← Back to 漢書

卷五十九 張湯傳

Volume 59: Zhang Tang

Chapter 69 of 漢書 ✓ Translated
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 69
Next Chapter →
1
使
Zhang Tang came from Duling. His father served as assistant magistrate of Chang'an. Whenever the father left on business, the boy Tang stayed behind to watch the house. When he came home, he found a rat had stolen the meat. Angry, he beat Tang with a stick. Tang excavated the burrow, smoked the rat out, recovered the leftover meat, then drew up a formal accusation against the creature. He subjected it to interrogation under torture, filed the written record of the inquest, examined it, passed sentence, and reported the outcome. He produced the rat and the meat as evidence, closed the entire case, and had the convict torn apart alive in the courtyard. When his father read the document, the wording read like that of a veteran prison clerk. He was astonished and thereafter set the boy to drafting legal briefs.
2
調
After his father died, Tang took a minor post as a clerk in Chang'an. The Marquis of Zhouyang had once been held in custody in Chang'an while he was still one of the nine ministers; Tang threw himself into helping him in every way he could. Once the marquis was free and ennobled, he became Tang's steadfast patron and presented him to everyone who mattered at court. Tang was assigned to the metropolitan governor's staff as an aide to Ning Cheng. Deemed reliable, he was recommended to the capital authorities, transferred to the post of captain of Maoling, and put in charge of work within the tomb park.
3
When the Marquis of Wu'an became chancellor, he called Tang up as a clerk on his staff and had him promoted to attendant censor. He prosecuted the witchcraft case involving Empress Chen, tracking every accomplice to the end. The emperor judged him competent and raised him to grand clerk of records. He and Zhao Yu rewrote the statutes and regulations, aiming for severe, tight legal language that would keep petty officials from shirking their responsibilities. Zhao Yu later rose to chamberlain for the palace revenues while Tang became commandant of justice. The two remained on excellent terms, and Tang deferred to Yu as he would to an older brother. Zhao Yu set his heart on impartial public service and stood aloof from intrigue; Tang, by contrast, traded on his wits to manipulate those around him. In his early days as a low clerk he skimmed funds and kept company with wealthy Chang'an traders like Tian Jia and Yu Wengshu. Once he sat among the nine ministers, he cultivated ties with eminent scholars from every quarter. Inwardly he often disagreed with them, yet he publicly affected the rhetoric of classical learning.
4
便 調
The emperor was then turning toward Confucian scholarship. When Tang tried major cases he liked to cloak his rulings in classical precedent, so he asked the court academicians to assign disciples trained in the Documents and the Spring and Autumn to serve as clerks in his office and help iron out disputed interpretations of the law. Whenever he submitted a doubtful case for decision, he first laid out the legal reasoning on both sides for the throne. Whatever the emperor endorsed, he incorporated into the commandant's codified precedents, giving full credit to the sovereign's discernment. If the emperor faulted a memorial as soon as it was presented, Tang at once withdrew it with an apology and bent to the sovereign's wishes. He would then name some worthy among his supervisors or clerks and say, "These men urged that course on me; when Your Majesty censures me, it is because I was too dull to follow their advice." The blame thus rarely stuck to him. When a proposal won praise, he would say, "I cannot claim credit for that memorial—it was drafted by such-and-such a supervisor or clerk." That was how he promoted subordinates: he broadcast their merits and glossed over their lapses. If the emperor wanted a man ruined, Tang handed the file to a clerk known for pitiless severity. If the emperor wished someone spared, he assigned the case to a clerk with a reputation for leniency and even-handedness. Against powerful families he would twist the statute book and frame charges with malicious ingenuity. Against humble, defenseless commoners he would sometimes remark aloud, "The letter of the law may condemn him, but let His Majesty weigh the matter." Time and again the court accepted Tang's wording and let the accused go. Though he had risen to high office, he kept up scrupulous private conduct, entertained a wide circle, and looked after the sons of old friends who held petty posts and his own indigent kinsmen with exceptional generosity. He called on the great ministers in person, whatever the season. So despite legal harshness and a jealous temperament—far from even-handed—he enjoyed a reputation for benevolence. The ruthless clerks who served as his enforcers likewise wrapped themselves in the language of the classics. Chancellor Gongsun Hong often spoke of him in glowing terms.
5
In the treason trials of Huainan, Hengshan, and Jiangdu he pursued every lead to the bottom. The emperor wanted to pardon Yan Zhu and Wu Bei. Tang objected: "Wu Bei helped lay the plot from the beginning, and Yan Zhu enjoyed intimate access to the inner apartments—he was a minister of the ruler's inmost counsels—yet he secretly conspired with the kings. If they are not put to death, the law will never again command respect." The emperor accepted his argument and condemned them. His habit of outmaneuvering senior ministers and claiming the credit in such trials was typical of his style. He was therefore trusted more heavily and promoted to imperial counselor.
6
When Hunye and his followers submitted, the Han mobilized on a vast scale against the Xiongnu; floods and drought struck the eastern heartland; refugees streamed from their homes and looked to the state for relief until the public granaries stood bare. Reading the emperor's wishes, Tang proposed minting the white-metal currency and the five-zhu coin, bringing the empire's salt and iron under state monopoly, squeezing the great merchant houses, promulgating the "report-your-neighbor's-wealth" statute, and breaking up powerful clans that engrossed land and labor—all the while bending the statutes to give the policy a legal veneer. Whenever Tang spoke at audience on fiscal policy, he went on until the sun stood low in the west, and the Son of Heaven forgot his meal. The chancellor was a figurehead; every important decision passed through Tang. Common folk could not live in peace; unrest spread. State ventures brought little gain while corrupt clerks fed on the people, so Tang cracked down with harsh punishments. From the highest ministers to the meanest commoner, everyone blamed Tang. When Tang fell ill, the emperor visited his house in person—such was the height of his favor.
7
便 便 使 使使
The Xiongnu sued for a marriage alliance. At the council before the throne, Academician Di Shan said, "An alliance by marriage is the prudent course." The emperor asked why. Shan replied, "Arms are unlucky instruments; they should not be lightly wielded again and again. Gaozu tried to strike the Xiongnu and was trapped in desperate straits at Pingcheng; after that he settled for peace through intermarriage." Under Emperor Hui and Empress Lü the realm knew quiet prosperity. When Emperor Wen turned against the Xiongnu, the northern frontier knew nothing but the miseries of war. Under Emperor Jing the seven kingdoms of Wu and Chu rose in revolt; the emperor shuttled between the two palace complexes while the whole country held its breath for months on end. After Wu and Chu were crushed, Jing never again spoke of major campaigns, and the realm grew wealthy and secure. Since Your Majesty took the field against the Xiongnu, the interior has been drained and the frontier left exhausted and destitute. Judged by that record, an alliance is still the better policy." The emperor turned to Tang, who said, "That is the talk of a pedantic scholar who understands nothing." Di Shan retorted, "I may be a simple loyalist, but your imperial counselor is loyal only in pretense. In the Huainan and Jiangdu trials he stretched the law to vilify the kings, pitting kin against kin until no prince felt safe at his post. That is the loyalty I call false." The emperor's face darkened. "I give you one commandery," he said. "Could you keep the raiders out?" "No," said Shan. "What about one county?" "I could not," Shan admitted. "Very well—one fortified barrier sector along the wall?" Shan saw he had argued himself into a corner and would soon be handed over to the law; he answered, "I could." The emperor promptly sent him to hold a signal tower on the frontier. A little over a month later the Xiongnu rode up and took his head. After that no minister dared speak lightly against the war party.
8
Tang's client Tian Jia was a tradesman, yet he lived by a stern code of honor. Tang had borrowed money from him in his clerk days; after Tang rose high, Jia still rebuked his conduct like a man ready to die for principle.
9
Seven years as imperial counselor ended in his downfall.
10
使 使 使
Li Wen of Hedong had long been Tang's enemy. When Wen became vice director of the imperial secretariat, he combed the palace files for anything that might incriminate Tang and showed him no quarter. Tang kept a favorite clerk, Lu Yéju, who saw how Tang brooded on the grudge. Yéju arranged for a sealed denunciation accusing Wen of misconduct; when the case landed in Tang's hands, he tried Wen and had him executed, all the while knowing Yéju was the author of the charge. The emperor asked, "Who is behind this anonymous accusation?" Tang put on a show of surprise. "Almost certainly some old enemy of Li Wen," he said. When Yéju fell ill and lodged with a neighbor, Tang visited him in person and massaged his feet. The kingdom of Zhao lived by its foundries; its king repeatedly sued the monopoly officials, and Tang as a rule ruled against the king. The King of Zhao set out to dig up dirt on Tang. Yéju had once prosecuted the king, who nursed a grudge. The king now sent up a joint memorial: "Zhang Tang is a chief minister; when his clerk Yéju fell ill, Tang actually massaged the man's feet—clear evidence of some monstrous conspiracy between them." The case was referred to the commandant of justice. Yéju died before trial, but the investigation ensnared his younger brother, who was locked up in the guide office prison. Tang happened to be interrogating other inmates there. When he saw Yéju's brother, he meant to help him quietly while pretending not to notice him. The brother did not understand and blamed Tang; he had someone memorialize that Tang and Yéju had conspired to frame Li Wen. The case was assigned to Jian Xuan. Xuan had old scores with Tang; he seized the chance to investigate to the limit, though he had not yet reported his findings. Then robbers broke into the burial mound in Emperor Wen's mausoleum park and stole the consecrated coins. At court Chancellor Zhuang Qingzhai agreed with Tang that they would both apologize. When they came before the throne, Tang reflected that only the chancellor made the seasonal rounds of the shrines and therefore bore responsibility; he himself had nothing to do with it, so he offered no apology. The chancellor apologized alone, and the emperor ordered the censorate to look into the matter. Tang meant to shape the documentary evidence so as to implicate the chancellor in prior knowledge; the chancellor grew alarmed. The three chief clerks of the chancellor's office hated Tang and conspired to destroy him.
11
使 使使簿 使
Chief Clerk Zhu Maichen had nursed a grudge against Tang for years—the story is told in his own chapter. Wang Chao of Qi had risen to right metropolitan superintendent through his technical expertise. Bian Tong was a specialist in the "short and long" school of persuasion—abrasive, violent-tempered. He had served as chancellor of the kingdom of Jinan. All three had once outranked Tang; later they were stripped of their posts and ended up as chief clerks under him, forced to humble themselves. Whenever Tang acted for the chancellor, he knew how exalted these three had been and took every chance to humiliate them. The three chief clerks put their heads together. "At first Zhang Tang pledged to apologize with you," they said, "then he betrayed you; now he means to impeach you over the desecration of the imperial tombs because he wants your seat; and we know the dirty secrets he is hiding." They had agents seize Tang's confederate Tian Xin, charging that whenever Tang was about to memorialize a ruling, Xin learned of it in advance, cornered goods, grew rich, and split the profits with Tang. They added further counts of misconduct. Word of the accusations began to reach the throne. The emperor asked Tang, "Whatever policy I mean to adopt, the merchants seem to know it in advance and stockpile accordingly. Someone must be leaking my deliberations." Tang offered no denial and again feigned surprise: "No doubt there is." Jian Xuan weighed in with his own memorial on the Yéju business. Convinced that Tang had lied to his face, the emperor dispatched eight successive envoys to cross-examine him from the written record. Tang insisted he was innocent and refused to confess. The emperor then sent Zhao Yu to confront him. When Zhao Yu arrived, he rebuked Tang. "Have you no sense of proportion? Think how many families you have destroyed in the cases you have tried! Every charge against you now carries weight. His Majesty is moving to commit you to prison so you may settle your own affairs—why prolong the interrogation with endless denials?" Tang then drafted a memorial of apology: "I began as a mere scribal clerk and owe my rise to the three highest offices entirely to Your Majesty's favor—yet I have failed in my responsibility. Those who schemed to bring me down are the three chief clerks of the chancellor's office." He then took his own life.
12
At his death his estate amounted to no more than five hundred catties of gold, every ounce of it from official salary and imperial gifts—nothing ill-gotten. His brothers and sons wanted an elaborate funeral. His mother said, "He was a chief minister of the throne and died under a cloud of slander—what good would pomp do?" He was taken to the grave on an ox cart, in a plain inner coffin with no outer shell. When the emperor heard, he remarked, "Only such a mother could have raised such a son." He then had all three chief clerks arrested, tried, and executed. Chancellor Zhuang Qingzhai committed suicide. Tian Xin was cleared and released. The emperor still regretted Tang's fate and began again to advance his son Zhang Anshi.
13
His son: Zhang Anshi.
14
祿
Zhang Anshi, courtesy name Ziru, entered the court in his youth as a gentleman-attendant by virtue of his father's rank. His neat calligraphy won him a post with the Masters of Writing. He threw himself into the work and never left the capital even on his statutory days off. On an imperial progress to Hedong three document cases went missing. An edict summoned anyone who could identify them; only Anshi recognized the files from memory and wrote out their contents in full. When the originals were later recovered and checked, nothing was missing. The emperor was so impressed that he promoted him to director of the Masters of Writing, then to grand coachman of the household.
15
使
At that time Huo Guang's son Huo Yu held the post of general of the right while also bearing the title of grand marshal. The emperor stripped him of his field command, leaving the grand marshal's title a hollow honor while removing his real military following. A little over a year later Huo Yu rose in rebellion and his entire clan was wiped out. Anshi, who had always been cautious and easily alarmed, was already anxious at heart. His granddaughter Zhang Jing had married into a Huo-affiliated family and stood liable to collective punishment. Anshi grew haggard with dread, and it showed on his face. The emperor noticed, took pity, asked his attendants for the story, and pardoned Jing to set his mind at ease. His fear only deepened. He held the levers of confidential policy, winning a reputation for meticulous care. Not a whisper of what passed in the inner palace reached the outer court through him, nor vice versa. Whenever a major decision had been taken, he would plead illness and withdraw; and if he then heard that an edict had been issued, he would start in alarm and dispatch a clerk to the chancellor's office to learn what it said. Even senior ministers at court had no idea that he had been in on the discussion.
16
調
Once he recommended a man for office. When the appointee came to thank him in person, Anshi was furious: recommending talent for the public good was not an occasion for private gratitude. He broke with the man entirely, then after a cooling interval allowed the relationship to resume—on his own terms. A gentleman-attendant of long and distinguished service had not been promoted and spoke up for himself. Anshi replied, "Your record is known to the enlightened ruler. A subject does his duty—why should he bargain over seniority in his own voice?" He refused outright. The man was promoted soon afterward in any case. When his headquarters chief clerk was promoted and came to say farewell before leaving for his new command, Anshi asked whether he had ever found fault with his administration. The chief clerk said, "You are the sovereign's right arm, yet you never push candidates forward. Critics call that a fault." Anshi answered, "When a clear-sighted ruler sits on the throne, the worthy and the unworthy sort themselves out. Subjects have only to mind their own conduct—why should I play patron to office-seekers?" That was how far he went to efface his own footprint and keep clear of factional power.
17
祿便殿漿
While he was superintendent of the household, a gentleman-attendant relieved himself on the palace floor while drunk. The duty officer asked leave to prosecute. Anshi said, "How can we be sure it was not wine he spilled? Why turn a minor slip into a criminal offense?" Another attendant forced himself on a palace maidservant; her brother laid a complaint. Anshi said, "The girl is a bondservant venting spite—she slanders a man who wears official cap and gown." He had the girl reassigned as a punishment slave. His habit of covering others' missteps ran in this vein throughout his career.
18
Seeing how exalted he and his father had become, Anshi grew uneasy. He asked that his son Yanshou be given a provincial post, and the emperor appointed Yanshou governor of Beidi. A year later, pitying Anshi's age, the emperor recalled Yanshou to court as left aide in the secretariat and chamberlain for the imperial stud.
19
Though ennobled at the highest rank with a fief of ten thousand households, he dressed in plain black silk and his wife spun the household's cloth herself. Seven hundred retainers were each put to skilled manual labor. He micromanaged the family estates, pinching every cash, until his private wealth outstripped even Grand General Huo Guang's. The emperor treated Huo Guang with awe and kept him at a distance, but he was genuinely intimate with Anshi in a way he never was with Guang.
20
Anshi's son: Zhang Yanshou.
21
Yanshou's son: Zhang Bo.
22
Bo's son: Zhang Lin.
23
殿
Zhang Lin was as modest and frugal as his forebears. Whenever he climbed the towered halls of the palace, he would sigh, "The houses of Sang and Huo are my warning—how stern a lesson that is!" As death approached, he distributed his goods among kinsmen and old friends and ordered a simple burial with no tumulus. Zhang Lin married Princess Jingwu. When he died, his son Zhang Fang succeeded him.
24
Lin's son: Zhang Fang.
25
輿 使
During the Hongjia era Emperor Cheng wished to revive Emperor Wu's habit of informal outings and banquets with his inner circle. Zhang Fang, as the princess's son—quick-witted and polished—won exceptional favor. Zhang Fang married the daughter of Xu Jia, the Marquis of Ping'en and younger brother of the empress. The emperor staged the wedding himself, granted a mansion of the first rank, and filled it with wardrobe and ornaments from the imperial workshops, so that courtiers quipped it was as if the Son of Heaven had taken a bride and the empress had given her daughter away. The palace stewards of both households provisioned the estate without stint; couriers from the two palaces arrived in an unbroken stream of carriages; gifts ran into the tens of millions of cash. Zhang Fang held concurrent rank as palace attendant and general of the household gentlemen, commanded the encamped troops at Pingyue, maintained a full staff, and enjoyed ceremonial honors equal to a field general. He attended the emperor waking and sleeping and stood alone in favor. He was the constant companion on disguised excursions—north to Ganquan, south to the hunting parks of Changyang and Wuzuo, cockfighting and racing horses through the streets of Chang'an—for years on end.
26
使使 使使 使駿 調 宿
The emperor's uncles on his mother's side grew jealous of his influence and complained to the empress dowager. She rebuked Zhang Fang harshly, saying the emperor was still young and his conduct at court and abroad lacked restraint. Omens and disasters multiplied at the time, and memorialists laid the blame at the door of Zhang Fang and his like. Chancellor Xuan and Imperial Counselor Zhu Fangjin therefore submitted a joint memorial: "Zhang Fang is insolent, overbearing, and utterly without self-control—profligate and debauched beyond measure. When four attendant censors led by Xiu were sent to his house to arrest wanted men by name, Zhang Fang was at home. His slaves barred the gates, strung crossbows, and fired on the officers, defying the imperial messengers and refusing them entry. Learning that a commoner named Li Youjun meant to offer a daughter in marriage to the throne, he had Jing Wu, the music bureau's intendant for pitch pipes, try to seize the girl for himself and fail, then sent ruffians such as Ru Kang to Li's house; they left three people wounded. On another occasion, nursing a grudge against the music-house patrol officer Mang over a county matter, he dispatched more than forty chief slaves led by Jun, armed to the teeth. In full daylight they stormed the music bureau, shot up the yamen, seized the chief clerk's sons and nephews, smashed furniture and equipment, and threw the inner palace into panic. The chief clerk's son Ben shaved his head and donned the convict's iron collar and red robe in token of submission, while the yeoman Diao and the other clerks went barefoot to Zhang Fang's gate to kowtow in apology—only then did he call off his men. His slaves and their hangers-on traded on his power: they murdered a magistrate whose wife they could not take, slaughtered the kin of anyone who offended them, then took refuge inside Zhang Fang's compound. When the authorities could not lay hands on them, they often walked away unpunished. Zhang Fang's conduct was reckless and he piled up grave crimes, enough to disturb the balance of nature. He stood first among disloyal ministers. His guilt was obvious, yet he had long enjoyed imperial indulgence. Such wanton disregard of duty is little short of treason. No subject's wickedness could exceed this. He must not remain in the palace guard. We beg that Zhang Fang be stripped of office and sent to his fief, to nip this evil in the bud and give the empire what it wants to hear."
27
祿
The emperor, unable to refuse outright, relegated Zhang Fang to commandant of Beidi. Within a few months he was recalled to serve again as palace attendant. At the empress dowager's insistence he was transferred out again, this time as commandant of the Tianshui dependent state. During the Yongshi and Yuanyan reign periods eclipses came year after year, so the emperor kept Zhang Fang away from the capital for a long stretch, though edicts of inquiry and reassurance followed him without cease. After more than a year abroad he was allowed home to his mansion to nurse his mother, the princess, in her illness. When she had recovered several months later, he posted Zhang Fang as commandant of Hedong. The emperor still loved Zhang Fang, but he could not withstand pressure from the empress dowager above and his ministers below, and more than once he dismissed him with tears in his eyes. Later he recalled Zhang Fang to serve as palace attendant and grand coachman at the middle rank of two thousand piculs. A year later Chancellor Zhu Fangjin renewed the attack. The emperor had no choice but to dismiss Zhang Fang, grant him five million cash, and order him to his fief. A few months later Emperor Cheng died. Zhang Fang grieved so deeply that he wept himself to death.
28
Long before, Anshi's eldest son Zhang Qianqiu and Huo Guang's son Huo Yu had both been generals of the household gentlemen when they campaigned under the Trans-Liao general Fan Mingyou against the Wuhuan. On their return they called on Huo Guang, who questioned Qianqiu about tactics and terrain. Qianqiu answered from memory, sketching the campaign map in the dust without a single error. When he put the same questions to Huo Yu, Yu could not recall a thing and said, "It is all on file somewhere." From that day Huo Guang respected Qianqiu and wrote Yu off as worthless, sighing, "The house of Huo is fading; the house of Zhang is on the rise!" After the Huo clan was extirpated, Zhang Anshi's descendants held one high post after another. From the reigns of Xuandi and Yuandi onward, more than ten of them served as palace attendants, regular attendants, mounted escorts in the various bureaus, or colonels of the guard. Of all the families ennobled for merit, only the Jins and the Zhangs remained so close to the throne—almost like imperial in-laws.
29
Zhang Fang's son: Zhang Chun.
30
Zhang Chun, Zhang Fang's son, succeeded to the marquisate. He was modest, frugal, and self-disciplined, thoroughly versed in Han institutions and precedent, and carried something of the old Marquis Jing's manner. He kept his title even under Wang Mang, and in the Jianwu era rose step by step to grand minister of works; Guangwudi carved a detached village out of the old Fuping fief and re-enfeoffed him as marquis of Wushi.
31
The Zhangs had begun at Duling. Zhang Anshi's household moved with each imperial tomb town under Wudi, Zhaodi, and Xuandi—three relocations in all—before returning to Duling.
32
滿
The historian's comment: Feng Shang claimed that Zhang Tang's line shared an ancestor with the Marquis of Liu, but Sima Qian does not say so, and we leave the point aside. Since the founding of Han, hundreds of families have received marquisates, yet none has held its fortune and imperial favor as steadily as Fuping. Zhang Tang was a cruel judge and came to a bad end himself, yet in promoting able men and speaking well of others he earned the posterity he deserved. Zhang Anshi walked the middle path—his cup was full, yet he never let it spill. The quiet kindness Zhang He once showed the future Emperor Xuan also played its part in the family's lasting good fortune.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →