← Back to 晉書

卷七十三 列傳第四十三 庾亮

Volume 73 Biographies 43: Yu Liang

Chapter 73 of 晉書 · Book of Jin
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 73
Next Chapter →
1
Yu Liang His sons were Bin, Xi, and He; his younger brothers were Yi, Bing, Tiao, and Yi.〉
2
姿
Yu Liang, whose courtesy name was Yuangui, was elder brother to Empress Mingmu. His father, Yu Chen, has his own biography in the "Treatise on the Outer Kin. Liang was striking to look at and a gifted conversationalist, drawn by temperament to the Zhuangzi and Laozi; he carried himself with austere dignity and let ritual guide every action, so that even the women's quarters stayed orderly without harsh discipline. People of the day ranked him with Xiahou Xuan and Chen Qun. At sixteen he was summoned as an aide by Prince Donghai, Sima Yue; he declined, stayed with his father in Kuaiji, and kept to himself with cautious reserve. Contemporaries found his upright severity intimidating, and no one dared drop in uninvited.
3
西 使 退
While Emperor Yuan still held the eastern commandery post, he heard of Liang's reputation and appointed him aide in the western bureau. At the audience his manner proved more polished and striking than anyone had expected; the emperor came to think the world of him and arranged the marriage of Liang's sister to the crown prince. Liang pressed his objections, but the ruler would not hear of refusal. He was reassigned as adjutant on the Chancellor's staff. He earned a share of the credit for the victory over Hua Yi, received the Duting marquisate, moved onto the Chancellor's military staff, and took charge of correspondence. Early in the Eastern Jin restoration he became a gentleman of the Palace Secretariat, oversaw editorial work, and lectured to the heir apparent. His lectures and commentary drew frequent praise. He and Wen Qiao had both been on cordial, informal terms with the crown prince before either man held high office. The emperor was then enthralled with statutory punishments and gave the crown prince a copy of the Han Feizi; Liang argued that the Legalist doctrines of Shen Buhai and Han Fei were cruel, corrosive to moral education, and unworthy of the heir's attention, and the heir took his point to heart. He rose through the posts of palace attendant, Gentleman at the Yellow Gate, and regular attendant cavalryman. Wang Dun was stationed at Wuhu; the emperor dispatched Liang to consult with him. As Dun talked with Liang he unconsciously edged his seat closer; afterward he sighed, "Yuangui Yu leaves Pei Xia in the dust!" On that basis he memorialized for Liang to be named chief of the Palace Guard.
4
Emperor Ming appointed him Supervisor of the Palace Secretariat; Liang answered with a memorial of refusal:
5
祿
I am a mediocre man with nothing remarkable in my past; when the heartland was torn apart and the old capital fell, I simply followed my late father into exile, found refuge with a worthy patron, and survived—nothing more than staying fed. I never imagined I would stumble into such timely luck or live to see a reign like this. When the late emperor began his rise he singled me out for favor beyond the ordinary—treating me as a trusted servant of the state and binding our houses by marriage—so I rode kinship and imperial regard into offices I never deserved. From my young adulthood I entered official life, breathed the court's rarefied air, moved constantly through the inner palace, and even commanded the Six Armies; within a dozen years I had outstripped men senior to me. No one has been showered with favor so utterly out of proportion to his merits as I have. Petty men draw modest stipends; blessings piled too high breed catastrophe. Knowing when enough is enough is what I should cling to. Yet I kept grasping at honor and climbing blindly, day after day, until slander piled up and I smeared this sacred court. I meant to speak plainly about this, but the late emperor passed away before I could; my feeble sincerity never reached him.
6
使西
Your Majesty has ascended the throne; governance is made new, the chief ministers are capable, and the ranks are well manned—the ancient hymn of harmony truly belongs to an administration this impartial. Yet the dynasty's favor still does not end—you would place me at the head of the Palace Secretariat again. If I take the Palace Secretariat, I advertise to the world that private ties steer public office. Why? I am, to you, the empress's elder brother. Suspicion clings to marriage ties in a way it does not to blood kin or even cousins. Even when the sovereign aims at perfect fairness and true virtue is without selfishness, the world has long since drifted from the right Way. Across the realm everyone favors in-laws; if every heart is partial, there is no common good under Heaven. That is why both Former and Later Han stayed safer when they checked empresses' clans and courted danger when they elevated affinal relatives. Had the seven great houses of the Western Capital and the six great houses of the Eastern Capital not been imperial in-laws but risen solely on merit, they might not all have survived—yet they would not all have been destroyed. Their utter ruin owed still more to those intimate marriage connections.
7
使 使
I have watched ordinary families hold office without court factions or timely patrons—their roots stay shallow. If they avoid grave offense they may still be tolerated. Outer kin lean on the sovereign as Heaven and Earth, tie their fortunes to the turning seasons, and spread roots everywhere—they loom large. Once they clutch power and imperial favor, the realm eyes them askance; one misstep brings guilt no execution can wipe away. They invite disaster on themselves and drag the state down with them. Why is it so? Because partiality toward affines is something ordinary hearts cannot shed—distant allies earn trust, while in-laws promoted to power invite suspicion. When suspicion festers among the people, catastrophe is conceived inside the palace women's quarters. History's lessons on this point should freeze the blood. Where ordinary sentiment cannot help but hesitate, the sage yields rather than forcing the issue. Trading on kinship for a scrap of influence cannot compare with steering clear of suspicion to prove utmost fairness. Given my modest abilities and these grounds for suspicion, to seat me at the ruler's breast within and put troops in my hands without—no one has ever heard of order coming from such an arrangement; but disaster from it can be waited for on one's feet. Even if your two chief ministers grasp my sincere foolishness and many at court understand my intent, you cannot knock on every door under Heaven until every heart is satisfied!
8
Wealth, honor, and imperial favor are not things I can pretend to forget; nor can I pretend to welcome stripes, shame, and poverty. Obeying brings ease; refusing brings pain. I may be dull, but why would I defy the times and my sovereign and invite disaster? I look to the harsh lessons of history, weigh my limits, and know my fault; my life is a small thing beside bringing regret on the state—which is why I keep laying my heart bare. Yet my poor sincerity runs thin and wins no sympathetic hearing; I tremble with anxiety and scarcely know where to turn. If Your Majesty would bend Heaven and Earth's mirror upon my folly, then the day I die I shall still feel alive.
9
The emperor accepted the memorial and dropped the appointment.
10
Once Wang Dun harbored treasonous intent, he cordially feared Liang inwardly while lavishing honor on him in public. Liang, anxious and afraid, resigned citing illness. He later succeeded Wang Dao again as Supervisor of the Palace Secretariat. When Dun rose in arms, Liang was named General of the Left Guard and joined the other generals against Qian Feng. When Shen Chong fled toward Wuxing, Liang received the imperial baton and supreme command of the eastern expedition to run Chong down. After peace returned he was made founding Duke of Yongchang County and awarded fifty-four hundred bolts of silk for his service; he firmly declined both honors. He was transferred to the post of General Who Guards the Army.
11
西
As the emperor sank deeper into illness he refused to see anyone; even his ministers could not reach him. General Who Soothers the Army, Prince Sima Zong of Nandun, General of the Right Guard Yu Yin, and others had long enjoyed the emperor's affection; they were plotting with Prince Sima Yang of Xiyang to move against the chief ministers. Liang forced his way into the sickroom and wept until he could not speak. Then, grave-faced, he explained how Yang and Zong planned to oust the chief ministers and rule together—the fate of the altars, he said, would be decided that very day—and his words cut like knives. The emperor was shaken to clarity; he drew Liang up beside the throne and, with Minister Wang Dao, received the deathbed edict to guide the young ruler. Liang was given concurrent appointment as palace attendant and transferred from supervisor to director of the Palace Secretariat. The empress dowager held court, and Liang decided every matter of state.
12
Earlier Wang Dao had governed with leniency and held the people's goodwill; Liang enforced statutes and ruled by the letter of the law, and for that he lost hearts widely. The late emperor's testament had promised honors for senior ministers, yet Tao Kan and Zu Yue were left out; both suspected Liang of tampering with the text and openly nursed grievances. Fearing revolt, Liang posted Wen Qiao to Jiangzhou to widen his backing and strengthened Stone City against trouble. When Prince Zong of Nandun again plotted to oust the chief ministers, Liang executed Zong and stripped his elder brother Yang of rank. Zong was near kin to the throne; Yang was an elder statesman of the ruling house and had been tutor to the late emperor—all under Heaven concluded that Liang was cutting down the imperial clan.
13
便西 西 使
Bian Xian of Langye belonged to Zong's cabal and died with him. Xian's elder brother Chan fled to Su Jun; Liang ordered Jun to hand him over, but Jun hid him instead. Jun also harbored fugitives and ruled by terror alone; Liang saw him as certain trouble and summoned him to the capital as Minister of Agriculture. The entire court called the move unwise; Wen Qiao, General Who Pacifies the South, wrote again and again to stop it—all to no avail. Jun then rose in arms together with Zu Yue. When Wen Qiao learned that Jun had defied the summons, he wanted to march down to shield the capital; the Wu region also wanted to raise loyal troops—Liang forbade both, and wrote Qiao: "I fear the western front more than Liyang—do not move one step past Leichi." Soon Jun's general Han Huang struck Xuancheng; Liang sent troops but could not hold them; Jun rode the momentum straight to the capital. An edict invested Liang with the baton and supreme command of the punitive forces; they gave battle outside the Jianyang Gate. Before the lines could form the men threw down their armor and ran. Liang fled west in a skiff while disorderly soldiers looted one another; his escort shot at the enemy but struck the helmsman by mistake, and the man dropped at the twang of the bow—every face on board went white with panic. Liang never changed expression and said evenly, "How could this hand be allowed to strike the enemy!" The crew steadied at once.
14
便
Liang fled south with his brothers Yi, Tiao, and Yi to join Wen Qiao, who had always revered him and, even amid rout, wanted him as supreme commander. Liang refused firmly; he and Qiao instead put Tao Kan forward as leader of the alliance. When Tao Kan reached Xunyang he already nursed a grievance against Liang; rumor said he meant to execute the regents to appease the realm. Liang was terrified; when they met he owned every fault, and his bearing remained composed and impressive. Kan's anger drained away unawares; he said to Liang, "You fortified Stone City against this old fellow—why come begging me today!" They talked and feasted the whole day through. When they ate, Liang nibbled the scallions and left the whites—a gesture Tao Kan recognized as courtesy toward him. Tao Kan asked, "What is this for?" Liang replied, "The whites are good for planting." Kan admired him even more and said, "This is not mere refinement—there is real substance for governance here."
15
退
After they reached Stone City, Liang sent Supervising Protector Wang Zhang against Zhang Yao, a follower of Su Jun, and Wang was beaten instead. Liang returned the imperial baton to apologize. Tao Kan replied, "Ancient worthies took three defeats before their point was made; you, sir, have only reached two. These are desperate times; we should not keep score of setbacks. He added, "When power splinters among too many court factions, the state invites calamity. Do you think our ruin came from Su Jun alone?" While Liang held White Rock Fort with two thousand men, Su Jun brought more than ten thousand infantry against him from every side, and his troops went cold with dread. Liang rallied his men to fight as if their lives hung on it; Su Jun's forces pulled back, and they pursued and took several hundred heads.
16
After Su Jun fell, the emperor boarded Wen Qiao's boat; Liang was admitted to audience, kowtowing until he could barely breathe for weeping, and an edict told the ministers to take their seats beside Liang at the imperial dais. The next day Liang pressed his dust-covered forehead to the ground again, begged to retire his bones, and offered to take his whole household into exile among the mountains and seas. The emperor sent senior ministers with a handwritten message of reassurance: "This was a crisis for the altars, not your fault as maternal uncle." Liang still submitted a memorial:
17
退便 退 退使
I am a mean little man with no talent for governing the age; I climbed through kinship into offices I never deserved, and the heavier my unauthorized honors grew, the louder the slander became. The house faced repeated crises, so I dared not step away; I drifted from post to post until I burdened the court with prominent appointments. When the late emperor fell ill I helped tend his medicines; I heard his deathbed testament and took part in planning what followed—not because virtue singled me out, but because I was family. I knew it was wrong yet could not run from the charge: even common friends honor a trust, let alone the bond between sovereign and minister, rooted in the natural order—I grieved too deeply to turn away. The late emperor favored me beyond my deserts as though we were still commoners in plain clothes; his kindness outweighed my life, and I repaid that encounter with everything I had. When Your Majesty still wore mourning and the late empress dowagers personally ran state affairs, bridging inner palace and government, I stood where duty placed me—I threw myself into the work and did not hedge. I knew I might accomplish little, yet I meant to answer with my life. Yet my talent was slight while my rank was high; I pressed forward and forgot restraint, swelled with favor, and little by little lost sight of myself. I could not steady the realm within or without, nor step back and yield to worthier men of the lineage, until the whole realm looked askance and reproach boiled over.
18
Zu Yue and Su Jun, unable to stomach their grievances, exploded into open revolt—and I set it in motion. The altars nearly fell and the temples stood empty; grief drove the late empress dowagers to their deaths; for more than a year Your Majesty has supped after dark while the realm trembled in mourning and men laid down their lives—I brought this about; the guilt is mine. If the court carved me inch by inch it would not appease the spirits in the seven ancestral shrines; if my ashes were scattered and my kin wiped out it would not satisfy the blame of all under Heaven. I have betrayed the state in the gravest way—Heaven would not shelter me, Earth would not carry me. Yet Your Majesty shows mercy and stays the executioner; the offices indulge me and leave the sword sheathed. From antiquity to this day, has anyone been as faithless to ruler and family as I? I failed to fall on my sword at the palace gate; I cling to breath and call it life—yet living like this is death. How can the court still rank me among civilized men, and how can I show my face in human company?
19
I mean to throw myself into the wilderness to ponder my faults, yet the edict calls that mere self-preservation. Because Your Majesty will not bend to understand me, my guilt only weighs heavier. I beg Your Majesty to heed how past courts erred in handing office to the wrong men: even if you spare my head, cast me off and let me live or perish alone—then the realm will see what reward and warning mean.
20
The emperor replied:
21
Your memorial is painfully sincere; it moves me to sigh. A kindly uncle should weigh responsibility for the whole realm as you do—you have argued every point to its limit. Where great principle is clear and your reasoning carries the day, why trade petty concessions back and forth?
22
Su Jun's treason belongs to a kind no written record has seen. Heaven and Earth could not abide him; neither men nor spirits could pardon him. Fool and sage alike could see that if he did not rebel this year, he would the next. You and the other ministers rose in fury and raised troops because you could not endure seeing the sovereign insulted. By every measure of duty and loyalty, who could call you faithless? Had supreme command brought defeat, the offices should have applied the law openly to uphold the dignity of state—that would have been fair. Instead you alerted the regional commanders, swept down like a whirlwind, buckled on armor yourself, and Su Jun's head ended on the public pole. When the crisis passed, order returned: I could take the throne again, the altars stood firm, and the temples received sacrifice—was that not your doing and that of the commanders who risked everything? This is the hour to record merit and give rewards—why reopen old blame?
23
使
The realm lies in ruins; tens of thousands lie dead while a tyrant's armies camp across the river. For now you must carry out the late emperor's charge, shoulder these bitter trials, and give me—a mere boy—something firm to lean on; nothing would bless the realm more.
24
西西
Liang tried to slip away to the eastern hills and seas from Jiyang. An edict ordered officials to impound every boat. Liang then asked for a frontier post to prove himself and was named credential-bearing commander of Jiangan forces in Yu and Yang (including Xuancheng), General Who Pacifies the West, acting Inspector of Yu Province, and concurrent administrator of Xuancheng. He took the post and set up headquarters at Wuhu.
25
Wang Dao governed while the emperor was a child in troubled times: he kept to broad policy, ignored petty detail, and left generals such as Zhao Yin and Jia Ning to their own devices—they broke the law at will, and senior ministers were alarmed. Tao Kan once meant to march against Wang Dao and remove him, but Xi Jian refused to join, so Kan dropped the plan. Now Liang wanted to mobilize and oust Wang Dao; he consulted Xi Jian again, and Jian again refused. Liang wrote to Xi Jian:
26
At Wuhu we thrashed it out: Wang Dao's faults were grave, but the times were desperate—if regional commanders held the moral high ground they could still restrain him, so we swallowed our anger and talked Tao Kan down. Since then he has not mended his ways in the least.
27
殿
From boyhood to manhood the emperor has been in the grip of palace insiders when within the walls and of lowborn military men when without; no one has taught him to parse the classics, and no gentleman has counseled him. Attending ministers may not be brilliant, but they are fit for public counsel on past and present—surely they cannot be lumped with palace generals and horse guards! You say nothing about elevating good ministers but praise picking generals and horse guards—does that match what Jia Yi meant by nurturing a ruler's virtue through proper habit? The First Emperor tried to keep the common people ignorant and the realm knew it was wrong—would you keep the sovereign ignorant? While the emperor was young, no wise men were brought forward to tutor him. Now that he has come of age, power ought to return openly to the throne. Instead of bowing and handing back the reins, Wang Dao clings to the loftier title of imperial tutor; a grown emperor must endure insolence from a minister who still plays mentor. The sovereign knows this flouts the proper relation of lord and minister, yet must treat him with extraordinary deference. The Son of Heaven perches on the top line of Qian—the "arrogant dragon" of the Changes—with a vacant throne in all but name. He wields the awe of one who overshadows the throne and bends every official; none dare defy him. The late emperor left no ministers strong enough to enforce his will; circumstances bent before this arrogant schemer, and the court fed the evil instead of cutting it out. Zhao Yin, Jia Ning, and their ilk breathe treason—if we endure this, what would we not endure?
28
We once swallowed our outrage because the age was desperate and arms could not flare again—we hoped Wang Dao would own his faults and mend his conduct. Now he indulges those men until neither sovereign nor subject fears anything—he thinks a pack of ruffians can prop up the realm. You and I both enjoyed the late emperor's trust and accepted grave charge—if we leave this villain in place, how do we answer him beneath the earth? Consider what truly stabilizes the altars, then weigh which of us can bear the lighter or heavier part and act accordingly.
29
Xi Jian refused once more, and the matter died.
30
使西 便 西
Shi Le had just died, and Liang planned to reconquer the Central Plains: he handed Yu Province to General Who Supports the State Mao Bao and sent him with Fan Jun, governor of Xiyang, and ten thousand picked troops to hold Zhucheng. He named Tao Cheng General of the Southern Gentlemen and governor of Jiangxia and led five thousand retainers into the Han basin. His brother Yu Yi became Colonel of Southern Tribes and governor of Nan commandery, stationed at Jiangling. He promoted Chen Xiao of Wuchang to General Who Supports the State and Inspector of Liang Province and sent him toward the Ziwu corridor. A secondary force struck Shu, reached Jiangyang, captured the rival regime's Li Hong of Jingzhou and Huang Zhi of Ba commandery, and sent both to the capital. Liang would command a hundred thousand men from Stone City to support the other columns and memorialized: "The Shu and Hu rebels grow crueller by the day, slaughter one another within their ranks, and shed followers on every side. Shu is weak while the Hu remain strong; both till their fields and hold their lines while preparing to strike. Xiangyang links Wan and Xu to the north and the Han River to the south—its terrain can be held and its fields can feed an army. I should shift my headquarters to Shicheng below Xiangyang and string forces along the Yangzi and Han. Within a few years the troops will be hardened; when opportunity opens we advance together on Luoyang. One decisive stroke shows everyone where survival lies: offer defectors a path back, absolve men forced into rebellion, align with Heaven and human sentiment, strike the traitors, and wipe away shame—that must be this court's first duty. I beg Your Majesty to approve this plan and give it full support. Huai, Si, and Shouyang should likewise be occupied; I will drill the troops assigned there. Let the court assemble its ministers under the palace sophoras and set the grand strategy." The emperor forwarded the memorial for deliberation. Wang Dao agreed with Liang, but Xi Jian argued that supplies were lacking and a major campaign was premature. Liang submitted another memorial pressing for the redeployment. Then the enemy took Zhucheng and Mao Bao drowned. Liang apologized and stripped himself of three ranks, serving thereafter as acting General Who Pacifies the West. An edict restored his former rank. He was soon offered the ministry of Works alongside his other posts; he refused repeatedly and never accepted.
31
使
After Zhucheng fell, Liang sank into grief and rage and fell ill. When Wang Dao died, the court summoned Liang to serve as grand tutor, governor of Yang, and overseer of the Masters of Writing; he refused again, and the emperor let him. He died in the sixth year of the Xiankang era (340), aged fifty-two. He was posthumously honored as Grand Commandant with the posthumous title "Wenkang" (Cultured and Mild). When his remains arrived, the emperor came in person to mourn. At burial he was further accorded the seal and ribbon of Duke of Yongchang. Yu Bing submitted a memorial: "I have reviewed what passed before and recall what Liang said to us brothers—how earnestly he pressed this point. Again and again he begged to retire until nearly ten years had passed. This was no mere love of yielding or neglect of duty—the rebellion had burst right under the capital's eaves, yet our late emperor was a soldier-statesman whose planning covered every angle; the war ended almost before it began and the traitors were destroyed. Judged by events, the credit belongs to the throne; measured by fate, the victory was more than human effort could claim. Men such as Liang merely rode the wave of imperial strategy and did their jobs—what is there to argue about? What reward could match their merit? Later, when his stumble drew blame heavier than his past deeds, Your Majesty graciously accepted his pleas. Liang meant to spend himself repaying the dynasty; who could know death would take him while the court still flourished—his humble aims forever unfulfilled, and our grief cuts to the marrow. Issue an edict that completes the grace he was promised, and Liang will rest honored though dead." The emperor agreed. At Liang's funeral He Chong lamented, "To bury such a jade tree in dust—how can the heart bear it?
32
退 便
Once Liang's mount bore the "white forehead" marking; Yin Hao thought it ill-omened for its master and urged him to sell the beast. Liang replied, "How could I ease myself by passing misfortune to another?" Yin Hao withdrew in embarrassment. While Liang was at Wuchang, Yin Hao and other aides climbed the south tower one autumn night; they did not notice Liang's approach and started to scatter. Liang said lightly, "Stay awhile—this old fellow feels quite inspired here." He sat on a camp stool and talked and recited poetry with them until the evening ended. His uninhibited manner was typical. He had three sons: Bin, Xi, and He.
33
Even as a child Yu Bin showed uncommon composure. Wen Qiao once hid in the dark to frighten him; Bin stayed perfectly calm, then knelt and said, "Sir, was this really necessary?" Observers said he was every inch his father's son. He was killed during Su Jun's revolt.
34
西
Yu Xi earned an early reputation and began as administrator of the Wu princedom. Emperor Mu favored belles-lettres; when Xi reached his post he submitted poems laced with tactful criticism. He followed with a memorial: "Your Majesty's virtue rivals Tang and Yu, yet labor levies run endless and the people are exhausted. A few provinces prop up business for the whole realm—the strain defies description! Even Emperor Wen of Han, ruling a prosperous age, lived plainly and cut capital cases to some four hundred—almost idle prisons. Jia Yi still warned of kindling stacked beneath the throne. Measured against antiquity, our plight should deepen Your Majesty's alarm. Your Majesty's insight lights every corner—surely no blind man's counsel is needed to see how to save the age. My house owes the dynasty generations of favor; I would repay even the weight of a hair. Sent east, I speak only what I have seen, and presume to offer this earnest counsel for the good of government. If Your Majesty can spare a moment from judgment to read these words. Most of his verse and prose were not preserved. Xi died just as higher office opened before him. His son Zhun rose from palace attendant to replace Huan Shiqian as inspector of Yu and General of the Western Gentlemen at Liyang during the Taiyuan era, and died in office. Zhun's son Yue became inspector of Jiang Province under Yixi. Zhun's brother Kai has a separate biography.
35
耀使便 西 退 祿
Yu He, courtesy name Daoji, was studious and a capable writer. When his uncle Yu Yi prepared to move headquarters to Xiangyang, fifteen-year-old Yu He wrote: "Advancing on Xiangyang lets us awe Jing and Chu, farm and fortify at once, and edge toward the Central Plains until converts flock to us and brutes submit—the foundations of peace could be laid overnight. The Yin spent three years subduing Guifang; Yue Yi holding Qi dragged on for years. Our dynasty is strong but not Shang-strong; the Hu bandits may be weakened but still field armies. The Han waters offer no cliff-like barrier; Fang citadel is steep but not impassably rugged. Grain barges fight the current; soldiers groan under endless labor. If desperate foes strike east and west at once, our supplies face interception and distant columns cannot snap shut like the Changes' "sudden" strike. Every course I weigh seems imprudent. Bright and dull alike see it—how much more men who bear command! Withdraw the banners, pick a winnable plan, strengthen walls and farms, and drill the troops. When Heaven turns against the barbarians, boats and columns can strike north by land and water within weeks—not months. Weigh the long plan and count only what can work." Yi marveled at the boy. Under Shengping he succeeded Kong Yan as governor of Danyang and petitioned away more than sixty oppressive levies. Early in Taihe he replaced Wang Ke as chief of the Palace Guard and died in office. His son Heng rose to vice director of the Masters of Writing and was posthumously honored as grand master of brilliant splendor.
36
西 西 退 使 西
Yu Yi, courtesy name Shuyu, won praise from Liang in youth for his plain good sense. At his capping Prince Sima Yang of Xiyang summoned him, but he declined. When Prince Donghai Sima Chong commanded the Long River garrison he picked Yi as merit officer, then named him magistrate of Jiyang, army marshal on Chong's staff, gentleman at scattered cavalry, and finally general of the left guard. His service against Su Jun earned him the barony of Guangrao; he became governor of Linchuan, supervised Liang and Yong, then served as General Who Supports the State, inspector of Liang Province with credential staff, stationed at Weixing. Liang then commanded six provinces; Yi was posted far afield because his tolerance could hold men together—east and west could aid each other. He soon added supervision of Di and Qiang forces in Qin Province. Yi sent gate captain Huo Zhuo to fetch dependents; Zhuo instead drove three hundred souls into the arms of Shi Hu. Liang reported the crime and demoted Yi to General Who Establishes Might. The court wanted him recalled, but Liang wrote: "Yi leads with restraint and kindness; the province is small but profits from his gentle rule. Zhuo's crime was isolated—few followed him. Yi's rank is weighty; petty faults should not decide his recall. Hearts in the province are steadying; rebel leader Ai Xiu offers submission; over five hundred Upper-Luo families who sided with the enemy wish to yield—give them peace and the fear will end." The court agreed. Because his command was remote and supplies failed, an edict pulled Yi back to Banzhou with his troops. He soon became General Who Supports the State and inspector of Yu, took the title General of the Western Gentlemen, oversaw four commanderies between Xuancheng and Anfeng with credential staff, and camped at Wuhu.
37
Yi gave Emperor Cheng a white feather fan; the emperor returned it because it was not new. Attendant Liu Shao said, "When the Cypress Terrace rises into the clouds, the master builder still stands below; when the orchestra swells, Kui and Ya hear it first. Yi offered the fan for its quality, not its novelty." Later Yi said, "That man belongs at the emperor's side." He also once sent poisoned wine to Wang Yunzhi, governor of Jiang Province. Wang suspected poison, fed it to a dog—the dog died—and reported secretly to the throne. The emperor snapped, "The elder uncle already shook the realm—will the younger uncle try the same?" Yi drank poison and died at fifty. He was posthumously named palace attendant and General Who Guards the Army with the posthumous epithet "Jian" (Straightforward). His son Tong inherited the title.
38
調
Yu Tong, courtesy name Changren, was celebrated young but refused summons from the ministry of Works and the grand commandant. He transferred to staff the heir apparent and Prince of Kuaiji, then served as General Who Establishes Might, protector who pacifies the tribes, and governor of Xunyang. He died at twenty-nine; contemporaries mourned a gifted man lost too soon. His son Xuanzhi rose to governor of Xuancheng.
39
Yu Bing, courtesy name Jijian. Where Liang taught by prestige and virtue, Bing led by modest simplicity; the younger brothers followed suit and prized ritual—the age esteemed them, and Liang called them the jewels of the clan. He declined the minister of Education but accepted appointment as secretary gentleman. His part in defeating Hua Yi brought the marquisate of Duxiang. Wang Dao named him senior clerk on the minister of Education's staff; he went out as governor of Wuxing.
40
便 西
When Su Jun rebelled he struck Bing, who could not hold out and fled from Wuxing to Kuaiji. Kuaiji's governor Wang Shu gave Bing temporary rank as General Who Rouses Might against Zhang Jian's detached force in Wu. Zhang Jian's followers were many and no general dared strike first. Bing drove Zhang Jian's forces back, then pressed west toward the capital while momentum held. He also sent Teng Han against Su Jun's Stone City stronghold and took it. For his outsized merit Bing received the Xinwu marquisate but refused it. He was offered Gentleman at the Yellow Gate but again declined to serve. Xi Jian asked him to serve as chief clerk on the ministry of Works staff; he refused. He became General Who Rouses Might and governor of Kuaiji. Summoned as chief of the Palace Guard, he declined again. He soon became Supervisor of the Palace Secretariat, governor of Yang, commander of Yang-Yu-Yan forces, General Who Punishes Captives, with credential staff.
41
Wang Dao had just died and the court was anxious. Liang had refused high office, so every eye turned to Bing. Once in power he ran state affairs night and day, honored worthy ministers, and promoted new talent—court and countryside alike hailed him as a true chief minister. Where Wang Dao had ruled with leniency, Bing leaned on stern law. Yin Rong objected; Bing replied, "Even the worthy Chief Minister could not sustain pure indulgence—how much less I!" Fan Wang warned him, "The heavens have shown prodigies—you must ward them off with restraint." Bing answered, "I cannot read the stars—I can only do my duty as a minister." He also audited household registers, drafted more than ten thousand unlisted men, and filled out the army rolls. Edicts revived talk of past honors; Bing memorialized: "My house disgraced the throne—had Jin law run its course we would have been executed long ago. Yet in the turmoil penalties could not be enforced, so men like me could still serve. We who stayed loyal raised armies after ruin and earned merit despite earlier guilt—that is why we still breathe; the court no longer holds every old fault against us. That mercy is vast enough—how dare we haggle over merit pay or minister of Works honors? Grant what we ask of the offices, and my humble petition is complete." The throne agreed.
42
While Emperor Cheng lay dying, forgers circulated a fake Secretariat order barring chief ministers from the gates—the attendants turned pale. Bing stayed calm: "That cannot be genuine." Questioning proved it a hoax and everyone steadied. He was promoted to general of the left. Under Emperor Kang he became chariot-and-cavalry general. Wary of faction at court, he asked for a frontier post. When Yu Yi marched against Shi Hu, Bing kept his existing rank while commanding seven provinces (plus four Yu commanderies), served as inspector of Jiang with credential staff at Wuchang, and backed his brother. Before leaving he memorialized:
43
I inherited privilege and rank yet lack exceptional gifts or foresight. Royal crises stripped the court of its pillars; imperial favor somehow settled on me. Five years have passed in anxious service. I have neither advanced Your Majesty's designs nor ordered the realm, yet you heap honors on me and hitch worn-out nags to ask for deeds beyond reach—only staggering grace explains it!" So I speak plainly: set aside ceremony for a moment and listen."
44
輿
The foe still lives; armies stand ready; the borders are weak and the interior tired—no one can gauge the next raid;" the people know no rest;" and talent still sits unused. Your Majesty sits far above and must rely on ministers for sight and hearing. Loyalty needs encouragement; diligence needs oversight. Ancient rulers listened widely even while handling every affair; they heard peasants and woodcutters for good reason. Our woes rival any age; Your Majesty bears heaven's mandate amid obstruction—every heart mourns what passed and fears what comes. Yet peace may still follow peril if we seize the moment. Expand tolerance thick as earth and heaven; root policy in stillness; teach and supervise tirelessly. Summon worthy advisers; weigh policy in open court until truth reaches the throne. Master the essentials, tighten the purse, and Yao-Shun rule lies within reach! Duke Wen of Wei wore rough cloth—nothing stops sage virtue! As the ancients put it, knowing is easier than doing; doing is harder; lasting peace is hardest." Accept counsel as did modest kings of old, and the realm will rejoice. Day and night I harbor these thoughts yet cannot fully voice them; laying down this brush I fear I have said too much.
45
Soon Empress Dowager Chu summoned him to serve at court; he pleaded grave illness. He died soon after, aged forty-nine. He was posthumously named palace attendant and Minister of Works with the epithet Zhongcheng (Loyal Achiever) and honored with the grand tai-lao sacrifice.
46
Bing was sober and careful by nature and lived plainly. When his son Xi borrowed ten bolts of official silk, Bing beat him and made him repay from his own purse. Dying, he told Jiang Bin, "I go with my pledge to the house unfulfilled—such is fate! Bury me in plain seasonal dress—nothing from the public stores." When he died his heirs had no silk even for a shroud. He kept no concubines and left no stash—the age admired him for it. Bing's seven sons were Xi, Xi, You, Yun, Qian, Miao, and Rou.
47
Xi and his brothers
48
西
Yu Xi, courtesy name Shiyan. He rose from secretary to senior clerk, gentleman at the Yellow Gate, and nominee for Jian'an governor; before taking Jian'an he served as chief clerk and general of the right guard, then palace attendant, then General Who Supports the State and governor of the Wu princedom. Xi tied by marriage to the empress and Bing's daughter wed Duke Haixi—the brothers stood high at court. Under Taihe, Xi commanded Xu-Yan as General of the Northern Gentlemen; Yun governed Guang with credential staff; You ruled Dongyang; Qian served the grand tutor; Miao joined the Prince of Kuaiji's staff; Rou was a regular attendant. Qian was the most gifted; Huan Wen feared him.
49
Murong Li's siege of Liangfu cut the streams; Zhuge You fled Tai commandery; several Qi commanderies fell and Xi lost his post. He was soon recalled as General Who Guards the Army. Xi refused in anger. Stripped of rank he looted northern headquarters stores; Huan Wen had him impeached and dismissed again, so he lived as a guest in Jiyang. Guo Pu once divined for Bing: "Your line faces ruin unless it dwells in the three Yang lands." Xi therefore sought Shanyang, You took Dongyang, and the family settled at Jiyang.
50
西 便 西
When Duke Haixi fell, Huan Wen executed Qian and Rou as friends of Prince Sima Zun of Wuling. Xi fled with Miao and Youzhi into the Hailing marshes. Yun drank poison at Guangzhou. You's daughter-in-law, Huan Mi's daughter, begged Huan Wen and spared him. Former inspector Wu Shen, Xi's cousin, fed him secretly for a year. When Huan Wen learned of it he sent troops after Xi. Wu Zun joined Xi on the coast, seized boats, and slipped into Jingkou by night. Bian Dan fled Qu'e over the wall; the garrison scattered. Xi armed hundreds of prisoners while Zun rallied outside, proclaiming that traitor Huan Wen had deposed the emperor and murdered princes under forged orders from Duke Haixi. The capital mobilized and sealed its six gates. Liu Shi, Xi Yizhi, Guo Long, and others raised troops against him. Bian Dan and Hong Rong of Qu'e drafted two thousand county levies at New City against Xi. Xi lost and bolted the gates. Huan Wen sent Zhou Shaosun; the city fell and Xi was taken. Xi, Miao, and five kinsmen died in the Jiankang marketplace; Zun and allies followed; only You and Yun's children survived.
51
You's son Shuxuan rose to general of the right guard. Yun's son Kuozhi governed Dongyang.
52
祿
Yu Tiao, courtesy name Youxu. He avoided service under the grand tutor, then served as gentleman at the Yellow Gate and governor of Yuzhang. He became overseer of the Secretariat, village marquis, then champion general and governor of Linchuan. Huang Tao declared himself emperor at Yuzhang with Li Gao as minister; Tiao crushed their hundreds of black-robed followers. He was the least gifted brother and rose little. He died in office and was posthumously named general of the left.
53
便婿
Yu Yi, courtesy name Zhigong. He was imposing in bearing and showed strategic genius young. Du Yi and Yin Hao topped their generation in reputation, yet Yu Yi dismissed them: shelf them until peace returns, then talk of office." At court he spotted the boy Huan Wen and told Emperor Cheng to treat him as a future pillar—not a routine in-law but a general like Fang Xuan or Shao Hu—who could carry the realm through crisis."
54
使 西
When Su Jun rose, Yu Yi was twenty-two; Liang gave him a hundred men in plain clothes to hold Stone City. When the defense collapsed he fled with Yi. After peace returned he entered Tao Kan's staff, became adjutant, and rose to aide-de-camp. On staff he carried himself with grace and sharp debate. He soon became General Who Rouses Might and governor of Poyang. He moved to General Who Establishes Might and governor of Xiyang. He won the people's trust. He became colonel of southern tribes and governor of Nan, added rank as General Who Supports the State with credential staff. After Zhucheng fell and Stone City was ringed, Yi fed the city with surprise sorties and smuggled supplies. Stone City held—credit belonged to Yi. He received the Duting marquisate.
55
西 使西 駿使
At Liang's death he took six provinces, the post of General Who Pacifies the West, and Jing Province from Liang's camp at Wuchang. A young imperial uncle commanding the upper Yangzi drew skeptical eyes. He drove himself without pause, ran a tight camp, and planned for the long term—within years the province prospered and opinion hailed his competence. South of the river men leaned toward Jin; Dai Kai of Runan brought thousands to surrender. He reached east to Liaodong and west to Liangzhou to line up allies for a major strike. Murong Huang and Zhang Jun answered with envoys and promised coordination. He meant to crush the northern barbarians and Cheng Han—every word showed it. When Colonel Qian Qi's advice suited him, Yi promoted him to Five-Camps general and gave two hundred hu of grain. Heavy eastern taxes drove people by sea to Guangzhou; Governor Deng Yue's open foundries taught tribes to cast arms. He warned that smuggling and tribal casting on the eastern rim would arm rivals against the court.
56
退 使使
Yin Hao had ignored every summons, yet when Yi offered marshal posts he still stayed home. Yi wrote urging him to reconsider. Earlier Yin Xian's harsh rule at Changsha had prompted Bing to write Yi. Yi answered that Yin Xian had arrived swaggering yet effective, and family ties had eased local resentment. Lately Yin Xian's public zeal faded while private greed grew—Yi felt less warmth toward him. Yet Yi respected virtue and friendship too much to judge Hao only by his father's sins. Jiangdong law favored magnates and punished only the weak. When a million hu vanished from Stone City, magnates murdered petty clerks to close the books. Shan Xia doubled registered households at Yuyao yet magnates hounded him from office. Ji Mu and Xu Ning lost their posts when their impeachment mission failed because Huan Yi interfered. Such miscarriages explain why Jiangdong governance failed. We are mired in the same foul court—we must fix law together. Of twenty commanderies under Jing, Changsha is worst governed. Leaving Changsha unreformed repeats the granary scandal. Yi's blunt judgments sounded like this.
57
Emperor Kang's accession stirred Yi to propose a northern expedition:
58
忿 西 西 便
Shi Hu is sixty, spent by debauchery, deserted by followers, and gambling everything on Liaodong. Murong Huang may not hold Liaodong. If no Hu pins Murong down, the south will face the same peril. Hence Yi mobilized militia despite outrage. East and west may not move together; he would advance via Anlu and the five-hundred-mile Han corridor. He led thirty thousand under Wang Yanqi, Xie Shang, Yuan Zhen, and Cao Ju, ordered Huan Xuan to strike Huangji and threaten Qin-Yong via the Dan. He planned to hold enemy reins, trade rest for enemy fatigue, and reconquer within years. At Xu-Luo he wanted Huan Wen on Guangling, He Chong on the Huai line, and Lu Yong at Hefei. He begged instant approval—debate would miss the moment. Speed wins wars—not prolonged polish.
59
使
He then impressed labor and draft animals across six provinces until people cursed. He meant to take Xiangyang but told the court he was moving to Anlu. The emperor and Sun Chuo begged him to wait. He went anyway. At Xiakou he wrote again:
60
調 便
He reported gains north of the Han and several Jiangxia towns. He left Wuchang on the nineteenth and reached Xiakou on the twenty-fourth with troops ready. Draft animals arrived exhausted and fodder ran short. Winter dried grazing and two thousand-mile marches risked breakdown—he paused the push. Low winter rivers made supply impossible.
61
西退
Xiangyang anchors Jing-Chu, borders Yi-Liang and the Central Plain—fertile, defensible, and supplied by water. He lacked genius but owed the dynasty his best effort. Four years he drilled troops, trusting throne and people to wear the barbarians down. His Yonghe memorial to fort Lexiang and farm had died in committee.
62
Omens and intelligence since showed the Hu failing. Even without conquering the plain he had to seize choke points. He moved headquarters into the Han and aimed at Xiangyang. He ordered columns back to their posts and promised reports.
63
西 西 使 西
Forty thousand men earned him overall command of the expedition. At Xiangyang he massed the army, showed arms, and shot an arrow saying his campaign would fly straight. Three volleys rallied the ranks. Court had sneered at the Xiangyang move—only Bing, Huan Wen, and Sima Wuji backed him. Bing offered to hold Wuchang as reserve. Ministers vetoed Bing's move. Yi gained General Who Punishes the West and southern colonelcy. Hundreds of Hu sortied from Fancheng; Cao Ju crushed them at Raogou. He hosted frontier peoples with guesthouses and protocol officers. When Huan Xuan died Yi named Fangzhi Yicheng governor over Xuan's troops, made Ying Dan dragon-galloping general at Xiangyang, and posted adjutant Si Xun as general who establishes might and inspector of Liang at west city. After Kang and Bing died Yi left Fangzhi at Xiangyang, rushed to Xiakou, absorbed Bing's army, and named Tong governor of Xunyang. He was ordered back to Jiangzhou as inspector of Yu but declined Yu. He asked to move to Lexiang; the court refused. He rebuilt arsenal and granaries for another advance. Zhou Fu and Cao Ju struck Shu and beat Li Huan at Jiangyang.
64
Yu Yuanzhi echoed his father's style until Huan Wen removed him. Huan Wen then installed Liu Tan over the Han river and Yicheng in place of Fangzhi. The transmitted text breaks mid clause after mentioning Fangzhi. Fangzhi and Yuanzhi were banished to Yuzhang.
65
使 滿 使 使
The historians say consort kin bathed in inner-palace favor and traded on access. Their gates brimmed with treasure until arrogance followed. Fine mounts and military power made them overbearing. Antiquity honored merit over in-laws, checked excess, and seldom gave kin the keys of state. Tushan at Xia did not ride with the worthy ministers. The Si house at Zhou did not rank with eastern states. The sages planned long ahead. Yu Liang rose as kin and helped draft the deathbed charge. His prose and speech dazzled and made him primus among peers. Yet talent misjudged the realm; Great gifts paired with shallow judgment. Executing Zong showed resolve to cut rot at the root; The emperor's gift of a ruler warned him like bristles on the back. Su Jun and Zu Yue nearly toppled the altars. Soon they turned on the chief minister and plotted to oust the regent. Had Xi Jian joined them, armies would have marched against the throne—little better than classic traitors Tai, Chan, An, and Jie. Mercifully the law's net let whales slip—the Yus escaped execution—proof of dynastic mercy, not slack justice. Yu Yi's poison cup killed a governor; two generations on only the three Yang settlements remained—the later ruin matched the crime.
66
The ode runs: Yuangui masked ambition while kinship opened the inner palace to him. Dim judgment misruled the realm—rebellion slipped through every crack. Yielding on Changsha policy shamed them beside true loyal ministers. Jijian stayed honest and modest—virtue made his name fly. In prosperity he lived spare; in power he feared excess. Zhigong strode forth with passion and won a soldier's fame.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →