← Back to 舊唐書

卷一百二十六 列傳第七十六: 李揆 李涵 陳少游 盧鸑 裴諝

Volume 126 Biographies 76: Li Kui, Li Han, Chen Shaoyou, Lu Yue, Pei Xu

Chapter 130 of 舊唐書 · Old Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 130
Next Chapter →
1
西
Li Kui, whose courtesy name was Duanqing, came from Chengji in Longxi, though his family had long lived in Zhengzhou and ranked among the foremost lineages of the age. He was descended from Xuantao, who had served as an academician in the Prince of Qin's household and as a supervising censor, and was the son of Chengyu, director of the Secretariat, who after death was posthumously honored as Minister of Personnel. As a youth he was quick-witted and devoted to learning, and showed a gift for writing. Near the close of the Kaiyuan reign he took the jinshi degree, served as assistant magistrate of Chenliu, and submitted a work to the court. The emperor ordered the Secretariat to examine his prose, after which he was elevated to Right Reminder. He was next made Right Supplementation Censor and Attendant of the Heir Apparent, with responsibility for memorials from members of the imperial clan. He rose to vice director in the Bureau of Merits and director in the Bureau of Evaluations, holding in each office the duty of drafting imperial edicts. Accompanying the court into Jiannan, he was appointed drafting secretary of the Secretariat.
2
殿
Early in the Qianyuan era he was given the additional post of vice minister of rites. Kui had observed that those who presided over examinations often tested candidates on form alone, raising barriers and demanding written responses without recognizing that men lacking real ability could not even frame an argument within the literary canon—thus missing entirely the purpose of seeking talent. When he tested jinshi candidates on their essays, he had copies of the Five Classics, the standard histories, and the Qieyun set out on tables in the courtyard and told the examinees: "Our realm seeks men of talent, not memorizers. The texts are here—use them as you will. Within months his reputation reached the emperor. Before the examination season ended he was promoted to vice director of the Secretariat, appointed chief minister, made grand academician of the imperial libraries, and assigned to compile the national history.
3
Kui was distinguished in bearing and eloquent in audience. Each proposal he offered struck the mark of sound counsel. Emperor Suzong admired him greatly and once told him: "Your family standing, your character, and your prose are alike the finest of our day. People of the time therefore spoke of his "three unrivaled gifts." While he was still a drafting secretary, the imperial clan petitioned to add the honorific "Assisting Sage" to Empress Zhang's title. Suzong called Kui in for his view, and he answered: "In antiquity, empresses and consorts received posthumous titles only after death. To bestow such an honorific upon a living empress was without precedent. Under the misrule of the Jinglong years Empress Wei had seized power and taken the title Assisting Sage. To grant the same title now would repeat that unhappy precedent. Your Majesty is enlightened and devoted to ritual. How could you follow the example of the Jinglong era! Suzong started in alarm. "Mediocre advisers nearly ruined my house," he said. The proposal was dropped. At that time Daizong, formerly Prince of Guangping, had been redesignated Prince of Cheng. Empress Zhang had a young son, and quietly there was talk of setting him up as heir instead. On another audience Kui was present when Suzong said casually: "The Prince of Cheng is the eldest legitimate son and has earned distinction. It is time to name the heir. What do you think? Kui bowed in congratulation. "When Your Majesty speaks thus, the altars of state are blessed and the realm rejoices. Your servant is overcome with joy." Suzong said with satisfaction: "My mind is made up." From that time he enjoyed the emperor's favor and was soon entrusted with the highest responsibilities.
4
西
Banditry was rife in the capital; murder victims were left in the streets. Li Fuguo, then riding high, asked to assign five hundred Imperial Guard cavalry to patrol duty. Kui memorialized: "In Western Han the Southern and Northern Armies were made to balance each other. That was how Zhou Bo, entering the Northern Army through the Southern, was able to save the Liu dynasty. Our dynasty likewise divided civil and military authority between the Southern and Northern Bureaus so that each might keep watch upon the other. If the Imperial Guard replaces the Gold Crow Guard on night patrol, who will restrain them should sudden trouble arise? The emperor accordingly rejected the request for Imperial Guard patrols.
5
姿 祿 使
As chief minister Kui was learned and forceful in debate, yet he was fiercely ambitious for rank and gain, and public opinion turned sharply against him. His elder brothers, men of reputation in their own right, languished in minor posts, yet he never brought them forward. His colleague Lü Yin, though of far humbler birth, had once outranked him in power. After leaving the chief ministership Yin had served as guest minister and then as military commissioner of Jingnan, where his reputation flourished. Fearing Yin's return to court, Kui secretly sent secretariat staff into his jurisdiction to dig up offenses. Yin lodged a secret defense of himself, and Kui was demoted to senior adjutant of Laizhou. The edict declared that he had "stirred unrest across the eight southern Hunan prefectures and obstructed military control at Jiangling. Within days of Kui's dismissal his brothers were all appointed vice directors in the Bureau of Gates. Years later he was transferred to the post of prefect of Shezhou. While Kui was in power, Chief Minister Miao Jinqing had repeatedly recommended Yuan Zai for high office. Trusting in his own pedigree, Kui looked down on Zai's humble origins and refused the recommendation, telling Jinqing: "Men of true distinction go unused while creatures with the heads of deer and the eyes of rats come begging for posts. Zai never forgave the insult. Once Zai became chief minister and Kui was due for reassignment, he had him named acting director of the Secretariat and sent to convalesce in the Jiang-Huai region. Without salary and with his household in want, more than a hundred widows and orphans in his family lived by begging. For fifteen or sixteen years he drifted from prefecture to prefecture. Whenever a local governor treated him coldly he moved on, passing through more than ten jurisdictions in all. After Yuan Zai was executed for his crimes, Kui was made prefect of Muzhou, then recalled to serve as chancellor of the National University and minister of rites, but Lu Qi bore him ill will. While Dezong was in exile in Shannan, Kui was appointed envoy to Tibet for the peace conference and promoted to Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. He reached Fengzhou but died of illness there in the fourth month of the first year of Xingyuan, aged seventy-four. He was posthumously honored as Grand Marshal, and the state provided for his funeral.
6
Li Han was the great-grandson of Li Daoli, Prince of Gaoping. His father Shaokang had served as prefect of Songzhou. Han was plain, modest, and careful in conduct, esteemed among the imperial clan, and rose through posts as gentleman attendant of the heir apparent and palace censor. Guo Ziyi, military commissioner of Shuofang, recommended him as judge of the salt ponds within the passes. When Suzong fled north to Pingliang he had not yet chosen a destination. Han and Du Hongjian, acting commissioner of Shuofang, drafted a memorial detailing the forces being mustered in Shuofang and the stores of grain, arms, and supplies on hand, praising Han as a worthy scion of the imperial house, steadfast and loyal. Han was sent to Pingliang to present it in person. Han spoke with clarity and force, and his counsel matched the moment. Suzong was delighted and appointed him vice director in the Right Secretariat, then promoted him through the Bureau of Enfeoffments to vice director of the Court of the Imperial Clan.
7
使 使 使 西使 使歿 使 殿 使 祿使
In the first year of Baoying, as Hebei was brought back under control, Daizong, knowing Han for loyalty and steady judgment, made him left attendant of the heir apparent, censor-in-chief, and pacification commissioner for Hebei. When his mother died he was recalled from mourning to resume his post. At every relay station along the way he spoke only on official business, ate plain food, drank water, and slept on the ground. On his return he asked leave to complete the full mourning period. Daizong, seeing how grief had wasted him, consented. When mourning ended he was made supervising censor and then left vice director of the Department of State Affairs. When trouble broke out in Youzhou he was again appointed pacification commissioner for Hebei. In the first month of the sixth year of Dali he was made prefect of Suzhou, chief censor, and overall military governor of Western Zhejiang. In the eleventh year he came to court and was appointed chief censor. When Li Qiyun, observation commissioner of the capital region, died, Han succeeded him. When Dezong came to the throne he judged Han too mild for hard decisions and made him junior tutor of the heir apparent and deputy commissioner for the imperial tombs. Han's aide, palace censor Lü Wei, memorialized: "His father's name is Shaokang, yet his present title violates that taboo. This may offend ritual propriety. Chief Minister Cui Youfu replied: "If every minister spoke up whenever the court erred, that would be the way to true peace." Lü Wei was promoted to vice director in the Bureau of Gates. Soon someone objected: "When Han was vice director of the Court of the Imperial Clan, Lü Wei said nothing. Now that Han is junior tutor, this memorial is opportunistic. An edict declared: "Lü Wei overstepped his place by memorializing a petty complaint about his superior's title. Recalling how the Song avoided the name Sicheng and the Jin the name Cicao, We admired his loyalty to his superior and thought his report forthright. We therefore showed him special favor and a generous reward. We have since learned that the character shao he cited was no issue when Han already held the title of vice director. What was acceptable then is unacceptable now—how greatly he has deceived Us! He cannot remain at court among the capital officials. Let him serve in a distant prefecture as a warning to shallow men. He is demoted to secretary of Shezhou with nominal rank." Han was reassigned as acting minister of works and director of the Court of Imperial Entertainments, while retaining his post as deputy commissioner for the imperial tombs. Not long afterward he retired with the title of Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. He died in the ninth month of the first year of Xingyuan and was posthumously honored as Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent.
8
西 殿 使 使 使使
Chen Shaoyou was a native of Bozhou. His grandfather Yan had served as vice protector-general of Anxi. His father Qing had been a staff officer in the Right Martial Guards and was posthumously honored as minister of works through Shaoyou's promotions. As a youth Shaoyou was quick and articulate. He studied the Zhuangzi, Liezi, and Laozi, entered the Hall of Venerating Mystery as a student, and his fellows chose him to lecture on the classics. Some classmates had studied the classics on their own and arranged a day to take the lectern and challenge one another in debate. When the day came, Shaoyou mounted the platform with measured step. His voice was clear and his reasoning sharp, and every eye in the hall was on him. Every passage he cited carried layered meanings his peers could not answer. Grand Academician Chen Xilie was deeply impressed and, finding they shared a clan name, treated him with great favor. After passing the examinations he was appointed magistrate of Nanping in Yuzhou, where his administration won wide praise. During the Zhide era Wang Silu, military commissioner of Hedong, took him on as staff planner. He rose through posts as rectifier in the Court of Judicial Review, investigating and palace censor, and military commissioner aide. In the first year of Baoying he was recalled to the capital as vice director in the Bureau of the Treasury. He was soon made attendant censor and commissioner for Uyghur grain supplies, then acting vice director in the Bureau of Appointments. The practice of appointing envoys with acting court rank began with Shaoyou. The following year Pugu Huai'en appointed him aide to the deputy commander-in-chief of Hebei, director in the Ministry of War, and attendant censor. He was made prefect of Jinzhou, then reassigned to Tongzhou before taking office, and later served again as prefect of Jin and Zheng. In office Shaoyou was resourceful and adaptable, and men praised his executive talent. Yet he taxed heavily, cultivated the powerful, and so rose rapidly through the ranks. Soon Li Baoyu, military commissioner of Zelu, recommended him as deputy commissioner, censor-in-chief, and acting governor of Chen and Zheng.
9
使 宿 使
In the second year of Yongtai Baoyu had him named marching army secretary of Longyou and acting left attendant of the heir apparent while retaining the post of censor-in-chief. That year he was appointed prefect of Guizhou and observation commissioner of the Guiguan circuit. Shaoyou found the Lingnan frontier too remote and began scheming for a post nearer the capital. The eunuch Dong Xiu then controlled the secretariat. Shaoyou lodged in his lane, waited until he left the palace at dusk, and called on him casually: "Seventh Brother, how large is your household? And what does it cost you each month? Xiu replied: "I have long held a post at court, my household is large, and prices are soaring. It costs more than a thousand strings a month." Shaoyou said: "At that rate your salary would not last a few days. You must constantly beg help from outsiders to make ends meet. If someone offers you loyal support and supplies, you need only shelter him—it is an easy thing to do. I am no great man, but I will supply all of Seventh Brother's expenses myself—fifty thousand strings of cash each year. I have more than half of it here now—please accept it at once. The rest I will send after I reach my post. Would that not spare you worry as well?" Xiu, delighted beyond his hopes, formed a close bond with him. When he had finished, Shaoyou wept and said: "The southern heat and pestilence grieve me at our parting. I fear I shall never return alive to see you again. Xiu said at once: "Your talent is too fine for a distant post. Wait ten days at ease while I do what little I can." By then Shaoyou had also bribed Yuan Zai's son Zhongwu. With recommendations from Xiu within the palace and Zai outside, within days he was made prefect of Xuanzhou and overall military governor of Xuan, She, and Chi.
10
使 使 祿 貿 使
In the fifth year of Dali he was transferred to prefect of Yuezhou, chief censor, and observation commissioner of Eastern Zhejiang. In the eighth year he was made senior adjutant of Yangzhou and military commissioner of Huainan. He was also granted the title of Silver-Green Glory Grand Master of Splendid Happiness and enfeoffed as Baron of Yingchuan. Wherever he served he worked to restore order, though he governed chiefly by calculation and small favors. His clerks did their jobs and the people found a measure of peace. When the court was beset by troubles, he memorialized to raise the circuit's two-tax levy by two hundred cash per thousand. An edict then ordered every circuit to follow Huainan's example, adding one hundred cash to the price of each dou of salt. Over more than ten years Shaoyou held three of the empire's wealthiest great commands in succession. He taxed and traded without a day's pause, amassed hundreds of millions in wealth, lavished bribes on the powerful, and held refined scholars in contempt. He first cultivated Yuan Zai with annual gifts of gold and silk worth some one hundred thousand strings, and bribed influential eunuchs such as Luo Fengxian, Liu Qingtan, and Wu Chengqian until his praise reached the inner palace. Later, as Yuan Zai's long tenure bred suspicion of his misdeeds, Shaoyou drew somewhat apart from him. Soon Zai's son Bohe was demoted to Yangzhou. Shaoyou befriended him openly while secretly having his faults reported to the throne. Daizong took this for loyalty and treated him all the more favorably.
11
退 使
When Dezong came to the throne, Shaoyou was repeatedly promoted to acting minister of rites and minister of war. In the third year of Jianzhong, when Li Na rebelled, Shaoyou recovered Xu, Hai, and other prefectures, then abandoned them and withdrew to Xuyi. He was further made acting Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and granted three hundred actual fief households. That year he was made co-chief minister on the spot. Guan Bo had once served on his staff, and Lu Qi had been with him in Pugu Huai'en's mission office in their youth—hence his sudden elevation in rank.
12
使 使 使 使
In the tenth month of the fourth year the emperor fled to Fengtian. Bao Ji, commissioner of the two taxes for Bian and the east, was in Yangzhou and had not yet heard the news. Ji's aide Cui Yuan rushed word to Shaoyou. Bao Ji had some eight million strings in tax revenues on hand. Believing the rebels would hold the capital for some time, Shaoyou seized the funds by force. He sent his aide Cui to demand Bao Ji's payment records and two million strings for military expenses. Ji replied: "These funds require an imperial order. He refused. Cui said angrily: "If you get your way, you will be like Liu Changqing; if not, like Cui Zhong. Liu Changqing had once been transport commissioner and was ruined by Wu Zhongru; Cui Zhong had hoarded army funds and was executed by Guo Guangbi. Ji was terrified and did not resist. All funds bound for the capital were seized by Shaoyou. Ji came to call on him in person. Shaoyou received him with a formal bow and dismissed him. Fearing for his life, Ji fled to Baisha. Shaoyou sent his aide Fang Rufu to summon him again. Ji, more frightened still, claimed an inspection tour and rowed hastily across the river, his wife and children hidden among the document cases. At Shangyuan he was detained again by Han Huang. Ji had left three thousand troops under Gao Yue and Yuan Fu to guard the treasure; Shaoyou seized them all. Those who crossed the river with Ji were detained by Han Huang as well, and Ji went on to Jiang, E, and other prefectures with only a few clerks. Ji hid a memorial inside a pellet, reporting Shaoyou's seizure of the funds. When Shaoyou's envoy next arrived, the emperor asked: "Did Shaoyou seize Bao Ji's funds—is that true? He replied: "After I left Yangzhou, I did not know." The emperor said: "Shaoyou is a guardian of the realm. If he took the funds to guard against other thieves or supply the army, what harm was there?" The regions were cut off and the dynasty still reeling. Near and far, men marveled that the emperor's judgment reached so far and adapted so wisely to circumstance. When Shaoyou later heard of this he was reassured.
13
使 使
When Li Xilie captured Bianzhou he announced his intention to strike the Jiang-Huai region. Terrified, Shaoyou sent his staff planner Wen Shu from Shouzhou to offer submission to Xilie: "At Hao, Shou, Shu, and Lu I shall soon dismantle the forts, sheathe our weapons, and await your orders. Shaoyou also sent touring officer Zhao Shen to Yanzhou to ally with Li Na. That year Xilie declared himself emperor and sent his general Yang Feng with a false amnesty to Yangzhou. At Shouzhou, Prefect Zhang Jianfeng's scouts seized him. Before two palace envoys and Shaoyou's aide Xu Zirui, Jianfeng rebuked Feng publicly and beheaded him. Xilie was furious and appointed his general Du Shaoqian false vice director and military commissioner of Huainan, ordering him first to take Shouzhou and then Guangling. Jianfeng fortified Huoqiu and held it strictly. Shaoqian could not break through. Later Bao Ji reached court and reported the seizure in full. Shaoyou was terrified and memorialized that the funds had all been spent on urgent military needs and that he would repay the full amount. But his jurisdiction lay in ruins and he could not repay the throne. He and his trusted clerks therefore imposed heavy new taxes on the people to raise the sum. Before long Liu Qia recovered Bianzhou and found among Xilie's papers a false court diary entry: "On such-and-such a day Chen Shaoyou submitted a memorial of submission. When Shaoyou heard this he was stricken with shame and alarm, fell ill, and died within days, aged sixty-one. He was posthumously honored as Grand Marshal, and buried with the usual state rites.
14
殿 使
Lu Yue was a native of Fanyang in Youzhou and the great-great-grandson of Yigong, vice minister of works under Emperor Taizong. His father Ziqian had been advisory staff officer in the Prince of Ying's household and was posthumously honored as vice director of the Secretariat through Yue's promotions. Yue entered office young through hereditary privilege and was known in service for practical competence. He rose through posts as recorder of Langzhou, investigating and palace censor, attendant censor, and prefect of Jinzhou. Chief Minister Yang Yan favored him, recalled him as director in the Left Secretariat and junior metropolitan governor of Jingzhao, then promoted him to metropolitan governor. Yue had no scholarly training, cultivated the powerful, and governed with harsh impatience. Lu Qi detested him, had him impeached, and demoted him to secretary of Fuzhou. He was later made prefect of Raozhou, then of Fuzhou and observation commissioner of Fujian. He died of illness in the seventh month of the second year of Zhenyuan.
15
祿
Pei Xu, whose courtesy name was Shiming, was a native of Luoyang in Henan. His father Kuan had served as minister of rites and enjoyed great renown in the Kaiyuan and Tianbao reigns. As a youth Xu passed the mingjing examination and served as staff officer of Henan prefecture. He was open and direct by nature and disliked petty detail. He rose to granary clerk of Jingzhao, then retired to the eastern capital to mourn his father. When An Lushan seized the two capitals and the eastern capital was later recovered, Xu was appointed gentleman for deliberation of the heir apparent. Soon the Prince of Guo had him appointed attendant censor and aide for the garrison fields of Xiang and Deng. He then entered mourning for his mother. When the eastern capital fell again to Shi Siming, Xu hid in the mountains. Siming had once served under Xu's father and, cherishing that old tie and long admiring Xu's reputation, was determined to have him. He sent dozens of mounted pursuers who tracked Xu down and captured him. Siming was delighted, addressed him as Young Master without using his name, and falsely appointed him censor-in-chief in charge of judicial decisions. As Siming slaughtered members of the imperial clan, Xu secretly slowed the process and saved several hundred lives. He also sent intelligence on the rebels' strengths and weaknesses to the court. When this was discovered, Siming raged at him and he barely escaped execution. After the rebellion was suppressed he was made gentleman attendant of the heir apparent, then director in the Bureau of Evaluations, and was repeatedly summoned to advise the throne.
16
使 便殿
When Daizong was at Shaan, Xu walked on foot to the mobile court carrying the seals of the Bureau of Evaluations and the Southern Bureau. The emperor said: "A fierce wind reveals the tough grass—how true that proves. He was to be made censor-in-chief, but Yuan Zai blocked the appointment and he was made commissioner of transport, salt, and iron for Hedong instead. A great drought afflicted the Guanzhong region. When Xu came to present accounts, Daizong received him in the side hall and asked: "What are the yearly receipts and expenditures of the wine monopoly? Xu was silent for a long time. The emperor asked again. Xu replied: "I have been thinking. The emperor said: "About what?" He replied: "Coming from Hedong I traveled three hundred li and saw farmers grieving—grain and beans still unplanted. I had hoped Your Majesty would first ask about the people's hardship, yet you question me about profit. Mencius said that to govern a state is nothing but benevolence and righteousness—why speak of profit? That is why I did not answer at once." The emperor leaned forward and said: "Without your words I would never have heard this." Xu was appointed director in the Left Secretariat. The emperor often consulted him, but those in power envied him and he was sent out as prefect of Qianzhou, then served successively at Rao, Lu, and Bo. He was recalled to serve as general of the Right Gold Crow Guard.
17
宿 使
Early in the Jianzhong era the emperor governed through penal law, and every official trembled with fear. Slaughter was forbidden in the tenth month, and as the season drew near the imperial tombs the ban grew especially strict. The Esteemed Father, Guo Ziyi, Prince of Fenyang, had a servant slaughter a sheep and bring it in. The gate guards caught him, and Xu memorialized the offense. The emperor praised his fearlessness before the powerful and repeatedly commended him. Someone asked him: "The Duke has saved the dynasty—would you not cover this for him? Xu smiled and said: "That is not something you would understand. The Duke's power is too great. The new emperor is sure to suspect that his following is too large. By exposing this small fault I show that I do not court his power. Above, I fulfill my duty to the ruler; below, I reassure a great minister. Is that not fitting?" Separate tribunals had been set up in the court hall to decide common cases, and litigants would strike the Petition Drum. Xu memorialized: "The admonition drum and the slander post were established to reach hidden wrongs and give voice to honest counsel. Now frivolous and cunning men beat the drum, reach the emperor's ear, and in the end it is over trifles. If that is so, what need is there for officials and regular governance!" The emperor agreed and returned all such cases to the regular courts. Believing that legal clerks twisted the law and often pursued old grudges, Xu presented his "Admonition for Prison Officials" as an indirect critique. Soon he was demoted to secretary of Langzhou because a monk he favored had broken the law. He was recalled as right attendant of the heir apparent, then made general of the Palace Domestic Army. When Tibet invaded he was soon made vice minister of personnel and chief censor and appointed envoy to Tibet, but did not go. Not long afterward he became guest of the heir apparent, vice minister of war, metropolitan governor of Henan, and deputy protector of the eastern capital.
18
Five generations of Xu's family had served in Henan. When he took office he never sat in the chief seat, did not press confessions in corruption cases, and governed with generous mildness. He died of illness in the eleventh month of the ninth year of Zhenyuan, aged seventy-five, and was posthumously honored as minister of rites.
19
The historiographer writes: Li Kui's counsel enriched the emperor's mind, and he was fortunate to serve an enlightened ruler; yet in blocking the worthy to hold his post he proved in the end no admirable man. Shaoyou chased profit with the times; Lu Yue curried favor with the powerful through crafty office-seeking. Judging their words and conduct, none deserves praise. Han was renowned for restraint and integrity; Xu governed with mild ease. Both nearly approached true benevolence.
20
The encomium reads: Li, Chen, and Lu Yue—their words and conduct were not genuine. Han and Xu were mild in manner—they nearly approached true benevolence.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →