← Back to 金史

卷八十三 列傳第二十一: 張通古 張浩子:汝霖 張玄素 張汝弼 耶律安禮 納合椿年 祁宰

Volume 83 Biographies 21: Zhang Tonggu, Zhang Hao son: Rulin, Zhang Xuansu, Zhang Rubi, Ye Luanli, Na Hechunnian, Qi Zai

Chapter 83 of 金史 · History of Jin
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 83
Next Chapter →
1
:椿
Biographies 21: Zhang Tonggu; Zhang Hao, son Rulin; Zhang Xuansu; Zhang Rubi; Yelu Anli; Na Hechunnian; and Qi Zai
2
Zhang Tonggu
3
使 使使 西使 使使 西使西 使 退宿 使
Zhang Tonggu, whose style name was Lezhi, came from Yi County in Yi Prefecture. Whatever he read stayed with him at a glance; he commanded the full range of classical learning and history, and wrote with uncommon skill. He earned his jinshi degree in the second year of the Liao era name Tianqing (1112) and took a post as clerk in the Privy Council. After his father's death, the court recalled him from mourning back to office; he pleaded to stay home but was overruled, so he slipped away and withdrew to live quietly at Xingping. After the Jin founder Taizu took Yanjing, the city was handed over to the Song. The Song court, eager to attract distinguished talent, summoned Tonggu. Tonggu refused the offer and went into hiding at the foot of Mount Taining in Yi Prefecture. When Wuzongwang reclaimed Yanjing, Liu Yanzong—already a friend—recognized Tonggu's ability and made him chief memorialist in the Privy Council, then transferred him to head the military and punishments bureau. In the fourth year of Tianhui (1126), with the new Department of State Affairs in place, he was made Vice Minister of Works and put in charge of all six ministries at once. Gao Qingyi introduced a merit-review system that stripped many officials of their posts, and Tonggu lost his office as well. Prince Zonggan had long known Tonggu by reputation and valued his talent; he sent an envoy urging him to plead his own case and win reinstatement. Tonggu refused, saying, "So many men of learning have already left office—what sort of heart would I have to seek a post for myself alone?" Zonggan argued the case on his behalf. He was appointed Deputy Military Commissioner of the Central Capital and sent as envoy to deliver the imperial edict to the south; the Song emperor wanted to face south while obliging Tonggu to face north. Tonggu said, "A minister of a great power should stand before the ruler of a lesser state. The Son of Heaven has granted Henan and Shaanxi to Song, and Song has pledged to submit memorials as a vassal—an envoy cannot be made to face north. If you mean to demean the envoy, the envoy will not dare deliver the edict." He then called for his horses and prepared to return north. The Song emperor hastily had east and west seats arranged—the envoy facing east, the emperor facing west—and the reception of the edict, bowing, and rising all followed proper ritual. On his return he learned that Song had already posted garrisons in Henan, and said to his escort Han Xiaozhou, "The Son of Heaven has carved out territory to enlarge your southern realm; the south ought to think how to repay so great a favor. Now you rashly post guards and invite suspicion; if an army marches to demand an accounting, what excuse will you offer? The lands south of the Yangzi cannot even be held secure—how much less the Qi region?" Xiaozhou said in alarm, "I have heard and will obey." He immediately galloped off to report to the Song emperor. The Song emperor hastily ordered the garrisons withdrawn. Tonggu reached the Supreme Capital and reported everything to Zonggan, adding, "While their deployments are still unsettled, we ought to discuss taking the territory back." Zonggan said with delight, "That has long been my intent." He was immediately appointed Acting Commissioner of the Branch Secretariat at the Regional Command. Before long, an edict ordered Zongbi to retake Henan; Tonggu asked to go ahead to Bian first and deliver the message. By the time he reached Bian, the Song forces had already withdrawn. Someone told Tonggu, "The Song withdrawal was a feint; we now hear they will strike from Xu and Su prefectures." Tonggu said, "When southerners announce they are coming, that is exactly how they cover a retreat." He sent scouts, and the Song forces had indeed broken and fled. Zongbi slapped his thigh and laughed. "Who says a scholar cannot understand war?"
4
滿
A Henan soldier named Sun Jin falsely claimed to be "the emperor's younger brother, the Investigating Grand Prince" and plotted a revolt. At this time Prince Hailing was Chancellor; he already coveted the throne and wished first to eliminate Emperor Xizong's younger brother, Prince Zuowang Changsheng. Because Sun Jin had claimed to be the imperial younger brother and grand prince, Hailing named Zuowang as the culprit and framed him. Since Crown Prince Ji'an's death, Emperor Xizong had no settled heir, and the matter weighed heavily on his mind. Empress Pusan was domineering, and he could not have his way in the inner palace; he grew depressed, drank heavily, and in drunken confusion would fly into rage and kill men with his own hand. When Hailing slandered Prince Zuowang, Emperor Xizong believed it without question and sent the guardsman Tesi to Bianjing to investigate. The Regional Command knew the emperor's mind was fixed on Prince Zuowang and steered Sun Jin's testimony to implicate him. Tonggu seized on the flaw in the case and argued strenuously to stop it. When Sun Jin confessed, it emerged that he had only borrowed a grand title to deceive the crowd and extort wealth—no such prince existed at all. Tesi submitted his report; Hailing slandered him, saying, "Tesi is even now currying favor with Prince Zuowang." The emperor trusted Hailing all the more, had Prince Zuowang killed, and killed Tesi as well. The Regional Command officials then reproached Tonggu: "You misled us—we now face death as accomplices." Tonggu said, "To die punished for doing what is right is better than living in disgrace." Once Hailing had killed Prince Zuowang, he did not pursue the others; only Tesi was punished, and the Regional Command was spared.
5
At the opening of the Tiande era, he was made Left Vice Commissioner of the Regional Command, then Grand Councilor, enfeoffed as Prince of Tan, and later as Prince of Yun. He asked to be relieved of state affairs on grounds of illness, but the request was denied. He was appointed Grand Mentor and enfeoffed as Prince of Shen. Hailing ruled his subordinates with severity and kept power tightly in hand; princes and great ministers rarely saw even a trace of warmth from him—only toward Tonggu did he always show courtesy.
6
殿 簿 使
It happened that the monk Fabao of Cizhou wished to leave; Zhang Hao and Zhang Hui tried to keep him but could not, and other court officials also wanted him to stay. Hailing heard of it and summoned officials of the third rank and above, rebuking them: "I hear that whenever you visit the temple, the monk Fabao sits in the place of honor while you sit at his side—I find this unacceptable. The Buddha was once a prince of a small kingdom who willingly gave up wealth and rank, disciplined himself in hardship, and thereby attained enlightenment—hence the reverence he receives today. To seek blessings and profit from him is mere delusion. Moreover, monks are often failed examination candidates and marketplace drifters who turn to the cloth when they cannot make a living; in rank they are not fit to receive the same ceremonial treatment as clerks and assistant magistrates. Old women in the lanes, facing death, mostly put their faith in them. You hold the rank of chief ministers, yet you imitate this—it is unworthy of your station. Grand Mentor Zhang is a seasoned elder versed in all three teachings and fit to serve as your model—why not learn from him?" He summoned Fabao and said, "You are a monk—whether you stay or go is your own affair. Why let the court know of it?" Fabao trembled in fear and did not know what to do. Hailing said, "You are a senior monk and ought to have firm resolve—are you afraid of death now?" He had Fabao beaten two hundred strokes in the court hall; Zhang Hao and Zhang Hui received twenty strokes each.
7
Tonggu was by nature cheerful and unpretentious; though he held the rank of chief minister, he lived as simply as a poor scholar. His son Chen passed the examinations in the third year of Tiande on the Yang Jianzhong list.
8
簿 使使
Zhang Hao, whose style name was Haoran, came from the Bohai community in Liaoyang. His family had originally borne the surname Gao and descended from the King of Dongming. His great-grandfather Ba served the Liao and took the surname Zhang. During the Tianfu era, when eastern Liao was pacified, Hao won Taizu's attention with a policy proposal and was appointed to handle documents before the throne. In the eighth year of Tianhui (1130) he received his jinshi degree and was appointed Secretary Gentleman. When Emperor Taizong was about to visit the Eastern Capital, Hao supervised repairs to the inner palace, was promoted out of turn to Minister of the Court for the Imperial Clan, acted as provisional signatory of the Palace Domestic Service, managed documents before the throne, and first established court ritual. He asked leave to care for his parents and resigned his post. He was recalled and appointed prefect of Zhao Prefecture. When the new official system took effect, he served as Grand Master of the Palace and Minister of Justice. In the second year of Tianjuan (1138) he codified inner and outer ceremonial forms, served successively as vice minister of Revenue, Works, and Rites, and was promoted to Minister of Rites. When the Tian Jue faction affair broke, the censorate and secretariat were emptied out, and Hao was put in charge of all six ministries. Documents piled up in heaps, yet he decided and dispatched without delay; people admired his ability. On grounds of illness he sought a provincial post and was appointed military commissioner of Zhangde Army, then director-general of transport for the Yanjing circuit. Before long he was appointed prefect of Pingyang. Pingyang had many bandits; when Hao captured a Linfen man who had robbed a woman by night, he had him publicly executed, and banditry soon subsided. In the suburbs there was an illicit shrine that many in the prefecture patronized. The temple acolyte and the field-holder disputed the profits from offerings and incense, and for years the case went unresolved. Hao demolished the shrine and cast its images into the water. Powerful clans and crafty clerks withdrew from sight, and none dared offend. The prefecture was brought to excellent order. He then repaired the shrine of Emperor Yao and built the Pavilion of the Surviving Custom of Beating the Earth.
9
使
Hailing summoned him as Minister of Revenue and appointed him Vice Grand Councilor. In the second year of Tiande he entered mourning for his mother. Recalled from mourning, he resumed as Vice Grand Councilor and was promoted to Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. In the third year of Tiande the walls of Yanjing were expanded and palace buildings were constructed. Hao, together with the Yanjing military commissioner Liu Qia and the prefect of Daming Lu Yanlun, supervised the work, and Hao was authorized to propose appointments on the spot. Before long, in the hot summer months, many laborers fell ill with epidemic disease. An edict dispatched physicians within five hundred li of Yanjing to treat them, with medicines supplied by the state; those who saved many lives were granted office, the next rank received rewards, and the lowest were to be investigated and reported by the transport commission.
10
使 使殿
Hailing planned to attack Song and was about to visit Bian, but fire destroyed the inner palace at Bianjing; he therefore put Hao and Jing Sihui in charge of building the Southern Capital palaces. Hao calmly memorialized, "When the Central Capital was built in former years, the realm gladly rallied to the work. The people's strength has not yet recovered; if we burden them again, I fear the work will not be completed as easily as before." His advice was not heeded. When Hao took leave at court, Hailing asked about the advantages and disadvantages of going to war. Hao did not dare speak bluntly; he answered in guarded terms, hoping in a small way to dissuade Hailing from going to war, and memorialized, "I observe that Heaven has long intended to end the Zhao line." Hailing was startled. "How do you know that?" He answered, "Zhao Gou has no heir; if a distant collateral is enthroned, turmoil is sure to follow, and the Song can be brought to heel without the trouble of war." Hailing was pleased with what he heard, but he would not act on it. When Hao arrived at Bian, Hailing repeatedly sent the eunuch Liang Chong to inspect the work; the completion of a single hall cost vast sums. Chong would point and say, "This part does not meet the prescribed form. Chong would have it torn down at once. Hao could not stand up to him and accorded him equal ritual standing. When the Bian palace was finished, Hailing came from Yan to take up residence there. Hao was appointed Grand Tutor and Director of the Department of State Affairs and was further enfeoffed as Duke of Qin.
11
After Hailing reached Bian, he went months without holding court, drilling troops daily for the southern campaign and deploying his generals. Hao wished to present memorials on state affairs but could not gain an audience. When Hailing sent Zhou Fu'er to Hao's house, Hao attached a memorial: "The generals are all newly promoted youths; I fear they will mishandle state affairs. You should seek veterans skilled in warfare and appoint them as thousand-household leaders and company commanders." But Hailing had already fixed his deployments; he hated to hear this and had Hao beaten with the staff. Hailing was to lead the army out from Bianjing himself, while the empress and crown prince stayed behind to guard the capital. Hao remained behind to administer the Department of State Affairs.
12
使使
Shizong took the throne at Liaoyang; the army at Yangzhou mutinied, and Hailing was assassinated. An envoy of the military governor killed Crown Prince Guang Ying at the Southern Capital. Hao sent Wanyan Mouyan, an outer-office official of the Ministry of Revenue, to present a congratulatory memorial. In the second month of the following year, Hao came to the capital for court and was received in audience. Shizong said to him, "I reflect that the throne is hard to hold; day and night I am vigilant and afraid, with no leisure to rest easy. You are an elder of the state; exert yourself to help govern, so that posterity may praise your virtuous rule and you do not betray the trust I place in you." Soon after he was appointed Grand Preceptor and Director of the Department of State Affairs and enfeoffed as Prince of Nanyang Commandery. Shizong said, "In the Zhenlong era you were chief minister and could not set things right—how can you be without fault? Building the two palaces exhausted the people; you did remonstrate, so the realm does not blame you but only resents the Zhenlong reign. Yet you served in the Secretariat for more than ten years and know government affairs well; that is why I employ you again as chancellor. Exert yourself and do not betray my intent." Hao kowtowed in thanks. A few days later Shizong told Hao, "As Director of the Department of State Affairs, whenever you find usable talent, you should recommend and appoint it." Hao recommended Heshilie Zhining and others; they all later became renowned ministers.
13
殿 退
Hao fell ill and was on extended sick leave. The emperor sent Left Department Director Gao Kan and Hao's nephew Zhang Rubi to convey his instructions. Hao dragged himself in despite his illness; the court at once ordered that he need not bow on entering, granted him a seat east of the palace steps, and required him to advance for audience only when consultation was needed. If he was unwell, he need not come to the Secretariat every day; major affairs could be decided at his home. Though Hao accepted the edict, he repeatedly asked to retire. In the summer of the third year he renewed his earlier request. He was then appointed acting military governor of the Eastern Capital. Illness kept him from taking up the post, and he asked to retire.
14
使
Earlier, a close attendant had wanted to abolish the civil-service examinations; the emperor said, "I will hear what the Grand Preceptor has to say." When Hao came in for audience, the emperor asked, "Has there ever been an emperor who dispensed with literary learning?" Hao answered, "There has." The emperor asked, "Who?" Hao said, "Qin Shihuang." The emperor turned to his attendants and said, "Am I to be another First Emperor!" The proposal was dropped.
15
使
That year he died. The emperor suspended court for one day. An edict ordered Left Palace Attendant Zhao Xingxiang to lead the officials in offering condolences, with funeral gifts of a thousand taels of silver, fifty bolts of fine colored silk, and five hundred bolts of plain silk. His posthumous title was Wenkang. In the fifth year of Mingchang he was granted a place in the sacrifices at Shizong's temple. In the first year of Taihe his portrait was placed in Yansqing Palace. His sons were Ruwei, Rulin, Runeng, Rufang, and Ruyou.
16
His son Rulin
17
Rulin, whose style name was Zhongze, was clever and studious from youth; Hao once said of him, "He is the thousand-li steed of our house." In the second year of Zhenyuan he was granted the jinshi degree immediately below Lü Zhonghan on the examination list, was specially appointed Left Remonstrator, became magistrate of Daxing County, and was twice promoted to Outer-office Director of the Ministry of Rites and Hanlin Academician-in-Waiting. In the eighth year of Dading he was appointed Director of the Ministry of Punishments; summoned to audience in the Fragrant Pavilion, the emperor told him, "You are being moved from academician-in-waiting to director—do not take it as a demotion. The Ministry of Punishments lacks Han officials, which is why I am giving you the post. Besides, you have not been in office long; for now I am only testing what you can do. If you discharge your duties well, you will be promoted. Your father the Grand Preceptor rose from Minister of Revenue to chancellor, leaping from Chongde Grand Master to Golden Purple rank—you have seen it with your own eyes. Give your whole heart to the task and do not disgrace your father." The following year he was appointed Left Tutor of the Heir Apparent, while retaining the concurrent post of Outer-office Director of the Ministry of Rites.
18
使
Earlier, Wang Zhen, director of the Petition Office for Hearing Grievances, had been transferred to Outer-office Director of the Ministry of Rites; Shizong told the chief ministers, "This appointment does not satisfy public expectation; a ritual post should go to a learned man, such as Zhang Rulin." Rulin was then ordered to hold the post concurrently while Wang Zhen was reassigned. He was promoted to Vice Director of the Ministry of Punishments. He left office to observe mourning, then was recalled as Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent and promoted to Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent, concurrently serving as Censor-in-Chief. Shizong summoned him and said, "You once observed that investigating censors often win reputation for county and prefectural officials through trading favors, while good officials who simply uphold the law and make no display go unrecommended. I feel the same. Now that you head the Censorate, you can reform this abuse." Soon after he was made Metropolitan Transport Commissioner of the Zhongdu Circuit, Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent concurrently Minister of Rites, then transferred to the Ministry of Personnel and appointed Censor-in-Chief.
19
簿 使
At that time Gao Dewen, registrar of the imperial mausoleum district at Jiangling, had extorted large amounts of rice from tax households and was arrested by the Censorate. Rulin submitted two alternative penalties for the emperor's decision. Shizong rebuked him: "I promoted you because I thought you impartial. Dewen has connections in the inner palace, so I know this case well. Would I bend the law for palace favoritism? I did not expect you to show such partiality." Rulin knelt and apologized. After a while the emperor turned to Left Remonstrator Yang Boren and said, "The censorial officials are this corrupt." Boren replied, "When guilt is uncertain, the law favors leniency; that is why two penalties were submitted for Your Majesty to decide. Besides, good men are hard to find; better a dull but upright official than a clever but corrupt one." The emperor's face darkened. "You are all dull and not upright." Before long he was again demoted—for failing to expose the offenses of Gao Gongmei, push-official of Daxing—and appointed Defender of Di Prefecture. Soon he was again made Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent, concurrently Minister of Rites. He was appointed Vice Grand Councillor while retaining his post as Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent. That same day Rulin's elder brother Zhang Rubi was also promoted to Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs, to the envy of contemporaries.
20
''
Later, during a court session when he was discussing affairs before the throne, Shizong said to him, "Reading Tang history, I see that Taizong at first was fiercely diligent, but in his later years his discussions with ministers were often mere fine phrases; I am not like that." He added, "Emperor Taizong of Tang was an enlightened ruler, yet even he erred in his later years. I cannot match sage-kings and enlightened rulers, but I constantly strive to be the same man from first to last. Though I am old now, my reverent caution never slackens for a moment." Rulin replied, "The ancients said, 'Everything has a beginning, but few keep the end'—only the sage has both beginning and end! What Wei Zheng meant when he said that preserving what has been won is hard refers precisely to this." The emperor agreed. In the twenty-fifth year Zhangzong, as Prince Yuan, was put in charge of Daxing Prefecture; the emperor ordered Rulin to attend only on days when there was business and to tutor him closely. Soon he was demoted one rank for disbursing on his own authority the food allowances of the Eastern Palace's imperial grandsons. After a time he was transferred to Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs.
21
祿
By then Shizong had reigned long and knew the realm thoroughly; he wanted worthy men with whom to pursue good government, but his chief ministers all hedged and muddled through, recommending no one. One day Shizong summoned the chief ministers and said, "You sit in the highest offices—why have you never recommended anyone? Besides, you are old; is there really no one among you fit to succeed you? Only when I say that someone is usable do you chime in. If you offer nothing yourselves and men are promoted only after I have discovered them, how many more years will that take?" He then turned to Rulin and said, "Take the vice director here—even he came to my attention only because the right chancellor mentioned him." Rulin replied, "Had we known anyone worthy, we would never have hesitated to recommend him. The trouble is simply that there is no one." The emperor said, "In the Spring and Autumn era the states were fragmented and their territories small, yet each still claimed to possess worthy men. Today the realm is vast—how can there be no talent? It is only that you refuse to recommend anyone. Now I must drive myself on if we are ever to reach good government. When I am gone, with whom will my descendants share the work of rule?" Rulin and the others could only sit there, ashamed. In the twenty-eighth year he was promoted to Grand Councilor, made concurrent compiler of the national history, and enfeoffed as Duke of Rui. When Shizong fell ill, he and Grand Marshal Tushan Kening and Right Chancellor Xiang together received the dying emperor's testament. Zhangzong ascended the throne. He received the title Grand Master of Splendid Happiness with Silver-Green Tally and was promoted to Duke of Shen.
22
使便 使
Earlier, Right Chancellor Xiang had said, "Emperor Xizong's sacred birthday fell on the seventh day of the seventh month, but because of Jingxuan's death anniversary it was moved, and foreign congratulations were received in the first month instead. Today the Heavenly Longevity Festival falls in the seventh month, when rains are violent; envoys from abroad traveling to court are impeded on the road. I ask that it be shifted to another month for their convenience." Rulin said, "The way of kings is to show the realm that one's word can be trusted. The Song emperor Gou's birthday also fell in the fifth month. At that time both courts were at Huining, and our state sent envoys with birthday gifts across thousands of miles without anyone citing floods as an excuse for delay. We have been at peace with Song for many years; to plead summer rains now would expose us as insincere. Even if the rains are worse than usual and the envoys miss the appointed day, that is still preferable to changing the festival outright." Vice Grand Councilor Liu Wei, Censor-in-Chief Tangut Gong, Vice Censor-in-Chief Li Yan, Minister of Justice and Right Remonstrance Officer Wanyan Shouzhen, diarist Wanyan Wuzhe, and Associate Director of the Petition Office Sun Duo likewise all opposed the change. The emperor at first sided with them, but in the end adopted Xiang's proposal. The emperor was then in mourning for Shizong; when he first went out hunting, the Remonstrance Bureau submitted a joint memorial arguing that hunting was improper while he was still in heart mourning. Later, when the winter hunt came round, Rulin remonstrated again. An edict answered him, "If you will speak up on every matter like this, what have I to fear? Yet times change and ancient precedent cannot be copied wholesale. What matters is to weigh each case and strike the right balance."
23
使 便
One day the emperor told his chief ministers, "You are too rigid about seniority in appointments—how can you ever find the right men that way?" Rulin replied, "Waiving formal qualifications is reserved for truly extraordinary talent." The emperor said, "Cui Youfu as chancellor recommended eight hundred men in under a year—were they all extraordinary?" About then the responsible offices reported that commoners were keeping private copies of statutes and that this might breed litigation, and asked that the practice be banned. Rulin said, "A king's law should be like the great rivers: easy to steer clear of and hard to violate. Our dynasty's laws are plain and public; they are now fixed as permanent statutes, and everyone in the realm knows them by heart. If households may keep copies, people will know the law for themselves and hesitate to break it—that itself helps good government. It is better not to forbid the practice." The court issued an edict adopting his view.
24
In the third month of Mingchang 1 he submitted a memorial asking to retire; the request was denied. In the twelfth month he died. The emperor was then hunting at Raoyang; when news of his death arrived, he ordered the whole bureaucracy to attend the funeral, added to the condolence gifts, and granted the posthumous title Wenxiang.
25
Zhang Xuansu
26
使 西使使 使涿 西使使使
Zhang Xuansu, whose style name was Zizhen, shared a great-grandfather with Zhang Hao. His grandfather You and his father Kuang had both served the Liao and risen to military commissioner. Xuansu first entered office through hereditary privilege. When Gao Yongchang seized Liaoyang, Xuansu was inside the city. When Walu's army arrived, he opened the gates and surrendered; he was specially granted the hereditary meng'an post at Tong Prefecture. During the Tianhui era he served in turn as Western Upper Gate Commissioner, Guest Reception Commissioner, and Eastern Palace Accounts Office. In Tianjuan 1 he was appointed military commissioner of the Jingjiang Army and put in charge of Zhuo Prefecture; on the integrity review he ranked at the top and was promoted one rank. Prince Daoji of Wei held the Central Capital in absentia; Xuansu was made co-intendant of his household, then transferred to military commissioner of the Zhenxi Army, promoted to transport commissioner of the Eastern Capital Circuit, and finally made military commissioner of the Xingping Army. In the late Zhenglong era bandits rose everywhere; Xuansu drafted laborers to raise the walls and moats. His colleagues urged him to stop, but he would not listen. Soon raiders struck neighboring prefectures, none of which was ready, while Xingping alone stayed safe. When Shizong took the throne, Xuansu came to pay his respects at the Eastern Capital. While still at the Eastern Capital he had curried favor with Hailing by reporting that Shizong had once taken government grain for his own use and by collecting several similar charges. When he now came to audience, Shizong ignored every charge. Xuansu and Li Shi strongly urged an early move to Yanjing, and the emperor was deeply convinced. He was transferred to Minister of Revenue, took command at Dingwu, and then retired. He died at the age of eighty-four.
27
Xuansu was generous in manner but stern in temper, and people feared as well as respected him. He often wrote a few characters on a scrap of paper to treat malaria, and the illness invariably cleared—people marveled at it.
28
Zhang Rubi
29
使 調簿
Rubi, whose style name was Zhongzuo, was the son of Xuanzheng, military commissioner of the Zhangxin Army and elder brother of Xuansu. Rubi first entered office through his father's hereditary privilege. In Zhenglong 2 he passed the jinshi examination and was appointed registrar of Yuejiao County in Shen Prefecture. Xuanzheng's wife, née Gao, was kin to Shizong's mother Empress Zhenyi; Shizong took Xuanzheng's daughter as his second consort, who became known as Consort Yuan. She bore Prince Zhao, Yunzhong. When Shizong took the throne at Liaoyang, Rubi and his uncle Xuansu both went to join him; Rubi was promoted to Hanlin Academy Attendant for Imperial Orders.
30
殿 使
Shizong held audience at the Cuiluan Pavilion and summoned Left Department Director Gao Yan and Rubi, asking, "What is being said outside about the recent appointments? Report the truth and hold nothing back. If anyone is unfit, he should be replaced." Gao and Rubi had nothing to say. From Huangtong on spending from the inner storehouses knew no limit; clerks traded on connections to cheat the court, and vast quantities vanished. Rubi, with Director of Palace Registers Gao Gongmu and inner-hall attendant Wang Tian'er, audited the stores, drew up categorized registers, and organized four warehouses to hold them. The inner-storehouse commissioner Wang Kedao and others were each flogged one hundred strokes, while Rubi and his colleagues were each promoted. Soon he was made concurrent diarist and transferred to Outer-office Director of the Right Department. He left office to observe mourning for his mother. Recalled from mourning as Outer-office Director of the Ministry of Personnel, he rose in stages to Minister of Personnel and was appointed Vice Grand Councilor.
31
使
An edict relocated Jurchen meng'an and mouke households to the Central Capital and allotted them official fields in the near suburbs—all of it stony, thin soil. The rich land had long been leased by powerful families, who treated it as private property. While the emperor was out hunting, meng'an and mouke leaders came forward to say the allotted land could not be farmed; he ordered official fields that commoners had long rented to be taken back and given to them. He then ordered Rubi to work out a policy. Rubi proposed, "Lay down clear rules and a deadline, and let commoners come forward on their own. After the deadline, let others inform against offenders; if the charge is proved, give the informer a reward." The emperor approved his plan. He also sent Associate Transport Commissioner of the Central Capital Zhang Jiusi to seize and register the fields.
32
使 使 使 使
The emperor asked, "Goryeo and Western Xia both style themselves our vassals. When our envoys reach Goryeo they stand as equals with the king. The Xia king stands to receive them while our envoys bow—why the difference?" Left Vice Grand Councilor Xiang answered, "Under the Liao, Xia was a nephew state by marriage; because of the Liao princess, the Xia king stood to receive our envoys' bows. Our court made peace with Xia on Liao terms, and that is why the practice continues." Rubi said, "The treaty oath says we follow Liao ritual in full; that usage has stood for forty years and should not be altered." The emperor said, "You are right." Learning that many junior appointments from the Department of State Affairs were incompetent, he summoned Rubi to the Fragrant Pavilion and said, "Your fellow chief ministers are old; you must shoulder the work." Rubi replied, "My ability is too slight to live up to Your Majesty's expectations." He was promoted to Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. About then the Revenue Ministry was selling grain from the state granaries; Rubi asked that the Nuantang Courtyard be allowed to buy it. The emperor reproved him: "Are you trying to bank secret merit? Why fuss over something so small?"
33
使 使退
Left Chancellor Tushan Kening was released from civil administration and made commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs. That same day Rubi too submitted a retirement petition from his sleeve. The emperor sent word to refuse him: "You are not yet old; you may not retire." He was promoted to Left Vice Director and, on the same day as his kinsman Vice Grand Councilor Rulin, took office—a glory for the whole clan. If a man under sixty asked to retire, the emperor would not allow it. Rubi said, "Your Majesty's instruction once allowed retirement at sixty." The emperor rebuked him: "I promised retirement only to those who reach sixty—not to anyone younger. When I set retirement at sixty, that was a policy you could accept or challenge—you should have spoken up then. You all kept silent. This is exactly the sort of thing I mean." Later, for unilaterally increasing the imperial grandsons' provisions, he and Chief Councillor Shoudao, Right Councillor Niagua Wetela, and Participating Councillor Zhang Rulin were each demoted one rank. The emperor said, "The law would require dismissal; I am only imposing a mild penalty." While Rubi was on medical leave, the emperor told the chief ministers, "Rubi has long been in power, knows the institutions well, and can judge talent—but his heart is not straight." He was removed from office and appointed Guangning Yin, and given a rhinoceros-horn belt.
34
As chief minister, Rubi never offered direct, principled remonstrance. When the emperor wanted something done, Rubi would smooth the way; when the emperor did not, he would drop a hint to test his mood. When rebuked, he would speak softly and take the blame, and never in the end defied the throne. The emperor knew this too. He was also corrupt, scheming to seize famous gardens, grand houses, and rare treasures from one family after another, and men of judgment despised him for it. In the twenty-seventh year he died.
35
使
Rubi and Yongzhong were uncle and nephew by marriage, and they secretly acted as a faction. After Zhangzong's accession, Rubi's wife Lady Gao repeatedly whispered sedition to Yongzhong, nursing ambitions beyond his station: she had Yongzhong's mother painted for worship and prayer, and employed diviners to read Yongzhong's fate. When the authorities investigated, Lady Gao was put to death. The case touched Rubi, but because it came to light only after his death, his honors were not posthumously revoked.
36
Yelu Anli
37
使殿 西
Yelu Anli, whose original name was Nahe, came from the Yaolian line. Orphaned young, he became known for filial devotion to his mother. In the chaos at the end of Liao, through every hardship of exile, he never for a day failed in the daily care owed a parent. After he entered Jin service, men in power respected his character and made him handle documents in the Marshal's Office; he was appointed Left Guard Attendant. At the opening of the Tianjuan era he followed the Marshal into Shanxi. When his mother died he could not go home to bury her; the Marshal took pity on him and gave lavish funeral gifts. Anli endured the fierce summer heat and drew the bier more than a thousand li; grief wore him to skin and bone, and wayfarers marveled aloud. After mourning he rose from clerk of the Branch Secretariat and supervisor in the Ministry of Works to Director of the Left Department.
38
使
In the Tiande period, when the Branch Secretariat was abolished, he entered court as Vice Minister of Works and eventually became Minister of Works. The following winter he served as envoy for the Song New Year mission. He was ordered to try the case of Prince Han, Wang Heng, at Guangning. Heng showed no sign of rebellion; Anli returned and so reported. Hailing was furious, suspecting that Anli—as a former man of Prince Liang Zongbi—was shielding Heng. He rebuked Anli: "Li Dielie is guilty of three crimes. His claim that Alihutuhu had a sworn bond and should not die—he has already confessed to that. As for saying the horses were unworthy to present, and secretly dispatching assassins—can those be denied? You report to me only to gauge my mood and decide how hard to press—that is all this is." He sent Anli back with Li Laoseng to investigate again. Laoseng thereupon killed Heng in prison. Hailing still believed Anli had killed Heng on his own initiative to destroy the evidence and spare the clan. This was how Anli refused to flatter those above and crush those below.
39
椿
Na Hechunnian
40
椿 西椿 椿 殿 椿使 椿 椿 椿
Na Hechunnian, whose original name was Wuye. When the Jurchen script was first created and a school opened in the Western Capital, Chunnian studied with children of the tribes and was the quickest to learn. Later, outstanding students were sent to the capital for instruction by a Yelu teacher from the Upper Capital; Chunnian was among them. He became a clerk of the Imperial Secretariat, rose to Palace Attendant Censor, and was then made Investigating Censor. While Hailing was Chief Councillor, he recommended Chunnian as Outer Director of the Right Department to draft the new code. When Hailing seized the throne, he appointed him Remonstrating Grandee. Chunnian had a drinking problem; Hailing ordered him to abstain, and he never touched wine again for the rest of his life. He became Director of the Secretariat, compiled the Veritable Records, received a hereditary military command, and served as Hanlin Academician and Censor-in-Chief at once. At the start of Zhenyuan, when Upper Capital military households were resettled in the Central Capital, Shandong, and other circuits, he was rewarded for the labor with a jade belt and stud horses. He oversaw the removal of the imperial tombs and, on returning, became Chief Commandant. He was given his present name and appointed Participating Councillor. Hailing said to Chunnian, "Officials of your caliber are rare—is there another like you? Chunnian recommended Grand Court Judge Hesilie Loushi. Hailing appointed Loushi Outer Director of the Right Department. Within ten days Hailing told Chunnian, "I tried Loushi, and he is exactly as you said. Only the worthy recognize the worthy—how true that is. Loushi was later given the name Liangbi. He had chief-ministerial talent; under Shizong he rose to Left Chief Councillor and was hailed as a worthy minister.
41
椿
In the second year of Zhenglong, Chunnian died. Hailing came in person to mourn him, posthumously enfeoffed him Special Advancement-holder and Duke of Tan, gave the posthumous name Zhongbian, and granted two thousand taels of silver, a hundred rolls of brocade, a thousand bolts of silk, and ten million cash for the funeral. His eldest son Canmou He was made General of the Pacification of the Far and inherited the command; his second son Heda was made Loyal Martial Regiment Commander. When the body was returned for burial, another million cash was granted and road expenses were supplied.
42
椿 西 椿 椿
Chunnian had chief-ministerial talent and liked to advance scholars, yet he also amassed property for his descendants. He seized more than eight hundred qing of official land on the Southwest Circuit. In the Dading period, during a land survey, commoners petitioned that the powerful had seized official fields and the poor could not plant. Wendusi Zhong's son Changshou, Chunnian's son Canmou He, and more than thirty other households had seized over three thousand qing in all. An edict ruled that each household keep its ox-head tax land plus ten more qing, and that the rest be given to the poor to farm on rent. His contemporaries often cited this to mock Chunnian.
43
使 調 便 婿
Qi Zai, courtesy name Yanfu, was from the Jianghuai region. Late in Song he entered office through medicine. When the Jin army took Bian he was captured and later assigned to the Imperial Medical Service. He rose in succession to Grand Master of Palace Attendance and Imperial Medical Commissioner. Repeatedly rewarded by the throne, he burned to repay the favor. When Hailing prepared to attack Song, Zai wished to remonstrate but could not gain an audience. Then the primary consort fell ill and Zai was summoned to treat her. As soon as he was admitted to audience, he submitted a memorial of remonstrance. In essence it read: "At the founding of our dynasty, the ancestors took the realm by right against wrong; in less than ten years they overthrew Liao and crushed Song. Even then, though above stood the martial Wuyuan and civil Wenlie, heroic founders, and below stood Zonghan and Zongxiong, bold in counsel and battle, they still could not unite the realm and left Jianghuai and Bashu to Song. How much less can today's strategists and generals match those men. Moreover Song has committed no crime; to march against them is to march without just cause. On top of that come massive corvée levies: building the Central Capital, establishing the Southern Capital, repairing arms, mobilizing armies—taxes and labor crush the people and resentment fills the land. This is failure in human affairs. Recently a comet appeared in the Ox and Dipper, and Mars lay hidden in the Wings and Chariot. The ji year brings self-punishment; malignant qi gathers at Yangzhou; Venus has not yet risen—armies that advance will be defeated. This is Heaven out of season. River fleets are stranded as the waters fall and ships cannot keep pace; yet among rivers, lakes, and islets Song horsemen ride and shoot and cannot be driven away. This is terrain against us. His words were fierce and unsparing. Hailing was enraged and ordered him executed in the marketplace; his property was confiscated, and the realm mourned him. Qi Zhan, Zai's son-in-law, was suspected by Hailing of having drafted the memorial. He pleaded, "I truly knew nothing of it." Hailing had Zhan beaten with the staff anyway. He summoned bureau officials of the Inner Palace to Xiande Gate and announced Zai's execution.
44
祿 使
The following year Shizong took the throne in Liaodong. In the fourth year an edict posthumously made him Grand Master of Governance and restored his fields and house. When Zhangzong took the throne, an edict sought out his son Gongshi, Loyal and Valiant Regiment Commander and wine inspector of Pingding, and promoted him to Director of the Imperial Pharmacy Bureau. Early in Taihe, when posthumous titles for meritorious ministers were fixed, Secretariat clerk Li Bingjun submitted: "Some matters should be urgent yet are delayed, light yet weighed heavy—such is the force of moral principle. I observe that the late Grand Master of Governance Qi Zai was executed for loyal counsel; every man who honors righteousness was wounded to the heart. When Shizong took the throne he was posthumously honored; Your Majesty employed his son—a great grace. King Wu restored Bi Gan's tomb; Confucius praised Bo Yi and Shu Qi—how is this any different? Yet the offices cling to the letter of the law, holding that because his rank was not third grade he falls outside the rule for posthumous titles—I find that doubtful. If posthumous titles require third-rank office, then in that day men of high rank and rich stipends were not lacking—yet all feared punishment and smeared themselves with flattery; not one dared speak or offer a single plan for the realm. In the end the man who won fame by dying for principle came from the ranks of physicians—enough, perhaps, to shame them a little. I hold that an extraordinary man deserves extraordinary honor. I beg that Your Majesty order the offices to grant a special posthumous title to honor his loyalty—this too would uphold moral principle." The rescript read: "Approved." The order went to the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, which granted the posthumous title Loyal and Resolute.
45
退 椿
The commentator says: How strange a ruler Hailing was—clever in managing those below him, yet indifferent to their welfare. When a gentleman serves at court, every act must follow ritual—only then can he avoid disgrace. Zhang Tonggu and Yelu Anli never rose as high as Zhang Hao, yet in how they advanced and withdrew they held to principle throughout—their worth was far greater. Hao took part in every affair and every task; he served as chief minister longer than any other, was used to the full yet rewarded thinly—was that not partly of his own choosing? When Hailing campaigned against Song, Hao and Anli were both great ministers—one remonstrated in guarded language, one in a secret memorial—no more than better than silence. Qi Zai was only a physician by profession, yet he alone remonstrated to the full; afterward everything unfolded as he had warned. Hailing put him to death—and in doing so secured his fame for a hundred generations. Na Hechunnian promoted men of talent and carried himself with the bearing of a gentleman. He died just before the Song armies marched, yet given his zeal for amassing property, he was hardly a man who would forget himself for the realm. As for Qi Zai—he stands alone, beyond comparison!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →