Gong he cried, "Must two able men try to destroy each other?" Ding Gong withdrew his troops. After Xiang Yu fell, Ding Gong came to pay his respects; Gaozu had him paraded before the host and declared, "Ding Gong was a faithless servant to his king; he helped cost Xiang Yu the empire." He had him executed, saying, "Let no future minister take Ding Gong as his model!"
7
使 西
Luan Bu came from Liang. When Peng Yue was still a commoner, he and Luan Bu had been companions; broke, they hired out as laborers in Qi and Luan tended a tavern. They parted for some years; then Luan Bu was kidnapped and sold into slavery in Yan. He avenged his master's family on their enemies; the Yan general Zang Tu, impressed, appointed him a commandant. When Zang Tu became king of Yan, Luan Bu served as his general. When Zang Tu rebelled, the Han attacked Yan and took Luan Bu prisoner. King Peng Yue of Liang heard of it and petitioned the emperor to ransom him and appoint him a grandee of Liang. Luan Bu was on embassy to Qi when, before he could return, the court summoned Peng Yue on a charge of treason, wiped out three generations of his kin, exposed his head in Luoyang, and decreed arrest for anyone who dared mourn or look upon him. Luan Bu returned, laid his report beneath Peng Yue's severed head, and offered sacrifice and tears. The officials seized him and reported to the throne. The emperor summoned Luan Bu and shouted, "Were you in league with Peng Yue? I forbade anyone to claim his body or mourn him; you alone offered sacrifice and wept—your guilt is as plain as open rebellion. Boil him at once." As they dragged him toward the cauldron, he turned and said, "Let me speak one sentence before I die." The emperor asked, "What is it?" Luan Bu said, "When you were besieged at Pengcheng and driven from Xingyang to Chenggao, the only reason Xiang Yu could not push west was that King Peng held Liang and kept Han and Chu locked in a stalemate that wore Chu down. At that moment a single shift of Peng Yue's weight—if he had thrown in with Chu, Han would have shattered; if with Han, Chu would have shattered. And at Gaixia, without King Peng, the house of Xiang would never have fallen. After peace was won, King Peng received his bronze tally like any other vassal king and hoped to pass his line down for ages. Now a single levy of troops from Liang, and because King Peng was too ill to march, you suspect him of treason. No sign of revolt appeared; to kill him on petty pretexts will make every man who helped you win the throne look over his shoulder. King Peng is dead; I would rather join him in the cauldron than live on—throw me in." The emperor spared him and appointed him a commandant.
8
Under Emperor Wen he served as chancellor of Yan and rose to general. Luan Bu used to say, "A man who will not endure indignity in poverty is no man at all; a worthy man who cannot have his way when fortune smiles is no worthy man." Those who had done him kindness he repaid with generosity; those who had wronged him he destroyed to the letter of the law. During the rebellion of Wu and Chu he won a marquisate at Ju for his service and returned as chancellor of Yan. Between Yan and Qi the people set up shrines to him and called them the altars of Duke Luan.
9
When Luan Bu died, his son Ben inherited the title; under Emperor Wu the fief was stripped after Ben, as Grand Master of Ceremonies, supplied defective sacrificial beasts.
10
Tian Shu was a native of Xingcheng in Zhao. His clan was the old royal Tian house of Qi. Tian Shu loved fencing and studied Huang–Lao doctrine under Master Yue Ju. He was scrupulous, blunt-spoken, and drawn to the chivalrous life. He moved among the great houses until men of Zhao recommended him to Chancellor Zhao Wu, who brought him to King Zhang Ao of Zhao and had him appointed a gentleman of the palace. For several years the king admired him but had not yet promoted him.
11
Then Zhao Wu, Guan Gao, and their circle plotted regicide; when the plot was uncovered, the Han court ordered the arrest of King Zhang and every minister implicated. In Zhao, anyone who dared follow the king would die with three generations of his kin. Only Tian Shu, Meng Shu, and a dozen others shaved their heads, donned the convict's collar and crimson robes, and followed their king to Chang'an. When King Zhang Ao's case was cleared he was released, stripped of his kingship, and ennobled as Marquis of Xuanping; he then recommended Tian Shu and the other nine men. The emperor received them in audience and spoke with them; not a single minister at the Han court could match their caliber. Pleased, the emperor appointed them all as commandery governors or chancellors to feudal kings. Tian Shu governed Hanzhong for over a decade.
12
Soon after Emperor Wen took the throne, he summoned Tian Shu and asked, "Sir, can you name the worthiest men in the realm?" He replied, "I am hardly fit to judge such matters." The emperor said, "You are a man of weight yourself; you must have an opinion." Tian Shu kowtowed and said, "The former governor of Yunzhong, Meng Shu, is such a man." Meng Shu had just been dismissed because the Xiongnu had overrun Yunzhong in force. The emperor said, "The late emperor kept Meng Shu at Yunzhong for more than ten years, yet when the raiders broke in he failed to hold the line, and hundreds of soldiers died for no good reason. Is that the conduct of a 'worthy elder'?" Tian Shu kowtowed and said, "When Guan Gao and his fellow plotters rose against the throne, the Son of Heaven decreed death for three generations of any Zhao official who followed King Zhang—yet Meng Shu shaved his head, took the collar, and followed his lord to the grave. How could he have dreamed he would one day govern Yunzhong? Han and Chu were deadlocked and the army was on its last legs, while Modun had just bent the northern tribes to his will and unleashed them on the frontier. Meng Shu knew his men were too spent to bear another order to battle—yet they stormed the walls like sons defending a father, and hundreds died. That was not Meng Shu driving them to their deaths. That is precisely the mark of a true elder statesman." The emperor exclaimed, "Meng Shu is a remarkable man!" He was summoned back and reappointed governor of Yunzhong.
13
使
Some years later Tian Shu lost his post for a legal infraction. When King Xiao of Liang had the Han adviser Yuan Ang murdered, Emperor Jing sent Tian Shu to investigate the kingdom of Liang; he uncovered the full truth. On his return he was asked, "Did Liang do it?" He answered, "Yes." "Where is the proof?" Tian Shu said, "Your Majesty should not press the matter of Liang. If the king of Liang goes unpunished, the law of the Han is void; if he is executed, the empress dowager will eat without relish and sleep without rest—and that grief will be yours to bear." The emperor admired his judgment and appointed him chancellor to the king of Lu.
14
使 使
Soon after the new chancellor took office, more than a hundred people came forward claiming the king had seized their property. Tian Shu seized their ringleaders and had two thousand men flogged, shouting, "Is the king not your sovereign? How dare you lodge complaints against your own lord!" The king of Lu was mortified; he drew funds from the inner treasury and told the chancellor to make restitution. The chancellor replied, "Let Your Majesty's own agents pay them back; otherwise it will look as though the king did wrong and the minister claimed the credit."
15
The king of Lu loved the chase; the chancellor always accompanied him into the royal park, whereupon the king would send him off to the lodge to rest. The chancellor would sit in the open outside the park and refuse to leave, saying, "While my king endures wind and weather, why should I seek shelter?" After that the king rarely went out on long hunting trips.
16
He died in office some years later. Lu offered his youngest son, Ren, a hundred catties of gold for the funeral, but Ren refused, saying, "Duty forbids my tarnishing my father's reputation."
17
使
Ren, known for his courage, became a retainer of the General of the Guards and repeatedly campaigned against the Xiongnu. The general recommended him for a gentleman of the palace; he rose to two-thousand-bushel rank as chief clerk to the chancellor, then lost his post. Later he was dispatched as inspector over the Three He region; his report pleased the throne, and he was named metropolitan commandant of the capital districts. Within a month he was promoted to superintendent of trials. Some years later, when Crown Prince Li mutinied, Tian Ren, who commanded the gate guard, failed to seal the capital in time and allowed the prince to break out; he was convicted of abetting a traitor, and his entire clan perished with him.
18
The historian's verdict: In an age dominated by Xiang Yu's fury, Ji Bu won fame in Chu for raw courage; he repeatedly charged into battle and tore enemy banners from their poles—a true fighting man. Yet when he was broken, enslaved, and humiliated, he clung to life without yielding his purpose—why was that? He trusted his own abilities; shame did not break him because he still meant to put his gifts to use. In the end he became one of the Han's celebrated generals. A worthy man weighs his death with utmost care. Maids and common folk who work themselves into a passion and take their own lives show no courage—only the shallowest recklessness. Luan Bu mourned Peng Yue at the risk of his life; Tian Shu followed Zhang Ao into chains as if going home. They knew exactly where they stood; the steadfast heroes of old could scarcely have surpassed them.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →