← Back to 舊唐書

卷一百九十二 列傳第一百四十二: 隱逸

Volume 192 Biographies 142: Recluses

Chapter 202 of 舊唐書 · Old Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 202
Next Chapter →
1
退 退
In earlier times rulers beautified rustic retreats and called forth hidden worthies, honoring the virtue of principled retirement and calming the fever of grasping ambition. Hence Zhuangzi composed the apocryphal "Yielding the Throne," Huangfu Mi wrote lives of eminent recluses, and the examples of Xu You and Ying Qiu stand forth in clear splendor. Yet men like the two Gongs of Han remained loyal to the Liu house, refused to serve Wang Mang, and would go thirsty rather than drink from the tainted spring — their withdrawal was not mere rejection of society, and that is truly admirable. Huangfu Mi and Tao Yuanming scorned their times and shunned reputation, gave free rein to feeling among streams and peaks, and cared nothing for office or seclusion — that was another kind of excellence. Some lived outwardly as hermits while their hearts clung to court — using rustic garb to hunt profit, feigning mountain solitude to angle for fame. In retreat they lacked true integrity; in advance they had nothing to offer the times. They earned the scorn of "The Mountain Moves" and the mockery of the sea bird — such men are hardly worth esteem. Ruan Ji defied the world in studied madness; Wang Ji drowned himself in wine. Short on talent but rich in insight, they mourned their age and hid their gifts — these were men of profound understanding. Emperor Gaozong and Empress Wu sought sages in the hills, dispatched summons to remote caves, called again and again at hermits' doors, and just as firmly sent their carriages back. Yet figures such as Tian Youyan and Shi Deyi prized only solitary conduct; while men like Lu Hongyi and Sima Chengzhen chiefly valued escaping reputation. On the larger question of when to serve or withdraw, to speak or hold silence, they scarcely merit serious debate. Their earlier accounts are preserved here as supplementary material for this section.
2
Wang Ji, courtesy name Wugong, came from Longmen in Jiang Prefecture. In his youth he formed the closest of friendships with Li Bo and Lü Cai. During the Sui Daye reign he entered office on a filial-and-incorrupt recommendation and was made assistant magistrate of Liuhe County in Yangzhou. The post did not suit him, and he resigned to return home. Ji already owned a few acres on a river islet. Nearby lived the recluse Zhongchang Zixian, who cultivated himself through diet and regimen. Ji admired his unadorned integrity, wished to live close by, built a cottage on the islet, and amused himself with lute and wine. Once, traveling on North Mountain, he wrote a "Rhapsody on North Mountain" to declare his intent; most of its text is omitted here.
3
Because he had farmed with his own hands on the eastern terrace, contemporaries called him Master of the Eastern Mound. He might linger in taverns for days on end, often scratching poems on walls that enthusiasts loved to recite. He died in the eighteenth year of the Zhenguan era. On his deathbed he set the date himself, ordered a simple burial, and had already drafted his own epitaph. His collected writings ran to five scrolls. He also began a History of the Sui, which remained unfinished at his death.
4
His elder brother Wang Tong, courtesy name Zhongyan, was a celebrated scholar of the Sui Daye period, known as Master Wenzhong, and has a separate biography.
5
Tian Youyan
6
調
Tian Youyan was a native of Sanyuan in the Jingzhao region. He first entered the Imperial University, then withdrew and roamed Mount Taibai. Whenever woods and streams pleased him, he would linger and find it hard to go on. His mother, wife, and children all shared his wish to live beyond worldly affairs, and for more than twenty years they wandered the hills with him. He later settled on Mount Ji, built a house east of Xu You's shrine, and styled himself "Xu You's eastern neighbor." During the Tiaolu reign, Emperor Gaozong visited Mount Song and sent Vice Director of the Secretariat Xue Yuanchao to call on Youyan's mother. Youyan came out in rustic dress and a farmer's hat to pay his respects; the emperor told attendants to hold him back from full obeisance. The emperor asked, "Sir, you cultivate the Way in these mountains — are you well content of late?" Youyan replied, "I am incurably devoted to springs and cliffs, hopelessly addicted to mist and sunset glow; in this enlightened age I am blessed to wander freely." The emperor said, "In winning you today, am I not like the Han emperor who gained the Four Whiteheads of Mount Shang?" Xue Yuanchao said, "Gaozu of Han summoned the recluses only because he meant to displace the heir; how can that compare with Your Majesty's honoring of true withdrawal and your personal visit to the hermit's cave!" The emperor was delighted, brought Youyan to the imperial lodge, sent his whole family by relay carriage to the capital, appointed him a Chongwen Hall academician, and had him converse with the heir apparent's junior tutor Liu Rengui. When the emperor later planned the Fengtian Palace on Mount Song, Youyan's former home stood beside the construction site. He ordered it spared, wrote the inscription himself, and hung it over the gate: "Home of the Recluse Tian Youyan." In the Wenming era he rose to Grand Master of Splendid Happiness and became groom of the heir apparent; at the start of Chuigong he was implicated in ties with Pei Yan and was specially allowed to return to the hills.
7
Wang Youzhen
8
使
Shi Deyi was a native of Kunshan in Suzhou. Early in the Xianheng era he withdrew to Mount Wuqiu and contented himself with lute and books. Sometimes he rode an ox with a gourd at his side, wandered through country towns and markets, and was known as a free spirit. Emperor Gaozong heard of him and summoned him to Luoyang. Before long he pleaded illness and went home to the east. From the highest ministers down, everyone wrote farewell poems; Deyi replied in verse, and his lines were exceptionally fine. Early in the Tianshou era Zhou Xing, commissioner for Jiangnan and left assistant director of the Secretariat, recommended him; Empress Wu summoned him to court with an edict that read: "The Suzhou recluse Shi Deyi cherishes the subtle Way and lives with steadfast integrity; humility shows in his village, filial devotion in his home. He has repeatedly refused office and long since gone to dwell like Yan Ziling on the river shallows; turning away from court dress and taking the high road to the hermit's valley. Learned and retentive, versed in ritual and devoted to the Odes, he tends his nature in the countryside and is content with the plow. We have received Heaven's mandate, founded the throne, and sought worthy men night and day among stars and in the deep hills. He has met the auspicious age, laid aside the hermit's vine sash, and answered our flourishing rule by leaving his rustic garb; coming from the seacoast to the capital, he has shown sound judgment in when to serve and when to withdraw. His character is admirable and we look to him for honest counsel; he should be specially honored with appointment to the remonstrance office. Let him be made Grand Master of Splendid Happiness." Later, when Zhou Xing was executed, Deyi was dismissed because he had been Zhou's nominee. Released to the hills with the rank of Grand Master of Splendid Happiness, he never afterward enjoyed quite the renown he had known as a true recluse.
9
Wang Youzhen
10
Wang Youzhen was a native of Henei in Huaizhou. His father Wang Zhijing served under Empress Wu as vice director of the Lin Terrace and was renowned for calligraphy. In his youth his mother fell gravely ill; the physician said only human flesh could cure her. Seeing no other remedy, Youzhen cut flesh from his own thigh to feed her, and she soon recovered. Empress Wu sent officials to verify the story at his home and specially honored him for it. Youzhen was devoted to learning, read each of the Nine Classics a hundred times, and taught his sons and nephews with a father's strictness. He never spoke of others' faults and was especially devoted to Buddhist scriptures; he abstained from meat and strong flavors, never broke his word, and contemporaries held him a true gentleman.
11
During the Chang'an era he served as magistrate of Changshui. He later resigned and returned to his farm. When Emperor Zhongzong was crown prince he summoned Youzhen as remonstrance officer, but Youzhen declined. Early in the Shenlong era he was again made palace attendant to the heir apparent, and the authorities were ordered to summon him with full ceremony. When he arrived he firmly pleaded illness and refused the post. An edict declared:
12
退 祿 祿
Upholding the example of Bo Yi and Shu Qi can shame the greedy; honoring the way of Yan Hui and Min Ziqian can reform the manners of the age. The newly appointed palace attendant Wang Youzhen is a wellspring of virtue, a rare exemplar among men: filial in serving his parents, trustworthy in his own conduct. He is learned in letters, indifferent to wealth, long experienced in office, and repeatedly praised in performance reviews. He bears the manner of the ancients and keeps a gentleman's integrity. Yet he has set his will against the world, fixed his heart beyond mundane things, entered deeply the gate of liberation, and vowed to keep the Buddhist discipline. Recently summoned to serve the heir apparent, he has steadfastly refused honor and pleaded his case again and again. He holds to pure conduct and will not take carriage or official dress; he delights only in the discipline of meditation and never seeks rich food. We mean to honor integrity and restrain decadence; though we desire talent for the court, we will not override his wish for the hills. Let him receive a generous rank while his refined purpose is fulfilled. Let him hold the post of palace attendant to the heir apparent in supernumerary status, receive full salary for life, and be free to pursue the Way at home. The local prefecture and county shall look after him and deliver his salary each season to his home.
13
歿 祿
When Xuanzong was crown prince he again petitioned for a ceremonial summons, but Youzhen, now elderly, pleaded illness and never came. He died in his nineties in the fourth year of Kaiyuan. The court then issued an edict: "To honor virtue, respect worthies, adorn the funeral, and remember the departed — this is how a sage orders the realm and deepens custom. Wang Youzhen was endowed with the finest vital force and kept his heart in primal simplicity. His filial piety was inexhaustible and reached the spirits themselves; his Way was beyond naming, and he loftily withdrew from the world of men. We had hoped to reward his kind and rely on him to steady the manners of the age; his sudden death fills us with deep sorrow. He held no high office in life and so lacked the full rites due a court minister, yet in death he deserves honor — let him be granted the vestments of a senior minister. Let him be posthumously made Silver Blue-light Grand Master of the Palace, and let the magistrate of his home county perform special mourning rites."
14
Lu Hongyi
15
Lu Hongyi, courtesy name Haoran, was originally from Fanyang but moved his household to Luoyang. He studied from youth and was accomplished in several calligraphic scripts; he withdrew to Mount Song. Early in Kaiyuan the court twice sent ceremonial gifts to summon him, but he did not come. In the fifth year an edict declared:
16
使 便
We are slight in virtue, yet humbly occupy the throne. We have long regretted the decline of the subtle Way and the failure of pure civilization to flourish, and we constantly yearn for forgotten worthies, hoping to hear the teaching of the sage sovereigns of old. You penetrate principle at the center, plumb the deepest subtleties, master the Way of the Grand Unity, and practice the virtue of the Mean — steadfast and lofty, fully the equal of the ancients. We have therefore sent repeated summons, expecting worthy service, yet each time you have pleaded excuse and refused to come. For years we have waited with open heart; though we honor your integrity as a true recluse, we miss the lesson of Kaofu that reverence should ever increase. Is it that the court and your life's purpose are at odds? Or will you indulge yourself in the hills and never return? Ritual has its great bonds — the duty between ruler and subject cannot be cast aside! The capital is near and should pose no difficulty. We send silks as gifts and proclaim this intent anew — we trust you will change your mind and answer our wish!
17
殿
Hongyi answered the summons. In the sixth year he reached the eastern capital and at audience did not perform a full bow. The chief minister sent an attendant to inquire; Hongyi replied, "I have heard the Old Master say that ritual is where loyalty and trust grow thin and cannot be relied upon. Your mountain subject Hongyi ventures to present himself in loyalty and sincerity alone." The emperor then summoned him to the inner hall and treated him to food and wine. An edict declared: "Lu Hongyi answered our summons and came; we questioned him on the supreme Way and found him in harmony with pure custom. To elevate a recluse is to encourage the realm. He should be made Remonstrance and Discussion Grand Master." Hongyi firmly declined, and the emperor issued another edict:
18
In the time of Emperor Yao, the throne fully honored Xu You's integrity; and only Yu the Great heeded Bo Cheng's lofty withdrawal. Thus we know that even a sovereign has men he does not subordinate, and lords have men they do not treat as mere friends — how great is the timely meaning of withdrawal! The Mount Song recluse Lu Hongyi keeps his distance in deep seclusion and fixes his heart on calligraphy and plain living; he withdrew to fulfill his purpose and practiced righteousness to attain his Way; and has slept among clouds in forest valleys for many years. Does not the Classic say, "Raise a recluse, and the hearts of the people will turn to you"?" We therefore sent letters to his cave, summoned him with full ceremony, and hoped he would counsel us and enlarge good government. Yet he stood apart, steadfast and hard to move; he quieted himself to steady his character, washed his heart to keep his purpose pure, firmly refused honor, sought to deepen custom, and would not lower his aim in order to preserve his integrity. Yan Ziling of Kuaiji could not be bent to office; Wang Ba of Taiyuan in the end returned home on grounds of illness. Let him return to the mountains with the rank of Remonstrance and Discussion Grand Master. Each year grant him a hundred dan of rice and fifty bolts of silk for his needs and medicines, and order the local authorities to deliver them to his retreat. If he learns of the court's strengths and failings, let him report them fully in memorial.
19
As he prepared to return to the hills, he was again given a recluse's robe and a cottage, and the imperial favor shown him was very great.
20
Wang Xiyi
21
Wang Xiyi was a native of Teng County in Xuzhou. Orphaned and poor, he devoted himself to the Way. After his parents died he herded sheep for hire to pay for their burial. When the funeral was over he withdrew to Mount Song and studied under the Daoist Huang Yi for nearly forty years, mastering his methods of breath control and nourishing life. After Huang Yi died he moved to Mount Culai in Yanzhou and made a companion in reclusion of the Daoist Liu Xuanbo. He loved the Book of Changes and Laozi, and sometimes ate pine and cypress leaves and various herbal powders.
22
During the Jinglong era, though past seventy, he grew ever stronger in body. Prefect Lu Qiqing called on him with full courtesy and asked how to govern people well. Xiyi said, "Confucius said, 'Do not impose on others what you yourself do not desire' — one may practice that all one's life." When Emperor Xuanzong toured the east, he ordered the local authorities to summon Xiyi with full ceremony; brought before the imperial carriage, Xiyi was already ninety-six. The emperor had Chief Minister Zhang Yue question him on the Way and duty; eunuchs helped him into the palace, and the emperor delighted in their conversation.
23
In the fourteenth year of Kaiyuan an edict declared: "The Xuzhou scholar Wang Xiyi has renounced worldly learning, embraced simplicity, long shunned the dust of the world, and walked alone among forest and cliff. As we performed the Feng and Chan rites, we turned our seat to honor worthies; he came at our call and answered our gracious summons. Though his path recalls the Four Hoaryheads of Mount Shang, he has already passed the age of Fusheng; let rank be granted to honor learning and to exalt respect for age. Let him be made Grand Master of Splendid Happiness and acting erudite of the Directorate of Education, with permission to retire and return to the hills. The local authorities shall present silks, wine, and meat in spring and autumn, and he is also granted one suit of clothes and a hundred bolts of silk." He soon died at a great age.
24
退
After the reigns of Empress Wu and Emperor Zhongzong there were Wei Dajing of Pu Prefecture and Li Yuankai of Xing Prefecture, both of pure purpose who refused office; and Wang Shoushen of Pu Prefecture, Xu Renji of Chang Prefecture, and Sun Chuxuan of Run Prefecture, all of whom withdrew from office and were praised by their contemporaries.
25
Wei Dajing
26
Wei Dajing was deeply learned in the Book of Changes and rarely spoke a needless word. Empress Wu summoned him by edict, but he pleaded illness and did not go. He was old friends with Xiahou Qiantong of Wei Prefecture; when he heard that Qiantong's mother had died, he walked there to offer condolences. A neighbor tried to stop him, saying, "It is the height of summer — how can you walk a thousand li? A letter would suffice." Dajing replied, "A letter a foot long cannot express all that I mean." He went anyway. At Wei Prefecture, Qiantong happened to be away; Dajing went to the house, set out mourning mats, performed the condolence rites, and left without even asking after the family. Early in Kaiyuan, when Bi Gou was prefect, he said to Magistrate Kong Shenyan of Jie County, "Master Wei's virtue is profound and deserves special recognition. The ancients marked the lane of Gan Mu to honor worthies — we should do the same." Shenyan called at his door, but Dajing was by then elderly and pleaded illness, refusing to see him. He once divined the day of his death, dug his own tomb, and wrote his epitaph in advance; he died exactly as foretold.
27
Li Yuankai
28
使 祿 祿
Li Yuankai was broadly learned and skilled in astronomy, pitch pipes, and calendrics, yet by nature modest and cautious and never spoke of others' faults. His fellow townsman Song Jing had studied under him in youth. When Song Jing became chief minister he sent silks and meant to recommend him for office, but Yuankai refused everything and made no reply. During the Jinglong era Yuan Xingchong, as prefect of Ming, invited Yuankai to the prefecture, questioned him on the classics, and gave him clothing. Yuankai declined, saying, "One of my humble station should not wear fine new clothes — I fear I could not bear such splendor without inviting misfortune." Xingchong then smeared the garments with mud and gave them thus; unable to refuse further, Yuankai accepted. On returning home he sent Xingchong five liang of plain silk from his own silkworms, saying, "By right one must not accept unearned wealth." Earlier, Cui Yuanjian of Ding Prefecture was expert in the Three Rites; his fellow townsman Zhang Yizhi, then in favor and power, had recommended him. Cui had entered office as Grand Master of Splendid Happiness, retired at home, and in his district requested half his salary. Yuankai reproved him, saying, "To receive salary without merit is a calamity." Yuankai died at more than eighty.
29
Wang Shoushen
30
Wang Shoushen enjoyed a fine reputation. During the Chuigong era he served as investigating censor. When the fabricated treason cases began, Shoushen's uncle Zhang Zhim, vice minister of justice, ran the imperial prison and reported that Shoushen had shared knowledge of the affair. Shoushen pleaded illness, resigned, and asked to become a monk. Empress Wu was at first greatly surprised; but Shoushen stated his case in language of great force, and the empress gladly consented, granting him the monastic name Facheng. His judgment was refined, and the worthies of the age held him in esteem. He died at an advanced age.
31
Xu Renji
32
使
Xu Renji was summoned and appointed Left Reminder during the Shenglü era. Three times he memorialized on the government's failings, and each time his advice was ignored. He told others, "Three remonstrances ignored — it is time to go!" He then pleaded illness and returned home. Early in the Shenlong era a consolation commissioner praised Renji's conduct as able to reform custom, and he was again summoned as Left Suppleter. Again he memorialized three times without response, and then went to the chief ministers asking to be released from office. He was soon made magistrate of Lingchang. His wife and children did not accompany him to his post; his official quarters held only clothes, shoes, and books — nothing else.
33
Sun Chuxuan
34
Sun Chuxuan was summoned as Left Reminder during the Chang'an era. He was skilled at writing and once lamented that the realm lacked books to spread fresh knowledge. Early in Shenlong, when Huan Yanfan and other meritorious ministers held power, Chuxuan sent Yanfan a letter on the affairs of the day; when Yanfan ignored his advice, Chuxuan resigned and returned home. He died of illness.
35
Bai Lüzhong
36
Bai Lüzhong was a native of Junyi in Chenliu. He was broadly learned in letters and history. He once lived in seclusion in the ruins of ancient Daliang, and contemporaries called him Master of the Liang Mound. During the Jingyun reign, he was summoned to serve as a collator in the Secretariat. Before long he resigned his post and went home.
37
In the tenth year of Kaiyuan, Wang Zhikong, Minister of Justice, recommended Lüzhong for living in seclusion while studying, for his austere integrity and antique virtue, and proposed that he replace Chu Wuliang and Ma Huaisu as a reader in the inner court. In the seventeenth year, Yang Songlu, Chancellor of the Imperial University, again recommended Lüzhong as fit to serve as an academic official, and the court summoned him to the capital. When he arrived, Lüzhong pleaded old age and illness and said he was unfit for office. An edict declared: "The recluse Bai Lüzhong, formerly a collator in the Secretariat, excels in scholarship, embodies the Way in rustic seclusion, probes the hidden to reveal its depths, and in withdrawal has fulfilled his purpose. We therefore sought him as one would draw water from the streams of Confucius's teaching or seek a worthy at Yimen — his pure character stands above rank, and official emblems hold no value for him. Now in the twilight of his years, he should receive higher rank, that he may enjoy the honor of a formal appointment and that our esteem for worthy men may be fully displayed. Let him be appointed Grand Master for Dispersal at Court."
38
退
Lüzhong soon petitioned to return home. The emperor's own hand wrote: "You have made filial piety and brotherly duty your foundation, withdrawn quietly from worldly affairs, and passed into old age unstained by the dust of public life. I have long heard of your great virtue, and court rank is granted you not merely to honor a man of the hills, but to encourage proper conduct among the people. Visit the capital for a time, then return at leisure to your old home. He stayed several months and then went home. Wu Jing, a Left Cavalier Attendant and fellow townsman of Lüzhong, said to him, "Your household has always been poor; you never took so much as a peck of grain or a bolt of cloth. What practical good does fifth rank do you? Lüzhong replied cheerfully, "When the Khitan invaded in past years, every household was registered for corvée at the gate. I alone was exempted because I had read a little, and I have felt ashamed ever since. Even if I gain nothing else from it now, my family may lie at ease for life and be free of labor service — how rare a benefit is that! Before long he died at a ripe old age. He wrote Refined Discourse on the Three Mysteries in one fascicle, annotated the Laozi and the Yellow Court Inner Landscape Scripture, and left collected writings in ten fascicles.
39
— Wang Yuanzhi —
40
The Daoist master Wang Yuanzhi was a native of Langya. His grandfather Jingxian had been inspector of Jiangzhou under the Liang dynasty. His father Tanxuan had been inspector of Yangzhou under the Chen dynasty. Yuanzhi's mother was the daughter of Ding Chao, a director in the Liang Bureau of Imperial Carriages. Once while napping by day she dreamed that a spirit phoenix alighted on her, and she conceived; she also heard crying from within her womb. The monk Baozhi told Tanxuan, "The child you bear will become a leader among the immortals."
41
殿 使 涿
Yuanzhi was clever as a youth and read widely across many books. He first went to Mount Mao, became a disciple of Tao Hongjing, and received his Daoist teachings. Later he also studied under Zang Jing, known as Master Zongdao. The Chen ruler heard of him and summoned him to the Chongyang Hall to lecture; he was greatly admired. When the future Emperor Yang of Sui was Prince of Jin and stationed at Yangzhou, he sent Wang Zixiang and Liu Guyian in turn to summon him. Yuanzhi came to pay his respects, and in a moment his beard and hair turned white. The Prince of Jin was frightened and sent him away; shortly afterward they returned to normal. When Emperor Yang visited Zhuo Commandery, he sent Vice Director Cui Fengju to invite him. Yuanzhi was received at Linshuo Palace, and the emperor personally performed the rites due a master. He ordered the Jade Purity Mystery Altar built in the capital to lodge him. When the emperor went to Yangzhou, Yuanzhi advised that he should not leave the capital region so far behind, but Emperor Yang would not listen.
42
宿
While Gaozu was still in obscurity, Yuanzhi once secretly conveyed to him the signs of imperial destiny. During the Wude reign, after Taizong had defeated Wang Shichong, he and Fang Xuanling went in disguise to visit Yuanzhi. Yuanzhi came out to greet them and said, "There is a sage among you — could it be the Prince of Qin? Taizong then told him the truth. Yuanzhi said, "You are about to become emperor in an age of peace — take care of yourself. When Taizong took the throne and was about to grant him high office, Yuanzhi firmly asked to return to the mountains. In the ninth year of Zhenguan, the emperor ordered Taishou Abbey established on Mount Mao in Run Prefecture and ordained twenty-seven Daoists there. An imperial letter descended: "Master, your conduct is plain and unassuming, your virtue pure and refined. You cast off worldly clutter and dwell in transcendent stillness, renewing your breath, eating sacred fungus and elixirs, contemplating the mysteries beyond the Three Clarities, and restoring youthful hair long past a hundred years. Your Way surpasses the great masters of old, and your fame has stood high since antiquity. Who but one who received secret formulas at the golden altar and hidden scriptures from the jade casket could attain such a state! When I was still in the princely household I sought instruction from you early on, and your exemplary bearing has never left my thoughts, waking or sleeping. Reading your recent memorial asking to return to your old mountain, I have already issued a separate edict honoring your lofty resolve and permitting the establishment of an abbey to express my long regard for you. I do not know whether you have already reached the lands south of the river, or when the halls you are building will be finished. I await word of the particulars and look forward eagerly to hearing from you. I have recently sent the imperial astrologer Xue Yi and others to visit you and convey my wishes."
43
調 祿
That year Yuanzhi said to his disciple Pan Shizheng, "I have seen the register of immortals. Because in my youth I accidentally injured a child's lip, I cannot ascend to heaven in broad daylight. I see that I am appointed Earl of Lesser Chamber, and my departure is near. The next day he bathed, put on cap and robes, burned incense, and lay down to sleep. He died at the age of one hundred twenty-six. In the second year of Tiaolu, Yuanzhi was posthumously granted the title Grand Master of Palace Service and given the posthumous name Master Ascending to Truth. When Empress Wu held court, he was posthumously granted the title Grand Master of the Gold Purple Light. In the second year of Tianshou, his posthumous title was changed to Master Ascending to Mystery.
44
— Pan Shizheng —
45
宿
Pan Shizheng was a native of Zanhuang in Zhao Prefecture. He lost his mother while young and lived in a hut beside her tomb, becoming known for exceptional filial devotion. During the Daye reign he was ordained a Daoist and became a disciple of Wang Yuanzhi, who fully transmitted to him the hidden secrets and talisman registers of the Daoist tradition. Shizheng lived in purity and few desires at Xiaoyao Valley on Mount Song for more than twenty years, eating nothing but pine needles and drinking only water. When Gaozong visited the Eastern Capital, he summoned Shizheng to speak with him and asked, "What do you need in the mountains? Shizheng answered, "All I need are pine trees and clear springs, and the mountains have no lack of those." Gaozong and Empress Wu treated him with great respect and stayed two nights before returning. Soon afterward the emperor ordered Chongtang Abbey built at Shizheng's dwelling and Jingsi Abbey erected separately on the ridge to lodge him. When Fengtian Palace was first established, the emperor ordered a special gate opened at the mouth of Xiaoyao Valley and named it the Gate of Immortal Roaming; and on the north side of the park he established the Gate of Seeking Truth — all these names were created for Shizheng. When the Court of Imperial Sacrifices presented newly composed music, the emperor also ordered pieces named Praying to Immortals, Gazing at Immortals, and Raising Immortals. Before and after, he bestowed several dozen poems upon him.
46
Shizheng died in the first year of Yongchun at the age of ninety-eight. Gaozong and Empress Wu remembered him with unceasing fondness, posthumously granted him the title Grand Master of Palace Service, and gave him the posthumous name Master Embodying Mystery.
47
— Liu Daohe —
48
殿
The Daoist Liu Daohe was a native of Wanqiu in Chen Prefecture. At first he lived in seclusion on Mount Song together with Pan Shizheng. When Gaozong heard of him, he ordered Taiyi Abbey built at his retreat for him to live in. He was summoned into the palace and treated with deep honor. When the emperor was about to perform the feng rite on Mount Tai, prolonged rain fell. He ordered Daohe to perform rain-stopping rites in Yiluan Hall, and shortly the sky cleared. The emperor was greatly pleased. He also sent Daohe ahead by fast courier to ascend Mount Tai first and pray for divine blessing. The rewards he received before and after he always distributed to the poor; he never kept anything for himself.
49
Gaozong also ordered Daohe to compound an elixir pill, and when it was finished Daohe presented it to the throne. He died during the Xianheng reign. When the emperor built Fengtian Palace and moved Daohe's burial chamber, his disciples opened the coffin to rebury him. The body was only an empty skin, split open along the back like a cicada shell, with teeth and bones entirely gone. All declared it corpse dissolution. When Gaozong heard of it, he was displeased and said, "Master Liu compounded elixir for me, then took it himself and departed as an immortal. What he presented to me was no different!"
50
— Sima Chengzhen —
51
The Daoist Sima Chengzhen, whose style name was Ziwei. He was a native of Wen in Henei and a fourth-generation descendant of the Marquis of Langya, who had been governor of Jin Prefecture under the Zhou dynasty. He loved learning from youth and had little taste for office, so he became a Daoist. He studied under Pan Shizheng and received from him talisman registers and the arts of grain abstention, breath cultivation, and elixir ingestion. Shizheng especially valued him and said, "From Tao Hongjing, the Recluse of Mount Mao, the Orthodox Unity teaching has passed through four generations to reach you. Chengzhen traveled through many famous mountains and finally settled on Mount Tiantai. When Empress Wu heard of him, she summoned him to the capital and issued a personal edict praising him. When he was about to return, she ordered Li Qiao, Director of the Palace Library, to give him a farewell banquet east of the Luo Bridge.
52
In the second year of Jingyun, Ruizong sent Chengzhen's elder brother Chengyi to Mount Tiantai to fetch him to the capital, brought him into the palace, and questioned him about yin-yang lore and numerology. Chengzhen answered, "The intent of the Daoist scriptures is this: 'In practicing the Way, daily diminish; diminish again and again, until you reach non-action. Yet even what the eye and heart perceive must still be diminished further, and I have not yet finished doing so. How then could I pursue heterodox arts and add to my cleverness and schemes! The emperor said, "To cultivate the self through non-action is indeed lofty and pure! But how would one govern a state through non-action? He replied, "A state is like the body. The Laozi says, 'Let the heart wander in simplicity, harmonize the breath with the vast calm, follow things as they naturally are without selfishness, and all under Heaven will be well ordered.' The Book of Changes says, 'The sage harmonizes his virtue with Heaven and Earth.' From this we know that Heaven speaks without words yet is trusted, and accomplishes without acting. The principle of non-action is the way to govern a state. Ruizong sighed and said, "This is precisely what Guangcheng taught!" Chengzhen steadfastly refused to stay and returned to his mountain retreat; the court still gave him a treasured zither and a cloud-woven cape as farewell gifts, and more than a hundred court poets sent verses to honor his departure.
53
使 西
In the ninth year of Kaiyuan, Emperor Xuanzong again summoned him to the capital, where the emperor personally received Daoist initiation registers from him; the gifts bestowed before and after were exceedingly lavish. In the tenth year, after the emperor returned to Chang'an, Chengzhen once again asked to go back to Mount Tiantai, and Xuanzong wrote a poem to bid him farewell. In the fifteenth year, he was summoned to the capital once more. Emperor Xuanzong had Chengzhen choose the finest site on Mount Wangwu and build an altar hall to live in. Chengzhen submitted a memorial stating, "The spirit shrines now worshipped at the Five Sacred Peaks are merely mountain deities — not the true perfected immortals themselves. Each of the Five Peaks has a sacred grotto-realm, and a perfected immortal of the Highest Clarity descends to take charge — governing mountains and rivers, wind and rain, and the ordering of yin and yang throughout the seasons. Their caps and ceremonial robes, their attendant immortals and retinues — each has a fixed rank and title in the celestial order. I ask that separate halls be built for ritual fasting and worship. Xuanzong accepted his advice and commanded that each of the Five Peaks receive a shrine to the True Lords; Chengzhen was charged with designing the images and ritual forms by consulting the Daoist canon.
54
使 祿
Chengzhen was skilled in seal and clerical calligraphy; the emperor had him copy the Dao De Jing in three script forms, revise the text, establish an authoritative version of five thousand three hundred and eighty characters, and submit it to the throne. The emperor named Chengzhen's residence on Mount Wangwu the Yangtai Abbey, inscribed the plaque himself, and sent an envoy to present it. He was granted three hundred bolts of silk for his medicinal preparations. Shortly thereafter, the emperor sent Princess Yuzhen and Director of Imperial Sacrifices Wei Tao to Chengzhen's hermitage to perform a Golden Register ritual, and bestowed further gifts upon him.
55
祿
That same year he died on Mount Wangwu, at the age of eighty-nine. His disciples submitted a memorial stating that "On the day he died, a pair of cranes circled the altar, white clouds rose from it and reached up to the sky, and the Master's face looked as though he were still alive. Emperor Xuanzong was deeply moved and issued a decree: "He merged with the undifferentiated and passed beyond measure; entering the vast void, he transformed of his own accord. Though he stood apart with visible presence, at the ultimate limit he vanished into mystery. Sima Ziwei, the Daoist of Mount Wangwu, anchored his heart in the triumph of the Way and comprehended the deepest mysteries; he traveled through sacred mountains and secretly attuned himself to immortal grottoes. In life he contemplated the subtle wonders and wandered freely in the realm of fulfilled understanding; In death he returned to his source and entered the stillness where nothing more need be done. His name is duly entered in the register of perfected immortals, and his place is among the spirit lords of Heaven. The forested valleys remain unchanged, but the distant heavens have grown empty; When I recall his eminent virtue, sorrow fills my heart. He should be granted posthumous honors to illuminate his immortal merit in the registers of Heaven. Let him be posthumously honored as Silver-Green Light Grand Master of Splendid Happiness, with the title Master of True Unity. The emperor also personally composed his funerary inscription.
56
Wu Yun was a scholar from the Lu region. From youth he mastered the classics and wrote well, but failed the jinshi examinations. Noble and fastidious by temperament, he could not bear the ways of the world. He entered Mount Song, studied under Pan Shizheng, and became a Daoist of the Zhengyi tradition; through fierce devotion he mastered its arts entirely. During the Kaiyuan period he traveled south to Jinling and pursued the Way on Mount Mao. After some years he journeyed east to Mount Tiantai.
57
使
Wu Yun was an accomplished writer; while in Shan he joined literary circles in Yue for gatherings of poetry and wine, and his compositions circulated as far as the capital. When Xuanzong heard of his reputation, he sent envoys to summon him. When he arrived, the emperor took great pleasure in conversing with him and appointed him as a Hanlin attendant. When the emperor asked him about Daoist doctrine, he answered, "Nothing surpasses the five thousand words of the Laozi; all the branching glosses and sprawling commentary are nothing but a waste of paper! Asked about the pursuit of immortality, he replied, "That is the affair of recluses in the wilds, to be pursued through years of devoted practice — it is not something an emperor should treat as a pastime." Whenever he sat with Buddhist and Daoist clergy as ministers presented their reports, Wu Yun spoke only on moral doctrine and affairs of state, weaving in poetry now and then to convey his true feelings. Xuanzong held him in the highest esteem.
58
祿
During the Tianbao period, with Li Linfu and Yang Guozhong in power, government discipline grew daily more chaotic. Seeing that the realm was headed for turmoil, Wu Yun urgently petitioned to return to Mount Song. After repeated petitions were denied, the emperor ordered a separate Daoist hall built at the Songshan abbey. When An Lushan's rebellion was imminent, he asked to return to Mount Mao, and permission was granted. Soon the heartland descended into chaos and bandits roamed the Huai and Yangzi regions, so he fled east to Kuaiji. He wandered between Mount Tiantai and the Shan district, exchanging verses with Li Bai and Kong Chaofu, living freely among streams and cliffs, and many admirers followed in his wake. He died at last in the Yue region. His collected works filled twenty scrolls; essays such as "The Profound Outline in Three Chapters" and "On Whether Immortality Can Be Learned" won acclaim among discerning scholars.
59
During his Hanlin service Wu Yun enjoyed exceptional imperial favor, earning the jealousy of Buddhist clergy throughout the court. The powerful eunuch Gao Lishi, a devout Buddhist, had slandered Wu Yun before the emperor; offended, Wu Yun petitioned to leave the court for the mountains. His essays harshly attacked Buddhism, a stance that earned criticism even from learned contemporaries. Yet his prose was learned and eloquent, his style luminous — every essay he wrote was copied and circulated. Li Bai had wild freedom and Du Fu had epic grandeur — who else but Wu Yun could unite both?
60
— Kong Shurui —
61
使
Kong Shurui was a native of Zhao Prefecture. His great-grandfather Changyu served as Director in the Ministry of Rites' Food Department. His grandfather Shun held office as Investigating Censor. His father Qican was magistrate of Baoding. From youth Shurui, along with his elder brother Kefu and younger brother Kerang, were all renowned for filial devotion to their parents. After they were orphaned, all three retired to seclusion on Mount Song. Shurui was an indefatigable scholar; during the Dali period Transport Commissioner Liu Yan repeatedly recommended him as a man of Yan Hui's and Min Ziqian's virtue and of You and Xia's erudition. Emperor Daizong summoned him to serve as Harmonizing Officer in the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. He rose to Doctor of the Imperial Academy, then served successively as Assistant Director in the Ministry of Personnel and as a historiographer at the History Institute. Whenever the emperor promoted him, Shurui would come briefly to court to express gratitude, then within ten days plead illness and retreat to his mountain home.
62
殿 退
When Emperor Dezong took the throne, he appointed Shurui Remonstrance Officer with silver seal and vermilion sash, and dispatched Henan Intendant Zhao Huibo to Mount Song with an edict and the ceremonial gifts of dark silk and crimson brocade to summon him in proper form. Once Shurui arrived, the emperor received him in a separate audience hall, granted him a residence and stables, and appointed him Reader to the Crown Prince. Within ten days he submitted repeated petitions firmly declining office and begging, as before, to return to his mountain retreat. The emperor replied by edict: "You cherish the statesmanship of Yi Yin and Tai Gong, and embody the spirit of Guangcheng's noble retirement. You cultivate simplicity in your rustic retreat and have repeatedly refused rank and office. As emperors once sought sages on Mount Tong and by the Wei River, why must you cling so stubbornly to modest refusal! Do not defy my will — put your talents to use at court. Unable to persuade the emperor to accept his resignation, Shurui at last took up his duties. Before long he was promoted to Vice Director of the Palace Library, concurrently Right Censor to the Crown Prince, and again appointed historiographer. An expert in geography, Shurui thoroughly revised the Geographical Treatise during his institute service, and it was acclaimed as the most comprehensive account of its day.
63
退
Gentle and uncontentious by nature, he was so modest at social gatherings that he seemed barely able to speak — and for that everyone respected him. Linghu Yan, who served alongside him as compiler, often pressed petty grievances against Shurui, but Shurui always yielded and never quarreled — for which contemporaries honored him as a man of mature virtue.
64
歿
In the fourth year of Zhenyuan, he was dispatched with an edict, imperial provisions, and hundreds of garments to the site of the Pingliang peace conference to perform burial rites for fallen soldiers — a task entrusted to him because of his scrupulous character. In the ninth year he submitted a memorial on grounds of illness, asking to be relieved of office. The emperor refused, replying: "Your virtue anchors the court and your conduct sets the moral tone for the realm — I depend deeply on the silent example you provide. I cannot grant your request, and I trust you will understand."
65
Only after Shurui petitioned three more times was his request granted; he retired as Guest of the Heir Apparent with the purple-gold fish pouch and was sent home. He received fifty bolts of silk and a suit of clothing as parting gifts. By custom, retired officials were not provided government transport, but Dezong, showing special favor to scholars, ordered an official carriage provided for his journey home. He died in the ninth month of the sixteenth year of Zhenyuan, at the age of seventy-one. He was posthumously honored as Minister of Works. He had a son named Minxing.
66
— Minxing —
67
殿 使
Minxing, styled Zhizhi, passed the jinshi examination in the fifth year of Yuanhe under Vice Minister of Rites Cui Shu. When Lü Yuanying served as commissioner over Yue and E, he recruited Minxing as his administrative aide. He left office to observe mourning for his mother. Later, when Lü Yuanying became commissioner of the Eastern Capital and was transferred to Hezhong, Minxing followed him on both appointments. In the fourteenth year he entered court service as Right Reminder and was promoted to Left Supplementation Censor. During the Changqing period he served as Court Diarist, then Left Department Assistant Director, Merits Bureau Director, Academician of the Hall of Assembled Worthies, Personnel Bureau Director, and soon Remonstrance Officer. He memorialized accusing Xingyuan army supervisor Yang Shuyuan of secretly inciting troops to mutiny and murdering Military Commissioner Li Jiang. No one else dared raise the matter, but Minxing submitted a forceful memorial of protest, and Yang Shuyuan was duly punished — for which public opinion acclaimed him.
68
The son of a distinguished minister, Minxing was from youth upright and fastidious, and widely admired; Once he entered public life, he counted among his friends the leading talents of the day. Though his reputation stood at the pinnacle of his generation, in steadfast integrity and moral refinement he fell far short of his father. He died in the first month of the ninth year of Dahe, at the age of forty-nine, and was posthumously honored as Vice Minister of Works in the Ministry of Revenue.
69
使
Yang Cheng, courtesy name Kangzong, was a native of Beiping. For generations his family had been a line of officials. Because his family was too poor to buy books, he sought work as a copyist in the Hall of Assembled Worthies, secretly read the office holdings, and for days on end never left his room; After six years he had mastered every subject he studied. He then withdrew to live as a recluse on Mount Zhongtiao. People from near and far admired his character, and many came to study under him. When neighbors quarreled, they did not take their disputes to the magistrate but came to Cheng for a ruling. Li Mi, commissioner of the Shaan-Guo circuit, heard of him, went in person to his village to call on him, and was deeply delighted by their conversation. When Li Mi became chancellor, he recommended Cheng for appointment as Archivist. Emperor Dezong sent Yang Ning, magistrate of Chang'an County, with silks to Cheng's home in Xia County to summon him; Cheng came to the capital in plain hemp clothing and submitted a memorial declining the appointment. Dezong sent a palace eunuch to present official robes and dress him in them before issuing the appointment, and granted him fifty bolts of silk. He was soon promoted to Remonstrance Officer.
70
Before he even reached the capital, everyone looked forward to meeting him and said, "Yang Cheng the mountain recluse has disciplined himself rigorously and cares nothing for fame or gain — now that he is a remonstrance official, he will surely serve even at the cost of his life. Everyone feared and respected him. When he arrived, the other remonstrance officials were already flooding the throne with petitions on every petty matter, and the emperor grew ever more weary of it all. Cheng, meanwhile, was drinking heavily day and night with his two younger brothers and his guests; no one could fathom his intentions, and all dismissed him as a man of empty reputation. Someone came to Cheng's home intending to ask him why he behaved this way. Cheng read his purpose at once, invited him to sit, and kept pressing wine on him. When the guest refused, Cheng would drink the cup himself; Unable to refuse, the guest joined him in toasting back and forth. Sometimes the guest would pass out first on the mat; sometimes Cheng would pass out first in the guest's arms, too drunk to hear a word he said. He told his two younger brothers, "Figure out from my monthly salary how many mouths we have to feed, how much rice we need each month, and what firewood, vegetables, and salt will cost — set that aside first, and give everything else to the wine seller. Keep nothing. He never saved anything at all. Even when something he needed urgently could not be spared, if a guest admired an object and called it fine, Cheng would gladly hand it over. A man surnamed Chen would time his visits to the day Cheng collected his salary, praise the quality of his coins and silk, and walk away with a gift every month.
71
At that time Emperor Dezong often kept power from his chancellor, allowing those around him to exploit their proximity and govern in his name. Pei Yanling, Li Qiyun, and Wei Qumou were then promoted in succession through flattery and deceit; they slandered the chief ministers and attacked senior officials, and Lu Zhi and others were all unjustly dismissed while no one dared defend them. Cheng then prostrated himself at the palace gate and submitted a memorial, joining Reminder Wang Zhongshu in denouncing Pei Yanling's corruption and declaring Lu Zhi and the others innocent. Dezong was furious, summoned the chancellor to discuss the matter, and was about to punish Cheng. The crown prince Shunzong alone spoke in Cheng's defense, and Cheng was spared punishment thanks to him. When Jinwu General Zhang Wanfu heard that the remonstrance officials had prostrated themselves at the gate in protest, he rushed to the Yanying Gate and shouted in celebration, "The court has an upright minister — the realm will surely know peace! He then went to Cheng, Wang Zhongshu, and the others and said, "If remonstrance officers can speak out like this, how can the realm fail to be at peace?" Then he kept shouting, "Peace! Peace!"
72
Wanfu was a soldier over eighty years old, and from that day his fame resounded throughout the empire. At the time the court was daily on the verge of appointing Pei Yanling chancellor; Cheng said, "If Yanling is made chancellor, I will seize the white hemp appointment edict and tear it to pieces. In the end he was demoted to Academician of the Imperial Academy over the Pei Yanling affair.
73
When Cheng arrived at the Imperial Academy, he summoned the students and told them, "The whole purpose of learning is loyalty and filial piety. Are there any among you who have long neglected your parents? The next day more than twenty students told Cheng they were going home to care for their parents.
74
There was a man named Xue Yue who had studied under Cheng; hot-tempered and impulsive, he had offended the court by speaking out on public affairs and was exiled to Lianzhou, a wanderer with no fixed home. Censorate officers tracked him down to Cheng's house. Cheng seated the censorate officers at his gate, shared a farewell cup with Xue Yue, and with tears escorted him to the city outskirts. When Dezong heard of this, he judged that Cheng had harbored a criminal and transferred him to serve as prefect of Daozhou. Two hundred and seventy Imperial Academy students, including Wang Luqing and Ji Chang, went to the palace gates to petition that Cheng be allowed to stay; after several days the clerks blocked them and their memorial never reached the throne.
75
簿 使 使 使 使
At Daozhou he treated officials and commoners as one would members of a household — punishing when punishment was due, rewarding when reward was due — and paid little heed to paperwork. The people of Daozhou tended to be short in stature; every year rural households were levied for tribute, and their men were registered as "dwarf slaves." When Cheng took office he forbade treating free men as chattel; pitying the common people for the yearly anguish of being torn from their families, he submitted a forceful memorial demanding abolition of the practice, and the tribute was stopped from that time on. The people all looked to him with gratitude, and many wept in relief. The previous prefect had been guilty of corruption. While the circuit commissioner was investigating the case, a clerk who had curried favor with the former prefect gathered evidence of his crimes to claim credit for himself; Cheng had him beaten to death on the spot. Tax collections fell short of quota, and the circuit commissioner repeatedly rebuked him. When the prefecture submitted its merit ratings, Cheng wrote his own grade: "My care for the people has been exhausting and my tax collection inept — rank me lowest of the low. The circuit commissioner sent an assistant commissioner to oversee tax collection; when he arrived at Daozhou, he was surprised that Cheng did not come out to greet him and asked the prefectural staff. They replied, "When the prefect heard the assistant commissioner was coming, he assumed himself guilty and locked himself in the jail — he dares not come out. The assistant commissioner was alarmed, rushed into the jail to see Cheng, and said, "What crime have you committed, my lord! I have come only on orders to inquire after your health." The assistant commissioner stayed a day or two without leaving, and Cheng refused to return to the guest quarters; instead he day and night sat and slept on an old door panel lying outside the gate until the assistant commissioner, unable to bear the situation, took his leave. Later another assistant commissioner was sent to investigate; unwilling on principle to carry out the assignment, he set out with his wife and children but slipped away halfway along the road.
76
When Emperor Shunzong took the throne, an edict recalled Cheng to court — but Cheng had already died. Men of learning mourned his loss; that April the court granted his family two hundred strings of cash and ordered the local prefecture and county to provide relay transport so his body could be returned home for burial.
77
西使 便殿
Cui Guan was a native of Chenggu in Liang Province. A Confucian scholar who had no taste for official advancement, he made his living by farming. Growing old without sons, he divided his fields, house, and household wealth among his servants and set each up in an independent livelihood. Guan and his wife then withdrew to the southern mountains of Chenggu and took no further interest in household affairs. They arranged for their former servants to visit in rotation, offering wine and food whenever one stopped by. Husband and wife lived facing the woods and streams, amusing themselves with whistling and poetry. Zheng Yuqing, military commissioner of the Shannan West Circuit, admired his character and recruited him as a staff adviser; only after repeated invitations did Guan come to the commissioner's residence. As an official he had no administrative skill and was painfully inept at worldly affairs; Yuqing, treating him as an elder worthy of respect, indulged him generously. In the eighth year of Taihe, Left Supplementation Censor Wang Zhifang submitted a memorial on public affairs and was summoned for an audience; Emperor Wenzong received him in the informal hall and questioned him about current affairs. Zhifang was also from Xingyuan and lived as Guan's neighbor on Mount Chenggu; that day he recommended Guan for his lofty character, and an edict summoned Guan to serve as Court Diarist. Guan pleaded illness and refused to take up the appointment. He ended his days on the mountain.
78
The eulogy says: True recluses forget their cares, neither hiding away nor seeking display. Those who use withdrawal to angle for reputation — such genuine integrity grows ever rarer. Some build cottages among springs and rocks; others cast off office and enter the world of court and market. When the heart cares nothing for office or seclusion — that is true freedom.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →