← Back to 金史

卷一百二十九 列傳第六十七: 酷吏 高閭山 蒲察合住 佞幸 蕭肄 張仲軻 李通 馬欽 高懷貞 蕭裕 胥持國

Volume 129 Biographies 67: Ku Li, Gao Lushan, Pucha Hezhu, Ning Xing, Xiao Yi, Zhang Zhongke, Li Tong, Ma Qin, Gao Huaizhen, Xiao Yu, Xu Chiguo

Chapter 129 of 金史 · History of Jin
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 129
Next Chapter →
1
Biographies 67
2
Cruel Officials — Gao Lushan, Pucha Hezhu
3
Favorites of Fortune — Xiao Yi, Zhang Zhongke, Li Tong, Ma Qin, Gao Huaizhen, Xiao Yu, Xu Chiguo
4
The Grand Historian once said, "The Legalists are harsh and stinting in mercy." How true those words are. Jin law was severe. Though the statutes were revised from earlier codes, they largely followed the harshest precedents. Under Emperor Xizong great prosecutions arose again and again; under Emperor Hailing the imperial clan was cut down; charges were twisted to fit; and informers who denounced treason were rewarded with swift promotion. Court and country alike turned to cruelty as a mark of achievement, and slanderers flourished. The harm spread near and far — a dreadful state of affairs. Much of the Jin history is lost; from surviving older records only two such men can be named. Hence the compilation of the Biographies of Cruel Officials.
5
Gao Lushan
6
調使使 使使
Gao Lushan was from Ximu in Chen Prefecture. He entered service as an imperial guardsman, became deputy commissioner of the Shunyi Army, then held xiangwen posts under Tangguo and Yila Duzha, and later served as deputy commissioner of the Zhenwu Army, commandant of the Prince of Cao's household, and administrator of Daming. He was made prefect of Ru Prefecture, then transferred to Shan Prefecture. The law forbade beating people to death with cudgels outside proper procedure; Lushan laughed when he saw it and said, "That would be hard to enforce too." That very day he took an especially heavy staff and beat to death a local subject named Yang Xian; he was stripped of one rank and removed from office. After some time he was demoted to administrator of Fengxiang, then served as prefect of Yuan, Ji, and Si prefectures, became defense commissioner of Zhengzhou, was promoted to commissioner of the Puyu Circuit, and held commands over the Linhai, Pan'an, and Ningchang armies in turn. In the second year of Zhenyou, when the city was taken, he died in the fighting.
7
Pucha Hezhu
8
西
Pucha Hezhu began as a petty clerk. Long favored by Emperor Xuanzong, he wielded dazzling power; he was cruel by nature, and though everyone knew he was ruining the state, no one dared speak against him. His son, who had served as a guardsman, was expelled first. Hezhu was then appointed prefect of Heng Prefecture and waited his turn in a nearby county. Later, when the main Mongol forces entered Shaanxi, the Guanzhong region was thrown into turmoil. Rumors spread that Hezhu was going to Hengzhou to flee north. The court ordered Kaifeng to detain his family. Hezhu complained bitterly, "Kill me and the realm will be at peace." Censors soon impeached him. At first the court considered flogging and a fine, but the chief ministers judged that inadequate, and he was beheaded at the gate of the Kaifeng prefectural office. People at the time spoke of "the three villains of the Xuan court" — Wang Ali, Pucha Yaozhu, and Hezhu among them.
9
During the Xingding era, in the prosecution of the imperial son-in-law Pusan Ahai, more than seventy inquisitions were opened in the capital. Ali and his associates seized the moment to spread terror; court officials lived in fear and could not protect themselves. Only Ji Wenzhi of the Kaifeng prefectural staff, convinced that Ahai had not rebelled, refused to sign the documents. When Ahai was executed, Wenzhi was left untouched.
10
Yaozhu retired early in the Zhengda era and lived in Suiyang. When mutinous routed troops rose up, he and his entire household were killed.
11
使
Emperor Xuanzong favored harsh punishment from the start; court officials were often flogged, and some who spoke up were killed on the spot with blade or cudgel. When Gao Qi held power, he used punishments as he pleased. After the court moved south across the river, the habit took root; even scholar-officials caught the fever. Tushan Sizhong, the right vice censor-in-chief, liked to beat people with a hemp mallet and was nicknamed "Lord Hemp-Mallet." Transport Commissioner Li Teli was called "Half a Sword" — short in stature but sharp in cruelty. Hanlin Academician Feng Bi was known as "Feng the Chopper." As censor, Lei Yuan went to Caizhou, seized local bullies, and had five hundred men beaten to death; he was called "Lei Five Hundred." Wanyan Majin and others were likewise notorious for cruelty; but Hezhu, Wang Ali, Li Huan, and their like were the most cunning and vicious of all the clerks.
12
Whoever in this world indulges his desires has sooner or later been ruined by them. The dragon is the most numinous creature under Heaven; let it acquire a craving and others control it — and the same is true of rulers. Cravings are not only for soft pleasures; war, hunting, building projects, and quests for immortality — flatterers know how to feed every taste. Jin emperors were inwardly beguiled by pleasure and outwardly addicted to grand projects; none surpassed Xizong and Hailing, with Zhangzong close behind. From Xiao Yi to Xu Chiguo, the History of Jin names seven of the worst flatterers. All won favor under those three rulers, destroyed themselves, and ruined the state — every disaster began with indulgence. Is that not a warning? Hence the compilation of the Biographies of Favorites of Fortune.
13
殿 殿 殿 祿
Xiao Yi was a Xi tribesman who won favor under Emperor Xizong and fawned on Empress Daohou, rising eventually to Vice Director of the Secretariat. On a stormy night in the fourth month of the ninth year of Huangtong, thunder shattered the roof ornaments of the imperial bedchamber and fire from outside set the inner curtains ablaze. The emperor moved to another hall and wished to issue a self-reproach edict. Hanlin Academician Zhang Jun was assigned to draft it. Jun meant to answer Heaven's warning with deep humility. His draft included such phrases as "my virtue is unlike [the norm], offending Heaven's majesty" and "considering my few and dim qualities, this insignificant young one." Yi translated and reported, "'Unlike' means utterly lacking in virtue; 'few' means alone and without kin; 'dim' means ignorant of affairs; 'minute' means blind; 'young one' is what one calls an infant — the Han are using written words to insult their sovereign." The emperor flew into a rage, had guards drag Jun from the hall, and had him beaten hundreds of strokes — yet he did not die. With his own sword he slashed Jun's mouth and had the body minced. Yi was rewarded with a belt of heaven-piercing rhinoceros horn. Relying on imperial favor, he looked down on his peers and earned Hailing's hatred. After usurping the throne, he raised the ranks of senior ministers, generally promoting them to Silver-Green Glory Grand Master. A few days later he summoned Yi and demanded, "For what crime was Academician Zhang Jun executed, and for what merit did you receive a reward?" Yi had no answer. Hailing said, "Killing you would be no difficult matter — but people might think I was settling a private grudge." An edict then struck his name from office, sent him home to his fields, and confined him within a hundred li.
14
Zhang Zhongke
15
宿 使使 使退
Zhang Zhongke, nicknamed "Calf" as a boy, was a market-town ruffian who earned his living telling romance tales and adventure stories laced with comic patter. Hailing kept him at court for amusement. When Hailing was Prince of Qi he made Zhongke his document secretary; after his accession Zhongke became a secretary of the palace library. Hailing once behaved lewdly before Zhongke with his consorts; Zhongke could only cry that he deserved death and dared not look up. He once ordered Zhongke to stand naked for his inspection; attendants were often forced to strip, and even Tushan Zhen was not spared. Vice Minister of War Wanyan Pulian and Junior Administrator of Daxing Li Dun had both been ruined by bribery, yet Hailing kept them in key posts at his side. The actor Yu Qing'er was given fifth-rank office; Wang Zhizhang, a slave of the Dashi household, became a palace library secretary. Zhizhang's testicles were misshapen and protruded; Hailing personally inspected them and saw nothing indecent in it. The slaves Heshang of Tangguo Bian's household and Gewen and Gelu of Wudai's household were placed in the inner guard; some by favor rose to first rank. Some of those at his side held no office at all; if he called one by name he would at once grant a high rank and ask, "Can you name that rank again?" He often scattered gold among the cushions; those who pleased him were told to take what they wanted — such was the recklessness of his largesse. When the Song envoy Yu Tangbi came to congratulate Hailing on his accession and was about to return, Hailing sent a jade belt as a gift for the Song emperor with this message: "Your father often wore this belt. I bestow it now so that, as if you saw your father again, you will not forget my goodwill." When the envoy withdrew, Zhongke said, "That is a treasure rare in the world — a pity to give it away so lightly." The emperor said, "The lands south of the Yangtze will one day be mine; this is only stored in an outer treasury for now." From this people knew that Hailing intended to invade the south.
16
'使 ' '鹿 '鹿 '鹿 '鹿
Soon he was promoted to deputy director of the palace library, then to junior director. While the Yanjing palaces were being built, officials took timber from the Tan Garden in Zhending Prefecture. Zhongke seized a chance to say the timber was unusable. Hailing suspected bribery and removed him from office. Before long he was reappointed junior director. Hailing hunted on Tuni Mountain and halted at Duowa. He poured a libation to Heaven and bowed, telling his ministers, "As a boy practicing archery I came to a gate and silently prayed: 'If I should one day rise to great honor, let one arrow lie across the ridge of the gate. When he shot, the arrow indeed lay across the ridge of the gate. Later, as commissioner of the Central Capital, he held a great hunt here. Before the beaters closed the ring he prayed, 'If I am to attain high rank, I shall take three deer within a hundred paces.' If I were only to become a chief minister, I would take but one. Before a hundred paces he took three deer in succession. He prayed again, 'If I unite the realm within the Four Seas, I shall again take one great deer.' And indeed he took one great deer. I once told Xiao Yu of this; I have come again to this place, and so I offer worship and libation." Hailing intended to seize the south. He staged auspicious signs to sway his ministers, and Zhongke always anticipated his intent and urged the southern campaign.
17
使使使
In the first month of the second year of Zhenyuan, when the Song New Year's envoy Shi Ju took leave at court, Hailing had Left Commissioner Jing Sihui ask him, "In how many examination categories does the Song state select scholars?" He answered, "Poetry and rhapsody, classical exegesis, and policy essays are all used together." He asked again, "What office does Qin Hui hold, and how old is he now?" He answered, "Hui is Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and Grand Councilor; he is sixty-five." He added, "I have heard Qin Hui is a worthy man — that is why I asked."
18
使使使 沿
In the second year of Zhenglong, Zhongke became Left Remonstrance Grand Master and compiled the imperial diary, but received only the remonstrance salary and was not allowed to remonstrate. In the first month of the third year, when the Song New Year's envoy Sun Daofu took leave, Hailing had Jing Sihui instruct him, "Tell your emperor: in dealings with our state you have often been insincere. I cite two examples. When your people flee into our territory, our border officials send them back at once; when our people flee into yours, your authorities make excuses and refuse to return them — the first matter. You secretly buy saddles and horses along the border to prepare for war — the second matter. Besides, horses are useless without men to ride them; a million horses are worthless if you lack the riders. Do you think we are unprepared? If I choose not to take your state, so be it; if I wish to take it, that will not be difficult. I hear that receiving defectors and buying horses on the sly are the work of your Grand Marshal Yang. Captives have told me about him — he is no threat." He added, "I have heard Qin Hui is dead — is it true?" Daofu answered, "Hui is indeed dead — and I myself was recommended by him." He added, "Your state's conduct of late is nothing like the Qin Hui era — why is that?" Daofu said, "Let me return home and lay out each of your points before the Song emperor." Hailing was already bent on invading the south; he had planted those two charges—harboring defectors and illicit horse-buying—then woven them into talk of other things.
19
便殿 西 姿西 ''
Hailing called in Zhongke, the Right Supplementation Censor Ma Qin, the Collator Tian Yuxin, and the Regular Attendant Xishi to wait on him in the privy chamber. Hailing was discussing the Book of Han with Zhongke and said, "The Han domains stretched only seven or eight thousand li; our realm spans ten thousand li today—surely that is greatness." Zhongke said, "Our lands are vast, but the world still has four sovereigns—Song in the south, Goryeo in the east, Xia in the west. True greatness would be to unite them." Hailing asked, "What have they done wrong that I should attack them?" Zhongke said, "I hear the Song are buying horses, readying arms, and taking in defectors from Shandong—how can that be no offense?" Hailing brightened. "Liang Guan once told me the Song have a Noble Consort Liu of extraordinary beauty—Shu's Huarui and Wu's Xishi are nothing beside her. One campaign and I win both—what people call getting a bonus on the way. When the south hears I am marching, they will run for the ends of the earth." Qin and Yuxin answered together, "Sea islands, barbarian coasts—we know every road. Where could they flee?" Qin added, "When I served in Song I led campaigns against the southern tribes—that is how I know." Hailing turned to Xishi. "Would you dare fight?" He answered, "You have favored me for years; I would not shrink from death." Hailing said, "Do you think they will dare march out? If they do, will you truly stand and die against them?" After a long pause Xishi said, "Timid as I am, I would still face them as an enemy." Hailing asked, "Where would they march out from?" He said, "Nowhere but the Huai line." Hailing said, "Then Heaven has handed it to me." Then he said, "When I march to destroy Song it will take at most two or three years; then I will subdue Goryeo and Xia. After the realm is one, I will promote by merit and reward officers and men—they will forget their hardships."
20
使
In the third month of the fourth year, Zhongke died. On the night before the winter solstice Hailing dreamed Zhongke begging for wine. When he woke he mourned at length and sent an envoy to pour offerings at his grave.
21
便 便殿 使便
Li Tong won Hailing's favor through clever compliance and ingratiating flattery. He rose through the ranks to Right Department Director, then was appointed Minister of Personnel. Petitioners and bribes crowded his gate. On yiyou of the first month of Zhenglong 2, an edict summoned officials from the Left and Right Departments and the Censor-in-Chief down to report at the privy chamber. Hailing said, "No one knows a son like his father, no one knows a minister like his lord—I have tested that. When I asked about talent, you either recommended your own kind or your friends. I hear Jurchen and Khitan seeking office all needed Minister of Justice Wudai and Privy Council Deputy Yaoshe to speak for them first, with Left Department Vice Director Aligulie handling the paperwork. Bohai and Han seeking office relied on Li Tong at Personnel and Xu Lin at Revenue for introductions, with Left Department Director Wang Wei running the process. Of everyone in office I know few and do not know many—yet are they not all my ministers? Why should nearness or kinship matter? Serve without fault and you may reach minister, vice-minister, or commissioner; commit an offense and punishment will be merciless." Before long he was made Vice Councilor.
22
沿 使 使西西西使
Hailing, trusting in generations of power, meant to wage war on a vast scale and unite the realm. He once said, "Only when the world is one family can rule be called orthodox." Tong read his mind and, with Zhang Zhongke, Ma Qin, the eunuch Liang Guan, and other court favorites, lavished talk on Jiangnan's wealth—its people, its jade and silk—getting ahead of his desire and saying it first. Hailing believed them, made Tong his chief strategist, and began planning war against the south. In the second month of the fourth year Hailing told the chief ministers, "Song may bow, but their oaths are hollow; I hear they are buying horses on the border and taking defectors—we must prepare." He sent envoys to register meng'an tribes and Bohai households in every prefecture and county for service, and to seize civilian horses on every circuit. Envoys were then dispatched across Shangjing, Supin, Huligai, Helan, Puyu, Taizhou, Xianping, Dongjing, Basu, Hesuguan, Linhuang, the southwest and northwest pacification commissions, Beijing, Hejian, Zhending, Yidu, Dongping, Daming, and Xijing Circuit to register every man from twenty to fifty. Even families with aged parents and many sons were denied a single son left at home. In the eleventh month of the fifth year Yin Jing, prefect of Yidu, and thirty others were ordered to convoy weapons from every circuit to the army's staging points for issue when the troops arrived. Surplus stores and gear that could not be repaired in time were heaped up and burned.
23
使使 使
In the first month of the sixth year Hailing had Tong tell the Song envoys Xu Du and others, "I once followed Prince Liang and lived at Nanjing; I loved its country. Imperial tours are as old as kingship. There is open country south of the Huai where I wish to hunt; my escort will not exceed ten thousand. Go back and tell your emperor; let his officials announce my intent so the people of Huainan need not fear." In the second month Tong was promoted Right Vice Chancellor. The edict read, "You have overseen arms and armor to completion; I reward your loyalty with this post. When the southern campaign ends, further honors will follow."
24
使沿 使 使使 使
In the fourth month Privy Council Deputy Gao Jingshan was sent as birthday envoy to the Song emperor, with Right Department Vice Director Wang Quan as deputy. Hailing told Quan, "When you see the Song ruler, accuse him to his face of burning the Nanjing palaces, buying horses on the border, and harboring defectors. Demand that such-and-such ministers come here for me to question myself, and claim the Han and Huai lands. If he refuses, berate him loudly—they will not dare touch you." Hailing meant Quan to provoke the Song emperor and supply a pretext for invasion. He told Jingshan, "On your return, report everything Quan said." Quan reached Song and abused the emperor exactly as Hailing had instructed. The Song ruler said, "They say you come from a great northern house—how can you behave like this?" Quan shot back, "Zhao Huan is dead already." The Song ruler sprang up, broke into mourning, and the audience ended. When Hailing reached Nanjing the Song sent envoys to congratulate his move of the capital. He had Han Rujia meet them at the border and say, "I have only just arrived; I hear of trouble in the north and may return to the central capital—no need to congratulate." The Song envoys turned back.
25
西西西 調 滿 調 調
Then the court seized mules and horses empire-wide; officials of seventh rank and above might keep one horse, with more allowed by higher rank. Registered civilian horses in the east went to western armies and western horses to eastern ones; convoys crossed day and night without pause, and the dead littered the roads. Officials who lost too many animals, fearing punishment, sometimes took their own lives. Convoys trampled fields and pressed men into service as horse handlers and laborers. An edict reserved Henan's stored grain for the main army alone. Wherever convoys passed they had to be fed; when stores ran out officials appealed. Hailing said, "This region still has plenty in the barns, and the fields are full—let the animals graze the standing grain. Even two years without harvest would do no harm." When craftsmen were summoned from every circuit to the capital, plague killed untold numbers, and the realm began to boil. Horses were levied by household count; rich families surrendered as many as sixty. More than five hundred sixty thousand horses were levied, yet each household had to feed them until the army marched.
26
使使使使 使
On a hunting excursion Hailing went to Tongzhou to inspect warship construction and registered more than thirty thousand sailors from every circuit. When Zhang Wang and Xu Yuan rebelled in Donghai County he sent Xu Wen of the Directorate of Waterways with a fleet to crush them. Hailing said, "I care nothing for one county—I am testing the navy." The people could endure no more; rebels swarmed—large bands seizing cities, small bands holding hills and marshes. He sent twenty-four Imperial Guards, including Puchain, each with fifty armored men, to garrison Shandong, Hebei, Hedong, Zhongdu, and other circuits and hunt bandits. Wanxi was made deputy commissioner of Dingwu, Shangxian of Anwu, and Puja of Zhaoyi; each received a silver plaque and orders to drive the hunt. Bandits in Shandong struck Yizhou; the magistrate of Linyi, Hu Sa, died fighting. At Daming, Wang Jiu and others seized the city; their force numbered tens of thousands. Khitan raiders such as Bianliujin and Wang San rode openly by day with a dozen men and banners; troops dared not stop them. They looted treasuries and piled goods in markets for the crowd to seize; the poor welcomed the bandits while the law-abiding suffered. Gao Yanfu of the Imperial Storehouse, Yelü Dao of the Court of Review, and Hanlin attendant Da Ying, returning from missions, all reported on the bandits. Hailing hated such news, had them beaten, and struck Da Ying from the rolls; after that no one dared speak.
27
使 使使
Hailing took personal command and divided forces from every circuit into thirty-two armies—Divine Strategy, Divine Might, Divine Swiftness, Divine Sharpness, Divine Perseverance, Divine Wings, Divine Courage, Divine Fruit, Divine Design, Divine Edge, and the Martial and Prestige series—each with a chief and deputy commander under the left and right frontier marshals and the three grand command offices. Each army received an inspector and deputy inspector. Yitaibao Benzhe became Left Frontier Grand Marshal; Tong became deputy grand marshal. Because Benzhe was a veteran general Hailing put him at the head of the armies to satisfy expectation, but Tong in fact ran everything.
28
Hailing summoned his generals, issued strategy, and feasted them at the Ministry of State. Hailing said, "Grand Marshal Liang's southern campaigns dragged on for months year after year. This campaign will not be like his—at most a hundred days, at least a fortnight. Do not complain of the march; with one heart win the great victory and I will reward you richly. Slackness will be punished without mercy." Fearing supply lines would fail, he forbade servants on the crossing; every soldier who heard it groaned. Tushan Hou and Crown Prince Guangying stayed behind; Chief Minister Zhang Hao, Left Chancellor Xiao Yu, and Vice Councilor Jing Sihui remained to govern.
29
宿使 使
On jiawu of the ninth month Hailing mounted in armor and rode out. The next day the consorts followed; the palace wailed long. On yisi of the tenth month, under dark skies they lost the road and did not reach Mengcheng until the second watch. On dingwei the main force crossed the Huai; at midstream Hailing bowed and poured a libation. At camp he saw men building stockades and had Zhang Yongqian of the Four Directions Office executed. Near Luzhou he sighted a white hare, galloped to shoot, and missed. Soon the rear guard caught it and presented it. Hailing rejoiced, gave gold and silk, and told Li Tong, "When King Wu attacked Zhou a white fish leapt into his boat. Now I have this—it too is a lucky sign." On guihai he reached Hezhou; officials sent a health memorial. Hailing told the envoy, "Do you mean to spy on me? Do not come again until Jiangnan is pacified—then you may submit congratulations."
30
使 宿 退
Liangshan Marsh had run dry and the first warships could not move. Hailing ordered Tong to build new ones with brutal urgency; troops worked seven or eight days without rest, tearing down houses in the city for timber and boiling corpses for ship oil. A platform was raised on the river. Hailing in golden armor climbed it, sacrificed a black horse to Heaven, and threw a sheep and a pig into the water. He called Commander Ang and Deputy Commander Puluhun and said, "The fleet is ready—you may cross." Puluhun said, "The Song ships are huge; ours are small and slow—I fear we cannot cross." Hailing snapped, "When you followed Prince Liang chasing Zhao Gou to the islands, were all their boats large? Tomorrow you and Ang cross first." Ang, hearing he must cross first, was stricken with dread and thought of fleeing. At evening Hailing sent word to Ang, "That was a flash of temper—you need not cross first." The next day he sent A'lin, chief of the Martial Peace Army, and Asa, deputy of the Martial Swiftness Army, to lead the fleet across first. Palace Duty General Wendu Aola, Directorate of Education director Ma Qin, and Armory Regular Attendant Xishi all went into battle. Hailing posted yellow and red flags on the shore to command movement: advance when the red flag went up, fall back when the yellow flag dropped. Once across the river, two vessels pushed ahead toward the south bank but grounded in the shallows. They traded fire with Song forces for a long stretch until their arrows were spent; both boats were taken, with the loss of one meng'an and over a hundred troops. Hailing withdrew to Hezhou.
31
After the council concluded, Li Tong went in again and said, 'Your Majesty has led the army in person deep into enemy country and now withdraws with nothing gained. If the troops scatter in front while the foe presses from behind, that is no sure plan at all. Leave men south of the river while the imperial train heads north, and even your commanders will fall apart. The northern forces near Liaoyang may already be wavering. Send men across the river first, haul the boats in, and burn them—cut off any thought of going home. Only then should Your Majesty ride north. North and south will fall into place in a matter of days. Hailing agreed. The next day he marched for Yangzhou. At Wujiang he stopped at Xiang Yu's shrine and sighed, 'A hero like that—and still he never held the empire. What a waste.'
32
使 使沿
At Yangzhou he posted Yelü Meda and the Shenguo Army to hold the Huai ford. Any soldier coming back from the front without papers from headquarters was put to death. He had palace arrows fitted with golden dragons, marked Imperial Arrows, and silk messages bound to them shot across to the south bank. The text accused Song of burning the Southern Capital's palaces, buying horses, and luring border troops and civilians—hence this punitive campaign to right wrongs, with a pledge that his army would not harm so much as a hair of the people. Thus he tried to win over the Song side. Song general Wang Quan in turn freed three captured Jin troops carrying a bill of Hailing's crimes. Li Tong brought the document in—and immediately had it burned.
33
Hailing flew into a rage and insisted on forcing a crossing at once. A bold cavalry monk named Gaoseng tried to coax his comrades into desertion. When the plot surfaced, Hailing had the troops hack him apart with their blades. He decreed a chain of blood: a deserter's puliyan died, a puliyan's mouke, a mouke's meng'an, a meng'an's zongguan. Terror in the ranks only deepened. On the day jiawu he ordered Yaohu craft and grain barges moved to the Guazhou ford, with crossing set for the morrow—delay meant death.
34
On yiwei, Wanyan Yuanyi and his men struck the imperial encampment. Hailing was murdered. Headquarters blamed the southern war on Li Tong and his circle. Tanshi Yongnian was family by marriage; Guo Anguo was hated by all—each was executed. In Dading 2 an edict stripped Li Tong of rank and title, to the relief of the realm.
35
使
Ma Qin—nicknamed Han Ge in youth—had served in the south and knew its routes. In Zhenglong 3, with the southern campaign looming, Hailing called him up from magistrate of Guide to Right Subsidiary Remonstrator. Qin was flighty and blind to larger stakes. After every audience he would tell others, 'The Emperor and I talked over such-and-such—it's going to happen.' He treated Hailing like a fellow clerk. He rose step by step to Vice Director of the Directorate of Education. At Hezhou, when Hailing meant to send Pulu Hun across the river, Pulu Hun said the craft were too small. Hailing sent for Qin, telling his attendants beforehand, 'If he says the boats won't do, kill him.' Qin came in and was asked, 'Will these boats carry us across?' Qin answered, 'Give me a raft and I'd still go.' In Dading 2 he was dismissed and struck from the rolls. The same day Da Ying, formerly Hanlin Academician Awaiting Orders, was made Secretary Director. In the Zhenglong years Ying had warned of banditry in Shandong. Hailing took offense, had him beaten, and cashiered him. Emperor Shizong valued Ying's blunt honesty and loathed Qin's sly flattery—so Ying was brought back and Qin cast out.
36
Gao Huaizhen
37
使
Gao Huaizhen served as a clerk in the Department of State Affairs and had long been on familiar terms with Hailing. Hailing had long nursed treasonous designs. He and Huaizhen once traded confessions of what each wanted. Hailing said, 'I have three aims: first, that every weighty matter of state issue from my hand alone. Second, to march abroad, conquer, and drag enemy kings before me to answer for their crimes. Third, to take the finest women in the realm for my own.' Word spread among sycophants and small men; they rushed to feed his vanity. Zhang Zhongfu, assistant magistrate of Dading, told him, 'I dreamed you and the Emperor played cuju. You charged through on horseback and knocked him from his mount.' Hailing was delighted. Xizong had ruled long and left power to senior ministers. Hailing, a near kinsman, seized the chancellorship and the whip hand of favor, laying the groundwork for murder—urged on at every step by creatures like Huaizhen. Once Hailing seized the throne he made Huaizhen Compiler of the Imperial Diary and posthumously ennobled his late father, the former prefect of Bin, as Grand Master of Palace Attendance. Huaizhen climbed to Vice Minister of Rites. In Dading 2 he was reduced to Grand Master of Governance and sent back to his village. In Dading 5 he and Xu Lin were both recalled; Huaizhen was named military commissioner of the Dingguo Army. The Emperor warned him: 'Under Zhenglong you were treacherous, greedy, and obsequious. Opinion held you in contempt. I thought that unless you were given a second chance you could never reform. Cling to your old ways and I will not spare you.'
38
Xiao Yu, born Yaozhe, was a man of the Xi. He began as a meng'an at the Central Capital. When Hailing was posted there as military commissioner the two became allies and talked endlessly of the empire's future. Yu sensed Hailing's ambition and whispered, 'You are the former Grand Preceptor—Taizu's eldest son. Men and Heaven alike should look to you. If you mean to act, I will spend myself in your service.' Hailing welcomed him and they began to plot in earnest. It was Yu who first opened the path to regicide.
39
As Left Vice Chancellor, Hailing made Yu Vice Minister of War, then associate commissioner at the Southern Capital, then shifted him to the Northern Capital. Leading the mobile secretariat, he stopped at the Northern Capital and told Yu, 'I mean to raise my standard with the armies south of the river, secure the two He provinces first, then drive north. Rally the meng'an to answer when I call.' They set a date and he moved on. Recalled from Liangxiang, he could not keep his promise. He murdered Xizong, seized the throne, and made Yu Director of the Secretariat.
40
使
He feared Taizong's sons and plotted their ruin with Yu in secret. Yu was cunning and cruel. He framed the Grand Tutor Zongben, Bingde, and others for treason. Hailing executed Zongben; Tangutuo Bian's agents killed Bingde, Zongyi, more than seventy of Taizong's line, and thirty-odd descendants of Prince Qin Zonghan. After Zongben was dead, Yu found his retainer Xiao Yu, coached him to write a full confession of treason, and had him file the denunciation in his own name. When Hailing published the charges across the empire, the outrage was universal. For destroying Zongben he made Yu Left Vice Chancellor with the title Third-Rank Peer, named him meng'an, and showered him with twenty million cash, four hundred horses and oxen, and four thousand sheep. A month later he was Grand Councilor and supervisor of the national history. By custom the chief minister oversaw the histories. Hailing handed the task to Yu and said, 'Taizu took the mandate by divine force; his deeds fill the four seas. I fear something may be lost—hence you.' In time he rose to Right Chancellor and Director of the Secretariat. In office Yu acted with little restraint; power and favor pooled in him until he dominated the court. Hailing leaned on him utterly; other ministers merely assented.
41
使 使 使西使 使 使 使 使 使
Yu was close to Gao Yaoshi and once repeated Hailing's private remarks to him. Yaoshi reported them and added, 'Yu nurses a grudge.' Hailing summoned Yu, warned him, and let the matter pass. When others accused Yu of hoarding power, Hailing judged it mere envy and paid no heed. He noticed that Yu's brother Xiao Zuo was Left Deputy Director of Palace Inspection and his brother-in-law Yelü Pili Left Guard General—a family bloc—and moved Zuo to prefect of Yidu and Pili to commissioner of Ningchang to quiet suspicion. Yu did not grasp Hailing's motive. Kin posted abroad without his knowledge fed his fear that the emperor already distrusted him. Hailing's brother Gun, Grand Preceptor, ran the Three Departments and shared power. He checked Yu's independence; Yu told Hailing that Gun was plotting against him. Hailing was suspicious and bloodthirsty. Fearful for his life, Yu joined the former prefect Xiao Feng's slave, former censor-in-chief Xiao Zhaozhe, Bozhou associate Yaoshe, and his son-in-law Elabu to place a grandson of the fallen Liao Prince of Yu, heir of Emperor Tianzuo. He sent Xiao Tunna to the northwestern pacification commissioner Xiao Haohu—known as Huaizhong. Huaizhong hesitated. 'This is grave,' he said. 'Send someone with real standing.' Yu dispatched Zhaozhe. Zhaozhe, once censor-in-chief, had been cashiered for crime—his disgrace was his passport to Huaizhong. Huaizhong asked who else plotted. Zhaozhe named Yelü Lang, commissioner of the Five Circuits. Huaizhong hated Lang already, and distrusted Zhaozhe for his earlier memorial on the Tadan revolt. He arrested Zhaozhe, jailed Lang, and sent word to the throne. Yaoshe wrote the clerk Bai Da, promising riches if he aided Yu. Bai Da turned the letter in. Still trusting Yu, Hailing took Bai Da's charge for slander and ordered him executed in the marketplace. As Bai Da was marched out the Xuanhua Gate, Director Tanshi Zhen arrived with Huaizhong's denunciation, met him on the way, heard his story, and stopped the execution. Zhen had already reported the plot; at his plea Hailing ordered Bai Da freed at once.
42
使 西
Hailing sent a chancellor to question Yu, who confessed outright. Hailing was stunned, still half in disbelief. He brought Yu before him and questioned him face to face. Yu said, 'A man does what he must. At this point, what is there to hide?' Hailing asked again, 'What grievance drove you to this?' Yu answered, 'Your Majesty consults me on everything—yet you posted Zuo and the others without telling me. Prince Gun at the mobile secretariat says I hoard power and keeps me at arm's length. I feared that was your will. You swore life and death with me and Tangutuo Bian. Bian's ruthlessness killed him—and I knew I might be next. I rebelled only to save my skin. Taizong's innocent sons died by my hand. My own death is overdue.' Hailing said again, 'I am emperor. Had I doubted you, could I not have moved against your kin in court? You misread me. Taizong's line was not yours alone to destroy. I acted for the realm.' He added, 'We have long been close. For old times' sake I spare your life—but never again as chancellor. Guard your family's graves till you die.' Yu said, 'After treason such as this, how could I face the world? Strangle me, and let it warn the disloyal.' Hailing stabbed his own left arm, smeared the blood on Yu's face, and said, 'When you are dead you will know I never truly doubted you.' Yu said, 'I enjoyed your extraordinary grace too long. I see my error now—but repentance comes too late.' Hailing wept as he saw Yu out the door, then had him killed, along with Yaoshe and Xiao Feng's slave. The slave's wife was a daughter of the Prince of Yu; she and her son Gu had joined the plot and were executed as well. He sent Imperial Guard Pang Ge to the northwestern pacification commission to kill Lang and Zhaozhe. Tunna and Elabu fled; Tunna was caught and executed in the market, and Elabu hanged himself.
43
宿
Tunna fled past Hejian's junior administrator Xiao Zhixiang, who at first knew nothing of Yu's plot and sheltered him for three days. Tunna went to Zhixiang's retainer Chazha. Chazha sent word to Zhixiang, obtained Tunna, and sent him on elsewhere. A slave in Chazha's household exposed the matter. Vice Minister of Personnel Wachan investigated. Zhixiang said, "Tunna stayed two days and left." Legal officers ruled that Zhixiang had concealed the facts and misled the Department of State Affairs—a crime punishable by fine. Hailing ordered Zhixiang executed, had Wachan and the legal officers beaten, and had Chazha beaten four hundred strokes to death.
44
使
Pang Ge killed Zhaozhe and others and four innocent men besides. Hailing ignored the excess and merely had him beaten fifty strokes. An edict announced Yu's crimes to the empire. Informers were rewarded: Huaizhong became deputy privy council commissioner, and Bai Da was made keeper of the seals. Gao Yaoshi was made compiler of the imperial diary and promoted to General of Manifest Martiality. Yaoshi, who had once reported Yu's discontent, was rewarded at last.
45
Xu Chiguo
46
Chiguo was pliant, fawning, and clever in intrigue. Consort Li had begun in low station and won the emperor's favor. Chiguo had long served in the crown prince's household and knew the emperor's appetite for pleasure. He used secret arts to court him and bribed the consort's attendants lavishly. Ashamed of her low birth, the consort sought weight through the outer court and praised Chiguo's talents until the emperor trusted him utterly. Consort and favorite worked as one, and he dominated the government. The deaths of Princes Yongtao of Zheng and Yongzhong of Hao, the dismissal of Wanyan Shouzhen, and like crimes all began with Consort Li and Chiguo. Office-seekers greedy for profit flocked to his door. People said across the realm, "A classics boy for chancellor, a supervising maid for consort." The saying mocked their base and vulgar rise.
47
使使''
In Chengan 3 the censorate impeached Zhang Fuheng, remonstrator of the Right Department; Zhang Jiazhen, supplementation drafter; Zhao Shu and Zhang Guangting, associate military commissioners; Gao Yuanfu, personnel chief; Zhang Yansou, penal vice director; and clerks Fu Rumei, Zhang Han, Pei Yuan, and Guo Ye—all runners at Chiguo's gate, mocked as the "Ten Sages of Xu's Gate. Fuheng and Jiazhen were the worst—obsequious climbers unfit for remonstrance. All should be removed from office." The throne approved. Chiguo retired as Grand Master of Governance for the Imperial Clan; Jiazhen and the others were sent to provincial posts.
48
使使 退退 使
Soon he was named to administer Daming but, before he left, was made deputy privy council commissioner to assist Commissioner Xiang with troops at Beijing. One day the emperor summoned Hanlin compiler Lu Duo on another matter and asked him to compare Dong Shizhong and Zhang Wangong. Duo said, "Shizhong rose by clinging to Xu Chiguo. Chiguo is a treacherous petty villain, unfit to command armies. He will neither satisfy public expectation nor win the troops. If he becomes chancellor again after this campaign, he will ruin the realm." The emperor said, "Ministers find it hard to move men in or out; for a ruler it is easy. Do you think I would make him chancellor again? I will promote him two ranks and let him retire—that is all." He soon died on campaign; his posthumous title was Penetrating and Keen. Later the emperor asked Grand Councilor Zhang Wangong, "Chiguo is dead—what sort of man was he, after all?" Wangong answered, "He was never scrupulous—the Pingle Tower wine-selling affair shows that." The emperor said, "That is not true greed for profit. When Ma Qi was vice councilor and sold the provincial monopoly brew for himself—that was greed for profit." His son Ding is treated in a separate biography.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →