← Back to 舊唐書

卷一百三十六 列傳第八十六: 竇參 齊映 劉滋 盧邁 崔損 齊抗

Volume 135 Biographies 86: Dou Can, Qi Ying, Liu Zi, Li Mai, Cui Sun, Qi Kang

Chapter 140 of 舊唐書 · Old Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 140
Next Chapter →
1
簿
Dou Can (styled Shizhong) was the great-great-grandson of Dan, Minister of Works. His father Shenyan had been magistrate of Wenxi; when Can rose to prominence, Shenyan was posthumously appointed Minister of Personnel. Can mastered the law codes and statecraft; he was stern and proud, forceful, upright, and decisive. Through hereditary privilege in youth, he rose step by step to Warden of Wannian. A colleague on duty in the office, hearing near evening that a parent was ill, asked Can to stand in for him. A prisoner escaped from jail. The Metropolitan Governor checked the duty register and was about to submit a report. Can at once pleaded, saying, "He failed to report in the proper form; I actually substituted for him. The blame ought to fall on me." He was demoted to Warden of Jiangxia for the offense; many regarded his conduct as righteous.
2
使 使
He was promoted in succession to Warden of Fengxian. A county man named Cao Fen was enrolled in the Northern Army. Fen was habitually fierce and violent. Drunk, he beat his younger sister; their father tried to rescue her but failed and threw himself into a well and died. Can arrested and tried the Fen brothers for a capital offense. The other officials all asked that punishment wait until mourning was finished. Can said, "A son exists because of the father; a father dies because of the son. If mourning delays punishment, then killing a father goes unpunished." He fixed their guilt according to law and had them beaten to death; the whole county feared and submitted. He was transferred to Directing Censor of the Court of Judicial Review. While examining cases in the Jiang-Huai region he stopped at Yangzhou. Military Governor Chen Shaoyou was arrogant and overbearing and did not go out to the suburbs to welcome him, but had army clerks relay inquiries. Can spoke forthrightly and reproved him. Shaoyou repented and feared, and urged Can to come; Can did not wait to cross the river. On his return his memorial accorded with the emperor's intent. At the time Wu Prefecture Governor Deng Ting was convicted of embezzling eight thousand strings of cash. Ting had old ties with those in power, and because an amnesty coincided with the case, they wished to remit the embezzled goods. An edict ordered the hundred officials to deliberate jointly in the Ministry of Personnel. Most hoped to please those in power; Can alone firmly insisted on applying the law, and in the end the embezzled goods were levied. The next year he was made Supervising Censor and sent on mission to investigate the case of Hunan judge Ma Yi. At the time Yi had reported a subordinate magistrate for embezzling as much as a thousand strings of cash. The son of the convicted man, through a favorite of power, falsely memorialized against Yi. Can in the end cleared Yi of guilt. Yi was in truth a capable official; later he served repeatedly under Prince Cao Li Gao and was known for uprightness and forceful competence.
3
殿 退
Can was transferred to Attending Censor within the Palace, then changed to Vice Director in the Ministry of Revenue, Director in the Ministry of Justice, Attending Censor, and Supervisor of Miscellaneous Affairs. Before long he was promoted to Censor-in-Chief. He did not avoid the powerful and noble and was known for strict handling of cases. He was repeatedly summoned and received in audience to discuss affairs of the realm. He also differed often from those in power, and the emperor greatly valued him and sometimes had him participate in deciding great affairs of state. The chief ministers were quite jealous of him and repeatedly blocked and suppressed him, yet could not harm Can. Yet he often followed personal inclination and damaged the law. When the salaries of the hundred officials were first fixed, because he had once been a Directing Censor he favored that office, so its salary was set higher than that of the regular directors of the court; when the ranks and order of the hundred officials were fixed, he first placed the Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices above the Left and Right Mentors of the Heir Apparent; and because he hated Mentor of the Heir Apparent Li Sheng, he moved the Mentor's rank down below all the prefects of the capital districts, which knowledgeable men greatly ridiculed. Soon he was additionally made Vice Director of the Ministry of Revenue. At the time in the capital a household's pig bore two heads and four feet; the relevant offices wished to memorialize it; Can said, "This is a pig calamity—how can it be reported above!" He ordered it discarded. At that time a sacrificial ox bore a calf with six feet. Minister of Imperial Stud Zhou Hao told the chief ministers and asked to memorialize it; Li Bi also answered in jest and sent them away.
4
使 使 使
Former Huainan Military Governor Chen Shaoyou's son Zhengyi requested inherited enfeoffment. Can wrote in large characters on the gate of the Ministry of Personnel: "Chen Shaoyou's rank combined the eminence of general and minister. At a juncture when the realm changed amid peril, the sovereign bore disgrace and could not yet make the matter clear. What heart has this foolish son to rashly seek transmission and inheritance?" Zhengyi feared this and did not dare seek enfeoffment, but left. At the time Shence General Meng Hua had merit in battle but was falsely memorialized by a great general, who said Hua plotted rebellion; there was also Right Dragon Guard General Li Jian-yu, who had earlier been trapped by the Tibetans and after a long time extricated himself, but was falsely accused by his troops of secretly communicating with the Tibetans. All were liable to death and had no way to clear themselves. Can fully tried the cases and cleared them all; from this everyone looked to him with hope. The next year he was appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat and Co-equal Commissioner of the Chancellery, and concurrently head of the Bureau of Revenue and Salt and Iron Transport Commissioner. Whenever the chief ministers were summoned on alternate days for audience in Yanying Hall, all the chancellors would leave; Can always remained behind for a long time. He used the Bureau of Revenue as his excuse, but in fact monopolized great affairs of state. Can had no learning, but repeatedly appointed kin and partisans to important posts as his eyes and ears; military governors in all directions feared him. Li Na already feared Can, and gifts arrived in full; outwardly he showed respect for Can, but in secret he undermined him. Those the emperor personally trusted mostly slandered Can. Dou Shen also communicated with Wu Tongxuan, and when the affair was discovered, Can followed personal likes and dislikes, relied on power and coveted profit, and knew no limit—he was ruined in the end because of this. Can was demoted to Vice-Prefect of Chen Prefecture—in the fourth month of Zhenyuan 8.
5
使 使 使使 使 退
When Can reached Chen Prefecture, Bianzhou Military Governor Liu Shining sent him five thousand bolts of silk. Hunan Observation Commissioner Li Xun had a rift with Can and reported the matter in full; a palace emissary also encountered Shining's envoy on the road and likewise memorialized the affair. Dezong was greatly enraged and wished to kill Can. Chief Minister Lu Zhi said, "Dou Can and I have no private tie. Taking revenge over an affair is human feeling. Yet I participate in the chief ministership and ought to preserve public form. To put Can to death for his offense may be excessive punishment." Thereupon the matter was halted for the time being. Soon afterward an emissary was again sent to tell Zhi and the others, "What you memorialized is good in broad outline, yet this man has connections within and without; his intent is hard to fathom. I have traced the circumstances, and the matter is clearly established. Moreover Dou Can there is in contact with the various frontier commanders. The affair of the altars of state is weighty; you must quickly advance documents for disposition." Zhi memorialized, saying, "Your servant has received the imperial voice face to face and, fortunate to receive the secret edict, all spoke of the altars of state. Knowing too that the investigation has already been thorough, how dare I not share the same grief and indignation above and cut off doubt within? Would I wish to delay and give further cause for concern? But because Can once bore heavy responsibility, this is what is called a great minister. Between advancement and withdrawal there should still be propriety; at the moment of execution there must be no lack of grounds. Liu Yan long managed goods and wealth and at the time also drew resentment and slander. When guilt was added and punishment imposed, the matter was not clear. Rebels could then use it as a pretext, and the multitude also felt pity for him. When punishment is obscure, the harm is not light; the precedent is not distant, and one ought to be heavily cautious. Dou Can recently held the balance of power and greatly relied on private favor, accepted bribes, and indulged kin and partisans—this the court discussed together and the realm commonly reported. As for secretly harboring a different design and about to raise great evil—the traces have not yet been exposed, and no one knows. We have newly received the heavenly countenance and discuss adding capital punishment, yet we have heard only of treacherous intent and still do not know the grounds of the plot. Moreover, among the multitude of officials, how can all be fully informed? If severe punishment is suddenly applied, it will surely be taken as false accusation; public sentiment will be shaken, and the affair is no small matter. If it is not handed over for external investigation and interrogation, I fear it will be hard to fix the charge. I beg that sagely attention be retained and further deliberation be given. Dou Can and I have never had a private tie; Your Majesty already knows this clearly. What concern would make me rashly wish to rescue him? Truly because the affair concerns the body of the state, righteousness cuts off private resentment, I hope that punishments may not be excessive in a time of clarity, and the way of the ruler may be kept from loss in sagely virtue." He was then demoted again to Administrator of Huan Prefecture. His son Jingbo was banished to Quan Prefecture; his daughter the nun Zhenru was assigned to Chen Prefecture; his goods, property, and concubines were sent on to the capital. Can at the time was deeply hated by the eunuchs of left and right, who slandered and obstructed him without cease. Before he reached Huan Prefecture he was granted death at Wujing garrison in Yong Prefecture, aged sixty.
6
Dou Shen was a clansman of Can. He rose in succession to Junior Vice-Governor of the Metropolitan Prefecture and was transferred to Drafting Attendant. Can especially favored him. Whenever appointments and dismissals were discussed, Can often consulted Shen; Shen sometimes leaked them to gain power and accept bribes. Wherever Shen went, people regarded him as a magpie of good omen. Dezong heard much of this affair and repeatedly admonished Can, saying, "You will one day surely be burdened by Shen. Better to send him out to cover public criticism." Can said, "Your servant has no strong sons or nephews. Though Shen is a distant relative, I have always been close to him and cannot bear to send him far away. I ask to guarantee he will commit no other offense." The emperor said, "Though you protect yourself, what of the multitude?" Can persisted in his former reply. Shen also did not repent.
7
便
Vice Director of the Ministry of War Lu Zhi had a rift with Can. The brothers Wu Tongwei and Wu Tongxuan were together with Zhi in the Hanlin Academy, all receiving Dezong's favor, and they too competed for favor and were not in accord. General of the Golden Guard, Heir of the Prince of Guo Ze Zhi, was on good terms with Shen and Tongwei and Tongxuan, and so they joined in overthrowing Zhi. On Zhi's conduct of the examination selection, they said Zhi's examination selection was not genuine. Wu Tongxuan took a clanswoman as an outside wife. Dezong knew he slandered Zhi and also ordered investigation; the full extent of his wicked conduct was obtained. Thereupon Ze Zhi was demoted to Administrator of Zhao Prefecture, Wu Tongxuan to Administrator of Quan Prefecture, and Dou Shen to Administrator of Dao Prefecture. Within ten days Can was demoted to Vice-Prefect of Chen Prefecture, and on the same day Lu Zhi was made chief minister. The next year Dou Can was demoted again to Huan Prefecture. Dezong said to Lu Zhi, "Dou Shen, Dou Rong, and Li Ze Zhi from first to last share the same evil and stop at nothing. They are also all insignificant men, not comparable to Dou Can. You should conveniently discuss disposition. All who were intimate with them are to be sent off to distant and vile places." Zhi memorialized, saying:
8
Dou Can's offenses truly merit execution. Sagely virtue is broad and tolerant, striving to preserve the whole affair; specially lenient in strict law, bowing to spare the remainder of life. Favor from beginning to end truly suffices to move the multitude; the kindness of gentle warmth is not a private fortune for this man alone. The demoted offices discussed are respectfully set forth in a separate memorial. As for Dou Shen, Dou Rong, Li Ze Zhi, and the like, they all share the same evil and are indeed hard to tolerate; yet because guilt follows in connection, the law has principal and follower: the principal ought to bear the heavy penalty, the follower ought to be treated lightly. Since Can has received gracious sparing, Shen and the others should also be reduced and lowered. Moreover within the faction there are also differences between the good and the wicked; to show a little distinction suffices to display discouragement and encouragement. Dou Rong and Can, though not close kin, were also very intimate; yet in close confidence there were no depraved affairs at all. It was also heard that in indignation he repeatedly spoke frankly; because of this suspicion gradually formed, and in his later years he was much seen as distant and suspected. If one discusses present secret affairs, the origin has not yet been fully investigated; if one goes by recent conduct, it should not reach treacherous danger. I fear a difference in treatment is needed to show clarity. We have deliberated: Dou Rong should be demoted further to a distant office; Dou Shen and Ze Zhi should both be stripped of name and banished—then the lighter standard may be satisfied and the grace of cherishing life fulfilled. To rush toward power and attach to influence is the common custom of the age. Without lofty integrity standing out, how can one stand alone apart from the crowd? Dou Can long bore the balance of power and specially received lavish favor. Whom the ruler appoints—who dares not follow? Some visited his gate and court; some were connected as cousins by marriage; some were specially received and guided; some were suddenly recommended and promoted—men of this sort were eight or nine in ten. If one listens to loose talk, all will be called factional favoritism. Unless one were very close in friendship, how could all be demoted together? Moreover Dou Can was dismissed nearly a full year ago; private partisans and close kin should already have been implicated together at the time. Public sentiment has long settled and must not be shaken again. We have deliberated: except in cases of secret plotting and wicked affairs with Dou Can, all are not to be questioned.
9
An edict followed this, and Shen and the others were banished to Lingnan. After Can was granted death, Shen was beaten to death; all the Dou clan were demoted, and Rong escaped death.
10
使 使殿 使
Qi Ying was from Gaoyang in Ying Prefecture. His father Qi was Acting Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and concurrently Investigating Commissioner in the Ministry of Works. Ying passed the jinshi examination and responded to the Examination in Eminent Learning and Comprehensive Phrasing; he was appointed Army Aide of Henan Prefecture. Huai-Bian Military Governor Linghu Zhang summoned him as Chief Clerk and repeatedly appointed him Supervising Censor. When Zhang was gravely ill, Ying drafted the final memorial and together with him planned subsequent affairs. Ying persuaded Zhang to submit a memorial requesting replacement and to send his son Jian back to the capital; Zhang followed all of this and gave Ying his daughter in marriage. After Zhang died there was military disorder; Ying escaped and returned to the Eastern Capital. He-Yang Three Cities Commissioner Ma Sui summoned him as judge and memorialized him as Attending Censor within the Palace. At the beginning of the Jianzhong era Lu Qi was chief minister and recommended him; he was promoted to Vice Director in the Ministry of Justice. When Zhang Yi went out to garrison Fengxiang, he memorialized Ying as judge. Ying was eloquent in speech and had considerable experience in military affairs. Several times his discourses and memorials accorded with the emperor's intent, and soon he was transferred to Army Marshal and concurrently Censor-in-Chief. Dezong was at Fengtian; Fengxiang was pressed by the rebel Zhu Ci. Yi was timid and slow and did not understand military affairs. Among his subordinate generals was Li Chu Lin, fierce, violent, and feared in the army; seizing an opportunity he was about to plot disorder. Several days earlier Ying and his colleague Qi Kang perceived the plot and spoke to Yi, asking that he be dealt with early. Yi did not follow Ying's words but showed his magnanimity, summoned Chu Lin, and spoke to him, saying, "I wish to have you serve on the outside." Chu Lin feared this; that night he raised disorder, killed Yi to respond to Ci; many in the army were directed by Ying and so escaped harm. Thereupon he went to the mobile court at Fengtian and was made Censor-in-Chief.
11
At the beginning of Xingyuan he followed the emperor to Liang Prefecture; whenever they passed dangerous places Ying always held the reins. Once the imperial horse suddenly shied and ran and leaped greatly. The emperor feared Ying would be injured and ordered him to release the reins; Ying firmly held them for a long time before stopping. The emperor asked the reason. He said, "If the horse runs wild and stumbles, it will injure only your servant; if I release the reins, it may offend the imperial dust. Though your servant die ten thousand deaths, how could I answer for it?" The emperor praised him without end. At Liang Prefecture he was appointed Drafting Attendant. Ying was fair-skinned, tall, and his speech was high and clear. When the emperor returned to the capital from south of the mountains, he often had Ying attend at his side, or ordered him to ride ahead. When they reached cities, towns, and prefectures, he had Ying proclaim edicts and orders; the emperor trusted him all the more. That winter he was transferred to Secretariat Drafter.
12
In Zhenyuan 2, with his existing office together with Left Regular Attendant Liu Zi and Drafting Attendant Cui Zao he was jointly appointed Co-equal Commissioner of the Chancellery. Zi was upright, silent, elegant, weighty, and sparing of words; Ying was modest, harmonious, pleasant in speech, and pleasing to subordinates, deciding nothing on right or wrong; most affairs of government were decided by Zao. Before long Zao fell ill; Ying handled state affairs and also seized opportunities to dare speak on affairs. At the time the Tibetans repeatedly raided; public sentiment was shaken, and it was said the emperor wished to go on tour to avoid the barbarians. Ying memorialized, saying, "The barbarians disturb China—this is your servant's crime. Now public sentiment is fearful and alarmed, saying Your Majesty is packing baggage and preparing provisions. I have heard that great fortune does not come twice—why not deliberate thoroughly with us?" Thereupon he prostrated himself and wept; the emperor too was moved. At the time Drafting Attendant Yuan Gao offended the imperial intent; Ying repeatedly requested him as Left Assistant and Censor-in-Chief.
13
使西使 西使
When Ying took the jinshi and hongci examinations at the Eastern Capital, Zhang Yanshang was Prefect of Henan and Eastern Capital Regent and treated Ying generously. When Ying became chief minister, Yanshang left the chancellership and became Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. He repeatedly outlined current affairs for Ying to carry out, and when those close to him sought office, Ying mostly did not agree. Yanshang grew angry and said Ying was not material for a chief minister. In the first month of the third year Ying was demoted to Prefect of Kui Prefecture, then transferred to Heng Prefecture. In the seventh year he was appointed Censor-in-Chief and Guiguan Observation Commissioner, then changed to Prefect of Hong Prefecture and Jiangxi Observation Commissioner. Ying often thought that he had recently been a chief minister, dismissed without great fault, and hoped to be recalled to service; he therefore extorted tribute offerings and greatly made gold and silver vessels to please the emperor's intent. Earlier, silver vases had been as high as five feet or more. When Li Jian was Jiangxi Observation Commissioner he presented one six feet high. At this time, because the emperor's birthday fell on the Dragon Boat Festival, Ying made a vase eight feet high and presented it. In the seventh month of Zhenyuan 11 he died, aged forty-eight, and was posthumously made Minister of Rites.
14
調 調便
Liu Zi (styled Gongmao) was the grandson of Left Regular Attendant Zixuan. His father Kuang in the early Kaiyuan era was Left Reminder; father and son in succession served as historiographers. Kuang, following Liu Xiang's Garden of Persuasions, compiled Continuation of the Garden of Persuasions in ten scrolls and presented it; Xuanzong commended it. Zi in youth, through hereditary privilege, was appointed by selection as Corrector of the Heir Apparent and served as magistrate of Lianshui. Vice Director of the Ministry of Personnel Yang Guan recommended Zi as fit to be a remonstrance official; he was appointed Left Supplementation Officer, changed to Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, and again made Left Supplementation Officer. He resigned office to attend his parents and returned to the Eastern Capital; Prefect of Henan Li Yi registered and memorialized him as Merit Officer. Before long he entered mourning for his mother. When mourning ended he was promoted to Vice Director in the Ministry of Public Works, transferred to Vice Director in the Ministry of Merit, and judged the Southern Bureau, diligent in official duty and assiduous in following the law. He was promoted to Director in the Ministry of Merit and repeatedly appointed Drafting Attendant. Following the emperor to Fengtian he was transferred to Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and managed ritual. In the first year of Xingyuan he was changed to Vice Director of the Ministry of Personnel and went to Hong Prefecture to manage selection affairs. At the time, after bandits and robbers in the capital, the realm suffered locusts and drought, grain prices soared, and selectees could not come for reassignment. Zi was ordered to manage selection south of the Yangzi to accommodate men of the Jiang and Ling regions; the age praised his fulfillment of duty.
15
退
In Zhenyuan 2 he was promoted to Left Regular Attendant and Co-equal Commissioner of the Secretariat and Chancellery. In the chancellorship he offered no memorials, but was mostly modest and yielding, frugal, cautious, and fearful—that was all. In the first month of the third year he kept his existing office and ceased managing affairs of government. In the fourth year he again became Vice Director of the Ministry of Personnel. In the sixth year he was promoted to Minister of Personnel. Dou Can, as chief minister, became Minister of Personnel; Zi was exchanged to Minister of Justice. Before long the Censorate impeached and memorialized that when Zi was previously in the Ministry of Personnel selectees were excessive and lax; an edict stripped his gold and purple rank. Zi had classical learning, was good at holding discourse, and by nature was frugal, austere, and hating evil. In managing selection he often exposed dismissals and replacements; those who were fraudulent especially feared him. In the tenth month of the tenth year he died, aged sixty-six, and was posthumously made Grand Governor of Shan Prefecture.
16
使 使
Zi's older male cousin by the same grandfather Zan was the son of Left Regular Attendant Hui in the Dali era. In youth, through material privilege, he entered clerical service and was repeatedly appointed Assistant Magistrate of E County. When Chief Minister Du Hongjian returned from the south to court, his route passed through E; Zan prepared supplies meticulously. Hongjian's judge Yang Yan, because Zan was the son of a famous scholar, recommended him; he was repeatedly appointed Attending Censor and Zhejiang Observation Judge. When Yang Yan became chief minister, Zan was promoted to Prefect of She Prefecture and was known for diligence and competence. An old woman was gathering hazelnuts when a fierce beast was about to devour her; a young girl cried out and fought the beast to save her, and mother and child both escaped. Xuan-She Observation Commissioner Han Huang memorialized this extraordinary conduct; he was given gold and purple dress and was promoted again to Prefect of Chang Prefecture. When Han Huang entered the chancellorship he divided what he had formerly commanded into three circuits; Zan was made Prefect of Xuan Prefecture, concurrently Censor-in-Chief, and Xuan-She-Chi All-Circuits Training and Defense Observation Commissioner. Zan was at Xuan Prefecture for more than ten years.
17
便
Zan's grandfather Zixuan was a famous scholar of a generation in the Kaiyuan court; his father Hui broadly mastered the classics and histories; only Zan did not know books, but relied on forceful severity to establish authority, and officials feared him, treading as though on thin ice. Xuan was rich and fertile under heaven; Zan long served as fiscal inspector, heavily levied and amassed goods, and prepared tribute offerings to seek favor. His sons and younger brothers all lacked family instruction; even in childhood they could insult and look down on others; gentlemen despised them. In Zhenyuan 12 he died, aged seventy, and was posthumously made Minister of Personnel.
18
簿
Lu Mai (styled Zixuan) was from Fanyang. In youth he was known for filial piety, friendship, prudence, and solidity, and was deeply favored and esteemed by his maternal uncle Cui Youfu. He passed both classics examinations and served in succession as Corrector of the Heir Apparent and magistrate of Lantian. Through outstanding performance in document judgment he was appointed Chief Clerk of Henan and served as collator in the Hall of Assembled Worthies. Court ministers recommended his literary conduct; he was promoted to Right Supplementation Officer, Attending Censor, and Vice Director in the Ministries of Justice and Personnel. Mai's uncles, brothers, and sisters were all in the Jiang region; in a year of locusts and famine he earnestly requested a senior post in the south, and thereby was appointed Prefect of Chu Prefecture. He entered the capital as Director in the Ministry of Gateways, was promoted to Right Remonstrance and Censor, and repeatedly submitted memorials on the gains and losses of current policy. He was transferred to Drafting Attendant. When performance evaluations were being settled, Mai firmly declined, saying that since the date of appointment was recent and he had no administrative achievement, he did not dare accept the highest rating; men of the age respected this. He was promoted to Right Assistant of the Department of State Affairs.
19
Director of Imperial Construction Yuan Gen was to act as Grand Marshal in sacrificing at the shrine of Empress Zhaode, but on a private mourning anniversary he would not receive the oath of abstinence. The censorate impeached and memorialized him; an edict ordered the Ministry of Personnel, ritual officials, and legal officials to deliberate jointly. Mai submitted a memorial, saying, "Your servant examines the 'Records of Ritual': when a grandee or officer is about to sacrifice for the ruler, and after the washing of the sacrificial vessels his parents die, he still completes the sacrifice. Examining Tang ritual as well: during preliminary abstinence one may have mourning for a relative within the second degree of mourning; during strict abstinence one may have mourning for a relative within the first degree; if ill during abstinence one returns home and does not perform the sacrifice—nowhere is there text on refusing the oath of abstinence on a mourning anniversary. Although the leave regulations grant one day of leave on a mourning anniversary, the meaning of the 'Spring and Autumn Annals' is that one does not decline royal service because of family affairs. Now Gen relies on the ordinary form of leave but violates the new order to act in sacrifice. Weighing severity: the oath of abstinence belongs to the strictness of the sacrificial affair; comparing ritual forms, the mourning anniversary is an ordinary regulation. Searching the canonical grounds in detail, the affair concerns offering and presentation—it is not fitting to use the mourning anniversary as an excuse." Thereupon Gen was punished by forfeiture of salary.
20
MH西 輿
In Mai's ninth year, with his existing office he became Co-equal Commissioner of the Secretariat and Chancellery; after more than a year he was promoted to Vice Director of the Secretariat. At the time great affairs were decided by Lu Zhi and Zhao Jing; Mai kept himself upright and neutral, preserving the documents and following the law—that was all. Yet he was friendly, loving, respectful, and frugal. Mai's younger male cousin by the same grandfather Qi served as judge of the Western Sichuan Circuit of the Southern Route; he died at Chengdu and was buried at Luoyang. The route passed through the capital; Mai memorialized asking to go to the east of the city and weep before the bier, and this was granted. In recent times chief ministers mostly considered themselves lofty and weighty; for kin within three degrees of mourning they might not even follow to condole; but Mai alone stirred the thin custom and asked to attend his younger brother's mourning; gentlemen approved this. In the ninth month of the twelfth year Mai suffered a stroke in the Hall of Administration, was carried home in a litter, and submitted a memorial asking to leave office; this was not granted, and an edict ordered the chief ministers to visit his residence and inquire after his illness. From this time he submitted five memorials in all, firmly requesting retirement. An edict said, "Your conduct and footing are upright and square; your capacity and insight are broad and abundant. Since taking the post of chief minister, loyalty and purity have been all the more seen. Just when we relied on your counsel, you suddenly fell ill. Months and years grow longer; memorials repeatedly arrive; petitions are made again and again; modest yielding is hard to override. Moreover the rites for nurturing the worthy should now grant a leisurely rank. Though the sincerity of requesting release is earnest, we bow to your submitted memorial and are truly disheartened." He was then made Senior Mentor of the Heir Apparent. In Zhenyuan 14 he died, aged sixty, and was posthumously made Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent; funeral gifts of cloth and silk were granted. Mai married again and had no sons; he took his younger male cousin's son Ji as heir.
21
便 使
Cui Sun (styled Zhiwu) was from Boling. After his great-grandfather Xinggong, name and rank were low and declined. At the end of the Dali era Sun passed the jinshi examination, passed the Examination in Eminent Learning and Comprehensive Phrasing, was appointed collator in the Secretariat, and was again appointed magistrate of Xianyang. His father-in-law Wang Hong was Prefect of the Metropolitan Prefecture; he was changed to Evaluator in the Court of Judicial Review and was repeatedly promoted to Director in the Ministry of War. In Zhenyuan 11 he was promoted to Right Remonstrance and Censor. When Vice Director of the Chancellery and Co-equal Commissioner Zhao Jing died, and Vice Director of the Secretariat and Co-equal Commissioner Lu Mai requested leave for illness, Minister of Revenue Pei Yanling had long been on good terms with Sun and therefore recommended him to Dezong. In the twelfth year, with his existing office he became Co-equal Commissioner of the Secretariat and Chancellery, together with Drafting Attendant Zhao Zongru on the same day managing affairs of government; both were granted gold and purple. At first the two chief ministers had affairs of mourning; for ten days within and without the court looked expectantly for men of renown and virtue. Sun by comparison had no reputation or substance; when the appointment was issued, within and without the court were disappointed. By nature he was narrow, cautious, and timid; whenever affairs were discussed at Yanying Hall, he never spoke. In the autumn of the fourteenth year he was transferred to Vice Director of the Chancellery and Co-equal Commissioner. That year the old palace at Zhaoling was burned by wildfire; the relevant offices requested repair and maintenance. "The old palace at Zhaoling is on the mountain. Established long ago, it was once burned by wildfire and was largely destroyed; the palace was soon moved to the left side of Yaotai Temple. Now it is the year of universal mourning; repair and establishment are to be discussed. Because the supply of water is somewhat distant and the people are worn and exhausted, we now wish to build anew at the present traveling palace site, hoping that in the long term it will be convenient for people. Moreover, because the old system is being moved and changed, I fear the ritual intent is not complete; the chief ministers and hundred officials should be ordered to deliberate jointly." Many of those deliberating said, "Since the old palace has burned, it should be moved down the mountain." The emperor's intent did not wish to move it; he would rebuild only on the mountain and appointed Sun commissioner for repair and maintenance of the eight tombs. Thereupon at the five tombs Xian, Zhao, Qian, Ding, and Tai five hundred seventy rooms were built; at Qiao Tomb one hundred forty rooms; at Yuan Tomb thirty rooms; only Jian Tomb remained as before, with repair only. For bedding, curtains, and all items in the tomb chambers and above, the emperor personally inspected them and then handed them to Sun to send to the tomb sites.
22
便 祿
Sun, because of long illness at home, was granted two hundred bolts of silk for medicine. The honored posts of the northern and southern departments—Sun had passed through them all; in office he had no reputation among men. Though he held the chancellorship, his mother lay in an open coffin in the wild; he did not speak of visiting the tomb or discuss moving the coffin to join her husband; his elder sister was a nun and died in a nearby temple; through the whole mourning he did not attend; gentlemen blamed him. Added to this, he was excessively deferential and, in receiving visitors, was ingratiating—not merely seeking to preserve himself. From Jianzhong onward, chief ministers rarely remained long in office and within several years were dismissed for guilt; Sun used this to fit the emperor's intent and secretly held great responsibility for eight years. The emperor also knew that public opinion despised him for holding salary and seeking favor, yet pitied and treated him generously. In Zhenyuan 19 he died and was posthumously made Grand Mentor of the Heir Apparent; funeral gifts were five hundred bolts of cloth and silk and four hundred shi of grain.
23
西使
Qi Kang (styled Xiaju) was the grandson of Huan, Prefect of Pingyang in the Tianbao era. His father Ao died in a low first appointment; because of Kang's eminence he was repeatedly posthumously made Chancellor of the Directorate of Education. Kang in youth retired to study in Shan of Kuaiji and was skilled in writing, excelling in memorials and reports. In the Dali era Shou Prefect Zhang Yi summoned him as judge; he was clear and versed in clerical affairs and quick in literary learning; Yi greatly valued him. At the beginning of Jianzhong Yi was Jiangxi Observation Commissioner; Kang also followed him in the staff headquarters. In the third year Yi, from Vice Director of the Secretariat and Co-equal Commissioner, went out to garrison Fengxiang and memorialized Kang as Supervising Censor, still serving as staff aide; planning in the headquarters mostly came from Kang.
24
使 使 使 使
Dezong was at Fengtian; Yi was killed by Li Chu Lin. Kang rushed to the mobile court and was appointed Attending Censor; within ten days he was changed to Vice Director in the Ministry of Revenue. Chief Minister Xiao Fu was Jiang-Huai Comforting Commissioner and made Kang his judge. When Dezong returned to the capital, after the great banditry, the realm suffered drought and locusts and state revenue was exhausted. Salt and Iron Transport Commissioner Yuan Xiu, because Kang had talent and use, memorialized appointing him Director in the Ministry of Granaries to put in order Jiang-Huai salt affairs. At the beginning of Zhenyuan he was Deputy Commissioner of Land and Water Transport, supervising Jiang-Huai grain transport to supply the capital. He was promoted to Remonstrance and Censor. He served as Prefect of Chu Prefecture, then transferred to Prefect of Tan Prefecture and Hunan All-Circuits Training and Defense Observation Commissioner. He entered the capital as Drafting Attendant, then became Prefect of Henan, served as Director of the Secretariat and Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, and replaced Zheng Yuqing as Vice Director of the Secretariat and Co-equal Commissioner of the Secretariat and Chancellery.
25
便 使
Earlier, each year selectees of the Ministry of Personnel were tested in document judgment; separate memorializing officials reviewed and ranked them high and low; after the review the Secretariat and Chancellery again memorialized choosing officials to review and fix the ranking, and this gradually came to be regarded as convenient. Kang then memorialized, saying, "The Minister and Vice Directors of the Ministry of Personnel are already the court's careful selection; it is not fitting to appoint separate examining officials for repeated review." The next year, when other officials had finished examining document judgments, the Vice Director of the Ministry of Personnel was made to review himself; within one year the document-judgment examining officials were abolished—this was Kang's memorialized proposal. By precedent the Vice Director of the Ministry of Rites managed the tribute examinations; his kin and friends were then tested at the Ministry of Merit. They were called "separate-head examinees"; Kang also memorialized abolishing this. Soon he memorialized abolishing vice-prefects, field-tax officials, and field-administration officials in all prefectures and districts, as well as duplicate bureau assistants; he also abolished dispatch clerks of the Secretariat and various clerks and attendants. Soon he was additionally made compiler of the national history. Though Kang read books, he had no far-reaching wisdom or great design; in whatever office he held he always sought utmost precision, and in the end this became conspicuous; public opinion slighted him for narrow severity. When he fell ill he submitted a memorial asking to leave office and was changed to Senior Mentor of the Heir Apparent; in the end he did not attend court thanks. In Zhenyuan 20 he died, aged sixty-five, and was posthumously made Minister of Revenue; two hundred bolts of silk were also granted to his family.
26
=
[Commentary] The historiographer says: Dou Can formed factions and did not heed the ruler's admonition—this was rebellious. Qi Ying's crooked tribute and seeking reuse were very wrong, yet in loving the ruler and handling affairs he often had the words of an elder. Zi and Mai had family conduct cultivated and careful, and in handling affairs could be praised; though their capacity was narrow, they were not disqualified from being gentlemen. But men like Sun and Kang—what are they worth mentioning? Yet they suddenly stained the platform and locust tree—surely because the ruler of the age was too easy.
27
The praise says: Things in the same vessel—what is valued is broad passage. Dou fawned and Qi flattered; partial bias is the same. The conduct of Zi and Mai can adorn the person. To bring ease to the steaming multitude—why place them in the middle?
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →