← Back to 舊唐書

卷九十五 列傳第四十五: 睿宗諸子

Volume 95 Biographies 45: Ruizong's Sons

Chapter 99 of 舊唐書 · Old Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 99
Next Chapter →
1
Cui Riyong was from Lingchang in Huazhou; his forebears had relocated their household from Boling. After earning his jinshi degree, he began his career as magistrate of Ruicheng. In 701, when Empress Wu traveled to Chang'an, her route took her through Shaan Prefecture. Zong Chuke was serving as prefect at the time. Riyong handled provisioning for the imperial stopover, procured delicacies far and wide, and distributed them to every member of the entourage in Chuke's name. Chuke was so pleased when he heard of it that he lavished praise on Riyong and recommended him at length, and Riyong was accordingly promoted to magistrate of Xinfeng. Shortly afterward he received appointment as investigating censor.
2
祿
During the Shenlong period (705–707), Zheng Pusi, Director of the Secretariat, placed a daughter in the inner palace and secretly engaged in forbidden cult practices. Riyong immediately submitted an impeachment memorial against him. Pusi was riding high on imperial favor at the time, and Emperor Zhongzong took no notice. Riyong pressed his case passionately in open court debate, speaking with blunt forthrightness, and Pusi ultimately confessed his crimes. Zong Chuke, Wu Sansi, Wu Yanxiu, and their allies were then taking turns as court factions. Riyong quietly attached himself to each in turn and was rapidly promoted to Vice Minister of War and concurrently a Xiuxian Hall academician. After Emperor Zhongzong died suddenly and Empress Wei seized power as regent, Riyong feared he would be caught up in the coming purge. Learning that Prince Lin (the future Xuanzong) was planning a coup, he used the monk Purun and the Daoist Wang Ye as intermediaries to visit the prince's residence in secret, pledged himself deeply, and plotted to help place him on the throne. Xuanzong once told him, "In what we are planning now, I act solely for my family—not for my own gain. Riyong replied, "Such filial devotion moves Heaven itself—the enterprise is bound to succeed. Strike at once, while they are unprepared. Even a brief delay may bring unforeseen trouble." The night the Wei faction was overthrown, he was appointed acting Administrator of Yong Prefecture. For his service he was made Silver-Gleaming Grand Master of Splendid Happiness and Vice Director of the Yellow Gate, with a seat in deliberating state affairs; he was enfeoffed as Duke of Qi with a substantive fief of two hundred households.
3
忿 滿
After barely a month as chief minister he clashed with Vice Director Xue Ji; their bitter dispute at the Secretariat cost him his post, and he was reassigned as Administrator of Yong Prefecture with his seat in government withdrawn. He was soon sent out as Senior Administrator of Yangzhou, then served in turn as prefect of Wu and Bian, Military Commissioner of Yanzhou, and Senior Administrator of Jingzhou. On a visit to court he said, "Princess Taiping's rebellion is imminent. When Your Majesty was still in the princely residence and wished to move against her, you were bound by the roles of son and subject and had to rely on stratagem and force. Now that you occupy the throne, a single edict is all that is required. Who would dare disobey? If the traitors gain the upper hand even briefly, the resulting turmoil will be grave indeed. The Emperor replied, "If matters stand as you say, I am chiefly afraid of alarming the Retired Emperor. You should reconsider." Riyong said, "I have heard that the Son of Heaven's filial piety and the commoner's filial piety are entirely different things. For the commoner, filial piety means disciplining oneself, living frugally, and deferring to a parent's wishes; for the Son of Heaven it means securing the realm and stabilizing the altars of state. If the rebels strike now, the imperial enterprise itself will be lost—how could that fulfill a Son of Heaven's filial duty! I beg Your Majesty to secure the Northern Army first and then arrest the rebels; the Retired Emperor need not be disturbed at all." Xuanzong adopted his plan. During the campaign against Xiao Zhizhong and Dou Huaizhen he was again made provisional Inspector of Yong Prefecture, and his substantive fief was raised to four hundred households in all. He was soon appointed Minister of Personnel.
4
殿
Riyong once compiled twenty pieces from the Mao Odes, the Greater and Lesser Elegantiae, and Sima Xiangru's Letter on the Feng and Shan Sacrifices, and presented them in a birthday memorial as gentle admonition, together with an account of announcing the completion of great undertakings. The Emperor answered in his own hand: "Poetry moves Heaven and Earth, stirs spirits and ghosts, enriches humankind, and adorns moral instruction. What my heart esteems in poetry I wish to match; may the officers who gather songs help remedy my shortcomings. In antiquity the feng and shan rites ascended Mount Tai to announce the completion of great deeds; my own virtue is slight, and I am far from grasping the highest Way. I listened with awe, and Xiangru's rhetoric indeed stirred me; yet I bore Guan Zhong's warning in mind as well and felt shame anew. Your learning is broad and your insight complete; in reviving the old to illuminate the new, this presentation shows your loyal earnestness all the more clearly. Surely in searching the libraries of Penglai you did not forget to awaken me; and on this auspicious day in the Orchid Hall your words offered counsel of real depth. I have read them again and again, and they comfort my heart. I now grant you one set of robes and fifty lengths of goods, as proof that no loyal word goes unrewarded."
5
He was soon sent out as prefect of Changzhou; three hundred households were stripped from his substantive fief, and he was transferred to prefect of Ruzhou. In 719, when household levies were reduced across the empire, a special edict declared: "At the restoration of the Tang, the rebel faction plotted treason. Cui Riyong had secretly discussed the matter beforehand and truly shared in the original design; yet his fief was later reduced under the general rule. His merit was outstanding, and his fief should be restored to the original grant of two hundred households. In 722 he was transferred to Senior Administrator of the Bingzhou Metropolitan Command. He died soon afterward at the age of fifty. He was posthumously appointed Minister of Personnel and given the posthumous title Zhao ("Illustrious"). He was later posthumously made Metropolitan Governor of Jingzhou as well; his son Zongzhi inherited the title.
6
祿 殿 使
Riyong's eloquence and quick wit surpassed others'. Whenever crisis struck the court he turned disaster to advantage and secured wealth and high office. After the Xiantian period (712–713) he sought a return to the chancellorship but never achieved it. He often said, "Everything I have done in life I decided on the spot; there is no need to cling stubbornly to one's first plan. Even now, whenever I think of it, I feel as though needles were pricking my back. Cui Rizhi, Riyong's paternal cousin, likewise possessed administrative talent. During the Jingyun era (710–711) he served as Vice Prefect of Luozhou. When Prince Chongfu of Qiao raised rebellion in the Eastern Capital, the officials all fled and hid; Rizhi alone rallied the local staff to the garrison command and joined the encamped troops to suppress the rebels. After Chongfu's death Rizhi was promoted to Silver-Gleaming Grand Master of Splendid Happiness for his service and eventually rose to Metropolitan Governor of Jingzhao. Impeached for corruption by Censor Li Rubi, he was demoted to assistant magistrate of She County but was soon promoted again, eventually reaching Director of the Palace Domestic Service. Rizhi had long been on good terms with Zhang Yue, who recommended him and petitioned for his appointment as Censor-in-Chief; the Emperor refused. Rizhi was instead made General of the Left Feathered Forest Guard, while Cui Yinpu, Metropolitan Governor of Henan, was appointed Censor-in-Chief; Yinpu and Yue became estranged as a result. Rizhi was soon transferred to Minister of Rites. Because he had served so long, whenever officials gathered at court he was placed in the same row as the Ministers; contemporaries dubbed him "the Minister in practice," and the nickname stuck. In 728 he was sent out as Senior Administrator of the Luzhou Metropolitan Command. He soon retired on grounds of age and later died; he was given the posthumous title Xiang ("Assisting"). Zhang Jiazhen was a native of Yishi in Pu Prefecture. At twenty he took the Five Classics examination, was appointed magistrate of Pingxiang, but was dismissed for an offense and returned home. During the Chang'an period (701–705), Attending Censor Zhang Xunxian, serving as Investigation Commissioner of Hedong, recommended Jiazhen as qualified for a censor's post and offered to surrender his own rank to secure the appointment. Empress Wu summoned him for audience and spoke with him from behind the screen. Jiazhen said, "That a commoner like myself should gain audience in the inner palace is a chance that comes once in a thousand years. Yet within a foot's distance I am separated as if by clouds and mist and cannot behold Your Majesty's face; I fear the bond between ruler and subject is not fully honored. Empress Wu immediately ordered the screen raised, spoke with him at length with great pleasure, and promoted him to investigating censor. He rose to Secretariat Drafter and served in turn as Military Commissioner of Qinzhou and Senior Administrator of Bingzhou; his administration was stern and severe, and officials and clerks alike feared him.
7
Early in the Kaiyuan reign he came to the capital on official business; the Emperor heard reports of his excellent administration and repeatedly praised and encouraged him. Jiazhen then said, "I lost my parents young; my brothers have depended on one another ever since. My younger brother Jiayou has just been appointed Vice Prefect of Binzhou; we are posted to opposite ends of the empire, united in heart yet separated in body, our spirits torn apart by ten thousand li. I beg that he be transferred to a post near mine; my brother and I will serve the state with all our strength and die without regret. The Emperor admired his brotherly devotion and specially transferred Jiayou to prefect of Xinzhou.
8
使 使 祿
The nine Turkic clans had recently submitted and were scattered north of Taiyuan. Jiazhen petitioned to establish a garrison army, and the Heavenly Troops Army was accordingly founded at Bingzhou with Jiazhen as its commissioner. In the spring of the sixth year (718) Jiazhen returned to court. Soon someone accused him of extravagance and corruption in the army. Censor-in-Chief Wang Jun impeached him on that basis, but the investigation found no evidence, and the Emperor was about to punish the accuser for false reporting. Jiazhen said, "In antiquity the Son of Heaven heard government from above: the blind sang ballads, the sightless recited, craftsmen remonstrated, and commoners criticized—only then did the ruler weigh all these voices. If Your Majesty punishes these accusers now, you will block the path of those who speak, and nothing under Heaven will reach Your Majesty's ears. I beg Your Majesty to waive punishment in this case and keep the channels of criticism open. The Emperor agreed and commuted the death sentence; from that time he regarded Jiazhen as a loyal minister. Jiazhen also once said, "My mind and strength are at their peak—this is the season to serve with my life. In a few more years I will be old and useless. I beg Your Majesty to employ me while I am still able; I do not fear death. The Emperor valued him all the more for his clarity and eloquence. In the spring of 720, when Song Jing and Su Ting left office, Jiazhen was promoted to Vice Director of the Secretariat and appointed Associate Chief Minister. Within months he was made Silver-Gleaming Grand Master of Splendid Happiness and promoted to Director of the Secretariat.
9
殿
Jiazhen decided cases with swift judgment and was skilled at court presentation, but his nature was forceful, impatient, and self-willed, and contemporary opinion often criticized him. The Secretariat Drafters Miao Yansi and Lü Taiyi, Director of Evaluations Yuan Jiajing, and Palace Attending Censor Cui Xun were all Jiazhen's protégés, holding prestigious posts and constantly gathered at his door to discuss policy. A contemporary saying ran: "The Chief Minister's four talents: Miao, Lü, Cui, and Yuan."
10
簿 退
In 722 the Emperor traveled to the Eastern Capital. The Luoyang Registrar Wang Jun had built a residence for Jiazhen in hopes of securing a censor's post; when a bribery case came to light, the Emperor ordered a public assembly at court to decide his execution. Jiazhen pressed the officials to hurry the execution and silence him, then shifted blame onto Censor-in-Chief Wei Kang and Vice Censor-in-Chief Wei Xuxin; both were demoted. That winter Director of the Secretariat Jiang Jiao was convicted of a crime; Jiazhen again joined Wang Shouyi in petitioning for corporal punishment, and Jiang died on the road into exile. Soon afterward Military Commissioner of Guangzhou Pei Xianxian was imprisoned; the Emperor asked his ministers what sentence was appropriate, and Jiazhen again petitioned for corporal punishment. Minister of War Zhang Yue stepped forward and said, "I have heard that punishment does not reach high officials, because they stand close to the ruler. Hence the saying: 'A gentleman may be killed, but he must not be humiliated. This autumn I received orders to tour the frontier; midway I learned that Jiang Jiao had been beaten at court for his crime and died on the road into exile. Jiang held third-rank office and had rendered some service. If he was guilty, let him be executed if death was warranted or exiled if exile was warranted; he should not have been beaten and humiliated at court as though he were a common soldier. Moreover, the law provides the Eight Deliberations, under which meritorious nobles are protected. What is done to Jiang cannot be undone. Pei should be exiled according to the facts of his case; he must not be beaten again on a whim. The Emperor agreed. Jiazhen was displeased. As he withdrew he said to Yue, "Why press the point so hard? Yue replied, "A chief minister takes office when the time comes—who can hold the post forever? If every noble minister may be beaten, I fear we ourselves will soon face the same fate. I spoke not for Pei's sake but for gentlemen and scholars everywhere." Earlier, when Jiazhen was Vice Director of the Ministry of War, Zhang Yue was Vice Minister. Now Yue ranked below Jiazhen, and with no deference on either side Yue was deeply resentful; he used these words deliberately to provoke Jiazhen, and the two became estranged. The Emperor also appointed Jiazhen's younger brother Jiayou as General of the Golden Guards; with both brothers holding posts of general and minister, contemporaries feared them greatly. In 723, when the Emperor visited the traveling palace at Taiyuan, Jiayou's corruption was exposed. Zhang Yue urged Jiazhen to wear mourning dress and await judgment, barring him from court audience; Jiazhen was sent out as prefect of Youzhou, and Yue replaced him as Director of the Secretariat. Jiazhen was bitter and said to others, "There are fortunately two Directors of the Secretariat—why hound me so relentlessly! The following year he was reappointed Minister of Revenue and concurrently Senior Administrator of Yizhou, with authority over the military commissioner's affairs. The Emperor ordered Jiazhen to attend a Secretariat banquet with the chief ministers; still resenting Zhang Yue's maneuver against him, Jiazhen rolled up his sleeves and erupted in furious abuse until Yuan Qianyao and Wang Jun intervened to calm him.
11
The following year, for associating with Wang Shouyi, he was demoted to prefect of Taizhou. He again replaced Lu Congyuan as Minister of Works and prefect of Dingzhou, with authority over Beiping military affairs, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Hedong. Before his departure the Emperor composed a poem in his honor and ordered the officials to see him off outside the Upper East Gate. On reaching his post he erected a eulogy stele at the Mount Heng temple, composing the text himself and carving it on white stone with black inscription—a work of striking beauty. The shrine had accumulated several million in cash from offerings near and far; Jiazhen, claiming the merit of his eulogy, took tens of thousands for himself. In 729 Jiazhen, ill, petitioned to seek treatment in the Eastern Capital; the Emperor granted his request. On reaching the capital he had gone blind; the Emperor dispatched the physicians Inner Attendant Tian Xiuyu and Commandant Lü Hongtai by relay post to treat him. He died that autumn at the age of sixty-four and was posthumously appointed Metropolitan Governor of Yizhou. He was given the posthumous title Gongsu ("Respectful and Solemn").
12
Though Jiazhen had long held prestigious posts, he never established landed estates. At Dingzhou some associates urged him to acquire farmland. Jiazhen said, "I have enjoyed the honors of high office and once served as chief minister—before I die, why should I fear hunger? If I fall under censure and punishment, even vast estates will be useless. I have lately seen officials seize vast estates, only to leave them after death as resources for worthless sons and nephews to squander on wine and women—what folly that is. All who heard him sighed in admiration.
13
簿 退 婿
When Jiazhen first became chief minister he recommended Han Chaozong, registrar of Wannian County, and promoted him to investigating censor. More than ten years after Jiazhen's death, Chaozong, now Metropolitan Governor of Jingzhao, memorialized: "Since Your Majesty's accession, every chief minister appointed has risen and retired with propriety, beginning and ending well; though they have died, their descendants still serve at court. Only Zhang Jiazhen's son, born in his later years, has still not entered official service. The Emperor was moved as well and immediately summoned the youth, bestowing the name Yanbao and specially appointing him Military Staff Officer of the Left Inner Rate. Under Emperor Dezong he rose to chief minister; his career is recorded in a separate biography. Zhang Jiayou was capable and resourceful. Demoted from Right General of the Golden Guards to colonel of the Puyang garrison, by 737 he had become prefect of Xiangzhou. Since the Kaiyuan reign more than ten Xiangzhou prefects had died or been demoted in office. Jiayou learned that Yuwen Jiong had served as area commander of Xiang at the end of the Northern Zhou and died for the state, and he established a shrine to Jiong's spirit to seek divine protection. After three evaluations he was transferred to Left General of the Golden Guards. Later, when Wu Jing became prefect of Ye, he added imperial regalia to Yuwen's spirit image as well. From then on prefects of the commandery suffered no mishaps. Xiao Song was the great-grandnephew of Xiao Yu, Left Vice Director of the Secretariat and Duke of Song in early Zhenguan. His grandfather Jun had been a Secretariat Drafter renowned in his day. Song had a magnificent beard and a grand, imposing bearing. He first married the daughter of He Hui of Kuaiji and thereby became brothers-in-law with Lu Xiangxian of Wu Commandery. Xiangxian was then Vice Magistrate of Luoyang, a chief minister's son of very high family standing. Song had not yet entered office. Xia Rong of Xuanzhou, who claimed skill in physiognomy, told Xiangxian, "Within ten years you will reach the highest rank, yet you will not equal the Xiao clan in nobility—they will hold high office and enjoy long life. Contemporaries did not believe him.
14
調 殿
In 705 Song was appointed administrator of Mingzhou. Soon Attending Secretariat Director Huan Yanfan, Prince of Fuyang, went out as prefect of Mingzhou, esteemed Song on meeting him, and treated him with exceptional courtesy. In 710 he served as magistrate of Liquan. Lu Xiangxian was then Vice Director of the Secretariat and secured his appointment as investigating censor. When Xiangxian entered the government, Song was rapidly promoted to Palace Attending Censor. Early in the Kaiyuan reign he became Secretariat Drafter. He served alongside Cui Lin, Wang Qiu, and Qi Huan, who all regarded him as poorly educated and unremarkable, but Yao Chong, Director of the Purple Asterism, foresaw his future success and favored him deeply. He served as prefect of Songzhou and after three promotions became Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and Vice Minister of War.
15
西 祿 退 西使 使 祿 祿 使西
In 727 Wang Junyao, prefect of Liangzhou and Military Commissioner of Hexi, relying on his large force attacked Tibet every year. The Tibetan generals Sinoluogonglu and Zhulongmangbuzhi captured Guazhou, seized Prefect Tian Yuanxian and Junyao's father Shou, stripped the city of all military stores and grain, and destroyed the walls before withdrawing. They also attacked Yumen Army and Changle County, but Magistrate Jia Shishun held the walls firm and the enemy withdrew. Before long Junyao was killed by Uyghur tribes at Gongbi Post, sending shock through the He and Long frontier regions. Xuanzong judged that Junyao, a brave but unstrategic general, had brought disaster on himself; he selected Song as Minister of War and Military Commissioner of Hexi, with authority over Liangzhou affairs. Song requested Pei Kuan, Guo Xuji, and Niu Xianke for his staff, and asked that Zhang Shougui, commissioner of the Jiankang Army and Left General of the Golden Guards, be made prefect of Guazhou to rebuild the city walls, gather the populace, and restore their livelihoods. Song was further promoted to Silver-Gleaming Grand Master of Splendid Happiness. Sinoluogonglu's reputation was then at its height; Song spread disinformation among the Tibetans that he was secretly communicating with China, and the Tibetan ruler summoned and executed him. The following autumn Tibet invaded in force; Ximoming again led troops against Guazhou, but Shougui drove them off. Zhang Zhiliang, Military Commissioner of Longyou and Area Commander of Shanzhou, led troops to Fengbo Valley southwest of Qinghai, engaged the Tibetans, and won a great victory. In the eighth month Song sent Vice General Du Binke with four thousand crossbowmen to fight the Tibetans below Qilian Fortress. The battle raged from morning to evening; the enemy broke and re-formed repeatedly, then collapsed in rout. One Tibetan vice general was beheaded on the field; the survivors fled into the valleys wailing on all sides. When the victory bulletin arrived Xuanzong was delighted and made Song Associate of the Third Rank of the Secretariat-Chancellery; his favor was unmatched.
16
西 殿祿
In 729 Yuwen Rong and Pei Guangting were appointed chief ministers, and Song was further made concurrent Director of the Secretariat. Since Zhang Yue, Duke of Yan, had left the post of Director of the Secretariat in 726, the office had been vacant for four years; Song now filled it. He continued to hold the Hexi commission in absentia. He was made Academician of the Jixian Hall with charge of academy affairs, concurrently editor of the national history, and promoted to Golden-Gleaming Grand Master of Splendid Happiness. His son Heng married Princess Xinchang; when Song's wife Lady He attended court and bowed at the feast, Xuanzong addressed her as his mother-in-law by marriage with great ceremony. He was soon further enfeoffed as Duke of Xu. In the second month of 733 Attending Secretariat Director Pei Guangting died. Guangting and Song had shared power for years on poor terms; the Emperor now asked Song to recommend a successor. Song nominated Han Xiu, the Right Vice Director, as a man of mature judgment. When Han Xiu became chief minister he was stern and upright and would not defer to Song; they argued before the Emperor until Song offered to resign. The Emperor's affection for Song remained strong; he permitted Song to take the title Right Chancellor of the Department of State Affairs while leaving the chancellorship, and made Han Xiu Minister of Works. He soon appointed Song's son Hua as Drafting Attendant.
17
使 婿 祿 使
In 736 he was appointed Grand Preceptor of the Heir Apparent. When Zhang Shougui, Military Commissioner of Youzhou, was demoted to prefect of Kuozhou for bribing the eunuch Niu Xiantong, Li Linfu exposed Song's own bribery of Xiantong, and Song was demoted to prefect of Qingzhou. He was soon reappointed Grand Preceptor of the Heir Apparent, but Song again petitioned to retire. Song loved taking medicines and elixirs; after leaving office he planted herbs in his garden and compounded them for his own use. Hua was then Vice Minister of Works; Heng, as the emperor's son-in-law, held third rank. Song lived in white-haired retirement for more than ten years, his household wealthy and honored among the gentry. He died in 749 at more than eighty years of age and was posthumously made Grand Master of the Palace with ceremonial equal to the Three Excellencies. Xiao Hua was transferred to Vice Minister of War at the end of the Tianbao era. During the An Lushan rebellion he failed to accompany the court in its flight, fell into rebel hands, and was appointed prefect of Weizhou under the rebel regime. In 758 Guo Ziyi and the armies of the nine commissioners crossed the Yellow River to attack An Qingxu at Xiangzhou; Hua secretly sent memorials pledging to serve as an inside collaborator when the imperial army arrived. The rebels discovered his plot and imprisoned him. Cui Guangyuan recovered Weizhou, broke his chains, and freed him. The people of Wei admired his benevolent administration and petitioned Guangyuan to retain him; the court formally appointed him prefect of Weizhou. Soon Shi Siming led his forces south; Guo Ziyi feared Hua would be captured again and memorialized for Cui Guangyuan to replace him, summoning Hua to headquarters. After the rout at Xiangzhou Hua returned to the capital but, still tainted by his service under the rebels, was demoted to provisional Vice Director of the Secretariat. Hua was careful, dignified, and refined, with strong family discipline; men of standing praised him. He was soon promoted to Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. In 759 he was sent out as Governor of Hezhong and Military Commissioner of Hezhong, Jin, and Jiang.
18
使 殿
In the twelfth month of 760 an edict declared: "In choosing one to assist me, I seek one who reads the signs of the times; the realm is not yet pacified, and statecraft is urgently needed. I require a brilliant exemplar to aid the age; talent to unify policy is close at hand. Proper Counselor Xiao Hua, former Governor of Hezhong, concurrently Vice Censor-in-Chief and Military Commissioner of Jin and Jiang prefectures, Pillar of the State, heir to the Duke of Xu, bearer of the gold and purple fish tally: renowned as a chief minister, heir to a distinguished house, his words elegant and his virtue steeped in wise counsel. Twice serving in the palace administration, he knows utmost conduct well; in serving the ruler he aspires to excellence; in reviewing ministers he seeks true ability. He extends the worth of Yi Zhi, reopens the gate of Han ministers, returns to stand beside the sun and moon, and assists in ordering the realm. Let him take part in government at the Purple Asterism Hall and employ the Mean to establish the supreme pole. He is appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat, Associate Chief Minister, Grand Academician of the Jixian and Chongwen Halls, and supervisor of editing the national history."
19
仿
The eunuch Li Fuguo then controlled the palace guard, wielded power through imperial favor, and sought the chancellorship, pressuring chief ministers such as Pei Mian to recommend him. Hua resisted firmly, and Fuguo was enraged. While Emperor Suzong lay ill, Fuguo forged an order removing Hua from the chancellorship and retaining him as Minister of Rites, then installed Yuan Zai in his place. After Suzong's death, while Daizong was in mourning seclusion, Yuan Zai, courting Fuguo's favor, demoted Hua to acting military adjutant of Xiazhou; he died in exile. Among the later descendants of Xiao Heng and Xiao Hua, Heng's son Fu rose to chief minister under Emperor Dezong. Hua's sons were Heng and Wu. Heng's son Fu became chief minister in the Dahe era (827–835). Wu's son Fang became chief minister in the Xiantong era (860–874); each has a separate biography. Zhang Jiuling, style name Zishou, also known as Bowu. His great-grandfather Junzheng was Vice Prefect of Shaozhou and settled the family at Shixing; the clan is now counted as from Qujiang. His father Hongyu was posthumously made prefect of Guangzhou because of Jiuling's eminence. Jiuling was clever and perceptive as a boy and skilled at literary composition. At thirteen he presented a letter to Guangzhou Prefect Wang Fangqing, who greatly admired him and said, "This youth is bound to go far. He passed the jinshi examination, earned the second grade in the special examination, and was appointed Collator. When Xuanzong was crown prince he gathered literary talents from across the empire and personally examined them; Jiuling ranked at the top and was promoted to Right Reminder. The Emperor had not yet performed the suburban sacrifice in person; Jiuling submitted a memorial stating:
20
Jiuling was esteemed for his talent and discernment. The Ministry of Personnel repeatedly assigned him and Right Reminder Zhao Dongxi to grade candidates for the outstanding selection and civil examinations; they did so four times in succession, and each time their judgments were praised as fair. In 722, after three promotions, he became Vice Director of the Bureau of Merit. Zhang Yue was then Director of the Secretariat; he shared Jiuling's surname and treated him as a kinsman of the younger generation, cherishing him greatly and often saying, "Among later men of letters he stands first. Jiuling, delighted to find a patron, attached himself to Yue as well. In 723 he was appointed Secretariat Drafter.
21
使
In 725 the Emperor traveled east and performed the feng and shan sacrifices. Yue himself fixed the posts for attendants at the Mount Tai ascent, promoting many recording clerks and chief clerks from the two secretariats and his own intimates acting in office, then specially advancing them and leap-promoting them to fifth rank. Yue first ordered Jiuling to draft the edict. Jiuling told him, "Office and rank are the public vessels of the realm; virtue and reputation come first, merit and seniority next. If ranks are turned upside down, ridicule and slander will follow. The blessings of the feng sacrifice come once in a thousand years. Men of pure reputation and high rank receive no special grace, while clerks of the lowest ranks are first given insignia and ribbons. I fear that once the edict is issued, the empire will be disappointed. The draft can still be revised. I beg Your Excellency to consider carefully and leave no cause for regret. Yue replied, "The matter is settled. Idle talk is not worth worrying about!" He did not heed the advice. When the edict was issued, court and country alike blamed Yue. Vice Censor-in-Chief Yuwen Rong had just mastered the field-household system; whenever he memorialized, Yue often opposed him, and Rong grew resentful. Jiuling again urged Yue to take precautions; Yue again refused. Before long Yue was impeached by Rong and left office; Jiuling was transferred to Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and soon sent out as prefect of Jizhou. Jiuling's mother was elderly in their home district, and the Hebei posting was far away; he memorialized firmly to exchange it for a Jiangnan prefecture so he could hear from her more often. The Emperor graciously agreed and made him Area Commander of Hongzhou. He was soon transferred to Area Commander of Guizhou and also served as Investigation Commissioner of the Lingnan Circuit. The Emperor also appointed his younger brothers Jiuzhang and Jiugao as prefects on the Lingnan Circuit so that at seasonal festivals they could all visit their mother in peace.
22
使祿 祿 祿
When Zhang Yue directed the Jixian Academy he often recommended Jiuling as fit to be an academician and imperial adviser. After Yue's death the Emperor recalled his recommendation and appointed Jiuling Vice Director of the Secretariat Library, Jixian Academician, and deputy director of academy affairs. He was soon promoted to Vice Director of the Secretariat. He often submitted confidential memorials, many of which the Emperor adopted. He soon mourned his mother's death and returned home. In the twelfth month of 733 he was recalled from mourning and appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat and Associate Chief Minister. The following year he was promoted to Director of the Secretariat and concurrently editor of the national history. Military Commissioner of Fanyang Zhang Shougui had his lieutenant An Lushan campaign against the Xi and Khitan; when Lushan was defeated, Shougui seized him and sent him to the capital, requesting that court law be applied. Jiuling memorialized: "When Rangju led the army forth, he executed Zhuang Jia; when Sun Wu taught warfare, he beheaded palace women as well. Shougui's military orders must be enforced; Lushan ought not be spared death. The Emperor specially pardoned him. Jiuling said, "Lushan has the heart of a wolf cub and the face of a rebel. I beg to execute him for his crime and forestall future trouble. The Emperor replied, "Do not, like Wang Yifu who recognized Shi Le too late, mistakenly harm a loyal man." Lushan was released and sent back to the frontier.
23
祿 使
In 735 he was made Golden-Gleaming Grand Master of Splendid Happiness and enfeoffed as Earl of Shixing County. Li Linfu lacked learning himself and resented that the Emperor valued Jiuling's literary conduct and integrity. He brought Niu Xianke into government; Jiuling repeatedly objected, and the Emperor was displeased. In 736 he was transferred to Right Chancellor of the Department of State Affairs and left the chancellorship. Whenever chief ministers later recommended high officials, the Emperor always asked, "Does his bearing match Jiuling's? By precedent officials tucked their court tablets in their belts before mounting a horse. Jiuling's health was frail, and he often had an attendant carry his tablet; he therefore devised the tablet pouch. The tablet pouch began with Jiuling.
24
使 忿
When Jiuling was chief minister he had recommended Chang'an Vice Magistrate Zhou Ziliang as investigating censor. Ziliang then rashly predicted fortune and calamity; the Emperor personally interrogated him and ordered his execution at court. Jiuling was demoted to Senior Administrator of the Jingzhou Metropolitan Command for having recommended an unfit man. He soon requested leave to visit his parents' tombs, fell ill on the journey, and died at sixty-eight. He was posthumously made Metropolitan Governor of Jingzhou and given the posthumous title Wenxian ("Literary Exemplar"). As chief minister Jiuling proposed restoring the ten-circuit investigation commissioners and urged several Henan prefectures to plant rice by irrigation to expand garrison agriculture. The garrison-field project cost labor without profit and was eventually abandoned. His nature was impatient and quick to anger; commentators thought less of him for it.
25
祿
His son Zheng served as magistrate of Yique. During the An Lushan rebellion he fell into rebel hands but refused to accept appointment under the rebel regime. After the two capitals were recovered he was appointed Right Supporter of the Heir Apparent. His younger brother Jiugao rose from a Secretariat director's post to serve in turn as prefect of Tang, Xu, Song, Xiang, and Guang prefectures. Jiuzhang served in turn as prefect of Ji, Ming, and Cao prefectures and as Director of the Court for Diplomatic Reception.
26
歿 使 使 便
When Jiuling was Director of the Secretariat, on the Tianzhang Festival the officials offered birthday congratulations, most presenting rare treasures; Jiuling alone presented five scrolls of the Golden Mirror Records on the rise and fall of dynasties in antiquity, which the Emperor greatly admired. He also formed lasting friendships with Vice Director Yan Tingzhi, Left Vice Director Yuan Renjing, Right Subordinate Mentor Liang Shengqing, and Vice Censor-in-Chief Lu Yi. Tingzhi and the others were men of talent, and their friendships with Jiuling never wavered from beginning to end—a quality much praised at the time. Early in the Zhide era (756–758), the Retired Emperor in Shu recalled Jiuling's foresight and issued an edict of praise and posthumous honors: "To set straight a great hall requires pillar and stone; to flourish an imperial enterprise requires a assisting minister. In life one preserves honored name; in death one proclaims great virtue. His end did not satisfy the hopes of men, and an added posthumous grant truly belongs in the state's regulations. The late Director of the Secretariat Zhang Jiuling: spirit descended from the sustaining mountain, he crossed the stream to serve as minister; in the Kaiyuan era he diligently assisted the throne to success. His forthright counsel secured the altars of state; his foresight matched the oracle stalks; to cherish such a worthy assistant forever is to know a great minister. His name endures on bamboo and silk; fuel-gathering at his tomb must be forbidden. From the rank of eight orders let him advance to the position of the Three Excellencies. He is posthumously appointed Minister of Education, and an envoy is dispatched to Shaozhou to perform sacrifice. He left collected works in twenty scrolls. Zhang Zhongfang, great-grandson of Jiugao, was bright and refined as a youth. As a child his father's friend Gao Ying saw him and marveled, saying, "This child is extraordinary and will surely be a pillar of the state. If I gain high office, I will surely raise him up. Later, when Gao became Censor-in-Chief, he was the first to recommend Zhongfang as censor. He served as prefect of Jinzhou. A local man's fields were seized by a eunuch; Zhongfang memorialized three times and ultimately righted the injustice. He entered office as Director in the Bureau of Revenue and opposed Li Jifu's posthumous title; Jifu's faction hated him and he was sent out as military adjutant of Suizhou. He was gradually promoted to serve as prefect of Fu, Cao, and Zheng. He became Remonstrance and Policy Advisor. E Prefect Cui Fa insulted a junior eunuch attendant, provoking Emperor Jingzong's fierce anger; he was handed over to the censorate for investigation. When the New Year's general amnesty was proclaimed, Cui Fa alone was excluded. Zhongfang memorialized in essence: "The great grace is about to spread over the empire, yet it does not reach before the throne; the generous rain first reaches even insects, yet Cui Fa alone is left out. Cui Fa was spared death as a result, and contemporaries praised Zhongfang. In 835, as Metropolitan Governor of Jingzhao, when ministers and generals connected to the Sweet Dew incident were slaughtered en masse, Zhongfang secretly ordered their bodies identified. Before long an imperial edict allowed the dead to be gathered for burial, and the remains could be identified—an outcome owed entirely to Zhongfang's efforts. Soldiers were running rampant at the time, and Zhongfang was regarded as too mild and ineffectual for the crisis. He was found unfit for office, appointed governor of Hua Prefecture, and later transferred to be Director of the Secretariat. He died in the second year of the Kaicheng era, at the age of seventy-two. He was posthumously appointed Minister of Rites and given the posthumous name Cheng. Li Shizhi, also known as Chang, was a grandson of the Prince of Hengshan, Li Chengqian. His father, Xiang, rose to the post of vice-prefect of Huaizhou. Shizhi began his career at the start of the Shenlong era, when he was appointed a captain in the Left Guard. During the Kaiyuan reign he rose through several posts to become governor of Tong Prefecture, where he earned a reputation for vigorous and capable administration. When Han Chaozong of the Secretariat was serving as an inspection commissioner, he singled Shizhi out in a memorial of recommendation, and Shizhi was promoted to Area Commander of Qin Prefecture. He was soon transferred to governor of Shan Prefecture and then recalled to the capital as Intendant of Henan. Shizhi was straightforward by nature and did not fuss over petty detail, which made life easier for his staff and subordinates. A little over a year later he was appointed Censor-in-Chief. In the twenty-seventh year of Kaiyuan he also served as chief administrator of the Youzhou metropolitan commandery and oversaw the military commission there. Shizhi's grandfather had been condemned and stripped of rank, and his father had later been demoted by Empress Wu, leaving the family funerals incomplete. He submitted a memorial asking that the remains be reinterred in the vacant place at Zhaoling. The throne then issued an edict posthumously restoring Chengqian as Prince Min of Hengshan and honoring Xiang as Area Commander of Yue and Duke of Xun, while several uncles and deceased elder brothers received posthumous awards as well. Several coffins were brought to the capital together, the funeral was conducted on a grand scale, and commemorative stones were carved at the burial site. He was soon appointed Minister of Justice. Shizhi was fond of entertaining friends and could drink a gallon of wine without losing his composure. He held banquets at night and cleared official business by day, so that nothing lingered on his desk.
27
穿 使 使 使
In the first year of Tianbao he succeeded Niu Xianke as Left Chancellor and was enfeoffed in succession as Duke of Qinghe County. He clashed with Li Linfu over power, and because Shizhi was open and unsuspecting, Linfu undermined him from the shadows. Linfu once told Shizhi, "Mount Hua holds gold ore. Mining it could enrich the empire, but His Majesty does not yet know of it. Shizhi was pleased by the suggestion and, on a later occasion, mentioned it to the emperor in an easy, informal manner. Xuanzong was delighted and turned to Li Linfu for confirmation. Linfu answered, "I have known of this for a long time. But Mount Hua is Your Majesty's natal mountain, the seat of the dynasty's vital force. It must not be mined, and that is why I did not dare bring it up. The emperor took this as proof of Linfu's devotion to him and began to look on Shizhi's counsel as careless and ill-considered. Huangfu Weiming, military commissioner of Longyou; Wei Jian, Minister of Justice; Pei Kuan, Minister of Revenue; and Han Chaozong, Intendant of Jingzhao—all were close to Shizhi. Li Linfu slandered each of them, fabricated charges, and they were exiled in succession. Fearing for his safety, Shizhi asked to be given a honorific post without real responsibility. In the fifth year of Tianbao he was dismissed from the chancellorship and retained only the title of Junior Tutor to the Heir Apparent. He immediately summoned relatives and friends to a celebration and wrote a poem that began, "Having stepped aside from the chancellorship, I now take joy in wine and lift my cup. Tell me, guests at my gate—how many of you came today? In the end he was demoted to prefect of Yichun on the charge of his association with Wei Jian and the others. Later the censor Luo Xiyi was dispatched to execute Wei Jian, Lu Youlin, Pei Dunfu, Li Yong, and others in exile. Wherever word spread that Xiyi was coming, officials and commoners alike were seized with dread. When Xiyi passed through Yichun, Shizhi learned that he was on his way and swallowed poison to die. Li Jiqing, styled Zi Jiqing, passed the Mingjing examination in his youth and showed considerable talent for literary composition. He took the special imperial examination and passed in Broad Learning and Eloquent Composition, then rose twice to the post of county magistrate of Hu in the Jingzhao metropolitan prefecture. Under Emperor Suzong he rose through several posts to Secretariat Drafter, but was later demoted to vice-prefect of Tong Prefecture on an official charge. When Emperor Daizong came to the throne, he launched a broad effort to recall men who had long been passed over, and Jiqing was summoned from Tong Prefecture to serve as Junior Intendant of Jingzhao. He was soon restored as Secretariat Drafter and then appointed Vice Minister of Personnel. Shortly afterward he was also made Censor-in-Chief and sent on a consolation mission through Henan and the Jiang-Huai region, where he promoted neglected talent and advanced loyal, upright men—conduct for which contemporaries praised him. After several years overseeing personnel selection, he was transferred to Right Regular Attendant. Jiqing had a generous spirit and wide-ranging knowledge, was skilled at friendship, and carried himself with an open and easy manner. At court he made the promotion of worthy men his chief concern, and for this the scholarly class held him in high regard. He died in the second year of the Dali era and was posthumously appointed Minister of Rites. Li Rong, styled Sun Rong, was upright and disciplined by nature and skilled in administrative affairs. In the tenth year of Zhenyuan he died in office as military commissioner of Wei Prefecture, having risen through a series of posts. Yan Tingzhi was a native of Huayin in Hua Prefecture. His uncle Fangyan served as a director in the Ministry of Revenue during the Jingyun era. Tingzhi was studious from youth and passed the jinshi examination. In the first year of Shenlong he passed a special imperial examination and was appointed magistrate of Yixing. When Yao Chong was governor of Chang Prefecture, he noticed Tingzhi's imposing bearing and natural talent for administration and came to think very highly of him. When Chong returned to power as Director of the Secretariat, he brought Tingzhi in as a Right Reminder.
28
Emperor Ruizong loved music and would listen until he forgot his fatigue, and Emperor Xuanzong was also accomplished in musical theory. On the first full moon of the second year of Xiantian, the foreign monk Botuo asked that the city gates be opened at night and a hundred thousand lamps lit. Ruizong watched the performances from Yanxi Gate for four days in all. They also staged again the grand communal feast of the first year of Xiantian. Ruizong watched from the tower of Anfu Gate as the ministries held their banquets, night after day, for more than a month. Tingzhi submitted a memorial of remonstrance, which read:
29
The emperor accepted his advice and put a stop to the festivities.
30
殿使
At that time the attending censor Ren Zhigu abused the authority of the censorate and hurled insults at court officials in procession. Tingzhi sharply rebuked him for disrespect, but the censorate in turn impeached Tingzhi, and he was demoted to an outside staff post in Wan Prefecture. During the Kaiyuan reign he served as an outside director in the Bureau of Evaluations. He oversaw the examinations for two years and won wide praise for fairness, cutting the number who passed by half. He was promoted to director in the Bureau of Evaluations and, by special edict, was again put in charge of the civil examinations. He was later promoted step by step to Secretariat Drafter. At that time Du Xian, Vice Director of the Chancellery, and Li Yuanhong, Vice Director of the Secretariat, served together as chancellors and did not get along. Du Xian was friendly with Tingzhi, while Yuanhong had long favored Song Yao and brought him in as a Secretariat drafter. When he joined with the diarist Zhang Xuan and others to grade the Ministry of Personnel lists, Yao again clashed with Tingzhi over standards and reported the disagreement to Yuanhong. Yuanhong challenged and rebuked Tingzhi. Tingzhi replied, "Your Excellency holds the highest office in the land, yet you indulge petty men and harbor personal grudges—that is hardly fitting for a chief minister. His words and manner were both fierce. Yuanhong asked, "Who is this petty man? Tingzhi answered, "Song Yao." For this he was sent out to serve as governor of Deng Prefecture and then Junior Intendant of Taiyuan. Wang Maoqi of the Palace Domestic Service had been sent to Taiyuan, Shuofang, and You to audit troops and horses. Years passed, and he then sent an official dispatch to Taiyuan demanding arms and equipment. Tingzhi noted that Maoqi carried no imperial commission. Maoqi had long enjoyed the emperor's favor, and Tingzhi feared trouble might follow, so he reported the matter in a secret memorial. He was soon transferred to serve as governor of Pu and then Bian Prefecture. Every post Tingzhi held was run with strict discipline, and subordinates did not dare transgress. When he took charge of a major prefecture, people walked in fear and scarcely dared breathe aloud.
31
耀 耀 使
In the twentieth year Wang Maoqi fell from favor and was ordered to die. Xuanzong remembered Tingzhi's earlier memorial, promoted him to Vice Minister of Justice, and showed him deep favor before appointing him Director of the Grand Treasury. He was close to Zhang Jiuling. When Jiuling became chancellor, he appointed Tingzhi Left Assistant Director of the Department of State Affairs to oversee personnel selection, with Lu Jingrong overseeing military appointments—both were regarded as outstanding appointments of the day. At that time Pei Yaojing as Palace Attendant, Li Linfu as Minister of Rites, and Zhang Jiuling all served together as chancellors. Jiuling had risen through literary talent, reviewed drafts in the Hanlin Academy, and also served as Director of the Secretariat, enjoying exceptional favor from the throne. Yaojing and Jiuling had long been on good terms. Linfu was subtle and calculating; seeing that Jiuling was in favor, he treated him well outwardly, but in his heart he was no ally. Li Linfu had brought Xiao Jiong in as Vice Minister of Revenue. Once, on a condolence visit with Tingzhi, Xiao Jiong picked up a copy of the Book of Rites at an inn and read aloud, "The seasonal offerings—prostrate hunting. Jiong had entered office young and had little learning. He did not know the term for the wax and harvest festivals and misread the characters. Tingzhi questioned him in jest, and Jiong repeated the same mistake. Tingzhi told Zhang Jiuling, "Can the Secretariat really harbor a 'Prostrate Hunting Vice Minister'? For this remark Xiao Jiong was sent out as governor of Qi Prefecture, and Li Linfu came to hate Tingzhi deeply. Jiuling once wanted to bring Tingzhi into the chancellorship with him and said, "Minister Li enjoys deep favor from His Majesty. You ought to call on him at least once and cultivate a cordial acquaintance. Tingzhi had always been proud by nature and despised Linfu's character. For three years he never paid a private visit to Linfu's house except on official business, and this only deepened Linfu's resentment. When Tingzhi interceded for Wang Yuanyan, prefect of Yu, Li Linfu had him questioned inside the palace. Zhang Jiuling was dismissed from the chancellorship as a result, and Tingzhi was sent out as governor of Ming Prefecture. In the twenty-ninth year he was transferred to be prefect of Jiang Commandery.
32
便
In the first year of Tianbao, Xuanzong once asked Li Linfu, "Where is Yan Tingzhi? He is still a man worth promoting. Li Linfu then summoned Tingzhi's younger brother Sunzhi to his house to renew old acquaintance, promising that Sunzhi's son would be given an outside post. He told Sunzhi, "His Majesty thinks very highly of your elder brother. You must find a way for him to enter the capital for an audience—he will surely be given a major appointment." He had Sunzhi obtain a petition from Jiang Commandery stating, "He has a mild wind disorder and asks permission to enter the capital for treatment." Li Linfu then submitted the petition with the comment, "Tingzhi is elderly and has recently suffered from wind disorder. He should be given an honorary post and allowed to seek treatment." Xuanzong sighed and muttered his displeasure for a long while. Li Linfu then memorialized to appoint Tingzhi an outside household tutor and sent him at once to convalesce in the Eastern Capital.
33
西 歿
Tingzhi had long devoted himself to Buddhist teaching and was a follower of the monk Huiyi. When he reached the Eastern Capital he was despondent over his thwarted ambitions and fell ill. He wrote his own epitaph, which began: "In the first year of Tianbao, Yan Tingzhi, then prefect of Jiang Commandery, submitted a forthright memorial asking leave. Heaven's grace granted his request, allowing him to retire for his health and appointing him concurrently Household Tutor to the Heir Apparent. He had held twenty-five offices in all. Each time he received the emperor's favor and was honored with promotion, yet he could not fully repay that debt—what steps had this broken nag to climb in answering such vast grace? At seventy he had no scope left to serve, and men of standing mourned for him. In the ninth month of that year he took to his sickbed and died at his private residence in a lane of Luoyang. In the eleventh month he was buried, as proper ritual dictated, on the western plain beside the pagoda of the monk Dazhao. He had served his sovereign with loyalty and been recorded, however undeservedly, in the state histories; he had done his clumsy best in office, and his name sometimes passed among the people's songs. The changing hills and valleys could serve as his own record; what need had he for literary ornament? He left instructions for a simple burial, to be laid in his ordinary clothes. Tingzhi and Pei Kuan were both devoted Buddhists. At the end of the Kaiyuan reign Huiyi died; Tingzhi wore hemp mourning and escorted his remains to the shrine niche. Pei Kuan was Metropolitan Governor of Henan; when the monk Puji died, Kuan and his entire family wore mourning dress, set up a mourning shelter, and his wife and children escorted the funeral to Mount Song. Hence Tingzhi's epitaph reads "buried beside the Dazhao Pagoda," seeking spiritual blessing there. Tingzhi had long valued friendship and kept his promises; he generously supported the families of deceased friends and married off dozens of orphaned daughters; contemporaries greatly respected him for it.
34
使
His son Wu served in the Guangde era as Vice Director of the Yellow Gate, Governor of Chengdu, and Military Commissioner of Jiannan. The historian writes: Cui Riyong attached himself to Wu Sansi to gain high office, took part in suppressing the Wei clan, and thus seized great power. His own words—"Everything I have done in life I decided on the spot; there is no need to cling stubbornly to one's first plan"—are all too true. He cannot be mentioned in the same breath as those who hold steadfast to the righteous path even unto death. Though Zhang Jiazhen established no landed estates, he was eager for power and profit, formed factions with court intimates, and had Jiang Jiao and Pei Xianxian beaten—he was no impartial statesman. Xiao Song rose to Director of the Secretariat without distinctive policies to his name, yet he built merit defeating foreign enemies—truly a man destined for far-reaching achievement. Jiuling won praise in both letters and government; he was the outstanding choice of his generation. Shizhi was informal with subordinates but diligent in public affairs—alas that he did not die a proper death! Tingzhi's talent and discernment matched the best of his peers; he scorned to court the powerful, earned enemies, never reached the chancellorship, and ended his days nursing illness as a palace official. Though wealth and honor come from Heaven and fortune has its own decree, that man Linfu truly deserves to be cast to wolves and tigers.
35
The encomium reads: In the Kaiyuan age, talented men filled the court. Riyong lacked constancy; Jiazhen courted reputation. Song, Jiuling, Shizhi, and Ting each had his own measure of worth. They all reached the highest offices, yet each fell somewhat short of true moral fragrance.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →