← Back to 舊唐書

卷一百九十下 列傳第一百四十下: 文苑下

Volume 190 Biographies 140: Men of Letters 3

Chapter 200 of 舊唐書 · Old Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 200
Next Chapter →
1
殿 便
Li Hua, whose courtesy name was Xiashu, came from Zhao commandery. In 735 he passed the jinshi civil examination. During the Tianbao reign he entered court service as a supervisory censor. He rose in turn to attendant censor and to vice director in both the Ministry of Rites and the Ministry of Personnel. Hua excelled at literary composition and was on friendly terms with Xiao Yingshi of Lanling. While still a jinshi candidate, Hua composed a Rhapsody on the Hanyuan Hall of more than ten thousand characters. Yingshi read it and exclaimed, "It ranks above the Jingfu and below the Lingguang. Hua wrote in a warm, elegant style with little of the grand and heroic, whereas Yingshi's diction was sharp and brilliant. Hua thought his own work the better and suspected that Yingshi's praise was insincere. He therefore composed his Lament for an Ancient Battlefield, smoked and smudged the manuscript until it looked like an old relic, and hid it among Buddhist texts. While Hua and Yingshi were leafing through Buddhist books they came upon it. Hua asked him, "How do you rate this essay? Yingshi replied, "It will do." Hua asked, "Among the leading writers of our day, who could match this?" Yingshi answered, "If you give the matter a little more thought, you could write at this level yourself." Hua was dumbfounded. Hua wrote a treatise arguing that tortoise-shell and milfoil divination ought to be abandoned, and thoughtful men endorsed his position.
2
祿
When An Lushan seized the capital, Emperor Xuanzong fled the court. Hua failed to join the imperial entourage, fell into rebel hands, and was given a false appointment as Secretariat Drafter. After the capital was retaken, the Three Offices classified his offense at a reduced grade and demoted him leniently. He was then dismissed to live at home, where he died. Hua once wrote the epitaph for Yuan Dexiu, magistrate of Lushan; Yan Zhenqing penned the inscription and Li Yangbing cut the title in seal script. Later generations copied it eagerly, and it became known as the "Stele of Four Excellences." His collected works in ten juan circulated widely in his day.
3
怀
Li Shangyin, whose courtesy name was Yishan, came from Henei in Huai prefecture. His great-grandfather Shuhuan passed the jinshi examination at nineteen and ended his career as magistrate of Anyang. His grandfather Fu rose no higher than recording secretary of Xing prefecture. His father was Si.
4
Shangyin could already write essays as a boy. When Linghu Chu governed Heyang as military commissioner, Shangyin presented his writings to him, though he had not yet turned twenty. Chu admired his youth and talent, treated him with exceptional courtesy, and let him mingle with his sons. When Chu served at Tianping and Bian, Shangyin followed him as a staff officer. Chu paid his travel expenses each year and sent him to the capital with the tribute mission to sit for the examination. In 837 he finally passed the jinshi examination, took his first office as proofreader in the Secretariat, and was later transferred to magistrate of Hongnong. In 842 he again distinguished himself in the examination for legal and documentary excellence.
5
When Wang Maoyuan governed Heyang, he recruited Shangyin as chief clerk and secured for him appointment as censor awaiting imperial disposition. Maoyuan admired his talent and gave him his daughter in marriage. Maoyuan had studied the classics and was a Confucian in learning, yet he came from a military family. Li Deyu had long favored him, and while Deyu held power he appointed him commander of Heyang. Deyu was locked in bitter enmity with Li Zongmin, Yang Sifu, and Linghu Chu. Once Shangyin entered Maoyuan's service, Zongmin's faction held him in deep contempt. By then Linghu Chu had died and his son Tao held an outer court post. Tao regarded Shangyin as ungrateful and especially despised his lack of principle. Before long Maoyuan died. Shangyin came to the capital in search of office but remained unemployed for a long time. Soon afterward Supervising Secretary Zheng Ya was sent to inspect Guizhou. He invited Shangyin to serve as administrative aide on the observation staff and acting vice director of the Ministry of Waterways. Early in the Dazhong reign Bai Minzhong came to power, with Linghu Tao in the inner secretariat; together they forced Li Deyu from office. Ya was condemned as a member of Deyu's faction and was demoted to prefect of Xunzhou. Shangyin followed Ya in the far south for several years.
6
Three years later he returned to court. The capital intendant Lu Hongzheng memorialized to place him on his staff and put him in charge of petitions and memorials. The following year Linghu Tao became chief minister. Shangyin repeatedly petitioned to explain his circumstances, but Tao ignored him. When Hongzheng governed Xuzhou, Shangyin again served him as chief clerk. When that appointment ended he returned to court, again pressed his literary writings in search of office, and was appointed Erudite of the Imperial University. Soon the Henan intendant Liu Zhongying was sent to govern the eastern Shu region. He recruited Shangyin as administrative aide on his staff and acting director of the Ministry of Works. Late in the Dazhong reign Zhongying was demoted for an unauthorized execution. Shangyin was dismissed, returned to Zhengzhou, and died of illness not long afterward.
7
Shangyin could write in the ancient prose style and disliked regulated parallel composition. He had served on Linghu Chu's staff. Chu excelled at memorials and edicts and taught Shangyin that craft, after which Shangyin began to write in the contemporary style of court documents. Learned and with a formidable memory, he wrote tirelessly once he took up the brush and was especially skilled at dirges and funeral offerings. His fame stood with Wen Tingyun of Taiyuan and Duan Chengshi of Nancheng; contemporaries called them the "Thirty-six." His literary sensibility was clear and refined, and in this he surpassed Tingyun. Yet both lacked firm moral principle. They relied on talent, behaved with eccentric vehemence, and men in power looked down on them. Neither advanced in official career and both were thwarted to the end of their lives.
8
His younger brother Yishou also passed the jinshi examination and served repeatedly on provincial staffs. Shangyin left a collection of memorials and formal petitions in forty juan.
9
Wu Tongxuan came from Haizhou. His father Daojian was a Daoist priest skilled at teaching children. In the Dali reign he was summoned to court to instruct the crown prince and the imperial princes in the classics. When Dezong was still crown prince he studied under Daojian. The Tongxuan brothers moved freely within the inner palace and constantly attended the prince in his pastimes, and for this they won exceptional favor. Tongxuan and his elder brother Tongwei were both learned and skilled at literary composition, their style rich and ornate. In youth Tongxuan passed the Child Prodigy examination. His first offices were Regular Scribe in the Secretariat, clerk in the Left Courageous Guards, and reviewer in the Court of Judicial Review. Early in the Jianzhong reign, at the examination for worthies and upright men, Tongxuan entered the category for elegant literary phrasing, placed in the second tier, and was appointed registrar of Tong prefecture and household registrar of the capital district.
10
Early in the Zhenyuan reign he was summoned to serve as a Hanlin academician. He was promoted to diarist-attendant and drafter of edicts, and together with Lu Zhi, Ji Zhongfu, Wei Zhiyi, and others shared the duty of drafting imperial documents. Lu Zhi was richly gifted in language and enjoyed Dezong's special trust because he had shared the hardships of exile. The Tongxuan brothers had likewise attended the emperor when he was crown prince. The two sides therefore competed for favor and came to resent one another deeply. Zhi was narrow and quick-tempered by nature. He repeatedly denounced Tongxuan before the throne and argued: "In peaceful times craftsmen, painters, and calligraphers merely waited on the emperor in the Hanlin. There were no 'academicians' as such. Only after the Zhide era did the Son of Heaven gather worthy scholars within the palace to draft edicts in draft script. Because they waited in the Hanlin Academy for orders, the title came into use. In times of flight and disorder appointments were sometimes made on the road in advance, and drafting was entrusted to them only as an expedient. Now the realm is at peace and every ministry is in its proper course. The duty of drafting edicts should return to the Secretariat drafters. The title of Hanlin academician ought by rights to be abolished. Zhi believed Tongxuan had brought in a faction of allies and was working within the palace to exclude him, and for that reason he wished to abolish the Hanlin Academy. Dezong would not allow it. When Zhi was placed in charge of the Ministry of Personnel and conducted the civil service examinations, he received a formal appointment and was removed from inner-court duties — all because Tongxuan had slandered him.
11
In the seventh year he was promoted from diarist to Remonstrator and Drafter of Edicts. Tongxuan had expected that after long seniority he would be appointed Secretariat Drafter, but was made Remonstrator instead and was deeply disappointed. Lu Zhi and the chief minister Dou Can were bitter enemies. Can's nephew by marriage, Attendant-in-waiting Shen, was especially favored by Can and took part in every Secretariat deliberation. Wherever he appeared people called him "the Magpie." Shen was a paternal cousin of Li Zezhi, heir to the princedom of Guo. Shen and Zezhi were close friends. Zezhi was a general of the Imperial Guards, fond of learning and skilled in letters. Shen and Zezhi secretly joined the Wu Tongxuan brothers in a plot to bring down Lu Zhi on Dou Can's behalf. Zezhi had someone compose a libelous letter accusing Zhi of conducting the examinations dishonestly and accepting bribes. At the time Tongxuan had taken an imperial clanswoman as an illicit consort, and Dezong already knew of it. When the emperor learned that Shen and Zezhi had slandered Lu Zhi, investigators watched them and confirmed that they had plotted with Tongxuan. The emperor was enraged. He removed Dou Can from the chief ministership and soon demoted Can to secretary at Chen, Shen to registrar at Jin, Li Zezhi to secretary at Zhao, and Tongxuan to secretary at Quan. The emperor summoned Tongxuan for a personal audience, questioned him himself, and rebuked him for dishonoring the imperial clan. When he reached Great Wall Post in Huazhou, he was ordered to take his own life. Soon afterward Lu Zhi was appointed vice director of the Secretariat and Grand Councilor in Dou Can's place.
12
Tongwei, in the fourth year of Jianzhong, rose from magistrate of Shou'an to outer-court director in the Ministry of Revenue and was then summoned as Hanlin academician. Soon he was transferred to director in the Ministry of Personnel and drafter of edicts. He served in the same forbidden secretariat as his younger brother Tongxuan, to the envy of the scholarly world. In the seventh year he was made director in the Ministry of Rites and soon afterward promoted to Secretariat Drafter. When Tongxuan died, Tongwei appeared at the capital gate in plain robes to await punishment. The emperor specially pardoned him, yet Tongwei still did not dare observe mourning for his brother.
13
Tongxuan's diction was graceful and elegant, and the emperor favored him above all others. Early in the Zhenyuan reign Empress Zhaode died. The court ordered Li Shu to draft her posthumous title and eulogy, and the chief ministers Zhang Yanshang and Liu Hun to compose the temple hymns. When the drafts were submitted none satisfied the throne, and Tongxuan alone was summoned to rewrite them. For every important drafting assignment from the throne, if the text was not Tongxuan's the emperor was never content — such was the regard in which he was held.
14
Wang Zhongshu, whose courtesy name was Hongzhong, came from Taiyuan. Orphaned while young and poor, he became known for filial devotion to his mother. He loved learning and excelled at letters, but refused to sit for the provincial examination. He would befriend only men of established reputation. With Yang Xian, Liang Su, and Pei Shu he formed friendships without reserve.
15
In 794, at the examination for worthies and upright men able to speak frankly and remonstrate boldly, Zhongshu placed in the second tier and was promoted directly to Right Remonstrator. Pei Yanling headed the Revenue Commission. With boastful falsehoods he slandered the worthy, and Zhongshu submitted a memorial denouncing him at length. He rose in succession through director posts in the central ministries. In 810 he advanced from director in the Ministry of Personnel to Drafter of Edicts. Zhongshu wrote with a warm, elegant mind, and every edict that left his desk was copied and circulated. The capital intendant Yang Ping was impeached by the censor-in-chief Li Yijian and demoted to district defender of Linhe. Zhongshu was on friendly terms with Ping and declared openly at court that Yijian had manufactured charges against him. For this Zhongshu was demoted to prefect of Xia. He was later transferred to Suzhou.
16
西使 西
When Emperor Muzong ascended the throne, Zhongshu was recalled and appointed Secretariat Drafter. That same year he was sent out as prefect of Hong, imperial censor-in-chief, and observation commissioner of Jiangnan West Circuit. Jiangxi had long enforced harsh laws against private brewing under the wine monopoly. When Zhongshu took up his post he memorialized to repeal them. He also drew twenty thousand strings from official funds to pay taxes for impoverished households. In the winter of 823 he died at his post.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →